Latest / Politics with Paul / America's 250th: What's Changed the Most Over the Years? | Politics with Paul #98
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome back to the Posics with Paul podcast, your home for nonpartisan discussion of
- 0:05political science and civics.
- 0:07I am your host, Paul Rader.
- 0:10With the two hundred and fiftieth birthday of America just around the corner, I think it
- 0:16makes sense to look back at just how much has changed.
- 0:19When you've been a country for two and a half centuries, some things are bound to change.
- 0:24High profile public figures have come and gone.
- 0:27What issues are salient has often shifted, and political loyalties have transformed.
- 0:34So much is different over the course of two hundred fifty years.
- 0:38And with America's two hundred and fiftieth birthday, let's look at just how far along
- 0:43we've come.
- 0:44Many aspects have gotten better over two hundred fifty years.
- 0:48Some have gotten worse, and some are just as flawed as they were before.
- 0:52Regardless, let's look at some of the most seismic overarching changes to American
- 0:58political culture and life.
- 0:59Now, of course, there are way too many things to cover at one time and in one episode, so
- 1:04we'll look at some of the most seminal and or lesser known transformations in American
- 1:10politics.
- 1:11And at the end, we'll consider what may be some of the biggest changes to come.
- 1:17So let's first talk about voting rights and citizenship.
- 1:21Now, arguably the most noticeable and well known change in American politics has been the
- 1:27expansion of suffrage, which is voting rights.
- 1:31I know it sounds a little bit like suffering, but really suffrage is a good thing.
- 1:36Now that's one of the most noticeable or notable well known changes, but some people may
- 1:44not know the full extent of it.
- 1:47In episode 32 of this podcast, I talked a lot more in-depth about how much voting rights has
- 1:54expanded over time.
- 1:55We'll we'll condense it down into a shorter version here.
- 1:59So voting used to be heavily restricted by who could use it, who was actually allowed to vote.
- 2:07In fact, a lot of people don't realize early on, even being a white male was not enough.
- 2:13You had to have property because they were often considered people who did not have
- 2:18property were often considered not educated enough, that they didn't have enough stake in
- 2:22public affairs and that they were too dependent on other men to have their own will.
- 2:28But not too far along, property rights were the first major barrier to go And some of that took
- 2:38a little while in some states, in other states it was much quicker.
- 2:43But then you saw the fifteenth amendment ratified in 1870, which gave the right to vote
- 2:49for black men, not for every racial minority.
- 2:53That would take a little bit longer and get to that in just a moment.
- 2:55But the nineteenth amendment was ratified in 1920, which gave the right to vote for women.
- 3:01And then throughout the first half of the twentieth century, you saw more racial
- 3:05minorities granted citizenship and therefore could get the right to vote.
- 3:09Now the fifteenth amendment technically was not a was not abridging or it said that you could
- 3:17not abridge the right to vote based on race.
- 3:21But a lot of different racial minorities weren't considered citizens, so they didn't
- 3:25actually get the right to vote.
- 3:28So things that changed that were laws like the Indian Citizenship Act for Native Americans in
- 3:341924, the repeal of the Chinese Exclusion Act in 1943 for Chinese Americans, and then the
- 3:41McCarran Walter Act for all Asian Americans.
- 3:45Though they kept some immigration quotas in place, it granted citizenship to a lot more
- 3:52Americans of Asian descent.
- 3:54Then in the '20 or in that in 1961, excuse me, you saw the twenty third amendment, which gave
- 3:59Washington DC residents the ability to vote for president.
- 4:05And then the twenty fourth amendment in 1964, which abolished poll taxes.
- 4:10So in in in a way, it enfranchised poor voters because poll taxes, basically, you had to pay a
- 4:16fee to be able to vote And almost always, that was targeted against black voters because they
- 4:22tended to be more poor as a result of Jim Crow laws.
- 4:28And then the twenty sixth amendment in 1971 decreased the minimum voting age from 21 to 18
- 4:36years old.
- 4:36Now some states had already been doing that, but this made it across the board uniform.
- 4:43You're gonna be voting if you're 18 years old no matter what.
- 4:47So now more people than ever are able to register to vote, and registering to vote is
- 4:54fairly easy for the most part, though not certainly not for everyone.
- 4:59And how easy it is to actually cast a ballot as a voter is a bit of a mixed bag depending on
- 5:04where you go.
- 5:06And so the biggest current battlegrounds when it comes to voting rights is for former and
- 5:11convicted felons.
- 5:13So those are things like, should we automatically restore voting rights for felons
- 5:19after they get out of prison, or should it only be for nonviolent offenders who get out?
- 5:25Should you be able to vote as somebody who's currently in prison?
- 5:29And all sorts of different ways that states handled this issue.
- 5:36But that's the biggest battleground you see right now.
- 5:38But generally speaking, voting rights have come an incredibly long way in two hundred fifty
- 5:44years.
