Latest / Once Upon a Time at the Oscars / Libeled Lady (1936)
Transcript
- 0:13Hello everyone and welcome to Once Upon a Time
- 0:15at the Oscars. The show that takes you through
- 0:17every Best Picture nominee from 1927 to, oh,
- 0:20today. I'm Kyle. I'm Ryan. Today we're talking
- 0:24about some ladies. We are in a silly, goofy mood.
- 0:27We're having a great time. Just one lady. You
- 0:30know what? I was about to say, we're not talking
- 0:31about ladies. We're talking about one lady. And
- 0:32you know what? Well. She's liable. Yeah, that's
- 0:35true. There's two ladies in this movie. We're
- 0:38only talking about one of them, I guess. You
- 0:39know what? I'm going to call you on your bluff.
- 0:41There's more than two ladies in this movie. Oh,
- 0:43no. What have I done? Wow. You need to sit down
- 0:46and listen. Okay. When women speak, I sit and
- 0:49I listen. You and me both, pal. And you know
- 0:51what we need is we need to not talk about that
- 0:54on a podcast of two men. No. I've been divorced
- 0:57once. I can't do it again. I would like to avoid
- 1:02it. Yeah. Unpopular opinion. You know what? I'm
- 1:04just going to go ahead and say it. I'd like to
- 1:05avoid it. And I'm going to tell you, from experience,
- 1:07it's a good call. You think so? I think so. Because
- 1:10when I have free time, I kind of just want to
- 1:12use it on video games, movies, and hanging out
- 1:14with friends, playing music maybe. I feel like
- 1:17paperwork and court systems and stuff is not
- 1:20where I want to be. No. Yeah. But you know what?
- 1:22Unpopular opinion. I'm sure that everyone's like,
- 1:24woo, courts. Woo, paperwork. Well, you have to
- 1:27have your divorce party after. That's something
- 1:30exciting. It's a divorce party. We don't need
- 1:33nobody. That's the same Hunt song called House
- 1:36Party that I just incorporated to be a divorce.
- 1:38Just to be clear, I've never had a divorce party.
- 1:41Should I throw you one? Do you think you throw
- 1:43a divorce party or do you think it's thrown for
- 1:45you? I have heard of some people that are like,
- 1:49celebrate. Let's do it. You know who would have
- 1:51celebrated? Sam Dodsworth. Yes, he would have.
- 1:54Sam Dodsworth would have had a divorce party.
- 1:55He would have. But we're not talking about Sam
- 1:57Doss. Not anymore, we're not. No, we're not.
- 2:00We're talking about some Warren Haggerty's. We're
- 2:03talking about some Gladys Benton's, Bill Chandler's,
- 2:05and Connie Allenberg's. Because we're talking
- 2:08about the libeled lady. We are. It is Allenberry,
- 2:12but I loved what you did there. Allenberry? Allenberry.
- 2:15Yes. So, libeled lady. Have two last names then,
- 2:18girl. It is Allenbury is how it's spelled. But
- 2:23if you're Allenberry, put an E and an extra R
- 2:25in there. Well, it's certainly not Allenburg,
- 2:27which is what you said originally. It is not
- 2:30my fault. It is not my fault if my Ys look like
- 2:35Gs because I do the fun little like, I'm going
- 2:38to do something where you can see it and people
- 2:40at home can't. But I think they're going to be
- 2:41able to visualize what I'm doing by the sound.
- 2:43Okay. Where I go like a whoop. You know what
- 2:45I mean? When you like do like the Y. Can you
- 2:48guys see that? Yeah. In your mind. So think about
- 2:50a Y. Yep. And think about when you're writing
- 2:52like the whoop. There it is. But then with a
- 2:54G, it's like the whoop. Like it's just an extra
- 2:57little whoop at the beginning. Yeah. I noticed
- 2:59a little cadence change there as well. Oh, you
- 3:03know what? When I was reading this, I didn't
- 3:05take into consideration the cadence change. That'll
- 3:07do it. That'll do it. Wow, you're right. And
- 3:09on my face. Libeled Lady was directed by Jack
- 3:12Conway. Yes. Who we've talked about before. That
- 3:16is pronounced Conway. We're doing great. I was
- 3:19about to call you on that. Ryan, hit me with
- 3:21what this was nominated for. This was nominated
- 3:24for one thing. Nailed it. Only one thing. It
- 3:27was the outstanding production of this film on
- 3:30behalf of MGM Metro -Goldwyn -Mayer. That's it.
- 3:34And you know, this enters that rare, I don't
- 3:37want to say rarefied air because there's a couple
- 3:38other films like this, but it's not common. that
- 3:41we see just one nomination here. Certainly modern
- 3:43day, but even back then, we just talked about
- 3:46Dodsworth with seven nominations. Yes. We've
- 3:48seen plenty of films with like, you know, three
- 3:49plus nominations here. This one, I will say in
- 3:53terms of the type of film that it is, just glad
- 3:56I'm talking about Dodsworth, plenty of other
- 3:58films of like high. story concept this is a little
- 4:03bit more of like the you know what it almost
- 4:05is it almost feels like a ginger rogers fred
- 4:08astaire concept but with no singing and no dancing
- 4:10and no ginger or and no ginger or uh stare yeah
- 4:14yeah uh Oh, yeah. Ginger or a stare. I said Ginger
- 4:17or a Rogers, which is also true. Yes, this was
- 4:20based on the screenplay by Maureen Dallas Watkins,
- 4:23Howard Emmett Rogers, and George Oppenheimer.
- 4:26Not that one. The story was by Wallace Sullivan.
- 4:29This is a screwball comedy, if there ever was
- 4:33one. Yeah. And we, you know, no one's going to
- 4:37be surprised to hear me say the names William
- 4:40Powell and Myrna Loy together. This is the...
- 4:45Honestly, honest to God, I'm not even joking.
- 4:48When I saw Live Old Lady and I opened it up on,
- 4:51I think it was, how did I watch this? It may
- 4:54have been Prime for rental. But when I opened
- 4:57it up and the opening image is William Powell
- 4:59staring into Myrna Loy's eyes, that is legitimately
- 5:01what was in my head. Yes. Yeah. Let's go. It's
- 5:05so good. This is the fifth of 14. Oh, my goodness.
- 5:11Powell and Loy films. The most exciting thing
- 5:13about hearing that is there's nine more opportunities.
- 5:17There's nine more of these suckers to come. And
- 5:19that's great because you know what five or six
- 5:21of them are, well, in total. Thin mans. Thin
- 5:24mans. Yeah, yeah. So a lot of great stuff to
- 5:27come. Favorite Girl Scout cookie. Great Ziegfeld.
- 5:30Not my favorite of their pairings. Yeah, of course.
- 5:35I thought we were still talking about the thin
- 5:36mint cookies. Yeah. Really? Is that your favorite
- 5:40Girl Scout? No. Cookie. Name your favorite Girl
- 5:43Scout right now. Top five Girl Scouts. Sally
- 5:45Mae. Big fan. What was Jenny Lewis in True Beverly
- 5:51Hills? What was her name? I don't even know what
- 5:54that is. True Beverly Hills? Yeah. Taylor, just
- 5:57check your phone right now. You have a text message.
- 6:00My entire life is getting text messages from
- 6:03your wife saying, what is wrong with you? Because
- 6:06I don't know anything. Well, True Beverly Hills
- 6:08is kind of like one of the top five things for
- 6:11her. If you need a TED Talk, just say True Beverly
- 6:16Hills three times in a mirror. Gotcha. And she
- 6:18appears with sunglasses and a turtleneck on.
- 6:20And baked goods? Sunglasses. Sorry, just glasses.
- 6:23Not baked goods. She's going to yell at you about
- 6:25True Beverly Hills. I am not saying that name.
