Latest / Film And Whiskey / Gladiator / Elmer T. Lee
Transcript
- 0:00In 2000, director Ridley, Scott. And star Russell Crowe gave the
- 0:04world, a modern sword and sandal epic, that Drew critical and
- 0:08popular. Acclaim.
- 0:09In 2021, we return to America's most awarded Distillery for
- 0:14another allocated bourbon. The film is Gladiator, the
- 0:19whiskey is Elmer T, Lee and we'll review them both.
- 0:22This is the film and whiskey podcast.
- 0:43Welcome to the film and whiskey podcast.
- 0:45For each week. We review a classic movie and a
- 0:48glass of whiskey. I'm Bob book.
- 0:50I am Brad. G of Seven Hills, father to a
- 0:54cute daughter husband to a beautiful wife, and I am Friend
- 1:00Bob, but I'll have my revenge in this podcast, or the nation.
- 1:08Yeah. Fred.
- 1:08The great thing about that is, you know, you're from a city
- 1:11named Seven Hills. And that's a metaphor that in
- 1:13Rome, that's what they called, Rome the city on Seven Hills.
- 1:16I'm so glad you picked that up. Hell yeah, I did, man.
- 1:18I paid attention in seminary. I think he paid more attention
- 1:23to the history of Rome than Ridley, Scott to it.
- 1:26That's probably true. Hey man, it is really good too.
- 1:29I hear your voice like it's it's been a crazy couple weeks for
- 1:32us. I know we talked about this a
- 1:34little bit on last week's episode but for me like I just
- 1:37moved to a new house, it's the first house lol.
- 1:41Homeowner now it's been it's been an experience already after
- 1:46like not even a week of living here we found out the furnace
- 1:49needs replaced. We found out that there was a
- 1:52gas leak, you know, just all the good things happening in the
- 1:56realm of homeownership already, for me, bro.
- 1:58I'm not gonna lie. This is actually going to be
- 2:01really mean, so I apologize in advance like we Haley.
- 2:05And I bought the best house in the world, like we have had zero
- 2:10issues and all I ever hear from all my friends who own homes is
- 2:14that there's like just inordinate amounts of issues
- 2:16that come up in home ownership and I don't know what like we
- 2:19did, right? But we got a really chill house.
- 2:22I'm happy for you, man. I as long as you recognize that
- 2:25you are in the very small minority of people, rest of us.
- 2:29Struggling percent. Yeah, my basement stays dry.
- 2:32When it rains. Haven't had any furnace it.
- 2:35Like it's just, it's a wild place.
- 2:36It's awesome. So Brad, I do feel.
- 2:39I feel for you, man. That's yeah, it's all right man.
- 2:41We're getting settled. I don't have a permanent
- 2:43recording space yet. I'm in the basement right now.
- 2:45So this it probably sounds different than most episodes
- 2:48will but bear with me as I try to find a new recording closet
- 2:53in my home. So if we will see how that goes
- 2:56Bob we I need to come up there and build you something like we
- 2:59need to get Legit recording booth.
- 3:01Yeah, I think we should just build a whole like Wing onto the
- 3:04house. Yeah, yeah, it'll be the, it'll
- 3:06be like in Beauty and the Beast Spa, no one enters the West Wing
- 3:10sponsored by our patreon account.
- 3:12That's right. It'll only take us like, I don't
- 3:15know. 370 months. Yeah, raise the required.
- 3:19You know, we'll get there eventually.
- 3:20Yeah, we'll get there. We'll get there.
- 3:22Well, Brad. We're here to talk about the
- 3:232000. Best Picture Winner Gladiator, a
- 3:27movie that I, you know, what? I saw this a CH when I was a kid
- 3:30and it's always always on cable. I feel like AMC just exists on
- 3:35reruns of this and The Walking Dead and the Shawshank
- 3:38Redemption. But I got to be honest with you,
- 3:41man, I can't remember the last time I sat down and watched this
- 3:45all in one sitting it's been on my show, like, you know, I own
- 3:47it. It's on my shelf, I got it.
- 3:49When they were selling those, they used to do DVD two packs
- 3:53and it came with Braveheart. So it was a Broward Gladiator to
- 3:57pack. I have the exact same one.
- 3:59Yeah man. It's a classic of the DVD genre,
- 4:02but I'm like, I'll just say this of all the two packs that have
- 4:07ever come out. I don't know if they've ever
- 4:09paired two movies more perfectly together.
- 4:13Yeah, I think, for good and for bad, like, 100 peaking back to
- 4:17our brave heart episode. And this movie Just shares so
- 4:21much DNA with Braveheart and, you know, bright honestly, like
- 4:24I think we'll get into it, but I'm not gonna lie.
- 4:27I think watching this movie after probably 10 years.
- 4:29Of distance. It was a very, let's just say,
- 4:33different experience. For me, this time around.
- 4:36Okay? Can I just tell you that?
- 4:38I, so I haven't seen Gladiator and probably, like, three, four
- 4:41years. And because we watch Braveheart
- 4:45somewhat recently and like, I saw them both on the same case.
- 4:49I legit was waiting for Lucilla, you know, played by Connie,
- 4:53Nielsen to come up to Commodus at some point and say, like it's
- 4:58okay because I carry His baby. And then I realized that the end
- 5:02I was like, wait a second. That was Brave heart.
- 5:03Yeah, rock Rock movie. You know, they both really
- 5:08leaned heavily into the, I miss my dead wife, but I'm also going
- 5:13to sleep with this other pretty lady, and I think it kind of
- 5:16throws the whole movie off, in both instances.
- 5:18I mean, in this one, at least he doesn't sleep with her.
- 5:21Yeah. You just like kisses are once.
- 5:22Yeah. He's like I'm not attracted to
- 5:24you at all and then she's like, hey, make out with me.
- 5:26And he's like, okay, maybe a little, they just move.
- 5:29Vaughn from there may be a little you know I am.
- 5:33I am a gladiator now. I deserve this, you know.
- 5:36Oh 100% man. I mean proximal acid.
- 5:38Did you like girls boys? We can send it to you.
- 5:42Alright. Man before we get you off the
- 5:44rails here, I think we should throw over to Brad explains,
- 5:47which is the part of the podcast, where Brad breaks down
- 5:50the plot of the movie that he has just seen often for the
- 5:53first time. I am going to go ahead and
- 5:55assume this was not your first time seeing this as you owned
- 5:58the DVD to pack. Right.
- 6:00Yeah, this is probably a round number 10.
- 6:03So like something wrong. I've seen it quite a few times
- 6:05my hand tight like bread. And I don't mean this in, like,
- 6:08a patronizing way at all. We're about to be so
- 6:11patronizing, you, but seriously, you watching a movie ten times
- 6:15that this has to be really high up, your list of most re-watched
- 6:18bragi movies. Yeah, I I've said this before
- 6:21but actually let's make a contest of it film.
- 6:25One, Whiskey Nation, if you can name my most watched news, Movie
- 6:30re-watched movie, then you'll win some sort of prize because I
- 6:34know that at some point in the history of this podcast, I've
- 6:37mentioned it. No, I like it.
- 6:38Well. Okay, get out us on social media
- 6:40or on our Discord Channel, with your answers to that question.
- 6:44And Brad will send you in his words, some sort of prize.
- 6:48Yeah. Well, how about how about the
- 6:49Luca Mariano? We got all those packets and
- 6:52bunch of samples. Cool.
- 6:54Boom. All right there.
- 6:55Boom, boom. All right.
- 6:56Brad, let's get into Brad explains.
- 6:58Can you break down the plot of This movie for our listeners, in
- 7:0160 seconds or less. I sure can Bob, the movie
- 7:05Gladiator is about Russell Crowe wanting to be the Spaniard guy
- 7:10that like, Farms his Spanish land with his Spanish wife in a
- 7:14Spanish son, and he doesn't get to do that.
