Latest / 10 Minute Murder | Bingeable True Crime Stories / Sweet But Psycho: Isabella Guzman

Transcript

Sweet But Psycho: Isabella Guzman · 10 Minute Murder | Bingeable True Crime Stories

0:02
Discretion is advised. This is ten minuted murderer. Forty seven year old you
0:22
Me Hoy was becoming more and more frightened of her teenage daughter, eighteen year
0:28
old Isabella Guzman. The two of them had never had a great relationship,
0:32
and they frequently argued ever since Isabella was a little girl. The arguing got
0:38
so bad that when Isabella was only nine, she spent a portion of time
0:41
living with her biological father in the hopes that some distance would improve the relationship
0:47
with her mother. According to Isabella's stepdad, Ryan Hoy, Isabella continued to
0:53
disrespect her mother throughout her teenage years. After she dropped out of high school,
0:58
the relationship deteriorates, did it even further, her behavior escalated to include
1:03
screaming at Yumi and even spitting at her. The assaults and threats came to
1:10
a head on Wednesday, the twenty eighth of August twenty thirteen, when Yumi
1:15
received a threatening email from her daughter. The email was simple, saying you
1:21
will pay, but Umi was so shaken by it that she and Ryan decided
1:26
to call the police and report that their daughter had threatened to harm them,
1:30
as well as calling the police about the threat, Umi and Ryan called Isabella's
1:34
biological father and asked him to come and talk to his daughter. Robert Guzman
1:40
had always had a much better relationship with Isabella, and Umi hoped that he
1:45
might be able to calm her down. Robert was aware that Umi and Isabella
1:49
always had a strained relationship. Umi worked grueling twelve hour days at her portrait
1:55
studio in town, trying to support the family, but Isabella just quote,
2:00
didn't appreciate anything her mother did for her. Soon after the phone conversation,
2:05
Robert Guzman drove over to the house and he called Isabella into the back yard
2:09
to speak to her alone. Quote. I started to talk to her about
2:13
the respect that people should have for their parents, Robert said. And I
2:16
was trying to let her know that she should be obedient to her parents,
2:21
not rebellious, and that she should try to listen more. And everything was
2:24
going fine in the conversation. I thought I made progress, but obviously it
2:30
didn't do nothing, because hours later this thing happened. When the police arrived
2:36
at the house, they had a stern talk with Isabella, telling her that
2:38
because she was a legal adult, if she didn't behave her mother could kick
2:43
her out of the house. They didn't seem to think that there was a
2:46
serious threat. Instead, they viewed her as a rebellious teenager who needed to
2:51
learn a lesson to you. Me and Ryan's relief, the presence of the
2:54
police seemed to work. Isabella calmed down and left them all alone, spending
3:00
the rest of the early evening alone in her bedroom. It was something that
3:05
she often did when she was upset, retreating to her room and listening to
3:08
her iPod. Later that night, Ryan was eating his dinner in the living
3:13
room of the house when Yumi went upstairs to have a shower. Shortly afterwards,
3:17
Ryan was startled by a loud banging noise and Umi calling for help.
3:23
He ran upstairs and he tried to enter the upstairs bathroom, but when he
3:28
tried to push the door open, he saw that Isabella was inside with Umi.
3:31
She pushed her back against the door to hold it shut and then locked
3:36
it behind her. Ryan quickly noticed two things. The shower was still running,
3:42
and there was a puddle of blood flowing from underneath the door. Ryan
3:46
then ran to call the police, telling the dispatcher that his wife had been
3:51
attacked, and he tried to get into the bathroom again. Shortly afterwards,
3:55
Isabella opened the bathroom door and walked straight past him. She was carrying a
4:01
bloody knife in one hand and looking straight ahead as if she didn't see her
4:05
stepfather at all. Without saying a single word, Isabella calmly walked downstairs and
4:13
left the house, wearing only a pair of shorts and a pink sportspra In
4:17
the bathroom, Ryan saw Yumi lying naked on the floor, her eyes opened
4:24
and pointed in the direction of the ceiling. Isabella had stabbed her mother a
4:29
total of seventy nine times in the face, throat, and neck. Ryan,
4:33
who was still on the phone to nine one one, explained what was
4:38
happening. The operator instructed him to clear yu Me's airway and start to perform
4:44
CPR. He did his best to try to revive his wife, but her
4:47
injuries were too severe she was already dead. On Thursday afternoon, the police
4:54
received a call from a concerned member of the public who believed they had seen
4:59
a body inside a park car. Officers traveled to that parking garage where the
5:03
caller had been found the vehicle, but now there was no sign of a
5:08
body anywhere. A brief search of the car uncovered items that were believed to
5:13
be connected to Isabella, so a K nine team and several undercover officers were
5:17
called in to thoroughly search the area. During the search, an undercover officer
5:24
saw a teenage girl matching Isabella Guzman's description walking calmly out of the parking garage.
5:30
He stopped and talked to her, but before she walked out of the
5:33
building and into the parking lot, the three officers strategically followed Isabella, and
5:41
before she could decide how to escape, they had completely surrounded her and drawn
5:45
their weapons. She was quickly placed under arrest and taken to the Aurora Police
5:49
headquarters. That Friday, a judge ordered that Isabella beheld in the Arapahoe County
5:56
jail without bond leading up to her trial. Short date was meant to have
6:00
taken place on Thursday, but it had be postponed after Isabella simply refused to
