Latest / Lantern Voices / Exploring Topics in Non/Human Coexistence, Part 1
Transcript
- 0:14Welcome to Lantern Voices, a podcast by Lantern Publishing
- 0:18and Media. The opinions and information expressed in this podcast do
- 0:22not necessarily reflect the views of Lantern Publishing and Media
- 0:26Incorporated. Hello everyone. It is great to have you back here with
- 0:30us. Welcome to Lantern Voice, a podcast by Lantern Publishing
- 0:34and Media. My name is Louisa. I am your host for this episode. Our introduction
- 0:39for this episode will be a little bit longer, but that is because we have
- 0:42so many amazing guests. We got a very special two part
- 0:46episode for you today and it's one of our new releases Exploring
- 0:50topics and Non Human Coexistence. In this first part we talked
- 0:54with editor Nathan Poirier and author Stanley Trinetti and Lucrezia
- 0:58Barucca. In two weeks from now we'll release part two with three
- 1:02more authors that contributed to this book, Amanda Williams, Mark Tsushita
- 1:06and Varun Joshi. Exploring Topics in Non Human Coexistence is
- 1:10a collection of essays that talk about living and coexisting in a larger than human
- 1:15world. The authors come from many backgrounds and the essays talk about topics
- 1:19such as black transfeminism, brahminical vegetarianism,
- 1:23spirituality, humane education, and actions that
- 1:26go beyond education when it comes to animal rights activism. The book came out
- 1:30March 6, 2025 and it is available for purchase everywhere you buy books including
- 1:34on ebook format on our website. Stay with us here until the very end
- 1:39of the episode to get a special discount coupon on our ebook store for
- 1:43all books ever featured here on Lantern Voices. It is the
- 1:47first time that we have so many guests in an episode and the first time
- 1:50that we have a two part episode. So after you hear both of them,
- 1:53let us know what you think about this format. You can leave your thoughts in
- 1:56the comments if you're listening to this episode on Spotify or YouTube or Apple
- 2:01podcast, but if you're in a different platform, that's okay too. Just let us know
- 2:05how we're doing on our social media. We are at lanternpm on Instagram and Bluesky,
- 2:09Lantern Publishing and Media on Facebook and LanternPM official
- 2:13on TikTok. So let's go to today's interview.
- 2:17Nathan, Emily and Lucrezia, welcome to Lantern Voices.
- 2:21Hello everyone. Welcome. How are you all doing today? Great.
- 2:24How are you? I am doing great as
- 2:29well and I'm very happy to have you here at Lantern Voices with us today.
- 2:31Thanks for having me. Thank you very much. I will start presenting
- 2:36you all to our listeners, but I would like you to do that a
- 2:40little bit. So my first question is how did you end up as
- 2:44contributors to this Book, what was your journey to get here? And we were talking
- 2:48before the recording a little bit that you do know each other, that you had
- 2:52great conversation before. So how. How did that happen? Who are you,
- 2:55and how did you get here today? Emily, why don't you go ahead? I mean,
- 2:58okay, I feel like you should go because you're the one who, like, at least
- 3:01brought me into this, but, okay, I guess I'll go. So, yes,
- 3:06my name is. My name is Emily. Pronouns are she, hers. And I had the
- 3:10pleasure of attending the anthrozoology program at Kenesha
- 3:14University with Nathan and then also two of the other editors,
- 3:18Sarah and Aaron. And I think it was
- 3:212018 is when I graduate, graduated the anthrozoology
- 3:25program. And then a couple years later, I started my own business
- 3:30called Coexistence Consulting. So when Nate reached
- 3:34out to me about the book, was very excited because the topic of coexistence
- 3:38is something I'm very passionate about. And I was also just really
- 3:42excited to just deepen my connections with some of the colleagues and
- 3:47friends that I had made throughout the anthrozoology program, including.
- 3:50Including Nathan here. And then also at the time when Nate contacted me
- 3:54about the book, I was a doctoral student at Antioch University,
- 3:58specializing in humane education. And my
- 4:02very first day of the program, I met Macy Sutton, who has a background
- 4:06in human health and vegan advocacy, which, you know,
- 4:09paired well with my background in animal wellbeing and anthrozoology.
- 4:13And so we have since collaborated on several projects
- 4:17and have become, like, very dear friends. And so it was.
- 4:22It just felt like the perfect fit to ask her to co write the chapter
- 4:26that I wrote for. That we wrote for this book. And so, yeah, it was
- 4:30just a really fun experience to, again, like, reconnect with.
- 4:34With Nate, Sarah and Aaron, and then to work with
- 4:37Macy and to now see the chapter published. Amazing. All right.
- 4:41So I guess on my involvement. So I am an editor
- 4:46and a contributor. The contributor role I consider much more incidental to
- 4:50this project. The editor goal or role was much more intentional.
- 4:55So this book was so viewed by myself,
- 4:59as well as Sarah Tomasello, the lead editor of this book,
- 5:03as a extension of a previous book Sarah and I
- 5:07did together. So we put out a call for chapters for a book three
- 5:11years ago now. And we got a lot of responses, almost overwhelming.
- 5:14So we decided to do two books. We split the responses up into
- 5:18sections or chapters, ideas that seem to make sense together.
- 5:21So one book was one general idea, and this coexistence
- 5:25book was A second idea. So a lot of the chapter ideas seem to work
- 5:30together well, so we kind of split them in two in this way. So that's,
- 5:34that's kind of how we came to this book. Sarah and I have been academic
- 5:38partners for a while. We've done a lot together. And so we were
- 5:42looking to edit together and we did. So this is the second book published that,
- 5:46that, that her and I have edited because Sarah and I also went to this
- 5:50Kinesius. Well, Sarah went to Kinesia for undergrad and the anthrozoology
- 5:54graduate degree that Emily, myself, Aaron, and maybe one or two others
- 5:59from this book did as well. We wanted to make this more of a Kinesius
- 6:02affair. Once we kind of realized that and got Aaron on as a third,
- 6:06we were. We were looking to extend that connection kind of as deeply as we
- 6:09could get it. And then having, in terms of having any chapters in this book
- 6:13myself was mostly an opportunity. Since this book was happening
- 6:17and I had some ideas, I figured this is a good place to just go
- 6:21ahead and put. So my name is Lucrezia Barucca and
- 6:26my pronouns is she. So basically, at the
- 6:29time of the call for contributors, which I remember correctly
- 6:33was around May 2022, I was studying environmental humanities
- 6:37at Troposcript University in Venice. And particularly
- 6:41I was attending a course on critical animal studies where
- 6:45I discovered about this call and was suggested to send any of
- 6:50my ideas for contributing to the book. And so it was a beautiful
- 6:54coincidence because I had. I had been working on
- 6:59this topic of suffering, which was my contribution to
- 7:03the book even before starting the master. And actually I must
- 7:07say also that it was thanks to those researches that I ended in this
- 7:11field of study. In fact, I had written my final thesis
- 7:15of bachelor about the unnecessary suffering of non
- 7:18human animals according to some less known works of Russian
- 7:23writer Lyftos. However, my research had never been published and
- 7:27therefore this book was the opportunity to bring a part of
- 7:31it to light. I just sent my ideas to
- 7:36the. To the editors and we had some discussions then.
- 7:40And working with them was amazing because we could exchange our ideas
- 7:44and they've always been like, very, very available to
- 7:48accept what was my view on things
- 7:52and how to write them. But at the same time it was the first time
- 7:56also that I was being edited. So it was interesting
- 8:00to me to see this editing process, how it worked and also
- 8:05to accept for the first time that someone could put hands on
- 8:09my work. So I really appreciated it as a. As an experience,
- 8:13this collaboration process. How was it to work on the book
- 8:17with other people and not just by yourself. Do you want to go first,
- 8:20Nathan? I can. Yeah, sure. So, yeah, editing with
- 8:25multiple editors. So I've edited multiple books every time
- 8:28with at least one other person. And I prefer that.
- 8:32It's just nice to collaborate. So when there's more
- 8:36than one person, you can also split tasks, which really helps with
- 8:40responsibilities and what you do or
- 8:43what you feel like doing, what you're stronger in doing or weaker in doing.
- 8:47You can complement each other. So that's one of the things we were looking for.
- 8:51And since this became. In the sense this non human coexistence book became the second
- 8:54book when that was not our plan, Sarah and I, we were looking for more
- 8:58editors to help with that workload, since now we are looking at two books instead
- 9:02of one. So we had this idea of bringing on other people.
- 9:05And we both have worked with other people. And since Sarah and
- 9:09I had already worked together and collaborated, we knew that was good. We felt like
- 9:12we could bring others on. And so that's really what happened.
