Latest / Inside Commerce: Ecommerce Strategy, CX and Technology Podcast / EP312: From Concept to Launch - Crafting Paul Smith's Premium Loyalty Experience, With Head of Digital Hannah Bennett
Transcript
- 0:00For retail is is a really joint of experience prior to loyalty
- 0:04kind of launching, we did a huge project internally to kind of
- 0:07really allow our consent, align our consent.
- 0:10So making sure that, you know, prior to this our store staff
- 0:13were blind to whether a customer was signed up to newsletters or
- 0:16to SMS. So we really did, like you say,
- 0:18kind of go back to that foundation of what kind of needs
- 0:20to be visible to the store staff.
- 0:23You listen to Inside Commerce, a weekly ecom strategy, technology
- 0:26and CX focus podcast hosted by experienced digital consultants
- 0:29and re platform specialist James Get and Paul Rogers.
- 0:31Get insights into ecom strategy, leading brands, hear from
- 0:34industry thought leaders and leading tech vendors.
- 0:36With practical advice to. Help you improve your online CX.
- 0:41Hello and welcome back to the Inside Commerce podcast.
- 0:45It's just me today as James has got commitments with his
- 0:48clients, but I'm joined again by Ed, founder of Lime Sharp and
- 0:53Hannah, Hannah Bennett's Head of Digital from Paul Smith.
- 0:57Both of you have been on the podcast before.
- 1:00Do you maybe want to start by giving us a bit of a kind of
- 1:03introduction to yourself, your role, your background, Maybe
- 1:06starting with you, Hannah? Yeah, sure.
- 1:08Hi. So Hannah Bennett, Head of
- 1:11Digital at Paul Smith. I've been here it's really 16
- 1:14years now, probably up to a year since we last spoke.
- 1:17And so oversee our digital growth really we've got some
- 1:21aggressive plans now for the next three years that we're
- 1:23working on, part of that being loyalty.
- 1:26So yeah, I'm excited to speak how I got there.
- 1:29Lovely. And then head.
- 1:30Cool. Yeah, Hi, My name's Ed.
- 1:32I'm the owner at Lime Sharp. We're a digital commerce agency,
- 1:37so working with amazing brands like Paul Smith, which we're to
- 1:40talk about today. Overall services include kind of
- 1:43design, technology and strategical services.
- 1:47And obviously this podcast is about kind of loyalty and how we
- 1:50can support it the brand with their program.
- 1:53So yeah, I'm really excited to be on the podcast and thanks for
- 1:56having us, Paul. Great.
- 1:58I think this is your third time on the podcast, isn't it?
- 2:00So the Inside Commerce veteran. Perfect.
- 2:04So, so I invited you both on to talk about the kind of release
- 2:09of the Paul Smith loyalty programme.
- 2:11I was fortunate, fortunate enough.
- 2:14So you guys invited me into a few of the sessions through the
- 2:17kind of early stages of the programme.
- 2:20Then as you got closer to launch.
- 2:21So I've seen lots of the kind of developments and kind of seeing
- 2:26how the programme evolved from some of those early sessions.
- 2:29So I thought it'd be good to kind of go through some of that
- 2:31together. So maybe you starting with you,
- 2:34Hannah. So the first question, can you
- 2:37just talk us through some of the goals behind the project?
- 2:39And then also before we started recording, you talked a little
- 2:43bit around kind of you've been wanting to do this for five plus
- 2:47years and you've kind of struggled with internal
- 2:49challenges and getting different stakeholders on board.
- 2:52So can you talk us through that kind of journey?
- 2:55And yeah, those overall goals, overarching goals?
- 2:58Yeah, sure. So yeah, loyalty has been a hot
- 3:01topic and a frustrating topic at Paul Smith for, like you say, 5
- 3:05plus years. We have gone through so many
- 3:08iterations of what it could and should be like.
- 3:11Should it be more covert? We're doing it behind the
- 3:14scenes. Do we want it to be quite loud
- 3:16and brash? But how does that kind of
- 3:17resonate with the kind of premium brands?
- 3:20So we've gone from hiring internally to try and solve that
- 3:24problem. And it kind of, it was never
- 3:26taking off really to a point where, you know, we boiled it
- 3:30down to, I think it was 4 stakeholders in the end.
- 3:33So digital, retail, brand, marketing and financial
- 3:37planning. So there's kind of four big
- 3:40groups there that you're trying to keep happy that don't
- 3:42naturally always in line, which is when kind of Ed and kind of
- 3:47kindly came in of how can you really kind of bang our heads
- 3:50together of what, what are we really trying to get out of this
- 3:53program? What's the purpose of it?
- 3:56How can it be designed so intuitively to the brand that it
- 4:00feels authentic? That's something that's really
- 4:01important to Paul and the brand side of things.
