Latest / Well Bound Podcast / Ep. 49 - When AI Talks Nutrition, Should We Listen?
Transcript
- 0:07[SPEAKER_03]: Welcome back to another episode of Wellbound, where your host is Peyton Janch, and Brooke Snyder.
- 0:12[SPEAKER_03]: And in today's episode, we are going to be talking about something that is a little bit more prevalent.
- 0:18[SPEAKER_03]: I feel like just in the past couple years, which is the use of artificial intelligence for really like nutrition and health care requests or needs from individuals.
- 0:30[SPEAKER_03]: I see this a lot now and here from like friends and clients that they're utilizing things like chat GPT for example to come up with a fitness plan or a nutrition plan or
- 0:46[SPEAKER_03]: any random question and I know from personal experience that there are some pros and cons and so we'll get into those.
- 0:52[SPEAKER_01]: I think this is a really relevant topic just because it's something that we now know like it's not going away and so people are relying on it more and more and I've even seen you know online or on social media people making jokes about like oh our doctors are typing our problems into chat to be great and relying on those answers which is obviously not the case but we wanted to kind of go through the pros and cons of
- 1:15[SPEAKER_01]: being able to utilize some of their services because I'd be lying if I said that I never used chat GPT like to help me craft an email or help me make something sound a little bit better or you know whatever the case might be or even looking something up really quick like sometimes I know a lot of people prefer chat GPT over a search engine like Google for example right
- 1:38[SPEAKER_01]: They're now starting to lean that way and prefer using it as a search engine versus going to the internet.
- 1:45[SPEAKER_01]: It's on the internet, but you know a typical search engine like Google, Yahoo, etc.
- 1:49[SPEAKER_01]: And I just think it's really interesting.
- 1:50[SPEAKER_01]: So I don't know, we can kind of get into some like pros, cons, and then some research.
- 1:55[SPEAKER_03]: Yeah, yeah, because I think we're both definitely on this side of kind of like Brooke said like there's a benefit in a ease of being able to utilize these kind of resources and we're not like knocking it at all because like Brooke said we probably both used it for different things.
- 2:12[SPEAKER_03]: Yeah, but there are some things to just be careful about when it comes to personal health and kind of the questions that we're asking.
- 2:20[SPEAKER_01]: So yeah, I think I think I think kind of what Payton's saying is there's a difference in
- 2:26[SPEAKER_01]: utilizing it for some generalized needs or recommendations versus like personalized care that you would seek out otherwise from a health professional.
- 2:37[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, yeah, cool.
- 2:38[SPEAKER_01]: So let's go over the pros first.
- 2:40[SPEAKER_01]: Don't you think?
- 2:41[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, kind of talk about some cons.
- 2:42[SPEAKER_01]: Yep.
- 2:43[SPEAKER_01]: And I think we've kind of mentioned some of these already.
- 2:45[SPEAKER_01]: I think the first pro that's huge is it's very quick way to receive information, right?
- 2:51[SPEAKER_01]: Super fast.
- 2:51[SPEAKER_01]: You can type in whatever you want to type in and it basically spits out an answer immediately, which in our world of kind of that like short term gratification, or I don't know.
- 3:03[SPEAKER_01]: I know I have a lack of patience sometimes if my phone is even taking a second to load, you know, or if I'm in a spotty cell phone spot.
- 3:11[SPEAKER_01]: I get frustrated, so I think that's a very big pros.
- 3:15[SPEAKER_01]: It's a very quick way to receive information, and then you can also access that information, twenty four seven, which is huge in terms of, like,
- 3:26[SPEAKER_01]: You can't always access your doctor, your dietation, or even, like, I don't know, you're a makeup artist or your hair stylist.
- 3:33[SPEAKER_00]: Well, thank you.
- 3:33[SPEAKER_01]: You can't access these people at twenty four seven, so it's a good access point.
- 3:38[SPEAKER_01]: Like, you could type something in a midnight when you have a, well, that's what I was saying.
- 3:41[SPEAKER_01]: Not gonna let you sleep.
- 3:42[SPEAKER_03]: I was just gonna say that, like, if you're in the middle, up in the middle of the night, and you're just like, stewing over something, because I do this, and I always try to talk myself out of getting on my phone, because I don't want to wake myself up.
- 3:54[SPEAKER_03]: but there's sometimes I'll wake up and it's like the most random question like how was this created you know and it's like okay if I can just like figured out then I can be done with it and go to bed again I don't encourage you to get on your phone in the middle of the night because it'll probably make you wake up more but it's there right and it's available for
- 4:12[SPEAKER_01]: things like that.
- 4:13[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, which is a huge pro.
- 4:15[SPEAKER_01]: And I guess could also be seen as a con because we talk about the usage of, you know, our phones and things, but whatever, I put it, I wanted to put it in the pro category because I think in terms of having access, twenty four seven to something, whereas you're not going to have access to your provider, twenty four seven.
- 4:32[SPEAKER_01]: I think it's a great tool.
- 4:34[SPEAKER_01]: It's also free to use.
- 4:36[SPEAKER_01]: So that's a huge pro.
- 4:38[SPEAKER_01]: And today's, in today's economy,
- 4:41[SPEAKER_01]: But seriously, like everything costs a lot of money.
- 4:43[SPEAKER_03]: Like everything's like a paid subscription to.
- 4:45[SPEAKER_03]: So I'm shocked.
- 4:46[SPEAKER_03]: I know that there's like upsell pieces like to do more photo uploads or whatever you can pay.
- 4:52[SPEAKER_01]: But for the most part, there's a lot of free opportunity.
- 4:55[SPEAKER_01]: Agreed.
- 4:56[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah.
- 4:57[SPEAKER_01]: And then another pro is that how it pulls its information is it uses really large datasets to provide general advice and recommendations.
- 5:08[SPEAKER_01]: And so I think
- 5:09[SPEAKER_01]: It's important or a pro that they're using very, very large sets of data.