- 6:28We got here from thin man. We did. We're doing
- 6:29well. So along with William Powell and Myrna
- 6:32Loy, we have Gene Harlow and a name that a lot
- 6:36of people might know, but not from a screwball
- 6:38comedy like this. Spencer Tracy. Yeah. Is here.
- 6:41And you know what? You're going to learn that
- 6:42he is more screwball than you think. Really?
- 6:45Yeah. Great. Really? Screwball comedies for Spencer
- 6:48Tracy. Yeah. Quite a bit. Quite a bit. So he's,
- 6:51he's. Known for his pairings with Katharine Hepburn,
- 6:54which is very exciting for the future, is, help
- 6:59me with this, Philadelphia Story. That is Jimmy
- 7:01Stewart, Katharine Hepburn, and Cary Grant. Okay,
- 7:06so it's not Spencer Tracy. No. Why do I think
- 7:08Spencer Tracy, like, I hear that and I think
- 7:10noir. Why is that? Dick Tracy, probably. Wow.
- 7:14Is that it? You know what I love about... We're
- 7:16about to hit a year of the podcast in a little
- 7:19bit here. What I love is that you clocked me
- 7:21immediately. Like you were like, oh, no, you're
- 7:23thinking of Dick Tracy. And yeah, I was. 100%.
- 7:27What can I say? Good job. So this is, like I
- 7:30said, a screwball comedy. It has like a semi
- 7:33-convoluted plot. It's pretty complicated. Yes.
- 7:36To start, Spencer Tracy plays Warren Haggerty,
- 7:40who works at a newspaper publishing company.
- 7:42And a story just dropped where Connie Allenberry,
- 7:47played by Myrna Loy, has been... libeled in the
- 7:51press as destroying a marriage she was involved
- 7:55in uh an infidelity case she's a man chaser yes
- 7:59that is what it is and she like canceled a wedding
- 8:03with her antics that is not true at least from
- 8:07myrna loy's uh that is not true based on that
- 8:13was myrna loy outside yeah she's like that's
- 8:15not true colin allenberry says no that's not
- 8:19true Connie Allenberry says that's not true.
- 8:22That's not true at all. So she sues the publishing
- 8:24company. For how much, Kyle? Five million dollars.
- 8:28Yowza. Yes. So Warren Haggerty comes up with
- 8:32this plan where he is going to take his fiancée,
- 8:36Jean Harlow. He has interrupted their wedding
- 8:40day to go deal with this case. Yes. He is just,
- 8:43he's not the best partner. He's so caught up
- 8:46in work. And all she wants is to get married
- 8:48and, like, I, Jean Harlow is so good in this
- 8:51because she's just like, I can't stand you. You're
- 8:55so annoying. Yeah. Like she's just, but she keeps
- 8:57coming back to it. Yeah. She's so laid back about
- 9:00it, but just, I love that type of character that
- 9:03like rolls her eyes. Um, there's something, I,
- 9:05I don't know if it's you and I know it's someone
- 9:08else. We've. Talked about goofs before, little
- 9:11gags. Gags is a word that pops up in here a lot.
- 9:14Yes. Where I can say with full confidence that
- 9:17Gene Harlow's Gladys Benton is sick of Warren
- 9:21Haggerty's gags. Yes. His little goofs. 100%.
- 9:24Warren Haggerty comes up with this plan where
- 9:27he is going to get this con man kind of guy,
- 9:31William Powell, playing Bill Chandler. He's getting
- 9:34Bill Chandler to seduce Connie Allenberry and...
- 9:39pose as the husband of Warren Haggerty's actual
- 9:42fiance, Gladys Benton. Thank you so much. You
- 9:45see how convoluted this is, guys? It's so complicated.
- 9:48So Warren Haggerty is engaged to Gladys Benton
- 9:51and works with Bill Chandler, but has propositioned
- 9:54a scenario in which Bill Chandler gets married
- 9:57to Gladys Benton in order to then cheat on her
- 10:02with Connie Allenberry. Yes, to enforce the fact
- 10:06that Connie Allenberry did wreck a marriage.
- 10:09So instead of paying the $5 million lawsuit,
- 10:12they will frame Connie Allenberry for actually
- 10:16being a man chaser. Yes. And then thus not have
- 10:19the lawsuit be thrown out. There is no libel.
- 10:21Yes, no libel. Yes. And hence, Connie Allenberry
- 10:24is the libeled lady. Thank you for cleaning up
- 10:28that plot. I'm going to go ahead and say off
- 10:29the bat, man. Can I say something controversial?
- 10:32Go for it. Hell yeah. Yep. Hell yeah. Yep. I'm
- 10:36on board. You give me a libeled lady. Well, you
- 10:39give me movies like libeled lady all day long.
- 10:42Yep. You know what's so nice? A couple weeks
- 10:45ago, we had to do a triple feature of some movies
- 10:47where we were like, oh, this is going to be a
- 10:48fun one to talk about. And now, we're sitting
- 10:50down, we're like, this is going to be a fun one
- 10:52to talk about. Like, we're excited. Yes. We are
- 10:54pumped. I love it. And Liable Lady, it's one
- 10:57of those movies where you see one nomination
- 10:59for outstanding production, and you're like,
- 11:00really? Nothing else? And then you watch, and
- 11:02you're like, oh, I get it. Yeah. Like, I understand.
- 11:04And not in a negative way, but like a, oh, sure.
- 11:07It's not like there's acting that is, this is
- 11:09the thing. It's really more the chemistry between
- 11:11these characters. Yeah. And that's the screwball
- 11:13comedy. That's the romance. It's just the characterization.
- 11:16And it's just fun. It's so much fun. I feel like
- 11:20the Academy and the members of the Academy, they
- 11:22went and they saw this movie and they were just
- 11:24like, man, I had some fun. I don't know what
- 11:26I would nominate it for, but it's got to be present
- 11:29at the Academy Awards. Yeah, this rocks. I mean,
- 11:31I have a fun little like, we should have a Ryan's
- 11:35Conspiracy Corner where it's just. What should
- 11:38we call it? Ryan's Aliens Are Real Corner? Like
- 11:42some kind of conspiracy. I can't think of a fun
- 11:44name that's not controversial, so whatever. Rye
- 11:46Believe. Rye Wanna Believe. Yeah. Rye Wanna Believe.
- 11:50There it is. My God, that's it. So in this edition
- 11:54of Rye Wanna Believe, William Powell is so good
- 11:59at being William Powell. Yes, he is. He is so
- 12:02good at being William Powell that I think that
- 12:04they just named this guy Bill. Oh, yeah. They
- 12:07said, screw it. You know what? You're playing
- 12:10Bill. You are Bill. And this is, like, what,
- 12:14the third movie that we've covered with William
- 12:16Powell specifically? Maybe more. Yeah. Because,
- 12:18what, Thin Man, Great Ziegfeld, and now this.
- 12:23Was there another? I don't recall. I don't think
- 12:26so. I want to say, like, A Grand Hotel. A movie
- 12:28that has everyone in it that's just like, oh,
- 12:30yeah, William Powell's right there. Like, freeze
- 12:32frame. I found him. I first thought you were
- 12:35like, I found a fourth. So, third movie we've
- 12:38seen him in, and this is the third example of,
- 12:41oh, you're just William Powell. You're right.
- 12:44He's just playing himself. Right. But that's
- 12:46so perfect. And it rocks. And especially when
- 12:49you put him with Myrna Loy. I say it's the third
- 12:51time we've seen William Powell. You know what
- 12:52I know for sure? It's the third time that we've
- 12:54seen William Powell with Myrna Loy. This is true.
- 12:58I mean, I think Thin Man is still like the perfect
- 13:01pairing of those two. Because I think they both
- 13:03have an opportunity to shine just as much as
- 13:05each other. Yes. Whereas great Ziegfeld, he is
- 13:08kind of sharing the screen. It's mostly him,
- 13:11but then he's sharing it with, I forget the actor's
- 13:14name, forgive me, but his first wife and then
- 13:17Myrna Loy. Yeah. And then in this, Myrna Loy
- 13:20doesn't have as much screen time as I would have
- 13:23loved, but still she's pretty heavily involved.
