Latest / The Last Known: True Crime, Missing Women & Unsolved Mysteries / The Axe in the House: What We Know About Lizzie Borden | The Last Known
Transcript
- There is a silence that lives inside a house so heavy it feels like it could crush your ribs. It is the kind of quiet that waits for you to realize you are not alone. Let’s begin with the air. August 4th, 1892. Fall River, Massachusetts. The heat would have been thick, pressing against the windows of a home that looked wealthy from the outside but felt different on the inside. Andrew Borden and his wife Abby were found dead. Two brutal axe murders. No one else was ever charged. Not the maid. Not a stranger. Just them. And then, their daughter. Lizzie Andrew Borden was thirty-two years old. She stood at the center of a storm that would swallow her name whole. But before we talk about the blood, let’s talk about the life. Because justice isn’t just an outcome; it’s a presence. And in this case, the presence is complicated, layered, and deeply human. Lizzie wasn’t born into luxury. She was born in 1860 to Sarah Morse and Andrew Jackson Borden. Her mother died when Lizzie was young. A younger sister, Alice, died too, very early. So Lizzie grew up with Emma, her older sister, and a father who was trying to build something stable. Andrew had struggled as a young man. He came from a once-wealthy family but had fallen on hard times. He worked hard. He made furniture. He sold caskets. He became a property developer. By 1892, he was worth three hundred thousand dollars. That is over ten million today. A fortune. But money didn’t buy warmth in that house. It bought space. And yet, even with all that wealth, the Borden home lacked indoor plumbing. They lived in an affluent area, yes, but they weren’t in the Highlands, where the truly fashionable families lived. They were close to the industrial noise, close to the immigrants moving into the neighborhood. Andrew Borden was a director of textile mills. He was president of the Union Savings Bank. He was powerful. And he was known for being incredibly frugal. Stingy, some said. He kept the world out. He kept the discomfort out. And he kept his daughters close. Three years after Sarah died, Andrew married Abby Durfee Gray. Lizzie was six. Abby brought two children of her own. The dynamic shifted. Lizzie later said she called her stepmother ‘Mrs. Borden.’ Can you hear that distance? ‘Mrs. Borden.’ Not mother. Not Abby. A title. A boundary. She long believed Abby had married her father for his money. That suspicion festered. It sat in the corners of the house like dust. Lizzie and Emma were raised religiously. They went to Central Congregational Church. Lizzie taught Sunday school to the children of recent immigrants. She served as secretary-treasurer for the Christian Endeavor Society. She was involved with the Woman’s Christian Temperance Union. She helped with the Ladies’ Fruit and Flower Mission. On paper, she was the model citizen. Devout. Helpful. Presentable. But behind closed doors, the tension grew. By 1890, they had a live-in maid, Bridget Sullivan, twenty-five, from Ireland. Bridget testified later that Lizzie and Emma rarely ate meals with their father and stepmother. They ate apart. They lived parallel lives under one roof. And there was anger. Real, simmering anger. Andrew gave real estate gifts to Abby’s family. His daughters resented it. They wanted what they felt was theirs. They demanded a rental property—the house they had lived in until their mother died. Andrew agreed. They bought it from him for one dollar. Just one dollar. A symbolic transaction, perhaps, or a gesture of control. Then, in July, they sold it back to him for five thousand dollars. Almost eighteen thousand today. Why sell it back so quickly? Was it a test? A game? Or was it simply about the money? The cash? The resentment wasn’t just emotional. It was financial. And money, in a house without plumbing, becomes the only thing that feels solid. May 1892. Andrew killed pigeons in his barn with a hatchet. He believed they carried disease. Lizzie had recently built a roost for those birds. Common recounting says she was upset. Disputed veracity, maybe. But the image sticks. A father killing what his daughter nurtured. With a hatchet. July 1892. An argument. Both sisters take extended vacations in New Bedford. They leave. They don’t speak to him. They return. Lizzie stays in a rooming house for four days before coming back to the main house. Four days of absence. Four days of choice. She chose to stay away. Even briefly. Then, August 3rd. John Vinnicum Morse, Lizzie’s maternal uncle, arrived. Andrew invited him to stay overnight in the guest room. They discussed business. Speculation has always swirled around that conversation. Did it aggravate the tension? Did it involve property transfers? We don’t know. But the household had been violently ill for several days prior. Some say it was mutton left on the stove. Abby feared poison. She didn’t trust Andrew. In Fall River, Andrew wasn’t a popular man. People whispered. People judged. And now, his own family was sick. Or pretending to be. Or afraid. The air in the house was thick with suspicion. With illness. With unspoken threats. And then, Thursday morning came. August 4, 1892. Early morning. Andrew was found dead in the living room. Abby was found upstairs in her bedroom. Both struck with an axe. Brutal. Efficient. The news spread through Fall River like a shockwave. Lizzie was arrested. But let’s pause here. Let’s remember her name. Lizzie Andrew Borden. Not ‘the killer.’ Not ‘the suspect.’ Lizzie. A woman standing in the wreckage of her family. Her brother Brian was away at school. He wasn’t there. Only Lizzie, Emma, and Bridget remained. The primary suspects. The maid, Bridget, never faced charges. But the eyes of the city turned to Lizzie. Why? Because she was the daughter. Because she stayed. Because she provided inconsistent alibis. She claimed she was sleeping when the first blow was struck. Later, she said she was reading a book titled ‘The Curse of Civilization.’ These stories didn’t fit. They didn’t add up. And then, the search of her room. Blood-stained clothing. She said it was paint from a previous day. Forensic analysis suggested it was human blood. Circumstantial evidence piled high. Suspicion mounted. The public wanted answers. The press wanted drama. But the courtroom needed proof. And proof is a hard thing to find in a house that lacks plumbing, where secrets are buried under floorboards and silence. The trial in 1893 was a spectacle. Widespread publicity across the United States. Everyone had an opinion. Everyone had a theory. But Lizzie sat there. Quiet. Composed. Perhaps too composed. The jury heard it all. The motive. The money. The relationship. The blood. The lack of direct physical evidence linking her to the weapons or the scene. That gap mattered. In a court of law, gaps can save you. In the court of public opinion, gaps are filled with fear. They acquitted her. June 1893. The gavel fell. Justice, in its legal sense, was delivered. But did justice arrive? Or did it merely pass through? Lizzie and Emma inherited their father’s estate. They bought a house in the Highlands. The Hill District. The wealthy neighborhood they had previously avoided. They renamed it ‘The Maples.’ Emma moved away after twelve years, to New Hampshire. Lizzie stayed. She lived out her life in that house, in that town, under that name. People watched her. They waited for her to crack. To confess. To break. She didn’t. She lived. She aged. She died of pneumonia on June 1st, 1927. At sixty-six. Nine days later, Emma died. Two sisters. One legacy. One mystery that refused to die. The silence here is loud. It echoes in every retelling, every film, every folk rhyme. ‘Listen, ma’am, did you hear about the murder of the Bordens?’ The rhyme persists. The story persists. But Lizzie’s life persisted too. For thirty-four years after the acquittal. She walked those streets. She paid her taxes. She existed. And no one ever charged anyone else. No one else was convicted. The truth remains locked in that house, in that silence, in that summer of 1892. We walk away from Fall River carrying more questions than answers. But we carry Lizzie’s name with respect. We carry the dignity of a life that was scrutinized, judged, and ultimately freed by a system that demanded more than suspicion. This story is drawn from public records and widely reported accounts. Our thoughts are with everyone affected. I’m Teresa Howarth. Keep listening. Keep remembering.