- 5:17[SPEAKER_01]: But I mean, we'll get into the cons later.
- 5:19[SPEAKER_01]: I think it's a pro that they're using an extremely large database.
- 5:24[SPEAKER_03]: Right, because you don't want their advice coming from like two opinions.
- 5:28[SPEAKER_01]: Yes, exactly.
- 5:29[SPEAKER_01]: Or a very small subset of information.
- 5:31[SPEAKER_01]: Right.
- 5:32[SPEAKER_01]: So I think those are just some pros that I could rattle off the top of my head.
- 5:36[SPEAKER_03]: Yeah, and I mean, I, like I mentioned, I have friends and clients who talk about using chatGPT or other resources for like nutrition help or fitness help and specifically a pro that I've heard friends and clients talk about.
- 5:53[SPEAKER_03]: is they'll put in, so for example, you know, they're like, I don't have a plan for dinner, but I have like food at home and they will put in a list of all the food items that they have in their pantry or their fridge and say, hey, help me create a dinner recipe or help me create a snack recipe.
- 6:09[SPEAKER_03]: And it helps them utilize the things that they already have instead of having to go out and buy more things or spend money when they already have food and it helps reduce food waste.
- 6:20[SPEAKER_03]: And it also can just help get creative in the kitchen.
- 6:22[SPEAKER_03]: I mean, if someone else is giving you a recipe idea, it's kind of fun.
- 6:26[SPEAKER_03]: So I think that's a very healthy and a good
- 6:30[SPEAKER_01]: pro to utilizing this kind of universe I think sometimes we just need a little help in the advice department and or just kind of being able to drum up an idea with some of the ingredients you have at home and I even think this would be a good resource to use if I know a lot of people to who'd type in like
- 6:50[SPEAKER_01]: I would like a healthy grocery list with some recipe ideas for the family.
- 6:53[SPEAKER_01]: So though, I don't know.
- 6:56[SPEAKER_01]: I think that's also a great way to budget eat healthy and reduce food waste like Peyton said.
- 7:00[SPEAKER_01]: But then they'll give you a list that you can take to the store along with some recipes to create, let's say it's dinner recipes to create that week for your family.
- 7:10[SPEAKER_01]: And something like that that can take them into load potentially off of you.
- 7:15[SPEAKER_01]: I think it's great.
- 7:17[SPEAKER_01]: It's not tailoring anything, you know, specifically to you necessarily, but it's providing some ideas and you know, and some healthy options for you to utilize for either yourself, your partner or your whole family.
- 7:30[SPEAKER_01]: And I think that either of those two examples, the one that Peyton gave and the one I gave, I think are great ways to utilize AI.
- 7:37[SPEAKER_03]: Yeah, and I'll talk about later.
- 7:38[SPEAKER_03]: I kind of did a personal plug-and-play trial, and I'll talk about this later, but basically I asked it to spit that out some recipes based on these things that I put in, and it gave me some really good suggestions for like well-rounded meals.
- 7:54[SPEAKER_03]: They weren't necessarily super specific to me based on my needs, but they had like a variety of fruits and vegetables, and they had good protein and all of that.
- 8:04[SPEAKER_03]: And so, I mean, that's a win.
- 8:06[SPEAKER_01]: or can even spark an idea that you're like, oh, I love making this.
- 8:10[SPEAKER_01]: Like, I can make it more so make it more like my mom's, you know, I don't know, meatloaf or something.
- 8:15[SPEAKER_01]: If it gave you that as an option.
- 8:18[SPEAKER_01]: So it may just help you come up with ideas.
- 8:21[SPEAKER_01]: But I think that would be those are all great ways to use it and pros of AI.
- 8:25[SPEAKER_01]: And I'm sure there's others.
- 8:28[SPEAKER_01]: But those were kind of the ones off the top of our head that we could really think of.
- 8:32[SPEAKER_01]: And then as far as cons go, do you want to kind of like we can get into cons?
- 8:37[SPEAKER_01]: Do you feel about talking about pros?
- 8:38[SPEAKER_03]: Yeah, I feel good about that.
- 8:39[SPEAKER_03]: Cool.
- 8:41[SPEAKER_03]: I'll kind of talk about just the fact that with utilizing the internet and software and like not human
- 8:51[SPEAKER_03]: person, right?
- 8:52[SPEAKER_03]: Yeah.
- 8:53[SPEAKER_03]: There is misinformation out there.
- 8:54[SPEAKER_03]: It's just like when you go on social media and you might be talking to or looking at someone's content that you think really knows what they're talking about.
- 9:03[SPEAKER_03]: They know their stuff and then come to find out once later like it was misinformation and it wasn't correct and you know it wasn't well researched information.
- 9:12[SPEAKER_03]: So there is misinformation out there and outdated information is seen all the time.
- 9:17[SPEAKER_03]: I know I've had people who unrelated to nutrition or health like type something and they're like that is not like even right.
- 9:24[SPEAKER_03]: Like someone who is very knowledgeable about a topic asked something about that and then it spit out or sped out false information.
- 9:33[SPEAKER_03]: It's just like if you've ever asked the internet something and have been given false information, I mean, it happens all the time.
- 9:40[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, I mean, I know we've said this probably a bunch of times on the podcast, but sometimes I feel like eighty percent of my job is battling that meant misinformation, that people either see on the internet or social media.
- 9:53[SPEAKER_01]: And I think that there's an element to that with AI as well.
- 9:58[SPEAKER_03]: Yeah, because it's like if you if you don't know that the information is false, obviously, I've talked about a couple instances where the people could really looking be like, hey, that's not even true.
- 10:07[SPEAKER_03]: Like that's not right.
- 10:08[SPEAKER_03]: But if you don't know, you're just going to believe what it says.
- 10:12[SPEAKER_03]: I don't know what you don't know.
- 10:13[SPEAKER_03]: And obviously, when this is then related to a nutrition or a health specific situation, it may be harmful in that regard.