- 9:16I mean, Aaron and Mark, well, I knew both of them, and so I
- 9:20figured they would be good to work with, and they were good to work with.
- 9:23And so we just had a lot of communication. That was the big
- 9:27thing is we would let each other know when we were available, what we wanted
- 9:31to do, like what chapters we were maybe most interested in reading, or more
- 9:35like editing so that we could play to each other's strengths.
- 9:39And we just kind of saw who was available for what throughout
- 9:43the whole process and split this pretty evenly. The editor name order
- 9:47is rather arbitrary. We put Sarah first on purpose because
- 9:51this was again, part of a collaboration
- 9:55between her and I. So her name and my name
- 9:59switch order as we alternate when Sarah and I collaborate on things.
- 10:02But Sarah took a lot of the lead on this book and making a lot
- 10:06of the bigger decisions and such good working with people. And I
- 10:10mean, I would even edit with five people, but four is a good number.
- 10:13But it's just nice to have other voices in the mix, other opinions and.
- 10:16And strength. Yeah, I would definitely echo that experience.
- 10:20I mean, for. For me, it helped with collaborating
- 10:24with someone who I had collaborated with in the past. And,
- 10:28you know, the. The fact that Macy and I have also are also friends,
- 10:32you know, made it, like, a very enjoyable experience.
- 10:35And in many ways, Macy and I work very
- 10:40similarly, but we also are very different too,
- 10:44kind of, you know, Nate, like what you were saying about kind of bringing out
- 10:47the different strengths, like, that was definitely my experience writing
- 10:52with Macy. We both have definitely have different writing styles and
- 10:56just slightly different ways of thinking about things while
- 11:00also still kind of having those same core values. So I felt like it
- 11:04helped broaden the perspectives that we could incorporate
- 11:09into the chapter while also kind of holding true to,
- 11:13to, to the goal of the, of the chapter. And yeah,
- 11:17I just, I personally really enjoy collaborating. I feel like if
- 11:21given the opportunity, I will collaborate with someone on things just because again,
- 11:25you, you end up expanding the perspectives that you
- 11:29can incorporate and you are, you're able to,
- 11:32to hopefully also reach, reach a wider audience through, through,
- 11:36you know, bringing in more voices. So I'm a big fan of collaboration.
- 11:40That is so true. I think the three of you have similar,
- 11:44yet different experiences with this project. It's very interesting because we're talking
- 11:48about coexistence and yes, we're talking about coexistence with non human animals,
- 11:52but it's also coexistence with your fellow authors
- 11:56and with everybody making sure that this project is going to come in unity.
- 11:59One of the things that I love the most about all the anthologies that we
- 12:02have and essay collections that we have at Lantern, and it's something that I read
- 12:06in the book, in a Brazilian book a while ago, is the importance
- 12:11of having multiple voices in contemporary nonfiction writing.
- 12:15Especially because we're so hyper connected with Internet and everything that
- 12:19we, we can benefit from that we don't need to have like a single point
- 12:23of view anymore, and we can use that to our benefit. So my next question
- 12:27is for Nathan, but everyone can jump in if they like.
- 12:30Is that right? At the introduction, the editors talk about non
- 12:35interference as a guiding principle. So,
- 12:38Nathan, can you talk about how the principle of non interference connects
- 12:42with the book's title, Non Human Coexistence? And I think that that forward slash
- 12:46instead of a hyphen was a very intentional choice. And I think it
- 12:50has to do with this. Yes, it is. So I will, yes, talk about
- 12:54that forward slash specifically. First, though, connecting Non Interference to
- 12:58the title, at least the title, the part of the title, Non Human Coexistence.
- 13:02I basically wrote those parts of the introduction on this idea. And so this was
- 13:06an idea I've had for a while. I really liked the idea of Non Interference,
- 13:10of leaving others alone to a good extent. So when it came time
- 13:14to write this introduction, it was at a time when I kind of felt lost
- 13:17for ideas. And so what I decided to do is kind of
- 13:21bring some things together. I had written in various places, fairly fragmented
- 13:25parts of ideas that were unpublished and bring
- 13:29them together. And I just kind of thought that would also fit the book as
- 13:32well because people were fairly fragmented in reality. The non interference idea
- 13:36was something that I had written about in school papers and
- 13:40I had talked to people about and I've just heard other people write
- 13:45about it or talk about it. And every single time, I don't think I have
- 13:49I had ever encountered someone talking favorably about this idea.
- 13:53And every time, not only was it not favorable, but there seemed to be a
- 13:56knee jerk negative reaction whenever I brought it up to
- 14:01the extent where people really just didn't want to listen. They had preconceived ideas
- 14:05and thought non interference was ridiculous. And so
- 14:09it just kind of annoyed me for a long time. And while I was a
- 14:12student I kept it a little quieter because you're still building confidence at that point.
- 14:16And so I thought this book was then a really good opportunity to
- 14:20put this here as kind of a statement and to flesh it out a little
- 14:24bit more. And there's a couple reasons, a couple big reasons why I think non
- 14:28interference works as a good underlying principle for non human coexistence.
- 14:31And one of those is that many, if not most of us in the world
- 14:35these days are disengaged from nature. Now we are very separated
- 14:39and that may not be by choice, but we are. If our modes
- 14:44of civilization were cut off. Most of us do not know how to procure
- 14:47food. Most of us do not know how to build shelters or even maintain our
- 14:51own shelters. We do not know how to find water or purify it
- 14:55for drinking. Any of us that rely on medications or even things like glasses,
- 14:59we would be in major, major trouble if civilization were
- 15:03to collapse. And so my thought there is that we
- 15:08don't know what we're doing. And so if we try to intervene in non human
- 15:13nature, we are not going to do a good job, at least by and large
- 15:16many individuals. We just won't be able to do it. We don't have the knowledge.
- 15:20And if we. And so I think it's a bit arrogant to think
- 15:24that we can just interfere in various ways and that things are going to be
- 15:28okay. And the second reason related is kind of anti mainstre Anthropocene
- 15:32thinking. And that is specifically there's maybe only about 2 million species
- 15:36that are known, but there's easily up to something like 50 million or more species
- 15:40that are believed to exist. And so we only even know about, and we don't
- 15:44necessarily know much about many of those species we do know about. But we only
- 15:48know a small fraction of the total species that exist. So again, I think
- 15:52it's pretty arrogant to think that we can just control life, that we can control
- 15:55biological, chemical, physical processes, when we hardly really know anything that's
- 16:00even out there. So a lot of this reason for the non interference stems from
- 16:03a general human ignorance and arrogance. And that's, and that's of course not in
- 16:08every single person and whatnot. But I think those,
- 16:11those reasons do kind of override in general. And then
- 16:16to connect this to the non human coexistence, but particularly non human with
- 16:20a slash is with that wording we wanted to
- 16:24bring together humans and non humans, but also allow for differences.
- 16:27And so I think the slash accomplishes that when human and non human are brought
- 16:31together without a space, without a word, and, but they're also kept slightly separate
- 16:35with that forward slash. So it kind of brings together but allows for differences.
- 16:39And this is a little bit awkward to read as well as maybe a little
- 16:43bit awkward to think about. But that was the point is we wanted to
- 16:46provoke thought and draw people's attention to this idea. What about bringing together but
- 16:51allowing for differences? And I don't even know if non slash human is considered
- 16:54a word. If you add that slash, what happens? And that's part of the awkwardness
- 16:58and the thought that we really wanted to provoke. And then this also
- 17:02extends to humans in general as well. So some of the reasons I was giving
- 17:06before about humans not knowing what to do really about or in non human nature,
- 17:10but leaving other people alone I think also works really well. And in
- 17:15particular I think of things like colonialism and gender colonization should not
- 17:19exist because in those sorts of instances those people should have been left alone.
- 17:23It is not okay to just take over another culture or to wipe
- 17:27out another people. If instead the colonizers
- 17:32had left them alone, I think we'd be in better shape and similar for gender,
- 17:36especially right now with this whole two gender, you know, issue and
- 17:40defining it that way, you know, that's, that's nonsense. And so if someone
- 17:45hears of a gender that they don't know or that they don't
- 17:49understand, I think just leave it alone. Like you do not need to bother people
- 17:53who are identifying in some way that's not harming anybody.
- 17:57And so if we just left that alone, right, let people be
- 18:00in those sorts of respects, I think we'd be a lot better off.
- 18:07We know the vegan activist community is out there and we want
- 18:11to connect with each and every one of you. We are proud supporters of
- 18:16initiatives that fight for a more compassionate world for all animals,
- 18:19humans and non humans alike. For more content on
- 18:23vegan activism, follow Lantern on social media. We are Lantern Publishing
- 18:28and media on Facebook lanternPM on Instagram and
- 18:32@laneNPMofficial on TikTok.
