Latest / Bloomberg Law / M. Night Shyamalan Beats Copyright Suit
Transcript
- 0:00Speaker 1: You're listening to Bloomberg Law with June Grasso from Bloomberg Radio.
- 0:06Speaker 1: Do you know who you welcome to your home? M Night.
- 0:11Speaker 1: Shamalan is known for making films with supernatural overtones. His
- 0:15Speaker 1: series for Apple TV Plus, Servant has those paranormal elements,
- 0:19Speaker 1: a psychological thriller about a mother who hires a nanny
- 0:23Speaker 1: to care for her child, Jericho. But Jericho is actually
- 0:26Speaker 1: a doll, taking the place of her infant son who died.
- 0:32Speaker 1: She's gone. You can put a dog down. I'm fine
- 0:35Speaker 1: as I am last Jericho when he was thirteen weeks
- 0:39Speaker 1: Dorothy took it hard. This is the only thing that
- 0:41Speaker 1: brought her back. I should take Dejiko for to walk now.
- 0:47Speaker 1: You hired a nanny for a doll. But Another filmmaker
- 0:53Speaker 1: claims that Servant is shockingly similar to her film The
- 0:57Speaker 1: Truth About Emmanuel, a movie about a mother who hire
- 1:00Speaker 1: as a babysitter to care for her child Chloe, who
- 1:03Speaker 1: was actually a doll replacing her dead infants. What happens
- 1:06Speaker 1: if the baby wakes up? You rock her back and forth,
- 1:10Speaker 1: and you talked to her because she likes that. She
- 1:12Speaker 1: likes to be talked to. I am just dying me
- 1:17Speaker 1: that baby, and director Francesca Gregorini sued Schamalan and Apple
- 1:25Speaker 1: for copyright infringement, but a federal judge throughout her lawsuit
- 1:29Speaker 1: before it could go to a jury, joining me as
- 1:31Speaker 1: intellectual property litigator Terence ross A partner Captain Uten Rosenman,
- 1:36Speaker 1: So Terry Gregorini claims that not only is the plot similar,
- 1:41Speaker 1: but that there are strikingly similar and highly idiosyncratic artistic choices.
- 1:46Speaker 1: Tell us more about the complaint well. At the core
- 1:49Speaker 1: of her complaint was the argument that the central themes
- 1:54Speaker 1: of her work and m Night's work were similar to
- 2:01Speaker 1: be a coincidence and therefore had to constitute copyright violation.
- 2:06Speaker 1: In particular, she asserted that there was this irrational reciprocal
- 2:11Speaker 1: devotion between mother and nanny that arose out of the
- 2:15Speaker 1: mother's loss of her child, that occurred in both her
- 2:19Speaker 1: work and in m Night's work, and that that similarity
- 2:25Speaker 1: was sufficient to constitute copyright infringement. Now, she went on
- 2:29Speaker 1: to say that there were also similarities with respect to dialogue, mood, setting, pace, character,
- 2:37Speaker 1: sequence of events, but the core argument really was the
- 2:40Speaker 1: similarity in the themes between the two works of this relationship.
- 2:45Speaker 1: Between a mother and a nanny that arose out of
- 2:47Speaker 1: a loss of a child. So they're both about a
- 2:50Speaker 1: grieving mother who cares for dolls if it were a
- 2:54Speaker 1: real child, and the relationship with the babysitter or nanny.
- 2:58Speaker 1: Why wasn't that enough for the job? Well, the judge's
- 3:02Speaker 1: view was that although they start from a similar premise,
- 3:07Speaker 1: they really tell completely different stories. The court noted that
- 3:12Speaker 1: in Emmanuel, it's really about normal teenager who's struggling to
- 3:17Speaker 1: cope with the guilt of knowing that her mother died
- 3:20Speaker 1: at childbirth, while the servant sort of focuses on a
- 3:24Speaker 1: paranormal theme, guessing there's something fundamentally different and odd, bordering
- 3:29Speaker 1: on paranormal with respect to the nanny. So he found
- 3:32Speaker 1: they're not substantially similar as a matter of law. How
- 3:37Speaker 1: do you come to that decision as a matter of law. So,
- 3:41Speaker 1: the way the copyright law has evolved with respect to
- 3:46Speaker 1: these charges of similarities in creative works such as movies
- 3:52Speaker 1: or television shows the courts that the analysis has to
- 3:56Speaker 1: be broken down into two parts. In the first part,
- 3:59Speaker 1: the court has to determine whether or not the accused
- 4:04Speaker 1: copied version was sufficiently copyrightable that a lawsuit should be
- 4:10Speaker 1: allowed to go to a jury in the first place.