- 10:21[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, agreed.
- 10:22[SPEAKER_01]: And I think Peyton kind of touched on this a little bit, but that lack of like human touch or human interaction and just that kind of like eye of a provider.
- 10:31[SPEAKER_01]: I think that that can be a con because for example, when reviewing blood work or in complex cases where I'm just going to talk about in complex maybe like nutrition cases where they have either multiple kind of things going on or multiple conditions that we're dealing with.
- 10:49[SPEAKER_01]: or some of those with very specific dietary needs, allergies and tolerances on top of maybe a health condition.
- 10:57[SPEAKER_01]: This can be really difficult to rely on something like AI for because you don't have that human touch or that eye of the provider.
- 11:06[SPEAKER_01]: And I also think that human element can be in the form of even like empathy, understanding or accountability from a provider too, like think about a fitness coach or your personal trainer.
- 11:18[SPEAKER_01]: You know, yes, and I have done this to sometimes have chat GPT help me write up a workout because I'm going to the gym and I just can't even.
- 11:27[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah.
- 11:27[SPEAKER_01]: tolerate the thought of putting something together but it's like are you going to are you going to show up and actually do it are you going to put yourself in the way that's needed or is it tailored to specific muscle groups or specific
- 11:44[SPEAKER_01]: I don't know.
- 11:45[SPEAKER_01]: Things that you need that a personal trainer or a string coach would be able to help you achieve certain goals that you have because they understand physiology obviously better than chat GPT.
- 11:56[SPEAKER_03]: Well, yeah, and I just think about two like
- 11:59[SPEAKER_03]: I don't know asking for health information or not having a person there that knows you and has asked all these questions like you might personally be leaving information out that's critical for a professional to do the work.
- 12:16[SPEAKER_03]: And I know I can have two people that come in to see me that look exactly the same, have roughly the same schedule and their needs look very different.
- 12:24[SPEAKER_03]: And so, you know, it's kind of like not always a one size fits all when we're in putting information in, but it's using a bunch of data and you're going to get more of a one size fits all approach based on your height, your weight, your activity level.
- 12:39[SPEAKER_03]: which isn't the only thing that we're looking at when we're calculating all of your needs.
- 12:43[SPEAKER_01]: Right.
- 12:44[SPEAKER_01]: And I know both patented myself really pride ourselves in creating more individualized approach for our clients or like my athletes and stuff.
- 12:53[SPEAKER_01]: But I also sometimes this kind of, I guess freaks me out or I put this in the con category.
- 13:01[SPEAKER_01]: When we talk about inputting information, let's even say just about yourself.
- 13:05[SPEAKER_01]: We know that AI isn't going away and we're going to continue to, let's say if it was health-related, input information about yourself.
- 13:14[SPEAKER_01]: And so what, potentially, privacy or security concerns, pop up?
- 13:18[SPEAKER_01]: I don't know the answer to this.
- 13:20[SPEAKER_03]: I think if there was like a data breach,
- 13:22[SPEAKER_03]: Like someone can know so much about you.
- 13:24[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, I'm like AI is obviously saving your information.
- 13:27[SPEAKER_01]: So if you give it a bunch of personal information or medical information, what are the implications of this in the future?
- 13:34[SPEAKER_01]: Like we really don't know that.
- 13:37[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, we really don't know that.
- 13:38[SPEAKER_01]: And so depending on what you're giving it,
- 13:42[SPEAKER_01]: And sometimes I've asked it for ideas like when we're trying to come up with ideas about the podcast.
- 13:47[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah.
- 13:47[SPEAKER_01]: What's some trending wellness topics going on right now?
- 13:50[SPEAKER_01]: And or if I've asked it questions about, you know, we now know that I'm pregnant.
- 13:57[SPEAKER_01]: So I've asked it a couple of things of like, at this week, because none of my apps have the actual fruit size.
- 14:02[SPEAKER_01]: So sometimes I just ask you release.
- 14:04[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah.
- 14:05[SPEAKER_01]: Or I think it's just the one app that I have.
- 14:06[SPEAKER_01]: I don't want to put a bunch of apps on my phone.
- 14:08[SPEAKER_01]: So sometimes I look up like what for size or kind of what's going on in that week.
- 14:11[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah.
- 14:12[SPEAKER_01]: just because again it's it's really quick and I don't really feel like digging for the information.
- 14:16[SPEAKER_01]: It's just something that maybe Matt and I want to talk about over dinner.
- 14:19[SPEAKER_01]: But I'm like okay so chat GBT knows that I'm pregnant.
- 14:23[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah.
- 14:23[SPEAKER_01]: Also knows that I host a podcast and sometimes like I think it's creepy how it starts to spit out tailored information for even those two things.
- 14:31[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah.
- 14:32[SPEAKER_01]: And I'm just like, oh my gosh, this is kind of wild when we think about, yeah, if there was a data breach or how is this going to transpire in the future when we have asked it so many questions.
- 14:42[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, it starts to formulate an idea of like, not who you are, but your interest things that you're going through, like it saves all that.
- 14:50[SPEAKER_01]: It's just kind of weird to me.
- 14:52[SPEAKER_03]: I know that when I, because at work, I use it a lot when I'm trying to
- 14:59[SPEAKER_03]: create an email that sounds a little bit more professional like if I'm just like toast in my head and I can't figure out how to make something seem like really concise like that's usually my problem is I'm like long-winded in my email and I'm like I'll copy what I all wrote out and then I'll put it in something I'm like please make this concise and then I'll pick it up just like whatever I want definitely
- 15:20[SPEAKER_03]: But I'm always really careful to like leave out people's names.
