Latest / Psychology In Seattle Podcast / Attachment Theory Emails (Part 1) (2020 Rerun)
Transcript
- 0:00Hey, deserving listeners. I compiled a bunch of emails from y'all about attachment
- 0:04theory, so I thought i'd get all those out of the way. Let's
- 0:07answer your patron emails about attachment theory. This first email is from anonymous patron.
- 0:14They write, is it possible to develop an insecure attachment as an adult?
- 0:19When I was twenty four, I had a very traumatic breakup. I'm
- 0:23thirty now and I've been able to hold down along and I haven't been able
- 0:27to hold down a long term relationship since that breakup at the age of twenty
- 0:30four. After breaking up, I now relate strongly to the avoidant attachment you
- 0:35described in your deep dive end of email. Yeah, so, anonymous patron
- 0:40here is saying that prior to being twenty four, she might have been secure,
- 0:46or at least mostly secure. She had a traumatic breakup when she was
- 0:50twenty four, and for the past six years she would describe herself as being
- 0:55avoidant attachment. And often when I talk about attachment theory and the way it's
- 1:00often discussed in the literature is that we develop our attachment theory in response to
- 1:07our relational environment when we're very young. One two three, four or five
- 1:12years old, and that that attachment style will persist into adulthood. And yeah,
- 1:21research shows that there is a correlation, but it's not a guarantee for
- 1:23sure. And research shows that later events can change one's attachment style good and
- 1:30bad. So, for example, in therapy, hopefully you are experiencing a
- 1:36secure attachment and will thus change your attachment style from being insecure to more secure,
- 1:42so you can become more healthy attachment wise when you experience healthy attachments.
- 1:49Also, which stands to reason, if you experience damaging attachment experiences, then
- 1:56your attachment style will move more towards insecure away from secure. So attachment style
- 2:05does more for over time, absolutely, And it's also dependent on your partner.
- 2:09If your partner is more undifferentiated, more insecure, then in all likelihood
- 2:15you're going to move more towards attachment insecurity. You might have noticed this about
- 2:21yourself if you've had enough partners in your life, you might have noticed with
- 2:23some partners you seem to be way more insecure than you did with other partners.
- 2:30So there's that. It's dependent on that. It's also dependent on how
- 2:32the relationship is going. If the relationship is going well, then in all
- 2:37likelihood both members are going to edge more towards secure attachment mood society society is
- 2:46uncertain, or society's treating you badly, then that obviously could edge you more
- 2:51towards insecure. And if society is treating you badly for a long period of
- 2:53time, then you might actually be permanently so to speak, insecure. You
- 3:00know, the important thing to remember is that attachment style it's not a trait.
- 3:05It's a style of relating. That's why they call it style. Now,
- 3:08sometimes I discuss it, and sometimes in the literature it's discussed as a
- 3:12trait, as something that is a part of your personality. And I would
- 3:16certainly uphold that construction of it. But sometimes it's more useful to think of
- 3:23it according to its name, which is it's a style, meaning that it's
- 3:27a habitual way of managing closeness and the fears of rejection. You know,
- 3:31one can change one's habits temporarily. For example, when you have a need
- 3:38for recharging your battery. You know you're you've been working too much and you
- 3:43need to go on a vacation, you need to relax. Well, let's
- 3:46say someone they just love going to a Mexico beach. Whenever they think about
- 3:53being burnt out at the office, they just think, Oh, I just
- 3:57got to get to Cancoon or whatever. And so for this person, they
- 4:02frequently have a need to relax and to not be burnt out at work anymore,
- 4:08and they have a style of meeting that need by going to a Mexico
- 4:13beach. So when they have that need bubble up inside of them, sometimes
- 4:18it happens two times a year, Sometimes it happens five times a year.
- 4:21Sometimes it happens every hour, Sometimes it happens once every three years. But
- 4:25as that need bubble bubbles up for them, like oh, I need to
- 4:29get out of town, they have a style that to meet that need.
- 4:33They go to Vegas, or they go to Alaska, or they go on
- 4:39a fishing trip or something. You know, people people have styles, and
- 4:42just look around you regarding vacation, people tend to have styles, not always.
- 4:46But the point is is that you could imagine someone having a style.
- 4:51But imagine one year that their partner doesn't want to go to Mexico and instead
- 4:57wants to go on a hike. But you've never done that before. You
- 5:00like to go to a Mexico beach, but you want to please your spouse,
- 5:04so you adjust to that new way of meeting your need, which is
- 5:08hiking. You say to yourself, Oh, you know, I'd much rather
- 5:12go to a Mexico beach, but you know my partner really wants to go
- 5:15hiking. So okay, fine, I'll adjust and I'll figure out how to
- 5:20meet my needs of relaxation through hiking instead, even though that's not my habitual
- 5:26way. Well, that's what an attachment style is in a certain angle of
- 5:30looking at it. It's just a habitual way of meeting your needs, and
- 5:33it can be adjusted with some effort. To further this analogy in the past,
- 5:39let's say that you've been attacked by a bear while hiking. So you
- 5:44really do not like hiking because when you think of going into the woods,
- 5:46you think of that moment in the past where a bear attacked you, and
- 5:51you try to go hiking again after the bear attack, and you just cannot
- 5:56relax. And so when you think about relaxing and getting your needs met for
- 6:00getting away from work, you do not think of hiking. You're just like,
- 6:03no, no, no, I do not relax when I go hiking.
- 6:08But let's say you put your mind to it, and you're like,
- 6:12you know what, bear attacks are pretty rare. And so I'm going to
- 6:15do baby steps, and I'm going to start out with a little hike and
- 6:17then a bigger hike, and then eventually I'll habituate to hiking, and then
- 6:23I can get my needs met through hiking. I can get my relaxation,
- 6:26vacation, recharge, my battery needs through hiking. But I the only way
- 6:30I'm going to be able to achieve that is if I habituate to that habit
- 6:34if you will, by having my body learn that hiking is actually not scary.
- 6:42People learn as children how to get their attachment he's met. For secure
- 6:46people. They learn that they can assume that they are lovable and that others
- 6:53can be trusted. For secure people, when they were being when they were
- 6:58being raised, most of the time, they were being treated in a way
- 7:01that told them that they were good, They were a good kid, and
- 7:06that they were lovable and likable and good enough and capable and worth it and
- 7:12worthwhile and you know, important enough, not all the time, of course,
- 7:17but enough such that the child says, you know what the world is
- 7:20teaching me that I'm lovable and the world is also teaching me that I can
- 7:25trust other people for the most part, not all the time, but for
- 7:28the most part. And so when I walk around in the world, I
- 7:31have a style of relating to people that comes from that working model that you
- 7:38know, I haven't been told anything nice to me today for a little bit
- 7:41of time, or I haven't been shown today that my relationships are secure.
- 7:49But I know from past experience since I was born, that I can trust
- 7:55other people that even though I'm not close, even though there's no direct evidence
- 7:59of them telling me that they love me today, I can trust that they
- 8:03do love me because when I was a child, that's what I learned over
- 8:07and over and over again, was that love was constant, it was unconditional,
- 8:11it was stable. And so even though I don't have any direct evidence
- 8:16in front of me right now that my loved ones love me, I trust
- 8:20that they do love me. And I also trust that if I really want
- 8:24reassurance, that I can ask for reassurance or I can I can have a
- 8:30bid for attention or love by you know, texting my partner or saying I
- 8:35love them, or holding their hand, and I trust that they will respond
- 8:39well because since I've been born. That's how it's always worked out, and
- 8:41so I don't have a complex about reaching out. Okay, so that's secure
- 8:46attachment. Now. Of course, securely attached people as we call them,
- 8:50don't always have that perspective. You know. That's one of the falsehoods that
- 8:54often is learned by attachment theories. Somehow that for securely attached people, bowl
- 9:00they're always happy and they never get upset and they're never hurt. And this
- 9:03is just ridiculous. No one is securely attached to all the time. Take
- 9:09it for me. For avoidant people, they learned early in life that in
- 9:13order to get their attachment needs met, it's best to turn away from people.
- 9:16For them being vulnerable is they're hiking and being attacked by a bear.
