Latest / I Love You Keep Going with George Haas / Cognitive vs Procedural Practice
Transcript
- 0:01You're listening to the I Love You Keep Going podcast with
- 0:04George Haas. For more information, please
- 0:06visit our website at www.metagroup.org.
- 0:10That's www.m ETTAGROU p.org. So welcome everybody.
- 0:19This is I love you. Keep going.
- 0:21It is 7:35 PM Pacific Daylight Time.
- 0:25It's 7/18, 2024, July 18th, 2024.
- 0:30And I thought that I would talk a little bit about the nature of
- 0:34cognitive oriented practice versus procedural oriented
- 0:37practice, and particularly in light of the attachment work
- 0:44that we do. But I think it also applies to
- 0:48any of the meditation practices in, in Buddhist philosophy,
- 0:53there were seven paths for enlightenment and only one of
- 0:56them is meditation oriented. In the West we get very biased
- 1:01toward meditation as the the only path toward enlightenment.
- 1:05But in, in traditional communities that isn't the case.
- 1:10One of them is a cognitive way of going to simply to understand
- 1:16the teachings, understand the Dharma and in that way work into
- 1:21a place of liberation. Some people like name is not
- 1:33popping up, but some people in, in the West also talk about a
- 1:40kind of struck enlightenment that happens so that you also
- 1:44don't need to take the path of meditation and also the path of
- 1:50service. Not giving you a complete list.
- 1:56My experience of, of working cognitively is that it only
- 2:01works in low stress environments because if you get too much
- 2:05stress, it has a negative impact on the, the cognitive minds
- 2:08functioning. And, and you're then stuck
- 2:11really in, in the unfiltered procedural memory.
- 2:15And that procedural memory just has a catalogue of strategies
- 2:21that you use to manage the experience of the present moment
- 2:25as it unfolds. And we get that conditioning
- 2:31very early on. Really.
- 2:36I I'm not gonna argue for against neo neonatal experience
- 2:46before birth experience, but certainly the diet and the
- 2:50stress and the conditions that the the mother has the birth
- 2:57mother has will affect the development of the child.
- 3:03And then the child is born depending on the the quality of
- 3:08the environment they develop in response to it.
- 3:15A human babies are a marvelous thing in the sense that they're
- 3:20born with their brains only partially developed.
- 3:24This is different than most mammals.
- 3:28And so that we have the unusual experience of our brains forming
- 3:35in direct relationship to the environment, not just through
- 3:41the, the, the, the, the birth mother taking care of us.
- 3:46And then we're born with these capacities that are instinctual
- 3:53and so many other species, but our our brains develop in direct
- 3:59response to the experiences of the environment that we have,
- 4:05the care that we're provided with.
- 4:10And that lays down these deep procedural tracks.
- 4:16Human babies don't really have a sense of who they are.
- 4:20And there isn't really a mechanism in humans to be able
- 4:24to see ourselves clearly. We really see ourselves mainly
- 4:29in the reflection of other people.
- 4:31And that process also starts very young, that spontaneous,
- 4:42authentic calling out to the world for the care that we need
- 4:46without even knowing what that care is.
- 4:49And then understanding in that very primal way the way that the
- 4:55care is delivered. And creating a representative, a
- 5:00representation of ourselves based on the experience of the
- 5:05care that we received and valuing the kinds of requests
- 5:11and for care that we have based on the way that we're responded
- 5:17to. And so if you have a resourced,
- 5:21rested, focused, capable caregiver, the experience of
- 5:27requesting care and receiving care is very different than if
- 5:31you have a stressed, resourceless, incapable
- 5:38caregiver and how they view the same request for care.
- 5:43It's not that the the the care for one baby is greatly
- 5:49different than another, but the environment.
- 5:56Some babies settling are quite easy in the sense that they
- 6:00don't develop colic and they're not overly sensitive to the
- 6:04environment. Some babies that do develop
- 6:08colic have a lot of pain in the beginning of life as the
- 6:12digestive system comes online and so they need a a higher
- 6:16level of care at that time. Or some babies have a
- 6:20sensitivity to the sensing experience, which requires a
- 6:25greater control of the environment so that they're not
- 6:29overwhelmed by the sensory stimulus that happens.
