Latest / Onramp Bitcoin Media / The Hidden Truth About Tether's $500B Valuation: What Wall Street Isn't Telling You
Transcript
- 0:02It all comes down to computers communicating.
- 0:06The information superhighway can be a confusing mix of on ramps
- 0:09and off ramps. Bitcoin is worthless artificial
- 0:14gold. Is it still rat poison?
- 0:17Probably rat poison squared. We need to get into the world of
- 0:21OK, this is actually foundational technology.
- 0:24What the Internet of Money does is it creates a single network
- 0:28which can do a microtransaction to a giga transaction.
- 0:36The Internet is going to be one of the major forces for reducing
- 0:41the role of gun. The one thing that's missing
- 0:44that that will soon be developed is a reliable E cash.
- 0:51Hey guys, thanks for tuning in to another episode of final
- 0:54settlement. We had a really jam packed and
- 0:57tight episode this week covering all the recent investment in
- 1:00business news related to cloud fair and Google launching stable
- 1:06coins as well as some really bullish indicators coming in
- 1:10from Vanguard, Deutsche Bank and also BNY Mellon around digital
- 1:15asset adoption. Quick word from on RIM.
- 1:18We have a lot of exciting things coming out in the coming weeks
- 1:21as far as products. We're also piloting the new
- 1:23pricing structure. We've, you know, heard from the
- 1:26market that we have the Rolls Royce of custody.
- 1:28A lot of clients and prospective clients love it, want it, but
- 1:32pricing has been a big prohibitor of adopting and so
- 1:35we're piling out some new pricing that I think you all
- 1:38will enjoy. If you want to get ahead of it
- 1:41and learn more about it, shoot me a note personally, Michael at
- 1:43honor@bitcoin.com. I'll relay it to you or happily
- 1:46take the console one-on-one and look forward to hearing from you
- 1:49and hopefully you enjoy the podcast.
- 1:51Onto the show. All righty, gentlemen.
- 1:53Good morning to everyone. It's another episode of Final
- 1:57SETTLEMENT. Today is Monday, September 29th,
- 2:0110 O 5:00 AM Eastern Time. Gentlemen, how are we doing,
- 2:05Michael? Liam.
- 2:07Well, if we just got the last shakeout before it's it's game
- 2:13time, then I think doing pretty good and we're going to sit for
- 2:15another quarter at, you know, chop salvation of 100 to 120.
- 2:22I don't know if my my body can take it.
- 2:24Let's just. I was almost going to say
- 2:27October. I was almost going to say, let's
- 2:29let it RIP to like 70 just a weekend.
- 2:31I almost honestly, I wouldn't even mind if it went there
- 2:35because then we, we probably wouldn't get the, I think we've
- 2:38talked about this. We're going to get the
- 2:40upsurgeance or the the resurgence of the the dat
- 2:43insanity and then the real craziness or the real carnage
- 2:49will occur, You know, 18 months from now.
- 2:52I don't think that would happen if we got to 70.
- 2:54It would just get flushed and everybody would be like, that
- 2:56was a good game. Next game.
- 2:58That's a good. Point that that's a good point.
- 3:00It does feel like, you know, one thing to point to to say that,
- 3:04you know, we definitely haven't topped is that a lot of the a
- 3:07lot of the treasury plays haven't even bought Bitcoin yet.
- 3:10They, you know, they've announced allocations are
- 3:13announced plans to announce, you know, business operations and or
- 3:17Bitcoin buys. A lot of them, most of them
- 3:19haven't even happened yet. Yeah.
- 3:22I mean, just imagine like the level of again, the main reason
- 3:27we haven't talked about it, because I think they come back
- 3:29and then it'll be the next level where the the real carnage and
- 3:32losses. But imagine the amount of like
- 3:35from all time highs where these companies are trading nobody out
- 3:38there talking, just just silence, you know, And how many
- 3:43people bought at these like tops were sold a bill of goods.
- 3:47I see these notions on Twitter. We're like, I'm down to 100K you
- 3:50scammers. Like what happened?
- 3:51It's not supposed to be. I was promised better Bitcoin
- 3:55and I've gotten worse Bitcoin. Well, look, it's the the old
- 3:59notion if you, if you're nearer to the space, they used to say
- 4:04you know you are the yield if you don't know where the yield
- 4:06come from, comes from, but also that the friends you made along
- 4:09the way. Because the real yield.
- 4:12So your community will will ultimately be the the yield you
- 4:15can hang your head on. But no, in all seriousness, just
- 4:19be careful out there and stay away from the debts.
- 4:21Just buy the good stuff. Buy the good stuff, hold it
- 4:25Well, All right, guys, we didn't get to talk about this last
- 4:29week, but this was the biggest news item in my mind from last
- 4:32week. Tether $500 billion valuation on
- 4:36this latest private raise that they're doing, they're raising
- 4:3920 billion. Michael, I'll kick it to you.
- 4:42First thoughts? Yeah, I think and more time to
- 4:48think about it and I think that's where starting it's it's
- 4:50obviously huge news. We didn't get to chat about it,
- 4:52but also I think there's a very interesting notion of how much
- 4:57assets tethers holding is filtered into that valuation.
- 5:01One of the valuations obviously pretty insane and put we put it,
- 5:04I believe, like top five private companies in valuation.
- 5:07I think it said it made the the Co founder that's behind the
- 5:10scenes one of the most wealthiest men in the world.
- 5:15I think even like second baby ahead of Satoshi, I think was a
- 5:19headline. But anyway, I think that there
- 5:22is a lot to the fact that they probably end up getting some
- 5:27level below this. There's a number of assets
- 5:30sitting on them. I think they generate $5 billion
- 5:32last quarter profit. They're the dominant stable coin
- 5:36issuer. So there's a real opportunity to
- 5:39get access to that business. They probably don't get the full
- 5:43500 billion. We talked a little bit about it.
- 5:46You know, the notion of strategic investors is probably
- 5:48one of the biggest ones to align with who whatever parties you
- 5:51are going to insert, you know, Tether dominance globally.
- 5:56The thing that I think is probably the most interesting I
- 5:58talked about is really how Tether and USDC are actually
- 6:01different businesses. And when I say that is in maybe
- 6:06tethers going to be try to be USDC and maybe USC is going to
- 6:09try to be tether, which probably is likely.
- 6:10But tether is really for like, I don't want to say even emerging
- 6:13markets, because I think that's how they hide under the emerging
- 6:16markets. And what was the other one that
- 6:17was like a sigh up the global S. Those are just like these terms
- 6:21for people to get investors, you know, capital into for, for it's
- 6:25almost like a ESG for venture. Point being is they work in like
- 6:29black markets. They work in dollars that exist
- 6:31in large amounts. You know, nobody's working in
- 6:33emerging markets gets a $500 billion valuation.
- 6:35Like there's real serious capital being moved.
- 6:38And point being is they're more on the street, like they're more
- 6:41on the corners. They're going to be in different
- 6:43networks across the world. And those dollars are going to
- 6:46be fundamentally different than where you see Circle and USDC
- 6:50playing, which is more in trad Phi D Phi, very much regulated.
- 6:56You have a lot of KYC constraints when it comes to,
- 6:59you know, interacting. I think it just came out last
- 7:01week's CFTC allowing for stable coin deposits for derivatives.
- 7:05You can imagine they're probably not using Tether to start there.
- 7:08So I think they're just different companies.
- 7:10And I think what's most fascinating is who else will
- 7:12will come about and will participate at real scale in
- 7:17this world of stable coins. So yeah.
