Latest / The Thyroid (and Hormone) Fixer Podcast: Thyropause, Menopause, Metabolism and How to Fix It / 402. Breast Cancer and Hormone Connection - Do Hormones Cause Cancer?
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to the Thyroid Fixer podcast. I'm your host, Dr. Amy, and we're diving deep into the world of hormones, especially for all you fierce women in perimenopause and menopause, and anyone dealing with hypothyroidism. If you're struggling with weight gain, you feel like shedding those pounds is an impossible feat. If you're dealing with plummeting energy levels, gut-wrenching fatigue, or a libido that seems to have left town, then you're in the right place.
- 0:25And don't even get me started on the hair loss. If these symptoms are sounding all too familiar, you sound your tribe. Welcome. Because my goal is to educate, empower, and shake up your world.
- 0:38I want you to embrace every inch of that badass woman that you truly are. So if you're ready to dive in and fix things, let's get started. Dr. Julie Taguchi, thank you so much for joining me. You are just a wealth of knowledge, and this is so needed. We were talking off camera before we started here just about how many questions I receive from my own patients, from my listeners, and I'm going to be able to get started.
- 1:03surrounding using hormones before they're diagnosed with breast cancer. Hopefully they won't be. But even after they've gone through some kind of cancer treatment or they are diagnosed with breast cancer. So we're going to really get in the weeds today and answer some tough questions, some burning questions that are definitely on my listeners' minds. They are thinking this, even if they haven't said it yet.
- 1:27So welcome to the show. And I really want to start off by hearing from you what your path was, because you started off just in oncology, you know, conventional medicine, and you've enlightened yourself. You've dove into the studies on hormones. And now you're kind of what we were talking about. You're a way out of the box thinker.
- 1:50integrative oncologist because we can't just call you just integrative because you're doing things that even integrative oncologists aren't doing. So please start off with telling us more about you and really how you came into this field.
- 2:04So first of all, thank you for having me and sharing our time together. I appreciate that. Well, it's really interesting. As you said, I started out in mainstream medicine, and I was really actually fortunate enough to run into a person named Susie Wiley. I don't know if you know her or know about that name, but this woman lived in Santa Barbara, and she had been doing research on hormones and ovarian cancer. And so she was doing actual experiments with somebody in town.
- 2:30And mostly using progesterone, showing that progesterone can basically kill cancer cells. Okay. So she came into my office because I had a 90-year-old gentleman with metastatic transitional cell carcinoma of the urinary bladder and the kidney. And he had moved from Louisiana to Santa Barbara to be with his daughters.
- 2:52who were taking care of him. This man was a physician and he had every, I call it the every apathy you can imagine, cardiomyopathy, the neuropathy. It was amazing. And when I first met him in Santa Barbara, he already had surgery, he had partial surgery, he had chemotherapy, and he had one round of radiation therapy and he was supposedly in remission. He comes to see me
- 3:13I get a chest X-ray and it's the classic bullet hole chest X-ray. So when I say that, it means he had metastatic disease to the lung. His urine was bloody and he had positive cancer cell there. So that was his second recurrence. And so he said, I want hospice. But on hospice, his daughter lived next door to the researcher who was doing the work in the progesterone.
- 3:36And the daughter said, is there anything you can do for me, dad? And I said, oh, we can just give him progesterone. And they did. They gave him a ton of progesterone, but they came to my office and asked me first. I said, you know, he's 90 years old. His brain is intact. He's a physician. He can write for his own progesterone. He's on hospice.
- 3:52I'm game for that. If he wants to do that, I am happy. And lo and behold, they literally gave him so much progesterone. It was like he was pregnant, I think. But six months later, he's still alive. And he's not having any respiratory problems. The bleeding went away from the urine.
- 4:07And we got a chest X-ray and his chest X-ray was clear. And I said, okay. Oh my God. Oh my God. You have my attention. Wow. Okay. This is crazy. And so it was really the interesting thoughts of, with the hormones. And I asked a lot of my oncology colleagues, what happened? And people, oh no, he'd really had prostate cancer. Oh, you know, transitional cells really sensitive to hormones anyway, because it's up your, the bladder tissue, right? Yeah.
- 4:35But still doesn't explain what happened, right? No one's saying that princess killed it. So anyway, he lived another six months and died, I think, probably of a PE because he was immobile. Because it didn't fix the neuropathy or the myopathies. But in hindsight, it makes me think that we probably should have used just massive doses of testosterone. So that's thinking about that for a man. But anyway...
- 5:00So that's how I got into this. And then I started paying attention to this woman who was stocking my office with all these papers. And here, look, hormones do this, hormones do that. And I'm not kidding. We would meet and I would just challenge her. And she would say things like, why would estrogen cause cancer? Why would estrogen, the hormone that makes women women and the species propagate, why would it take you out? You want to promote the species.
- 5:24You want to assure that this happens. So, you know, she would tell me things like that. And I would argue back, like, no, we have this study and this study and this study. And she's going with a hello.
- 5:35doesn't it make sense that hormones are going to protect you and they run your life? And it took me a while, but, and I eventually agreed with her. And then I agreed to do this book with her, the sex lies of menopause, which was basically a thesis about why women should have hormones. And it published a year after the women's hormone initiative was published. Right. Which we're going to talk about. It was right on the hills of the women's health initiative saying, don't take hormones are going to cause breast cancer.
