Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Advanced Trial Tactics: Punitive Damages Business Torts, Part 2
Transcript
- 0:03Hello and welcome to Advanced Trial Tactics.
- 0:06How do you get those penalties part two and speaking
- 0:08today we have or this evening we have Lynn Fiorentina
- 0:12and Malcolm McNeil who are both partners at Aaron
- 0:14Fox. Malcolm is our beloved past president here
- 0:18at VHBA and has over 35 years of litigation and
- 0:21commercial experience in a wide variety of matters
- 0:24including business and commercial, construction
- 0:27defect, Employment disputes, administrative proceedings,
- 0:30trade secrets, probate, media, and entertainment,
- 0:33intellectual property, partnership distillations,
- 0:35and real estate. Malcolm has 25 years of experience
- 0:38resolving civil disputes as a mediator and is
- 0:41a paddled mediator for the United States District
- 0:43for its Central District of California. And in
- 0:46addition to his litigation experience, he has
- 0:48litigated a wide variety of businesses. business
- 0:50disputes including those for venture capital
- 0:53formation, retail, entertainment, textile, manufacturing,
- 0:56import, export, real estate investments, aviation,
- 0:59and publishing. He is keenly aware of the legal
- 1:02and business needs of his clients and provides
- 1:04strategic solutions to commercial disputes to
- 1:06help enable its clients businesses to keep moving
- 1:09forward. He also has experienced cross -border
- 1:12negotiations and has an established network of
- 1:14colleagues globally assisting foreign countries
- 1:17with needs arise. Malcolm's practice has included
- 1:19representations of clients in most forums, including
- 1:22administrative forums statewide and nationally.
- 1:25Known for his leadership and accomplishments,
- 1:27particularly for his clients with business interests
- 1:29in China, Malcolm is a panel member of the Shenzhen
- 1:33Court of International Arbitration, the Beijing
- 1:35International Arbitration Commission, and the
- 1:38Harbin Arbitration Commission. And Malcolm has
- 1:41also served as a co -leader of Aaron Fox's International
- 1:45Group, I'm sure I've missed several groups that
- 1:48Malcolm is involved with because it's very extensive.
- 1:51And Lynn is also a partner at Aaron Fox and her
- 1:55diversified practice allows her to function as
- 1:57a trusted advisor to companies and individuals
- 1:59across a broad array of industries and practice
- 2:02areas, including the consumer. product space,
- 2:05all forms of civil litigation with both class
- 2:08actions and Proposition 65 and white collar commercial
- 2:12litigation and government investigations. In
- 2:14the civil arena, Lynn defends cases involving
- 2:17alleged financial fraud, employment and wage
- 2:19hour violations, unfair competition on the business
- 2:21and professions Code 1700, and Prop 65 violations.
- 2:26Lynn also represents alcohol beverage suppliers
- 2:29and distributors and breaches of contract and
- 2:32business tort litigation. She has extensive experience
- 2:35in drafting pre -trial motions and setting up
- 2:38cases for trial. In the criminal area, Lynn represents
- 2:42clients in the defense of the Foreign Corrupt
- 2:44Practices Act, False Claims Act, Clean Water
- 2:46Act, and money laundering antitrust laws. She
- 2:49also defends students in Title VII university
- 2:51disciplinary matters with parallel criminal proceedings.
- 2:54Lynn has extensive experience defending business
- 2:57organizations, employees, and witnesses and representing
- 3:00victims in government investigations and criminal
- 3:02actions. Her broad experience also includes conducting
- 3:05internal investigations and white collar matters
- 3:08and governmental investigation and interfacing
- 3:10with state and federal prosecutors. Lynn has
- 3:13criminal trial experience in state and federal
- 3:15court. I am super impressed and I'm looking forward
- 3:18to part two. There's a lot of really good information
- 3:20here today. We're glad you could come. Thank
- 3:25you for that introduction, Hillary. That was
- 3:27fantastic. And yeah, I'm sure you left some things
- 3:30out and talking about my background, but I'll
- 3:32forgive you this time. No, that was very, very
- 3:35nice. This is part two of a program that we started
- 3:40earlier this year and we put it together because
- 3:43there was a growing. interest among practitioners
- 3:47on punitive damage issues because of a slate
- 3:50of cases that came down. The great news, by the
- 3:52way, besides hearing about our being partners
- 3:55in the same law firm, Lynn and I are very good
- 3:58friends. We've tried cases together. We've worked
- 4:01on cases together. And that's why we wanted to
- 4:03do this program together, because we watched
- 4:06how other practitioners deal with the issues
- 4:08of punitive damages during trial and in pretrial
- 4:11motions and motions in lemonade. And it was a
- 4:14great area for us to also research and we actually
- 4:16learned a little bit. I can tell you that as
- 4:19we prepared for the program. So what we're going
- 4:22to do today is we're going to do a brief overview
- 4:24of the first part of the program and we tried
- 4:27to break off the last part of the program to
- 4:30deal with the hypothetical situation so that
- 4:33we could give you some practical tips as to what
- 4:35other practitioners have done in the past. So
- 4:38as you can see this was today's agenda at that
- 4:40time. And we started with what constitutes malice,
- 4:44oppression, despicable conduct, and we established
- 4:49the basics. We brought all of you into a discussion
- 4:53over the Casey jury instructions 3943 and 3945.
- 4:58And let's move to the next slide real quick.
- 5:01and we talked about what malice is and how that
- 5:06works because it's an intentional action that
- 5:10you're trying to prove in court with a knowing
- 5:12disregard of the rights of others and you hope
- 5:15to find and elicit the facts during discovery
- 5:17that will support a finding of malice so that
- 5:20you can argue credibly to a jury or alternatively
- 5:24if you're on the defense side you want to be
- 5:25able to say there was a lack of malice you want
- 5:27to be able to say there was no malice here there
- 5:30may have been a mistake there may have been something
- 5:32that transpired, but there was no intent to cause
- 5:34injury. Injury may have occurred, but it was
- 5:37not something that my client wanted to have happen,
- 5:41nor did they do it in a willful disregard of
- 5:43the rights of another. And to the next slide,
- 5:47please. The same with oppression. because oppression
- 5:52is finding you the case where you want the jury
- 5:55to be outraged by the action you want the jury
- 5:58to find that it was despicable what occurred
- 6:01and that the plaintiff may have been subjected
- 6:03to cruel actions cruel in some cases a persistent
- 6:10group of actions that occur over a period of
- 6:12time all done in the knowing disregard of the
- 6:15plaintiff's rights next slide Despicable, we
- 6:23talked about despicable conduct is any conduct
- 6:26that is, these are important words folks, vile,
- 6:29base or contemptible that would be looked down
- 6:32on and despised by reasonable people. Now, I'll
- 6:35tell you where I've seen practitioners make mistakes
- 6:37on this is they'll throw everything into the
- 6:40discussion and say that that is vile, base or
- 6:43contemptible or despicable. Choose your facts
- 6:47wisely. Don't throw everything into the mix when
- 6:49you're arguing it because if you throw in Let's
- 6:53say less less offensive conduct and try and claim
- 6:56that it is despicable. At trial, you're going
- 6:59to lose the jury because they're going to say,
- 7:01well, that's really not despicable, so maybe
- 7:04that isn't and maybe that wasn't so bad. So choose
- 7:07your facts wisely. More is not better necessarily
- 7:11unless the conduct that you're complaining about
- 7:14and arguing to the jury is consistent and similar
- 7:17and has the same type of effect on a jury for
- 7:21a jury to find that is reprehensible. Next slide,
- 7:24please. Fraud. The fraud means that a defendant
- 7:30entity intentionally misrepresented or concealed
- 7:33a material fact. This is one of the easiest things
- 7:36to find by the way in a case because if you're
- 7:39conducting discovery as we do under our system
- 7:41as Exhaustive as it is you're gonna usually be
- 7:44able to find something that you can characterize
- 7:46as fraud Whether or not it is actually fraud
- 7:49You're gonna have to argue that fact and again
- 7:52I tell you to be cautious on the plaintiff side
- 7:54make sure that you don't find every I will refer
- 7:58to it as innocent misrepresentation or concealment
- 8:02as a fraud because if you do that, you may lose
- 8:05the jury because they're going to say, well,
- 8:08I can understand how that was a misstatement
- 8:11or that may have been a mischaracterization or
- 8:13whatever. Choose your facts wisely. Get a good
- 8:16fact of fraud, such as something right on point
- 8:20that shows it was concealed. And we'll talk about
- 8:22that in a little while when Lynn talks about
- 8:25the findings in the Monsanto case. And Malcolm,
- 8:29if I could just interject for just a second.