- 9:22For the hiker who got attacked by a bear, they don't want to go
- 9:26hiking anymore. They learned that in order to get my vacation needs met,
- 9:31I cannot go hiking' that's just not a place to go. I need to
- 9:35go somewhere else to get my attachment needs, my vacation needs met, I
- 9:39need to go to Mexico. So for the avoidant people, they learned being
- 9:43vulnerable is bad. Do not be vulnerable, because although it seems like that
- 9:48might be a route to getting my needs met for attachment, it did not
- 9:52work out in the past. So let's just as a heuristic of rules to
- 9:58guide my life, let's not do let's not be vulnerable because because that will
- 10:03be bad for preoccupied people. It's they learn early in life that it's best
- 10:07to amplify one's needs to be ultra vulnerable, if you will, And for
- 10:13them to be temporarily separate is their hiking. For them, when they are
- 10:20left alone or when people aren't paying attention to them, or when there's not
- 10:24direct evidence of contact with other people, they that's their hiking. That's that's
- 10:30their bear attack. And so they run from being slightly separate from people because
- 10:39to be slightly separate for them when they were young usually ended up being traumatic
- 10:43for them, and so they learn that to avoid separateness, and so they're
- 10:48in a constant state of of doing one style of relating to other people,
- 10:52which is to be extremely vulnerable, to be demanding, and to seek closeness
- 11:01on a constant basis, because if they didn't do that when they were young,
- 11:03then bad things happened in the same way that for the hiker when they
- 11:07went hiking, bad things happen. So you avoid that and you instead try
- 11:11to get your needs met through only one way. So to extend the metaphor
- 11:16even further, it's probably best to get our vacation needs met in a variety
- 11:22of ways, particularly if we're going to vacation with other people, because other
- 11:26people are going to have other ways that they want to vacation and so to
- 11:31be routed into. You know, let's sort of take it to a severe
- 11:35case of let's say someone the only way they can relax is if they go
- 11:39to Baja California in Mexico, that they just have to go to Cabo.
- 11:46That's their only option. They everywhere else they just cannot relax. Well,
- 11:52now let's say you know, they live in Minnesota and they don't have the
- 11:56money to get to Capo, or it's the pandemic and they don't have the
- 12:03you know, the it's not possible to go there, or their spouse just
- 12:11doesn't want to go to Cabo again or something. You know, there's just
- 12:13all sorts of reasons why you can't go to Cabo. But because this person
- 12:18is so rigid on going to Cabo. They have to forego getting their needs
- 12:24met until they can get to Cabo, instead of being flexible to other ways
- 12:30to getting your vacation needs met, maybe just a day trip, maybe a
- 12:35road trip, maybe another place with another beach, you know, I don't
- 12:39know, Lake Erie or something. But the point is is that when we
- 12:46get locked in on a certain way, then we are limited in our ways
- 12:50of getting our needs met. And that's what insecure attachment does to us,
- 12:52is that for secure people, they have a lot of flexibility that can react
- 12:58to the situation. For insecure people, they're kind of routed into a limited
- 13:03way of getting getting their needs met. It's not entirely accurate way of putting
- 13:09it, but I hope you get my connection to the analogy. I'm always
- 13:13curious as to what I'm going to do with my analogies. But anyway,
- 13:18the other thing here is that for some people, they're a mixture. So
- 13:22to extend the analogy even further, some people like hiking, but only if
- 13:26the hikes are short and in nice weather. So if we're going with people
- 13:31that love to go to Mexico beaches, some let's say you have someone that
- 13:35look, you know, by default they love going to a Mexico beach,
- 13:39but they also like to vacation but hiking, but only if the hike is
- 13:43short and in nice weather. These people often go to Mexico beaches, but
- 13:48sometimes they also want to go hiking if the conditions are right to get there
- 13:52to get their relaxation needs met. In the same way, people can have
- 13:58a mixture of attached styles, where some people might amplify their you know,
- 14:03a preoccupied person will amplify their attachment reactions to get their attachment needs met.
- 14:07But occasionally they also like to avoid others, and they also like to get
- 14:13their attachment needs met by just avoiding other people. They like to manage their
- 14:18attachments and to manage their worries of rejection by just saying, you know what,
- 14:22I give up on life. I mean I give up on relationships,
- 14:24not life. And so that's another thing that people will say, Well,
- 14:31you know, I feel like I have parts of avoidant, parts of secure,
- 14:35and parts of preoccupied. I don't understand well. Research shows and anecdotally
- 14:43that people can be a mixture. It depends. Now for some I will
- 14:48when I talk with them, I will for myself if I was to conceptualize,
- 14:54and of course it's just a conceptualization. It's not like a blood test
- 14:56gives us a reality of someone's attachments style. But the way I conceptualize people
- 15:01is such that a lot of times I will say something like, well,
- 15:05after talking with you, even though you're framing it as a mixture, I
- 15:09would say that you're you're actually more this attachment style. And sometimes this happens,
- 15:16like, for example, some preoccupied people will say, you know,
- 15:20yeah, when I read the preoccupied attachment style list, I'm definitely that.
- 15:26But there are times in my life when I'm very avoidant, and so when
- 15:30I talk with them, they will tell me their story, I'll and I'll
- 15:33discover for my own conceptualization of them that I would say, yeah, I
- 15:37would absolutely call you preoccupied. But occasionally it becomes so overwhelming for you that
- 15:45you actually will just stop relationships because it's totally overwhelming. That's not avoidant style.
- 15:52Avoidant people are avoidant consistently usually, and in fact, avoidant is one
- 15:58of the most consistent stint attachment styles you'll find people because it's very stable.
- 16:04In fact, avoidant people tend to be very stable because of that reason.
- 16:07They just aren't affected by other people. They don't even notice other people really,
- 16:15because early in life they just neurologically turn themselves off to other people.
- 16:18And so there's a lot less factors, a lot fewer factors that will affect
- 16:23their mood and their life, and there there's so much more insular to themselves,
- 16:30and so they will They're suffering, for sure, but their suffering is
- 16:36more consistent over time. And so for someone to say, you know what,
- 16:42I'm preoccupied a lot, but I'm temporarily avoidant, that doesn't really fit
- 16:47the spirit of the concept of the concept of avoidant people, because avoidant people
- 16:51are are avoidant all the time. Now, it just depends on how you
- 16:56look at it. You know. You know, another clinician might come along
- 17:00and talk to that, my dog is barking at the mail person. I
- 17:07swear I go out whenever my dog's like this. I go into the living
- 17:11room and I go to him, and I'm like, okay, you know,
- 17:12I get it. Thanks for telling us that someone's outside. That's great,
- 17:18But we don't need the ten thousand barks. And you know, with
- 17:26the pandemic, there's a lot of deliveries these days, right, you know,
- 17:30food delivery and blah blah blah, and so the dog barking happens a
- 17:34lot. I mean it, you know, it's not a big deal.
- 17:37But when I'm recording, I'm such a I don't know what I say.
- 17:42I'm such a rigid recording person. I like the recording to be pretty good,
- 17:48and so whenever there's an anomaly, I get a little miffed. But
- 17:52anyway, I hope it doesn't bother you. All right, let's go on
- 17:55to another email. All right, This next email is from patron Yasmin from
- 18:00Copenhagen. She writes, is it possible for you to talk about emotional manipulation
- 18:06and how it relates to attachment? What is an emotional manipulator? How is
- 18:11an emotional manipulator created? What went wrong in the mother child dynamic that created
- 18:18a son that becomes emotionally manipulative in future relationships? And of email? Okay,
- 18:26well, so the first thing I'll say is that emotional manipulator is not
- 18:33a term in my field. I don't ever hear people. I'm guessing some
- 18:37clinicians talk about this, but it's an internet thing. I'm guessing there's a
- 18:42lot of material on the internet talking about, you know, narcissistic abuse,
- 18:51emotional manipulation, gas lighting, these kinds of things. And some people have
- 18:56said, I know Kirk doesn't like the word gas lighting. I don't not
- 19:00like the word gaslighting. I just think that it's overused. And I also
- 19:04think that meaning that it's used too broadly to describe things that aren't actually gaslighting.
- 19:11A lot of people are in relationships where they feel hurt, justifiably,
- 19:18and they're looking for some kind of I don't know, story or narrative to
- 19:23tell them selves as to why they got hurt, why they got dumped by
- 19:27someone, or why they got ghosted by someone, or why someone cheated on
- 19:30them, and they will look to the internet, and the Internet will provide
- 19:34these kinds of answers. It's like, well, you know you dated an
- 19:40emotional manipulator, that's what happened to you. You know you dated someone who
- 19:45was a gas lighter. You dated someone who was, you know, a
- 19:48narcissistic abuser, you dated them, you know, a malignant narcissist. There's
- 19:53there's all these catchwords. I'm on the Internet a fair amount, so I
- 19:56see this stuff too. And it it's not that these things aren't real.
- 20:02It's just that they're overused, you know. If if I don't know,
- 20:06but I'm guessing, if you did a poll of like, how many of
- 20:11your past relationships were either a gas lighter or emotional manipulator or a malignant narcissist,
- 20:18I would venture to say, according to a certain group of people on
- 20:21the internet, they would say like eighty percent of their as particularly men because
- 20:26this is sort of a sort of a women internet thing potentially, that they
- 20:32would say, but you know, men certainly do this as well, that
- 20:36they you know, this group of people on the internet would say like,
- 20:37oh yeah, eighty to ninety percent of the people that I've dated have been
- 20:41malignant narcissists. And that's just statistically not likely. It's likely what happened was
- 20:48a variety of things that led to the breakup. Maybe the person just wasn't
- 20:52into you. Maybe the person was immature, Maybe the person was had traumas
- 21:00of their own and we're being triggered. Who knows. There's just a variety
- 21:03of possibilities that are potentially present when we look at a breakup. Malignant narcissm
- 21:11and emotional manipulation as it might be conceptualized on the Internet. It isn't necessarily
- 21:18like, now, are there malignant narcissists, Yes, are their emotional manipulators?