- 4:05And yeah, luckily if you've been to portsmouth.com, you can see
- 4:08that now. So I think like challenge wise,
- 4:11it's our retail customer shops and and behaves very differently
- 4:16to our online customer. And it's often really hard with
- 4:19loyalty I found to kind of do things on the masses that feel
- 4:22really special. Whereas in stores for years
- 4:25we've been doing great VIP servicing like talks with Paul
- 4:29through the collections that are upcoming early access to buy,
- 4:33which is then really harder to translate for online customers.
- 4:37So that was kind of the big challenge that we were trying to
- 4:40solve initially, but it's feeling authentic and feeling
- 4:45different. You know, Paul's still here,
- 4:47he's still involved in the company.
- 4:48We're 55 years old now. It needs to feel something like
- 4:52he would have done back in his shop all those years ago.
- 4:55So I think that was really nice to kind of get.
- 4:58You know, luckily we've been working with Line Shark for like
- 5:005 years plus now, right? They're good at knowing us
- 5:05internally, but also challenging our thinking.
- 5:07So, yeah, I think that was kind of where we started and amazing
- 5:12the speed that we then kind of reached once that that kind of
- 5:15stakeholder alignment sessions that Ed's team ran were were
- 5:18fantastic. Great.
- 5:21And I guess obviously working with you guys on the paid side,
- 5:24like I've seen first hand, like Paul Smith is, there's probably
- 5:28a lot more to Paul Smith than the average person thinks.
- 5:31Where you've got so many different customers, so many
- 5:33different price points. And it's kind of like a
- 5:35department store in that, you know, you've got such a breadth
- 5:38of products that obviously could lean quite nicely to the loyalty
- 5:42side, but it does make it a bit more complex.
- 5:45And then Ed, so the, I think the second session that I joined was
- 5:49when you and your team kind of presented 3 different routes for
- 5:54the loyalty program. So from a kind of creative
- 5:57direction perspective, but also the kind of the the kind of
- 6:01logistics behind the program, Can you talk through kind of
- 6:05some of the research and some of the thinking behind those kind
- 6:08of given some of those bits that I just pointed out and how you
- 6:11went about kind of yeah, building those concepts?
- 6:15Yeah. So I think one of the points
- 6:16that maybe Hannah didn't mention was, you know, the the brand is,
- 6:20as she, as she did say, incredible at rewarding those
- 6:23customers that have been sort of long term Paul Smith fans coming
- 6:28into the store. Yeah, with Paul doing some
- 6:30really nice unique things for them.
- 6:32But I think a a big challenge that we're all kind of trying to
- 6:36solve was acquiring customers during promotions and sale times
- 6:40and getting them to convert to their 2nd and 3rd order, which I
- 6:43guess Paul, you probably see from from your side working in
- 6:47the sort of paid space, quite a frequent challenge, you know,
- 6:50investing really heavily into social and paid traffic to, to
- 6:55get the first sale. But then, you know, how do you
- 6:57engage that customer to to go out and and purchase more?
- 7:01So I think, you know, Paul Smith probably could have gone and
- 7:04continued with a really covert programme with the VIP tier and
- 7:08taken it into that kind of next stage.
- 7:10But it felt like there was a really kind of big opportunity
- 7:13to not lose sight of of that amazing experience those
- 7:16customers were getting. But you know, bring something in
- 7:20for, for those maybe those customers that are that are
- 7:23purchasing a gift or not aware of that kind of breadth of of
- 7:28products you were just talking about, Paul.
- 7:30So yeah, I think prior to the creative sessions, we did those
- 7:34kind of stakeholder alignment sessions where we actually just
- 7:37presented back what a lot of the kind of market was doing in
- 7:39terms of points, tiers and services.
- 7:42And it was actually quite eye opening of the the different
- 7:47breadth of brands that were taking very unique approaches to
- 7:50to loyalty, especially around kind of service only type
- 7:54programs. And I think initially when we
- 7:58first started discussing the programme, Hannah, we were
- 8:01pretty focused on just having a tier based solution.
- 8:04So there was no kind of thinking of any kind of points or
- 8:08currency and burn type program based on Paul Smith being a sort
- 8:13of premium brand. We didn't think that kind of
- 8:14aligned with the the overall sort of vision.
- 8:17So that actually came sort of much later during the sort of
- 8:20creative concepts really. So I think we kind of defined
- 8:24the overall program mechanics at quite an early point,
- 8:28specifically around tiers, how to structure them.
- 8:31And obviously we're kind of working with yourself on that
- 8:33one, Paul. And then the creative team sort
- 8:36of took that away. And like, like we similarly to
- 8:40how we work with sort of redesign projects, we always
- 8:43kind of create two to three different types of concepts.
- 8:45That's really just to, I know, take the handbrake off on
- 8:49overall kind of creative thinking and really try and do
- 8:53something quite sort of unique and special.