- 6:36So in the beginning where there isn't this cognitive ability to
- 6:39learn, we really are in a process of laying down these
- 6:45tracks of procedures and the way to request something to try and
- 6:50elicit the care that you need even before there's a conceptual
- 6:54capacity for a framework to talk about this stuff.
- 7:01So somewhere along the way the, the brain develops and you
- 7:08develop these capacities for a, a cognitive mind, you develop a
- 7:15capacity for autobiographical reference, autobiographical
- 7:19memory, let's say the earliest would be 3:00-ish or so.
- 7:26Most people it's four or five or six or seven.
- 7:33And then we, we learned these procedures.
- 7:38Procedural memory, you know, is pretty good at the things that
- 7:41you the tasks that you need to perform that that the body
- 7:47learns to do, like walking. When was the last time you
- 7:52actually had to think so much about walking?
- 7:57Injuries aside, you sprained your ankle and suddenly walking
- 8:03becomes something that you have to think about advantage.
- 8:05But if your, if your feet are in good shape, your legs are in
- 8:09good shape, your hips are in good shape, your balance is in
- 8:12good shape. Once you learn the process of
- 8:15walking, you can, you can just do it without thinking.
- 8:18That's the procedural memory doesn't have to engage the, the,
- 8:23the cognitive memory, the autobiographical.
- 8:28Do you remember learning to drive a car?
- 8:32If you did, two hands on the wheel, checking your mirrors,
- 8:40sort of sliding out into the road, everything had to be
- 8:45monitored. And once you learn to do it, of
- 8:47course, now you can drive without thinking about it, go
- 8:51from place to place, changing the radio, sipping your latte.
- 9:07But when we really break that down and begin to examine how
- 9:10that happens, I like to to talk about it in this procedure of
- 9:17forming conceptual reality, which is you have the capacity
- 9:21to send something the object that can be sensed when there's
- 9:25contact, consciousness of that sensing experience arise at this
- 9:29still before the self experience, just pure sensing.
- 9:34And then it's evaluated for urgency.
- 9:36There's a a whole quality of memory that's in the body that's
- 9:41in the muscles that precedes the the brain stem pushing the stuff
- 9:48along to be processed and then the ordering of urgent does it
- 9:58need immediate attention? Does it not matter if we ever
- 10:02get to it neutral? Is there time for a pleasant
- 10:06experience? And then that raw, unfixated,
- 10:16undefined, meaningless sensing experience is compared to the
- 10:21perceptual database that if there's an entry in the database
- 10:23that's close enough, a whole thread of meaning attaches to
- 10:27that sensing experience. And then it's fixated into
- 10:33conceptual reality, which has meaning to it as narrative to
- 10:42what also comes along with this is the intention for the
- 10:45response and then the action that we take in response, the
- 10:54intention. And then we gather the the
- 10:58results, the outcome of the action that we take.
- 11:03The self experience engages just as conceptual reality is
- 11:07unfolding. And it really is the witness
- 11:10that evaluates whether or not the the whole unconscious
- 11:13process, that whole procedure that just unfolded is good idea
- 11:19or not. And if it's not a good idea, you
- 11:22have that moment of intervention before the intention is
- 11:26translated into an action. And we would say in Buddhist
- 11:31thought that you, you create karmic threads that you may have
- 11:34to deal with for 1000 lifetimes, let's say.
- 11:42Or did you ever just catch yourself in the middle of a
- 11:45sentence that you knew that if you finished, it would be a
- 11:47disaster, and so you fudge it into some other thing.
- 11:51There's like this clumsy beginning of a sentence jammed
- 11:56into the end of another sentence.
- 12:00There's a politeness that we all engage around these kinds of
- 12:04constructions. We let it, we let it go.
- 12:22So part of this process of understanding the nature of
- 12:26everything to see clearly the human condition and what we're
- 12:30faced with is to begin to watch that process so that we can see
- 12:38the meaning that we're assigning to the present moment
- 12:41experience. We don't really live in what's
- 12:45happening and and we live in what it means to us and what it
- 12:52means sources that that combination of the
- 12:56autobiographical memory and the procedural memory.