- 15:25[SPEAKER_03]: Like I know we were talking about a specific behavioral health provider and I was like I would just leave a blank or like insert name because I'm just like I don't know like it kind of makes me uncomfortable and I'm not someone who admittedly is very like always concerned about safety and like whatever right I think I've talked about that before I'm not someone who's like
- 15:45[SPEAKER_03]: peaking behind my shoulder like when I'm out on a walk at night and even though I'm a young female like I just I don't know I'm not as in tune with that which is probably a fault of my own but yeah so that is one thing that I'm pretty careful about though which is saying something I just think we don't know a fear of the unknown there kind of is
- 16:06[SPEAKER_01]: I think can be a little bit scary because we don't really know the direction that AI is going right and so Yeah, I just think we'll leave that at that but also I mentioned in the prose section that
- 16:21[SPEAKER_01]: What these AI, I don't know, companies, organizations, sites, search engines, search engines use is a very large data set.
- 16:31[SPEAKER_01]: But my question or follow up question would be like, okay, well, where are these, what data sets are you using?
- 16:39[SPEAKER_01]: Like what potentially like other big time companies and organizations research platforms have paid for you to potentially use their data?
- 16:48[SPEAKER_01]: is their bias in those data sets, are we pulling from only certain data sets?
- 16:53[SPEAKER_01]: Like, I just don't know what's happening behind the scenes.
- 16:55[SPEAKER_01]: And so, like, again, deciding.
- 16:57[SPEAKER_01]: Exactly.
- 16:58[SPEAKER_01]: Like, I'm not sure what databases, certain AI outlets are using, but I think it's just an important thing to think about.
- 17:05[SPEAKER_03]: It would be a really, okay, this is just an idea that came to my mind.
- 17:09[SPEAKER_03]: It would be a really cool idea to give like health professionals a job and choosing like what information AI is utilizing.
- 17:22[SPEAKER_03]: So like having us peer review or whatever just the information that's there and picking and choosing like research that's that's good research and sold research or
- 17:33[SPEAKER_03]: throwing out something that was just like on a blog site or something.
- 17:37[SPEAKER_01]: Because I don't really know the behind the scenes with AI outlets.
- 17:40[SPEAKER_01]: Like, I didn't even sense of like what people are behind the scenes.
- 17:45[SPEAKER_01]: I always just assumed it was this one big algorithm that a bunch of people came up with.
- 17:49[SPEAKER_01]: And we can insert data into that algorithm to have them pull information from it.
- 17:53[SPEAKER_01]: And it probably all that coding and stuff goes over my head.
- 17:56[SPEAKER_01]: But it would provide, like what you're saying.
- 18:00[SPEAKER_01]: It could potentially provide job opportunities for health professionals to who really enjoy data and viewing data and researchers too to kind of review this information and kind of audit it a bit.
- 18:12[SPEAKER_03]: Yeah, it's like if you guys, um, I don't know the government or whoever's choosing this, if you guys want to give more opportunities for jobs, there's an idea.
- 18:20[SPEAKER_03]: That'd be interesting.
- 18:21[SPEAKER_03]: I just think that that's like a way that we could humanize it a little bit and make sure it's a little bit more accurate.
- 18:26[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah.
- 18:27[SPEAKER_01]: I don't know.
- 18:27[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, no, that's a really good idea.
- 18:29[SPEAKER_01]: But I think all in all, we were kind of giving pros and cons, even just on generalized advice, but obviously a major con is using this for very specific and very individualized items.
- 18:42[SPEAKER_01]: I just don't really think is your best bet.
- 18:44[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah.
- 18:45[SPEAKER_01]: And I think you can touch on some of the research here and some of the, I know you mentioned that you did a kind of an experiment on yourself.
- 18:52[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah.
- 18:52[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah.
- 18:53[SPEAKER_01]: And I think that'd be interesting coming from
- 18:55[SPEAKER_01]: your perspective.
- 18:56[SPEAKER_03]: Yeah, so I was kind of just looking around to see because this is a newer thing, right?
- 19:00[SPEAKER_03]: But there's been a little bit of research done here and there and whatever.
- 19:04[SPEAKER_03]: So I pulled this article I found off of PubMed and it's called the role of artificial intelligence and nutrition research, a scoping review.
- 19:15[SPEAKER_03]: And this was from June, twenty eighth of twenty twenty four.
- 19:19[SPEAKER_03]: So it's just over a year old, which is good.
- 19:22[SPEAKER_03]: It's new.
- 19:24[SPEAKER_03]: And specifically, I took a little portion off here, because I kind of explained and walked through different areas and pros of different areas, like looking over nutrition information or analyzing, blah, blah, blah, whatever.
- 19:36[SPEAKER_01]: I encourage you to read through, because there are some cool stuff, but maybe we'll put the link in our, either Instagram, caption, or on the description notes of this episode.
- 19:48[SPEAKER_03]: Yeah, and so this was just like looking through things.
- 19:51[SPEAKER_03]: I took a little excerpt out of here and it just says this.
- 19:56[SPEAKER_03]: When a thick-tissious woman asked for diet for a diet telling ChadGPT about her food allergies, ChadGPT failed to recommend diets not having allergens in four out of the fifty-six meals.
- 20:07[SPEAKER_03]: So it did a great job besides if someone who really wasn't knowledgeable on the allergens and keeping them out,
- 20:15[SPEAKER_03]: four of those suggestions had allergens in it.
- 20:18[SPEAKER_03]: So like that would be very serious, potentially life threatening.
- 20:22[SPEAKER_03]: And potentially life threatening for this fictitious woman that we talked about.
- 20:25[SPEAKER_03]: And it says a diet deficient in energy was selected.
- 20:28[SPEAKER_03]: So a calorie restricted diet was selected on purpose to validate if the model would provide nutrition, nutrition advice.
- 20:37[SPEAKER_03]: No warning was generated and energy was also miscalculated in some of the meals.
- 20:42[SPEAKER_03]: So for accuracy of the results, the chat GPT diets were assessed by a dietitian who had completed postgraduate studies in nutrition.
- 20:51[SPEAKER_03]: It is worrisome that chat GPT may provide misleading information to non-experts in nutrition.