- 8:55I think taking that approach was really successful for for this
- 8:58type of project. So they went back and we
- 9:01actually bought on another designer in the team who hadn't
- 9:04worked on Paul Smith. So we were, we were doing a big
- 9:07redesign project at exactly the same time was doing this Lonzie
- 9:10project. So we had designers that were
- 9:12about fully immersed in the brand that had been working with
- 9:14with Paul Smith for years. We decided to bring on another
- 9:18designer, Faye, into that kind of creative process to support
- 9:23Leslie, our creative director and re immersed her.
- 9:27So took her down to the stores, to the flagships.
- 9:30Had a really good opportunity to go into Paul's office in Covent
- 9:34Garden where he yeah still works today on on occasion, which was
- 9:40a huge inspiration for the program.
- 9:41But I think that that gave the design team a lot of kind of
- 9:44inspiration to go away and create these different 3
- 9:46concepts. I think it was quite safe to say
- 9:49we had two super strong ones. Maybe the the third route didn't
- 9:53kind of shine a light on what was kind of the routes for
- 9:57option 1:00 and 2:00. But I think the, the first route
- 9:59in Collectors Club, which is the one that was live was, was so
- 10:03strong. I think everyone in the kind of
- 10:05stakeholders in that room like let's.
- 10:08Just. So, yeah, I think that overall
- 10:14kind of brand immersion the same, the same sort of process
- 10:16as as we would do for a redesign or a design project was was
- 10:21really valuant now in that sense.
- 10:24What do Mattel, Victoria, Beckham, Sennheiser and Glossier
- 10:28all have in common? They power their businesses with
- 10:32Shopify. Shopify is the most innovative
- 10:36and scaled commerce platform on the planet.
- 10:40It also happens to have the best converting checkout on the
- 10:43planet. Shopify, powering the future of
- 10:47enterprise commerce. Find out more at
- 10:50shopify.com/enterprise. OK.
- 10:53I don't know if hopefully we're allowed to say this, but I can't
- 10:55remember what the third concept was.
- 10:57I remember the first one was obviously the collectors club
- 10:59and the focus was on the stamps, which was my favorite and I
- 11:02think a lot of people's rooms favorite.
- 11:04Second one was super strong. So that was the locations and
- 11:07like the stores and the cities, like big geographic playing.
- 11:11What was the third one? The third one was almost like a
- 11:13behind the scenes family one. Yeah.
- 11:16So being like part of the kind of Portsmouth family and there
- 11:19was some really nice kind of art direction in there, but probably
- 11:23the strength of, you know, route one and two was probably what
- 11:27made that one feel slightly weaker.
- 11:29But it's always good to help everyone decide.
- 11:31Yeah, absolutely. And we've kind of already done
- 11:34this a little bit already. But I guess just for people that
- 11:37are listening that aren't able to go and check out like the
- 11:40landing page of the site and can maybe one of you maybe start
- 11:43with you, Hannah, just give us a bit of an overview of the
- 11:45program and talk through some of the kind of key incentives and
- 11:49maybe the rationale around those a little bit.
- 11:51Yeah. So it's it is a tier and I'm
- 11:54going to say points once, but we call points stances tier and
- 11:57stamp based programme. So what we were finding for
- 12:02online customers obviously discount is important.
- 12:06So how could that still play an elevated part of the programme.
- 12:10So it's a redeemable stamps is part of the programme.
- 12:13So you kind of earn stamps on your purchases and then you can
- 12:17redeem them against future purchases there.
- 12:20Your spend then puts you into a tier to get you access to
- 12:23benefits. And then this is where we really
- 12:26had to keep refining and keep kind of sense checking where we
- 12:31want to be as a brand versus how we operate as a brand.
- 12:35So that point you made earlier about was being a department
- 12:37store, you know, we do get customers that would just
- 12:40happily just buy socks with us all the time.
- 12:42And that spend is very different to that customer that just come
- 12:45straight in and buys a suit. So try really trying to get
- 12:48those those different tiers pitched correctly for us was a
- 12:52real challenge of then what are the benefits that and rewards
- 12:56that really important to those customers.
- 12:58So we did, we did have to play around with those tiers.
- 13:02Sorry the lights have just come off in the room.
- 13:05So getting those tiers right to suit the customer that just
- 13:07comes in and buys a suit and then kind of goes on to buying
- 13:10kind of other parts of their outfitting versus that gifting
- 13:14or low purchase customers, quite difficult for us.
- 13:17And we're trying to keep ourselves as a premium brand and
- 13:20not letting this kind of sinkers into giving too much away too
- 13:24soon. So we did end up adjusting those
- 13:26tiers as we were kind of refining the program closer to
- 13:29launch to from 5 tiers down to four and kind of really keeping
- 13:34those good benefits at the second tier, which starts from
- 13:38500 lbs and allowing that kind of points and that kind of
- 13:42effectively kind of cash back on your next spend.