- 6:04that's what the fear of God in physicians and in women to basically avoid hormones at all costs, because just like you said, hormones cause cancer period end of story. And, and that's fascinating because when you're saying Suzanne Wiley, you're talking about TS Wiley, right? Yeah.
- 6:25Sorry. Yeah. Right. Okay. Okay. That's how I know her. So I never met her. I definitely want to, but I have shared with my listeners that I'm currently doing rhythmic dosing right now. And I find it fascinating. I mean, and in a nutshell, all hormones, whether you're doing rhythmic or static dosing, they're going to provide a benefit. So keep going with your story. And then I'd like to transition into just kind of an overview for hormones.
- 6:50everyone listening, and I know it's an exhaustive list, but just kind of a brief overview of all the different protective and beneficial aspects that each one of those hormones that we can replace can provide to an individual. Well, if I just start with estrogen, estradiol, we always have estrogen, by the way, in our system. Our bodies always make it. When you're premenopausal, you have estradiol from the ovaries. When you're postmenopausal, you have estrone from the adrenal glands.
- 7:19It's an androgen that turns into estrogen via fat. But, you know, that's what we get probably compensatory 10 pound weight gain. It's because we need to make more estrogen. But estrogen has like several thousands of functions in the body, like many, many, many. Besides the obvious, we have the obvious. Oh, and it can provide sexual function, bladder, urinary incontinence, prevent urinary incontinence. It can help with your skin. It can help with...
- 7:44cardiovascular, the elasticity of your vessels, it can help with your heart, it can help with clearly with your bones. And of course, at the end of the bones, we have joints, it will, you know, reduce your arthritic symptomatology. You know, there's going to be a huge microbiome effect, by the way, between pre and postmenopausal women, there's a gigantic difference between how the bugs are with and without estrogen. It's called the estrobilome, it has its own name. So
- 8:11I mean, I can keep going, but I'm just saying there's a lot. Brain function, right? We know that there's protective, estrogen protects the brain in many different ways. There's the, I think it's the thalamus, the hypothalamus, there's a size. The estrogen keeps that particular structure of the brain plump and functioning. There's also, it can reduce beta tau entanglement for the
- 8:37actual dementia, Alzheimer's. So there's a lot. Yeah. Yeah. So many benefits. I know the list, like I said, it's exhaustive, but just giving that overview, when you start to say all the benefits of hormones, I think it piques the attention of the listener because-
- 8:57You know, you think estrogen as I'm trying to remove myself from what I know. So kind of going back to when I was, you know, my teens or 20s, what did I know about estrogen? Okay, estrogen gives us boobs and it gives us hips and it has something to do with my period. And I know I don't want to be estrogen dominant and that's all I know. But to hear you actually say estrogen.
- 9:20A laundry list, which I've said before on the show too, of all the benefits of estrogen as a replacement hormone when it starts to decline. It's huge. It's huge. Let me just add one more thing that people don't think about, but estrogen has an influence on the mitochondria and ATP production.
- 9:38for energy. Yep, absolutely. I think that's a big one. That's a big one because so many people are struggling with energy, especially in perimenopause menopause. And then you stack that with other hormone imbalances and thyroid problems. And yeah, there are energies in the toilet. And that's the one thing that they wish that they could get back in addition to losing weight and just feeling better overall. Okay, progesterone. Let's do progesterone.
- 10:03So progesterone. So it's usually it's made with estrogen and a high enough estrogen. Okay. When you it's produced from the, when the egg is popped, the egg is popped.
- 10:14It produces more and more progesterone when there's no pregnancy, then it starts to fall off. So it has to be made in conjunction with the right amount of estrogen. Okay, because only estrogen makes progesterone receptors. Okay, so if you don't have enough estrogen, you don't have the right progesterone receptors. And so things may not go completely perfectly. But it does slow down smooth muscle. So that's why you don't have the contractions. Progesterone can cause a little bit of...
- 10:40like constipation too, because it's slowing down the intestinal movement. It is a chill, for most women, it's a chill pill, the chill hormone, and can reduce anxiety. The one thing that I always tell people who are on hormone replacement, it's really important to know that progesterone will actually block part of the estrogen receptor. And so there's women who say, oh, I'm great on estrogen, but as soon as I start the progesterone, I feel like crazy.
- 11:07And we're back to the estrogen progesterone balance again, there has to be enough estrogen to for the progesterone to work well, and to be tolerated. That's why we never give estrogen unopposed, like we never just give estrogen without giving some progesterone with it, correct? Correct.
- 11:27That's correct. And so you think about you're leading me, thank you to remind me, of course, the most recent reason why we give the progestin or progesterone is to protect the uterus because estrogen will increase the lining unopposed estrogen or estrogen given all the time.
- 11:41will increase the uterine lining. And over time and over years, there is a potential for uterine cancer, okay? And so we know that cycling or suppression of the lining with the progesterone or classically progestogens has reduced the issue and the incidence of uterine cancer. I want to take that thought because what I want to say is if you don't have a uterus, they say, oh, well then,
- 12:10You don't need progesterone. And I'm going to ask you that. Yeah. No, because the body is so amazing. It uses that same cycle to protect all the organs in your body, including your breasts now. OK, so if you're having estrogen and you're having unopposed estrogen for the breast for years later,
- 12:29We know that the incidence of breast cancer can go up, and we see that in the nurse's health study. And after 10 years of oral premarin, then there's a slight increase of breast cancer. So we can see that. Progesterone on board helps, right?
