Latest / Building Brand Gravity: Attracting People Into Your Orbit / What You Need to Know About Crisis Management w/ Dr. Lashonda Eaddy
Transcript
- 0:01There are three typical types of crisis, those with a victim, those that
- 0:05are accident, and those that are preventable. Learn about these and how to
- 0:09manage your trusts with doctor Leshanda EDI in the next episode of Building Brand Gravity.
- 0:22You are listening to Building Brand Gravity Attracting People into Your Orbit, a
- 0:27GNS Business Communications podcast. This is a show for communications pros across industries looking
- 0:35to gain an inside of you into industry influence. You're about to hear a
- 0:40conversation with leading industry professionals talking about the importance of building business impact through sound
- 0:46brand strategy. Let's get into the show. Hello and welcome to this next
- 0:55episode. I'm Steve Halsey, one of your hosts, and with me today
- 0:59is doctor Lesha to Edie. She has her PhD APR. She's an Assistant
- 1:03Professor of Public Relations at Penn's State, a senior research Fellow with Arthur W.
- 1:10Page Center, and much much more. Doctor Edie, Welcome and thank
- 1:14you for joining us here today. Thank you Steve for having me. I'm
- 1:18looking forward to this conversation. I am too, and you know, you're
- 1:22really in a pretty unique spot as we think about our profession. A very
- 1:26noted crisis history expert. You really focus on how you build a bridge between
- 1:33theory and practice. You've been really widely published, a frequent speaker on the
- 1:37topic, And yeah, I guess let's start there. How did you end
- 1:42up being a crisis history expert and what is it that really makes this such
- 1:47a passionate area for you? Well, I think i'll back up to why
- 1:51I'm in academ at all first, and I'll try to make it fast.
- 1:53But thinking back to my undergraduate days at the University of Tennessee Go Halls,
- 2:00I as a student, I was very passionate about the public relations, excited
- 2:05to get out into the industry. But I also knew that one day I
- 2:07wanted to be a professor. Back then, I thought that I would work
- 2:12my way up the corporate ladder, become a CCO or CMO, that my
- 2:16kids would be growning out the house, and then I would have, you
- 2:20know, be a professor as a second career. Well, as you know,
- 2:23things don't always go as planned, and so I didn't quite make it
- 2:28to that position. But what I what I was able to do was work
- 2:32in the industry for a number of years for some really great companies. Get
- 2:37some wonderful experience, and then once I got my masters and had to write
- 2:40a thesis, I even planned to go back into the industry then, but
- 2:45once I wrote a thesis, I said, oh, my goodness, I
- 2:46don't think I could write a dissertation later. I have to do it now.
- 2:51And so fortunately I was able to then get my doctorate, and once
- 2:54I did that, I was like, Okay, so maybe there's a way
- 2:57for me to still be in the industry, but to stay in academ as
- 3:00well. And so I'm really fortunate that I was able to find a kind
- 3:05of the sweet spot for me, which, as you were saying, is
- 3:07kind of this position where I really try to do all I can to bridge
- 3:12the gap not only between theory and practice, but also between academ and the
- 3:17industry, because I think that is more broadly kind of what the whole issue
- 3:23is, because oftentimes I think professionals think, you know, there's the old
- 3:27addage that says, oh, that works in theory but not in practice,
- 3:30and sometimes that might be true. But being on the academic side and knowing
- 3:35what the theories are and some of the work that's being done more oftentimes to
- 3:38not a lot of the theory and the scholarly work can actually help professionals and
- 3:44chief communicators do their job better. But I also think that us as academics
- 3:49don't do a great job usually of really getting our research insights and the digestible
- 3:54bites and sharing it with the people who can actually use it. You know,
- 3:59just because it ends up in one of the top scholarly journals doesn't mean
- 4:03that the people who can use the information other than researchers are going to get
- 4:08it there. And so for me, that's really what I try to do
- 4:11with all of my research. Even in the classroom, I try to help
- 4:14my students as the future public relations professionals of tomorrow. I try to help
- 4:19them see how the theories that I'm sharing with them, how the research that
- 4:23I'm doing directly relates to also what we're talking about that's happening day to day
- 4:29and the news, you know, the crises that we were seeing, So
- 4:30that hopefully when they get out of the Penn State walls, that they'll also
- 4:36start to incorporate some of that insight that can even just inform their strategy even
- 4:43more. And for the crisis history piece, the way that I got interested
- 4:46in crisis history is that there's one of the prevailing crisis communication theory just basically
- 4:54says that when a crisis happens, it's one of three different kinds. There's
- 5:00victim, which would be like an act of terrorism. There's accident that would
- 5:03be kind of like a technical malfunction, and then there's preventable, which are
- 5:08like intentional misdeeds by employees or just you know, share negligence. And so
- 5:14that theory says that people attribute more or less responsibility to the organization that's in
- 5:18crisis based on what kind of crisis has happened. And then it also says
- 5:24that there are certain intensifiers that can actually move everything up higher. And so
- 5:29one of those is performance history, which is basically the rapport that organizations have
- 5:33with publics before crisis happens, or is perceived to have with them. And
- 5:39the second part is crisis history, which in the theoretical sense means and organizations
- 5:44previous crisis. But I know that when other people outside of crisis history academics
- 5:50here crisis history, they think about literal crisis history as well. So that's
- 5:55how my research also bridges into looking at historical crisis like the Great Depression,
- 6:01the flu of nineteen eighteen, the polio epidemic, HIV age epidemics as well.
