Latest / Onramp Bitcoin Media / Assassination Markets, AI Layoffs & Paper Bitcoin | THE ₿ROADCAST EP. 25 with Matt Odell
Transcript
- 0:00All right everyone, welcome to the broadcast Part 25.
- 0:03This is where we catch up on news, tweets, videos, charts,
- 0:06trends, and any other Bitcoin related content that stood out
- 0:09to us in the past two weeks. Usually I'm here with Michael
- 0:13and Brian, but we have Matt O'dell as a special guest.
- 0:16Welcome, Matt. Thanks for having me.
- 0:19We had to bring in Matt because the vibes are really low right
- 0:22now. You know, if I knew we signed up
- 0:24for this pod to do it all 2026 and the price is going to be
- 0:27here, maybe would have rethought it.
- 0:29So we needed Odell to spice up whatever the Hell's happening.
- 0:33Yeah, and it's some fun and it's funny because I said, you know
- 0:36everything that stood out to us with Bitcoin and the first thing
- 0:40that Matt brought in was a a Poly market chart.
- 0:43So what's up with that? Over the weekend, we basically
- 0:50saw the first high volume legitimate assassination market
- 0:57that's ever existed in humanity. It's something that a lot of us
- 1:01have been theorizing for a while in terms of prediction markets.
- 1:05Prediction markets have had difficulty bootstrapping in
- 1:11practice until Polly Market came around.
- 1:13And specifically under this new administration, Polly Market was
- 1:17under basically under attack by Biden.
- 1:20The CEO and founder had his apartment rated, but as soon as
- 1:23Trump got in, it was like off to the races.
- 1:25And now they have tons of volume.
- 1:28And they had a market over the weekend.
- 1:29That was basically when will the Ayatollah be out of Iran?
- 1:35And as soon as war broke out, it actually turned into an
- 1:38assassination market while everyone was basically betting
- 1:41on whether or not he had been killed or not.
- 1:43And that market concluded because he got killed and people
- 1:47were paid out. It was over $100 million in
- 1:49volume on that market. And now, now they launched a new
- 1:54market who will be the next supreme leader of Iran?
- 1:57And it's basic, but they all keep getting killed by air
- 2:00strikes. So it's basically a another
- 2:03assassination market that they launched.
- 2:05And people are betting on who survives to take over.
- 2:10So theory has become reality. Obviously Polymarket is running,
- 2:13running on a shit coin network, but you can deposit Bitcoin.
- 2:19It is you know, I would I would still consider it a Bitcoin app,
- 2:23probably one of the most successful Bitcoin apps of all
- 2:25time. And just a quick high level of
- 2:27why I think prediction markets are interesting.
- 2:29You know, they get a lot of shit because insiders are trading
- 2:31them and and they definitely bet benefit insiders.
- 2:34If you're trading them, they benefit insiders, but if you're
- 2:37tracking them, they benefit outsiders because it basically
- 2:40provides an incentive for insiders to leak information to
- 2:43the broader public so that we have better quality information
- 2:47to work off of. So I think they're fascinating
- 2:50and I think particularly seeing a $10 billion plus valued
- 2:53company that has investment from New York Stock Exchange running
- 2:57assassination markets at high volume is absolutely wild and
- 3:01the single biggest story of the week.
- 3:03So I don't mean to put. You on the spot.
- 3:06But I have questions about prediction markets because
- 3:08you're the only individual that I interact with.
- 3:11That's like keeping me up to speed that these things exist.
- 3:14I mean, I know they're, they exist and they're, they're
- 3:16growing. But I'm curious based on like
- 3:18your knowledge and also thinking adversarially, like what's the
- 3:21angle why they're proliferating? Because I know like obviously
- 3:23new admin and they were allowed, but there feels like some other
- 3:27version of, I don't call it a psyop, but like, how do, how
- 3:31does the the machine benefit from like these markets?
- 3:34Because I feel like that's part of the story of why they're
- 3:37proliferating and where they'll continue to grow.
- 3:40Because theoretically these things could have existed five
- 3:42years ago, 10 years ago, even offshore, they could have gained
- 3:45this kind of steam. They they didn't.
- 3:47And there's a reason why now they're like NYSNYSSE, right?
- 3:52ICE owns a piece of of them. So like, what's your take if you
- 3:56have one on that? Yeah.
- 3:59I mean, look, I think there's a couple things.
- 4:00First of all, for these things to be accurate, you need to be
- 4:05able to bet in size anonymously. Why is that?
- 4:10Because they once again to for it to benefit external onlookers
- 4:15to watch, insiders have to be able to profit off of it.
- 4:19And an insider can't profit off of it if they're KYC, Ed and
- 4:22docs, right? Because then they'll lose their
- 4:24job or lose their government position or what not.
- 4:27So you need to be able to bet on it anonymously.
- 4:30I think also at size users need to have some assurances that it
- 4:38will be objective in how it concludes the market, right.
- 4:40If you if you bet $10 million that that there an airstrike
- 4:46happens and an airstrike happens, you don't get paid out,
- 4:48then all of a sudden that really hurts the credibility of the
- 4:51markets. So as a result, you needed to be
- 4:53at least relatively decentralized, right, to have
- 4:57the anonymity and to have the ability to to have good robust
- 5:02guarantees on payouts. So so that's why we haven't
- 5:05really seen them yet. And I mean, the founder does, I
- 5:09think deserves a lot of credit for how he designed Polymarket.
- 5:12Is it perfect? No.
- 5:13Is there still central centralized elements to it?
- 5:16Yes. We saw, bought the body
- 5:17administration nearly crushed the thing.
- 5:20And it's because there's people involved, right?
- 5:21And when there's people involved, you go after the
- 5:23people, you don't go after the actual protocol.
- 5:26But that's why it took so long for them to even have like the
- 5:31tech that like mostly worked to make it possible.
- 5:35And then in terms of like, if you want to like go a little bit
- 5:38deeper in terms of you said sigh up or conspiracy, like where
- 5:42does the deep state benefit from it?
- 5:43I mean, I think the deep state has a long history of incubating
- 5:48technology that provides them more data points and more
- 5:51information, whether that's something like Facebook, whether
- 5:54that's something like SpaceX with Starlink, whether that's
- 5:57something like the Tor Project Bitcoin, right?
- 6:03I, so I mean, I think they get a big advantage here, right?
- 6:06I mean, if we can go like the rabbit hole is so deep, which is
- 6:10why I think it's fascinating. But if, if, if the powers that
- 6:15be want to know what's happening on the front lines of Ukraine,
- 6:19there's an incentive for Russian soldiers that are poorly paid to
- 6:24open up their phones and bet on the markets actively.
- 6:27And they have active markets for the small skirmishes that are
- 6:29happening across the front lines.
- 6:31And people have made websites that basically chart the
- 6:35different projected probability outcomes of all those battles so
- 6:38you can get a better idea of it. And who even knows what Palantir
- 6:41has like Palantir is probably combing this data like crazy.
- 6:45So I, I think, I think the data is, is probably a, a super good
- 6:50reason why they would want that. And we saw with the elections,
- 6:53for instance, polls are often inaccurate.
- 6:55But when people have skin in the game and they actually need to
- 6:57put real money on the line, they tend to be more, much more
- 7:00accurate results. Are they perfect?
- 7:01No, but it's it's the most accurate signal we've ever had.
- 7:06Yeah, that makes sense. I, I agree with that.
- 7:09Like I, like I just told you before we recorded and I've
- 7:12shared this before about that. I think this is probably the
- 7:14best application of, of crypto that we've seen since 10 years,
- 7:19you know, over since, since since inception, like you said,
- 7:22Freedom of Information plus freedom of capital.
- 7:24But I think also what another thought I have is this does feel
- 7:30like we're in this Idiocracy type phase.
- 7:34You know, I, I don't know if you saw this, this video today that
- 7:37the White House tweeted that they, I don't know, they made it
- 7:40with VO3 or some sort of AI video creation tool, which was
- 7:45just I don't know. No, I had to think of Idiocracy.
- 7:47It's just so it's crazy that, you know, you call it an
- 7:52assassination. What did you say?
- 7:55Assassination market, right? But it's also just ridiculous
- 7:59entertainment in a sense, right? Like it really feels like
- 8:02Idiocracy. And I also think that this is
- 8:04even a new layer of entertainment in terms of, you
- 8:08know, war, violence and stuff like that.
- 8:10You had military movies and stuff before kind of to
- 8:13desensitize people towards war and stuff like that.
- 8:16But here, I mean, if you can make money, if your guy gets
- 8:19fucking bombed, that's next. That's next level entertainment
- 8:25in a different way. I would say so.
- 8:27So I also think it's kind of also kind of has something to do
- 8:33with that, that it's just everything becomes a game and
- 8:36nothing really seems super serious or deep anymore.
- 8:41But I think we'll we'll get to that.
- 8:44We have some stuff about Iran, but you know, it is actually
- 8:48pretty serious and you're not seeing everything on the news,
- 8:51right? Plus, you know, if you have this
- 8:53kind of entertainment around these types of events, then, you
- 8:56know, I, I wonder how many people actually pay serious
- 8:59attention to to stuff that's happening right now.
- 9:01Yeah, just the the thing to touch on, I don't have a lot
- 9:04there, but is that is like Primo slot from the government.
- 9:08Yesterday I saw one of the what was it?
- 9:10Twitter's like what the F exists?
- 9:11And I was like, I had to click it because the the tweet and
- 9:15it's just like quoting like Rocky and Maverick Top Gun or
- 9:19whatever. And they're just like bombing
- 9:21things from movies. It's pretty wild.
- 9:26It dude, it's super wild. I'm trying to ah here.
- 9:29I got it. I got it.
- 9:30Wait, look. Wake up.
- 9:32Daddy, Sean, welcome dog son, strengthen on us.
- 9:35Strengthen on. What will you do without
- 9:37freedom? Mavericks in doubt.
- 9:43You can't conceive of what I'm capable of finishing this fight.
- 9:48Yeah, I'm thinking on fact. Here to fight the truth.
- 9:52And justice the American way. I am the danger time.
- 9:56To find out maximum effort, sure, here it comes.
- 10:08Sorry about what? I'm a European dude.
- 10:11That's the. Official White House Twitter
- 10:14account too. You should honestly scare people
- 10:16because like the only take I have from that is revving up the
- 10:20like war engine to get a bunch of people.
- 10:23Of course you know. Which is like get get you
- 10:26excited with fucking memes, dude, That's crazy.
- 10:30That's crazy. OK, I think this is a fun
- 10:36bewilderment in a sense, right? Even if you think it's crazy,
- 10:39you know, imagine the reaction of the people on my side of the
- 10:44ocean. But yeah, All right, let's,
- 10:46let's move on to the next one. Maybe something lighter and
- 10:49maybe something darker. Actually, Mike, you, you had
- 10:53this one. Yeah, I mean, I thought this was
- 10:56fascinating because my dogs were working.
- 11:02I thought it was just fascinating because nobody,
- 11:04everyone is feeling like what's happening with AI and their
- 11:07jobs, but then they just like continue the CEO all the way
- 11:12down to put out research on like who's actually screwed and how
- 11:14quickly. But also the key take away from
- 11:20here that I was thinking about was that like this world we
- 11:23lived in. We know that because the money
- 11:25was broken, that we, the, the foundations like faulty, like
- 11:28what was or what what was isn't there.