- 7:18Instead, he's the empty Emperor's primary General, he
- 7:22beats the Germans and then his son and I do not his son, the
- 7:27emperor's son, kills the emperor and Becomes the emperor.
- 7:31And then tries to kill Maximus. Maximus goes back, home is
- 7:34family's dead. He got becomes a slave becomes a
- 7:36gladiator and then he becomes so good at being a gladiator that
- 7:40he denies the emperor's power Commodus, the emperor tries to
- 7:44fight him in one-on-one combat and like Stacks the the battle
- 7:47in his favor, but Maximus is a badass and kills many ways and
- 7:51freeze the Roman Empire from the tyrannical reign of The
- 7:56Emperor's. Boom, also he dies.
- 8:00Yeah, dude. I'm not going to lie, man.
- 8:02For all the crappy cinematography in this movie
- 8:05that last scene when they're carrying maximus' body off and
- 8:09you just see Lucilla standing in the middle of the arena.
- 8:12And you just see Commodus his body lying there.
- 8:16That's it, it's over shop for coverage.
- 8:18I don't have to you know what it reminded me of though.
- 8:21The very end of West Side Story, when they're carrying off Tony's
- 8:25body, And you've got, Raffia following them out of the end of
- 8:29the camera, pulls back up from the park.
- 8:31And yeah, man, ever made me that quite a bit West Side Story.
- 8:35That's the one where they had that song.
- 8:36There's nobody, like, Maria. Is that wrong?
- 8:40Maria wrong Maria. Oh sorry, sorry.
- 8:44All right, man, I want to Dive Right into this movie and I
- 8:46can't tell what a better place to start would be.
- 8:49So I'm gonna let you pick and I think the two options because we
- 8:52got to discuss both of them are the script and the Action.
- 8:57Now Ridley, Scott is the director here.
- 8:58We've talked about him on the podcast.
- 9:00Before we have at least I have lots of opinions about Ridley
- 9:04Scott, but I also have lots of opinions on the story and the
- 9:07script in this movie. Brad, where do you think we
- 9:10should start here, dude. My boy rids.
- 9:12Co he, he struggles in this movie.
- 9:17All right, let's yeah, let's do Ridley, Scott them because
- 9:20Ridley Scott is one of the most famous directors that has been
- 9:23working for well over 40 years now.
- 9:26He has made incredibly great movies.
- 9:28He's most famous for alien and Blade Runner, you know, he's
- 9:31been nominated for best director.
- 9:33I can't remember if he won, best director for this film are not
- 9:35actually, I don't think he did, I think Angley 14, Crouching
- 9:38Tiger in this year, but, you know, he's a really, really
- 9:43famous director. And yet, I feel like over the
- 9:45years, he has just kind of become like a very serviceable,
- 9:52passable director. And when you go to see a Ridley
- 9:55Scott move, There's not a lot of like stylistic things that I
- 9:59think characterize a Ridley, Scott movie, you know what I
- 10:03mean? Like you look at all the movies
- 10:05he's made in the last 20 years and they're kind of all over the
- 10:07place. They all kind of feel the same
- 10:10and I guess that's a good sign but I also don't know that
- 10:13Ridley Scott has made a great movie in 40 years and and that
- 10:18means that's where I struggle with him.
- 10:19Like, is he really a great director or is he just one of
- 10:22our best kind of Directors for hire?
- 10:26And you're kind of guaranteed to get a three star movie out of
- 10:29him. Yeah, I mean, when you look at
- 10:31where he started with alien, and then you look at something like
- 10:35Gladiator, which won him best picture somehow.
- 10:38And then you go to, like, his next collaboration with Russell
- 10:41Crowe, which was Robin Hood? Which I don't know if you saw
- 10:45that, but it was really, really bad.
- 10:47No bueno. Yeah, no bueno.
- 10:49I like, I just look at him and I think that overall I just feel
- 10:54like, Ridley Scott is an Average director that struck gold in his
- 10:59first movie. I haven't seen Blade Runner so
- 11:02you know, you can, you can discount my opinion as you will.
- 11:05But overall like I don't know, especially like when you talk
- 11:09about a specific style that he has like his style is just
- 11:16really flat washed-out cinematography where there's not
- 11:19a lot of color and that works when you are filming a Sci-Fi
- 11:25alien. Ian on a, you know, derelict
- 11:28space cruiser type movie, but it doesn't really work when you're
- 11:32doing a movie like Gladiator, like Robin Hood.
- 11:36Like all, you know, these other movies where they should be a
- 11:39lot brighter, there should be a lot more color.
- 11:41I think that's one of the things that frustrates me most about
- 11:44this movie is that the cinematography is just average.
- 11:48The coloring of the movie is boring.
- 11:50There's just a lot of issues with gladiator and as I come out
- 11:54you know swing in I love this movie for the longest time, like
- 11:58there's a reason I watched it 10 times, there's so much of this
- 12:01movie. I really liked and there's some
- 12:04of it that I still enjoy, but as I get older, I think it now.
- 12:08No man. I just look at it and I go man
- 12:10in 1999. American Beauty one.
- 12:14Best picture and then you have a 2000 Gladiator winning it and it
- 12:18just, I don't know. It's just a hard left turn.
- 12:21Yeah, it really is man. And I think the most frustrating
- 12:23thing for me watching this movie which again, is a movie that I
- 12:27like, for the most part is how uneven the direction is because
- 12:32there are some sequences where it really feels like he must
- 12:35have sat down and storyboarded this like the it flows really
- 12:39well. He picked all his shots really
- 12:40well and then there's other sequences where it just seems
- 12:43like they filmed. The same thing from like 15
- 12:46different angles and they just kind of spliced it together and
- 12:49you know, the opening battle scene, I feel like there's a
- 12:52pretty great kind of set up for this battle that you're going to
- 12:55get and then the battle starts and it is just a mess, dude.
- 12:58It's like incomprehensible. I didn't know where I was.
- 13:01I had no sense of the geography. And I think that there are like
- 13:05a number of sequences like that throughout the movie.
- 13:08And it really just kind of seems at least the edit that we got
- 13:11here, like, Ridley Scott, Had really good ideas for like forty
- 13:17percent of the movie. And then the other 60% it was
- 13:19just kind of like, all right, like we're going to see what we
- 13:21get here. Yeah.
- 13:22That like there's a part of me that wonders of this movie could
- 13:25have been like an hour and 40 minutes long instead of two
- 13:28hours and 35 minutes because as I as I get deeper into the
- 13:32movie, the first half of the movie is, is hard to get
- 13:37through. There's, there's some good
- 13:40moments throughout but I don't know, I think that you're
- 13:44Hitting the nail on the head. Bob, there's Great Moments in
- 13:46this movie that like give you hope for a phenomenal movie, but
- 13:50enough of it just drags you down that.
- 13:53I mean it's the pacing. It's the cinematography, it's
- 13:56the dialogue. It's the acting.
- 13:58There's just, I don't know, but I don't know.
- 14:01Where do you want to go? Well, that's it.
- 14:03Maybe this is a good place to kind of transition into the
- 14:05script because I feel like there are moments where this script is
- 14:08really good, but for the most part, it's not good at all.
- 14:12And then I also feel like there are moments where I really
- 14:14Scott's direction is really good.
- 14:15And then there are times where that's not good at all.
- 14:17And I think the most frustrating thing is that they never really
- 14:21seem to be working in sync together, like when the script
- 14:24is, is doing some okay, Exposition or something like, it
- 14:28seems like Scott's direction is just wandering off in a
- 14:30completely different direction for lack of a better word.
- 14:33And then there's other times where it's like, oh, Ridley
- 14:35Scott is taking this turd of a scene that was written and he's
- 14:39really making something suspenseful or intriguing out of
- 14:42it but But again, like it just doesn't seem like those to
- 14:46really work together and they're kind of always at odds.
