Latest / The Narrative with Aaron Baer / Katy Faust Talks The High Cost of Gay Marriage on Children
Transcript
- speaker-0: So I just want to say for the sake of this podcast, you may not want to listen to this in front of your kids, because even I'm going to generalize some of what was said, and your kids still should not hear it. speaker-1: Yeah. Welcome back to the narrative Aaron Bear, Samuel Say with our good friend Katie Faust from Them Before Us. Katie, thanks for hopping on with us. speaker-0: It's fun to hang out with you guys. I was surprised to see Samuel. Surprised in a good way. very, very nice to chat with you guys. speaker-1: Again, w once again, all the best people come to Ohio sooner or later. I always remind folks, like when Trump was trying to work out things with Iran, who did he send? He sent an Ohioan because we get stuff done around here to send. Now, don't point out that we're still in a war, but that's beside the point. He still sent an Ohioan on that one. But Katie, we wanted to have you on for for two reasons. Number one, we've relaunched the podcast, brought Sam on, and we wanted to make sure, you know, our status as You know, a hate group, SBLC certified and and you know, bigots was well established here. Didn't want to didn't want anyone to think we've gone soft. So we brought in the hardest person we know in Katie Faust. speaker-0: Right. Bigot with a capital B, baby. That's what I have to offer. speaker-1: Exactly. Come get some. but the the the second one was you just had a a story in The Federalist, which I I'm not quite sure I want to recommend folks go read because it is it's disturbing. Yeah. it's about the the diary of this gay dad and his sexual exploits that he writes that his daughter is kind of always right there in the background of while he's having anonymous sex with all of these men, right? and I remember when I first saw it, besides the, you know, sort of repulsion that comes from seeing something like this and the details that he shares in his diary that he published, it it jumped out to me a and I I wanna get here, but it jumped out to me that we're in an election season. And I remember when I first started working in public policy, we were talking a lot about marriage and the importance of marriage between a man and woman. This election cycle to see a politician bring that issue up would be very rare. And I I I want to get to that, but I first want to talk about this article that you wrote for the Federalist. and why, you know, this is one of these, the this diary of from this gay dad would have been something that I would have been very happy to never known about and live in peaceful bliss to to not know this kind of thing was happening. but Katie, why and you've written other articles like this before for the Federalist. Why do you think it's important to br shine light on these types of stories today? speaker-0: Because not all families are equal. That's the bottom line. And unfortunately, we have repeated this cultural mantra for so long that we think that any arrangement of caring adults are going to be just fine for the kids, and it's absolutely not. The Federalist, I like sanitized the recap of this gay dad's journal. The Federalist still had to put an explicit warning on my article. So I just want to say. For the sake of this podcast, you may not want to listen to this in front of your kids, because even I'm going to generalize some of what was said, and your kids still should not hear it. So just note that like we're now three or four degrees of separation from what actually took place in this guy's house, and he is a two-month-old. Okay. That's like I can't even talk about it in generalities around your children's ears, even though they might be eight or ten or twelve. But kids are living this. Kids are living this world where an adult sexual appetite completely governs his entire world, and his two month old daughter is a scheduling footnote in what he thinks about in this one week window that we have into what matters to him. speaker-1: And I mean you see it y you sort of documented the article it again with the with the parental warning on this of him literally bringing sexual partners that he meets anonymously online into his daughter's bedroom. and then later on just that like the next day going with another anonymous partner and taking her to the doctor and having sexual fantasies about the doctor while he's in there. and Katie, I think you you you really highlight something in this about the way especially gay men sort of fetish that's sort I want to butcher that word, have a fetish about having kids and then parade them around. And there's something that their biological realities can't cope with that a mother wouldn't do or couldn't do in the same way as this gay dad. Can you talk about that a little bit? speaker-0: Yeah, you know, you just have to read his, you can read my recap. You can read his original 2,500-word diary entry at the cut, the New York magazine offspin, and you can just see there is no woman with a two-month-old who's postpartum who would think or do, say or choose any of the things that this guy is hungry for and planning on and obsessively focused on. I mean, he is constantly thinking about sex. How to get it, where to get it, and he doesn't care from who. If it's his husband, fantastic. If his husband is unavailable, he will find some faceless. And literally he's choosing faceless people, people that won't show their faces that he can hook up with. Sometimes it's, you know, ended up being at a party up against a washing machine for some guy that he's never met before, never gonna see again. And everything is sexualized. You know, even when his daughter, even when his daughter is drinking out of a bottle and formula drips down her cheek, he's thinking about rural sex. You know, it's every single thing that he's thinking and doing and choosing has to do with gratifying his sexual appetites. Women don't do that. I you know, I'm an adoptive mom and I didn't do that even after I brought a baby home that I didn't give birth to. This is not how women think. And especially if your body has stretched for nine months, why parts of your body have widened to the point where you can push a 10 centimeter head out of your body. A lot of us end up getting stitches, sitting on donuts, you know, to recover, who can't lift a certain amount of of weight, you know, especially if it's a cesarean section. Our bodies are we're told not only should you not have sex, most of us are not ready and not wanting it for the first at least six weeks of postpartum life because women's bodies demand a refocusing of their attention away from sex, away from. Romantic gratification and it forces you because you are incapacitated in some ways, but also the body, the baby is dependent on your body. You must reorient your body around the needs of the infant. There is nothing about a man's body that demands the same kind of attention reorienting. And we can get into this if you want, but it's fascinating that. Dad's behavior does change after the baby is born. We've got studies that show, and you guys are fathers. Sam, you're a new father. I don't know how much you want to talk about this, but there is a demonstrable, measurable drop in testosterone, up to about 30% in men after they have an infant in the home. Now, gay fathers will say, well, we can have that testosterone drop too, because that has to do with infant caregiving. But when they measure it, they actually see that it is the steepest drop in the first month for co-residing fathers. That means that something is going on in the hormone, pheromone interplay between a man who's co-residing with his wife, who's pregnant and gave birth, that something in his own body drops. And sexual pursuits are not as important. And this increase. In vasopressin, this protective hormone that men have increases. So it serves the mom and the baby by downshifting his sexual appetite and upgrading this feeling of this is my wife and this is my baby, and you stay the heck away from them, or I will cut you. Okay. So that's actually the way men's bodies are supposed to change. His body, this gay dad's body. It didn't have any of the physiological demands that the wife did. And it didn't have any of the framework to respond like a normal father's body would, because he was never living with the child's mother. He simply rented her and then plucked the child from her and took her home. And there's really no reason to interrupt his no his nonstop revolving door of of sexual partners. speaker-1: Sorry, real quick. And I know, Sam, I know you've got something here, but I will just say what this reminds me of. And I've never been a fan of sort of trying to caveat marriage here that people always say traditional marriage or or things like that. And no, it's just marriage. Marriage is a thing. We don't need to put a word before it to describe it. But there is something here to to what you're saying of of natural marriage, which is there is a nature, there's something about our nature, our biology that plays into marriage, right? And again, that that's This idea of