Latest / Once Upon a Time at the Oscars / Marty Supreme (2025) ft. Tim aka Chromdar
Transcript
- 0:00Good evening ladies and gentlemen and welcome
- 0:03to once upon a time at the Oscars Hello, everyone,
- 0:38and welcome to Once Upon a Time at the Oscars.
- 0:41The show that takes you through every Best Picture
- 0:42nominee from 1927 to today. I'm Kyle. And I'm
- 0:45Ryan. We are continuing coverage of the 2026
- 0:48Academy Award Best Picture nominees. We are.
- 0:51That's true. Yes. Thank you for the... Validation.
- 0:55Validation, that's what it is. I got you. Today
- 0:57we're talking about Josh Safdie. We're talking
- 1:00about Marty Supreme. And in effort to do that,
- 1:03we want to make sure that we brought in someone
- 1:05who is pretty well -versed in all things Safdie,
- 1:08Josh, or Benny otherwise. And we brought in my
- 1:11very close friend, actually my best friend, my
- 1:13brother, Tim. Tim, thanks for joining us, man.
- 1:15Oh, yeah. Thanks for having me on. Yeah, man.
- 1:17I'm excited you were able to join. When I first
- 1:19asked you about joining us for one of these movies,
- 1:23I think your two picks here, your first was,
- 1:26I think you said Martin Supreme, and your second
- 1:28pick was Begonia. And that was the day before
- 1:31we recorded Begonia, so I was like, Marty Supreme
- 1:33it is. Yeah, it was very good. I think it's probably
- 1:38a better movie for me to touch on because I guess
- 1:43I remember it more vividly than Begonia for some
- 1:46reason. I don't know why. The ending of Begonia,
- 1:49I certainly remember really vividly, but not
- 1:53everything leading up to it. Marty, I have a
- 1:55pretty solid memory of what happened. Yeah, well,
- 1:58we actually got to see that together in theaters
- 2:00when you were in town for the Christmas break,
- 2:03and we were able to see Marty Supreme in theaters,
- 2:04which rocked. But also, you've followed the Safdies
- 2:07pretty closely in terms of the projects they've
- 2:09done. We've talked about... Good Time. We talked
- 2:12about Uncut Gems. We saw that together, too.
- 2:15And then we actually, just before recording,
- 2:18we were talking about Benny Safdie's most recent
- 2:20entry, The Smashing Machine. So correct me if
- 2:22I'm wrong, that's all of their entries, right?
- 2:24No. They have a movie that Criterion put out
- 2:28that I own and I haven't watched yet called Daddy
- 2:31Long Leg. Oh, was that before Good Time? before
- 2:34um and i believe it stars i think josh safty's
- 2:38the main character but um i believe what's his
- 2:42face uh abel ferrara who's in marty um yeah i
- 2:46think this is that's the first film they worked
- 2:48on together wow man i did not realize that it
- 2:52went back that far and it's actually really interesting
- 2:53because benny safty is uh co -starring with robert
- 2:56pattinson on good time right Well, yep, yep.
- 2:59So they kind of switched up, which is interesting
- 3:01because Josh Safdie hasn't been in front of the
- 3:04camera for any of the movies that you've seen,
- 3:07right? Correct. Yeah, interesting. I wonder if
- 3:10he's any good. Well, that's interesting because
- 3:12Benny Safdie has done more of, you know, he's
- 3:15obviously directed The Smashing Machine, but
- 3:17then he mostly went on to do a lot of acting
- 3:19roles. You know, I saw him. He's in The New Odyssey
- 3:22with Chris Nolan. He was in Oppenheimer. He's
- 3:25a voice in the new Super Mario Galaxy movie,
- 3:28which is a thing. And he was also... Oh, are
- 3:33you there, God? It's me, Margaret. Oh. He's the
- 3:36dad with Rachel McAdams. Wow. I was just like,
- 3:39what is Benny Safdie doing on screen right now?
- 3:41He's good. The Curse, obviously, he was a very
- 3:44big part of that on TV with Emma Stone and, oh
- 3:47my gosh, Nathan Fielder. Wow. So the Safdies
- 3:50are all over the place. But I mean, Josh is a
- 3:52very big name this race because, I mean, Marty
- 3:56Supreme is a very big contender, right? Like,
- 3:59I think everyone's talking about Timothee Chalamet
- 4:01with this, but it can't be overlooked that this
- 4:04had nine nominations. Pretty hefty amount. So
- 4:06jumping right into it, Kyle, do you want to talk
- 4:09about those nominations? Yeah. The nine Oscars
- 4:11include Best Director for Josh. Safdie, lead
- 4:14actor for Timothee Chalamet. Original screenplay
- 4:17would go to Josh Safdie and his partner, Ronald
- 4:20Bronston, who also received, both of them received
- 4:24the editing nomination. Casting for Jennifer
- 4:27Venditti. Cinematography for Darius Kanji. Production
- 4:31design for both Jack Fisk and the set deck, Adam
- 4:34Willis. Costume design for Miyako Belize. And
- 4:38then best picture. For the producers, Eli Bush,
- 4:41Ronald Bronstein, Josh Safdie, Anthony Katagas,
- 4:45and Timothee Chalamet. And speaking of Timothee
- 4:48Chalamet, the cast rounds out with Timothee Chalamet,
- 4:51Odessa Azeon as Rachel Misler, Gwyneth Paltrow
- 4:55as Kay Stone, the Hollywood actress, Tyler Okonkwo,
- 4:58also known as Tyler the Creator, as Wally, that's
- 5:02the only name I found on here, Fran Drescher
- 5:04as Rebecca Mauser, and Kevin O 'Leary as Milton
- 5:08Rockwell. The setup for Marty Supreme, set in
- 5:121952, follows Timothee Chalamet's character,
- 5:15Marty Mauser, as a ping pong player. He wants
- 5:18to be the best in the world, won't stop at anything
- 5:20to get to that point. And the movie really is
- 5:23a sequence of his rise and fall. And whether
- 5:28that's by his hand or just by circumstance and
- 5:30everything he'll go to and the people that he'll
- 5:32put behind him and under the bus, so to speak,
- 5:36to get to where he wants. So, Tim, let's start
- 5:38with you. What did you think about Marty Supreme?
- 5:40I thought it was very good. I think it was a
- 5:43no -brainer for Best Picture nomination. And
- 5:47I think in terms of... You know, it was it was
- 5:50stressful in the way of their other films, which
- 5:52has kind of been like their thing. But I thought
- 5:54it kind of reined it in a bit and made it more
- 5:58palatable for for everybody. And then I think
- 6:02also made it more enjoyable because you're not
- 6:04like, you know, like you said, we saw Uncut Gems
- 6:06together and that was like extremely stressful.
- 6:08Yeah. And I didn't think Marty Supreme. I didn't
- 6:10feel like I was like incredibly stressed. It
- 6:13was more it's just easier to enjoy. And it's
- 6:16just a really, really well made film. Yeah, I
- 6:18agree with you. I also really enjoyed it. I feel
- 6:21like he, Josh Safdie did a thing where instead
- 6:25of uncut gems was more like, I think from the
- 6:2815 minute mark of uncut gems to the very last
- 6:31scene, it was just nonstop anxiety. And with
- 6:33Marty Supreme, I think there's more sequences
- 6:35that are like extremely anxiety inducing, but
- 6:38they're broken up. So it's not just a continuous.
- 6:40One of my favorite scenes in the movie, and it's
- 6:42in the first teaser trailer that they dropped.
- 6:45And I think that's kind of cuts the tension a
- 6:47lot is just after a scene where Marty and Wally
- 6:49have just completely tricked a bowling alley
- 6:53full of people and conned them into giving them
- 6:56more money. They have a scene where they're,
- 6:58I think they're dancing to, is it Fats Domino?
- 7:01um on the radio and they actually like waller
- 7:05that's waller thank you um so they're they're
- 7:07uh singing and they get out of the car and they're
- 7:11actually kind of like ghostwriting it a little
- 7:12bit but in 1952 and uh they're singing the trumpet
- 7:16part And it's just so infectious to see how much
- 7:19fun they're both having. So little scenes like
- 7:22that really cut that tension. And I feel like
- 7:24that was something that was missing in Uncut
- 7:25Gems. So I agree. I think this was much more
- 7:28palatable. I did really enjoy it. I would watch
- 7:31it before watching Uncut Gems again, just because
- 7:33I feel like that would put me in a bad mood.
- 7:35But I really enjoyed this. And it's just, you
- 7:37can't really talk about this movie without talking
- 7:39about Timothee Chalamet. But we will get there.
- 7:41Kyle, what did you think? So it's interesting
- 7:44because I've never seen Uncut Gems. this was
- 7:46my first safety movie period. Oh, cause you saw
- 7:49this before the smashing machine. Yes. So everybody
- 7:52that has rightfully so compared it to uncut gems
- 7:56and been like, you know, this was either easier
- 7:58to watch or it was matched with the level of
- 8:00chaos and stress from uncut gems. This is what
- 8:04I've got. I can't compare it to anything. And
- 8:06I think that the stress levels were very high
- 8:09because again, I have nothing to compare it to
- 8:11it. I enjoyed the movie. It's one of these weird
- 8:15movies where you're kind of following the villain
- 8:18in a way. Timothy's character, he's not a great
- 8:21dude. He's awful to everybody. Everything he
- 8:24does in the movie, everything he says in the
- 8:26movie is pretty despicable. So it's one of those
- 8:30where you have to kind of force yourself to love
- 8:33to hate this guy to find any kind of enjoyment
- 8:35in the film. And I think the way that the events
- 8:39were presented, it... did after a while start
- 8:42to feel like, here's this awful experience. Okay,
- 8:47we're through that. Now here's another one to
- 8:48pile on. And it almost felt just like sequence
- 8:51after sequence of, we're going to do this for
- 8:54the, almost like the shock value. So it was a
- 8:56little exhausting for me, but not just because
- 8:59of the stress, more of how it was presented to
- 9:02stress me out, if that makes sense. It does.
- 9:05You know, I'm thinking about... Not having the
- 9:08knowledge of uncut gems. under my belt when we
- 9:12saw marty supreme because not to spoil anything
- 9:16with uncut gems but when you watch when i watch
- 9:19a safty movie now i'm kind of like oh what's
- 9:22this this can't be good like this isn't gonna
- 9:24end well for whoever's involved here so when
- 9:26you watch uh marty get into these perilous situations
- 9:29it's never like oh he's gonna get out of it it's
- 9:32fine you're kind of waiting for like the the
- 9:34other shoe to drop so i was prepared for that.