- 5:44It's not specifically targeted against demographic groups anymore.
- 5:50Not at least not when it comes to race and gender and age.
- 5:55Although some people would perhaps argue that 16 year olds should get the right to vote, but
- 6:01that's that's a
- 6:01whole other can of worms.
- 6:04So
- 6:05the next thing to talk about, and this is a very wide ranging discussion, is changes to
- 6:13elections and nominating processes.
- 6:17Now elections in America are largely administered at the local level, and most laws
- 6:23are set by the states.
- 6:24The US constitution doesn't really set a whole lot of rules when it comes to elections.
- 6:31It was mostly left up to the states.
- 6:33And so there has been a ton of change in how these elections work as states have shifted in
- 6:39their political ideologies and partisanship and all sorts of state specific factors have come
- 6:46into play.
- 6:48And there's too much to cover here, but there's a lot of this that is covered in episodes
- 6:53thirty one and thirty two of the podcast and various other ones along the way.
- 6:57But we'll discuss a few of the more considerable changes.
- 6:59I won't go in-depth with the twelfth amendment.
- 7:01That had changed presidential elections where previously first place vote getter was
- 7:07president, and then the second place vote getter was vice president.
- 7:10Now, obviously, it's a lot different.
- 7:12You have presidents and vice presidents run on the same ticket, and that's because of the
- 7:16twelfth amendment.
- 7:18So I think it bears mentioning here, but I don't wanna go too in-depth with it.
- 7:23There are some other ones that I wanna focus on that are less well known, and one of those is
- 7:29the process of casting a ballot.
- 7:33So these days, you go to a polling booth, you fill out the bubbles, you put it in the
- 7:41scanner, and it says you voted.
- 7:43Well, in the really early days, it was actually done by a voice vote.
- 7:48You actually went to your polling place and said the name that you want to vote for, and
- 7:52then it was tabulated.
- 7:54Paper ballots became increasingly common throughout the eighteen hundreds, but even
- 7:58then, it wasn't standardized.
- 8:00Newspapers could print out blank ballots that readers could take and pull it off the
- 8:05newspaper and then fill it out and then bring it to a polling place.
- 8:09And, also, even political parties could print out their own ballots, which yeah.
- 8:15What could go wrong there?
- 8:16Conveniently, these ballots just had the party's candidates.
- 8:20And so they targeted the, in particular, new immigrants coming to America by promising them
- 8:27housing and jobs and so on in exchange for party loyalty.
- 8:31It was a really easily exploitable system for them to use.
- 8:36Hence, as the nineteenth century wore on, a lot more reforms would happen.
- 8:42Public demand for secret balloting ramped up, and it was adopted in the waning years of the
- 8:48nineteenth century.
- 8:49And an array of machines used for elections since the secret ballot have been invented,
- 8:55including lever machines and punch cards and now optical scanners and scantrons that you see
- 9:02today.
- 9:03Another way that voting has or elections have tremendously changed is that we directly vote
- 9:10for US senators now, and that was through the seventeenth amendment in 1913.
- 9:15US senators actually used to be selected by the respective state legislatures.
- 9:20And in fact, some governors also used to be chosen by state legislatures back in the really
- 9:25early days in the early nineteenth century.
- 9:29Many framers of The US constitution had not intended for direct election of the US senate
- 9:34like they decided for the US house.
- 9:36Remember, not all the framers agreed on everything, and some of them wanted more direct
- 9:41election for the legislative branch in general.
- 9:44But it was part of this big compromise called the Connecticut Compromise, which made the US
- 9:50house based on population and direct election, and the US senate would give two senators no
- 9:56matter how big your state was and make them indirectly or rather, well, yes, indirectly
- 10:02elected by the state legislature.
- 10:04So the people would vote for state legislatures, and then the state legislatures
- 10:08would vote for the US senators.
- 10:10And some of those reasons included preventing mob rule and excessive democracy and protecting
- 10:16states' rights by providing state governments a way to check the federal government, and that
- 10:21state legislatures would be more quote unquote enlightened in choosing these US senators
- 10:27because these US senate seats were so prestigious and impactful on federal policy.
- 10:35Now whether you agree with those reasons or not, that was why the US senate was made the
- 10:43way it was back then.
- 10:44But in the early twentieth century, that changed.
- 10:47And for over a hundred years now, we have directly elected our US senate in a similar
- 10:53fashion to the US house.
- 10:55Another way that you may not realize how elections have changed incredibly, more so the
- 11:02nominating process, is how much we've shifted from caucuses to primaries.
- 11:07In the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries, caucuses and conventions were how candidates
- 11:12for office were chosen.
- 11:13Caucuses were private meetings held by members of the party, though not necessarily by secret
- 11:18ballots.
- 11:18Sometimes they would openly discuss it.