marriage being a thing unto itself is about more than just two loving people. There is something biolog biological that's going on here. But sorry, Sam, go ahead. Yeah. speaker-2: I speaker-1: As you speaker-2: said being a a father of a three-month-old daughter that was i extremely disturbing and i don't want my wife to get mad at me so i'm not gonna go into much detail about what you what you mentioned about just how the fathers change when our our wives have children but that's something that i realized I was in protection mode it's My priority is is my my wife and my children. So that's not really what I'm thinking about. So when I when I read that was like, wow, okay. I I had never really thought about that. Right. So it really does show the difference between a biological father raised with married to the mother and a gay man who just buys or rents a child. speaker-0: Yep, that's exactly right. There is a natural is the right word. Not traditional, not biblical, natural. There is a natural interplay when it is male and speaker-1: Just to call out there, I think natural and biblical are the same thing, but that'll be a fun conversation. So keep going. Yeah. speaker-0: So what I'm saying is like I'm not saying that this is right because the Bible says so. The Bible says so because it's right. You know, the Bible is a reflection of the true reality of the nature of human and the nature of the world. And it gets this right, that there is something about male and female coming together in a comprehensive union that results in children that actually changes the behavior of both the husband and the wife towards the child in a way that a contract, an intent to parent, the purchase of a child. The selecting of gametes from sperm or egg-selling catalogs will never be able to replicate. There is something about a man and a woman coming together and literally creating new life through their union that reorients their behavior. Now, everybody in the audience is like, what about adoptive parents? And I will say, as an adoptive mom, I will say that is a legitimate parent-child relationship. It is a sacrificial parent-child relationship. But even that is a different parent-child relationship. The child has to detach from the person with whom they formed a a bond for nine and a half months and reattach to biological strangers. And studies show that that presents some challenges for children, even if it happens in the hospital. So adoption is redemptive, but there is something about God's original plan as reflected in nature, where the child is continuously connected to the people, the two people that made them. That distinctly advantage that baby, often because the mother and father's body, minds, and choices reorient around the child's needs. speaker-2: I love what you said about the about adoption as a whole, but especially what you said about how it's sacrificial, in that you see the difference between a biblical natural marriage where it is we are reflecting our father and his adoption. Whereas with with gay couples, you know, who claim to be married, who claim to be married, it's not a sacrifice at all. Right. So that then would encourage some of the things that we see, as you said in the article. Well, one of the things I wanted to ask is, and I think Aaron mentioned this earlier. I hear a lot of surveys, reports claiming that a lot of the newer Gen Z conservatives are starting to change their minds on gay marriage. And I don't know if that's true, but on top of that, if that is true, I'm not seeing that being reflected in the White House where Trump still seems to be very firmly. Pro-gay marriage. So what do we make of all that and what do we do to have the White House and other Republicans and Conservatives care about this issue? speaker-0: Support for gay marriage within the Republican Party was at its peak in 2022. It was about 56%. Last year it dropped down to 39%. This year it's 37%. So support for same-sex marriage among conservatives is plummeting. Some of that can be attributed to the T overplaying its hand, where people said, okay, the transgender thing is out of I I supported gay marriage. The transgender thing is out of control. And a lot of people going, well, wait a second. If marriage if if if biology, male and female, doesn't matter in marriage, why should it matter in the locker room? Why should it matter in the swimming pool? Why should it matter in the bathroom? And they're exactly right. That what you've seen is this movement, for example, very prominently last month among the log cabin Republicans, for dropping the T. They're like, we're gonna be an LGB activist organization. This is the gay affirming cohort within the Republican Party. And they got all kinds of fanfare. Hey, we're dropping the T everyone's like, thank goodness. it's about time. Yeah, we're gonna go back to kind of the old school sexual orientation advocacy. But you know what? People are right to say, no, no, we're not gonna, we're not gonna stop with just rejecting transgenderism. We're actually gonna move back up through the phil to the philosophical roots of this, which is male and female are different. And male and female are distinct. And male and female matter. That matters when you are running track. That matters when you're playing basketball. That matters most in the one venue where you make new life. And so I think that we're seeing support for gay marriage falling because of the T. But I will also say it is because people hate seeing motherless babies crying on the chests of hairy men that purchased them through surrogacy. And it's absolutely red pilled. A lot of conservatives, a lot of Christians who said, Well, what does gay marriage have to do with me? And like, That doesn't harm anybody. They believe the human rights campaigns line of how is my gay marriage going to do anything to your heterosexual marriage? And the answer is it may not, but don't buy and sell babies. And it looks an awful like gay marriage is connected to the purchasing of children, which it is. So I think that the next generation, they really are done with the c things that they're supposed to believe the out of being polite. And they're saying, no, we don't like that. We actually like our country. We think that men and women are different. We don't think that men are inherently toxic just because they're a little more competitive and aggressive. And we actually think that men and women should get married and have babies, have lots of them. And we know that gay people cannot do that. So I think that the next generation is the next generation of conservatives for sure is much more based than the boomers are. And I do think it's going to take a while for the boomers to catch up because they were just conditioned into this world of. tolerance and honestly like they were infected for decades on that conservatism is really just libertarianism. Get the government out. But the reality, government needs to properly define what marriage is. We're not saying that they should force it. I'm saying don't lie about it. Don't lie about marriage. speaker-1: Yeah. And and I think there's a a piece of it as well. Th there there's two things there, Katie, that jump out to me. The first is that we're beginning to see the left be more and more exposed to this idea that that that you know you can believe what you want to believe and let me just do with my life what I wanna do. That's just not how things play out, right? It it is it is the minute a Burgafell came down, it went straight into, well, now you have to be a part of this same-sex ceremony. Now you have to You know, you have to affirm this in in the workplace. You have to offer benefits to same sex couples. Like it it became all of these different things of, well, no, it this is not no longer just a private thing. Now we're gonna make you celebrate this with us. You've got to come to the Pride Parade with us at work. You gotta put the flag up on your desk and all of this kind of stuff. Who you gotta wear the ribbon, i i if you will. the other thing though that I think is so important about this, and and I think this is a massive lesson. for the conservatives to learn is we we totally misunderstood the nature of the gay marriage debate we were having. Right. And I I I lived through that in, you know, I I started in this work around 2010. and when when we were in the court cases, right? We had just lost the Prop 8 case and it was all all actually we just lost the Windsor case and then the Prop 8 case and and everything was was escalating from there. And What you put your finger on with them before us is the we thought the the fundamental question here was what is marriage, right? And we we would always the conversation was like, well, why is it gonna, you know, we're gonna get to same-sex marriage and then we're gonna have polyamory and all that kind stuff. And some of that stuff, you know, started polygamy, all that kind of stuff. We started seeing some of it, but it never really crescendoed the way the trans stuff did. Because the true argument of the the LGBT community was that there is no difference between male and female. That was the