- 14:50And, you know, you talk about the first half of this movie,
- 14:53man, like I kind of had to watch this movie and bits and pieces,
- 14:57and that is never ideal for watching a movie.
- 14:59But again, I've seen it a ton of time.
- 15:01So I know what's coming. But I have to say, man, the
- 15:04first half of this movie is just an absolute slog.
- 15:08Like I came to watch a movie called Gladiator.
- 15:11I want to see a man Gladiator. Wait dude, you know what I mean?
- 15:15Like I just I want to see somebody in the Colosseum and
- 15:19there is just this protracted bike setup of Roman politics and
- 15:26the relationship between the emperor and his son and it's
- 15:31just goes on forever. Like he doesn't even get sent or
- 15:35he doesn't even wake up, you know, as a slave until I think
- 15:38like the 45-minute Mark, he doesn't actually get to the
- 15:41Coliseum until the hour and a half.
- 15:43Mark That point. There's only an hour left in the
- 15:45movie. It just kind of seems like the
- 15:48pacing of this film is way off to me.
- 15:51See, for me the I think the the first half has different issues.
- 15:55I actually kind of liked the protracted prologue if you will.
- 16:00I guess I really enjoy the setup of Maximus has character of his
- 16:04relationships with Commodus and Lucilla and Marcus Aurelius.
- 16:09Like, I enjoy that opening sequence because you get to see
- 16:13See. Who Maximus is what he is all
- 16:16about? I don't know.
- 16:17I was reading some reviews of the movie and a lot of people
- 16:19complain about how. He's, he's just such a simple
- 16:23character, right? He's a great fighter that wants
- 16:25to go home and that's kind of a stereotypical thing.
- 16:28But honestly, I like that Trope. I like the idea of The Reluctant
- 16:32Warrior. So that's not something that
- 16:34bothers me. I think for me the first half of
- 16:37the movie, It's the battle sequences that struggle and like
- 16:41there's a there's a few cool shots of like The arrows flying
- 16:45through the air and the catapults launching these fiery,
- 16:48you know Boulders, but for the most part, I think the entire
- 16:53movie struggles with the battle sequences the, their, their
- 16:56film, strangely their cut to Pieces as far as like, the
- 17:01choppiness of the editing. So, for me, that that opening
- 17:05sequence, the opening battle sequence and really most of the
- 17:07battle sequences, for the whole movie.
- 17:10I just think Scott really struggles as an action director.
- 17:13Four grand large-scale Warfare. Yeah, I think that's a good
- 17:17point man. And one of the things I noticed
- 17:19this time around was that weird slow mo effect that they put
- 17:22into place in a lot of the battle sequences and not to nerd
- 17:26out too much. But you know, when you're
- 17:27recording a movie on film, the way the film goes through the
- 17:30camera is you get 24 film cells, or frames per second.
- 17:34So when you play back film, like on a spool in a movie theater,
- 17:37it's 24 frames a second. And so if you wanted to film
- 17:41something in slow motion, let's say you wanted to slow it down.
- 17:44Half. You need to record that, add a
- 17:46frame rate, that's much higher. So you record that in the camera
- 17:49at 48 frames a second, so that when it plays back at 24 frames
- 17:52a second, it plays in slow motion.
- 17:55But sometimes, like, when you can't afford 48, frame stock,
- 17:58or, you know, like, you just don't have the resources, you'll
- 18:01see, like filmmakers will, just go ahead and use 24 frames, and
- 18:04then just play it back, really slowly.
- 18:06And you can kind of tell each click of the frame.
- 18:09It doesn't look seamless anymore.
- 18:10It's not like tricking your eye into thinking that it's like a
- 18:13fluid. Mint.
- 18:14And they do that a lot in this movie where it's like it's in
- 18:17slow motion but it's not really slow motion.
- 18:20It's like cheated slow motion and it has that weird choppy
- 18:23kind of flicker effect to it and it was super distracting for me
- 18:27like there was a lot of camera work and you mentioned that
- 18:29cinematography there's a lot of Zooms in this movie and I like
- 18:33for some reason I just I don't get down with when cameras zoom
- 18:37in movies in general but especially like, when you're
- 18:40showing me ancient times and there's this Sounds stupid to
- 18:44say like this but like every time there's a zoom you become
- 18:48very aware of the fact that there's like a camera in this
- 18:50place and it really pulls me out of whatever world you're trying
- 18:54to build. So there were a few things like
- 18:56that that Ridley Scott and his cinematographer chose to do
- 18:59that. Just like it takes you out of
- 19:01the world of the movie. Yeah, there's multiple times
- 19:04where he uses the like slightly lower angle than the objects
- 19:09face. It's like a mid-range Zoom.
- 19:13Umm from Far like from decently far away, but you're like,
- 19:16looking up at Marcus Aurelius or you're looking up at.
- 19:20I think it's Senator grakkus at one point, as he's delivering a
- 19:22line. And I'm just like, that's just
- 19:24it just feels like a really weird decision.
- 19:27Like, like, do you want us to focus on them?
- 19:30Do you not, like why is the camera so far away?
- 19:32But you're slowly zooming in from a weird angle.
- 19:35Like, I don't know what I'm supposed to focus on and I think
- 19:39the other thing that frustrates me about that is I feel like
- 19:42half the time like When they're zooming in on something, the
- 19:47object, they want you to pay attention to isn't like clear of
- 19:51other objects or people. And so, you end up seeing like
- 19:54close-ups of just random extras faces as they're like, looking
- 19:58around right in front of Marcus Aurelius.
- 20:01And you're like what what what come on bro.
- 20:03Like look at these extras out of here man.
- 20:06I will say I did notice a couple times like some of the choices
- 20:10stylistically that they did make I think really got borrowed from
- 20:13They got borrowed from pretty heavily by Peter Jackson for the
- 20:16Lord of the Rings. Like all of the sequences where
- 20:20Russell Crowe is like a stroll, planing never like astral
- 20:24projecting and thinking about his dead family that is like
- 20:27100% the kind of frame rate, the kind of color grading, the kind
- 20:32of weird, you know, with pans and zooms that Peter Jackson
- 20:37does whenever Frodo puts the ring on and they show, you know,
- 20:41whatever Frodo seeing in Mordor. And and so I, you know, to their
- 20:45credit there is some stuff in this movie that I think was
- 20:48really influential on filmmaking in the early 2000s, but there is
- 20:53a lot of nitpicking. We can do here Brad and I guess,
- 20:58you know, just to kind of pull back a little bit from that
- 21:00nitpicking. I think we should talk about
- 21:02Russell, Crowe the man wins the Oscar, for this movie.
- 21:04I don't really know why. And that's not to say, he's not
- 21:08good, but I just, you know, we've seen a lot of great
- 21:10Russell Crowe performances. I don't know that I'd put this
- 21:12in like his top. Four or five performances and
- 21:15yet at the same time, you know, the the credits come on and the
- 21:19cuts right to Maximus his face. And he is imagining himself.
- 21:24Basically, walking through these wheat Fields going to see his
- 21:28family and it cuts back to him and you realize he's on the
- 21:30battlefield and he's been daydreaming and they just let
- 21:33the camera Linger on his face for like, I don't know. 20
- 21:36seconds, he sees a butterfly or a bird or something fly off and
- 21:41he watches it and dreams about being free and you can See, all
- 21:44these things registering on his face of I'm daydreaming and I'm
- 21:48snapping back to reality. But I want to go back to the
- 21:50Daydream. I'm thinking about this bird and
- 21:53then he, he resolves himself to go fight this battle.
- 21:57And I think from the very GetGo, just that little touch is of its
- 22:01kind of like a microcosm for the whole movie that this script is
- 22:05not very good, it doesn't flush. His character out very well.