- 11:31We live in this anomaly with Fiat and there's all these like
- 11:34constructs that came from it that are just going to get
- 11:36evaporated and we're always going to.
- 11:39But with like AI, they're just, it's probably going to happen a
- 11:41lot quicker because all these jobs shouldn't exist.
- 11:43You know, square blocks shouldn't have had 10,000
- 11:46people. Google shouldn't have whatever
- 11:47number. But like, now this is just going
- 11:50to dissolve it faster, especially because the money's
- 11:52breaking and margins are compressing because of
- 11:54inflation. That it's just a crazy thing to
- 11:58be like, this is at the forefront.
- 12:00I know everyone here kind of works independently and is kind
- 12:02of in charge of their own destiny, especially because
- 12:04they've been holding a Bitcoin. But just like, put yourself in
- 12:06the shoes of working at McKenzie your whole life or being a
- 12:09corporate bank man. And you know, this stuff's
- 12:12coming in the same way. You know, like geopolitical
- 12:14uncertainty, US uncertainty is there and now your job's
- 12:18uncertain, but you have no angle on how to actually play it
- 12:21because most people don't have agency.
- 12:23It's just a crazy time. Any thoughts, Matt?
- 12:31It's definitely not priced in. I think we live in our own
- 12:35little bubble. I think also people is
- 12:39interesting, right? Anthropic is it it flips on on
- 12:45who is the most successful of these big AI companies at any
- 12:49given time, like who's the most effective?
- 12:51And I mean, Anthropic has been on a tear lately.
- 12:53Their models have been outperforming everyone else.
- 12:57So they very much have the spotlight and, and them
- 13:01specifically their CEO Dario is one of these effective
- 13:06altruists. He was like basically buddies
- 13:07with SPF of FTXI mean SPF invested in Anthropic, I think
- 13:13very early, maybe even the seed round for instance.
- 13:17And so he very much has like this woke protectionism
- 13:20regulation mindset, and he's definitely trying to build a
- 13:23regulatory mode around himself. So that's why he very much leans
- 13:26into the research of we're going to kill these jobs.
- 13:29We're going to have AGI. We think our AI models have
- 13:32consciousness. You know, some, some of them are
- 13:35like absolutely ludicrous. But the job loss thing is not.
- 13:39We're seeing a substantive change, a paradigm shift in how
- 13:44people will work and what jobs are valuable and what jobs are
- 13:48commoditized. And it really hasn't hit
- 13:50markets. But that was very long winded.
- 13:52And one of the reasons I went into that context is because a
- 13:55lot of the other AI guys are going the opposite route because
- 13:59they don't want discontent, they don't want riots, they don't
- 14:02want revolutions as they make their billions of dollars.
- 14:05And Elon, for instance, keeps telling people that they're
- 14:07going to have universal high income and everything's going to
- 14:10be great. Don't you worry about a thing.
- 14:12You don't have to take personal responsibility.
- 14:14You don't have to take agency. So you have a combination of,
- 14:17first of all, people not paying attention and second of all,
- 14:19listening to the wrong people and we're kind of sleepwalking
- 14:23into this thing. I think there's very few of us
- 14:25that are actually thinking about it.
- 14:27I think block firing 4000 people was the tip of the iceberg.
- 14:32I think that wasn't purely AI related, as you kind of alluded
- 14:35to. I think it's absolutely insane
- 14:37that he had 10,000 employees to begin with.
- 14:39What were they all fucking doing?
- 14:41But if you start multiplying that against the S&P 500, you're
- 14:46talking about billions of dollars of consumer spending
- 14:49that is not entering the economy.
- 14:51And those, a lot of those people are unhireable.
- 14:53Like I don't, I, I always go back to that COVID video that
- 14:58went viral of like the two women who are like product managers,
- 15:01like sitting in there sitting in a pool and like a Ibiza or
- 15:04whatever, talking about how they do no work all day.
- 15:06Like those people are never getting hired again.
- 15:08They have no, no useful skills. And you just extrapolate that
- 15:13across the entire economy, and we're in for a big world of
- 15:16hurt, I think. Yeah.
- 15:17Just real quick from two things on that.
- 15:19One, you wouldn't hire them to walk your dog and then 2 is in a
- 15:23vacuum. If it was just those layoffs,
- 15:25they might have been OK, especially in a pre kind of 5%
- 15:28or whatever interest rate world. But now how many of that 5000
- 15:33gets hired less than probably 10% and then you multiply that
- 15:36times multiple companies and then the soft job market.
- 15:39The other thing that's worth noting, it is very interesting
- 15:42because I didn't think about it, but you you called it with like
- 15:45Dario sane versus Sam Altman because he right after I think
- 15:49it was the blocks layoff was like this is BS.
- 15:51They're using it as a scapegoat that it's AI that these
- 15:55companies just over hired. So there's that own like
- 15:57internal AI dynamic on like how much they want themselves to be
- 16:01the boogeyman or AII. Think that I think that's a
- 16:06great point. It's, it's funny, right?
- 16:11It's, it's I'm thinking about some similarity to to Bitcoin.
- 16:15I, I always think, you know, like, let's say a trust in the
- 16:20dollar or, you know, for example, in the euro falls
- 16:23further. I definitely see Christine
- 16:25Lagarde say at some point, you know, it's these people that are
- 16:28into crypto and into bitcoins that, you know, make other
- 16:31people lose trust in the currencies and, and they are,
- 16:34they are the bad person, right. But you know, fucking Christine
- 16:37Lagarde is following policy of debasing a currency into
- 16:41oblivion, right? But she's pointing outside and
- 16:44I'm, I'm, I'm thinking something similar here as to to what you
- 16:48said, Mike, I, you know, this technology is inevitable.
- 16:52The acceleration is inevitable. I think in a, in a, in a on, on
- 16:57a macro level. I last week I read an article
- 17:01about how the tension between US developed models and the US kind
- 17:07of like business approach with which is basically kind of like
- 17:10classic SAS type, right? You have a, you have a monthly
- 17:14payment or a yearly payment and you have like these tiers,
- 17:16etcetera. And you see people switch easily
- 17:20between models, right? So like today there's this new
- 17:23GPT model and people are like, well, you should switch over
- 17:26again. So a lot of people, I mean, I'm
- 17:28I'm paying Gemini open AI and and entropic, right, all three,
- 17:35But I also paid for for cursor. I skipped that.
- 17:38I paid for perplexity. Now I skipped that, but the
- 17:40Chinese strategy is, is very different.
- 17:45They just open source everything, which is fascinating
- 17:47by the way, from a for, for Chinese, they're open sourcing
- 17:51and they're just, you know, putting it, putting it out
- 17:53there. And you have this Quen model,
- 17:55which I think is at the level of Opus 4.6, right?
- 17:58So their, their whole strategy is to just acquire more, more
- 18:02people. So there's these different,
- 18:04there's like a, there's like a open source versus capitalist
- 18:07type of thing going on where again, like I said, the, the
- 18:11Chinese are, are going at the open source angle.
- 18:13So my point is this technology is inevitable.
- 18:17But like you said, Mike, I fully agree that they're going to
- 18:20externalize the logical result of of this, which is, you know,
- 18:28everything a person who's sitting behind a computer can
- 18:31do, an agent with a 200 IQ can do while living in the computer
- 18:38and making an infinite amount of offspring on the on the same
- 18:42device, right. So I mean, you're already seeing
- 18:44that and the writing is on the wall.
- 18:46But I think your point to to this, this kind of like
- 18:49outsourcing of the of the blame, It's probably, probably correct.
- 18:54Yeah, one thing. To call out like what Matt was
- 18:56saying about polymarket, there's something around selling like
- 18:59the seas of descent and allowing that to proliferate.
- 19:03I think if that is part of the strategy with China and the open
- 19:06source nature, because I don't think it's about acquiring more
- 19:09people. It's about when you have the
- 19:11whole US like whatever GDP is risen because of AI investment
- 19:14and if you get effectively like deflate that because everyone
- 19:17can have that locally run. I downloaded coin the other day.
- 19:20It's not 4.6, but it can run on a daily driver laptop.
- 19:23It's pretty insane without latency because the other stuff
- 19:26like Mama, the other, I forgot what the other one was.
- 19:30They were just like like he couldn't do it.
- 19:32It was unrelatable to like the frontier stuff.
- 19:35And so I think it's a similar angle there.
- 19:37There's just like second and third degree angles around
- 19:40what's happening that like we don't see.
- 19:44And then the other, the, the most fascinating thing I know,
- 19:46Matt, you thought about this is like AI and Bitcoin are so
- 19:50similarly disruptive, but also embraced by so few people.
- 19:56Like these numbers aren't exact, but directionally they're pretty
- 19:59close. Is basically .01% of the human
- 20:01population has any material exposure to Bitcoin where it
- 20:04would hurt if they lost it in the same way .01% of total
- 20:07humanities using any of these tools where it would really hurt
- 20:10if they got them shut down. Like I know you guys felt it
- 20:13when what other data centers were getting bombed and like
- 20:16Anthropic was down. You're like, holy shit, I
- 20:17couldn't. I was trying to work, but
- 20:19there's just so few people on either side of that that.
- 20:23There's like, it's almost like anxiety inducing because you're
- 20:25like, the rest of the world's going to catch up to this and
- 20:28how insane is the world going to look when everyone's doing this?
- 20:32Yeah, I mean, I was talking to a Bitcoiner that's much smarter
- 20:37than me, and the way he described it, I thought was
- 20:41fascinating and a good way to describe it.
- 20:43Basically, he's an investor much, you know, a sophisticated
- 20:49investor outside of Bitcoin, and he discovered Bitcoin very early
- 20:53and held a good bag. But the way he looks at it is he
- 20:58looks at it any given time, you kind of have a dot plot of
- 21:00potential future outcomes. So you can like imagine like a
- 21:04dot plot chart with time as the X axis and you have all these
- 21:10different scenarios that can happen and where we end up in
- 21:13three years, five years, 10 years, 20 years.
- 21:16And because of AI, that dot plot has never been larger than it is
- 21:20right now. Nobody has any idea where we're
- 21:23going to be in five years. And because of that, I think if
- 21:27anyone who's paying attention, it creates a level of insomnia,
- 21:31paranoia. You feel like you can't keep up.
- 21:34You're like trying to keep up. You're trying to be prepared,
- 21:36but it's impossible to be prepared because you have no
- 21:37idea what's coming next. And, but also at the same time
- 21:42that that level of chaos brings a lot of opportunity.
- 21:45So for, for a certain group of people that seize the moment, it
- 21:50can be absolutely life changing. But for the overwhelming
- 21:54majority of people, I think the chaotic transition is going to
- 21:57be quite painful. And I do not think markets have
- 22:00realized that yet. I don't think most participants
- 22:02have realized that yet. And it's a very, it's a grim
- 22:06realization to come to right. So the mind doesn't want to
- 22:10conclude that that is what is actually playing out, but we're
- 22:13seeing it happen real time. Yeah, I always find it super
- 22:18interesting that like each technological progression
- 22:22basically puts more energy in a smaller package.