- 13:26Yes. As Connie Allen. And I got to say, like,
- 13:29you're first introduced to Gene Harlow and Spencer
- 13:33Tracy. Like, those are the two opening characters.
- 13:36Yes. And their dynamic is incredible as well.
- 13:40And I think that's the thing. Like, I know William
- 13:42Powell and Myrna Loy. I'm going to love them.
- 13:45Gene Harlow and Spencer Tracy, I don't know.
- 13:47Oh, nope. I already love them. That's the amount
- 13:49of time it took watching this movie. Gene Harlow's
- 13:52voice is so funny. Like I said, I just love how
- 13:58spiteful she is and just spunky. All of her,
- 14:02especially when she gets married, she is such
- 14:05a little spitfire. I love Jean Harlow. she's
- 14:09great she is so good and the thing about uh one
- 14:15sequence that i absolutely love about this is
- 14:16where she and um bill get married yeah and it
- 14:21is just a very quick like i do i do like just
- 14:23married and just like a slight kiss and then
- 14:26uh she gives a kiss to the best man which is
- 14:29warren hagerty and they are just like absolutely
- 14:32macking on each other going to town and william
- 14:35powell looks over to the uh the minister the
- 14:38yeah or whatever yeah um and is like oh he's
- 14:43a old family friend and they continue because
- 14:45he's like he's a really old family friend uh
- 14:47and it's just so much fun and so funny and i
- 14:53the comedy of this i absolutely loved i couldn't
- 14:56get over it i mean so let's break it down the
- 14:59we could see from a mile away what's going to
- 15:01happen And maybe it's like hindsight. Maybe it's
- 15:04us being in the modern times to where we see
- 15:06a setup of like, oh, yeah, you're going to have
- 15:08to really fall in love with this girl. Is that
- 15:10OK? And you're like, you guys are going to fall
- 15:11in love. Right. And this girl's like, oh, you're
- 15:13making me marry this guy. I'm going to hate him.
- 15:14You're going to develop a crush on him, aren't
- 15:16you? And it's going to be complicated. And I
- 15:19thought I was a little concerned that things
- 15:20were going to get so complicated where it was
- 15:22like, hey, I actually don't end up with Myrna
- 15:23Loy. I end up with Jean Harlow. But I think the
- 15:26way this played out was pretty near perfect.
- 15:28I think so, too. It is taking what has worked
- 15:31in the Fred Astaire, Ginger Rogers movies, and
- 15:35then taking it a step further, right? We don't
- 15:38do just the musical aspect, but it is, well,
- 15:40what's the one thing that we're missing from
- 15:42this? The physical comedy. William Powell, for
- 15:45the first time, I think, in what we've seen from
- 15:48him, at least in the Academy consideration, is
- 15:52doing some incredible physical work here. And
- 15:55there's a sequence later on. We're jumping ahead.
- 15:58But I think this is a movie that is not so much,
- 16:00let's tell you what happens. And it's more the
- 16:01moments and what it leads to. Yeah. He falls
- 16:04for this girl. And he is really trying his best
- 16:07to impress her. And in doing so, he has found
- 16:10himself having to really commit to her father.
- 16:13Yeah. Who is this like magnate, like huge riches.
- 16:16This is where the money comes from. And that's
- 16:18James B. Allenberry. Played by Walter Connelly.
- 16:20And Walter Connelly. It is Connelly, right? Walter
- 16:23Connelly is continuing some excellent work here.
- 16:27He is a great character actor. And he is a great,
- 16:30like, hey, we need a guy who's a foil, but also
- 16:31he's really fun. Yeah, veteran of the Frank Capra
- 16:34films we've watched. 100%. And he's continuing
- 16:36the trend here. He is so good. But in trying
- 16:39to get close to Connie, he finds that he needs
- 16:43to really impress her father. And in doing so,
- 16:46finds out that he is a huge angler. fan of fishing
- 16:49so he brushes up on his knowledge on how to fish
- 16:53talks to them about like really like all kinds
- 16:56of fish all day but then finds out that in order
- 16:58to really impress them he has to follow them
- 17:00to this area and fish with them and in doing
- 17:05so not only is he having a tough time catching
- 17:09fish but he actually like falls into the river
- 17:12multiple times trying to catch a fish and I was
- 17:15just really impressed with the filming on this
- 17:18because the joke is he's not good at it, right?
- 17:21And there's a whole like, oh, wow, he's so...
- 17:23Look at the way he flicks his wrist and the way
- 17:26that he trains himself on how to do these specific
- 17:28casts. Thank you. And even though I said it at
- 17:34the same time, I don't know why I thanked you.
- 17:35I was like, more like shut up. But thank you.
- 17:37So he does the underhand cast, but he's falling
- 17:41trying to catch these fish. And there's an...
- 17:44awesome scene where he's sitting down in the
- 17:47middle of the river and he just puts the um the
- 17:49rod behind him and just sits down and while he
- 17:52does this there's an underwater shot and i'm
- 17:55still interested in how they did this i'm sure
- 17:57there is a tank and they just filmed outside
- 17:58of the tank but they uh filmed a fish swimming
- 18:02up to the hook and looking at it and you never
- 18:04see the fish biting onto the hook i think i said
- 18:07that right You never see the fish biting onto
- 18:09the hook, but you do see the fish swimming away,
- 18:12and you assume he has the hook. And all of a
- 18:15sudden, he gets carried away with the rod, and
- 18:18he's trying to pick it up. And in doing so, what
- 18:21is he—do you remember what he finds? He has his
- 18:23fishing book. Yes, but the kind of fish that
- 18:26he has is like a rarity. Oh, it's just a big
- 18:28fish is what it is. So they called it a name,
- 18:31but I think it's what they've named it and not
- 18:33like the actual name of the type of fish. It's
- 18:36like catching lockjaw, that kind of thing. Yeah,
- 18:38something like that. Like this legendary fish
- 18:40in this lake. And he's catching it, but while
- 18:42he is catching it, it's more like it's caught
- 18:44him. Right. And he's running after it and trying
- 18:47to pull it out of the water. And in doing so,
- 18:49Connie runs up with a net. And tries to catch
- 18:52it. But even her father's like, don't do that.
- 18:54You're going to rob the man of the thrill of
- 18:56reeling in the fish. But he kind of needs this,
- 18:59too, in real time. It's just such a great play
- 19:01of, like, what he's doing and what they think
- 19:03he's doing and, like, the absurdity of it. And
- 19:06this is what I think is, like, we're looking
- 19:08at It Happened One Night. We're looking at the
- 19:10screwball comedies of all screwball comedies
- 19:11to this point. And we are trying to kind of,
- 19:14like, match that to what we've seen of the Rogers
- 19:17and Astaire musicals. That's just the comparison
- 19:20I saw was the absurdity of these connections
- 19:25and misunderstandings of like a Top Hat or a
- 19:28Gay Divorcee. And I think at this time, Swing
- 19:30Time? Or is that next year? It was nominated
- 19:33separately this year. Yeah, so the Swing Time
- 19:36of this too. So I think it's taking on that is
- 19:39what I felt, but putting some of the... comedy
- 19:43and screwball nature from like an it happened
- 19:45one night yeah so it's funny that you mentioned
- 19:47that uh is it walter connelly walter connelly
- 19:50it's funny that walter connelly pops up who is
- 19:52as you mentioned a capra uh veteran yeah in something
- 19:55that feels kind of capra -esque in that sense
- 19:57yeah capra -esque because it happened one night
- 20:00being the origin of the screwball comedy but
- 20:02also like Not only is this a screwball comedy,
- 20:05but it's a funny one. They don't always hit.
