Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Dealmaking, Touring, and AI: 2026 Music Law Update
Transcript
- 0:03I'm David Straga, Secretary of the Beverly Hills
- 0:05Bar Association's Entertainment Law Section,
- 0:08and welcome to today's seminar entitled Dealmaking,
- 0:10Touring, and AI, 2026 Music Law Update. Before
- 0:14introducing our fantastic speakers for today,
- 0:17I'd like to take a moment to acknowledge Lawyer's
- 0:19Mutual Insurance Company, who generously sponsors
- 0:21the Entertainment Law Section and this great
- 0:23programming. For five decades now, Lawyers Mutual
- 0:26has been the only California -based company to
- 0:28continuously provide professional liability insurance
- 0:31to lawyers throughout the state. Lawyers Mutual
- 0:34is not only highly experienced, but also directed
- 0:37by a group of dedicated expert lawyers, including
- 0:39some who operate a hotline for when thorny issues
- 0:42arise. It's a truly excellent resource. They
- 0:45offer special rates and competitive premiums
- 0:47across many practice areas, including your 10
- 0:49o 'clock. and learn more about them at LawyersMutual
- 0:52.com. Now, I'm delighted to introduce our three
- 0:55expert panelists, starting with Pamela Klein.
- 0:58Pamela is a partner at Rossi, Valdivia, Klein,
- 1:01Fine, and Spectre PC with over 30 years of experience
- 1:03in the music and entertainment industry, as well
- 1:05as recording artists, songwriters, and producers
- 1:07on all aspects of their careers, including recording,
- 1:10publishing, and course writing. She's a member
- 1:12of the School of Independent Record Labels, Publishers,
- 1:14and Digital Content Licensors. known for her
- 1:17sound counsel, integrity, and mentorship. She's
- 1:20also served as the business affairs executive
- 1:22at Atlantic Records, Warner Chapel Music, and
- 1:24Warner Records. Recent representations included
- 1:27by Grammy Award -winning writer -producer Rodney
- 1:30Darkchild -Jerkens in the sale of his iconic
- 1:32catalog and handling Colombian megastar Carol
- 1:35G's global collaboration with Reebok. Next up,
- 1:38we have Karen Mitchell. Barron is a partner at
- 1:41Barnes & Thornburg, who represents recording
- 1:43artists, athletes, content creators, entrepreneurs,
- 1:45and other entertainment industry professionals
- 1:47across a wide transactional manner. City Recording,
- 1:51Publishing, Touring, Endorsements, and Talent
- 1:53Representation Agreement. Ramon, a prior insider
- 1:56experienced in the music, sports, media, and
- 1:58radio industries, along with her status as a
- 2:00certified contract advisor with the NFLPA and
- 2:03the NBPA, She brings a business -minded perspective
- 2:06to helping clients build durable brands and enterprises,
- 2:09from record labels to athlete -led ventures.
- 2:11Her practice spanning entertainment and media,
- 2:13intellectual property, and corporate finance
- 2:16also includes serving as outside counsel to music,
- 2:19gaming, web 3, and digital media companies navigating
- 2:23emerging issues at the intersection. Your analyst
- 2:27is Tom Dean. Tom is a partner at LePolt Law,
- 2:30where he specializes in talent representation,
- 2:32advising recording artists, content creators,
- 2:34producers, and songwriters on all aspects of
- 2:37their entertainment careers with over 15 years
- 2:39in the music and entertainment industry. Tom
- 2:41brings an insider's perspective to structuring
- 2:43and negotiating agreements, spanning recording,
- 2:46publishing, brand partnerships, live performance,
- 2:48and more. He works the diverse client roster
- 2:51from A -list hip hop and R &B artists to Grammy
- 2:53nominated producers and top social media influencers,
- 2:56helping them navigate complex legal issues while
- 2:59achieving their professional goals. Finally,
- 3:01we have our moderator for today's panel, another
- 3:03expert in the field, John Baldivia. John is also
- 3:06a partner at the aforementioned Rossi Baldivia
- 3:08client firm, where he negotiates a wide variety
- 3:10of contracts for major label recording artists,
- 3:13songwriters, and prominent influencers. from
- 3:15a strong background in music transactions and
- 3:18entertainment and intellectual property litigation.
- 3:21He's been recognized as a Super Lawyers Rising
- 3:22Star for Southern California from 2020 through
- 3:252026, and also as a top music lawyer by Billboard
- 3:29magazine from 2022 through 2026. For law, John
- 3:33spent 10 years working in the music industry
- 3:35for both major and independent record labels.
- 3:38That's a group of speakers we have today. Now
- 3:40let's get started, and please take it away, John.
- 3:43Thank you, David. So while this isn't really
- 3:48an AI panel, I know that a lot of what we're
- 3:51going to be talking about has been strongly influenced
- 3:53by AI because that's the most recent developments,
- 3:56at least with regard to the legal perspective
- 3:58within the music industry. And so I want to start
- 4:01off with that. When we talk about recording deals
- 4:05and publishing deals, I want to throw this question
- 4:07to the panelists. Where have you seen AI really
- 4:10make An impact in the way that these deals are
- 4:13being negotiated. I guess start from the recording
- 4:15side You know, I think one thing we've seen You
- 4:23know for starters is we're starting to get some
- 4:24amendments sent our way for some of our clients
- 4:27already signed to Sign to recording deals, you
- 4:31know, obviously the idea of AI and training the
- 4:36recordings on AI Probably wasn't contemplated
- 4:39in any of our current clients recording agreements.
- 4:44So now we're starting to get some amendments
- 4:45from the major labels and other labels looking
- 4:49for that right to include the recordings in that
- 4:53training. Yeah. In addition to that, a lot of
- 4:57the labels and the newer deals, they are putting
- 4:59their foot down and trying to add that language
- 5:03into the new forms that they have and force artists
- 5:06to sign on. agreeing to those rights at the forefront.
- 5:13So it's kind of interesting dynamic to see labels
- 5:17asking for those rights, but when it comes to
- 5:21your clients delivering content that has AI in
- 5:24it, what does the label stand has been there?
- 5:27So I think from at least from my perspective,
- 5:29I've seen that labels don't want anything with
- 5:30AI in it. Yeah, I think I've seen that. I've
- 5:33only honestly seen it in one instance and that's
- 5:35where some artwork was made using AI. And the
- 5:40label just politely rejected it, saying that
- 5:44it looked great, but not something that they
- 5:47were going to use. But I think the big conversation
- 5:53about it right now is Tyga's album. Didn't Tyga
- 5:56come out saying he used AI a lot in the production?
- 6:01Who released that? Was that Empire? They didn't
- 6:03seem to care, right? Yeah, it was Empire. I've
- 6:08seen language and agreements where particularly
- 6:12Universal and Sony who are still in lawsuits
- 6:15over AI don't want to have any AI in the music
- 6:21they put out because they don't want it to negatively
- 6:25impact their ability to succeed in the lawsuit,
- 6:28right? Because they don't want... I think it's
- 6:30Suno, but I don't quote me on the Suno part of
- 6:32it, but I'm pretty sure it's with Suno or they
- 6:34don't want Suno to be able to say, yeah, but
- 6:37you know, all this music that you've put out
- 6:40uses our AI or some AI anyway, because I don't
- 6:45want her to undermine their lawsuits against
- 6:47them. And I don't really know if it's an ideological
- 6:53basis of the lawsuit or if it's just a means
- 6:57to extract a higher percentage of revenues because
- 7:01either one has been the case in the past, right?
- 7:06What about with respect to publishing deals?