- 22:28And the people that's noticed that are always the ones that
- 22:34profit from it, despite the kind of like drawdowns or obvious
- 22:40obstacles that arise, right? So I'm thinking about like,
- 22:43let's say the first people that that had a, had a car, like in
- 22:46the early days of a car, there were like people walking in
- 22:49front of a car announcing that there was a car coming, right,
- 22:53to protect the people that were still walking on the street.
- 22:57And there were all, you know, there's always people that look
- 22:59at you, you know, in disgust or whatever, like, oh, you're using
- 23:04this for that or you're, you're making a, you know, sure that
- 23:07there's job loss or whatever, whatever the negative impact is
- 23:11of, of a new technology. But it's never been a bad idea
- 23:15to adopt A new technology where you can clearly see that it is a
- 23:221000 or I think in the, in the AI in, in, in the case of AI,
- 23:26it's like it's like 1000 X or maybe even a 10,000 X, right?
- 23:30Like when I do deep research with Claude, it researches 1000
- 23:35sources in 14 minutes. Like dude, that's that's that's
- 23:40like 3 full time jobs or something for some for some for
- 23:43some. Yeah, and it would take them
- 23:45like a week. Well, not only to research, but
- 23:49to actually, you know, analyze and synthesize and yeah, yeah,
- 23:52like, like all that stuff, right.
- 23:53So. So how many people would you
- 23:55need to conduct the same research and get to the same
- 24:00insights from relevant sources? Yeah, I, I and.
- 24:07Also, it's the worst that it'll ever be today and I'm already
- 24:10mind blown right, so the. Thing that it makes.
- 24:13A deal with underestimation. The thing that makes it really
- 24:16messed up in, I'm sure you guys have thought about it, but I
- 24:19don't know if you like put it together like this is that we
- 24:23live obviously like it like the market, free market wins, but
- 24:27the free market and the like high agency people haven't
- 24:30necessarily had all these tools. And so it's similar like to
- 24:34Bitcoin and the term like gunpowder and it's asymmetry.
- 24:37You can't actually insulate yourself from it.
- 24:39So historically, people could be like, I don't really want to
- 24:41adopt the next thing. Can't opt out.
- 24:45Yeah, you can't opt out. Somebody's going to go adopt it
- 24:47and then they're going to steal your market share from all these
- 24:50different things, whether it's SEO optimization, like being
- 24:52able to undercut you on price, doing more with less.
- 24:54So you're basically like screwed either way.
- 24:56You just basically you're going to turn either Amish or you got
- 25:00to like figure out a participate and if you fit in the middle
- 25:02ground, you're basically screwed because that's just there's not
- 25:05going to be room for average effectively.
- 25:07By the way, you just accidentally said something that
- 25:12just shows how you know, big of a change is coming that we don't
- 25:17even really. That's just hard to comprehend.
- 25:18And that's the words SEO optimization.
- 25:22First of all, humans will not be doing it.
- 25:23But the next question I have is what does quote UN quote search
- 25:27engine optimization look like? What does search engines look
- 25:30like in a future where it's mostly agents doing everything?
- 25:34It doesn't look like it does today.
- 25:36It might have a completely different term in the 1st place.
- 25:38It might have completely different objectives by
- 25:39whoever's running it. I mean, I think directionally a
- 25:44decent analogy is what China did and outsourcing did to blue
- 25:49collar jobs. This is going to do to white
- 25:51collar jobs. I don't think it captures the
- 25:55pure craziness of what's about to happen, but it's a, it's a
- 25:59directionally correct analogy. And even even if it's just that
- 26:03level, which is quite simple, that's like a quite simple
- 26:05level. The jobs are being outsourced to
- 26:08computers. That's devastating.
- 26:12And it doesn't have to be everyone unemployed.
- 26:13Unemployment jumps up 6%, seven percent, 8%, and you have really
- 26:18significant effects happening to the global economy.
- 26:21And you can say rightfully so as well, because that's the one
- 26:24thing I didn't mention on that chart.
- 26:25It was like the notion of there's been inversion, right?
- 26:28The crazy people, the Luddites, the gold bugs weren't wrong.
- 26:31There was just a time scale. And again, being too early is
- 26:34the same as being wrong. But in this new world, the
- 26:36welder, the plumber, the people that you can't kind of like
- 26:41strip out because of AI are the people that are going to be able
- 26:43to make the money. And this also ties to the global
- 26:46perspective because like energies neither created nor
- 26:48destroyed. So if we destroy a bunch of
- 26:50white collar jobs that have been here, it's actually going to
- 26:53move to a bunch of other places that have Internet connections
- 26:56via Starlink or whatever and have access to AI frontier
- 26:58models. Somebody's going to benefit from
- 27:01this. And so a lot of times we look at
- 27:02it from a Western view, when in reality this is a global
- 27:04phenomenon and a lot of people are actually going to get a
- 27:06fighting chance at survival as well.
- 27:09The only thing is, like when Mark Zuckerberg took advantage
- 27:14of the Internet, he brought along for the ride, you know,
- 27:18100,000 people or whatever. I don't know what their employee
- 27:20base is. I know Google right now has
- 27:22190,000 employees, right? So when Sergey and Larry took
- 27:27advantage of a fundamental technology shift and became
- 27:31absolutely filthy rich, they brought along a whole subclass
- 27:35of people that also did quite well for themselves.
- 27:39But in this situation, you could have, you know, one to 10
- 27:44people, 100 people that do really, really fucking well, and
- 27:47they bring nobody up with them. It's fucking crazy to think
- 27:52about. Well, I have, I have a poll, I
- 27:57have an item later about AI and, and, and Bitcoin and I agree, I
- 28:03agree with you. But it also, I don't know if
- 28:07these are the right words, but it's also kind of like healthy
- 28:11cleansing in, in, you know, in, in like a Fiat driven economy.
- 28:16Like you said, this video of these two women in the pool,
- 28:19right? Like I'm a product manager, you
- 28:21know, it's it's it's also kind of the decadence that comes in a
- 28:28Fiat driven money system where yeah, there's just money, you
- 28:33know, in in nominal terms. The question I think is, is
- 28:38there is there value, right? And if there is a new way of
- 28:43being more productive I see a link or is this?
- 28:47The link play the video. Yeah, I'll play it.
- 28:50I don't. Want to get in trouble in saying
- 28:52what they should be doing, but like, that's the point of what
- 28:54Brahm's saying and the cleansing is like.
- 28:56Maybe they should have been doing something else and other
- 28:58people should do other things. Yeah.
- 29:00This was the top. This is like Marty.
- 29:02This is the top. That is job marketing world.
- 29:05Yeah. Job.
- 29:07So anyways, this is our current workstation.
- 29:11Callie and I are what you call product managers.
- 29:14Callie, what is your team over? My team is over reporting and
- 29:20personal tools and I am over what we call card experience.
- 29:25So we work on like anything from activating your credit card to
- 29:30freezing, reissue shipping, all the good stuff.
- 29:36What's APM? We help prioritize and help the
- 29:43engineers see on track. And help them know what to
- 29:46build. I don't think the engineers like
- 29:48working with her. I can promise like that.
- 29:50She didn't sound too confident in her project management
- 29:53skills. Yeah, well, you know what?
- 29:56I love it. It is.
- 29:57It is literally like I, I don't think I, I don't know if I
- 30:03mentioned this to you, Mike, but I have this friend and we're
- 30:05always tinkering here in this office with AI and stuff like
- 30:08that. And we have, you know, in an
- 30:10evening, we're just fucking around and we saw this video of
- 30:13Eric Schmidt and he said, yeah, that's so crazy.
- 30:17Like, nowadays you can just tell an agent to read all of
- 30:20chemistry and then you can do stuff.
- 30:22And we just looked at each other and they were like, read all of
- 30:25chemistry. What does that mean?
- 30:27Right. Like what what does that imply?
- 30:29What what can you do when you can have an agent that just
- 30:32reads all of chemistry or reads all of physics?
- 30:35And then we were kind of debating whether, you know, a
- 30:38super curious, playful, open minded entrepreneur type person
- 30:44with five agents that read all of chemistry could actually go
- 30:48further than, you know, 5 pH DS who all read different types of
- 30:52information and synthesized it in a different way and just have
- 30:55a human experience with ego and, you know, all all these things,
- 30:58you know, could you go further than those five, you know, pH DS
- 31:05for for example? And our, our, you know, our
- 31:08conclusion was totally, you know, and they said.
- 31:12No, it's not. It's not the.
- 31:14You don't think so? I know no.
- 31:16It's not because AI is just a frag, it's just a mirror into if
- 31:20somebody's the highest level, they will come up with other
- 31:24things for the AI to do to like tie.
- 31:27It's the same idea of like you. Know without AI meaning without
- 31:32the without the AI like just the the the information pros just to
- 31:36gather information to synthesis the processing.
- 31:38What I'm saying now, person's context that already had the
- 31:41professional domain will always be able to do more with that
- 31:44information than the person that's starting off of scratch.
- 31:48So like it just allows you to become average.
- 31:50It's the same thing with me trying to do designs or video.
- 31:53I can get to average but I can never get to the highest level
- 31:57because if the person at the highest level is using the same
- 31:59tools, they're already have the domain discipline.
- 32:01This is why engineers will be like million X engineers, but
- 32:04I'll never be able to get to like that level.
- 32:06That's the same concept with with chemistry.
- 32:10I'm more sharing like I don't fully agree.
- 32:14I think there's also a certain pride in having a certain
- 32:18knowledge, having a certain degree or whatever.
- 32:21Like this is kind of the tension where we're at.
- 32:23That's more my point. Like I do think that there will
- 32:26be people that have an open creative, entrepreneurial mind
- 32:29that will probably use AI to find either solutions to like
- 32:36breakthrough problems or create like breakthrough innovative
- 32:40concepts just because they have a perhaps amateuristic interest.
- 32:45But they now have this tool that's kind of democratizes this
- 32:48whole synthesis, synthesis of information and processing it,
- 32:53etcetera. And I like we're looking at the
- 32:55PM, the PMS here, you know, if you're a deaf and you know what
- 33:00to build the PM skill is literally 1 download and Claude
- 33:05now right like that's. More of my.
- 33:07Point. So you can be a 10 year PM, but
- 33:10if you just have a computer that just listens to the thing you
- 33:13want to build, that helps you organize and plan and whatever,
- 33:17then yeah, it's fun that you have 10 years of PM experience
- 33:20and read all the PM books and whatnot.
- 33:23But there there's not really a difference.
- 33:27Just one thing to say on the like positive thing that most
- 33:29people don't is that like Fortune 500, it's roughly 5% of
- 33:34their CapEx is spent in like information technology.
- 33:37It's not even just technology, just anything related to
- 33:39security, 5% Fortune 500. So think about, I don't know if
- 33:44this is true, but the amount of engineers like applications,
- 33:49let's say it's flat to a little bit up.
- 33:52The reality is there's just been not enough engineers.
- 33:54Like when you think about if that's only for portrait 500,
- 33:57think about all the mom and pop shops and everything you go into
- 34:00in your regular world that could be optimized by software.
- 34:04So there will be that also on the other side.
- 34:06And it is just a lot of people that need work that have these
- 34:09tools will be able to like further efficiencies in the
- 34:11world. So it's not all, you know, kind
- 34:15of like bearish on humanity. It's just it's what Matt said.
- 34:18I like that angle of you're always looking at it from an
- 34:21investor in from an investor perspective.
