Latest / The Jeremy Ryan Slate Show / 1066: England Wasn't Conquered at Hastings. It Was Conquered in the 20 Years After.
Transcript
- 0:00History tells us England was conquered at Hastings.
- 0:03That's the cover story. What happened on October 14th,
- 0:071066 was a single afternoon of fighting that ended with Harold
- 0:12Godwinson dead in the dirt and William the Conqueror in
- 0:16possession of a battlefield. But conquest is not what happens
- 0:20on a battlefield. It's what happens in the 20
- 0:23years afterward. In those twenty years, roughly
- 0:2710,000 Normans replaced the ruling class of an entire
- 0:31Kingdom of 2 million people. The old aristocracy, the old
- 0:35church hierarchy, the old land owners, all are gone.
- 0:40Not gradually over centuries, but in a single generation.
- 0:44The real story of 1066 is in a battle.
- 0:47It's the system the Normans installed underneath the battle,
- 0:51a blueprint for how a small elite captures a much larger
- 0:55society and makes that capture permanent.
- 0:58Because once you understand how the Normans did it, you start
- 1:02seeing the same pattern operating throughout history.
- 1:06Conquest isn't just winning, but replacing.
- 1:09And the Normans wrote the playbook every successful
- 1:12conquering elite has read since. Today I'm joined by David Mannar
- 1:18of Empire's podcast to walk through one of the most thorough
- 1:21regime changes in recorded history, the Norman Conquest of
- 1:27England. Welcome back to Hidden Forces.
- 1:47In history, I'm your host, Jeremy Ryan Slade, the CEO and
- 1:50Co founder of Commander brand to check us out over at
- 1:53commanderbrand.com. And today we have an interview
- 1:57for you, which I know we we do every once in a while.
- 1:59And I like to bring guests into subjects I'm especially
- 2:02interested in. And I'm very interested, as you
- 2:04guys know in English history, as we've done some more of the
- 2:08roses stuff with Dan Jones and we've had some some other stuff
- 2:10coming up as well. But our guest today is David and
- 2:15he is the host of the Empire Builders YouTube channel as well
- 2:19as I believe the the app we have is called Lex as well.
- 2:22So you're doing a lot of really great stuff stuff.
- 2:25So David, thanks for hanging out with me today.
- 2:27Man, yeah, thanks for having me. So I, I wanted to dive into
- 2:31this, this whole idea of, you know, really just concentrating
- 2:34on the year 1066, because it is a, a very pivotal year in my
- 2:39opinion, not just in English history, but I think in global
- 2:42history too, because we look at patterns on this channel and
- 2:45things that you can kind of see happen again in history.
- 2:47And what happens in the Norman invasions is, is something that
- 2:51really does seem to reoccur in different ways.
- 2:54So the thing I wanted to start with is you can walk us through
- 2:58Anglo Sax Anglin in 1065, the year before the conquest.
- 3:02What state was England in and how valuable was it that three
- 3:06rulers actually wanted to fight over it?
- 3:09Yeah. So it's definitely not a
- 3:10coincidence that there were three rulers, all incredibly
- 3:13impressive personalities with with great armies that were
- 3:18competing for this island Kingdom.
- 3:21I mean, this was kind of in some ways the envy of Europe.
- 3:24It was arguably the most centralized monetized state in
- 3:27northwestern Europe. It had a pure silver coinage
- 3:30that had a functioning royal administration.
- 3:32And so when the Vikings came, it was kind of open season.
- 3:36They they weren't used to working with such a a well oiled
- 3:40machine. So when they went from, you
- 3:42know, from poachers to gamekeepers and were actually
- 3:45running England for a time under Canute the Great, at one point,
- 3:48they imposed 100% effective tax rate.
- 3:52So it's kind of like legalized pillage.
- 3:53Yeah, that's a fun fact for you. But I think you know, nothing
- 3:59expresses the the state of England quite at this time quite
- 4:04as well as this, this one quote from a 12th century source,
- 4:07Henry of Huntington, he wrote in the Historia on Glorium.
- 4:12Britain is the most blessed of islands, rich in crops and
- 4:16trees, with plentiful streams and Woodlands.
- 4:18It is also rich in deposits of metals, namely iron, tin and
- 4:21lead, and some silver and solids.
- 4:23Coinage is made from pure silver.
- 4:24So, you know, that's a little bit later, but the situation in
- 4:29the 12th century was similar to that of the 11th century and
- 4:35even before then again, England was this this land blessed with
- 4:39natural resources, with this precocious centralized
- 4:43administration. And so it's not a coincidence
- 4:46that you have these three players who, you know, like
- 4:51Harold Hardrada was already ruling in in Norway, willing to
- 4:55conquer, already ruling in Normandy, had good things going,
- 4:58but, you know, still wanted to really stake at all on this one
- 5:03game of pitch and toss and and take over England.
- 5:06Well, I guess let's look at those 3.
- 5:08So there were three serious claimants, as we mentioned after
- 5:11Edward the Confessor died in 1066, Harold Godwinson, William
- 5:15and Normandy, and Harold Hadrata that you just mentioned.
- 5:18You know, why did all three genuinely believe they had a
- 5:21legitimate claim to the throne? Because I think actually, when
- 5:25you look at it, I think Harold Godwinson's is the one of the
- 5:29more interesting one of the three.
- 5:31But you know, I guess. Why did each one think they had
- 5:32a claim? Yeah, so Harold Godwinson's is
- 5:36probably the most straightforward.
- 5:37He's Edward the Confessor's brother-in-law.
- 5:39Edward the Confessor's the king whose death sets this this Game
- 5:43of Thrones into motion. Harold Godwinson is the most
- 5:47powerful man in England. His family kind of rules large
- 5:50swathes of England and he's he's he's Edward's brother-in-law.
- 5:54His sister was married to him, but it was a childless marriage.
- 5:57Hence this succession dispute. Right after Edward the
- 6:00Confessor's death, the witch on the Anglo-Saxon kind of
- 6:06succession council meet and acclaim him king the next day.
- 6:10This is really, really fast and Godwin as sources also claimed
- 6:15that there was a deathbed grant that Edward the Confessor, who
- 6:19was known for his piety, was a well meaning king despite his
- 6:23hatred of the Godwin's. We can get into why he hated the
- 6:27Godwin so much, but he he was well meaning and he probably
- 6:32knew that the alternative in the form of like a Harold Hardrada
- 6:36or whatever menace came out of Scandinavia or even his first
- 6:40cousin once removed willing to conquer them.
- 6:43Coming to claim the throne is going to result in a lot of
- 6:45bloodshed. And so it is possible, even
- 6:48though this is, you know, Godwin friendly, Godwin's friendly
- 6:51sources that that claim this deathbed grant happened and but
- 6:56God. No, go ahead.
- 6:57And I was going to say, and then how does William of Normandy tie
- 7:00into this whole thing? Yeah, William of Normandy is he?
- 7:05He's Edward's first cousin once removed.
- 7:07So his great aunt Emma of Normandy was Edward the
- 7:10Confessor's mother. She was married to Ethelred the
- 7:15Unready and William claims that Edward promised him the crown
- 7:20via via emissary, actually another Norman, an Archbishop
- 7:27who was on his way to Rome to receive a papal concentration.
- 7:32So in 1051, he claims that, you know, that this newly
- 7:37consecrated or to be consecrated Archbishop Roberts stopped in
- 7:42Normandy and said, you know, Edward said you can have the
- 7:44crown essentially. And then what happened about 15
- 7:49years after that, a little bit less in 1064, Harold Godwinson
- 7:54himself actually got waylaid. We don't know why he was going
- 7:57to the continent, but he apparently got captured by one
- 8:02of Williams vassals in Normandy. And that allowed William to
- 8:06intercede on his behalf and and haul Harold Godwinson before him
- 8:12and receive, you know, receive a grateful herald who then swore
- 8:18on holy relics at rule one that he would respect William's claim
- 8:22to the throne. And then he acknowledged him as
- 8:24king one day. But this is, you know, this
- 8:27comes from Norman's sources after the fact.