- 7:09Have you seen AI had an impact on the provision
- 7:11that you're seeing in those deals? I was going
- 7:18to say less so in publishing, I feel like, than
- 7:20on the recorded music side. But Karen, what were
- 7:24you going to add to that? No, I was going to
- 7:26say I was able to get a publisher recently to
- 7:30agree to include in the approval rights, approval
- 7:34for the writer to, you know, whether or not their
- 7:39works were going to be used in training. So yeah,
- 7:42I've got that as well. Yeah, I've had similar
- 7:46success where, but my understanding, and I know
- 7:50that we've had some different understandings
- 7:52amongst us, which I think is important to to
- 7:55call out is that there's the training side of
- 7:58it and then it's how it gets used. So if your
- 8:02writer or your artist actually is called out,
- 8:05or even if it's the style of XYZ person, then
- 8:09that's where your protection really comes in.
- 8:12But if it's just part of a blanket license of
- 8:15overall training, it's a little more nebulous,
- 8:21if you will, a little fuzzier as to what your
- 8:24rights are to prevent that. I suspect if you're
- 8:27a legacy artist who helped build a company, like
- 8:29for example, and I don't know this as a case,
- 8:32but Neil Young, for example, at Warner Records,
- 8:35he helped build the company and he's still actively
- 8:37on the roster. There's no way that Warner isn't
- 8:40going to say yes to basically whatever he wants
- 8:43because he's Neil Young, so he can do what he
- 8:46wants. But if you're the artist that got signed
- 8:49last week, you probably have a little less leverage
- 8:53than that. I'd say it definitely depends on who
- 8:57the label is or distributed, whoever the party
- 9:00on the other side is. I agree with that notion,
- 9:03Pam. I'm sure certain publishers or recording
- 9:06labels are a bit firmer on their stands. But
- 9:11I have seen certain record labels agree to actually
- 9:16carve out AI grants, licenses. uh from the blanket
- 9:20license uh caveat for our audience usually you
- 9:26know you can get the artist a set of approval
- 9:29rights over certain uses of whether it's a recording
- 9:32or a composition in a publishing deal but usually
- 9:35there's a provision saying you know notwithstanding
- 9:39these approval rights if we we the label or publisher
- 9:43are granting a blanket license to substantially
- 9:46all of our catalog, then you don't get approval
- 9:49in that instance. And so I have seen it recently
- 9:53where they have carved out the AI rights. I mean,
- 9:56I have a client who was very, very adamant that
- 9:59he does not like AI at all. And so that was something
- 10:02that we fought for and were able to get it done.
- 10:07Cool. Are you seeing these approval rights being
- 10:11granted at all on the major label or publisher
- 10:14side, without naming names? Is there any success
- 10:17at that level, or is this more on like the smaller
- 10:20companies that are willing to give these rights?
- 10:25There was one major publisher that agreed to
- 10:29it. Agreed to publish approval rights? Approval
- 10:32rights, yeah. Yeah, I think a lot of the majors
- 10:35are probably taking a stance and we just want
- 10:37the rights to go do it. Yeah. You know, there's
- 10:41probably going to need to be some flexibility.
- 10:42I mean, we're in the early stages of this, right?
- 10:46It would be and I also understand that the AI
- 10:49that the Suno Urio That their training kind of
- 10:53resets every like six months or something like
- 10:57that So I do think maybe there's the option to
- 11:01Kind of do an opt -in opt -out Whenever you feel
- 11:05like it kind of thing like maybe if you have
- 11:08a port if you have your royalty portal maybe
- 11:11you have a box that you can check saying yeah,
- 11:14I'm opting in to AI licensing kind of thing and
- 11:18then if you know it's three months later you
- 11:20decide like that's a bad idea you can opt out
- 11:24uncheck the box and then on the next turn you
- 11:27uh like your work is removed that I feel like
- 11:32would be a great system whether or not that can
- 11:34be implemented who knows whether or not the labels
- 11:37are anymore yeah it'd be interesting if an LLM
- 11:39can actually retrain as the rights are are coming
- 11:42in and out I think that's a great idea. I think
- 11:47that from an operational perspective. Yeah, that's
- 11:51where the problem lies, right? The royalties
- 11:56team is sort of off over here, many of them in
- 11:59Nashville, right? And then the creative team,
- 12:04the marketing team, and really the company, the
- 12:07part of the company that does the digital deals
- 12:09is over in another place. So I think it's interesting,
- 12:15the training component of it, because if a company
- 12:19doesn't have the ability to offer a huge catalog
- 12:22for which whatever the AI technology is for that
- 12:28particular company, if they don't have the ability
- 12:30to offer this huge bundle of songs or recordings,
- 12:36then What are they in fact offering and what
- 12:39does their advance look like? What does the market
- 12:41share look like? And so forth and so on, right?
- 12:44Like the point of a blanket license is we have
- 12:46this really, really, really big bag of, you know,
- 12:50stuff and therefore we can offer it to you. But
- 12:55the more you can pull out of that bag and at
- 12:58will. then the more likely it is that your share
- 13:02of the market and your advances therefore shrink
- 13:05from a label or publisher perspective. I mean,
- 13:09from a talent perspective, it's like, it's our
- 13:12stuff, we should have a say. But to me, that's
- 13:15the dynamic because anyone who's gonna do it,
- 13:19you wanna extract the most amount of money from
- 13:22the technology, right? From the pseudo, from
- 13:24the audio, from all of the companies. And how
- 13:28can you do that if you don't have a huge market
- 13:32share or a huge, you know, thousand pound gorilla
- 13:36with which to offer? You know, so I think that's
- 13:39that's a competing dynamic from a company perspective.
- 13:45Yeah, that's a good point, Pam. Operationally,
- 13:47it does. There's some pulling tension there.
- 13:50I think there's always kind of that between like
- 13:52the labels and the artist sides, right? Yeah,
- 13:55yeah. Staying on recording and publishing deals,
- 14:00but getting away from AI for a minute. So there's
- 14:05obviously this historical notion of a traditional
- 14:09record deal, a 15 -point or even 18 -point royalty
- 14:12deal that we've seen traditionally, but have
- 14:17we started seeing people move away from that
- 14:19kind of concept and starting to retain more of
- 14:22their ownership when entering into these deals?
- 14:27Yeah, definitely. Karen, take away. Yeah, no,
- 14:30absolutely. We're seeing a lot more licenses
- 14:33and just distribution deals, even distribution
- 14:36deals with majors themselves. And I think it's
- 14:39just a sign of how a lot of these companies have
- 14:43to stay away from those traditional royalty deals,
- 14:46work for hires, where they have to be more competitive.
- 14:48You know, a lot of artists are coming to the
- 14:50table and already having established themselves
- 14:52and kind of built something independently and
- 14:55then ordered for majors to have these artists
- 14:58move over to their labels, they have to offer
- 15:02them these types of deals. I see a lot of distribution
- 15:06companies that are offering full label type services.
- 15:10They're also offering budgets that are comparable
- 15:13to some of the major label budgets. So I think
- 15:16in order to just be competitive in general, they
- 15:18have to move away from those old school deals
- 15:21and more into licenses. Yeah, can I ask? Sorry
- 15:27to interrupt the question asking John, but I
- 15:29have a question about the services. So in for
- 15:34the distro companies or even like the major word,
- 15:38the distribution arms, you know, the ADA's. Or
- 15:43orchards or whatever. Are you seeing it as a
- 15:45function of? Like the old school deals where
- 15:49it was almost like a drop down menu of for X
- 15:53service. We will charge you this. Is it like
- 15:55a a la carte menu that you can choose from? Or
- 15:58are you seeing it more blanket? Like, OK, we'll
- 16:02take an extra 5 % if you do all you get all these
- 16:06services from us. How are you seeing it? I'm
- 16:09seeing both, but more so the latter of what you
- 16:11said, where it's like a higher fee. if they're
- 16:15going to include those services and it's just
- 16:16all wrapped in. I think maybe some of the more
- 16:20traditional distributors have kind of been around
- 16:23for a while. They're still doing that drop down
- 16:25menu, but a lot of the newer distributors that
- 16:27are coming to the table, I've just seen like
- 16:29a higher fee includes all the services and otherwise
- 16:32you can elect to do this lower fee, but you're
- 16:35not going to have those services added. So here's
- 16:39a question. and i don't have an answer to it
- 16:41and i don't know that we would have an answer
- 16:43to it until five or ten years from now we start
- 16:46seeing audits on these kinds of deals but do
- 16:51we think that ultimately talent will end up with
- 16:57a higher in pocket return under these kind of
- 17:03deal i mean the theory is we will right that's
- 17:05the whole point of it but do we think that in
- 17:07reality it really will because Record companies,
- 17:12it used to be that they did two things. They
- 17:14paid your advances and paid for your recordings
- 17:18to be made, right? And they were marketing machines.
