Latest / The Human Factor: Exploring the Intersection of Humanity, Technology, and Transformation / Episode 021| Season 2| When Generations Collide - The Generational Fault Lines of Organizational Transformation
Transcript
- 0:05Think about the last major change initiative your
- 0:07organization launched. Now think about who embraced it
- 0:13and who resisted. Was there a pattern?
- 0:17Did the people who had been with the organization the longest
- 0:21push back the hardest? Did the newest employees adopt
- 0:27first? Did the people in the middle?
- 0:30Those middle managers seem to check out entirely.
- 0:35Most leaders explain these differences through personality
- 0:39or politics. She's always so resistant to
- 0:43change. He's so difficult.
- 0:46That group is never on board. But, well, what if the pattern
- 0:53isn't about individual or group personality at all?
- 0:57What if the way people respond to change in transformation is
- 1:02simply shaped by something far more foundational than
- 1:06individual or group temperament, Something that's rooted in when
- 1:11they entered the workforce, what world they grew up in, and what
- 1:17implicit promises they believe their organization made to them?
- 1:23That's what we're exploring today, and my guest has spent
- 1:28more than 20 years studying exactly this question.
- 1:33I'm Kevin Novak, CEO of 2040, digital professor at the
- 1:37University of Maryland, and author of the book The Truth
- 1:41about Transformation, Leading in the Age of AI, Uncertainty, and
- 1:47Human Complexity, along with the Ideas and Innovations.
- 1:50Weekly newsletter. Welcome to the Human Factor
- 1:54podcast, the show that explores the intersection of humanity,
- 1:58technology, and transformation, along with the psychology behind
- 2:04transformation success. This is Season 2, Episode 8, and
- 2:10if you've been following this season, we've been building a
- 2:14diagnostic framework for understanding why change in
- 2:17transformation fails at the very human level.
- 2:23Episode 1 explored the identity crisis the transformation
- 2:27triggers. Episode 2 with my buddy
- 2:30Elizabeth Stewart examined emotional contagion.
- 2:35Episode 3 unpacked the structural traps of middle
- 2:39management. Episode 4 looked at the
- 2:43algorithmic mirrors. Episode 5 with James Elliott
- 2:48examined the organization's immune system.
- 2:52Episode 6 explored structural silence, the system that teaches
- 2:57people not to speak. In last episode, Episode 7, we
- 3:03explored the psychological contract, the unwritten
- 3:07promises, the change in transformation always violates.
- 3:13Today, we're adding a dimension that every previous episode
- 3:19touched, but none directly addressed the generational fault
- 3:24lines inside organizational change and transformation.
- 3:29If you've been with us since Season 1, you may remember
- 3:33Episode 2, The Gen. Z Factor.
- 3:37I explored how younger generations are rewiring
- 3:41workplace psychology and why traditional management
- 3:45approaches are failing with nearly 40% of the workforce.
- 3:51That episode, it opened the door.
- 3:54Today, we're walking through that door.
- 3:57Every concept we've explored this season?
- 4:00Identity crisis, emotional contagion, structural traps, the
- 4:05immune system, silence, the psychological contract, all of
- 4:10these play out differently depending on when someone
- 4:14entered the workforce and what formative experiences shape
- 4:19their expectations of the institution's authority and,
- 4:23and, well, the work itself. And the research on this is
- 4:27substantial. Karl Manheim's foundational work
- 4:31on generational consciousness, which was published originally
- 4:35in 1928 and is still cited across social science
- 4:39disciplines, establish that people who shape formative
- 4:43experiences during their impressional years develop a
- 4:47distinct orientation towards the world.
- 4:51They just don't have different preferences.
- 4:54They hold different assumptions about authority, about risk,
- 4:58about loyalty and institutional trust.
- 5:03And those assumptions are exactly what determines how
- 5:06someone experiences organizational change and
- 5:09transformation. To explore today's topic, I'm
- 5:12joined by Ryan Vet. Ryan is a generational futurist.
- 5:17He is AUSA today best selling author of Cracking the
- 5:21Millennial Code. He's a serial entrepreneur who
- 5:25started his first business at the age of 14.
- 5:28He currently serves as CEO of Boone, an on demand healthcare
- 5:32staffing platform. He holds an MBA from Purdue and
- 5:36certifications from Harvard Business School and Cornell, and
- 5:40he has worked with organizations ranging from startups to Fortune
- 5:44500 companies like Samsung and Warner Brothers.
- 5:48He's also LED for AI powered startups and also sits on Elon
- 5:54University's Advisory Board for the Doherty Entrepreneurship
- 5:57Center, which means he works directly with the generation
- 6:02that is about to enter the workforce.
- 6:05Ryan, welcome to the Human Factor podcast.
- 6:09Thanks so much for having me, Kevin.
- 6:10Ryan, before we get into the research frameworks, I want to
- 6:14ground this in your experience. You describe yourself as a
- 6:18generational futurist, which is specific and very deliberate
- 6:23framing. What does that mean to you, and
- 6:28how did your own experience as a serial entrepreneur, starting at
- 6:32the age of 14 and building across multiple industries,
- 6:36shape how you think about the way different generations
- 6:40experience change inside organizations?
- 6:43Thanks for that question, Kevin. I think it's a little bit
- 6:46humorous how how I've gotten to each step of the journey.
- 6:49But now where I am today, hindsight's 2020 and see how it
- 6:52all connects. I was getting on stage speaking
- 6:54about AI. Of course I have from human
- 6:56hesitation to AI acceleration. And what does that mean for us?
- 6:59I'm not talking about tools and the latest greatest thing
- 7:01because dirty new tools will start by the time I'm done and
- 7:04half of them will have shut down.
- 7:05So it's really more what does this mean for society and
- 7:07culture and for us as human beings and what's going on?
- 7:10So as I'm about to get up, they describe me as a futurist and
- 7:14I'd I'd heard the title, but I was like, that's, that's
- 7:16interesting. I've, I've never, you know,
- 7:18ascribe that title to myself. And so I, I talked to the
- 7:22meeting professional afterwards who, who had put this all
- 7:24together and wrote my bio. And you never know when you get
- 7:27on stage, I've done over 1000 live presentations.
- 7:29You get some interesting intros, some are completely fabricated,
- 7:32some are not. And so I started unpacking this
- 7:34and she was like, well, if you look at all of your work,
- 7:36everything you've done is leading to the future.
- 7:39You, you're always asking questions about the future.
- 7:41So I was like, OK, I'll take it. And that as I processed it, I'm
- 7:44not economist. I, I do look at the economy,
- 7:46obviously, but that's not what I'm focusing on.
- 7:48I'm really looking at generations.
- 7:50And that did start when I was a teenager.
- 7:52My first legally incorporate incorporated company was 14.
- 7:55And so I've been very entrepreneurial and had some
- 7:58successes and, and plenty of failures too.
- 8:00That's that's what makes a good entrepreneur.
- 8:02And as I I navigated each one of those, especially starting as a
- 8:05teenager and millennial managing Gen.
- 8:07X and Boomers at the time, there was a lot of conflict.
- 8:10And I chalked up a lot of that to my age, which absolutely a 14
- 8:14year old manager of people older than themselves is always going
- 8:18to create conflict on so many levels just beyond generations.
- 8:21But then Fast forward several years to 2009, real estate
- 8:26company asked me to come speak to why millennials weren't
- 8:28buying houses, which at the time was a flawed question because
- 8:32most millennials weren't old enough to buy houses.
- 8:35But I answered it because at that point, Twitter was
- 8:37thriving. And I had an early Twitter
- 8:39account with a lot of followers at the time.
- 8:41And I think I have just as many followers now because around
- 8:43that time I also got off the platform.
- 8:45But but I started to look at the world through how humans
- 8:50interact with one another, where we've been as culture and
- 8:52society and where we're going in into the future.
- 8:55And so from a generational perspective though, because your
- 8:58experiences and my experiences, my kids experiences are all very
- 9:01different because of where we were raised, when we were raised
- 9:04and what was going on in the world and society.
- 9:06So that's kind of how it all packages together.
- 9:09So how do you on the futurist side, just an additional
- 9:13question, how do you process conceptualizing what that that
- 9:20next phase is going to be? Yeah, I know we'll get into it
- 9:25even more more deeply, but history repeats itself.
- 9:27There's nothing new under the sun.