- 6:08To see how we can actually have insight even from all those years ago.
- 6:12That helps us today because I think oftentimes people think that, you know,
- 6:16if it happened before the advent of the internet or social media, that
- 6:20there's no use to us. Well, that's not exactly true. Like,
- 6:25yes, the challenges and maybe the communication landscape might be different, but in
- 6:30more ways than not, I think there's really nothing new under the sun,
- 6:34and so I try my best to show people that, yeah, well,
- 6:40and I think, you know, one of the things that's probably changed more
- 6:44is I would say a couple of things. One is the immediacy in which
- 6:47the information gets out and then secondly the ability to get it out so broad.
- 6:54And it was interesting as you were really talking about how you got to
- 6:59where you are, and that that professional experience I think is really key for
- 7:02doing that bridge so that as crisis professionals, you know, we understand the
- 7:09importance of strategy, we understand the historical context, and at least in my
- 7:14experience of close to thirty years in this industry, you know, I found
- 7:18that in a lot of times those sudden breaking crises are a lot easier to
- 7:24manage than the preventable ones that built up over time. And you know,
- 7:29you presented some really fascinating research I believe it was in Denmark recently, and
- 7:34it's called the trust factor, rethinking multinational companies and health organizations impact on public
- 7:42health and safety crises. And I want to get into the public health and
- 7:46safety part in a little bit, but what I thought was really interesting about
- 7:49that was this concept that you and the team are working on of trust erosion.
- 7:57Can you give a little bit of background as to what is trust erosion
- 8:00and how does that help practitioners try and understand and conceptualize how to deal with
- 8:05crisis. Right, So, firstly, I'm sure many I'm sure you and
- 8:11many others are familiar with Edelman's Trust Barometer. I think they've been doing that
- 8:15annual survey of people across the world for it, I think at least twenty
- 8:20years now. I don't quote me on that, but for a while now
- 8:24they've been doing this annual survey. And so for the past two years that
- 8:28trust parometer actually indicated that there was declining trust in government and health organizations,
- 8:35but an increased trust in business, which was surprising, I think to a
- 8:41lot of people. Maybe not Edelman, but I feel like everybody else was
- 8:45thinking, Oh, my goodness, what big business is who people trust the
- 8:48most? And so the team of researchers that you mentioned and I all thought,
- 8:54oh my gosh, we got to look at this closer, because who
- 8:56would have think ever that people or would look to business as the most trusted
- 9:01social institution. And when you put that in this whole kind of landscape of
- 9:07COVID that still continues to go on now, but of other like social issues
- 9:11that have been going on across the world. It's a really interesting time for
- 9:18that to be happening, because if you think about the COVID example, if
- 9:22a government and health organizations are not trusted but businesses are, then the people
- 9:28the experts that have the information that folks actually need, they don't have the
- 9:33trust of those people. And so then on the flip side of that,
- 9:37these multinational companies that do have this newfound trust, they also then have to
- 9:43decide, you know, are we going to continue just to be focused on
- 9:46the bottom line, which would be completely acceptable as well, even though we
- 9:52know we're the most trusted social institution now or are we going to take on
- 9:56this newfound role and actually see what, you know, what new role we
- 10:01need to play in helping not just COVID but other social issues because people trust
- 10:07us the most now, and so our team really believe that this whole kind
- 10:13of juxtposition of that created this ethical dilemma also for organizations that have to make
- 10:20that decision, because oftentimes, not only are they not equipped to really do
- 10:24that, they aren't the experts in it. And so what we really believe
- 10:30ultimately is that this whole trust erosion and this shift from those organizations and institutions
- 10:37that have the information that people need, we think that it's going to require
- 10:41some unconventional partnerships between multinational organizations, between NGOs and governments and health organizations,
- 10:48because at the end of the day, hopefully we all want to work towards
- 10:52what's best for the overall good of mankind of the whole world. But who's
- 11:01supposed to do that? And so I would say, and maybe I'm a
- 11:05bit naive in this belief, but I think that public relations professionals and chief
- 11:11communication officers are in a really unique position to really be able to move this
- 11:16forward because our whole job is to be aware of really all the things in
- 11:22the company, and where a lot of other functional areas working silos and don't
- 11:26really talk to each other unless they have to. Communicators have to be in
- 11:31the know about all of that internally. But also our boundary spanders and are
- 11:35the ones that are in the communities that are also keeping the ear to the
- 11:39ground and see what's going on. And so I think that we're in a
- 11:43very unique position where we can hopefully help our organizations move towards this you know,
- 11:48shared understanding and share goal of helping the overall public good. Yeah.