- 8:30There's there's a historian, David Bates, who says that it is
- 8:35certain that this oath occurred, Some sort of oath occurred,
- 8:39unholy relics. However, the two men clearly
- 8:42understood the implications of this oath differently.
- 8:47It to me, I think that's why it's so interesting to
- 8:49understand your sources that you're pointing out.
- 8:51It's a Norman source because I've, for me, I always look at
- 8:53the example of, of 1st century Rome and, and people wonder, you
- 8:57know, what was the age of Augustus look like?
- 8:59And when you, when you look at, you know, he was possibly a
- 9:01patron of Livy, possibly a patron of, of, of Virgil, you
- 9:06don't have a good idea of what it actually looked like unless
- 9:08he let you look at it. So I think understanding source
- 9:11really is kind of vital to understanding the narrative as
- 9:13well. Definitely there's there, you
- 9:16know, and a large portion of the story is then retold via
- 9:20friendly Norman sources. So who knows how it really went,
- 9:23but we try to do our best and and there are some Godwin
- 9:27friendly sources that that do survive.
- 9:30And so we have those at least. But you know, of the three, I
- 9:33would say that Harold Hardrada story is the most kind of
- 9:37convoluted. I mean, that guy was an
- 9:40absolutely fascinating figure. Could be.
- 9:42It could easily be a Hollywood kind of sword and sandal epic.
- 9:47You know, former Borangian who saw action as far afield as
- 9:50Mesopotamia. Like truly unbelievable stuff
- 9:53was. This era quite so intriguing to
- 9:55me as well, just because there's Ragnar and so many characters in
- 10:00this era. But anyway, continue.
- 10:02Yeah, and he's called the last Viking because he was Christian,
- 10:05right? And he, he was a Christianized
- 10:07Viking and saw action in Italy, in Mesopotamia, came back,
- 10:14reclaimed his throne, which was which was taken from him and his
- 10:18brother the sainted Olaf. And again, it his is a
- 10:22convoluted story, but Long story short, he succeeds a guy called
- 10:27Magnus the Good as king of Norway.
- 10:29Magnus had also been king of Denmark.
- 10:30Hardrada tries to claim Denmark is repelled.
- 10:33And so he has this chip on his shoulder.
- 10:35And Tostig, who is the brother of Harold Godwinson, the
- 10:39embittered brother, journey to Norway to kind of lure him into
- 10:44one last hurrah because Hardrada had this adventurous life.
- 10:47And so, you know, he was down for one last adventure. 11 kind
- 10:51of one last rodeo. Tostig.
- 10:54Why as embittered as he was the former Earl of Northumbria, but
- 10:58he had overtaxed the the population and was his titles
- 11:03were stripped from him. He was replaced by a guy called
- 11:05Morkar was a brother named Edwin.
- 11:07We'll hear about those two pretty soon.
- 11:10And anyways, he's like Harold Hardrada.
- 11:13You should you should invade England and what adds further
- 11:18kind of legitimacy. It wasn't just, you know,
- 11:21Tostick comes asking to, you know, Tostick intercedes and
- 11:27invites him to invade England. There was, there's a another
- 11:31added element, which is that Magnus the Good, who, as I said,
- 11:34was hard drive, his predecessor, had signed a pact with a former
- 11:38king of England named Hart the Canute.
- 11:40This was another son of Emma of Normandy, but Emma and Knut the
- 11:46Great, not Emma and at the ready and ready.
- 11:49And this pact between Hartha Knut and Magnus stipulated that
- 11:52if either of them died childless, the other would
- 11:54inherit his Kingdom. And so Hardrada was Magnus's
- 11:58successor. Hartha Knut had died childless,
- 12:03and so he was. He was coming to collect on
- 12:05Magnus's debt, essentially. It it's kind of interesting as
- 12:10well, like how intertwined the three are as well, that they're
- 12:13not just three particular characters going after the same
- 12:16Kingdom to some extent, you know, with Tossic and, and
- 12:20Harold Hadrada or with even the encounters between Harold
- 12:24Godwin's and William Mcmormandy, they, they, they are actually
- 12:27very intertwined and not three independent people laying up in
- 12:30the same Kingdom. They're absolutely right.
- 12:32They're deeply intertwined. All three of them are really
- 12:36impressive. Again, I like all three of them
- 12:38could have been the kind of main character of this era, but it
- 12:42happens to be William because that's just how the dice landed.
- 12:46But you know, it's the Middle Ages.
- 12:48Everything is a family drama and they're all interconnected that
- 12:51there's all these interweaving familial links, you know, tossed
- 12:55egg with with Hardrada and you know, then the connection to
- 12:58Edward the Confessor 1 is the brother-in-law once the first
- 13:01cousin once removed. And it all goes back to Emma of
- 13:04Normandy, this kind of femme fatale who who was buried to not
- 13:10one but two pretty important kings in English history, Canute
- 13:14and Atharet, and kind of set this whole thing into motion.
- 13:18Well I guess looking at how we actually get to the battle the
- 13:21the military events of September and October 10th, 66 are one of
- 13:24the tightest sequences in medieval history right?
- 13:26Stamford Bridge is the force March South and Hastings less
- 13:30than three weeks apart. How did Harold end up fighting 2
- 13:33invasions in three weeks and what did that cost him when we
- 13:36actually get to Hastings? It's one of the most jam packed
- 13:40three-week periods in medieval history.
- 13:42In fact, it's it's probably the most jam packed.
- 13:44It's like simply an unbelievable sequence of events.
- 13:47Harold had spent the summer of 1066 waiting for William, and
- 13:51this is an amazing example of bad luck turning to good luck
- 13:55for William. The winds weren't in his favor,
- 13:56but Harold Godwinson would have been ready for him.
- 14:00But because of and I guess. Just for people listening, you
- 14:04know Harold is is king at this point already or what is Harold
- 14:07stance? Exactly, Harold Harold Godwinson
- 14:10is is King Edward the Confessor had died and William stakes his
- 14:16claim remarkably quickly. And again, Harold Godwinson had
- 14:19rushed to get himself a claim king the very next day right
- 14:23after Edward the Confessor's death.
- 14:26And anyways, because the invasion didn't materialize
- 14:30because the winds weren't in William's favor, the harvest
- 14:33season is approaching and Harold Godwinson disbands his troops.
- 14:37But then he hears that on September 20th, the OR in in
- 14:43September, Harold Hardrada lands with about, you know, over
- 14:4810,000 men. And the battle of Fulford is
- 14:51fought on the 20th of September. That's the battle where Edwin
- 14:56and Morkar brother Earls, one of which was tossed his replacement
- 15:02as Earl of Northumbria get defeated.
- 15:04And then four days later on the 24th of September, York gets
- 15:07taken, you know, most important city in the north.
- 15:10And on September 25th, so one day after York's taken five days
- 15:16after Fulford, Harold Godwinson is already up there and he
- 15:21fights this at Battle of Stamford Bridge.
- 15:23So this is one of the most remarkable forced marches in
- 15:27history. They cover, I mean, presumably
- 15:30he, he somehow finds out on the 18th or so that that Harold
- 15:38Dardon had landed. And so they cover something like
- 15:40200 miles per week. And this is an infantry army, so
- 15:44it's 25 miles per day on foot. And obviously Hardrada is
- 15:49completely blindsided, as is Tostig.
- 15:52And so they, you know, they had first treat with one another.
- 15:56According to Snorri Sturluson, this is obviously a
- 15:58romanticized, a cow from the most famous Icelandic historian
- 16:02who, who's, you know, the author of the Prose EDA.
