Latest / Under The Pallet Wrap / Episode 9 - Ops Maker or Breaker? - Lifting The Lid On Automation
Transcript
- Dan Culverhouse: welcome to nine ⁓ of Under the Wrap. in light of the feedback and the comments we've been having today, we're talk about warehouse automation, as that was a request from somebody this week ⁓ and for us to ⁓ have a conversation ⁓ around this topic. So the we're gonna ask ourselves is: should ⁓ all warehouse operations Have a goal to be automated. ⁓ and let's be honest, it's a topic that if you're talking warehouse operations, you can hardly get through a conversation without it coming up. ⁓ everybody discusses it, everybody considers it. It's like an unstoppable wave of development ⁓ at the moment. ⁓ a great hunger for ⁓ for for these ⁓ these ⁓ technologies. You can't go to a ⁓ a warehousing exhibition without being flooded and ⁓ amazed. By some of the solutions that are out there and being offered. And, you know, providing you with solutions for your productivity, for your accuracy, for your handling complexity, for your lack of available labour, and for, I don't know, simply doing more in less. today we're asking the question: should all operations be looking at automation? ⁓ And Keith, what do think? Keith: I think as you can imagine that warehousing, operations, e-commerce, business is a variable beast and what works for some does not necessarily work for all. I think I always take the position that yeah, of course you should be efficient. That's my driver, efficient, ⁓ customer centric, continuous improvement mindset. Sometimes that leads you to automation. Sometimes it doesn't. Sometimes that could be to the detriment of your business. I'm pro automation when it works. ⁓ I'm fascinated by the subject. It's something that you spent many a year working on. What would you say the main drivers were for automation for most businesses? Because growth the big word, isn't it? But growth isn't necessarily the right reason. What would you say is the bigger driver? Dan Culverhouse: No. I've I've been involved in a lot of ⁓ automation ⁓ work. ⁓ my specialism within ⁓ supply chain has always been warehouse operations. ⁓ and through ⁓ I have done ⁓ number of significant developments that have involved ⁓ automation, but not all of them. ⁓ some of them we chose to not do it. ⁓ and I think what you see ⁓ is probably three key focuses that drive people to think about automation. One is productivity. We want to do more, we want to get more through, ⁓ we want to get more things done with the people that we have. secondly is accuracy and consistency, and I think that is probably one of the greatest successes of of automated solutions is they're very, very consistent and accurate. They drive adherence to process, ⁓ which ⁓ it can be very, very helpful depending on what you're doing. ⁓ and then the third one ⁓ is ⁓ able utilize space better. So you've got a warehouse, it's full, ⁓ you can't you don't really want to expand or you don't have room to expand. ⁓ so you look at solutions to how to utilize that space better. your storage can become in much more dense ⁓ if people don't need to come and out of it all the time. ⁓ So there you know there are are great ⁓ great opportunities. And automation was traditionally the ⁓ I guess the exclusive right of business. ⁓ you know automation solutions were multi-million pound projects. They involved cranes, they involved miles of conveyor, they involved big sortation machines. So, you know, you needed to ⁓ you need to be a big business to justify all of that. But that's simply not the case anymore. ⁓ with the onset of much more modular and more autonomous solutions. So I know I mean things like and this is kind of the robotics side. So where you would once had a conveyor to get from A to B. You can now use what we would call an AGV, which is a manless truck, which can pick up a pallet or pick up some boxes, and it can take it to another point of the warehouse without any ⁓ any human intervention. And that presents a whole different opportunity and a whole different wave of solutions. And it also lowers the barriers for entry. So much smaller businesses can benefit from automation. So I guess to the to our question, should all have the goal. No, I don't think they should, but they could benefit from it. Keith: it's definitely a long journey from start up to full automation ⁓ yeah, sometimes it confuses me when people are talking about automation, is that what they mean in the traditional sense? Because I have spoken to ⁓ ops directors and COOs who have been adamant that that's what the business needs. ⁓ automation. I've been looking at the warehouse and I'm thinking really. ⁓ How have you come to that conclusion at this stage? Because there's a load of stuff that comes before these decisions. know, and lots of different improvements you can put in place, such as Pictolite, or you can automate label printing, you can automate different elements of the supply chain. Semi-automation, but full automation, fully mechanical. That's a big shift. You know, I think there's a journey before you decide that a burgeoning business is already ready for that full automation. I think you should know what you're spending your time and money on in great detail before you ⁓ start ringing the automation bell. Dan Culverhouse: I have a ⁓ a mantra