- 18:38My first thought is when you were. Talking about that forward slash and what made
- 18:42you think. I think the first time that I was looking into it I.
- 18:46My first like when I first read the title it was like, oh, you're talking
- 18:49about coexistence. You're talking about humans and non humans coexisting together.
- 18:53So that's why it's the slash because everybody is kind of one,
- 18:58one single, I don't want to say entity but like world, universe, we're all inhabited
- 19:02in the same place. And those are some topics that are touching some of the
- 19:06essays. So that was my first thought. When you talk about non interference
- 19:11and people have like a knee jerk reaction, why do you think that happens?
- 19:15I think because negative or bad
- 19:20versions of terms get popularized.
- 19:24The same sort of thing happens with various ideas
- 19:29like antinatalism. That was a topic we
- 19:33had in, we emphasized in the first book with Sarah,
- 19:37as well as things like human extinction or something I came across recently that,
- 19:41that evokes the same story sort of thing and,
- 19:45or anarchism. And so I think people just get.
- 19:49There's a popular imagination of terms and I'm not necessarily sure where it
- 19:53comes from. It's probably different for different terms, but a lot of things just get
- 19:56propagated. So like with antinatalism, what always comes to people's minds
- 20:01is coerced restrictive reproduction.
- 20:04And that's not what antinatalists are talking about. If you actually go
- 20:08read them, that's not what they're talking about. And so, but that's important,
- 20:12that is an important idea and that is related.
- 20:15And somehow people pick up on this stuff and they just run with it.
- 20:19And I can tell because people who make these sorts of accusations
- 20:23of well, this is what that term means and that's ridiculous and you shouldn't use
- 20:27it. When I go read the literature of these terms like I do,
- 20:30that these people are dismissing, you see that it's completely different than all these
- 20:34people dismiss it as. So clearly these, these reactions are coming from a place also
- 20:38of ignorance. And so I, I think it's just one of outright dismiss from,
- 20:42from popular things that they hear and, and don't think to
- 20:46go interrogate themselves. So we wanted to put this out there and make people confront
- 20:50it. You Know whether they liked it or not. Yeah, I just wanted to jump
- 20:53in and say that, you know, I thought that the editors did such
- 20:57a great job of describing this concept in
- 21:02a way that does really explain the
- 21:05benefits of non interference. And, and, and also maybe
- 21:10put some of those minds at ease that might have that, you know, initial reaction.
- 21:14Because I think, I mean, even if I'm being like,
- 21:18you know, if I'm being reflective,
- 21:20you know, I also had that kind of like, reaction at first,
- 21:25like, how could we possibly not interfere with other animals when we're so
- 21:29connected with them? And, and also I think that there's this, I mean,
- 21:32obviously there's the one piece that the, the control piece, right. We like to,
- 21:37humans like to be in control. And this idea of not interfering
- 21:41means that a loss, maybe a loss of control, which obviously humans
- 21:45aren't big fans of. But I, for me personally, I also felt like,
- 21:49oh, non interference, that's like taking away
- 21:52these relationships that I have with other animals. And that
- 21:56doesn't feel good. But obviously the deeper I
- 22:00dug into this and especially like reading, you know, how the editors spoke
- 22:04about this, that's not really what it's about, at least how
- 22:07I interpreted it. There's of course going to be situations
- 22:12when it doesn't benefit the other animals
- 22:16to be in relation with humans, and we have to respect that. But of
- 22:20course, in the immediate term, you know, we are living with companion animals.
- 22:25There are billions of farmed animals on this planet. Like,
- 22:29there are animals that we necessarily have to interact with that we have to,
- 22:33you know, be in relationship with. And so to me, this idea
- 22:37of non interference really is, comes down to like,
- 22:40understanding the perspectives of the other animals and, and determining
- 22:44how, how they would choose to
- 22:48engage with us and allow that to lead those interactions
- 22:53and relationships. And so yeah, I, I just really appreciated
- 22:57that perspective. And, and also, you know,
- 23:00that, that you did explore Nate, that you like, explored kind of the
- 23:04nuance of like, we do recognize that there are situations where,
- 23:09you know, interference and interaction might
- 23:13have to occur. You know, of course we can't just like, I can't just stop
- 23:17taking care of my dogs and my cat. But there's
- 23:21also so many examples. Like even in my relationships
- 23:25with my dogs and my cat, for example, if I'm embodying this idea
- 23:29of non interference, you know, to the best of my ability, I'm attending
- 23:33to how they want to interact with me. Like, do are.
- 23:37Do they consent to me touching them to,
- 23:41you know, like. And so I think that that kind of this
- 23:45Idea of non interference kind of, at least for me, again forces me
- 23:49to take a step back and to kind of
- 23:53question what our relationships and interactions with
- 23:57other animals could be if we actually attended
- 24:01to what they want and
- 24:06need and not imposed ourselves,
- 24:10you know, as humans, you know, into their, into their lives,
- 24:14if that makes sense. It's like attended and respected in a way because
- 24:18from what I've learned reading the book, even if you have the best of
- 24:22intentions, it's not about doing what you think it's best because usually people,
- 24:25and that would include non human animals and that people know what's
- 24:30best for them so they also know what's best for them. We don't
- 24:34have to like put ourselves in this pedestal. So I think that's, that's what I
- 24:38grasped from the context that you're talking about is not interference. Yeah,
- 24:42I agree. Like it's about actually and Nate, I feel like this also kind of
- 24:46speaks to what you mentioned earlier about when you were talking about
- 24:50how humans like we don't, we don't, we don't even know. We don't
- 24:54really know about the other animals, the other, the,
- 24:57the other species, the other beings that we share this earth with.
- 25:02And so, you know, who are we to, to see
- 25:06ourselves as the, the, the ones that must control or
- 25:11manage. Yeah. And they. I would love to hear if you have any like follow
- 25:14up thoughts or if, if any, if I misinterpreted your,
- 25:19you envision this concept kind
- 25:23of coming to being like, I would love to hear your thoughts. So whenever you
- 25:27put an idea out there, it's open to interpretation. So I, you know,
- 25:30realized that any, any way anyone or any contributor interprets that is,
- 25:34is fine. Realized we opened it up to that if we were going to publish
- 25:38it. But no, I think that's, that's, it's great the, the way you're thinking
- 25:42about this too. But just one small other comment I wanted to say
- 25:46is Louisa brought up respect. He said that word respect. And I
- 25:50swear I read this somewhere, but respect implies
- 25:54restraint. And so that's, that's the idea here. If you actually respect
- 25:58others, then you need to restrain yourself from interfering
- 26:02on them to a harmful extent. In a sense. It's that simple.
- 26:06It's that simple. I think in theory, but it's, it's can be much more complicated
- 26:10in practice. When I was talking about the choice for the forward
- 26:14slash and I was talking, now we're talking about respect, restraint,
- 26:17coexistence and all I think the word I was looking for
- 26:21was a word that Lucrete puts in her chapter that is
- 26:25interbeing. So I'll try to hook this
- 26:28a little bit with what you were talking about in your chapter, to sum it
- 26:32very briefly, based on what I understood in my own words. So please correct me
- 26:35if I understood something wrong. Interbeing would be the idea that everything that is
- 26:39human, non human, alive or not, it's not only connected, but actually one and the
- 26:44same. And you talk about this idea when it comes to understanding suffering and more
- 26:47specifically, what types of suffering are necessary and others that can be eliminated.
- 26:52Can you talk a little bit about that? Because I think talking about
- 26:56pain and suffering, it's. It's something that's a little down, but it's out there in
- 27:00the world. So it's something that needs to be addressed. Yeah. I start my reflection
- 27:04by understanding suffering according to the Buddhist principle of interdependent
- 27:09rising, that is, in other words, the inter being, as you've
- 27:13mentioned. And there the Buddhist philosophy identifies the origin
- 27:17of suffering like an innate trait of life, as is said
- 27:21by the first of the four number. So in this sense I argue
- 27:25that as everything inter is, even life and
- 27:29suffering, inter are, and that is the kind of suffering that is defined
- 27:33as necessary, as it is part of the experience
- 27:37of life itself. So without suffering there would be no
- 27:42life. And following this, I consider that if we inter
- 27:46are with everything else, even our experience of life
- 27:51as well as that of suffering, inter are with the experiences
- 27:55of life and suffering of the others. And thus I
- 27:59reflect upon the invisible chain of events that
- 28:03can link to apparent distant
- 28:07experiences which seem therefore having
- 28:10nothing to do one another. Here I come to
- 28:15understanding that any particular experience, even that of even
- 28:19one of joy, pleasure or happiness, is inextricably
- 28:24linked with any other kind of experience which
- 28:28can be of the same sort or completely different and even opposite.