- 20:07And the writing and the comedy in this is so
- 20:10good. And I think a lot of that can be accredited
- 20:13to the actors at play here. That William Powell
- 20:16in the river scene is just incredible. And I
- 20:19love that he has a whole sequence where he's
- 20:22chasing the how to fish or fishing for dummies
- 20:25book down the river. Yeah. And he's just like
- 20:27leaping into the water, diving headfirst into
- 20:31the water, trying to catch up to it. And it is
- 20:33not the type of like cartoonish comedy I expected
- 20:36to see from William Powell. But I think that's
- 20:39one of the reasons this works so well for me.
- 20:42I said this before. It feels like an episode
- 20:44of like a comedy show, like a sitcom. And I think
- 20:48that's one of the things I miss from like the
- 20:49modern era is you don't get movies like this
- 20:52anymore. You know, it's funny that you say that,
- 20:55because what you just kind of put into my head
- 20:58was that I wonder how much of like a Dick Van
- 21:01Dyke inspiration came from this, of like a tall
- 21:04individual that is like falling over himself.
- 21:06Because when you think of like a pratfall in
- 21:08like a TV show, in like a charming individual,
- 21:11I immediately think of Dick Van Dyke. And even
- 21:14like the opening of the Dick Van Dyke show kind
- 21:16of reminds me of what we're seeing in this exact
- 21:18scene of him like falling in the river. Because
- 21:20you're right, it's not just him like... you know
- 21:23losing i'm thinking of uh the roger bulger is
- 21:27that right from broadway melody of 1936 uh roy
- 21:30roy bulger thank you it's not like that sequence
- 21:33he has where he's like losing his balance intentionally
- 21:36and like moving side to side yeah but in water
- 21:38you're you're saying you said it earlier he's
- 21:41falling on his face Yes. Into the river and then
- 21:44like getting back up and falling over again.
- 21:45And this is just him committing to that like,
- 21:48you know, physical bit over and over in almost
- 21:50one take. So I thought so much of like, you know.
- 21:54other tall lanky individuals following the pratfall
- 21:57yeah to me that's like a dick van dyke and i
- 21:59wonder how much of that is kind of like you know
- 22:01originating from this and the work that like
- 22:04a roy bulger does we talked also in like um i'm
- 22:07sorry it was great ziegfeld that uh roy bulger
- 22:10was in yes it was beverly hillbillies In Broadway
- 22:13Melody of 1936. Buddy Epson. Buddy Epson of Broadway
- 22:16Melody of 1936. A similar situation where we're
- 22:20seeing these taller individuals and the way they
- 22:22can move. And whether that is for musical or
- 22:25for comedy purposes, either way, it's very entertaining.
- 22:27I'm really enjoying that aspect. But the main
- 22:30thing that ties us back. isn't just the comedy
- 22:33of it. It is very good. But it's also, how much
- 22:35do you want to see William Powell and Myrna Loy
- 22:37make it work? Yeah. But also Gene Harlow in this.
- 22:40Like, I love that there's chemistry with Powell
- 22:42and Harlow here as well. Man, when they do first
- 22:46get married, Bill Chandler and Gladys Benton,
- 22:49Powell and Harlow, she's so funny because she's
- 22:51so resistant to this idea of having to marry
- 22:54Bill Chandler. She wants to marry her fiancé,
- 22:57Warren Haggerty. Because she's a pawn. Yeah.
- 22:59That's the way she sees it. And, you know, If
- 23:02this movie didn't have such a happy ending, I
- 23:04would be like, man, I feel bad for Gladys. She's
- 23:08just getting put through it. But when they first
- 23:10get married, like you mentioned, the kissing
- 23:14scene is very funny where she... kisses warren
- 23:16hagerty afterwards but i love when they're like
- 23:19oh before you know it it'll be your silver anniversary
- 23:22and she goes it better be in the next six weeks
- 23:24and it's just like it's such good writing there's
- 23:27a lot of like two men are having a conversation
- 23:29to each other and then gene harlow is in the
- 23:31back ad -libbing some lines in between yes perfect
- 23:34and she's so good at it god and then there's
- 23:36the scene as well where any any time like random
- 23:40people come into the room They have to act like
- 23:43a married couple. And it's it's just like over
- 23:46the top where she's calling him like Billy Willie
- 23:48or something like that. And he calls her like
- 23:50fluffy, fluffy, fluffy or something. It's just
- 23:54like absurd. But then they'll they'll be holding
- 23:57each other. And he like one point he goes to
- 24:01like caress her cheek immediately clocks that
- 24:03she is not into it. Yeah. Like grabs her shoulder.
- 24:07Once the people leave the room, and it's just
- 24:09those two, she bites his hand. Yeah. It's so
- 24:13funny. And he even, like, winds his hand back
- 24:15to, like, hit her. Yeah. And then, like, I think
- 24:17he stops or Haggerty stops him. I think Haggerty
- 24:20walks in. He's like, whoa! Yeah. It's so funny.
- 24:23And, like, what's great is you see Jean kind
- 24:25of, like, falling. Jean Harlow. You see her kind
- 24:29of falling for Bill. Uh, because he's so good
- 24:32at putting on the charm and playing this performance
- 24:35that she is kind of believing his performance.
- 24:38Yes. There is not like actual chemistry between
- 24:40them. She's just believing what he is performing
- 24:42for other people. And it's easy for her to feel
- 24:46this way because Haggerty is so distant and like
- 24:48not committed. Well, it's not that he's not committed.
- 24:50It's just not his focus. He's just busy. His
- 24:52focus is work. Yeah. And he is always put that
- 24:55in the forefront. It felt a little bit like front
- 24:57page in that of, uh, I forgot the lead's name,
- 25:01but him choosing the paper and the editorial
- 25:05gig over his relationship, and they're about
- 25:07to move to celebrate their wedding. It felt like
- 25:12I see the similarities in front page, but I liked
- 25:16seeing the different side of that, of how Jean
- 25:18reacts to it. And I believe that she would fall
- 25:22in love with Bill. Yeah, because I would. Or
- 25:24at least a crush. Maybe not be in love. Oh, yeah.
- 25:27I mean, who wouldn't fall in love with William
- 25:28Powell? So a couple things about this. Obviously,
- 25:31Spencer Tracy, a big part of this movie. Myrna
- 25:34Loy was also pretty involved with this, obviously.
- 25:37But Spencer Tracy had a lot of fun ribbing Myrna
- 25:40Loy on the set of this film. They got pretty
- 25:42close. But while they're on set, he would do
- 25:44a couple things. One thing that I saw that I
- 25:46thought was very funny, worth noting that Myrna
- 25:48Loy at this time was recently married to a producer
- 25:51named Arthur Hornblow Jr. And to rib her a little
- 25:56bit, Spencer Tracy actually set up a table. in
- 26:00catering and called the table, I hate Hornblow.
- 26:05And then everyone who felt jilted by Myrna Loy
- 26:08would sit at the table and talk. So he set up
- 26:11a table to kind of like, you know, make fun of
- 26:13that. And I thought it was very funny to think
- 26:15of a table, like being a producer and walking
- 26:17on set and seeing the I hate horn blow on the
- 26:19table would be very funny. Some rumors about
- 26:23some possible affairs between Spencer Tracy and
- 26:26Myrna Loy. Obviously, I can't speak to any of
- 26:28that. But the fun facts of like, you know, little.
- 26:31jilts and little like ribs like that i thought
- 26:33was like fun yeah to kind of show that like they're
- 26:35having fun on set too without being inappropriate
- 26:37absolutely and when you often run into this actress
- 26:41hated working with this director it's nice to
- 26:44see these little like gags and pranks and just
- 26:47fun work environments absolutely and it kind
- 26:49of continues with gene harlow and william powell
- 26:51too because did you know that gene harlow and
- 26:54william powell were a couple i did not know that
- 26:57at the time of this movie they were together
- 26:58That explains the chemistry. Jean Harlow actually
- 27:01wanted to play Connie, the Myrna Loy part, because
- 27:04she would end up with Powell's character. Right.