that was the argument we missed, which is why, you know, 2015 hits and we get just run over by this freight train of transgender ideology. And we have, you know, we go from it's what our wolves and white coats report showed where we went from, you know, a handful of gender clinics to over 250 nationwide, because this was never just about this this one type of relationship. It was about the nature of male and female and and how we've we've gotten that wrong. And so I guess, Katie, my my question for you is how are you guys, how how do you think we need to go about writing the ship on this? Some of it seems to be happening, but I'll just as an aside, I will say I sent this around to to my my staff and my board today. you know the Senate leadership fund just bought Tens of millions of dollars in ads attacking Sherid Brown in Ohio for backing trans procedures on kids, forcing Catholic hospitals to do trans procedures. and, you know, eight years ago when we first started pounding the drum on this on 2018, when we first found out about the children's gender clinic at Cincinnati Children's Hospital, nobody would have believed us on this issue. Like nobody would have thought that this was real and nobody nobody wanted to talk about it, let alone do anything about it. Now you have Senate campaigns running ads on these things. Like that's that's a real win. That's something we have genuinely changed the culture on. How do how do we go continue to kind of go yeah, you know, I don't I don't even know if it's right about going back upstream on this, but how do we keep that momentum to get marriage back? speaker-0: Tell you exactly how. The tide turned on transgenderism, not because adults were going through their own transgender treatment procedures. The tide turned because kids paid the price. And you had very real public victims. And you could see how it damaged them and harmed them. Because when people have a tangible victim with a face and somebody to defend, they'll say, you know what? I actually don't like that. Why did we lose on this before? Because we didn't make it about the kids. The pro-gay marriage side said, gay adults that can't get married are the victims. You're treating them like second-class citizens. You know, that was the pronouncement on behalf of the court. You know, these gay adults need dignity and they can't have dignity unless they can have marriage. And our unfortunate counter to that for the Christians and the conservatives, the way we largely responded is: but if you get gay marriage, Christian adults are going to be the victims. We Christians are going to have our consciences infringed on. We'll have to bake cakes or arrange flowers or assign marriage licenses. You don't want to victimize us, do you? And that actually doesn't play very well. Because people will say, okay, you're telling me that my gay brother, who's been with his partner longer than you have, they can't get married because you might have to bake a cake. Yeah, I'm sorry. The truth is that when you get marriage policy wrong, it is not adults who are the victims. It is children who are the victims. And you guys, I recognize that there's First Amendment and religious liberty considerations that have absolutely come into conflict with Obergefell, but Christians are not the primary victim. Children who lose their mother or father, because we have said that men and women are optional in the project of the family, they are the victims. And now we are starting to see some of the effects of that happening in the world of real life children. Like we're seeing the kids that are being acquired by two men who at worst are just motherless, but sometimes also acquired by pedophiles or foreign nationals that are breeding them in man mansions in California or overseas, where they have a hundred surrogate-born children in the United States because of Obergefeld era laws that make it so easy to detach children from their biological parents and reattach them to biological strangers. We are seeing it over the last 11 years, where state after state is scrubbing the words male and female, husband, wife, mother or father. From their parenthood statutes, because now just saying mother and father constitutes discrimination, right? Now, if you acknowledge that some children have a mother and a father, it sounds bigoted. And so we have reoriented all of our parenthood laws so that we can serve gay rights. And gay rights is offended by the presence of male or female in the family, especially as it relates to parenthood. So children are the victims. When we redefine marriage. Maybe it's not going to be on the ballot this year for a lot of states, but if we have anything to do with it, it absolutely is going to be a huge part of the conversation over the next couple years. because as you guys are aware, them before us is spearheading a national coalition to overturn gay marriage because it victimizes children. And we've got over a dozen states next year that are going to be running legislation that is going to feed into a constitutional challenge. speaker-1: So Katie, I guess the w the one thing you said that I will disagree with just from my i experience on it was we did talk about children need a mom and a dad. I mean I I I like I I remember seeing the I remember making those arguments in in debates and and things like that. I think but to your point, people didn't believe that same sex marriage would hurt kids. They I I I mean I I I will tell you I remember When just and I'm gonna leave I'm gonna leave names off this one. I made I made Sam name names earlier. but I remember when I first came to Ohio and I met with one politician, and we sat down and the first thing out of his mouth was, Aaron, you should know we're we're we're not gonna agree with each other on gay adoption. And I gotta be honest, I had a lot of things on my mind that day. I gay adoption wasn't like top of mind for me. And I was like, All right, let's talk about this completely random topic. Let's go in on gay adoption. Why you know, why why we don't think it's a good idea? But but that was the the general ethos at the time was that no, there are no harms to kids. That that that's just a silly argument. You guys just you think all gay people are perverts and so you don't think they should have kids. And again, I think you could actually look at, you know I I I remember when you do you remember when the Glenn Greenwald sex tapes came out online? and Matt Walsh, I think, had a had a post that was like, you gotta recognize this is like sort of standard sexual practice for guys in this world. So on the whole whole, there is actually something there. I think that's again what's what's so exposing about that diary entry entry you made. I just think I I think in many ways we tried to make those arguments then. I don't think the world was ready to believe us. And sadly, you know, it it's even like the trans stuff, once, once people saw Riley Gaines. They believed us boys are like boys are gonna dominate girls and in girls' sports if we go down this whole trans path. And I think sadly, every time you see some buff dude take his shirt off and sit in a hospital bed like he just delivered a baby w holding some adopted child, they're they're starting to say, okay, that's kind of messed up. speaker-2: I have to be honest, I think I disagree with you a little bit. Yeah. I think you're right that that Wright and Evangelicals did talk about how it harms children. And maybe I'm wrong, but I think what maybe Katie is saying, and I would agree with her, is that it wasn't the primary argument. The primary argument was that it it would be a threat to religious liberty. That's what I remember the most. Maybe I'm wrong about that, but but but it To me, honestly, it was it's recently and I would have to say it's primarily through Katie that I I realized that the ch I mean, I knew of course it would harm children, but I think on an advocacy level, I realized that the most effective way to address the issue was to use the left's narrative of victimhood, but then but in but in this way, in the correct way to say there is victims in on this on this issue, and it's children. And then I think it does also victimize, I think, Christians as well too. But I think in the most effective way to address the argument, we have to address children. I and I think until recently, the right has not been doing that as well. speaker-1: So as an aside, you would be super fun sometime, Katie, we're gonna have to have you back. I'm gonna, you know, the the good news of this is CCV at the time was Citizens for Community Values. in 2004, we led the marriage amendment campaign here. And we've got a basement full of archives of our ads, of our and we it was a successful, like we won 62% of the vote in Ohio. Like it's the it was the whole thing of like because of the marriage, you know, Carl Rove said. Because of the marriage amendment and and he called out my predecessor Phil Burris, George Bush won reelection. And I don't I don't know if you guys should be thanking us for that. I don't know if we that we celebrate the George. But but no I wa but George Bush appointed Alito