- 7:21Well, what do you make of whatever they're calling it
- 7:25USAT? So, you know, they're, they're
- 7:28new stable coin, their new Tether stable coin that's
- 7:30specifically for U.S. markets. Because that that to me is, you
- 7:36know, a pretty, pretty overt play against the circles of the
- 7:39world. Yeah, I mean, I think it's
- 7:42similar. I mean, it's not similar.
- 7:43The first thing that came to mind is TikTok, like TikTok
- 7:49didn't necessarily at first have a bifurcation of different
- 7:53geopolitical regions. It started at one and everyone
- 7:55could have access to it. So now when you go and like
- 7:59segment it out, it already has like a certain level of
- 8:02penetration to just shift over versus something like this.
- 8:06Even though they have the liquidity, it's like you're
- 8:08starting over from scratch. And I think this is what Liam
- 8:12had brought up a while ago when we talked about it.
- 8:14It's not to say that they won't have the connections.
- 8:17I think that they're just starting in a different level
- 8:20and they're probably going to be launching at the same time
- 8:22Fidelity and a few other larger players enter the space.
- 8:26And that's really probably goes back to the investment
- 8:30opportunity is because if you're going to go to whatever largest
- 8:33financial institutions, asset managers, you're going to want
- 8:36to be able to get liquidity already like baked into the
- 8:39offering or to be able to like white label or whatever they're
- 8:42going to do from an issuance perspective.
- 8:45That's honestly probably the real reason to give up any of
- 8:47your business that's producing $5 billion in net profit on a
- 8:50monthly, on a quarterly basis is because you're looking for, you
- 8:53know, to win the whole game. And to do that, you need to make
- 8:56sure that you can basically entrench your, your coin and
- 8:59their rails. Yeah, there.
- 9:02There was a few things that stuck out to to me around this
- 9:05as I sort of digested it over the past week or so.
- 9:10One of them was, was interestingly over the weekend,
- 9:13they put out sort of a, an ad or a sort of a video commercial for
- 9:18USAT, the new US version of a Tether stable coin.
- 9:24And I just found it interesting because they opted to create a
- 9:28video from AI, like they didn't go hire somebody to do it, spend
- 9:32a ton of money. They probably, you know, spent a
- 9:35couple $1000 to create like a pretty good looking AI
- 9:40commercial or video. And it just struck me as like,
- 9:43you know, this massive company that's just valued at 500
- 9:46billion is going to be discerning with their capital
- 9:49and leverage deflationary tools to create an AI commercial as
- 9:53opposed to going out and spending a ton of money, which
- 9:55they clearly have and, and could have spent to create an ad.
- 10:00And it just struck me as as very sort of aligned with with how
- 10:04they've done everything from an efficiency to efficiency
- 10:06standpoint, how they think about their balance sheet holding a
- 10:08ton of Bitcoin, holding a ton of gold.
- 10:11I just thought that was a, you know, a little little detail
- 10:14worth highlighting in all of this.
- 10:18Yeah, this is going to be really fascinating to see who they
- 10:20bring on because to Michael's point, like the the real thing
- 10:23is this is a net new coin. And just like anything else,
- 10:26they need liquidity. So it's probably going to be
- 10:28some of the largest financial players in the space, maybe even
- 10:32a little bit of a nod to the US sovereign wealth fund as well,
- 10:36possibly in there, even though they're pretty much already the
- 10:38same thing. And I would also say MGX is the
- 10:45same one who invested in finance recently is an interesting one.
- 10:48There are a lot of different exchanges all across the world
- 10:51who would be potential investors in this.
- 10:54But 500 billions does seem a little bit rich, especially if
- 10:58interest rates are going to be going down in the medium term,
- 11:02especially on the short side of the curve.
- 11:05But yeah, I mean, it's, I wonder what else they're doing this for
- 11:11if it's not just because they don't need the money.
- 11:13They have all the land, they have the gold, they have the
- 11:15Bitcoin, and they're printing cash with the other side of
- 11:18their business. So it has to be strategic
- 11:21investors that they're really looking for, otherwise why raise
- 11:24any capital? Well, I wouldn't say they don't
- 11:27need the money in the sense of Brian actually.
- 11:30I mean, I would say if they can keep this same trajectory of how
- 11:33they've been efficient and prudent with capital spend, then
- 11:38any money in their hands is worth almost 10 to 100 X in
- 11:41anybody else's hands. And if you're getting any near
- 11:46anywhere near this level of valuation and getting 10 to $20
- 11:50billion, you can park in Bitcoin because you know, that's where
- 11:53it's going. And you get any form of lift
- 11:56into that, whether it's a 50 percent, 100%, which is probably
- 12:00conservative based on our, you know, personal projections of
- 12:03where Bitcoin goes. You're effectively getting 40 to
- 12:05$50 billion to give up 2% of your business.
- 12:10It's pretty asymmetric along with the the the partnerships
- 12:16and, and it. Yeah.
- 12:18And I guess the last part is like, I think that they really
- 12:20recognize and I've, and I've been going on this rabbit hole.
- 12:23We'll talk about sending a rabbit hole.
- 12:26It's just like this level of power, the level of power needed
- 12:31for AI in like where this is all heading is really kind of, it's
- 12:36going to put us in a weird place.
- 12:37And I think they know that. And ultimately whoever has the
- 12:39most capital is going to be able to be key maker in that sense of
- 12:44controlling the data centers. And I think they're probably
- 12:46wanting to play in that world. And it would make sense to bring
- 12:49on capital, especially right now at the price.
- 12:51I don't think, I think most people probably shocked that
- 12:53we're sitting in late 2025 and we're only at $100,000 Bitcoin,
- 12:59yeah. In a related headline, Michael,
- 13:03I think you brought this one along the lines of stable coins,
- 13:06but also AI. And we have some other AI links
- 13:09to get to, but I'll bring up this one.
- 13:10Google AI, stable coin payments, a first protocol for autonomous
- 13:14agents. Would you make of this, Mike?
- 13:17Yeah, I think the there was this link and then the other one
- 13:22because I can loop them together is the cloud fair and the new
- 13:25stable coin. I think there's a couple of
- 13:28interesting parts. We touched a little bit about
- 13:30just the notion of, you know, digital native money online is
- 13:36people are waking up to, it probably wasn't really couldn't
- 13:40happen before because of interchange in the
- 13:42microtransactions. I think you take that coupled
- 13:46with the amount of like agents and proliferation of just
- 13:49software online and you're starting to see it make sense.
- 13:55I think we all understand on a long on a time horizon, you want
- 13:58a neutral money that's probably has more programmability.
- 14:01And really the two aspects are you don't have the regulatory
- 14:10and the just everything that would come to the apparatus or
- 14:12something like this. So like at face value, it goes
- 14:14back to being the lipstick on a pig, right, Where like stable
- 14:17coins are the lipstick on a pig in in a stratified world where
- 14:20you know, Bitcoin, lightning, other forms of rails on base
- 14:25layer Bitcoin or the real innovation.
- 14:27So I think like that is obvious. The one that's a little bit less
- 14:31obvious that it goes back to the power generation that when you
- 14:37have these cycles being run in the number of tokens that are
- 14:40increasing because it's my understanding like now open AI
- 14:45like has 800 million users, right?
- 14:47It's like fastest growing business like ever.
- 14:51And then the amount of inferences based on what they
- 14:54were initially cycling for, based on now with reasoning has
- 14:57increased, increased exponentially as well.
