Latest / Educating All Learners Alliance / Learner-Centered Education | A Conversation with Alin Bennet of Education Reimagined
Transcript
- 0:00Hello,
- 0:00everyone.
- 0:00My name is Alan Bennett.
- 0:01I'm Vice President of Practice and Field Advancement and education reimagined.
- 0:05We are a catalytic organization with a mission of ensuring that learner centered education is available to all Children in the United States.
- 0:13Previous to that,
- 0:14I was with a small state public district in Rhode Island called the med school in Providence,
- 0:20Rhode Island.
- 0:20And I was a teacher or principal and a district lead there for,
- 0:23for about 15 years.
- 0:25So like talk to you a little bit today about education reimagines work in the learner centered field.
- 0:30But first start off a little bit with our,
- 0:32with our origin story.
- 0:33Back in 2014,
- 0:35education reimagined in cooperation with an organization called Convergence.
- 0:39Gathered 28 diverse stakeholders.
- 0:41These stakeholders represented fields like higher education,
- 0:44workforce development,
- 0:45youth development PK 12 education,
- 0:48both in the conventional sector,
- 0:50the reform sector and the transform sector.
- 0:52And these folks took a year long journey to really dive into this question.
- 0:56If you were going to recreate the education system,
- 1:00really letting go of the current legacy system.
- 1:03And if you're gonna start a new,
- 1:04with new possibility,
- 1:05what would you envision and they came up with this learner centered vision after that year long journey.
- 1:10And within that learner centered vision,
- 1:12there are a set of assumptions that we really hold that set us apart from the conventional dominant current mode of education in,
- 1:20in the country.
- 1:21And it really changes how one sees learners learning and the purpose of education.
- 1:27And it's a really a distinct field that we are trying to expand and calibrate and collaborate with over the past uh eight years or so of our organization's existence.
- 1:37And so let me dive into some of those five assumptions.
- 1:40And so,
- 1:41um the very first assumption,
- 1:42uh which makes it distinct from the uh conventional system is that the work of education is learning and not the delivery of education.
- 1:50And that education is a natural process and no one has to be coerced or forced into the process if it's done well.
- 1:56And so that's the first assumption.
- 1:57The second assumption is that education is done by and with the learner and not to and for the learner.
- 2:03And in that way,
- 2:05the learner sector education,
- 2:06the adult roles really shift more of a facilitator and a person who knows the child really well and can support them no matter their uh various strengths needs and lived circumstances.
- 2:16Their third assumption is that all learners are unique,
- 2:19wondrous and curious and that they shouldn't be compared to some mythical average learner that that doesn't exist that diversity and that difference has to be applied to all Children no matter their race,
- 2:30no matter their lived experience,
- 2:32their neurodiversity,
- 2:33physio,
- 2:33diversity,
- 2:34gender,
- 2:35sexual orientation,
- 2:36any of those things has to be applied to all Children.
- 2:39And we mean each and every child.
- 2:41The fourth assumption is that learning happens when a learner's purpose,
- 2:45interests and curiosities are embraced.
- 2:47And that is really the centerpiece of their learning.
- 2:49And it's often the conventional desire to put kids into uh fit kids into a box and bring them to a common destination and sifting and sorting them along the way that causes some of the issues that we see as disengagement,
- 3:01you know,
- 3:01behavior issues and problems in the classroom.
- 3:05And then finally,
- 3:05the fifth assumption and the overarching assumption is that the purpose of education is for every learner to discover who they are their unique gifts and how they can contribute those gifts meaningfully into the world in a life that is thriving and meaningful to them.
- 3:20Within those five assumptions of learner centered education,
- 3:23it is really a world view.
- 3:25It is not based on a model or a design structure or anything like that.
- 3:30It is really how you see learners learning and the purpose of education.
- 3:33And so we see this expressed all over the country over our 10 years of discovery.
- 3:38So it looks different at big picture learning learner center of education looks different.
- 3:41At Montessori learner centered education looks different in acting academies,
- 3:45for example.
