Latest / Daily Crime and Justice | True Crime, Trial Coverage, and Murder Cases / MISTRIAL: The Lindsay Clancy Jury Deadlocks 11-1 for Acquittal After Seven Days, and the SJC Refuses to Step In
Transcript
- 0:03Speaker 1: Calaroga Shark Media.
- 0:10Speaker 2: This is Daily Crime and Justice from Calaroga Shark Media,
- 0:13Speaker 2: powered by AI. I'm Garrett Fisher, and this is a
- 0:16Speaker 2: special bulletin. At about 11 o'clock Friday morning, after seven
- 0:20Speaker 2: days and nearly 40 hours locked in a room, the
- 0:23Speaker 2: jury in the Lindsay Clancy case sent Judge William Sullivan
- 0:26Speaker 2: a note. It read, It is with a heavy heart
- 0:29Speaker 2: that we report we are unable to come to a
- 0:31Speaker 2: unanimous decision and will not be able to. Those last
- 0:35Speaker 2: six words are the ones that ended it. Will not
- 0:38Speaker 2: be able to. Not cannot today. Not need more time.
- 0:42Speaker 1: Will not.
- 0:44Speaker 2: Sullivan said that under the statute and the case law,
- 0:47Speaker 2: he did not feel he had any choice but to
- 0:49Speaker 2: declare a mistrial. And then something happened that veteran Massachusetts
- 0:54Speaker 2: lawyers are calling unusual. He put his own ruling on
- 0:58Speaker 2: hold and gave Kevin Reddington one hour to run to
- 1:01Speaker 2: the state's highest court and try to stop it. 12
- 1:04Speaker 2: jurors sat in a room down the hall for that hour.
- 1:07Speaker 2: Nobody told them why they were waiting. The Supreme Judicial
- 1:10Speaker 2: Court refused to intervene. And at about 2.30 Friday afternoon,
- 1:15Speaker 2: William Sullivan brought that jury back into his courtroom, declared
- 1:19Speaker 2: them deadlocked, declared a mistrial, and let them go home.
- 1:23Speaker 2: Jury notes indicate those nine women and three men were
- 1:25Speaker 2: split 11 to 1 in favor of acquitting Lindsay Clancy.
- 1:29Speaker 2: Here is everything that happened and what it means. Start
- 1:37Speaker 2: Thursday afternoon because that is when this cracked open. The
- 1:41Speaker 2: foreperson sent Sullivan a note saying one of the 12
- 1:43Speaker 2: was not following the law on reasonable doubt. Sullivan had
- 1:48Speaker 2: Lindsey Clancy wheeled up to the bench, which had not
- 1:50Speaker 2: happened once in five weeks of trial, and then brought
- 1:53Speaker 2: each juror in individually to be asked whether they could
- 1:56Speaker 2: follow his instructions. Every one of them said yes. He
- 2:00Speaker 2: re-instructed the panel and sent them back. Then a second
- 2:04Speaker 2: note arrived late Thursday, and this one was more specific.
- 2:08Speaker 2: According to Sullivan, it said the holdout juror has acknowledged
- 2:12Speaker 2: doubt but refuses to apply it to the verdict. Read
- 2:15Speaker 2: that sentence twice, because both sides did. Friday morning at
- 2:19Speaker 2: 9 before the jury was brought in, the lawyers fought
- 2:22Speaker 2: about what it meant, and it got ugly. Kevin Reddington
- 2:25Speaker 2: told the court the note clearly and unequivocally indicates the
- 2:28Speaker 2: panel is 11 to 1, and that this person will
- 2:31Speaker 2: not apply reasonable doubt to the evidence and return a
- 2:34Speaker 2: not guilty verdict. He said the juror, whom he referred
- 2:38Speaker 2: to as a man, had made a false statement under
- 2:41Speaker 2: oath to the court. He went further than that. He
- 2:43Speaker 2: said he would go so far as to say the
- 2:45Speaker 2: juror lied under oath. And he asked again that the
- 2:49Speaker 2: man be removed. Jennifer Sprague opposed it, and her argument
- 2:54Speaker 2: was disciplined. She said the note indicates a disagreement among
- 2:58Speaker 2: jurors about how to weigh the evidence, and that there
- 3:01Speaker 2: is no indication the juror is intentionally trying to mislead
- 3:05Speaker 2: or lie to the court. She noted there had been
- 3:08Speaker 2: no suggestion of how the majority was leaning. She asked
- 3:11Speaker 2: that they simply be sent back. Sullivan refused to question
- 3:16Speaker 2: the juror at all. He said he saw no need
- 3:19Speaker 2: for an inquiry of that particular juror and that the
- 3:22Speaker 2: note does not indicate a person who has refused to
- 3:24Speaker 2: follow the law. He said he would remind the whole
- 3:27Speaker 2: jury to follow his instructions whether they like it or not.