- 15:00And so you basically have to get in real time, not only that
- 15:03spend from the user, but spent back to whether it's your power
- 15:06users, what you're paying for with getting GPU chips, like the
- 15:09whole production line has to effectively be streamlined or
- 15:14somebody's having to hold the float on whatever capital is
- 15:16being spent. And I just, I never really like
- 15:19thought of it in that way where it makes complete sense that as
- 15:22you start getting the proliferation of AI models
- 15:25across applications on the front end all the way to the power
- 15:28production, it's going to make more and more sense to start
- 15:31having payments just flow through all of that, which is
- 15:34very bullish Bitcoin because at the end of the day, like there's
- 15:37a 10 different reasons why you'd rather take Bitcoin and SAT
- 15:40streaming versus USCC. But anyway, so that that was
- 15:45just like, I don't know if you're expecting that take, but
- 15:47that's kind of where my mind was going with these different
- 15:49dollar stable coins with these like AI driven Internet
- 15:51economies. And then this was the other or I
- 15:54just found this link related to clear Cloudflare launches.
- 15:58Net dollar stable coin for AI driven Internet economy was just
- 16:01the other one that you were referencing.
- 16:03Yeah, I mean, this sounds like Chuck E Cheese tokens, I guess
- 16:06because this is like just their own intranet.
- 16:08I don't even know how it would work or what's the
- 16:10interoperability, but it's still the, the same point of like
- 16:14they, they Cloudfare has its own payment gateways or gateways in
- 16:19general to protect the Internet. And if you're going to be, you
- 16:22know, moving across them, you're they're going to naturally want
- 16:25some form of payment. And this just streamlines that
- 16:29whole process. We have any thoughts on on
- 16:33either of these? It is interesting because I'm
- 16:36not. That's an interesting point you
- 16:38bring up about just the instant payment.
- 16:41Especially as these types of businesses scale faster, I think
- 16:44that there's going to be a lot of credit that these companies
- 16:48are just used to like paying with net 30, net 90 days with
- 16:52discounts. If they pay upfront, I think
- 16:54that they're going to still find that credit elsewhere if they're
- 16:57not necessarily given to buy their other partners rather than
- 17:00just saying like, hey, you can pay us in 90 days or, or
- 17:03whatever it is. I don't necessarily know how
- 17:06that's, that's going to play out, but that is a really
- 17:08fascinating opportunity. And then kind of on a related
- 17:12note, I thought that it was really interesting about the
- 17:15Circle Explorers perversible USDC transactions.
- 17:19I think that many people when they're looking at, you know,
- 17:25getting paid, they they essentially just want exactly
- 17:27what they have right now, but with slightly lower fees.
- 17:31Like it's too much to understand that transactions can be final,
- 17:36especially when you're dealing with significant chunks of
- 17:38payment. And so I think that this is this
- 17:44is naturally going to happen and going to be the most popular
- 17:47kind of B1. I think that there will be fraud
- 17:49from this, but it's going to be interesting how they enforce it.
- 17:53I think it's going to be really human capital intensive.
- 17:56And I think that Tether will probably likely also follow suit
- 18:01just because the market forces will demand it.
- 18:03Was curious your guys saw as well.
- 18:07I agree. I I think this is the big thing
- 18:09that it's the biggest one of the biggest opportunities for
- 18:14anybody listening, whether they're building or investing.
- 18:17And ours is the delta between what the utopian, or I don't
- 18:23want to call it utopian, but vision for digital currencies in
- 18:26bitcoins final settlement versus when it gets there might be 100
- 18:29years. Like it's truly a, a great
- 18:32renaissance, like a complete rethinking of everything.
- 18:34Because what you're describing in finality that everyone
- 18:38accepts really changes the whole dynamic of like a relationship
- 18:41with a merchant. Meaning maybe you're on a long
- 18:43enough time horizon. We get to a world where
- 18:46businesses actually do what they say they're going to do and they
- 18:48return the money or the, or the goods if the the client doesn't
- 18:51receive it and they don't want their social score.
- 18:53And there's other things, but that's just like a whole
- 18:55different way from a user interacting.
- 18:58And so to your point, Liam, if everyone is used to, whether
- 19:01it's both sides, if you're the, you know, merchant, you're used
- 19:05to this way and it's made sense and your mental model of
- 19:08everything is aligned with that. And on the other side, if you
- 19:11interact with, if you buy something increasingly in a
- 19:13world where client services and products are degraded, you want
- 19:17to be able to have recourse, but you can't.
- 19:19Like everyone's going to get more familiar, comfortable with
- 19:22just the marginal increasing. We have to be OK with that.
- 19:25Like we can't. It goes back to do you want to
- 19:26make money or do you want to be right?
- 19:27Most people be like, well, that's insane.
- 19:29And like, sure, I agree there's a lot of value just accepting
- 19:31final payment for goods and services in Bitcoin.
- 19:36But there's a time and place for that.
- 19:37And there's very like, you know, small things.
- 19:39Today we talked about it, I think last week's.
- 19:41If you're selling gold and you ship gold to somebody, it's like
- 19:45I want the Bitcoin before I ship the gold.
- 19:49But if you're selling a shirt or somebody has to do a return, it
- 19:52just makes a lot more sense. So anyway.
- 19:55Yeah, I think what what I have on screen here, I think captures
- 19:59kind of what we're referencing here, like immutability doesn't
- 20:02reflect how institutions work. While immutability is central to
- 20:04blockchain design, the idea of every transaction being
- 20:07irreversible under all conditions has only served the
- 20:09ethos of early crypto industry. It does not reflect how
- 20:12financial systems operate at institutional scale.
- 20:16And I think that actually it's fine if it's essentially just
- 20:20moving money forward and back between pretty large parties of,
- 20:24you know, exchanges and very large hedge funds through banks.
- 20:28Those are kind of like the three large touch points that stable
- 20:32coins touch at this point. But as it goes to more on the
- 20:36margins and there were final transactions for anybody who
- 20:40buys and sells large goods and services that doesn't actually
- 20:43have a direct relationship or somebody they can call up if
- 20:46thing doesn't go necessarily according to plan.
- 20:48There's just going to be so much fraud, especially in kind of the
- 20:51B ones of getting these stable coins to decent scale.
- 20:56And so they, they're either going to accept, all right,
- 20:59well, I'm going to lose a massive amount of money on the
- 21:02fraud on the B1 of trying to integrate stable coins into our
- 21:05payment flows, or I can use reversible transactions and kind
- 21:10of settle this with Circle. So I don't know exactly how it's
- 21:14going to play out, but that's it's interesting to see.
- 21:17It's such a great point because something that I'm ashamed we
- 21:20haven't even talked about, or I've never thought about it
- 21:23personally, is like, so if everyone's holding these stable
- 21:26coins, well, theoretically they're holding private key
- 21:29somewhere or authentication. So we already know, like there's
- 21:33a certain sample size of people holding Bitcoin that are just
- 21:36getting robbed and hacked and social engineered all day long
- 21:38and nobody hears about. Well, theoretically that's going
- 21:41to increase with stablecoin proliferation from an order of
- 21:44magnitude from like 2 to 100 X, which would mean if they're
- 21:47holding their own private keys, well, people can barely hold
- 21:50their own personal, you know, house keys.
- 21:53And then if they're on a on a server or somewhere and your
- 21:55phone is authenticating, it goes back to it.
- 21:58You're going to have to reverse these things.
- 22:00And how do you credibly prove that somebody else didn't lose
- 22:02it? So that's like on that side.
- 22:04And then it ties into the like self custody route, which I've
- 22:07always already gotten to this place.
- 22:08When once you get enough, you're long, long enough in Bitcoin,
- 22:12you kind of like, you know, you would see value.
- 22:15I think it's going to make more and more sense where if you had
- 22:17a bank account, your savings account held Bitcoin, you have
- 22:19your checking account and let's say your checking account is
- 22:22either depleted or you need a larger purchase.
- 22:23How it would just auto convert from your savings and your
- 22:26checking and you could spend those dollars into it.