- 9:29And if you look at any society, any civilization, whether it's
- 9:33recent history or you're going back to the Byzantine Empire,
- 9:36there are certain trends that you can see that replicate time
- 9:39and time again. And then you go and look at the
- 9:40human being. Humans are are fairly
- 9:42predictable creatures. I love Danarelli's book
- 9:46Predictably Rational, and it's just a fantastic book because at
- 9:51the end of the day, we're all searching for meaning and
- 9:53purpose and we want significance over success, but we often look
- 9:56in the wrong places. So we build something and then
- 9:58it comes tumbling down. It's it's a cycle over and over
- 10:01again. So as we look to the future, a
- 10:02lot of what I do is, is not, I'm not a technological futurist,
- 10:06even though I've been involved in AI startups for almost 2
- 10:09decades now. That's not been the point of
- 10:11saying, hey, we're trying to make humans better, we're trying
- 10:15to make society better. We're trying to remove friction,
- 10:17which ultimately backfires. But what are those patterns that
- 10:20we can see? And how can we get ahead of that
- 10:22as leaders, as we're looking into the future, to bring our
- 10:24teams, bring our cultures, bring our societies along so that we
- 10:28don't lose the humanness that makes leadership great?
- 10:30Ryan, what you're describing connects directly to one of the
- 10:33most important and unappreciated concepts in organizational
- 10:37psychology. Karl Mannheim argued that
- 10:40generational identity isn't just about age.
- 10:44It's about shared formative experiences that create what he
- 10:48called a generational consciousness, a distinct lens
- 10:53through which an entire cohort interprets the world.
- 10:57The implications for change and transformation are, of course,
- 11:01significant. Homers entered the workforce
- 11:04during an era of institutional expansion and upward mobility.
- 11:09Gen. X came of age during economic
- 11:11disruption, downsizing, and the collapse of the lifetime
- 11:16employment model. Millennials, well, they were
- 11:19shaped by the digital revolution and the 2008 financial crisis in
- 11:25Gen. Z.
- 11:26As I explored in Season 1, Episode 2, the Gen.
- 11:30Z factor has never known a world without smartphones, social
- 11:34media, and institutional skepticism.
- 11:37That episode examined how Gen. Z is fundamentally rewiring
- 11:42workplace psychology and what we're seeing now in those
- 11:46rewired expectations that don't exist in isolation.
- 11:51They collide with the expectations of every other
- 11:56generation in the building. Each of these cohorts carries
- 12:00fundamentally different assumptions about what
- 12:03organizations owe them, what loyalty means, how decisions
- 12:08should be made, and how change should be communicated.
- 12:14When a change or transformation initiative enters an
- 12:17organization, it doesn't land on homogeneous workforce, it lands
- 12:23on a multi generational landscape where each group
- 12:27filters that change through their own generational
- 12:31consciousness. And this is where leaders get it
- 12:35wrong. They assume resistance is
- 12:38resistance, when in reality a boomer's resistance often comes
- 12:45from a different place entirely than a Gen.
- 12:48Z employee's disengagement. So in your work with
- 12:51organizations and writing Cracking the Millennial Code,
- 12:56how have you seen this? How have you seen this all play
- 12:58out when a major change initiative hits a multi
- 13:02generational team? And so you've been in a variety
- 13:07of different types of organizations, you've started
- 13:09your own company, you now run an on demand healthcare service.
- 13:14So what are the distinct patterns you see in how each
- 13:17generation responds? I think one of the things that
- 13:21we have to zoom out is, is actually as almost contrarian as
- 13:26this is to my own work, we have to step away and and look past
- 13:30generations for just a minute because I think we have almost
- 13:33pigeonholed ourselves into this conversation about generations.
- 13:35When change management comes comes down the line.
- 13:39The reality is, if you look at just basic change management
- 13:41theory, there's always going to be detractors.
- 13:44There's always going to be people that are, are thriving in
- 13:47change that want the change. There's going to be people that
- 13:49think they want and then once it happens, are become a detractor
- 13:52and and that happens regardless of generation.
- 13:54So I think that's the first thing that we have to realize.
- 13:56Whether you have all Gen. X working in your workplace or
- 13:59you got all the generations from silent down to Gen.
- 14:02Z in your workplace, there's going to be people on every side
- 14:05of the the conversation. So that's part of the
- 14:07conversation. But then the second is we have
- 14:09to realize that every single generations lived experience
- 14:12their their cohort that they grew up with and the experiences
- 14:15that they have in the moments in which they were raised are going
- 14:18to shape how they perceive authority, how they perceive
- 14:20trust, how they perceive communication.
- 14:22And those are all common elements when you're looking at
- 14:24change management initiatives in an organization or corporation
- 14:28that if you don't have buy in and trust doesn't mean everyone
- 14:31has to agree with you, but you have to have the trust that
- 14:33you're making the best decision for the organization.
- 14:35That's going to look very different between a baby boomer
- 14:37and then skip 2 generations and looking at a Gen.
- 14:39ZA pretty much the bookends in the workforce right now.
- 14:42We do have a couple silent generation.
- 14:43It's in there. But when you look at that,
- 14:46that's a pretty radical difference in how they perceive
- 14:48trust. Baby boomers generally trust
- 14:50institutions. They trust titles, education,
- 14:53experience. Gen.
- 14:55Z is very much against that as a whole.
- 14:57They trust authenticity. They they want to know that you
- 15:00care about them as a person. They don't want any fluff.
- 15:02They don't want corporate jargon.
- 15:04They don't want any of that. It's a totally different
- 15:07perception of trust. And so when that's communicated,
- 15:10you can erode trust almost instantly if you communicate it
- 15:12based on one generations perceived idea of what is stable
- 15:15and what is not. So do you see leaders who are
- 15:19assumed to understanding that? There's definitely some leaders
- 15:25that that understand that. And I think honestly, sometimes
- 15:28we clutter the conversation too much by talking about
- 15:31generations or, or even talking about these differences because
- 15:34at the end of the day, you're still human beings leading other
- 15:36human beings. And if you look at the recent
- 15:38body of work and in recent being, you know, the last two to
- 15:40three decades, we've shifted from these management style
- 15:44books to leadership style books, back to management style books
- 15:47and now managing the different generations.
- 15:49And I think there's actually, and even with some of my earlier
- 15:52work, even with the book you mentioned earlier, I think there
- 15:56it's flawed logic a little bit. The the management techniques in
- 16:00there are absolutely rock solid. I stand behind them.
- 16:02The myths that we cracked about the millennials, absolutely rock
- 16:05solid. But the whole premise is saying,
- 16:07hey, because they are millennials at that point or
- 16:09because they are Gen. Z, they're going to have these
- 16:11characteristics and you have to treat them a certain way.
- 16:14Well, the book was written when millennials were still
- 16:16graduating college. Now they're all in the workforce
- 16:19and many are well past that management roles and having
- 16:21kids. And in the book, parts of it
- 16:23apply to Gen. Z, but part of it we're looking
- 16:25at the age of the individual. And a lot of these snapshots,
- 16:30whether it's articles or books, get stuck looking at a
- 16:33generation at a certain moment in time that is not indicative
- 16:37of their entire life cycle. So Ryan, a question on
- 16:45recognizing there's, there's commonality and change
- 16:48management, right? And to your point, trust, trust
- 16:53is earned differently across the generations based on the values
- 16:56of how people have come up and and what they retain.
- 17:02And with the research that you're currently doing, do you
- 17:05see any significant differences with Generation Alpha?
- 17:12So Gen. Alpha, they're turning 13 this
- 17:15year at the time of this recording.
- 17:16And so we've got a limited subset of data and even less on
- 17:21on Gen. Beta being born starting 2026.
- 17:23So you've got these two younger generations.
- 17:25But what you can't start to do, and this is where kind of the
- 17:27futurist hat comes in, is you can look at the parenting
- 17:30decisions in the cultural implications of what has
- 17:32happened at two other generations at around the same
- 17:36age. So one of the frameworks that I
- 17:37use is called the generational prism.
- 17:39So if you're, you're listening, it's kind of a triangle and on
- 17:42one, one arm you've got the age and the other arm you've got the
- 17:45moment. And then a prism refracts light.
- 17:48So when you shine light through it, the refraction of that is
- 17:51usually, you know, some beautiful color on the table or
- 17:53whatever, you're refracting the light.
- 17:55That's where the label comes. And so you got this age moment
- 17:58label framework that I use so often when looking at
- 18:00generations. And I, I think we've for the
- 18:03longest backwards. We start with the label saying
- 18:05millennials are lazy, Gen. Z are anxious.
- 18:10While there might be some merit to stereotypes, because
- 18:13stereotypes do, whether or not we like it, usually cover, have
- 18:16some grain of truth. That's why they stick.
- 18:19We, we start at the wrong spot. And so I, I always say, Hey,
- 18:23let's, let's take their age, so 13 for, for Gen. alpha right
- 18:26now. And let's rewind a generation.
- 18:27So when Gen. Z was 13 and yes, some last year
- 18:29were 13. But if you go to the middle of
- 18:31the cohort, we're, we're looking about 15 years ago.
