Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / ROIC Separates Wealth Creators From Money Burners
Transcript
- 0:00You know, back in the early 20 tens, you just look at the
- 0:02traditional accounting metrics, Amazon looked like this, this
- 0:06massive value destroying machine.
- 0:08Oh, completely. Just razor thin margins.
- 0:10Right. We're just straight up losses
- 0:12quarter after quarter, and the financial press was constantly
- 0:15questioning when they would ever figure out how to, you know,
- 0:18actually make a real profit. Yeah, it was the biggest joke on
- 0:21Wall Street for a while. Exactly.
- 0:23But anyone relying on those headline numbers completely
- 0:26missed out on, well, one of the greatest wealth creation stories
- 0:30in modern market history. Because they weren't failing at
- 0:32all. They were aggressively winning.
- 0:34They were. And to see that, you only needed
- 0:36to look at one specific kind of hidden metric.
- 0:40It's the ultimate truth teller that just cuts right through all
- 0:43those accounting illusions. So welcome to the deep dive.
- 0:46Today we are unpacking that exact metric for you, which is
- 0:50return on invested capital or ROIC.
- 0:53It really is the Holy Grail of corporate profitability.
- 0:56It is, and our stack of sources today is just phenomenal.
- 1:00We're pulling from financial modeling guides by breaking into
- 1:02Wall Street, some really dense forensic accounting reports from
- 1:05new Constructs, and a couple of deep dive analytical essays from
- 1:10Dividend School and Nuggets of investing wisdom.
- 1:13Really good stuff in this. Yeah, they're great.
- 1:15So our mission today is to figure out why ROIC separates
- 1:20the true wealth creators for the money burners, how you actually
- 1:23calculate it without getting totally lost in footnote
- 1:25purgatory, and why Wall Street's obsession with top line growth
- 1:30means they just constantly mispriced these incredible
- 1:32businesses it. Happens all the time.
- 1:34It does, but before we jump into the mechanics of all this, a
- 1:37quick note for those of you looking to really take your own
- 1:39analysis to the next level to access more advanced research's
- 1:43applications and our latest published personal intelligent
- 1:45multi agent deep value intelligence.
- 1:48Welcome to explore and join deep values dot AI community to track
- 1:52total market temperature. Welcome to Search and download
- 1:54iOS App Buffett Indicator from Apple App Store.
- 1:58And I should add a quick reminder regarding the
- 2:00information we'll be discussing today.
- 2:02All analysis is based on publicly available sources and
- 2:05may be subject to revisions or differing interpretations.
- 2:08All contents from this channel are for research and
- 2:11entertainment purposes only and do not constitute any investment
- 2:14or financial advice. Conduct your own due diligence
- 2:16before making investment or financial decisions.
- 2:19Don't forget to like this video. Much appreciated.
- 2:22Awesome. Housekeeping done.
- 2:23Yeah. So let's just get right into it.
- 2:25We constantly hear acronyms thrown around a financial media
- 2:28right? Like ROEROA EBITDA.
- 2:31Oh, and alphabet soup. Seriously.
- 2:33But ROIC is the one that seasoned investors quietly
- 2:36obsess over. And there's a very specific
- 2:38reason for that, isn't there? Yeah, absolutely.
- 2:40I mean, metrics like return on equity or Roe, they're
- 2:44incredibly vulnerable to, well financial engineering.
- 2:48So a management team can artificially boost their Roe
- 2:50simply by taking on a dangerous amount of debt and using it to
- 2:53buy back stock. Oh wow.
- 2:55So they haven't actually improved the business.
- 2:56Exactly. They haven't made the underlying
- 2:58business any better at all. They've just levered it up.
- 3:01They've added risk, but ROIC on the other hand, it strips away
- 3:05all that financing noise. It looks purely at the operating
- 3:08engine. Right, and that isolation of the
- 3:11operating engine is what makes it so powerful.
- 3:13The formula itself is actually pretty elegant.
- 3:15You basically take no pat and divide it by invested capital.
- 3:19OK, let's break that down for everyone.
- 3:20No, Pat. Yeah.
- 3:21So no, PAT stands for Net Operating Profit after tax.
- 3:26The numerator is basically your operating income with taxes
- 3:29taken out. But crucially, and this is the
- 3:32key part, it completely ignores interest expenses.