- 22:28And point being is like you can't do any of that with self
- 22:31custody. Like so are you just never going
- 22:33to spend the money? Like what's the plan?
- 22:35You know, these things just haven't been fully thought
- 22:37through. Anyway, that just came to mind
- 22:40when you were referencing about fraud.
- 22:41It's like, so everyone's gonna hold stable coins and that's
- 22:44better rails. But like what happens when
- 22:46somebody logs into somebody's account, drains their full
- 22:49account on Charles Schwab or whatever, and then like how do
- 22:54you reverse it if that gets auto converted into BTC, like who's
- 22:57on the hook there? Yeah, all great questions.
- 23:03One other stable coin related headline.
- 23:07I just wanted to share it. I saw it come across this
- 23:09morning, but SWIFT to work with consensus on blockchain
- 23:13prototype for cross-border payments.
- 23:15I just thought this was a poetic headline just given, you know, I
- 23:18think a lot of the crypto narratives over the past decade
- 23:22have been, you know, the, the sort of proverbial thing is like
- 23:28we're just going to replace SWIFT with XYZ protocol, more
- 23:32efficient database, etcetera. And now SWIFT is just going to
- 23:35disrupt themselves and create a better database themselves.
- 23:39So everybody's getting into it, the incumbents and the crypto
- 23:42crypto natives. But I just thought, I thought
- 23:44this was a a curious headline given given sort of the past 10
- 23:47years of people claiming to disrupt SWIFT.
- 23:51You know, but this kind of maybe we've gone like full circle of
- 23:58what I've really enjoyed about having these podcasts is more in
- 24:00client meetings and discussions. You get to really get your
- 24:03position work through because we're just effectively having
- 24:06like and you have to be a little bit tighter obviously on a
- 24:08recorded podcast. So point being is what if this
- 24:13is, this actually makes logical sense of the way we had to get
- 24:17to like a decentralized Bitcoin futures like you effectively had
- 24:19to go from a centralized storage system or database, however the
- 24:23contract was. And then you had to come to the
- 24:26false primitives that, you know, again, not decentralized, blah,
- 24:29blah, blah. But it at least had the concepts
- 24:31of Bitcoin. And then as because it was, it's
- 24:34again too big of a leap to go from like X all the way to Y or
- 24:39whatever Y is in the future we just talked about like this kind
- 24:42of actually makes sense that it would go down this route.
- 24:45Yeah, I mean it's not a bad thought.
- 24:46I I would normally file this under just noise to to ignore.
- 24:50But I think I think you are right in the sense that this
- 24:53could be just the logical progression of it's, it's the
- 24:56same thing we talked about with the stablecoin stuff in, in
- 24:59generalities around the normalization of of these
- 25:02digital rails necessarily helps the adoption of Bitcoin over the
- 25:06medium to long term. Yeah.
- 25:09And I think the one caveat is I don't even know what this is
- 25:13like to be honest. I just, I'm just mainly
- 25:15referencing like Swift consensus ETH stablecoins.
- 25:19It's makes sense that would be the the choice or whatever.
- 25:23I do think that with all that said, whoever has a clear vision
- 25:27for the future, we will will be the winners and key makers in
- 25:31the future because they will have more time to look at the
- 25:33problem and we'll understand where the markets going having a
- 25:3710 to 100 year time horizon. So it's not to say to do any of
- 25:40this. It's like if you're had a good
- 25:41like Jack Dorsey's probably a great example at square.
- 25:43There's probably things that 5D chess that they're playing and
- 25:47what they're what they're doing because they understand Bitcoin
- 25:50is a long term winner and it lets them take a long term
- 25:52horizon versus a lot of this stuff.
- 25:55Some of them may never make it out because their businesses
- 25:57won't, you know, make it through whether it's the solvency,
- 26:01because that's the craziest thing when I think about stable
- 26:03coins and derivatives and collateral is just the thinking
- 26:07about the amount of rug pulls that are going to come in when,
- 26:10like Liam mentioned, interest rates being reduced.
- 26:13That's another concept hit me. Hit me the other day is like, so
- 26:16interest rates go down, more capital is inserted in the
- 26:20system, more tokens, more USDC Tether are created, more
- 26:25insanity ensues in the token to economy.
- 26:29And like that's effectively going to draw, that's eventually
- 26:32going to pull everyone down with it.
- 26:35At a certain point, it feels inevitable.
- 26:39Yeah, yeah. Liam, any any other thoughts on
- 26:43that or we can move on? No, we can move on, I think.
- 26:46So I wanted to talk a little AI. There was a headline and a
- 26:51Bloomberg article that caught my attention over the weekend.
- 26:55Hedge fund legend David Einhorn of Green Light Capital, I guess,
- 26:59was interviewed by Bloomberg, and he's cautioned that the
- 27:03unprecedented amount of spending on artificial intelligence
- 27:06infrastructure may destroy vast amounts of capital, even if the
- 27:09technology itself proves transformative.
- 27:14And I think that this is reflective of a lot of what
- 27:16we've been talking about on the show over the past several
- 27:19months, honestly, in terms of all these headlines that we see
- 27:22every week around AI spend. And effectively, you know, even
- 27:26from Zuckerberg, just saying, we're going to throw hundreds of
- 27:29billions of dollars at this and we basically can't afford to
- 27:32lose. Like there's there's a
- 27:34achievable goal. So great that all capital
- 27:38discipline is effectively out the window.
- 27:40And, and Einhorn is kind of just calling out that line of
- 27:43thinking and saying, you know, there's a reasonable chance that
- 27:47a tremendous amount of capital destruction is going to come
- 27:49through this cycle. I'm sure it's not 0, but there's
- 27:52a reasonable chance of a tremendous amount of capital
- 27:54destruction. So I want to get your guys
- 27:56thoughts on this. I think it's, it's very
- 27:59reflective of, of what we've been discussing on this show
- 28:02around capital discipline and, and just, you know, how what
- 28:05capital allocation is going to look like as we move forward
- 28:07into a new world where we have some money, where we have all
- 28:10these deflationary forces. And then we just have, you know,
- 28:14massive amounts of capital being thrown at the infrastructure
- 28:17build, which, you know, there, there seems to be a, you know, a
- 28:21pot at the end of the rainbow, but it, it's still an unknown,
- 28:24generally speaking. So there's likely to be a lot of
- 28:28capital destroyed as as a result of this.
- 28:29But curious your guys. Thoughts.
- 28:31Yeah, I think that's very well said.
- 28:34And that just kind of happens every single time there is a new
- 28:38industry that's gets to be pretty large.
- 28:41You can think about the Internet and how much was destroyed in
- 28:43the.com boom and boss, as well as just even like the digital
- 28:48asset space in general. And just how many different
- 28:51tokens have been created, how many different hedge funds and
- 28:54venture capitalists have been born trying to, you know, create
- 28:58a better Bitcoin or, you know, better digital token?
- 29:02I think that it's just any time that there's something that's
- 29:04truly transformative that has just a massive total addressable
- 29:08market, there will be like a massive misallocation of capital
- 29:11because everybody wants to get in there.
- 29:13And they think that even if they're on the periphery, they
- 29:17somehow will be rewarded just because they're in the same type
- 29:19of category. And also just because there is a
- 29:22lot of the investors will demand that they are in the hot
- 29:28category, even if they can't necessarily be in the right
- 29:30deal. And so the investors necessarily
- 29:33have to chase bad deals in order to continue to raise capital.
- 29:36Everybody hope you're joining the podcast.
- 29:38Wanted to give a quick word from early riders, the venture firm
- 29:41pioneering Bitcoin as a hurdle rate, the only Bitcoin
- 29:43denominated venture fund. There's some real exciting
- 29:47announcement that recently came out of the stables.