- 3:31Speaker 2: Reddington pushed him to read it forcefully, and Sullivan said...
- 3:35Speaker 2: What do you want me to do? Get a brass band?
- 3:38Speaker 2: I'm not an actor. That line is going to outlive
- 3:41Speaker 2: this trial. And underneath the snark is the whole legal
- 3:44Speaker 2: problem in one sentence. Because look, I'm going to be
- 3:47Speaker 2: honest with you about what was actually being asked there.
- 3:50Speaker 2: A judge can remove a juror who commits misconduct. Drinking,
- 3:54Speaker 2: researching the case at home, talking to reporters, refusing to
- 3:58Speaker 2: deliberate at all. A judge can remove a juror who
- 4:02Speaker 2: flatly announces they will not apply the law.
- 4:05Speaker 1: A judge cannot.
- 4:06Speaker 2: Remove a juror for reaching a conclusion the other 11
- 4:09Speaker 2: do not like. That is not a technicality. That is
- 4:13Speaker 2: the entire architecture of a 12-person jury. If a judge
- 4:18Speaker 2: can pull the one person standing in the way of
- 4:20Speaker 2: a verdict, then you no longer have a unanimity requirement.
- 4:24Speaker 2: You have a vote with a referee. And here is
- 4:28Speaker 2: what makes this case so hard. A juror who has
- 4:31Speaker 2: honestly applied reasonable doubt and landed somewhere the other 11
- 4:35Speaker 2: have not looks. From outside that room, exactly like a
- 4:39Speaker 2: juror who is refusing to follow the law. There is
- 4:42Speaker 2: no test that separates them. There never has been. The
- 4:46Speaker 2: note said he acknowledged doubt but would not apply it.
- 4:49Speaker 2: Reddington heard a man admitting he was ignoring the law.
- 4:53Speaker 2: Sprague heard 11 frustrated people describing an argument they were losing.
- 4:58Speaker 2: Sullivan looked at the same words and said, it does
- 5:00Speaker 2: not show a refusal to follow the law. All three
- 5:04Speaker 2: of those readings are available from that one sentence. That
- 5:07Speaker 2: is why judges do not do what Reddington was asking. Now,
- 5:11Speaker 2: about the split, and I want to be careful here.
- 5:14Speaker 2: Reporting indicates the jury was 11 to 1 in favor
- 5:17Speaker 2: of acquitting Lindsay Clancy. That comes from the jury's own
- 5:21Speaker 2: notes as characterized in open court, and it is Reddington
- 5:24Speaker 2: who put the number on the record. Sprague pointed out
- 5:27Speaker 2: there had been no indication of how the majority was leaning.
- 5:31Speaker 2: But if it is accurate, and it appears to be,
- 5:34Speaker 2: then it means something significant that is going to get
- 5:37Speaker 2: flattened into nothing by the end of the weekend. It
- 5:39Speaker 2: means 11 citizens of Plymouth County, after 21 days of testimony,
- 5:44Speaker 2: 84 witnesses, 6 psychiatric experts, and 300 exhibits, were prepared
- 5:49Speaker 2: to say the Commonwealth had not proved that Lindsay Clancy
- 5:52Speaker 2: could stop herself. Not that she did not kill her children.
- 5:57Speaker 2: Nobody disputed that. That the state did not carry its
- 6:00Speaker 2: burden on whether she was criminally responsible when she did.
- 6:04Speaker 2: That is not the same as a jury that was
- 6:06Speaker 2: about to convict. It is very nearly the opposite. When
- 6:10Speaker 2: we come back, the note, the mistrial, and the one
- 6:14Speaker 2: hour that followed. Sullivan sent them back Friday morning with
- 6:29Speaker 2: a reminder to follow the law whether they liked it
- 6:32Speaker 2: or not.
- 6:33Speaker 1: About two hours later, the note came.
- 6:36Speaker 2: It is with a heavy heart that we report we
- 6:38Speaker 2: are unable to come to a unanimous decision and will
- 6:42Speaker 2: not be able to. Prosecutors said that language required a mistrial.
- 6:47Speaker 2: Reddington asked that they be sent back one more time.
- 6:50Speaker 2: He asked Sullivan to poll the jury individually, citing what
- 6:54Speaker 2: happened in the Karen Reed mistrial. Prosecutors objected and said
- 6:58Speaker 2: this situation was different. He asked Sullivan to survey the
- 7:01Speaker 2: jurors on whether they could reach agreement on a lesser charge,
- 7:04Speaker 2: second-degree murder or manslaughter, before pulling the plug. Sullivan denied
- 7:10Speaker 2: all of it. He said under the statute and the
- 7:12Speaker 2: case law, he did not feel he had any choice.