that I have used many, many times with companies when I'm talking to them about the possibilities of you know, when we're talking about new solutions development and one of the options could be automation. ⁓ and that is that I always start the conversation with ⁓ never a mess. ⁓ If operation ⁓ is struggling, a bit chaotic, not the best plan. Please don't think that automating it is going to fix that. It doesn't. It just accentuates the problem. You know, it just means you'll be able to do more mess and it'll make a bigger mess in the same space. You know, I think if there are two things that I would say to people when they're considering automation One is you need to know how your operation works in detail. It should be process driven, it should be written down, you should understand it. And the second is you should have a very clear understanding about what your objectives are. What do you think you're going to achieve by automating? and you need to be really, really tough on yourself to make sure that you actually are going to achieve that. Because I've seen this many, many times is once you start going down the road into automation, it's really exciting. You know, I mean it is, I mean, like, you know. Talk about kids in a sweep shop and you know, or in a toy shop is probably even better ⁓ analogy, is that there's this this world of amazing solutions. ⁓ and it's really exciting. Running an automated warehouse is exciting. It's also, if it's not going well, incredibly stressful. ⁓ and I've written about that before. So I think you need to be really clear on those two ⁓ on those two things. And if if you really don't have a good grasp on What's causing your operation problems? You know, because you might just think, I've just got too much business. If I could automate, I could be able to do more through this space. Maybe that could well be true. But you really need to understand what is the bottleneck, what is causing the problem. You know, because sometimes, as you say, just a little bit of planning or a little bit of change in the process and you can unlock that problem and continue it through. And then for automation isn't what you needed. Keith: Yeah, I've seen it myself where the goal for two years time is full automation. But when I've really got into the nitty gritty, you know, understanding how many people are currently on inbound, for example, and seeing their lack of visibility has been almost like the major cost saver of the year. Providing them with... visibility of what orders are coming in and then everything else flows from there. If you don't know that, how much you're spending and why and what is prohibiting your development, yeah, you're right, that's very thin ice, that's dangerous territory. If you think about automation in any which sense, any element of your life, it's like the phrase, the sledgehammer to crack a nut. You you get hot one day a year in your house. I'm going to change all the air conditioning throughout my whole house and come up with a complicated heating system. It doesn't solve the problem of buying a fan. it's. Yeah, it's very exciting, as you say, very, very exciting and efficiencies. Dan Culverhouse: You'd appreciate it today though. Yeah. It really is. Keith: Process improvements are very exciting to me. And when automation is the solution, I mean, what a great thing to be involved in so much learning. But it's just as satisfying sometimes building a communication plan or SOPs or bringing your team together or connecting the dots. And even that journey of understanding where the biggest costs are, you know, and understanding, I worked on a packaging project once where I managed to save Dan Culverhouse: Awesome. Keith: something like 360K. And it was through reducing elements and automating parts of the process, the void fill getting rid of the tape in full, but reducing the non-value added steps. If we hadn't thought that way, we might have put in a packing machine ⁓ and ⁓ very machines it doesn't suit every scenario. Dan Culverhouse: It doesn't. And you know, automation does not replace good management. and if you don't manage it and you don't have good understanding of what's going on, it's a disaster and it will destroy what you think. Yeah, I absolutely ⁓ Keith: You're not going to understand what's going on with a... You can't see the stock within the automated warehouse. You can't see it. What are going to do? Dan Culverhouse: Yeah. Yeah, 'cause you can't go in and just find it, right? Like in an old warehouse, you can't just go walking through the racking because most of the racking doesn't have any aisles in it because you removed them to make it more dense and to use cranes. And therefore, you can't just go and look. you absolutely need that clarity of process. You know, and and going back to this the objectives of why you automate, you know, you get this ⁓ I d I just want to automate a process, I just don't want to deal I have so many people issues. Just automate it and take away the people. I've been doing this in pretty much ⁓ for the last twenty-five years and I've never seen a manless operation. The closest I came ⁓ was ⁓ with a an ice cream warehouse where it was lit it was connected to a ⁓ a manufacturing plant where basically it just produced pallets of ice cream and these things were built on the production