- 12:45Yes, yes, yes. In terms of at least in the cyclical model. Okay. Also, you have progesterone receptors in the brain. And the most important thing that I think most people don't know is that there's progesterone receptors in the bone. And progesterone really is the bone builder versus estrogen can help reduce the bone loss. But man, progesterone is the builder.
- 13:04Oh, interesting. I didn't know that. So have you ever seen women that were diagnosed with osteoporosis, osteopenia, come out of that diagnosis? They go on progesterone, they do a follow-up DEXA or bone density scan, and all of a sudden, oh my gosh, you no longer have this issue. You've rebuilt bone. Yep. Yep.
- 13:25Absolutely. Actually, I'm doing a research study right now. We're trying to get NIH funding and private funding, and it's doing basically rhythmic dosing against this patch and oral cyclical progesterone at the standard levels. And we're comparing those two hormone protocols and bone density is the endpoint, the primary endpoint. We have a million secondary endpoints, but bone density is reversed. But yes, we can turn it around like nobody's business. It's really interesting. Yeah.
- 13:52That's amazing. That is a benefit that I have not heard yet. So I'm so happy that you said that. So there's progesterone. And then finally, testosterone, which I talk about ad nauseum on here as well. It is not just a male hormone. Females need it as well. So can you go over the benefits of testosterone? Yes. First of all, the ovaries make testosterone, okay? The ovaries make testosterone that gets converted into estradiol as a reproductive woman.
- 14:19And of course, you need to, once you have popped that egg, you know, estrogen levels go up, then drop sharply, then the testosterone levels have to go up, because they eventually turn into estradiol, but they go up because you need to use that egg.
- 14:31So in terms of the fertility and all of that, it's an important signal. But in the postmenopausal woman, you still make some testosterone if you have ovaries. There's always a little bit of testosterone in the background. The testosterone helps with its mental health, its bone health, its muscular, keeping your muscle mass, et cetera.
- 14:51So there's a lot of benefits and besides mood and drive. Yeah, absolutely. And protection of your muscles because we don't want sarcopenia as we age too. That's a whole other thing.
- 15:02issue and your bones, if your bones are becoming brittle, you're not on estrogen progesterone. Now you're losing muscle as well. That's where we see the classic, I fell, I broke my hip. I was in the hospital, couldn't move, died. And it's like, you didn't die from falling down. You didn't die from even the hip fracture. But had you have the muscle to protect you, that might not have happened. Or if you had all hormones on board, might not happen like at all because your bones would be strong. Yeah.
- 15:31I mean, you're absolutely right. And I said muscle mass as well, also metabolism. And so there are like people who are type 2 diabetics or my diet, people have diabetes. It's like, you know, I really like them to be on board with the testosterone exercising because they can build more muscle mass. And obviously the more...
- 15:48muscle mass that needs to be maintained, it reduces their insulin resistance. So reason to have testosterone on board. Right, and that has a trickle effect into so many different disease states because insulin is so inflammatory. We won't go down that path because I want to stay in the hormone and cancer realm. But let's talk about the Women's Health Initiative study because you were saying some...
- 16:09amazing things off camera. Like, wait, wait, we need to get this recorded. I've talked about the WHI study on here before, but the way that you broke it down is just so beautiful. And ladies, this really is, even if you've never heard of the Women's Health Initiative study, this is the starting point
- 16:27to why your conventional doc says, don't go on hormones, you don't need hormones, hormones cause cancer, X, Y, Z. And this fear is still really permeating the medical community. And it still is in the minds of so many women
- 16:43And I would really like to break this down and listen to you explain what exactly we found, what was done in the Women's Health Initiative study that we kind of can't use if we're talking about bioidentical hormone replacement and then what the findings were. I'm sure your listeners are well-educated.
- 17:03educated, but to review, the Women's Health Initiative was started in the early 90s as a cardiovascular study because they had a signal that estrogen, at that point in time, I want to remind you, this is only using Premarin and a progestin called medroxyprogesterone acetate. It is not
- 17:21I call them drugs with hormone effects, and they are not hormones. Absolutely affect the receptors very differently. And, of course, permarin comes from a horse. We are not horses. So there's an inflammatory aspect of the permarin. But this study was done because there was a signal showing that at least oral permarin was helping reduce cardiovascular issues. And so the Women's Health Initiative...
- 17:46wanted to study that. And it was a great study because I studied a lot of women and we learned a lot of information that maybe had some wrong interpretations initially. So there were two groups. One was the women who had a uterus. They were given oral premarin and oral medroxyprogesterone acetate every day. We call that continuous combined therapy versus the placebo that some women didn't get anything.
- 18:09There was another group with women who did not have the uterus, and they were given only oral premarin against another group of placebo. So those two studies were continuously side by side going along. After five years, the group found a signal of there was like one more breast cancer in this group.