- 18:33What was happening, you know, 10 to 15 years ago when millennials
- 18:36were 15, you're looking almost 20 to 30 years ago when Jenna
- 18:41and you start rewinding saying what was going on in the 90s and
- 18:44early 2000, what was going on in the late 20 teens?
- 18:47And you, you start looking at the age that they were and then
- 18:51the moment in history that they were.
- 18:53And then you can start to see what's sticking.
- 18:55So I think, you know, Gen. Gen.
- 18:57Z and Gen. Alpha are actually both, and we
- 19:01use the term digital natives, but they're actually less
- 19:04accepting of change because of that.
- 19:06While millennials grew up with technology and, and they saw
- 19:10everything from no phones to smartphones and in their growing
- 19:13up years, a rapid curve on, on technological adoption from no
- 19:17Internet to, you know, social media and Wi-Fi.
- 19:21All of those things happen within the millennials every
- 19:23single time they logged into thefacebook.com Facebook.
- 19:26Before. They dropped the definite
- 19:28article there. Every single time it was a
- 19:31different thing. They had timelines and they had
- 19:32walls and they had pokes and they had, and so they're used to
- 19:37change. But by the time Gen.
- 19:39Z started getting onto these platforms, and arguably they got
- 19:41on too early, that's a deeper conversation.
- 19:44But when they start getting on these platforms, there were no
- 19:46more changes. So they actually were already in
- 19:50the social media era. Gen.
- 19:51Alpha's gonna have the same thing with AI.
- 19:54You know, all of a sudden from 2022 to today, we saw generative
- 19:58AI just take the world by storm. And every single time that now
- 20:01could generate images, now could generate video that was shocking
- 20:04to Gen. Z and millennials, Gen.
- 20:06X and Boomers. Gen.
- 20:08Alpha is going to have lived with that.
- 20:09So I think we're going to see similar trends with the
- 20:12implications that social media the lived for the entire life of
- 20:16Gen. Z had on Gen.
- 20:17Z. We're going to see the same
- 20:18thing. With Gen.
- 20:19Alpha, and if we're not careful, we're going to see the
- 20:22implications of cognitive erosion and just taking normal
- 20:26daily brain practices that you and I have done and we're going
- 20:29to see them offload that onto a machine and that's going to be
- 20:32really dangerous if we're not careful.
- 20:34Yeah, I think what's interesting just to digress, because I see
- 20:38this in the class that I teach is the higher levels of anxiety
- 20:43because of all that digital interaction.
- 20:45And that higher level of anxiety in that interaction permeates
- 20:53across decision making. It permeates across any other
- 20:56physical interaction. And one would not have predicted
- 21:01that that would be an outcome so pervasive around Gen.
- 21:05Z. And, and there are a few
- 21:07examples I use in the class about about alpha.
- 21:11Were there indications that may get even worse.
- 21:14So to your example about AI and in essence, being so immersed in
- 21:19it from the get go, it will be interesting to see what
- 21:22cognitive or just general mental health issues may result from
- 21:28that. So sorry to digress, it's a
- 21:31patient area of mine that I write a lot about.
- 21:36No, I think it's good and I think the implications are, are
- 21:38bigger than generative AI, especially with Gen. alpha.
- 21:41We, we think about the LLMS like ChatGPT, claw Gemini and and all
- 21:45of that. But there there's the component
- 21:47that we're not thinking about. A child can hop on and talk to.
- 21:52I'm not going to say it out loud, otherwise everyone's phone
- 21:54will glow. But you're your Apple friend,
- 21:56right? And they can ask what the
- 21:58weather is today. They can ask how long is it
- 22:01going to take to get to the grocery store at six years old?
- 22:04And there's implications to that.
- 22:06While it's convenient, while it's beneficial and helpful,
- 22:10they can pick up and they can talk to their parents.
- 22:13Robot phone character again, won't say it, but they can say
- 22:17hey, so and so. Call whomever.
- 22:20No longer are they scrolling. They're not learning to read for
- 22:23the names or scroll through a phone, books or a Rolodex.
- 22:26They'll never know what that is. They'll never have to memorize
- 22:28those phone numbers. And we've removed these friction
- 22:31points that I don't think we even think about that this
- 22:34generation has never seen before.
- 22:36Unlocking the door with voice, opening blinds and shades with
- 22:40voice, the refrigerator telling you what, when you need to get
- 22:43milk. Those little things are, are
- 22:45great innovations. And I'm, you know, a living
- 22:47paradox because I, I love and have worked towards those
- 22:49innovations, but also there's massive implications to that,
- 22:53that I don't think we're thinking about the little
- 22:54things. We get so sidetracked by these
- 22:56LLMS and, and things that there's a lot of other things
- 22:59that Gen. Alpha in particular is already
- 23:01experiencing as part of their lived life that they're already
- 23:05not doing those. They've already removed so many
- 23:06friction points that I think are beneficial to formation.
- 23:09Yeah. And not to further digress, but
- 23:11I mean that really comes down to is there a necessity for any
- 23:15knowledge retention when it's so easy to access in the moment?
- 23:20And so then that begets a lessening of critical thinking
- 23:24skills that they may need. And other situations.
- 23:29What Ryan is describing connects to something we explore in
- 23:32depth. Last episode, Denise Russo's
- 23:36research on psychological contracts established that every
- 23:40employment relationship contains an unwritten set of mutual
- 23:44expectations that goes far beyond the offer letter.
- 23:49But here's what most applications of that research
- 23:51miss. Those psychological contracts?
- 23:54Well, they're not universal. They are shaped by the
- 23:58generational context. A boomer psychological contract
- 24:02with the organization often centers on loyalty, reciprocity.
- 24:07I give you decades of commitment.
- 24:11You provide stability, upward mobility, and institutional
- 24:17respect. When change of transformation
- 24:20disrupts that contract, the response isn't just resistance.
- 24:24It's a sense of betrayal rooted in decades of perceived mutual
- 24:29obligation. A Gen.
- 24:31X employee psychological contract is often built on
- 24:34autonomy. I deliver results and you leave
- 24:38me alone to do my work my way. Transformation that centralizes
- 24:44decision making or introduces new oversight layers violates
- 24:50that contract in a way that can feel suffocating.
- 24:55A millennials contract frequently centers on purpose
- 24:58and development. I bring my whole self to work,
- 25:02and you provide meaningful work, growth opportunities and
- 25:06transparent leadership. Transformation that feels
- 25:10performative or disconnected from a clear purpose violates
- 25:15that expectation. And Gen.
- 25:18Z, the 40% of the workforce, has a psychological contract that
- 25:23many organizations aren't even equipped to understand yet.
- 25:28It's one built on flexibility, digital fluency, and
- 25:33institutional skepticism. They're not looking for a 30
- 25:36year career. They're looking for alignment
- 25:39and authenticity. I want to build on something
- 25:41from Ryan's own work that I think is one of the most
- 25:44important reframes and transformation thinking.
- 25:48Ryan's Catalyzing Change framework positions human
- 25:52resistance to change not as opposition to the change itself,
- 25:57but as a fear of loss. That distinction shifts the
- 26:01entire diagnostic question from why are people resisting to what
- 26:07do people believe they're about to lose?
- 26:10As you all know, I'm big on William Bridges, and his
- 26:14research on transitions makes a related and very critical
- 26:18distinction between change and transition.
- 26:21Change is the external event transition.
- 26:26It is the internal psychological process of letting go of the
- 26:31old, navigating the uncertainty of the neutral zone, and forming
- 26:36a new beginning. Most organizations manage to
- 26:41change, almost none manage the transition, and the transition
- 26:48is where people actually live during change and
- 26:51transformation. What makes this even more
- 26:54complex is that the losses people fear often generationally
- 27:00inflicted. A boomer facing an AI deployment
- 27:04may fear the loss of institutional expertise it took
- 27:08decades to build. A Gen.
- 27:11X manager may fear the loss of autonomy.
- 27:15Is new systems centralized decisions?
- 27:20Well, they may fear the loss of the growth trajectory they were
- 27:25promised, and a Gen. Z employee may fear the loss of
- 27:30flexibility as change in transformation creates new
- 27:34rigidity. The same change initiative or
- 27:37transformation 5 different fears of loss.
- 27:43And a leader who diagnosis all of them as resistance will
- 27:48usually craft a single response to the dresses.
- 27:51None of them. Ryan, when you worked with
- 27:55leaders on the catalyzing change concepts, one of the most common
- 27:59losses that each generation fears during transformation.
- 28:04And what do leaders consistently miss about the generational
- 28:08dimensions of that fear? Both excellent questions.
- 28:10I think the first one, what does each generation fear?
- 28:14I think you have to look at what has governed each generation for
- 28:18the most part. And for the sake of time and
- 28:20brevity, I'm going to generalize.