- 27:06Right. But it's funny because she kind of gets
- 27:08a little bit of that here, too. And you're right.
- 27:10That chemistry is dynamite in this. And it makes
- 27:13sense because they're close, too. But you know
- 27:15what's almost more impressive to me? I don't
- 27:17mean to, you know, Guy watches Myrna Loy and
- 27:19William Powell in two movies and now he's obsessed
- 27:21with it. Guy. But. In this, it almost makes it
- 27:25more impressive how much I believe Myrna Loy
- 27:28and William Powell should just be together. Yeah.
- 27:30Because I know that she's married to Arthur Hernblow
- 27:32Jr. And he's obviously in a relationship with...
- 27:36Jean Harlow. Thank you so much. I almost said
- 27:38Joan Crawford. Jean Harlow. Where'd she come
- 27:40from? Jean Harlow. But you still believe them
- 27:44so well. Yes. And it doesn't feel like, oh, that's
- 27:47just the thin man characters falling in love.
- 27:50Oh, that's just the great Ziegfeld and his wife
- 27:52falling in love again. It just feels like it's
- 27:55Tom Hanks and Meg Ryan. Yeah. I understand that
- 27:58this is Sleepless in Seattle, but it's also Joe
- 28:00versus the Vulcan, you know, but it's also You've
- 28:02Got Mail. But damn it, I just want to see Powell
- 28:05and Loy fall in love. And that's all that matters
- 28:08to me. And to get that along with a fun comedy
- 28:12like this. I had so much fun with The Thin Man.
- 28:14The Great Ziegfeld exists. And then this. I think
- 28:19that's the best way to remember Great Ziegfeld.
- 28:20Yeah. Is I enjoyed it, but I understand one of
- 28:24these things does not belong between these three
- 28:26movies. Right. God, I had so much fun with this.
- 28:29Yeah. And it really is like there's no technical
- 28:34elements of this that like really stand out.
- 28:37It's filmed well. The industry has found its
- 28:41groove, its flow, and the baseline for a good
- 28:45movie at the Academy Awards, it's going to look
- 28:48good. I think when movies start experimenting
- 28:53and trying new things, that's when you see those
- 28:55nominations pop up, but this didn't have any
- 28:58of that. It did have a killer cast, and it had
- 29:01a great script, and it is just so much fun. And
- 29:05these are characters that you're familiar with
- 29:07or actors that you're familiar with and that
- 29:08you know and love. And it's kind of a weird one
- 29:13to talk about because it really is just us being
- 29:15like, I had so much fun. I know. This was great.
- 29:18But I was laughing out loud at William Powell
- 29:21in the river. I was laughing out loud at Myrna
- 29:25Loy in the river when she has to net the fish
- 29:27because she is screaming in fear of this fish.
- 29:32And when... When they pull the fish up and they're
- 29:35praising Bill Chandler's catch and all of that,
- 29:39and Father Allenberry is like, well, you've got
- 29:42to take out the hook now. And he's, no. No, you
- 29:47invited me. He was like, I would hate to take
- 29:49this legacy away from you if you'd be able to
- 29:52catch this thing, so why don't you do it? Exactly.
- 29:54And the look on Myrna Loy's face, she is so disturbed
- 29:59by this giant fish. It's, God, I love her. Myrna
- 30:03Loy. Me too. I think she is... I was talking
- 30:08with a friend of the pod, Ashton. She'll be on
- 30:12an episode here soon, no spoilers. I was talking
- 30:15with her about a movie that I think, probably
- 30:17my favorite movie of the year so far, Tuner.
- 30:20starring Leo Woodall. A lot of great things to
- 30:22say about it. Hopefully we get to talk about
- 30:24it in the Oscar year next year. I don't think
- 30:26we won't, but I hope so. And I was talking to
- 30:28her about how Leo Woodall should win the Cutiest
- 30:31Patootie of the Year award. And I think Myrna
- 30:35Loy is my current representative of Cutiest Patootie.
- 30:38Like, she is just so darn cute. Yeah. And it's
- 30:42like a button nose situation. Like, she is just
- 30:44so pretty in every single thing I see her in.
- 30:46And again, when she's partnered with William
- 30:48Powell, it's just hard not to look at both of
- 30:50them. Yes. I also want to say, you mentioned
- 30:52something about how this is kind of hard to talk
- 30:54about because it's just a series of, God, I love
- 30:57this. Yeah. It's... It's kind of also because
- 31:00it was only nominated for outstanding production.
- 31:02Exactly. We can't sit here and say, well, here's
- 31:04the cinematography, here's the sound recording,
- 31:06here's the score, because there isn't any representation
- 31:09of that in the Academy. So it's hard for us to
- 31:11kind of justify some of those things when even
- 31:14essentially the Academy is just like, hey, man,
- 31:16it's just good. Yeah. Like, yeah, but what's
- 31:18good? And they're like, it. Yeah. The movie.
- 31:20It was fun. It was a blast. The other thing I
- 31:22want to talk about. is kind of how unconventional
- 31:26a lot of this is. So obviously, you know, a big
- 31:29part of the story on this is that, what's Walter
- 31:35Connolly's name in this? You said father. James
- 31:37Allen Berry. Mr. Allenberry. Yeah, okay, so Mr.
- 31:40James. So Mr. Allenberry in this, he's obviously
- 31:43very interested in keeping out of the public
- 31:45eye and not having any controversy. So when he
- 31:48sees that his daughter is falling in love and
- 31:50getting more involved with this guy that he really
- 31:52likes, Bill, he then is shortly introduced to
- 31:57the idea that he's married and that he has someone.
- 32:00Because obviously all of this is leading up to
- 32:02they are trying, they being Warren Haggerty,
- 32:05to get a... photographer or a private detective
- 32:08to catch bill and um connie together so they
- 32:13can obviously have the fruit proof that they
- 32:15need to put in the paper that she is a man chaser
- 32:17but it becomes clear to uh father allenberry
- 32:22oh my god i keep saying conway father uh allenberry
- 32:24thank you that he's married and he tries to get
- 32:29to the bottom of this ultimately he ends up meeting
- 32:31his fake wife this is uh joan gene harlow i got
- 32:36there and when he meets her he's very much stay
- 32:40here my god do not be seen in public do not engage
- 32:43with anyone stay here i'm gonna go deal with
- 32:45it and this all leads to i think this movie could
- 32:49have had what it happened one night had where
- 32:51it's hey the last 15 minutes of this movie is
- 32:54us resolving what we've talked about over a series
- 32:57of incidents this is where Connie is going to
- 33:01find out that he's actually married, but not
- 33:03really. And this is where she's going to distance
- 33:06herself from him. But then they find themselves
- 33:07again. And you're just waiting for all that to
- 33:10happen. Right. And I love I was a big, big fan
- 33:14that this movie resolves that in a matter of
- 33:16like 90 seconds. Yeah. Because Warren Haggerty
- 33:20shows up at the house. This is, of course, we
- 33:23already talked about Spencer Tracy. Spencer Tracy
- 33:25shows up. And so does Jean Harlow. And they're
- 33:28at the apartment. with Bill and Connie. And this
- 33:33is where you're like, okay, Connie's going to
- 33:35find everything out and be so mad at Bill. And
- 33:36Bill's like, yeah, we talked about it. I told
- 33:39Connie everything. And she's cool. She understands.
- 33:41And we're still in love. So don't worry about
- 33:44it. And then he patches things up with Warren
- 33:48and Gladys. This is Jean Harlow's character.
- 33:50But in the process of doing so, Gladys isn't
- 33:53sure she really wants to choose Warren. Right.
- 33:55Right. And this is where Bill kind of sets him
- 33:57up and he's like, hey, if you like, let me punch
- 33:59you right now, you're going to be super vulnerable
- 34:01and she's really going to want to be with you.