then and we got dubbed. So we'll we'll we'll take the W. both W's. but the it would be fun to go back and look at those ads and be like, okay, so what were we right on and what we're were we wrong on. but yeah, I I don't know, Katie. What what what do you think? speaker-0: I think about what was taking place in the oral arguments and what was populating the amicus briefs from our side. And it was disproportionately religious liberty focused. you know, I was one of the people that filed an amicus brief in that court case. I I was one of six kids with an LGBT parent that filed an amicus brief against gay marriage. And there was one brief on the other side that was talking about how these kids really need gay marriage. You know, it was from the people at the organization of collage, which is kind of like the the parenting organization of kids that have like LGBTQ parents. so there wasn't a whole lot of focus on the kids. There was one speaker-1: Do you think that's right on the legal arguments? On the amendment side I think it was a little different, but that's certainly trug legal argument. speaker-0: Yeah. Yeah. I'm just thinking about like that big national conversation was very much focused on adults. And that they did have talking points ready if the kids came up, right? Like, well, isn't this the way we need all the people we can that are adopting kids from foster care? And they really did leverage that edge case of this child was not going to be adopted by anyone else, and now they have this stable home that are it where they're being raised by these two lesbians. That is an edge case, right? It is true that some same-sex couples are going to adopt children that a lot of other people don't want, but that's an aberration, both from the perspective of the availability of adoptive parents, but also it's not what gay couples want. Gay couples want biological kids, just like everybody else wants biological kids. So again, like in the case where they do have families, just like the guy that you met with, like, this is gay adoption, like we need gay adoption. That's actually not what gay couples want. They want to procure children through third parties. They want to purchase egg and sperm so they can have some kind of biological connection and rent out the womb of a woman that's economically disadvantaged if possible. By their own admission, two thirds will say that's actually our preferred pathway. If we don't have enough money, maybe we'll adopt. speaker-1: Well, the the other crazy thing about it too, Katie though, as well, is gay couples actually don't really want marriage. Right. Like we we I remember I pulled the numbers in Ohio and it was like there's two point three million married couples in Ohio and it's like thirteen thousand gay gay married couples. Like it's was it was such a power play from the very jump of all of this. But now because of IVF and and surrogacy and all this kind of stuff, the the damage has spread across ha has has been experienced by so many others. and like at the end of the day, I I I I I'm I've been saying, like, listen, if you're choosing sexual anarchy, right, if you're choosing sex with with the same, you know, same sex as you, like you don't choose sexual anarchy plus monogamy, right? Plus plus you know, like it It's such a the the to to the broader point, especially about children, the sad thing is the lies of that whole campaign and effort have been so exposed over the last decade. And now is the opportunity to start making the case on what's actually going on here. Katie, we're we're gonna have to have you back on because I love talking to you and it's fun mixing it up. and but for those who want to get involved with with you, where do they find you online right now, Katie? speaker-0: greaterthancampaign.com is where you can see about our massive national coalition of which CCV is a part. yeah, go check it out. Just, you know, I'll send you a newsletter once a month to keep you up on it, but take a look at all the people involved. I mean, it is all of conservatism speaking with one voice. We've got the Catholics and the Protestants. We've got we got some Jews. I got it all, baby. you know, we've got we've got people from The Blaze and the Daily Wire. Dr. Albert Mueller, Lila Rose, we've got Focus on the Family and the Colson Center and Family Research Council. I mean, like we have everybody and all of us are committed to saying this is not a vehicle of adult validation. This is actually an institution centered around the rights and well-being of children, and you can't have it. We are taking it back on their behalf. so go. Greater ThanCampaign dot com and get on there. You can also go to thembefore us.com and just get our regular newsletter and I will arm you to the teeth to fight for kids. speaker-1: that's awesome. Katie, appreciate what you're doing. and looking forward to having you back next time on the narrative. Hey everybody, Mike Andrews joining you real quickly to say if you enjoyed hearing from Katie Faust on today's episode, you've got a chance to hear her live in downtown Columbus at CCV's annual Essential Summit on Friday, October twenty-third. You don't want to miss this opportunity. She'll be in a breakout session. She'll be on the main stage as part of a panel discussion. We've got great speakers, including Frank Turek, Rosaria Butterfield, Bishop Patrick Wooden, Matt Spaulding from Hillsdale College, and of course CCV President Aaron Bear. And if you act right now and get your tickets before the end of September, we will give you $50 off two tickets or more. Get your tickets today at Essentialsummit.org. All right, and welcome back to the narrative. Aaron Bear with my buddy Sam Say. Back with us one more time. I was gonna say, you know, last time Joe and Ryan were like, we can't bring this guy back on the podcast, but I fought for you, man. I was like, we need this guy here. You he really, really I know it was you know, rookie podcast first time, but I believe in Samuel Say. speaker-2: I love this D E I thing. speaker-1: That that's really what it was. That's exactly it except we well w actually the the thing is we we we fired a white man to bring you on here. We fired Mike Andrews on here. So I don't that you I guess it is kind of a good a good trade. but but Sam again grateful for you, brother, being on the pod with us. and I I was especially looking forward to talking to you. e and you even came dressed for the conversation today with your Brean Christian shirt shirt. speaker-2: It's funny. I promise it wasn't intentional because last last week I forgot to mention that I'm a teacher at Berry and Christian Academy. Yeah. And then my wife was like, You forgot to mention that. So this morning when she saw me wearing this, she's now you you're trying to make it up for that. I'm like, nah. speaker-1: It's good. Right. Your enrollment's going to explode now. I off of our four listeners on the podcast. But the, you know, the the there was a New York Times editorial this week. and we're not normally reading the New York Times around these parts, but this one kind of exploded everywhere. It was from Nicole Hannah Jones, who, you know, some of our more astute listeners might be aware of that name. she was the primary editor behind. The biggest piece of leftist propaganda that we've had over the last probably ten years, which is the the sixteen nineteen project. Which before we even get in the story, I mean, y you kind of blew up on the scene around all the BLM stuff early on. Yeah. Was did you dive into the whole sixteen nineteen project conversation? I've read it speaker-2: I read about it but I didn't focus a lot of my writing on that. But okay, definitely it was it was is it was a f fundamental to the whole critical race theory, anti racism, policies and stuff. So I did I did follow it, but I didn't follow it as much as most people probably did. speaker-1: And the the basis of the whole 1619 project, for those of you who don't remember, was that you know the idea is that 1619 was the true founding of America, not 1776, because that was when the first chattel slavery ship arrived in America was in 1619. Yeah. which we'll save that whole conversation for another time. But the the race baiters at the New York Times and Nicole Hannah Jones are still at it. Yeah. but actually this was one of the more like depressing or just tragic editorials I've read in the New York Times in so long. And and it was it's especially infuriating because here you have NK NHJ Nicole Anna Jones not really learning the lesson. She's sort of living the fallout of her worldview. but she doesn't even come to the right conclusion from it. And the the title of it, I want to make sure I get this right. The title of her Op-ed was in fighting for every black child did I betray my own. and and basically the she tells the story of how her and her husband, you know, sort of upper middle class New Yorkers, wanted to prove a point and not send their daughter to a private school, but instead chose to send them to send her daughter to one of the New York public schools, which Are up there with some of the worst performing public