- 20:57[SPEAKER_03]: However, the AI diet recommended following dietary guidelines.
- 21:01[SPEAKER_03]: So it was just saying, hey, here's all this stuff, but just make sure you're looking at the DGA's.
- 21:06[SPEAKER_03]: Which, okay, that's kind of like a
- 21:09[SPEAKER_01]: By availability, yeah, very blanket statement and probably just a liability statement.
- 21:14[SPEAKER_01]: Yes.
- 21:15[SPEAKER_03]: It says in contrast, another study asked Chad GBT to formulate a diet for a person with type two diabetes.
- 21:22[SPEAKER_03]: And the model was able to provide lunch recipes aligning with the recommendations of the American Diabetes Association, which is probably helpful.
- 21:30[SPEAKER_03]: Similar results were given when the model was asked to provide a diet for a patient with hemodialysis.
- 21:36[SPEAKER_03]: The recommended diet was aligned to the patient's profile, however, when the questions were asked again, different answers were provided with incorrect dietary plans for the patients.
- 21:46[SPEAKER_03]: Probably depends how you word.
- 21:47[SPEAKER_01]: Yes.
- 21:47[SPEAKER_01]: Your questions, which can be difficult because how is the, I guess I'll just use consumer for the patient.
- 21:55[SPEAKER_01]: Right.
- 21:56[SPEAKER_01]: Supposed to know exactly how to word it to get him proper.
- 21:59[SPEAKER_03]: Well, yeah, because it's like as a dietitian or as a nutrition professional, like we know the prompts and the questions to ask in order for us to get the data and the information that we need.
- 22:09[SPEAKER_03]: But if you are just, you know, like me, if I was going in and trying to figure out like what was wrong with, I don't know some health thing that I wasn't educated on, I'd just be putting in the very basic information that I thought might be needed, but I might be missing something.
- 22:24[SPEAKER_03]: And so I think this just shows that although there are some really great resources, it's not like a hundred percent accurate and effective.
- 22:34[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah.
- 22:34[SPEAKER_03]: Which, again, can be scary, especially for utilizing it for, like, our health.
- 22:39[SPEAKER_03]: Mm-hmm.
- 22:40[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah.
- 22:40[SPEAKER_01]: I think a hundred percent.
- 22:42[SPEAKER_01]: I think there's, like I said, there's ways to use AI that can really help you get creative when you feel like you're in a rut.
- 22:51[SPEAKER_01]: I've seen people utilize it for, hey, what are some good craft ideas I could do with my kids?
- 22:56[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah.
- 22:56[SPEAKER_01]: Or it's really hot out today.
- 22:59[SPEAKER_01]: What's, what are some indoor activities to do with,
- 23:03[SPEAKER_01]: Kids, family members, pets, like things like that, that I think something like chatGBT is awesome for just to spark that creativity in our own brains and our own minds when we feel like we can't think of something on our own.
- 23:16[SPEAKER_01]: I think it's great that we have a resource we can turn to and basically get information within
- 23:21[SPEAKER_01]: five seconds yeah, but when we're talking about more like medical healthcare specific nutrition information I do think it can just get a little bit hairy because Are you getting did you ask the question properly?
- 23:36[SPEAKER_01]: So then are you getting the correct response?
- 23:39[SPEAKER_01]: Maybe not even the correct response but a
- 23:43[SPEAKER_01]: evidence-based one.
- 23:44[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah.
- 23:45[SPEAKER_01]: And is it individualized and tailored towards you?
- 23:50[SPEAKER_01]: Maybe you didn't give it enough background information on your previous hell history.
- 23:54[SPEAKER_01]: Mm-hmm.
- 23:54[SPEAKER_01]: And it just kind of spirals at my opinion.
- 23:57[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah.
- 23:57[SPEAKER_03]: Yeah, I know like I've used it for coming up with like date night ideas that we could do at all.
- 24:02[SPEAKER_03]: So it was like what is something that can do like with my husband at home instead of going out like when Julia would be sleeping and we don't have a sitter.
- 24:10[SPEAKER_03]: Um, I just be like, what are some things we can do?
- 24:12[SPEAKER_03]: And it would spit out some like ideas.
- 24:13[SPEAKER_03]: That's a good idea.
- 24:14[SPEAKER_01]: I'll have to use that as something like that.
- 24:16[SPEAKER_03]: But it's stuff like that that I mean, I'll probably utilize it a lot like with my kids and coming up with ideas like you said like little craft ideas or whatever because
- 24:27[SPEAKER_03]: Otherwise, you can scroll on Pinterest and find great ideas, but if something can tell you right away, then that's really cool.
- 24:32[SPEAKER_03]: So with that too, I will add in my personal trial.
- 24:38[SPEAKER_03]: So I plugged in my information, all this things that I thought chatGPT would need to know about me in order to come up with a good estimate for my needs.
- 24:49[SPEAKER_03]: So calories, protein, carbs, and fat.
- 24:53[SPEAKER_03]: And you asked it to estimate those for you.
- 24:55[SPEAKER_03]: Or you plugged that in.
- 24:57[SPEAKER_03]: I asked them to estimate it for me.
- 24:58[SPEAKER_03]: So I gave them like my height, my activity level, like the basic stuff.
- 25:04[SPEAKER_03]: But otherwise, they don't know anything else about me.
- 25:07[SPEAKER_03]: They don't know I'm a mom.
- 25:08[SPEAKER_03]: I maybe I left out that I was nursing sometimes.
- 25:12[SPEAKER_03]: Like there's just things that I don't know you're pregnant.
- 25:15[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah.
- 25:15[SPEAKER_03]: I don't know if you put that right.
- 25:17[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah.
- 25:17[SPEAKER_01]: Right.
- 25:17[SPEAKER_03]: Oh my god.
- 25:19[SPEAKER_03]: Oh, well, it doesn't take that out.
- 25:21[SPEAKER_03]: Well, I was gonna say it doesn't matter.