- 34:03And that's exactly what happens. Well, that's
- 34:05the great moment is they are, first Gladys is
- 34:09like, you know what? I don't want to be with
- 34:12Warren anymore. I'm not going to give you your
- 34:13divorce. Yeah. I'm not doing it because I really
- 34:16like you, Bill. And Warren has never treated
- 34:19me right. So Connie takes the initiative here
- 34:22and she's like, hey, you. gorillas keep fighting
- 34:25i'm gonna go talk to her and she goes into a
- 34:27separate room and she explains like you know
- 34:30he's it was all an act like you're going to pursue
- 34:35this that isn't real and you're gonna be heartbroken
- 34:37trust me and at that moment you hear the men
- 34:42start to fight and uh the door is locked at this
- 34:45point for some reason so gladys is like banging
- 34:47on the door and she's like warren please let
- 34:49me out warren warren warren and it's when And
- 34:53Bill hears that, that he's like, hey, you dummy,
- 34:57Warren, you hear who she's calling? It's not
- 34:59me. She's calling for you. So I have an idea.
- 35:04And he socks him in the nose so that she'll be
- 35:07more sympathetic to Warren, which is exactly
- 35:10what happened. She comes out and she's like,
- 35:11oh, my God, what did he do to you? This brute.
- 35:13And she smacks Bill in the face. And I love his
- 35:16reaction where he's just like holding his nose
- 35:19immediately. And after everyone walks away, he
- 35:22just stands there and he goes, ooh. Like, it
- 35:27really hurt him. He is, look, in a time where
- 35:31we see a lot of, like, Clark Gables and we hear,
- 35:33yeah, like, he really, he's homophobic. Like,
- 35:37there's a lot of things. He doesn't want to portray
- 35:38any kind of femininity. It is amazing. And I
- 35:42know that Clark Gable's not alone. You see a
- 35:43lot of, like, masculinity and they're afraid
- 35:45to be, like, feminine. It is so relieving to
- 35:48see. William Powell just like it doesn't matter
- 35:52like what's masculine what's feminine what's
- 35:53funny right and like who I'm comfortable doing
- 35:57because I know who I am I love that and it's
- 36:00so much fun you see that in his pratfalls you
- 36:02see that in the way action of being hit or reaction
- 36:04of being hit by a woman like instead of like
- 36:07oh that hurt for a woman it's just more like
- 36:08how yeah yeah he's very like charming in that
- 36:12do you remember when he gets up after punching
- 36:14Warren And he's doing that like fisticuffs. He's
- 36:17like bouncing up and down with his fists. It's
- 36:19so good. It's great. And the thing I love about
- 36:22this too, this is where I would like maybe say
- 36:24sound recording has a chance, is that both Warren
- 36:28and Bill have... over their noses. Yeah. Because
- 36:33they're bleeding from their nose. And what's...
- 36:36This is kind of a fun thing. This is an indictment
- 36:38of the movie. I just thought it was kind of funny.
- 36:40Because of the code and everything, obviously
- 36:41blood wasn't going to be a part of it. At one
- 36:43point, Gladys walks up to Warren to check on
- 36:46his nose after Bill punches him. And she lifts
- 36:48up the towel. And she's like, oh, you're covered
- 36:50in blood. And if you reveal it, it's like...
- 36:52There's nothing there. There's nothing there.
- 36:54I thought it was really funny. Classic. But in
- 36:56doing so, Connie's father walks in. And he's
- 37:01like, what's the meaning of this? I know that
- 37:03woman as Bill's wife, and she was going to cause
- 37:05controversy. So what's going on? And I know Warren
- 37:07Haggerty from the publication that is trying
- 37:10to defame my daughter. And we're suing them.
- 37:14So what's going on here? And both Bill and Warren
- 37:16try to talk to him with the towels on their noses.
- 37:19So it's a very muffled like this kind of thing.
- 37:21And I thought the sound on this was great because
- 37:23you have Jean and you have or Jean Harlow and
- 37:25you have Myrna Loy trying to talk to him. But
- 37:28also you have Bill and Warren, not Wallace. And
- 37:31you have them trying to talk through the muffled.
- 37:34And what I love about this is it's such a wrap
- 37:38up ending. And it's almost kind of like, hey,
- 37:39guys, we got to make this 90 minute like thing
- 37:41where the last scene of the movie is him being
- 37:44inundated with information of he's like. What
- 37:46do you mean she's married to Warren? Right. And
- 37:49everyone's talking at him and it just kind of
- 37:51closes almost Looney Tunes -esque on his face.
- 37:53Yeah. I thought this was great. So what could
- 37:56have just been like 15 minutes of melodrama and
- 37:58like, you know, we know they're going to end
- 38:00up together. It really was them being like, yeah,
- 38:02you know what? We figured it out. We didn't film
- 38:05it. We didn't put it on screen, but we figured
- 38:06it out together. And now we're going to resolve
- 38:07things pretty quickly. Yeah. And I mean, this
- 38:10is where it gets super convoluted, too, because
- 38:12there's the whole thing of Bill's not going to
- 38:14divorce Gladys. But it turns out she was married
- 38:17previous before Warren. And there's like a whole
- 38:21thing there where, oh, well, they didn't actually
- 38:22get divorced or the divorce didn't count. So
- 38:25she was never married to Bill. And it's like
- 38:27it does not matter. It doesn't. It's such a mess.
- 38:30And one of those very similar to the Fred and
- 38:32Ginger movies where you're just like, what? Whatever.
- 38:36William Powell, Myrna Loy, Gene Hart. Like, that's
- 38:39what I'm here for. I don't care what's going
- 38:41on at this point. Well, there's like a there's
- 38:43a diversion, which is, hey, I'm not going to
- 38:46divorce you. I want you to myself. So you can't
- 38:48go off and marry Connie. That's diversion one.
- 38:51But then diversion two is, well, actually, I
- 38:54found out that you were married before this.
- 38:57So technically, you didn't get a divorce, which
- 38:59means you and I and our wedding or marriage is
- 39:02null and void. So we're not really married. And
- 39:05that's diversion two. Diversion three is, well,
- 39:08the divorce that I got was actually in this other
- 39:11country, and we found out that they banned divorces.
- 39:13So now I'm not actually divorced. Such a mess.
- 39:17Which means that, like, we are together. And
- 39:19basically the last diversion was like, okay,
- 39:22well, the guy who ordained us. Not there, or
- 39:24not ordained, but like married us, is not really
- 39:26ordained, so we're not really married. And they're
- 39:28like, hooray, we're happy. What is it called
- 39:30when there's like something random shows up at
- 39:33the end of a movie that is like the fix? What
- 39:37is that called? It's not plot device. I know
- 39:39what you're saying. I just don't know the term
- 39:41for it. I can't remember what it's called. Not
- 39:43MacGuffin, not Red Heron. It is. It's a MacGuffin.
- 39:45Oh, MacGuffin, okay. That is exactly what this
- 39:47ending is. It's just like, okay, that came out
- 39:49of nowhere. Never at any point did we hear about
- 39:51a previous marriage or anything like that. Yeah.
- 39:53But now we've resolved it with this MacGuffin.
- 39:55Yeah, I mean, let's talk about other scenes.