- 13:45For those newcomers where we actually do need to do a bit
- 13:47more hard work on them, educating them on the brand and
- 13:50the different product groups that we offer.
- 13:52Yeah, absolutely. I don't know if you want to add
- 13:55anything to that Ed. I just think the the really nice
- 14:02thing about the program is how kind of targets it is a specific
- 14:06sort of customer groups or specific types types of
- 14:09customers that obviously the, the tier system is like superb
- 14:14or rewarding. Like the hardcore spenders, you
- 14:17know, the people that are shopping with the brand on a
- 14:19frequent basis and, and trying to get the original objectives
- 14:21of, you know, getting customers from their first and second
- 14:23purchase, you know, through those tiers.
- 14:26But there's some also some really nice other elements with
- 14:29like gamification, which I never really kind of thought would be
- 14:33sort of right for for Paul Smith.
- 14:36But as we were exploring this kind of like the the creative
- 14:40concepts, it, it made a lot of sense due to a lot of the kind
- 14:45of inspiration directly from from Paul.
- 14:47You know, he's a massive sort of collector as a individual and
- 14:51you go into his office and there's like, you know, objects
- 14:53that are sent in from from customers, like stuff that he's
- 14:57collected during his travels, you know, absolutely loves
- 15:00Japan. So the kind of third sort
- 15:02element of this sort of stamp collecting idea came came as
- 15:08part of those creative concepts, but as well as the sort of
- 15:11feeling like, I don't know, really easy to understand for a
- 15:13customer because they're so used to collecting stamps from coffee
- 15:17shop type programs. Also gave Paul Smith a lot of
- 15:21opportunity to get like really creative and unique with the
- 15:23program that I think that's the actual layer that takes it from
- 15:27feeling like a a standard loyalty program to something
- 15:30like where you spoke for for Paul Smith.
- 15:32I don't know if you want to talk a little bit more on the and
- 15:36those special edition stamps that kind of like adds that in
- 15:40so. Yeah.
- 15:41I think it was probably my favorite meeting I've been in at
- 15:44Paul Smith was during that concept call with everyone, you
- 15:48know, talking about those four kind of stakeholders of trying
- 15:51to convince them we were all like collaborating on ideas.
- 15:54So customers can just build their digital stamp book as part
- 15:58of the programme as an additional like gamification
- 16:01layer, as Ed said. And the ideas going around the
- 16:03room that date were so exciting. And I think still now people are
- 16:07kind of coming up with new ideas where a customer can build their
- 16:10own collection of stamps digitally.
- 16:13So whether that's visiting our stores.
- 16:15So all our stores have one of the stamped objects that has
- 16:18been sent to Paul over the years and there where a poor customer
- 16:21can get their Floral St. stamp called the Melrose stamp as well
- 16:26as buying into product groups. So if you buy Stripe, you can
- 16:29get your Stripe stamp. If you've brought lucky enough
- 16:32to get a Barber and our recent collaboration, you've got the
- 16:34Barber stamp going to listening to our Spotify playlist.
- 16:40And it's been really nice to just watch customers then after
- 16:44all these ideas and how how they're kind of engaging with
- 16:47that side of things. Yeah.
- 16:49So as you said earlier, I think it's such a good foundation as
- 16:52well. I like your like even just for
- 16:54the retail side, like your stores are like insane, like
- 16:57definitely the best kind of experience amongst our clients.
- 17:00So I think there's so much you can do with the stamps and so
- 17:04much you can do to like bring that into the store experience
- 17:06as well. And so every time James isn't
- 17:09here to keep me organised, I always end up adding in random
- 17:12questions. And Hannah, I've added one for
- 17:15you, which hopefully you won't mind me kind of asking you on
- 17:18the fly. But one of the things that oh,
- 17:21in fact, probably the biggest thing that impressed me about
- 17:23the roll out and implementation of this program is how quickly
- 17:26you handed all the internal kind of deliverables and workload
- 17:30because it it's such a broad program and there's so much
- 17:33content and you know, so many emails and I would say that need
- 17:36to be built. And can you just talk us through
- 17:38kind of how you approach to getting all of that work done
- 17:41and kind of managing that internal?
- 17:44Yeah, literally we've got a really strong project team
- 17:47internally and it what's nice is that you we can divide the
- 17:52project between the different departments.
- 17:54I think this has been a real like one of the real true
- 17:57projects where everyone's BAU changes like pre and post
- 18:02loyalty. So breaking that up into the
- 18:05different stakeholders than within the teams.
- 18:07So whether that's digital marketing and then CRM within
- 18:11that, whether that's retail and retail training, whether that's
- 18:14the POS system and how that's integrated.