- 7:16Speaker 2: And that is legally correct. In 2020, the United States
- 7:20Speaker 2: Supreme Court confirmed that verdicts in serious criminal cases must
- 7:23Speaker 2: be unanimous.
- 7:25Speaker 1: Twelve people or nothing.
- 7:27Speaker 2: When twelve people tell a judge four separate times across
- 7:30Speaker 2: four days that they cannot get there, and then write
- 7:33Speaker 2: that they will not be able to, the judge's options
- 7:36Speaker 2: run out.
- 7:37Speaker 1: Sullivan had already.
- 7:38Speaker 2: Used the Tui Rodriguez charge, the dynamite instruction, on Wednesday.
- 7:43Speaker 2: Massachusetts allows two. He had one left, and it would
- 7:46Speaker 2: not have mattered. Then came the part nobody expected. Before
- 7:50Speaker 2: the jury could be brought in to hear the mistrial declared,
- 7:53Speaker 2: Reddington asked the court to pause. He wanted to file
- 7:56Speaker 2: what is called a Chapter 211, Section 3 petition, an
- 8:01Speaker 2: emergency appeal to a single justice of the Massachusetts Supreme
- 8:05Speaker 2: Judicial Court, arguing there are structural problems in this case
- 8:09Speaker 2: created by the failure to remove that juror. He told
- 8:12Speaker 2: the court there was a clear and present danger, in
- 8:15Speaker 2: his words, that this individual was taking a position that
- 8:18Speaker 2: was intractable for reasons nobody knew, regardless of proof beyond
- 8:23Speaker 2: a reasonable doubt. At 11.30, Sullivan gave him one hour. Now,
- 8:28Speaker 2: I want to explain how unusual that is, because the
- 8:31Speaker 2: coverage is treating it as a technicality and it is not.
- 8:35Speaker 2: A single justice of the Supreme Judicial Court handles emergency
- 8:38Speaker 2: petitions on a rotating basis, one of the seven justices
- 8:42Speaker 2: at a time, for exactly these situations, Fast-moving criminal matters
- 8:47Speaker 2: where somebody's liberty is on the line. Friday's single justice
- 8:51Speaker 2: was Justice Dalila Wendland. Lawyers do sometimes run to a
- 8:55Speaker 2: single justice to try to overturn a trial judge on
- 8:58Speaker 2: the eve of a trial. What is not common is
- 9:01Speaker 2: a trial judge announcing a mistrial and then holding his
- 9:04Speaker 2: own order so the losing side can go over his
- 9:06Speaker 2: head about it. That is Sullivan protecting the record. He
- 9:10Speaker 2: knows this case is going to be picked apart for years.
- 9:13Speaker 2: He is not going to be the judge who slammed
- 9:15Speaker 2: a door shut before somebody could file. The bar, though,
- 9:19Speaker 2: was brutal. To overturn him, that court would have had
- 9:22Speaker 2: to find clear and egregious error by the trial judge,
- 9:25Speaker 2: looking at the entire record of these deliberations, including four
- 9:29Speaker 2: separate notes from 12 people all saying the same thing.
- 9:33Speaker 2: And while the lawyers filed, 12 jurors sat in a
- 9:36Speaker 2: room and waited without being told why. Lindsay Clancy was
- 9:41Speaker 2: taken out of the courtroom almost immediately. Her family filed
- 9:44Speaker 2: out silent and solemn. Outside, about 30 members of the
- 9:48Speaker 2: public spilled into the hallway, loud and disorganized enough that
- 9:51Speaker 2: a court officer had to herd them backward down the corridor,
- 9:55Speaker 2: shouting at them to keep walking until he said, stop.
- 9:58Speaker 2: A woman who had traveled from Worcester to sit through
- 10:00Speaker 2: this trial said it was a shame that there is
- 10:03Speaker 2: no winning here and that she had to give the
- 10:05Speaker 2: jury credit for how hard they had worked. She was
- 10:09Speaker 2: right on all three counts. The Supreme Judicial Court denied
- 10:12Speaker 2: the petition. Sullivan announced it in open court and said
- 10:15Speaker 2: he intended to bring the jury in. Reddington tried one
- 10:19Speaker 2: last time, He asked for a hearing on what he
- 10:21Speaker 2: called a good faith issue with the holdout, arguing the
- 10:25Speaker 2: man was not holding out in good faith over the
- 10:27Speaker 2: facts or the law, but was refusing to apply the
- 10:30Speaker 2: law after having acknowledged doubt. Sullivan denied it, citing the
- 10:34Speaker 2: reasoning he had already given that morning. Then he brought
- 10:38Speaker 2: the jury in, said he was declaring them deadlocked, declared
- 10:41Speaker 2: a mistrial, and discharged them.