schools in the nation. And her whole thing was like, we're not gonna racially segregate, we're gonna be the change, we're gonna send our daughter to these schools. And now that her daughter is a teenager, she's realizing that her decision set her daughter back academically years. Yes. and she's coping one with the failures of herself as a as a mother in making this decision. Her daughter is upset with her at this. I mean, her daughter just When you read her daughter's comments, it just breaks your heart. Yeah. but her her conclusions she reaches, she still still doesn't even get the point. Yes. of what actually happened in the story. But when you read this, especially as an educator, yeah. What jumped out to you on this one? speaker-2: There are so many thoughts on it's speaker-1: Yeah. speaker-2: hard to even articulate first. She is a true believer. Yeah. You you see that because we know them in the BLM, one of the, I think it's Patrice Colors, the founder of BLM. She moved into an all-white neighborhood and several homes and is enjoying life, enjoying white privilege, right? Right. But her, she decided to put not herself, but her daughter. Yeah. In an environment where a lot of these students are coming from, you know, like and A a n a community just filled with gangs and all this and and the school's obviously just, as you said, one of the worst in America. So you know that she, you know, and she because she wanted her daughter to experience an all-black school and wanted to prove that, you know, to help all the all the other students. So she's a true believer in that in that sense. And you're reading, and I'm hoping, even though I suspect she's not gonna change her mind, as I'm reading the article, I'm hoping that at the end there will be A true self-reflection. It truly. Right. And then instead she still blames the same thing she's been blaming the entire time. speaker-1: racism, blames us for underfunding public schools, all this thing. speaker-2: Exactly. Yeah. And as an educator, you know, it's fascinating 'cause one of the very first things that I noticed when I started teaching in Marion, Ohio, which is a very rural area. My students are, except for one, all white. And the funny thing is the things she's describing in at the school that her daughter or the schools that she's been she's been going to, it's in terms of just a poor education. It's identical. This is not a race issue. This is an issue that is unfortunately all too common in public schools across America. Yeah. But by prioritizing the issue of race, he's missing the real point here. And it's not even, I would say it's not even really about wealth either. Now, I think wealth plays a role into this, but you know, maybe we can can get into this later. But I think the poverty element is dealing with a cultural issue. and not so much the very basis of why these schools are struggling. And I've seen that in Marion, you know, teaching at Baryan Christian Academy. And this is not maybe the most important thing, but one thing that really annoyed me about the article is this constant talk about segregation. speaker-1: Yes. That's the first out of this first thing I wrote to. speaker-2: Go. Okay. These schools are not segregated. No. They're I'm so like it it every every time I hear the i i I can't I can barely articulate because I'm so I get so annoyed. Sunday morning, they say Sunday morning is the most segregated hour in America because of they say that churches are segregated. No, they are not. Segregation means intentional separation. This is not segregation at all. So in fact, she herself is the one that chose to send her black daughter speaker-1: Exactly. speaker-2: Exactly. So she didn't have to, she chose that's not segregation at all. No. So I I as I'm reading this, I'm like, man, you're you while she she says that the schools are segregated, while she still talks about what happened with civil rights, right, with desegregation. So which one is it? Was there integration or was there not? Yeah. There are issues leading to why you have schools the way they are, whether they're all black and things like that, but it's not because the government is making this happen. Right. You yourself chose to have your daughter go to this school because you thought that was better than her going into a a so called all white school. speaker-1: And it's it's it's so obviously stupid what she's saying, right? Be and she compares, like she literally compared herself, and this is the self-aggrandized views that Nicole Hannah Jones has of herself. She compared what she was doing by sending her black daughter to the New York public schools to the black kids in the South in Brown v. Board of Education. Yeah. Right. When they were purposely Desegregating the schools by the because it was illegal for black kids. Like there were there were police that would stop you if you tried to go in there. And again, flashback to those black families at the time that were doing that. They were doing that because that white school had better educational resources. Exactly. And so they were like, I want my kid to have this. They were not doing what Hannah what Nicole Hannah-Jones was doing, which is to say, I've heard this school is terrible. But I'm gonna s I I'm going to choose to send my kid to this school. It's speaker-2: Yeah. speaker-1: so diluted, so self-aggrandized. I I I remember thinking this during all the BLM stuff of when when people would say America's just as racist as it was in the 1960s. Again, this was after we literally had a black president. Yeah. Like it is is to say like it's so demonstrably not. Why do you want it to be that way? If if it feels like Nicole Hannah Jones wants to cause it feels it's almost like if they don't have this grand struggle to fight, sh she doesn't think her life has meaning, apparently. speaker-2: That is such an important point that unfortunately critical race, the work ideology suggests that if you if you don't have the black struggle, you're not really black. I know that's really what she's trying to say. That my daughter, I don't want my daughter hearing accusations of her being white. Yeah. Her being called white. So there she can say, hey, I struggled. I I was in the ghetto. I struggled. I did all this. Right. All right. That's what it seems like that's she's she's not saying it outright. But it seems like that's what she's really getting at. And you know, you mentioned Obama. And this is one thing that I found I find it fascinating she didn't mention Obama's name at all. Yeah. In that I would blame Obama for a lot of the issues that's happened. I think it was in 2015, is when he signed the Every Student Succeeds Succeeds Act, which I think is better titled Every Student Suffers Act. Because you you it was around then all of a sudden you saw you saw a sharp, sharp rise. in all the issues that she's talking about, which is record level high graduation rates and yet record level proficiency rates in terms of at a much lower level. Yeah. And it's because through through that bill, through that law, it forces states well, I can't say it forces, but it really compels, it encourages states to increase graduation rates to keep their federal funding. And what happens is in the states I I mentioned this in an article that I wrote recently called I'm forgetting my own I think it's called raising a generation of ill of of illiterate graduates. Yeah. Where states are being compelled now to put pressure on school districts, who then also put pressure on teachers to say, hey, don't fail these students. Yeah, because we need to maintain our high graduation rates. And it's just been a massive problem for the last 10 years, it's getting worse and worse. So the point is, it's her anti-racist views of we just want to help, want to create an equitable. education system that's causing a lot of these problems. And yes, she's still advocating for it at the very end. Instead of realizing that all the money being poured into the schools, all these things aren't helping because there is a massive, massive issue with the very idea of again, anti racism or equity in education. speaker-1: Yeah, I mean w I'm gonna take us down a rabbit trail here for a second, Sam, because this reminds me of I I I had a post on on Sunday on X that just took off 'cause it was a video that Maurice Clarette, former Buckeye great, you know, he was the the running back for the Buckeyes in the O three or four national championship game, sometime in there. and he went to high school with me. he was a senior when I was a freshman. and it was a really great interview he did on Ryan Clark's podcast, a clip about how, you know, after, for those of you who don't know Maurice Claret's story, you know, is he was Mr. Football in Ohio. He won the so he was the top high school athlete athlete, mist foot football player in the state, got into OSU, was just sort of took college football by storm his freshman year. they won the national championship. And then he tried to jump to go pro. after that year, which at the time you had to you couldn't go pro until after your sophomore year. ultimately he he filed a lawsuit against