- 17:22Those are basically the two main things record
- 17:25companies did for you. They did your marketing,
- 17:27because they were supposedly experts at marketing,
- 17:29because they're a record company, and they paid
- 17:31for the recordings to be made. Now, do we think
- 17:39that and that used to be just part of their overhead.
- 17:42Then they started outsourcing and then it cost
- 17:44money and so forth and so on. Anyway, just anybody's
- 17:47thoughts. I'd be curious your thought to see
- 17:49if we think that would ultimately be more money
- 17:52in the artist's pocket or if it's going to be
- 17:54a what. Well, I mean, I think the concept of
- 18:00that is that if you're doing something where
- 18:02it's just this drill, right, that means you're
- 18:04taking on the onus yourself for all the other
- 18:07stuff, right? which gives you a lot more control
- 18:11over those costs. I mean, Pam, you've seen that
- 18:14some of our labels have been very successful
- 18:17at managing their own marketing services, managing
- 18:21their own other operational service that otherwise
- 18:23a label would handle. But it's very case by case,
- 18:30isn't it? Not everybody can do that. It depends
- 18:33on the song, right? At the end of the day, it
- 18:34all comes down to the music. Like the financial
- 18:37success of an artist depends on how great a song
- 18:40he or she writes, right? And records and releases,
- 18:43that's a big part of it. Yeah, costs are a big
- 18:47piece of it, but one thing I would say to your
- 18:51question, Pam, I think that at the end of the
- 18:53day, like the ownership that the artists are
- 18:56keeping because they're taking on... these additional
- 18:59distribution or these like marketing services
- 19:02and stuff like that, that John's talking about,
- 19:04like taking on the onus of these additional duties.
- 19:07You know, at the end of the day, they own the
- 19:09copyright in these recordings. You know, by the
- 19:12time they're 50 years old, maybe they can do
- 19:14a copyright sale now. And then depending on how
- 19:17successful they are, right, how big of songs
- 19:20they are or whatnot, there's your financial gain
- 19:23at that point. You know, it's more of a long
- 19:27game. than it is like a current like, hey, am
- 19:29I going to get am I going to become a millionaire
- 19:31in the next two, three years? You think in long
- 19:35term, seeing the force as opposed to the trees,
- 19:38like I'm maintaining ownership over my intellectual
- 19:41property. And it might be a little bit of a slow
- 19:44burn for starters. But when I'm ready to retire
- 19:47and just spend the rest of my days with my kids
- 19:50and grandkids, I'm going to be able to cash out
- 19:52for a 10 to 20 X multiple, something like that.
- 19:58Are we seeing that shift a lot more to, and sorry
- 20:00to cut off the question, but I'm trying to, I
- 20:02know there's a lot that we've got to cover in
- 20:04an hour's worth of time, but are we seeing this
- 20:07a lot in publishing deals as well where writers
- 20:12are trying to have their rights revert back more
- 20:16often nowadays than before? I would say so. I
- 20:20mean, just to the whole idea in general, I very
- 20:24rarely, I have a hard time recommending anything
- 20:26other than a license deal or on the recording
- 20:29side or a admin or like a CodePub with a reversion
- 20:33on the publishing side. Yeah, I agree with Thomas.
- 20:36It's full reversion. Like, especially with the
- 20:39majors out the door, like full reversions, what
- 20:43we're seeing, or at least what I'm seeing. Yeah,
- 20:46I would say even just five. or seven years ago,
- 20:50that was a hard fight. Now it's like, okay, fine,
- 20:53just give us enough time and we'll make it work.
- 20:56So it's just a time advance kind of equation
- 20:59as opposed to ownership and they just assume
- 21:02they're not gonna have it forever. Yeah. Some
- 21:04of the smaller indie independent publishers,
- 21:07they're still, you know, being on the partial
- 21:09reversion. But that's part of their business
- 21:12model, right? Because they need the assets to
- 21:16sell one day. Presumably, they're going to sell
- 21:18to a major when they're, whoever founded their
- 21:21company is ready to retire. And so they need
- 21:23to have something that they can actually sell
- 21:25aside from like just passive income streams.
- 21:27Yeah. And also they have no legacy, right? The
- 21:32majors have, whether you're on the recorded or
- 21:36publishing side, the majors have legacy music,
- 21:43legacy songs, legacy recordings. And so that's
- 21:46what keeps it all afloat. And so they're building
- 21:48their legacy by getting that copyright, I would
- 21:50say, to your point, Thomas. Yeah, sure. So what
- 21:54about with respect to entertainment income participation?
- 21:57Where have you seen a trend or shift with regard
- 21:59to that aspect of a record deal? What's that?
- 22:06I mean, listen, I'll let Karen and Pam speak
- 22:09to their experiences. But in my experience, if
- 22:11the label brings in the deal, great. They can
- 22:14participate. They can get a commission. But the
- 22:17days of 360 label partake participating in all
- 22:22aspects of the artist's financial career, thank
- 22:24you for that. Sorry, no. Yeah, no, same, 100%.
- 22:29It's really only if they bring it in. I remember
- 22:32a couple of years back, maybe it was eight years
- 22:35ago, nine years ago, some of the labels were
- 22:37trying to actively go after artists and get back
- 22:42those funds. Yeah, I remember getting, they hired,
- 22:45I think it was... I'm not going to say the name,
- 22:47but it was one of the majors. They hired someone
- 22:49that their sole job was to reach out to the artist
- 22:52teams and try to collect on the entertainment
- 22:55income. And that didn't work out for them. So,
- 22:59yeah. Even back when I was at Warner, which is
- 23:04now four and a half years ago, we were already
- 23:07giving it all up. I think Atlantic held out a
- 23:10lot longer than we did on the Warner side. But
- 23:16It didn't. I mean, and you know, you know, some
- 23:19companies have like, uh, better merchandising
- 23:24companies, but really all you're doing is saying,
- 23:27go talk to them. You know, we used to try and
- 23:30get it all together. And now it's like, go talk
- 23:33to Roboto about your merch deal. They know what
- 23:35they're doing. We're not doing that. You know,
- 23:37we're, we're just handling this part. But, um,
- 23:41yeah, but I, I do have to give up. I've seen.
- 23:45Uh, like first negotiation rights for that. Like
- 23:48you do have to come talk to them first about
- 23:51some of these things, like for publishing or
- 23:54for merge particularly. Um, but that's just,
- 23:58you know, it's a conversation. So it's, it's
- 24:01sort of an ice in the winter. Easy thing. Yes.
- 24:03We'll have a conversation with you and wait a
- 24:06little while before we close anything out. I
- 24:08agree with that. I see the same thing. First,
- 24:12right? Negotiation may be a matching, right?
