Latest / Think Fast Talk Smart: Communication Techniques / 234. Need to Know: Lead With Transparency, Character, and Silence
Transcript
- 0:02Matt Abrahams: Effective leaders, effective communicators, focus on
- 0:07clarity, context, and character.
- 0:10My name's Matt Abrahams and I teach strategic communication at
- 0:14Stanford Graduate School of Business.
- 0:16Welcome to Think Fast Talk Smart, the podcast.
- 0:21Today I am grateful to speak to General Stanley McChrystal.
- 0:25General McChrystal is a retired four star general, former commander of US
- 0:29and international forces in Afghanistan, and a renowned expert on leadership.
- 0:34He is best known for revolutionizing counter-terrorism operations and building
- 0:38cohesive teams in complex environments.
- 0:41He's a highly successful author with books like Team of Teams and his latest,
- 0:46On Character: Choices That Define a Life.
- 0:50Welcome, I have been excited for this conversation for a long time.
- 0:53Thank you.
- 0:54General Stanley McChrystal: Well, Matt, thanks for having me.
- 0:55I'm looking forward to it as well.
- 0:57Matt Abrahams: Excellent.
- 0:57Shall we get started?
- 0:59General Stanley McChrystal: Please.
- 1:00Matt Abrahams: General McChrystal, I'm a huge admirer of your book Team of
- 1:03Teams, and in it you talk about shared consciousness and shared information.
- 1:07What is it that leaders can do to build that shared consciousness,
- 1:12especially in an environment where we're drowning in emails and Slacks?
- 1:16How can we actually come together around a shared point of view?
- 1:21General Stanley McChrystal: The first thing about sharing information that I
- 1:23found later in my military career is we had natural silos vertically, and then
- 1:29we also had the hierarchy creates other boundaries for the flow of information.
- 1:35So information in structures, bureaucracies, think pyramid shaped
- 1:39hierarchies, tend to follow carefully prescribed routes up and down and
- 1:44whatnot, and not across as easily unless it is encouraged and in fact demanded.
- 1:51And so what I found was first, you need to change the mindset.
- 1:55In the old days in, in the military, you never got in trouble for
- 1:58information you didn't share to someone.
- 2:02But you could be criticized if you shared some information that
- 2:05you didn't have approval from your boss or your chain of command.
- 2:08So we tried to flip that on its head and say that you are responsible
- 2:13for informing other people of things that they need to know.
- 2:17And then you say, how do I know what they need to know?
- 2:19And the answer is, you never really do.
- 2:22So the default needs to be to share and then overshare.
- 2:27In fact, I, I said something when I took over the Counter-terrorist Force, which
- 2:30was a complex community of different organizations, the goal is to have
- 2:36everyone know everything, all the time.
- 2:40Now, that's impossible, clearly.
- 2:42But the concept of shared consciousness is we all have a common contextual
- 2:47understanding of what the situation is, what we are trying to do, and
- 2:53then people can make decisions without going and get approval for everything
- 2:58they're gonna do because they have the context, they're informed.
- 3:02And so the biggest thing I found was first change the rules of information
- 3:07sharing, and then more slowly change the culture of information sharing.
- 3:12Matt Abrahams: So context is critical.
- 3:13And also the approach, being that the idea is get all the information to everybody
- 3:19and not worry about the potential negative ramifications of that information.
- 3:23General Stanley McChrystal: The idea that information is power, you don't want to
- 3:27share information 'cause someone knows that you won't be quite as important.
- 3:30So it becomes very important to break down those hesitations in sharing information.
- 3:37And then there's the last one, which I really see more in civilian business.
- 3:41We don't want to scare the children, so we don't want to tell 'em that
- 3:44revenue's down or that there are headwinds in the marketplace.
- 3:48The reality is when we leave a vacuum in our teams, they fill it with the
- 3:53darkest ideas available because there are all sorts of information sources out
- 3:59there, many of which are very flawed.
- 4:01So you have to not try to prevent information, you have
- 4:04to compete with information that they're already receiving.
- 4:08Matt Abrahams: That's a really powerful point, that if you're not communicating,
- 4:11people will find and fill that vacuum on their own, and it might be much
- 4:15worse than what the reality is.
- 4:16I'm curious, I totally appreciate and understand changing
- 4:19the mindset and approach.
- 4:21Were there certain things that you've implemented or have seen implemented
- 4:24that really help reinforce it?