- 21:23Yeah, there are psychopaths in the world. There are people who purposely
- 21:27try to hurt other people. Know, I've met these people, have treated
- 21:32these people. They're real, They're terrible, they're very destructive, and they
- 21:36can be extremely scary to be around, and we'll just create a wake of
- 21:41heartache and pain for themselves as well. I mean, that's the thing that
- 21:45people often miss about these these disorders is that for the individuals, they do
- 21:53not usually benefit from their disorder. People who have narcissistic personal disorder, people
- 22:02who have psychopathic personal disorder, people who are antisocial. Every person I've met
- 22:07and treated and heard about with these actual disorders are suffering tremendously, not only
- 22:14just emotionally, but also in their lives. Their lives are train wrecks.
- 22:17And so to just look at someone and be like, they hurt me or
- 22:21they lied to me, they're a psychopath, or they're a narcissist, or
- 22:26their emotional manipulator is you know, it's not a clinical term. Now you
- 22:30can say to yourself, I felt as though I was being gas lit or
- 22:34I felt as though I was being emotionally manipulated, that's fine, But to
- 22:40diagnose someone as they are this they you know, I have diagnosed my past
- 22:47partners as being emotionally manipulators. Well, now we're getting into clinical psychology world,
- 22:53and that's you know, that's where I'm gonna say, let's pump the
- 22:59brakes for a second again. If you felt as though you were being lied
- 23:03to, and if you felt as though the person treated you like a psychopath,
- 23:08or they seemed to be narcissistic in a way that harmed you, you
- 23:15are one hundred percent free to say that. That's not a diagnosis. It's
- 23:18not a label, it's not a it's not a judgment, clinical call that
- 23:22you're making about another human being. Okay, So when you know, when
- 23:26patron Yasmin's from Copenhagan says, you know, what is an emotional manipulator?
- 23:32I don't. I don't know again because it's not a clinical term. But
- 23:34I'm guessing what the Internet is referring to is you're with someone who tries to
- 23:42get you to fall in love with them by being very nice and will pursue
- 23:51you a lot and will make you feel like you're on top of the world,
- 23:56like you, you know, you you tend not to trust people,
- 24:00but this person really got you to trust them, and you over time fell
- 24:07in love with them and became attached to them, and then they just,
- 24:11for whatever reason, something happened and they just rejected you. And then you
- 24:15start to construct a narrative about them that maybe they never did love me and
- 24:19they were just manipulating me the whole time. I'm guessing that's a scenario that
- 24:25people would for themselves apply the term that person was an emotional manipulator. So
- 24:32if we're going off of that, I don't know, there's a number of
- 24:34other scenarios. But if we're going off of that, why would that happen?
- 24:38What you know, if you're looking back on a relationship and you're just
- 24:41like that person got me to open up to them. They seemed, you
- 24:45know, totally trustworthy, and they said a lot of things and then later
- 24:52did things that made me think the whole thing was just one big, massive
- 24:56manipulation. Okay, so why would someone be that way? Well, again,
- 25:00one is is that they did love you in the beginning and they just
- 25:04fell out of love with you. That happens and it's a hard thing for
- 25:08people to accept, and you know it makes sense, but I think we
- 25:14can all, I hope agree that when you just ask someone, say you
- 25:19just grab a random thirty year old and you're just like, okay, tell
- 25:22me about everyone that you thought you were in love with. You know,
- 25:26just list and really, you know, be generous, don't be conservative.
- 25:30You're like to go back to when you were ten years old, and let's
- 25:34go forward and just tell me everyone you thought you were in love with.
- 25:37And the person would probably rattle off I don't know ten people, you know,
- 25:41maybe a few. Some people would be twenty five people that they thought,
- 25:45well, you know, there were a lot of people that in the
- 25:47first few weeks I was thinking, well, I think I'm really in love
- 25:49with this person. Okay. Now often people will look back and say it
- 25:53wasn't really love, But you know that's just you now looking back at the
- 25:59time. If we asked you, are you in love, You're like,
- 26:00yeah, I'm in love. And you know what, if we told you,
- 26:03nope, not real love, you'd be like, f you, it's
- 26:07real love. Okay. So love is in the moment. It's you know,
- 26:11love isn't something we look back on. Love is something that we feel
- 26:14in the moment. So now, out of all those loves, so say
- 26:21you've had you know, five to ten moments where you were like, yep,
- 26:25I was in love, how many of those ended? How many of
- 26:29those loves took a turn and ended for one reason or another. Maybe you
- 26:34just got bored of the person, Maybe you fell in love with someone else.
- 26:37Maybe the person turned you off to a certain extent. You didn't you
- 26:41fell out of love with him. So we can all agree that a lot
- 26:45of love. In fact, perhaps the majority of the times we fall in
- 26:48love, it ends. The love ends. And so when that happens to
- 26:53us, when we are the ones experiencing someone else who fell out of love
- 27:00with us, it's hard, I think, for us to accept that,
- 27:04for whatever reason, they just fell out of love with us. But when
- 27:08we are the ones falling out of love, we totally understand it. I'm
- 27:12justifying it. We're just like, well, I fell in love because we
- 27:15just grew apart, or I fell in love because I don't know, I
- 27:18just I was in a different phase of my life. Or I fell in
- 27:19love because I don't know, I don't know, things just changed. I
- 27:22don't know why. I just yeah, you know, if it's your partner
- 27:29that you're breaking up with, ask you, you know, why did you
- 27:32say that you loved me in the beginning of the relationship. And you're like,
- 27:33well, I don't know. I did love you in the beginning relationship.
- 27:37Well why don't you love me? Now? I thought love was forever.
- 27:40You know, there's this whole idea of love us forever. It's not
- 27:41forever. I mean, in terms of the way people often use the word
- 27:45love. Clearly, it's not forever. And that sucks and I get it,
- 27:49and it hurts. And it's perhaps a more palatable narrative to say that,
- 27:56oh, that person was manipulating me the whole time, that person was
- 28:02evil. That person tricked me, and for some reason, I don't know
- 28:06why for a lot of people. That's a more palatable narrative. To me,
- 28:11A much more palatable narrative is they loved me. They had issues,
- 28:15but they loved me, and then they fell out of love with me before
- 28:18I fell in love with them, and I still love them, but they
- 28:22no longer loved me. But they did in the beginning. And yeah,
- 28:26they lied to me about this and that because they didn't want to hurt my
- 28:30feelings, but that was a bad choice. They should have just told me
- 28:33or you know, whatever the situation was. But anyway, but to finally
- 28:37your question, patroniasmen, you know what's wrong with the mother child dynamic that
- 28:41created a son? You know, again, we have a male here that
- 28:45becomes emotionally manipulative. So if I'm going to just say that someone actually is
- 28:52emotionally manipulative, Okay, So this person is Macavalian and their Dark tettrad stuff.
- 28:59They're narcissistic, can all likelihood, they're psychopathic and all likelihood meaning that
- 29:02they don't have empathy for other people, they don't have a capacity to care.
- 29:07They might even like to hurt other people. They might be sadistic.
- 29:11So I believe that's the dark Tetra had the Dark four narcissism, psychopathy,
- 29:17machiavellianism, and sadism. These people are extremely rare, by the way we're
- 29:22talking on the order you know, less than a less than a percentage of
- 29:26people who have all these traits. And you know what's wrong with the mother
- 29:32child or the you know what's wrong with the attachment dynamic of a child that
- 29:37would lead to that. We don't really know because it's always hard to study
- 29:41because these people are so rare that and they don't usually comply with assessments or
- 29:49they can't necessarily be trusted. It's a hard it's a hard job to try
- 29:56to look at this group of people and determine what's common about their histories that
- 30:00would have led to that behavior. The common wisdom is that it's partially genetic,
- 30:07meaning some people are born with a disposition in this direction, and also
- 30:12partially environmental. Every person that I know famously, you know, Jeffrey Dahmer,
- 30:18these kinds of people who have these traits, and every person I know
- 30:23professionally who have these traits had terrible childhoods, or at least something was particular
- 30:30about their childhood that was not ideal for their attachment. So we're talking abuse,
- 30:37We're talking abandonment. We're talking you know, drug addicted parents who had
- 30:42very chaotic lives. We're talking you know, parents that just leave their kids
- 30:48with other people, you know, all sorts of things, and that can
- 30:52often lead to what I would call an emotional manipulator. All right, let's
- 30:56take a break and we get back. Let's answer more emails. All right,
- 31:07we're back from the break. If you haven't become a patron of the
- 31:11podcast yet, that's how we know you like what we're doing. We get
- 31:15an email every time someone signs up, and it warms our hearts, particularly
- 31:18mine truly, So if you are a patron, thank you so much.