- 16:06But he, he says that a lone writer comes up to Harold
- 16:10Hardrada and Tostig. And this lone rider says,
- 16:15Tostic, you could get your earldom back.
- 16:16And the Tostic says, yeah, what about, what about my new friend
- 16:19here, Harold Hardrada? And the lone rider says he can
- 16:22have 7 feet of English ground as he is taller than other men.
- 16:28So, so. But here's the kicker, right?
- 16:31The the lone rider rides off and then Harold, Harold Hardrada is
- 16:34like, who is that guy? And he said that that was my
- 16:37brother, Harold Godwinson. Yeah.
- 16:41So again, everybody is super impressive in this story.
- 16:44And Harold Hardrada, not to be outdone, stands and fights
- 16:48despite being blindsided. Right.
- 16:49He had come to treat because he thought this was some forward
- 16:52diplomatic party. Actually, Harold Godwinson had
- 16:55come with his whole army. And so his men were on the.
- 16:59Bench and you said of Hardrada has about 10,000 men at this
- 17:02point. Do we know how many men that
- 17:04Godwins had had at this point? He probably had, he had a larger
- 17:08army. It was probably closer to
- 17:0915,000. But the the numbers are quite
- 17:13slippery there. There's always a range well.
- 17:15The numbers in any historical battle, especially outside of
- 17:19modernity, are are very often skewed depending on what effect
- 17:23the writer wants. To go you you look at
- 17:27description as an army contemporary sources, yes.
- 17:33No, you look at descriptions of the Persian temporary sources.
- 17:35With the conquer came with 150,000 men.
- 17:44The the numbers are what they are but Harold Godlinson had the
- 17:49bigger army and Harold Ardrada and Tostic didn't even have all
- 17:54of their men. They they had this forward force
- 17:57and the bulk of their army they had to call to come reinforce
- 18:01them and they didn't have their armor either.
- 18:04So they they fought without their armor and both died on the
- 18:07battlefield of Stamford Bridge. And Harold Hardrada apparently
- 18:13takes an arrow in the neck, which kind of pre sages the way
- 18:18that Harold Godwinson would go eventually.
- 18:22Which. Which honestly, looking at the
- 18:25the Godwin's in death too that I guess we'll get into that more
- 18:28in the future, but that's likely not even the way he died.
- 18:31But anyway. True, it's 5050, you know,
- 18:36there's another depiction of his death on the Bayou Tapestry, as
- 18:38we'll come to exactly. But anyways, if the story had
- 18:42ended here, if William the Conqueror didn't exist or didn't
- 18:44show up, lost his nerve, then Harold Godhenson would go down
- 18:49as one of the greatest warrior kings in English history.
- 18:52I think that that's worth emphasizing.
- 18:54He he had just defeated the last Viking, and the Battle Fulford,
- 19:00where Edwin and Morkar were defeated by Tostig and Harold
- 19:04Hardrada, was the last time a Scandinavian force would beat an
- 19:08English one on English soil. So this was the end of the
- 19:10Viking menace. Well, we mentioned the, you
- 19:16know, myths around how Harold Godwinson may or may not have
- 19:19died. And and Hastings has accumulated
- 19:21more myths and almost any battle in English history.
- 19:25The the arrow to Harold's eye, the faint retreat, the
- 19:28chronology of the day itself and what's actually solid in record
- 19:32and and what gets exaggerated. Yeah.
- 19:35So the sources are very Norman leaning, like William of
- 19:38Poitier, Guy of Amiyan, the Bayou Tapestry, which was
- 19:41commissioned most likely by William's brother Otto.
- 19:45And so the details are a little bit hazy.
- 19:49But what we know for certain is this.
- 19:51We know that it was a dawn to dusk engagement.
- 19:55There was a midday pause, which might come across as pretty
- 19:58unexpected and anti climactic, but it was not unusual for that
- 20:01time. They had to rest, recuperate,
- 20:04eat. The commanders had a moment to
- 20:07strategize. Maybe I should back up for a
- 20:10second and just kind of set the stage for the battle for a
- 20:13moment as well. The forces are roughly equal to
- 20:15one another. About 7 to 13,000 on both sides,
- 20:21but you know, as as per our discussion about the, the
- 20:25contemporary sources being crazy, William is supposed to
- 20:28have come with 150,000 men, but there's just no way you could
- 20:33support anything near that. You know, a 10th of that is
- 20:36incredibly impressive. I'd be surprised if they're
- 20:39hitting 15,000. And then strategically, though,
- 20:44I should say that Harold Godwinson, as impressive as he
- 20:46was, it seems to have a real, it seems to have had a real
- 20:49impulsive streak. I mean, the fact that he had, he
- 20:52rushed down to, you know, by mid-october to fight the Battle
- 20:58Hastings can be called foolhardy.
- 21:01I mean, with winter setting in, William was actually getting
- 21:04desperate. He, his army would begin
- 21:06starving. He, you know, first thing he
- 21:08did, he landed Pevensey, he set up a wooden Mott in Bailey and
- 21:12he began raiding Sussex and so on.
- 21:17On one hand he was trying to forge for supplies.
- 21:19On the other, he was he was baiting Harold Godwin because I
- 21:22Harold Godwinson, because this was ancestral Godwinson land.
- 21:27And so it may have been because of that.
- 21:29It may have been because that's just the way he did things.
- 21:31It may have been because it had worked so well when he defeated
- 21:34Harold Hardrada. But Harold Godwinson rushes down
- 21:39with, you know, part of his force, like the the Hus Carlos,
- 21:42I imagine, who are super weakened or exhausted from from
- 21:46the the battle the the previous month and then a freshly raised
- 21:49force of Fiat or levy units. And because so he kind of gives
- 21:53up the home ground advantage in that way.
- 21:57But anyways, as as to the composition of the forces, the
- 22:00the Anglo Saxons have an infantry force.
- 22:03The Normans bring over a couple thousand horses.
- 22:06So they have a cavalry force. They have about 1/2 infantry,
- 22:111/4 cavalry and 1/4 Archers. So the the Anglo Saxons do not
- 22:16do not have Archers. They have the home ground.
- 22:18They have their, you know, very sturdy shield wall.
- 22:21They have the high ground and this means that the the Norman
- 22:26Bowman couldn't replenish. They were less effective they
- 22:29they couldn't replenish their arrows and also they were they
- 22:33were shooting uphill. But you know, they did get at
- 22:37least one lucky strike with an arrow potentially.
- 22:41We, we don't actually know we'll come to that.
- 22:45But there was we, we know that there was a turning point during
- 22:49the second-half of the battle when there there was a rumor
- 22:56that spread throughout the ranks that that William had died.
- 22:58And this is, you know, all credit goes to William to
- 23:01conquer here. He takes off his helmet rather
- 23:04than losing his nerve, he takes off his helmet and he starts
- 23:06riding up and down the ranks, which are teetering and
- 23:11basically lets them know, hey, I'm still alive.
- 23:14I'm still in the fight. And So what turns into this
- 23:18retreat, you know, this was this was probably like this retreat
- 23:25was not intentional. But each time, pretty soon the
- 23:29Normans find out that each time they go to retreat, the
- 23:33Anglo-Saxon shield wall waivers. So pretty soon they start
- 23:37feigning their retreats and like a tried and true battle tactic
- 23:40of the Middle Ages, they start feigning retreats over and over
- 23:42again. And eventually the Anglo-Saxon
- 23:44shield wall kind of falters and they they get overly aggressive
- 23:48and then the Norman's counter attack and eventually they
- 23:52strike down Harold Godwinson. The three shows 2 figures.
- 23:55We're unsure which one is Harold Godwinson 1 is shot in the eye
- 24:00and the other one is written down by a Norman horseman.
- 24:05It's incredibly interesting looking at that as well, because
- 24:10that retreat, you're actually changing the ground, right?