- 8:31This is great. Just a reminder for everybody
- 8:34with fraud, you have got to plead it specifically
- 8:38with specificity as to the who, the what, the
- 8:41when, the where, the dates, all of that. You
- 8:44know, if you're going to if you're going to base
- 8:45this on a fraud claim, you've got to have the
- 8:48particularity there or it's going to get thrown
- 8:50out potentially on demur. So just a reminder
- 8:53for everyone on that point. Lynn, absolutely
- 8:57true. I've seen cases thrown out where counsel
- 9:00have not elicit enough facts from their clients.
- 9:03Sometimes, and I've seen, I learned from an experienced
- 9:06practitioner a long time ago, he had his clients
- 9:10write out a statement and say write out a statement
- 9:13from beginning to end in your handwriting and
- 9:15I want five pages. five pages of getting the
- 9:19client to put down everything that they didn't
- 9:21necessarily provide in an oral interview with
- 9:24the lawyer because as Lynn said Sometimes those
- 9:27facts are elusive although if you end up sitting
- 9:30down and thinking about that You'll be able to
- 9:32allege the specificity the dates and names and
- 9:35who took down numbers, etc But but so do your
- 9:39homework ahead of time before you start crafting
- 9:40the complaint Okay next So punitive, then we
- 9:47went into a second phase, which was the punitive
- 9:49damages against the employer or principle for
- 9:52conduct of the employee. This is a next slide.
- 9:56You'll take a look and you'll see jury instruction.
- 10:003943 and in 3943 it says that the plaintiff must
- 10:04show by clear and convincing evidence that the
- 10:06employee, the agent or director or whomever of
- 10:09the company was acting on behalf of the entity
- 10:12which is typically the easiest thing to prove.
- 10:14The next one is that the entity knowingly employed
- 10:17an unfit employee or agent which is a little
- 10:19bit harder to prove because you're even if you
- 10:21get a personnel file and you and you succeed
- 10:24in doing so you may not find that they actually
- 10:26knowingly employed an unfit employee. So you
- 10:29need to dig for that information. You also need
- 10:32to show that the employer authorized the conduct,
- 10:35which is also another one that is challenging
- 10:37when you're trying to prove it. And finally,
- 10:41that the defendant entity knew of the employee's
- 10:44wrongful conduct, but they approved of that conduct
- 10:47in some manner. That can also be by after acquired
- 10:50facts. if an act occurs and they don't take any
- 10:54remedial action against that employee, that itself
- 10:57can be deemed to be approval of the conduct because
- 11:00they did nothing to remediate the situation.
- 11:04And the defendants, very easily on the bottom,
- 11:07the defendant can contest this with clear and
- 11:10convincing evidence that we didn't know what
- 11:13was going on with that employee. This was a one
- 11:15-off act. We thought he was OK. We thought she
- 11:18was going to do well. We thought that he was
- 11:20this. The employer is going to say that they
- 11:22did their appropriate pre -screening of the employee,
- 11:25had no idea, no prior complaints, et cetera.
- 11:28That's what the defendant's going to have to
- 11:30prove. Then we turn to the KC jury instruction
- 11:353945, our next one. And that is that punitive
- 11:40damages can only be awarded against A defendant
- 11:44entity, I'm sorry, but all of a sudden on my
- 11:47screen it popped up everybody's picture. Penal
- 11:51damages can only be awarded against a defendant
- 11:54entity only if the plaintiff can prove by clear
- 11:57and convincing evidence that one of the things
- 12:00we've already talked about exists, and that is
- 12:03that you need to show malice, oppression, or
- 12:06fraud. And by the way, the standard is clear
- 12:09and convincing evidence. the conduct was committed
- 12:13on behalf of the entity, et cetera. The defendants
- 12:16must show, again, in converse, that by clearing
- 12:20convincing evidence that the conduct was taken
- 12:22and was absolutely independent of the policies,
- 12:25the procedures, the manuals, whatever was in
- 12:27place in the employer's... instructions to its
- 12:32employees and whatever was on its website talking
- 12:35about its responsibilities to its customers or
- 12:38clients, etc. So the defendant needs to say,
- 12:41well, no, these are all of our policies. We had
- 12:43them out there and in our policies is violated
- 12:46all of them. So we did not in any way ratify,
- 12:49condone or prove the conduct. So then we get
- 12:53to a very important for this is what the next
- 12:56slide is. determining punitive damages under
- 13:01both of these. Now, this is the area that we're
- 13:04going to be focusing on a little bit. And this
- 13:06is right where we just about broke off the first
- 13:08time we all met. And that was that the plaintiff
- 13:12can use a variety of factors in order to show
- 13:15and enhance the nature of the actions and get
- 13:19a larger punitive damage award. Whether the conduct
- 13:24caused physical harm or not. We were having a
- 13:26discussion of this offline, and juries are obviously
- 13:30more likely to award if you're able to show the
- 13:34oppression, fraud, or malice. If there's physical
- 13:38harm, they will intend to enhance the punitive
- 13:41damage award more than they would in, for example,
- 13:44a financial loss. If there's a fraud, and the
- 13:47money has been stolen. So keep that in mind that
- 13:50physical harm has more emotional appeal to a
- 13:54jury because it can be argued in a financial
- 13:57situation that compensatory damages are enough.
- 14:03They may have lost $450 ,000 as a result of the
- 14:06defendant's stockbroker's conduct, but an award
- 14:10to award that plaintiff the $450 ,000 plus interest
- 14:14is an appropriate response. They will get their
- 14:16money back. Punitive damages are not appropriate.
- 14:19And that argument can resonate with some jurors.
- 14:23Whether the defendant disregarded the health
- 14:25or safety, you're going to see a little bit.
- 14:28I was just going to throw in a couple of examples.