- 34:23You're always just trying to layer on the least amount of
- 34:26assumptions, right? And like if you're looking at a
- 34:28dot plot, there's just every there's no, your assumptions are
- 34:31basically all thrown out the window.
- 34:32You don't have a lot of framework to work from outside
- 34:35of like that kind of we money and very few people are even
- 34:38there. Yeah, I mean, I agree with that.
- 34:40And and eventually my point is I also just think this is a good
- 34:44thing, right? I do think it's it's a good
- 34:48thing. It just forces you to think
- 34:50about, OK, how can I add add value?
- 34:53And maybe, you know, for the women in this in this video, it
- 34:57might be a totally different thing that they would actually
- 35:00enjoy and. What do you think they should be
- 35:03doing? I don't know, you wanted to make
- 35:06a joke. But no, I'm not going to make a
- 35:09joke, OK? Let's move on to a Bitcoin item
- 35:12that I brought. You probably saw, we saw, we saw
- 35:15Ray Dalio this week talking about flaws in Bitcoin.
- 35:20There was Chamath who got roasted with people that said,
- 35:25you know, you better talk about all the specs you did where
- 35:28people lost 99.8% of all the funds and he crashed out and and
- 35:33whatnot. But my point is more about let
- 35:38me see if this is yeah. Chamath is getting crushed so
- 35:41hard. He bought, he paid for
- 35:43somebody's kids college. Did you see that?
- 35:46Yeah, he said. Like show me our losses and I'll
- 35:48reimburse you or something, right?
- 35:50Yeah, he invested in their college funds and then the guy
- 35:53tweeted out he was like, Shamath is such a class act.
- 35:55What a great dude. Weird.
- 35:58OK, wild times. What I want to talk about with
- 36:02with you guys is, you know, what Dalio and Chamath are missing
- 36:08and I liked what Jeff Parts Park said here.
- 36:10You know, they fail to understand why central banks are
- 36:12broken and why they need Bitcoin, right?
- 36:15They're talking about, you know, central banks will never buy
- 36:18Bitcoin, etcetera, etcetera. I talked to Dave Weisberger this
- 36:22week and he said, you know, he's correct.
- 36:24You know, the ECB, the, the, maybe the US Treasury will buy
- 36:29it, but the Fed will never buy it, etcetera.
- 36:31So in big countries, no, obviously they're not going to
- 36:33buy it. But small, smaller countries,
- 36:37which in general already have less power with regard to their
- 36:43their currency, yeah, they, they might adopt Bitcoin, right?
- 36:45But it's more about the, like Jeff says, the growing distrust
- 36:50in centralized organizations that don't really have the
- 36:53receipts to show that decentralization of everything
- 36:58basically was a good thing. So I just wanted to highlight
- 37:01this and also, yeah, I wanted to get your guys takes on on, you
- 37:06know, Dalio Chumath and whatever else you've seen that's perhaps
- 37:11related to this. Well, they specifically were
- 37:14saying that the reason governments reason central banks
- 37:18and governments won't buy Bitcoin is because of lack of
- 37:21strong privacy guarantees, which I think is just a a false
- 37:25premise to begin with. I mean, I've been very focused
- 37:30during my time in Bitcoin on trying to make Bitcoin easier to
- 37:33use privately. And I think there's still a lot
- 37:35of work to be done. But it is very much possible to
- 37:39use Bitcoin in a private way regardless of how the protocol
- 37:43is set up. And the protocol is set up
- 37:44specifically so we have transparency first, right?
- 37:48And provable supply so that you're able to realize that
- 37:51there's no debasement going on, no inflation going on.
- 37:55It is interesting because Chamath is historically a
- 37:59massive shit corner and so I'm expecting that he's going to try
- 38:02and pump Z cash as his plan here which is ridiculous.
- 38:07It's not a competitor to Bitcoin and governments will never adopt
- 38:10it for sure because it's controlled by a small group of
- 38:14people. US based company and you have no
- 38:18assurances on whether or not there's silent inflation going
- 38:22on, which is fundamentally a key value prop.
- 38:25I think of good money. Now he's in that in that clip,
- 38:29he's actually comparing it to gold, which is interesting.
- 38:32And he says gold has privacy and I guess gold kind of does have
- 38:36privacy because it's analog. It has a lot of other
- 38:39disadvantages to Bitcoin. I can't be moved around very
- 38:43easily. It can't be secured very easily.
- 38:45I can be counterfeited much easier than Bitcoin.
- 38:48It's almost impossible to counterfeit Bitcoin.
- 38:50All you have to do is run a Bitcoin node to verify that
- 38:53you're getting real Bitcoin. And gold is an interesting
- 38:55example, right? Because Elon said when he was
- 38:59working for the government said that they were going to audit
- 39:01Fort Knox and walk around with a live stream camera and show us
- 39:04all the gold bars in Fort Knox. And then he got a black eye and
- 39:06got kicked out of the government.
- 39:07And we haven't heard a word since about what's in Fort Knox
- 39:10or not. And you have a perfect example
- 39:13there that if they had Bitcoin, they could eat very easily
- 39:16without putting the security of the Bitcoin at risk.
- 39:18Verifiably prove that they own Bitcoin and how much Bitcoin
- 39:21they own. And I think he's missing that
- 39:24key piece, which particularly should incentivize smaller
- 39:29governments. All of those features of Bitcoin
- 39:31should incentivize smaller governments to be the first
- 39:33movers here. We always see the challengers be
- 39:35the first movers regardless of what what niche it is.
- 39:38I mean, another example on that front is we have Cash App moved
- 39:42first because they were second behind Venmo.
- 39:45Venmo came second, right? MicroStrategy was like a no name
- 39:49tech company. Sailor was a no name
- 39:51billionaire. He was the first mover into
- 39:54Bitcoin because he had something to prove and needed an edge,
- 39:56right? And so we'll see that.
- 39:58I think we see the challenge of governments move first and then
- 40:01you see the big dogs move later when they basically have no
- 40:04option but to adopt. Yeah, I, I also think these,
- 40:09the, the comments are kind of unfair because like you said,
- 40:13you can, you can build any technology on top of Bitcoin,
- 40:17but it's more about Bitcoin being this fundamental base
- 40:21layer. And if there is, I always say
- 40:26like a forced transparency there, like you said, you know,
- 40:29like if if I say I have X amount of Bitcoin and you, you, you say
- 40:33to me, well, prove it by, you know, signing this challenge and
- 40:38I say no, then you know, you cannot trust me because you can
- 40:42force me to be transparent, right?
- 40:44And to establish a trust, a relationship.
- 40:47So I always think that that is more a you could, you could have
- 40:53a philosophical conversation about that or you could just
- 40:55say, you know, like, it's just not there is no privacy.
- 40:58So it's bad. But that's also kind of
- 41:00deceptive because you, like I said, you can build any
- 41:02technology on top of it. And the fun thing is it's I got
- 41:071,000,000 views on this, on this video.
- 41:09I had a video of how the Dutch government moved 15 billion in
- 41:14gold. I mean, this is not really
- 41:16obscure guys. Like this is not really, you
- 41:19know, this is how you move 15 billion in in gold.
- 41:22And The funny thing is that there was a news item that
- 41:26accompanied this, this video. And the person who was like in
- 41:30charge of of this transport was asked like, how how do you keep
- 41:33this secrets? You know, this is for the
- 41:35national news guys. How do you keep this secret?
- 41:37And his deep answer was, yeah, you just shut your mouth.
- 41:41Was literally the quote. It's like the an article.
- 41:44Those those trucks are not like I don't know if you guys saw
- 41:47yesterday like Elon Decoy where he was going in and like it's a
- 41:51great video. I like, I like that.
- 41:52I like that. That's.
- 41:53Good. He showed up to the courthouse
- 41:54and he ran. That's what reminds me like
- 41:56there's no gold in those trucks. Going back real quick to to
- 42:01math's point, yeah, it came out today.
- 42:02Kazakhstan is putting like $350 million in in crypto.
- 42:06I would imagine it's Bitcoin on their balance sheet.
- 42:09But I think like we give too much credit.
- 42:13I can't I I think it would like fed speak in what Dalio and
- 42:16Chamath say in the sense of like their portfolios probably looked
- 42:21very different than what they're talking about.
- 42:23And I went, I was it was just this morning.
- 42:25I had it not to listen to full thing, but I saw in the time
- 42:27stamp or Dalia was all in pot or whatever he was on was talking
- 42:31about gold and Bitcoin. I wanted to hear what he said
- 42:33and obviously he talked about privacy, but then he also talked
- 42:36about quantum and like one other thing.
- 42:39And it just reminds me of like how inorganic all the flood
- 42:44feels right now because these are similar concepts that are
- 42:46coming out around privacy. Z cash quantum.
- 42:49And it was just 6 to 12 months ago that Dolly was putting on a
- 42:525 to 15% position that he was talking about in his portfolio
- 42:56that everyone was happy about. And like we know Chamath has
- 42:59been in Bitcoin or at least had exposure a very early on that he
- 43:03like rolled in the GBTC. So I just don't carry like a lot
- 43:06of weight when these guys say things because they part of the
- 43:08machine, specifically the Dalio part of the machine, they go
- 43:10with wherever the winds going and they need to and then they
- 43:13switch when it's the right time. So, like, I don't believe that
- 43:17they believe what they're saying.
- 43:19It's the same thing with like, Musk has no idea how Bitcoin
- 43:21works and he pushes Doge back in 21.
- 43:23It's like, so the smartest plan on the person, the smartest man
- 43:26on the planet Earth doesn't understand Bitcoin, but we do.
- 43:29Like I don't accept that. That's part.
- 43:32There's probably some truth to that.
- 43:33I mean, I also think they're just flat out wrong, right?
- 43:38Like you can, you can use Bitcoin privately, particularly
- 43:41if you're sophisticated like a government.
- 43:43I mean, you mentioned Kazakhstan.
- 43:45It goes hand in hand with the idea of challengers.
- 43:47But also on the privacy side, Kingdom of Bhutan was one of the
- 43:51first movers on Bitcoin. Obviously, El Salvador was too.
- 43:55Nobody knew they were stacking sets.
- 43:57Nobody knew they had a bag of Bitcoin.
- 43:59The only reason we found out that the Kingdom of Bhutan had
- 44:02Bitcoin was because they got doxed in the Celsius bankruptcy,
- 44:07which is just a complete Fiat phenomenon, completely unrelated
- 44:10to Bitcoin. If they, if they had gold with
- 44:12some company and the company went bankrupt and they were in
- 44:14the bankruptcy proceeding, we would know they had gold in the,
- 44:17in the, in the bankruptcy estate.
- 44:19And that's how we found out that they had Bitcoin in the 1st
- 44:21place. Venezuela, We, we, the US
- 44:24government went in and, and, and abducted Maduro.
- 44:28And there's speculation that the Venezuelan government has a shit
- 44:30ton of Bitcoin. They definitely have a shit ton
- 44:32of Bitcoin. Well, show me where their
- 44:33wallets are. No one knows how much Bitcoin
- 44:36they have. How much Bitcoin is North Korea?
- 44:40North Korea? How much Bitcoin is North Korea?