- 39:59Like, that's really what the movie is. It's just
- 40:00fun. If you are a fan of William Powell and Myrna
- 40:05Loy, the scene where they swim out in the middle
- 40:08of the night to, like, her lake fort. thing i
- 40:12don't know what that was yeah so she has like
- 40:15um a little shed like area that is uh a shed
- 40:19i mean it's big dude a big it is big so garage
- 40:22do you want to hear garage i i want to hear like
- 40:24grotto palace it's so fancy let's meet in the
- 40:28middle of grotto okay she has a grotto that is
- 40:30like put on like pallets and sent out like it
- 40:33is it is in the lake you keep describing it like
- 40:35like the the loser gang from it built this it
- 40:39is like fantastical it is fantastic like a raft
- 40:43i'm just saying she has okay you you want to
- 40:45hear it i'll give it to you she has a mini island
- 40:47yeah that is in the middle of a lake that they
- 40:49live off perfect she has a mini island that they
- 40:51go and like stay at and they're doing a midnight
- 40:54swim uh and this is all kind of a ploy to like
- 40:57be seen swimming midnight like under the moon
- 41:00and have like the photographs and everything
- 41:02or at least have uh bill's fake wife Jean Harlow,
- 41:07show up and accuse her of chasing her man. Yeah,
- 41:09this is the moment. But this is also the moment
- 41:12where we see kind of a side play by William Powell,
- 41:16where he's like, hey, I'm actually falling for
- 41:17this girl. You know what's probably easier? If
- 41:19we don't... jeopardize her uh fame and her like
- 41:23reputation yeah and instead i just sweet talk
- 41:26her to drop the uh the case altogether yeah and
- 41:30that's probably better but i have to lie to you
- 41:31guys and tell her she left she's not here so
- 41:33sorry and he has to like stand on the middle
- 41:35of the road in what is like a horror movie yes
- 41:37this scene is so funny because this movie is
- 41:41not even remotely scary but at one point they're
- 41:43driving late at night And it's Warren Haggerty
- 41:46driving. And he's with Gene Harlow. And I think
- 41:49there is a third man in the back who's like a
- 41:51reporter or a photographer or something. I think
- 41:53so. Or he's the private detective. That's what
- 41:56it is. Right, yeah. And he has them in the backseat,
- 41:59and they're driving in the middle of the night,
- 42:00and all of a sudden the camera cuts to be the
- 42:02front of the car, and you just see the headlights
- 42:04on the road, and you see a body. You don't even
- 42:07see William Powell. You just see a body emerging
- 42:10into the road, stopping them. And it's so, again,
- 42:13these movies are black and white, so it's so
- 42:15pale that it's like an apparition has appeared.
- 42:18Right. To terrify this vehicle. It's the start
- 42:20of every horror movie where they swerve out of
- 42:22the way and then it's like, there was nobody
- 42:23there. Yes. And he just stops them. They don't
- 42:26even really swerve. It's just more like, oh,
- 42:28and then stopped. And then Spencer Tracy is like,
- 42:31I'm looking for my daughter. That's a Silent
- 42:33Hill reference. That's exactly what happens in
- 42:35Silent Hill. Not even in my restless dreams was
- 42:36I going to catch that reference. Nope. See what
- 42:38I did? Yep. Okay. Nailed it. You're right. Like
- 42:41that's a scene of like seeing the romance between
- 42:43Myrna Loy and William Powell. But at the same
- 42:45time, William Powell trying to charm his way.
- 42:47out of this scenario so everyone can win um it's
- 42:50just another like i want to see william powell
- 42:52win especially when it means getting to myrna
- 42:54lloyd yeah it's so good look man i don't i don't
- 42:58want to be that guy that like i have that i i
- 43:02think it's the uh intended point of having myrna
- 43:06lloyd be as cute as she is yes but i have that
- 43:09like reaction where i see her on screen and i'm
- 43:13just like i think i love her You know, and like
- 43:16I catch myself like kicking my feet. Yes. And
- 43:18stuff. And I'm just like, oh, wait, wait a minute.
- 43:20So snap out of this. I completely agree with
- 43:23you. But I think I feel that way more about the
- 43:27two of them together where it's like that's mom
- 43:28and dad. Yeah. But at the same time, when they
- 43:32were at the Mojo Dojo Casa house or whatever
- 43:34that Myrna Loy has. Yeah. There were definitely
- 43:37moments where I was like, oh, man, I love them
- 43:40together. I'm going to need you to leave, William.
- 43:44And that's what we call Oedipal. Yeah. Yeah.
- 43:48No, I just think they're mom and dad in the sense
- 43:50of, like, I just want to see them together. Totally,
- 43:51totally. But Myrna Loy, no, I completely agree.
- 43:54It's also funny that you say that you don't really
- 43:55want to be a simp, although we have made many,
- 43:58many jokes about you being infatuated. With Bessie
- 44:03Love is one. I do love Bessie Love. There's someone
- 44:06else that you've mentioned that we've watched
- 44:07way more. Norma Shearer? Norma Shearer. I like
- 44:10Norma Shearer a lot. 100%. I like Norma Shearer
- 44:12a lot. It's just in Romeo and Juliet, her wig
- 44:16was just way too big. Yeah. Or at least whatever
- 44:18they did with her hair made her look like her
- 44:20head was two times the size. You know, sometimes
- 44:22I wonder if... If the podcast is like a bad place
- 44:26to kind of talk about like, oh, yeah, I really
- 44:29love her. I think she's beautiful. But I think
- 44:31we do a pretty good job of being like, yeah,
- 44:33William Powell is a hunk. He's so suave. He's
- 44:37so charming. But I often wonder like, you know,
- 44:41at what point does that become problematic? Oh,
- 44:46interesting. I think it's all a matter of intention.
- 44:49I think it's very easy to kind of like accuse
- 44:51someone of something, but the proof is in the
- 44:55intention behind the person. So I think we are
- 44:57far removed from any kind of like Tex Avery Wolf
- 45:02cartoon of like a wooga, bang, bang, bang on
- 45:05a table. But like, I think at the same time,
- 45:08the right way to think of it is what you just
- 45:10said, which is you can get it either way. Like,
- 45:13is this person beautiful? Sure. Is this guy handsome?
- 45:16Totally. Is he beautiful? 100%. Right. You have
- 45:19to be able to give it both ways. If we are saying,
- 45:21like, oh, he's a really good actor and she's
- 45:24beautiful, that's wrong. Because we shouldn't
- 45:26be doing that. But both of those things can exist.
- 45:30Yeah. Also, I think there's a very big difference
- 45:31of, like, oh, yeah, she's beautiful. And, like,
- 45:33I would part seas and move mountains to get to
- 45:37this person. Yeah, yeah. So there's, like, a
- 45:39yearning that I think sometimes can make it really
- 45:41creepy. But in this, it feels very tasteful.
- 45:45Not me about to describe the desire to go for
- 45:48a midnight swim with Myrna Loy as a yearning.
- 45:51And then you saying, I think the yearning element
- 45:54of it is a little creepy. Listen. But you aren't
- 45:56saying like, you're saying like, move over, William
- 45:58Powell, which is very cute and funny. You're
- 46:00right. What you're not saying is like, I have
- 46:02bought a scuba suit and I have found myself in
- 46:04it. And I will be time traveling. No, I just
- 46:06think that like. I understand, though. You know.
- 46:10In these movies, too, I think that's the way
- 46:12a lot of these stars are presented. It's an element
- 46:15of celebrity during this time period. And I think
- 46:18that you're kind of supposed to fall in love
- 46:19with a lot of these characters. And I think that
- 46:21this movie does a great job at making you fall
- 46:24in love with just about everybody that's on screen.
- 46:26Yeah. But it's... Myrna Loy and William Powell.
- 46:29So there's a lot of love to give there. Well,
- 46:31and also the other thing, too, that feels so
- 46:33good about the two of them is that we have not
- 46:35yet read anything that's like, they're very difficult
- 46:37to work with. Right, right. And if there is proof
- 46:39of that, whoever's listening to this, don't show
- 46:41us. Yeah, don't tell me. We don't need to know.