- 14:34On the first point, the physical harm, just to
- 14:36give the audience a sense. of what we're getting
- 14:39at there. When you think back to the 1970s and
- 14:47the Pinto case, we talked about this case seriously
- 14:50injured and some cases killed. That's going to
- 14:53be a situation where likely you're going to get
- 14:56punitive damages, particularly if the company
- 14:59could have changed, say, the design of the product,
- 15:03but they decided not to because of cost. those
- 15:06types of facts are gonna be ones that are going
- 15:09to make the company or the defendant in that
- 15:12case vulnerable to punitive damages. So I just
- 15:14wanted to throw out an example there. Another
- 15:17one that I saw a lot early on in my practice
- 15:20in the asbestos litigation arena was punitive
- 15:24damages awarded in those cases where companies
- 15:29were alleged to have known of the hazard of asbestos
- 15:34back in the 70s, and yet they still used it in
- 15:37their products. And lo and behold, plaintiffs
- 15:42were getting cancers and mesothelioma some 20,
- 15:4530 years later. Those are the types of cases,
- 15:48I think, where that physical harm element really
- 15:52is illustrated. Not to empty mouth. No, that's
- 15:56fine. And I think the Pinto case is a great example
- 15:59because I think that the, when you, if you go
- 16:01back and for those of you that may be too young
- 16:04to have remembered what happened with the Ford
- 16:06Pintos, the Ford, do some research, do a Google
- 16:10search on the Ford Pinto litigation. In that
- 16:13case, all five of these factors were met. The
- 16:16conduct caused physical harm. The Ford had disregarded
- 16:20the health or safety. The plaintiffs who bought
- 16:22the cars were not rich folks. It was an economic
- 16:25car. It was a car meant to be sold to a certain
- 16:29segment of the public. It involved a pattern
- 16:32or practice. They knew what was going on and
- 16:34continued to allow it to go on. And there was
- 16:37trickery or deceit because it was never disclosed
- 16:40either to the dealers or to the general public.
- 16:47So moving to factor two, did they know the risks?
- 16:54Maybe we should use the Pinto case, Lynn, and
- 16:58discuss it from that standpoint, that the defendant
- 17:00knew the risks and chose to proceed. They had
- 17:03proof that there was a problem with the car and
- 17:06that if it was rear -ended at a particular speed,
- 17:09a bolt would penetrate the gas tank and the car
- 17:12would explode. With that information at hand
- 17:14they elected to proceed forward. Anyway, they
- 17:17attempted to hide this Go ahead. Yeah, I was
- 17:20gonna say about them just giving another example
- 17:22in this context, right the companies that were
- 17:27Making these products back in the 70s and some
- 17:30of these were, you know products you can use,
- 17:32you know insulation things in your home or in
- 17:35a shipyard or whatever they knew based on studies
- 17:38that there were you know, human hazards to being
- 17:43exposed to these fibers, but they still included
- 17:46them in their products for a number of years
- 17:48after that, after having that knowledge. So again,
- 17:52new of the risks shows to proceed. So just to
- 17:54give another example there. Sure. No, perfect.
- 17:57And that's going to be a good segue into your
- 17:59segment here, Lynn, because the third element
- 18:01here says the plaintiff should seek evidence
- 18:04where the defendant did not adequately disclose
- 18:06contributions in an effort to shape scientific
- 18:10inquiry. And that leads us into the next slide.
- 18:14which is showing us a hypothetical, which is
- 18:17where we wanted to begin today's new information.
- 18:21And the facts of this case are on this slide.
- 18:24And I'm going to turn it over to you at that
- 18:26point, Lynn. It's all yours. Great. Thank you,
- 18:28Malcolm. That was terrific. And I think it gave
- 18:31everybody kind of a reminder of what we're talking
- 18:35about here from fact, you know, fraud, malice,
- 18:38oppression to now getting into, you know, how
- 18:41do we, how do we prove or defend against these
- 18:44claims? So our first hypothetical here, and this
- 18:47is a case that some of you are probably going
- 18:49to remember because it's these cases, it's actually
- 18:53several cases, but the one we're talking about
- 18:55here was not all that long ago. And here's really
- 19:00the key fact. So in 1974, Monsanto, which is
- 19:04the company that makes the weed color reed killer,
- 19:07excuse me, Roundup, which if you're old enough
- 19:12to remember it, I remember my dad using it in
- 19:14the yard on the weekends to kill weeds. I remember
- 19:16it very well. That company received approval
- 19:19from the EPA to sell glycephate -based herbicides
- 19:23based on invalid studies examining the cancerous
- 19:27effects of glyphosate on animals. Glyphosate
- 19:31is obviously a chemical. It over time has been
- 19:35shown to cause cancer in animals and I believe
- 19:39later in humans and has been a source of controversy
- 19:42because of that. Despite the EPA's findings that
- 19:46the study was fraudulent, Monsanto did not remove
- 19:49the product from the market. In 1983, a new study
- 19:54showed that mice exposed to glycophage were more
- 19:58likely to develop kidney tumors. You see this
- 20:01a lot too with these types of cases, right? Where
- 20:03there's animal studies done linking a chemical
- 20:08or chemicals to a disease, often it's cancer,
- 20:13lymphoma, something like that. And despite knowing
- 20:16that those studies exist, the company's still
- 20:19going to sell the product. In some cases, and
- 20:22I can remember this happening in the asbestos
- 20:24context, the companies would claim, well, those
- 20:26were just animal studies. They're not human studies,
- 20:28so it doesn't really matter. We'll see about
- 20:31that. But getting back to the fact pattern, upon
- 20:35showings that the EPA planned to classify glyphosate
- 20:39as a possible human carcinogen, Monsanto hired
- 20:42a pathologist to persuade the agency that the
- 20:46observed tumors are not related to glyphosate.
- 20:49The APA was not convinced by the pathologist
- 20:52and requested Monsanto to perform a new mouse
- 20:55study and worked with them to design the study
- 20:58to which Monsanto did not do. Then you jump ahead
- 21:02to the 1990s where Monsanto retained an expert
- 21:05in genotoxicity to review studies that roundup
- 21:09has genotoxic effects to which the expert concluded
- 21:13that glycephate is capable of producing genotoxicity.
- 21:18Monsanto sent their own studies to the expert.
- 21:21The expert recommended additional studies to
- 21:24resolve issues concerning the genotoxicity of
- 21:27glyphosate. Monsanto performed only some of the
- 21:32recommended studies. In internal emails regarding
- 21:36the genotoxicity expert, Monsanto toxicologist
- 21:40stated that they were seeking experts that could
- 21:43be influential supporters. and that their current
- 21:48expert was not it. So they were expert shopping.
- 21:51They were looking for an expert to say that glycephate
- 21:55was not carcinogenic. They, Monsanto, sent a
- 21:59backup supporter admitting that they were vulnerable
- 22:02in the genotoxicity area. And I think that's
- 22:06where the fact pattern on this one ends, although
- 22:09I'm going to give you a few more tidbits, the
- 22:12audience, just so you're aware. What was really
- 22:16interesting I think about this case is sort of
- 22:18the knowledge and the cover -up. You had a senior
- 22:23toxicologist at Monsanto in 2003 who wrote in
- 22:29an internal email that they could say that glycephate
- 22:33is not a carcinogen as they had not done necessary
- 22:36testing on the formulation to prove otherwise.
- 22:40Five years later in 2008, that same senior toxicologist
- 22:44was sent an email regarding a press release on
- 22:48a study showing that glyphosate could double
- 22:51the risk of developing lymphoma. Wow, right?