- 24:12Because you mentioned at this point in time the English have
- 24:16the better ground and by saying tree they're actually getting
- 24:20them to give up their advantage. Exactly.
- 24:24They come running down the hill. Not to mention they come out of
- 24:28their shield wall, which is nigh impenetrable.
- 24:32And so it, you know, you, you see that battle tactic play out
- 24:36and again and again in medieval engagements, from Manzi Kurt to
- 24:39Grunwald to to Hastings. So I guess if we look at
- 24:43nightfall on October the 14th, Williams won the battle.
- 24:46Harold's dead, but England wasn't actually conquered yet.
- 24:50What was Williams actual position when the sun went down
- 24:53in Hastings? His position was that he had won
- 24:56the war and now it is time to win the peace.
- 24:58So Harold Godwinson was dead, his brothers were dead who had
- 25:04taken part in the battle, and Herald's sons, though, were
- 25:07still in play and they fled to Ireland.
- 25:10Which is where they they they would flee kind of habitually.
- 25:14They would go to Ireland or Flanders and kind of wait things
- 25:17out. There's also Edgar affling.
- 25:19This is another claimant that never gets brought up because he
- 25:22was kind of a feat, kind of a non player, younger, less
- 25:26experienced than all the other men who Yeah, he's so he was as
- 25:29unimpressive as the other ones were impressive.
- 25:32He kind of gets like rolled over.
- 25:33He gets steamrolled by by these these these giant personalities.
- 25:37But he's the son of Edward the Exile and his birthplace was
- 25:42either Hungary or somewhere even further east.
- 25:45And he's alive in London. He's briefly acclaimed.
- 25:47But you know, William comes and by December 25th he has his
- 25:51coronation. But his coronation is a total
- 25:53disaster. It breaks out into a riot.
- 25:56There's a fire. This is because the Anglo-Saxon
- 26:00start chanting and it's unclear to the Normans if they are
- 26:03chanting in in unison with them and a claiming William King or,
- 26:08you know, doing something treasonous.
- 26:11And so there's a another 12th century source ordered Batalis,
- 26:15who writes that the people who had been rejoicing in the church
- 26:18were thrown into confusion and a crowd of men and women of every
- 26:21rank and status, compelled by this disaster, rushed out of the
- 26:25church. Only the bishops and clergy
- 26:26along with the monks stayed terrified in front of the altar
- 26:29and only just managed to complete the consecration right
- 26:32over the king who was trembling violently.
- 26:35So this is not the image of willing to conquer we have.
- 26:38It does seem like he kind of lost his nerve.
- 26:40But you know, the coronation still goes through.
- 26:42And even during the coup of Brumaire, Napoleon is supposed
- 26:45to have had a similar reaction where he gets all fainty and
- 26:48then his brother Lucy and kind of saves the day, right?
- 26:51But the important take away from the coronation is that the Anglo
- 26:55Saxons were not finished just yet.
- 26:58And for the next 5 years, from 1066 to 1071, there'd be a major
- 27:01rebellion every year. So there's a lot of work to be
- 27:05done. And it's interesting too,
- 27:07because I think when you look at Hastings, you know, Hastings is
- 27:10the battle William wins, he starts to establish this new
- 27:14monarchy. But I think very often,
- 27:15especially look at the Northern conquest, the battle itself
- 27:19isn't just the conquest, it's actually what happens after.
- 27:22And if we look at the conventional story, it tends to
- 27:25stop with Hastings. But the most dramatic part of
- 27:28the 1066 actually happens in the next 20 years.
- 27:31So what happened to the Anglo-Saxon woolly class?
- 27:36In the words of 1, historian Levi Roche wrote a great book
- 27:38called Empires of the Normans Empires plural because the
- 27:41Normans were all over the place right in Normandy, Italy, the
- 27:46Holy Land in England and their their legacy is is most enduring
- 27:50in England as as we will come to.
- 27:53But Levi Roche wrote that this was the most complete
- 27:56replacement of a ruling elite in British history.
- 27:59And the numbers kind of speak for themselves.
- 28:01By 1086, so 20 years after Hastings, only 8% of England is
- 28:06still in Anglo-Saxon hands. And the same story that plays
- 28:10out in the secular sphere also plays out in the ecclesiastical
- 28:13one. In 1066, only four out of 14
- 28:17bishops hail from the continent. By 1087, it's 14 out of 15.
- 28:23And we'll mention the last one. And because kind of thoughts got
- 28:26to wonder about that, the 15th one, right?
- 28:28What his experience was like, what we'll, we'll mention him a
- 28:31little bit later, but there was really no precedent for this in
- 28:35medieval Europe. I mean, this was just completely
- 28:38unprecedented. Maybe the closest parallel that
- 28:40I can think of is Ottonian Germany in the 10th century.
- 28:44But there's distinctions there because what happens is early
- 28:48on, you know, at the in the aftermath of the Carolingian
- 28:51Empire's dissolution, the German question is very much unsettled
- 28:57whether this is going to be 1 unified state or not.
- 29:00And Henry the Fowler, this very important figure, gets elected
- 29:04and he's a conciliator and he basically tries to make
- 29:09everybody happy. And then his son Otto the first
- 29:12takes power and a giant rebellion happens.
- 29:15And he's a little bit more willing to resort to force to
- 29:18put it down. And then he this kind of clean
- 29:20sweep of the German nobility. But there's no there's no ethnic
- 29:24component here. Plus it happens all at once.
- 29:26It's this kind of Big Bang shake up of the ruling class.
- 29:30Whereas the thing that gets missed about willing to conquer
- 29:35takeover is that it wasn't all at once.
- 29:37It wasn't all just Hastings. It was iterative.
- 29:39So it happened over the course of five years.
- 29:42And again, there was a major rebellion for for each of those
- 29:45five years. There are three major ones that
- 29:48I want to pinpoint. The first one, 1067 in Exeter,
- 29:52which leads to confiscations of of land.
- 29:55But you know, William, William still gives him a tax break.
- 30:00He he he, he still shows himself willing to reconcile with the
- 30:05Anglo Saxons. 1068 things heat up even more.
- 30:08Edwin and more car come back and rebel and there's further
- 30:12confiscations and this leads to the first wave of castle
- 30:15building. Many of those being, you know,
- 30:18starter forts and wood. But gradually some of those turn
- 30:20into the stone castles which really leave such an enduring
- 30:27kind of legacy on the on the English landscape 1069, there's
- 30:32a big northern rebellion. This is the one that leads to
- 30:35the herring of the north. Edgar affling, you know, the son
- 30:39of Edward the exile, the kind of non player actually does take
- 30:43part in this one, but again proves A feat.
- 30:45A Sven of Denmark flirts with the idea of joining in, but
- 30:50ultimately William is able to put it down.
- 30:53And then this leads to the herring of the North.
- 30:56Why does William approach it this way?
- 30:58Because if you look at it, it is vastly different, as you said,
- 31:01than than any time period in history.
- 31:03Because even if you look at how I feel like so often, because
- 31:06it's what I know the best, you go back to Rome and Rome would
- 31:09just replace kind of the the top 1% and those new people will be
- 31:12part of their empire. But he basically replaces
- 31:15everyone. Why does?
- 31:16Why does he approach it like this?
- 31:19It's a good question. I think he doesn't approach it
- 31:21all that differently from from the way Canoe the Great would or
- 31:24anybody would the the important thing.
- 31:27So England just kept getting these invaders mostly from
- 31:31Scandinavia. And William is distinct because
- 31:35although obviously the Normans come from there, you know,
- 31:39ultimately they, they come from Scandinavia and Norman comes
- 31:41from Northman, right? And they play the part of pirate
- 31:45Dukes. They're, they're housing the
- 31:47Scandinavians as they're rating England and playing both sides
- 31:51to perfection. And eventually they make their
- 31:53own bid for the English throne through William.