- 18:27group compared to the placebo out of like 5,000 women. And they were completely freaked out about that. Not freaked out, I should say, that was a signal to stop it. That's really what they did, a pre-planned signal to stop. And so what ended up happening, we heard this announcement in 2002 that breast cancer hormones
- 18:45increased the risk of breast cancer by 26%. Okay, 26%. So I am not kidding. When doctors heard that, they said, oh, 26, like one in four. So that means one in four women who go on hormone replacement will have breast cancer. That's what the interpretation was, but it's not. Okay. It was just a 26% increase against the placebo. And when you go back to the numbers, there were eight patients
- 19:12It's like you did, there were eight more cancers out of that group divided by the number, total number of cancers. It turned out to be like a quarter. So it was just that one more person was one more point or 26%. And it was like, the risk was 0.4%.
- 19:28percent a year if you did that so it's like tiny tiny risk now in that group that got the cancers those people already we know now those people already had breast cancer right the breast cancer does not develop in years on hormone replacement does not happen so it just these were occult cancers that probably were diagnosed when the study happened right because women who were on placebo also got breast cancer and when you compare the two groups
- 19:54The death of breast cancers are the same 20 years later. There's another finding now that if women who are on the hormones, they might even actually live a little bit longer compared to the ones not on placebo. The overall death rate is actually the same. So that was awesome. The problem in 2002, we had this big, huge scare that breast cancer happens from the hormone replacement.
- 20:20One out of four women are going to get it. Like, why would you do that? You'd be crazy. But it was the statistics. Doctors didn't understand the statistics. They didn't know how studies were evaluated and why that was said like that. I mean, really, it was a major disservice to women. And when you hear Joanne Manson, who was the author of that study, she was saying, well, we didn't intend for women to, you know, people not to have hormones. They say that now. But, you know, that's what the data showed. They had to follow that.
- 20:49Right. I was going to say, haven't the authors of the study come out recently and basically kind of backpedaled like, we're sorry, we're sorry your hormones were taken from you. Things weren't really quite right with this study in a nutshell. Right. And they didn't know. But looking back though, we can, we have gained a lot of great information from that. But in that same study, as I was saying to you before,
- 21:16The Women's Health Initiatives, they took women who were 50 to 80 years of age and started them on hormones with these drugs with hormone effects. And so women who were 60 were at least 10 years without having a period or without their hormones. And we know that without hormones, you're going to have...
- 21:35more risks and incidents of cardiovascular disease and, you know, the coronary disease, et cetera. So what we know now is that there's this, the current, I want to say the law is that you don't start women over 60 on hormone replacement. Okay. Because women who are 50 to 59, you know,
- 21:54if they took even these drugs with hormone effects, you know, any, anything, they had an overall cause mortality benefit. They did better. They didn't, they did better. And then if you gave a woman the same drugs with hormone effects after the age of 60 and 70, they had more adverse outcomes and it was like the benefits were not the same. So they said, Oh, it's harmful to give hormones after 60. Okay.
- 22:20But it's based on this study. And the other one is the ELITE study. It's very similar in terms of the timing hypothesis. Are you familiar with the ELITE study? No. What's that one? It's another very, it's a really important one that women who, they took women, they gave them oral estrogen and vaginal progesterone. And they followed their intimate thickness and they divided it into women who were, their last period was 10 years, within 10 years or after 10 years.
- 22:47And so same thing, women who are within 10 years had a benefit of decreased intimal thickness of the carotid arteries. And then women who were past 10 years of menopause, they did not get that same benefit. So...
- 23:03Do you have an issue giving women hormones or starting women on hormones over the age of 60? I do not. And I think there's some women who need them, but I don't. And I have been doing hormone replacement like this for like almost 30 years, 25 years. And rhythmic dosing for 25 plus years. I've been on rhythmic dosing myself for 24. I started in 2000.
- 23:28Okay. So I, so I was not afraid. I didn't know the data, right? We didn't have that message to our brain to not do that. So I did it and I never, I never saw a problem with it. So did you start before you entered men? Did you start in perimenopause? Started at the age of 40. And I, and it was, my story is interest is just different because at the age of 40, I had a lot of inflammation from musculoskeletal issues.
- 23:56I couldn't move my neck, my shoulder. I injured my shoulder. I wasn't sleeping at night because I was in pain. And then I was, I didn't, I can say this now because I can see it, but I was massively inflamed. When your body is massively inflamed, when you're a reproductive woman, your body does not want to get pregnant.
- 24:14Because it's saying you cannot sustain a pregnancy. So what does it do? It shuts down your hormones. So I did a hormone evaluation when I was going through all of this. And I was like in the very menopausal range, even though I was still having periods. And it was really a secondary shutdown of the hormones. I started on some hormones. I dabbled in it because I wasn't going to do ready for rhythmic. And I wasn't getting a lot better. And then really, it was really TSY. He says, just do the damn protocol.
- 24:44And that was a month that changed my life. So I didn't, the pain had gone away. I was able to move. I was able to sleep. You know, my mood, everything was better in a month. So that was my come to Jesus moment. Thank you very much.
- 25:01So, um, and I continued on it, even though I was, I don't know if I had to or not, but I've been on it since then. Well, it's just trying to do the math in my head, which is why I kind of prompted you. You don't look like you are 64. If I'm doing the math correctly, I'm like, Oh my God, you people have to just go to YouTube to watch this because that's always like, you're saying, Oh, I've been on hormones for 24 years. I'm like.