- 10:43Speaker 1: 38 hours, 7 days, 9 women, 3 men.
- 10:44Speaker 2: Done. And then he said something to them that I
- 10:50Speaker 2: want you to hear because after a week of lawyers
- 10:53Speaker 2: arguing about whether one of these people was a liar,
- 10:56Speaker 2: the judge who watched all 12 of them for six
- 10:59Speaker 2: weeks had a different assessment. He told them that every
- 11:02Speaker 2: one of them knew going in how long this case
- 11:04Speaker 2: would run and how hard it would be to sit
- 11:06Speaker 2: and listen to. That they braced for that duty anyway.
- 11:10Speaker 2: He said he understood how hard everybody had worked. And
- 11:13Speaker 2: then he told them he understood that they gave everything
- 11:16Speaker 2: they could and probably more than they thought they could.
- 11:19Speaker 2: That is the last word on this jury and.
- 11:22Speaker 1: It should be.
- 11:22Speaker 2: 12 strangers gave six weeks of their lives to the
- 11:26Speaker 2: hardest question a courtroom can ask. And they could not
- 11:29Speaker 2: get there. And the judge told them they had nothing
- 11:32Speaker 2: to apologize for. So what happens now? A mistrial is
- 11:37Speaker 2: not an acquittal and it is not a conviction. It
- 11:40Speaker 2: is not a finding of anything at all. Double Jeopardy
- 11:43Speaker 2: does not bar a retrial after a hung jury, so
- 11:46Speaker 2: Plymouth County District Attorney Timothy Cruz has three options. He
- 11:50Speaker 2: can retry it. That means starting over from jury selection.
- 11:53Speaker 2: 21 days of testimony again. 84 witnesses again. Patrick Clancy
- 11:58Speaker 2: back on a stand describing what he found in his
- 12:00Speaker 2: basement again. That 911 recording played in a courtroom again.
- 12:06Speaker 2: And both sides now know exactly what the other one has.
- 12:09Speaker 2: He can offer a plea. A Boston defense attorney and
- 12:12Speaker 2: former prosecutor not involved in the case put it plainly
- 12:15Speaker 2: this week. Anytime the threat of a retrial with first-degree
- 12:19Speaker 2: murder hanging over a client comes back into play, defense
- 12:22Speaker 2: lawyers will at minimum explore whether there is interest in
- 12:25Speaker 2: a resolution, or he can decline to retry it at all.
- 12:29Speaker 2: That happens more than people think, and for two reasons.
- 12:32Speaker 2: Sometimes prosecutors conclude they will get the same result the
- 12:35Speaker 2: second time. And these cases are enormously expensive, particularly when
- 12:40Speaker 2: both sides are paying for competing psychiatric experts. An 11
- 12:44Speaker 2: to 1 split for acquittal weighs on every one of
- 12:46Speaker 2: those calculations. Whatever he decides, Lindsay Clancy is not going anywhere.
- 12:52Speaker 2: She has been held at Tewksbury Hospital for more than
- 12:54Speaker 2: three years, on suicide watch, and she stays there while
- 12:58Speaker 2: this is sorted out.
- 12:59Speaker 1: She is paralyzed. She will be for the rest of
- 13:02Speaker 1: her life.
- 13:04Speaker 2: And one more thing that is going to matter enormously
- 13:07Speaker 2: in whatever comes next. Both Lindsay and Patrick Clancy have
- 13:11Speaker 2: separate civil lawsuits pending against several of her medical providers,
- 13:15Speaker 2: alleging she was over-medicated while being treated for postpartum mental
- 13:19Speaker 2: health problems. Those cases were always going to be shaped
- 13:22Speaker 2: by whatever a criminal jury said about her mental state.
- 13:25Speaker 2: A criminal jury just said nothing at all. And I
- 13:28Speaker 2: want to end where this show always ends. Cora Clancy
- 13:32Speaker 2: was five years old and in kindergarten. Dawson Clancy was three.
- 13:36Speaker 2: Callan Clancy was eight months old and had been alive
- 13:38Speaker 2: for less than a year. They died on January 24th, 2023.