- 31:57I don't think William behaves all that differently from the
- 32:00other English invaders, but I think there is a critical
- 32:03difference that comes from the Norman's experiences in
- 32:08northwestern France, which was this brutal, brutal place
- 32:12between the count of own Jew, the king of France himself.
- 32:16You know, William had actually repelled an invasion, a combined
- 32:20force of the count of own Jew and the king of France, who
- 32:24behaved less like a king and more like the first among
- 32:27equals, right? France was pretty decentralized.
- 32:30And so they made a bid for Normandy and William is able to
- 32:35kind of pick them off, fights the battle of Veraville and has
- 32:39this really, really kind of brutal schooling in power and
- 32:46just staying alive. You know, he has three he he
- 32:52inherits a like 6 years old. He's 6 to 8 when he inherits the
- 32:56the ducal throne of Normandy and he has three guardians.
- 33:01All three of them are killed the the the last of which is killed
- 33:06in his bed chambers as while he's still a kid.
- 33:08So he witnesses it. So it's this brutal place to
- 33:11grow up and he he takes to it pretty fast and he manages to
- 33:15survive. And what what you get in
- 33:17northwestern France is this innovation of the castle.
- 33:21So you have the first castles by, you know, the the count of
- 33:24Anjou, not the one who invaded William, but his father
- 33:28Folkanera, who is such a fascinating and brutal
- 33:32personality. He he is kind of a castle
- 33:36building pioneer. And so William is enmeshed in
- 33:39this environment where you have the first castles, the first
- 33:42Knights, and he brings all that stuff to England.
- 33:44And so he doesn't behave all that differently.
- 33:47The, the, the important part of invading England was you have to
- 33:49have an army, otherwise you end up kind of like Edward the
- 33:52Confessor, where he comes in kind of saunters his way back to
- 33:57England and he doesn't have an army to affect what he wanted to
- 34:03get done. And he becomes kind of well, he
- 34:06becomes completely cowed by the Godwin clan, right.
- 34:10So William has an army, but he also has like the army par
- 34:15excellence in England, full of full of Knights.
- 34:18And they also have this innovation of the castle.
- 34:21They they build all these starter forts in in wood and
- 34:24then the most important ones they turn into stone.
- 34:27And this allows them to basically keep stripping
- 34:32troublesome, rebellious magnates of their lanes and titles and
- 34:37gradually impose themselves to the point where, again, less
- 34:42than 8% of England is in Anglo-Saxon hands 20 years
- 34:45later. Well, I, I just to, to take a
- 34:47look at the scale of this, you know, the estimates that often
- 34:50get cited are around 10,000 Normans replaced as Anglo-Saxon
- 34:54ruling class to roughly 5 to 6000 land holders.
- 34:57So how reliable are these numbers and and what was the
- 35:00actual mechanism for this replacement?
- 35:02Like what did it actually look like on the ground?
- 35:05Yeah, I'm not sure about those exact numbers.
- 35:08I I have that figure about less than 8% remaining in Anglo-Saxon
- 35:11hands. Interestingly there there are
- 35:13good figures on the invasion force.
- 35:16There's something called the Shiplist which records how 776
- 35:22ships were amassed in preparation for the invasion.
- 35:28You know, besides Williams Basils, there were also the
- 35:30Bretons and the Flemish who took part in the invasion and people
- 35:34would get you know what, what the what, what the rebellions
- 35:38allowed William to do was essentially make good on all
- 35:42those vassals contributions, you know, and they were awarded in
- 35:45proportion to what ships and material they they contributed.
- 35:49So very good numbers on that as to you know, how how many of
- 35:54them it was exactly those numbers sound vaguely right.
- 35:59You know, it, it was an army of more or less 10,000 that that
- 36:03William needed, you know, upper bound estimate like 15,000.
- 36:06And, you know, a lot of those were, again, Knights who would
- 36:11then man castles and become the progenitors of of dynasties.
- 36:19So, so how does that look like in a mechanism?
- 36:21Is it basically, sorry, this isn't your land anymore, sorry,
- 36:24this isn't your landing when you're dead?
- 36:26Like like how does that? How does that actually work in
- 36:28terms of implementation? It's a good question.
- 36:31So during this time, there's a continental trend that you
- 36:37basically don't execute your enemies or kill them on the
- 36:39battlefield, but you try to ransom them, you exile them and
- 36:42you try to be a little bit more humane about, about your choice
- 36:47of punishment. So William, yeah, is in some
- 36:52ways he's incredibly brutal. In some ways he's more humane
- 36:54as, as per this continental trend, he he's basically, you
- 36:58know, even though England is this envy of Europe, in some
- 37:01ways it's behind. And so he's he's getting England
- 37:03up to date with castles, with, with Knights, with OK, let's be
- 37:07a little bit more. Let's maybe exile our enemies
- 37:10instead of kill them. And this is actually been
- 37:12interestingly, this has been pointed to as the reason why so
- 37:15many Normans wound up in Italy. It's like they would have been
- 37:18killed under the old order, but now they were just exiled and
- 37:23they're like, OK, well, I guess I can't do anything here
- 37:25anymore. And so they got, they go to
- 37:27Italy and impose themselves there.
- 37:29And that, that winds up playing to the Norman's favor because
- 37:33those Normans in Italy are sort of like a liaison between the
- 37:37Pope and and the Duke of Normandy.
- 37:40And yeah, we'll, we'll get to that a little bit soon.
- 37:43The whole invasion can kind of be seen as a as a quasi crusade
- 37:46as well. But yeah, like, look, the the
- 37:48bedrock of it is for, right? If you wanted to get anything
- 37:51done in England, you needed an army.
- 37:53Otherwise, again, the, the, the example of what what happens is
- 37:58Edward the Confessor, he comes, he's 40, he has no army.
- 38:00And so he's just steamrolled by the Godwins.
- 38:04Well, you mentioned the Harrying of the North earlier, which was
- 38:061069 and 1070, and it's one of the most brutal episodes of the
- 38:10Conquest. How does that fit into the
- 38:12broader pattern? And does this secure Williams
- 38:15rule? And how?
- 38:16How so? So it takes place over the
- 38:19course of three months from 1069 to 1070 as you say.
- 38:23And it's another completely unprecedented episode in
- 38:26Williams life and rain. It's near genocidal.
- 38:30Up to 75% of the population is exterminated like either dead or
- 38:37fleas resettles and those who stay are in for a brutal winter.
- 38:45There's famine and Long story short, the North doesn't rise
- 38:49again during William's reign, right?
- 38:51Because now this is no place for an army to to forage or even
- 38:55materialize, right? So much of the population is is
- 38:59dead. It's not just wanton cruelty.
- 39:02So you know the the reason Ford was these repeated rebellions,
- 39:06right? This comes at like the end of
- 39:08that five year cycle of rebellion, after which William
- 39:12rules for another 15 years. And it's a very different type
- 39:17of experience than those first five years.
- 39:20He's actually able to get a lot done because there's no one left
- 39:23to oppose him. So the logic was make a desert
- 39:26and call it peace, right. Caesar and Gaul, Charlemagne and
- 39:30Saxony. It was it was exactly that kind
- 39:33of episode. But yeah, so Charlemagne is
- 39:36middle medieval history, but it's, you know, at the very
- 39:39beginning, I would say later on, you know, high Middle Ages, this
- 39:45kind of thing is completely unprecedented.
- 39:47Well, you mentioned the castle building earlier in the Norman,
- 39:51you know, as part of Norman culture, but there's also
- 39:54imposed French speaking aristocracy, A reorganized
- 39:57church. You mentioned earlier the
- 39:59doomsday survey and he's all kind of arrived somewhat
- 40:02together. But how much of this new Norman
- 40:04system was deliberate, and how much was just William
- 40:08improvising based on whatever came up?