- 31:22All right. This next email is from upper tier patron Lara or Laura from
- 31:27Toronto. She writes, I've started dating again after a year long relationship where
- 31:33I was ghosted. It's been a tough few months as my anxious attachment and
- 31:37abandonment traumas have been triggered by the ghosting. How do I bring up my
- 31:42anxious attachment when dating? And at what point is it too soon? For
- 31:48instance, I get anxious when I don't hear from a date, as I
- 31:52automatically think they are ghosting me. I am seeing a therapist to work through
- 31:56these attachment injuries. At what point in dating is it okay to open up
- 32:00about this anxiety? End of email? Well up at your patron, Laura.
- 32:06I commend you for thinking about this. It's a wonderful thing to think
- 32:09about. You are aware of your your preoccupied attachment. You are going to
- 32:15therapy to work on that. I commend you, commend, you, commend
- 32:20you. And now you're dating and and you're recognizing it. You're like,
- 32:24I get preoccupied to get very anxious when I don't hear back from someone,
- 32:29and I automatically think they're ghost to me. So you are reflecting on your
- 32:34attachment reactivity in a differentiated manner. You're not allowing those notions to run wild.
- 32:40You're you're looking at it and you're thinking, I know what feels like
- 32:45I'm being ghosted. But there's no direct evidence that I'm being ghosted. It
- 32:50could just be that they just don't like texting right away, or they're busy,
- 32:52or maybe they're they're unsure if they like me at this point and we're
- 32:58just beginning to date. I don't know. Maybe they're dating other people and
- 33:01that doesn't mean a bad thing either. So you're doing that. You're doing
- 33:06so much great work, and I command you. And now you're asking when
- 33:09and how do I bring up to people I'm dating that I have anxious,
- 33:14preoccupied attachment. You know, when do I bring it up? And how
- 33:17do I bring it up? It's a wonderful question, and I encourage more
- 33:22people to think about this. I don't know the answer to question because it
- 33:30really depends on so many things. It depends on what you want to do,
- 33:35it depends on the people you're dating. But I will say that I
- 33:39could absolutely see and have seen a situation where say it's you know, date
- 33:46three or something, and you tell someone you're just like, look, I
- 33:51just want to tell you something. I you know, we're on our third
- 33:55date. I don't want to be too heavy about this. I don't want
- 33:58to freak you out, but I just want to tell you because I just
- 34:01this is this sort of person I am. I'm in therapy because I have
- 34:06had a lot of abandonment in my life. I was abandoned by my father
- 34:10when I was young, and I was abandoned by past relationships, and so
- 34:19I have this fear pretty much all the time that people are going to abandon
- 34:22me. And I've already had that feeling about you. Now that's not on
- 34:27you, and you've been great, but I just have this terrifying fear that
- 34:31you're going to abandon me. And it's totally unjustified. It doesn't it doesn't
- 34:37have any reflection on you. It has everything to do with my past and
- 34:44So there's two things I just feel like I want you to know. One
- 34:46is is that I have that, and so maybe you can take care of
- 34:52me a little or just consider that you know that I have that. You
- 34:57don't have to, of course, because that's my burden at this point and
- 35:00not yours. But the other thing is that I might actually become reactive in
- 35:07a way that I'm not proud of if you don't get back to me right
- 35:10away. Again, that's not your fault, it's totally it's totally my dad's
- 35:15fault for a bandon me. It's but if I text you and you don't
- 35:21text me back right away, all those traumas kind of come bubbling up.
- 35:24And if I don't have an appointment with my therapist right away, like I'll
- 35:28have a couple of days where I'm I'm in a bad mood and I might
- 35:34lash out at you kind of. I might actually when you do finally text
- 35:38me back, I might actually be a little snotty with you, which is
- 35:42totally unfair to you. And you know this, this is my burden,
- 35:49but I don't know. I just wanted you to know that because I'm in
- 35:53the past and dating, I would try to hide this and it wouldn't go
- 35:58well. And so you know, I just wanted you to know that.
- 36:00Okay, So you know, some people say, oh, that's kind of
- 36:05corny, and as I always say, if he if healthy is being corny,
- 36:08then be corny, because look, you live life, wants people,
- 36:13and why not live it honestly and why not live it in reality rather than
- 36:20trying to act like things don't exist, like your preoccupied attachment. Now,
- 36:23when do you do that? Well, I don't know. And honestly,
- 36:27if if if I did that to someone on a third date and they ran
- 36:32for the hills, then you know, f them. I mean if they
- 36:37can't handle, if they're not mature enough to handle a conversation like that,
- 36:39then I don't I don't want to date them. So uh, you know,
- 36:44feel free to say that on the first date, especially in the way
- 36:46that I said it. Right, you notice the elements were I explained it.
- 36:50I didn't blame them. I also said that it's not their burden and
- 36:54they don't have to deal with it if they don't want to, because they
- 36:58don't you know, maybe they're just like you know, I just want to
- 37:00day. I don't want to talk about anything deep or anything. You know,
- 37:02that's and that's fine. So, uh, you noticed that I gave
- 37:09them an out. I said reality, but I didn't blame it on them,
- 37:15and I gave them an opportunity. Now imagine if someone was like,
- 37:19oh my god, I'm so glad you said that, because you know,
- 37:21I'm kind of that way too, and or I have a different issue.
- 37:23I have my own things, you know, and I just I really admire
- 37:28that you, you know, bring that up, because that's just amazing and
- 37:30it makes me like you even more. Well, you know, marry that
- 37:35person. All right, it's going to another email, all right. This
- 37:39next email is from upper tier patron Audrey. She writes, I feel like
- 37:45I have this fearful avoidant attachment style based on some light research, and I
- 37:51want to understand it better. With my past relationships, I build intense emotional
- 37:55connections with people, rush into relationships, suddenly become confused as to how I
- 38:01felt, and eventually would cheat on the person and leave. I hate that
- 38:06I do this, and I don't want to keep hurting people that I care
- 38:08about. Can you help explain this phenomenon and how I can better? How
- 38:14I can do better when building future relationships and of email. First off,
- 38:19I commend your wisdom. You're taking responsibility. You have a lot of self
- 38:22awareness. That's fantastic. And the answer I have is, you know,
- 38:27therapy might be the only place you can find out And I know I always
- 38:29say that, but it really is the only way. You need someone that
- 38:35is an expert to explore these things with you. There's a reason why we
- 38:38have these experts in the world is because they are needed, and the personalization
- 38:45of that exploration is very important. As I said before, I'll work with
- 38:49people who you know, they're smart, they understand, and eventually we will
- 38:54get to a place where they very much understand their attachment style, they very
- 38:58much understand their relations traumas. But that does not change the fact that they
- 39:04will be in denial about it. Sometimes it'll be hard for them to remember
- 39:07there are relational trauma reactions that will convince them of old ways of thinking.
- 39:15And it takes years. It takes a long time, you know. There,
- 39:20It's not uncommon for me to work with a client and after six months
- 39:22they fully understand I fully assessed them, and they fully understand my assessment of
- 39:29them. And then begins the journey of really applying that and healing and experiencing
- 39:37new things. And it takes a long time. So even if I did
- 39:40somehow have the answer, it take a long time. But anyway, hypotheses
- 39:44to explore. Yeah, fearful attachment is one fearful avoidant or disorganized. Sometimes
- 39:51it's called it's maybe it's a maybe I don't hear fear in what you're talking
- 39:54about, But it's possible that you are experiencing fear and you're not aware of
- 39:59it, or you didn't or you just simply didn't mention it in the email.
- 40:01Fearful avoidant people tend to experience a fair amount of actual fear when they
- 40:08get close to people, just a real sense of terror that they're going to
- 40:13get hurt, or just an unnamed fear that it's hard for them to put
- 40:19a you know, a sort of a word to anyway, So I'm not
- 40:23really hearing that, but it's possible. I mean, definitely, insecure attachment
- 40:29is probably present. There's a flavor of insecure attachment and personality disorder that we
- 40:35call passive aggressive. Now in the common language, passive aggressive is used in
- 40:39a certain way. This is the clinical definition that was developed decades ago and
- 40:45is different, much more precise and much more comprehensive and much more I don't
- 40:51know valid, And essentially, in a nutshell you can listen to a whole
- 40:54deep dive on passive aggressive person I storting, go to a website, find
- 40:59out when that was. I think it was, I don't know, a
- 41:00few years ago. Anyway, you have to be a patron. But people
- 41:05who have pass aggressive personality for reasons related to their childhood early childhood, they
- 41:10will feel hurt and scared of people, as everyone does, and their way
- 41:16of coping with it is through passive aggression. They will they will have hostile
- 41:22motivation and then and they will express that hostility in a hidden or passive way.