- 4:25It's one thing for the leader to say, share everything so we
- 4:28all have the same information.
- 4:30But a lot of people inherently might not do that.
- 4:32So is it role modeling?
- 4:34Is it rewarding when it's done well?
- 4:36How do you actually get people to do that?
- 4:38General Stanley McChrystal: I could mention several.
- 4:40The first of course is role models, senior leaders.
- 4:42They've gotta be as transparent as they can.
- 4:45We like to look up at the sphinx like CEO, who only pronounces
- 4:50something occasionally, but I found it's better to over communicate.
- 4:53The second is you've gotta set up processes and
- 4:56technologies which allow that.
- 4:58And so nowadays with information technology as omnipresent as
- 5:03it is we can usually reach everybody almost at any time.
- 5:08We need to leverage that.
- 5:10Matt Abrahams: So it's really about people, process, and tools are the ways
- 5:14that you actually affect that change.
- 5:15Thank you.
- 5:17You have often worked in very diverse situations with military,
- 5:20government, international partners, and local populations.
- 5:24All of these have very different goals, communication styles, and cultural norms.
- 5:29How do you adapt to ensure clarity and build trust, especially when you are
- 5:34in very ambiguous and uncertain times?
- 5:38General Stanley McChrystal: Yeah, Matt, first you have to
- 5:39start out by recognizing it.
- 5:41I remember, and I've described this, I'd be in Afghanistan and I'd be
- 5:44meeting with Pashtun elders with a different language than I spoke, a
- 5:48different religion, a different culture.
- 5:51So when I sat with them and talked, it was just absolutely obvious
- 5:55that we had a cultural divide in communicating, and so we were very
- 5:59careful about how we communicated.
- 6:01Then I would meet with people from the US Department of State, for example.
- 6:05They speak English, we have a shared culture, a shared
- 6:08religion, all of those things.
- 6:11But actually the cultural divide was huge.
- 6:15And I could be speaking military and thinking that it is being heard with
- 6:21the same kind of understanding that I hope it will, and that wasn't the case.
- 6:25And then vice versa.
- 6:26And sometimes just titles or uniforms or difference in organizations can create
- 6:32this, but we don't seem sensitive to that.
- 6:36And so we walk out of the room and we say, Matt's just, he's stupid.
- 6:41He's got a bad attitude.
- 6:42He doesn't listen.
- 6:43When in fact that comes at it from a completely different direction than
- 6:48I do, and we need to appreciate that.
- 6:50Matt Abrahams: I have certainly been called stupid and unprepared in many
- 6:52situations, but the point you are making is very clear that we have to first
- 6:56appreciate and understand the differences.
- 6:58And sometimes those cultural differences aren't just the things
- 7:01you see on the outside, how somebody looks or where somebody is located.
- 7:05Those cultural differences can be within the same organization.
- 7:08You and your colleagues in the State Department are part of the US government.
- 7:13So really important to recognize it and then adjust your communication, for sure.
- 7:17All leaders have to give difficult news and challenging information.
- 7:23Maybe it's a failed project, a change in strategy, or even negative feedback.
- 7:27How do you approach giving bad news or challenging news?
- 7:31Is there a structure you use?
- 7:33A way of going about it that you have found helps you to be more successful?
- 7:37General Stanley McChrystal: I think the first is you've gotta
- 7:38communicate it as clearly and as quickly as you are capable of doing.
- 7:43There is no real advantage in trying to make it seem not as
- 7:48serious as it is or to sugarcoat it.
- 7:51And so I think you start by saying, okay, I've got some very
- 7:55serious information to pass.
- 7:57Here it is.
- 7:58Now the other thing though, occasionally a leader will do that
- 8:02and then wanna walk out of the room.
- 8:04Drop the bombshell and wanna walk outta the room.
- 8:06Context is very important because if a CEO walks into the company and says,
- 8:13everyone's pay is gonna be cut fifty percent, life's hard, and walks out,
- 8:19you get one response from everybody.
- 8:21If the CEO goes, okay, lemme be upfront.
- 8:24Everyone's pay is being cut.
- 8:25Here's why.
- 8:27Here's the context, here's the rationale.
- 8:29Here's what we're trying to do with it.
- 8:31Now you gotta avoid the temptation to say, and you know it's gonna be okay,
- 8:35if you're not sure it's gonna be okay.