- 3:46So it's really not about a model,
- 3:47it's about a world view of how you see Children in learning.
- 3:51That being noted,
- 3:52we have seen five common design elements within learner centered environments that really distinguishes them either even further from conventional learning environments.
- 4:01And so I'll go over those five elements.
- 4:03Now,
- 4:03the first one is that uh these environments cultivate learner agency.
- 4:07And when we say learner agency,
- 4:08we mean that the there are structures in place for learners to to increasingly develop ownership over their learning journey based on their developmental readiness to take that agency on and that their learning is purposeful and meaningful to them.
- 4:21The second is that these environments ensure that the learning is socially embedded and that they really take the stance that education is fundamentally a relational endeavor and that these learners build their socially embedded capacities with their peers,
- 4:35with other adults,
- 4:36with the entire community.
- 4:37And they do so in a way to ensure that learners can bring their entire cells into any space that they go to and they can be 100% their authentic cells in the room leaving nothing at the door.
- 4:47And then,
- 4:47so that's what we mean by the socially embedded element.
- 4:49The next element is that they make learning personalized,
- 4:52relevant and contextualized.
- 4:54And this is often a co-opted term or a term that means different things to many different people.
- 4:58So when we say personalized,
- 4:59we do not mean personalized in that learners have limited choice on how they engage or that they can move so in their own sort of time and pace.
- 5:07It is really that personalized,
- 5:08meaning that the starting point is the learner interest,
- 5:11their passions and their desires and where they want to go in the world.
- 5:14And that is the starting point for them.
- 5:16And then it is also a match for their needs and strengths as learners.
- 5:20And so when you combine those two things,
- 5:22the learning automatically becomes relevant and contextualized to that learner in a little bit more powerful way.
- 5:27The fourth element is that they make their learning environments open walled,
- 5:31meaning that they really acknowledge that learning happens everywhere and anywhere at any time.
- 5:36And not only that,
- 5:37but they also ensure that those learning experiences are credentialed.
- 5:40So it's not something extra you do because there's something special about the hours of 9 to 3 or an assignment because it's directed by a teacher.
- 5:47They understand that learning experiences happen all over the place and that they work hard to make sure that they are credentials and recognized as powerful learning experiences.
- 5:55And then the last design element that we have seen commonly in learner centered environments is that they make learning competency based and by competency based,
- 6:03which is another term that means different things in different fields and our distinctions for competency based.
- 6:09It really means that a learner can show what they know and what they can do in a way that is a match for their strengths,
- 6:15needs and desires in the future.
- 6:17And that is really a match to them.
- 6:19And it is not a way to sort in students using common standardized tests that put them into,
- 6:25into certain buckets as learners.
- 6:27And so within those five elements and within those five assumptions,
- 6:32you know,
- 6:32over the past eight years,
- 6:34we've really acknowledged the presence of diversity,
- 6:36inclusion and equity within those distinctions.
- 6:39Because if you really honor that every learner is curious,
- 6:42wondrous and unique,
- 6:44then that you will do your best to make sure that the learning environment is,
- 6:47is diverse.
- 6:48If you really want an environment to be socially embedded,
- 6:50you have to have a strong inclusive lens to do that.
- 6:54And if you really want to support every learner to understand who they are,
- 6:58what they can contribute to the world and then they're in their passions that you're going to serve them in a way that best serves them,
- 7:03which is much different than the distinctions for equity and diversity and inclusion that happens in the conventional sector.
- 7:11You know,
- 7:11our organization really believes that it sits in two different beliefs around what diversity is in the conventional system.
- 7:17Diversity is really simply the presence of a diversity and learner centered environments.
- 7:22We see that they not only have the presence of diversity,
- 7:25but they see that diversity as essential for having strong powerful learning experiences because that we can all share and learn from each other who have different lived experiences.
- 7:33Uh Inclusion in a conventional setting is really about just sending an invitation.
- 7:38Really,
- 7:38we like to say like an invitation to the party and in the learner centered environment,
- 7:42it is create a condition where people don't need an invitation.