- 3:36So it does not care if the company is paying like millions
- 3:40to bondholders? Not at all, because I guess the
- 3:43moment you include interest expense, you're no longer
- 3:45measuring how good the company is it selling its products.
- 3:48You're just measuring how the Treasury Department decided to
- 3:51fund the balance sheet. Right.
- 3:52You're blending operational efficiency with capital
- 3:55structure, which just muddies the waters completely.
- 3:58Precisely. So by using notepad, we strip
- 4:01the financing noise out of the profit.
- 4:04Then for the denominator invested capital, we do the
- 4:07exact opposite. We throw all the financing back
- 4:09into the pool. Yes, invested capital includes
- 4:12all the debt and all the equity. It represents every every single
- 4:15dollar that bondholders and shareholders have entrusted to
- 4:18management to run the operation. So combining those two creates a
- 4:22metric that is completely capital structure neutral.
- 4:26Completely neutral, that's. Fascinating.
- 4:28So like if you take two companies selling the exact same
- 4:30software with the exact same operating margins, but company A
- 4:35is funded entirely by issuing stock and Company B is funded
- 4:38entirely by taking out bank loans.
- 4:40They will generate the exact same ROIC.
- 4:44Wow. So management cannot hide
- 4:46operational incompetence behind cheap debt.
- 4:48They can't. The math won't let them.
- 4:50But, you know, computing that percentage is really only half
- 4:52the battle. Because knowing a company
- 4:54generates, say, a 12% return on its capital doesn't actually
- 4:57tell you if it's succeeding until you compare it to a
- 4:59benchmark, right? Right.
- 5:01The benchmark is the absolute core of corporate finance.
- 5:04It's called the WACC. Don't use ACC weighted average
- 5:08cost of capital. Exactly.
- 5:09This is the blended cost of a company's debt and equity.
- 5:13Think of the WACC as the hurdle rate.
- 5:16If a company's ROIC is greater than its WACC, it is creating
- 5:20value. Meaning every dollar management
- 5:22takes in and deploys generates a return higher than what it costs
- 5:26to acquire that dollar. Yes, and conversely, if the ROIC
- 5:29is lower than the WACC, the company is actively destroying
- 5:33shareholder wealth. Actively destroying it?
- 5:35Wow. So what should we expect those
- 5:37hurdles and returns to look like in the real world?
- 5:40Because I assume a like a steel manufacturer has a vastly
- 5:44different profile than a cloud computing from.
- 5:46Oh, totally. The capital intensity really
- 5:49dictates the expectation there. For Heavy Industries like
- 5:51utilities, automotive, manufacturing, telecom, you are
- 5:54dealing with massive physical assets.
- 5:56Factories, cell towers, that kind of thing.
- 5:58Right. So in ROIC of maybe 10 to 15% in
- 6:01those spaces is generally considered solid provided their
- 6:03cost of capital is you know down around 6 or 7%.
- 6:06OK, that makes sense. But what about asset light
- 6:09businesses? For asset light businesses like
- 6:12software consulting or really strong consumer brands that
- 6:15don't need to build massive factories to scale, you really
- 6:19expect to see an ROIC north of 20%.
- 6:22Got it. So the absolute percentage
- 6:24matters, but the spread between the ROIC and the WACC is the
- 6:28actual value creation. That spread is everything.
- 6:32And that spread is so fascinating because it
- 6:34fundamentally contradicts the narrative you see on the
- 6:36financial news networks every single day.
- 6:38Oh, completely. Like if you tune in during
- 6:41earnings season, the entire conversation is dominated by top
- 6:44line growth. It's always about revenue
- 6:46growth, user growth, expanding the total addressable market.
- 6:50Yeah, it's an obsession. But if a company has a negative
- 6:52spread, meaning their ROIC is actually lower than their WACC,
- 6:56then hyper growth is actually disaster, isn't it?
- 6:58It's a total disaster. The Dividend School piece covers
- 7:01this growth trap perfectly. They explain that growth without
- 7:04return is just malignant. Malignant.
- 7:07That's a strong word. But it's true.
- 7:09If a business model inherently destroys, say, $0.05 of value
- 7:14for every dollar of capital it deploys, then scaling that
- 7:17business model by 50% year over year just means management is
- 7:21accelerating the destruction of shareholder wealth.