- 13:03One way to tell the difference is you might think that somebody
- 13:08is not coming and you were not fulfilling an obligation that
- 13:16they made to you because of a tardiness or a way that they
- 13:23respond. That would be an evaluation of a
- 13:32cognitive evaluation of events or things that are being said
- 13:36that are unfolding. But then the body mind takes
- 13:39over with this habit of feeling rejected, this habit of feeling
- 13:43unworthy, this habit of despair that you'll always be alone,
- 13:50which is the procedural amplification of the
- 13:53interpretation of the present moment.
- 13:55So there is some value in pulling these things apart so
- 14:00that you can see when that sweeping energy of the
- 14:04procedural responses is beginning to activate so that
- 14:07you can circumvent it. We do tend to, when we create
- 14:14these conceptual realities, create these.
- 14:20Built into that intention and action is also the expectation
- 14:26of the outcome, which is the procedural part of making sense
- 14:31of things. One aspect that's also important
- 14:38to talk about is the imagination.
- 14:40The procedural database is only good if you have entries in the
- 14:47database that are applicable to the present moment situation.
- 14:52It's quite ordinary and those of us who really like novel
- 14:56experience tend to go for things where there isn't much track
- 15:01record associated with it, so it has a freshness to it.
- 15:06When there's no entries or a series of entries in the
- 15:10procedural database in order to understand and make meaning,
- 15:17then the imagination kicks in and begins to create new
- 15:23meanings. And one of the things that
- 15:24happens to people who face adversity in their early life is
- 15:30the imagination is pinched off. And so we don't have the
- 15:35capacity to imagines solutions or assign meaning to experiences
- 15:41in the present moment. It can produce a kind of
- 15:44helplessness, which is strongly associated with the
- 15:47preoccupation. But also that inhibition and
- 15:51restriction around the capacity to explore is strongly
- 15:55associated with preoccupied people.
- 15:59There is the the part of childhood where you really don't
- 16:04learn how to explore, and there's also the part of
- 16:08childhood where exploration was interfered with.
- 16:12So there's strong negative associations associated with the
- 16:18the project of exploration. Then, because those can be quite
- 16:22painful, we begin to pinch off the imagination around how to
- 16:28explore as a way of reducing the pain of life.
- 16:35What we don't maybe understand is that the meaningfulness of
- 16:39life really comes from that capacity to explore, and we
- 16:41really need it to feel engaged and alive.
- 16:49And if we don't have it, what comes instead is a kind of
- 16:54despair at the difficulties of things.
- 17:03So one of the reasons why I am such a proponent of meditation
- 17:07is because it really does work mainly in the perceptual
- 17:12database. And you can change the way that
- 17:15the database responds to the the current experiences of the
- 17:22present moment so that you create different meanings.
- 17:27And you can work at it to change the expectations of the way
- 17:32things will turn out. And when you change those
- 17:37things, you create these realities that are starkly
- 17:41different from the ones that are habitual.
- 17:45Based on that early conditioning, one of the things
- 17:50that happens is you make up a, you make up your mind.
- 17:54Let's say that as a phrase, you from conditioning anticipate,
- 18:00often rightly, what the outcome of certain gestures in your
- 18:05family system might be. And so you begin to inhibit the
- 18:10the expression of those because the anticipated outcome is
- 18:15unpleasant and and you are avoiding it really.
- 18:25But as you move outside of the family system into the world, if
- 18:27you don't notice actually that you're creating these afflictive
- 18:33expectations of what could happen and the restrictions that
- 18:37are involved in that, you restrict your exploration, your
- 18:42involvement in the present moment based on those condition
- 18:49responses from the past and reinforce the experience around
- 18:59your expectation. A kind of self fulfilling
- 19:03activity. When we use meditation to create
- 19:09these different entries in that perceptual database, when the
- 19:14body mind goes to the perceptual database to see if there's
- 19:17something close enough to it that we could make meaning out
- 19:21of it, there's very well reinforced these beliefs of what
- 19:29what can happen. And when you use meditation, you
- 19:33put these little filaments of alternatives in there.
- 19:38And then if you use those to create the experience of
- 19:41reality, of course you have an actual experience, not something
- 19:45that's purely visualized or purely from the process of
- 19:49meditation then creates. It's just listening to my dog
- 19:58chewing something, something he can chew.