- 11:21And in conventions were more general meetings where delegates of the party attended.
- 11:26But in the early nineteen hundreds during the progressive era, one of the reforms that was
- 11:31picking up traction that was gaining steam was the idea of primaries where a set of candidates
- 11:38would run for the party nomination, and then we'd vote for them directly.
- 11:41It was seen as a way to address political corruption and to take power away from
- 11:47political machines and party bosses that had been controlling nominations for decades and
- 11:53decades.
- 11:54Now you almost never see caucuses, Occasionally do like in Iowa, and conventions have had a lot
- 12:01less direct control over elections since then.
- 12:04And this is one of the reasons why people say political parties in America are relatively
- 12:08weak these days because voters have a much more direct choice in who becomes the party's
- 12:16nominees as opposed to the parties themselves picking and choosing and saying you have to
- 12:20deal with this whether you like it or not.
- 12:24So, occasionally, you see those caucuses, and conventions still happen a lot, but they don't
- 12:29really they're a bit more of a formality now.
- 12:33But, occasionally, you still see caucuses have some impact.
- 12:37And then lastly, I wanna talk about changes in the ways that presidential candidates campaign
- 12:45a particular way that you might not realize, and I'm talking about travel in this case.
- 12:51Now, obviously, transportation has tremendously improved since the founding fathers' time, but
- 13:00you may not realize just how much it has changed how presidents have and presidential
- 13:06camp candidates have campaigned.
- 13:09Today, presidential candidates travel all around the country.
- 13:12They do countless interviews, debates, all that jazz, but it wasn't anything remotely like that
- 13:18to start off.
- 13:19In the early days of the republic, campaigning for yourself was actually seen as unbecoming
- 13:25and disapproved of and inappropriate.
- 13:27It was the idea according to the founding fathers, not necessarily these specific words,
- 13:33but the idea was that the office seeks the man, not the other way around.
- 13:38So how did you campaign?
- 13:41Other people did it on your behalf.
- 13:43Somebody that you know in federal government or in states say, hey.
- 13:47You know what?
- 13:48I think you know who would be a really good candidate?
- 13:51My buddy, George, John, Thomas.
- 13:56They would make a really good president.
- 13:58And let me tell you why they would make a really good president.
- 14:00So people would campaign on your behalf if you wanted to be a presidential candidate.
- 14:05William Henry Harrison in 1840 was really the first presidential candidate to actually tour
- 14:11and give speeches, though successive major major party nominees weren't really successful
- 14:19with that strategy.
- 14:20William Henry Harrison was able to parlay into a one month presidency.
- 14:23He died one month into the presidency, but it worked out for him.
- 14:27And so when James Garfield was campaigning in 1880, he kinda looked at how previous
- 14:37presidential candidates had gone about it.
- 14:38And instead of stomping around the country to give speeches, he's decided he would conduct
- 14:45the first front porch campaign where people would actually come to the candidate's house to
- 14:51hear him speak.
- 14:52Instead of him traveling to you, you traveled to him, which sounds insane these days,
- 14:58especially with concerns about security and privacy and knowing about where people live.
- 15:03But that's how it was at that point.
- 15:06Benjamin Harrison in the eighteen eighty eight presidential election campaign, he did the same
- 15:12thing.
- 15:13He used a front porch campaign.
- 15:15William McKinley did it in 1896, though front porch campaigns after that would decline in use
- 15:22for a while.
- 15:22Warren Harding, when he campaigned in the nineteen twenty election, he used the front
- 15:27porch campaign, and it was used in 1924.
- 15:30But even by that point, it was falling out of use.
- 15:33And in 1912, when Teddy Roosevelt was running to try to return to the presidency, he had
- 15:39already served two terms before, but tried to get back in as a third party candidate because
- 15:44he was very disgruntled with William Taft, who he had basically deemed his successor.
- 15:51And so what Teddy did is he embarked on one of the first whistle stop tours where candidates
- 15:56traveled on trains and then voters would come to the train stops to hear them speak.
- 16:00So instead of you traveling around the country to meet voters where they are and voters
- 16:06traveling to go meet you where you are as a presidential candidate, it was kind of
- 16:10something in the middle where presidential candidates would travel to somewhere, but
- 16:15voters would flock to that area to go and see that presidential candidate speak.
- 16:21And as, of course, as the twentieth century progressed, candidates would more frequently
- 16:25travel around with faster trains, continually improving cars, flights, and so on as
- 16:32technology and transportation has gotten better and better.
- 16:34And now it has since become expected that legitimate presidential candidates will travel
- 16:39basically all over the country.
- 16:42Now how about shifting party loyalties?
- 16:47We've had a two party system for almost the entirety of America's existence, save for prior
- 16:53to the US constitution's ratification when there were no formal parties and a short period
- 16:59after the dissolution of the federalist party when it was just the Democratic party that
- 17:05existed on its own for a little while.