- 40:11The quasi prono crusade framing was kind of deliberate, like
- 40:14this rapprochement with Rome, the papal banner being
- 40:18bequeathed to William. That's actually an important,
- 40:21it's another layer that adds to his kind of legitimacy.
- 40:26And and it goes back to it. It goes back to the Archbishop
- 40:30of Canterbury being fired, funnily enough.
- 40:33So Edward the Confessor puts this Norman Robert in charge of
- 40:40Canterbury as Archbishop, and he's the guy who goes and
- 40:44promises William the throne. And the Godwins are very unhappy
- 40:49with just a Norman Archbishop of Canterbury in general.
- 40:52And so they get him fired. And Rome's like, hold on, you
- 40:55know, isn't there somebody you forgot to ask, right.
- 40:58So the well. Henry the Eighth would disagree,
- 41:00but you know. Exactly.
- 41:02Yeah, I think there's also some similarities between Henry the
- 41:05Eighth and William. You know, they have this like
- 41:07kind of athletic youth. Later on, they cut this bloated
- 41:09figure cleric temper. And, you know, funnily enough,
- 41:15this papal gambit to put William in charge of England backfires
- 41:18because then William is quite aggressive about asserting his
- 41:21royal rights and, and breaking from Rome.
- 41:24And to kind of, you know, there's a quote about him, can't
- 41:27remember which historian at this point, but basically that he
- 41:31was, he was authoritarian in, in every aspect of his life.
- 41:34And so that extended to the ecclesiastical sphere as well.
- 41:39But at the time of the invasion, he he was on the papacy side.
- 41:43And that that conferred a degree of legitimacy to him.
- 41:47And so, yeah, there's this this kind of the quasi product
- 41:50crusade framing the, the feudal aspects, you know, the shipless
- 41:53meticulously recording which vassals provided what in
- 41:59anticipation of future rewards in the form of land grants.
- 42:05You know, the castle building, the Knights, All of this was
- 42:08kind of like, of course we're going to do this.
- 42:10This is what you do in northwestern France.
- 42:13This is how you wage war. And we're bringing this method
- 42:16of warfare to England. And obviously it can it meant
- 42:19that they they won up to the the Anglo-Saxon army, which was by
- 42:24no means an unimpressive force, you know, very impressive force
- 42:27of Huscarls. And then you know, the the the
- 42:29levees were weren't professional soldiers but the Huscarls kind
- 42:33of were like almost like a proto standing army.
- 42:37What wasn't planned? The total replacement of the
- 42:40Anglo-Saxon ruling class. Again, William tried to work
- 42:44things out with them. He spared Edwin and Morkar, he
- 42:47spared Edgar affling a royal claimant.
- 42:50Canute the Great probably would have just killed them all.
- 42:53But again, William is trying to be, is trying to play into these
- 42:57continental trends of show. Show mercy to your enemies,
- 43:01especially if they're only only if they're aristocrats, right?
- 43:05Nobody cares about the the commoners.
- 43:07You can kill the commoners, but if somebody is of gentle birth,
- 43:11then you have to spare them. You have to try to work things
- 43:13out. But every time there's a
- 43:16conciliation, there'd be another rebellion.
- 43:17And so it was forced. That actually allowed William to
- 43:20stay in power. But I just want to emphasize the
- 43:22goal wasn't to change English society.
- 43:25The goal was just to stay in power.
- 43:28And society changed as a result. And so, yeah, society's changed.
- 43:33The changed so much to the point that you can call this a vaguely
- 43:39colonial enterprise, but that was by no means planned.
- 43:42It was largely improvisation. So it's just basically he did
- 43:46whatever he had to do to to stay in power and it's just continued
- 43:49continued consolidation because at that point that that is what
- 43:52he had to do to survive. Exactly.
- 43:56So we mentioned the the Doomsday Survey a few minutes ago and the
- 43:59Doomsday Book. It's one of the most
- 44:01extraordinary documents to survive from the medieval
- 44:04period, which by the way, one of my favorite podcasts out there
- 44:07from history hit is called Gone Medieval.
- 44:09They did a whole podcast series on the Doomsday Book I'd
- 44:12recommend to people. But what was William actually
- 44:15trying to do with it? And what does this existence
- 44:18tell us about what the Normans understood about power?
- 44:23It's it's one of my favorite documents from history ever.
- 44:27Like it's one of the most comprehensive, if not the most
- 44:30comprehensive survey of a pre industrial society in European
- 44:34history. So incredibly impressive.
- 44:37And it tamed from this need to control and control comes from
- 44:42information, right. Information is power.
- 44:45This was Williams philosophy. It was commissioned on Christmas
- 44:491085 and completed in one year. So the speed is also impressive.
- 44:55Must have been a really nice Christmas present for for
- 44:57William, but like it came really really fast.
- 45:01Now the one year 2,000,000 words were turned out 800 pages.
- 45:05Nearly every settlement South of the TS gets you know how many
- 45:10plow ands, Vilanes mills, all sorts of these important
- 45:15agricultural measures recorded. And there's a lot of propaganda
- 45:20baked into doomsday as well. So you have this term that comes
- 45:24up a lot like tempore Reggies Edwardy tempore Reggies William,
- 45:29like in the time during the reign of King Edward.
- 45:32During the reign of King William, they paid this much
- 45:35right and they're trying to get the most up to Interestingly,
- 45:40what you don't see is a TRG, or you know, you don't see one for
- 45:44In the Time of Godwin. It kind of ties into legitimate
- 45:48succession in a lot of ways. Exactly.
- 45:50It's it's writing him out of history.
- 45:53It's a damn Natio memorii that's baked into into doomsday.
- 45:58And yeah, there's a, it's divided into little and great
- 46:02doomsday. Just a fun fact.
- 46:04A little Doomsday covers Norfolk, Suffolk, Essex.
- 46:08The Great Doomsday covers the rest of England South of the
- 46:10Tees. And people don't often ask kind
- 46:15of one point. I was like, wait, where does
- 46:18that name even come from? Doomsday.
- 46:20And the answer comes from. Not even spelled.
- 46:26It's not even spelled the name way it's pronounced too, which I
- 46:28think is confusing to people. Exactly.
- 46:30Yeah, Domesday. But it's it's pronounced
- 46:34doomsday and it it does mean what you you might think that
- 46:39that name means and suggests so under William's great grandson,
- 46:43the the treasurer of England, Richard Fitzneal writes the
- 46:46natives. It's interesting that even still
- 46:49use that that term, right, The natives of England right.
- 46:51Still like a couple generations after and the Normans see
- 46:54themselves as kind of other than anyways, He says the natives
- 46:59call this book doomsday. That is the day of judgment.
- 47:02This is a metaphor for just as no judgment of that final severe
- 47:05and terrible trial can be evaded by any subterfuge.
- 47:08So when any controversy arises in the Kingdom concerning the
- 47:11matters contained in the book and recourse is made to the
- 47:14book, its word cannot be denied or set aside without penalty.
- 47:18Basically like they're the IRS. You're not going to run away
- 47:21from them. They, they have all the data and
- 47:23they're going to, they're going to use it against you.
- 47:26It's kind of interesting as well.
- 47:27Like the thing I'm curious about, and you may or may not
- 47:29know this, but what did the Normans call it if everybody
- 47:32else was calling it doomsday? Not to my knowledge.
- 47:40Yeah. I I've only ever heard of it
- 47:42referred to as the Doomsday Book.
- 47:44OK, well if we look to to 3 or 4 centuries later the the English
- 47:47language, English law aristocracy, they still have a
- 47:51very deep Norman fingerprint. You know, what should these
- 47:54changes from 1066 have been most durable and why those ones
- 47:58specifically? I'm not sure which one you can
- 48:02say is the most durable, but I would point to three categories
- 48:05of changes, all of which are incredibly important.
- 48:08I guess in the very literal sense of the word durable.