- 8:37But you can communicate things like, I am committed to this team.
- 8:41We will work through this.
- 8:43If we think back to COVID-19, when it first started, the
- 8:46great thing was uncertainty.
- 8:48And so we had to all communicate with our teammates who are now
- 8:51geographically distributed, and many of 'em are sitting in their
- 8:55apartments or at their kitchen table.
- 8:57They don't know if they're still gonna have a job.
- 8:59They don't know how to interact.
- 9:00And so we can communicate, Hey, this is serious.
- 9:05We don't know exactly how it's gonna play out, but here's what you can count on.
- 9:09I'm gonna be committed for your welfare.
- 9:12Promise those things that are within your power to promise.
- 9:15Matt Abrahams: So it sounds to me like three things are really important.
- 9:17One is clarity, being very clear and direct.
- 9:20Second is understanding and appreciating the context and sticking in that context.
- 9:25And then what I also heard you talking about was connection, really connecting
- 9:29to the people, not just dropping it and running, but connecting the information
- 9:33and the next steps to the individuals.
- 9:35And I think those three steps of clarity, context, and connection are
- 9:40really important for any communication, let alone that's challenging.
- 9:44I'd like to follow up on this COVID situation that you mentioned,
- 9:47because that fundamentally changed the way we communicated.
- 9:50We were all remote and distanced.
- 9:53How have you dealt with leading and communicating when you're
- 9:57doing it through a screen, when not everybody is in the same room.
- 10:01What best practices do you employ to help you be effective and continue to connect
- 10:06and build trust with those you're leading?
- 10:08General Stanley McChrystal: Yeah.
- 10:09Let me start, Matt, I actually had a head start on this because in the
- 10:13Counter-terrorist Force starting in 2003, my force was spread across seventy-six
- 10:18bases in twenty-seven countries, and we were just at the beginning
- 10:23of secure video teleconferencing.
- 10:26And so that's how we communicated essentially all the time.
- 10:30Now, I learned a number of things.
- 10:32I learned first that it's not nearly as effective as we wanna believe it is.
- 10:36It's not like being in the room.
- 10:38And so, the first is you try to build up, whenever you have the opportunity,
- 10:44relationships, usually in person, that you can then build and communicate later.
- 10:50So if you and I had a real close personal relationship, we could
- 10:53then do virtual things at a much higher level of effectiveness
- 10:57than if we didn't know each other.
- 10:59So you're building upon a foundation.
- 11:01The next thing is communication, particularly between different ranks
- 11:06in an organization, can be fraught.
- 11:09So for example, I would communicate with very junior people and
- 11:13I was a commanding general.
- 11:14And they would come on the screen and clearly they are terrified
- 11:18because they've never spoken to someone that senior before.
- 11:21And I tried to first say, hello, Susan, how are you?
- 11:26And in many cases they go, how does he know my name?
- 11:29The answer is, I had a cheat sheet because I knew that was important to do that.
- 11:34And then when they communicated at the end of their communication, I would always
- 11:38ask a question, even if I knew the answer.
- 11:40And that was for two things.
- 11:42It was to communicate to them that what they are doing is important and listening,
- 11:47and to give them another opportunity to demonstrate their expertise.
- 11:51Because you're building their confidence and you're trying to
- 11:54build this relationship as you go.
- 11:57I would never sit there just quietly and go, thank you.
- 12:01We're okay.
- 12:02Because if you're a young person and you brief Matt Abraham's, and then at the end
- 12:06of it you just go, thanks, I have no idea whether you're thinking, thanks, that
- 12:11was terrible, or, thanks, that was great.
- 12:13So you have to exaggerate your positivity.
- 12:17You have to be very careful about your negativity because I found
- 12:21that if I am multitasking, if you're briefing me and you spent a lot
- 12:25of time and I'm down looking at my computer or I'm talking to the person
- 12:29next to me, one, it's disrespectful and it's embarrassing to you.
- 12:34And two, it just, it makes you not want to communicate and so
- 12:38it becomes really difficult.
- 12:40And finally, if you got bad news to communicate, that's gotta be done
- 12:45very carefully because if you've got a group of people and someone does
- 12:50something and you sort of take 'em on.
- 12:53It's not like in a room where at the end of the meeting you can walk to
- 12:56the end of the table and put your hand on their shoulder and go to the
- 12:58coffee maker or something like that.
- 13:01They are going to literally stew in what they think was your negative impression.