- 18:16So really getting everyone on board early to kind of hear the
- 18:20scale of the project, how they play a part, layering in then in
- 18:25a proper kind of agile methodology when they're meeting
- 18:28every week to give updates, problems, status updates.
- 18:33So a a true kind of divide and conquer to kind of hit that that
- 18:36go live. So, you know, we have Lime Shark
- 18:39as well to support on the front end build.
- 18:41So I think for those core central people, it was a lot.
- 18:45But then once you've kind of divided that work out, they've
- 18:47kind of OK, yeah, I've got to get a stamped objection.
- 18:50Every store with a training guide retail ran an extensive
- 18:54training program throughout the weeks and became those kind of
- 18:57collector club ambassadors across the different retail
- 19:00network to educate them. So yeah, it was, it was a lot of
- 19:05work. It was a please don't talk to me
- 19:07about anything else other than loyalty for quite a while.
- 19:11Sense. Well, yeah, I think, yeah, I was
- 19:13quite surprised when you actually kind of completed it on
- 19:16time. So, yeah, did well to get that
- 19:18done so quickly. And then changing the topic
- 19:21slightly. So I mean, you were both kind of
- 19:25involved in selecting the vendor behind the kind of base loyalty
- 19:29mechanics and you ended up going von Tavo.
- 19:32And I think you ended up, I think you did quite a a detailed
- 19:35kind of process looking at different vendors and what they
- 19:38could bring to the table and like where you'd need to
- 19:40customize etcetera. So maybe both of you kind of
- 19:45what are your, how have you found kind of working with them
- 19:48maybe Edge starting with you from a technical perspective and
- 19:51then coming back to you Hannah from a kind of business
- 19:54perspective? Sure.
- 19:56And we hadn't worked with Ontario before, before this
- 20:00project. So it was a new product for us
- 20:03in a space that we know quite well.
- 20:05So we're kind of quite excited about working with with Ontario.
- 20:08But I think what stood out from for us as an agency, obviously.
- 20:12With the kind of overall Paul Smith text actors are very much
- 20:16I guess like best in class type mentality when selecting these
- 20:21products in that kind of headless composable space.
- 20:24So I think choosing a platform that was API first like Ontario
- 20:29where you know, they're not dictating anything to do with
- 20:33kind of design or how it kind of interacts how customers interact
- 20:36with the front end. I think that overall sort of
- 20:38flexibility put them in a really kind of good based in our in our
- 20:43mind of who we wanted to work with.
- 20:45And, and I think a lot of the features that were coming out of
- 20:49the sessions that we wanted to deliver, specifically with the
- 20:54stamp collecting idea, you know, the game patient elements,
- 20:59points bidding, those types of things.
- 21:01They have a lot of that functionality within their than
- 21:04their products alongside digital wallets and kind of reporting.
- 21:08So they kind of ticked a lot of boxes from a feature and
- 21:11functionality standpoint. I think just overall the
- 21:14development team who were sort of implementing on the front end
- 21:17side really enjoyed working with it.
- 21:19Documentation was good. Obviously it's API first, so
- 21:22it's really kind of native to what they wanted to do.
- 21:25I don't really think we could have delivered this type of
- 21:27account experience specifically with a platform that was kind of
- 21:31more sort of widgets. I think also that that's a good
- 21:34sun nod to the central platform in that, you know, the accounts
- 21:37up to us to design. We're not dictated how that kind
- 21:40of needs to look and feel. We can do kind of whatever we
- 21:42want in there. So if you go through and kind of
- 21:44create an account on the Paul Smith site now you'll see the
- 21:48the breadth of which we push that account specifically for
- 21:50those projects. So I think all of the the sort
- 21:53of vendors and partners involved in that we're really pleased
- 21:55with. And how, how did you end up
- 21:58integrating with the POS system? So Anna, you briefly mentioned
- 22:01before that there is an integration like how did you, is
- 22:04that just to kind of, you know, bespoke point to point
- 22:07integration where you're kind of looking at the the balance in
- 22:11real time or yeah, how did you end up going about that?
- 22:14Yeah, we used the middle Ware through Laravel for that ways
- 22:17integrations to get that real, it needed to be so seamless
- 22:21between online and offline. So that as soon as you spend in
- 22:25store, you're seeing that within my account on postmates.com and
- 22:28calling that directly from Antharvo as well as showing the
- 22:32rewards on the pause as well. So that when you walk into a
- 22:35store, they know exactly what T you are, how many stamps you've
- 22:37got to spend that. We've got this reward active
- 22:40this at the moment, and you can see that in there.
- 22:42So yeah, we have 1 developer kind of really orchestrating
- 22:47that layer then, and then all the complexity that comes with
- 22:50returns and pending periods and things like that.
- 22:53It's great that you did that for day one.