6:05
leave her jail cell. Throughout the hearing, Isabella seemed like she wasn't taking
6:11
the situation seriously, making faces at the camera in the courtroom and smiling when
6:16
the judge informed her that she was facing a first degree murder charge. Isabella
6:21
began crying, but then she looked straight at the courtroom camera and pointed at
6:27
her tears as if saying, look, I'm crying. Isabella decided to plead
6:32
not guilty by reason of insanity, and shortly afterwards a psychiatric evaluation led to
6:39
her being diagnosed with schizophrenia and found unfit to stand trial. According to Isabella,
6:46
she hadn't realized that she was stabbing her own mother. Instead, she
6:49
had been experiencing delusions that she was stabbing a different woman by the name of
6:55
Cecilia because she believed that she had to kill Cecilia to quote save the world.
7:01
Isabella was institutionalized at Colorado Mental Health Institute, due to be released when
7:08
the time came that she was found to be no longer a threat to herself
7:12
or others. She spent seven quiet years receiving treatment at the Colorado Mental Health
7:17
Institute. Then in twenty twenty two things happened. Isabella declared that she was
7:25
now mentally fit for release, and she became an online celebrity. The footage
7:31
from her hearing in twenty thirteen had been reposted on TikTok, and bizarrely,
7:36
she quickly gathered a fan base of supporters. The videos were reposted to music
7:42
that romanticized Isabella's actions, including the Ava Max song Sweet but Psycho. Commenters
7:49
praised Isabella's physical appearance, filmed videos of themselves imitating the facial expressions that she
7:56
made in court, and even created Instagram fan pages dedicated to photos of Isabella.
8:03
Many people even suggested that you me must have done something to Isabella to
8:07
result in the crime, or that Isabella's actions had been completely out of character
8:13
for her, a sentiment that was partially shared by Isabella's biological father, Robert
8:18
Guzman. Robert had previously told the media, quote, Isabella's a good kid.
8:24
She's good hearted. But I don't know what could have happened, honestly
8:28
to provoke this kind of reaction. Isabella's aunt, Melanie Guzman, also believed
8:33
that there was something more to the case. She visited Isabella a month or
8:37
so before the murders and thought that she appeared to be a completely normal teenage
8:43
girl. Quote. Her demeanor was sweet, Melanie said, describing Isabella.
8:48
She's very coquette, and I can see her yelling, screaming, storming off
8:52
and locking herself in a room, but not being violent like that. During
8:58
her time at the Colorado Mental Health Instant, she claimed that her outbursts of
9:01
anger were a response to the abuse that she suffered from you me. She
9:07
claimed that while both of her parents were Jehovah's witnesses, she made the decision
9:11
to leave the religion as a young teenager, causing her mother to treat her
9:16
very poorly. But she also said that if she could change what happened that
9:20
day or take it back, she would quote. I was not myself when
9:24
I did that, she said in an interview with CBS four Denver, and
9:28
I have since been restored to full health. I'm not mentally ill anymore.
9:33
I'm not a danger to myself or others. In mid twenty twenty one,
9:39
a judge approved Isabella's request to leave the institute to go to external therapy sessions,
9:45
but her request to be discharged from psychiatric care was denied. That's ten
9:58
Minute Murder Today, brief and binge able true crime. My name's Joe.
10:03
I'm the host, and thank you so much for taking the time to listen
10:07
to ten Minute Murder Today. If you're new, make sure you hit subscribe
10:11
wherever you're listening right now, and that will more easily allow you to catch
10:13
up on all the back episodes of Ten Minute Murder. Also, if you've
10:18
got social media, connect with me there and see the pictures of what we
10:22
talk about here in the podcast. It's never gross and graphic though. Quick
10:26
email from one of you that listens. Hello Joe, greetings from Wyoming.
10:31
I was wondering if you could cover this case I heard about. Then she
10:33
goes in to talk about this case, which, by the way, is
10:35
very interesting. Also, I wanted to ask if there is any chance of
10:39
you doing another podcast of longer episodes or even interviewing people. I love the
10:45
brief ones that you do so much, but sometimes I have a want to
10:48
listen to longer ones and wish you did that. Also, if you read
10:52
this on the podcast, please use only my initials HB. Thank you for
10:56
doing ten Minute Murder. I will say her name HB. Thank you for
11:01
the email, HB. And the answer is yes, I'd like to do
11:05
longer episodes, even though the reason I started this podcast was for people like
11:11
me who have a shorter attention span and only can take it in small doses.
11:16
Before you know, you kind of lose focus a little bit, but
11:18
I also do listen to longer podcasts myself, so I'm capable of doing that,
11:22
and I do like longer ones. But yeah, I've done longer episodes
11:28
for ten Minute Murder also, so there's some sprinkled in back there. But
11:31
I've thought about creating a new podcast where I do longer episodes and also coincidentally
11:37
interviewing people as well, but there are no immediate plans to do that because
11:43
it just doing this one takes a lot of time and effort, so I
11:46
don't currently have that bandwidth to do that, but hopefully one day, pretty
11:50
soon that I will be able to do that. That's my ultimate plan anyway,
11:54
to have this, to keep this podcast, but also expand and do
11:58
more and more. All right, that's going to do it. Thank you
12:01
so much for listening to ten Minute Murder. Have a good night or morning
12:07
or day, whatever you're doing.