- 28:32An obvious example relates to eating. Imagine this lovely
- 28:36family finally together for Christmas around their rich
- 28:40table, which they have prepared with lots of love and care.
- 28:44However, forgetting that eating animals means supporting
- 28:49the chain of events that is linked to their experience of pain
- 28:52and suffering. And a good reason about this which
- 28:56I mentioned is this moral table King
- 29:00of Assyria, written by Lef Tolstoy,
- 29:03which perfectly fits this kind of life entanglements.
- 29:09Instead, another example that I use that shows two complementary
- 29:14appearances of suffering is that of slaughterhouses workers
- 29:18and their animals to slaughter. Whereas this relation can be
- 29:22considered a case as a case of shared suffering.
- 29:26And therefore, to come to the point, all this reasoning finally
- 29:30shows that on one side there is a kind of suffering
- 29:34which I called vital in the sense that it is vital
- 29:38to life and that we need to accept as part of
- 29:42our existence. And another one, which what interests me
- 29:47and I think interests also our speech is what
- 29:51I name unnecessary suffering that is caused
- 29:55by intentional violence and lack of love. And this kind of suffering
- 29:59can surely be alleviated, if not even eliminated,
- 30:03thanks to the awareness we develop towards the weight of our actions
- 30:08and the interdependence of our experience of life with that of
- 30:12others, both human and non human. And I
- 30:16would just add that this also resonated with what we said
- 30:20about the non interference principle, according to me.
- 30:24So when I read it I thought, oh wow, we are actually seeing
- 30:28some similar things concerning this. But also sometimes accepting
- 30:34some kind of suffering that we can't help means not interfering
- 30:38with it. And in other cases we can
- 30:42witness a suffering that we can help and therefore interfere according
- 30:46to what might be right. And so I
- 30:50also think that it resonates with this kind of. Which you were
- 30:54talking about in the very end. Now, with the principles of non interference,
- 30:58there is one chapter, one episode of this podcast that
- 31:02we recorded with Jess Bug, who wrote you had to be thoughts on
- 31:05ecological grief in the Anthropocene, published by Lantern. And she
- 31:09mentions about helping a caterpillar across the road.
- 31:13Just like it's not going to make a huge impact, but it's
- 31:16going to make a difference for that caterpillar. And we were joking. Oh wait a
- 31:20minute, that's the literal butterfly effect. Because how things happen
- 31:24later. And that to say is I, I kept,
- 31:28kept that, that thought kept going in my head. I still think about it every,
- 31:31every so often. I bring it up in other episodes here in the podcast fairly
- 31:35often, but it's because we were talking about
- 31:39respecting what animals want for them. But at one point,
- 31:43if you have a road that shouldn't be there, we already interfered. So by
- 31:47helping the caterpillar we would just be making sure like
- 31:51it's almost like a non interference because it's a double interference. Kind of
- 31:55tricky also to establish this line that says when we
- 31:59are really interfering and we're not. But yeah, as you said, it's.
- 32:03We might need like. I think the research that has been done already
- 32:07gives us some, a lot of hints, but it's sure that there
- 32:11would be, we would need way more research about this in order to also
- 32:16be way more aware of when actually
- 32:20we are interfering and going beyond this line
- 32:23or not. Yeah. And if I might, I mean this notion
- 32:27of, of us having already interfered. And then fixing our
- 32:31negative interference is definitely another layer of things. And that's,
- 32:35that's something Emma Maris talks about a bit in maybe
- 32:40both her books, but especially the more recent one that definitely deserves its own treatment
- 32:44as well. But there is a difference between like pushing your original thought,
- 32:49like continually trying to correct the original action versus
- 32:53taking other actions that can make up for it. And so rather
- 32:57than constantly like just kind of saying here moving animals
- 33:02around to fix the environments we've damaged for them, let's just stop
- 33:06harming the environment. I think that's the idea. And at one
- 33:09point in the book, multiple people mention about how easy it would be for
- 33:14nature to regenerate if we're not here messing it up.
- 33:17So. And I think we all saw that in 2020 when I everybody was home.
- 33:21Lantern Publishing and Media is devoted to sharing messages of
- 33:25compassion. Our books inspire a better world by telling the stories of
- 33:29animal rights activists, climate activists, and the fights
- 33:34for a world where everyone can live in harmony, no matter their species.
- 33:37Lantern is a 501c non for profit organization.
- 33:41Your donation helps us keep our work going. If you can,
- 33:45go to lantern lanternpm.org donate to
- 33:49help us with any amount. Once again, the website is lanternpm.org
- 33:55donate. Your generous gift enables you to support
- 33:58our collective mission to inform, inspire and educate.
- 34:02Thank you very much. Emily.
- 34:05In your chapter, you and Macy say that
- 34:09humane education acknowledges and embraces this inevitable discomfort
- 34:14through its emphasis on critical reflection and community. I got that quote
- 34:18from the text. Do you have any examples you have experience of
- 34:22effective humane education? You mentioned we see it more often geared toward
- 34:26kids. Have you seen situations in which it was implemented with
- 34:29adults too, or just effective examples
- 34:33that we can use for reference? Yeah, absolutely. I appreciate you asking
- 34:38for examples because I think it's so easy to talk about some of these
- 34:42different concepts and ideas, but to really envision what it, what it
- 34:46actually looks like in real life is really important. I think
- 34:49it's hard for me to choose like, just one example, you know, like in the,
- 34:53in the case or in, in our chapter, we make the case that human education
- 34:57is, is a practice. So it's, it's something that anyone and everyone can
- 35:02integrate into their daily interactions with other humans.
- 35:06You know, of any age, whether that's interacting with a friend or family
- 35:09member or if you are working in spaces. Like, one of the things
- 35:13in my work that I've talked about is how, you know, like veterinarians
- 35:16or people who are working in animal shelters, like, we can be integrating
- 35:20these concepts that we have that humane education
- 35:24proposes into, into these conversations that we're
- 35:28having. And so I've been doing this for several years now.
- 35:32I've, and I've definitely experienced how human like a humane education approach
- 35:36can promote like a more coexistence centered
- 35:40perspective. So for example, I often teach about non
- 35:44human agency and consent. And you know, I could very
- 35:48easily kind of vilify people for not being more
- 35:52considerate of other animals, you know, or kind of keeping with our conversation about
- 35:56interference and non interference. Like I could certainly vilify folks for
- 36:00interfering with other animals, for not respecting them. But I
- 36:04try to approach them co learners with
- 36:09this kind of empathetic recognition that we have all been
- 36:13conditioned to ignore what other animals want
- 36:17and need. We there have, there are many systems of oppression at play
- 36:20that rely or that benefit from our kind of ignorance
- 36:25of, of the realities of other animals. And so
- 36:29when I'm discussing these things with people, I try to help people
- 36:33feel like it's not completely their fault that there
- 36:37are these other larger systems at play. And so
- 36:41when we can feel that way, when we, when we realize that, when we can
- 36:44bring awareness to that, I think it kind of creates these doors for us to,
- 36:48to, to kind of one critically think, but also to
- 36:52feel like we maybe have some power to change. And so as
- 36:56part of this process, like I'll also kind of bring in like stories of
- 36:59specific non human animals because that always helps
- 37:03people kind of feel open and excited to chat. So like I'll talk about
- 37:07my friend Pearl, the sheep and how like she would communicate with me that
- 37:12she was consenting or not to an interaction. Just like throughout this process
- 37:16of, of empathizing and sharing stories,
- 37:20we, it helps to create this space where we can
- 37:24critically reflect and discuss. We sometimes have to like face
- 37:28the uncomfortable truth that we are participating in harming
- 37:32other animals, even those we care most about, even like the dogs and cats
- 37:36in our homes. And but one, we, once we do that,
- 37:40like once we can see that we are not supporting
- 37:44the agency of other animals, once we can understand that
- 37:49they do communicate their consent to
- 37:53us through their behavior and body language, we can start to imagine
- 37:57what different relationships with them can look like.
- 38:00And if we're doing this in a space of like vulnerability and accountability,
- 38:03accountability, you know, kind of in community with one another,
- 38:06we can then better face that discomfort and move
- 38:10through it and again imagine new ways of being. And so for
- 38:14me, as I'm describing this, like this is humane education, like this is
- 38:19if you read the chapter for listeners. You know, you'll notice some of the things
- 38:23that I just shared as part of this example come up in as part of
- 38:27like the strategies that make up humane education. So storytelling and critical
- 38:31reflection and empathy, you know, fostering empathy.