- 9:38And, you know, I think Tim was too with everything,
- 9:40all the research, the prior movies he's seen
- 9:43of the Safdies. So I wonder if I would have felt
- 9:46the same way if this was the first entry for
- 9:47me walking into it. But I definitely think it's
- 9:50a hero story. I think, you know, you mentioned
- 9:53villain and he is an anti -hero in a sense, but
- 9:55at the same time, they introduced the real villains
- 9:59of the story, which are like, you know, the Kevin
- 10:01O 'Leary's and the Abel Ferrero's, like the people
- 10:04oppressing and holding down Marty from like keeping
- 10:06him. dream. So I did very much like it. I agree
- 10:10with you. You know, there's the first scene that
- 10:12I felt like I was just ready to kind of like
- 10:14crawl under my chair was the hotel bathroom or
- 10:18the hotel bathtub scene of that movie, of Marty
- 10:20Supreme. And that's when I was like, okay, this
- 10:24is what I kind of expected from a Josh Safdie
- 10:27picture. But it's also kind of strange that this
- 10:29is the first time that Timmy and Josh Safdie
- 10:31have worked together because it does seem like
- 10:33a really good pairing. Like Timmy is... going
- 10:36for it in this movie uh tim what were your what
- 10:39were your prior thoughts to timothy chalamet
- 10:40walking into marty supreme um i kind of think
- 10:44he's the goat currently um i think he's the man
- 10:47i think uh he's good in everything he's in which
- 10:51is funny because i remember seeing that movie
- 10:53it's called like hot summer night or something
- 10:55oh yeah i'm out and i was just like all right
- 10:59Like, I didn't think he was, like, remarkable.
- 11:01So I don't really know when the switch flipped,
- 11:02but, like, I just think when he's, I mean, I
- 11:05loved A Complete Unknown. I thought it was really
- 11:08well done. I thought his performance was just,
- 11:10like, he just, like, sunk into it. And then I
- 11:14think he did, you know, Dunes Great and then
- 11:17Marty Supreme. I think he just like acted his
- 11:19butt off. Yeah, I don't know. I think I think
- 11:22he's really good. And I think at this point,
- 11:24we can kind of trust him in anything. I 100 %
- 11:26agree with you. I think I've heard the term four
- 11:28quadrant actor a lot. When you talk about like
- 11:31people who can like really hold the Hollywood
- 11:33placement, and you want someone who can really
- 11:35do drama, but can also do kind of like, you know,
- 11:38an action, but can also do a comedy, but can
- 11:40also do like family. And with Timmy, like he's
- 11:44pulling out like complete unknown. He's pulling
- 11:46out Dune. He's pulling out Lady Bird, Little
- 11:49Women, doing great work there. And then the real
- 11:52moment that for me, not this movie alone, but
- 11:54just the fact that he did it, the moment where
- 11:56I was like, oh, this guy is a force to be reckoned
- 11:58with was when he did Wonka. Interesting. When
- 12:01he did Wonka and he did a Paul King movie, and
- 12:03I was like, he's doing good work, but it's for
- 12:06children and families. And he's singing, because
- 12:10this was before Complete Unknown. My guy is getting
- 12:13it. Like, you can do Dune, and you can do Complete
- 12:15Unknown, not at that time. You can do Lady Bird,
- 12:18and you can do Wonga. Like, you are all around,
- 12:21whatever you need to do, you're doing great at
- 12:23it. And it's worth pointing out that for Marty
- 12:25Supreme, he did the research. He spent years
- 12:27training to be a ping pong player, or table tennis.
- 12:31So, he's doing the work. You know, he was playing,
- 12:34infamously, guitar on set of Dune to prepare
- 12:37for Complete Unknown. You don't see a lot of
- 12:41people go into the lengths that he's going to.
- 12:43And I think this just kind of solidifies him
- 12:46a bit for me. That leads me to something we'll
- 12:48talk about a little bit later here about what
- 12:50I think his chances are. But Kyle, what do you
- 12:51think about his performance? It's not my favorite
- 12:53of his performances. I think he's great. So last
- 12:57year, infamously, during his Oscar run with A
- 13:01Complete Unknown, he had that. acceptance speech
- 13:04where he said, you know, I want to be one of
- 13:06the greats. I am one of the greats. I should
- 13:08be compared to Michael Jordan and all of these
- 13:11other like huge celebrities and athletes. And
- 13:15when he did that, I was like, yeah, this is cool
- 13:18because you should. You should be proud of your
- 13:20work, especially if you're performing at that
- 13:22level. However, the further we've gotten away
- 13:25from that, the more I'm kind of like, take it
- 13:28easy. Just calm down a little bit. You're going
- 13:31a little too hard. Do you mean in terms of like
- 13:33the press? Yes. Okay. And, you know, not even
- 13:36the press for the movie because I didn't see
- 13:37any of it. I didn't see the Zoom call, which
- 13:40I actually think is kind of interesting. He essentially
- 13:42made like a short film. Yeah. That was amazing.
- 13:46Yeah. It's really unique and creative. But I
- 13:49think everything else, like I've just all the
- 13:52little interviews and things where I've continued
- 13:54to hear him just double down on the, you know,
- 13:57I'm one of the greatest. I'm putting in the work.
- 13:59I deserve this. I think he's just going too hard,
- 14:02and that unfortunately is starting to bleed into
- 14:05his performances, I think, for me. I say that
- 14:08with this being the first thing I've seen since
- 14:10A Complete Unknown that he's worked on. I don't
- 14:13know. It's a great performance. I think it is
- 14:14one of those where it feels like 95 % improv,
- 14:19you know, where he's got a general idea of how
- 14:22the scenes are supposed to play out, and then
- 14:24he's just kind of running his mouth, which works
- 14:26well for this movie. So I think it's unfair for
- 14:29me to criticize it at all because it's so believable
- 14:32because of the level of improv that it feels.
- 14:35But I think his persona is starting to weigh
- 14:38on me a little bit. Well, Tim, you had mentioned
- 14:41previously when we were talking about his off
- 14:44-pot, when we were talking about his character
- 14:47work, that a lot of the press that he did for
- 14:49this was supposed to be in character of Marty.
- 14:51Is that right? Yes. So I felt very similar where...
- 14:56Just kind of like, oh, at the very beginning
- 14:58of it, the really press run for Marty, I was
- 15:01like, he's, like, being really cocky and kind
- 15:04of crazy and almost, like, borderline, like,
- 15:06maybe he's not doing so well. But, like, because
- 15:09it was just so over the top. But then you see
- 15:11the movie, and then he said in interviews, like,
- 15:14he's essentially, like, trying to be in character
- 15:16while, like, promoting it. And that's kind of
- 15:18the character, right? He's, like, overzealous.
- 15:20He's cocky. He's, like, a jerk. But it's really
- 15:22interesting because he's not, like. getting up
- 15:24on podcast stuff being like i'm from the 50s
- 15:27he's like you know he's doing it like he's taking
- 15:30that like the spirit i don't know if my cheese
- 15:32mode yeah exactly the spirit of it and like bring
- 15:35it into himself like who he is now so i think
- 15:38that's cool and he's also like brian was it you
- 15:41that watched some award show recently and said
- 15:44he like dropped all that yeah it was uh normal
- 15:48it was the critics choice awards uh he won and
- 15:52he he just kind of dropped it all together and
- 15:54was just like thanks i really appreciate it you
- 15:56know shout out to my love and then shout out
- 15:58kylie and that was it so he kind of dropped it
- 16:01there but up until that point it was 100 we were
- 16:03talking about wow and i wonder if that like him
- 16:06receiving that specific award is like there was
- 16:10no fanfare because he's like this isn't the one
- 16:12that i'm going for like i don't really care about
- 16:15this one i'm for the oscar the the face that
- 16:18he made when he received the critics choice award
- 16:20was kind of like all right cool the the term
- 16:23that i thought of immediately when he made that
- 16:25face was like uh game like time to play ball
- 16:28like that was him being called up essentially
- 16:30yeah like him being called up and now i need
- 16:32to hit the home run like with this whole run
- 16:34that i'm doing so uh I do think, we'll go ahead
- 16:38and jump into this, I do think that he's going
- 16:40to win. The only thing that I, and Kyle, I'm
- 16:44really excited to talk to you about this, I have
- 16:46been since I saw this movie, the only thing that
- 16:48I could see going against Timothee Chalamet is
- 16:50that you cannot deny his performance. This is
- 16:52an undeniable performance. He is so, so good
- 16:55in this movie. He says some things in this, and
- 16:57this is more the screenplay that we can talk
- 16:58about, that I don't really feel comfortable repeating
- 17:01on a podcast, but absolutely demolished me in
- 17:04theater. um i was just kind of like guffawed
- 17:07is the best thing i could think of and the entire
- 17:09theater that tim and i were in were just like
- 17:10what like you're just saying some heinous things
- 17:14but it was so to tim's point speaking to that
- 17:17spirit of like you know i i am a winner like
- 17:19sorry if it's controversial but like i'm a winner
- 17:21and i'm gonna do what it takes which makes sense
- 17:23with this press run but the thing that i'm really
- 17:26interested to hear you talk about kyle is that
- 17:28The Academy Awards don't always recognize the
- 17:30person who gave the best performance, right?
- 17:32There's a lot of retroactive awarding that can
- 17:35happen. And Timothy is currently running against,
- 17:40in my eyes, the two people, he's running against
- 17:43the king example of how we can be retroactive
- 17:46with our awards. Would you agree? Oh, you're
- 17:50talking about Leo? Yeah. Yeah, yeah. Yeah. 100%.
- 17:53Yeah, I was on set this past week and specifically
- 17:56I got into a conversation about the Revenant
- 17:59and Leo's win for that and how it's just like,
- 18:01this one? Really? And it is one of those things
- 18:05where it's like, oh, he's gone years without
- 18:07winning. Let's give it to him now. Do you feel
- 18:10that that's where Timothy is this year? I think
- 18:13that we have seen across the board with directors,
- 18:16actors, we've seen the Academy award people and
- 18:20be like, hey, sorry about not awarding you for
- 18:22this movie previously, but we got you this time.
- 18:24And it's not always like you deserved it for
- 18:26that. I think Leo deserved a win for Once Upon
- 18:29a Time in Hollywood. I think that he deserved
- 18:34it for Wolf of Wall Street. I think he's deserved
- 18:36it across the board. He didn't win for those.
- 18:38But then The Revenant comes along, not my favorite
- 18:40performance of his, and he wins for that. And
- 18:43it feels very repetitive of we're just going
- 18:46to give it to someone when we feel like they
- 18:48need it. Because Timothee Chalamet is also like
- 18:51he just turned 30, I think. Yeah, he's 30 now.
- 18:53He's 30 now. He has so much life ahead of him.