- 7:24It's like a factory that loses $0.10 on every widget it
- 7:28produces, and the CEO proudly announces they're doubling
- 7:32production to capture market share.
- 7:33Exactly. They are just plowing more and
- 7:36more capital into a broken model.
- 7:38And yet, because Wall Street is so obsessed with the top line
- 7:40momentum, that stock might actually pop on the earnings
- 7:43announcement. It's crazy, and it happens all
- 7:45the time, particularly in emerging tech right where
- 7:47investors are willing to subsidize losses for a long
- 7:50time, hoping for future monopoly pricing.
- 7:52Yeah, but eventually gravity takes over.
- 7:55The companies that sustain massive market capitalizations
- 7:57over decades are the ones where growth and return align.
- 8:01The sources point to NVIDIA over the last decade as like the
- 8:04absolute master class in this alignment.
- 8:06NVIDIA is the perfect case study because everyone attributes
- 8:08their stock chart simply to the AI boom.
- 8:11Right? But the underlying engine of
- 8:13that company was compounding wealth long before anyone had
- 8:16even heard of ChatGPT. Oh, way before.
- 8:19And it all comes down to how their business model is
- 8:21structured to minimize physical invested capital while
- 8:25maximizing Notepad. Because they utilize a fabulous
- 8:28manufacturing model. Exactly.
- 8:30Unlike traditional makers historically who had to spend
- 8:3310s of billions of dollars constantly building and
- 8:35upgrading these physical fabrication plants, NVIDIA
- 8:38outsources the manufacturing. And building those plants
- 8:41drastically inflates the invested capital denominator.
- 8:44Right. Massively so.
- 8:45By outsourcing, NVIDIA keeps that denominator low.
- 8:48They pour their capital primarily into research and
- 8:50development to create highly defensible intellectual property
- 8:54instead. Which means when the demand for
- 8:56their chips explodes, their operating profits skyrocket, but
- 9:00their capital base doesn't have to grow proportionally.
- 9:03That's the magic. Over the last 10 years, Nvidia's
- 9:06ROIC consistently beat its WACC by a massive margin.
- 9:11Because they maintained that positive spread, every dollar
- 9:14they retained and reinvested into new R&D or acquisitions
- 9:17generated returns far in excess of its cost.
- 9:20And that translates directly into phenomenal free cash flow.
- 9:23Yes, when you have a massive spread, you throw off cash and
- 9:27that gives you the firepower to fund the next wave of innovation
- 9:31without having to constantly go back to the market to issue more
- 9:34stock or debt. So if ROIC is this definitive,
- 9:39if it's basically the ultimate lie detector for a business
- 9:41model, why is it buried deep in the footnotes?
- 9:45Why isn't it stamped on the front page of every 10K right
- 9:48next to earnings per share? Well, based on the forensic
- 9:50research from new constructs, it seems like getting to a true
- 9:53ROIC requires an unbelievable amount of tedious manual
- 9:57adjustments. Because Wall Street relies
- 9:59heavily on gap accounting, and gap doesn't always reflect
- 10:02economic reality. Not at all.
- 10:04Gap accounting is inherently conservative, often to a fault.
- 10:07The new construct source features a start billing
- 10:09statistic that really highlights the severity of this.
- 10:12Oh, the CFO survey. Yeah, they cite a survey of over
- 10:14500 chief financial officers. These are the people whose
- 10:18entire job is to sign off on the financials.
- 10:20And 20% of those CFO's believe that reported earnings are.
- 10:24And I quote. Fudged.
- 10:26Wait, 20%? One in five CF OS admit the
- 10:30headline numbers are essentially manipulated.
- 10:32One in five, and they estimated the magnitude of that
- 10:35misrepresentation to be roughly 10%.
- 10:38That is wild. So the reported net income or
- 10:40EPS, you see flashing across your screen is frequently
- 10:44distorted. To get a true picture of
- 10:46profitability, you really have to do the forensic work of
- 10:50adjusting both the income statement and the balance sheet
- 10:53to reverse those accounting illusions.
- 10:55And a huge part of that distortion has to be how the
- 10:59accounting rules treat future investments, right?