- 41:29And one of the ways that some people will express that hidden hostility is
- 41:34through cheating and through leaving it. It's an interesting phenomenon that it's hard to
- 41:42describe well enough. But in a nutshell, say you have someone who is
- 41:46in a relationship and they have a lot of relational traumas growing up, and
- 41:52they're really desperate for closeness and it's, you know, on their mind a
- 41:57lot, and they enter into relationship, they start to establish some closeness and
- 42:04with that closeness comes worry about being hurt. Right, no closer you get
- 42:09to someone, the more power they have over you, the more they can
- 42:13hurt your feelings, the more they can devastate you. And with that power,
- 42:17when you feel that, when you have certain relational traumas that lead to
- 42:22passive aggression, and you feel that power that someone has over you even though
- 42:25they're not using that power in a bad way against you, if you have
- 42:30passive aggressive personality spectrum, then you will actually be very hostile about that power.
- 42:37You don't want people to have that power over you because in the past
- 42:39that meant bad things for you, and so one of the ways that you
- 42:43can strike back against that power is through hidden hostility, and a form of
- 42:50that is through cheating, And so that's another possibility. The other possibility is
- 42:53that you lack a connection with yourself and you don't really know what you want,
- 43:00and you end up being attracted to people and engaging in relationships that you
- 43:05actually don't really want to be in, and then at a certain point you
- 43:08cheat. But another way of saying that is that you never really wanted to
- 43:12be in the exclusive relationship to begin with, but you didn't really know that,
- 43:16and so by cheating, you're expressing this need to just get out of
- 43:22the relationship. That's another possibility. All right, Let's go on to another
- 43:24email, all right. This next email is from listener Angie from Sacramento.
- 43:29She writes, I'm hoping for some input regarding my eight year old son and
- 43:34attachment. My son has always been very sensitive and emotional since infancy. I
- 43:40have always made an effort to identify his emotions and reinforce those feelings and that
- 43:46they are, that they are okay and fine. But I fear that practicing
- 43:51this more nurturing approach has led to pacifying his emotional outbursts. At eight years
- 43:58old, he is still having fits when he feels misunderstood, or when he
- 44:04asks to turn off the video game, or when he is asked to turn
- 44:07off the video games, he will stomp, yell, cry huge tears,
- 44:12and find it incredibly difficult to calm down for a length of time. I
- 44:15have tried a few other approaches as well, like having him sit in a
- 44:20calm room until he is more calm, and then we talk about the situation
- 44:23and how his emotional outburst could have been prevented and expressed differently, but to
- 44:29be frank, I am not sure if any one of the methods I have
- 44:32practice is the right one. I want my son to have a strong attachments
- 44:37and awareness of his emotions, but I think he has reached an age where
- 44:42he fits, where his fits and temper tantrums are no longer age appropriate.
- 44:46Are there any emotional supportive methods to prevent or correct temper tantrums? I would
- 44:52so appreciate your input and truly respect your expertise and of email. Well,
- 44:58the first thing I'll say is I often say his p is complicated. And
- 45:00anyone who gives advice about these kinds of things and acts like parenting is not
- 45:06complicated doesn't understand what parenting is and has never been a professional who has helped
- 45:10people. I have helped hundreds of not thousands, of families with parenting,
- 45:16and this is a very frequent thing that have helped people with and one of
- 45:21the benefits of me having worked and you know I'm talking like working with families
- 45:25for years, right going to the home, sitting down with the kids,
- 45:29sitting down with the parents, observing the parents, advising the parents, talking
- 45:32with the other siblings, like just going around and round and one of the
- 45:37benefits that you have as a expert and professional with with my experience is you
- 45:43learn, wow, like, parenting is complicated, man Like, there's a
- 45:46lot of different nuances. And what a lot of simple minded people will think
- 45:54is that what worked for them works for all kids. And it's possible,
- 46:00but it's not likely. You know, what worked for your kid who had
- 46:05temper tantrums might not work for another kid with temper tantrums. It's just really
- 46:09really complicated. So I just want to put that out there. The second
- 46:15thing is that obviously get a specialist who will work with the whole family.
- 46:21I was a specialist and I didn't do this a lot, but I did
- 46:23enough of it over the first ten years of my career, going into the
- 46:28home, this sort of thing, and you have to find a specialist that
- 46:31will work with the whole family. There are quote unquote specialists that won't work
- 46:36the parents, which drives me nuts because how are you going to help the
- 46:40bigger picture if you just talk to the parents. So personally, I would
- 46:45find a family therapist who specializes in eight year olds who have behavioral problems.
- 46:52The second, the third thing I'll say is that temper tantrums are the worst,
- 46:58especially if they're chronic, and especially if they're extended into later childhood.
- 47:01It's very stressful. It could be embarrassing and heart wrenching. And no parent
- 47:07is you know, happy about temper tantrums. You one absorb their you know,
- 47:15just unbridled emotion. It's you know, it's hard not to absorb that,
- 47:19particularly if you don't have someone that you can pass. Best case scenario
- 47:23when you have an eight year old who's having a lot of temper tantrums,
- 47:25as you have like five adults, and whoever, whatever set of adults has
- 47:30the most capacity to do with that, they're the ones that step forward and
- 47:34the other ones take a step back. A lot of times, what we're
- 47:37looking at is a single parent with a kid like this, and that is
- 47:40not sustainable. You cannot parent a kid who throws these kinds of tantrums by
- 47:45yourself very well. It's hard to do so takes a village, particularly with
- 47:51kids who throw temper tantrums like this, So you end up judging yourself like
- 47:55what am I doing wrong? So you know it's and anyone who you know,
- 48:04doesn't you know, who looks at this is just like, well,
- 48:06I dealt with it with my kid in this really easy way, and I
- 48:08well, okay, fine, good for you. But you don't know,
- 48:13you know, by the nature of this email from listener Angie, I know
- 48:17she's talking about I've been there, and the kind of temper tantrums that I'm
- 48:22quite sure I would see if I were actually in the home are severe and
- 48:25long lasting and unreasonable and powerful and unrelenting and very stressful, and nothing works
- 48:37to stop it. And it it is. It's rough, you know,
- 48:42it is very very rough. And that's why it takes a village, because
- 48:46if it's that much stress, it needs to be passed around and shared.
- 48:51So some things to possibly consider are that his emotional outbursts are potentially within normal
- 48:57limits. He's eight years old, you know, people often will Everyone has
- 49:02sort of a different gauge of what is quote unquote age appropriate, and for
- 49:07some a temper tantrum at eight is normal and for others it's not. And
- 49:10there's no real way to measure that. I'd have to see it. But
- 49:15you know, it's possible that if you just ride this out another couple of
- 49:21years, it'll just go away, and that he just extended his temper tantrums
- 49:25a little bit longer than other kids, in the same way that sometimes kids
- 49:30develop language a little later, some kids learn to walk a little later,
- 49:35some kids learn math a little later. There's a lot of capacities that kids
- 49:39will develop over time developmentally, and not every kid is the same. So
- 49:45it's possible that it's just, you know, just normal and you're doing everything.
- 49:50The second thing is that it could be dispositional, meaning that it's not
- 49:53an indication of your parenting and there's really nothing you can do about it.
- 49:57You said that from the time he was born and he was sensitive, so
- 50:00that points in that direction. You could see it as just the way he
- 50:06was born. He's just very sensitive, very reactive emotionally. It's also possible
- 50:10that he suffers from a mood disorder, anxiety disorder, this sort of thing,
- 50:14and of course a specialist would assess for that, but it's also possible
- 50:16that it's just the way that it is and throughout his life. There's going
- 50:21to be pros and cons to being sensitive. You're experiencing some of the cons
- 50:25right now, which is temperate tantrums, but there are pros pros like you
- 50:30just really understand your emotions well or you pick up on the emotions about You
- 50:35might have a lot of empathy for other people. You might be very creative.
- 50:38You know, there's a lot of different pros to being sensitive, so
- 50:42who knows. But my point with that is that you know, a specialist
- 50:46might find that that's the conceptualization and thus, you know, just stay the
- 50:51course of their parenting. Because that brings me to my third thing, which
- 50:53is that your approach parenting wise sounds sound sounds good from your description. I
- 51:00can't tell. I have to observe it, but from your description it sounds
- 51:01great. You're helping him calm down, you're talking about emotions, You're helping
- 51:05him communicate his emotions in different ways. That's fantastic, you know, So
- 51:10from your description, I can't imagine changing that, Like what are you gonna
- 51:15what are you gonna change that too? And that brings me to my fourth
- 51:19point here is when I hear the phrase age appropriate, I get a little
- 51:23worried. Honestly, I don't know, but often that is associated with some
- 51:30sort of self judgment as a parent, or maybe even people pressuring you,
- 51:34like school people or I don't know, just other people pressuring you as a
- 51:37parent. I just like I don't think that is age appropriate. Now,
- 51:40there is such a thing as age appropriateness for sure, but we have to
- 51:45be careful when we go down that road because some parents, when they go
- 51:49down that road of like, my kid is having temperate chance rams that are
- 51:52not age appropriate, and thus I need to discipline the kid. That's often
- 51:57the what they're really getting at is you need to discipline this child. You
- 52:01need to not coddle them. You need to not just listen to their emotions.