- 18:57And we're going to have like, you know, we probably
- 18:59haven't gotten the best performance out of him
- 19:01yet. Right. Like to come. So he's got Dune 3
- 19:04coming on. He's got a lot that he's working on.
- 19:06I have a feeling that the Academy could be like.
- 19:08all right, young buck, sit down. Leo's here.
- 19:11And he gave a great performance in one battle
- 19:13with another. We love one battle after another.
- 19:16We're going to award it all these things that
- 19:18it is going to get. So why wouldn't we give it
- 19:20to Leo? Right. That's the only thing that stands
- 19:22in the way to me. Love Ethan Hawke. I did like
- 19:26Wagner Moore's performance. We'll get to that
- 19:28in Secret Agent. And I also really liked Michael
- 19:31B. Jordan in Sinners, which we'll also get to.
- 19:33But to me, when you talk about the two best performances
- 19:35of the year, it really is Leo in one battle.
- 19:39Well, actor. Leo in one battle and Timmy in Marty
- 19:43Supreme. I think I like Timmy a bit more in it,
- 19:46to be honest. I think he's performing a bit more
- 19:49and he has more screen time than Leo does in
- 19:51one battle. Yeah. But we're not talking about
- 19:54who deserves it the most. We're talking about
- 19:55who the Academy is going to award it to. And
- 19:57to me, I think it's going to be a retroactive
- 19:59award to Leo. And that's the only thing standing
- 20:01in Timmy's way. What do you think, Tim? I don't
- 20:05know. I would be happy for it to go either way
- 20:08there. I just started rewatching One Battle because
- 20:11they put it on Max. And I think if you put the
- 20:16two movies together, I think Battle is better.
- 20:20And I think... leo is just playing a more interesting
- 20:24role for him like he hasn't really played anything
- 20:27quite like that it does kind of remind me of
- 20:29his character um in once upon a time the movie
- 20:33not the podcast and uh yeah i i don't know i
- 20:37think it's more like it's a little more out there
- 20:40it's like his first pta movie right um and i
- 20:44don't know i i think i i would say it's a 50
- 20:4750 between the two of them um because yeah i
- 20:50don't know uh yeah i i think i think probably
- 20:54i would put my money on leo um but i could see
- 20:57it going either way and i think either way is
- 20:59fair i don't I mean, imagine if you're a Timothee
- 21:02Chalamet and you lose to Leonardo DiCaprio. Or
- 21:05you're Leonardo DiCaprio and you lose to, like,
- 21:08the It guy right now, you know? Yeah. Yeah, there
- 21:11really isn't a lose -lose situation because you
- 21:14understand why you did, if you're either of them.
- 21:17I think it's a really interesting thing to look
- 21:19at who deserves it versus who you think the Academy
- 21:21is going to recognize. But I mean, we talked
- 21:24about his press tour. His press tour rubbed a
- 21:26lot of people the wrong way, and I think that's
- 21:27another reason why he dropped it at the Critics'
- 21:29Choice, is that a lot of people were like, hey
- 21:31man, this is going to be a bit much. He already
- 21:33didn't get a ton of great reception with his
- 21:35speech that you mentioned, Kyle, last year. Which
- 21:38I also liked. You know, I think it brought a
- 21:40lot of sports to it. Yeah. People don't like
- 21:42when people call their shot, right? And when
- 21:44people are like, I'm trying to be this thing.
- 21:47Like, that's... It's funny, I don't know how
- 21:49much y 'all have listened to about, like, interviews
- 21:50with, like, Josh Safdie, like, talking about
- 21:54the movie. But, I mean, in general, I was going
- 21:56to mention earlier we talked about he's pretty
- 21:59unlikable in this film. Like, Marty Supreme as
- 22:02a character is pretty, like, you know, nasty
- 22:04in a lot of ways. And I've listened to a lot
- 22:07of interviews with both the Safdies, and their
- 22:09other films always follow a protagonist that
- 22:12I think would be considered. You know, you could
- 22:15use those same words to describe them. And they
- 22:18like to say they're not anti -heroes. They're
- 22:21not villains. They're just people and they're
- 22:23flawed, but they love them, which I think is
- 22:25really interesting because. I have a friend who
- 22:30walked out of the movie and hit Marty Supreme
- 22:32and hit me up and was like, I hate that. I feel
- 22:35like there's a bunch of young kids in the theater,
- 22:37young boys, that are going to walk out and be
- 22:38like, there's my personality for the next few
- 22:42years. Yeah, I saw a lot of that where people...
- 22:45I feel like I'm on the side of TikTok where women
- 22:48talk about movies a lot. Stinky boy movies. Exactly,
- 22:52stinky boy movies. I saw a lot of people talk
- 22:56about like, this is going to be the new Fight
- 22:59Club or the new American Psycho, where it's just
- 23:02like these really unhinged, problematic male
- 23:05characters that young male adults cling to. And
- 23:08they're like, wow, look at everything he did
- 23:11and sacrificed to get to where he wanted to be.
- 23:13I want to be great like that. And it's like,
- 23:16yes, but also let's take it easy because he is
- 23:20so problematic in this movie. His character is
- 23:23problematic. And that's why I think it's interesting
- 23:25that they go on a limb to say, yeah, he's not
- 23:28an antihero, he's just a flawed individual. It's
- 23:31like, you can't be comprised of just flaws. Right.
- 23:35To be an antihero. And, you know, it's interesting
- 23:38because I think that... This has existed for
- 23:41a long time, right? Like Scorsese did Taxi Driver.
- 23:45So there's been flawed individuals that the wrong
- 23:49audience has been like, hey, that's my guy. Right.
- 23:51That the director's like, hey, you probably shouldn't
- 23:53have done that. The difference in Marty Supreme
- 23:54is that there really is a direction that Safdie
- 23:58chooses that... kind of redeems the character
- 24:01a little bit right like whereas those other movies
- 24:03they can say yeah nope this guy's flawed don't
- 24:06worry about it yeah they try to redeem their
- 24:08characters which i understand why you would try
- 24:10but then that makes that audience that is a little
- 24:12more you know hey this is my guy be like yeah
- 24:15see everything worked out really well not to
- 24:17spoil marty supreme but i do think they try to
- 24:19redeem that character a bit more than they did
- 24:21in their previous entries Or I should say Josh's
- 24:24previous entries. I need to watch the previous
- 24:26entries. Because if this was them redeeming that
- 24:28character, wow. Well, you'll see. You need to...
- 24:34like really uh prepare yourself for a good time
- 24:38but i think more because i recently just watched
- 24:41uncut gems too if marty supreme stressed you
- 24:44out that movie like is going to like hurt you
- 24:47it's so so so like it's marty supreme times like
- 24:51five yeah and it's just like coming at you i
- 24:54remember we saw it with with uh our dad yeah
- 24:57And we sat relatively close to the screen. And
- 25:02it was stressful. I remember he kept being like,
- 25:06oh, God. But correct me if I'm wrong. The characters
- 25:12in that movie, are they not criminals? Well,
- 25:16they are. See, that's the thing. The Safdies
- 25:18love to pick like, you know, flawed individuals
- 25:20within a, not underground, but an unappreciated,
- 25:23potentially criminal background. So they are
- 25:27criminals, but kind of like above the line criminals
- 25:30in terms of like, I'm a jewelry reseller and
- 25:33I make a lot of bets. Right. Yeah, I think that's
- 25:36what changes it for me too, is if you're showcasing
- 25:40criminals and criminal activities, I mean, that's
- 25:42why the gangster. genre is so beloved of course
- 25:44obviously you know i don't condone what they're
- 25:47doing in goodfellas but i'm like yeah i'm along
- 25:49for the ride this is really controversial of
- 25:51you to say i know i know but when you have just
- 25:54a regular guy who's like yeah i play ping pong
- 25:57but also i'm like the most detestable human being
- 26:01of all time that's when it's like oh this is
- 26:04this is really problematic because this is ping
- 26:07pong you know this isn't a big deal i don't know
- 26:10but um Yeah. I do really want to talk about,
- 26:15like, we spent a lot of time talking about Timothee
- 26:16Chalamet, which is, I think, the correct way
- 26:19to talk about Marty Supreme. Sure. Because this
- 26:21is his movie. But one thing I really want to
- 26:24talk about is, and I guess I want to let you
- 26:26go off a little bit here, Kyle. I want to talk
- 26:28about production design. Because I think that
- 26:31Marty Supreme, the other thing that it does very
- 26:33well. is it really does feel like it transports
- 26:36you to 1952. There's a reason why I understand
- 26:39that people don't feel like it was fully in 1952
- 26:42that I'd love to talk about. But I think the
- 26:44production design goes a long way here. I had
- 26:46read that they actually sprayed the streets and
- 26:50specifically the trash outside to make it look
- 26:53more like a wet, like lived in New York in 1952.
- 26:57But Jack Fisk, a huge name for the Academy, right?
- 27:01Yeah, yeah. He was nominated in the past for
- 27:04There Will Be Blood, The Revenant, and Killers
- 27:07of the Flower Moon. Along with the set deck,
- 27:10Adam Willis, he was also part of that Killers
- 27:12of the Flower Moon nomination. And those are
- 27:15movies with major production designs. Killers
- 27:19of the Flower Moon. I've never heard of any of
- 27:19that. Yeah, I know. They're kind of lesser known
- 27:22titles, but big, big production designs, especially
- 27:27in Killers of the Flower Moon with it being like
- 27:30a period piece. Yeah, you can't deny that this
- 27:32movie, I mean, it looks like New York in the
- 27:3450s. We're in New York, right? Yeah. Right now?
- 27:37No, no, no. In the movie. That'd be bad if I
- 27:39was like, it looks just like New York. It takes
- 27:41place in Chicago. I was like, there's a chicken
- 27:43outside. Yeah, no, it is for sure set in New
- 27:47York, 1952. No, it looks great. It looks like
- 27:50the streets, like you said, they sprayed the
- 27:52garbage with water so that it just looked gross
- 27:56and fresh, fresh trash. It looks... Stinky. We're
- 28:00back to stinky boy movies. I would give her that
- 28:04Marty Supreme is 1 ,000 % a stinky boy. Right,
- 28:07right, right. Yeah. Yeah, 1 ,000%. Especially
- 28:10because you're trying to take a bath and then
- 28:12the bath falls apart. You can't even get unstinky.
- 28:14That dog can't get a bath. He can't get a bath.
- 28:16Poor dog. No one's getting a bath in this. No.