- 7:46They simply feel welcome to join into a community of,
- 7:49of human beings.
- 7:50And they can be their full 100% authentic selves when in their space and and lastly,
- 7:55in equity,
- 7:56equity in the conventional system is really about getting kids to the same place,
- 8:00using pretty similar mechanisms to get them to that place.
- 8:03And in the learner centered environment,
- 8:05it is really equity is about giving every single learner what they need to thrive and be successful in their PK 12 experience.
- 8:12And after,
- 8:13at the same time,
- 8:14compensating for the historical inequities that exist in the world and making sure that those are corrected so that they can thrive in the world.
- 8:22And so particularly since the pandemic,
- 8:25uh education we imagined has really been focused on expanding and elevating single site learner centered environments.
- 8:33So identifying learner centered environments across the country,
- 8:37connecting them with other learner centered environments because they're often siloed in,
- 8:40in small pockets across the country.
- 8:42So letting them know that there is a community and a movement going on and doing our best to what they're up to.
- 8:48And then furthering learner centered practice.
- 8:50But something that came across in some of the data and the research we were doing was during the pandemic was how much the community really,
- 8:58really picked up where the PK 12 system couldn't fulfill its role.
- 9:02And so we saw youth development sector really stepped up.
- 9:05We saw so social service sectors really step up and fill some of those academic and social emotional gaps that came in And they were doing so in a really ecosystem way and really just connecting folks from the school out into the community um based on necessity.
- 9:20So we did observe that happening,
- 9:22but we saw it happening at different levels.
- 9:24And what we realized and what we witnessed was that it was more often families and learners that had access and means both financially and just so with social capital,
- 9:35they were the ones successfully navigating these emerging ecosystems of learning.
- 9:39And so,
- 9:40while education,
- 9:41we imagine acknowledged that a lot of the most advanced learner centered environments were already operating ecosystem that it could not be delivered equitably because it is not accessible to all learners across the country.
- 9:53And so that's when we really pivoted to this idea of ecosystems of learning.
- 9:58And so this is really acknowledging the wisdom and the resources that live in the community and allowing learners and learning environments to access an entire suite of learning experiences for,
- 10:10for their learners.
- 10:11And doing so in a way where they don't have to make programmatic choices.
- 10:15When they are delivering that.
- 10:17In this ecosystem design,
- 10:18we saw different aspects of ecosystems emerging.
- 10:21So the first ecosystem we acknowledge was the one that I just mentioned where there are community resources centered on learning and then there's the school and they're completely siloed and separated and it's up to the family and the child to navigate that ecosystem.
- 10:35The second version we saw and you can often think of cities of learning like Chicago City of Learning or Dallas City of Learning where the out of school time partners and the community partners are really well connected,
- 10:46but they're still not connected to school.
- 10:48None of those learning experiences are credentialed by the school.
- 10:51And it's often seen as a an addition or an extra curricular for the child and it's really in,
- 10:57in service of the PK 12 or to fill in the gaps that the PK 12 system cannot sort of contend.
- 11:04And we would also say that is often inequitable because that's up to a family ability to sometimes mostly pay for those uh opportunities and to access those opportunities.
- 11:15Uh The third sort of ecosystem we see is a really you can compare it to the community school model.
- 11:21So think like Harlem children's zone,
- 11:23for example,
- 11:24where there are very intentional systems in place to connect the out of school uh players and have them do push in services into the school.
- 11:33So sometimes you'll see community partners come and do social services,
- 11:36they'll come in and do extra curricular,
- 11:38they'll come and do a wide variety of things inside of the school.
- 11:43Um And you know,
- 11:44varied in varied environments,
- 11:47different environments,
- 11:48sometimes that learning is credentialed,
- 11:49sometimes it's not.
- 11:50But again,
- 11:50it is really in service of the school and based on families to access that school itself.
- 11:57And just like some of the learner centered environments,
- 12:00we find that there's not enough uh and not enough to meet the demand for families.