- 17:08But how those parties have looked and where their power lies have shifted tremendously over
- 17:13time.
- 17:14The parties themselves have changed somewhat.
- 17:17Federalists dissolved, then there is that one party rule for a little while.
- 17:22And then Whigs filled the vacuum, and then they dissolved and were replaced by Republicans.
- 17:26And now it's been Republicans versus Democrats ever since the eighteen fifties.
- 17:32Now depending on who you ask, the Democratic Party is the same as the Democratic Republicans
- 17:36that tussled with Federalists, and some people consider Andrew Jackson's transformation of the
- 17:41party when he was president to be the starting point of today's Democratic Party.
- 17:46But in any case, today it is democrats versus republicans.
- 17:50And although the level of competition has shifted between the two major parties over
- 17:54time, the fact that they've been both relatively stable and staples of American
- 18:00government for a hundred seventy years is a lot different than the two party systems before.
- 18:04So in a way, that has changed a lot since America was founded.
- 18:11And another aspect of that party dynamic is that third parties and independents also used
- 18:19to be a lot more competitive.
- 18:21Now they still didn't take that many offices compared to the main parties and have rarely
- 18:28made noise in presidential elections, but you did see them win a lot more often, and they
- 18:35were a lot more common in congressional and state level elections way back when.
- 18:39As some examples in the US house from 1837 when Whigs first took congressional seats to
- 18:47nineteen o five, there was at least one third party or independent member of the US house,
- 18:53and most times there was at least a handful of them.
- 18:57And then from 1911 to 1955 in the US house, there was at least one third party or
- 19:02independent US house member for all of those years too, though not nearly as many as there
- 19:07had used
- 19:07to be, though it was
- 19:08still quite a few, especially compared to today.
- 19:11And in the US senate, there was not nearly as often third party and independent members as
- 19:17there was for the US house, partly because the US senate is a much smaller chamber than the US
- 19:23house is.
- 19:25But there have been some periods where there is more third party representation than usual,
- 19:30more independent representation than usual.
- 19:33Almost every year from 1847 to 1885, there was a third party or independent US senator, mostly
- 19:40because of issues relating to the civil war or after the civil war and reconstruction policy.
- 19:46The eighteen nineties and first few years of the nineteen hundreds saw a bunch of populist
- 19:53and silver oriented US senators.
- 19:55Silver policy as in whether we should be on the silver standard or the gold standard back then
- 20:01was a very hot topic back then because of how to control inflation, especially for farmers
- 20:07who were trying to figure out how to basically sustain their lives and their livelihoods by
- 20:15growing crops.
- 20:16And the nineteen twenties through nineteen forties saw at least one farmer labor and or
- 20:22progressive US senator.
- 20:24Now farmer labor is something much more specific to the state of Minnesota where they
- 20:31are now part of the democratic party.
- 20:34It's their democratic farmer labor party in that state.
- 20:39Nowadays though, you almost never see a third party or independent in congress.
- 20:44It happens a few times.
- 20:45There have been a couple in the US house that have switched from democratic or republican to
- 20:51an independent or third party in recent memory.
- 20:54But that was right before they either retired or they decided not to run for reelection or
- 20:59they tried to run for reelection, but they were defeated.
- 21:02Justin Amash, I believe is how you say his last name, in Michigan a few years ago was a
- 21:08Republican during Donald Trump's first stint as president, was very outspoken against Trump.
- 21:16I believe he changed to a libertarian and wanna say he did run for real oh, no.
- 21:24I I think
- 21:24he did It declined to run
- 21:26for real action, and I think he tried to run again later on but was not successful.
- 21:32So he's just one example, and there have been some that have changed independence.
- 21:35And, yes, there are a couple of independents in the US senate right now, Angus King and Bernie
- 21:41Sanders, but they caucus with democrats and vote so often with democrats that they often
- 21:46are just considered democrats anyways.
- 21:49And there have been a few that have changed independent right before they left like Kirsten
- 21:53Tsunemah and Joe Manchin.
- 21:55But they in terms of, like, actually winning elections as independents or third parties and
- 22:03staying that way as independents and third parties, you pretty much never see that anymore
- 22:09unless it's Bernie Sanders or Angus King.
- 22:12And over time, third party choices have decreased on the ballot as well, and ballots
- 22:17ballot access has been restricted for them.
- 22:19And there's this assumption that if you're voting third party, you're just wasting a vote.
- 22:24So that's made third party office holders a lot less common as well.
- 22:30And also the strongholds of democrats and republicans have shifted dramatically over time
- 22:34too.
- 22:35States that used to always vote Republican then became Democrats, or if they voted specifically
- 22:41Republican in presidential elections, they eventually shifted Democrat and vice versa.
- 22:47Republicans used to be very robust in the Northeast, and now they're pretty clearly the
- 22:52minority party in most of those states, states like Massachusetts and New York.