- 4:13Speaker 1: In the second part of the test, the jury then
- 4:16Speaker 1: determines whether there is in fact, actual sufficient similarity. The
- 4:20Speaker 1: judge sort of serves as a date keeper in determining
- 4:25Speaker 1: what gets to a jury in this type of copyright case.
- 4:28Speaker 1: And here the judge made a determination that there was
- 4:33Speaker 1: such a significant disparity in the two works with respect
- 4:40Speaker 1: to those elements that could be copyrighted, that the case
- 4:43Speaker 1: should not go to a jury, and therefore dismissed it
- 4:47Speaker 1: with prejudice. I'm sure we'll see an appeal of that
- 4:51Speaker 1: decision on the procedural Graham myth to whether or not
- 4:54Speaker 1: the judge would be allowed in the law to make
- 4:57Speaker 1: that determination on his own as opposed to sending it
- 5:00Speaker 1: to a jury. But that's the process that the judge
- 5:03Speaker 1: actually used here. Why not send it to a jury.
- 5:06Speaker 1: And we've seen a lot of times where a judge
- 5:09Speaker 1: could dismiss a case before trial, but decides to let
- 5:12Speaker 1: it go to the jury and then afterwards you can
- 5:15Speaker 1: throw out the verdict. Why not let a jury decide here?
- 5:19Speaker 1: In this case, the judge clearly was unimpressed by the
- 5:23Speaker 1: claims of copyright infringement. He expressly held that the mood,
- 5:28Speaker 1: which was one of the elements accused of copyright infringement,
- 5:31Speaker 1: is not protectable under copyright law in the first place.
- 5:35Speaker 1: He also held that home nursery setting is EANs the
- 5:40Speaker 1: affair which is not copyrightable, and essentially saying that this
- 5:44Speaker 1: is just too common a setting for it to be
- 5:47Speaker 1: something that could be copyrighted in this particular work. They
- 5:51Speaker 1: are also elements individual elements that he just didn't regard
- 5:55Speaker 1: as significant, such as stolen wine that had to be
- 5:59Speaker 1: paired with and cheese, the home birthday dinner celebration, the
- 6:04Speaker 1: mothered stretches in a mirror. These were things that he
- 6:08Speaker 1: described as unprotectable stock scenes, and therefore it was within
- 6:15Speaker 1: his purview he said, to dismiss the lawsuit without sending
- 6:20Speaker 1: it to jury. Terry, were you surprised by the judge's
- 6:23Speaker 1: decision to toss the case out. I am a bit surprised.
- 6:27Speaker 1: I certainly thought that this lawsuit was alleging some elements
- 6:31Speaker 1: that were unprotectable and that would be dismissed out. But
- 6:36Speaker 1: I also thought that there might be some elements that
- 6:41Speaker 1: were sufficiently played as protectable that they might stay in
- 6:47Speaker 1: and the lawsuit would go further. I think there is
- 6:50Speaker 1: definitely a reaction in that court, the Central District to California,
- 6:56Speaker 1: to the public and media criticisms earlier decisions in copyright
- 7:02Speaker 1: cases in which the court has allowed cases to go
- 7:07Speaker 1: to the jury, resulting in verticts in favor of the
- 7:10Speaker 1: plaintiff and then handicapping the judge's ability to do anything
- 7:15Speaker 1: about the case after the fact, even though the judge
- 7:19Speaker 1: may have doubted whether or not there was copyright infringement.