- 46:43But I think that helps it because we're like,
- 46:45hey, these two people are fantastic on screen,
- 46:49and I want to believe that they're just as fantastic
- 46:51off screen because I love them so much. And any
- 46:54evidence that you have to prove otherwise, do
- 46:56not show me. Because I want to live in this world
- 46:58where the two of them are actually that amazing
- 47:00and that much fun. But I have to believe that
- 47:03William Powell and Myrna Loy—I mean, look, we're
- 47:06introduced to Myrna Loy in The Thin Man with
- 47:08her, like, falling on her face, chasing after
- 47:10Asta. So clearly, neither of them are afraid
- 47:13to, you know, be the butt of the joke because
- 47:16they're so confident in themselves. Yeah. So
- 47:19all of this, you know— You were right to say
- 47:22at the very beginning that this is difficult
- 47:25to talk about because we enjoyed it so much and
- 47:27because it was just nominated for Outstanding
- 47:28Production. There's not a lot that you can get
- 47:31into with the plot points and talk through it
- 47:33because who wants to hear that? But instead,
- 47:35I think the main takeaway from this is if you
- 47:38enjoyed The Thin Man, if you enjoyed the chemistry
- 47:40of great Ziegfeld and nothing else, and you want
- 47:44to relive that in a Ginger Rogers, Fred Astaire
- 47:47-like musical of that time without the music,
- 47:51that this is the movie to go see. Yeah. And I
- 47:53don't think this is like the best movie of the
- 47:55year when we talk about these Oscar nominations.
- 47:58I mean, Doddsworth, we both raved for about an
- 48:00hour and 10 minutes about how much we enjoyed
- 48:03a very difficult subject tackled in such a unique
- 48:06way for that time. Right. Even I think if we
- 48:08saw a movie from 2026 tackling that way, we're
- 48:10like, wow, how interesting. So in that sense,
- 48:13I loved this movie and I had such a good time
- 48:15with it. And I'm not afraid to go ahead and jump
- 48:17into it. I gave this four stars. I'm going to
- 48:19give it four stars as well. I think we both know
- 48:22this isn't like a five -star classic, like you
- 48:24can defend it to the end of the days. But at
- 48:26the same time, you just have so much fun with
- 48:28it. That's what it is. It's so much fun. And
- 48:32I could rewatch this movie over and over, I think.
- 48:37The four leads in this movie are so enjoyable
- 48:40and entertaining that I just want more. And I'm
- 48:44so happy that there's so much more Powell and
- 48:46Loy. to come but like gene harlow and spencer
- 48:50tracy are also so dynamically funny in this and
- 48:54i just want to see more of everybody it's such
- 48:56a blast uh i completely agree i also want to
- 49:00call out real quick um off pod right before this
- 49:02started i told you kyle about how i received
- 49:05a text from a friend of the pod ashton and uh
- 49:10That I have a song stuck in my head because of
- 49:11her. Oh, yeah. And I just checked my text and
- 49:14she said she was looking forward to the shout
- 49:15out. So she bangs, she bangs. There you go. That's
- 49:19so funny that I forgot what song it was and I
- 49:21was getting ready to hear Pants on the Ground.
- 49:24Pants on the Ground. So. What's that? You don't
- 49:28know that song? What is that? That's from American
- 49:29Idol. The guy that came out and he's like. William
- 49:31Hung. No, no, no. That's. What you were doing.
- 49:35Yeah, She Bangs with William Hung, yeah. I'm
- 49:36talking about... Oh! You know Pants on the Ground?
- 49:39This guy didn't get past the audition. Looking
- 49:40like a fool with your pants on the ground. Yeah,
- 49:42oh my God. That's what I thought you were going
- 49:44to sing. I forgot all about that. Well, how can
- 49:46you forget, man? Well, because he's not William
- 49:48Hung. Do you want to get into double features?
- 49:50Yeah. Okay. So, I'm going to start because I
- 49:52don't love my double feature. Okay. I haven't
- 49:55seen this movie in a long time, and I remember
- 49:57really enjoying it. And... Now, when I think
- 50:00about revisiting it, it kind of makes me a little
- 50:02sad. But it is kind of like a more modern day
- 50:05screwball comedy that hinges on a couple that
- 50:09are in love and then they aren't really in love
- 50:12because things go kind of rough on their honeymoon.
- 50:15But then they learn how to fall back in love
- 50:17together, which I think is kind of like Gladys
- 50:19and Warren in this movie. So I'm going to go
- 50:22with the 2000 film Just Married with Ashton Kutcher
- 50:26and Brittany Murphy. Oh, yeah. Oh, yeah. Yeah.
- 50:29I get sad about Brittany Murphy. We're both very
- 50:33big King of the Hill fans. Yes. So Luanne. Rest
- 50:37in peace, Brittany Murphy. Yeah. All right. So
- 50:39let's talk about my double feature. So I picked
- 50:43My Man Godfrey. Oh. 1936, directed by Gregory
- 50:47LaCava. So this is another film that not just
- 50:51came out this year, but also starred William
- 50:54Powell. This is William Powell, Carol Lombard,
- 50:58and Alice Brady. I picked this. I haven't seen
- 51:02this. I actually just told you off pod that I
- 51:04picked this up yesterday on Criterion DVD. Yeah.
- 51:07Very excited. We don't have to watch it for the
- 51:09pod, but I love William Powell so much that now
- 51:12I'm going to test this out. And sans Myrna Loy,
- 51:16do I like William Powell as much? This is what
- 51:18the test is. I'm excited to see. But the plot
- 51:21of My Man Godfrey just sounds so... Right in
- 51:25line with libel lady in the sense that Carol
- 51:28Lombard's character picks up Godfrey, played
- 51:32by William Powell, who's like in a dump in like
- 51:35the East River to play as her partner. And she's
- 51:40a socialite. So he has to kind of play the part
- 51:42and trick everyone into believing that he is
- 51:44in a relationship with her. And if William Powell
- 51:46does one thing well, it's convince people that
- 51:49he is charming enough to be a socialite husband.
- 51:53I'm very excited to see it, but just the synopsis
- 51:55alone and William Powell coming out in the same
- 51:56year, it feels like that's destined to be talked
- 51:59about. I'm going to watch it before the ceremony
- 52:02episode as well. Let me know when you need to
- 52:04borrow it. Yeah, will do. So, I meant to say
- 52:08this at the top of the pod, so sorry that I missed
- 52:10it, but we'll drop it here. You can always reach
- 52:12out to us at outaopodcast at gmail .com. Also,
- 52:16join the Patreon so you can have a lot of fun
- 52:19benefits, including getting the episodes early,
- 52:21our Horror of the Overlooked episode that drops
- 52:23on the 13th of every month, and all the fun benefits
- 52:28that come with the Discord and getting to vote
- 52:30in polls. A lot of fun there. We also talk a
- 52:33good bit about the ability to... Contribute by
- 52:37writing questions to us and asking questions,
- 52:39letting us know what should win Best Picture
- 52:41instead. All those things are underneath the
- 52:43Patreon, and we appreciate any and all contributions
- 52:46so we can continue to run this podcast full steam.
- 52:49Absolutely. The next film we will be talking
- 52:52about is Three Smart Girls, which I know nothing
- 52:56about. Well, I do. You know why? Because I surround
- 52:59myself with just the best women. Damn it. All
- 53:03the women of my life. You know what? I know so
- 53:05many more than three smart girls. I know thousands
- 53:09of smart girls. I do, too. Wow. Yeah, okay, man.
- 53:12Way to piggyback on my compliment. You're right.
- 53:15Tell you what I know a lot about is one dumb
- 53:18guy. Yep, we'll be covering that. Make that two.
- 53:22In 1989. Well, yeah, we're dumb. Yeah, three
- 53:27smart girls. I'm very excited to talk about that.
- 53:30And we only have three films left in our coverage
- 53:33of 1936. We are coming. closer to the close of
- 53:37the ninth academy awards which means if you guys
- 53:39are interested in voting for who you think deserves
- 53:42best picture or you want to get emails into us
- 53:45now's the time to do it uh it's always the last
- 53:48sunday of the month which will be the 27th of
- 53:51september so get them in before then but yeah
- 53:54look forward to three smart girls i think that's
- 53:57it that's it as always i'm kyle i'm ryan and
- 54:00we'll see you at the movies