- 11:01Like if I'm building a software platform or developing a new
- 11:04drug, GAP forces me to treat all that R&D as an immediate
- 11:09operating expense. Yep, it hits the income
- 11:11statement right away. And that completely crushes my
- 11:13net income for that year. But economically, R&D isn't like
- 11:17paying the electric bill. It's an investment in an asset
- 11:20that's going to generate cash for the next decade.
- 11:22That is the most significant adjustment required for modern
- 11:24companies to calculate a true ROIC.
- 11:27You have to stop treating R&D as an expense.
- 11:30You must capitalize it and amortize it over its useful
- 11:32life. Walk me through how that works
- 11:34mechanically. Sure, The source gives a very
- 11:37clear example. Suppose a tech company incurs
- 11:40$120 million R&D expense this year.
- 11:43Instead of letting that $120 million completely destroy your
- 11:46profit margin, you take it off the income statement and add it
- 11:50back to invested capital on the balance sheet.
- 11:53OK. So you are recognizing it as an
- 11:55asset? Right, because management
- 11:57essentially bought $120 million worth of future intellectual
- 12:00property. Then in your profit calculation,
- 12:03your adjusted notepad, you replace that massive one time
- 12:06expense with a much smaller amortization charge.
- 12:09I see. So if you assume the software
- 12:11has a five year useful life, you only take a $24 million charge
- 12:15against your profit this year. Wow, that completely transforms
- 12:19the financial profile of the company.
- 12:21The operating profit looks drastically higher, but the
- 12:23capital base, the denominator, looks larger too.
- 12:26Exactly. It forces the investor to
- 12:28actually measure whether that R&D investment is earning a
- 12:31return over the next five years, rather than just treating it as
- 12:34a sump cost. And this brings us right back to
- 12:36the Amazon example we talked about at the start.
- 12:39The Nuggets of Investing Wisdom source highlights this
- 12:42beautifully. Oh, Amazon is the classic
- 12:44example of this. Because in the 20 tens, they
- 12:46were pouring billions into developing AWS and building out
- 12:51their prime logistics network under GAAP rules, a massive
- 12:56portion of this was expensed immediately.
- 12:58Which is why their reported earnings were perpetually near
- 13:010. And traditional value investors
- 13:03just refused to touch the stock. They looked at the Gap ROIC and
- 13:07thought Amazon wasn't even earning its cost of capital.
- 13:10But if you made the adjustments, if you capitalize the R&D and
- 13:13recognize the infrastructure spend for what it was, the true
- 13:17ROIC showed a completely different reality.
- 13:19It unmasked the fact that Amazon was building a highly profitable
- 13:23wide Moat monopoly. Exactly.
- 13:25The core operations were incredibly capital efficient,
- 13:28but the gap accounting severely penalized their aggressive
- 13:32reinvestment phase. So doing these adjustments isn't
- 13:35just an academic exercise, it's literally the difference between
- 13:38missing a generational stock and holding it Excellent.
- 13:40What other illusions do we have to fix on the balance sheet to
- 13:44get the real number? Well, excess cash is A major 1A
- 13:47company like Apple might sit on 10s of billions of dollars in
- 13:50cash that isn't actually being deployed in the core business.
- 13:53So it shouldn't be counted against them.
- 13:55Right. When calculating invested
- 13:57capital, you typically only keep one to three months worth of
- 14:00operating cash in the denominator because that's all
- 14:03that's required to run the day-to-day business.
- 14:05You strip the rest out. Because if you leave a massive
- 14:08cash hoard in the denominator, you're artificially depressing
- 14:12the ROIC. You're making management look
- 14:15worse at operating the business than they actually are.
- 14:18Spot on. You also have to adjust for
- 14:20things like off balance sheet operating leases and pension
- 14:23deficits. It really is meticulous forensic
- 14:25work. OK, so let's say I'm running a
- 14:27stock Screener tonight and I do all this rigorous work to filter
- 14:30the S&P 500 for the highest adjusted ROIC.
- 14:34Is there a sector where this metric is just going to blow up
- 14:36in my face? Like are there business models
- 14:39where even the adjusted ROIC is totally irrelevant?
- 14:43Oh, definitely. ROIC is not a universal skeleton
- 14:46key. Both the Ryan O'Connell and
- 14:49Dividend School sources explicitly map out where this
- 14:52metric breaks down, and the most glaring exception is the
- 14:55financial sector. Because of how banks treat
- 14:59interest. Exactly.