the NFL. He lost his lawsuit. So he lost a year playing football. Tried to go pro the next year, but he'd basically been out of the game for so long had and didn't really have a good support system around him, made some bad choices, made got got picked up by the Broncos, never really played. And then eventually at 22, He was found with a bunch of guns and liquor in his car and all these things. He got sent to prison for seven years. he's out now. He's sort of reformed reformed his life. My understanding is he's a Christian, all these things. Great. And he did this interview with Ryan Clark where he talked about how when he got to prison, he realized he had seven years, his football career was done, so he might as well learn to read. And he so he really invested in reading and reading comprehension. Now he talked about how much he loved to read. Awesome, great redemptive story. The problem with it is what it means is that Warren G. Harding High School, the high school that I went to with him, gave a diploma to a kid who couldn't read. And Ohio State University accepted a kid who couldn't read. Two academic institutions. And why did they do that? Because he was great at football, right? Because he he and he genuinely was great. He might have been the best high school athlete I've ever seen. He was the best high school athlete I've ever seen. The reality is though, and this was my my post I I made online, is that Maurice's is one of countless stories, not just in Ohio, but all over the country, of primarily black stud athletes who are great, who at sports, who have no accountability whatsoever in their lives. Yes. And they get to just skate through school. Maybe they make it to high school. To to college football. Most of them don't. And then certainly even fewer of them actually make it to the NFL. but the minute these guys can stop scoring touchdowns, they are completely abandoned, right? And they don't have the base, and because they never had accountability when they were in high school or in college, they have none of the basic skills. And actually they were kind of groomed to think they could do whatever they want. And I will tell you, I know kid after kid who started, you know, we had a our our high school football team and when I was at Harding. Was one of the best in the country. We had like a 40 home game winning streak. We were division one. It was phenomenal. but I know multiple kids I went to high school with who either ended up in prison or dead by 25, who were stud stud athletes when they were in high school. and that's what this system grooms and that system to your point to the ob to to the Obama policy just poured gasoline on this, where we are giving diplomas to kids that mean nothing. Yes, that signify. Absolutely nothing. Th there's one other thing though on this Nicole Hannah Jones piece that I I really gotta hit. And that is you know, because her she she brings out along with the same old tropes about segregation, she brings out the whole old trope around these public schools are underfunded. This school that her kid goes to, that Hanna Nicole Hannah Jones' kids goes to in in New York gets over fifty thousand dollars per kid. Right. Staff there start at around a hundred thousand dollars in salary. This school is flush with cash. They have all the resources they could ever need. Meanwhile, schools like Brian, or you know, I always point to one of the other schools because CCV helped start Bereen Christian. And we, you know, our Christian education network started another school in Columbus, called West Side Christian. Their tuition is about sixty, two hundred dollars a year. and we teach kids to read there. Actually, The the closest public school, Burroughs Elementary, in in the city of Columbus gets about $26,000 per kid. about three years ago, they had a six percent passage rate on the third grade proficiency test. Wow. Our school at $6,200 per kid got had same kids, same poor kids, all of this kind of stuff, broken families dealing with poverty. We had a 75% passage rate on the third grade proficiency test. So why is that? Right. And I would tell you it's because form creates function. Yes. Yes. Right. We have to ask ourselves, what are the public schools built to produce? Right. We we put all of these policies, all of these structures in place. And what are they built to produce? Well, first and foremost, when you go to any teachers union conference, you go, you go to any of those places, the vast majority, maybe not, let's say at least half. You look at the agenda of the speaker speakers, all of the topics are around either DEI, so diversity, equity, inclusion, or SEL, social emotional learning. It's all about sort of self-actualized self-actualizing these individual kids, right? That that's what they emphasize. Right. I will tell you, it's a reason why you look in New York and 80% of those under the age of 30. voted for Zoran Mamdani, right? That these schools are built to produce kids who vote for Zoran Mam Dani. Yes. Or are dependent on Zoran Mam Dani's programs. Yes. The second thing is though, I I I remember I shared this on X a little bit ago, a a a a teachers union posted what their top five priorities were. And they were collective bargaining, public school funding, retirement security, affordable health care. And what they called accountability for publicly funded schools. And what they meant by that is they wanted to regulate and ultimately eliminate school choice programs. Yes. Right. That's their that's their the way they would put it, right? Anything that allows a kid to take a voucher or a scholarship to a a a private school, they want them to be basically put under the same thumb that the public schools are under. Now, notice how in the teachers union's priority Nothing about student success, nothing about literacy, nothing about anything in there is their priorities. What these schools are built to make is first and foremost a funding mechanism for adults. And it does that very well. Lots of adults get paid lots of money from the public education system in America. Not many kids, comparatively, are being educated. And this is the just the buzz saw that Nicole Hannah Jones has run into. speaker-2: It's hard to follow that. But speaker-1: No, I I it's speaker-2: it's it's it's very well stated. just going back to the article, there was one thing that I think I think I think her name is Naya, is the daughter's name, said that I think is to me basically the thesis of her entire article. Although I'm not sure that she still gets the point. Yeah. She said, This is what the this is what Nicole Hannah Jones is saying, quoting her daughter. For a moment, Naya said nothing. Then she told me, sometimes, I wish instead of always thinking about other kids, you would have thought about me. I never really got the education I wanted. Now, in the article in context, she seemed to be prioritizing that she should have been focusing on what her daughter wanted over what she wanted. But that's not what I am. thinking about when I hear that. It's not what what her daughter wanted. It's that she just didn't get a real education. Period. Period. No. Because her mother was not thinking really about her daughter's, to your point, was not thinking about her daughter's education. She was thinking about the pr like just the just thinking about the entire school system and how she could basically be affirming their ideology, the entire ideology of the of anti-racism, just that these students basically are oppressed. Yeah. And that if I can send my daughter there, I can make a point against what others are saying. Well people for example, what what what you and I are saying, she wants to make a point against what you know what we believe. Right. Instead, she finds out that well, her ideas really Aren't working in her daughter's case. But instead of really thinking that through and saying, well, wait a minute, this means that maybe my entire worldview is wrong. No, she just chooses to then blame people like you and me still as well. Even school choice. You blame school choice in your article as well, too. When, well, she loved the freedom of being able to put her daughter in a different school. speaker-1: And she actually the the last line of the of the story really captures that cause she's talking to somebody that says, when when she's sort of walked through what's going on with her daughter, she says, This is the reality of a segregated system. And it's not just segregation by race and class, it's by ability. This is the reality of school choice systems. Like Again, so think about a a few things what they're suggesting here on this, Sam. Like first off, she's suggesting already with these school systems, the answer to it is to just force all of these kids into this one system. Right. Think think about how dumb that is to say, hey, look, we see kids being educated over here well, and we see everybody suffering over here. So their answer is instead of how do we get these kids into a system like this. They're saying, how do we force all of these kids doing well into this garbage over here? Yes. That's insanity. Like that, that's