- 22:08The dialogue is going to be terrible and yet Russell Crowe
- 22:11is going to do the heavy lifting.
- 22:13To make this believable and I think he needs to get the
- 22:17credit. So like, you know, even though I
- 22:19don't think he deserves the Oscar necessarily, maybe he
- 22:22does, because he took, what could have been a very Bland
- 22:25mediocre character and he makes something out of it.
- 22:29I was in say, I think that if there's anything I enjoy about
- 22:33this movie, I actually like a lot of the performances in this
- 22:37film. I like Russell Crowe.
- 22:39I like Oliver Rita's proximo, I like Connie Nielsen is loose.
- 22:44I really like Joaquin, Phoenix as Commodus.
- 22:48I like the the characters, who play the Senators, I like the
- 22:51character who plays the, the numidian, his gladiatorial
- 22:56friend. Like, there's a lot of
- 22:58performance in this in this movie that I think pull a really
- 23:02average to bad scripts like out of the toilet and give you a
- 23:07movie that's that's endearing and charming and motivating as
- 23:12so. I think that if there's anything
- 23:13that It really helps this movie out.
- 23:15It is the acting performances. Well, let's go in on that a
- 23:18little bit because I do think we should talk about Joaquin,
- 23:20Phoenix. He earns a Best Supporting
- 23:22Actor, nomination, I believe for this movie, and I think he
- 23:25deserved it, he's really, really good in this movie.
- 23:28And honestly, I noticed it in that scene, where he murders his
- 23:32father. You know, in my mind, I had
- 23:34thought that there were two separate scenes that he has the
- 23:37confrontation and then he comes back later and murders him, but
- 23:39it's all one scene. And I don't really want to focus
- 23:42on the murdery part of it. I Focus on what's before that
- 23:45when Marcus Aurelius comes, and breaks the news to comment as
- 23:48the, he's not going to be Emperor and you have Joaquin,
- 23:52Phoenix just really baring his soul and and just saying like,
- 23:56Dad, why don't you love me? The many forms of courage?
- 24:01Devotion. To my family.
- 24:05Did you? But none of my virtues one your
- 24:10list. Even then it was as if you
- 24:14didn't want me for your son. Come with us.
- 24:19You go too far. Let's faces of God. waste,
- 24:26please you to make you proud. And, you know, I would, it's a
- 24:33great line actually because it's like a complete window into this
- 24:36character soul. I think he says, like, I would
- 24:38butcher the whole world if it meant that I could have your
- 24:41love and it is such an insight into like, wow, this guy is a
- 24:45freakin sociopath but also what's driving him is that he
- 24:48wants this approval and the fact that he can't get, it is the
- 24:52thing that's going to set him over the edge and watching him,
- 24:55just kind of beg and plead. And, you know, Marcus Aurelius
- 24:59is just already determined not to do it.
- 25:02It's really heartbreaking. And I think the frustrating
- 25:05thing for me was like, I'm watching that scene and I'm
- 25:07thinking to myself, oh, this guy's not as evil.
- 25:10As I remember him being a, he's really layered and I can
- 25:12understand his motivation. He's really upset about what he
- 25:17is perceiving as Maximus. Taking something from him and
- 25:20not just the the throne, but like his dad's love and then
- 25:24they just kind of turn him into like this cartoonish villain in
- 25:27the second half. And he loses all that Nuance,
- 25:30but even, even with that working against him, I think Joaquin.
- 25:33Phoenix is just freaking phenomenal in this movie.
- 25:36Yeah, I will just never forget watching this as a young
- 25:41teenager and just being blown away by how creepy he is in this
- 25:45movie. Like, I just think Joaquin.
- 25:48Phoenix, is terrifying in this film and even watching it, now
- 25:51is a thirty-year-old. I think you find the nuances of
- 25:54his performance. Like what?
- 25:56Like when he's in that scene you were just talking about Any
- 25:58talks about the four virtues that Marcus Aurelius had written
- 26:02to him about. And then he lists he goes.
- 26:04Well I knew that I didn't have those but but father I have
- 26:07other virtues. Like you can see that he's still
- 26:10trying to win his father's approval and it just isn't gonna
- 26:14work. And so for me as he enters the
- 26:16second half of the movie, I think the key to understanding
- 26:19him is the other great scene that I think he really has,
- 26:23which is where he's in the Senate and the Senate is like,
- 26:26you know, belaboring him with All these different things he
- 26:29needs to do and he gives you this line about.
- 26:32Like I will be their father and the people of Rome will be my
- 26:37children and I will love them. And I think that's like the
- 26:40motivating piece for this character is like, okay, well,
- 26:43if I never got the love that I deserved.
- 26:45I'm going to give it to my people.
- 26:47I'm going to treat them the way I should have been treated, you
- 26:51know, which is paired with this immoral.
- 26:53Let's start the Roman, you know, gladiatorial games back up.
- 26:57But at the Same time, like he's like /, he's almost like
- 27:01perversely, pure of heart. Like he desires love, even if he
- 27:06pursues it and ungodly and forsaken type of ways.
- 27:11Absolutely. All right, man.
- 27:12I think we're off to a good start here.
- 27:14There's lots to like what this movie, but there's definitely
- 27:16some flaws here. Let's see what we think about
- 27:19the whiskey for the day, which is Elmer T lie.
- 27:22When you say, let's get to it. Alright, so today we are
- 28:05checking out, Elmer T, ly, single-barrel bourbon.
- 28:08This comes from Brad's favorite Distillery, Buffalo Trace and
- 28:12just like most Buffalo Trace products.
- 28:14It is nigh impossible to find and Brad.
- 28:18There's not too much to say here because we have set it all about
- 28:21Buffalo Trace. But just in terms of the
- 28:23specifics, this is only a 90 Proof bourbon.
- 28:26It is from Mash bill. Number two, which is a Rye
- 28:30bourbon. They think it's about 15 to 18
- 28:32percent Rye. It shares the mash bill that
- 28:34Blanton's carries which is also a single barrel which is also
- 28:38kind of in this General proof point.
- 28:42I'm excited to try this Brad because I've never actually
- 28:44gotten a chance to sit down and try Elmer T ly partially because
- 28:48it's really hard to find just to buy it at retail.
- 28:51But also, you know, when I go to a bourbon bar, I know how much
- 28:55it costs these bars to get a bottle.
- 28:56And so the markup on this stuff is in Shane and honestly, if I'm
- 29:01going to be paying 20 plus dollars for a poor of bourbon,
- 29:04I'm probably gonna want something that's not just a 90
- 29:07Proof bourbon. So I'm excited to try it.
- 29:10We have a sample from our friend at TK bourbon on Instagram.
- 29:15He sent us a sample of this. We are very very grateful for
- 29:17that Brad. You've kind of had a checkered
- 29:19history with Buffalo Trace. So are you familiar with the
- 29:23Elmer T ly brand? And how are you feeling about
- 29:25this one going into it? God bless about.
- 29:27I just looked it up and Like 100 to 300 dollars on the secondary
- 29:32Market. Yeah.
- 29:34But the retail is like 40 bucks. Yeah.
- 29:37You're not. That's what I'm saying.
- 29:38Yeah. Bob I don't need to get started
- 29:41on this. I damn it.
- 29:45This is just so frustrating because I drink the whiskey
- 29:48already. I took all my freaking notes,
- 29:49it's a solid whiskey. Yeah.
- 29:51Like like it's pretty good and I like honestly at $38.
- 29:56I gave it a six out of town value.