- 28:19But no, 100 % I agree. Cool. Aside with Jack
- 28:24Fisk, he's married to Sissy Spacek. I did not
- 28:27know this. Fun little fact. They worked together
- 28:30on Eraserhead. And Jack Fist played the man in
- 28:35the moon, I think his character is called. And
- 28:38they both get a special thanks to both of them
- 28:41at the end of Eraserhead. Sissy Spacek did the
- 28:44clapboard. And I love that. I love imagining
- 28:48little Sissy Spacek just being like, I'll be
- 28:51in Cary soon. You know? The infamous word she
- 28:56always said. I'll be in Cary soon. She's famous.
- 28:59I think she said that in Bloodline, too. I'm
- 29:04so happy, and I should have known that you were
- 29:06going to call out Bloodline whenever we get on
- 29:07a podcast together. You and I really were like,
- 29:10we were the Bloodline hive. We were like telling
- 29:12everyone, you need to go watch Bloodline right
- 29:14now. I tell everybody, season one, season two,
- 29:17don't watch the other one. Yeah, that's fine.
- 29:19I do remember the biggest fight that Taylor and
- 29:22I ever got in was after we started Bloodline.
- 29:24We were just like both ready to just go to war
- 29:26after watching that. And we're like, all right,
- 29:28you're the person. Yeah, so I agree. Production
- 29:32design was pretty fantastic here. I think the
- 29:34original screenplay has a chance. I told you
- 29:38my controversial opinion that I think that when
- 29:40we talk about... Who's going to win Best Picture?
- 29:43I think it really is between One Battle and Sinners.
- 29:47And I do think that they're going to respectfully
- 29:49clean up on their, or respectively, I keep doing
- 29:52that, clean up on their own side of screenplay.
- 29:55One Battle being adapted of the Thomas Pynchon
- 29:58novel, and Sinners being original screenplay.
- 30:02So I don't think that Marty Supreme can compete
- 30:04in that. But I do want to call out that I think
- 30:06it is a good screenplay. I think that some of
- 30:08the detestable things that Marty is saying in
- 30:11this, do come from the screenplay. I think the
- 30:13interaction he has with the characters, it doesn't
- 30:15feel like, Kyle, we talked about Disraeli last
- 30:18year. It doesn't feel like a Disraeli movie and
- 30:20that he's trying to steamroll over everyone else.
- 30:23It really is. And that's why I think Timothy's
- 30:25doing such a great job in this. He is a powerhouse
- 30:28performer, but he is... He is bouncing off of
- 30:31the other actors in his scene. Specifically,
- 30:33I really like him with Tyler, the creator, Wally.
- 30:37I think their relationship in this, some of the
- 30:40most interesting moments in the movie for me.
- 30:42Yeah. Specifically, that last scene between the
- 30:44two of them where Marty is being pulled out by,
- 30:48is it Abel Ferreira, the dog owner? Uh -huh.
- 30:50Okay, so when Abel Ferrer is kind of pulling
- 30:52him out of the pool hall, and he sees Wally from
- 30:55across the room, and they kind of share like
- 30:57one last look at each other. And that's the last
- 31:00that we see of Tyler, the creator. That's why
- 31:01I say last. Loved that little, like, it seemed
- 31:04like a little heartbreak between the two of them.
- 31:06And I loved that aspect. So a screenplay, I do
- 31:10want to call it a little bit there. Costume design,
- 31:12when we talk about the 1950s, it makes sense.
- 31:14The period piece is going to come into play with
- 31:16talking about that. Fine, good. I think it served
- 31:20its purpose just as production design did. I
- 31:22mean, Marty Supreme is wearing like a tank top
- 31:25and, you know, an unbuttoned over shirt throughout
- 31:29most of it. I'd shout out his necklace, glasses,
- 31:33and mustache before anything else. Yeah, yeah.
- 31:37But like Gwyneth Paltrow's character, Kay Stone,
- 31:39the famous actress, you know, you have that aspect
- 31:41of it. I think you always have the excitement
- 31:44when you do a period piece of just, you know,
- 31:47let's make sure we're doing things either accurate
- 31:49or a fun interpretation of this time period.
- 31:52I think they went accurate with it. Probably
- 31:54not like the front runner for the costume award,
- 31:57but good job. You know, it looks good. Yeah.
- 32:00I mean, it's not bad by any means. I just think
- 32:01it's kind of like, you know, yeah, of course
- 32:03it's good. Right. Like nothing too stellar. You
- 32:07did talk in our previous episode of when we talked
- 32:10about casting. Yes. Casting is something that
- 32:14I think is interesting for Marty Supreme because
- 32:16I really do like just about everyone in this
- 32:18movie. Well, all the actors, I should say. Characters,
- 32:21it's hard to like some of them. But I do really
- 32:23like the actors all around. I think the casting
- 32:26here was very smart. Again, to bring in Tyler
- 32:29O 'Connor, Tyler, the creator, I thought he did
- 32:31a fantastic job. Kind of a controversial figure,
- 32:33Kevin O 'Leary in this movie. Yeah. I'm a big
- 32:37fan of whatever on earth he's doing in this.
- 32:40Can't say that translates off screen, but I think
- 32:42that he does a fantastic job of being that villain.
- 32:45He is mostly playing himself to a certain degree.
- 32:48He has some moments in this that I was just like
- 32:51hollering like a chimp in the theater, like just
- 32:54absolutely unreal. So he factors into that as
- 32:57well. Casting, I'm a big fan of. Yeah, yeah,
- 33:00for sure. It's one of those things where like
- 33:02he shows up on screen and I'm kind of like. I
- 33:04don't really love this guy, but he's doing exactly
- 33:07what he needs to be doing for this movie, so
- 33:08he's kind of the perfect choice for it, which
- 33:11you can almost say about Gwyneth Paltrow. I'm
- 33:14not the biggest Paltrow fan, but I think she
- 33:16serves her purpose. She was spot on. Surprisingly
- 33:19very good in this. She is a great actress, but
- 33:21you haven't seen that from her in a while, so
- 33:24I'm glad they got that out of her. Yes. Yeah,
- 33:27much better than Shakespeare in Love. Yes. I
- 33:32want to say on the casting front, I think that
- 33:34is one of that is like this movie's maybe like
- 33:37strongest point. Yeah. The I listened to some
- 33:41interview and they talked about Jennifer Vendetti,
- 33:44who did the has done the been the casting director
- 33:47for, I think, all of their the joint Safdie Brothers
- 33:50films. But it talked about Josh Safdie was like.
- 33:55We have to get people. We refuse to have anyone
- 33:58in this movie that doesn't have a 1950s face.
- 34:01Like if their face doesn't read like they would
- 34:04be someone seen in the 50s or like in a book
- 34:06somewhere, old photos, they cannot be in this.
- 34:10And they really stuck to that. And then Safdie
- 34:13also pulled some people in, you know, the monster
- 34:17Kevin Leary guy, because he's like, hey, this
- 34:20would be perfect for this role. The guy who's
- 34:23Marty Supreme's good friend, the heavyset guy,
- 34:25I forget his name. Oh, yeah, from the video.
- 34:29Yes, so that's where he found him from. I forget
- 34:33the name of that. Some Knicks video? I think
- 34:37it was a New York sports team. I think it's the
- 34:39Knicks. Yeah. And he said something absurd to
- 34:42the camera. And he just had this like, you know,
- 34:45really just chewed up the scenery of just like
- 34:47this one little clip and just, you know, presents
- 34:50himself in a really funny way. And he was like,
- 34:51that guy should be in this. And so I think he
- 34:54went about it in a really interesting way. And
- 34:56I think the movie really makes you feel present
- 34:59and like sucked into that time because they really
- 35:02did cast all these people. Look just like that's
- 35:06what you think of when you think of 50s, right?
- 35:08You're referring to him saying that someone had
- 35:11a resemblance to his father, correct? Yeah, that's
- 35:13a PG way of saying it. Kyle, I'm very excited
- 35:17to show you that video and tell you that afterwards.
- 35:20Yeah, no, I agree. I mean, you're right. It wasn't
- 35:22just finding, hey, Gwyneth Paltrow would be great
- 35:24for this. It really is looking beyond A -list
- 35:27actors and finding the people that would be fantastic
- 35:29for that role. I really like the character you're
- 35:32talking about. I think he's another great...
- 35:35that's something you didn't have an uncut gems.
- 35:36Someone who kind of brings the main character
- 35:39into reality a little bit, puts their feet back
- 35:41on ground is like saying like, Hey man, look,
- 35:44I want the best for you and I'm doing the best
- 35:46that I can for you. I need you to meet me halfway
- 35:48on this. And, of course, the unrelenting energy
- 35:51of the main character is that they never can.
- 35:52And they want to continue to soar while the other
- 35:54person's firmly planted on Earth. He does a great
- 35:58job in that movie. It's not just a funny little
- 36:00role for him from that video that Tim's talking
- 36:02about. It really is like he is performing. So
- 36:05the casting I couldn't be happier with on this.
- 36:07I think it does deserve the recognition here.
- 36:09I wouldn't be mad if it won. I just don't foresee
- 36:11that happening. What do you see winning over
- 36:13it? Did you say that already? Yeah, well, I think
- 36:15you're dead on about One Battle, Tim. I think
- 36:18you mentioned you would want to see maybe Leo
- 36:23win, but One Battle has a better movie overall.
- 36:25And I think that's because that Marty has Timothee
- 36:28Chalamet's performance, and that's really what
- 36:30I think carries that movie. Whereas One Battle
- 36:33is a series of performances that I think carry
- 36:35that overall. So I think One Battle has a real
- 36:37chance of taking that. But also, you can't overlook
- 36:40the cast. work in centers. I think those individuals,
- 36:45your Michael B. Jordan, Winnie Masako, uh, Delroy
- 36:48Lindo, Haley Steinfeld, Jack, uh, O 'Connell.
- 36:52Sure. Yeah, let's say that. I'm pretty sure that's
- 36:54correct. I thought the work they did was incredible
- 36:56as well. Like that's another one where you can't
- 36:58have that movie without the whole team. While
- 37:01I like the casting a lot in Marty Supreme, I
- 37:03do think that it's Timmy's movie and you could
- 37:05potentially put other people in those other roles
- 37:07and it's still pretty good. But that's not to
- 37:09speak badly of them. I think they're fantastic.
- 37:11They're just up against some powerhouse movies
- 37:13where, and this is what's really exciting, Kyle,
- 37:15to your point of what we talked about earlier.