line, they were automatically loaded into vehicles, it went across the The yard, or you know, a few hundred meters. these pallets were automatically unloaded from a truck and then went into a high bay warehouse, oxygen suppressed because they had no reason to break a pallet ever. It only ever went out in pallets. So came in in four pallets, was put away into a high bay, no lights, ⁓ oxygen in there whatsoever. ⁓ and ⁓ when it was called out, it was always called out in pallet quantities. So it came out. via pallet conveyor and was ⁓ then on the way out was loaded by somebody onto the truck ⁓ and they had a team of maintenance obviously to keep it going. Now that's the closest I have ever seen to an autonomously automated warehouse and that's because they never had to touch the product. Never. You know, and so literally when they used to go in and do maintenance they had to wear oxygen masks because there was no, you know, and the reason it's oxygen suppressed Is because it used less electricity as the cranes run up and down the aisles. There's less resistance, would you believe? Because there's no oxygen. So the air was create less resistance and it saved them money on electricity. So it was an incredible, you know, it's just a basic yeah, black box. chances of having things that simple, yeah. Keith: It's a very long journey to make something as intricate as that work as did ⁓ and a very specific problem solve. A perishable product where human touch can actually be detrimental to the product. So it goes without saying we need to develop our own solutions ⁓ One of the most effective automations I've ever seen and the guy who developed it was ⁓ justifiably proud of it. Dan Culverhouse: Yeah. Yeah. Keith: was when I worked in the flower industry and it was at the flower market and well the whole market was connected by the conveyor belts and an automated scanning system. Flowers, I mean the time scales involved in the flower industry are like you've never seen before. The auction begins at something like 4am. They've all got to be on trucks. Trucks by five, you know, it's an overnight business but It's got to move fast, it's perishable products, you can't have any mistakes. That would have been done very traditionally for many many years. People would use barrows, trolleys. mixed up flowers here, there and everywhere. It was a very efficient solution that joined the entire auction and the market together. Necessary to bring the industry forward and you had to take your hat off to him. It was an amazing achievement. But again, he knew the industry intricately. He knew exactly what he was trying to solve and he could not scale. the business without that automation because he would have had to rely on manual workarounds forevermore for human mistakes. People relying on shouting really to get messages across. So that was very impressive. Have you ever seen, I think I know what you're going to tell me here Dan, have you ever seen an automation that did not achieve what it set out to? Dan Culverhouse: Yeah, yeah. I I mean I could give you a whole list of stories. ⁓ but let let me ⁓ let me talk about one that I did. I worked in South Korea ⁓ many, many years ago. ⁓ when I was with ⁓ Tesco bought a company in South Korea. ⁓ their supply chain, so it was a hypermarket retail business, so big stores, may you know big, big SKU range, ⁓ took big deliveries. ⁓ and it was basically a direct-to-store model when we first bought the business. ⁓ and they wanted to centralize the ⁓ the distribution to reduce the amount of deliveries going into store. Now, South Korea is a hugely expensive labor market. So they were like, Okay, so Let's use some automation. You know, we've had some success with it in the UK. Maybe we can ⁓ maybe we can ⁓ do that. ⁓ and so I was asked, I just finished a big project in the UK and I was asked to go to South Korea ⁓ and manage this this project to introduce centralized distribution for the first time. and they wanted it automated because the cost of people was so high. And it and and it was so high. ⁓ so great project, ⁓ really exciting. So, you know, so we scoped out You know, this is the this is the business they had. Thirty hypermarkets, they were gonna grow to sixty over the next five, eight years, something like that. So suppliers are bringing it in, we would receive it, pick it to order, and it would be distributed out. So we built a massive sortation system that was 300 meters long in this place. Incredible thing. ⁓ And basically, what came in was just basically at the back the truck, you just chucked it onto conveyors. it through a scanning system, ⁓ worked out what it placed it against an order, saw the demand against it, ⁓ and then ⁓ and ⁓ sorted it to a store. ⁓ And ⁓ it was ⁓ it worked very I was very proud of it. ⁓ and it you know were doing a lot of productivity but things were changing with the internet and everything, they started to build convenience stores. So where they had a a business plan to have 60 hypermarkets within about two years of ⁓ of that, they had maybe 40 hypermarkets, but they had a hundred convenience stores. Now suddenly they have this sortation system that had maybe thirty chutes and you could have different stores at the end of each chute. The design to have big orders go into big stores. And then suddenly the business model was