- 25:29Did you start when you were 15? Like, would you? So, yeah, that's amazing. Amazing. You look amazing. So this is a testament as to everything that you said hormones protect us against or with. They protect our bodies.
- 25:47They're also protecting your skin and your hair and your vocal cords and how you look as well, because you look decades younger than what you actually are. And I know my husband kept saying, if you dye your hair, Julie, you can even look 10 years younger. You're like, no, I'm rocking a little bit gray. It's cool. It's all right. I heard it.
- 26:11It's good. So, okay. So now we have the Women's Health Initiative study coming in, scaring all these women, but they're not using bioidentical hormone replacement like you are using today or like we are using today in the proper hormone replacement. So as we look at BHRT,
- 26:32And like you said, you know, T.S. Wiley came with the boxes and massive amounts of paper and studies. Do we have those studies out that back the benefits of bioidentical hormone replacement? Not like we should. We don't. Number one reason for that is basically funding studies because nobody makes a profit. Right. Except the compounding pharmacists, you know, they get paid for making their product, but no one...
- 27:00makes any money out of it. You can't patent it. You can't, yeah, you can't turn it into a unpronounceable drug name. At least at this point in time. I mean, like the, you know, the, the estrogen, the estradiol patches are bioidentical, but it's the, it's the patch matrix that's been patented, or it's an oral formulation that's been patented. You know, the Premarin is a semi-synthetic, so it has its own processing of how it's made. So these things aren't the ones that are patented.
- 27:28The bioidentical hormones actually come from plants, so like soy or yam, and they are basically, I have to say, synthesized in the sense that they're shaped into human molecules. They look like human molecules so that they fit in the receptors accurately and do its job accurately. We don't have this. We have a few studies. There's a Fournier study. Some of the old studies will include bioidentical hormones.
- 27:55We have some, like the KEEP study was only, I think it was three or four years. They used a patch and some vaginal progesterone, not our standard of care at the moment, but they didn't use it for breast cancer. And it was only a short-term study, but it was like no harm done and symptoms were good, et cetera. We don't have any long-term studies of bioidentical hormones. Yeah.
- 28:18But we have practitioners like yourself and many out there that had the anecdotal evidence. I heard one speaker at A4M say, very similar to you, she's been doing this for 30 years. And how many cases of breast cancer have they come across in practice in 30 years? She pauses, waits, she goes, zero, zero in 30 years. So even just that data alone,
- 28:46No, it's not a randomized controlled clinical trial, but it's data that we can hang our hats on to say this is okay and this is actually beneficial. So now you deal with cancer. Let's start with the scenario of a woman comes to you and she's just been diagnosed. She's just been diagnosed with cancer, not on hormones, but...
- 29:09What do we do? What do you do for her? So in my role as the cancer center, I have to do the standard of care. I think that's important because we have a ton of data on standard of care and that's why they come, right? So I will tell that someone has a tumor, we have to get the information from the tumor. Is it estrogen receptor positive or negative? Progesterone receptor positive or negative? Is it HER2 positive? What grade or how aggressive? So we find this information out
- 29:38And we can, at that point in time, we'll make a decision whether they need chemotherapy prior to surgery or some maybe hormone, anti-hormones before therapy or surgical therapy, or they just go straight to surgery. And then we get more data at the time of surgery. Are the nodes positive? You know, what are the margins? What's the size? And we categorize all that information and we put people into staging. One of the most important tools we have is the Oncotype DX, which is.
- 30:06It's a 21 gene assay and it should basically tells us whether or not that tumor is going to be responsive to chemotherapy and whether chemotherapy will get, you know, create a benefit for that particular disease. And it's been a huge game changer. I give much less chemotherapy in the last, it's been around for maybe 20, almost 20, probably almost 20 years. And we've been able to reduce the amount of chemotherapy.
- 30:34The other tests that I've used, and it's totally not supposed to be used, but the information is valuable. There is a test called the Breast Cancer Index Test by BiotheraGnostics, and it's really meant to be placed to be done after four years of the ER-positive breast cancer after four years of anti-hormones. And they want to know that particular test.
- 31:02tumor is high risk and sensitive to estrogen so that the person has 10 years, do they need 10 years of anti-estrogen versus the standard five? And that's what that test tells us. But what it actually gives us is, is that tumor even sensitive to estrogen or not? There is a genetic signal that says that estrogen influences the tumor. So we don't use it up front. We use it
- 31:27later right later after women have had anti-hormones for no reason right because right they've stopped i can guarantee 100 side effects yeah yeah from like classic tamoxifen yes yes and i've known women it's horrible
- 31:47And Aromidex and Anastrozole. I mean, they have, I mean, women can survive it. I'm not saying it's not that it's not possible. 40% of the women go off of Anastrozole or the Aromidex and Aromidex inhibitors. But anyway, my point being is that we over-treat the hormone, the tamoxifen and Anastrozole, because we don't have how to predict who's going to respond. That test is not meant to be given up front. And so they can't use it.