- 37:17This is the first year where casting has been
- 37:19an award. So it's not even like, they made these
- 37:22movies being like, hey, we gotta, casting's gonna
- 37:23come up now, so it's gotta happen. It's really
- 37:25interesting that it comes in a year where there's
- 37:27movies, I would even kind of argue Hamnet is
- 37:30a pretty great cast as well. Yeah. There's great
- 37:32entries this year, more than I can imagine any
- 37:34other year. Yeah, well, I don't know if I would
- 37:36say more than any other year, but I think now,
- 37:38because we have this award, like, it's kind of
- 37:42forcing you to look at the cast as a whole, which
- 37:44is really exciting. One of the... Coolest things
- 37:47I think so far doing the research this year has
- 37:49been looking at the casting nominations and then
- 37:52diving into the people nominated, Jennifer Vendetti
- 37:56in this case, and just seeing what they've done
- 37:58in the past and being like, wow, so much work
- 38:02that should have been praised throughout the
- 38:04years that is just now getting recognition. Jennifer
- 38:07Vendetti might not be the best example here.
- 38:09She's fairly new. You mentioned previous Safdie
- 38:12movies she did. She also did the casting for
- 38:14Euphoria. Oh. Which is pretty cool. I didn't
- 38:17know that. She has a book that she released in
- 38:192022 as well that I would like to read. Can I
- 38:22ask you a question? The art and alchemy of casting.
- 38:26I mean, those are all pretty interesting things
- 38:28to kind of have under your cap to potentially
- 38:29take this first win. Yeah. I mean, this is one
- 38:33of those where I wonder, you could almost make
- 38:36the argument, like we were talking about Leo
- 38:38and the acting and everything, whose previous
- 38:41work has gone unrecognized because the award
- 38:43hasn't existed. I wonder if that'll play into
- 38:46it at all. Well, I think it was the Hamnet casting
- 38:49director that we were like, yeah, they did Star
- 38:51Wars. And it was either that or Nina Gold. Nina
- 38:55Gold. Yes. Yeah. Just I don't know. I don't know
- 38:58if that'll play into the awards at all or if
- 39:00it'll just be specifically this movie and what
- 39:03they did for this movie. Interesting. I hope
- 39:05so. Kyle, to your point and what was kind of
- 39:09mentioned earlier, too, about, you know, some
- 39:12people seem to get. Or, you know, they'll pick
- 39:15up an award and it kind of seems like it's for
- 39:17some things that they've done in the past, not
- 39:19just the movie. Really like their whole body
- 39:21of work. Y 'all should look up, if you haven't
- 39:23already, I just looked up while we were talking
- 39:25about it, the casting director of Sinners, Francine
- 39:28Meisler. She's been the casting director on over
- 39:33200 movies. And, like, it's, I mean, she did
- 39:37Ella McKay, so she should win for that. But she
- 39:41did most of True Detective. like it's it's honestly
- 39:45looking through this it's nuts uh the dune movies
- 39:49just just everything you can think of it's it's
- 39:52it's crazy so i feel like just like you said
- 39:54if vendetti's done great work but it's relatively
- 39:58new compared to some of the other people they're
- 39:59up against so if i'm her i'm looking at the lineup
- 40:02and being like I'm not getting this award. I'm
- 40:06going to have to really earn this over time.
- 40:09You know what I mean? I think that's really interesting
- 40:11because then if you apply that same logic to
- 40:13the other awards, then it kind of changes the
- 40:15landscape of expecting a Timothee Chalamet win.
- 40:17Right. Because you look at the longevity and
- 40:20that's what the Academy tends to do to your point,
- 40:22Tim. They tend to look at the career that you've
- 40:24had and like, hey, do you deserve basically a
- 40:26Lifetime Achievement Award behind this great
- 40:28performance that you gave this year? That tends
- 40:31to be where they look sometimes. more recently
- 40:34than before. But absolutely, I think that's a
- 40:37real possibility. Casting is really interesting.
- 40:39I think most people will look at casting and
- 40:41say, yeah, I like the cast of that movie. I think
- 40:43they all did a great job. That's not necessarily
- 40:45what they're looking for, right? They're talking
- 40:46about the actual art of casting these individuals.
- 40:50And did you choose the right people? So I think
- 40:53you're dead on. There's a real, like... I wouldn't
- 40:55say it's going to go to one person specifically.
- 40:57I would think that they may tend to use casting
- 41:00as above the line as a nomination, and that would
- 41:02go towards splitting the leads of the movies
- 41:06that are going to get the most. In my eyes, I
- 41:08could totally be wrong on that. That's just my
- 41:10projection. Before we hop off casting, I do want
- 41:13to make sure we talk about Odessa Azeon. I thought
- 41:16she was kind of a powerhouse in this. I think
- 41:19that someone who can match Timothee Chalamet's
- 41:22energy is difficult. Like someone who can kind
- 41:25of bring him down to earth, but also like meet
- 41:26him halfway. We talked a lot about other actors
- 41:29in this movie who can kind of like bring him
- 41:31down a little bit, even though Wally is helping
- 41:34him kind of like rile him up a little bit or
- 41:35get riled up by Marty. I think that there's a
- 41:38real split between the Rachel character where
- 41:41Rachel is trying to keep him grounded. But then
- 41:43I think maybe by the halfway point of this movie
- 41:45is kind of in the ride with him and like going
- 41:49as far as he wants to go because now she's just
- 41:51all in. And I thought she did remarkable in this.
- 41:55I've seen her before. She's currently in a show.
- 41:57I know Tim's watching right now or has watched
- 41:59I Love L .A. And I'm interested to hear your
- 42:01thoughts on it. But I thought she was incredible
- 42:03in this. Yeah. I mean, she was so, so good in
- 42:06Marty. And I mean, you bring up I Love L .A.
- 42:11She's so much better in that. Really? She's just
- 42:15like she's given the character that's like probably
- 42:18the most fun. character in the series where she's
- 42:21just like this like influencer who's like you
- 42:24like her and you're on her side but she's also
- 42:26like nuts um And she plays that really well.
- 42:30But then I think in juxtaposition to her character
- 42:32in Marty Supreme, you just really see the range
- 42:35that she has. And I do think she was like perfectly
- 42:38casted for that role because she's just she's
- 42:40got this thing about just her acting style where
- 42:43it's like you just you're you're in the scene
- 42:45when she's in it because you're just the delivery
- 42:48of her lines. I think it just just feels so sincere.
- 42:52But I think she was perfect in this movie. Just
- 42:54like you said, kind of, especially in juxtaposition
- 42:57with Marty Supreme. I guess it's funny to call
- 43:00him that. But what's his name in the movie? Mouser.
- 43:03Mouser. Way less cool name. What if the movie
- 43:06was called Marty Mouser? Well, I think, unfortunately,
- 43:10it would definitely be confused with Mighty Mouse.
- 43:12Or Mickey Mouse or something. So that's probably
- 43:14why they did it. But, Kyle, what did you think?
- 43:17Of Odessa? Yeah. She's fantastic. She's so good.
- 43:21I think that... In any other year, or rather
- 43:24in a year where it's not as cramped with great
- 43:27performances on Supporting Actress, I would say
- 43:29she has a very, very real chance. But, I mean,
- 43:32we'll talk about the other nominations later
- 43:34on, but just a lot of competition that I'm not
- 43:38sure. Was she nominated? No. Okay, that's interesting,
- 43:42because she was nominated at the Golden Globes.
- 43:44Right. But she wasn't nominated here. Again,
- 43:47speaking to the competition, but... Even more
- 43:49so where I think her name needs to be mentioned
- 43:50because I thought she was well deserving of that
- 43:52nomination. Yeah, you know what? I'm going to
- 43:55say it real quick. Elle Fanning, I would have
- 43:58rather have seen Odessa in this spot than Elle.
- 44:01Do you have like a parking lot outside I can
- 44:03invite you in afterwards? Or like, where do you?
- 44:05Well, I mean, first of all, Sentimental Value
- 44:07got two nominations in the supporting category.
- 44:10And I think that always kind of works against
- 44:14a movie and the chances of that winning in that
- 44:16category anyway. So I think they should have
- 44:18just campaigned for, uh, what is it? Inga Ip's
- 44:22daughter, Lillias. Yeah. Should have, should
- 44:24have just went with her. I think she's. Yeah.
- 44:27Insane. Yes. And, and then just, you know, Odessa.
- 44:31could have gotten a nomination and it would have
- 44:32been great. We'll talk about it on the sentimental
- 44:34episode or sentimental value episode. Well, actually
- 44:36both things. But I do think that one performance
- 44:41is a powerhouse performance. Like it's just all
- 44:42around. I think there's a really subtle performance
- 44:44that Elle Fanning is giving in that movie. We'll,
- 44:46we'll talk about it. So I do like her nomination
- 44:48there, but I agree. It's kind of surprising not
- 44:50to see a nomination for Odessa in this role.
- 44:53So yeah, worth talking about to go see her performance
- 44:56for that for sure. Yeah. 100%. That is interesting,
- 45:00though, that two of the leads in Sentimental
- 45:05Value were nominated and she wasn't. I'm looking
- 45:08at the nominees, and it's pretty tight, though.
- 45:13But I want to ask you all real quick off topic.
- 45:15Who do you have for Best Supporting Actress this
- 45:19year? Oh, I mean, Inga. Ipstar or Lilius, I think
- 45:24for me, is my vote. I think she's absolutely
- 45:27crushing it in that. Now, I mean, Kyle, do you
- 45:30want to talk to the nominations real quick? Yeah,
- 45:32sure. The two we mentioned from Sentimental Value
- 45:34are Elle Fanning and Ipstar or Lilius. Then you
- 45:37have Amy Madigan in Weapons, which I'm surprised
- 45:40that wasn't your go -to right away. That's who
- 45:41I want to win. I don't know who I think is going
- 45:43to win. Woonmi Masako in Sinners, and then Tiana
- 45:46Taylor in One Battle After Another. I think that
- 45:49Tiana... could take it and i it's worth mentioning
- 45:53that the first nominee or the first um awards
- 45:55that are given out in the night are the best
- 45:57supporting actor and actress so those tend to
- 46:00be the splash of like hey let's how interesting
- 46:03are the awards going to be tonight yeah i think
- 46:05to me it's between inga and tayana i i would
- 46:08really like to see inga take the win on this
- 46:11because i think she's doing an incredible similar
- 46:14to jesse buckley we talked about last episode
- 46:16with hamnet like i think she's giving a performance
- 46:20that really does tend to like hinge on the final
- 46:22couple moments for her not fully but i think
- 46:24there is a huge realization in the character
- 46:27in those final scenes And I think it's the same
- 46:29thing for Inga in Sentimental Value. I think
- 46:31the interaction she has with her sister at the
- 46:34end there really is kind of the reveal that kind
- 46:37of unlocks the whole movie for me of a conversation
- 46:40of how she wasn't as affected by her childhood
- 46:42as her sister was. Just her crying. Not even
- 46:46a video, just a photo of her crying has just
- 46:48kind of reduced me to tears. So I think she's
- 46:52giving one of my favorite performances, and I
- 46:54would love to see her win. But also, speaking
- 46:57very shortly, but we'll get to her episode next
- 46:59week, Teyana Taylor is just kind of undeniable
- 47:02in her limited screen time on One Battle. Kyle,
- 47:06who do you have? Odessa. She's just going to
- 47:09sneak in there? Yeah, it's so weird. I think
- 47:12she probably was my... favorite of just the performances
- 47:16I saw in the supporting actress category, but
- 47:18she didn't get nominated. So, yeah. Tiana Taylor,
- 47:22I would say. You're like, Odessa, but I guess
- 47:25Tiana. Yeah, I don't know. I don't know. I feel
- 47:28like this is one where I'm like, you didn't...