- 28:22And obviously it's much more complex than what I'm going to
- 28:25share. So for forgive the
- 28:27generalizations, but for the sake of conversation and time, I
- 28:29think they're they're generally helpful.
- 28:31So you've got baby boomers who believed in institutions,
- 28:34believed in stability, believed in climbing the corporate
- 28:37ladder, quantity over quality. If they were the first and last
- 28:40out, that meant they were going to get the raise, they were
- 28:42going to get the corner office. Gen.
- 28:44Z listening corner office used to be achievable.
- 28:46That used to be the thing that wasn't all desks and bullpens.
- 28:49So you know, that was that was the baby boomers mindset.
- 28:53And they are working longer than other generations.
- 28:56They're still trying to fill up that bank account.
- 28:58They're still trying to build wealth.
- 29:00All these things that that they sought to do from day one of
- 29:04their career change is scary to someone who believes an
- 29:08institution should be stable. They're, they're looking at all
- 29:11this technology. They've seen enough
- 29:12interruptions to know, OK, Internet didn't disrupt their
- 29:15jobs that much. It changed how they work, but
- 29:16they still had a job. But but they're, we're hesitant.
- 29:19Now. You look at Gen.
- 29:20X Gen. X has always been skeptical of
- 29:22institutions, mainly because their parents trusted them too
- 29:24much And you see it flip flop. And I, I talk about the
- 29:27generational pendulum and, and so Gen.
- 29:29X, they're hard workers though. So they're not going to be the
- 29:33first one in and last one out. They're not going to be the
- 29:36first one out, first one or last one in and first one out either.
- 29:39So they're, they're different than both boomers and
- 29:41millennials in that way. And kind of the barbell
- 29:43generation, like I say, they're they're a smaller generation
- 29:46that kind of are are being weighed down by the boomers and
- 29:49millennials on either side. We have more angst, supposedly.
- 29:52You do, you do. But it's good and I do, I do
- 29:55think. And there's actually data,
- 29:56plenty of data to back it up. Gen.
- 29:57X is one of the best workers in the workforce.
- 29:59They for so many reasons, but they're being on work life
- 30:01balance. They saw their parents to sell
- 30:04their souls to, to their jobs. And I say parents plural because
- 30:06generally it was 2 parents working and, and so Gen.
- 30:11X was like, I don't want to do that.
- 30:12And Gen. X, not millennials.
- 30:14Gen. X is who we have to thank for
- 30:15the idea of work life balance. That was their concept.
- 30:18They're still, if they haven't a project that they need to get
- 30:21done, they'll come in, they'll stay late, they'll get the
- 30:23project done, but they also want to protect to some extent,
- 30:26their, their family time and, and focus more on their family.
- 30:28That's where we get helicopter parents because they want to be
- 30:30more present for their kids than their parents were for them.
- 30:33So you Fast forward and you look at millennials, well,
- 30:36millennials actually are extremely productive
- 30:38individuals. And I think this is a big
- 30:40misnomer. And we've started to see as
- 30:43millennials of age and now, you know, the the youngest
- 30:45millennials are turning 30 next year.
- 30:48So we've seen the shift. But I think especially when
- 30:52millennials first got in the workforce, they seem to be
- 30:55disrespectful, lazy and titled, not trusting authority.
- 30:59They were skeptical of anything, especially if it involved pen
- 31:01and paper, and they cared about the planet.
- 31:04So save this e-mail or save the paper.
- 31:07Don't print this e-mail, all of that.
- 31:11We've seen some of that fall away.
- 31:12But what's interesting is millennials output was just so
- 31:15much greater than any other generation because they were so
- 31:18efficient and proficient using technology.
- 31:21And so they could execute tasks at a faster pace, which
- 31:24automatically created trust issues with the previous
- 31:26generations in the workforce of millennials.
- 31:29And millennials would never offer to stay late.
- 31:31And again, generalization never offered to stay late for that
- 31:34project, Wouldn't offer to come in there.
- 31:35If you're paying them to come in at 8:30 or 9:00, they're going
- 31:38to come in at 8:30 or 9:00. And if you stop paying them at
- 31:414:00, they're going to leave at 4:00.
- 31:43You know, not four O 1. And that was always the joke.
- 31:45And there, there's a lot of truth to that.
- 31:49There is, there is, yes, and the research is indicative yes.
- 31:52Yeah. And so it's, you know, that's a
- 31:54minute ago. I said stereotypes stick because
- 31:57there is some grain of truth. And we have seen millennials as
- 31:59they care more about their work and they get to this management
- 32:02level that they are exhibiting more traits of Gen.
- 32:06X and Boomers where they will, when necessary, stay late, but
- 32:10they're not going to do it unnecessarily.
- 32:12And so they've they've got a different kind of trust issue.
- 32:15Theirs is all about transparency.
- 32:16They want information because they've always had information.
- 32:19They started with Ask Geez, then went to Bing, Yahoo, AOL and
- 32:23Google and now LLMS. And what's interesting is millennials are
- 32:27adapting generative AI faster than any other generation, in
- 32:30large part due to the fact that as they were growing up, the
- 32:33Facebook did become Facebook. Myspace was no longer existent,
- 32:37you know, or barely existent. You didn't want to hang out
- 32:40there at least. So you had all these.
- 32:42Yeah, you had all of these different changes.
- 32:45And so transparency was the big word for for millennials.
- 32:49And then Fast forward to Gen. Z, they took transparency to the
- 32:51next level. They want authenticity, meaning
- 32:54I'm going to show up and I'm going to be my authentic self.
- 32:56And if I do not want to be here today, I'm going to wear it on
- 32:58my face. And you're going to know that I
- 32:59don't want to be here. And I'm going to let you know
- 33:01that I don't want to be here. And you better treat me the
- 33:03same. And I think that the biggest
- 33:05issue for trust that's just really alarming and really
- 33:08challenging for most leaders has this idea that Gen.
- 33:11Z believes over it's almost 3/4, just shy of 3/4 of Gen.
- 33:15Z members believe that their company and their boss should
- 33:18take a political stand on current social issues.
- 33:21That's extremely shocking and really frightening to a lot of
- 33:25leaders, especially older leaders that have been more
- 33:28reserved and have always been told that their politics stay at
- 33:32home. You know, they check their
- 33:33personal stuff at the door that that's become a, a, a tremendous
- 33:36issue. Which brings me to the answer to
- 33:39your second question is what do you do about that?
- 33:44How can you navigate those changes?
- 33:45Is it even possible to overcome that?
- 33:47And I think it goes back to something really, really simple.
- 33:50Somewhere along the line, we got sidetracked by looking at labels
- 33:53and by trying to overanalyze all of the data on generations that
- 33:58we forgot something really simple.
- 33:59As leaders, we need a clear vision and mission of where
- 34:02we're going. And when you have that extremely
- 34:04clear vision and mission, you can easily kind of stay out.
- 34:08And I say easily, it's not as easy as I wish it were, but you
- 34:11can stay out of some of the political conversations.
- 34:13You can stay out of some of the things and say, this is this is
- 34:16where we're going as an organization.
- 34:17These are our values. And you bought into this.
- 34:19And this is where we're marching forward together.
- 34:22And we don't have to answer those questions because it's not
- 34:24relevant to our mission. And, you know, not all Gen.
- 34:27Z is going to like that. But so often we've just lost
- 34:31sight of that because we keep trying to manage problems
- 34:33instead of lead people. An interesting element because
- 34:37we, we do this on the work with clients where we're focused on
- 34:41strategic planning. And to your point on the on the
- 34:45mission, right, we, we frame it as a shared purpose and trying
- 34:50to have them align and be articulate and not articulate
- 34:56simply to what the leadership believes that should be.
- 34:59But also as a commutative to the others across the workforce with
- 35:05the end aspiration that people do indeed get to rally behind
- 35:09that shared purpose. And not to dismiss the political
- 35:14statements right of taking a stand, but it does seek to give
- 35:23some purpose related to the organization the perhaps the
- 35:28younger generations can can better identify with.
- 35:32Exactly, exactly. And I think you use the word
- 35:36purpose and what's consistent across every generation and it
- 35:40manifests itself differently. But what's consistent is every
- 35:42single person wants purpose in their life.
- 35:44Every, everybody seeks meaning. And, and again, each generation
- 35:48has taken that differently. Boomers wanted meaning from
- 35:51their, their job titles, that they collected their degrees,
- 35:54that they collected things like that.
- 35:56Gen. X want a meaning by what their
- 35:57family life look like, what their personal and community
- 35:59life look like. Millennials wanted purpose to be
- 36:03transcendent. That's the first generation that
- 36:05that saw the world as effectively becoming 1.
- 36:09You could reach out to anyone in the world for almost nothing.