- 44:42Show me the addresses, right? You can figure out some of the
- 44:45addresses, right? Some of them have been docked,
- 44:48some of them have been figured out, but a lot of them haven't
- 44:51been. And even if you could figure it
- 44:53out, you can't seize it. So the last point I would make
- 44:57here, by the way, is if your most of your exposure to crypto,
- 45:02quote UN quote, crypto is shit coin land, it's really bad out
- 45:04there. Like if you use Solana, Chamath
- 45:06is a huge salonable Etherium. You have one address that is
- 45:10literally your entire financial transaction history and they
- 45:12have horrible privacy. So if you're used to stable
- 45:15coins, you know, using USD tokens on Solana or Tron or
- 45:18something, you're used to having very, very little privacy when
- 45:22you interact with crypto. And if you want to give them the
- 45:24benefit of the doubt, some of that belief could be coming from
- 45:28those interactions that they've had.
- 45:32All right, let's move to this one, Mike.
- 45:36Yeah, I thought this was interesting because I I've taken
- 45:39the other side of, you know, why bit or gold's made its run the
- 45:42liquidity, the the 5000 year track record.
- 45:45But the reality is counterparty risk still matters.
- 45:49Where you live still matters and you know, there's was reported
- 45:54earlier today that there's a discount over spot on spot
- 45:57because in Dubai people are trying to get out.
- 46:00There was reported I think a couple days ago, there was
- 46:02caravans and it was for the ultra wealthy.
- 46:04We're having to travel through the desert 10 hours to get to
- 46:06Riyadh to just fly out and to think about having your gold in
- 46:10a bank in your mansion and then figured out how to get out of
- 46:14the country with that, you're sitting on 10s of millions of
- 46:16dollars. I think that this is one of the
- 46:18just fundamental mispricings. I think it's on one of your
- 46:22links. So I don't want to steal the
- 46:23Thunder, but related to these air pockets that exist in the
- 46:26global economy because there's too much debt, not enough
- 46:27dollars that most people don't even price Bitcoin for the lack
- 46:31of for the, yeah, lack of counterparty risk you have to
- 46:33deal with depending on who, how who and how you custody it.
- 46:37Where in every other aspect of that you have some centralized
- 46:40party that can just tell you one day it's not yours.
- 46:44And once the world wakes up to that, that's when you really
- 46:46start to gain an appreciation for it's this old like like
- 46:52mental exercise. Would you rather have 500,000 in
- 46:55BTC or would you rather have $1,000,000 in Silicon Valley
- 46:57Bay, right? Because you could take that
- 46:59500,000 Bitcoin, you could sleep well at night with it.
- 47:02But the $1,000,000, even if it's there theoretically tomorrow
- 47:05it's gone. And do you really want to live
- 47:07in that world? It's part of the way I
- 47:09rationalize Matt. We've been pinging about like,
- 47:11man, what do we sign up for in this, like this?
- 47:14Just this whole thing's crazy for to be involved this long.
- 47:16But there is, you know, the draw downs being all in Bitcoin.
- 47:19But there's still a level of Zen will at least like I'll die by
- 47:23my sword, not by somebody else's.
- 47:25And that's all you can really ask for in this life is like, if
- 47:28I'm going to mess it up, it'll be on me, not because some
- 47:30counterparty decided that my goal is not lying anymore.
- 47:34Yeah, Matt, before you reply, let I'll just also show my link.
- 47:40You know, these, these credits, these withdrawals that BlackRock
- 47:44blocked, I have similar thoughts here, right?
- 47:47Like The funny thing as Michael's pointing out the use
- 47:52case for Bitcoin. You know, you can hold it in
- 47:54self custody. You can move it.
- 47:56Yeah, if you want to. You can move it anywhere if you
- 48:00want to, right? You could spend it on something
- 48:03if if you wanted to. So just these three things plus
- 48:08these two, you know, these three characteristics plus these two
- 48:13examples, I fully agree with Mike that it's going to become
- 48:17more and more clear that you need to own your wealth
- 48:21yourself. And you can and I also fully
- 48:24agree with Mike. You know, if, if this is not it,
- 48:27then at least we tried because keeping on outsourcing
- 48:33everything finance related to either the geographical
- 48:38restrictions or these, you know, these types of, of, of
- 48:43companies. We're seeing that it works less
- 48:48and less. And, and like something like
- 48:49this with, with BlackRock, I think it's extremely serious.
- 48:54You know, only 9.3% of the money was redeemed and it's kept at 5,
- 49:02right? So, you know, is, is that a
- 49:04Ponzi or what? You know, how, how, how does
- 49:07that even work? I I think a lot of people that
- 49:10actually own this don't even know how it works.
- 49:12But yeah, I just wonder how long it takes before more, more
- 49:16people wake up to, you know, all this security and abstraction
- 49:21that just exists while at the same time Bitcoin also exists.
- 49:27Yeah. I mean, anyone who's dealt with
- 49:33investments is aware that there's always a disconnect
- 49:35between assets under management and liquidity.
- 49:38And usually the market doesn't realize the disconnect until
- 49:42there's crises and people are trying to withdraw their money.
- 49:46So there's really no surprise here to me that this is
- 49:48happening. I would say that it should be
- 49:50concerning to people because it seems like they couldn't cover,
- 49:55they couldn't even come close to covering it.
- 49:59It says here, at least if I, if I'm going to quote this tweet, I
- 50:02don't know how accurate this tweet is, but they had $1.2
- 50:05billion in withdrawals and they only paid out $620 million.
- 50:09And supposedly the entire fund is $26 billion.
- 50:12So if they only had $620 million of liquidity for a $26 billion
- 50:15fund, then maybe all the numbers are all bullshit, right?
- 50:19And I think that's what a lot of the math a lot of people are
- 50:21doing on the Bitcoin side. Look, Bitcoin, real Bitcoin held
- 50:27in self custody is the ultimate safe haven asset.
- 50:30There is no second best. There is nothing better than it.
- 50:33And anyone who's ever experienced Bitcoin in self
- 50:35custody intrinsically understands this and realizes
- 50:38that they know it. But we're in crisis mode right
- 50:42now. The world is in chaos and people
- 50:45are flocking to safe havens. And I think the one of the main
- 50:49reasons that Bitcoin is trading like a risk asset and it's
- 50:52trading like, frankly, like dog shit amid this chaos is because
- 50:56all the new people that have been onboarded, most of the new
- 50:59people that have been onboarded have been onboarded into
- 51:01custodial suit products, whether that's Blackrock's own ETF,
- 51:05whether that's things like MicroStrategy.
- 51:07And if that's how you interact with Bitcoin, it is not a safe
- 51:10haven at all. All the properties that make
- 51:12Bitcoin a safe haven evaporate when you're trusting A
- 51:15custodian, a third party to hold it for you and manage it for
- 51:18you. And so it makes sense that those
- 51:20market participants wouldn't be thinking of Bitcoin as a safe
- 51:23haven. And what do you look, if you
- 51:24look at the market price of Bitcoin, we've almost, we've
- 51:28almost nearly round tripped to when the ETFs were launched,
- 51:31when the ETFs, when BlackRock ETF was launched, it was January
- 51:342024 is a little over two years ago, Bitcoin price was $47,000.
- 51:40We're slightly up from that point.
- 51:43And why is that? It's because the world is in
- 51:45chaos and people aren't treating it like a safe haven access
- 51:48asset. Because they're not holding self
- 51:49custody. They're not holding real
- 51:51Bitcoin. 22 quick things. Also, Blackstone reportedly had
- 51:55to pay 400 million out of their own pocketbooks for redemptions.
- 51:58I will, I will push back and you can, you can, you know, come
- 52:01back if you want, we can have a discussion.
- 52:03I'll say that like self custody, there's an angle on the other
- 52:08side of it. If you're in Dubai with self
- 52:10custody and you're out at the restaurant, you're probably not
- 52:12carrying your private keys and your house gets bombed and like
- 52:15now you're kind of screwed or you're traveling because you
- 52:18lived in Dubai, you came to the States.
- 52:20Well, probably it doesn't make sense to do that.
- 52:22Most people aren't sophisticated to have geographical multi sig
- 52:25self custody. So like what I've always stance
- 52:28is barbell approach. It's how people manage their
- 52:31capital, whether it's their dollars or gold, they like have
- 52:33some in self custody. They can always owe shit.
- 52:35Maybe your seat is in your wallet with a passphrase.
- 52:38And then there's stuff like we do or others I do.
- 52:41But I do think that there's a reality of like where I came to
- 52:44this conclusion because I was all in self custody, multi say
- 52:47collaborative custody. Then I'd go overseas and travel
- 52:49to Dubai and I'm like, holy shit, my wife got somebody to do
- 52:51the cabinets. It's like who's in my house?
- 52:53And what if you put the whole thing together?
- 52:55So I think like that's the angle of you get to a point, you start
- 52:58having kids, you start having a plan around it, and then
- 53:01diversification to a Fiat extent starts to become just like Fiat.
- 53:05But there is a reality. You don't want to get knocked
- 53:07out of the game because somebody bombs you, you're travelling and
- 53:09then you're self custody is all like screwed.
- 53:11To be clear here on ramp is a a microcosm in the in the suite of
- 53:21products in Bitcoin land. Yeah, and I wouldn't group in
- 53:24with MSTR and I bet. Because yeah, you're just
- 53:27saying. Over the asset you can withdraw
- 53:30actual Bitcoin if you want to actually withdraw Bitcoin.
- 53:33So it's I would say it's much even though it's not self
- 53:36custody, it's collaborative multi institutional custody.
- 53:39It's much closer to self custody than I bet for instance.
- 53:43Yeah, I was just referring. To.
- 53:45Self custody by the gold. Standard.
- 53:47It's gold Standard. It's like it, it is, but it is
- 53:50in in the sense if you're all your money's in Bitcoin and
- 53:53somebody bombs you and you don't have your access, you never can
- 53:56get it back. That's like the just the angle.
- 53:58Yeah, I mean you can kind of protect yourself from it, but
- 54:01first of all not living in the Middle East and second of all
- 54:03using distributed multi sig. What do you mean in Minneapolis?
- 54:07But here, here's a question for you, Tanguma.
- 54:10Do you think the majority of your clients at Onramp think of
- 54:17Bitcoin as a safe haven asset or as a risk asset?
- 54:20Well see that's the interesting part.
- 54:22It's more safe haven what most. Of our that's what I'm saying,
- 54:24because it's not because it's closer to self custody than
- 54:27something like I bet. And then they basically hold a
- 54:29lot in self custody and then with us because in the world
- 54:32where they were traveling and they could never get back, they
- 54:35didn't lose their whole stat. But someone who's holding MSTR
- 54:38is not thinking of Bitcoin as a safe haven.
- 54:40Oh yeah, they're thinking of a speculative tech stock.
- 54:42They're thinking of it as a high risk asset.
- 54:45Yeah. That's what I mean.
- 54:46But yeah, but but this is just the this is the entire thing
- 54:52that we're in, I would say, right?
- 54:53Like we we although he he called the top sort of, you know, Mike
- 55:02and I laughed about Luke Roman saying, you know, I get the
- 55:06whole macro thesis. You know, I understand people
- 55:09should move to hard assets, but I'm going to sell Bitcoin
- 55:12because it trades like a tech stock, right?
- 55:15And I just think it's funny because it's stupid when people
- 55:18approach approach it like a tech stock and like an investment.