- 22:54So I feel like every major non Shopify loyalty program that
- 23:00I've been a part of that ends up being pushed back quite a long
- 23:04way. And maybe part of that just
- 23:06because of the POS system that's in place or you know, different
- 23:09people need to get involved. But I think it's, it's really
- 23:11good that you integrate that from day one, particularly given
- 23:14how big retailers for you guys and begin back to Montavo.
- 23:18So how, how have your team found it out of like a business
- 23:21perspective in terms of kind of setting everything up and
- 23:25measuring everything from like now that you're live?
- 23:28Yeah. I think, I mean the product is
- 23:30fantastic in terms of where you're probably just scratching
- 23:33the surface of the capabilities. We've definitely got ideas for
- 23:36the future. They have the Antarvan Academy,
- 23:39so we can get people kind of on boarded there internally so that
- 23:43once that technical kind of quite strict on boarding piece
- 23:46is done, you're then there to just configure it yourself and
- 23:49you can then work with them if you want to extend it.
- 23:52I think one of the reasons that we kind of, it was really tight
- 23:55to be honest between the two that we kind of got down to, but
- 23:58we just really wanted someone fully immersed in loyalty.
- 24:01Like we're not the expert. We really wanted to know those
- 24:04trends that were coming out, how we push the boundaries on the
- 24:07gamification to kind of pull those engagement leaders with
- 24:11customers. So that kind of loyalty
- 24:13knowledge really kind of stood out when we were doing the
- 24:15initial kind of discovery with them.
- 24:18Great. And the next question, so I've
- 24:21kind of ruined this question a little bit because I kind of
- 24:24touched on it second ago. But in terms of the retail side,
- 24:28So can you, can you maybe just talk us through kind of how
- 24:31integrated it is now with the retail channel and then any
- 24:35further plans to kind of push, Yeah, the like what loyalty
- 24:39represents for someone that walks him to the store?
- 24:42So currently for for retail is it is a really joint of
- 24:46experience prior to loyalty kind of launching, we did a huge
- 24:50project internally to kind of really allow our consent, align
- 24:54our consent. So making sure that, you know,
- 24:57pre prior to this, our store staff were blind to whether a
- 24:59customer was signed up to newsletters or to SMS.
- 25:02So we really did, like you say, kind of go back to that
- 25:05foundation of what kind of needs to be visible to the store staff
- 25:10as well as just the education. I think that's the hardest piece
- 25:13really so that you can confidently talk to a customer
- 25:16about all these different factors.
- 25:18So that's definitely something that retail are kind of working
- 25:21on their language in stores of. It's not just a loyalty program,
- 25:25it's a club. It's there's these benefits,
- 25:27there's this element. If you don't want to collect
- 25:29stamps, don't worry, you have to collect stamps kind of thing.
- 25:34I think in terms of like longer ideas, you know, we know that
- 25:37there's couples that shop in Paul Smith, there's families
- 25:39that shop in Paul Smith. So how can we kind of make that
- 25:42experience more joined up for them is definitely in the road
- 25:45map. One of the other objectives of
- 25:47the programme that came out in some of those initial meetings
- 25:50was kind of collecting more data from customers both in store and
- 25:54online. How have you kind of approached
- 25:56that with the programme, maybe starting with you Ed?
- 25:59I mean, I think that's definitely a key objective for
- 26:02for most brands when embarking on loyalty.
- 26:03It's like one of the biggest things that brands can leverage
- 26:06from, from the program or why they want to give away certain
- 26:09sort of perks and rewards is to, you know, get a better picture
- 26:13of who the customer actually is. So this was like a big part of
- 26:17the, I guess the sort of overall kind of design implementation.
- 26:21So we've created when the customer comes to create a new
- 26:23account, obviously there's triggers them to do that.
- 26:26So you know, coaxing them in with specific like welcome gifts
- 26:31or discounts initially. And then as part of that sign up
- 26:35process, we took quite a bit of inspiration from the Nike
- 26:39account where they've got, it's essentially just a preference
- 26:43sensor, but it's done in a really nice, engaging,
- 26:46intuitive, creative way. So you're asking the customer
- 26:49what their kind of interests are, how they like to shop some
- 26:52sort of personal information around like size and fit.
- 26:55So we're basically building a lot more information on the
- 26:58customer and using the loyalty program as a way to to generate
- 27:02more of that data. And then obviously passing over
- 27:06to the kind of marketing department within Paul Smith to
- 27:09segment on the information and do kind of really targeted
- 27:12sends. So the ambition then is to use
- 27:14that information to create a more personalized experience on
- 27:18the front end. You know, maybe we're showing
- 27:20only their sizes. They shopping in stock now.
- 27:22There's so much opportunity with that data, you know,
- 27:26merchandising categories around their kind of own kind of
- 27:29interests and stuff. So yeah, huge opportunity.