- 36:12Whereas before I remember I had aunts and uncles who lived
- 36:14overseas have to go get buy a calling card at Walmart.
- 36:17Dial in the forever long number from bondage and you would hope
- 36:20that they were available next to their phone.
- 36:21And if they weren't, you just wasted however much money trying
- 36:23to call them. And that's gone, which there's a
- 36:27lot of benefit to that and that's exciting.
- 36:29But millennials saw the world with all the issues in our
- 36:32world. And so they became concerned
- 36:34global citizens, which I think it is, is valuable.
- 36:38And now what's interesting is we see Gen.
- 36:40Z going back and focusing on the self.
- 36:42There's a lot of talk right now, Gen.
- 36:43Z revival, are they going back to church?
- 36:46And the data actually says no, which contradicts a lot of
- 36:50headlines. But they are one of the most
- 36:52spiritual generations, meaning they're they're seeking some
- 36:55sort of transcendent identity beyond organized religion,
- 37:00whether that is things as more New Agey as ayahuasca retreats
- 37:05down in South America or whether that's practicing Eastern.
- 37:09We're seeing a lot of Eastern traditions and faith practices
- 37:13come back in as well as, and Gen.
- 37:15Z males in particular that do commit to an evangelical or
- 37:19Christian based religion are doubling down on it.
- 37:21Even though the number is the smallest it's ever been.
- 37:23Those that have chosen to to go into organized religion are, are
- 37:27going with full force. And the pattern across all of
- 37:30that, the fact that Gen. Z is one of the more spiritual
- 37:32generations as a whole is were really fascinating because it
- 37:36shows that they they want this sense of purpose and they
- 37:38thought they could get meaning from likes and instant
- 37:40gratification and comments and being connected to all their
- 37:43friends. And they figure that that's not
- 37:45it. So they're asking, there's got
- 37:46to be something more. What is that?
- 37:48So Ryan, earlier you talked about what may have been in
- 37:52place 15 years ago or so forth, when a generation was forming
- 37:55their values. So related to the spiritualism,
- 38:01do you see where, and this is related to some of the headlines
- 38:07out there. So Gen.
- 38:08Z believes the world is ending, right?
- 38:10The the climate is going to collapse.
- 38:13There is hesitation, documented hesitation both with millennials
- 38:17and Gen. Z's about having kids and the
- 38:20world those but those kids may actually not have.
- 38:25And and so do you see those initial values coming into a
- 38:32maturity related to that spiritualism or though those
- 38:36even just perspective? Yeah, I think there's a lot of
- 38:39things we could go deep with family dynamics and over the
- 38:43years, but in fact, I'm going to generalize real grossly here for
- 38:46the sake of time, but Boomers basically made divorce not
- 38:50taboo. Gen.
- 38:51X didn't like that. And so we saw divorce rates
- 38:53actually hold fairly steady but declined slightly.
- 38:55And millennials, we're seeing this huge drop off in divorce as
- 38:59a whole, but we're also seeing a much lower percentage of
- 39:02marriage because they have moved to cohabitation.
- 39:05And, and so they, they've changed this, this family
- 39:07dynamic. And a lot of that we can, we can
- 39:11trace, we can trace a lot of this.
- 39:14Some of it's the religious constructs of family dynamics or
- 39:16what a family looks like, of course, but there is underlying
- 39:20fear specifically of Gen. Z, some later born millennials
- 39:24was specifically of Gen. Z of I don't want to bring kids
- 39:27into this world. I don't want my kids to
- 39:28experience this. And I would argue while some of
- 39:31that is rhetoric and you know, we're just seeing a slow life,
- 39:35adoption of, of marriage and things like that, or even
- 39:38cohabitation or, or reproduction in younger generations.
- 39:41I, I think a lot of it is they just haven't seen healthy
- 39:45relationships modeled in any aspect.
- 39:48I'm not talking about romantic necessary, but even platonic.
- 39:51They, they haven't had those real life interactions.
- 39:55I liken it to going to the mall, Gen.
- 39:56X, You know, the mall was their their sanctuary, if you will,
- 40:00the arcades, the movie theaters. And it was just a place where,
- 40:03yeah, or Pac-Man, exactly where they could go and hang out.
- 40:06And millennials caught the tail end of that.
- 40:08But I often say when you're walking down the mall with your
- 40:12friends and you could smell the popcorn from the the cinema, you
- 40:15could smell Mrs. Fields and Auntie Anne's pretzels and
- 40:17cookies, You know, you could smell all of those things.
- 40:20You found a penny on the ground, you picked it up as a friend and
- 40:22you toss it into the the fountain.
- 40:24All those little things that you can't achieve in a relationship
- 40:27that's digital. You just can't you?
- 40:30You might be in constant communication and texting all
- 40:32those time, but those little interactions that round out a
- 40:35full human experience are, are largely lacking with these
- 40:38younger generation. So you look at Gen.
- 40:39Z in particular and the loneliness studies are
- 40:42unbelievable. The US Surgeon General in 2023
- 40:44said that loneliness is now one of the greatest health concerns
- 40:49in in our country. We exchanged what we thought
- 40:52connectivity was to enhance the human experience.
- 40:55We've actually removed the most important elements of the human
- 40:58experience from from interacting and communicating.
- 41:00And so I think a lot of that Gen.
- 41:02Z doesn't know how that translates into deeper
- 41:05relationships beyond surface level friendships, platonic or
- 41:08even romantic. And so I think you're starting
- 41:10to see some of that play out in society.
- 41:14Yeah, definitely. But you, I mean, you hit on so
- 41:16many great points I have. I have students who bring
- 41:20forward how anxious they are when they have a physical
- 41:23interview or they have to have a physical interaction beyond the
- 41:29headlines. I mean, I think we all see that
- 41:32or hear about it on a personal or professional level, which I
- 41:36think that element of relationship has impact into
- 41:42organizational setting and where in our generations, you know, we
- 41:49equated that to organizational politics or this was just the
- 41:53way work worked. And they're having so much issue
- 41:56with that and the they're not expecting that to be the case.
- 42:01But indeed, you know, it is. And then they're getting more
- 42:06and more anxious to actually navigate that kind of situation.
- 42:09We've diagnosed the problem. Generational identity shapes how
- 42:14people experience change of transformation.
- 42:18Psychological contracts vary by generation.
- 42:22Fears of loss are generationally inflicted.
- 42:26Most leaders treat a multi generational workforce as a
- 42:30monolith and wonder why their change of transformation.
- 42:34Stalls or outright. Fails.
- 42:36So what do we do about it? The research points in a clear
- 42:41direction. Organizations that successfully
- 42:44transform across generational lines do three things very
- 42:49differently. First, they segment their change
- 42:52communication in a manipulative way.
- 42:56But in the same way any effective communication adapts
- 43:00to its audience. The message to a tenured
- 43:03employee needs to honor the institutional knowledge that
- 43:07they carry. The message to a mid career
- 43:10professional needs to preserve their sense of autonomy.
- 43:15The message to a newer employee needs to connect the change to
- 43:19purpose and growth. Second, they create multiple on
- 43:23ramps for adoption. Not everyone processes change
- 43:27but the same pace or in the same way.
- 43:31Research on technology adoption curve shows the generational
- 43:34digital fluency creates asymmetric responses to
- 43:39technological disruption. Some people need to understand
- 43:43the why before they even engage. Others need to experiment with
- 43:47the tool before they believe in the strategy.
- 43:51Forcing a single adoption path is how you trigger the
- 43:54organization's immune system across every generation
- 43:58simultaneously. 3rd, and this connects to Ryan's work at
- 44:03Ealing University, they invest in intergenerational exchange.
- 44:08The organizations to transform best are the ones where
- 44:12generational differences become a strategic asset rather than a
- 44:17source of friction. Just sort of bring this a bit
- 44:21back. You've LED for AI powered
- 44:24startups across different industries.
- 44:26AI is, arguably, you mentioned this earlier, the most
- 44:29significant transformation pressure right now.
- 44:32And it carries a unique generational dimension because
- 44:35assumptions about technology, automation, and the nature of
- 44:39work itself change dramatically across age groups.
- 44:45So how are you seeing generational fault lines shape
- 44:48the way organizations adopt or resist AII?
- 44:52Think the first and most important thing to realize is
- 44:55which generations are leading the charge on AI and which are
- 45:00not. In studies time and time again
- 45:02are are showing millennials are leading the charge, which is
- 45:04really really fascinating. So let's look at some of the
- 45:06other generations in the workforce.
- 45:08Gen. X.
- 45:08Would you equate? That to being of the age to be
- 45:11more middle management at that point.
- 45:14Yes. And so I think that that's
- 45:15absolutely a part of the equation is the fact that
- 45:17they're in places where they can adopt it.