- 24:16um never like a hard like we like we have to
- 24:19siphon off a percentage of our touring income
- 24:22also by the way most of the time at least for
- 24:28the new deals these artists are getting tour
- 24:31support there is no profitability to those tours
- 24:34yet and by the time the tours so that was the
- 24:36other thing they realized is wait touring income
- 24:39is percentage is illusory until the artist is
- 24:43so big they're gonna give you the middle finger
- 24:46about like getting any of it. So that's the funny
- 24:50part is that even big artists sometimes in the
- 24:53beginning need tour support. So then where is
- 24:56this profitability you're seeing? It's only for
- 24:58the really the biggest acts. And part of the
- 25:02problem was that the money was always somewhat
- 25:03illusory anyway. Sure. So on that point, I want
- 25:09to shift the touring and live performances, live
- 25:11events a little bit. I'd be remiss to not bring
- 25:15up the recent ruling regarding Live Nation and
- 25:17Ticketmaster, where a New York jury had basically
- 25:21found that they were liable on several monopolization
- 25:24claims, as well as numerous various state antitrust
- 25:28laws. Now, I don't know what the immediate impact
- 25:34of that is. I believe it's supposed to be further
- 25:36proceedings as to what award, if anything, is
- 25:38going to happen. But what do you see an impact
- 25:42if any? with regard to the shift in tours after
- 25:47this. I mean, do you see any shift in the way
- 25:50that tours are going to be priced? Ticket sales
- 25:53are stupid expensive nowadays. But do you see
- 25:57that being any kind of resolution coming from
- 26:00that as a result of this or no? That's the million
- 26:04dollar question, right? Because we've kind of
- 26:07gone through this dance with Live Nation and
- 26:09Tickmaster in the past. and they haven't had
- 26:12to divest. And so I think currently, yeah, aren't
- 26:15they in like the remedy stage? I believe that's
- 26:19where it's at, yeah. Yeah, where they're trying
- 26:21to figure out what the punishment is on this.
- 26:23So we'll see. You know, hard to kind of future
- 26:28trip and guess what would be the outcome. But
- 26:30I would imagine if they did have to divest, I
- 26:32mean, we're going to see more competitors in
- 26:34the marketplace then. It's not all going to be
- 26:37Live Nation venues. Ticketmaster ticketing, which
- 26:40is going to be more people, more possibilities
- 26:43for artists and booking agents and to work with
- 26:47more different promoters in different venues.
- 26:50Yep. On a related note, there is, for those of
- 26:55you who are paying attention, there is active
- 26:56legislation revolving around trying to increase
- 27:01transparency over ticketing. For example, on
- 27:05the federal level, there's the Main Event Ticketing
- 27:07Act, which is a bill designed to stop ticket
- 27:09-buying bots and protect consumers from online
- 27:11price gouging and scams, as well as the Ticket
- 27:14Act, which is designed to bring price transparency
- 27:17and consumer protections to live entertainment
- 27:19and ticketing industries by implementing a few
- 27:23things, such as all -in pricing, which is, you
- 27:26know, here is the price, this is everything that's
- 27:28included as far as little, you know, taxing fees.
- 27:33all in one price, which also then includes fee
- 27:36disclosures as to what constitutes everything
- 27:38within the fees, as well as additional refund
- 27:41protections. All of this can be found in the
- 27:44RID materials, which are, I believe in the link.
- 27:48I don't know if they're being emailed as well,
- 27:50but there is a link on this chat for those of
- 27:53you who are looking for it. But also kind of
- 27:58shifting with this industry is that we're seeing
- 28:01more and more festivals being broadcasted live.
- 28:06And so what that means, especially when we're
- 28:09talking about broadcasting in other territories,
- 28:13that you're starting to see a lot more activity
- 28:14in terms of getting rights for live performances,
- 28:20not only within the US, but trying to have it
- 28:23extend outside of the US. You're starting to
- 28:26see more activity around broadcasters entering
- 28:28into different deals with certain territories
- 28:30for example like if there was a There was a festival
- 28:33that was happening in Miami. That's gonna be
- 28:35broadcast to all of South America. Maybe you'd
- 28:38have Telemundo broadcast With with them live
- 28:43-streaming as a syndicate for all the other territories
- 28:45within the country. You're seeing a lot more
- 28:47of that happen as far as provisions within the
- 28:53agreements. I mean, we've seen a lot change in
- 28:56the wake of Astroworld and in the wake of COVID
- 29:00even, where you'll see a lot more provisions
- 29:03that talk about safety and security, reps and
- 29:09warranties, additional insurance requirements
- 29:12for performers obtaining their own insurance
- 29:16in order to perform at an event. even at festivals
- 29:20where there's a promoter that are presumably
- 29:22bringing in numerous performers into the fest.
- 29:28And provisions regarding health and safety, just
- 29:31assumption and risk of the possibility that you
- 29:34might get sick while you're on location. As far
- 29:40as event sponsors and kind of brand deals, the
- 29:47way that works in... A lot of artists are entering
- 29:52into brand deals. Once they get to a certain
- 29:53level, they want to do these partnerships with
- 29:56people. But you'll see brand deals sometimes
- 29:59cross over into tour support. Pam, do you have
- 30:02any feedback that you can share on how you've
- 30:05seen that work in your practice? Yes, it's a
- 30:11nightmare. That's my feedback. No, so what's
- 30:21happening now is in the bundle of rights that
- 30:25a brand would get, whether it's a financial institution
- 30:29or another brand, but particularly with financial
- 30:34institutions, they want, in addition to being
- 30:40able to... have somebody use their credit card
- 30:42or whatever it is for the purchase and and you
- 30:45know maybe an activation on site and kind of
- 30:47the typical brand things that venues and they
- 30:50also want pre -sale rights which can mean that
- 30:56you know there's a discount if you use their
- 31:00card or their method of payment to purchase your
- 31:05ticket so you'll get 20 % off or you'll get some
- 31:08sort of benefit. Um, and that all seems fine,
- 31:13uh, unless you go to South America where, and
- 31:18then probably it used to be the case in the U
- 31:20S but since our venues are monopolized and we
- 31:23don't have as much of an issue, right. But, um,
- 31:26going back to the prior, but the promoters locally
- 31:31used to control that. And there's a vague that
- 31:34happens when you get it. And so they pay real
- 31:38money. to have those rights because there's a
- 31:40huge vig. And then inevitably what happens is
- 31:45there's a showdown between a venue that deals
- 31:48with their local promoter because they're thick
- 31:51as thieves, pun intended. And then this other
- 31:56company that's maybe a multinational that comes
- 31:58in and says, hey, but we want to be, we have
- 32:01these rights. And from a drafting perspective,
- 32:07one of the things that really helped us in a
- 32:11situation was that the talent didn't have the
- 32:15obligation or make a warranty or representation
- 32:18that those rights were available in any particular
- 32:22market. So they weren't legally obligated to
- 32:26give them those rights. But to the extent that
- 32:30they were available, we're not giving them to
- 32:32anybody else. So for example, you go to Mexico
- 32:37or you go to Panama and some and other places
- 32:41We are not that the talent would not say all
- 32:47right, we're not We don't we're not taking sides,
- 32:51you know, they become Switzerland about it and
- 32:55That little nuance of drafting Really made the
- 33:00whole thing a lot simpler which is not to say
- 33:03that it was at all simple, but it did make it
- 33:05a lot simpler. So, yeah, so the big issue there,
- 33:10and I think it probably will continue to be a
- 33:13big issue, is the presale rights, because there
- 33:17apparently is quite a big about that and a battle
- 33:20between the sponsor, if they're a big enough
- 33:23sponsor, obtaining those rights and expecting
- 33:25them to make money off of it, and the local community,
- 33:29the promoter community, also expecting. those
- 33:32rights. Pam, can I have some questions on that?