- 48:10There's the Norman legacy on the physical landscape of England,
- 48:13the built environment. 500 castles get built by the end of
- 48:17Williams reign. This is a stunning number, but
- 48:21obviously not all of those are in stone.
- 48:23Still, it's a few dozen that are built or rebuilt in stone.
- 48:27The most famous example is the White Tower in the Tower of
- 48:30London. But beyond the castles, what
- 48:32gets missed a lot is this church building frenzy.
- 48:35Romanesque churches go up everywhere.
- 48:38There's a great book called Building Anglo-Saxon England by
- 48:41John Blair, and he writes the massive Romanesque rebuilding of
- 48:45English cathedrals and abbeys after a virtual clean sweep of
- 48:49their venerable predecessors was the Norman regime's most
- 48:52dramatic and enduring contribution to the built
- 48:55environment of England. And this this church building
- 48:59frenzy comes in two waves, 1066 to 11:30 and then 1100 to or
- 49:061066 to 1100 and then 1100 to 11:30.
- 49:10And we hear from that that that lone survivor among the clergy
- 49:17Wolf stand of Worcester, you know, the 15th clergyman who is
- 49:22not from the continent. And he's also he's the last
- 49:25surviving Anglo-Saxon pre conquest Bishop.
- 49:28And he's supposed to have wept as he gave the order to tear
- 49:31down a church called Saint Oswald's Church, built a century
- 49:34earlier and now do for a Norman overhaul.
- 49:38But, you know, in the wake of that came some amazing
- 49:41Romanesque cathedral, St. Albans, Bury St.
- 49:45Edmunds, Durham, Durham, called the jewel in England's
- 49:48Romanesque crown. And to by and large, to this
- 49:51day, England's greatest churches still are or have Romanesque
- 49:57elements. So this was, you know, the
- 50:00Romanesque architecture. It was kind of had been in its
- 50:04heyday a little bit earlier on the continent.
- 50:06So it's another example of England kind of catching up.
- 50:09And so they just went crazy over Romanesque architecture at this
- 50:12time. The concept was like, Oh yeah,
- 50:14we've already done that. Well, there's a a scholarly
- 50:18question about whether 1066 was a true regime change or just an
- 50:22unusually thorough medieval version of how the new king
- 50:25replaces the old elite. Do you think this?
- 50:28What do you think about this question?
- 50:29Do you do you think it's regime change or do you think it's just
- 50:33what William had to keep doing to survive?
- 50:37Let me answer that, but let me also just quickly mention those
- 50:41other two kind of categories of change.
- 50:44Yeah, absolutely brought in. I mean, it's the stuff that, you
- 50:46know, right, Like Old English to Middle English, French and Latin
- 50:49loanwords come pouring in to the point where, you know, there's a
- 50:54famous Argentine writer, Borges, who who who likes who in it, in
- 50:59one interview said there's basically three ways to say
- 51:01anything in English. You have the, the Germanic way,
- 51:04the French way and the Latin way.
- 51:06So you could say King from Koenig, you can say or like to
- 51:12describe a king right tingly from Koenig.
- 51:15There's regal from Latin, there's royal from French.
- 51:17And obviously that would not be true had it not been for, for
- 51:20William and the and the Normans who came pouring in.
- 51:23And then there's there, there are the the legal social
- 51:27ramifications. And this is huge.
- 51:29I mean, it is in many ways the beginning of feudalism.
- 51:32William kind of is to England what Charlemagne is to the
- 51:34continent. And also the castles, Knights,
- 51:39villages. It's the beginning of this kind
- 51:42of protection racket, if you you don't mind that analogy.
- 51:48Like basically the peasants are paying for the means of their
- 51:51own protection, yes, but also the the means of their own
- 51:55extortion, right? Like the Knights are the the
- 51:59Knights, the nightly order is a little bit of a, a protection
- 52:02racket in a way. So feudalism, menorialism,
- 52:05serfdom, and and also the phasing out of slavery, which
- 52:08had not been completely phased out in England because you have
- 52:11the backdrop of the Vikings who obviously took slaves in the
- 52:14continent. There, there were no such
- 52:16slaves. You had you had serfs more and
- 52:18more. And that would not be the case
- 52:20in England as well. But to answer your next question
- 52:24about whether this was a true regime change or something, you
- 52:30know, something more everyday I I would say that, yeah, 1066 was
- 52:37Jen or William the Conquerors takeover of England.
- 52:40Because as we've established it, it wasn't just 1066.
- 52:43There was that five year process afterwards and that went on for
- 52:47the next 20 years or after that five year process.
- 52:50He could really push through a lot of the things now that there
- 52:53was nobody to resist him. This was something distinct.
- 53:00It was that the critical difference was that again,
- 53:03everybody's trying to stay in power, and you can stay in power
- 53:05if you have an army. But another army might come
- 53:08right? And like her, like Harold
- 53:11Hardrada might have defeated Harold Godwinson.
- 53:13And then you would have had a probably more a more familiar
- 53:18story. If if Harold Hardrada had taken
- 53:21over England, you would have been another Canute the great
- 53:23type of figure as interesting as I I I find him.
- 53:26It would have been kind of mundane willing to conquer was
- 53:29interesting because he had these these means of staying in power
- 53:34and suppressing rebellion. And then because you have to
- 53:39realize about tassels like they are a both kind of like a an
- 53:44offensive tool as well as a defensive one.
- 53:48They they allowed like the council Bonjour to expand their
- 53:51territory. They would kind of they, they
- 53:53would settle in a wooden Mott and Bailey and then kind of like
- 53:57bring their cavalry, bring their Knights out and raid the
- 53:59countryside and then come hunker back in the castle and, and have
- 54:03this, you know, the defensive perimeter.
- 54:08And they, they allowed the the count of all accounts of Anjou
- 54:11to gradually expand into their neighbors territory.
- 54:14And the same thing now commenced in England.
- 54:17And so, you know, the, the, the William the Conquerors dynasty
- 54:22does end in 1135. But since then, every English
- 54:27monarch right up to King Charles the Third can trace his heritage
- 54:30back to willing to conquer. And what allowed them to stay in
- 54:32power was the castles, the Knights.
- 54:35And so all of that was genuinely distinct.
- 54:38Well, David, just as we wind down here, what's the biggest
- 54:41misconception about the Norman Conquest that you find yourself
- 54:44correcting most often your work? Yeah, so this might come out of
- 54:50left field a little bit. I've been talking about how Greg
- 54:53William is and kind of like what a pioneer he is.
- 54:56I do think a lot. But I I do hope I, I've made the
- 55:00case that a lot of that kind of comes from the backdrop of where
- 55:03he came from. And there's a whole kind of
- 55:05debate among scholars about how great William was.
- 55:09If it's his success that impresses us more than his
- 55:11character. I do think he he was a pretty
- 55:14interesting character in some ways, and certainly formidable,
- 55:17as I say, everybody in this story really was.
- 55:19But the biggest misconception about the Norman Conquest, I
- 55:24would say, is that William was the first Norman king.
- 55:27I think you could actually say that it was Edward the
- 55:30Confessor, William's cousin once removed and his predecessor.
- 55:34If we're going to go the doomsday route and write out
- 55:37Harold Goglinson, that his immediate predecessor, Edward
- 55:41the Confessor, that he he, it was he who was the first Norman
- 55:45to rule England. Traditionally, he's the final
- 55:50ruler of England's founding dynasty, the one that stretches
- 55:53back to Eckburn of Wessex, the the grandfather of Alfred the
- 55:56Great. But you have to remember that
- 55:58Edward the Confessor's mother was Emma of Normandy, the the
- 56:01jewel of the Normans, the one who did anything to survive,
- 56:04married to Ethel at the unready married Knut the Great literally
- 56:08weaponized her children with sometimes it's, you know, tragic
- 56:13consequences. Edward the confessor's brother
- 56:16would die because she invited him to England.