- 20:09You create these little filaments and if you use them as
- 20:13references for creating the meaning in the present moment,
- 20:16you then generate an actual experience which is also
- 20:18remembered and so. The the process of building up
- 20:22or changing the perceptual database happens through these
- 20:29tiny experiences of meditation. But over time, as you use them
- 20:34more and more to create the reality that you respond to, the
- 20:38more robust that they they become because they're based now
- 20:44on actual experiences, not just on the visualization aspect.
- 20:52The most successful series of of meditation practices around
- 20:57really adapting the perceptual database is the ideal parent for
- 21:04your protocol. But we do also need to attend to
- 21:09developing mentalizing and emotional regulation so that we
- 21:15can track things fast enough to notice when we're in a
- 21:20beneficial response and in an afflictive response.
- 21:24So that we can stop the afflictive responses faster and
- 21:30faster and and maneuver the body mind response into the
- 21:35beneficial responses. Because the the pure sensing
- 21:44experience does not contain an intrinsic meaning, We are very
- 21:53dependent on this process of assigning meaning to the present
- 21:57moment experience. And what you'll begin to notice
- 22:01if you do this is that the the way that you can make reality is
- 22:06extremely plastic. You can make it in all sorts of
- 22:10different ways. In fact, you can create an
- 22:12experience of present moment reality, mentalize around it,
- 22:18see clearly that it's not a good version of reality, drop it and
- 22:21reimagine the present moment experience immediately.
- 22:28And it takes on as it is transformed into conceptual
- 22:33reality, these very convincing elements to it.
- 22:38You know, you, you can walk around in the world and think
- 22:42it's solid and and that your perception of it is actually
- 22:51what's happening. This would be a a low
- 22:53mentalizing response, but can you track fast enough the
- 23:00thinking process that you understand what it is that you
- 23:04took in to create that string of mind moments that you're
- 23:08assigning meaning to? Can you create the meaning and
- 23:15then examine the meeting and validate that it is close enough
- 23:20to the to the sensing material that you took in that it would
- 23:24be reasonable to make that meeting?
- 23:26Or can you recognize when that actually didn't happen and
- 23:31reflect and and re evaluate what's actually happening so
- 23:35that by the time you hit the process of intention and action,
- 23:40you're actually in a pretty good evaluation of what's going on,
- 23:46your understanding, the meaning, and you're actually able to then
- 23:50engage in a process of communicating those experiences
- 23:54to someone else. In in the Theravada Buddhist
- 24:00motto that I mainly teach in, in the Sati Pattana Suta, in the
- 24:07refrain, it says mindfulness of inside, mindfulness of outside,
- 24:13mindfulness of inside and outside.
- 24:16And what we're really talking about is mindfulness of inside,
- 24:20the, the experiences that we have of ourselves moment by
- 24:24moment. Mindfulness of outside is the
- 24:27experience of other people's self and world.
- 24:31And the Buddhist frame self is you and the world is all of the
- 24:35other people. That's what we're really talking
- 24:37about, mindfulness of inside, mindfulness of outside,
- 24:41mindfulness of inside and outside, which is describing
- 24:45this process of communication between people.
- 24:50So if you look at Christian. But I've never, I guess I've
- 24:56never read the Sutos. Maybe I should.
- 24:58Can you unpack the the mindfulness of inside and
- 25:02outside piece? Because like maybe I'm a little
- 25:05in my head about this, but I think of like if, if there's an
- 25:10outside, I only experience it through my inside's interaction
- 25:14with the outside. So like the inside's always kind
- 25:17of included in that. That's my silly gloss.
- 25:22So can you expect like what that actually is in the in the SUTA?
- 25:33We really do exist in this relationship between the
- 25:39capacity to sense things and the meaning that we assigned to
- 25:43them. Some sensations are within the
- 25:47body and some sensations are outside of the body.
- 25:51That one makes sense. Some sensations are outside the
- 25:57body. Well, the source of the
- 25:59sensation could be internal, or the source of the sensation
- 26:03could be external. We're really limited in terms of
- 26:08the way that we know things. As I like to say, the spectrum
- 26:18of sound is vast and we can hear a tiny sliver of the spectrum of
- 26:22light is vast. We experience a tiny sliver of
- 26:25it. The spectrum of temperature is
- 26:28vast. We can survive in a tiny sliver
- 26:31of it. And so we have a, a way of
- 26:38taking in and understanding the world.