- 22:57Democrats used to dominate in the South, and you almost never saw a republican in office in
- 23:04those states way back when.
- 23:06Now democrats are clearly the minority in most of those states, states like Florida or Texas.
- 23:13And so these kinds of party changes that seem bizarre now, you you you'd see the way that
- 23:21some states are so heavily one party or another now that they used to be the other party.
- 23:28You might look at them now and be like, wait.
- 23:30This state used to be republican?
- 23:32This state used to be democrat?
- 23:33It might sound crazy, but things change a lot over the course of two and a half centuries.
- 23:39And another thing that has changed a lot in that time is that we've shifted from a
- 23:44patronage or spoil system to a lot more civil service oriented system when it comes to
- 23:52federal jobs.
- 23:54For most of the first one hundred years of America, federal jobs in politics was based on
- 23:59the spoil system or patronage.
- 24:01It wasn't just about, oh, it's who you know.
- 24:03It's about what you've done for those people that you know.
- 24:07So they aren't just gonna necessarily put you in just because, hey, this is my campaign
- 24:14manager's son.
- 24:15I'm just gonna put him in in this federal job.
- 24:17No.
- 24:18They had to have actually done something for you and for the party to actually get into
- 24:24office.
- 24:25And Andrew Jackson, in particular, used the spoil system to its fullest extent when he was
- 24:31president.
- 24:32And this spoil system existed well into what is called the gilded age, and that's the era that
- 24:38describes the late nineteenth century after reconstruction because there was a lot of
- 24:43considerable economic expansion during that time.
- 24:47And on the surface, everything seemed great.
- 24:49But underneath it, the seedy underbelly, there was this rampant corruption in business and
- 24:56politics.
- 24:57That was, at least in the case of civil service reform, until a turning point in the eighteen
- 25:02eighties.
- 25:03So at this point, Republicans were divided between two factions.
- 25:08There was half breeds and there were stalwarts.
- 25:11Half breeds were Republicans that supported merit based reforms while stalwarts supported
- 25:18patronage.
- 25:20And president James a Garfield, a half breed, had proposed civil service reforms.
- 25:27Unfortunately, he would not see it come to fruition as he was assassinated in 1881 by
- 25:32Charles Guiteau.
- 25:34Guiteau was a stalwart, and he was mentally ill, and he was very upset that he had not
- 25:40received a federal job for his work for the party.
- 25:44As a stalwart, he thought he should get it because look what he did for the party.
- 25:50Besides that though, Guiteau is at least allegedly he was alleged to have said that I am
- 25:57a stalwart of the stalwarts.
- 25:59Arthur is president.
- 26:01And that Arthur he was referring to was vice president Chester A.
- 26:04Arthur.
- 26:05Even though Garfield was a half breed, Arthur was a stalwart.
- 26:09It was sort of a try to be a compromise between the two factions.
- 26:13And so Chester A.
- 26:14Arthur assumed the presidency.
- 26:16So Chester A.
- 26:18Arthur must have decided to do away the with the civil service reforms.
- 26:23Right?
- 26:23After all, he was
- 26:24a stalwart.
- 26:25Actually, no.
- 26:26To probably everybody's surprise, Chester Arthur actually carried forward the civil
- 26:31service reform, and he would sign the Pendleton Civil Service Act in 1883.
- 26:37And among the Pendleton Civil Service Act's provisions for federal workers is that they
- 26:42would have open and competitive exams based on merit.
- 26:46So, basically, how do you know how well do you know the job?
- 26:49You would be protected from firing based on political motives.
- 26:53So they just didn't like your politics.
- 26:55They couldn't remove you just because of that.
- 26:57Prohibiting the government from requiring civil servants to campaign for them.
- 27:03You could not make them do that either.
- 27:05So if you were somebody in office or you wanted them to campaign for somebody in office, you
- 27:09could not coerce them to do that.
- 27:11And it also established the civil service commission to enforce this merit system.
- 27:17Now at the time, the law only covered about 10% of federal government employees.
- 27:23So it wasn't a huge wide ranging bill that you might have expected it to be, but it was an
- 27:29immense step forward.
- 27:31And since then, the civil service act and civil service reform has been expanded to apply to
- 27:37the vast majority somewhere around 90% of federal employees.
- 27:43And the federal government has also grown considerably since then.
- 27:45So not just percentage wise, but just the sheer number of people that are covered by the civil
- 27:52service reforms is a lot more expansive too now.
- 27:57Now that's not to say that there are no politics played whatsoever anymore when it
- 28:02comes to who gets federal jobs and who applies to federal jobs, but and who and who gets
- 28:09removed from federal jobs, but it is exceedingly more difficult to do that than it
- 28:15used to be.
- 28:16It it is much more difficult to try to play politics with who gets federal jobs.