- 29:58I was like yeah, it's a Solid. Whiskey $38 is a little
- 30:01expensive but like sure. Yeah, it's fine at Bob I came
- 30:04out with a 37 out of 50. Like, that's a really solid
- 30:08score for a whiskey and then I have to freaking find out that
- 30:11it's a Buffalo Trace bullsh, that you can't even got get it
- 30:15anywhere, and people are dropping 100 200, $300 for this
- 30:18crap, and it's not worth it. Listen man, I love that.
- 30:22You are so worked up that. You just skipped the whole
- 30:24whiskey segment already gave your final score.
- 30:28So I'm going to play catch-up You now because I think I'm the
- 30:30only one reviewing this whiskey at this point, but yes, I share
- 30:33your frustration. It is incredibly incredibly
- 30:36aggravating to see what's happening with the secondary
- 30:39market and Buffalo Trace, you know, to their credit.
- 30:42Like, they don't have a hundred percent say, in how their
- 30:46whiskey is sold. The three-tier system is really,
- 30:49really crappy. But Brad, let's just talk about
- 30:52what's in our glasses here. When I poured this out and I
- 30:56nosed it. I thought this was just really,
- 30:58really beautiful. Beautiful.
- 30:59This is an incredibly. I mean, it sounds simplistic to
- 31:02say nice, but this is a really nice nose.
- 31:05There's a lot of Apple on this and specifically for me, it was
- 31:08green apple. I get a lot of caramel on this,
- 31:11you know, obviously it's a bourbon.
- 31:12You're going to get Caramel on it and then I got like a little
- 31:15hint of like a cherry candy, maybe like a red vines or
- 31:17Twizzlers on this, it was really, really nice and
- 31:20pleasant, and lighter than some of the Buffalo Trace products.
- 31:24We've had in the past, it certainly was a little bit
- 31:26brighter and lighter than Blanton's and even Eagle Rare.
- 31:29I'm going to give this an 8 out of 10 on the nose.
- 31:34Come on. All right, all right.
- 31:35I mean you can do it. So for the nose, I think it has
- 31:38a really nice bright. Kind of vanilla note to it that
- 31:41like popped out to me at the start.
- 31:43And then underneath that was I'm right there with you.
- 31:46Bob it had this nice crisp refreshing, Apple knows to it.
- 31:50That was just Pleasant. I had I didn't expect it from
- 31:54this bourbon. I was honestly expecting more
- 31:57caramel. I really just kind of got a Hint
- 31:59of it but yeah, nice. Lots of vanilla, lots of Apple.
- 32:04I give it a 7 half out of ten on the nose and then when you get
- 32:06to the pallet, the mouth feels a little bit thin, but again it's
- 32:1090 proofs. I wasn't expecting a lot here
- 32:13thin, but really nice again and I gosh, I keep I hate that.
- 32:16I keep saying the word nice, but this is just like it's not even
- 32:19just inoffensive. It's just a very pleasant little
- 32:22whiskey and I enjoyed the heck out of it and, you know, so for
- 32:26me again, the apple carries over, there's lots of cinnamon
- 32:29on this Want to get a little bit of clove on the taste.
- 32:32Right before you go to swallow, I think it does turn just a bit
- 32:34bitter and it gets very Oaky and it reminded me a lot of Eagle
- 32:38Rare in that way. So, you know, compared to our
- 32:41notes from Eagle Rare. I still think.
- 32:43Overall the palette on this is really, really, I'm just a nice
- 32:47again but it's a really enjoyable experience.
- 32:50I'm gonna give it a seven and a half on the palate.
- 32:52You've been down to like Amish country and had been like the
- 32:56barn or Dare Dutchman, or something like that, right?
- 32:58Sure. Yeah, you know like their peanut
- 33:00they're creamy like peanut butter spread.
- 33:03Yes I do. That is what I got on.
- 33:07This will interesting. Okay.
- 33:08Like it was creamy, it was peanut buttery.
- 33:11There was a ton of vanilla and a little bit of that crisp.
- 33:16Apple came on through and I think honestly what you said I
- 33:20didn't write it down but cinnamon is a good note that
- 33:23like it's almost like a cinnamon peanut butter vanilla.
- 33:26I really like this. It didn't blow me.
- 33:29Out of the water but I thought it was a really solid complex
- 33:34palate that I gave an 8 out of 10 to.
- 33:37All right. So let's move to the finish
- 33:38here. I think the Finish is actually a
- 33:40little bit nicer than the palette because like I said it
- 33:43goes a little bit bitter and and heavily oaked on the end of the
- 33:46Finish or on the end of the palate.
- 33:48But for the finish, I actually think that some of those sweeter
- 33:52notes came back. It was a really nice and mouth,
- 33:54man. I've said, nice 18 times.
- 33:56It was a really mouth-watering finish.
- 33:58It didn't dry. My mouth out.
- 34:00It wasn't tannic at all. And I really appreciate that on
- 34:03a whiskey like this. I'm gonna give it once again a
- 34:05seven and a half out of ten. Yeah, once again this is this is
- 34:09a finish that is smooth and sweet.
- 34:12Like there's a little bit of oakiness a little bit of spice
- 34:15but I'm getting all that vanilla for me.
- 34:18The Apple kind of come becomes more pronounced at the end of
- 34:21this experience. And there's a nice little
- 34:24Kentucky hug to go along with it.
- 34:26I like the Finish it's an 8 out of 10 for me.
- 34:29Alright that takes us to overall balance Brad.
- 34:31I think this is a really well-balanced whiskey.
- 34:34There's not much to say here in terms of negatives, I think it
- 34:38does drop off a little bit from the nose to the palate.
- 34:41But then again from the palette to the finish, it goes back up
- 34:43again for a 90 Proof bourbon to not pack.
- 34:48A lot of a punch and to really stay in that fruit forward.
- 34:51Sweet vanilla caramel wheelhouse.
- 34:54I think they really knocked this one out of the park.
- 34:56I'm going to give it an 8 out of 10 on.
- 34:59The overall balance. Yeah, Bob, I can't really add to
- 35:02what you said there. It's a well-balanced whiskey and
- 35:06it had some surprising complexity from the nose, to the
- 35:09flow, to the palate. So for me, it's a seven, half
- 35:12out of ten, really well-balanced whiskey?
- 35:15All right, so this is where it gets, you know, Buffalo Tracy,
- 35:18because we're talking about the value here, Brad it retails for
- 35:24what, 40 something dollars, was it retail for 3799?
- 35:28All right, so let's Order up to 40, let's just say you're paying
- 35:30$40 retail, it doesn't sell for that, you know, anywhere you're
- 35:35going to be spending at least a hundred dollars to get this.
- 35:37Unless you are lucky enough to live in a state like Ohio and
- 35:40even then you're going to have to enter a lottery for the
- 35:43chance to buy it at retail which is ridiculous and its own right.
- 35:47So Brad this is the hard part, I think scoring this out at $40,
- 35:52makes it comparable to Eagle Rare and Eagle Rare was one of
- 35:56the Bourbons that made me fall in love with bourbon.
- 35:58But when we tried it, It about a year ago, I think we realized
- 36:01like in a lot of ways we have encountered many, many more and
- 36:06better, bourbons, and I actually think head-to-head, I might
- 36:09prefer this flavor profile to Eagle Rare.
- 36:12So if I could get it for 40, I'm going to give this like an 88
- 36:15and a half out of ten on value. If we're talking a hundred
- 36:17dollars, I don't see this being a hundred dollar whiskey at all
- 36:21and that makes it a really bad value.
- 36:24If I'm going to split the difference, Brad I guess I'm
- 36:28just going to give it a 4 out of 10 on value.
- 36:31Alright, so my original score for this was 6 out of 10 at $38.
- 36:35I think it's just a little overpriced if it was like if it
- 36:38was Eagle Rare range and like 32 33 dollars probably be like a
- 36:42seven or eight out of 10 on value.