- 38:35The results I've seen from this, from like having these kind of conversations with folks,
- 38:39from telling them about my friend Pearl the sheep and our,
- 38:43you know, interactions that we have and how she, even when she wants a neck
- 38:47massage, she'll approach me and kind of stretch her neck out and maybe
- 38:51lay down and rest her head on my, my lap. Those, those are all her
- 38:55ways of, of communicating with me. Like people.
- 38:58It, it really hits people in a different way. Like they, they become just
- 39:02more open to the possibilities of how we can, how we
- 39:06can be in relation with other animals. I've had like seasoned animal
- 39:11advocates, like other professional humane educators,
- 39:14like, approach me after like my, like presentations or, you know, the, the talks
- 39:18I've given on this topic. And I've shared that they, their perspectives
- 39:23have changed, that they, even though they've been interacting with animals their
- 39:27whole lives, that they are suddenly now questioning,
- 39:31you know, how they, how they have interacted with other animals and are excited
- 39:36to go out into the world with this new perspective.
- 39:39And so I think that of course part of this is
- 39:43like the novel kind of topic of non human consent. Like, I think
- 39:47that that's very impactful. But I also believe that integrating humane
- 39:52education strategies into how I teach about this topic is what
- 39:56has made it so impactful. I definitely think that, like,
- 39:59embodying the role of humane educator and how we teach and communicate with
- 40:04others can play a really powerful role in promoting coexistence.
- 40:08When I was reading your chapter, it reminded me a little bit about my experience
- 40:12in school growing up because I went to a Catholic school and
- 40:16more specifically a Franciscan school. So we learn
- 40:20a lot about nature and animals in a very, very early age because of
- 40:24religious teachings. And they would bring us to
- 40:28the school farm where we would be able to hang out with the cows,
- 40:32with the sheep, with the turkeys, where we could grow the vegetables and
- 40:36all that we could hang out. They had special reptil room that we
- 40:40could hang out with the reptiles and fibians as well. We had just for frogs,
- 40:45a whole section that was just like a conservation program and frogs
- 40:49that they were doing. So it was very nice. But at the same time I
- 40:53was thinking maybe I had humane education growing up. But then I realized that when
- 40:57all that animal coexistence with me became to a point that
- 41:01I was like, why am I consuming them? I should not. I should go
- 41:05vegetarian, should go vegan. I would have meals in
- 41:09school because we had a school that was the entire day. There were few options
- 41:12that were vegetarian. I turned vegetarian at 13 and
- 41:16I was like, what am I going to eat now in school? So it's the
- 41:19same school that it was giving me that message was also not providing the
- 41:23support needed. And I was like, no, I don't think that could be considered inhumane
- 41:26education because one thing doesn't kind of walk hand in hand with
- 41:31the other. Yeah, I mean that's definitely,
- 41:34definitely speaks to a lot of the,
- 41:37the conflict that we see in traditional education. And,
- 41:42and also I, you know, I think it's important to point out that humane
- 41:46education has been like as a field or as a concept has been around
- 41:50since like the late 1800s. And there's definitely different,
- 41:54different approaches to it, different perspectives about it. And certainly
- 41:59the way I approach humane education, the way I was taught about humane education,
- 42:02like from the institute, there's this,
- 42:06they, there's definitely this movement to make humane ed. Humane education more
- 42:11comprehensive, to really recognize how the,
- 42:15how different systems of oppression contribute to suffering and how
- 42:19we as individuals can ideally participate in
- 42:23taking action to hopefully cause like the, the most good
- 42:27and the least harm in our day to day lives.
- 42:30And so with that approach in mind,
- 42:34at least speaking for myself as a human educator,
- 42:37I'm thinking about even if I'm teaching about other
- 42:41animals, am I still causing harm if I'm including
- 42:45them in that educational process without attending to
- 42:49their agency and consent? So thinking about like you were talking about your experience,
- 42:54how you had other animals present in your educational
- 42:58experience, what are those messages that we're sending? If other animals are
- 43:02present in that, in that setting, against thou actually considering their
- 43:07consent, did they want to be there? Did they want to be participating
- 43:11or interacting with a bunch of children? And also where did they come from?
- 43:14Did they want to be taken from, from their homes or.
- 43:17And so there's that piece and then there's also another big part of
- 43:21humane education is that critical reflection piece is that acknowledge
- 43:25is that piece of acknowledging our assumptions and biases and
- 43:29in our cognitive dissonance. So to teach
- 43:33about other animals and trying to promote
- 43:36compassion towards them, but at the same time participating
- 43:40in their harm, you know, again, in my opinion isn't true humane education.
- 43:44Yeah, we're talking so much about cognitive dissonance lately, I've been feeling it's
- 43:49a topic that's been catching a lot of people's attention for good,
- 43:52hopefully, because it is something important to talk about.
- 43:56And with that being said, I'm kind of in the same topic.
- 44:00My next question is for Nathan. In your essay you make a case
- 44:04for including veganism and non human animal liberation. And it talks specifically
- 44:08about the thesis constructed by the author, Chiara Bocci.
- 44:12Did I pronounce their name right? I'm not fully
- 44:17sure myself yet. I've only written that name out and I am
- 44:21not sure 100 how to pronounce it. But I think the last name I would
- 44:25go with Bhatati Bodichi. Okay, Chiara Bodichi then.
- 44:29So in Chiara's book, Anarcha Feminism
- 44:33and now my accent is showing off. I promise that I'm not
- 44:38a native English speaker, so I'm doing my best with my accent here.
- 44:41Do you think there are issues in not explicitly including animal liberation,
- 44:46when humans talk about total liberation? I think your, your chapter talks
- 44:50a lot about that, but can you go into more details about what those issues
- 44:54are? Yes. So this is something
- 44:58that I look for all the time when I read essentially I'm
- 45:02looking for consistent ethics, I'm looking for a total liberationist ethics,
- 45:05what I, what I might call that. And so the issue here
- 45:09was I read that book and I loved it. And so part,
- 45:14part of that book was it's essentially framed as like
- 45:17the first all encompassing anarcha feminist theory. So there's been
- 45:21lots of writings on anarchic feminism, but they're usually smaller. Bhatat sheet
- 45:25really brought things together and gave it a, like a coherent grand
- 45:29framework and went with it. And so I'm really
- 45:33drawn to ideas like that. And so my natural instinct
- 45:36was then, okay, how can we extend this further? Bhadaji is clear that
- 45:41they are not theorizing some complete and closed theory. It is open and evolving.
- 45:45And so my thought was, well, what's missing? What else can be added to
- 45:49this? How can we extend this nicely, nicely put and laid out theory
- 45:53here? And so when I read that Vatici does include
- 45:57non human animals, they are periodically referred to, they come back
- 46:02to them, but the word vegan is absent. And so
- 46:06that was my hang up here. And the reason for that is that anthropocentrism
- 46:10is, if not the norm, I don't know if it'd be the norm over
- 46:15the world in terms of numbers, but at least it's the dominant ideology.
- 46:19So what I worry about is reading a book like Anarchy Feminism and many
- 46:22others is that people could read that they could read the phrase animal liberation in
- 46:27that book and they could read this holistic theory
- 46:32and ethics and they could walk away from that book not understanding
- 46:36that they need to be vegan. If they, if they buy into that theory,
- 46:39if they believe it, if they think it's convincing. That's what I wanted to insert
- 46:43and that's what I wanted to make clear is that is a clear implication and
- 46:46it's a clear part of what Bhattachi is doing, whether or not that's what they
- 46:49intend to do. And I leave that open in the chapter about maybe that was
- 46:53part of their intention and that's cool. But non human animals and veganism specifically,
- 46:57as wide as that term should be understood, is easily and often overlooked
- 47:01if it is not specifically named. So even when people say
- 47:06things like total liberation or freedom for all,
- 47:10often that's an anthropocentric, or if it's not anthropocentric,
- 47:14it includes some non human animals, or if it includes non human animals, maybe it
- 47:17doesn't include plants and so on, and it doesn't actually mean all. And so
- 47:22I'm really trying to emphasize that point here of yes, individual groups
- 47:26need to be named, because if they're not, then another thing I worry
- 47:30about is individuals among those groups don't see themselves named.
- 47:35And so they're looking at a theory and think, well, I'm not included
- 47:38here, the others are named, I'm not named, and that's a
- 47:42problem. And so I think the specific mentioning is indeed
- 47:46important so that others recognize, yes, what this person's doing is
- 47:50including me, or at least trying to. That's also true with non
- 47:54human animals. And being vegan in particular, is that some may easily
- 47:58think, even if they include non human animals in their thoughts and ethics, practices,
- 48:01practices, whatever, they might not
- 48:06still understand what vegan implies. And if you really care about non human
- 48:10animals, you would have to be vegan. And people
- 48:14all the time think exploitative and harmful practices mean liberation.