- 22:57In their response, they stated that they were
- 22:59aware of the results and that they knew it would
- 23:04only be a matter of time before the activists
- 23:06would pick it up. It's a pretty damning email
- 23:09piece of evidence. If you're Monsanto, you're
- 23:11the defendant in this case, you better be very
- 23:14concerned about that. And if you're the plaintiffs,
- 23:16in this case, this was a husband and wife plaintiff,
- 23:20patients who had developed lymphoma, allegedly
- 23:23from exposure to Roundup. You're gonna be very
- 23:26excited to have received this email, discovered
- 23:29it in discovery, because it's gonna show knowledge,
- 23:33it's gonna show a coverup. is going to show a
- 23:36disregard for the safety of other people. All
- 23:39the factors that Malcolm outlined on the last
- 23:42couple of slides, I mean, this this case is it.
- 23:45And just giving you a few more of the facts,
- 23:48the courts in 2001, the California Court of Appeal
- 23:54issued the decision and Pilli versus Monsanto
- 23:56Company, finding that there was a substantial
- 23:59evidence demonstrating that Monsanto disregarded
- 24:04the health and safety of others. I think it's
- 24:07clear from the facts that we went through, there
- 24:09were other facts as well that really were damning
- 24:12to them. Monsanto did not disclose contributions
- 24:18to published articles, finding no link between
- 24:21glassophate and cancer, they engaged in ghost
- 24:24writing, where they would write sections of articles
- 24:27that outside experts would just edit and sign
- 24:29their names to. And it was not until 2015 that
- 24:34glycophate and Roundup were fully considered
- 24:36a possible human carcinogen. So until that time,
- 24:39you know, we had the animal studies, we had the
- 24:42EPA coming out and saying, well, we think it
- 24:44may be, and we need to dive deeper into this.
- 24:49What's really fascinating about this case is
- 24:52that the husband and wife were each awarded $1
- 24:56billion. $2 billion in punitive damages. I mean,
- 25:06this damages and why and how they get awarded
- 25:08by juries. You can imagine the sympathy that
- 25:12these plaintiffs elicited, you know, a husband
- 25:14and wife who, you know, presumably use this product
- 25:18out in their yard, years and years, and they
- 25:21develop, they both develop this horrible disease.
- 25:25They were incidentally husband and wife were
- 25:28also each awarded significant compensatory damages.
- 25:32And so one of the things we'll talk about is,
- 25:34what is that magic number or ratio between the
- 25:39compensatory and the punitive? And the State
- 25:43Farm case that most of us, I think, studied in
- 25:45law school were familiar with, in that case,
- 25:48the United States Supreme Court held that a ratio
- 25:51of six to one. So six times the amount of compensatory
- 25:57would be the cap for punitives. In this case,
- 26:00the wife was awarded $56 million in compensatory
- 26:03damages and the husband $31 million. These are
- 26:06substantial numbers. And I think the facts just
- 26:09underscore, you know, again, why Monsanto was
- 26:13awarded punitive damages in this case, the knowledge,
- 26:16the cover -up, the deceit and trickery. I think,
- 26:19Malcolm, to your point with that slide, this
- 26:23case really has all those bells and whistles
- 26:25in it. So I'll stop there. Yeah, and it's just
- 26:29couple of comments everything is there I remember
- 26:33one commentator saying that there was a whole
- 26:36group of things that Monsanto did wrong because
- 26:39besides the sympathy that was elicited for these
- 26:42plaintiffs there was outrage against Monsanto
- 26:46not just not just the the plaintiffs who suffered
- 26:49the injuries as a result of this product but
- 26:53Monsanto's that compounded there the the factors
- 26:58that we've already talked about and they all
- 27:00came through and they all became a series that
- 27:03the the plaintiff's counsel was able to put together
- 27:06and put before the jury and one of the ones that
- 27:09in one of the commentaries they said that the
- 27:11the jury they argued to the jury that there was
- 27:14intentional ostrich behavior by Monsanto and
- 27:18it was not just ostrich not just passive ostrich
- 27:20behavior but intentional ostrich behavior and
- 27:23used an example of the fact that that yeah when
- 27:27you when you see that something bad is about
- 27:29to happen you intentionally avoid doing anything
- 27:31about it and that apparently was one of the strongest
- 27:34elements that Monsanto was able to or fell on,
- 27:40which caused those verdicts to occur. I was just
- 27:46going to say too, Malcolm, that the Pilead case
- 27:48is obviously not the only one, right? So there
- 27:51were a number of other lawsuits brought by different
- 27:54plaintiffs around the country against Monsanto
- 27:56that have also resulted in punitive damages along
- 28:00the same theories over time. And I do have to
- 28:04apologize because I realized I should have raised
- 28:06the question for the audience first. Is there
- 28:09sufficient evidence here to support an award
- 28:11of punitive damages? And it might be fun on the
- 28:14next time if we raise the question and let people
- 28:18write in in the Q &A to see what they think.
- 28:21So. Well, that's right. But this one would have
- 28:24been too easy for our esteemed colleagues, Lynn,
- 28:28because it's jam -packed with a lot of awful
- 28:32stuff. And I also recommend, for those of you
- 28:36that don't know, Bayer had purchased Monsanto
- 28:39at some point in time. And they vigorously started
- 28:43fighting some of this litigation. So for those
- 28:45of you that want to learn a little bit more about
- 28:47the history of this litigation, check it out
- 28:49online and you'll find a site that I think that
- 28:52Bayer, I believe it's Bayer that put it together,
- 28:55but they talk about the litigation and what they
- 28:57were doing in order to defend against the cases
- 28:59as time passed. So for those of you that are,
- 29:03that want to be nerds in the area and see what
- 29:06the defense is. Seems like a hard case to defend
- 29:09against, but it would be interesting to see what
- 29:11their theories and strategies were on that end
- 29:13of it, on the defense side. Well, exactly, exactly.
- 29:18So now turning to the next slide, and Lynn, if
- 29:23you want to pick this up. Yeah, let's go. Sure.
- 29:32Do we want to... Can we go to the next slide,
- 29:33please? Yeah, I think we should go to... This
- 29:39is one of my favorites of when we were preparing,
- 29:42I think. So what do you think? Okay. Is there
- 29:46a reasonable relationship between the amount
- 29:49of punitives and the plaintiff's harm? Well,
- 29:52Lynn just gave you in the Monsanto case the the
- 29:56actual or the compensatory damages and we I think
- 30:00we've already talked about it in the past and
- 30:01that is there has to be some rational relationship
- 30:04between the I won't say rational actually I should
- 30:07say relationship between the compensatory damages
- 30:10and the punitive damages awarded. So do you want
- 30:13to hit on that a little bit Lynn or would you
- 30:15like me to? Sure. I mean, I'll just reiterate
- 30:19that in the State Farm case, right, Supreme Court
- 30:21said six to one, you know, punitive damages could
- 30:25be as much as six times the compensatory. I've
- 30:29seen other cases with slightly different numbers.