- 47:32You didn't pick my team, so I'm not really watching
- 47:34the Super Bowl. In the immortal words of Alec
- 47:37Baldwin in 30 Rock, we count that and we're going
- 47:40to take that as a win for a vote for Amy Madigan
- 47:42in weapons. So thank you for your vote. Oh, OK.
- 47:44Tim, who do you have? It's tough because I ran
- 47:48into Elle Fanning at an ice cream shop at the
- 47:52SCAD Film Festival last year. And I ran into
- 47:55Tiana Taylor at a thrift shop in Atlanta a couple
- 47:58of years ago. So I'm close with both of them.
- 48:01Yeah, right. But and, you know, won me. It was
- 48:07incredible in Sinners. But Amy Madigan was the
- 48:12love interest in Uncle Buck. So I have to go
- 48:15with Amy Madigan. And I just think that would
- 48:17be like earth shattering for like horror. Right.
- 48:20And her performance made that whole movie. That
- 48:23was like the scariest performance. Of all time.
- 48:26And I've watched it, I saw it in theaters three
- 48:28times, I think. That performance is just like
- 48:31out of control. Even if you don't like horror,
- 48:34if you just were to see those scenes, you'd be
- 48:36like, wow, that is, they found an actual witch.
- 48:41That's a great point. And honestly, that kind
- 48:44of is the definition of the splash I was talking
- 48:46about, of like how they really want to make like,
- 48:48you know, hey, you should probably continue to
- 48:50watch the Oscars. And an Amy Madigan win is a
- 48:52way to do that. I would love to see that. I think
- 48:55Amy Madigan has existed in Hollywood for a very
- 48:57long time. The Academy likes to, like I mentioned,
- 49:00recognize the people who have had longevity and
- 49:02great careers. And they love an underdog story.
- 49:07And I think the absolute underdog in this category
- 49:11is Amy Madigan. So I think Amy Madigan is closer
- 49:15to third place than fifth for me in terms of
- 49:17who I think will win. But I would love to see
- 49:21that win happen. I hope you're right. Yeah. It'd
- 49:23be so cool. As we wind down here, are there any
- 49:26other categories that you want to speak on a
- 49:28little bit more about these, Kyle? Because I
- 49:29do think we've highlighted the ones that I think
- 49:31have some real chances for Marty Supreme come
- 49:33Oscars night. But I mean, nine nominations means
- 49:35it's across the board pretty nicely. Yeah. I
- 49:38think the only one we didn't specifically talk
- 49:40about was cinematography with Darius Kanji. I
- 49:43don't really see this winning the cinematography
- 49:45category. I do want to point out, though, that
- 49:48He's done some incredible work. He's been nominated
- 49:50for Evita in 1996, Bardo, False Chronicle of
- 49:55a Handful of Truths in 2022 that I saw, have
- 49:58zero memory of. Yeah, I love that you saw it,
- 50:01but you still had to hold the paper close to
- 50:02be like, is this the full name? Well, that speaks
- 50:04more on my handwriting than my memory. But he
- 50:07also shot Delicatessen, Seven, and the 2012 Best
- 50:12International winner, Amour. Very interesting
- 50:15that he filmed Seven. I think there's some little
- 50:17remnants of Seven in some of these shots here.
- 50:20Yeah, for sure. That's like sad, sweaty boy movie.
- 50:25Yeah. You know? I mean, you just described David
- 50:28Fincher, but yeah. Yeah, you're right. You're
- 50:31right. My gang, my guy. Yeah, and that goes for
- 50:34director, too. You know, I think that Josh Safdie,
- 50:36this felt like a Safdie movie, but I feel like...
- 50:39that doesn't translate to anyone who isn't a
- 50:41fan of their work. Yeah. Like it doesn't feel
- 50:43like the movie like stands on the direction.
- 50:46Right. More just, again, I think this is a character
- 50:48study, but not a vain character study where it
- 50:52feels like Disraeli of, Hey, I'm just going to
- 50:54steamroll everyone in this movie. That's not
- 50:55me. It does feel like he bounces off people.
- 50:58So I did appreciate that performance a lot more
- 50:59than like a George Artless. Yeah. Hey fellas,
- 51:03can I ask a question real quick? Of course. Thank
- 51:06you so much. So, Original score. Yeah. Do you
- 51:10guys feel that Marty Supreme was robbed? It's
- 51:13a good question. I think I ultimately agree with
- 51:17Kyle. Not really. I do think it deserves some
- 51:20conversation about the score. I think Uncut Gems
- 51:22was a little bit more electronic, but I think
- 51:25that a lot of people, rightfully so, have some
- 51:29complaints about the score of this movie because
- 51:31the score, the vernacular, something you've brought
- 51:34up, Kyle, and the... the songs that are put into
- 51:38it, like the licensed songs, kind of are at odds
- 51:41of what the time period is of this movie, right?
- 51:45Like, it is 1952, but the score is a little more
- 51:48electronic, which does not feel 1952. The songs
- 51:51that are dropped, Tears for Fears, Forever Young,
- 51:54don't fit that time frame. Some of the vernacular
- 51:57that they use doesn't feel like 1952. I think
- 52:00there's some really interesting theories as to
- 52:02why that might be. I'll mention those off -pod.
- 52:04They're a little more spoiler. But... I think
- 52:06the score is good. I just don't know that it
- 52:09can hold a candle to the other five nominees
- 52:11that we currently see. Yeah, I agree with pretty
- 52:15much everything you just said. Is there a nominee
- 52:16that is included for best score, Tim, that you
- 52:19would want to see out in place of Marty Supreme?
- 52:22Well, I haven't seen Hamnet. The Frankenstein
- 52:25score didn't... I don't remember that doing much
- 52:28for me, but it was a Guillermo movie, so I'm
- 52:30sure the score was awesome. And then... Yeah,
- 52:35I mean, okay. It was definitely... It was a Guillermo
- 52:38movie. It had music. To what extent? There was
- 52:40music. Yeah, it had music. I don't... I kind
- 52:43of can't remember. Y 'all just did Begonia. What
- 52:46was the Begonia score? Was it... I don't remember
- 52:49it. The Begonia score we talked about, yeah,
- 52:52was very effective, but it had moments of explosions
- 52:56where it just kind of erupted. It was like constant
- 52:59bee humming, basically, followed by just... hey,
- 53:03listen, get punched in the face. Yeah. Like,
- 53:07it's pretty awesome. I don't think Marty Supreme
- 53:11deserved the nomination. However, if it got nominated
- 53:14over Frankenstein, I would have been okay with
- 53:16it. Yeah. I imagine Frankenstein was just some,
- 53:18like, strings. Yeah, you pretty much just described
- 53:22it. I don't think there was enough, honestly.
- 53:24It could have used more of that. Yeah. Lots of
- 53:27strings. The movie could have used a little more
- 53:29of a lot. This is being recorded before we drop
- 53:35our Frankenstein episode, but let it be known
- 53:37that Tim just absolutely nailed everything we
- 53:39mentioned in our episode. Pretty accurate. Everything
- 53:41could have been done better. The fact that that...
- 53:44I'll let you keep going. The fact that Frankenstein
- 53:47is up for Best Picture, come on now. Come on
- 53:51now. I think you're doing such a great job of
- 53:54tying the theme together on this, Tim, because
- 53:55I think that's another legacy. I think that's
- 53:58the Academy honoring the legacy of Del Toro and
- 54:01how well he has been received at the Oscars previously.
- 54:04And why wouldn't we nominate? a Scorsese movie?
- 54:07Why wouldn't we nominate a Spielberg movie? Why
- 54:09wouldn't we nominate del Toro? I think that's
- 54:12a big part of it. I'm not going to complain too
- 54:14much because I think between Frankenstein, Sinners,
- 54:17Amy Madigan's nomination for Weapons, and the
- 54:20ugly stepsister in Makeup and Hairstyling makes
- 54:22it one of the most horror prevalent years we've
- 54:25seen in Academy history, which is very, very,
- 54:28very fun and something I love to see. But I do
- 54:30wish it was a bit better across the board with
- 54:33Frankenstein. I agree. Yeah. Yeah, as we mentioned.
- 54:36One real quick thing. Well, it probably won't
- 54:39be quick, but I'm throwing it out anyway. Before
- 54:41we start wrapping up. Last year was the Brutalist,
- 54:45right? Or was that the year prior? I think that
- 54:48was last year. It was last year. Hi, we're an
- 54:50Oscar podcast. We're well informed. This isn't
- 54:54going to surprise anyone who knows me, but I'm
- 54:55always like pre or post Oppenheimer. So I'm like
- 54:58Brutalist was post Oppenheimer. So it's last
- 55:01year. Yeah, it was last year. Gotcha. Brutalist
- 55:03to me last year. was the movie where as we got
- 55:07closer to the academy awards it seemed like there
- 55:10was a little bit more and more controversy that
- 55:14came out with the use of ai for adrian brody's
- 55:17uh hungarian accent yeah and all of that and
- 55:21then even even as the oscars wrapped up there
- 55:24was the controversy with just his speech and
- 55:26kind of the the cockiness of that do you think
- 55:28that marty supreme this year is going to be that
- 55:32film where as we get closer to the awards, there's
- 55:36going to be more and more controversy around
- 55:39it. Because there kind of was going into it with
- 55:41the casting of Kevin O 'Leary. I know there was
- 55:43talk about AI on some front. I should have looked
- 55:47into that before we started recording. I don't
- 55:50know how that played out, so don't quote me on
- 55:52all of that. But now there's, we talked about
- 55:55it a little bit before we started recording,
- 55:57some controversial stuff coming out about...
- 56:00The Safdie brothers and the filming of Good Times
- 56:03and a minor that was on set there. Even Timothee
- 56:07Chalamet himself. There's a lot of controversy
- 56:09just in the way that he has promoted the film
- 56:12and things. Oh, and Odessa had a controversy
- 56:15recently about being cast in a film where she
- 56:17was not of the proper race. And she released
- 56:21herself from that movie. How do you guys feel
- 56:25about just all of that in general? I think that
- 56:28it is definitely going to be the most controversial
- 56:30film of the year in terms of the Academy Awards.