- 11:54And and trust is a really interesting thing in that you know, you want
- 11:58to work so hard to earn it, and once you earn that mantle of
- 12:01trust, you have to hold that mantle of trust. And as you said,
- 12:05really with the impact of COVID, when you look at the impact of
- 12:09changing societal forces and issues, when you look at the impact of very deliberate
- 12:16misinformation, it can be a very tricky spot to be. And one of
- 12:20the things I thought was interesting based on the work that the team is doing
- 12:26is really this concept of a trust erosion management system. To me, you
- 12:31know, really was a good example of what we talked about earlier of putting
- 12:35together kind of that that academic thought and view and the rigor in the study
- 12:41with practical systems or ways of working. Can you talk a little bit about
- 12:48what is trust erosion and what is the management system that your team is proposing
- 12:52for communications professionals. Absolutely, so, going off of this whole idea that
- 13:00trust is erosion eroding for certain industries but has been is growing in others,
- 13:07we are proposing a framework and basically what we believe is that trust erosion mirrors
- 13:15kind of the sole erosion process, where once it starts, there are certain
- 13:18things that you can do to mitigate it, but you can't stop it entirely.
- 13:22And so depending on how fast that erosion is happening, there are different
- 13:26strategies and different approaches to make it slow down that you can use. But
- 13:31if it's happening more quickly, then of course there are other means to stop
- 13:35it. And so when it comes to trust erosion, we believe that there
- 13:39are moderate weather factors that kind of contribute to like the gradual eroding of trust,
- 13:45and those kind of things would be like the misinformation that you mentioned,
- 13:48Steve or disinformation, but also historical crises and those footprints from years before that
- 13:56can kind of help to slowly erode trust. And then also the legitimacy of
- 14:03topics and of issues that might slowly be growing. Those things are what we
- 14:09would refer to as moderate weather factors that can slowly erode trust. But then
- 14:15we also have what we call extreme weather factors, and those are things like
- 14:20the increased polarization of our society and the increased politicization that really kind of makes
- 14:28people, you know, emboldened or enraged, and that can really make this
- 14:33whole erosion of trust happen much faster. We also believe that volatile social climates
- 14:39and social justice violations, political instability, all of those types of things are
- 14:46extreme weather factors that can make trust erosion happen much faster. And then we
- 14:52also have other types of crises, like there's an idea of like sticky crises,
- 14:56where you know, it might not necessarily be a races that only affects
- 15:01one organization and one industry, but has ripple effects in the same goals,
- 15:05for like spillover crises where the origin is in one place, but for whatever
- 15:09reason, it expands beyond and has a really great impact. And so all
- 15:13of those things are also gravitational pulls that are pulling this trust away from certain
- 15:20organizations and industries, but it's going elsewhere to those that are actually gaining trust.