- 48:18A lot of people that are into animal welfare think that's essentially animal liberation.
- 48:23And it's not, it's the opposite of animal liberation. And I think of this,
- 48:27you know, there's, there's instances all over the place. I think of an article by
- 48:30Neal Stephens on in vitro meat, which is a whole topic, but meat
- 48:35grown from animal cells. And in, in an early article on the topic,
- 48:39Stevens describes killing a small number of animals as animal liberation just
- 48:43because we're not killing them in large numbers. That seems absurd to
- 48:47someone like me who reads that Or Ben Goldfarb, in a recent
- 48:52book called Crossings on Road Ecology, describes how he doesn't think taking long
- 48:57distance trips in his car or going fishing is contradictory to
- 49:00respecting animals in the environment. And this whole book is about how roads
- 49:04and cars are bad for the environment and non human animals. And so that's what
- 49:08I mean is readers can read these things that seemingly are inclusive but still
- 49:12not walk away understanding that veganism must be a part of their ethics
- 49:17if they care about what's being written and that some of these writings are often
- 49:20contradictory. And so I didn't frame the chapter
- 49:24in terms of all that, but the, that's what I'm trying to do here.
- 49:26And so my addition, this is not, I do not consider
- 49:30this a critique of Bhadaji, but it's an addition, it's a contribution.
- 49:34It's not aimed at Bhattaji themselves,
- 49:37but the imagined, my imagined readers of this volume
- 49:41who could read this and walk away thinking one thing and acting
- 49:45a different way. And this sort of reasoning is also I realized after the fact.
- 49:49But it's the same reasoning that Bhattachi titles their book Anarcha
- 49:53Feminism. The prefix anarcha they use to refer to all women and
- 49:57that's, that's one of their points there, is that types
- 50:01of feminism are often exclusionary of types of women.
- 50:05And that's not okay. So Bhata QI was partly bringing
- 50:10this theory together to be particularly inclusive. And so I'm just trying to,
- 50:14to stretch that logic in its own direction just a little bit further.
- 50:18It's interesting how we read a lot about liberation
- 50:22for all and many very important scholars around
- 50:26there, but it seems that every time you're talking all, all you're talking about
- 50:30non human animals and nature and all that seems like you're branding
- 50:34the content in a certain way and that people, oh, so this
- 50:39is just for animal activists. This is not going to be for everybody.
- 50:42It's almost like authors are a little scared of being too vocal
- 50:46about it because they're afraid that their content is not going to reach far enough.
- 50:50Yeah, I think that word scared, I'm glad you used it. I think that's
- 50:53a lot of it is is authors are scared either for the implications that I'm
- 50:57kind of talking about is what do they have to actually step up to with
- 51:01the words they are saying, or they're afraid at putting off people
- 51:04so people won't read their stuff, or they will critique it instead of talking
- 51:09about it positively, or they're just trying to appeal to more people, which I
- 51:13consider problematic. Essentially they're watering down their theory,
- 51:17they're appealing to mediocrity instead of, instead of trying to make an
- 51:21actual impact. So I think that that is an issue here.
- 51:25And I just think we should always be thinking wider. And an issue I've only
- 51:30very recently, since January come into is this issue of outer
- 51:34space. And so that's another realm that I realize I have overlooked and I think
- 51:38Bhatici overlooked as well. Bhatici stays terrestrial. And they're
- 51:42all very well may mean all. But outer space matters too. There are entities
- 51:47there there and that. That should be protected just like everything else.
- 51:51And so that, you know, we really need to be constantly trying
- 51:55to expand our minds and challenge ourselves. What are we leaving out?
- 52:00What are we doing that's not consistent with our beliefs? You talk about outer space.
- 52:03I'm not going to go too far into it because it's not an area that
- 52:06I know much, but it is something that seems so much
- 52:10bigger than us that is kind of scary that it's almost like there's
- 52:15nothing that we can do that can interfere with it too much because it's just
- 52:18so big. But we have history, Humans have
- 52:22history. And we've interfered with some pretty big things so far.
- 52:25Yeah, I realize that's not part of a topic right now, but it is,
- 52:29it is happening. That's. That's very real. Outer space is not mere science fiction
- 52:33or dealings with outer space is not mere science fiction. They are not hypothetical ideas.
- 52:37That stuff is starting to happen. But I think this relation, it would
- 52:42be very well thought of in terms of with outer space,
- 52:46humans in outer space, or Earth in outer space in terms of inter being stretch
- 52:50that idea as well being one in
- 52:54and of the entire universe. Because I think that applies.
- 53:00If you're. A human being living in the 21st century,
- 53:03chances are that you check your email every day.
- 53:06Also, chances are that your inbox is constantly pretty full.
- 53:10We know how important it is to keep up to date with things that matter.
- 53:14This is why our newsletter is so amazing. We only send one
- 53:18newsletter a month and within it you find all our latest news and
- 53:22sometimes access to exclusive content.
- 53:25Recently we went through all our contacts and did a huge cleanup.
- 53:29Trying our best to make sure that no one is in the list multiple times
- 53:33and no one's gonna keep getting tons of emails. We want
- 53:36to keep you informed without overwhelming you with a thousand messages.
- 53:41We know you don't have time to waste with 100 new emails. Give your time
- 53:45to what ready really matters. Go to lanternpm.org and
- 53:49sign up for our newsletter today.
- 53:54So Nathan was talking about how not only on Earth,
- 53:58but also with the space, with everything that is around us,
- 54:02with the universe itself. This idea of interbeing, do you think that it
- 54:05applies also not just for plants and earth animals,
- 54:10but also for whatever it's out there in the universe? I mean, yeah, for sure.
- 54:14When. I mean, when we imagine interbeing, as I
- 54:18want to mention, it's that we have to imagine
- 54:23that everything is interconnected. Even of course,
- 54:26not just applying to the restaurant, but also the universe, because everything
- 54:30is part of everything else. And so if you think about anything
- 54:34that's happening here, even just the fact that we are alive actually is
- 54:38because of, you know, sun and everything that actually
- 54:43exists in the universe. So yeah, for sure, everything relates.
- 54:47My next question that I have is for all of you. So a
- 54:51topic that seems to connect all your essays is the idea of thinking collectively while
- 54:55at the same time addressing individual needs. This book does not advocate
- 54:59for needs of the many versus needs of the few. It actually invites us
- 55:03to think about the possibilities of a larger than human world.
- 55:06So what are, do you believe, the main challenges that we have to overcome
- 55:10in order to get this information out there and make sure that people know and
- 55:14have access to this knowledge? I was. Yeah, still referring to this
- 55:18idea of interviewing. I think that there are many things that we can learn
- 55:22from that and find. Yeah, overcomes and challenges thanks to
- 55:26this idea as well. And I felt that if we simply understand that
- 55:30actually there is no separation between our individual existence
- 55:34and rest of the existence, we get this possibility of
- 55:38entering this larger than human space where we
- 55:43all belong together to the unity of things, and we
- 55:46all belong to each other at the same time. And following this
- 55:50one example that I quickly wanted to mention is
- 55:54that this can also be applied to the idea of love of
- 55:58itself, for example, which is one of the conclusions that I
- 56:02come to at the end. Because when we mention love,
- 56:05of course that should also apply to the idea of
- 56:09love. For example, since I perceive love as a rich power
- 56:14of an endless source and think that we should stop thinking about it
- 56:18in a separate way, in the sense that it will up something or someone that
- 56:22prevents us from loving something or someone else. On the contrary,
- 56:26whenever we generally love, we expand the amount of love in the
- 56:30universe. And so it follows that the possibility of love multiplies
- 56:35instead of splitting itself up into smaller
- 56:39parts. And once again then, it is fundamental to give importance to what we
- 56:43do daily. The quality of our actions and our love.
- 56:47And this should help us to, I don't even want to say to
- 56:51use the word build, but create more and more a larger
- 56:55than human space around us in our communities and share
- 57:00this way of inhabiting the universe.
- 57:03And in this sense we should not anymore think that we
- 57:07are the ones that can teach to others how to live.
- 57:10But since, since finally these others are us and
- 57:15they can also, they can learn from us as much as we can
- 57:19learn from them in this mutual exchange of love and possibilities,
- 57:23I would answer that the first challenge is to overcome
- 57:27any separation and then to learn better to communicate
- 57:31with others and understand the needs even
- 57:34when they communicate in a different way than ours as
- 57:38animals do, for example. And finally
- 57:42to love fully and authentically. And I know that
- 57:45this might sound a little theoretical, but finally I feel like
- 57:49it follows a bottom up reasoning and can be applied to communities
- 57:54and society as a basic principle to then build
- 57:57things upon. Yeah, I really love that.