- 56:33I don't think that that lends itself to... I
- 56:36don't think there's going to be further controversy.
- 56:38I mean, look, I reserve the right to be wrong
- 56:41on that. I hope there's no more controversy around
- 56:43that movie. But I think ultimately that's going
- 56:46to stop it from winning some of these nine nominations.
- 56:49I don't think that... There's a real chance that
- 56:52Timothy may not get the win here because of the
- 56:55spirit of Marty that he's channeled in his press
- 56:58tour that he's done for this movie. But I do
- 57:01still think that he has a real chance to win
- 57:04this, the way he's kind of turned things around
- 57:06recently with dropping that spirit. I agree with
- 57:09you that I don't think that controversy bodes
- 57:11well for the other nominations. And I... I am
- 57:15happy with the Odessa situation because it seems
- 57:18like she did catch it pretty early on. She's
- 57:21like, oh, hey, good point. I'm going to remove
- 57:22myself from that movie. So I think that was handled
- 57:24appropriately. I can't speak to the AI part.
- 57:28I'm not sure. I haven't heard a ton about that.
- 57:30I mean, unfortunately, if that's true. But I
- 57:32agree. I think that everything that's happening
- 57:34with the Safdies right now and then the Kevin
- 57:35O 'Leary casting, which is just more of an opinion
- 57:38than anything. I do think that's going to limit
- 57:42some of its chances in winning in those categories.
- 57:44I wonder if it's going to affect Timmy with his
- 57:47nomination for Best Actor. Tim, what do you think?
- 57:50Yeah, I don't know. I don't think any of the
- 57:54controversies have been... They seemingly haven't
- 57:58gotten the amount of exposure that I think that
- 58:02they would need to to really affect it. Because
- 58:07I've seen, like, I actually haven't read, like,
- 58:09the full details of the Safdie situation, but
- 58:13I feel like they haven't been super prominent.
- 58:16Like, I haven't seen them in many places. I don't
- 58:20hear a lot of people talking about them. So for
- 58:22some reason, they just didn't catch, like, the
- 58:24kind of steam that other situations have, you
- 58:28know? So I don't know. I'd be curious to see.
- 58:31But also, I always think about stuff like that,
- 58:34you know, There's so many people involved in
- 58:36it, and it sucks to taint the picture that way.
- 58:39But it does to an extent, right? Whether that's
- 58:43the people voting on it or just people's kind
- 58:46of... You know, there's movies we look back on
- 58:48that I'm sure we would say that movie name and
- 58:50then just think of some controversy around it.
- 58:52Sure. For example, the Twilight Zone movie, right?
- 58:56Sure. Which I think is pretty good. But when
- 58:58you think of it, you think of people who died
- 59:00filming it, right? Yeah. That's a great point.
- 59:03That's definitely not the first thing that popped
- 59:04into my head with what we've been talking about
- 59:06with him last year's Oscars, but that's true.
- 59:08Well, I mean, I just brought up Seven, and there's
- 59:10that whole element with Kevin Spacey. True. Great
- 59:14movie, but now when you watch it, you're like,
- 59:15whoa, look who it is. Yeah. That's one way to
- 59:20look at it. He really did that to a lot of movies.
- 59:22A lot of movies I put on, and I'm like, oh, God.
- 59:24Yeah. One movie that I think we're not missing
- 59:28in the divorce on that is K -Pax. K -Pax, rest
- 59:31in peace, Bozo. I don't know what that is. That's
- 59:36my most controversial take on this podcast is
- 59:38K -Pax. Is it? Rip Bozo. Have fun. You're not
- 59:43missing anything. I'd rather pay it forward.
- 59:45I'm missing everything. Is where I'm at on that.
- 59:47Oh, pay it forward would be dark to watch now.
- 59:50Yes, it would. 100%. Morals. Being a good person.
- 59:55He's the main character. Yeah, and they're just
- 59:57like, hey, don't you feel so bad for Kevin Spacey
- 59:59in this movie? And now you're like, not really.
- 1:00:02So, wrapping up here, one thing that we like
- 1:00:05to do here, Tim. Well, you know what? This doesn't
- 1:00:08feel fair. Final thoughts on Marty Supreme. Any
- 1:00:10final thoughts you want to share? Yeah, I just
- 1:00:13think it was awesome. And I was a fan. And like
- 1:00:17you mentioned earlier, Ryan, I just watched Smashing
- 1:00:20Machine recently. And much like with the Coens,
- 1:00:23you kind of saw who has the juice and who doesn't
- 1:00:25in their career divorce. I hope they get back
- 1:00:30together, honestly. but it would be cool to see
- 1:00:33what else Josh Safdie will do because I think
- 1:00:37the direction on this and just the overall finished
- 1:00:39product was just, to me, endlessly rewatchable.
- 1:00:43I can't wait to watch this movie again. I'm very
- 1:00:46excited for you to see Unclad Gems, Kyle, because
- 1:00:49I do think you're going to be like, where's Marty?
- 1:00:50Bring Marty back. Yeah, I don't know. I don't
- 1:00:53know. We'll see. We'll see. Maybe I like it more
- 1:00:55than F1. Who knows? All right, so let's talk
- 1:00:57a bit about our double features. I'm sorry, do
- 1:01:00you want to knock out ratings first to just completely
- 1:01:02close the door on Marty Supreme? I appreciate
- 1:01:04you. Thank you for keeping me honest. Yeah, please,
- 1:01:07go ahead. So I gave Marty Supreme a whopping
- 1:01:09three and a half stars. Wow. Yeah, probably lower
- 1:01:13than everybody here. Tim, do you remember what
- 1:01:15you gave Marty Supreme on Letterboxd? Or do you
- 1:01:19want me to tell you because I have your Letterboxd
- 1:01:20up? Oh, yeah. Tell me what I put. You and I actually
- 1:01:23rated it the same way. I forgot that your profile
- 1:01:25picture on Letterboxd is a death from Bill and
- 1:01:27Ted Face the Music, or Bill and Ted's Bogus Journey.
- 1:01:31You and I both were four and a half stars. Okay.
- 1:01:34Wow. I stand by that. Yeah, I think that's right.
- 1:01:37It's a powerhouse performance. Undeniable is
- 1:01:40a great word that we've been using, and I'll
- 1:01:41continue to use it for Timothee Chalamet. And
- 1:01:44I think the movie is extremely effective. I think
- 1:01:47ultimately it is just, it's... It is a very specific
- 1:01:51type of movie. And you have to be in the mood
- 1:01:53for that. And I don't think it always will be
- 1:01:54for me. So that keeps it from five stars all
- 1:01:57around. But I do agree with about four and a
- 1:01:59half stars. Although it didn't make my top 10,
- 1:02:01which was controversial. My top 10, I think I
- 1:02:04need a top 10 2 .0. I think you do too. Because
- 1:02:07sentimental value is just still, what an oversight
- 1:02:10for me. That's crazy. Yeah, F1 is definitely
- 1:02:13leaving that top 10. The more I revisit it. I
- 1:02:15forgot that was in your top 10. I had a good
- 1:02:18time. What a monster. I had a good time, okay?
- 1:02:21That was me doing my top 10. It was just me.
- 1:02:24I need Kool -In for sure. Okay, now double feature?
- 1:02:29Yes, now we can double feature. Third time's
- 1:02:30a charm. All right, so, Tim, we'd like to do
- 1:02:31a thing on here where we recommend a double feature,
- 1:02:35a second movie that would be paired well with
- 1:02:37this. Since you're our guest of honor, would
- 1:02:40you like to go first with your double feature?
- 1:02:42Ooh, I'd love to. Especially because we talked
- 1:02:45about earlier, I was a little nervous you and
- 1:02:47I would maybe pick the same one. Right. But I
- 1:02:50don't think it will from what else we spoke about
- 1:02:52it. But, yes, my double feature I would put with
- 1:02:55Marty Supreme. And I think Kyle would be, if
- 1:03:00you haven't seen this, I imagine you maybe have,
- 1:03:03but if you haven't seen it, this gives you, like,
- 1:03:05the Marty Supreme, like, watching one person
- 1:03:07go through this crazy stuff. It isn't as stressful.
- 1:03:11So it's Scorsese's After Hours. Oh, yeah. I have
- 1:03:15not seen this. Oh, have you seen it, Ryan? I
- 1:03:18haven't. I really want to, though. This is one
- 1:03:20of the greatest movies of all time, in my opinion.
- 1:03:23It's probably, if I had to do it, probably in
- 1:03:27my top five, next to Rebel Ridge, which I just
- 1:03:31rewatched, and that movie is still fantastic.
- 1:03:34Perfect. But yeah, so it stars, oh, what's his
- 1:03:40name? He's the man. He just showed up in Hot
- 1:03:43Stealin'. Uh, and he is, uh, pulling it up here.
- 1:03:47Um, Griffin dude, uh, Griffin done. Yeah. Sorry.
- 1:03:50Done. So he, uh, it's, it's a businessman in
- 1:03:55New York who just goes out one night and it follows
- 1:03:58just, you know, it's the whole one crazy night
- 1:04:00thing. And, uh, you know, takes place in like
- 1:04:03the CD part of New York, which obviously it's
- 1:04:05in the seventies. So, uh, you know, two decades
- 1:04:08after when, uh, Marty Supreme takes place. But
- 1:04:11it has that same sort of, like, really griminess.
- 1:04:15Even more so, right? It gets a little more grimy,
- 1:04:17I think, when it goes into the 70s. And it's
- 1:04:20just, he's going to diners. He's going to bars.
- 1:04:23He's getting chased out of things. People are
- 1:04:25dying. He's going to nightclubs, going to punk
- 1:04:27shows. And he's just trying to get home. It's
- 1:04:30a whole thing. It's homeward bound. He's just
- 1:04:32trying to get to his house. And he just keeps
- 1:04:34getting thrown into these other crazy situations.
- 1:04:37And I'm pretty sure they... I heard... josh safty
- 1:04:40cite this as like a inspo for the movie but i
- 1:04:43think they would pair really nice together as
- 1:04:45kind of shot being marty and then chaser being
- 1:04:48after hours because like i said it's not that
- 1:04:51stressful i think it's more just like you like
- 1:04:53watching the story it's enjoyable and the character's
- 1:04:56fun to watch just kind of bounce through these
- 1:04:58scenarios that's a great pick it's it's funny
- 1:05:01how timed that is because my buddy anthony uh
- 1:05:04just rated after hours on letterbox so he just
- 1:05:07watched it like last night or this weekend so
- 1:05:09i had to double check i was like did he just
- 1:05:11did tim just watch this and then rated it but
- 1:05:13no it was my buddy anthony so very prevalent
- 1:05:15uh that's that's an amazing pick yeah excellent
- 1:05:18I'm going to check it out. I almost picked it
- 1:05:20up on Criterion last week, but that's because
- 1:05:22I'm trying to film my Scorsese collection. Now
- 1:05:25I'm trying to do the directors, where it's like,
- 1:05:27well, hey, I need this director, all their movies,
- 1:05:29and what I can get on Criterion. Scorsese, as
- 1:05:32of this year, Killers of the Flower Moon is going
- 1:05:35to be on Criterion, so I can keep that going.