- 26:40And because we're mainly in relationship to humans at a
- 26:43level where we can understand the experience of other people,
- 26:48they can describe to us the experience of other things that
- 26:52makes sense to us. We can assume that all things
- 26:55are like that, but you may have seen on the Internet depictions
- 27:01of what a bees sees, or a dragonfly sees.
- 27:05Or you could be talking to your dog expecting a reasonable
- 27:10response from your inquiries in your language that you use and
- 27:18not necessarily be able to understand the way in which they
- 27:21communicate. So we can get very
- 27:24claustrophobic in in our perception of what's happening.
- 27:33But if I use the frame of an adult level of mentalizing, you
- 27:39understand within yourself the way that you're understanding,
- 27:45the way that you're decoding the experience of the present
- 27:51moment. You understand the meanings that
- 27:53you've assigned to the experience of the present moment
- 27:57and you understand what you would like to express about that
- 28:01experience to someone else. You know, that process of
- 28:07understanding what it is and then making an expression of it
- 28:13and seeing that our expression is received and and people
- 28:19respond to it. It starts in infancy.
- 28:21I mean, it's that mechanism of authentically expressing
- 28:26ourselves to someone and they're responding to it so that we have
- 28:36the experience of having an effect on the the world, on
- 28:42other people. This can get quite bashed up.
- 28:50And for a lot of people it is quite bashed up.
- 28:53And so they don't really track these processes particularly.
- 28:59But at an adult level of mentalizing where you really are
- 29:02capable of exchanging meaning with other people.
- 29:08That first piece is really understanding your experience
- 29:12and why you've arrived at your interpretation of what's
- 29:15happening. Is that making sense?
- 29:18The second piece is how do I express that to the person I
- 29:24want to express it to so that they understand what I mean?
- 29:30Because everybody's conditioned differently and everybody's
- 29:34meaning is slightly different based on the conditioning that
- 29:38that they experienced. When you get to know other
- 29:42people, what you begin to understand about them is that
- 29:46their point of view and your point of view are different
- 29:49because they're based their meanings are based on their
- 29:53conditioning and your meanings are based on your conditioning.
- 29:57And the better you know somebody, the more capable you
- 30:00are of transliterating the your authentic expression into
- 30:06something that they will understand what you mean.
- 30:10And then you make the expression and then you track how that
- 30:14expression lands. You want to make sure that
- 30:17they're actually getting what you're communicating, which
- 30:19means you have to inquire what their response is.
- 30:26And then in to complete that process, you take in their
- 30:32response and hopefully they're communicating it to you in a way
- 30:36that you really understand what their meaning is.
- 30:38And there may be some exchange about that, but let's say you're
- 30:43good at it with each other and you're able to express yourself
- 30:48so that you're understood and they're able to express
- 30:51themselves so that they're understood.
- 30:55Then the fourth piece is you modify your understanding of
- 31:01what's happening between you based on those exchanges.
- 31:06So that would be what I would call mindfulness of insight,
- 31:10mindfulness of outside, and mindfulness of inside and
- 31:13outside. That makes sense.
- 31:18We really do know how we're doing and how we're being
- 31:22perceived and where we're at from those reflections of other
- 31:27people. And So what we also want to do
- 31:32is put ourselves in a position where we have a robust group of
- 31:37people around us who will feedback to us that vital
- 31:41information of how we're actually doing and not find
- 31:46ourselves in a situation where we're actually being manipulated
- 31:50because the reflections back are not accurate.
- 31:55So maybe you can let me know if this is in in any way a good way
- 32:01to put it. Maybe mindfulness of inside is
- 32:03like the interaction of subjectivity with itself.
- 32:09Mindfulness of outside is the interaction of subjectivity with
- 32:12objects outside of itself. Then mindfulness of inside and
- 32:17outside is interaction between subjectivities, yes.
- 32:23OK. The more accurate it is, the
- 32:26closer you are to actually what's happening and the more
- 32:29skewed they are, the less you really understand what's
- 32:32happening. And when you look at it in an
- 32:35attachment frame, security produces this kind of reliable
- 32:40exchange and insecure and disorganization negatively
- 32:45effects that pretty dramatically.