- 45:19But a lot of these studies are showing independent use too, so
- 45:22not company sanctioned if you will or or using it for for
- 45:25certain projects. So I think there's, I really
- 45:27think the biggest thing is if you look, and we talked about it
- 45:29a moment ago, this, this trend line that Jen, that millennials
- 45:33always were changing in technology.
- 45:36They started with, you know, a car phone to a Nokia phone that
- 45:41they could play snake on to a razor flip phone to now iPhone,
- 45:45you know, and, and just think about the massive change in
- 45:48technology in that short amount of time from having to plug in
- 45:52with your gateway, those, those cow checkered boxes.
- 45:55And you had a separate monitor that you had to buy that two
- 45:58people had to carry to a uniformed 1 computer like an
- 46:02iMac or emac and then finally a laptop like.
- 46:05So they've, they've never seen technology be the same.
- 46:09And so they're, they're early adopters.
- 46:10Naturally, they've been trained and conditioned to say, hey, new
- 46:13technology, it's not going to, it's not going to break us.
- 46:15Let's try it. So I think that's one of the
- 46:17things. And then you you brought up the
- 46:17other point of where they are in their career.
- 46:19What's interesting, if you look at whether it's the political
- 46:22landscape in Congress or even the White House or you look at
- 46:28companies, you see baby boomers and millennials as the primary
- 46:32leaders across these institutions.
- 46:34And yet Gen. X makes almost a third of the
- 46:36workforce right now. I'm not saying they're not in
- 46:38leadership roles, but disproportionately they're not.
- 46:41And the question is, why is Gen. X not in in those leadership
- 46:43roles? I think part of it's the way
- 46:45they're raised. Part of it's the stage of life.
- 46:47They're being pulled in tension. Their parents are old and aging
- 46:49and living longer than humans have ever lived.
- 46:50So there's a lot of elder care. And then you've got their kids
- 46:54that are in college or just having families and they're
- 46:57they're more concerned about being grandparents.
- 46:59And so part of that is the stage of life and where they found
- 47:01themselves. They're not so concerned about
- 47:04climbing the the corporate ladder.
- 47:07So when the with the adoption of AI, millennials know that
- 47:10they've got a they've got to be relevant and it's their moment
- 47:13in in their life cycle, their corporate life cycle to prove
- 47:15themselves and they're not afraid of technology.
- 47:17So it's kind of the perfect storm for them and Gen.
- 47:19Z, you're seeing mixed reviews. A lot of them are skeptical of
- 47:23AI and yet using AI and a lot of them are using it for their
- 47:27personal lives. I just saw even on Valentine's
- 47:31Day I wrote a piece on how about 1/3 of Gen.
- 47:34Z had admitted to being in a romantic relationship with
- 47:38technology. Just yesterday I saw a headline
- 47:40that we're up to three quarters 3/4 have engaged and doesn't
- 47:44mean that they're currently in a relationship, but they're
- 47:46defining it to be in a relationship with some sort of
- 47:49LLM or generative AI robot girlfriend or boyfriend.
- 47:53Really, really fascinating to look at that.
- 47:55So they distrust it for corporate use, and yet they're
- 47:58engaging it in their their personal use.
- 48:00And it's very much like social media.
- 48:01They think there's no business for social media in in the
- 48:04workplace, which makes boomers happy, right?
- 48:07Gen. Z doesn't like that mixing of
- 48:10work and and pleasure. But we're seeing the same
- 48:13resistance in AI in the workplace with Gen.
- 48:14Z because they're afraid, like anyone's been afraid that's
- 48:17going to take their jobs. Just like we thought when Gen.
- 48:19X was coming out. Oh, we're not going to have jobs
- 48:21because computers are are are the main thing.
- 48:23And before that it was XY and Z. You know, go back, rewind 5000
- 48:27years. The assembly line has gotten rid
- 48:29of jobs. And yes, it absolutely
- 48:31eliminates jobs. But technology has also
- 48:34increased more jobs because you need more people to make more
- 48:36efficient assembly lines and monitor the data on those
- 48:38assembly lines and build the factories that those assembly
- 48:40lines go in or fix computers or develop software for computers
- 48:44or work on this thing called the Internet.
- 48:46So yes, AI is absolutely going to eradicate some jobs, but it's
- 48:49also creating new job market. And we saw growth this past
- 48:52quarter in the job market amongst Gen.
- 48:54Z in particular, meaning that they're getting placed in jobs.
- 48:57So where we saw a bunch of corporations stop hiring those
- 49:01entry level roles. We're, we're seeing it already
- 49:04that rapidly. I wouldn't say swing back, it
- 49:06was nominal increase, but we're, we're we're seeing some trends
- 49:09positively. Yeah.
- 49:10And I think that's, there's a bit of reality, Chuck, that's
- 49:13happening and that companies, So with the millennials who are
- 49:19driving a lot of the implementation and use inside
- 49:23organizations at the middle management layer, I think
- 49:27there's the hype and the translation of the hype to
- 49:31reality, but it's more so on the applicability to the actual
- 49:35business problems trying to be solved.
- 49:38And so we've seen a few instances where CEO was using AI
- 49:45to make decisions, but then when the questions about that
- 49:50decision making came from others, that CEO could not
- 49:53explain what the rationale was for the decisions, what the
- 50:00information was based on, was it, was it valid information and
- 50:04so forth. So I think there's obviously
- 50:07that relates to hallucination, but that you're seeing some of
- 50:09that natural organic output come and then question.
- 50:15So there there is a rationalization so to speak on
- 50:20what companies and organizations believe is possible.
- 50:24And I think to your earlier point that that's just as simply
- 50:27a maturation of a technology as people adapt to it and see where
- 50:33the true value is. You sit on Elon University's
- 50:38Advisory Board and you work directly with the generation who
- 50:41is now 40% of the workforce. What are you seeing in that
- 50:45generations relationship to institutions and the authority
- 50:49that should shape how leaders think about building
- 50:51organizations capable of sustained change and
- 50:55transformation? I think there's a lot of.
- 50:57We're going to see a lot of disruption in the upcoming
- 51:00workforce. So even zooming out to kids not
- 51:03in in college and university yet, you've got Gen.
- 51:05A13 this year. They're going to be able to work
- 51:08within the next two to three years depending on their state,
- 51:11and they'll be in college within the next 5.
- 51:14I think you're already starting to see the trend.
- 51:16We've seen tremendous dips in college enrollment in the last
- 51:21several years, and there's a lot of reasons for that.
- 51:24Gen. Z staying at home longer, Gen.
- 51:25Z saying college is too expensive and they don't want to
- 51:28have the the debt burden that even their older siblings did or
- 51:32their parents did. And we're seeing this return to
- 51:36manual labor, more blue collar work, which I actually think is
- 51:40really good. That's what the American economy
- 51:42was built on, was Main Street business and manual work.
- 51:45I'm not saying that's the only thing that's going to build our
- 51:47economy. I'm not an economist, but I
- 51:50think there's some really positive trends that we're
- 51:53seeing in these younger generations.
- 51:55But that also means that that could be devastating for higher
- 51:58education institution. And I think one of the big
- 52:02trends that we're seeing, So baby boomers in particular,
- 52:05again, gross generalization, but statistically we're the first
- 52:07generation where both males and females could go and graduate
- 52:10from college generally. So that's where we started to
- 52:13see that trend. And it became even more
- 52:14prevalent with Gen. X and then by millennials, it
- 52:17was required if you wanted a job.
- 52:19Baby boomers in earlier born Gen.
- 52:22X are now parents of those applying to school and they're
- 52:25trying to say, you know, what was that debt worth?
- 52:27It was all that worth it? And I think by the time you get
- 52:29millennial parents with now having Gen. alpha and even Gen.
- 52:33beta kids, they're going to be pushing back against
- 52:36institutions and institutions better pull it together real
- 52:40quick and figure out what does the new 4 year education look
- 52:43like? Because so many people are going
- 52:44to freshman year of freshman, sophomore year of high school,
- 52:48and then junior and senior year of high school, they're
- 52:49splitting between the Community College and and high school
- 52:52credit. So by the time that they
- 52:53graduate high school, they're already, you know, a quarter or
- 52:56halfway into their four year education.
- 52:59And that's changing the landscape of the student that's
- 53:01attending. Used to have students that
- 53:04wanted to go, and I was one of them that wanted to go as far
- 53:06away from home as possible to get away from mom and dad and
- 53:08experience that four year education.
- 53:10Now you're seeing a students look more and more closely to
- 53:14home. I think the other thing that has
- 53:16always been the case, but is even becoming more the case is
- 53:20students are looking for universities that already
- 53:24support their ideas. And I I think there's a lot of
- 53:28danger in that it that that scares me.