- 1:05:36Yeah. I'm excited. Kyle, do you want to go next?
- 1:05:39Yeah. So I went with a film that I think also
- 1:05:43follows a anti -hero who... I wouldn't call an
- 1:05:48antihero, straight up a villain that you're supposed
- 1:05:50to root for. But by the end of it, you're like,
- 1:05:53I kind of hope you don't win this ping pong tournament,
- 1:05:56Timothy. But for me, I went with 1983's Scarface.
- 1:06:02You're following Tony Montana. Notorious drug
- 1:06:06lord, gangster. He's awful. He's terrible to
- 1:06:09everybody in that movie. He's doing more blatantly.
- 1:06:14evil things in that movie than uh marty is like
- 1:06:17you know cutting people up with a chainsaw but
- 1:06:20i think that kind of follows the the same concept
- 1:06:24of like this is just he's not a great guy and
- 1:06:27he's striving for greatness all around yeah it's
- 1:06:30it's a villain's movie and that's that's how
- 1:06:32i feel about it i mean those are great picks
- 1:06:34because i think it speaks totally to the um the
- 1:06:36drive of the character of like you know we want
- 1:06:38to find someone who is couldn't be reprehensible
- 1:06:42Could just be like, you know, a troubled individual.
- 1:06:44But those are really great serious picks. One
- 1:06:48day I'll get there. Oh, no. Ryan, before you
- 1:06:50say yours, I just want to throw out real quick
- 1:06:52another one that came to mind for me that when
- 1:06:55Kyle started explaining or introing his pick,
- 1:06:58I was curious if you were going to pick it. And
- 1:07:01I think it won't be yours, Ryan, but the movie,
- 1:07:04the documentary Free Solo. Oh, yeah. That's not
- 1:07:07my pick. That guy is an anti -hero. His girlfriend's
- 1:07:11like, I'm worried about you. He's like, shut
- 1:07:13up. I'm going to climb this big mountain. You
- 1:07:16know, recently he climbed the, what is it, the
- 1:07:19101 in Taipei? Is that what it's called? That
- 1:07:21was on Netflix, right? Yeah. I was shocked to
- 1:07:25see that they are now married with kids. Yeah,
- 1:07:28that's wild. Like, what a woman, you know? I
- 1:07:31mean. To stick by him. Did you see the thing
- 1:07:34where after he climbed, she's like, say hi to
- 1:07:37the kids. And he's like, they're not watching.
- 1:07:39And she's like, but they will one day. And he's
- 1:07:42like, they're not watching. high and he's like
- 1:07:45really annoyed about it i think it'd be great
- 1:07:47if his kids were named like fiji and everest
- 1:07:49or like something where it's just like i just
- 1:07:51can't stop thinking about that mountain yeah
- 1:07:53for my double feature uh i picked a movie that
- 1:07:56i i looked at marty supreme and i i saw the the
- 1:07:59obstacles and the adventures and the characters
- 1:08:01that someone would meet along the way of like
- 1:08:04a singular journey of you know, how dedicated
- 1:08:07they were to get to a certain point or get something
- 1:08:09back and the characters that they meet. And I
- 1:08:11am, of course, referring to the 1985 Tim Burton
- 1:08:13classic, Pee -wee's Big Adventure. I do, this
- 1:08:17is kind of a zag, but I also really stand by
- 1:08:19it. I think that the zaniness that Marty gets
- 1:08:21into in this movie does kind of match. obviously
- 1:08:25a comedic difference in Pee -wee's Big Adventure,
- 1:08:27but I think that it kind of plays a similar way
- 1:08:30to me where it's kind of like, hey, I met Wally,
- 1:08:32and then I met Kevin O 'Leary, and then I met
- 1:08:34Gwyneth Paltrow, and then I got into this crazy
- 1:08:36situation in a hotel, and now I'm in Japan about
- 1:08:38to kiss a pig. And there's a lot of things happening
- 1:08:40that just feel very much like, how did Paul Reubens
- 1:08:43get into this situation? Obviously a very different
- 1:08:46movie and tone, but to Kyle's point, I think
- 1:08:48it's a welcomed shift. I think that the shot
- 1:08:51of Marty Supreme to Tim's analogy there is the
- 1:08:55chaser of Pee Wee's Big Adventure as the relief,
- 1:08:58right? Like the sigh of relief from like a big
- 1:09:00inhale of Marty Supreme. So that would be my
- 1:09:03earnest suggestion. A bit different, a bit of
- 1:09:05a zag from the tone you guys had suggested. But
- 1:09:07I do legitimately think that's a good pairing.
- 1:09:10I really like that. I could see Marty Mouser
- 1:09:13sitting down to watch a movie about his life
- 1:09:15and then walking out halfway and being like...
- 1:09:18I don't have to see it. I've lived it. I mean,
- 1:09:22at the end of the day, what is Marty Mauser but
- 1:09:25a loner and a rebel? Yeah. Dottie. Dottie. Good
- 1:09:28point. Great pick. Thank you. Solid. I love it.
- 1:09:31Great pairs all around. That's a great movie,
- 1:09:33too. It's so good. It's one of Tim's all -time
- 1:09:36favorites. Burton? It's a go for me, yeah. Well,
- 1:09:39true. It's your favorite Tim Burton, right? Yeah,
- 1:09:42but it's probably my favorite movie of all time.
- 1:09:45I think it's a masterpiece. Wow. Tim has a tattoo
- 1:09:48of not big adventure, but of holiday. Is that
- 1:09:52right? Yes. Yeah, the one that... Did he direct
- 1:09:56it or just produce it? Produced it. Produced
- 1:10:00it. Yeah, and it was... Yeah, I have the tattoo
- 1:10:04of the initials of something he says. This woman
- 1:10:07is trying to talk to him. He's not interested.
- 1:10:09And she says, she's like, please just give me
- 1:10:12some time, Peewee. And he's like, I -H -T -T
- 1:10:15-I -T -V -G, I think is what it is or whatever.
- 1:10:18I forget what the number is. It's somewhere on
- 1:10:20my leg. But it's, look at the time I have to
- 1:10:23be going. What a treasure. It's so good, man.
- 1:10:28I'm so glad we had Paul Reubens when we did.
- 1:10:30Yeah, look, hey, Tim, thank you for joining us.
- 1:10:32It was awesome to have you on here. I really
- 1:10:35appreciate you coming on to talk about movies
- 1:10:36in general, which is one of my favorite things
- 1:10:38to do with you, but I know you have a very storied
- 1:10:40knowledge of the history of the Safdies and everything
- 1:10:43they've done, so I appreciate you coming on to
- 1:10:45share that. Where can everyone check you out
- 1:10:48to hear more from you? Yeah, thank you guys for
- 1:10:51having me on. This was very fun. Yeah. Find me
- 1:10:53on Letterboxd at Kromdar. C -H -R -O -M -D -A
- 1:10:57-R, which is the name I go by for. I have a radio
- 1:11:01show called The Kromdar Hour in Savannah, Georgia.
- 1:11:04You can listen to it online every Thursday at
- 1:11:069 p .m. Eastern, where I have musicians, artists.
- 1:11:12I've had one director so far, Damian McCarthy,
- 1:11:15who did some awesome movies. And he has an oddity,
- 1:11:20and he has a movie coming out called Hocum. Adam
- 1:11:23Scott. He's the man. And yeah, you can find me
- 1:11:26there and on socials as well at the Cromdar Hour.
- 1:11:29And anyone who's not in Savannah can listen to
- 1:11:32that through the WRUU website, right? Yeah, wru
- 1:11:37.org streams live on the website. We'll share
- 1:11:40that link on the podcast website for everyone
- 1:11:43to check out. But it's a great show. I mean,
- 1:11:45I've been on it, so I have some personal stake
- 1:11:47in it. But no, I love listening to it every Thursday
- 1:11:50at 9 p .m. It really is, you know, we mentioned
- 1:11:51Pee Wee's Big Adventure. It really is kind of
- 1:11:53like the Pee Wee's Playhouse of radio shows.
- 1:11:55But there's actual great music and interviews
- 1:11:58with directors and musicians. So well worth your
- 1:12:01time to check out. Nice. I'll definitely be checking
- 1:12:03it out. Heck yeah, we'll have to have you guys
- 1:12:05on to talk about the Oscars closer to the date.
- 1:12:09We'll be there. Yeah, just let us know. We'll
- 1:12:11be happy to drop some hot takes, answer any questions
- 1:12:14you have. Well, cool. That's going to do it for
- 1:12:17this episode of the podcast and Marty Supreme.
- 1:12:19If you have any thoughts about this film or any
- 1:12:22of the other nominations this year. Shoot us
- 1:12:24an email over at outaopodcast at gmail .com.
- 1:12:28If you would like to support the show, check
- 1:12:30out patreon .com slash outaopodcast. We have
- 1:12:34a watch party coming up. That watch party is
- 1:12:37going to be Friday, February 27th at 8 p .m.
- 1:12:41If you want to gain access to the community Discord
- 1:12:45server, you can gain that access without any
- 1:12:49monetary... donation or whatever you do not have
- 1:12:52to back us for the dollar amount which we usually
- 1:12:54require we're running a promo right now just
- 1:12:57follow the page for free and you will get access
- 1:12:59to that discord i've decided that i'm going to
- 1:13:02run that promotion until the academy awards Oh,
- 1:13:04March 15th. Yeah, and just do it that way. So
- 1:13:06again, if you want access to the Discord, just
- 1:13:09follow us on Patreon for free. You can join in
- 1:13:12the conversation. Ryan's posting movie reviews
- 1:13:15there of just whatever he happens to catch that
- 1:13:18week. And then on the Patreon as well, I am doing
- 1:13:21my weekly Death Race recap, just going over everything
- 1:13:24I've watched that week for the Academy Awards
- 1:13:26leading up to the Oscar ceremony. Ceremony. God
- 1:13:30bless you for that. Thank you again so much,
- 1:13:32Tim. for coming on the show. We've loved having
- 1:13:34you, but that's going to do it. As always, I'm
- 1:13:37your host, Kyle. And I was born in 1601. I'm
- 1:13:40a vampire. And we'll see you at the movies.