- 32:48But because of the way that say, for instance, dismissing people
- 32:53navigate the emotionality of living through suppression, they
- 32:58don't find a lot of of means of evaluating whether the
- 33:03information they gather from outside is useful to them or
- 33:07not. So they tend to operate on
- 33:09internal working models so that they they take in what's there
- 33:14and they express themselves, but they're not engaged so much in
- 33:18the response of the other person.
- 33:22They're engaged mainly in in evaluating whether or not they
- 33:27get what they want from the situation.
- 33:29And if they don't, they tend to modify their understanding of
- 33:35what's happening and try something else.
- 33:38But it isn't based on the the complex feedback.
- 33:44It's based more on whether they get it or they don't.
- 33:49With preoccupied people, they're also not in that full exchange,
- 33:55but really just monitoring whether they're getting what
- 33:57they want. But they don't really evaluate
- 34:02and maneuver the responses so much as just try a slightly
- 34:09different approach. And that the hectoring strategy
- 34:13that they often use is meant to just break down the resistance
- 34:20to get them. It's much less managed in that
- 34:26way. The disorganized people really
- 34:28have a hard time expressing themselves because it's such a
- 34:32frightening experience for them. So it's they can easily go
- 34:38either into freeze or into just doing without really that make
- 34:51any sense. So using ideal parent figure as
- 34:58a as a as a, an example of how meditation practice can really
- 35:04affect the procedural databases that we go into these
- 35:10visualizations and we call up the meanings that are in the
- 35:18perceptual database, the procedural database.
- 35:22And then we activate the richness of them and the meaning
- 35:26of that. And then we layer in around that
- 35:29alternatives to that kind of historical understanding.
- 35:37And the more we layer around these alternative versions, more
- 35:42secure versions of possibility to respond, the body mind, when
- 35:48it goes through that cycle of creating conceptual reality can
- 35:52pull from one of these slivers, these filaments of possibility,
- 36:00and then create a reality from that rather than using the
- 36:03habitual ways of, of defining things.
- 36:06And what do you see in that moment of contrast when you
- 36:10create a, a, a reality of from the experience of the present
- 36:16moment, which is not defined by the, the conditioned response is
- 36:24your capacities may be quite different than.
- 36:28So that there's insight into the capacities that you have that
- 36:33you may have unintentionally over the course of a lifetime
- 36:39undermine because you didn't expect to be able to have the
- 36:43kinds of things that you wanted from that early conditioning
- 36:47response. And so that you're acting
- 36:50differently and the world is responding to it in a very
- 36:53different way because you've created these realities.
- 36:57And then you have these deep insights into the, to the nature
- 37:01of the human condition, which is really in this understanding of
- 37:07enlightenment that we talk about in, in, in Buddhist practice,
- 37:12which is you're creating these experiences of, of reality and
- 37:18that they're dependent on the way that you assign meaning.
- 37:25And then you can begin to change the way in which you assign
- 37:28meaning, which opens up really a pathway to seeing each moment,
- 37:35even the ordinary ones, constantly the ordinary ones
- 37:41with this deep sense of sacredness that arises when you
- 37:44really penetrate into that place of this one wild and precious
- 37:53life that you're in. Leaving out the metaphysical
- 37:57framework for a moment and just being, the experience of this,
- 38:01this life, and then seeing in that process the preciousness of
- 38:06things. And suddenly this idea of
- 38:09mindfulness of inside and mindfulness of outside.
- 38:13Mindfulness of inside and outside takes on a preciousness
- 38:16and sacredness that that may have been missing before.
- 38:22There's this capacity for openness, moving in a place of
- 38:31vulnerability at the end. Also understanding who's that,
- 38:35who's who's reasonable to do that with and who isn't.
- 38:42So that's why I like it. You start with the attachment
- 38:45stuff and you work through that. You, you develop an
- 38:49understanding of the, the way in which the cognitive mind is
- 38:55useful in the way that the procedural mind is useful.
- 39:00I'm not identifying too strongly with either and not relying on
- 39:04one over the other, but doing the things that are necessary to
- 39:08create a balance between them. That all making sense.