- 33:37So are you essentially, in your experience, are
- 33:39you letting the, you're just saying to the sponsor,
- 33:42hey, go figure this out with the promoters? Or
- 33:45are you kind of like needing them since? Well,
- 33:49you get drawn in, right? Because, but at the
- 33:52end of the day, under the contract, we are allowed
- 33:57to say to them, that's on you. Right. So if you
- 34:01go to the venue and the venue gives you pre -sale
- 34:04rights or your local financial institution on
- 34:09the ground there says, yeah, we'll run the money
- 34:12for you, then that's fine. But we're not saying
- 34:18that we're going to go to this one or that one
- 34:21and make them do it. Or we're not going to hold
- 34:24our concert in this particular venue. Because
- 34:26what happens is the venues are highly dependent
- 34:30on their promoters to push shows into their venues.
- 34:34So that's where the long -term relationship is.
- 34:37And the sponsor is usually the interloper, the
- 34:41more outsider party, and that's where things
- 34:45get really sticky. So yes, you end up trying
- 34:48to massage the side, but it's more along the
- 34:51lines of being a mediator rather than a participant,
- 34:56if you will. You're not, like, connecting them
- 34:59ahead of time as you're doing the deal with the
- 35:02sponsor, right? No, not even ahead of time. It's
- 35:06just that if they run into trouble... Getting
- 35:07the promoter a heads up or anything? Well, I
- 35:11think... I've kind of dipped my hand in this
- 35:17matter, too, with Pam. What is health is having,
- 35:21you know, with a particular artist, having the
- 35:23same agent bring in both deals, right? Because
- 35:25it's... It's not like you can have the tour agreement
- 35:28come at the same time as a brand deal. It's not
- 35:31always the case, right? One's going to come before
- 35:33the other and naturally the negotiation at one
- 35:36point is going to happen before the other but
- 35:37at least having the same agent kind of bring
- 35:41forth both of them. A little bit of a glue. There's
- 35:45already a glue in there in terms of, all right,
- 35:47here's what we have and here's what we don't
- 35:48have. Here's already kind of a projected idea
- 35:51of where we're trying to go as a whole. And so
- 35:55we know where these rights are going to fall
- 35:56and where they won't. And again, with the agent
- 35:59representing the artist, the artist is basically
- 36:01still Switzerland, but at least the agent is
- 36:05able to flag and say, hey, look, here's what's
- 36:08there. It's got to get sorted out. We're not
- 36:10choosing sides, but it has to be dealt with.
- 36:14Well, and to John's point, in the situation that
- 36:19I'm thinking of, the agency really you know,
- 36:25had, I wouldn't say they had an obligation, but
- 36:27they had a very strong interest in keeping everybody
- 36:31happy, right? Because they need the promoters
- 36:34locally. And they also, you know, maybe their
- 36:39other department, but the branding deal came
- 36:42in through them as well, right? So you've got
- 36:45one agent who is in the booking side of it all.
- 36:48And you're working with the local promoters and
- 36:49you've got another agent who brings in the brand
- 36:52and So there's this tension, but also mutual
- 36:57interest in placating all the sides. And so you
- 37:02really enlist the agency to work their relationships
- 37:07for you. Get this one to come around and be reasonable.
- 37:11Oh, make this one come around and be reasonable.
- 37:13And sometimes it doesn't happen. You know, sometimes
- 37:15it's just a firm. This is how we're doing it
- 37:18and you're screwed. And so the brand has to back
- 37:21off because of local custom. but you know you
- 37:25try and marry that. Staying on brand deals for
- 37:30a minute because I know that a lot of artists
- 37:32partner with a lot of brands to have their music
- 37:35show up on social media campaigns or even you
- 37:39know television campaigns if big enough but from
- 37:43from the standpoint of the music being used in
- 37:46the campaigns who's responsible for clearing?
- 37:51Brand. I like Pamela's approach on things like,
- 37:56you guys go do it. I'm right there with you,
- 37:58Pam. Because I know that I've seen deals come
- 38:01in and always the initial draft is saying that
- 38:03the artist reps and warrants that they have all
- 38:05the rights to the music and that they're going
- 38:06to give these rights to the brand. And I think
- 38:10100 % of the time, I've always pushed back and
- 38:12said, no, you guys do it. Yeah, totally. And
- 38:15that really is even like, I would say like, that's
- 38:18like an internal conversation with your agent
- 38:20team. or whomever is out there sourcing it for
- 38:22your clients, right? Like you're saying to them
- 38:25ahead of time, like as you guys are figuring
- 38:26out what your next steps are, like, hey, if we're
- 38:29going to do something where artists music is
- 38:31being used, brands got to clear that. You know,
- 38:34like that obligation, like that should be, I
- 38:36feel like a lot of agents know that, but that
- 38:39definitely should be part of the pre -conversation
- 38:41going into pitching. Yeah. They don't necessarily
- 38:46like it. Sorry. Go ahead, Karen. No, I was going
- 38:48to say it's easier. on our end, because we know,
- 38:51right? Like push that onto the brand to clear
- 38:54it. But I think where it becomes the issue is
- 38:56like on the influencer and the content creator
- 38:58side that they're doing these deals with these
- 39:01brands and implementing like some of our clients
- 39:03music, right? And pulling from the library on
- 39:07TikTok or on Instagram, not knowing that for
- 39:11using specific types of songs, they actually
- 39:13have to get that license, right? So like there's
- 39:16the pre -cleared music on these social media
- 39:19platforms, and then there's the music that actually
- 39:21would require them. And I've seen where the brands
- 39:24and maybe just in the content creator influencer
- 39:27economy, them not knowing ahead of time, they've
- 39:31always put it on the talent to, you know, to
- 39:34just clear those rights or to use music that's
- 39:36free and clear. And then it's coming back now,
- 39:39inviting a lot of them in the butt. So they are,
- 39:41you know, there's a lot of litigation around
- 39:44that, which, you know, we're aware of. There's
- 39:46companies out there set up specifically, like
- 39:50they have tools to identify when brands are using
- 39:53music that's not in this pre -cleared library
- 39:55on the platform. And they go out and essentially
- 39:59initiate the demand letters and threatening the
- 40:04copyright lawsuits. And then main goal just really
- 40:08extracting a settlement. It's like a whole new
- 40:11business model of, I guess it's like positive
- 40:14trolling in a sense. As a practice note, so two
- 40:19things have come up that have been interesting.
- 40:22One is that normally the agency and lawyer are
- 40:31very lockstep, right? We want the same things,
- 40:33we're on the same, but there's a point at which
- 40:35we slightly diverge and that is that the agency
- 40:40just wants it done. Right. They want to make
- 40:42the brand happy because that's their relationship
- 40:44there. They want to make the talent happy. So
- 40:46they just want it done. And so what that means
- 40:50from a lawyer perspective is we should get ethics
- 40:53credit for this, by the way, is that that we
- 40:59have to they want us to jump in and take some
- 41:03of that responsibility back. And of course, that's
- 41:06terrible for our client. It's terrible for us.
- 41:08because we're so far out of the loop of the creation
- 41:11process, usually, or at least it's like, oh,
- 41:14last minute thought. Yeah. Can you just clear
- 41:17this? You wanted to go live, you know, at midnight
- 41:19tonight and it's five p .m. So it's what's interesting
- 41:25is that the divergence of, hey, we really need
- 41:29you to help out. And so if we do, then the question
- 41:35is, well, How much are they allowed to rely?
- 41:39The contract says you're solely responsible for
- 41:43negotiating and clearing all music rights. On
- 41:47the other hand, we undertake to help, right?
- 41:50Because we did the clearances for the album,
- 41:54for example, right? So we have information. So
- 41:59it's just a question. I don't have an answer
- 42:00to it, but it is something that I think everyone
- 42:03needs to consider when we generously decide to
- 42:07help and Then something ends up going awry Pam
- 42:12you you left out the most important part of that
- 42:14provision In the event that the brand is not
- 42:17a license. It's not going to be a breach on the
- 42:19artist It's not a breach and remember the other
- 42:24part is that That it is You can almost always
- 42:31get a limitation on liability To the amount that
- 42:35they're getting paid for the overall deal, right?