small orders to many, many more ⁓ small retail outlets, and it didn't work anymore. It was less productive and actually very difficult to be able to distribute to all those stores at the same time. Five years after they spent multiple millions on that, they ripped it out and went back to painting lines on the floor. Keith: some of the biggest issues I've seen is that lack of flexibility. Building for a particular size operation ⁓ or a scenario, but different parts of the business grow and I haven't been accounted for. So they haven't got the allocation of space or ⁓ pick faces, et cetera. ⁓ And then... ⁓ Dan Culverhouse: ⁓ Keith: You know in the world of acquisitions and mergers, know, everyone's trying to exit these days business models change regularly It's not it's not uncommon for someone to be acquired and for the model to be To change dramatically sometimes, you know, you know It's all been taken into account, you know, it's been weighed up. It's a necessary thing. But how do you How do you factor in change when you're building automation in your experience? How can you least future-proof it for as long as the return of investment is there? Dan Culverhouse: Yeah. So I think there's a number important points to make here. Firstly, ⁓ automation is much flexible and agile today ⁓ than it used be. It's very much less ⁓ bolted down, heavy and is much more now agile, movable ⁓ solutions. So that would be the first thing. So the technology has moved on and you have a lot more. You know, you can reprogram something over a weekend and it will change ⁓ what it does in its entirety. The other thing I would say is because of that, ⁓ that you're not bolting everything to the floor. And I think that, you know, I said earlier this very simple example of where you used to have a conveyor running from A to B. Now you can just have a manless truck or a manless little robot running between the two. ⁓ and if you decided that actually you wanted it to go somewhere else, you just have to reprogram it, it can go somewhere else. ⁓ You know, and you've not you've not made the commitment. So you you you immediately have something which is more more agile and more modular, right? So nowadays, ⁓ I would always encourage an operation to say, you know, sometimes they go into a new site and you can it's greenfield, it's a little bit of a different discussion, but the majority of the time you're trying to adapt an operation while you're in it. And you know, I've always say just create yourself a bit of space, set up a portion of your warehouse under a new solution using ⁓ you know some form of the you know the the right solution of robotics and how we get to that is a different story but you can you can modularize it so you can just take you know one portion say 10% of your business run it through a solution is it good yes is it good no okay so what can we do to it how can we adjust it how can we change it you know ⁓ there are a lot of solutions now. You don't even have to buy. You can lease and rent robotics now. You know, so if you get it wrong, you can just take it out and change it. And and and you're you've not you've not committed to buying it and doing it a certain way for that, you know. So it's modular, so you can change it, you can add to it, you can you can relocate it within your operation without the ⁓ too much difficulty. The programming of these machines ⁓ and the configurations of them are much more user-friendly and ⁓ and and capable these days. So you can you can do different things with the same equipment. So the risk, you don't have to, you know, absolutely say, right, I'm doing it this way for the next 10 years because that's how long it's going to cost to pay this back. You can get going and then it can be amended and adjusted as you grow. So I think it it it has become a much a much more fluid, modular, ⁓ and flexible ⁓ challenge to have. Keith: It probably had to adapt. It probably had to adapt, didn't it? Because a lot of the scare stories probably found people weren't investing in these permanent solutions as readily. about I think some ⁓ people forget that when it comes to building automation, you take on board the maintenance team as well. Dan Culverhouse: Yeah, I I I think ⁓ you know it's very easy when you're ⁓ when you're designing ⁓ automation solutions and you're working on your business case so you've understood what you're investing and the productivity gains or the the the extra volume that you can get through the warehouse or you know the amount of checking that you can remove because you have an accurate picking process that doesn't make errors. You know, all these things, great. Savings, savings, savings. One of the really common problems ⁓ is people don't consider that there are certain things in your warehouse that will go up enormously. and facilities and maintenance is is pro is probably the most ⁓ extreme and you know most warehouses you have an old guy does the facilities he changes light bulbs and he oils the forklifts and you know and I'm I may be being a little bit unkind but it's a very you know in a manual warehouse where you're just maintaining a few forklifts changing some legs on the racking when someone bangs into it, changing light bulbs and things like that. It's it's a it's not a critical part of the operation. You go to automation, that