- 30:32Malcolm, I don't know if you want to comment
- 30:34on that at all, but I always refer back to State
- 30:38Farm because I just feel like that's sort of
- 30:39the gold standard in this sort of area of capping
- 30:42and things like that. It is but it's funny I'm
- 30:46recently licensed in the state of Washington
- 30:48and I know that the state of Washington has been
- 30:50quite liberal in upholding Damage awards that
- 30:53are beyond the six and or even in the nine to
- 30:56one range Which is what we were hearing was the
- 30:59upper range in the Supreme Court case. So I think
- 31:03what we need to reiterate at this point for everyone's
- 31:06benefit is whether or not you're seeking a large
- 31:09punitive damage award in a case Focus on your
- 31:13compensatories. Do what you need to do to show
- 31:16that the compensatories are sizable, significant,
- 31:20that the plaintiffs are going to need whatever
- 31:23treatment or remedial help that they're going
- 31:26to need. They may need and all of the typical
- 31:28things that you would look for in a typical personal
- 31:32injury setting. And you would want to make sure
- 31:34because if that figure is larger, and you have
- 31:37grounds for punitive damages, then those grounds
- 31:40for punitive damages will be a factor in relation
- 31:43to the compensatories. So if the compensatories
- 31:47are not developed well enough at trial and the
- 31:50jury doesn't quite see it but is sympathetic
- 31:53and awards the plaintiffs a nominal sum of money
- 31:56or a more modest sum of money, but they're also
- 31:59award punitives on top of that, the punitives
- 32:02will be limited to some degree by the compensatory.
- 32:05So don't spend so much time focusing on your
- 32:08punitives that the compensatory side of your
- 32:11case suffers. And I think, too, this kind of
- 32:15goes back to a point we discussed in the earlier
- 32:19presentations that we've done for this series,
- 32:23for the advanced trial tactics on business tours,
- 32:25and that is really developing your facts in discovery
- 32:31as to the compensatory damages. If you're on
- 32:35the plaintiff's side, retaining those experts
- 32:37early, if it's an injury case, getting the medical
- 32:40records, getting the incident reports, all the
- 32:42things, the witnesses, everything that you need
- 32:45because you wanna be able to demonstrate as much
- 32:48as you can on the compensatory side and for as
- 32:51long of a period. So in other words, if you've
- 32:54got some, your client has some type of an injury
- 32:57that's very serious and they're gonna require
- 32:59treatment, for the rest of their life let's say.
- 33:02I mean that's going to be a much larger compensatory
- 33:06case which then folds over into your punitive
- 33:09case. So I think developing those facts early
- 33:12not waiting until you get to trial is going to
- 33:14be really critical when you're looking at these
- 33:18types of issues. Well that's a good lead into
- 33:21our next slide because the next one talks about
- 33:24in view of the defendant's financial Let's go
- 33:29to element 3. In view of the defendant's financial
- 33:38condition, what amount is necessary to punish
- 33:40and discourage future wrongful conduct? Plaintiffs
- 33:43should be prepared to argue this is not grossly
- 33:47excessive because look at how much money this
- 33:49defendant has if you award a hundred thousand
- 33:51dollars and the company is on the in the fortune
- 33:5450 it's not going to make a difference and you're
- 33:56not going to deter this conduct in the future
- 33:58and it's just not enough money and so as a consequence
- 34:02they you need to be able to show that and defendants
- 34:06have become uh i've watched how they've been
- 34:09defending against these is that when it goes
- 34:11to showing the actual value of the company, the
- 34:15question is what is the value of that particular
- 34:17company, not a group of companies. As you'll
- 34:20note, they try and slice and dice. and divide
- 34:23up the conduct and sales and activities of each
- 34:28of the companies into separate corporations so
- 34:31that it reduces the size of the company for purposes
- 34:34of the grossly excessive standard that the plaintiffs
- 34:37have to show. So they're going to say, oh, they
- 34:39have multi -billion dollars of assets. And it's,
- 34:42no, no, no, they don't, actually. This is the
- 34:47New Co. Marketing Corporation that is the defendant
- 34:50here, New Co. Marketing Corporation, it is not
- 34:53worth billions. It has a net worth of $9 million
- 34:55or whatever it may be to show that it should
- 35:00not be. And therefore, if you award a lot of
- 35:02money against them, you can put them out of business.
- 35:04it would be grossly excessive to put them out
- 35:07of business as a result of this lawsuit. So that's
- 35:11the give and take between the plaintiff and the
- 35:14defendant during the trial. That's a great point,
- 35:19Malcolm, because I can think of cases we've been
- 35:21involved in where maybe the plaintiff is going
- 35:24to argue, look, we should look at the financial
- 35:26condition of the parent and all the companies
- 35:29that fall within that parent, not just the one
- 35:32entity that was involved here, the new co, marketing
- 35:35co, as you said. So if you're the defendant,
- 35:37you're trying to limit the universe. And if you're
- 35:40the plaintiff, you're trying to enlarge it, right?
- 35:42I think one thing that's really important for
- 35:44this here is just to remember punitive damages,
- 35:48the point of them is to punish the defendant
- 35:52and to deter that conduct in the future. So in
- 35:54cases where you have repeated or patterns of
- 35:58conduct where the defendant has engaged in this
- 36:01conduct previously, that's a tough case for the
- 36:06defendant, right? And it's going to most likely
- 36:10result in a punitive damage reward that's not
- 36:13going to be pleasant. So it sort of underscores
- 36:17the fact that if you're representing a company
- 36:20and they have made a mistake and they've done
- 36:21something wrong, the remedial aspect is critical
- 36:25on the first go around and fixing it so that
- 36:28they don't have this sort of pattern and practice
- 36:31theory alleged against them later on, whatever
- 36:34the case may be. Exactly. And on the next slide,
- 36:38we talk a little bit about what the defendants
- 36:41need to do in order to limit damages. So go to
- 36:44the next slide. You'll see the defendants can
- 36:48limit the damages by showing that the plaintiff
- 36:51was fully compensated. That goes back to the
- 36:53comment that I made earlier in the stockbroker
- 36:55case where the stockbroker committed fraud and
- 36:58the defense argues, well, a compensatory award
- 37:00is going to be enough. They've been fully compensated
- 37:03if you give them that award. And that's a stronger
- 37:07argument in a financial punitive damage case
- 37:11than in a personal injury punitive damage case.
- 37:19The compensatory damages are not unusually small
- 37:22or hard to detect or difficult to measure. No,
- 37:25we know that that account, the stock brokerage
- 37:27account, went from 436 ,000 to zero. So that's
- 37:31a quantifiable number, and that's a sizable number,
- 37:34and that's a large number, and they should get
- 37:36that amount if you decide to award that, but
- 37:38they should not be given a bonus as a result
- 37:41of that. and also to say that it wasn't the stockbroker's
- 37:45idea, it was the stockbroker who may have been
- 37:47errant in his or her advice to the customer or
- 37:51client, but they didn't intend to cause that
- 37:53harm. Okay. And this is a one -shot deal. Nobody
- 37:56said that this happened to a group of investors
- 37:59or that it was a practice and policy and procedure
- 38:02of the company to churn all these accounts down
- 38:05to zero. No, it was not. So those are the kinds
- 38:08of things that can mitigate the impact of the
- 38:11conduct that may lead to punitive damages. Great
- 38:15point. And one thing I wanted to just, and it
- 38:18doesn't necessarily fit in here, but I wanted
- 38:21to just mention for the audience that you know,
- 38:23it is fairly common for judges to reduce both
- 38:28the punitive and the compensatory damages on
- 38:32appeal or at some later proceeding. We saw that
- 38:35even in the Monsanto case, the compensatory damages
- 38:38were reduced slightly. on appeal, not significantly,
- 38:43but they were reduced. And so it shows that the
- 38:46judges really do have significant discretion
- 38:49here. And if they believe that a plaintiff has
- 38:51been overly compensated, whether it's through
- 38:55the punitives or just the compensatory damages,
- 38:58that they can take that into account and reduce
- 39:00those awards at a later proceeding. Let's go
- 39:07on to the next slide. I think we've got another
- 39:11hypothetical here. And do apologize to the audience
- 39:15because it looks like we've got the wrong rubies
- 39:17on the left -hand side because we're still referring
- 39:19to Monsanto. So just ignore that. And I think
- 39:24it might be interesting on this one to just go
- 39:27through the facts and then have the audience
- 39:29vote whether there is sufficient evidence here
- 39:32to award. punitive damages. What do you think
- 39:36about that? I think so too. Let me give an intro
- 39:40and then I'll let you run through the facts.