- 42:39and so that really is those two provisions from
- 42:44a drafting perspective is You at least stated
- 42:48in the contract that it's on the brand And then
- 42:52you also have a limitation on liability to the
- 42:55amount that is being paid under the deal. Now,
- 42:57if that amounts a lot, it's still not a great
- 43:00limitation, but it's something, you know. But
- 43:02if I had a deal come across my desk where the
- 43:06fee was X and the limitation they wanted to put
- 43:10on liability was for X. And I was just like,
- 43:13are you high? That is not happening. You know,
- 43:16it's just not going to. So you have to really
- 43:19watch it and make sure that they are commensurate
- 43:22with each other. And look, I understand why they
- 43:25wanted it, because the fee that they're paying
- 43:28and the amount of liability they could incur
- 43:30could be dramatically different. Are you seeing
- 43:33the brands carving out, because normally with
- 43:36those limitations of liabilities, if it was placed
- 43:38on my client, I'd carve out indemnification obligations
- 43:42from the brand. If you're saying that you're
- 43:47inserting the limitation of liability to protect
- 43:49the artist in that sense, are you seeing that
- 43:51they're carving out the information obligations
- 43:54from there? I'd have to look at the exact language
- 43:59in what I'm thinking of, but I think it's an
- 44:01overall, John, you may be more familiar, but
- 44:04I think it's an overall limitation period at
- 44:07the end. I think that usually just ends up being
- 44:10the subject of negotiation. It'd be great for
- 44:13the artist. I do want to move this over to copyright
- 44:16because there have been a recent number of cases
- 44:20regarding specifically termination that we should
- 44:23certainly bring up, not of which the least importance
- 44:27is. It better be a resonant case. Tom, do you
- 44:29want to give us a quick rundown of what's going
- 44:31on there? Yeah, it's a really interesting case.
- 44:37For everyone that's listening, if you have time
- 44:40to dig into the decision, the facts of everything,
- 44:45the way certain laws apply, very interesting,
- 44:48I find. The gist of it is the Fifth Circuit down
- 44:53in Louisiana, I think Texas is in there in Mississippi,
- 44:57ruled recently that... That authors may reclaim
- 45:03worldwide rights when terminating prior grants
- 45:06of rights under section 304 and presumably section
- 45:10203 as well But this particular case was a 304
- 45:14case But authors can reclaim worldwide rights
- 45:17where previous precedent that was set in the
- 45:20Ninth Circuit had previously said authors could
- 45:22only reclaim us rights And yeah, really interesting
- 45:27case. Vedder, apparently not. This was a co -write.
- 45:32Vedder and Ciro Vedder and Donald Smith were
- 45:35the writers. Vedder now owns 100 % of the copyright
- 45:39throughout the world. And yeah, just a really,
- 45:43I would really encourage everyone to read the
- 45:46opinion because how this all plays out, how all
- 45:49the facts and the laws were applied to get Vedder
- 45:52100 % of the copyright is really interesting.
- 45:55But it's a good thing, I think. I mean, the big
- 45:58takeaway is this is primed for a Supreme Court
- 46:01decision at one point. We now have this Ninth
- 46:04Circuit that says only U .S. rights apply. We
- 46:07have the Fifth Circuit that says worldwide rights
- 46:10can be reclaimed. And I would imagine within
- 46:14the next few years we'll see this type of issue
- 46:17in front of the Supreme Court. So from a drafting
- 46:22standpoint, then, does that make it above most
- 46:24importance to talk about what the choice of law
- 46:27is? Especially when you're talking about publishing.
- 46:29Yeah, that's a good point. I mean, you want to
- 46:32try and get in the Fifth Circuit. I don't know
- 46:35how realistic that really is for a lot of our
- 46:38clients and the businesses that we do business
- 46:41with. Usually it's L .A. or New York, I'd say,
- 46:45or probably in your case. You're in Pam's case,
- 46:47John, probably Miami a lot or Florida. Do you
- 46:51see a lot of Florida law in your agreements?
- 46:53We've seen a lot of that, yes. Yeah, sure. Pam,
- 46:56with regard to this choice of law point, I mean,
- 47:00there's a lot of industry in the U .S. that is
- 47:04actually based in the U .K. So how is that then
- 47:08interplaying with the ruling in the U .S. about
- 47:10termination rights and choosing maybe U .K. law
- 47:13to apply to a contract? Well, I don't know how
- 47:18it's going to play out. But the grants, or I'll
- 47:26just say, because they've done so many deals,
- 47:28but the hypnosis grants, they're a UK based company.
- 47:31And even though you deal with US lawyers and
- 47:34a lot of people are here in the US, they use
- 47:37UK law because they are a UK company. And they,
- 47:44you know, even though they're purchasing Originally
- 47:49a US copyright, they're assuming that the UK
- 47:54law will apply to their grant and they'll get
- 47:56their full rights in perpetuity. And interestingly
- 48:02enough, the UK doesn't have termination rights
- 48:04anymore. So that's the thing. And that's the
- 48:09crux of it is, is it a territorial thing the
- 48:12way infringement lawsuits are? Or is it, can
- 48:16you... can you put that infringement hat on the
- 48:21grants and termination rights? That's what I
- 48:25just pulled out of better. Thomas, you can really
- 48:29correct me if I've got that wrong. But I think
- 48:32that that's the interesting part. So the answer
- 48:38is I have no idea. I know they're trying it.
- 48:41And they try a lot of other things, like Well,
- 48:45if you go to Transfer the copyright that's okay
- 48:49fine, but then you don't get The money still
- 48:52we get to keep all the money so you can own it,
- 48:55but you don't get any of the money from it Which
- 48:57I have to think will fail should it ever be challenged?
- 49:01I mean what we got to wait another 35 years before
- 49:04we really know probably but That I think is particularly
- 49:09interesting if the the language that they put
- 49:12in there that said yeah If you fight about this
- 49:17and you win, you don't get the money. You still
- 49:20have to pay us all the money. I can't imagine
- 49:25that a court would say that that makes any sense,
- 49:28but maybe. So I mean, I think a big piece, you
- 49:31know, it's interesting. This is a real interesting
- 49:33issue because part of the court's reasoning in
- 49:37better was that. Yeah, it doesn't make sense
- 49:40to just give us rights back that doesn't align
- 49:43with what we think congressional intent was when
- 49:46enacting this law and the whole purpose of the
- 49:49law was to give the authors the second bite of
- 49:53the apple when they've given away their rights,
- 49:56not knowing the full value of the copyright at
- 49:59the time when they're disadvantaged in the negotiation
- 50:03state. We're talking about hypnosis or a catalog
- 50:06sale. You're talking about a well negotiated,
- 50:11you know, each side has lawyers, each side has
- 50:13done financial projections and analysis. Yeah,
- 50:18I agree. I don't know how, if someone were to
- 50:21now try and reclaim those rights from a catalog
- 50:24sale, yeah, it would be an unjust enrichment
- 50:27to allow them to keep the money at the same time.
- 50:31Well, it's interesting because you're right.