- 28:22Now, that's what has changed the most over two hundred fifty years, at least things that you
- 28:28might not realize have changed tremendously over two hundred fifty years.
- 28:31But let's look to the future.
- 28:33What will change the most over the next two hundred fifty years?
- 28:38And this doesn't have to be entirely what we think will happen, but some things that we
- 28:43would like to happen could be there too.
- 28:45I'm not necessarily saying all of these are things I want specifically.
- 28:50And let's also try to look at this much more positively, at least neutrally.
- 28:55Now I know that's very hard.
- 28:56I know it's very easy to look at the doom and gloom.
- 28:58I've talked about that on several recent episodes of the podcast.
- 29:01And I'll be honest, I am not exactly the dictionary definition of an optimist myself.
- 29:07But let's think about positive things.
- 29:10Let's assume that America is still here two fifty years in the future, or even if you don't
- 29:16want to think that far, what are some of the things that might change the most over the next
- 29:21fifty years or whatever number you want to use?
- 29:26And there are a few that I'm going to talk about specifically, but there's just as just
- 29:34like how the talk about what has changed the most is super expansive, so is talking about
- 29:40what could change tremendously.
- 29:44In fact, this might be an even more expansive conversation, but I'll just highlight a few
- 29:48things.
- 29:49Number one is government accessibility, and I put this in the same vein as government
- 29:55transparency.
- 29:57Despite two hundred fifty years, there are still tons of problems with government
- 30:02accessibility, enough that I wanna make a podcast episode on it in the future, in the
- 30:07near future, hopefully.
- 30:09Now, obviously, in some ways, government has become more accessible because of how much
- 30:15information how much faster information travels, how much you can just easily look up
- 30:19information, how much you can actually travel yourself to get this information.
- 30:25But there are still so many things that can be improved.
- 30:29We don't teach how to research government well, and it's also hard to find unbiased
- 30:34information.
- 30:35So sometimes we get frustrated with what we think is people not not researching things.
- 30:43And and, yes, some people just don't go and research things on their own, and and they're
- 30:47lazy about it.
- 30:48But some people just don't know where to go, and we don't teach them very well.
- 30:53And sometimes we think we know it better than we actually do.
- 30:56Another way that governments are inaccessible, especially local governments, they get very
- 31:01little media attention, say for the biggest cities like New York City or Los Angeles or
- 31:06Chicago or whatever other big city you wanna use, Miami.
- 31:12Besides those states, you really don't see local areas talked about that much.
- 31:18Maybe some of the biggest counties too, but a lot of people don't realize just how important
- 31:22local government is, and it's harder to find information about local government.
- 31:27Kind of a catch 22.
- 31:29People don't research, don't care as
- 31:32much about local government because they think it doesn't matter because it doesn't get
- 31:34covered as much, and it doesn't get covered as much because people think it doesn't matter and
- 31:38that they don't care about it.
- 31:40And even if you wanna look up these local governments, it's mostly just the biggest ones
- 31:44that have information about them.
- 31:46These special districts that a lot of people don't realize, like water districts, police and
- 31:51fire districts, they're very hard to find information about, even for those of us who are
- 31:57involved in politics for a living, which I've talked about before.
- 32:00When people who are involved
- 32:03in politics for a living like me have trouble finding this information, it's incredibly
- 32:08difficult, if not impossible, to expect people who don't follow politics for a living to be
- 32:14able to do it.
- 32:15Government websites often suck because they don't get updated.
- 32:21They're hard to navigate.
- 32:23They are just flat out missing info.
- 32:26All sorts of ways that websites for local governments and even state governments too just
- 32:34it's just a slog to go through them, or they look like they haven't been updated forever or
- 32:40they look like they were made with early two thousands geo cities.
- 32:44There's so much there that can be improved too.
- 32:47And rural areas have very little access to broadband Internet, and that's an issue that's
- 32:53becoming more and more salient across both parties.
- 32:57But I think we will see a lot of significant improvements to many of these things as the
- 33:02lack of accessibility is becoming a bipartisan issue that both major parties are seeking to
- 33:09fix to some extent.
- 33:10Now, obviously, there's gonna be a
- 33:13lot of debate and dissent on how to fix it, but at least recognizing that these are problems
- 33:20and having people across the political spectrum recognize these are problems is an important
- 33:26first step to have.
- 33:27So I think you will see a lot of improvements on that front when it comes to government
- 33:32accessibility.
- 33:33At least I hope so.
- 33:35Another tremendous change that is going to be coming or is coming and is already here is
- 33:40artificial intelligence.
- 33:42Now, I know it's a
- 33:44very scary topic right now and I'm not a fan exactly of it myself either.
- 33:51It's unfortunate how much it's becoming a part of
- 33:56our everyday lives.
- 33:57It's everywhere, but it is here to stay and it's becoming more ubiquitous.