- 25:23[SPEAKER_03]: I'm surprised.
- 25:24[SPEAKER_03]: I'm pregnant too.
- 25:27[SPEAKER_03]: No, I've already announced it publicly.
- 25:29[SPEAKER_00]: I know that.
- 25:30[SPEAKER_00]: Oh my god.
- 25:30[SPEAKER_00]: I can't believe it.
- 25:33[SPEAKER_02]: I'm leaving it in.
- 25:34[SPEAKER_02]: Surprise and packing.
- 25:36[SPEAKER_00]: We're both crazy.
- 25:39[SPEAKER_02]: Anyway.
- 25:40[SPEAKER_00]: I'm crying.
- 25:43[SPEAKER_02]: I was gonna say that too and then I was like, oh, yeah, they don't know that.
- 25:46[SPEAKER_00]: I totally forgot.
- 25:47[SPEAKER_00]: I'm so sorry.
- 25:48[SPEAKER_00]: This second day like to eat my heart's saying.
- 25:49[SPEAKER_03]: Well, it's not, it's not a secret.
- 25:52[SPEAKER_03]: It's all over social media.
- 25:53[SPEAKER_00]: I have to wait until I put it on the podcast yet.
- 25:56[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, I'm so sorry.
- 25:57[SPEAKER_02]: It's okay.
- 25:58[SPEAKER_02]: We can get into that later.
- 25:59[SPEAKER_00]: But touch on that and another episode.
- 26:03[SPEAKER_03]: Anyways, yes, I'm also pregnant in like a couple days like behind-brooks.
- 26:09[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, we're just so excited and crazy, but okay.
- 26:13[SPEAKER_03]: Anyways, so yeah, so there's a lot of information that I could have potentially left out right, but I gave them the basics, the basics of what would be needed.
- 26:22[SPEAKER_03]: And I would say that the calorie, it gave me one, it didn't give me a range, it gave me a calorie need.
- 26:30[SPEAKER_03]: Um, and I would say that it was okay, but when I asked about like protein carbs and fat, the protein needs it gave me work quite a bit lower than what I would have calculated for myself like thirty grams of protein lower, which is like just pretty significant.
- 26:48[SPEAKER_03]: However, then I asked it to give me a meal plan based on my estimated needs, and it did give me some really well-rounded recipe ideas, which I kind of mentioned earlier, which I thought could be helpful for people, but that piece just about it not being accurate.
- 27:04[SPEAKER_03]: Like, I would hate for someone to be like, okay, I'm going to try to lose weight.
- 27:08[SPEAKER_03]: and I'm gonna put in this information and then it spits out this information and I'm gonna follow that but then I'm not seeing results or I'm doing this for six months like what is happening and it's like we just need to tweak something.
- 27:22[SPEAKER_03]: So I think that's the piece to where it makes me a little bit worried because I already know like people will come to me and be like oh I need one gram of protein per pound right like as a goal and I'm like
- 27:34[SPEAKER_03]: Well, you know, that's not always true.
- 27:37[SPEAKER_03]: So yeah, I just think that it's just not super individualized, which becomes the issue of any situation with using AI for health.
- 27:47[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, I agree.
- 27:47[SPEAKER_01]: And I think, well, first of all, thank you for doing that little personal experiment because I think that that kind of gives some clarity and insight into some of the pros and cons we're describing here.
- 27:58[SPEAKER_01]: I just think when it first came out, I remember being so scared of it because I was like, yeah.
- 28:03[SPEAKER_03]: I didn't use it for the first couple years.
- 28:05[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah.
- 28:06[SPEAKER_01]: Like everyone, everyone was talking about how it's like our future.
- 28:10[SPEAKER_01]: All these jobs are going to be moving to AI.
- 28:12[SPEAKER_01]: Like everything's going to be AI.
- 28:14[SPEAKER_01]: My husband is very like progressive in that mindset of like, yeah, everything's going to go to this and I'm like, don't say that.
- 28:21[SPEAKER_01]: Like I was like, don't say that.
- 28:22[SPEAKER_01]: Don't say that.
- 28:22[SPEAKER_01]: Don't.
- 28:23[SPEAKER_01]: I don't even want it.
- 28:24[SPEAKER_03]: It didn't help that all these movies are coming out with these robots.
- 28:27[SPEAKER_03]: Like taking over the world.
- 28:28[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah.
- 28:29[SPEAKER_01]: I'm like, I don't even want to think about how
- 28:34[SPEAKER_01]: I don't know, knew or how this would like take people's jobs or I didn't even want to think about that.
- 28:41[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah.
- 28:42[SPEAKER_01]: And now I don't know, maybe we've been conditioned, I have no idea.
- 28:45[SPEAKER_01]: But now, after a lot of my friends were like, have you used Chad G.B.T.
- 28:50[SPEAKER_01]: for anything or you hear these like students having it like type their papers for them or do stuff?
- 28:56[SPEAKER_01]: I probably would have thrived in college and I have this as a reason.
- 28:59[SPEAKER_01]: So much free time would you have had if you were so much more crazy.
- 29:04[SPEAKER_01]: Anyways, after I heard that a bunch of my friends had been using it as a resource, or even just using it help, like you said, make an email more concise, or have it help you with some ideas for XYZ.
- 29:16[SPEAKER_01]: I started to use it sparingly here and there.
- 29:19[SPEAKER_01]: how this can be really helpful and I think like I said I try to utilize it to have me spark my own either creative ideas or if I'm just in a rut have it come up with some ideas for me that I'm like oh that's awesome and then maybe utilize a recipe and it's in your rotation after that and it's great that AI helped you come up with that
- 29:40[SPEAKER_01]: But I just remember how scared I was years ago, just about AI in general.
- 29:44[SPEAKER_01]: And now I would consider it helpful in certain areas of my life, but I just think it's important to kind of
- 29:52[SPEAKER_01]: I don't know, still proceed with caution when it comes to certain things.