- 53:31We know as statistically speaking, that that liberal arts
- 53:34four years education lean, lean far liberal and and lean far
- 53:37left as a whole. And and it's actually increasing
- 53:40more and more. But what used to be so amazing
- 53:42about a four year education, which a lot of schools have have
- 53:45lost this discourse is you could go with someone that was super
- 53:49right wing and super left wing and a university was a place
- 53:52where you were supposed to talk about those things on the quad
- 53:54and you could still be friends and have dinner.
- 53:56And now we're seeing almost this ideological sorting with
- 53:59universities. I'm going to go to a school that
- 54:01teaches conservative policy because that's what I believe
- 54:04in, or I'm going to go to a school that teaches more liberal
- 54:08left-leaning policy because that's what I believe in.
- 54:10And while I think that's absolutely OK to some extent, we
- 54:13naturally gravitate towards people that think like us.
- 54:16The beauty of a four year education, in my opinion, one of
- 54:19the beauties of it is, is that discourse is that experience.
- 54:22That rooming was someone that you don't agree with on
- 54:24anything, but you still room together and you get along and
- 54:26you figure out how to talk about the things in life that your
- 54:29lived experiences make you who you are and that makes you a
- 54:32well-rounded individual. So I see a lot of those things
- 54:35changing and I think, you know, Elon in particular, I'll brag on
- 54:40them, has been on the forefront of AI.
- 54:41They've had some great AI teams, but they're also so strict on
- 54:45how it's used. So while they have been cited
- 54:48early in research and a lot of research around AI and how
- 54:51higher edge should be using AI as out of their university in
- 54:53conjunction with others, it's not just them, but they're
- 54:55they're on these think tanks. They're also really promoting
- 54:58critical thinking. And that is that is ultimately
- 55:02what we need to do. Otherwise we're going to be
- 55:04George Orwell's in 1984. We're going to be, you know,
- 55:07have new speak and we're going to, you know, Disney's Wally
- 55:10even I think is a great example where we're, we're programmed by
- 55:13the machine. And I think the institutions
- 55:16that that still encourage those conversations will be so
- 55:19helpful. I'll give one, one personal
- 55:21example. We've got young kids at home and
- 55:23everyone's like, oh, are you teaching your kids how to use
- 55:25ChatGPT or Gemini or whatever you're using today?
- 55:28And I, I said I did and then I didn't.
- 55:31I let my son after he graduated before he started kindergarten,
- 55:35graduated preschool. That that in and of itself is a
- 55:37joke, but we're not going to unpack that.
- 55:42I I said I would love you to plan a trip.
- 55:46I want you to be responsible for the trip.
- 55:48Here's the budget and everything so good parenting move, right,
- 55:50giving responsibility and I let him do it on on ChatGPT.
- 55:53He planned a great trip. We went to Asheville, NC, went
- 55:56to some caves that he wanted like he planned exactly what we
- 55:59did with help of AI. After that, I've never let him
- 56:02use AI again. And the reason being is there
- 56:05was no critical thinking involved.
- 56:07Not at all. He didn't have to budget the
- 56:09money we had said that he could use or the distance from our
- 56:12house or I should have gone to AAA if they even have physical
- 56:16AAA locations and gotten him a map as a 5 year old, he probably
- 56:20could have done it. And yet we have outsourced so
- 56:22much of this thinking because we, we think they're not able to
- 56:26do it. And that is so incorrect.
- 56:27That is so incorrect. And could he have driven us
- 56:29there and gotten an accurate? Absolutely not.
- 56:32But we could have pointed him in the right direction.
- 56:33So I tell people when they ask me, you know, are your kids
- 56:37using AI and stuff? I say they're absolutely not.
- 56:39And they say, well, they're going to be behind.
- 56:41I said, no, they're not. If they can talk to a human in
- 56:43logic and be reasonable, that's how they can talk to AI better
- 56:46than anyone else. They're not.
- 56:47They're going to be able to think creatively.
- 56:49And when AI hallucinates or fails or even the, you know, the
- 56:52executive outsourcing something can't even defend their own
- 56:55reason that they outsourced it. If you teach them logic and how
- 57:00to talk, they can talk to a machine.
- 57:02What I think so it's interesting that the parent decision you
- 57:07made right and across my students, many of them being
- 57:11Gen. Z, they have based on taking the
- 57:15class I teach and doing some research made the decision that
- 57:20their kids will not have the phone as early as they did.
- 57:24And the recognition of now late in later years of what they were
- 57:29exposed to that and their own understood consequences of that
- 57:36use. And I think the critical
- 57:39thinking element is still preserved in some regard.
- 57:42And it may be more of the social psychological elements that
- 57:47they're they're speaking to at times.
- 57:49But you know, it's an interesting output of to your
- 57:55earlier point in the beginning of history and many ways offers
- 58:00a pattern and there are some things that come in and out as
- 58:05far as a revolving door and that can be indicative to the future.
- 58:10Exactly, exactly. I think one of the biggest
- 58:12detriments that we have to be aware of is we are seeing these
- 58:15positive trends. A younger millennials and Gen.
- 58:17Z are saying they're not giving their kids phones and yet they
- 58:20are still living in the phone world, which, you know, they're
- 58:24outsourcing parenting to ChatGPT.
- 58:26My kid got bit at school. What do I do?
- 58:28Write the letter to the principal.
- 58:29Those are friction points that we cannot remove.
- 58:31And I think, you know, taking screens away is great.
- 58:34I, I'm all for that. We don't have our kids don't
- 58:37have screen time at all. Like my friends are talking
- 58:39about how many minutes I'm like, ours are 0.
- 58:40Like, yeah, we'll watch a family movie every once in a while.
- 58:42We can't even get through a full 90 minute Disney movie, which is
- 58:44great. I'm OK with that.
- 58:46I'm I'm thrilled with that. They'd rather be outside and the
- 58:52number of started Disney movies is pretty significant on our,
- 58:54our Disney Plus. But what, what I think is really
- 58:58concerning is yes, we're telling our kids not to do this, but
- 59:01we're still outsourcing our thinking, our parenting to these
- 59:04LLMS and and other things. And I think that is a bigger
- 59:08trap in a more detriment because you're removing the emotion from
- 59:12being a parent. And parenting is hard.
- 59:14And we're talking about a lot about parents, but it also has
- 59:16to do with leaders, right? We can't outsource leadership.
- 59:18Either we we can't outsource the difficult decisions in the
- 59:20workplace or the HR situation to LLMS. Think about it first.
- 59:24Come up with your solution. And if you absolutely must use
- 59:27AI, put your solution in there and help them poke holes from a
- 59:30legal perspective, from a compliance perspective or
- 59:32something like that. But my goodness, go sit down
- 59:35with someone on your team and hash it out and do a whiteboard
- 59:38session. It seems like a waste of time,
- 59:40but I can tell you those exercises, putting those
- 59:42friction back into the decisions are actually going to be much
- 59:45more beneficial long term. Agree.
- 59:47Agree. So after 20 plus years of built
- 59:50building companies, advising leaders, and studying how
- 59:54generations shape organizational behavior, what have you learned
- 59:59about change and transformation that surprises people?
- 1:00:04I think it's that it hasn't changed.
- 1:00:07I think everyone's like, what's why is change so hard right now?
- 1:00:10And I said because we've gone away from the roots of what
- 1:00:13makes change important. And a lot of it is leaders being
- 1:00:16afraid to lead. And it is a scary time to lead.
- 1:00:19But leadership was never an easy calling.
- 1:00:21And I think for a season, leadership might have been
- 1:00:23easier than it was early on and than it is right now.
- 1:00:28I think there's definitely a sweet spot of leadership when
- 1:00:31not saying it was ever easy, but when it was easier and now
- 1:00:34leadership's hard again. If you aspire to that, that
- 1:00:37office, to that title, you have to take on responsibility.
- 1:00:41And that means not everyone's going to be your friend.
- 1:00:43And I think that that is countercultural.
- 1:00:45Older generations knew that he often had abuse of power and
- 1:00:49other issues. And I'm not saying you have to
- 1:00:51go back to that route, but it also means you you have to be
- 1:00:54decisive and make decisions that are best for the company and and
- 1:00:57best for your team. That's part of your company.
- 1:00:59It's the main part of your company, but you've got to do
- 1:01:01them decisively and with integrity and move forward even
- 1:01:05if you don't want everyone over. So in change management, I just
- 1:01:10see so many leaders apologizing. They they have all these caveats
- 1:01:14and why I'm doing this. And if this, and I understand
- 1:01:16that it's just like, this is the decision we made and this is
- 1:01:19where we're going. And This is why I think it's
- 1:01:21best for our company and shut up.
- 1:01:24Shut up and stop talking. You know, it's, it's an
- 1:01:28important point because did an episode a few episodes ago and
- 1:01:34it was, and I write a lot about this as well, is, you know,
- 1:01:39there's more picked up in the body language and there's more
- 1:01:46insecurity that comes by virtue of the body language.