- 15:28And so for that when we think about this whole idea of those weather
- 15:33factors, we also believe that the trust erosion process is cyclical. So even
- 15:39though today governments and health organizations are the ones that are suffering from trust erosion,
- 15:46that then those like multinational companies and business they're actually in a trust maintenance
- 15:52phase where their trust is an eroding. But we really believe that no matter
- 15:56where you are in that process, you have to be aware of your position
- 16:02at that time because there are different things that you would need to do as
- 16:06far as strategy is concerned to try to take advantage if you're in the trust
- 16:11maintenance phase or if you're in the trust erosion phase, that you would need
- 16:15to do to help rely on you know, industry or community partners and other
- 16:22external groups that might be able to help you get the information still that you
- 16:26need and hopefully regain the trust that is being lost. Yeah, I love
- 16:30the analogy of using weather erosion and whether it's you know, something that builds
- 16:37over time, or whether it's like a hurricane or a flood that really just
- 16:41comes in very quickly. I think that's a really apt way to help people
- 16:48visualize it. The other thing I think is interesting when I think about the
- 16:52flow of the trust erosion system, it's got multiple, multiple parts. You
- 16:57know, you talked about either trust maintenance or trust erosion, but it's this
- 17:03idea that when a crisis happens, or when you're in that situation, the
- 17:07cycle goes through phases of mitigation, redirection, restoration, prevention, preservation,
- 17:14and conservation. What I think is really interesting about that cyclical process is a
- 17:19lot of times when people come into crisis, they think, well, we're
- 17:22going to return back to normal, or we're going to return back to where
- 17:26we are. What I think is really interesting about that cycle is you're moving
- 17:32to a new place as you manage as you navigate through the crisis, or
- 17:36at least at least that's my take. When you're moving from a mitigation to
- 17:41redirection, it means that however you react to the crisis, you are moving
- 17:45the organization to a new place. And then I guess I would postulate you're
- 17:51moving your trust to a new place. Is that an accurate way to think
- 17:53about it? Yes, absolutely, and hopefully, I know for organizations that
- 18:00can happen faster, you know, because nobody wants to be down on the
- 18:06low end where they are losing trust. But yes, exactly, that's exactly
- 18:10what it is. And so I think it also can be optimistic to see
- 18:14that it's cyclical as well, because just because you might not have trust right
- 18:19now as an organization or an industry, all hope was not lost. And
- 18:23so what we're offering in those stages that you mentioned, Steve, it's also
- 18:30suggestions for how you strategize depending on where you are in this whole cyclical phase
- 18:36of trust erosion. And so I think that that really is key is identifying
- 18:41where you are quickly, but then developing a strategic mindset to figure out how
- 18:47you can move your organization out of that particular place if it is a part
- 18:52of trust erosion, but if you are in the trust maintenance phase, but
- 18:56also thinking about how can we continue to maintain what we have and to conserve
- 19:00it as well. Yeah, and one of the things I think I think
- 19:03is really interesting about, you know, as you think about the theory that
- 19:08you're working on with trust erosion and that management system. Really the concept that
- 19:14you're doing of using social media to study trust for more of an academic setting,
- 19:18and what I'm really intrigued at is, you know, the studies looking
- 19:25at social media because it's major channel of health information dissemination, it's a major
- 19:32channel of health misinformation. You know, quite honestly, you can capture some
- 19:37emotive exchanges, there's a bit of an echo chamber effect. But maybe you
- 19:45can talk a little bit about why you chose social media, how you're using
- 19:48that to really kind of gauge and track trust. And then I guess the
- 19:52second part of that is based on the success of really determining what are the
- 19:59lessons to corporate communicators or to cmos as to how they need to be instructing
- 20:03their teams to think about these social media indicators to help them manage trust.
- 20:11Awesome. So for the social media part of this study, we actually are
- 20:15looking at official tweets from WHO, the World Health Organization, and then also
- 20:22from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. And the reason that we focused
- 20:26on them for this particular part of the study is because they were issuing and
- 20:33continue to put a lot of health information out as the authorities or the respective
- 20:38authorities as far as health information goes. And so we know even the CDC,
- 20:45you know, admitted earlier or a few months ago that they had a
- 20:49pretty big failure when it came to communicate and regarding COVID. But we also
- 20:55know that this whole idea of decline and trust in government and health organizations,
- 21:00we need to figure out, you know, other indications of what we might
- 21:04be able to do from that perspective of those organizations can prove that. And
- 21:08so but this part of the study, we're looking at the sentiment in the
- 21:14day immediately following some key announcements from both the CDC and the WHO to see
- 21:21how people respond it. And we're really fortunate to have somebody on our team
- 21:25from a Star and Singapore and they have this machine learning that they've created called
- 21:30Crystal phil where they can look at sentiment and they can even look at certain
- 21:36discrete emotions that are that are being articulated through people's comments to those official tweets.
- 21:44And so we're in the process of analyzing that data too, because we
- 21:48also think that perhaps just like this trust erosion and cyclical that depending on what
- 21:55point we were in the pandemic, since that's what we're looking at for that
- 21:59particular analysis, that it kind of ebbs and flows, and so people's you
- 22:04know, anger or sadness or fear might have been at certain levels at the
- 22:10beginning of the pandemic and maybe tapered off and then maybe increased later. And
- 22:15so we're even hoping that we might be able to look at things kind of
- 22:18logically to see where there might have been dramatic changes in people's sentiment because that
- 22:25also can be connected to behavioral outcomes. I mean, not through this particular
- 22:30analysis, but it at least can give us insight and to say, you
- 22:33know, people at the beginning were you know, in a heightened sense of
- 22:37fear because of the unknown, and we don't really like uncertainty and unknown things,
- 22:42and so that might have been a prime opportunity to get information to them.