- 13:08And so it becomes very important.
- 13:10And then the last thing, in big groups, you even have to watch your
- 13:13facial expressions 'cause somebody's briefing you and I used to take my
- 13:17glasses off and go like this, and the chat rooms would light up and they'd
- 13:23say, what's bothering the old man?
- 13:24Well, sometimes I just had to wipe my face off, but I became sensitive
- 13:27to the fact that without being in the room, they are relying on fewer
- 13:32cues, and so they over-index on those.
- 13:37So I think we've all gotta make a real conscious effort to understand
- 13:42that virtual is not the same.
- 13:44And a lot of people say, no, we're a virtual society now.
- 13:47We don't need to be in person.
- 13:49My counter to that is we found out during COVID that remote education for
- 13:54our children doesn't work very well.
- 13:56And you say, well, that's kids.
- 13:58No, that's all of us.
- 13:59We ought to pay attention to that because if it didn't work, hasn't worked
- 14:03in education, why do we want to tell ourselves we're as effective, remotely
- 14:10working as we want to believe we are?
- 14:12Matt Abrahams: That last point is a really important one because if you think
- 14:14about it, you have teachers who have been trained in ways to communicate and to
- 14:18connect, and if they can't make it work, how can we expect those of us who don't
- 14:22have that training to be able to do it.
- 14:24So several things there that you said are really important.
- 14:26I'm gonna start with the nonverbal presence.
- 14:29When we have fewer cues, we really pay attention to them and we have to make sure
- 14:33that we do things as simple as looking at the camera when we're talking to people,
- 14:37reminding ourselves that what we do signals information, not just what we say.
- 14:42The fact that you would go out of your way to build connection and comfort is really
- 14:48important because when we don't have that preexisting relationship, it really is
- 14:54mandatory that we actually try to connect.
- 14:56And I love that you would not only connect with the person by identifying their name.
- 15:01But at the end, you would check in with them through asking a question.
- 15:03Others paraphrase or summarize.
- 15:06There's a lot you can do to signal that you're interested
- 15:08and that you heard the person.
- 15:10And being virtual really forces us to do that.
- 15:12So thank you for those best practices.
- 15:14In your latest book, On Character, which I love and think is really important,
- 15:19especially in this day and time.
- 15:21You argue that character is iterative.
- 15:23It's built through a succession of choices and actions.
- 15:27How can individuals leverage their everyday action and communication
- 15:31as tools for their own personal development of their character?
- 15:35General Stanley McChrystal: Yeah.
- 15:36I feel very strongly about that, Matt, and thanks for the kind words.
- 15:39We start something, think of a diet you start, or you quit smoking, or you
- 15:43make some other promise to yourself, I am going to do something differently
- 15:47than the way I've done it that's gonna make me a better person in some ways.
- 15:51As you do those things, typically the longer you go, the more reason
- 15:56you have not to break the strength.
- 15:59If you've been on your diet for two days, you can break it
- 16:02and you don't feel that bad.
- 16:02If you've been on it for two months, you say, I don't wanna break
- 16:06this because I really feel good.
- 16:08On character the same way applies.
- 16:11Some of them are just simply habits.
- 16:14I am going to be honest, and you might say, no, wait a minute.
- 16:18I'm an honest person.
- 16:19I don't have to remind myself.
- 16:21We do have to remind ourselves.
- 16:23We have to remind ourselves what we mean by integrity, how honest we
- 16:28intend to be in every interaction, and we have to hold ourselves to that.
- 16:32How we treat people, the respect we show for people, the grace we give to people.
- 16:38Again, it's something where we have to establish a clear standard and says,
- 16:43my standard for dealing with this kind of people in this kind of situation is
- 16:47this, and I am not gonna violate it.
- 16:50Now, you will find you get tired or irritable and you might, but
- 16:55that can't reset the standard.
- 16:56What you've gotta do is you say, my standard is this.
- 17:00I didn't do that.
- 17:01I'm gonna, that's a mistake.
- 17:03I will try not to do that again.
- 17:06But we have a series of things that become almost like the rules of civility that
- 17:11George Washington made so famous when he wrote 'em down when he was a young
- 17:15man, and some of 'em are very basic, but they were just reminders to him.
- 17:19There's certain things you do and don't do.
- 17:22We need the same for ourselves.
- 17:24Matt Abrahams: Absolutely.