facilities manager becomes one of the most important people in your leadership team. Because the way that that's approached, you know, automation maintenance has to be done on a preventative basis. So you have to cycle it in, you have to plan it into your day or into your week. and you know the uptime of that automation is a really, really important metric because if it's if it's down for four hours a day, you know, it's never gonna pay for what what you do. So that facilities person becomes a very high, highly important member of your team, probably paid a very different skill set to what it is, and then you know, you don't have a couple of people changing lightbulbs you have an entire maintenance team which are electrically, mechanically skilled. So they're much so it's a big expense, right? So for all the benefits that you're taking from ⁓ from your solution, you have to build in that you have to put this very much highly skilled team in place. Planning and analytics, a completely different field once you get into this. Running an automated warehouse is effectively running a production line. That's the way you have to perceive it. You were basically changing your traditional warehouse to a production line. Because what you do in one part of the warehouse completely is affecting the rest of it. It's all connected. ⁓ and you have to completely shift your mindset. And there are expenses and there are costs, cost of carrying the spares. Huge amount of money. But overall, generally, you know, if you've done your business case right, it it it still provides you. I mean, you know, we're we're we're being quite ⁓ I guess, challenging with ⁓ with this. Automation done right is a game changer. I mean they are some incredible examples of solutions that are really make a huge difference. And I don't want to sound, you know, I've made my career out of delivering these solutions, but it's so important to do it for the right reason. Keith: No, it's just approach to precaution. I've been... I've been at work before when the automation is packed in. I think it was to do with the generator running out of fuel. Again, this is we're talking about a facilities manager having a different different skill set. mean, obviously that was a bit of an oversight. But yeah, it closed down. Whereas in the past you would improvise and... You know, look to the people, what can we do? A bit different. In this case, all the stock is within the automation. There wasn't really much that could be done apart from fix it. At cost and yeah, so it's always worth it. Yeah, you've got to be on the ball. It becomes a bit easier. It's amazing how many businesses don't have a contingency plan for any circumstances, let alone a power outage. Dan Culverhouse: Yeah. You're running a factory. Mm-hmm. Keith: Yeah, that was an interesting thing. mean, the looks of horror when everyone realised that nothing was working and realising that the only fix was to fix it. There was no way we could just get down on the floor and do something a bit different and everyone picked by hand. It had changed. Dan Culverhouse: Yeah, yeah, yeah. It it's another good example of why you shouldn't go into automated solutions lightly. For every all your solutions, all the things you put in place, you need to have contingencies for. Power outages, you know, in the past, okay, so you went onto emergency lighting, you could still operate, right? But if all the machinery goes off, you ⁓ we've got a big problem, which is why automated warehouses should always have a hundred percent backup generation. And they should always make sure that the bloody tanks are full of fuel so you can actually run it. You know, it is if you can you know and this is where You know, we've talked a little bit about the importance of going into it with great clarity as to what it is you're trying to achieve and making sure you have a good understanding of what you do before you do it. ⁓ Really important things to start with. Beyond that, the the process of designing what is the right solution, what the solution should cover and what it shouldn't cover. So because you know that that comment full automation is very rare. You normally have what might call uglies that just don't fit and you have to run them, you know, you have to have a manual side to your operation as well. You know, that design and process, one is designing solutions. And ⁓ the first thing I would say is be very careful if you're an operation, you go to an automation company and ask for a solution. Because and and I'm not being hard on on automation companies. It it's just the reality of the situation. An automation company will sell you a solution that they'll tell you is the best one. Of course they'll tell you it's the best. It's their it's their you know, but automation companies don't provide an end end-to-end solutions for everything, right? So sometimes they have to adapt their solutions to work for what you want. So you think, okay, ⁓ they're telling me this is great, brilliant. But if you went and asked another automation company, they might do something very different because what they provide is different. And then it becomes a really difficult this guy says I should use this type of automation, this guy says I should use this type of automation. How do you make that decision? I would always encourage