that's but it's the only thing their worldview will allow them to do. They can't possibly acknowledge that the worldview is broken. Yeah. The the other aspect of it is it is so condescending to there are so many families. I I just know at at my kids' school, at at a a lot of the schools in the Christian education network that are serving. inner city kids, kids that were in the public school system. And then once they get into a better system, that's form is actually created so that kid is able to get an education, that the form is focused on educational outcomes, you see it working. speaker-2: Yes. speaker-1: Yeah. There there's almost something that it it it's again, once again, the racism of the left comes through where Nicole Hannah Jones is suggesting there's something fundamentally wrong with these kids over here. And i therefore we need to force everybody to be with them. It it makes it makes no sense whatsoever. speaker-2: There was another thing that her daughter said that I thought was very interesting. Her daughter didn't go into it. She didn't I don't think she specified what it what she was talking about, but I think I know what she's talking about. She said that at her new school, her all white school. That these students weren't smarter. They weren't necessarily I guess you should just say that they weren't smarter, however, in terms of just naturally. Yeah. But they just had more. And to me, from what I've noticed as an educator for the last couple of years now, is that I suspect what she is saying is what I saw reading the article that. Hannah Nicole Jones seems to be undermining her own good work in terms of how faithful she has been, not in putting her, not in putting her daughter in a bad school, but that she still was persistent. I thought it was very interesting. I think the reason why her daughter is succeeding now is because her mother was faithful. Not again in putting her in a bad school. Right, right, right. But Even with that bad choice, she still was active. Yeah. And the point I'm trying to make is I think the other students that are in this all white school, perhaps it's because their parents have been doing the same thing that Hannah Nicole Jones has been doing, but in this in a sense of placing the their their children or their their their you know daughters, sons just in good school. So she was late into doing that. But these parents, it's not because they're white. It's not because they're even wealthy. It's that they're just good parents. speaker-1: Well, Sam, you I will almost guarantee you, you know what the primary distinguishing factor I will I will almost guarantee one hundred percent between the two schools are. Which do the kids have a married mom and dad at home? It's exactly it. It it it's I the the the the the private school wherever she or the charter school wherever they're sending their kids to, I will guarantee has a Over 50%, probably over 80% of the kids have a married mother and father at home. whereas yep, exactly like Naya, like coming from that stable environment where the parents are making decisions together. So yeah, they they well, number one, the research would show if you're coming from a two-parent home, you have more resources to to spend, more money to to to spend on things. So that just makes sense first and foremost. and number two, married parents. Are more invested in the lives of their children. Yep. Because one, they can be, because they have two people carrying the financial load. But generally, too, when you have two people who created this one child, they're going to be more invested there. These are are just common sense things that again, the the the left, for all of their brokenheartedness about wanting to and and the, you know, their their justice talk and wanting to care for the oppressed, they don't reach to the most obvious answers. Yes. Right? Yes. I will. Again, at that public school, 80% or more of those kids are coming from a single parent home. Yes. Yes. Right. speaker-2: You're actually exactly right 'cause I checked it. It's exactly that. really? Yeah. speaker-1: Yeah. See, I mean that that's that's the reality of this conversation. And so we'd rather talk about 1960s tropes than what's actually going to fix these things. And the problem, too, is that public school is perpetuating to the next generation the same sexual ethic that got them into the mess in the first place. All right. We we we're gonna have plenty more time to unpack this. We gotta get on to the next topic though, because I I wanted to let you cook on this. And I know last time we we talked a little bit about this. Yeah. but this has been something that's that's raging online right now. And I do think this is one of those topics that you might not be feeling this conversation yet. but it's one of those topics that's sort of bubbling up within the church, especially within some of the conservative movement and and things like that. And again, I I don't wanna Whenever I see something like this pop up, I I I'll be honest, Sam, I struggle a little bit about like, okay, do I want to give this oxygen? Yeah. Right. Is this a fringe thing that's going on? and I think on this in particular, there are some influential voices that are starting to push some ideas that I think would be anti bib biblical. but I also think it is a good clarifying moment for us to talk about topics around what does it mean to be an American. how should Christians think about race? Yeah. And immigration and all that. So I I think the thing that set it off and w we mentioned this a little bit in the last episode. So a guy who's running statewide in Texas, this guy, Bo French, posted on X a photo of a bunch of Indian immigrate immigrant students at the Texas game. again, that's what I was most offended by was that they were voting for Texas. Yeah. but they were like just losing their minds cheering on Texas. and this, you know, politician posted a picture of them and said, you know, something along the lines of it's it's, you know, we're being taken over or something like that. And and saying this is the problem with allowing mass migration is all of these all these Indian students at a University of Texas game. It sparked a firestorm. but I I I will say I was disheartened by seeing some folks be like, well, he kind of has a point. We need to lean into that. So, you know, I know you're working on an article on this right now, but true to form, form equals function, you are slow to write. So So what were your thoughts when you saw this? speaker-2: Yeah. It reason why it's taking me so long to finish this article is I have so many thoughts on it. I'm trying to I try I try to keep, you know, write hopefully short articles and I'm struggling to be very substantial with my words here. It's because there are a lot of issues here. So the first thing is one, being an immigrant, it's something I'm fascinated by. But the thing is this, while I'm an immigrant, I've I think I said this last week, in that I I recognize that America, no, no foreigner has a right to America. You just don't. It's just not how it works, right? Immigration is a privilege, not a right. And I think mass immigration is a problem in terms of obviously if you're saying that it's that they're if a country or a nation is welcoming so many people into the country in a way that is harming that country, then that's a problem. Of and every country has a right to restrict. I think even There's nothing wrong with saying to a certain ex to certain point, if a country's really struggling and you even want to stop immigration for a period, that's completely okay as well, because again, it's not a right, it's privilege. What I find fascinating about this to me is as I study American history, as I'm preparing, you know, at some point to take, you know, become a citizen, I'm fascinated by this topic of what does it mean to be an American? And one of the things I've been reading Lately has been about nativism and how this is not really a new thing in American history. What I find fascinating is I saw a lot of I don't know if I want to mention names, but I saw a Polish American conservative really negotiating. speaker-1: Yeah, you gotta name the name now because speaker-2: I will say it. I will say it. There it is. I wanted to say it, but you know, I said I didn't I didn't want to create problems, but I wanted to say it. Let's go. Yeah. But He was very big on, you know, essentially Indian Americans can't be, you know, Indian, you know, immigrants can't be Americans and all this stuff. But well, that's fascinating, because the same thing was said about Polish Americans in the past. Yeah. But it seems like we've now because it wasn't just Polish Americans, it was Italian Americans, it was Irish well, Irish, Polish, Italians coming into America were seen as never being able to really embrace American culture. speaker-1: Thankfully the Jews have never really bat us. They n no one's ever no one's ever had a problem with Jews coming around. Yeah, keep going. speaker-2: Fascinating thing about this, I'm like, wait a minute, we've it's the same thing, but now it's well, if you're a white