- 55:23I wish it's called Luke, for whatever it's worth.
- 55:25Yeah, I would just say that at the time I made fun of Luke.
- 55:28And sure, whatever he. He nailed that.
- 55:31He nailed that call. The hard part is buying back in
- 55:34SO. But this is what I'm saying.
- 55:35Right. I've done half of it so far,
- 55:36yeah. So my comes.
- 55:38Back in. So my point is twofold.
- 55:41Yes, I agree. But if you have a long term
- 55:44outlook and you think it's a safe haven asset and you've
- 55:47tried to sell and buy back lower and you failed or not, I mean I
- 55:52failed in the past miserably. You know, I'm just, I'm just
- 55:57huddling and that's for me with a longer term outlook is just
- 56:02easier than trying to search for this next trade or whatever.
- 56:06So it was more of my opinion, like if you understand the
- 56:09bigger picture and that Bitcoin is actually a safe haven asset
- 56:14on many different levels. Yeah, just huddle and chill
- 56:19basically, right. And don't try to overanalyze.
- 56:21Like why are some people looking at it as this risk, risk on
- 56:26thing and trading like a nest? You know, when I see the
- 56:29sentence Bitcoin is trading like a NASDAQ stock, I'm like, no,
- 56:31there's people that are trading Bitcoin that are viewing it as
- 56:34an investment instead of a safe haven as it asset that is vastly
- 56:38superior to any other option that they have.
- 56:42You know, and that's fine, but that is kind of what what we're
- 56:46what we're in. To be clear, I mean, I
- 56:48wholeheartedly agree with you and I think a perfect example is
- 56:51what we saw over the weekend, right?
- 56:53If you are a high net worth Dubai resident and you followed
- 56:58Luke's advice and you went full hog into gold from Bitcoin, and
- 57:03then crisis hits and you want to get back into Bitcoin, it is
- 57:06very difficult. When you need Bitcoin the most,
- 57:09it can be very difficult to obtain it and secure it, as
- 57:13opposed to just, you know, being safe and having your safe haven
- 57:17and just hobbling. That's the thing I think we
- 57:19like, I know we appreciate, but it always dawns on me when you
- 57:22see those pictures on Twitter where all the money's getting
- 57:25caught in the duffel bag and there's dollars and there's all
- 57:27this stuff and people talk about putting a Rolex on and trying to
- 57:30get $50,000 and we're looking at air pockets.
- 57:33It's just the notion that you can maintain all your life
- 57:37savings in this asset, move it borderlessly, not have any
- 57:41intermediary. It's just an insane proposition
- 57:44in a world that's used to just having to ask for permission.
- 57:47Mind blowing from your accountant.
- 57:48Yeah, it's mind blowing. Yeah, sorry, I didn't want to
- 57:52interrupt, but this is no, no. I just don't think we fully
- 57:54logical. It's so it's like in your face.
- 57:56There's literally nothing like it.
- 57:58I had to send someone a Zelle payment earlier today.
- 58:01They have a $2000 daily limit. How does anyone take that
- 58:05seriously? I wish I'd had that.
- 58:07I only get 1000. I only get 1000 daily limit on.
- 58:10Ridiculous. Yeah.
- 58:14So it's all permissioned, right? But my blockchain is fat, no.
- 58:18OK Anyway, I just wanted to make a chat.
- 58:21OK, I'm happy Matt is here because I want to get your take
- 58:25on this. I've said previously on the
- 58:28different episodes after I talked to American huddle, who
- 58:32said to me, you know, Bitcoiners are like 8 year ahead of eight
- 58:35years ahead of people. I'm I'm I'm seeing these
- 58:39fractals of like trad 5 people just in their 2017 crypto
- 58:4420/17/2018 crypto type stage, right?
- 58:48And so I saw Bank of Japan to test blockchain settlement for
- 58:52bank reserves, right? And then some governor said XYZ
- 58:56and I said, I think it's fascinating that Tratfi is in
- 58:59this 2017 crypto moment, right? So we eventually realize that
- 59:03Bitcoin is the way like if you just hold Bitcoin Azure
- 59:06Foundational Bank Reserve, you can conduct instant final
- 59:08settlement of any size every 10 minutes on the most secure
- 59:11blockchain ever, right? So I just want to get your take
- 59:15on this, how you view this lag that I think exists and perhaps
- 59:22also, yeah, maybe your future outlook how that will how that
- 59:26will play out. Yeah, I don't know.
- 59:31It's frustrating to live through.
- 59:33It's definitely true. We live in the future.
- 59:36The few people paying attention live in the future.
- 59:38I mean, I think it's probably similar on the AI side to our
- 59:40earlier conversation. But I mean, ultimately I think
- 59:46all these people will start to realize that trusted third
- 59:49parties are the security hole if they are the problem.
- 59:54And if you don't have a native bearer asset like Bitcoin, all
- 59:58this blockchain mumbo jumbos just is exactly that.
- 1:00:01It's just all bullshit. You don't actually have any
- 1:00:03final settlement. You don't actually have
- 1:00:05settlement at all. You're trusting a third party to
- 1:00:07do that settlement. I mean we're seeing it with all
- 1:00:10types of real world asset stuff. Where it requires A trusted
- 1:00:14issuer in order to access the asset, whether that's
- 1:00:17fractionized real estate or gold or whatever.
- 1:00:20And I think it just takes longer for people to realize.
- 1:00:22And also it requires pain. You know, we can wax on and wax
- 1:00:27off about how USD tokens like Tether have trusted third party
- 1:00:32risk, right? But Tethers also operated for I
- 1:00:36think over a decade now and it's still working, you know, And so
- 1:00:40people don't get rugged, then your theoretical concerns are
- 1:00:45never actually become realistic concerns.
- 1:00:47And once they become realistic concerns, that's when people
- 1:00:50actually start to to learn through pain.
- 1:00:53Yeah, I mean, that's 100% it. It's the pain.
- 1:00:56And that's where I go back to the anxiety inducing because you
- 1:00:59remember and you were, you were talking about this early with
- 1:01:02the, the Shane, was it no Hong Kong riots.
- 1:01:04And it wasn't till Hong Kong riots happened that people
- 1:01:07recognize, oh, signal went through the roof.
- 1:01:09And then we've seen this in other markets with bit chat.
- 1:01:12But then I remember viscerally back in 2275% of the BTC.
- 1:01:17It was like roughly in this little public knowledge, like
- 1:01:19$13 billion to wherever Unchained holds at the time, 75%
- 1:01:24of it came in three exact instances.
- 1:01:26It was blocked by Celsius, FTX or Celsius blocked by FTX.
- 1:01:30And so it goes to that point, like we live in these small
- 1:01:33fractals of every cycle. There's just such a small,
- 1:01:35that's why the shit corners and the, the, the charlatans can get
- 1:01:39away with this because there's such a small percentage of
- 1:01:42people that are paying attention or allocated.
- 1:01:44So they get rugged and they go on to the bigger mark because
- 1:01:47the, the Tam grows, but it's still so small in relative
- 1:01:51terms. And it's not until the pain
- 1:01:53happens like what I experienced this all day long.
- 1:01:55It punched the face. Talk to the largest institutions
- 1:01:57who are explaining why we do it the way we do it.
- 1:02:00And you're just going to have to wait till the market gets rubbed
- 1:02:02via Coinbase or whoever else till the market realizes, oh,
- 1:02:06crap like or the Iran stuff or happens here.
- 1:02:09And so we just have to literally wait.
- 1:02:10It's the same thing as the AI. It's not until people are
- 1:02:12getting laid off in droves and they have nothing to do with sit
- 1:02:15around and try to figure this stuff out that they're going to
- 1:02:17be willing to do it. And we just have to sit here and
- 1:02:19talk about it until that all happens and hope we're on the
- 1:02:22other side of it. I mean, I remember in 21 people
- 1:02:25were in my comments on on Twitter saying that not your
- 1:02:29keys, not your coins was FUD and that Mountain Cox was 10 years
- 1:02:32ago and the industry has matured and it's never going to happen
- 1:02:35again. And then like less than a year
- 1:02:37later, as you said, three massive quote UN quote
- 1:02:40institutions in the space FTX sponsored the fucking Super
- 1:02:43Bowl, all went under. And then people realized, right?
- 1:02:47But then they're going to forget again, no realize this is going
- 1:02:51to give. Yeah, because right now it's
- 1:02:52like, well, it's BlackRock, Fidelity and State Street.
- 1:02:56They'll never lose the the Bitcoin.
- 1:02:59That's like, they literally just like tie it to whatever social
- 1:03:01proof they need. And yeah, it's, it's the same
- 1:03:06side of the crypto stuff. It's the same story every couple
- 1:03:08of years. There's some reason why that
- 1:03:10centralized counterparty will never lose the Bitcoin, and
- 1:03:13there's lots of easy anecdotes. 1 is it's just data.
- 1:03:15Data is private keys. Private keys will, like all data
- 1:03:18gets leaked on a long enough time horizon or the other
- 1:03:21angles. If there's a single point of
- 1:03:22failure, there will always be a single point of failure.
- 1:03:24Like it's just on what time horizon will that happen?
- 1:03:30Yeah, I don't really have that much to add, but I I do agree.
- 1:03:37I always think it's funny that sometimes, you know, people that
- 1:03:40are our critics kind of act from this point of view that
- 1:03:48everything should already be crystallized, right?
- 1:03:50Like when when bitcoiners talk about the future or like, you
- 1:03:53know, this should be the proper function of Bitcoin, This is why
- 1:03:56you should hold it or a central bank or whatever.
- 1:04:03Yeah, Like I said, I just think the critics, they, they operate
- 1:04:06from this, this, this, this, I don't know, standpoint of
- 1:04:10everything being crystallized, which is just not the case,
- 1:04:13right. We are envisioning a certain
- 1:04:15future and talking about how Bitcoin fits in somewhere.
- 1:04:20But this is an yeah, this is a, a, a developing thing every day,
- 1:04:25every year, whatever. Mike, what do you want to?
- 1:04:28Say, well, does this say to be fair, like it's the same thing
- 1:04:31as AI and that like, it is a pretty wild construct in that
- 1:04:36like most people don't want it to exist.
- 1:04:38And rightfully so. Because if you said, well, it
- 1:04:40should have all the money, but it's like all the money's going
- 1:04:42to change and you're going to have to relearn and understand
- 1:04:45all these things. It's the same thing as AI.
- 1:04:46It's like, I'd rather just not to be a real thing.
- 1:04:49And then you come up with every reason why it can't work in
- 1:04:52quantum's the most recent thing versus just figure it out.
- 1:04:55It's the same thing AI. You have to relearn everything
- 1:04:57you thought you knew and for whatever reason we decided to,
- 1:05:01but that's the status of how people want to operate.
- 1:05:06Yeah, I agree. I mean, this is always how it
- 1:05:09goes just to resistance to all the change.
- 1:05:13All right, I'm looking at the time.
- 1:05:14Let's do two more items. Matthew, you brought this.
- 1:05:18I have a question, but I'll let you go first.
- 1:05:24Yeah. I mean this one just, it was a
- 1:05:27deal that I personally got done. So that's why I put the link in
- 1:05:30there. But bitwise when the ETFs were
- 1:05:33launching, January 2024 really started.