people to find some independent expertise that has got the experience of working with these various different solutions to be able to just take what you want. And tell you what in the market is most suitable without any skin in the game, right? You know, if if you've got if you're gonna sell, because even you know, you get the integrators that take multiple solutions and put them together, most of them still have partnerships with these companies and they will they will always go to certain companies first. But find some independent expertise that can really validate what it is that you need and provide you with a clarity over what the right solution is and what. not to automate because there are certain things that you just say, you know what, 80% of your business would work really well, but this 20%, don't touch it. It will be a disaster. training, it takes adjustment, configuration. People need to see this as a long-term ⁓ strategy rather than I don't put it in and I mean I can cut my people in half and I'm ⁓ you know great. It just doesn't work like that. When you get it right, you have a long term goal and you have strategic ⁓ perspective on it, you can deliver incredible you know, I've seen productivity improvements in the tens of percent, twenty, thirty percent improvements because they really thought it through and got it right. I've also been to some operations where you know, I had I had a really interesting one. I worked for a promotions company. We used to sell promotional ⁓ items and we worked with a retailer in Denmark. They had this incredible ⁓ automated warehouse. It's so much kit in it, it was incredible. I remember being in a meeting with them and they asked me if I could go and source a different warehouse and deliver this product to store independently of their supply chain because their warehouse was so expensive. They had bought so much equipment and they had automation to do everything, it became very restrictive and very expensive to run. Then they actually asked us to set up a separate supply chain. Keith: We didn't deliver the efficiencies in the long run, yeah. Dan Culverhouse: I mean it was just like mind blowing. But that's the price of getting it wrong. But of course, this was a multimillion dollar, you know, investment. They were stuck with it for the next fifteen years probably. But, you know, at the time, it was about a year or so old at that time, is that they couldn't they couldn't make it pay. It was costing them more than their old manual warehouse was costing. ⁓ and that's the price of getting it wrong. Keith: Absolutely and we've both workplaces where you get the tacked on processes. New products that don't fit the automated flow so they don't need a manual workaround. Certain specialist packing or labeling requirements like dangerous goods that weren't factored in. Some new workaround processes. Teams developing around the add-on. Dan Culverhouse: Yeah. Keith: processes, glitches in the flow developing into teams that ⁓ cover that glitch. ⁓ Seen all sorts, I mean it's all part of the journey, it's not right or wrong, they make for some good memories but yeah also goes to show. You know, speaking to the people who do the job and involving the right stakeholders as well is essential. mean, trying to develop automation without speaking to warehouse staff is absolutely like assuming you know the pain points from ⁓ spreadsheets Dan Culverhouse: Don't make a disaster. you're absolutely right. You know, I think ⁓ yeah, i it it it it's it's a game changing ⁓ project to take on in the right circumstances. So if you know what your challenges are and you know how your operation works, you have very clear, realistic goals, and you employ the professionals to make sure that the decisions are right, the deployment is right. You know, I I I've I've got a number of operations. You know, I did one 27 years ago that is still running and it's still delivering. You know, it's incredible. Keith: That must be give you a lot of pride. Dan Culverhouse: You know, the the the the staying power of that you know, in it was i I I it's I have huge pride in in knowing that that operation is still going now. It's the the first big one I ever did. ⁓ and it's still running. and that's incredible. You know, and that has that that was irritated. Hey. It does but it's doing the job, right? Keith: It did a job. It did a job that it was intended to do and it did it well. Sometimes I think people will be surprised if you go behind the doors of some of the big names or ⁓ massive businesses and they'll be surprised how literal to machine this sometimes is. It really does depend. If it's sufficient, it's sufficient. Obviously, things like the parcel carriers. Dan Culverhouse: Yeah. Keith: their warehouses are phenomenal. They couldn't operate without automation. ⁓ The scale of those operations and they're amazing to see. But sometimes simplicity is what drives ⁓ effectiveness and you'll see some well-organized warehouses and systems in place. I've seen some beautiful warehouses that are just the cleanest warehouse you'll see and that is part of the beginning of their efficiency journey. Sorting cleaning, routine, that is the first step. And they can see everything that's happening. I love the design of some warehouses where simple mezzanine gives you such a good view of