- 39:42This is yet a different kind. We've talked about
- 39:45dangerous chemicals, we've talked about financial
- 39:47cases, etc. This one is a hospitalization policy.
- 39:52This is one of those, it's in the category like
- 39:55disability insurance policies. I've litigated
- 39:58those cases where the has denied disability benefits
- 40:04to, and I've been on the plaintiff's side of
- 40:05those, where they denied benefits because they
- 40:10believe that the insured was still able to work,
- 40:14it didn't meet the definitions of disability
- 40:15under the policies. And those cases are dangerous
- 40:19cases for the insurance companies to deny coverage
- 40:23on because if they do, there's typically an expert
- 40:26somewhere which will say that the plaintiff was
- 40:28limited in some fashion. Here you had an interesting
- 40:33case involving and someone who is already injured
- 40:37who is a sympathetic plaintiff. So this is sort
- 40:40of in the same lines because in the disability
- 40:42cases what I was able to show was the deteriorating
- 40:46financial condition on my client as a result
- 40:49of the continued failure to pay the disability
- 40:52benefits and that continued decline in my client's
- 40:56standard of living. And things change very dramatically.
- 40:59As a result of that, the insurance company ultimately
- 41:01settled on the courthouse steps. And this is
- 41:04similar to that in terms of the sympathetic plaintiff.
- 41:06So I'll leave it to you, Lynn. Interesting. Yeah,
- 41:09sure. That's a great intro to it. So in this
- 41:12particular case, Stonebridge, an insurance company,
- 41:16insured Nickerson under a policy that provided,
- 41:20and Nickerson is the patient here, under a policy
- 41:23that provided $350 a day in coverage for hospital
- 41:27confinement for covered injuries. 350 a day for
- 41:31confinement and intensive care, and 150 per visit
- 41:34to the emergency room. So as most of you probably
- 41:37know, insurance companies are very, very strict
- 41:40and persnickety about what's covered and what's
- 41:43not. Lynn, you're going to need to repeat it
- 41:55because you're breaking up a little bit. Apologies
- 42:04to the audience. Necessary treatment. Lynn, go
- 42:13back. Yeah, there you go. Because we lost some
- 42:16of your audio there. I apologize. No worries.
- 42:20I apologize. I'm going to just turn my video
- 42:22off there for just a second. See if that helps.
- 42:26Okay, so I'll repeat the last couple of facts.
- 42:30So the carrier had certain criteria that had
- 42:33to be met as to whether certain treatment would
- 42:36be considered covered under the policy as necessary
- 42:39treatment. And they had a specific definition
- 42:41of what constituted a hospital stay under the
- 42:43policy. So Mr. Nickerson is a vet. He served
- 42:48in the Marines. He was entitled to stays at the
- 42:53VA at no cost. and sadly he became paralyzed
- 42:57in 1997 from the chest down in an accident. And
- 43:02so about 10 years later he fell out of his wheelchair
- 43:05and he was treated at a VA hospital for injuries.
- 43:09He was first in the emergency room then in a
- 43:12spine. Lynn, why didn't you turn off your camera?
- 43:32Can we go to the next slide please? Yeah, Lynn,
- 43:34we didn't get any of that. You may want to turn
- 43:37off your camera. Okay, I'm going to turn off
- 43:39my camera and I do apologize to everybody. No
- 43:41worries, it happens. Okay, good old internet
- 43:45connectivity. So the patient here, Mr. Nickerson,
- 43:50he served in the Marines and he was entitled
- 43:53to stay in paralyzed in 1996. Can we go to the
- 44:21next slide, please? We're still having some problems,
- 44:25Lynn. It looks like we're still having difficulties.
- 44:28Malcolm, would you mind reading that portion
- 44:30of this? Maybe Lynn, if you want to sign out
- 44:32and sign back in and that might. Yes, I'll do
- 44:34that. I apologize. Yeah, and let me go. Yeah,
- 44:38because I think everybody's we've heard a couple
- 44:40of things and let me just go back. Yeah, he fell
- 44:43out of his wheelchair and as a consequence. The
- 44:47bottom line was that he needed a part for his
- 44:50wheelchair. He filed his insurance claim They
- 44:53want the Stonebridge it looks like took over
- 44:57a month to to respond and requested additional
- 44:59information Then they wanted a medical peer review
- 45:03everything everything that they were doing appeared
- 45:06to be something that they were doing for For
- 45:10delay because I think that's one of the facts
- 45:12that I always you always rely on in these types
- 45:15of cases so he protested and I and the question
- 45:21at the end of the day was I I think Lynn Lynn
- 45:25are you back with us now? Yes, we can so so the
- 45:32question is that it says there was no indication
- 45:35that you had any medical conditions that required
- 45:37inpatient acute care and was not consistent with
- 45:41professionally recognized standards of care.
- 45:45So I think that's where we want to put the poll
- 45:47to the audience, right Lynn? Yes. Okay. So is
- 45:51there sufficient evidence for punitive damages
- 45:54here? I think would be the question. Yeah. And
- 45:59the second question, once you get past that,
- 46:02if the answer is yes, the question is what measure,
- 46:05how outrageous is it? Or is it mildly outrageous
- 46:10or substantially outrageous? Let's keep an eye
- 46:14on the... And you're all entitled to put something
- 46:18in the chat. Or the Q &A, whichever. The Q &A,
- 46:25either. The Q &A is fine. The answer is yes,
- 46:52there are enough facts for punitive damages.
- 46:59Thank you, Lorraine, for participating. And another
- 47:10one of our viewers and listeners said, yes, I
- 47:13think he deserves punies, and I think the insurance
- 47:16company's behavior was substantially outrageous.
- 47:26good well i think that answers that all right
- 47:31should we should we go ahead and go to the next
- 47:34slide and look at some of the answers yes let's
- 47:38do it okay we you went through this slide i believe
- 47:41already right That he protested yet. Yes. All
- 47:44right. So factor one, did the conduct cause physical
- 47:50harm? Actually, the court found no. The court
- 47:54found that the evidence indicated that his injuries
- 47:57were solely economic. The injuries arose from
- 48:00a transaction, not a physical assault or trauma.
- 48:04Now, remember, as empathetic and sympathetic
- 48:07as this patient was, right? He was paraplegic.
- 48:11He had suffered prior injuries. He serves for
- 48:14our country. So an extremely sympathetic individual.