- 39:14That meta pasa practice that I, I, I like to promote on the, the
- 39:22heart side, the loving kindness side.
- 39:24They're really developing the capacity for positive
- 39:28experience. Positive experience, like
- 39:31negative experience creates an emotional response.
- 39:34And if you find that positive experience is dysregulating the
- 39:41way that negative experience can be dysregulating, you may find
- 39:45that you're restricting the the vehicles for really intensely
- 39:49positive experience because the dysregulation that comes from it
- 39:53is too much. And so developing these
- 39:55capacities for really intense positive experience that isn't
- 40:02then dysregulating Christian. Do you think that to a certain
- 40:09extent everyone kind of has this, that they need to expand
- 40:12their window of tolerance for positive experiences?
- 40:14Or is it that they got specific, like there was something in the
- 40:20way that their caregivers reacted to their positive
- 40:23expressions that kind of shut those down?
- 40:25Or like why? Why is it that that would
- 40:27become? It doesn't seem intuitive to me,
- 40:30even though I understand that it's.
- 40:32I understand that it's true, but it doesn't seem intuitive to me
- 40:34that positive experiences would dysregulate people.
- 40:39Well, I think that if we take the positive negative division
- 40:43of any kind of strong emotional response to something that's
- 40:47happening will fall within the window of tolerance or exceed
- 40:50the window of tolerance. And then your family system will
- 40:54have strategies for regulating that kind of intensity.
- 40:58The better those strategies are, the more resilient you'll become
- 41:02in terms of being able to manage those kinds of experiences and
- 41:06maybe maybe even expand the capacity for the intensity.
- 41:14And the the positive system and the negative system are two
- 41:17different systems and we are biased in this human body that
- 41:20we live in toward the managing the negative experience.
- 41:24So it's, it's quite ordinary for people to not develop a strong
- 41:31enough capacity for the positive side of things.
- 41:35If you grow up then in a secure household that that would be
- 41:39true even though the conditions were better.
- 41:45And then if you grow in up in insecure, disorganized
- 41:49households where there's a lot of adversity, the focus is not
- 41:54so much on developing the positive capacities.
- 41:59And because they're two different systems, you have to
- 42:01work on both of them. Often in the Theravada
- 42:07communities that I've been involved in, the main focus was
- 42:11on insight practice. And I know for half the time I
- 42:15studied with Shenzhen, he was convinced that if you just did
- 42:19the insight side, that would lead to enlightenment, that
- 42:23would relieve the need for an intentional development of the
- 42:27positive side. But I don't think that that
- 42:31actually panned out. And the the, the balance, if you
- 42:38look at it, are you in good balance between the positive and
- 42:44negative side or are you lopsided at some?
- 42:48If you're lopsided toward the negative side, you should just
- 42:51do enough of the hard practices that you rebalance it.
- 42:55Or I would even recommend that you move yourself into a
- 43:00lopsided position where you have a great capacity for positive
- 43:05experience. And the litmus test of that is
- 43:10when something goes wrong and you listen to the mind respond
- 43:14to it, Is it responding in a kind and loving way that's
- 43:18actually helpful, actually useful for you responding?
- 43:23Or do you go into a kind of negative dive?
- 43:27And if you do go into a negative dive, then you should at least
- 43:31be spending half of your practice on developing the
- 43:34capacity for positivity. You can stay in balance and also
- 43:41consistently respond in a in a positive way to what the world
- 43:47presents, which is, you know, big, scary, unpredictable.
- 43:57How can you stand on the groundless ground and be
- 44:01responsive? One way to do that is to create
- 44:05over and over these realities that are mainly on the positive
- 44:11side of things. Makes sense, Christian.
- 44:17So this might be kind of 1/2 formulated question, but if if
- 44:24you're either on the positive or maybe on the negative side, if
- 44:28you're having a negative experience and you have expanded
- 44:32your window of tolerance, then that, does that mean that you're
- 44:38just able to kind of without mediation through some maybe
- 44:43masking emotion or thing that you do, you're just taking that
- 44:47in sort of directly or you're feeling the emotion directly?
- 44:51Or are you actually in the moment like using a strategy
- 44:56that kind of tamps down the emotion for you?