- 56:20And then Godwin Harold, Godwinson's father had him
- 56:23killed and his party scout and enslaved.
- 56:26So it was a it was a brutal time in England too.
- 56:31But because of this, Edward was not only half Norman, he also
- 56:37spent a good deal of his life in Normandy.
- 56:39So he he escaped, right? He came from Normandy when his
- 56:42mom called him. His brother died and he manages
- 56:45to escape the clutches of the Godwins.
- 56:47He goes back to Normandy, which he pretty much called home.
- 56:50His, his preferred language would have been French.
- 56:53And he only becomes king of England in his own right at the
- 56:56age of 40, so that by that time his closest friends, his
- 57:01confidants are all Normans. And he starts bringing them in,
- 57:05much to the displeasure of the Godwins, who he hated, despite
- 57:09having to to marry one of them. And you know, Robert, this, this
- 57:16Archbishop of, of Canterbury, who I mentioned already, the one
- 57:19who relayed Edward's promise to William, if, if indeed he ever
- 57:23made such a promise, was, was Norman.
- 57:27But there were other officials too.
- 57:29And This is why the Godwin, you know, this brought the Godwins,
- 57:35you know, this made them clash with the king.
- 57:39But they would, they would always get their way because
- 57:42Edwin, Edward the confessor didn't have an army.
- 57:48So there there's the Norman officials, there's, you know,
- 57:55his preferred method of communication being French, that
- 57:59of his officials too. And then there's also the
- 58:02construction of Westminster Abbey, which was a Romanesque
- 58:05church, the largest in England, one of the largest in
- 58:09Christendom. And I think to close things off,
- 58:12I actually want to quote from Levi Roche because he puts it
- 58:14really, really well. He says as his final resting
- 58:18place, Westminster Abbey symbolizes Edward's rule.
- 58:22It may have been constructed from English materials and by
- 58:24English hands, but in spirit and style it looked to Normandy
- 58:27almost all the features we traditionally associate with the
- 58:30later conquest of 1066. Francophone aristocrats.
- 58:33Reforming prelates, Stone keeps. Romanesque architecture can be
- 58:37seen under the Confessor. So basically, the Norman
- 58:42Conquest was already in motion before the Norman Conquest
- 58:44happened. It was since like the beginning
- 58:47of the 11th century. That is wild.
- 58:51So the take away is, you know, it starts way earlier than you
- 58:54think and it also ends after one might think it.
- 58:57It doesn't all go back to 1066. I mean, 1066 was this absolutely
- 59:02action-packed year. A lot happens, but all of these,
- 59:07you know, it, it it's all it was all set into motion much
- 59:11earlier. And it also the jury was by no
- 59:15means out, although it it kind of was because William came from
- 59:18this backdrop that gave him the tools to properly subordinate
- 59:22England. But you know, I mean, it's a
- 59:25testament, however, like foolhardy Harold Godwinson's
- 59:28rush to the South was, however, who foolhardy Hastings was.
- 59:33It's a testament that it even came as close as it did, right?
- 59:36Williams army almost retreated until he, you know, to his
- 59:40everlasting credit, took off his helmet, rode up and down the
- 59:43line and shut everybody. I'm still in the fight.
- 59:45I'm still alive. And it could have gone another
- 59:47way. And then, you know, all those,
- 59:49those means of oppression or control, whatever you want to
- 59:53call them, would have never been allowed to kind of unfold
- 59:59because, you know, just can't pitch battles were really rare
- 1:00:02in the Middle Ages. And, you know, this year had
- 1:00:05like a disproportionate share of them.
- 1:00:07Yeah, well, I, I have to give a shout out to our our mutual
- 1:00:12friend Michael, who's a memory medieval on X, because I had
- 1:00:14reached out to him to do this episode and he said no, no, no,
- 1:00:17you have to talk to David. He is much more qualified than
- 1:00:19me to do this. So I really appreciated to you
- 1:00:23doing this today, David, but I know you have a lot of great
- 1:00:27stuff going on out there, including empire builders and
- 1:00:29including an app you have as well.
- 1:00:30So, you know, what are you working on and and kind of what
- 1:00:33can people expect if they got to check you out?
- 1:00:36Yeah, so right now on Empire Builders, I'm doing a lot of
- 1:00:40different, I got a lot of different types of content
- 1:00:43planned. I, I just put out something
- 1:00:44about American history. That's a big interest of mine as
- 1:00:48well. Although, you know, I've done a
- 1:00:50lot of medieval and ancient history on the channel.
- 1:00:53And the, the biggest thing I'm working on though, is Lex.
- 1:00:56It's a social app for reading. So it's kind of like Goodreads,
- 1:01:00but you can actually read the books there, allowing the
- 1:01:02platform to like authenticate your, your ratings and your
- 1:01:05reviews. You can actually log how much
- 1:01:07time you've spent on a book, whether you read it on Lex or
- 1:01:10no. But Lex offers you 6,000,000
- 1:01:12public domain books. So it's the biggest collection
- 1:01:15of public domain works on the Internet as far as I know.
- 1:01:18You know, great if you're familiar with Project Gutenberg
- 1:01:21or standard e-books or Librivox. Librivox for audiobooks and, and
- 1:01:25Lex has that as well. And yeah, you could see what
- 1:01:28other people are reading, connect with friends.
- 1:01:30I got some features around book clubs and bookstores in the
- 1:01:33pipeline. So you can kind of see like
- 1:01:35wherever you are in the US to begin with, see, you know, where
- 1:01:39your closest libraries are and book clubs, bookstores and see
- 1:01:42what events they're putting on, if they're reading anything you
- 1:01:44might be interested in or have read already.
- 1:01:47And so, yeah, it's a social app for reading.
- 1:01:49It's called Lex. It's on the App Store, iOS,
- 1:01:51Android. So yeah, if that sounds
- 1:01:53interesting, please do go check it out.
- 1:01:56Very cool and and saying Libri Box really takes me back, man.
- 1:01:58That was like the old days of podcasts before they were really
- 1:02:01podcast. They were all audio books in the
- 1:02:04the public domain. What the heck?
- 1:02:08There's some great, there's some actually, you know, it's it's
- 1:02:10amateur. They're not paid to do this.
- 1:02:11They do it out of love of the game.
- 1:02:13So I really admire that. And but some of them are really
- 1:02:15good and I think have gone pro since some of them like I think
- 1:02:21Corey Miller that they've they've even published on on
- 1:02:24Audible as of late. Very cool.
- 1:02:26Well, David Mannar, thanks for hanging out with me.
- 1:02:28Where can people check you out man?
- 1:02:31Empire Builders on YouTube and also on X as well.
- 1:02:35So here's where this leaves us. The story we're told about 1066
- 1:02:39is a battle. One afternoon, 1 arrow, one dead
- 1:02:42king. But the real conquest happened
- 1:02:45in the 20 years nobody talks about, when 10,000 Normans
- 1:02:50quietly replaced the entire ruling class of a Kingdom of 2
- 1:02:55million. The land, the church, the
- 1:02:58language, the law, all of it rewired in a single generation.
- 1:03:03That's the pattern worth remembering.
- 1:03:05Conquest is winning a battlefield.
- 1:03:08It's replacing a system. And once you see how the Normans
- 1:03:11did it, you start noticing the same blueprint everywhere else
- 1:03:16in history. Huge thanks to David Mannar of
- 1:03:19the Empire's podcasts. Go check out his show in the
- 1:03:22link in the description. If this changed how you see
- 1:03:251066, subscribe. Because the hidden forces don't
- 1:03:29just stop at Hastings. This has been hidden forces in
- 1:03:32history. I'm Jeremy Ryan Slate.
- 1:03:35Please like this video, leave us a comment, and smash the
- 1:03:38subscribe button if you want more hidden forces in history.