- 34:02But for as much as it is used for evil, selfish, and nefarious ends, there is also a
- 34:10lot of potential for it to do good and improve government function.
- 34:15It could make government websites more accessible.
- 34:17It could help regular people understand debates better, like being able to parse what
- 34:23candidates are saying or the different sides of policy debates, and so on.
- 34:31It could compare and contrast how different governments operate based on a variety of
- 34:36factors and inform us about how we can improve our own government's functions and structures.
- 34:43In episode 83 with my guest Ramon Perez, he discussed the use of AI and how it can improve
- 34:50government transparency and accountability.
- 34:52Now, again, I know artificial intelligence is scary, and it will be used for improper ends,
- 34:59and it can also be used to make government less accessible and less transparent and make
- 35:07policies even harder to understand by giving people bad information.
- 35:10But there is a lot of potential for it to not do those things too and to make us more
- 35:17prepared for false information.
- 35:21But artificial intelligence is going to transform how we engage with government and how
- 35:28government operates whether we like it or not.
- 35:31Another thing you're going to see a lot of in two hundred fifty years another two hundred
- 35:36fifty years is more shifts in party loyalties.
- 35:40Now when you're in the thick of things, it's very easy to miss the forest for the trees, so
- 35:48to speak, because you're in the thick of things.
- 35:51It's you think, oh, there's no way these things are going to change.
- 35:54We don't realize trends are happening until we're actually looking at them in the rearview
- 36:00mirror.
- 36:01And it often takes a long time to sustainably change the party affiliation of states and
- 36:07other large areas.
- 36:10Republican states don't become democratic overnights.
- 36:12Democratic states don't become republican overnight.
- 36:16But two hundred fifty years, yeah, party loyalties are guaranteed to shift over the
- 36:24course of that time and even fifty years too.
- 36:27But what will that look like?
- 36:29Where will it happen?
- 36:31Why will it happen?
- 36:33That's hard to say.
- 36:33We have this concept in politics called a realigning election, and some elections are
- 36:40looked at as these watershed moments where the demographics of the parties have shifted over
- 36:50time.
- 36:52And depending on who you ask, some people would say 2016 with Donald Trump's first election is
- 37:01a realigning election.
- 37:02Not everybody agrees with that.
- 37:03But what you have seen a lot of is since the sixties, there's been a what are sometimes
- 37:09called a great sorting out where instead of like a what seems like to be an overnight
- 37:15switch, it's just a slow gradual change where you saw states in the North gradually shift
- 37:24from republican to democrat, especially in the Northeast.
- 37:28You saw states in the South shift from democrat to gradually more republican.
- 37:34Now what is that going to look like in the future?
- 37:39Which areas of the country are gonna suddenly shift towards Republicans when they've been
- 37:44Democratic or shift towards Democrats when they've been Republican?
- 37:48I mean, who knows?
- 37:49It could be some sort of issue that we haven't seen yet that really turns everything on its
- 37:55head.
- 37:56Again, it's hard to really say when you're in the middle of things, but it's going to happen
- 38:01at some point over fifty years, a hundred years, hundred fifty, two hundred, two hundred
- 38:06fifty years.
- 38:07It may be another candidate that is completely different than anything we've ever seen before
- 38:14and is incredibly galvanizing in a different way that cuts across different political groups
- 38:21that you otherwise thought would not mesh together.
- 38:25It's it's hard to say right now, but it's going to happen at some point where things that we
- 38:31think are here to stay now that democratic areas that are never gonna become republican or
- 38:36republican areas that are never gonna become democratic, they're gonna change at some point.
- 38:41And then lastly, there's obviously going to be a ton of different changes to election rules
- 38:46and formats because those are always continually refined and changed.
- 38:55Now depends on what level of government you're talking about and where, but there's going to
- 39:00be a lot of that change.
- 39:03Like, some offices at the state level, they often shift between whether they're elected or
- 39:08appointed.
- 39:09So some of those are gonna become go from appointed to elected or elected to appointed.
- 39:14Elected being that they're chosen by regular voters, and then appointed meaning they're
- 39:18appointed by somebody in the government, typically a governor.
- 39:22Will that happen at the federal level where we might elect more than just president and
- 39:28congress?
- 39:29Maybe we only elect a member of the cabinet.
- 39:35I don't necessarily see that happening, but two hundred fifty years is a long time.
- 39:40Maybe we will see.
- 39:41Or maybe there's a an office that we don't even have yet that will eventually be created, and
- 39:47then that is elected.
- 39:48I don't know.
- 39:50That that kind of thing would require a change to the US constitution, or at least it would
- 39:54likely need a change to the US constitution.
- 39:59Will we see term limits for US Supreme Court right now?
- 40:02US Supreme Court has lifetime appointments.
- 40:06That might pick up steam with how much people are losing their faith in the supreme court,
- 40:14and a lot of it is based on political views whether they agree with the court's rulings.