- 32:13technically, but the information that they use at year four or after four years of like tamoxifen is exactly the same at time zero. They use the same original tumor to tell you that, oh yeah, instead of five, you need 10. Well, could you know that at the beginning? Yes, but they don't. And it's about money. And of course, if you're, they're concerned that if you
- 32:33did two to five years of hormones, is that going to change the outlook? What's the influence? So I always tell people, do your two years of anti-estrogen therapy, and if you can't tolerate, we'll do the test. We'll do this test earlier than later. And if you can't tolerate the two years, we'll do it right away. We'll just get what we can get to see if you can even be on hormone replacement if you're so miserable.
- 32:58real hormones right so if someone is estrogen receptor positive or even progesterone receptor positive do you still is that a a marker for this person cannot have estrogen cannot have progesterone or what does that mean when it comes to hormone replacement with these with these women
- 33:20So most important thing, it took me a while to figure this out too. Gosh, normal breast tissue has estrogen and progesterone receptors on it. It's normal to have that. And we know that oncology, that estrogen receptor, high estrogen and progesterone receptor positivity is a good thing because it is more like a breast cell versus not a breast cell and a cancer, its own individual thing.
- 33:46So we like having strong estrogen receptor positive and progesterone positive tumors. It's a bonus. It's a plus. But does that mean that you can't have estrogen? And the answer is no, but that's because the cancer is, that's how the cancer presents and what it looks like. It's basically the breast cell was taken over by a cancer process. And that's why I would say it was hijacked into a breast. And so, but it looks like a breast, but it's hijacking, acting like its own thing.
- 34:15Okay. Now, can estrogen influence the growth? Yes, it can about 50% of the time, but the other 50%, it doesn't. And that's the thing that's really interesting. I am sure you've heard the stats where they say, well, if you take the anastrozole or the tamoxifen, we can reduce the risk of recurrence by 50%. Well, that's the 50% that is sensitive to the estrogen and the other 50 is not. Right. That's why that marker. And we don't know what the other 50% is.
- 34:44It could be insulin. It could be other growth factors and things that might be under our control or not under our control. Sure. Right. Even genetics. So kind of going into the BRCA gene, even when we're looking at that, that's not prognostic. I mean, again, we can look at the extreme case. We always reference Anagelina.
- 35:07Angelina Jolie, who chopped off her breasts because she had a genetic marker that came back positive and had obviously a family history. But we don't have to do that just because we have signs and signals. That doesn't mean that it's going to actually express itself. And that's certainly not a reason to avoid hormones. In fact, it might even be a reason to start on hormones because of their protective effects. Am I saying that correctly? Yeah, that's interesting. Yeah, I like the way you said that.
- 35:34The bracket thing, it's interesting, is that we know that if you remove your ovaries and remove your breasts, nobody has a problem giving hormone replacement. Just FYI, that's our current guidelines. Removing the ovaries after childbearing makes sense because you can't detect ovarian cancer early enough to make a difference. So, you know, you can't palpate your ovaries and go, oh, yeah, I have a little mass in there. Let's evaluate it. So they remove it to reduce that.
- 36:01But when it comes to the breast, we have very good screening now with MRI scans, particularly for the high-risk patients. And so I've had women on hormone replacement who are BRCA1, BRCA positive, on hormone replacement as a postmenopausal woman. But I just say your deal is you have to be responsible for the screening and any risk. Obviously, you take all the risk.
- 36:29I'm happy to support you, but it's how you want to live your life and happy to support you in that regard. Right. Now I have also heard that testosterone is very breast protective. It literally protects us against cancer. Is that true as well? Thank you. It's a, yes, it is. It also inhibits the estrogen receptor. So it will reduce proliferation of the breast. So throw in the mix. Yeah. Yeah. And the, if you're sure you're seeing women who do
- 36:55bodybuilding and they they use testosterone right they have no breast tissue well that's true yeah large they have pecs but they don't have breasts unless they're unless they're implants right so you know so but yeah it's an important thing so testosterone back again plug for testosterone in addition to
- 37:14It's good. All three, right. So now you have someone that comes in and this is more of what I see. They've already gone through the treatment and they've been scared off of hormones. You know, my doctor told me, I can't use it, I can't use it. You're comfortable as an integrative oncologist, you are comfortable even after they've gone through the treatment and they've been told by, let's say their past oncologist, no, you have to stay away from hormones. Right.
- 37:44Is this your belief? I don't want to put words in your mouth. Is this your belief that we can start you on hormones and possibly reduce your risk of recurrence at that point? I do not say that. Can't at this point in time, but because we don't have that kind of data. I have to take everybody on an individual basis and review what their risks are because every woman has their own individual risks, right? Did you have children? Did you have like early pregnancies? Did you breastfeed for years?
- 38:12that will reduce your risk of breast cancer. Did you gain weight at perimenopause? Did you smoke? Did you drink? Did you binge drink? Because that actually has an effect. So there's different factors. Do you have a high-risk genetics? Do you have other family history that doesn't have a genetic factor? So I have to look at women. Once they've had cancer, I try to do the best in terms of looking at the risk of this particular tumor and this particular woman,
- 38:38And if she wants to be on hormone replacement because quality of life, the relationship, whatever it is that they want –
- 38:47I have to make sure they understand their risk. And if they're willing to take the risk, I will support it. You understand? I do educate them because women who have breast cancer have a risk of recurrence. They just have it. Exactly. And I don't know what that risk. It's either 50-50, actually, right? You either do or you don't. But I don't know what it is for, you know, always what it is. And when people say, oh, the cancer came back, you know, I really have to remind them, no, it never left. Right.