- 52:07You need to put them in time out. You need to tell them
- 52:09that there's a limit. You need to tell them to stop. Now.
- 52:14As I said from the beginning, parenting is complicated, and I'm not saying
- 52:16that those strategies aren't going to work. Maybe they will, and that's what
- 52:21a specialist would experiment with you. I've done that sort of work with parents.
- 52:24But what often happens is that parents are doing great from your description,
- 52:31you know, just giving the kids space, having a conceptualization that the kid
- 52:37doesn't have any control over these temper tantrums, you know, just staying the
- 52:42course and just suffering through it as best you can, and not really thinking
- 52:45there's much more you can do. About it. Then an outside person comes
- 52:50in, a teacher, some of your dating maybe your parents, and they're
- 52:53just like that, that's not age appropriate. You need to crack down on
- 52:57that. And then parents will go, oh, you know, I need
- 53:00to crack down, and then they start to crack down, and now we
- 53:02have Now we have a problem. Now we have a kid who has a
- 53:07disposition of sensitivity and he is being ostracized and disciplined for something he doesn't have
- 53:14any control over. And there's a lot of examples like this, when kids
- 53:17have ADHD, when kids are highly sensitive highly sensitive people, when kids have
- 53:23anxiety, whatever it is, there's this knee jerk reaction from a lot of
- 53:28people that you need to discipline it. And I'm here to tell you that
- 53:31discipline does not take away sensitivity. You know, it's just it's just not
- 53:37going to happen. That. The key assessment bifurcation that I would engage in
- 53:42with families like this is does the kid have control? Because if the kid
- 53:45has controlled, then yeah, the kid is just manipulating everyone. The kid
- 53:50is retaining some old behavior that they've learned works with people. Usually kids don't
- 53:54want to do that. Kids usually want to grow up. They usually want
- 53:58to be, you know, a big boy who knows how to handle things,
- 54:00and so that's not usually the case, but but some kids will,
- 54:04because some kids will just regress purposely as a way of manipulating people around them.
- 54:08And you can usually tell as a parent and as an expert, I
- 54:13could usually tell after a while that, oh, that kid is that kid's
- 54:16doing it on purpose. You know, that kid is drumming up. Now.
- 54:21Now, sometimes they can they can, you know, manufacture an emotional
- 54:25state that they become out of control. But in the beginning they're very much
- 54:30manufacturing it. But that's rare and it's not it's not very common. It
- 54:34certainly can happen, but often what I would find is that the kid really
- 54:38had no control over what was happening, that they were not trying to do
- 54:43this, and that they might have some volition in the moment, but really
- 54:49they're becoming overwhelmed very quickly, and it's virtually impossible for them to control it.
- 54:55One of the things you look to is different contexts for this sort of
- 55:00thing. Does the kid only throw temper tantrums when he's at home and at
- 55:06school he's totally fine. Now, that doesn't necessarily mean that it's a manipulation.
- 55:12It could just mean that he's really just clamping down on his behavior and
- 55:15emotions at school, and then when he gets home it just it's just too
- 55:20much to sustain that level of clamping down and then he let's lose. So
- 55:23it's not quite sure, but it is a data point to notice, so
- 55:30you know you cannot discipline this sort of thing away. And it's a temptation
- 55:36that parents fall into, and I get it, but I don't recommend going
- 55:39there unless a specialist were to guide you in that direction. All right,
- 55:45let's go to another email, all right. This last email is from Patron
- 55:50Hondai Hondai Handy from Istanbul. Patron from Istembul says, I want to start
- 55:57by saying thank you for changing my life. I had a difficult childhood and
- 56:00had some issues in my life before finding your podcasts, I was desperately trying
- 56:06to understand myself. I've been in therapy too, but never had but never
- 56:10heard of attachment theory in therapy. I've listened to your attachment theory deep dive
- 56:15a couple of times. Now. Even the little I understand has changed a
- 56:19lot for me in my life. Besides that, you're open minded and non
- 56:22judgmental approach on things really helped me gain a perspective in life. So I
- 56:28don't know how to express my gratitude, so just chiming in here that warms
- 56:31my heart. Patron for MISSI Bull, that's super nice of you, and
- 56:36it is just incredibly humbling to think that I and you across the planet are
- 56:44connecting. That's fantastic going on with your email. I am a preschool teacher.
- 56:50Children are too dependent on their moms in my culture. In fact,
- 56:53most of them have never been away from their mothers until they start preschool,
- 56:58which is when I come into the picture. You can see a lot of
- 57:01crying children on the first day of school after a couple of days of talking
- 57:07and trying to convince them, and when I see the child understands the process,
- 57:12I start to give my attention to other kids and ignore the crying child.
- 57:16But when they seem to be interested in anything other than crying, I
- 57:21instantly give my attention to them, and this always works. I've never had
- 57:24a kid to keep crying a week after a week in my eight years of
- 57:31career as a preschool teacher. But now I'm wondering and the light of attachment
- 57:36theory, is this a healthy thing to do for these kids or what would
- 57:39be more helpful to them? Can you talk about that end of email.
- 57:45Yeah, as I said before, it's very complicated. It's largely dependent on
- 57:49what's happening to them before entering preschool. You know, what the attachment was
- 57:53like between the child and the parents, what's happening outside of school. So
- 57:57there's a lot you don't have any control over, but just kind of looking
- 58:02at your and I have a lot of experience with this too, because my
- 58:06mom had a daycare in my house growing up, and I observed my mom
- 58:09do something quite similar to what you're talking about, where she would get a
- 58:15new and all the daycare kids were preschool or younger, you know, they
- 58:20were two to four years old, and in my house, in my own
- 58:24house, and we didn't have a large house, there would be fifteen three
- 58:29year olds sometimes taking naps in my bed. I couldn't even go in my
- 58:35room and I got home from school, and so I really saw my mom
- 58:40right before my eyes every day deal with this sort of thing. You know,
- 58:45whenever she got a new kid, it was always a chance that where
- 58:51the kid would have a real hard time adjusting. Some kids adjusted well and
- 58:53some kids didn't. And my mom was just a master at being able to
- 58:58integrate the child into the system, and she was a master at making kids
- 59:06feel understood and cared about. But also my mom was a master at not
- 59:13letting kids get away with purposely regressing and ruining things her ruin. She was
- 59:21just very very good at it. And it's very complicated. There's a lot
- 59:24of nuances to this, and there's not anything I'm going to be able to
- 59:29say that is going to fully encapsulate like what one should do in a situation
- 59:35like this. But it's great that you're thinking about attachment because that is something
- 59:38to consider. You know, some kids develop insecure attachment in part due to
- 59:44their experiences in daycare in preschool. You know, when you drop off a
- 59:49kid at daycare or preschool, there is a risk of the child will experience
- 59:53that as an emotional abandonment and a lack of security there also, so just
- 1:00:00just that fact of being separated from one's parents can actually be trouble for a
- 1:00:05kid. It's always trouble, it's just a matter of to what degree.
- 1:00:07Right Also in daycare and in preschool there can be bad things that can happen
- 1:00:13as a result of interactions to other kids or the teachers or the daycare,
- 1:00:17daycare, day scare, daycare runners that can lead to attachment and security as
- 1:00:23well. There's a lot that we can say, but just a side note
- 1:00:29here. You know, we have a society and maybe in Istanbul as well,
- 1:00:34but the United States, I can speak to this culture that you know,
- 1:00:37we value money, capitalism, and working and it's very common for it
- 1:00:43to be assumed that pretty quickly into a child's life they're going to go to
- 1:00:46daycare. And this isn't always a good decision. Now, I'm not saying
- 1:00:52that women are should stay home with the kids. That's often sort of the
- 1:00:58rhetoric where this go. But it you know, we evolved as a species
- 1:01:06who were never separated from our family and our tribe. We you know,
- 1:01:10there was no office that mom and dad went to one hundred thousand years ago.
- 1:01:15We gathered food, we you know, did all of our cavem and
- 1:01:22things with the kids either on our person or nearby, and thus kids were
- 1:01:30never faced with having being separated from us. So it makes sense that we
- 1:01:36have to be careful about that, and we and we can't just give into
- 1:01:38a cultural norm of well, you know, to parents, they often work.
- 1:01:44I have a career I have to do, and so daycare is just
- 1:01:46going to be part of the thing. As soon as I can get back
- 1:01:50to work, the better. Now, this is very complicated. I'm guessing
- 1:01:52I'm triggering some people. Most parents will send their kids to daycare. Certainly
- 1:01:58most parents send their kids to to preschool, and many kids grow up fine
- 1:02:04having been in that situation. For sure. I went to preschool when when
- 1:02:08I was a child and really loved it as a kid from I sort of
- 1:02:14I remember it. I actually have pictures from back then, and I remember
- 1:02:16really liking it. Now having said that, my mom was actually at the
- 1:02:20preschool, so you know, maybe that helped me. But so I'm not
- 1:02:23saying that preschool and daycare are bad things, but I'm saying that it needs
- 1:02:30to be carefully considered in light of attachment theory. There's a there's a lot
- 1:02:34of different things to look at, which which I'll get into in a second.