- 29:50If you haven't seen the news, Bitcoin Magazine did a report
- 29:53and you can also go to earlywriters.com to check it
- 29:55out. But ultimately why it matters is
- 29:57if you're building in the space and looking to either leave your
- 30:01company job or looking to partner to get, you know,
- 30:04funding to build things in the Bitcoin ecosystem or even
- 30:07outside the Bitcoin ecosystem. But coming at it from a first
- 30:10principles lens of trying to make more Bitcoin.
- 30:13We're going to have a four week fully funded Sprint at the Texas
- 30:17Hill Country campus that we are launching next year.
- 30:20We'd love to hear from you. You can book time with us or you
- 30:23can shoot us a note. A lot of exciting things
- 30:26happening on that front. So it encourage you to check it
- 30:28out. And if you just want to stay
- 30:29ahead of some of the research that Early Writers is producing,
- 30:32you can actually go to earlywriters.com and subscribe.
- 30:36Hope you guys enjoy the show. We have a great last trade
- 30:38coming up this week and again, some very fun, exciting product
- 30:42announcements in the coming week.
- 30:43So hopefully you stay. Tim.
- 30:45Thanks. So I'm so glad you brought this
- 30:49up because I was just thinking about this.
- 30:53I think William said it is obviously right in technological
- 30:57waves, capitals destroyed. We saw this with the railroads
- 30:59fiber. Dark fiber's one of my favorite
- 31:02because I had experience with like 20 years later than fiber
- 31:05getting rolled back out. I think it's completely
- 31:08different though, with AI and because I've been thinking about
- 31:11this and yeah, it's different in the sense that it's not apples
- 31:14to apples. I've been thinking about this a
- 31:17lot because it what Brian said, it's instinctually makes sense.
- 31:20Like there's all these numbers being thrown out there.
- 31:22Like how can everyone recoup it? We've loosely talked about this,
- 31:26but I hadn't been able to reconcile like what's actually
- 31:28happening. This is going to be a little
- 31:31fringe, but I'm curious of guys thoughts.
- 31:32And I think this is directionally bright is nobody's
- 31:36going to get paid back in real terms.
- 31:37And I don't even think they actually other than the
- 31:40companies that win. And the angle is that we know.
- 31:46I mean, we don't fully know. But the things I've been
- 31:49listening to is like the level and the amount of energy that we
- 31:52do not have to support. And this is really where the
- 31:54Renaissance of like nuclear fusion and all this stuff
- 31:57happening. But it was said that the amount
- 32:01of solar that China is going to put online this year, I believe
- 32:06is more energy total than all of the US, right?
- 32:10Like they are just so far ahead. And the main point is this.
- 32:14So when you look at the capital intensity of this race from the
- 32:20ASICS to the models to the data centers, to energy and standing
- 32:26up, the different forms of power generation, that it's
- 32:33exponential in the sense that as more computes being used, more
- 32:36people are using it goes back to the inferences in the amount
- 32:39from when GPTS first started to where it is today.
- 32:41Point being is energy is going to go through the roof, right?
- 32:46And energy already is like a proxy for kind of like human
- 32:50growth and intelligence, all the things we know flourishing.
- 32:52Point being is every. I think this is how we usher in
- 32:56Ubi. Seriously.
- 32:58Like I think that if you're holding hard assets or if you're
- 33:01holding real assets that accrue in real terms in the future, you
- 33:07are going to be fine. If you're not accruing that, you
- 33:11are going to be losing in real terms.
- 33:13But because AI is going to be ubiquitous from every aspect of
- 33:17everything we touch, it's going to be looked at as a public good
- 33:21that everyone needs to use it. And so people are going to get
- 33:23all this capital to spend, whether it's tokens or dollars.
- 33:26I don't know what it looks like because that's what's going to
- 33:29allow for the capital to be returned is those in nominal
- 33:33terms, not real terms, is all this cost is going to go up
- 33:35because the energy is the main output, right?
- 33:37And we don't, I think we'd all agree that energy is going to go
- 33:39exponential from here if like this is where the race is on.
- 33:44I think I did a decent job there because I just came up with this
- 33:46this morning. I was always listening to some
- 33:48stuff before this, but like it's kind of starting to come
- 33:50together of like what the actual strategy is.
- 33:52And that's why these numbers, nobody cares about them because
- 33:55they're not playing for like the tokens anymore.
- 33:57They're playing almost for like global superpower.
- 34:01And anyway, and this is where Bitcoin fits beautifully in the
- 34:04whole thing. Yeah, that's an interesting
- 34:07thought around. You know, Ubi taking a a form
- 34:10that isn't necessarily dollar based even.
- 34:12What if it's just, you know, the AI tokens or credits that that
- 34:16the humans need? Yeah, in the last part, this is
- 34:19really where also this is like where different information
- 34:23starts to connect and you don't even know it is.
- 34:27Paulo from Tether had a great podcast.
- 34:29I don't remember who it was with, but he was ultimately
- 34:31saying like, we don't even know for certain if like it's
- 34:34inorganic. When you think about these, you
- 34:37know, the status of the world, right?
- 34:39We have these like centralized, you know, banking institutions
- 34:41or whatever you want to call it, media companies.
- 34:43And it makes more sense for things to be distributed for for
- 34:46a number of reasons and the notion of compute and AI to be
- 34:51run locally, right from privacy perspective to even how you
- 34:54would train the model. There was other reasons to use,
- 34:58but the point being is that we don't even necessarily know.
- 35:03Like to your point on the Ubi stuff is like if you have these
- 35:06tokens, we've seen digital ID come in, right?
- 35:08So now you're tied to getting it through that.
- 35:10But there's going to be like this parallel track where you're
- 35:12going to have your own models. They're going to be on Prem or
- 35:15maybe they're going to be other localized.
- 35:17They can verify that data is not shared.
- 35:19I don't know. But point being is you're going
- 35:21to be able to interact with that.
- 35:22If you have a form of money that's better, that's censorship
- 35:24resistant, you can see kind of how like this starts to play out
- 35:29already today. And so that's the, I think the
- 35:32angle of the Ubi, it's like, well, if that's ubiquitous
- 35:34across everything, it's like, sure, you get it, but you need
- 35:36to like be able to do XY and Z and it'll start easy at first.
- 35:40Right, You've got to be a good, you've got to be a good digital
- 35:42citizen in order to receive your your credits of any kind.
- 35:46That's that's. For sure that's already
- 35:48happening here in New York though, which is Governor Kochel
- 35:52announces inflation refund checks are being sent to 8.2
- 35:56million New York households. You know, as a way it just goes
- 36:00back to the fact that you need to be in control of the token if
- 36:04you're going to and be able to increase its issuance anytime if
- 36:08you want the Ubi to be directed on that certain token.
- 36:12Otherwise, you're necessarily going to run out of them in the
- 36:15long term just because no value will accrue to it.
- 36:18Yeah. I do want to move on.
- 36:22We have some other links, but before moving on from AII, did
- 36:25want to share this tweet which summarized a note from JP Morgan
- 36:30around, you know how much of the stock market in particular is
- 36:34just being driven by AI related stocks.
- 36:36I thought some of these numbers were pretty startling.
- 36:39So 75% of the S&P 500 returns since Chat GPTS launch in
- 36:43November 2022 have come from AI related stocks, 80% of earnings
- 36:48growth over the same period and 90% of capital spending growth.
- 36:52So this is it really just reiterates everything we've just
- 36:54discussed the amount of money being thrown at these things and
- 36:56really sort of this hopeful, this hopeful thesis that it all
- 37:02works out that that it's all worth it, right?