- 39:12And that's the thing that's, I think, really striking for most people is that, oh, yeah, no, it was, it was, you've always had it. It's now showing up again years later because what we did didn't knock out the stem cell or whatever. We just didn't, we removed the evidence, but we didn't remove the root cause. Right. Right. And I think what you just said there too is so powerful. I want to circle back to it. You listed off.
- 39:37a long list of other behavioral and lifestyle and genetic factors that can, I don't wanna say cause cancer, but that can be the root of cancer. That it's not necessarily the hormones. It could be that you've been drinking and a smoker and you have the genetics for it and everything that you just listed off
- 39:59That we have to remember that as well. It's not just taking hormones or avoiding hormones that are going to determine our ultimate outcome, whether we get cancer, don't get cancer, and how that goes for us in the end. It's everything else. And I would even say that everything else is more impactful than hormones or no hormones.
- 40:20Absolutely. Even the birth control pills and dense breast tissue are probably the most. When I see somebody for the first time for breast cancer, in my mind, I'm going, what are the risk factors for cancer for her? And I can find multiple in every patient. Mm-hmm.
- 40:35Yeah. Yeah. And then we have to jump in and change your lifestyle. So is there anything that we did not talk about that you wanted to talk about today or that I just missed? Because this is just so fascinating. I'm kind of caught up in the discussion and I'm thinking about all the questions I get from my patients, my listeners. Is there anything that we didn't cover? I think, let me just go with the women that are on hormone replacement. I will say that anybody who has had ductal carcinoma in situ, DCIS, yeah.
- 41:02Okay, if it's been treated properly, never a problem. Honestly, those doctors are gonna say, Oh, you have a risk for more disease, etc. There's always a risk for more disease. The biggest risk for cancer, for breast cancer, if you have boobs in the first place, and you have birthday, boobs and birthdays, the older you get, the more risk you have for cancer, you can't help it.
- 41:21It's just what happens. Right. So just understanding that. But DCIS to me, as long as it's been, and I have my own personal data collection for those women on rhythmic dosing after DCIS, no problem. And even early stage one, usually not a problem. But, you know, as I said, stuff.
- 41:41Crap happens. Right. So can't say it's going to. My population, I have a little mini study and I've never published it. And I should because I didn't publish it because it wasn't as pristine and perfect like I'd like it to be.
- 41:52Right. But I had about 50 women and I put them on the rhythmic dosing and they all stages up, all stages up to, you know, one DCIS, zero, one, two, three, and four. And I put them on rhythmic dosing and I realized all the estrogen negative women, not a problem. As a matter of fact, I think rhythmic dosing should be given to women with ER negative disease because that rhythm I think will keep things in line. So it's really interesting.
- 42:17My patients did not do worse than, I'm going to say that they didn't do worse than what was expected. I don't want to say they did well, but I know they did well, they did better. But I can't say that as a general because it's not a randomized trial. Right.
- 42:31Right. No, you shouldn't still publish it though, because that's, again, it's unbiased data coming out that we need in the world to take the fear out of women and doctors alike, both, both subsets. Yeah. One of the things I should, I hope I'm at liberty to say this, but I knew one person in the study was an actress who died recently, who was a very big hormone promoter and even on rhythmic dosing.
- 43:01And she had recently died from breast cancer after having it 25 years ago. But people don't know. The story wasn't told. I know her story. So I have not been treating her for all of these years, but I have been in touch with her. Had been in touch with her. And, you know, she developed a second cancer disease.
- 43:19She had breast cancer. This is an example of what crap happens, right? She had an estrogen receptor positive, PR positive, HER2 negative tumor, like the year 2000, small stage one. She had a lumpectomy radiation. They told her she was going to die because she didn't get chemo. And she said, I'll die instead. She didn't want chemo. And she was right about that, actually. That disease was not going to help her. I mean, chemotherapy was not going to help her. And she was on hormones and started...
- 43:47the rhythmic dosing after that and did very well until a couple of years ago, she developed another tumor in the radiated breast. And I know when that happens, I have seen this happen before. When that happens, it is not good. They becomes a beast and that's what ended up taking her life. And she didn't do chemotherapy. She didn't do it. She said, I want it. I don't want, and she was really a hardcore person to the end. She did some chemotherapy after she got into some trouble. So she used it for palliation, but it,
- 44:18The hormones didn't do that. I would say the radiation did that. Right, right. And that brings me to really my last question for you, which is an important one. What about the whole mammogram versus thermography talk?
- 44:33where you have this group of really functional and integrative practitioners saying, no, no, no, don't do mammograms every year because you are radiating the breast and that can actually trigger a cancer that might be sitting there and that might stay dormant for 10 years, but you just get your mammogram every single year and boom, boom, boom, now you're activating it versus thermogram, thermography, which is...