- 29:56[SPEAKER_01]: And I do not think your doctors are using chat to BT like while you're in the office with them.
- 30:02[SPEAKER_01]: I hope not.
- 30:03[SPEAKER_01]: I know that there's been, there's been some videos like circulating around on social media of, and you never know what's fake or what's staged, right?
- 30:10[SPEAKER_01]: Right.
- 30:10[SPEAKER_01]: I'd like to think I have a good, like those prank videos that are very clearly staged.
- 30:15[SPEAKER_01]: I'm like, oh my gosh.
- 30:17[SPEAKER_01]: But there was, I just remember seeing this video, somebody in a white coat, and it looked like he had typed something into chatGbD, and it was like spinning out information.
- 30:25[SPEAKER_01]: And they were like, this is not my, like, doctor right now using chatGbD.
- 30:29[SPEAKER_01]: No, yeah, there's no way.
- 30:30[SPEAKER_03]: Then you look at the comments and the people are like, how are you like, well, I'm like, people do not understand.
- 30:34[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, I'm like, I'm like, I'm gonna get a skin.
- 30:36[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, it's either a skit or a joke, but yeah.
- 30:39[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, your, your doctors are not in, whether it's doctors or any other provider, like even,
- 30:46[SPEAKER_01]: dietitians, string coaches, personal trainers, dentists, any eye doctors, anyone in that field is not going to school for the amount of time they have to.
- 30:57[SPEAKER_01]: Spending so much money on their education.
- 30:59[SPEAKER_01]: To use chatGVT.
- 31:02[SPEAKER_01]: Maybe it helps them if they need a quick, like if I forget a conversion.
- 31:06[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah.
- 31:06[SPEAKER_01]: Something.
- 31:07[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah.
- 31:07[SPEAKER_01]: Like maybe it can help you quickly convert something, which is helpful in the moment.
- 31:11[SPEAKER_01]: Like very
- 31:12[SPEAKER_03]: Well, yeah, because I think it was calculating like my BMR and like with methylene and stuff like that.
- 31:17[SPEAKER_03]: And so I'm like, oh, that'd be nice.
- 31:19[SPEAKER_03]: Like if I needed to.
- 31:20[SPEAKER_03]: Yeah, do that because I mean those equations are kind of long and tedious for sure.
- 31:25[SPEAKER_03]: But yeah, I know I've used it to like
- 31:29[SPEAKER_03]: I'm not bad with Excel, but I don't know how to use all the extra formulas and whatever all the time.
- 31:34[SPEAKER_01]: I'm terrible with Excel.
- 31:35[SPEAKER_01]: Thank God I have that.
- 31:37[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah.
- 31:38[SPEAKER_01]: Oh, thank God.
- 31:38[SPEAKER_01]: Because we never had to take an Excel class, but I guess if you majored in business, I'm sure there's an Excel class.
- 31:46[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, and no, like actual classes tailored to Excel to learn all these formulas and stuff.
- 31:50[SPEAKER_03]: because there's classes, a couple of girls in my office took an Excel course because they have to use it a lot in their jobs.
- 31:57[SPEAKER_03]: I do a lot of not a lot but I do some reports like with health information and I have to do some like auditing within those and that's like the extent or like I'll do a budget sheet with like some blah blah blah.
- 32:11[SPEAKER_03]: But I've used it when I wanted to, um, so we did a prize drawing where, you know, if you did X, Y and C, you got three entries and I got five entries and I was like, okay, how am I going to do this?
- 32:25[SPEAKER_03]: Like, and make sure everybody has the right amount of entries based on their number and whatever.
- 32:31[SPEAKER_03]: So I just like told Chad GBT and said pick like a random person by giving them
- 32:36[SPEAKER_03]: each the appropriate now of entries and whatever and it gave me answer in like two seconds, it would have taken me hours to figure out how to do that.
- 32:43[SPEAKER_01]: Like something like that is so hopeful.
- 32:45[SPEAKER_03]: Yeah, yeah, and something that's like men's skill, right?
- 32:48[SPEAKER_03]: It's like I just knew it.
- 32:49[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, exactly.
- 32:50[SPEAKER_01]: It's not changing your
- 32:54[SPEAKER_01]: It's not like changing the course of anyone's life.
- 32:56[SPEAKER_01]: It's just saving you time.
- 32:57[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, which is really valuable.
- 32:59[SPEAKER_01]: And like today's purpose.
- 33:00[SPEAKER_01]: I feel like I spend, I don't know, hours either making these slips on hand or figuring out how to do it in any cell and then plugging that Excel information into some random generator on the internet.
- 33:12[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah.
- 33:12[SPEAKER_01]: Oh, no, you didn't plug the data set in right.
- 33:14[SPEAKER_01]: And yeah.
- 33:15[SPEAKER_03]: It's like, no, just like, you're formula is invalid.
- 33:18[SPEAKER_03]: I'm like,
- 33:19[SPEAKER_01]: Exactly.
- 33:19[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, like just fucking into AI and have them generate a winner for you.
- 33:23[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, great.
- 33:24[SPEAKER_01]: That's wonderful.
- 33:24[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah.
- 33:25[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah.
- 33:26[SPEAKER_03]: But yeah.
- 33:26[SPEAKER_03]: So I think those are just some of the things that we wanted to discuss is situations where it might be appropriate and that others that are a little bit worrisome for us.
- 33:35[SPEAKER_03]: And like I said, I mean, we're not like against utilizing this as a resource.
- 33:41[SPEAKER_03]: It just makes me a little bit nervous when people are starting to rely on it for like their health care needs.
- 33:47[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah.
- 33:47[SPEAKER_01]: I have a question for you.
- 33:48[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah.
- 33:49[SPEAKER_01]: What are your thoughts on somebody?
- 33:51[SPEAKER_01]: Because I haven't done this, but it just popped into my head.