- 37:04And that that hopeful sort of trajectory is now being sort of
- 37:11manifested within the stock market itself.
- 37:13And, and that, you know, potential is being priced in
- 37:17effectively where, you know, a lot of the, the growth we've
- 37:20seen over the past year is, you know, really just being propped
- 37:23up by a lot of this AI hype. Yeah.
- 37:25I mean, I know you want to transition, but I think this is
- 37:27a good indicator of nobody talks about enough.
- 37:31You hear a lot of the tradified crypto people and definitely
- 37:33tried by people talk about the the Fed, Fed speak around GDP
- 37:38growth and we're not in a recession.
- 37:40It's like we've been in a recession since basically 1971
- 37:42because GDP correlated to the amount of monetary units has
- 37:46been, I guess, inversely correlated.
- 37:49That's right. Point being that when you hear
- 37:54like we know the job numbers are cooked, we know GDP in nominal
- 37:59terms may be up, but in real terms it's not because cost of
- 38:01everything is going up. So when they look at like price
- 38:03earnings in, you know, revenue, they're not actually like the
- 38:06right numbers, they're not using the right benchmarks.
- 38:09And then this is the latest example of that because it just
- 38:12conveniently happened. I don't know, I won't make any
- 38:14claims because I don't really know.
- 38:15But like 21 when everything sees up or 22 after everything sees
- 38:19up with low interest rates, how AI just stepped in there?
- 38:22Because when velocity of money goes down, then naturally things
- 38:26start like seizing up. And AI like naturally stepped in
- 38:29for like all the different hedge funds, LP funds, endowments to
- 38:32start stepping into those markets.
- 38:34And then again, goes back to the stock market, which a majority
- 38:36of people hold their wealth in outside of houses.
- 38:40I also got juice. But there's no growth happening
- 38:42there from a, you know, GDP perspective.
- 38:44And so people, like, dance around AI and that we're gonna
- 38:46get this growth out of there. And it's like, yes, on a loan of
- 38:49time, there's gonna be a lot of crazy things.
- 38:50But today, there's not that much GDP growth happening.
- 38:52Like, nobody knows anybody really using effective AI
- 38:56outside of, like, individuals and maybe some units that I
- 38:59found really specific niches when it comes to like, legal and
- 39:01accounting and certain things that are just like, data set
- 39:04structures. But yeah, this is just yeah.
- 39:07A lot of that near term stuff would also, you know, likely be
- 39:10net negative for GDP as well if it's replacing jobs.
- 39:14Exactly. With all the layoffs, you're
- 39:15looking at that and those people aren't entering the workforce
- 39:19back like that's a. Yeah.
- 39:20Yeah, there's a there's actually a random plug for all this.
- 39:23I think you guys will appreciate him.
- 39:24Only halfway through is the long like he's from a lot of smart
- 39:30people. They call him like he's just a
- 39:32puppet for those Ponzi is. It's the NVIDIA CEO and he was
- 39:35with Brad Gerstner and Bill Gurley.
- 39:38On the half of that, yeah. Yeah.
- 39:40But like this is the kind of notion of this is the speak in
- 39:43Silicon Valley. Like this is where it's all
- 39:45going. And I think it's directionally
- 39:47right. But they're not the second and
- 39:493rd order consequences are not fully understood or appreciated.
- 39:53Or maybe it's just, it's just, you know, being a bloody server
- 39:57because it's your own bug. All right, moving on slightly.
- 40:02This is kind of related actually in the sense that you know,
- 40:06we've been talking around AI and and sort of the glut of capital
- 40:11spend headed to to that trend or that narrative.
- 40:14And this is a tweet from our our buddy Eric Balkunis talking
- 40:19about wind, solar and general ESGETF closures that have been
- 40:24occurring over the past couple years.
- 40:25And it's sort of accelerating. And so to me, this is, it
- 40:29relates to everything that we're talking about in terms of
- 40:32capital destruction, fads, narratives that ultimately wane.
- 40:37And that's, you know, effectively what we saw with
- 40:38with ESG. A lot of issuers got excited
- 40:40about ESGTFS, this sort of new area of thematic investing.
- 40:46And the reality of it was that, you know, there was no sort of
- 40:50excess return or alpha there. And most of these things ended
- 40:54up underperforming just broader indexes.
- 40:57And so the sort of fad and the narrative around them began to
- 41:00wane. And there was obviously sort of
- 41:03social pressures or social sort of more cultural evolutions that
- 41:07occurred in the ESG space as well.
- 41:10But I just thought this was interesting in light of
- 41:12everything we've been talking around.
- 41:13AI is I think you are even crypto for that matter.
- 41:16You know, I think you could see something similar play out with,
- 41:19you know, all of these ET PS, all these ETS for Doge 2X
- 41:22leverage, you know, all these things that feel very hot and in
- 41:25vogue right now. We could look back in a few
- 41:27years and see a lot of these these things just close as the
- 41:30issuers realize there isn't real demand for them.
- 41:33Yeah. The one thing this reminds me of
- 41:35that I wanted to say on the AI stuff is ultimately it goes back
- 41:41to the the claim of the futures here.
- 41:43It's not evenly distributed in the sense that there is a way to
- 41:46make money on Bitcoin and it means that you understand the
- 41:50tailwinds of what's happening. And then the businesses that are
- 41:55leverage for them in a positive way are going to create meaning
- 41:58like Bitcoin adoption, different things that we'd be seeing in
- 42:00this new world. But if the investor isn't
- 42:04aligned, if they're paying back in dollars or they're investing
- 42:06in ESG or what we just talked about in the CapEx around AI,
- 42:11you're better off holding spot Bitcoin.
- 42:13And then as that price appreciates, the market's going
- 42:15to naturally find it equilibrium where you can get a return on
- 42:18your Bitcoin. And I think that's the like
- 42:21maybe the most, the biggest take away I would leave.
- 42:25And if anybody listening with is like, if the investor doesn't
- 42:28understand what we're talking about or you don't feel
- 42:32confident that like the tailwinds of what their business
- 42:34will produce, you know, especially if a 10 year horizon
- 42:37is going to pay dollars. We don't even know where the
- 42:38dollar is in 10 years. But then going back to if you
- 42:42believe that Bitcoin's going to proliferate AI agents, you know,
- 42:45custody, like whatever it might be, that's going to have a
- 42:48positive spin in in the other side of it.
- 42:50Is it, imagine if it was Tethers, founders, CEOs that
- 42:53we're building something not even adjacent to Bitcoin, but
- 42:55they swept everything in there. I would still take the bet with
- 42:58that because they just are good business builders are efficient
- 43:01and that would produce a higher outcome than what they're
- 43:04spending their money on. But I think that's my big take
- 43:06away is there's going to be a lot of capital in Destroy.
- 43:07It doesn't have to be yours. You can just sit in the
- 43:09background and then wait for the right opportunities.
- 43:11That's what Bitcoin affords. You know you don't get rid of
- 43:14the dollars that are losing purchasing power yearly to
- 43:16figure out to go in a private investment.
- 43:19Yeah, I would say on this one as well.
- 43:21It's just, it didn't make any sense any of the ESG stuff
- 43:24because it came top down from government mandates and then the
- 43:28S&P 500 companies had to make changes in order to be compliant
- 43:33with every rule that they had. And then the ETFs came out of it
- 43:36because it was a trend that of mandated by government.
- 43:39Same thing that you saw over time, especially with too much
- 43:42hype and then capital destroyed from top down mandates from
- 43:44anything from solar and EBS etcetera.
- 43:48On the other side of the one thing that we haven't chatted
- 43:50about is the bottom up demand and the Vanguard now looking
- 43:55into Bitcoin ETFs for their clients as well as other crypto
- 43:59ETFs. We've seen that's just been a
- 44:02bottoms up type demand from all their clients.