- 50:33One of the arguments in Vedder was, well, the
- 50:36author is disadvantaged. But I think anybody
- 50:39would be hard pressed to say that a catalog sale
- 50:45author is somehow disadvantaged or unknowledgeable
- 50:56or even, as you say, that we don't know the value
- 50:58because usually you've got 20 years or more of
- 51:03history to know some projection of value. I mean,
- 51:07it is still a prediction for future, but it's
- 51:11a whole lot less of a risky prediction than brand
- 51:15new author. I think it's interesting. And yeah,
- 51:24I think it's really, really interesting. And
- 51:26I'm not sure that the logic holds in better,
- 51:29really. Because if your original sale was for
- 51:35worldwide rights, then wouldn't you terminate
- 51:40the original transaction? What you're terminating
- 51:43is the original transaction. Is a lawyer in the
- 51:48UK who is very fond of doing split territory
- 51:51deals, right? So they do one deal for the US
- 51:54and Canada maybe in another deal for ROW or one
- 51:57deal for Australia because people liked mushroom
- 52:00in Australia, whatever it was, right? So there
- 52:02was this trend 15 years ago or so where you would
- 52:07do split territory deals because then you get
- 52:09this chunk in advance here and you get another
- 52:11chunk over here and you can work it. And if you
- 52:14do that, then you definitely wouldn't be, obviously,
- 52:20terminating worldwide because you can only terminate
- 52:22the original grant. But if your original grant
- 52:25was worldwide, that's what Vedder's saying. I
- 52:29don't know. It's just a thought. It triggered
- 52:32thinking about all these split territory deals
- 52:35that people like to do. I would imagine you'd
- 52:37be able to, and I guess, yeah, it gets into territorial
- 52:40governing law issues, obviously. U .S. deal and
- 52:45ex -U .S. deal under better, you could terminate
- 52:49both and get all the worldwide rights back. I
- 52:54do want to turn to another case, sorry to cut
- 52:57you off Tom, but there is another case that involved
- 53:00termination or rather lack thereof. the Salt
- 53:04and Pepper versus UMG case. Karen, do you mind
- 53:06giving us the rundown of what happened there?
- 53:08Because I know there's a lot of impact potentially
- 53:10with the way that we use loanouts in record deals
- 53:14in our agreements. Yeah, absolutely. I'm trying
- 53:17to make it quick because I know we're running
- 53:19low on time. So for those that aren't familiar,
- 53:23essentially Salt and Pepper entered into a 1986
- 53:25agreement with a company called Noise in the
- 53:27Attic Productions. That was a production company
- 53:30owned by their producer. Noise in the Attic,
- 53:33aka NIDA, for the purposes here. So NIDA's agreement
- 53:36stated that it was the sole and exclusive owner
- 53:39of the master recordings and the copyrights in
- 53:41them. And then NIDA subsequently entered into
- 53:43a recording agreement with another label. Salt
- 53:46and Pepper signed an inducement to that agreement.
- 53:50Fast forward, those rights ultimately ended up
- 53:52at UMG. So 35 years later, Salt and Pepper sent
- 53:56UMG a termination notice under Section 203 Copyright
- 54:00Act seeking to terminate The UMG's rights in
- 54:03their earlier master recordings, and UMG disputed
- 54:06the notice. They claimed that the recordings
- 54:07were works made for hire. Sal and Pepper filed
- 54:10a lawsuit. UMG filed a motion to dismiss, claiming
- 54:14the termination was defective because the recordings,
- 54:16again, were works made for hire. So earlier this
- 54:19year, the court granted UMG's motion to dismiss
- 54:23the case. The court held that Sal and Pepper
- 54:26never plausibly established that they owned the
- 54:28copyrights in the first place and that they executed
- 54:31or that they executed a copyright transfer that
- 54:34could be terminated. So one thing that's important
- 54:37to know is also that this is not the final ruling.
- 54:39It is under appeal right now, but it is definitely
- 54:43a huge warning for us all because we, you know,
- 54:48one, there's a number of production deals that
- 54:51some clients and talent are entering into, but
- 54:53also a lot of our clients are. you know, entering
- 54:56into these recording deals through their loan
- 54:58out entities or through, you know, different
- 55:00furnishing companies. So I think, you know, there's
- 55:03a lot of importance there on whether or not what's
- 55:07being established, who's actually being established
- 55:09as the owner and the author and has the ability
- 55:13to terminate a copyright transfer. So, yeah,
- 55:17I think that that is kind of, I don't know, it's
- 55:21scary. What's interesting about the bill is that,
- 55:24if I recall, I don't remember seeing the words
- 55:26work made for hire in any of those agreements,
- 55:28right? Yeah, I don't think so. I think it was
- 55:32a rep and warranty that, or it was in the original
- 55:36agreement, it was an agreement that NIDA would
- 55:39own the copyrights. And then the subsequent deal,
- 55:42it was a rep and warranty that NIDA, in fact,
- 55:45owned the copyrights with salt and pepper, then
- 55:47signed an inducement saying, yes, I affirm that.
- 55:51Yeah. When we're talking about doing agreements
- 55:55between a loan out that's actually owned by the
- 55:57artist, a loan out at a record company where
- 56:00the loan out makes the rep and warranty that
- 56:02the loan out owns the rights to the records that
- 56:05are being transferred to the record company,
- 56:08and then the record company has the artist sign
- 56:09an inducement, has that inducement letter basically
- 56:14waived the termination rights of the artist?
- 56:18Yeah, that's what we... you know, we don't know
- 56:21yet. I guess depending on how this appeal, this
- 56:24may change how we're drafting and structuring
- 56:27all of our deals. I was going to say, you know,
- 56:31assuming a label or publisher, whomever would
- 56:34go for it, but I wonder if it would be possible
- 56:37if like an artist entered into a recording deal
- 56:40via a loan out company, if you could then amend
- 56:43or assign that agreement back to the artist as
- 56:46an individual and so those rights back. Can you
- 56:53assign back termination rights that they didn't
- 56:55exist in the first place though? Well, I guess
- 56:57my thought would be that you assign back the
- 57:01agreement to the individual and therefore the
- 57:04grant of rights being granted to the laborer,
- 57:07whomever, are now coming from the individual
- 57:09and no longer coming from the entity. The problem
- 57:13is it's not retroactive, right? So yeah, we could
- 57:17fix it. For newly created recordings or newly
- 57:21created compositions, but for the priors, I think
- 57:24we're still screwed. Maybe I don't know, but
- 57:26yeah, I mean, if you say it in there, like, this
- 57:29is a retro like we're retroactively assigning
- 57:33it, like, who knows, right? Right. But if you
- 57:36if you if a has already assigned to be and then
- 57:40B has assigned to see under like what happens
- 57:43in a recording agreement. He no longer has it
- 57:46to give back. Yeah Right. That's the problem
- 57:50for on the recorded music side and the public
- 57:53but the What you know on the pub side? That the
- 57:58simple solve is all the deals are in the individual
- 58:02capacity and the payments go to The company right
- 58:07if you want to run your business through the
- 58:09company you collect the payments but the contracting
- 58:12party the granting party Should be the individual
- 58:17because that's how you preserve it. You can't
- 58:19do that when you've got a true third party furnished
- 58:22LLC or corporation in between but you can do
- 58:26that when you've got There is there is one more
- 58:32case I want to bring up. I know there's some
- 58:33questions in the chat just really quick In December
- 58:37of last year cost communications versus Sony
- 58:39music and this is with regard to our you know
- 58:42the DMCA takedown provisions or the broken system
- 58:45that we try to rely on within our industry. There
- 58:50was a ruling that came down, Cox Communications
- 58:52versus Sony Music in December, where basically
- 58:55Sony Music had filed 163 ,000 takedown notices
- 58:59to Cox saying stop people from illegally uploading
- 59:02our music. Cox, for lack of a better word, kind
- 59:07of ignored. this 163 ,000 notices. And so Sony
- 59:12then sued Cox directly. And the initial ruling
- 59:16in the lower court was that Cox was held liable
- 59:20for both direct and contributory infringement.
- 59:23Went up on appeal and the contributory claim
- 59:26got dismissed. And then recently in December,
- 59:29the Supreme Court basically said that Cox was
- 59:33not liable for direct infringement either. and
- 59:36the reasons were because a direct infringement
- 59:38can only happen in two instances from an ISP.