- 22:48But once they see that the guidelines are ever changing, it seems daily,
- 22:53and then there's been this big announcement, you know, two and a
- 22:56half years later that oh oop, so we might not have done a great
- 23:00job. Then let's look and see what the sentiment was regarding that as well.
- 23:03And so even though this particular study is focused on the health organizations,
- 23:10I still think that there will be lessons learned for corporations because just because the
- 23:15health organizations are the focus of this study, it will be a corporation later
- 23:22and it might be in a different context. But I think a lot of
- 23:25the insight will translate there as well. So when you when you think about
- 23:29how that that insight translates, I mean, obviously, a global pandemic is
- 23:33a really big thing that affects everybody in a broad shape and a lot of
- 23:38times with crises, depending upon the industry in the company, it can have
- 23:42a very widespread impact, it can be very localized in terms of the nature.
- 23:48So I guess one of the questions that I have, just going back
- 23:52to you'd mentioned earlier, like the typical crises of victim accident preventable with social
- 24:00media as a gauge, either as a crisis management tool or as assessment of
- 24:04trust, you think it would be equally applicable in all types of crises or
- 24:10is it does it lend itself a little bit more to something that's got a
- 24:14little bit of a longer tail to it. I think it really depends more
- 24:18on the organization or the industry that's experiencing the crisis, because depending on where
- 24:23the stakeholders or target audience, whatever term you want to use. I know
- 24:29some people don't want to use stakeholders anymore, but whoever you're trying to reach,
- 24:34wherever they are, I think is really firstly the thing to consider,
- 24:40because if your target audience, if your main demographics are not on social media,
- 24:45then no it's not the best place to look to see how to handle
- 24:48it. But for more far reaching crises like the pandemic, or we could
- 24:56think about even back to two thousand and eight with the the Great Recession,
- 25:02you know, if your audiences are there and if the impacts are far reaching,
- 25:06then I do think social media is an easy tool to look at,
- 25:10but I don't think it should be the only thing. So, for example,
- 25:12in the study that I just talked about with social media, in addition
- 25:15to us doing that analysis, we're also completing interviews with CCOs from all over
- 25:21the world right now to really delve into this whole idea of trust erosion to
- 25:26make sure that we get insight from the boots on the ground to hear that
- 25:30yes, this is how it happens, and maybe you know ideally this could
- 25:36happen, but here are the reasons that we think it might be a challenge.
- 25:38And so I think in whatever the crisis is, whether it's a big
- 25:45spillover crisis like the pandemic is, or if it's more more unique or not
- 25:52more unique, but if it's smaller scale, but maybe impact in the whole
- 25:56industry versus the whole world, I still think is a really important consideration.
- 26:00So we can't put all our eggs in the social media basket, but we
- 26:04definitely should use it when we can, and from a researcher perspective. Fortunately,
- 26:11I don't know how long this will last, but the Twitter api is
- 26:15fairly open and so it really lends itself to research like that versus some of
- 26:22the other social media platforms that we don't have the same access to. Who
- 26:26knows if that will continue with the recent leadership change at Twitter, but it
- 26:33gives a really good opportunity to at least get some insight in some direction and
- 26:38how we might go with even other students. Well, well, I hope
- 26:42that that api stays open and that the users stay there to allow that to
- 26:48be a good tool for study, both for an academic standpoint and from corporations
- 26:53looking to manage trust and their reputation and issues. And you know, since
- 27:00we mentioned Twitter, I don't want to put you too much on the spot,
- 27:03but to me, they strike me as a really good example of a
- 27:07multinational company that's dealing with some serious trust erosion. So based on your kind
- 27:12of system, what what advice do you have or where are they in the
- 27:18cycle? Has the bottom fallen out or are we still going to be honest?