- 40:20Typically, republicans are more approving of the supreme court right now than democrats are
- 40:26just because of some of the rulings being more conservative and more favoring Republicans
- 40:32lately.
- 40:33Will we see age limits on congress and other offices that don't already have them?
- 40:38You see state level courts, a lot of them use it for their judges where they have to leave at
- 40:44a certain age.
- 40:45I think this one will be picking up more steam because it seems to have gained some traction.
- 40:50And one of my earliest episodes actually, maybe my first episode of the podcast talked about
- 40:56the age of elected officials and whether we would see potential maximum age limits on
- 41:04members of congress.
- 41:06It's not gonna be one fell swoop.
- 41:08It's gonna be each state doing it on their own,
- 41:12but it does seem to be getting to
- 41:16be a more and more accepted idea across Republican and Democratic lines and
- 41:24independents too.
- 41:26We'll probably see some more areas that use ranked choice voting where each candidate on
- 41:32the ballot is ranked one, two, three, however many candidates there are, and you choose them
- 41:37based on order of preference.
- 41:38You'll probably see more of those because that has started to pick up traction over time.
- 41:43Now how extensive will that be?
- 41:45It'll probably be more extensive at the local level and and with enough time might be picked
- 41:50at the state level.
- 41:51Federal level?
- 41:53Well, some states that use ranked choice voting already do use it for state and federal
- 42:00offices, but
- 42:00it is very rare to see that.
- 42:03But that will almost undoubtedly be expanded in use ranked choice voting.
- 42:10And who knows?
- 42:12With another fifty to one hundred years, we may see it become the primary way that we choose
- 42:20elected officials.
- 42:21Or maybe we see more multi member districts.
- 42:25There's a
- 42:26few of those already in states where districts have more than one person representing them.
- 42:31So the vast majority of states for the state legislative level and then congress also does
- 42:37one person per district, but most state legislatures do one representative per one
- 42:44senator per district.
- 42:46There's a few other states like, for example, Vermont actually does it in both their state
- 42:51house and their state senate where they have two, three, or even more people in a district.
- 42:58And so you might perhaps see more and more of those kinds of districts be adopted.
- 43:04I haven't personally seen a lot of talk about doing that more and more.
- 43:11Not gonna say that there's no way it wouldn't happen because you never know what's going to
- 43:15happen, but that might be something to watch out for.
- 43:19And then
- 43:19lastly, will we maybe see adoption of proportional
- 43:23representation?
- 43:24Now this one is a tricky one because that would require a lot of legal changes.
- 43:29It would almost certainly require a change to the US constitution where the apportionment of
- 43:36seats is based on the number of votes that were received in that area.
- 43:42So if a district has five seats and republicans got 60% of the vote and democrats got 40% of
- 43:51the vote, republicans will receive 60% of the seats and democrats will receive 40% of the
- 43:56seats instead of it just being a winner take all like you see in the vast majority of cases
- 44:03in US elections.
- 44:06And with gerrymandering in full swing, maybe proportional representation will be seen as the
- 44:13solution to that.
- 44:15And with a lot of the discussion about how third parties and independents get shut out of
- 44:20elections a lot of times, You might see this as the way to involve more third party competition
- 44:29or independent competition.
- 44:31Who knows?
- 44:32But that may be another major change you see.
- 44:36But you always gotta remember,
- 44:39there's a lot of things
- 44:39that stay the same in politics, but there's a ton that also changes, especially a lot of
- 44:43these details.
- 44:44And you never know what the future holds, and some things can surprise you quite a bit when
- 44:52you're talking about two and a half centuries.
- 44:55But in any case, whether you're optimistic, pessimistic, or neutral, it's going to be very
- 45:01interesting to see just how much changes even further over the course of two hundred fifty
- 45:06years.
- 45:06Now, obviously, we won't be alive at that point.
- 45:09At least I assume we won't be alive at that point.
- 45:12But nonetheless, it'll be interesting for future generations to see.
- 45:16And while we are still alive, it'll be interesting to see how much it changes over
- 45:21time.
- 45:22But that's gonna do it for today's episode of the politics with Paul podcast.
- 45:25As always, thank you so much for listening.
- 45:27Please like, comment, and share, and subscribe to the podcast on YouTube, Spotify, and Apple
- 45:34podcasts.
- 45:35Links to the show notes.
- 45:36My other works include five day educational email course about how we can more effectively
- 45:41mitigate polarization in politics and toxicity in politics.
- 45:46My book on political independence, which is available on several retailers, but especially
- 45:51on Amazon, and my writings on medium.com.
- 45:57And other links are my Facebook page, LinkedIn, websites, and my email,
- 46:05PaulRitterwrites@Gmail.com.
- 46:07So wrapping things up here.
- 46:10Thank you
- 46:10so much for listening, and we'll see you next time.