- 44:05They've, I don't know what their actual numbers look like, but
- 44:08I'm sure that they saw a number of their clients just net the,
- 44:12the platform because Fidelity, BlackRock, etcetera offered
- 44:15Bitcoin ETFs as well as they just saw that BlackRock is
- 44:19that's their most profitable product is their Bitcoin ETF.
- 44:22And so naturally, it's just going to kind of like we can
- 44:26talk about all the stable coins, etcetera, but it's just going to
- 44:30be natural economic and market forces that are going to drive
- 44:33all of the companies and consumers just who adopt Bitcoin
- 44:38rather than any other savings technology over the long term.
- 44:41It's it's definitely not evenly distributed in terms of
- 44:44knowledge around the asset, but it's just going to increasingly
- 44:47Dr. more and more people into the space.
- 44:49And that's kind of, you know to Michael's point about why you
- 44:53should focus on businesses that are that consumers are actually
- 44:56adopting rather than just top down based on any demands for
- 45:01stable coins and etcetera. Yeah, all that's very well said
- 45:06and and nice transition to this infographic that I wanted to
- 45:10pull up, which sort of just summarized a lot of headlines
- 45:13from the past week or two around trad fi incoming firms, you
- 45:18know, placing their chips on the table in in in terms of, you
- 45:21know, getting their clients access to digital assets,
- 45:24crypto, Bitcoin Vanguard is, you know, one that's very notable in
- 45:28the sense that they for a while were very anti.
- 45:31And I think the ultimately the end client demand, I think
- 45:35probably spurred them to to change their positioning on
- 45:38this. And so now they are going to buy
- 45:41crypto ETF access for their brokerage clients.
- 45:43Some other headlines on here. Morgan Stanley close to offering
- 45:46crypto trading through E*Trade calls it the tip of the iceberg.
- 45:50JP Morgan to enable crypto purchases via credit cards and a
- 45:54Coinbase partnership. BlackRock filed to launch a
- 45:58Bitcoin premium income ETF, which I believe will use a
- 46:01covered call strategy, and Citigroup considers custody and
- 46:06payment services. Charles Schwab plans to launch
- 46:08crypto trading. And Visa announced A partnership
- 46:13with Fold and Stripe to bring Bitcoin credit card rewards to
- 46:16the checkout aisle. Michael, any thoughts on on all
- 46:19these headlines from the past couple weeks?
- 46:22Yeah. I think we made a good point on
- 46:26ultimately what's going to drive market adoption is, you know, a
- 46:29better product and bitcoins just a better product from a store of
- 46:33value. And so these companies are going
- 46:35to be forced to play. I think from a pure market
- 46:39winning and investment perspective, most of these
- 46:41companies don't end up winning long term.
- 46:44And mainly because I've seen this first hand, but it makes
- 46:47sense too, is that Bitcoin really starts at first for these
- 46:51businesses as revenue driver, revenue driver.
- 46:54But unless they hit a certain market penetration in revenue
- 46:57and you could make the case BlackRock could get there or
- 46:59not, their existing businesses will eventually start to compete
- 47:03with them. And unless they can transition
- 47:06fast enough, they start to have to effectively like hamstring or
- 47:16just deliver subpar goods and services.
- 47:19The best example is when you think about custody, because
- 47:22most of these businesses are familiar with how they custody
- 47:25traditional assets. And that's completely different
- 47:28with Bitcoin. And if we go back to bitcoins
- 47:33bottoms up and the best products will win will then eventually
- 47:36these businesses will lose capital because people will go
- 47:39to the best product and service. And something that we've shared
- 47:43a little bit here, the guys have probably heard me say this 100
- 47:45times, but I'll say it again is because Bitcoin was an emergent
- 47:50asset. It started from the individual
- 47:52and worked up and just has to do with being consensus of one that
- 47:55you don't need a, you know, a board or a, you know, you don't
- 47:58need any kind of consortium to to outside of maybe somebody's
- 48:01wife to agree to go and purchase material amounts of Bitcoin.
- 48:05But because of individuals have been in this market for the
- 48:08longest time, they are the most sophisticated investor.
- 48:10I don't think that's ever really happened in any asset, probably
- 48:14outside of just gold monetization hundreds or
- 48:16thousands of years ago. Point being is these companies
- 48:19build products for other companies.
- 48:21They don't build it for the individual and individuals just
- 48:25make up companies. So it's, it's not even logical
- 48:27to say, well, individuals won't hold a bunch of Bitcoin.
- 48:29It'll just be companies like no, no, individuals just have the
- 48:32longest time. So they'll first get to what the
- 48:34best exposure is, But then secondarily the individuals
- 48:38you're made-up of companies. So if the individuals are using
- 48:40it, then why wouldn't the company eventually use it?
- 48:43And so I think that's another just big gap in opportunity
- 48:46because it comes up a lot of like, well, why would an XY or Z
- 48:49just do on ramp when it comes to like BNY?
- 48:51It's like, well, they probably will on a long enough time
- 48:53horizon, but they have no reason to do it at first for like 100
- 48:57different reasons. So that's kind of my big take
- 48:59away with this. I'll pause if you guys have
- 49:02thoughts on that. But then I did want to pull up
- 49:05two other reports that tie into this because I thought they were
- 49:08very interesting that. Yeah.
- 49:11Let's let's move on cuz I know we have a we have a hard stop in
- 49:13a few minutes. So the Y Combinator one, do you
- 49:16want me to? Pull that one before that just
- 49:18on the Tratify stuff. I'll do it real quick.
- 49:21So the first one was BNY Mellon put out a report last week and
- 49:26this wasn't tied to crypto currencies.
- 49:28It was basically titled 2025 investment insights for single
- 49:32family offices. They did a report on I believe
- 49:34284 family offices across all asset classes.
- 49:40The core concept here was on digital assets are becoming
- 49:43mainstream. 74% of investment professionals have either
- 49:46invested in crypto currencies or exploring the possibility 21%
- 49:49rise in 12 months. The share of those with no
- 49:52exposure interest has slumped 30 7% year over year, driven by
- 49:56favorable regulatory developments.
- 49:58And then they have a whole page. And I thought it was so
- 50:01cryptocurrencies. The feature is now nearly 3/4 of
- 50:04family office professionals have either invested in
- 50:06cryptocurrencies or exploring the possibility of 21% increase.
- 50:10So that's the first one. The second one I wanted to share
- 50:13was I know this bank is like not, I don't think they're
- 50:18solvent, but but they're still, you know, name is Deutsche Bank.
- 50:22They had this report that I don't know if anybody's even
- 50:24pulled up yet. I didn't I need to like do a
- 50:26tweet so we can have a link that's easy to go to, but it
- 50:30effectively is breaking down. The title is let me find real
- 50:34quick. So Bitcoin versus gold, the
- 50:36future of central bank reserves by 2030.
- 50:39And the core thing I want to pull out from it here is while
- 50:43gold is long been the standard alternative, the Trump
- 50:46administration's landmark decision to establish AUS
- 50:48strategic reserve this past March reignites the argument for
- 50:51central banks to hold Bitcoin as a reserve asset.
- 50:54And then it shows USD share of central bank reserves versus
- 50:57gold and the, you know, heavy increase in gold over the past.
- 51:01I guess this is 12 months. The point being is that this
- 51:05stuff is like really happening fast now.
- 51:08And you can make the claim it's inflation, it's new regulatory,
- 51:11new administration, whatever it is like it's only going to
- 51:14accelerate from here. And This is why these market
- 51:16cycles and structures completely different from where we're
- 51:19heading. It's just complete uncharted
- 51:21territory. Yeah, we haven't even really
- 51:25chatted gold this episode, which is a shocker.