- 1:05:37I started scrambling in November 2023.
- 1:05:41It looked like the ETFs were definitely going to get
- 1:05:43approved. It was just a question of
- 1:05:46timing. I'm one of the Co founders of
- 1:05:49Opensats. We're focused, we're A501-C3
- 1:05:52charity focused on supporting the open source contributors
- 1:05:55that make this movement possible, that are working on
- 1:05:57things that cannot be monetized. But they're foundational
- 1:06:00infrastructure for everything else that is being built out
- 1:06:03there. And they just didn't have
- 1:06:06ethical paths for funding. So we launched Opensats.
- 1:06:08We take no cut of donations, 100% pass through.
- 1:06:11We hold everything in Bitcoin. We're sending out $1,000,000 in
- 1:06:14Bitcoin every month. Right now we have about 200
- 1:06:18outstanding grantees in total since we've started, we've
- 1:06:21funded over 370 people totalling over $30 million all in Bitcoin.
- 1:06:28We just, we hold Bitcoin in multi sig.
- 1:06:29We send out Bitcoin payments once a month, but we're
- 1:06:33constantly, we're a charity. We're constantly looking for
- 1:06:35more funding options. And I was hoping that these
- 1:06:38ETFs, 1 silver lining of of paper Bitcoin was going to be
- 1:06:41that they would help position some of their massive revenues
- 1:06:44into open source development. I had conversations with
- 1:06:47multiple ETFs. You know, there's about seven of
- 1:06:51them, but there's like 4 that really matter.
- 1:06:53And Bitwise is the only one who came through and they're
- 1:06:56continuing to come through with their commitment.
- 1:06:58I think their commitment specifically as a volunteer is
- 1:07:02particularly awesome because it's tied to their profits.
- 1:07:06So it's reoccurring, 10% of their profits on their ETF.
- 1:07:10They donate to open source contributors through three
- 1:07:13organizations, US Brink and HRF. And it's particularly designed
- 1:07:17that way to try and reduce centralized points of failure.
- 1:07:19Instead of it all going to one organization, let's evenly split
- 1:07:22it. So yeah, I mean, I think this is
- 1:07:25going to continue to grow organically as they find more
- 1:07:28success with their product. And I would love to see more
- 1:07:31companies in the space do similar commitments.
- 1:07:36It would. It would definitely make my job
- 1:07:37a lot easier. And I think it also accelerates
- 1:07:39everything and provides indirect benefits and direct benefits to
- 1:07:43the companies that operate in the space.
- 1:07:45So shout out it was. Yeah.
- 1:07:48Well, I think you answered my question because I wanted to ask
- 1:07:53you what do you think about yeah, paper Bitcoin versus, you
- 1:07:57know, donating to this, which is obviously very important.
- 1:08:01I do remember that at the beginning when they all launched
- 1:08:05this announcement by Bitwise saying that they would send part
- 1:08:08of their profits to open source development, I think got got a
- 1:08:12lot of support and it's it's it's probably, yeah.
- 1:08:16Like you said, I think silver lining is probably the the the
- 1:08:19best term to to to describe it. Yeah.
- 1:08:23So I, I don't really have anything else to add.
- 1:08:24I just thought it was cool to see.
- 1:08:26Yeah. Yeah.
- 1:08:27Well, I mean, we're going to we're going to probably talk
- 1:08:29paper Bitcoin because I think that was my last topic.
- 1:08:30But before that, kudos to Matt for working on this and and also
- 1:08:35bitwise for following through. And then the reality of it's
- 1:08:38just to to add to Matt's point is you need objective people
- 1:08:43working on this protocol. And more so now than ever given
- 1:08:48without going on that rabbit hole, the notion of quantum and
- 1:08:51what are the economic actors or economic notes that are holding
- 1:08:54this Bitcoin want to think about forking And what does it look
- 1:08:57like? Like the reality is you don't
- 1:09:00want these large centralized entities being able to
- 1:09:03economically enforce or incentivize certain actors to
- 1:09:06start working on this protocol. You need objective people.
- 1:09:08You need organizations that are nonprofits to be doing that.
- 1:09:12So throwing that out and then, Matt, because it's right before
- 1:09:15tax season, people can get an offset in taxes, right, if they
- 1:09:18donate. Correct.
- 1:09:19I mean, yeah, for next year though, because it's already the
- 1:09:222026 tax year. But yeah, yeah, we're at 5O1C3.
- 1:09:26You can donate Bitcoin or or dollars.
- 1:09:29If you donate dollars, we automatically convert into
- 1:09:32Bitcoin. So you're like stacking for a
- 1:09:33good 'cause it, it, it benefits Bitcoin number go up in that
- 1:09:38way. And if you if you donate, if you
- 1:09:40donate with Bitcoin, you also have the choice of donating
- 1:09:42anonymously, which I think is pretty cool.
- 1:09:44Obviously you don't get a tax credit in that regard because we
- 1:09:46can't give you a tax receipt if you don't know who you are.
- 1:09:49But just to show the power of Bitcoin, it's pretty wild that
- 1:09:52someone can donate $500,000 anonymously through ABTC pay
- 1:09:56invoice. That's never been possible in
- 1:09:59the world of charities before. Part of the reason we're able to
- 1:10:01run so lean and efficient and have real, real, I think value
- 1:10:07add to the community is because we're built on a Bitcoin
- 1:10:10standard from the ground up. And to your point on you need
- 1:10:13objective people working on this stuff in Quantum, you know, I
- 1:10:16got a lot of shit during this period because while I was
- 1:10:20having these conversations with the different ETFs, Michael
- 1:10:22Saylor was going into private meetings and telling them not to
- 1:10:26donate to open source contributors.
- 1:10:28He's completely in his right not to donate himself.
- 1:10:32I'm never going to tell someone they have to donate to these
- 1:10:34things. It definitely rubbed me the
- 1:10:37wrong way that he was going out and telling other people not to
- 1:10:40donate when I was volunteering my time trying to convince them
- 1:10:42of the opposite. Which was already a huge hurdle
- 1:10:44to be honest, right? Why is he doing that?
- 1:10:47And what his argument was, if you have a bunch of developers
- 1:10:52working on things, they're going to mess things up and that they
- 1:10:56already have enough support. But anyway, I tried privately to
- 1:11:00resolve that. Couldn't get him on the phone,
- 1:11:03couldn't make it anything. So I just made it public that it
- 1:11:05was happening. I mostly reserved judgment at
- 1:11:08the time of how I felt about it, even though it could be
- 1:11:11insinuated. But I just wanted to be public.
- 1:11:13I wanted to be out there at the like the closed doors stuff was
- 1:11:18just felt wrong. Anyway, in his most recent
- 1:11:22investor meeting, quarterly meeting, he said we need a
- 1:11:25quantum task force, we need people working on these things,
- 1:11:28blah, blah, blah. It's like, Michael, this was two
- 1:11:30years ago. Maybe if we had more open source
- 1:11:33contributors working on these things and focus on these
- 1:11:35things, you wouldn't have to have a centralized task force to
- 1:11:38run out of your company. Yeah, they just want they want
- 1:11:41their quantum task force on this is is exactly that people
- 1:11:45discount or don't under fully understand.
- 1:11:50I don't think we have a lot of time left, but I would love to
- 1:11:53dive into this more because I think this is quite strange.
- 1:11:57And I agree with Matt that it's it's kind of.
- 1:12:01One thing. I understand.
- 1:12:03Sorry. I just want to say one thing
- 1:12:05like I like what Sailor says about, you know, Bitcoin is a
- 1:12:09rocket ship and but it is a it is a no, but it's like a
- 1:12:13precarious one, right? Like you don't, you don't just
- 1:12:16add a fucking fin on it or whatever.
- 1:12:19And I mean, I, I love that analogy and I fully agree with
- 1:12:22it. And I also think that he's also
- 1:12:25relating to, you know, people that want to make programmable
- 1:12:28money and, you know, blah, you know, this is a whole different
- 1:12:31conversation. But, you know, I, I think
- 1:12:33Bitcoin should stay boring and simple in a way that you can
- 1:12:37build on top of that. So that's how I follow that
- 1:12:42analogy, right? Like, like what he says with,
- 1:12:44you know, enthusiastic developers that want to do cool
- 1:12:47shit, like, you know, don't do it in Bitcoin, do it on top, do
- 1:12:51it on top of Bitcoin, right? But I I think not not funding
- 1:12:55this open source part is kind of strange.
- 1:12:57And then we got a transition because you guys see that Peter
- 1:12:59Jernis tweet. I don't know who it is, but it's
- 1:13:02like I'm the CEO of Palantir Technologies and just it's like.
- 1:13:05Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. Like someone, anyone that hasn't
- 1:13:07seen it, you should look it up because that's what reminds me
- 1:13:10of when Sailor or anybody speaks in that way.
- 1:13:12It's like, what are they saying versus what do they mean?
- 1:13:16And that's just the thing that we just don't get as humans,
- 1:13:19that people will say things but they're not there's, there's
- 1:13:21subtext to it. But to be clear here, I agree
- 1:13:25with that general premise. I'm very conservative when it
- 1:13:28comes to Bitcoin development. I think if Bitcoin should be
- 1:13:31boring, right, it should just be the best money.
- 1:13:34It's fundamental value properties.
- 1:13:36It's incredibly hard to change by default, which I think a lot
- 1:13:39of people miss. And it causes a lot of people to
- 1:13:41be unhappy when they want to see changes.
- 1:13:45But I will also say actions speak louder than words.
- 1:13:47I've never proposed a Bitcoin protocol change.
- 1:13:49I've never advocated for one. I've we've never directed
- 1:13:54funding towards one. But meanwhile, Sailor two years
- 1:13:58later has effectively proposed that we freeze a bunch of old
- 1:14:02Bitcoin without their consent because of quote UN quote
- 1:14:07quantum risk. And that's a huge move.
- 1:14:10That is that is you want to talk about people adding adding
- 1:14:14extraneous things to Bitcoin? Well, how about the first
- 1:14:17protocol level seizure at scale on a what's supposed to be a
- 1:14:21censorship resistant distributed network that nobody controls.
- 1:14:25So I mean, it should be interesting to watch that plays
- 1:14:28out. Maybe he pulls back from it,
- 1:14:29maybe he doesn't. And I would just say the last
- 1:14:32pieces, you know, I've been accused many times of like, oh,
- 1:14:35Matt called out Sailor just for his own career benefit.
- 1:14:40It's just it's logically does not flow.
- 1:14:43If you were operating investor circles over the last three
- 1:14:45years, being critical Sailor in any, any way whatsoever was a
- 1:14:50straight net negative for you. And people that won't accept
- 1:14:54that they're either lying to themselves or they're lying to
- 1:14:58everybody else because it's it's very obvious to anyone who's
- 1:15:01paying attention. Yeah, yeah.
- 1:15:05I mean, the this reminds me very much of the Fiat brain of who
- 1:15:10will build the roads like in the sense of people always this is
- 1:15:14how you really know kind of our brains because I talked to a lot
- 1:15:17of like really well-intentioned people.
- 1:15:19We're meeting older boomers in laws or whatever.
- 1:15:21And it's like, well, we need the government, we need people
- 1:15:23because how who will build the roads?