- 33:54[SPEAKER_01]: What are your thoughts on somebody who were to ask at the question of like, what's the best protein bar or protein powder or like something on the market?
- 34:02[SPEAKER_01]: Like what are some of the best brands?
- 34:05[SPEAKER_03]: I mean, I think I'd have to know a little bit more about where the information's coming from.
- 34:09[SPEAKER_03]: Like, is it coming from a blog poster?
- 34:12[SPEAKER_03]: Because it could be just super subjective and not like actually based on something.
- 34:16[SPEAKER_03]: Because I think that there's a lot of variance in that.
- 34:18[SPEAKER_03]: Like, what are you trying to ask?
- 34:20[SPEAKER_03]: Are you trying to ask what's the best protein bar that doesn't have a ton of sugar?
- 34:25[SPEAKER_03]: Or are you trying to ask like what protein bar has the most protein or what protein bar doesn't you sugar alcohols?
- 34:30[SPEAKER_03]: Like, what is your idea of
- 34:33[SPEAKER_03]: the best, you know, because for some people, certain ingredients are going to be really important to them, and for others, they're going to be really important to them.
- 34:41[SPEAKER_03]: But, chatGBT doesn't know that, or whatever AI reasons.
- 34:46[SPEAKER_01]: I just asked it.
- 34:47[SPEAKER_01]: One of the best protein bars on the market, I'm looking for some of the best brands.
- 34:52[SPEAKER_01]: Yes, what I said.
- 34:53[SPEAKER_01]: And just off the top of my head, I like some of them and don't like some of them.
- 34:59[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah.
- 34:59[SPEAKER_01]: So here's a breakdown of some of the best protein bar brands on the market.
- 35:02[SPEAKER_01]: Depending, it does say, depending on your goals and preferences, ingredients, taste, texture.
- 35:07[SPEAKER_01]: I think it's as athlete approval.
- 35:10[SPEAKER_01]: Because that's kind of a lot of relations about fitness stuff.
- 35:15[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah.
- 35:15[SPEAKER_01]: So I don't know if it's tailoring it towards that.
- 35:19[SPEAKER_01]: And again, like it gave me, can I see the list?
- 35:22[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, I just don't want to call it like brands, I guess I don't like.
- 35:25[SPEAKER_01]: But then it goes on to, I will show you the list.
- 35:28[SPEAKER_01]: Then after that it breaks it down into like best for athletes or high protein, best plant based options, cleanest ingredient labels, kid-approved slash pregnancy friendly, see like this is creepy.
- 35:41[SPEAKER_01]: What to look for in a protein bar.
- 35:43[SPEAKER_01]: So it gives you some additional information, but yeah, here's the list it came up with.
- 35:46[SPEAKER_01]: I probably like maybe half or like three to four on that list and some of them I'm like,
- 35:51[SPEAKER_01]: Oh, yeah.
- 35:53[SPEAKER_03]: Yeah, I'm just rolling the halls and grays.
- 35:56[SPEAKER_03]: Oh, yeah, and like it said, like based on your goals and blah, I'm going down to look at like the the extra stuff.
- 36:03[SPEAKER_03]: I wanted to see the thing at the bottom of like what to look for.
- 36:07[SPEAKER_03]: It says, okay, what it's saying to look for in a protein bar is greater than ten grams of protein, where plant based less than ten grams of added sugar,
- 36:16[SPEAKER_01]: I like this so far.
- 36:17[SPEAKER_03]: Yeah, it's fine.
- 36:18[SPEAKER_03]: Whole food ingredients have possible.
- 36:20[SPEAKER_03]: What does that even mean?
- 36:22[SPEAKER_03]: No artificial sweeteners or sugar alcohols.
- 36:25[SPEAKER_03]: It says can cause GI issues, which is true.
- 36:27[SPEAKER_03]: Yeah.
- 36:30[SPEAKER_03]: Which sometimes I'm dead.
- 36:31[SPEAKER_01]: I teach it that.
- 36:32[SPEAKER_03]: I know because I'm like some of the ones that it's suggested definitely have some sugar.
- 36:37[SPEAKER_03]: Yeah, but then texture like some more of their chewy some or crunchy some or chocolate like it's a personal personal preference.
- 36:44[SPEAKER_03]: So yeah, I don't know it's just
- 36:46[SPEAKER_03]: It's interesting because yeah, I'm like, okay, you said like don't choose ones with like more than ten grams of sugar or sugar.
- 36:53[SPEAKER_03]: I'll call some of the brands they recommended definitely.
- 36:56[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, so it's maybe not auditing the ingredients.
- 36:58[SPEAKER_01]: Anyways, just a fun little experience.
- 37:00[SPEAKER_03]: Yeah, I did in the moment, but yeah, so I think that's all though, just some information and our opinions like on it.
- 37:07[SPEAKER_03]: I'm sure to leave all into something and maybe we'll get some jobs out of it.
- 37:10[SPEAKER_03]: I don't know.
- 37:12[SPEAKER_03]: But that would be cool.
- 37:13[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah.
- 37:14[SPEAKER_01]: I don't really have much else.
- 37:15[SPEAKER_03]: Yeah, I don't either.
- 37:16[SPEAKER_01]: Okay.
- 37:16[SPEAKER_01]: Cool.
- 37:17[SPEAKER_01]: We will catch you next time.
- 37:19[SPEAKER_01]: And yeah, if you want more information on the topic, you can check out our, well, our Instagram.
- 37:26[SPEAKER_01]: We really just maybe we'll post the link to the review that Peyton talked about that research review, either in the,
- 37:35[SPEAKER_01]: notes, or sorry, in the caption on our Instagram, which is at well-bound podcast, or in the notes description on this podcast episode itself, maybe we will do both, who knows.
- 37:44[SPEAKER_01]: But yeah, that's it.
- 37:46[SPEAKER_01]: Alrighty, see ya.
- 37:47[SPEAKER_01]: Bye.