what's happening. That's a game changer. It's all sorts of things you can do. And it's a very exciting world and it continues to be one. And that's why we love it so much. You know, there's so many examples. Dan Culverhouse: Yeah, absolutely. Absolutely. And I but I will just say again, you know, we asked at the top, should all operations be considering it? Consider it, sure. But should they all do it? No. You know, I I can remember I was ⁓ I I was working ⁓ somewhere ⁓ and when I joined they had this this design for a a big FMCG ⁓ sort of grocery retail warehouse would say that that's incredible automated solution. ⁓ and I I I I when I joined we went through this process of analysis ⁓ and and and I I I ripped it up and and told them to not do it, save the money. And what we did, you know, we continue to have a standard traditional wide aisled ⁓ warehouse, but we just deployed very smart paperless ⁓ and geolocated ⁓ technology, so it kept everybody busy. And always productive wherever they were. So whenever they finished an assignment, and these warehouses are like two hundred thousand square feet, they're massive places, right? You can be half a mile from one end to the other. So when you finished your assignment at one end, it immediately dropped you another one based on where you were in the warehouse. So immediately you could start picking. So it just meant that the people were productive all the time. And that made it very, very flexible. Could ramp up and down with volume, it was absolutely fantastic. And it was by far the best solution for the task that they had. There are many other operations where you'd rip all that out and you'd put a put in a load of technology. But it's not always the answer. And you know these things these things vary based on what they are. Keith: You refer to Tim Wood? No, you were able to reduce you were able to reduce one of the seven wastes as they call it and that was motion. Always look at the waste and the blockers and what's prohibiting you from performing as you should. And I think almost a circle back to your answer, no, my answer's the same. Some things can be solved in a different way, in a simpler way before. Dan Culverhouse: Well it's in the biggest yeah. Keith: You know, one day you might explore the automation in full, but it's not always the right time. Sometimes it's too soon and there's plenty you can do on the ground. You almost need to make sure your house is in order. Everything's operating to the best of your capacity, your ability before you invest in the rest. Dan Culverhouse: I I think you've really hit the nail on the head with you make sure your house is in order. You need to have control and understanding of your operation before you go down this road. And, you know, it's not a scale thing anymore. Some quite small operations can benefit from a degree of automation. And, you know, all automation is not an on off switch. You know, it it is a sliding scale of engagement. And there are some very, very effective, low-cost ⁓ automation solutions that relatively small businesses can get great benefit from. So it's really a case of understanding what your operation is, how it works, where your pinch points are. And sometimes an automated solution is right to fix that pin pinch point. Sometimes it's just a layout problem, sometimes a configuration of your WMS. But You know, so you don't have to be a major you don't have to be Amazon, you don't have to be Tesco, ⁓ you don't have to be General Electric to benefit from automation. There are some amazing solutions that are very good for smaller businesses. You just need to know your business first. Keith: Absolutely. You can also be a very big business, it's semi-automated, but it's the same thing. It's knowing and understanding why and where and how. So that's... Dan Culverhouse: The best solutions, the best solutions are a combination of machine and human. It's a collaboration that makes it work. It's optimal. Anybody who thinks that it automation can't h help or everything needs to be automated, it's always wrong. It's always the degrees in between. And it's a collaboration between man and machine, person and machine to be a little bit more politically correct, I guess. But That's where they work the best. Keith: Well, never has it been more relevant. AI in itself is an automation of different processes. It's never been more relevant. Know why you're using it and what you want to enhance. But this has been a very interesting chat. We knew it would be. It was always on our list, but thanks. For the man, the gentleman who requested we talk about this, keep the suggestions coming because that's what we want. We want to chat about what. People in supply chain want to know about and people outside of supply chain, buyers, founders, anyone who wants to learn. Keep your suggestions coming. We, as you can tell, are more than happy to talk about any supply chain subject in depth. So, for now, goodbye. I hope you enjoyed this episode and we'll see you next time. Dan Culverhouse: Yep. ⁓ thanks for opportunity to talk about a subject that's very close to my heart and that has driven most of my career. ⁓ I've ⁓ I've enjoyed it. can't wait to hear your comments. Don't forget like, subscribe and all those things that make podcasters happy. ⁓ Thanks for listening. Speak to you again soon.