- 1:01:48If the leader, to your point, is not definitive and it's OK to
- 1:01:54say I don't know what I don't know, I'm not quite sure that
- 1:01:58these outcomes are going to happen, but I believe with some
- 1:02:03level of confidence this is the right direction.
- 1:02:06There is a human element to that that people respect, but there
- 1:02:09is also authenticity that permeates those that are needing
- 1:02:17to rally around that and move those balls forward.
- 1:02:21And to your point, I think, you know, there are people who are
- 1:02:24afraid to be leaders. I am in the school of there are
- 1:02:28people who are natural leaders and there are people who just
- 1:02:32can't be leaders even even with training.
- 1:02:37But there there is something deep down of that authenticity
- 1:02:42that is necessary and I think that will remain so.
- 1:02:47If the CEO ask you for one piece of advice before leading a major
- 1:02:51change of transformation across particularly a multi
- 1:02:55generational workforce, what would you tell them?
- 1:02:58Yeah, I think rewind, rewind 40 years, 30 years to when you were
- 1:03:02sitting around and you pulled in key stakeholders, you
- 1:03:05interviewed them, you ask them their opinion and you realize
- 1:03:08that not everyone was going to be on board.
- 1:03:10And that's part of change. And how can you most graciously
- 1:03:14and kindly lead an organization through change realizing you're
- 1:03:17not going to have 100% buy in? I can think.
- 1:03:20And this is a leader I greatly admire and I've watched him for
- 1:03:25many, many years and been a part of, you know, a voice in his
- 1:03:28organization for many years. They, they went down an
- 1:03:33initiative that was generally controversial.
- 1:03:36It, it took a political stand almost in an organization that
- 1:03:38they, they had never taken a political stand before.
- 1:03:40They, they'd had no reason to and in their type of
- 1:03:43organization. And they took a very political
- 1:03:45stand on the higher they made and a division that they spun
- 1:03:47up. And the entire time this leader
- 1:03:50was, hey, we're doing this because there's a group of our
- 1:03:54employees are members that don't feel heard.
- 1:03:56And then he started apologizing and he then apologized for each
- 1:04:00side of an argument. And I was like, he didn't
- 1:04:02definitively say this is what we're doing cuz it's best for
- 1:04:04our team and our company moving forward.
- 1:04:05And that's it, full stop. And he had gotten a lot of
- 1:04:09insight and a lot of wisdom. That was the interesting thing.
- 1:04:11He approached the change management probably the best
- 1:04:14like if you could, Cornell has a great, you know, eight week
- 1:04:17program on unchanged management. And if you follow their
- 1:04:20framework, like he probably did all the things right.
- 1:04:21The right papers found out the detractors had the individual
- 1:04:24conversations trickle down, conversate like beautiful until
- 1:04:28he stood up in front of his organization and started
- 1:04:31apologizing him hard body language was not lacked
- 1:04:34confidence. It was like a as a leader, if
- 1:04:37you didn't think this was the right decision, you shouldn't
- 1:04:39have done it. You're leading and that means
- 1:04:41sometimes you have to do things that are unpopular or if you
- 1:04:45thought it was the right decision, don't apologize for
- 1:04:47it. Just lead with confidence.
- 1:04:48Because then what what happened was the group he was trying to
- 1:04:51UN alienate became alienated. He had a mass exodus from his
- 1:04:54organization and it totally backfired, even though on paper
- 1:04:58his whole change management strategy was was appropriate, I
- 1:05:00would say. And so I to leaders, I say, hey,
- 1:05:03understand where you're going, understand why you're going
- 1:05:06there. Bring in stakeholders, have real
- 1:05:09one-on-one conversations, ideally in person, so you can
- 1:05:12see what makes someone uncomfortable.
- 1:05:13Ask them about it. Ask the hard questions, asked
- 1:05:16the hard questions. Don't be so defensive in those
- 1:05:20conversations. Be open to new ideas.
- 1:05:22And then when you do make your decision, lead, just be a
- 1:05:24leader. And again, it sounds
- 1:05:26oversimplified, but I think we've we're so afraid of, you
- 1:05:30know, young employees posting on Indeed or a subreddit or chewing
- 1:05:35us out on the Internet that we're afraid to make difficult
- 1:05:37decisions. But leadership is a difficult
- 1:05:40role. And you're not going to win 100%
- 1:05:42of the time, but you got to you got at least lead confidently.
- 1:05:45Yeah, definitely, definitely. So Ryan, thank.
- 1:05:48Thanks so much for coming on the Human Factor podcast and joining
- 1:05:52us today. So your work is a generational
- 1:05:55futurist combined with your experience building and scaling
- 1:05:59organizations from the ground up at the age of 14 brings a
- 1:06:04practitioner steps to this research that I think our
- 1:06:07audience is going to find genuinely valuable.
- 1:06:11So thank you and please mention your newsletter and then your
- 1:06:15research and your and your book as we close.
- 1:06:18Yeah. Well, I appreciate that, Kevin.
- 1:06:19Thanks for the opportunity. Thanks for having this
- 1:06:21conversation. I think it's important one as
- 1:06:23leaders, just remembering that we've got to put the human back
- 1:06:25into what we're doing. We can't outsource the human.
- 1:06:28We just can't. So a lot of my a lot of my work
- 1:06:32recently has been on a newsletter called Collide.
- 1:06:36It's completely free. You can find it at
- 1:06:38ryanvet.com/collide. And every single week it's an
- 1:06:42essay on trends. Everything from, you know,
- 1:06:45topics we covered today like are, is Gen.
- 1:06:47Z actually going to church or are they just more spiritual?
- 1:06:50You know, why did Justin Bieber, why is he the quintessential
- 1:06:52millennial to much heavier topics to what's loneliness or,
- 1:06:56you know, what's going on in the world with, you know, certain
- 1:06:59generations and, and behaviors. So it covers a lot of different
- 1:07:03things that helps and equips leaders to to give a mirror of
- 1:07:07where we are in the world today and and hopefully shed light on
- 1:07:10where we're going. And the world doesn't have to be
- 1:07:12as scary as we're making it out to be.
- 1:07:14We just have to remember that leadership is a high calling.
- 1:07:17And as leaders, we have to make difficult decisions and lead
- 1:07:20well. Treat people with dignity as we
- 1:07:23lead, and you'll win more people over than you think you will.
- 1:07:29Excellent. Thank you, Ryan.
- 1:07:31You're awesome dude. I enjoyed this.
- 1:07:34Well, thanks Kevin. I appreciate it.
- 1:07:36Fun conversation. The generational dimension of
- 1:07:39change and transformation is not a nice to have consideration.
- 1:07:44It is a structural factor that determines whether your change
- 1:07:48initiative generates alignment or it generates fracture.
- 1:07:53When you understand that each generation carries a different
- 1:07:56psychological contract, fears different losses, and responds
- 1:08:01to different communication approaches, you stop designing
- 1:08:05change and transformation for a monolithic workforce while you
- 1:08:09start designing it for actual human beings in the room.
- 1:08:15Every episode of this season has been building towards a more
- 1:08:18complete picture of why change and transformation sales at the
- 1:08:23human level. Identity contagion, structural
- 1:08:27traps, algorithmic blind spots, the immune system, structural
- 1:08:32silence, the psychological contract, and now generational
- 1:08:36fault lines. These aren't separate problems,
- 1:08:39they are dimensions of the same underlying reality.
- 1:08:43Change in transformation is very much a human process, and the
- 1:08:48organizations are treated as a technical process.
- 1:08:51You continue to. Fail at the rates the research
- 1:08:54predicts. If you found today's episode
- 1:08:57valuable, subscribe to the Human Factor Podcast.
- 1:09:01Wherever you watch or listen the podcast, leave a rating.
- 1:09:05And a comment. And share this episode with your
- 1:09:08leadership team, especially if your organization is navigating
- 1:09:13change and transformation across a multi generational workforce.
- 1:09:18Also, subscribe to my Ideas and Innovations newsletter on 2040
- 1:09:23Digital's website or on Sub Stack.
- 1:09:26You may need the weekly frameworks and research on why
- 1:09:29change succeeds or fails. Lastly, connect with me on
- 1:09:34LinkedIn while I post regularly about the psychology of
- 1:09:37transformation. Next episode, we're going to
- 1:09:41continue the journey. Until then, remember, change in
- 1:09:44transformation doesn't fail because of technology, strategy
- 1:09:49or market conditions. It fails because of people.
- 1:09:55And the more deeply you understand the human factor, the
- 1:09:59more likely your change or transformation is to succeed.
- 1:10:04I'm Kevin Novak, thanks for watching or listening.