- 44:57Not radiation, not as invasive, but it doesn't pick up on as much. But then you have the subset of people that say that it picks up on more. So what is your take on the proper way that women should screen themselves? I think it's going to depend on the person. It's going to depend on the woman because if someone has a BRCA gene, they're going to be at much higher risk than someone who doesn't. So those people deserve to have MRI screenings. Now, I have issues with MRI scans right now because they use intravenous gadolinium for their contrast.
- 45:27which is a heavy metal, but it is our, it's our gold standard. And it will find early active aggressive cancers before a mammogram. So that's why it becomes important. If you're talking about somebody who's older and their seventies and whatever, they're unlikely to get a very aggressive cancer. They might get the standard garden variety first cancer. I said garden variety cancer, but you know, they can have a mammogram every two years or so or intermittently, depending on how comfortable they feel. Yeah.
- 45:56But I think the issue is when you have a problem, you need a baseline. You'd like to have a baseline mammogram to compare it with or some kind of if the radiologist does a mammogram, for instance, let's just say you have a lump and it's not cancer, but you have to get it evaluated. Then you have to have something to gauge it against. Yeah.
- 46:17before they start poking holes in you, or they may want to watch it again and repeat it in another six months or so. So having an intermittent mammogram, if we're going to do that, is I think you're going to start a new process. So you're going to start hormones, get a baseline just to get it. I, as an, even as an oncologist, I am not, don't ask me how often to get my mammograms because I think it was, it was, might've been about five years ago. Yeah. But I have very dense breasts and my mammograms look like,
- 46:46the color of my ceiling because they can't see anything. You can't see anything in it. So it's like, to me, it's like worthless. And after having discussions with the radiologists and they said, well, maybe we can find some calcification sometime, you know, I forget it. So I do the, I do the whole breast ultrasounds as a,
- 47:03That's my screening. And thermograms, same thing like a mammogram. They can find smaller aggressive tumors, but they're not good at finding the classic ERPR positive tumor because those are more slow growing and less vascular. And lobular carcinoma, like no, doesn't even get picked up.
- 47:20Right, right. And my experience with the thermography is it showed areas of heat. And for two weeks, as I was then waiting for a mammogram, I got to worry. What did this show? What did this show? Then I got the mammogram.
- 47:35And I did go on for the ultrasound because I have dense breasts and breast implants. So had the ultrasound and it was just calcifications. So nothing to worry about. But just like you said, now I have, well, number one, I wasn't thrilled with the thermogram because it just...
- 47:52produced fear instead of a definitive anything. And I had to go get it all a mammogram anyways. And then number two, now I have that baseline, just like you said. So yeah, it's probably been about four years for me too. I probably should go back and just get it checked out again. But same thing, at least I have that baseline. So I really wanted to pick your brain about that, about how often we should be exposing our breasts to any kind of testing. Well, I think the real answer is none, right? Yeah.
- 48:22If you think about it, none. But that's not how our medical system works. And there's still the argument that mammograms save lives and mammograms don't save lives. You know, that's the whole point. Really, it's what the tumor is. Mammograms can help reduce your treatment, you know, treatment issues. But it comes down to the person. It also comes down to the worry because there are people who worry and they have the narrative and they can't go without it.
- 48:49So those people have to get it because they would not worry for years, right? Until they got it done and got that box checked. Yeah, exactly. I mean, they come to me and say, oh, I get mine done every six months. And I'm going, stop. Just stop. Yeah. No, that's overkill. We can say that with confidence. That's overkill. You got to stop.
- 49:11Yeah, exactly. Dr. Taguchi, thank you so much for coming on, for sharing your wisdom. This has been fascinating, fascinating. Your background, your knowledge, your experience is just off the charts. And this is what women need to hear. They need to hear from someone like you in the trenches who has been there, done that, treated women. I mean, the whole deal, you're walking the walk as well, taking your own hormones and you're walking testament of it as well. Like I said earlier,
- 49:39So can you tell people where they can connect with you? We're going to put your links in the show notes as well. But anyone that does want to connect with you, find you, what services do you offer? And how can they work with you if you're interested, if they're interested?
- 49:55You should know that I left the actual oncology world a couple of years ago. So I'm now in private practice and I do is my business is called Thrive Vera. It's like the era of Thrive, Thrive Vera Wellness Center. And it should be a T-H-R-I-V-E-R-A Wellness Center and it's.
- 50:13You should be able to find it. So you're working with everyone these days, not just cancer patients, correct? Oh, yeah, correct. Correct. So people who have not had cancer. So, yeah, so I work with that population. And so I do hormone replacement. I also do a lot of navigation still for...
- 50:28in education because I have people who can't get into the, see their doctors or their oncologists. They don't know what their PET scans mean. They don't know how to, and I can help educate or at least calm them down until they get to their doctors. Are these prepared to ask questions with an abnormal scan or blood work? What does it mean to ask the right questions? So I oncology navigation education too.
- 50:53Beautiful. Beautiful. Well, thank you so much for your time today. Like I said, we will put all the links to connect with you into the show notes. And I just thank you from the bottom of my heart for everything that you just gave the audience. Thank you for having me on. And I appreciate what you do too, because I'm going to be sending you a bunch of other people who have thyroid issues because thyroid and cancer and thyroid and hormone replacement kind of go hand in hand. They do. They do indeed. They do indeed. Well, thank you for that. All right. Be well. Be well.