- 15:00Our entire calculation, reliance on no PAT stripping out interest
- 15:04expense, so we can focus purely on operations, but for a bank
- 15:08taking in deposits, paying interest on them and lending
- 15:11that capital out to collect a higher interest rate, that
- 15:13spread is their core operation. You've hit the nail on the head.
- 15:17For a commercial bank or an insurance company, interest is
- 15:20not a financing cost. It is their primary operating
- 15:23revenue and expense. So if you strip out interest to
- 15:26calculate Notepad, you basically deleted the bank's entire
- 15:29business model from the spreadsheet.
- 15:30Pretty much you have to evaluate financials using different
- 15:33efficiency ratios and return on equity metrics instead.
- 15:36That makes a lot of sense. What about companies that are
- 15:38just fundamentally unprofitable right now, like early stage
- 15:41biotech or hyper growth saws companies?
- 15:43Unprofitable tech is the other major limit here.
- 15:46Early stage companies are almost always going to have a negative
- 15:50ROIC because they're burning through venture capital or IPO
- 15:53cash to aggressively acquire users and scale infrastructure.
- 15:58So looking at trailing ROIC for a startup is just staring at the
- 16:02rear view mirror of an investment phase.
- 16:04Yeah, it tells you nothing about the future.
- 16:06So for those companies, you can't rely on the current
- 16:09corporate level metric. You have to look at the unit
- 16:11economics. Exactly.
- 16:13You have to isolate the cost of acquiring a single customer and
- 16:16the lifetime value of that customer.
- 16:18And ask, if this company stopped burning cash for hyper growth
- 16:21today, what would its mature margins look like?
- 16:25Right, you are projecting a forward-looking steady state
- 16:28ROIC. You have to determine if the
- 16:31underlying unit economics are inherently profitable at scale,
- 16:34or if they're just structurally flawed.
- 16:36Let's pivot to market psychology for a minute, because everything
- 16:39we've discussed so far assumes the market is perfectly
- 16:41rational. Which is a huge assumption.
- 16:43Right. If a company does all this
- 16:45right, capitalizes R&D, strips out excess cash, proves it has a
- 16:49massive ROIC spread over its WACC, Wall Street must just
- 16:53throw money at them, right? Does higher ROIC always
- 16:56guarantee a premium valuation? Not always, no, And that
- 17:00disconnect is where the alpha is generated.
- 17:02The Breaking into Wall Street source provides a fantastic
- 17:05historical example of this with Best Buy versus Target.
- 17:09OK to massive mature big box retailers?
- 17:13Right now, economic theory dictates that if Best Buy has a
- 17:16higher ROIC than Target, Target, meaning Best Buy generates more
- 17:19cash profit for every dollar of capital tied up in its stores
- 17:22and inventory, then Best Buy should naturally trade at a
- 17:25higher valuation multiple. Market should reward the
- 17:28superior wealth creator. Exactly.
- 17:30But the data showed the exact opposite.
- 17:32At the time, Best Buy was actually trading at
- 17:34significantly lower multiples than Target, despite its vastly
- 17:37superior ROIC. So.
- 17:38Why was the market pricing target as the Better Business?
- 17:41Was it just a massive miscalculation by institutional
- 17:44investors? It wasn't a math error, was a
- 17:47narrative fear. During that period, the market
- 17:50was absolutely terrified of the showrooming effect.
- 17:53Oh, showrooming, where consumers use Best Buy stores just to look
- 17:57at electronics in person and then go home to buy them cheaper
- 18:00on Amazon. Yes exactly.
- 18:02The market priced Best Buy at a discount because they believed
- 18:05it's high. ROIC was just a fragile mirage
- 18:08that was about to collapse under e-commerce competition.
- 18:11But if you trusted the core capital efficiency, if you
- 18:15looked at the cash Best Buy was actually generating relative to
- 18:18its footprint, you could see the business was incredibly
- 18:21resilient. Right.
- 18:22The market's fear had created a massive mispricing, and that
- 18:25made it an incredible buying opportunity for value investors
- 18:28who trusted the metric over the narrative.
- 18:31That is such a great example of how investors should use ROIC.