- 27:23And I don't even know if I should say this, but as soon
- 27:26as Elon Musk became a part of the conversation for me, the trust was
- 27:30already leaving because we know that and I don't know, I haven't done my
- 27:37research recently, but we know that he basically cut his public relations department,
- 27:41he eliminated it. And so I don't know if that was maybe two or
- 27:45three years ago, but fairly recently. And when I saw that happen with
- 27:51him, when I saw him do that, I had flashbacks too when I
- 27:55was an undergraduate student and when I was learning how we had to make sure
- 27:59we could demaged that we were of value at it because we could be on
- 28:02the chopping block at any moment, and I really thought that we had grown
- 28:07from that as an industry as a field. But when he did that,
- 28:11I was thinking, you know, oh boy, if he continues to have
- 28:15success, then I don't want other organizations to follow suit. So whenever I
- 28:21saw his name after that, he already had lost credibility with me. Anyways,
- 28:26because I know how valuable strategic communication, public relations, all of that
- 28:32is, and so for him to basically say we don't need it, I
- 28:36really question that. So now with him being in control of Twitter, I
- 28:41just I really don't know, and early indication is that it's not looking great,
- 28:48and so I think as an industry we have to have conversations about what
- 28:53that really means. From not only or I would say primarily, I think
- 28:59the ethical perspective, because like you mentioned, you know, misinformation or disinformation
- 29:06that now is going to be more readily available, and people being able to
- 29:11purchase, you know, the blue check and that kind of thing. I
- 29:14think all of those things are huge red flags of where it might be going.
- 29:19Of course, I don't have a crystal ball, so I can't predict
- 29:22it, but I do think that as communicators, we already should be even
- 29:29before these things, actually before the transition actually happened. As soon as we
- 29:33saw that this was a possibility and this deal was on the books and in
- 29:38the works, hopefully we were at least having conversation amongst ourselves about what that
- 29:44might mean for us as a profession and if not, shame on us,
- 29:48and we need to get on it right now. Yeah, I definitely think
- 29:52this is an area where there's going to be a lot of all of discussion,
- 29:56and it's you know, and you know is going to be about you
- 30:00know, big concepts, but also some of the nuances of you know,
- 30:06how can you have an open public square where voices can be heard, which
- 30:10is very different from somebody walking into a crowded theater and screaming fire. I
- 30:15mean, they're they're they're very different things. So, like you said,
- 30:18I think as an industry, this is going to be a very interesting ethical
- 30:22decision and also just in counseling clients, whether you know, to continue to
- 30:29support the platform, to use the advertising. It is certainly going to be
- 30:33something that's going to going to evolve over time. So what about somebody who's
- 30:38doing it right? Are there are there good examples that you've seen or best
- 30:44practices that you would really like to point our listeners to to say, Hey,
- 30:48if you want to understand how somebody's done it right, this is a
- 30:51good example. Absolutely. So I always like to start with Ben and Jerry's
- 30:56because I think in this whole kind of social Oh, I'm sorry, I
- 31:00got to interrupt you. My absolute favorite American Dream without a doubt, my
- 31:04favorite Ben and Jerry's flavor vanilla caramel crunch, a little swirl o good stuff.
- 31:11I have to check that one out. I wasn't familiar with it,
- 31:15but it sounds like it would be my favorite team. So I'm gonna have
- 31:18to look for it next time I go shopping. Yeah, Jerry, you
- 31:22can send me my check. Yeah, they endorsement of you. Yeah.
- 31:26I think it was originally created for Stephen Colbert when he was doing the parody
- 31:33show. But sorry, American Dream, my all time favorite Ben and Jerry.