- 1:02:38So really what we're thinking about our outcomes, and as a preschool teacher,
- 1:02:46you have this system that you acclimate children to the to the preschool and
- 1:02:52you say, you know, you really try to give the kid a lot
- 1:02:55of attention at first, and then if they keep crying, which they often
- 1:02:59do, then you give your attention to other kids. And when the kid
- 1:03:05stops crying and engages in some other activity, then you return and give your
- 1:03:09attention back to that kid. And you say, this always works. That
- 1:03:15you in your eight years, you've never had a kid cry and cry and
- 1:03:19cry and cry. They eventually give up on the crying and they integrate themselves
- 1:03:23into the system. So there are two possibilities, both of which you know,
- 1:03:28I just don't know on a kid by kid basis, but two possibilities.
- 1:03:31One possibility is that the kid this is actually a good thing that you're
- 1:03:36doing, and this is something that the kid needs to go through and that
- 1:03:40you're dealing with it really well. There is some wisdom to just turning away
- 1:03:45when a kid decides to cry and have a fuss. There you know,
- 1:03:50that does work sometimes and doesn't harm. The second possibility is that some of
- 1:03:55the kids are being harmed in that they're just giving up. There is an
- 1:04:00old tradition of just leaving your toddler in the crib in a bedroom and closing
- 1:04:04the door and you just have kids cry it out. Now, this is
- 1:04:09complicated, as saying earlier, because you know, some kids will cry as
- 1:04:13a way of manipulating, and they benefit from learning how to you know,
- 1:04:17sleep in the crib by themselves, and they benefit from learning how to you
- 1:04:21know, have some independence at a certain age. But there are other kids
- 1:04:25who this is just not good for or it's not good for their current stage.
- 1:04:30And I'll get into how to evaluate that, and it's very it's very
- 1:04:33complicated. But some kids, if you do this technique with where you turn
- 1:04:40away from them as they're crying, they might actually be giving up, meaning
- 1:04:45that they are concluding, oh, I can't depend on people, I can't
- 1:04:49depend on her, I can't depend on anyone. So I'm going to cut
- 1:04:54off myself for my feelings and I'm just I'm just not going to pay attention
- 1:04:58to my needs because is no one else is going to pay attention to me.
- 1:05:01There's a lot of kids who are left in the crib by their parents
- 1:05:05and neglected in this way, even though the parents are following what they believe
- 1:05:11to be the right thing to do, and the outcome is you know what
- 1:05:15they want. They want the kid to stop crying, right, they want
- 1:05:18the kid to sleep through the night. Okay, mission accomplished. But at
- 1:05:21what cost? Has the kid concluded that they just can't depend on you and
- 1:05:28they're just they just gave up on attachments That happens, you know, we
- 1:05:30call this avoidant attachment. So so it's very complicated. So you can go
- 1:05:36to daycare, you can go to preschool and things can work out. You
- 1:05:42can not go to preschool and daycare and things cannot work out. So there's
- 1:05:46no there's no guideline here of like, well, if you want a healthy
- 1:05:49kid, don't send it to daycare. It's not what I'm saying. What
- 1:05:53I'm saying is the following. These are the key things to evaluate, which
- 1:05:58are you know, kind of hard to evaluate, But these are the questions
- 1:06:00you have to ask because it all depends on the child's perception. As I
- 1:06:03was saying earlier with the previous email, kids are born with a disposition and
- 1:06:09that you know, they bring a personality to the table, and so their
- 1:06:13perception of the situation changes. So you could have three kids, you could
- 1:06:17send them to the same daycare and the same preschool, and do all the
- 1:06:20same things all three of the kids, and one of the kids could adjust
- 1:06:25much more well than the other kids because they're just dispositionally set up to deal
- 1:06:29with that. So it all has to be tailored to the child's disposition.
- 1:06:32So the questions to ask are is the child getting their attachment needs met often
- 1:06:40enough? Now? No kid gets their attachment needs met all the time.
- 1:06:44It's just the trauma of growing up. And I say trauma in a very
- 1:06:48real sense. You know, there's always you know, when I teach my
- 1:06:53students and some of them are kind of struggling with the notion that their parents
- 1:06:58might have made some mistake. I sort of release everyone from that notion.
- 1:07:02I just say every child has cried for their parents, and their parents didn't
- 1:07:10come soon enough. Every child was put to bed at night, kicking and
- 1:07:15screaming even though they didn't want to go to bed. Every kid has been
- 1:07:20denied things that they wanted, and I felt devastated that their parents didn't give
- 1:07:27them that thing. You know, every kid had. Any parent who parents
- 1:07:31a kid, you notice those moments where your kid is just really upset at
- 1:07:35you. But there's no way around it, right, You're just like No,
- 1:07:41you can't walk out into the street because you're gonna get run over by
- 1:07:45a car. No, you can't just wander out the front door, even
- 1:07:48though you really want to. No you can't have my cell phone because myself
- 1:07:54I need my cell phone. No you can't grab the steering wheel of the
- 1:07:58car. No you can't eat that thing because it's a rock and you'll die.
- 1:08:04The kid doesn't understand it. All they feel in the moment is just
- 1:08:08they're just being denied something and they're devastated. It feels bad to be rejected
- 1:08:12in that way. Or No, you can't sleep with mommy and daddy past
- 1:08:17the age of four, you know, like you're just you're gonna have to
- 1:08:20sleep in your bed alone eventually. You know. I'm not saying that's what
- 1:08:26everyone's supposed to do, but I'm saying that every kid early in life goes
- 1:08:30through some very difficult things. So what I'm saying is often enough is a
- 1:08:33child getting their attachment needs met often enough. Now, how do you know
- 1:08:39if that's happening. Well, it's hard to know, but you gauge it
- 1:08:43based on the kid. You know, a lot of parenting recommendations they'll say,
- 1:08:47you know, do this, and do that, and do this well,
- 1:08:50okay, but how do you know if it's working well. The only
- 1:08:54way you know if it's the best thing for the kid is by gauging the
- 1:08:57kid. This is what attachment's all about, being a tune to the kid.
- 1:09:00You have to attune, meaning you're tuning in to the vibes of the
- 1:09:05child. You're paying attention to their emotional state and reacting in the moment.
- 1:09:11You know, some kids are you know, sensitive and needy. They're born
- 1:09:15that way and they are very frequently needing you to hug them or to be
- 1:09:23next to them, or to pay attention to them. And another kid might
- 1:09:28just be born a little bit more independent and maybe a little bit more manipulative,
- 1:09:32and thus you don't want to entertain those manipulations. Anyone who's raised kids
- 1:09:38and been around more than one child understands that kids are different when they are
- 1:09:43born. You might not realize how they're different until they're six, you know,
- 1:09:47six months, twelve months old, but you see those differences. You
- 1:09:51might not know what those differences are going to blossom into. But you know,
- 1:09:56every nine month old child is different. Every nine month old child that
- 1:10:00I've met has already some behavioral traits and you can see it. So there's
- 1:10:05you know, being mellow, there's being curious. There's kids who are very
- 1:10:10interested in electronics very early. There are kids who have a lot of eye
- 1:10:15contact their kids. Now, there are things that the edges of that disposition
- 1:10:18when we can talk about things that are disorders or labels or something. But
- 1:10:24there's a lot of arrange in between there anyway, So does the child feel
- 1:10:29attuned to Does the child feel as though as they're experiencing the world that their
- 1:10:34caretakers notice them and respond in a way that helps them. Is the child
- 1:10:41getting enough attention? Is the child getting enough state, enough of a safe
- 1:10:45space to explore who they are and what their emotions are. Does the child
- 1:10:50feel like people care about them? Is the child protected from undue negative experiences?
- 1:10:57So this is all child child centered, right? It's not. It's
- 1:11:01not this is the way to parent, right, it's how is the child
- 1:11:06experiencing this? And that's a pain in the butt. Right. As a
- 1:11:12preschool teacher, you're like, I don't have time to get to know every
- 1:11:15kid and you know their particular disposition. I have to get them to fit
- 1:11:19into this system where I can't give them my full attention. I need them
- 1:11:26to realize they're a part of a crowd now, and although their mothers usually
- 1:11:30always give them an underd percent of attention, I can't give them that.
- 1:11:33And they just have to adjust to that. Now. There's some wisdom to
- 1:11:36that, for sure. Every kid has to learn that lesson at some point.
- 1:11:41But some kids are going to be able to adjust to that more easily
- 1:11:44and some kids aren't. Some kids already come to the table with attachment and
- 1:11:47security from their time before you ever met them, when you met them at
- 1:11:53preschool, and some kids won't. So it's it's kid by kids specific.