- 36:45But at 100 200, $300, this has never been done before in the
- 36:51history of film whiskey podcast. I'm going to give it a negative
- 36:536 on value. And that brings my final score
- 36:59out to a 25 out of 50 valve. And I - that's a 12-point swing.
- 37:06We went from a 37 out of 52. 25 out of 50.
- 37:09Are you, are you really for real sticking with that number?
- 37:13You know I'm going to cut the difference and give it a zero.
- 37:17All right? Cool.
- 37:18So that brings you out to what 31 out of 50.
- 37:21All right. I'm at a 35 out of 50 so that's
- 37:24bringing us to a 33 on average. 66 out of 100 again.
- 37:29Like if we were just taking into consideration that the taste and
- 37:32the drinking experience, this is a much better bourbon than a 66.
- 37:37But when you've at when you factor value into it I think
- 37:41this is pretty appropriately rated.
- 37:43Yeah honestly I know that I'm harsh.
- 37:46It's honestly a solid whiskey. I understand why people want it.
- 37:50I understand why the price goes up on the secondary Market.
- 37:54I just think that Buffalo Trace needs to do Amore to keep the
- 37:58secondary Market under control, whether that's increasing
- 38:00production. Whether that's I don't know
- 38:04putting limits on how much it can be sold for otherwise.
- 38:07They stop selling to those, you know, third-party sellers.
- 38:11Like I don't know what it'll take but they need to get a
- 38:14handle on this because I think the beauty of whiskey is that
- 38:18it's an Everyman drink. Like like when I think about the
- 38:22world of whiskey, it's a place where anybody can come and join.
- 38:26And what Buffalo Trace is doing is they're creating a snooty
- 38:31select secondary Market where you're better than somebody
- 38:35else. If you get your hands on a
- 38:37bottle of their stuff and I just don't think that.
- 38:40That's right. I think that they need to do
- 38:43something about it. So Revolt, are you go the
- 38:46Revolt? That's right.
- 38:48We're you are the Maximus of this this coup that we're about
- 38:52to throw a game of right ice. You're damn right.
- 38:54I am and I think it. Needs to start with the film,
- 38:57whiskey podcast, stops supporting their stupid
- 39:00Whiskey's, but you keep putting them on here Bob.
- 39:02So you are the quintus. You are the quintessential to my
- 39:07to my maximum, right? Whatever man Brad right.
- 39:11Let's get back into talking about Gladiator.
- 39:13What do you say? Let's get to it.
- 39:14Bob All right, that was Elmer T.
- 39:55Ly bourbon a whiskey that we both really like, but I don't
- 39:58know if we would recommend it Brad, just because of the chase
- 40:02involved in getting a bottle. And that's exactly how we feel
- 40:06about Gladiator. So, we'll see you next week.
- 40:11Brad. I'm gonna call an audible here.
- 40:13Most weeks. You invent a brad G award to
- 40:16give out to our movie of the week.
- 40:18This week, I'm going to do it. I'm going to give the Bob Buckle
- 40:20This week do it and it's kind of dark.
- 40:23Are you ready for it? Well, who I love dark Bob, it's
- 40:27from the worst timeline. This movie gets the award for
- 40:31best child-sized. Mannequin, getting absolutely
- 40:35heated by a horse. This Pleasant, man.
- 40:40First of all, I gotta say for a movie that I like this movie has
- 40:45just so much unintentional comedy, especially in that first
- 40:49half like moments that I I laughed out loud where it was
- 40:52completely inappropriate to do so, but none more than when
- 40:56Russell Crowe's little son, is running towards that, you know,
- 40:59that platoon and saying like a paw, paw it just cuts right to
- 41:04the horse going push. That is kid lying out from,
- 41:09under the feet of this horse, it was the fakest looking and then,
- 41:13but they made a little sound effect.
- 41:14Like, if I can find the scene, I'm going to put the sound
- 41:16effect of this kid. Getting just, just trucked by
- 41:19this horses. So funny to me and tell me if
- 41:25I'm the worst person ever or if that actually was just a
- 41:27terrible idea on their part. Now as long as you add like a
- 41:32crowd, booing in the back. Like oh afterwards that I think
- 41:36it's a perfect sound clip. Did you ever get into Vine when
- 41:40vine was a thing? No, I honestly didn't.
- 41:42I thought it was like old Tick Tock.
- 41:44Is that what it was called much? Yeah, I never got into it, but
- 41:47I've been watching all of those like good vine compilations on
- 41:50YouTube lately and there's this one where it's like an
- 41:54infomercial, I think it's Alyssa Milano or something, and she's
- 41:57doing, you know, one of those infomercials for underprivileged
- 42:00kids and it starts with her saying, what would you do if
- 42:04there was a child standing right in front of you and then it cuts
- 42:07off and it cuts to somebody else, it could be like a home
- 42:10video of somebody just Trucking a kid out of their way.
- 42:14And it just reminded me like, I need to make the mash up of her
- 42:17saying, what would you do if there was a child and then cut
- 42:20Gladiator. And this kid, just yes.
- 42:23By this course. Yeah, that'll be the first video
- 42:26on the filmin. Whiskey Tick-Tock.
- 42:28Absolutely. They'll get us banned forever.
- 42:32No, Bob, honestly, the other moment that I will point out of
- 42:36bad mannequin Knology whatever you want to call it when.
- 42:41So you remember, he doesn't have almost any lines other than the
- 42:45God's favor you because their color is red.
- 42:48The the guy who like Challenges him when he first gets to the
- 42:52trainings of cool but then he kind of becomes his friend early
- 42:552000s. Dave Bautista guy?
- 42:57Yeah, yeah, Drax. But you know, a discount
- 43:00version. Yeah, discount Drax.
- 43:02So when discount Drax dies when they're like, let when the
- 43:07Gladiators are helping Russell Escape.
- 43:10That is the single worst most fake-looking deaths.
- 43:16I think I have ever seen in a movie, like, I don't think
- 43:19velocipede Dirk could have a worse death.
- 43:22You know what? I bet that whole last sequence
- 43:24of them do trying to do this escape and the whole coup
- 43:27attempt. Honestly Brad, I'm not gonna
- 43:29lie, I forgot. That was part of the movie.
- 43:32I remembered how it was going to end.
- 43:34I knew it was building to that but I totally forgot.
- 43:35There was this attempted escape from the prison and it felt so
- 43:40weird and tacked on and not filmed very well.
- 43:43Like, I couldn't really understand why is Russell Crowe
- 43:46like down in the catacombs now. Where is he going?
- 43:49And especially with that Guys death whom were calling discount
- 43:53Drax apparently when he gets killed, I really think it was
- 43:56one of those things where they were like, oh, shoot like we
- 43:59forgot to show him die and he's not in the movie anymore.
- 44:01We gotta go back and film that again.
- 44:03Yeah, because he's filmed in silhouette and it's just kind of
- 44:06out of nowhere. Like you don't even know it's
- 44:07him at first. And then you just see this this
- 44:09body get hit with like three or four arrows and then they kind
- 44:13of cut to a close-up and you can tell it's him and then he's
- 44:15dead. But he goes out.
- 44:17So, unceremonious, Lee for a Who you thought was kind of
- 44:21important to the movie, like they really just felt like a,
- 44:25like a disrespectful way to kill him off.
- 44:27Oh dude, it just felt so herky-jerky and weird.
- 44:32I just yeah. That was the death that just
- 44:34just kind of killed me a little bit on the inside.
- 44:37But I will say that the way that they filmed the Nets closing in
- 44:44like the traps being foisted upon Maximus and his allies.
- 44:49I actually really Got into that, like, for me, that set up that
- 44:53final battle in such a way where like it makes you feel like
- 44:58Commodus has already won. Like, by the time, he's giving
- 45:02the speech to his sister about how, like, if she tries to be
- 45:06nobleman that seen her sight. Oh, dude, it's so good.