- 48:18And the court still found, no, this is purely
- 48:21economic and there's no physical harm here. He
- 48:26did claim he suffered emotional harm, which we'd
- 48:30expect in a case like this. And he relied on
- 48:33a case titled Roby versus the Kessin, claiming
- 48:37that when a defendant's conduct causes emotional
- 48:40and mental damage, it is treated as a physical
- 48:42harm. The court still rejected that. that notion.
- 48:47They were not convinced by his citation to Roby.
- 48:51And just to give you a little insight on Roby,
- 48:53in that case, the plaintiff developed agoraphobia,
- 48:57became suicidal, forwent medical treatment, so
- 49:02didn't get treated, and was described as completely
- 49:05disabled due to the emotional harm caused. Nickerson
- 49:10had only felt strong emotions, but did not suffer
- 49:13any physical effects, the court found the Court
- 49:15of Appeal. So that was the distinguishing factor
- 49:19there. So a little bit different, I think, than
- 49:22what the audience probably was honing in on.
- 49:25I think everybody's honing in on the insurance
- 49:26company's conduct, which is natural, right? And
- 49:31not the physical harm to the patient. Yeah, because
- 49:38he needed a part on his wheelchair. I think that
- 49:40was probably the pivotal fact for that conclusion.
- 49:44Right, right. And factor two. So did the defendant
- 49:56disregard the health and safety of others? in
- 50:00its conduct. Again, we're focusing on the carrier
- 50:03here, the insurance carrier. The court found
- 50:05that the carrier disregarded the health and safety
- 50:08of Nickerson and others. Interesting, right?
- 50:12And by making that finding, the court relied
- 50:14on certain evidence that the carrier did not
- 50:18provide his doctor's letter to the peer reviewer
- 50:21and refused to recognize the necessary 109 -day
- 50:25hospitalization. I think that was a pretty convincing
- 50:28powerful fact there, 109 days and they said 18
- 50:32days or something along those lines. The carrier
- 50:35declined coverage on a finding that the VA hospital
- 50:38was not the most economically and medically appropriate
- 50:41hospital for treatment, despite the claim handlers
- 50:46concessions. That's also interesting considering
- 50:50that this is a veteran that we're talking about
- 50:52here. But my internet is unstable again. Can
- 50:56you guys hear me? Okay, Malcolm? Yes, we can
- 50:58hear you I was just gonna comment on the claim
- 51:01handlers concessions Yeah, I would like I would
- 51:05like more information on that because it's sort
- 51:08of like the inch What were those handlers? What
- 51:11were they conceding and at what point in time
- 51:13in the claim and do keep in mind in many of these
- 51:16claims the delays by the insurance company in
- 51:19an effort to sort of have the plaintiff give
- 51:23up is a tactic that was employed very heavily
- 51:27at one point in time. Definitely. And then they
- 51:31also relied on evidence that the carrier required
- 51:36Mr. Nickerson's care to be acute despite explicitly
- 51:40stating this requirement in the insurance policy.
- 51:48Again, these are, you know, more sort of you
- 51:52know, look, there's a document that says this
- 51:54and yet they are doing something else. And then
- 51:57number four, they expected him to return home
- 52:00despite his doctor's conclusions. That's pretty
- 52:03significant for the doctor to be saying, look,
- 52:07this patient needs to stay here. It's necessary.
- 52:11He needs to heal whatever the medical opinion
- 52:14was. And yet the carrier went against that. I
- 52:17think that's, that's pretty, pretty significant.
- 52:21It is. And just focusing back on number three
- 52:25just a little bit, I mean, it delves into insurance
- 52:28law, but the bottom line is besides the normal
- 52:31language that we all know that contracts are
- 52:34going to be construed against a drafter, in the
- 52:37insurance context, they're going to be construed
- 52:41strictly against the drafter and in favor of
- 52:44the policyholder. That's the law. So if you want
- 52:47to claim a... term that is sort of implied into
- 52:49a policy, that implication will not fly in court.
- 52:54Yep. So factor three is did the defendant know
- 52:58the plaintiff was financially vulnerable and
- 53:02take advantage of that? Yes, absolutely. The
- 53:06court found that this patient was financially
- 53:10vulnerable. He was a disabled. veteran in our
- 53:13country, 58 -year -old paraplegic, living on
- 53:17a sole income of a military pension. So that
- 53:20factor, you know, pretty easy for Nickerson's
- 53:24counsel, I think, to prove in this setting. Might
- 53:27have been different, right? Not a veteran, not
- 53:30a paraplegic. If it was someone that maybe had
- 53:32some other kind of condition that didn't debilitate
- 53:35them to that level, you might have had a different
- 53:38outcome. Well, definitely in the disability context,
- 53:42you'll see if somebody has disability insurance
- 53:45through their employer and they have two other
- 53:47disability policies and they have a third one
- 53:51that is now where coverage is denied. but their
- 53:55standard of living doesn't change much because
- 53:57they have other disability insurance that helps
- 53:59them to pay the bills. They don't have to move
- 54:00out of their house. They stay the same. Everything
- 54:03is more or less stable, except for the fact that
- 54:05they don't have the additional money that comes
- 54:07from that last policy. At that point, it's going
- 54:11to be hard for the for the plaintiff to argue,
- 54:13they're going to have to argue some change of
- 54:15circumstances, some vulnerability, something
- 54:18as a result of the denial of the policy. Doesn't
- 54:20mean they won't be entitled to the benefit of
- 54:22the policy if the carrier wrongfully denies it,
- 54:25but what it does mean is that the emotional element
- 54:28and the financial vulnerability part of it has
- 54:30gone, which of course would shoot out a lot of
- 54:34the punitive exposure that the carrier might
- 54:36otherwise feel. Exactly. Malcolm and Lynn, I
- 54:40have a question. Maybe we could, we review these
- 54:42in because I know we have a time schedule tonight.
- 54:46For punitive, I know we had talked about in our
- 54:50prep about looking at what a jury will award
- 54:53and what resonates with the jury. Can we, I know
- 54:57because you've done such a great job of filling
- 54:59in all the other details that you took all my
- 55:01other questions, but. I was wondering, what do
- 55:04you look at for juries? I know people do jury
- 55:07studies and focus groups and all things. What
- 55:10do you think are some effective ways to gauge
- 55:13what would resonate? And a jury can relate to
- 55:16say, I'm mad, I want to order, I want to, yeah,
- 55:20punitives are okay here. I think that's wanted.
- 55:24I would start with the, there but for the grace
- 55:27of God go I. If you're able to humanize the uh,
- 55:33impact of a certain situation where the jury
- 55:37can identify and relate and say, wow, if that
- 55:42were me, I would really be hurt or I would be
- 55:46upset or I would be angered or it'd be depressed
- 55:49or any number of things would have happened to
- 55:51me. If I, if the, if counsel can present the
- 55:56plaintiff's story in such a way that you have
- 55:59the identification factor. I think a lot in the
- 56:03trial advocacy work that I've done, I've seen
- 56:06that that's where the jury says, yeah, that reminded
- 56:09me of what happened to my mom, sister, brother,
- 56:12or whomever, or to myself. And that's why it's
- 56:14covered pretty carefully in Vaudire, because
- 56:17you want to know a little bit about those jurors.