- 1:11:59So when you say that you have this system where you essentially ignore them while
- 1:12:04they're crying. Not in a bad way, but you're just like, look,
- 1:12:09you know, you can cry, you can sit in that chair and
- 1:12:11you can cry, but I'm not going to entertain. As soon as you
- 1:12:14come around and realize, look look at all the other kids. They're they're
- 1:12:16having a good time. As soon as the other you know, the crying
- 1:12:20kid says, oh, I think I'll I think I'll play like the other
- 1:12:24kids, And then you start giving them attention again, and you're very nice,
- 1:12:27and you know, and you look at that situation, you're like,
- 1:12:30yeah, that always works well based on that description, and possible to tell
- 1:12:33if something good or bad is happening now basic on your descriptions, it's quite
- 1:12:38likely that good things are happening, but it's also possible that bad things are
- 1:12:42happening, that the child, because of the disposition or attachment style they already
- 1:12:47bring to the table, is actually giving up and saying, you know what,
- 1:12:53all right, I learned my lesson. Don't be vulnerable, don't express
- 1:12:57your needs, don't even notice your needs, and fit in, and don't
- 1:13:01create waves, and don't you know, ruffle people's feathers adapt to other people's
- 1:13:08needs. We all know as adults, some of us are like that,
- 1:13:12right. Some of us as adults, believe that we don't matter, believe
- 1:13:17that we can't be vulnerable with people, have a hard time connecting with our
- 1:13:20emotions. Why are we like that, Well, because when we were young,
- 1:13:25no one cared about our emotions. People made us feel like we were
- 1:13:29worthless. People made us feel like we didn't matter, And innocent parenting or
- 1:13:34preschool teaching methods can actually reinforce that in some children. Now I'm not saying
- 1:13:41you shouldn't do this. I don't know. You would have to assess it
- 1:13:45on a child by a child basis, and it's a lot of amorphous assessment
- 1:13:49of you know, is the child getting enough attunements. It's hard to measure
- 1:13:55that. Like I said, not every kid is attuned to all the time,
- 1:13:58so what does that mean? And you can't even gauge their behavior afterwards
- 1:14:02is a good indicator either, because like I said, some of the kids
- 1:14:08might be, you know, behaving well, but it's only because they gave
- 1:14:14up on humans. So you know, it's just hard to note. Now,
- 1:14:17is it your job to do this? No, I don't think so.
- 1:14:20The parents job, And if there are indications of issues, it's hiring
- 1:14:27a specialist to help with that. So I love that is sufficiently ambiguous to
- 1:14:36communicate how complicated raising children is and that when something works, we might not
- 1:14:45know if it's actually working. Like I said, you know earlier, when
- 1:14:50you leave a kid, you know, you have a kid it's crying all
- 1:14:53the time and can't be can't stand being left alone. Well, all parents
- 1:14:58understand. Look, eventually the kids going to have to learn how to sleep
- 1:15:00on their own, whether it's now or later. Eventually, you know,
- 1:15:03they can't sleep with us all the time, and they just have to realize
- 1:15:08that it's bedtime and they need to go sleep. Okay, every parent understands
- 1:15:11that. Now, attach my parent teeing oriented people would say, well,
- 1:15:17when the kid is ready, and maybe that's when the kid's eight years old,
- 1:15:20that's when we actually put them in out of the room. Then there's
- 1:15:23nothing wrong with that either. But you know, there's there's there's a little
- 1:15:26there's room there obviously, and one parent decides, you know what, we're
- 1:15:30just gonna break this child of this crying. We're gonna put him in the
- 1:15:33room at the crib and we're just gonna they're just gonna cry it out and
- 1:15:38we're gonna walk away. Well, and at the end of whatever period of
- 1:15:43time you do this, you know, a week or so, the kid
- 1:15:45just stops crying. Okay, mission accomplished. You you achieve that mission.
- 1:15:50It's impossible to know based on that description I just said, whether that's a
- 1:15:55good outcome or a bad outcome, because you have to look at the child
- 1:15:58holistically. What happened to that child? Did the child just learned? You
- 1:16:01know what I can do things on my own. I don't need my parents.
- 1:16:04I succeeded, I slept on and you know, I feel like I'm
- 1:16:08a big boy now who can sleep in his own room. Is that the
- 1:16:11narrative is that the experience the child went through, or my parents don't care
- 1:16:15about me, no matter how much I try to reach out to them.
- 1:16:17They don't love me, and I give up on humans. So you have
- 1:16:24to be attuned to a child overall holistically to even get a sense of the
- 1:16:29answer to that question. You can't just apply a parenting approach to a child
- 1:16:33without checking in with how the child is reacting to that. And this really
- 1:16:39applies to a wide variety of parenting approaches, by the way, and this
- 1:16:44is why it's problematic when people who had good experiences with a particular parenting technique
- 1:16:51with their own kids just judge every other parent for their way of parenting.
- 1:16:58Like something that just drives me crazy is you'll be at at the grocery store
- 1:17:03and you know there's a you know, parents and their three kids are in
- 1:17:14the cart and they're pretty wild, right, They're they're making a lot of
- 1:17:16noise, They're they're picking up things off the shelf, and throwing it around,
- 1:17:23and the parents are, you know, doing their best to somehow manage
- 1:17:28it, and that creates anxiety around people watching this. And then some other
- 1:17:33parent comes up and talks to the parents and just says, like, you
- 1:17:38know, I noticed that your kids are out of control. You really need
- 1:17:40to discipline them more. Okay. This drives me crazy because it's possible,
- 1:17:45I guess that that's accurate, But it's also possible that the parents are actually
- 1:17:54doing the best thing for the kids at this moment, and you just don't
- 1:17:58know the bigger picture. You don't know where those parents are coming from.
- 1:18:01There's so many other possibilities that could be happening where if you knew the full
- 1:18:05story, you would agree with their sort of hands off approach at the grocery
- 1:18:11store. You don't know, You have no idea. Now, there are
- 1:18:14certain things that you can say that are very likely problematic. It was I
- 1:18:19don't know a few years ago, I was at a pizza place in Edmund's,
- 1:18:24Washington, just north of Seattle, and there was this parent who he
- 1:18:30comes around the corner with his young daughter. Kid was I don't know,
- 1:18:35six or something, and the dad was just having a very childish argument with
- 1:18:44the girl. It was almost like the dad was showing off to me and
- 1:18:47everyone else that was sitting at It was an out it was outdoor seating,
- 1:18:54and I got this impression that dad was like trying to show off, trying
- 1:18:59to I don't know, be a make it kind of jokey, but he
- 1:19:02was. He was arguing with his six year old child and his six year
- 1:19:06old and it was clear that this was an ongoing thing because a six year
- 1:19:10old girl was very adept at verbal argument with her father, and I was
- 1:19:18assuming it was the father. I mean, in all likelihood it was,
- 1:19:23I mean the very least. It's a caretaker, and in no universe can
- 1:19:28I imagine that being a good parenting approach to argue like a child for long
- 1:19:33speriit time, and I think it was aggressive and calling her names obviously,
- 1:19:40you know, like emotional abuse and so so there's a line. So if
- 1:19:45you see something in the grocery store that is beyond a certain threshold, then
- 1:19:47yeah, something bad might be happening for sure. So I'm not saying that
- 1:19:51you can't judge other parents, but there's a there's a much wider variety of
- 1:19:58potential good parents approaches at that moment that a lot of other parents might not
- 1:20:04understand. And as someone as I said, who's treated hundreds, if not
- 1:20:09thousands, of families and situations like this, I'm here to tell you there
- 1:20:13it's just hard to tell. You really just have to know what the bigger
- 1:20:17picture is for the family. I mean, just throwing out some possibilities.
- 1:20:21So you know, you have the situation the grocery store, the kids are
- 1:20:24out of control. It's possible that the parents just adopted these kids and the
- 1:20:29kids are normally completely out of control, but right now they're just kind of
- 1:20:32out of control, and it's a win, right And they're trying to acclimate
- 1:20:38the children to the world, and they're trying to acclimate the family to each
- 1:20:42other, and they're they're picking their battles, and instead of battling the rambunctiousness
- 1:20:50in the grocery store, they're allowing the kids to feel safe enough to express
- 1:20:56themselves. And so they're they're making that calculation. They're at the grocery store.
- 1:21:00That's a possibility, and there's you know, hundreds of other possibilities that
- 1:21:05might we might find that justifies what's happening in the moment. And also I
- 1:21:13just wish that parents in public were just kinder and less judgmental of each other.
- 1:21:18You know, it's hard to parent kids, and let's just take it
- 1:21:25easy on each other and not jump down people's throats anyway. All right,
- 1:21:30So that was me answering emails about attachment, and I did not get to
- 1:21:34even half of the email. So I'm going to have to do a part
- 1:21:36two. All right, tune and next time I'm going to do part two.
- 1:21:40And everyone out there, please take care of yourself because you deserve it,
- 1:21:43you really really do