- 59:43It's one when the service is tailored to infringement
- 59:52if it's not capable or substantial or commercially
- 59:55significant in its non -infringing uses, or if
- 1:00:00it induces the infringing activity. There was
- 1:00:06a point towards the end of that opinion where
- 1:00:08it basically said that DMCA does not impose liability
- 1:00:11for ISPs who serve no infringers. The DMCA merely
- 1:00:15creates new defenses. When I read that, I essentially
- 1:00:21read that to mean that compliance with the DMCA
- 1:00:23is not a requirement to avoid copyright infringement
- 1:00:26liability from the DSP. It's a way to avoid infringement,
- 1:00:30but it's not required to comply with it in order
- 1:00:32to avoid liability. You know, what does that
- 1:00:36do to the weight of a takedown notice when, you
- 1:00:42know, when our clients ask us to send takedowns
- 1:00:46for music that hasn't been properly been paid
- 1:00:48for, properly cleared, or site artists that,
- 1:00:51you know, who didn't get properly papered when
- 1:00:56they've appeared on a record and they show up
- 1:00:59on somebody's song without being paid? I mean,
- 1:01:01what I'm seeing here is that When somebody submits
- 1:01:08a takedown notice, I mean, setting aside the
- 1:01:10fact of whether or not it actually works, that
- 1:01:15the DSP doesn't actually need to rely on the
- 1:01:20takedown notice to avoid any sense of liability
- 1:01:24there. I mean, does that kind of conform with
- 1:01:29everyone's understanding of how should operate?
- 1:01:40And not not really sure. In my experience, yeah,
- 1:01:46that's that's a good question to ask. So I think
- 1:01:51it's a big mess and I don't think we have an
- 1:01:54answer to it. That's what I think. I think that
- 1:01:57is ultimately the answer to it. So we're at the
- 1:02:01end of our program. I'm going to try to get through
- 1:02:03a couple of these questions really quickly. I
- 1:02:06see one from Daryl Thompson, which says, a number
- 1:02:11of issues discussed today might ultimately require
- 1:02:13litigation. Many of his clients don't have adequate
- 1:02:16funds to initiate litigation. Have you come up
- 1:02:21or found any alternatives? We were just talking
- 1:02:25about the takedown provisions, and I don't think
- 1:02:29they work. I mean, they work obviously in some
- 1:02:31cases, but I feel like it's whoever is friendlier
- 1:02:34with the DSP is the one that has their takedown
- 1:02:37notices handled better. But are there any other
- 1:02:44routes that someone with lack of funds can take
- 1:02:48in order to enforce their rights? Yeah, I'm not
- 1:02:57sure I know there's like a lot of litigation
- 1:02:59funds, but I feel like the case has to be worth
- 1:03:03like a certain there's like a certain threshold
- 1:03:05to it. Yeah, in my do you guys I feel like there
- 1:03:09actually was like a copyright or or something
- 1:03:15like that that handled cases less than like the
- 1:03:20$12 ,000 or $10 ,000 threshold to get into. to
- 1:03:25separate Small Claims Court and your regular
- 1:03:29courts. Does this sound familiar to anyone? I
- 1:03:34might be misremembering or something. Is it the
- 1:03:37Copyright Small Claims Court? Is that what you're
- 1:03:38referring to? Yeah. I do remember hearing that.
- 1:03:44Honestly, I don't know too much about it. But
- 1:03:47I do remember hearing that. So maybe that's an
- 1:03:50option, Darryl. You should pick. Do some, look
- 1:03:54into that, see if that's something. I think that
- 1:03:57might be specific to the second circuit, no?
- 1:04:00But I don't know, I could be wrong about that.
- 1:04:03There's a question for Karen, which says, my
- 1:04:07ears perked up at the mention of NVPA and NFLPA
- 1:04:10work in your bio. Is there any emerging increased
- 1:04:13overlap between your music and sports related
- 1:04:16work in response to any industry trends? Yeah,
- 1:04:20I mean, there's a ton of overlap, which could
- 1:04:22be another panel in itself with music and sports
- 1:04:26related. A lot of it coming with music as it's
- 1:04:32incorporated into sports, whether it's in court
- 1:04:35in arena or also really prevalent right now across
- 1:04:38social media and just content in the clipping
- 1:04:40industry. So we can definitely chat offline if
- 1:04:44you want to sidebar about it. Cool. Cool. All
- 1:04:46right. One final question. In any of your opinion,
- 1:04:51what is the biggest misconception AI companies
- 1:04:53have about what rights holders want from these
- 1:04:56licensing deals? Say that one more time. What
- 1:05:01is the biggest misconception that AI companies
- 1:05:03have about what rights holders, i .e. artists
- 1:05:08and writers, want from the licensing deals that
- 1:05:12AI is entering into? I mean, that's hard to say.
- 1:05:19I mean, I don't think anyone on this panel is
- 1:05:22negotiating with the Sunos or the Udios, so we
- 1:05:25don't know what they're like saying in terms
- 1:05:27of that. I mean, my initial thought would maybe
- 1:05:30be that they just want money and it's all about
- 1:05:33money, which maybe it is, but I feel like there's
- 1:05:35also a good chunk of the artist community that
- 1:05:39they have their principles about. they don't
- 1:05:44they feel like AI is just bad for the music industry
- 1:05:48in general so they want control as opposed like
- 1:05:52and they care more about that than liken it to
- 1:05:56if you remember in the early days of YouTube
- 1:05:59and Google and YouTube was totally infringing
- 1:06:05all the time they didn't want to pay any rights
- 1:06:07holders anything now they monetize all over the
- 1:06:09place but go back a decade and a half or two
- 1:06:13and they weren't paying at all. And then you
- 1:06:20would turn the page and they would be suing some
- 1:06:24other company for using their source code. So
- 1:06:29they were protecting their own copyrighted source
- 1:06:32code, having lawsuits about it, simultaneously
- 1:06:36building their business on their own infringement
- 1:06:38of somebody else's rights. So my philosophical
- 1:06:44high horse, if you will, about it is that I don't
- 1:06:48think that tech creators see what they create
- 1:06:53and the protection of that as the same as what
- 1:06:58recording artists create and the protection of
- 1:07:00that. They think that that should perhaps be
- 1:07:03free or everyone should be entitled to it. And,
- 1:07:06you know, there was a movement. I remember like
- 1:07:09in Way back in the 70s. It was still sort of
- 1:07:13flower powers 60s kind of everything is free
- 1:07:17that nobody should own any land because the natives
- 1:07:22didn't and how can you own land because it's
- 1:07:24the earth and whatever, you know, there's a whole
- 1:07:26thing and I almost feel like there's this thought
- 1:07:30process that says But yes, but music and art,
- 1:07:33it should be free for everyone to do whatever
- 1:07:35they want. So we're just providing this public
- 1:07:37service altruistically. Never mind that we're
- 1:07:40protecting our own copyrights. Never mind that
- 1:07:42we're making money off of this. Never mind that
- 1:07:44we're building, you know, million dollar homes
- 1:07:46in Palo Alto on the back of your content that
- 1:07:50you created and you can't pay your rent. So that's
- 1:07:53my highly biased view of the other side of the
- 1:07:59conversation. I think, you know, still though
- 1:08:03on the flip side of it, there's a lot of creators
- 1:08:05who are excited about what AI might be able to
- 1:08:08do in terms of the way that it might help them
- 1:08:10in terms of creating music and just making it
- 1:08:15easier for people to create content. So with
- 1:08:18that, I do want to thank everybody for being
- 1:08:22here. Thank the participants for speaking on
- 1:08:26this panel. Karen, Tom, Pam. And thank everybody
- 1:08:29else for tuning in and listening. So we're officially
- 1:08:34eight minutes over, but there's a lot of content.
- 1:08:36I wish we could have gone through more, but I
- 1:08:38think that's plenty. So thanks, everyone. Thanks,
- 1:08:41John. Thank you. Thanks, John.