- 56:20And that's what I would consider to be the most
- 56:23dominant factor, is trying to get an identification
- 56:27factor between the plaintiff and the jurors.
- 56:31Lynn? I think that's probably the most critical
- 56:34factor. I mean, just going back to the Monsanto
- 56:36example for the moment, right? That's a product
- 56:39that the general public widely used. you know
- 56:43many years ago and maybe even up until recently
- 56:46and you know I can bet you that on that jury
- 56:49there were people that use that product or they
- 56:51knew people that used it and it gets the jurors
- 56:54thinking wow that could have happened to me that
- 56:56could have been that could have been my you know
- 56:59my husband that got the lymphoma that could have
- 57:01been my neighbor my my mom my dad whatever um
- 57:05so I think that is critically the most important
- 57:08factor I also think having the the plaintiff
- 57:11be a sympathetic, credible, likable, relatable
- 57:16person. I think that's going to be very important
- 57:20to get that connection with the jury as well.
- 57:24But I think also too, it's the lawyers, right?
- 57:27I mean, Malcolm and I have seen in trial where,
- 57:29you know, if the lawyers are able to connect
- 57:31with the jury in a way as they're making their
- 57:34arguments, doing their examinations, that goes
- 57:36a long way too. So it's all of those things sort
- 57:39of tied together. And there's also, I was going
- 57:43to talk about one of the stockbroker cases that
- 57:47I had handled early on. And that's another, there
- 57:50were statements that were being presented to
- 57:53the plaintiff as the account eventually brought
- 57:57itself to zero. And what we were able to show
- 58:01is that the statements that were provided by
- 58:04the stock brokerage were almost hieroglyphics.
- 58:07That my client was a the husband died took the
- 58:11life insurance proceeds put it into this into
- 58:15this account with this broker with of an unnamed
- 58:18house and They and that and it just kept churning
- 58:21down to zero. She had a high school education
- 58:24married for 25 years Read the statements asked
- 58:28questions a broker wouldn't answer them when
- 58:30I showed the statements to the jury I said, do
- 58:33you understand these? And can you read this?
- 58:37Can you decipher what's going on? And defense
- 58:41counsel was sort of caught in a position of trying
- 58:45to say, well, no, it is clear, isn't it? And
- 58:48once that happened, the jury sort of, I could
- 58:51watch the jury sort of move sideways and no,
- 58:53it's not clear to me. And so, because they were
- 58:56trying to make an argument that the plaintiff,
- 58:58my client, was... Contributorily negligent for
- 59:03not reading and asking questions as her account
- 59:06eventually devolved itself to zero and it was
- 59:08a very important moment So the jurors afterwards
- 59:11it said the same thing to me said yeah, I I couldn't
- 59:14read that I wouldn't understand it. So That's
- 59:17another another thing show to show that they
- 59:20would have been confused in the same way that
- 59:22my client was confused So I think those are Wow
- 59:29We're there. Right on the dot. We're at the apex
- 59:35of the zenith. We kind of addressed, I think,
- 59:42this one earlier, just quickly. If there's a
- 59:45pattern in practice of this improper conduct,
- 59:51if we call it, that's obviously going to be.
- 59:54much more detrimental to the defendant. And here
- 59:58in the example with our VA gentlemen, the court
- 1:00:03found that the carrier's necessary treatment
- 1:00:05definition and the policy, again, the strict
- 1:00:10language in these insurance policies that Malcolm
- 1:00:13has mentioned, that that was employed against
- 1:00:17other insurers to deny claims for hospitalization
- 1:00:20or emergency room visits. So in other words,
- 1:00:22The carrier had used the same tactic with other
- 1:00:26patients. Sorry, that wasn't necessary treatment.
- 1:00:29We're not going to cover it. And the court found
- 1:00:32that to be a problem. We have a final question,
- 1:00:36and let's see if we can answer it before we sign
- 1:00:38off. And this question is, what happened to Nickerson?
- 1:00:42What happened to Nickerson? I think the question
- 1:00:47is, if I'm not reading it incorrectly, is did
- 1:00:51he get any money? I'm not sure, actually. It's
- 1:01:00a great question because I'm not sure I know
- 1:01:02either because the threshold question that it
- 1:01:06was not an injury rules out, of course, pain
- 1:01:09and suffering. It doesn't seem like the emotional
- 1:01:13component was the court didn't see, even though
- 1:01:19there's an allegation of emotional distress that
- 1:01:22that wasn't really bought into. So all of these
- 1:01:25other factors played into it. But what did he
- 1:01:28end up getting as a result of that? I mean, the
- 1:01:32court definitely found that there was concealment
- 1:01:36designed to increase profits and it deprived
- 1:01:40Nickerson of his legal rights. We certainly can
- 1:01:44look it up and get back to you all to let you
- 1:01:48know if he actually received any monetary compensation
- 1:01:51or punitive damages. I just don't know. And if
- 1:01:55you apply that to what we've already been talking
- 1:01:58about, that he only had a little bit of damage
- 1:02:01as a result of the... But this was a hospitalization
- 1:02:05policy, Lynn. So even if there was a bolt needed
- 1:02:08on his chair, that wasn't probably covered under
- 1:02:10the policy. Probably not. So there may have been
- 1:02:14grounds, Lorraine, for punitive damages. But
- 1:02:18whether or not there was compensatory damages
- 1:02:21that you would apply the punitives against, it
- 1:02:24doesn't look like it. That's not our definitive
- 1:02:26position, but that's sort of a glib answer based
- 1:02:29on what we've all learned through these two sessions
- 1:02:31of the advanced trial tactics and punitive damages.
- 1:02:36Lynn, your thoughts? No, I agree with that. Now
- 1:02:40I'm curious to know, so I'm going to have to
- 1:02:41look it up as soon as we finish the meeting here.
- 1:02:44If there's a way we can get a word out to you
- 1:02:45all, we'll do that. But you can also look up
- 1:02:48the case. It's at 20 Cal Reporter, sorry, 209
- 1:02:52Cal Reporter, 703. So if you want to look that
- 1:02:58up and take a read about Mikey, an interesting
- 1:03:02evening exercise as well. I think we're at the
- 1:03:08end here. Are we, are we through the slides or?
- 1:03:12I think we are. That's it. Yeah. Oh, factor five.
- 1:03:18We'll just let you know that the court found
- 1:03:20that the carrier did act. There was trickery.
- 1:03:22Trickery and deceit. So. Well, because they played
- 1:03:25with the word necessary. Yeah. That's really
- 1:03:28what happened. Insurance companies have to be
- 1:03:31very careful when they talk about words like
- 1:03:33necessary, because it's in the eye of the beholder
- 1:03:37oftentimes. And so they better be very, very
- 1:03:40clear about what's necessary versus desirable.
- 1:03:45And that's where those cases turn on very often.
- 1:03:52So, Hilary? It's just a great job as usual. And
- 1:03:57unless you have anything else to add, and we'll
- 1:03:59be continuing our advanced trial tactics series.
- 1:04:02And if anyone in the audience or anyone else
- 1:04:05has any questions about or wants to see other
- 1:04:08topics to discuss about, please feel free to
- 1:04:10contact us. Malcolm and Lynn, thank you so much.
- 1:04:14Thank you for your assistance on all of these
- 1:04:17programs. Hillary, good job. Thank you. Have
- 1:04:21a great evening, everybody. Bye bye.