- 12:05Uh The next type of ecosystem we see is the one that we see in the most current uh advanced learner centered environments.
- 12:14And in,
- 12:15in,
- 12:15in that sort of model of framework,
- 12:18in this fourth framework for ecosystems,
- 12:20there is a single site that really uh allows kids to access learning at any time anywhere,
- 12:26credentials that learning and really has strong partnerships with families,
- 12:30with the community and vice versa.
- 12:31The community has strong partnerships with the school.
- 12:33I happen to be,
- 12:35you know,
- 12:35I happened to teach and be a principal at one of these types of ecosystems.
- 12:39The Met school in Providence,
- 12:40Rhode Island where,
- 12:41you know,
- 12:41as long as long as it met certain criteria of rigor and reflection,
- 12:46any experience that a learner had was able to be credentialed and counted towards their high school experience.
- 12:52And so this is the most advanced,
- 12:54this is the most ecosystem.
- 12:56And at the same time,
- 12:58there's a certain level of fragility with these single sites and that those type of ecosystems.
- 13:03Because if the centralized hub of this hub and spoke model of ecosystem shuts down that ecosystem immediately collapses.
- 13:10And the learners can have that experience.
- 13:12And we've seen that way too often in the learner centered movements,
- 13:14these bright spots of learner centered will,
- 13:17will shine for a few years and then they'll,
- 13:18they'll shut down and that's from various constraints that come come within the the conventional system.
- 13:24And it's really based on this idea that learning centers environments are playing by a different,
- 13:29playing a different game,
- 13:30but trying to use the same rules to play that game.
- 13:33And so it is a level of fragility with these hub and spoke model of the ecosystem.
- 13:38And so it's this last vision of ecosystems where you have numerous sites all within a community,
- 13:45all sharing services together,
- 13:47all sharing the community's assets and resources and really allowing families to navigate a rich array and variety of resources across the community.
- 13:55And doing so in a way that builds social capital that exposes them to new experiences and has the community.
- 14:02See the value of kids and kids see the value of community,
- 14:06which is really important right now is we battle brain,
- 14:09brain and flight from community.
- 14:12I can think of myself.
- 14:12The first thing I wanted to do when I got out of high school was leave my town.
- 14:16And so we're really trying to shift that paradigm where kids can see value in the community that they work in,
- 14:20contribute to it while they're still in school.
- 14:23And that the community can see the same in their young people that we don't send kids to school to prepare them to be contributors to society,
- 14:29that they're full whole individuals right now and that they can contribute to the world right now.
- 14:33And so that's what education we imagine has been up to over the past year.
- 14:37And so our current work is identifying these powerful ecosystems of learning,
- 14:40elevating these ecosystems and then trying to do what we do with learner centered environments and really create a community of practice where they can learn from each other across district boundaries,
- 14:51state boundaries and community boundaries.
- 14:53Yeah,
- 14:54I think our sort of partnership and our connection with ELA is very natural because if all Children are going to be served,
- 15:02it is almost impossible to do it within the confines of the current dominant system.
- 15:09Uh because there's choices that have to be made when serving every kid,
- 15:12the the system was not designed to differentiate,
- 15:15to provide individualized supports or curriculum for learners.
- 15:19It was really designed in a different paradigm for learning where the thought was very industrial,
- 15:26where you can have kids have similar tracks,
- 15:28have similar experiences.
- 15:30And if there was any difference,
- 15:31you just track them and put them on a different assembly line.
- 15:33And so that is what the current system is designed to do.
- 15:36So if they try to fix that,
- 15:37it's like trying to put,
- 15:39you know,
- 15:39wings on a model T Ford and telling it to go to the moon that it's just,
- 15:43it's impossible for it to happen because it's not what it was designed to do.
- 15:46So it's no fault.
- 15:46It's not that the conventional system loves kids any less.
- 15:49It's just,
- 15:49they're trying to operate within a system that is doing the work.
- 15:52So if you are going to educate all Children,
- 15:54it has to be in a learner centered paradigm of education and not in a industrial conventional model.