- 18:35It doesn't give you a definitive buy or sell rating, but when you
- 18:38see a massive disconnect between a company's ROIC and its
- 18:42valuation multiple, it's a glaring signal that something is
- 18:45off. It tells you exactly where to
- 18:47dig. Either the market is mispressing
- 18:48the stock, or the market knows something catastrophic about the
- 18:51future that just hasn't hit the trailing numbers yet.
- 18:54Sometimes, though, the disconnect isn't driven by
- 18:57market fear. It's driven by the people
- 19:00running the company itself. The corporate governance angle
- 19:03here is fascinating because executive management teams are
- 19:06often incentivized to focus on the wrong metrics entirely.
- 19:09Oh, agency theory is a huge problem in corporate finance.
- 19:13The new construct source features a brilliant case study
- 19:16on Oracle arguing that management teams frequently
- 19:19destroy value simply because their compensation packages are
- 19:22misaligned. Because CE OS are often paid
- 19:24massive bonuses for hitting earnings per share targets or
- 19:27revenue growth targets. Exactly which encourages
- 19:31terrible behavior. I mean, if I'm ACEO paid on EPS
- 19:34growth, I might borrow billions of dollars to buy a mediocre
- 19:37competitor. The acquisition might add a
- 19:39little bit of that income which boosts my EPS so I get my bonus.
- 19:43But the return on the billions you just spent is abysmal.
- 19:46You've destroyed long term shareholder value just to hit a
- 19:49short term accounting target. That is wild.
- 19:52And that is the exact crap the Oracle thesis addresses.
- 19:56The argument is that if a massive legacy tech company like
- 19:59Oracle stop chasing accounting earnings and completely aligned
- 20:02its corporate strategy and executive compensation with real
- 20:06cash flows, meaning ROIC. The results would be staggering.
- 20:10How staggering? The study proposed that by
- 20:12shifting executive incentives to focus purely on returns on
- 20:15invested capital, Oracle could unlock an incredible $65 billion
- 20:20in dormant market value. $65 billion just by changing what
- 20:24the CEO gets paid to care about. Because the moment you pay
- 20:27executives to generate a spread or the WACC, they stop making
- 20:31ego driven, value destroying acquisitions.
- 20:34They stop hoarding excess cash. They become ruthless stewards of
- 20:37capital, and the market inevitably rewards that
- 20:40structural discipline with a higher multiple.
- 20:42It forces management to think like owners rather than just
- 20:45employees chasing a quarterly bonus.
- 20:47So bring this all together for you listening.
- 20:49What we've unpacked today is that ROIC isn't just some
- 20:51esoteric formula for hedge fund analysts, it is the ultimate lie
- 20:55detector for a business model. It really is.
- 20:57It cuts through the noise of leverage and debt, it slices
- 21:01through the conservative illusions of gap accounting.
- 21:04And it answers the only question that truly matters to a long
- 21:07term investor. Is this business actually
- 21:09creating wealth, or is it just spinning its wheels and burning
- 21:13cash under the guise of growth? It remains the cleanest window
- 21:16into a management team's ability to allocate capital.
- 21:20However, as we look to the future, I want to leave you with
- 21:23a structural question to ponder. Oh, I like where this is going.
- 21:26We've established that a high ROIC relies heavily on keeping
- 21:29invested capital low, right? But as we move deeper into a
- 21:33digital economy where AI platforms and software as a
- 21:36service companies can scale globally with almost zero
- 21:40physical assets and near 0 marginal costs, the traditional
- 21:44definition of invested capital is fundamentally shrinking.
- 21:47It's basically vanishing. Right.
- 21:48So we have to ask ourselves, if the denominator approaches 0,
- 21:51will our traditional metrics for measuring capital efficiency
- 21:54become completely obsolete? And if so, how will we quantify
- 21:59true value creation a decade from now?
- 22:01That is a profound thought. I mean, if it takes practically
- 22:05no capital to run an AI agent that generates millions in
- 22:08revenue, the math of capitalism starts to look very, very
- 22:13different. It really does.
- 22:15Well, thank you for joining us on this deep dive.
- 22:17You are now equipped to look past the top line growth hype
- 22:20and see the actual engine driving a business.
- 22:22The next time you hear ACEO touting record revenues on a
- 22:25financial network, you know exactly what to look for in the
- 22:28footnotes. Just remember it might look
- 22:30pristine on the surface. But until you adjust the
- 22:32accounting and check the return on capital, you're still
- 22:35swimming in murky waters.