- 51:28We've been talking cold every week, but new all time highs
- 51:31almost every day. I think we're over 38, 3800 an
- 51:35ounce. And yeah, it's it's indicative
- 51:38of everything we're talking about that that Deutsche Bank
- 51:40note. There's been other research
- 51:42notes and just headlines from a lot of, you know, more Tratify
- 51:46incoming folks that are, you know, at least vocalizing
- 51:50support for, you know, material allocations to gold, right.
- 51:54So not the not the typical 1 to 3% that we've seen for many
- 51:58decades in the Tratify space as sort of this doom and gloom end
- 52:02of the world type hedge in portfolios.
- 52:06Now it's being talked about in a much different light.
- 52:09You know, anywhere from 15 to 25% in gold being talked about
- 52:13is reasonable. And as as we've discussed many
- 52:15times on the show, that is just the natural evolution of things
- 52:19that, you know, how we get people ultimately to Bitcoin is
- 52:22by first, first understanding that there's a, there's a stop,
- 52:25you know, a spot in portfolios for sound money, for hard assets
- 52:30with gold obviously having the longest track record as such.
- 52:33And so encouraging to see a lot of those headlines and, and
- 52:38people vocalizing this because I think it's, it's just more and
- 52:41more in the zeitgeist everyday, particularly as gold continues
- 52:44to run here. We have many thoughts.
- 52:48I know I did want to. I'll pull up this South Korea
- 52:52update deal because I know you, I know you had some thoughts on
- 52:54that. Yeah there was just I mean in
- 52:58addition to everything that we've just been talking about
- 53:00about tried by adopting Bitcoin S I'm definitely no expert on
- 53:05South Korea and their regulatory structure, but it seems like
- 53:08they're getting more and more open to digital assets the whole
- 53:13there and there's this deal is pretty interesting to me so up
- 53:17it is the largest crypto exchange in South Korea.
- 53:20It seems like they have around 80% market share and neighbor is
- 53:24a Internet e-commerce as well as payments and financial platform
- 53:28over there. It seems like they're worth
- 53:30about $40 billion USD and this deal is interesting to me
- 53:34because they're not true a traditional bank, but they're
- 53:37more of a payments company as well as a little bit of lending
- 53:40too. And they are buying a crypto
- 53:44exchange. I know outside of the US there's
- 53:47a lot more focused on just crypto in general rather than
- 53:50just Bitcoin only. And so I thought this was
- 53:53particularly interesting as we see everything from cracking
- 53:56and, and all those other digital asset companies here in the US
- 53:59starting to go public. But it's also interesting that
- 54:03there are natural exit opportunities of just
- 54:06traditional payments companies. They, they have a large amount,
- 54:09they're essentially like the one of the blocks or squares over in
- 54:13South Korea, a lot of online payment terminals as well as in
- 54:17person almost like a stripe as well.
- 54:20And so it was interesting, I think that they're probably
- 54:23doing it to incorporate stable points deeper into the usage of
- 54:28their platform in order to reduce costs as well as just
- 54:30continue to gain market share and and hedge on their bets.
- 54:33But to Michelle point earlier, I think that this is kind of just
- 54:36a a competition of their business internally.
- 54:40And I don't think that these types of buyers are necessarily
- 54:43going to be the ones who survive long term.
- 54:45But it is interesting to see the aperture of potential buyers for
- 54:51digital asset based companies open up wider than banks and
- 54:55other financial institutions in terms of just that that hold
- 54:59capital. And I think that's a sign to
- 55:01come of everything that's that's coming in the US soon as well.
- 55:07Yeah, maybe this ties into that last link is the main 1 Brian,
- 55:12the the YC you don't have to play the clip, but if you just
- 55:14pull up the the video, I think to yeah.
- 55:19So this is AYC most recent podcast.
- 55:22Why now the time is to build in crypto and it's with the base, I
- 55:25don't know founder, whoever runs that unit at Coinbase.
- 55:31It goes to a few things. 1 is like, I do think we're going to
- 55:34see, we'll see some premium on Bitcoin companies, but really
- 55:37that premium is going to be lifted.
- 55:38I think in the, the downturn of the next cycle when people
- 55:41recognize that a lot of this stuff was like lipstick on a pig
- 55:45because you naturally need a lot of like risk management and
- 55:48conservative building if you're messing with money, especially
- 55:50digit and digitally native money.
- 55:53And on this podcast, they were referencing, you know, these use
- 55:57cases that actually make a lot of sense when it comes to like
- 56:00areas of focus that I don't think Bitcoin is really focused
- 56:03at A, at a, you know, best in class scale.
- 56:06When you think about YC and, and Silicon Valley went better
- 56:09buying experience, social lending scale, networks, creator
- 56:11economy, a lot of these things that have been niche deals, I
- 56:14think will eventually win on Bitcoin.
- 56:18But then they obviously like missed the boat on like how the
- 56:20rails will be run. And a good example was
- 56:22referencing how there's interesting opportunities now
- 56:25for local Fiat currency, stable coins.
- 56:27And it's like, well, who wants their local Fiat currency and
- 56:29the stable coin? It just makes zero sense.
- 56:33But the other thing that ties into where I think a premium
- 56:36ends up with the Bitcoin companies and it's really widely
- 56:39missed in this space is I didn't know that Balaji had this tweet
- 56:43or a presentation at the Bitcoin Magazine conference referencing
- 56:46that somewhere between 100K and $1,000,000 Bitcoin, that Bitcoin
- 56:50billionaires will eclipse billionaires on the planet
- 56:54Earth. And why that's interesting.
- 56:57Whether it's 500,000 million dollars is as long as we have a
- 57:00long term time horizon, believe that number will get there, then
- 57:02that will happen. It's probably not at the exact
- 57:05number because the other person's assets are also, you
- 57:08know, increasing in dollar terms.
- 57:12But the point being is nobody's focused on that.
- 57:14Nobody's focused on where do they hold the underlying.
- 57:17They're focused on stable coins are focused on crypto.
- 57:19But that underlying base, well, that individual is gonna
- 57:22naturally not only need financial services, but if that
- 57:25asset is increasing, well then there's gonna be more
- 57:27monetization around that base asset.
- 57:30It's just a huge gap. It's obviously something we
- 57:31focus on, but I think that's like a huge opportunity.
- 57:34Well, everyone's focused on payments and E cash and all this
- 57:36other stuff. It's like, how do you get your
- 57:38arms wrapped around the client that's holding the underline?
- 57:40Because that is who's going to dictate the future of where that
- 57:43money goes, how it gets spent lent and everything above and
- 57:46below. Yep.
- 57:49Very well said. The the primary use case is
- 57:52store value and that will continue to be the case for the
- 57:55foreseeable future. Any parting thoughts?
- 57:59I know we got a wrap here. Good Rep.
- 58:02We got to do them quick now. Next time that was.
- 58:05I thought that was a good one. Good tight wrap.
- 58:08Thanks. Boys, thanks.
- 58:09Next week, thanks for listening to this week's episode of the
- 58:16show. If you found the information
- 58:17valuable, please share the episode with a friend or leave a
- 58:20rating on your favorite podcast app.
- 58:22All the links we discussed in today's show will be in the show
- 58:24notes inside your podcast app. Before we finish, a quick
- 58:27reminder that Onramp Media is for informational and
- 58:29entertainment purposes only, and nothing should be construed as
- 58:32investment or legal advice. Regardless of where you are on
- 58:35your Bitcoin journey, we'd love to hear from you.
- 58:38Visit onrampbitcoin.com contact to schedule a consultation with
- 58:42one of our private client advisors.