- 17:25And you highlight something that you talk about, this say, do gap, how you have to
- 17:29commit to something and then you actually have to show it and demonstrate it.
- 17:34Before we end, I like to ask everybody three questions.
- 17:37One I create just for you and the other two I've been asking people for
- 17:41as long as we've been doing this show.
- 17:42Are you up for that?
- 17:43General Stanley McChrystal: Sure.
- 17:44Matt Abrahams: Alright.
- 17:45I've done a fair amount of work with the US military and intelligence
- 17:48agencies, and they're known for very structured communication with briefings.
- 17:53For those of us who are outside the military, what are one or
- 17:56two valuable communication skills that you learned that help you be
- 18:01successful in the things that you did?
- 18:03General Stanley McChrystal: The first is to be very clear.
- 18:05You know, we'd call it bottom line, up front.
- 18:07Say what you're trying to communicate, don't obfuscate
- 18:10it, and a bunch of other data.
- 18:12Just say, X is X, and that's what I think.
- 18:15The second is, understand that there is a hierarchical
- 18:19pressure for a certain outcome.
- 18:22Sometimes people have a briefing because they want to get a certain
- 18:26answer, and you've gotta understand that that's not your role.
- 18:30Matt Abrahams: So managing and maybe even pushing back against those
- 18:33conformity pressures is really important.
- 18:35And again, clarity, and make sure that what you're saying is
- 18:38upfront, not buried in the details.
- 18:40General Stanley McChrystal: That's right.
- 18:41Matt Abrahams: Question number two, and I'll be very curious to hear your answer.
- 18:43Who is a communicator that you admire and why?
- 18:47General Stanley McChrystal: There are a number of very effective communicators.
- 18:50If you go back to someone like Franklin Delano Roosevelt or Abraham
- 18:54Lincoln, they had a very measured cadence in communicating with the
- 18:58American people, and they always tied it to values and general goals.
- 19:04And so like Franklin Roosevelt at the beginning of his first term, you know,
- 19:08depths of the depression, he's trying to communicate hope, he's trying to
- 19:12communicate action, he's trying to communicate we are all in this together.
- 19:16And so I find when I read and listen to the old recordings of that, a real
- 19:22sense of he knew what he was trying to accomplish with communication.
- 19:27He wasn't just communicating for the joy of it.
- 19:30And so I admire people with that kind of discipline.
- 19:33Matt Abrahams: So it's the discipline, the focus, and attaching it to bigger values,
- 19:37and not surprising for somebody who has studied and thought a lot about character.
- 19:42Our final question, what are the first three ingredients that go into
- 19:46a successful communication recipe?
- 19:48I can almost be sure that clarity is going to be part of that.
- 19:52General Stanley McChrystal: Yeah, it's gotta be timely and it's gotta
- 19:55be genuine because at some point, whether or not we believe what we're
- 20:00communicating matters, we may get out and think we can disassemble in
- 20:04front of a bunch of people and they'll buy it, but over time it comes back.
- 20:08So if you don't believe it, it is problematic to stand up there and say it.
- 20:13Matt Abrahams: Clarity, timeliness, and genuine and authenticity really important.
- 20:19Well, thank you General McChrystal for your time and for your insight and
- 20:23for the good work you are doing around character and character building.
- 20:27Clearly in our time that's very important.
- 20:29I appreciate the learnings and the lessons.
- 20:32General Stanley McChrystal: You're kind to have me, Matt.
- 20:33Thank you.
- 20:37Matt Abrahams: Thank you for joining us for another episode of
- 20:39Think Fast Talk Smart, the podcast.
- 20:42To learn more about high stakes leadership under pressure, listen to episode 155 with
- 20:46Susan Rice or Episode 161 with Jen Psaki.
- 20:50This episode was produced by Katherine Reed, Ryan Campos, and me, Matt Abrahams.
- 20:56Our music is from Floyd Wonder.
- 20:58With special thanks to Podium Podcast Company.
- 21:01Please find us on YouTube and wherever you get your podcasts.
- 21:04Be sure to subscribe and rate us.
- 21:07Also follow us on LinkedIn, Instagram and TikTok.
- 21:10And check out fastersmarter.io for deep dive videos, English language
- 21:14learning content, and our newsletter.
- 21:17Please consider our premium offering for extended Deep Thinks episodes,
- 21:21Ask Matt Anythings, and much more, at fastersmarter.io/premium.