- 31:36So I'm sorry, doctor Edie. You said that they are an example
- 31:40of a company that's doing it right other than Delicious ice Cream. How are
- 31:44they getting their columns right? I think so because you know, people think
- 31:48that this whole idea of like social justice, social advocacy CSR is fairly new,
- 31:56but Ben and Jerry's has founded and has always been in the business of
- 32:00helping make the world a better place. And so I can't remember exactly what
- 32:05their home mission is, but I know it has something to do with basically
- 32:10making the world better through ice cream, and I know that that's literal,
- 32:15but also you know, figuratively speaking, they do that. And so I
- 32:20think that they are the exemplar when it comes to companies who are sure and
- 32:25solid and what their purpose is and then they actually live and act by it,
- 32:30because I think in our current climate, a lot of organizations you know,
- 32:36end up being performative and a lot of their initiatives and what they do,
- 32:38and I think it's because they forget to first rely on what their purpose
- 32:43is. And so I think that that Ben and Jerry's has been doing it
- 32:46great for a long time. And another company that I think more recently,
- 32:51I would say, you know, in the past decade or so that has
- 32:53really been making great strides, and that is Target. And you know,
- 32:58they did have maybe back in twenty seventeen around that time a slight mishap,
- 33:04I would say, where they were talking about, you know, the bathroom
- 33:07bills and that kind of thing, and I would, you know, I
- 33:09wonder, why would they insert themselves into this conversation if they even if they've
- 33:15already had that policy in their dressing rooms for years prior, why would they
- 33:21try to insert themselves in that conversation now? And I have no internal perspective
- 33:25at all, but I'm thinking that perhaps they really had some really great intentions
- 33:31and maybe just didn't have the right people around the table at that time to
- 33:36say, hey, let's take a step back to see if really we should
- 33:39be inserting ourselves into this conversation versus you know, possibly being prepared to respond
- 33:45about our policy if we are asked. And so that I would say was
- 33:51not the greatest moment for them. But since then, when it comes to
- 33:54like examples of making sure that their initiatives are not falling flat because they're they're
- 34:01not being performative, I think they're really great with how authentic and how strategic
- 34:07they've been with incorporating diverse perspectives and making sure that they actually have a seat
- 34:14at their table. Even as a consumer, I think it's really clear anytime
- 34:17I walk into a Target store, whatever observance is going on right now,
- 34:22I can tell that it's you know, they've been strategic and how they do
- 34:28that. There have been some other examples. I won't mention the companies where
- 34:31they slap a label on it and think that because it says Juneteenth that people
- 34:37are gonna be happy and we're gonna hold hands and seeing Komvayyad and it really
- 34:40it can't work that way, and I think more than one company has seen
- 34:45that. But Target really puts in the time and the effort and even for
- 34:50the different observances that they have. You know that they sell things for they
- 34:57show how they actually are investing. They they talk about the process involved and
- 35:01selecting what they are carrying for those different observances. And so I really think
- 35:07that intentional effort to show that not only are we talking the talk, we're
- 35:13also walking the walk, so that what we do is not performative. I
- 35:15think that's game changing and I think that more companies need to do that.
- 35:21But at the end of the day, it has to be about organizational purpose.
- 35:25And so anything that our company does, whether it's related to you know,
- 35:31proactive crisis management, responding to crises, but also deciding how and if
- 35:37they might respond to the different social justice issues that might come up. Purpose
- 35:44has to be the guiding light, has to be the compass for how they
- 35:47decide if and when they're going to talk about it and what that looks like.
- 35:52And lastly, I will say Southwest is a really great example internally of
- 35:58that as well, because when it comes to these social issues that can just
- 36:04bubble up sometimes out of nowhere, when you're a big company like Southwest,
- 36:08you know, moving that big ship and being able to respond timely can be
- 36:13really difficult because there's so much red tape. And so I have a lot
- 36:16of respect and admiration for them because once they realized that this was potentially going
- 36:21to be an issue that was going to continue to come up, they really
- 36:24spent the time between crises or between these social justice issues to develop a system
- 36:31internally and to vet it up the chain to make sure that we have a
- 36:37very fluid and live way where we can answer certain questions and make sure that
- 36:43if we are going to respond to something and if we decide to respond to
- 36:46it, that ultimately is still supporting what our overall purpose and kind of what
- 36:52their strategic pillars are. And so I think that was brilliant on their behalf
- 36:57on their part because when it comes, you don't have time often to work
- 37:02and vet everything up the ladder, because that could take days or weeks,
- 37:07and we know, because of social media and because of changing expectations of stakeholders,
- 37:14we don't have that kind of time always in silence, even if we
- 37:17are behind the scenes doing the work to get a response or to make a
- 37:22statement. Time is of the essence, and so I think more companies need
- 37:27to look for ways to have processes like that in place so that they can
- 37:30equip their chief communication officers and their chief communicators and be able to respond timely,
- 37:37but also to make sure that it's more than just you know, that
- 37:43performative saying the right thing when we know we can't actually back it up.
- 37:47Yeah. I couldn't agree more that it comes down to really having clarity of
- 37:52purpose and being true to that, because that's really when you get those key
- 37:55points that you talked about, the authenticity, having the right counselors in place
- 38:01to give the strategic advice, and to be very intentional, as you mentioned,
- 38:07when you want to insert yourself in the conversation or determine when you want
- 38:10to pull back and look at when you're asked, and then through it all
- 38:15understanding the importance of really needing to communicate with employees because they are they are
- 38:21your company, they are your brand, They're at the center of it.
- 38:23Well, this has been absolutely a fascinating discussion, and I could I could
- 38:29spend the entire day talking through these But but I guess as we get ready
- 38:34to close here, you know, thinking about all the things we discussed today,
- 38:37thinking about all the conversations you're having with global CCOs, what advice do
- 38:44you have for senior communicators? What is it that they need to think about.