- 58:01I feel like my answer to this kind
- 58:06of question is very similar. But I think that you,
- 58:09Lucrezia, just described it in such a way that I
- 58:14feel like will resonate with a lot of people. But yeah, I mean, I think,
- 58:16you know, speaking to like the challenges that we,
- 58:20that we're up against, you know, we're, we're certainly up against
- 58:23these various like systems of oppression like white
- 58:27supremacy and capitalism and speciesism or anthropocentrism.
- 58:31And so and I think that these systems of oppression
- 58:35require us to believe that coexistence
- 58:39isn't possible. In order for these oppressive systems to exist,
- 58:43we have to believe that it isn't
- 58:47in our best interests as individuals to coexist, to be in
- 58:51community with each other. And of course I, I mean I would like to believe
- 58:54that that's not true. Right. Like I'd like to believe that equitable interspecies
- 58:58coexistence is indeed possible and that we don't have to compete
- 59:02for resources. You know, we don't have to strive for power in
- 59:06order to have a good life. And so yeah, I think I very much,
- 59:10I love this idea of inter being and, and I think that coming to
- 59:14understanding, coming to understanding that, to embodying that
- 59:18I think would, would be so impactful. You know, I think we, we have to
- 59:22expand our ability to care for individuals. You know, kind of going back to
- 59:26your question, Louisa, like we have to care for individuals
- 59:30not only for ourselves and our immediate family, but also the individuals
- 59:34in our local community and then expand our idea of what community is
- 59:38and to have that not only include other
- 59:42humans but also the more than human world. And then we have
- 59:46to I think also, and I think this kind of relates to this concept of
- 59:49inner being. Like recognize that our individual well being is what makes up
- 59:54the collective well being. And so we are very much all
- 59:58inextricably interconnected and, and then in terms of
- 1:00:02like getting this information out there and making it accessible. Of course I'm
- 1:00:06clearly biased. That humane education I think would be a great strategy
- 1:00:10for. For at least one of the strategies for, for helping to.
- 1:00:14To start to shift these perspectives again.
- 1:00:17Like I think we can all, in our own work, in our own day to
- 1:00:20day lives, strive to cultivate critical thinking and empathy and
- 1:00:24compassionate action and to try to promote
- 1:00:28these ideas of interbeing, of interconnectedness with the goal
- 1:00:32of striving for coexistence despite the challenges that we
- 1:00:36face. What I would respond to this question of the main challenges
- 1:00:41to overcome and the way you put this Louisa,
- 1:00:44about getting information out there and making sure that people know things
- 1:00:48or know about certain things. I think it would be interesting see
- 1:00:53what would happen if people became comfortable with not knowing,
- 1:00:56not understanding and respecting that
- 1:01:00difference. You know, I remember a time when someone told me that
- 1:01:04while they have a dog and they enjoy dogs and they
- 1:01:08think it's fun to have relationships with them, they always value human
- 1:01:12relationships more because we understand each other or can understand each
- 1:01:16other better or more deeply. And I disagreed.
- 1:01:20I think the fact that we can have relationships with non
- 1:01:24humans precisely because they are not human,
- 1:01:27that that is way more fascinating that that can actually exist.
- 1:01:32That it does exist, that that sort of communication exists verbal and nonverbal.
- 1:01:35That to me is way more interesting than conversing with someone that I know knows
- 1:01:41the same language and body language and customs are things that I
- 1:01:45do that to me is very boring. It's normal. And so the fact.
- 1:01:49But if I'm communicating with a dog or anyone is neither one
- 1:01:53of us knows the other's world and we will never know the other's world.
- 1:01:57We just won't. There's an inherent limitation, there's a physical limitation. It'll never be overcome.
- 1:02:00And that's okay. Not only is that okay, I think it's exciting,
- 1:02:04it's wonderful. And that sort of not knowing is the limit I acknowledge
- 1:02:09and respect. And I think it makes the world so much more interesting.
- 1:02:13And as something also like plant studies blossoms
- 1:02:17right to use a plant metaphor these days, kind of behind animal studies.
- 1:02:21That idea is really big there of that Plants may have
- 1:02:25intelligence, they may have consciousness, they definitely have communication, but it
- 1:02:29is such a foreign to humans type of those things that we just,
- 1:02:33just don't understand them. And we can't. They don't have. We don't have the same
- 1:02:37physiological parts yet we have similar
- 1:02:40ways of being things that are intelligible
- 1:02:44in a roundabout way through ourselves. But we will never know what it's like to
- 1:02:47be a plant. And plants may never know that thing called a human exists or
- 1:02:51if that sort of thing even makes sense. But it's that unknowing that
- 1:02:56I think makes life so fascinating and just gives it the infinite
- 1:03:00possibilities for bringing people together if we can respect that sort of difference. I think
- 1:03:04we're always talking about learning more and knowing and also embracing
- 1:03:08the unknown. Even if we're talking about human relationships, you, you can
- 1:03:12never be 100% sure what's going on in somebody else's head or how they are
- 1:03:15feeling and experiencing the world. And yet we try to empathize or
- 1:03:20we are empathetic.
- 1:03:27Do you love new books? Do you need more titles about
- 1:03:31veganism, animal rights and climate activism on your bookshelf?
- 1:03:34Then go to lanternpm.org and check out all our
- 1:03:38books and ebooks available for purchase. You can find anything from beautiful illustrated
- 1:03:43picture books that introduce children to the values of compassion for our fellow
- 1:03:47animals to thoroughly researched non fiction books that give
- 1:03:51you all the facts to help you live a healthy, healthy vegan life.
- 1:03:55Go to lanternpm.org and explore all of her
- 1:03:59books today.
- 1:04:03My second to last question for everyone again
- 1:04:07since finishing writing for this book. What are the signs
- 1:04:11of hope? Moments of joy glimmers as some people put it. Have you
- 1:04:15witnessed in your life in regards to moving towards a world in which humans
- 1:04:19can coexist better with the more than human world? Well,
- 1:04:23I, I did have to think really hard about this question just because it can
- 1:04:26be hard, especially increasingly. I feel like it's just increasingly challenging
- 1:04:31for me sometimes to to find hope.
- 1:04:35But it is. You know there is still moments
- 1:04:40or glimmers of joy and I do there are certainly people
- 1:04:44like the people in this Zoom room today do give me hope that
- 1:04:48inspire me. And actually since finishing the chapter for
- 1:04:52this book, I started teaching undergrad and graduate students in
- 1:04:56animal behavior and anthrazoology programs. And my
- 1:05:00students definitely give me hope. Like they are so passionate about
- 1:05:04the well being of other animals. Many of them are already out in
- 1:05:08their communities promoting coexistence in different ways.
- 1:05:12Many of them are just, just so passionate about goody
- 1:05:16And I just. I feel like. And liberation. And so it is truly
- 1:05:21an honor to support them in their journeys. And. And yeah, they.
- 1:05:25They definitely give me hope. And I think concerning me I actually so because once
- 1:05:29again, when I also when I was writing my chapter, I kind of did this
- 1:05:33little storytelling. So I started from the past of
- 1:05:37my life, let's say. And I was reasoning on how my
- 1:05:41research was also affecting my life or helping my life
- 1:05:45as well. And so I guess one of the most beautiful phenomenon that
- 1:05:49I witnessed was really concerning my private life.
- 1:05:52And basically what happened is that I started
- 1:05:57to get close to all this research on suffering. But as well
- 1:06:01I started to get close to first
- 1:06:05vegetarianism and then veganism around my 20s.
- 1:06:08And I feel like. I claim I had these two different
- 1:06:12phases of which the book was kind of in between.
- 1:06:15So during this first phase I basically. It was a
- 1:06:20phase made of stronger radical speeches, lots of pressure
- 1:06:23towards those who surrounded me but hadn't made my choice yet.
- 1:06:27As if everyone had to have an epiphany kind
- 1:06:32of at the same time as I did. And a lot of professional suffering
- 1:06:36in seeing that things did not change as fast as I
- 1:06:40expected. Instead, since I wrote this chapter, I kind of entered the
- 1:06:44second phase where I was characterized by a lot of acceptance on
- 1:06:49one side, but on the other side it was not surrender.