- 13:44Speaker 2: It has been three years and seven months. Twelve people
- 13:47Speaker 2: spent seven days trying to decide what the law says
- 13:50Speaker 2: about their mother and could not do it. And now
- 13:53Speaker 2: there is a real chance this whole thing starts again
- 13:55Speaker 2: from an empty jury box. There is no version of
- 13:58Speaker 2: this where those three children get anything. Not justice, not closure,
- 14:03Speaker 2: not a resolution. The best available outcome for them was
- 14:07Speaker 2: always that adults would look at it carefully, and today
- 14:10Speaker 2: 12 adults looked at it as carefully as anybody could
- 14:13Speaker 2: and still could not agree. Cora, Dawson, Callen, someone has
- 14:17Speaker 2: to say their names. That's this special bulletin for Friday,
- 14:24Speaker 2: September 4th. We will have the full picture on Monday,
- 14:27Speaker 2: including whatever the district attorney signals about a retrial. If
- 14:30Speaker 2: this was useful, send it to one person who has
- 14:33Speaker 2: been following this case. And if you're listening on Spotify,
- 14:36Speaker 2: drop a comment because I want your.
- 14:39Speaker 1: Read on the holdout.
- 14:39Speaker 2: 11 people were ready to acquit and one was not.
- 14:44Speaker 2: Is that one person a failure of the system or
- 14:47Speaker 2: the reason we have one?
- 14:49Speaker 1: I'm Garrett Fisher.
- 14:51Speaker 2: Do better.
- 14:54Speaker 1: A few notes on sourcing and timing.
- 14:56Speaker 2: This bulletin was recorded Friday afternoon after the mistrial was declared.
- 15:01Speaker 2: Events in this case moved quickly all day and may
- 15:03Speaker 2: have moved again after we recorded. As of recording, the
- 15:07Speaker 2: Plymouth County District Attorney's Office had not announced whether it
- 15:10Speaker 2: will seek a new trial. On the 11-1 split, the
- 15:14Speaker 2: contents of jury notes were described in open court, and
- 15:17Speaker 2: the characterization of the panel as split 11-1 in favor
- 15:20Speaker 2: of acquittal was placed on the record by defense attorney
- 15:23Speaker 2: Kevin Reddington and reported.
- 15:24Speaker 1: By outlets covering the proceedings.
- 15:27Speaker 2: Assistant District Attorney Jennifer Sprague stated in court that there
- 15:30Speaker 2: had been no suggestion of how the.
- 15:32Speaker 1: Majority of jurors was leaning.
- 15:34Speaker 2: Jury deliberations are secret, no juror has spoken publicly, and
- 15:38Speaker 2: the court has not confirmed a numerical split. Treat that
- 15:41Speaker 2: number as reported rather than established. The assertion that a
- 15:45Speaker 2: juror lied under oath is defense attorney Kevin Reddington's characterization,
- 15:50Speaker 2: made in open court. Judge Sullivan expressly rejected it, stating
- 15:55Speaker 2: the note did not indicate a juror who refused to
- 15:57Speaker 2: follow the law. And Assistant District Attorney Sprague stated there
- 16:01Speaker 2: was no indication the juror was attempting to mislead the court.
- 16:05Speaker 2: No finding of misconduct has been made against any juror.
- 16:08Speaker 2: A mistrial is not a verdict of any kind. Lindsay
- 16:11Speaker 2: Clancy has not been convicted of anything and has not
- 16:14Speaker 2: been acquitted of anything. She pleaded not guilty by reason
- 16:17Speaker 2: of lack of criminal responsibility, and the Commonwealth carried the
- 16:20Speaker 2: burden throughout. Retrial after a hung jury does not violate
- 16:24Speaker 2: double jeopardy protections. Outlets have counted deliberation time differently, ranging
- 16:30Speaker 2: from roughly 37 to nearly 40 hours across seven days,
- 16:34Speaker 2: and have described the trial as running five or six
- 16:37Speaker 2: weeks depending on whether jury selection is included. We have
- 16:40Speaker 2: used approximations rather than adopting one outlet's count. This episode
- 16:45Speaker 2: discusses child deaths, suicide, and postpartum mental illness.
- 16:49Speaker 1: If you are struggling, you can call or.
- 16:51Speaker 2: Text 988 in the United States to reach the Suicide
- 16:54Speaker 2: and Crisis Lifeline. For postpartum mental health specifically, the National
- 16:59Speaker 2: Maternal Mental Health Hotline is available by call or text
- 17:03Speaker 2: at 1-833-TLC-MAMA. Postpartum psychosis is rare, it is a medical emergency,
- 17:10Speaker 2: and it is treatable when it is caught. The overwhelming
- 17:14Speaker 2: majority of people who experience postpartum mental illness never harm anyone. Bye.