- 27:31And I think that kind of profile quiz is, you know, really
- 27:35valuable for for the brand. Hannah, I don't know if you
- 27:39wanted to maybe talk specifically about how the
- 27:41marketing team is going to be kind of using that information
- 27:44and maybe that I, I guess the how interesting that additional
- 27:47data is to them. Yeah, it's, it's huge at the
- 27:51minute. Prior to, well prior to loyalty,
- 27:53it was just men's, women's and you know, we know a lot of women
- 27:57buy from men at Paul Smith as well.
- 27:58So it needed to be more than just that segmentation and that
- 28:03department store point that we've mentioned before.
- 28:05So, you know, tailoring what Paul Smith is known for is so
- 28:09different for so many customers. It could be that you're wearing
- 28:12a formal suit to work everyday, but it could be that you just
- 28:15want a more relaxed hearings. So really kind of asking how how
- 28:18can we help you enjoy Paul Smith more is one of those questions.
- 28:22What collections are you interested in?
- 28:24Is it is it our homeware? Is it our collaborations down to
- 28:28the stores that you visit? The size question was really,
- 28:31really interesting for us of, you know, even if it's just shop
- 28:34by sale and you just don't want to hear the noise of everything
- 28:37that's out of stock, we can just send, we know this, we've got
- 28:40this in for you. I think then it's really how we
- 28:43can, you know, we feel like we send too many emails at the
- 28:46moment. So how can we really segment
- 28:48further? We make, you know, really nice
- 28:51revenue from our kind of triggered campaigns and our
- 28:53flows. So building more on those
- 28:56customer journeys, on how you're shopping and how we can.
- 28:59Yeah, eventually on the homepage, you can see that this
- 29:02event's happening in our store in Paris.
- 29:05So go find out more and what can get the sizes ready for you when
- 29:09you come. In next question, Hannah, So
- 29:12what has the response been from the customers?
- 29:14How has yeah kind of your customers responded to it so
- 29:17far? Have you had a lot of kind of
- 29:18engagement and interaction? It's been really positive.
- 29:22For those that don't know, there is a Portsmouth fan club that we
- 29:25have which from the outside we're always kind of like
- 29:29dipping in and seeing what they're saying prior to going
- 29:32live. We did do focus groups.
- 29:34I think we're like really key to this and we did invite some of
- 29:37the fan club into that just to sense check that it wasn't us
- 29:40just getting excited by collecting stamps that it would
- 29:42kind of land well with our customers that it they kind of
- 29:45understood there was like nervousness, just redeemable and
- 29:49special edition stamps. Makes sense.
- 29:51Like are you bothered about collecting a stamp book?
- 29:54And yeah, safe to say they they're really enjoying it.
- 29:56So it's really nice to see them say like, oh, should we share
- 29:59how we found these stamps or should we just keep it to
- 30:01ourselves and taking screenshots and sharing?
- 30:04So I think there's definitely stuff we can be doing there.
- 30:07You know, you think of the Spotify Wrapped, there's
- 30:10definitely ways there. People are desperate for a
- 30:13physical element of these stamps.
- 30:14So we're working out how we can really personalize that side of
- 30:18things. But we have kind of gone organs
- 30:21blazing with this launch. It definitely wasn't a soft
- 30:23launch. So we've had really good events
- 30:26in store with stylists talking through new collections.
- 30:29We've had online customers that have never been into a store
- 30:31going in there. So really good kind of initial
- 30:34stages, but it is a big program. So we have got a lot of work
- 30:38still to do I think now on educating on the different
- 30:41elements, improving that retail experience.
- 30:44So, you know, you can tap in like Soho House style so that
- 30:49what you know you're there and you can kind of be a bit more
- 30:51subtle if you're practice one of our Smithies compared to a new
- 30:55cover. So yeah, I'm really pleased with
- 30:57how it's landed it. We just need to turn the volume
- 30:59up now. Lovely.
- 31:01And then Ed, from your side, you've obviously been super
- 31:06involved across everything and then owned a lot of the
- 31:09technical side. Are there any learnings I guess
- 31:13from your team or maybe things you might have done differently
- 31:16given kind of, I guess, the scale of the roll out and yeah,
- 31:19how much you've kind of done to architect things with a certain
- 31:22line? I think so of going into it with
- 31:26a really open mind and, and knowing that that things can
- 31:30sort of shift and evolve over that.
- 31:32I mean, it was a year long project really.
- 31:35And then as Hannah was mentioning, you know, post live,
- 31:38it's not the it's still an ongoing project.
- 31:41So it's got its own road map specifically.
- 31:43So I think just understanding the the size of everything and
- 31:48you know, there's nothing worse than like biggest fear outside
- 31:51of people understanding redeemables versus collectibles
- 31:54was launching the program and then it just like crickets.
- 31:56Nothing, nothing happening on it.
- 31:58I think the they've got this amazing framework now to like
- 32:02take it in whatever direction they want and push it as as far
- 32:05as it can go. So I think how it how it's all
- 32:11turned out, I couldn't be happier really.