- 1:06:53So I kind of kept on living according to my empathy and
- 1:06:57values, which I always thought pleasant with whoever
- 1:07:01showed interest towards non humans and our possibilities
- 1:07:05of coexistence with them. And having this,
- 1:07:08I had kind of a net already of sensitive and empathetic souls
- 1:07:13around me. And I saw that this kind of expanded. And I
- 1:07:18understood that by taking responsibility for my feelings and consequent
- 1:07:22actions, I kind of led a silent example which did
- 1:07:27not pressure anyone anymore, but simply touched people's intimate
- 1:07:31reflection. And as I wrote in my chapter, the key is acknowledging
- 1:07:36to be a uniquely interconnected fragment.
- 1:07:39You heal your interconnection and this healing drives.
- 1:07:42And this is what I witnessed. I saw how my way of being
- 1:07:46in word impacted my micronet of people as well
- 1:07:50as I saw that some of the people working in the same circles
- 1:07:54as I myself had been in some previous circle
- 1:07:58that had positively changed me. And I think that's a beautiful phenomenon to
- 1:08:03acknowledge as giant love have flourished around you and
- 1:08:06then are spreading under your eyes. And that can be linked
- 1:08:10with a lot of things that happened in my beginning to going vegan
- 1:08:14and then starting doing activism and seeing people around me, despite it getting
- 1:08:18more interest in what they eat. What they ate and how
- 1:08:23they felt towards some topics and issues,
- 1:08:27and then maybe starting doing optimism as well, or just
- 1:08:31people raising more questions towards some kind
- 1:08:35of choices that I had made or other people around
- 1:08:39me had made. So I think that that gave
- 1:08:43me a lot of joy to see that I was working at it as a
- 1:08:46fragment in this universe and that was something that I had witnessed.
- 1:08:50But I think that is beautiful. We have Emily,
- 1:08:54like you were saying, it's kind of hard to be hopeful lately.
- 1:08:58That's why I've been trying to wrap up the podcast episodes with moments of Joy.
- 1:09:02Moments of Hope also took a page out of Hope Bohannig's book, because on
- 1:09:06her podcast her last question is always like a moment of hope on
- 1:09:11my end. Since I've read the book, I'm being I'm almost fully vegan now,
- 1:09:15and I've had moments in which friends who were not
- 1:09:19even vegetarian decided to join me for a meal
- 1:09:22or something. They were like, no, I'll do fully vegan just to see what it's
- 1:09:26like. So I think that that's a good moment to help them see that
- 1:09:30it's not impossible, that it's not hard to wrap it up.
- 1:09:34I want to ask if anybody wants to to share anything with our listeners.
- 1:09:37So this would be the great moment. If you have any projects coming up,
- 1:09:41if you have any work out there in the online world that you want to
- 1:09:45share with our listeners, this is your moment. Get on the soapbox,
- 1:09:49spread the message, and if you can send me the links later, I'll add to
- 1:09:53the podcast description. So I am in the
- 1:09:57beginning stages of trying to put together two other edited books and they
- 1:10:01show should be co edited because I prefer the collaboration.
- 1:10:05But one of those is on anarchic feminism.
- 1:10:08So partially that book is to
- 1:10:12a more concerted effort on Bhadaji's anarchifeminism
- 1:10:16book to expand on that and build on that. But that is not the sole
- 1:10:19focus. Part of the point of that is I do see that as a very
- 1:10:22wide topic and I like wide topics and bringing people together to
- 1:10:26see where things where ideas can go. Another book, another thing that I
- 1:10:31think can be particularly interesting and relevant for listeners of a podcast like this
- 1:10:34is to co edit a book that is critical of in vitro meat
- 1:10:38or cultured meat or cultivated meat is
- 1:10:42the insider term. But that is a topic that
- 1:10:47lots of people just kind of jump on the bandwagon of and think is this
- 1:10:51great thing. And I think it's it's actually the opposite if you look at it.
- 1:10:54So those, those are projects I'm trying to
- 1:10:58start and, and work on and push forward. But in terms
- 1:11:02of anything else in general to the listeners, what I think, what I've
- 1:11:06kind of come to, what I do, and I like to try to encourage people
- 1:11:09to do personally through conversations or through writing, but is to question everything. And that
- 1:11:13was a Discovery Channel's slogan for a while. And I by no means mean
- 1:11:17to promote an entity like that, but the idea is certainly good
- 1:11:22if we take it literally. But that also most definitely includes questioning ourselves
- 1:11:26and that also includes what's left out of that little too
- 1:11:29pithy, right? Too simple. Question everything is also to continually
- 1:11:33question everything. So even after you've questioned everything and
- 1:11:37you've questioned yourself, do it again. And so it's more like question everything all
- 1:11:41the time. I think, I think that's the thing. Never, never stop thinking.
- 1:11:45Never stop trying to push your own boundaries and those of others.
- 1:11:49Yeah, I completely agree with that, Nathan. I think
- 1:11:52that I am just so, so passionate about
- 1:11:56critically thinking and reflecting on my own assumptions
- 1:12:00and beliefs and also being
- 1:12:05very critical and being willing to, to, to question everything
- 1:12:10around me. And I think that it certainly makes for a more, I don't
- 1:12:15know, just a more, not only a more interesting world like, kind of approach,
- 1:12:18at least for me. Like I approach, I try to approach everything with that curiosity.
- 1:12:22Not necessarily like critical, not necessarily like.
- 1:12:25I try not to be too judgy, but I also do try to approach
- 1:12:29things with, with curiosity and be willing.
- 1:12:33To. Consider the, the perspectives and experiences
- 1:12:38of others but also hopefully try to encourage others to
- 1:12:42critically reflect on their own beliefs and assumptions and,
- 1:12:46and their, their own perspectives. So thanks for mentioning that, Nate. But yeah,
- 1:12:50I think the, the other piece for me that is so important is community and
- 1:12:55connecting with others. And so I, I have a
- 1:12:59few different projects I'm kind of working on and definitely spending a lot of time
- 1:13:02teaching. But I do just love connecting with
- 1:13:07others. I love being in community with, with folks who are interested in
- 1:13:11these topics like interspecies coexistence and humane education and
- 1:13:15collective liberation and veganism, all of those things. So I encourage
- 1:13:19folks to reach out if they want to connect with
- 1:13:24me. My website is www.coexistence.consulting
- 1:13:29and I, yeah, I look forward to
- 1:13:32connecting with folks. So yeah, finally I would just add our listeners,
- 1:13:37just read the book, comment, make comments about it,
- 1:13:41share it with your neighbors and viewers and also,
- 1:13:44also give it to strangers because that will mean to make also
- 1:13:48your little work as a fragment of the universe,
- 1:13:52you are being aware of the importance you have in this life. I would say
- 1:13:56finally remember that you aren't an isolated piece of the Cosmo looking
- 1:14:00for your own sense of life. And since you are better,
- 1:14:04we all are part of a whole of this magic organism that
- 1:14:08breathes as we do. We must stay aware
- 1:14:12of our thing with everything, everyone and everywhere, thus remembering
- 1:14:17that any of our options, even simply giving this
- 1:14:21stranger, will produce a knock on effect that helps. Well,
- 1:14:25thank you very much all three of you for being here at Lantern
- 1:14:29Voices today. It was a pleasure talking to everybody and
- 1:14:33I'll let you go now. Thank you. Bye. Thank you. Yes,
- 1:14:36thank you very much Elisa. Thank you. This was part one of
- 1:14:40Exploring Topics in Non Human Coexistence. I hope you enjoy
- 1:14:44the interview with Nathan, Lucrezia and Emily today. In two
- 1:14:47weeks we'll talk to Amanda Williams, Mark Tsushita and Varun Joshi
- 1:14:52about their essays in this very same book. If you stayed
- 1:14:56with us until now, it's time to share with you our special discount coupon.
- 1:14:59If you go to lanternpm.org, click on ebox
- 1:15:03and search, select any ebook that was ever featured in this podcast.
- 1:15:07So Exploring topics the Veganic Growers Handbook, Hobo Hannix,
- 1:15:11the Humane Hoax Just bugs. You had to be there. You can click the bug,
- 1:15:15go to checkout and then on the coupon field you just
- 1:15:19write lantern voices 25. That is lantern voices just
- 1:15:23like the podcast all together and the numbers 2 and 5.
- 1:15:26That will give you 25% off on all ebooks
- 1:15:30that were ever presented here on Lent yout Voices now or in the future.
- 1:15:33So that means that for the next episodes you will also be
- 1:15:37able to use this Coupon to get 25% off on
- 1:15:41our ebooks. Thank you very much for joining us here today. Don't forget
- 1:15:45to rate the podcast that really help us to spread the word and reach more
- 1:15:49people. And follow us on Instagram @LAWPM.
- 1:15:52I'll see you in two weeks to continue the conversation on Exploring Topics
- 1:15:56in Non Human Coexistence. Bye.