- 1:15:25And it's like, well, if we all sit and we all live in the town,
- 1:15:27people listening and then our kids need to get to school,
- 1:15:29we'll build the roads because they need to get to school.
- 1:15:32And so it's the same idea here. It's like if Bitcoin needs to be
- 1:15:35fixed or worked on, we will figure it out because we will
- 1:15:37come together and aggregate and they'll be enough incentive to
- 1:15:40do that. But in the same like analogy,
- 1:15:43anybody, whether it's Sailor, he's the easy one to pick on
- 1:15:45because of his economic force in this industry.
- 1:15:47It's like you don't need that person to do anything.
- 1:15:50We will figure it out. But they pulled that, that
- 1:15:53credence with somebody like that.
- 1:15:54It's just so many individuals have to take a step back and
- 1:15:56realize that's what's happening or can happen because people
- 1:16:01just hold somebody because of their name, their stature in
- 1:16:05that place. And similar to Matt's point,
- 1:16:06it's like, you know, we deal with this all the time because
- 1:16:10our clients hold Bitcoin with MSTR and these other deaths and
- 1:16:14this is tie into the next thing. And it just been very out front
- 1:16:19because it's a public exciting trade.
- 1:16:21But the reality is if you want to be around long in this asset
- 1:16:25class, you have to protect the underlying asset, but you also
- 1:16:28have to protect your reputation because the only thing that
- 1:16:31lasts longer than the underlying is how long you're there.
- 1:16:33And if you put people in bad positions, they will remember.
- 1:16:36I mean, honestly, they actually don't remember it.
- 1:16:38But like our principles and, and we, we have to like look our
- 1:16:41kids in the eyes and be like, look, I didn't actually like
- 1:16:42lose a bunch of people's money. But most people don't think like
- 1:16:45that. And it's actually against
- 1:16:47general consensus because if you're you can maybe leave some
- 1:16:50money on the table basically, but long term it'll play out in
- 1:16:54the right way. All right, let's move on to the
- 1:16:59last item. Oh, this is this is basically
- 1:17:01tying into it. So what goes up comes down.
- 1:17:04We didn't label the episode of the show, but it it's just an
- 1:17:08interesting dynamic that's playing out right.
- 1:17:10We've seen the dats puking BTC but similar now Mara, they're
- 1:17:15kind of walking this back. I don't know who else recently
- 1:17:19this past week came out on the large mining side, but it just
- 1:17:23goes back to the lack of fundamentals in 25 where a bunch
- 1:17:28of people were putting back on the balance sheet because the
- 1:17:30perceived market appreciation from it, they didn't fully
- 1:17:33understand appreciate and we're holding this as a long term
- 1:17:37store value. And so ultimately as that goes
- 1:17:40up, they're going to puke it on the way down for a number of
- 1:17:42reasons. And so everyone that was super
- 1:17:45excited about it lacked that understanding that it eventually
- 1:17:48was going to get puked out whenever the market got volatile
- 1:17:50went against them. And so this is just the latest
- 1:17:53version of that. Do they say how much they're
- 1:17:58selling? No later day.
- 1:18:00Later Day put out a statement saying that it's just a change
- 1:18:06in policy, that they could possibly be selling it.
- 1:18:11A joke because they're getting they're getting incentive,
- 1:18:13they're getting incentivized, right, to move the AI and
- 1:18:16rightfully so from a capital market perspective and you know,
- 1:18:19leverage and interest rates, but they're also getting penalized
- 1:18:22because like how capital efficient does that look if
- 1:18:24you're holding this volatile asset that just, you know, you
- 1:18:26have $500 million in, you know, notional losses.
- 1:18:30So that that's the idea behind a lot of this.
- 1:18:33It's an interesting perspective wise, right?
- 1:18:36Because obviously sailor has said many times never sell your
- 1:18:39Bitcoin and hasn't sold any Bitcoin.
- 1:18:43And I bring him up because he's obviously the elephant in the
- 1:18:46room by far. I mean, I think there there are
- 1:18:48over 750,000 Bitcoin now in holdings, but he sold billions
- 1:18:53of dollars of his own stock to buy cash with, which is
- 1:18:57effectively the same thing. It's like you basically sold
- 1:19:01Bitcoin in that situation, but the market appreciates it in a
- 1:19:04completely different, takes it in a completely different way
- 1:19:06than if you outwardly sold Bitcoin, which is something that
- 1:19:10no one really talks about, but it's just interesting how the
- 1:19:12market perceives one versus the other.
- 1:19:16Well, yeah, I think I have a different take on that because
- 1:19:24what I that's why I'm also interested to hear more about
- 1:19:28your story, why he's so anti open source.
- 1:19:30Like when I of of all the stuff that I've heard Sailor, well, of
- 1:19:37all the things that I listened to when I heard Sailor talk
- 1:19:39about Bitcoin, I think a lot of his understanding is quite, I
- 1:19:44don't know if the word is profound, but he does see the
- 1:19:46bigger, the bigger picture, right?
- 1:19:48Like I re, I re I really like his really far like future
- 1:19:53outlook, which I think he really, he really sees it and
- 1:19:59he's acting on it, right? Like he is extremely early and
- 1:20:02yeah. Is it good or bad that he has
- 1:20:04750,000 Bitcoin? I personally don't think it's
- 1:20:09necessarily good, but. He's the only one that's
- 1:20:12actually acting upon a certain future outlook, right?
- 1:20:16Like if there were more, more people that would be bold enough
- 1:20:19to take that step because they come to the same conclusion,
- 1:20:22there would actually be some competition, right?
- 1:20:24So anyone can adopt Bitcoin even if you don't like it, you know?
- 1:20:26Yeah, all the all that stuff, but I also think it's it is
- 1:20:32super early, right? And the whole idea, I mean, you
- 1:20:35know you, we've all been into startups and investing and stuff
- 1:20:39like that. The whole idea when you have an
- 1:20:42idea and you are early is to survive until more people
- 1:20:46realize that it's a good idea, right?
- 1:20:48So even along the way, if Sailor would sell Bitcoin to survive, I
- 1:20:54honestly wouldn't think it would be a bad thing because I just
- 1:20:58have a certain idea about what I think is his thesis for a longer
- 1:21:03term. So for me, it's all about how do
- 1:21:06you survive until Bitcoin becomes a thing, if it becomes a
- 1:21:09thing. But that's the whole underlying
- 1:21:11thesis is that he thinks it becomes a thing.
- 1:21:14I want to say something. I want to hear about response to
- 1:21:15all of it. None of that tracks like because
- 1:21:19it tracks, you know, it, it, it tracks from, yes, like he's
- 1:21:22expounding these things. But what's the old adage?
- 1:21:24It's don't show me or don't tell me what your, your portfolio is.
- 1:21:28Show me or like, show me what your portfolio is.
- 1:21:29Don't tell me like what you're doing, wherever your money
- 1:21:31talks. And so you can say all these
- 1:21:34things and they can resonate, but at the end of the day, if
- 1:21:36you're saying you have to stay alive, it's incongruent to park
- 1:21:40all your Bitcoin at Coinbase if that's your whole deal or
- 1:21:43Fidelity or wherever it's at. I mean, I don't.
- 1:21:46Disagree with that. Nobody talks enough about like
- 1:21:49whether like. The simplest, easiest angle to
- 1:21:52Matt's point is if you're issuing all this debt for
- 1:21:54dollars, it is not expensive to build what we built or other
- 1:21:59institutions built to go build it.
- 1:22:00That is a rational thought. If you were a rational actor,
- 1:22:05for whatever reason, to go and set this up and manage your keys
- 1:22:09and hire a bunch of engineers, hire a bunch of operations and
- 1:22:12just manage it all. If you were what people think
- 1:22:14you are, and if you don't do that, then that's what tells you
- 1:22:16that it's something else is going on.
- 1:22:18Like that's the angle of where that doesn't lie.
- 1:22:21Yeah, it is wild that, and to be clear, he doesn't keep it all
- 1:22:24like Coinbase. It's like split up between
- 1:22:25multiple districts using the Titanic approach.
- 1:22:28Yeah, yeah, the you know, if if one compartment breaks, he still
- 1:22:32has the other compartments is what I'm referring to as the
- 1:22:35Titanic approach. But yeah, it is.
- 1:22:37I don't disagree, Mike. I don't disagree.
- 1:22:39But it's why it's also over if one of those gets lost, because
- 1:22:42then all credibility goes out and then that.
- 1:22:44Just I agree. Yeah, it's it's wild that you
- 1:22:47just even overpay, like spend $100 million and set up your own
- 1:22:51custodial operation. And then you could also custody
- 1:22:53all of your little child treasury companies, right?
- 1:22:55Like he could custody semblers and they can make a business out
- 1:22:58of it if he wants to. He's already running all the
- 1:23:01conferences and stuff for all the different Dats already.
- 1:23:04It would make complete sense for him to build out his own custody
- 1:23:07and then sell it as a product to the other custody companies.
- 1:23:10It would line up perfectly and it's wild to me that he hasn't
- 1:23:13done it. The other piece is to Bram's
- 1:23:15point. Look, I mean, he has, he's been
- 1:23:19selling preferred equity, which has dividend commitments, long
- 1:23:23term dividend commitments. And as the market was going
- 1:23:26down, a lot of critics were saying he wasn't going to be
- 1:23:29able to pay those claims in the future.
- 1:23:32Even though if you do the math, you know, he was, he was in a
- 1:23:35pretty a very solvent position. Like if you did the math, he was
- 1:23:38in a very solvent position. So I actually do not blame him.
- 1:23:42It actually makes logical sense to me to like say OK, I'm going
- 1:23:44to build up a 2 1/2 billion dollar cash position to show the
- 1:23:48market that no matter what, I can fund these things 100%.
- 1:23:52But it was the same as selling Bitcoin because the the Bitcoin
- 1:23:56per share went down accordingly. He diluted his shareholders.
- 1:23:59He sold stock that is valued based on the amount of Bitcoin
- 1:24:03that he holds to buy cash. It is the same exact thing as if
- 1:24:07he sold Bitcoin in practice but in perception it was.
- 1:24:12He didn't sell Bitcoin, he sold stock to load up on cash.
- 1:24:16And that's the only point I was just trying to make there.
- 1:24:18Is this interesting how the market perceives it differently
- 1:24:21than him selling Bitcoin. If he sold Bitcoin people
- 1:24:23probably would have freaked out and said he was going to sell
- 1:24:25the whole 750K back. But this holding the stock is
- 1:24:29not a claim on the Bitcoin. Yeah.
- 1:24:32So, OK, that's a different conversation.
- 1:24:35But the market treats it as one. Yeah, the market is treating it
- 1:24:38as I'm kidding. I'm kidding.
- 1:24:40All. Right, it's a good point.
- 1:24:42It's not really a joke. All right, Yeah, that's why I
- 1:24:47don't think it's a good thing to say at the end of a 90 minute
- 1:24:50live stream. But yeah.
- 1:24:52All right, guys. Well, let's wrap it up.
- 1:24:54I want to thank Matt for joining.
- 1:24:56You should do it again sometime. And thanks for being there,
- 1:25:00Mike. Thanks and thanks everyone for
- 1:25:03watching. Hope you find it valuable.
- 1:25:05Please follow along on YouTube and X and Spotify and we'll see
- 1:25:09you next time. All right.
- 1:25:11Cheers. Bye bye.