- 45:01Does that make sense the way that I'm asking that?
- 45:05If you stay within the window of tolerance, you don't need to
- 45:09mask or evacuate from the present moment.
- 45:13And so the intention action can be informed around the
- 45:16conditions of the present moment and you can attend skillfully to
- 45:20the stressor of the present moment.
- 45:24Whereas if you get swept up into some kind of self generated
- 45:28emotional regulation response, you could lose awareness of the
- 45:32present moment. And and then the responses that
- 45:36you make to what's happening are going to be related to the self
- 45:41generated emotional response rather than to the conditions of
- 45:45the present moment. What might be skillful to change
- 45:49the conditions of the present moment?
- 45:52OK. That's really where you want to
- 45:57see clearly. You want to be able to mentalize
- 45:59clearly what's, but that's what's happening so that you are
- 46:03able to stay in the present moment and take action that's
- 46:08related to the present moment rather than taking actions that
- 46:12are related to the constructions that you make to regulate the
- 46:16experience. That's dysregulating.
- 46:23So why don't we stop talking and do a little meditation practice,
- 46:28right? Let go of the meditation.
- 46:31So in July, we have a meditation and addiction level two class
- 46:37starting. It's going to be Monday, Monday,
- 46:38Monday, Wednesday and Fridays from 6:00 to 7:00 PM Pacific
- 46:43Time. I will do a didactic on Monday,
- 46:46a meditation instruction on Wednesday, and a process group
- 46:50on Fridays and we'll go over the the four modules that we talked
- 46:55about in our meditation based attachment focused relapse
- 47:01prevention program. The 1st is Craving and urging,
- 47:05which is really about understanding emotional
- 47:08regulation and how that's conditioned stress, anger and
- 47:12depression. Understanding how using thought
- 47:18based regulating strategies, particularly if they produce
- 47:22intense negative emotions tends to create a cycling depression
- 47:27that is a a main conduit for relapse to get out of the
- 47:32depression. We have persistent negative
- 47:35emotions, which is really beginning to address the
- 47:38somaticized emotional experience that often produces a lot of
- 47:43negative affect. And then the 4th one is
- 47:48difficult interpersonal relationships, which is really
- 47:51about the attachment conditioning that leads to
- 47:56addiction, mainly around adopting avoidance strategies
- 48:00either in an organized way or disorganized way.
- 48:05In August, we're going to start a level two class on Tuesday
- 48:09afternoons. The mentoring section of that
- 48:13class is already full, but there are some places open for just
- 48:19taking the classes. And then in September, we're
- 48:23starting a A level 2 meditation and attachment, which is going
- 48:28to be on Friday mornings. And that's mainly for the people
- 48:34who are on the East Coast or in Europe, a better timing for
- 48:38that. There's places both in the
- 48:41mentoring side and just in the class side for that.
- 48:45I'm also going to do some half day workshops on exploration.
- 48:52So we really take a deeper dive into the nature of exploration,
- 48:57understanding the difference between primary exploration and
- 49:00secondary exploration. And then I'm going to talk about
- 49:05in the second one, the development of the creative
- 49:11person versus the blocked person.
- 49:15So a lot of times conditioning, adverse conditioning prevents us
- 49:20from this spontaneous, authentic experience of ourselves from
- 49:26the, the creative aspects of life, both in the spiritual
- 49:30side, but also in, in the manifestation of primary
- 49:35exploration where you really do need to have that freely flowing
- 49:40creative experience. And so we, we look at the ways
- 49:45that exploration can be impacted around that.
- 49:47So that, and I'm going to use my exploration in photography to
- 49:55describe that process of, of that creative exploration.
- 50:03You don't have to be an artist or interested in making art.
- 50:07That creative energy really illuminates all aspects of life
- 50:14and including the, the, the pursuit of spiritual insights.
- 50:19So I think it's an important thing and I think that that's
- 50:24pretty much everything that's coming up in the next half a
- 50:27year. Take a look at it.
- 50:32Ioffer the this teaching freely, but I do hope that if you can
- 50:37support it, you'll support it. There's a donation button on the
- 50:45website. Any amount is appreciated.
- 50:48Thank you for your practice. I hope to see you soon on the
- 50:51path I know.