- 45:11And it's in the middle of, like, all of Maximus is allies being
- 45:14decimated or captured, but the emperor Claudius knew that
- 45:18they're up to something. And you'd have a busy little
- 45:22bees. And one night, he sat down with
- 45:26one of them. And he looked at her. and she
- 45:32said, What you've been doing? Busy little bee.
- 45:42Or I shall strike down those dearest to you, you shall watch
- 45:47as I bathe in their blood. And a was heartbroken.
- 45:57Little bit winded, him more deeply than anyone else could
- 46:00ever have time. For me that's seen is one of the
- 46:05most memorable from the movie. Yeah.
- 46:07That might have been the best overall sequence because that,
- 46:09you're right, they really expertly intercut it with what's
- 46:12going on at the prison. And, and I think that's one of
- 46:15the things with this movie that like, the first hour and a half.
- 46:18I absolutely hated the last hour Ridley, Scott's like, hey, watch
- 46:22me, go to work now. Like, I'm gonna do the thing and
- 46:24he does, like, it becomes suspenseful, I think the
- 46:28choreography of the action sequences gets a lot better for
- 46:31the most part. The direction and the editing or
- 46:33much tighter. So the movie really ends on a
- 46:37good note, and I think that it kind of makes you forget about
- 46:40how long it took to get there. Yep.
- 46:43But for me, like man, I don't want to jump right into final
- 46:45scores here and I don't think I will yet Brad, but I think
- 46:48that's the central thing I'm struggling with.
- 46:50As we get closer to giving this a final score, it's just a
- 46:54really uneven movie. Yeah, I mean, let's just go to
- 46:58the action sequences as an example of that because For me,
- 47:03something that has stood out to me.
- 47:04As I've learned more about film is something that friend of show
- 47:08Patrick age Williams. Once said, which is that in an
- 47:13action sequence? One of the most important
- 47:15things, a director can do is set the geography of the fight,
- 47:21right? That everybody knows the
- 47:23boundaries, everybody knows where the antagonist and
- 47:26protagonist are at every moment. And I think that when you take
- 47:30that lens and you It's a gladiator. 90% of the combat,
- 47:35and this movie is jarring. It's 57 Cuts per 4 seconds.
- 47:42You never know where you're at. You never know where Maximus is
- 47:46and relation to his people, like, it's just such a cluster
- 47:50of a battle sequence every single time, except for the
- 47:54final battle. Like, when Maximus and Commodus
- 47:58are fighting, he does such a better job of keeping you Aware
- 48:02of where they're at at all times.
- 48:04You don't have to keep track of like 87 different Gladiators
- 48:08fighting one another. You just have to focus on
- 48:11Maximus and his dark armor and Commodus in his amazed.
- 48:15It probably the best costume of the movie, he's all white like
- 48:19armor set piece like it's a beautiful action sequence and
- 48:25like even the the way that Commodus dies I legitimately had
- 48:30chills as he's like Hopelessly beating against Maximus with his
- 48:35free arm. I genuinely think that Commodus
- 48:39is death, is one of my favorite deaths in movie history.
- 48:43Yeah, listen, I agree with everything you're saying, like
- 48:46it ends on such a great note. It's just that I don't think
- 48:50they maintain it throughout the whole movie and before we get to
- 48:54final scores, Brad are there any other like nitpicks that you
- 48:56have with the movie or just things that made you kind of
- 48:58chuckled yourself things that stood out as Maybe?
- 49:02They could have done that a little bit better.
- 49:04Dude. The, the up-and-down nature of
- 49:06the dialogue in this movie, like some of the lines and some of
- 49:10the, the interactions I think are just out of this world.
- 49:14Good, like, like there are certain parts of this movie
- 49:19where the, the dialogue, I think anytime Russell Crowe speaks
- 49:23with his new midi and friend is, is spectacular.
- 49:28I just love the interactions that they have, but in spite of
- 49:31that, Are just some, I rolling Lee bad lines in this movie,
- 49:37that it doesn't matter. How much great acting you have
- 49:41from the people in this movie. There's just some bad writing
- 49:44for this film Bob, like, like, for example, when they're
- 49:48fighting the one battle where maximus' people are portraying
- 49:52the ancient Carthage, the ancient Carthage.
- 49:56When when Joaquin Phoenix says to the senator, he goes, now
- 49:59refresh my memory. I believe it was The Barbarians
- 50:03who were supposed to lose here. Like I just love the dripping
- 50:07sarcasm in that line. Like to me, that's like a peak
- 50:11line of this movie but then whenever I hate to say it but
- 50:16other than there may be their first interaction between
- 50:19Lucilla and Maximus every interaction that they have after
- 50:23that is just boring. Yeah.
- 50:25Like the lines are horrifically. Bad.
- 50:29Their dialogue is not engaging in any way you You can't tell if
- 50:33they're trying to make them into a love story or if they're just
- 50:36like kind of casually staring at each other.
- 50:39I don't know, man. So Brad.
- 50:41I'm gonna, I'm gonna throw a hot take out there.
- 50:44Hans Zimmer, did the score for this movie and it is one of the
- 50:47best-selling movie soundtracks of all time.
- 50:49This movie was a cultural phenomenon, like it made a whole
- 50:52boatload of money. Apparently, sold a whole bunch
- 50:54of CDs back in the day too. I gotta say, man, I don't think
- 50:58that the music matches the actual Action on-screen very
- 51:03well in this movie, like it's a cool soundtrack and I think a
- 51:07lot of the music is good but I noticed it in the first five
- 51:11minutes or so of the movie where they're playing, what sounds
- 51:14like a Pirates of the Caribbean type, huh?
- 51:17Theme over the battle with the barbarians and it's supposed to
- 51:21be like this really brooding kind of you know, the color
- 51:25palettes all grayed out and it looks like the opening scene of
- 51:28the Revenant or something and the music is just this kind of
- 51:31old. Wash buckling type thing.
- 51:33And at multiple points in this movie, I was just like, what's
- 51:38going on with the score here, because it either seemed like it
- 51:41was in a completely different movie, or it was so on the nose
- 51:45that it made me kind of roll my eyes.
- 51:47Like, when Russell Crowe wakes up on that wagon, and they're
- 51:50taking him to become a slave and they kind of cut to the
- 51:53marketplace. I'll be damned if that wasn't
- 51:56just lift it from Aladdin. Like that was, that was the
- 52:00Agrabah theme from Aiden, I'm 100% certain of it.
- 52:04I was like, where is the genie gonna burst out here?
- 52:07We got to start singing Prince Ali.
- 52:09Like, it was egregiously bad and the scene where like, Russell
- 52:14Crowe's family dies. I think this movie, like,
- 52:16started the Trope that we got all through the 2000s of
- 52:20anytime, a movie, is set overseas.
- 52:22And something dramatic happens. You have to have a female
- 52:26singing, like vaguely Middle Eastern lyrics in.
- 52:29What sounds kind of like a yodel.
- 52:31Do you know what I mean? It's Like throughout the whole
- 52:36sequence and it just none of it matched.
- 52:39What was going on on the screen? See, here's, I have two thoughts
- 52:44on that first. Thought Hans Zimmer also
- 52:46composed Pirates of the Caribbean curse of the Black
- 52:49Pearl. Oh, did he really say?
- 52:50Okay, so there's a reason that's that opening shared.
- 52:55See, literally, it is 100% the Dead undead.
- 53:01Adam I didn't intend turn up like it's it's 100% parts of the
- 53:06Caribbean and Hans just like took that one, little Motif and
- 53:10turned it into the entire Motif for the Pirates of the Caribbean
- 53:14Universe where it works. Much better much, much better.
- 53:18So that's that's my first thought.
- 53:20Second thought I actually think that if you take any of the
- 53:24orchestral music in this movie, it's not great.