- 32:13And I think the the initial findings has been great.
- 32:16There's still so much more to turn on in terms of a lot of the
- 32:19kind of automations and flows, a lot of the kind of in store
- 32:23activity. We're already kind of working on
- 32:26making the program more visible across the site because you
- 32:30know, everyone's got the people got their own internal ad
- 32:32blockers on when they're on E com stores now.
- 32:35It's like really difficult to get the kind of right messaging
- 32:37across. So, you know, we're kind of
- 32:39we're looking at working some of those flows.
- 32:41So I think the most important thing take away for us is that
- 32:44yeah, it's kind of yeah, phases and iterations and kind of even
- 32:49though we've launched, there's still a lot more to do.
- 32:51Yeah, makes sense. And then final question, Hannah,
- 32:56you've obviously done so much already and it sounds like both
- 32:58of you are like really looking forward to kind of rolling out
- 33:01some of the kind of features you're planning on building into
- 33:04the program. And but I guess like what are
- 33:06your kind of, what are some of the bigger things you're still
- 33:08looking at doing to kind of, yeah, continue to take the
- 33:12program to the next level? Yeah.
- 33:14We have, you know, as a legacy company or heritage company,
- 33:17should I say. We've got the complexity of like
- 33:20franchise. So we need to kind of on board
- 33:23our franchise customers because to a customer they'd still call
- 33:26Smith. So that operates in their kind
- 33:29of our Asian market a lot more at the moment.
- 33:31So we're desperate to kind of bring those involved wholesale
- 33:35as well as a huge part of our business.
- 33:37And we really want to work with our wholesale partners and not
- 33:40in a kind of, OK, we want to kind of take them back into a
- 33:43kind of direct, but how can we work with those that they get
- 33:47part of that Paul Smith world to buy Paul Smith from them again,
- 33:50not just another brand. So that's definitely something
- 33:53we're kind of working with now with our wholesale side of the
- 33:56business, the kind of family element, definitely push
- 34:01notifications. There's a whole new channel for
- 34:03us that we've got to kind of weave in there.
- 34:07So yeah, the road map is long and quickly being asked to kind
- 34:10of, you know, double stamp days, things like that, and pushing
- 34:13out buying a merch to think about new stamps when they're
- 34:16working with partners and things like that.
- 34:17So it's busy. It's busy.
- 34:21Right. Well, yeah, I mean, I've, I
- 34:23think personally I would consider this to be, yeah,
- 34:26industry leading. I think, you know, Paul Smith is
- 34:28perfectly placed as well to do so much cool stuff within the
- 34:32program. And you've obviously got so much
- 34:33of that already built in. But yeah, and I found it really
- 34:36interesting today kind of listening to you both talk about
- 34:39where it's going. Just before I kind of close the
- 34:42episode off, if people wanted to kind of ask you any questions on
- 34:46the program or get in touch with you, Ed, in terms of working
- 34:49with you on these kind of projects, how would people go
- 34:52about doing that, Maybe starting with you, Hannah?
- 34:55More than happy for anyone to reach out to me on LinkedIn.
- 34:57I know like leading up to this, especially in the last couple of
- 35:00years of how to position a loyalty program for a premium
- 35:04brand is really difficult. So yeah, more than happy to to
- 35:07talk about my experience. Hannah Bennett at LinkedIn.
- 35:11Then you. Had Yeah, we've actually got a
- 35:13Clex's club launch party coming up on the 19th of November.
- 35:18So if anyone is interested in coming to find out more about
- 35:22programme, pop some, pop some champagne and have a nice
- 35:26evening, then please reach out. Yeah and yeah, I'm available on
- 35:29LinkedIn. That's probably the the best
- 35:31channel to to get a hold of me. Lovely.
- 35:35Well, yeah, thanks so much for joining.
- 35:38And then, yeah, thanks everyone for listening.
- 35:40As always, please follow us and subscribe on wherever you're
- 35:43listening. And then, yeah, I'll be back
- 35:45with James again next week. And yeah, as always, feel free
- 35:48to shoot us any questions as well.
- 35:52You're listening to the Inside Commerce podcast, hosted by
- 35:54experienced consultants James Gert and Paul Rogers.
- 35:57Inside Commerce is your fast track to digital knowledge,
- 36:00featuring interviews with leading e-commerce retailers,
- 36:02industry thought leads and the C-Suite key tech companies to
- 36:05explore the latest digital strategy, customer experience
- 36:08and tech. Discover what the latest trends
- 36:10really mean and get practical advice based on experience to
- 36:13help fine tune your E Comm strategy and text.
- 36:16Follow us on LinkedIn and reach out to James and Paul if you'd
- 36:19like to discuss an ecommerce project.
- 36:21We hope you enjoy the latest episode.