person, you can be an American. Whereas if you are you have a different skin color, then maybe you can't, which is weird because they're black Americans. I mean, I know some would say they're not truly Americans, but but but they're Americans. So it's it's it's fascinating to me because I'm like, well, then you're you're suggesting that that culture is inherently tied to race or to you know race, which is A not a not a real biological truth. I think there's genetics and it's ethnicities, but there's no such thing as race. So that concerns me. And you mentioned you you mentioned Jews. And one of the things I I'm fascinated by, you can correct me here, but it seems to me, you know, that well, before I get to what's happening now, the Bible does say that all Israel will be saved one day. It's a prophecy. And well, to me, it seems to me that From what I understand, half of the nation of Israel have a more they they they look more European than what Ashkenazi, yeah. Yeah, yeah. Yeah. So the the point I'm I'm making is this. Two thousand years ago, Jews looked mo more like most Middle Eastern people. Whereas now half of Jews look more again, just look more European. Are they less Jewish now than before? No, because the Bible says that. These people are still Jews. So then what does that mean about America then? So then if someone if if if if America becomes less white, which I'm not saying I want, I really don't do not really care. I mean I yeah, I it doesn't really matter to me. But if that does happen, d are they any less is is it will America be less American? It just doesn't make any sense to me from a historical point of view, from a cultural point of view. And then biblically, I just don't understand how Christians can embrace such a race-centric view of everything, which goes back to the woke people. I think in many ways, these people who and they're I don't think they're French. I think they're growing. I th I think they're still not mainstream at all, but they want that. And they're and I think there's some donors who really, really have influence who want that to happen. But it just disturbs me that we seem to be saying that the woke people have won. Yeah. That yes, we want a race-centric society, which the right will never win. No. There's no way. So to me, I'm like, this is bad theologically, socially, and every way, but politically, you're never going to win. Yeah. If you tell immigrants or people who are not white that Trump had historic, historic number of Hispanic and I think even Indian voters as well, black voters, and you said to these people, Years later, you know what, you're not really an American. What do you think is gonna happen? Take care. speaker-1: Yeah, where's that kinda t? speaker-2: Right. So there's so many levels to all this, but it it's just it just fascinates me that a lot of these people have just lost their minds. speaker-1: Well, and it's it's you know, the this comes back to the debate that comes up that I've been seeing more and more of is an Amer is America sort of a land and a people, or is America an idea? And I would say because I would say to some extent it's both. Yeah. it is it's obviously very specifically a land. Right. it it is a it's it's a country that deserves to have its own borders, its own protection, all of that. When they say is it a people, the the problem with their argument, what they're trying to say, and right, and this this tends to be from the more sort of race baiting right, the the the the folks you're responding to here, that when they say it's it's a land and people, right? Or they or they might use the phrase blood and soil, right? Which was you know, kind of a Nazi phrase, things like that. when they say it's a people, there's like an implication that there is a bloodline of people that sort of passes down, right? the sort of the same way like there's like there's Italians and you can see sort of the bloodline of Italians that that get gets passed down. To your point, that argument falls apart, especially with mass European migration in the late nineteenth century. There there is an art I I I do reject the idea that America is purely an idea. Yeah. Right. Yeah. because it it denies the miraculous na nature of our founding. Right. The the i there were a specific set of people, our founding fathers, Thomas Jefferson, Ben Franklin, you know, all all of these guys that were were really you know, Alexander Hamilton, Washington, these profound men. That came from a very specific theological and philosophical and religious to say theological and and religious tradition that produced this country, right? And that we have to acknowledge that that Western idea, ideals, right? Those that that those thoughts, those principles that built certainly Europe and then inspired. you know, the Puritans to come over to America. Like there is a very real set of ideas that built this country and created the framework to create the most prosperous and powerful country in world history, right? We we do have to acknowledge that there was something special about that. And sometimes when I hear folks say America's just an idea, the the reality is ideas can change. Right. And I actually think that's what the left wants to do is they're they're trying to take the ideas that founded America and and twist them and and break them apart. But no, the the the truth is is that America was founded by a tradition of individuals who took these grand ideas that took centuries and centuries in the making to found a great country. And again, alluding to a conversation we had last week, the The idea is anybody who comes and subscribes to the American Creed can be an American. That's the that and and goes through the legal processes and all that kind of stuff. Yeah. But but buys into this baseline, unity around this American creed, then that's those are the ideas that that bind us together as an American people that make this whole thing work. speaker-2: I completely agree with you. And I think I I'll I'll use an I'll just tell you something that I think is one of the things I've been thinking about that concerns me about this. Because there's one thing that makes America unique from most places. When I first met my wife, I saw her last name. I'm like, you're Dutch. She's like, No, I'm not. I'm American. I'm like, Huh? You're Dutch, man. Your last name is as Dutch. Now that's because in Canada, at least where I'm from in the Toronto area. Everyone is your Dutch you're Dutch Canadian, you're Ghanaian Canadian, as just even the people who've been there for generations. Now they're Canadian, they l they they're you know, they love Canada, but they still recognize their ancestry very firmly. And that's okay. But I realize that my my wife was not rejecting her ancestry or anything like that. She's just saying, I'm a like I'm Amer that's all I know is America. And That's something that I've been fascinated by. And I've noticed that with certain people too. I've met some Ukrainian, you know, Americans and I'm like, yeah, Ukrainian. Good. No, no, no. I'm American. Yeah. And that's not something that I I've I've seen across most Western nations. Because of I'm forgetting the term. hot. America is a hot was a I mean, I'm forget. Melting pot? Melting pot. That's it. That's it. That's it. And I think there is that sense that I think the people that race based on the right risk destroying by in their I think in their I think they have nefarious desires to. One of them came out today as a socialist, but as a whole issue. But but I think f I think in their in their zeal to protect American identity. I think there is some truth to that. Some people do want, you and and those are the concern about the anti-white stuff, which is legitimate, right? Yeah. Like I I hate that stuff. So I think in theirs in for some of them anyways, those who I think are not quite as nefarious in their zeal to protect American identity, they risk losing it, which is a very common tale. And that's something that I'm concerned about. That you then create this segregation of different people in this nation and illegal immigration. So legal immigrants, absolutely, you should address that, right? Fix that. But there are people who've been calling themselves Americans for Decades and centuries. And if you tell me that if if you say to them that they're not Americans, then what do you think is gonna happen? Right. You create division. Yeah. And it only hurts the country that you're trying to protect. speaker-1: Yeah, no, amen. Well, Sam, again, we can go on about this and the Nicole Hannah Jones article forever. But man, I love talking the unpacking this stuff with you, brother. I love how love how your mind works. and it's gonna be a lot fun continue to go down this path with you on the narrative. appreciate everyone listening in this week. Again, hey, if you are new to the podcast, please do subscribe on YouTube. Also go to Apple Podcasts or Spotify. give us that five-star review. I th I think we earned it this week. I think this was some really high quality hot takes. but be be sure to leave a review for us and we'll be back next time here on the air. speaker-2: Yeah.