- 53:27It doesn't fit the movie. I agree with you 100%.
- 53:31Anytime they have a Wire for the soundtrack, I think it fits
- 53:36perfectly and it hits the nail on the head.
- 53:40So for me, I agree with you. That it becomes a Trope.
- 53:44But anytime anyone physically sings in this movie, I think it
- 53:48actually fits the movie Perfectly.
- 53:50All right? Brad last thing I want to talk
- 53:52about before we get to final scores I sent you a like a short
- 53:55video to watch because there's something that happens in this
- 53:57movie. That it happens.
- 53:59Kind of a lot and it's kind of egregious but It's the use of a
- 54:03thing called insert shots, and if you're familiar with the film
- 54:06language, you might know what an insert shot is.
- 54:08But imagine that you are well imagine that you're watching
- 54:11this movie, right? And Russell Crowe is being taken
- 54:14out to get executed in the forest and he is fighting these
- 54:19guys. And you get slashed, by one of
- 54:21them. He falls to the ground after he
- 54:22kills them, and Russell Crowe reaches behind his breastplate.
- 54:26And when he pulls out his fingers, it cuts to a shot of
- 54:29his fingers covered in blood, that's an insert.
- 54:32Shot is a shot that doesn't really go with the rest of the
- 54:35scene but it is inserted to give us information that we might not
- 54:39see. Otherwise it happens a lot when
- 54:40people are framed in close-up because there might be things
- 54:43happening outside the frame of their face that you need to see.
- 54:45And so they'll show a character opening a letter, you know, when
- 54:49when Rick in Casablanca stands on the train platform, he's
- 54:53reading a letter from Elsa. They show the letter and
- 54:55everything. It says, that's an insert.
- 54:57I think this movie relies on the insert shot in ways that make
- 55:02me. Me question.
- 55:03Sometimes, like, how well did Ridley Scott plan out this
- 55:07movie? Because there are so so many of
- 55:10them, and in a way that almost makes it seem, like he doesn't
- 55:14trust us to just understand what's going on.
- 55:17Like it Russell Crowe reaches behind his breastplate, and
- 55:20pulls out his fingers. And you see him kind of like
- 55:23wiping, what looks like a bloody substance on his fingers, even
- 55:26if you don't see, you know, that his fingers in close-up, you
- 55:31understand that he got hurt? And I mean he like grimaces in
- 55:34pain. Yeah.
- 55:35Okay dude got her got it you don't need to give me any more
- 55:38information than that and this movie has.
- 55:40I mean it uses insert shots as transitions between scenes like
- 55:44when he escapes from those guys and he goes riding on his horse
- 55:47day and night and he's they show him riding a day and then they
- 55:50cut to a shot of the Moon and it just lingers on the moon for
- 55:54like 5 seconds and then they show him by a campfire and it's
- 55:58dark behind him. So it's like well, we showed the
- 56:00moon so that you know, that it's night time now.
- 56:02Now, it's like, I didn't need that.
- 56:03I know it's night time. He has a fire and it's dark
- 56:06outside. Like, stop insulting.
- 56:08My intelligence, and I really think this movie's over relies
- 56:13on those little moments because they didn't really do a good
- 56:16enough job, framing the shots otherwise, well, I think the big
- 56:21issue is that he uses such a static camera throughout the
- 56:24entire movie. Like he I don't know if he ever
- 56:26moves the camera and so for me, the insert shots are Are because
- 56:33he needs somewhere to go with the camera.
- 56:36And so it's it is a struggle, it's not something.
- 56:39I noticed a ton and even after you sent me the video, I was
- 56:41like, oh yeah, I can think of a few like awkward insert shots
- 56:44throughout the movie, but it wasn't something that dominated
- 56:47for me. I think, for me, it was the
- 56:50inconsistent. I don't know style of the movie,
- 56:53like, you get a few shots of Russell Crowe, like cgi'd over
- 56:58the ground. Like moving over the ground,
- 57:01when he's dead. Dead.
- 57:02You get some random, like massive shots of the sky and
- 57:08like lightning. And I think that I'm watching
- 57:12tree of life for a second, like, like, there's just so many
- 57:16different styles of cinematography & art-direction
- 57:21happening in this movie. That that's the thing that
- 57:24really frustrated me about the cinematography.
- 57:26Alright. Brad, I think that we've
- 57:28nitpicked enough. And again, this is like one of
- 57:30those episodes where I hope we kept it.
- 57:32Meaning, I hope we don't seem like, we're just kind of pooping
- 57:35on the movie here but we both liked this movie.
- 57:38I have a feeling you might have liked it more than I did but
- 57:41let's find out. Brad, what would you give this
- 57:43as a final score out of 10 you know coming into it.
- 57:46I was expecting to give it a 9 out of 10.
- 57:49It's a movie. I've always loved.
- 57:50I knew that there was flaws, I knew that there was stuff about
- 57:53it. I you know, it's not a perfect
- 57:55movie but this time through there's just there's just a lot
- 57:59of stuff I realized wasn't well made Made.
- 58:02But for me, I don't know. There's something about this
- 58:07story about, there's a heart to this movie that I think is what
- 58:12captured, you know, an entire generation of moviegoers and
- 58:16there's a reason it won, best picture, there's a reason.
- 58:18It what made so much money? I just think there's something
- 58:22special about this movie and despite all of its flaws, I'm
- 58:25still going to give it an 8 out of 10.
- 58:27So Roger Ebert gave this movie two out of four stars and Roger
- 58:31Ebert For being a really well educated and understanding
- 58:37Cinema studies at a level that most people will never
- 58:40understand. He always seemed to relate to
- 58:43the Everyman, like, people watched Roger Ebert on TV, and
- 58:46if he gave a movie to Stars, it wasn't like, oh, he's just
- 58:48pretentious in a snob and I read his review today and I agreed
- 58:52with a lot of it, I watched this movie and it does remind me of
- 58:55Braveheart in so many ways because almost all of the
- 58:58nitpicks we had with Braveheart, we have with gladiator.
- 59:01It's Kind of a jumbled mess. Sometimes it has pacing issues.
- 59:05The script is not very good and yet the acting is really good.
- 59:08I think some of the battle scenes are spectacular.
- 59:10There are lots of memorable moments.
- 59:13I just think that this movie is still kind of like overvalued
- 59:17and over appreciated by people on IMDb it has an 8.5 out of 10.
- 59:23It's the number 45, I think movie of all time, like I just
- 59:27don't see it Brad. It's a really a really enjoyable
- 59:31to and If our movie that could have been two hours, I'm going
- 59:35to give it a 7 out of 10, but I think what I would like to hear
- 59:39from filmin. Whiskey nation.
- 59:40Is what exactly about this movie?
- 59:44If you love it, keeps you coming back to it?
- 59:46Because, you know, I look at other sword and sandals type
- 59:50epics like a Spartacus or even just things set in the desert.
- 59:54Like a Lawrence of Arabia things on a massive scale and I just
- 59:58don't think this movie really Compares Brad.
- 1:00:00And so I'd like to hear from Phil.
- 1:00:02Owen, whiskey Nation. If you love this movie reach
- 1:00:04out, let us know why you love it.
- 1:00:07What keeps you coming back to it?
- 1:00:09You can find us on social media on Facebook, Twitter or
- 1:00:12Instagram at film whiskey, or you can give us a phone call.
- 1:00:16Your voice can be heard on the film.
- 1:00:18Was he podcast? You can do that on our website,
- 1:00:20which is Anchor dot f. M /, film, whiskey next week, we
- 1:00:25are going to be watching Quentin Tarantino's 1992, debut film
- 1:00:29Reservoir Dogs. So join us.
- 1:00:32For that one. But until then I'm Bob book I'm
- 1:00:35Brad G and we'll see you next time.