- 7:23Speaker 1: So I do think we're seeing the pendulum swing back
- 7:26Speaker 1: in favor of copyright defendants in the eyes of the
- 7:30Speaker 1: judges in that particular court, which, by the way, the
- 7:33Speaker 1: court is fundamentally Los Angeles and which sees a large,
- 7:37Speaker 1: large number of these copyright suits involving the entertainment industry.
- 7:42Speaker 1: She says that she's going to appeal this is she
- 7:45Speaker 1: likely to get a reversal from the Ninth Circuit. I
- 7:48Speaker 1: think that's going to be very challenging for the plaintiff here.
- 7:52Speaker 1: It is not impossible, but the way that the judge
- 7:57Speaker 1: at the District Court has structured the decision, it makes
- 8:01Speaker 1: it very challenging for Ms Gregorini to argue that procedurally
- 8:06Speaker 1: the judge overstepped his role in a copyright lawsuit. Judge
- 8:10Speaker 1: was very careful to make findings a fact that the
- 8:15Speaker 1: elements that are shared by the two works are not
- 8:19Speaker 1: protectable in the first place, and therefore copyright infringement case
- 8:24Speaker 1: will not lie. It'll be interesting, though, to see what
- 8:26Speaker 1: the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals will do on this case. Jerry,
- 8:30Speaker 1: why did the pendulum swing in favor of defendants? Now?
- 8:34Speaker 1: I really think it starts with the Blurred Lines case.
- 8:39Speaker 1: There you've had a copyright infringement charge with respect to
- 8:43Speaker 1: some older Marvin Gay recording being copied by contemporary recording
- 8:49Speaker 1: artists allegedly. And in listening to the two recordings that
- 8:54Speaker 1: issue in the Blurred Lines case, most people came away
- 8:57Speaker 1: not understanding how they were sim or in any respect.
- 9:02Speaker 1: And yet the jury found copyright in the furnishment, awarded
- 9:06Speaker 1: significant amount of damages against the defendants Mr. Thick and Farrell,
- 9:11Speaker 1: And the reaction to that lawsuit was extraordinary in both
- 9:16Speaker 1: the legal community and in the media and entertainment businesses.
- 9:21Speaker 1: And I do believe that judges read the newspapers or
- 9:25Speaker 1: online versions of newspapers, and watch evening newscast and can't
- 9:30Speaker 1: help but be impacted by the blowback from their decisions
- 9:36Speaker 1: in future cases. And so I do think that we
- 9:40Speaker 1: see the pendulum swinging back in favor of copyright defendants.
- 9:45Speaker 1: How long that will last, I don't know, but there
- 9:48Speaker 1: is a definite change in mood with respect to these
- 9:51Speaker 1: types of copyright cases. In a press release, Greggorini called
- 9:55Speaker 1: the ruling disappointing but not surprising, given the balance of
- 9:59Speaker 1: power in the entertainment industry towards powerful men and institutions
- 10:04Speaker 1: sitting a nerve there. Yes, she's clearly recognized that the
- 10:09Speaker 1: media does play a role. Is we're of setting a
- 10:13Speaker 1: tone or context within which these copyright decisions come before courts,
- 10:19Speaker 1: and is attempting to play upon the justifiable backlash against
- 10:25Speaker 1: the imbalance of power in Hollywood and in other institutions.
- 10:31Speaker 1: Whether or not that helps her case at the Ninth Circuit,
- 10:35Speaker 1: I doubt it. But this case was as much about
- 10:39Speaker 1: striking a blow for women in the entertainment industry as
- 10:43Speaker 1: or recovering damages for copyright infringement, and so I guess
- 10:47Speaker 1: it's an important point that she's attempting to make in
- 10:50Speaker 1: that respect. Thanks Terry. That's Terence Ross, a partner at
- 10:53Speaker 1: Captain Uten Rosenman. And that's it for this edition of
- 10:56Speaker 1: Boomberg Law. I'm June Brasso. Thanks so much for listening,
- 11:00Speaker 1: and remember to tune in to The Bloomberg Law Show
- 11:02Speaker 1: weeknights at ten pm Easter right here on Bloomberg Radio