- 38:49Top three lessons about trust or crisis management that they should really get out
- 38:55of sticky tab right down, these are the three things that that Professor Edie
- 39:01says, I really need to think about to be better at counseling and doing
- 39:06my job. Well. Firstly, I would say, regarding trust erosion or
- 39:10trust maintenance, it would be to first identify where you are and use whatever
- 39:16tools you have available to you to determine that you know larger companies. I'm
- 39:22sure I'm monitoring that on a regular basis, but I know everyone doesn't have
- 39:28that availability. But listening to stakeholders and doing research as much as you can
- 39:35to find out where you actually stand so that then you can move forward and
- 39:38try to look for ways externally to create partnerships if you see that you are
- 39:45not very trusted, but then also look for ways to maintain it if trust
- 39:49is not a problem for you right now. So that would be the first
- 39:52thing. The second thing would be purposed. Like I was just talking about,
- 39:57I think that it seems so obvious that organization should be using their purpose,
- 40:02you know, as a god in light. But I think that sometimes
- 40:07common sense is not common in things that we think are obvious, they're not.
- 40:10And so I would just say, really across the board, making sure
- 40:15that everything that's happening as an organization is rooted and grounded in the overall organizational
- 40:21purpose is essential. But that goes down to, you know, from an
- 40:24internal cultural perspective. So your employees not only need to know what your mission
- 40:30and purpose is, they need to see it demonstrate it. Like if the
- 40:32organization doesn't demonstrate and doesn't have a culture that is in alignment with what it
- 40:38espouses to have as a purpose and a mission, then that's a big problem
- 40:44because employees are your number one asset, because without your employees, nothing happens.
- 40:52And then if you do determine that there's this kind of disalignment between those
- 40:58things, you have to do all you can to improve that culture, because
- 41:00if that doesn't happen, then I think it is definitely a course towards a
- 41:07bigger crisis when the culture is not there to back up what's being said.
- 41:13And so then lastly, what I would say is in this day, I
- 41:16talked a lot here at the end about this whole idea of like social justice
- 41:21and companies having to be a part of those conversations that you know, ten
- 41:25twenty years ago they wouldn't have touched with a ten foot poll. Well,
- 41:30that that time has changed now, and so I really think chief communicators,
- 41:35if they aren't on that boat, they need to start to talk to other
- 41:39parts of the c suite to let them know it's not a matter of if
- 41:45we'll ever have to deal with these things and speak about them, it's a
- 41:47matter of when. And so in order for us to handle it well,
- 41:52we need to proactively be looking at this. And I know that back to
- 41:55the whole culture conversation, that depending on the culture, that may or may
- 42:00not be easy. You know, that might be a really heavy lift and
- 42:05a tall order for a chief communicator to be able to say that, But
- 42:08at the end of the day, there's this whole idea. We have corporate
- 42:13social advocacy and responsibility from an organizational perspective, but at the individual level,
- 42:19there's also what we would call more entrepreneurship, which basically is kind of see
- 42:23us say, see us are, but in the individual ability. And so
- 42:29we need leaders that I'm more entrepreneurs and that are given the leeway to be
- 42:35that person to say, hey, this might sound like a good idea,
- 42:38but for these reasons, especially rooted in our purpose and for whatever else is
- 42:43going on in the internal and external terrain, this is why we shouldn't do
- 42:47it. And so I think that those companies that can have this whole kind
- 42:52of culture of openness that allows the chief communicator to also be the ethical compass
- 42:59and the you know, to offer expertise in these sort of situations that we
- 43:05really haven't had to deal with before. I think those are the companies that
- 43:08are going to do really great and that aren't going to be the ones doing
- 43:13the performative work, and that people are going to recognize actually serious about making
- 43:20you know, impactful changes that last for a long time. Yeah, that's
- 43:23that's that's really powerful, uh guidance you know, to really making sure you're
- 43:29making most of the available tools, using purpose as your guiding light. Realizing
- 43:35it's no longer a matter of if, it's when you're going to need to
- 43:37communicate on these key issues creating the processes and culture of openness. I think
- 43:44is is tremendous advice. So doctor Edie, thank you so much for joining
- 43:50us on Building Brand Gravity. For those of you listening, I would strongly
- 43:54suggest that if you like what you've heard today, to reach out to doctor
- 43:59Edie. She's a very well known public speaker, so she could be available
- 44:06for that. I'm sure she'd be happy to talk to you to give advice
- 44:10and counsel. And she's also a really noted author. So Doctor Edie,
- 44:15it was an absolute pleasure. Thank you so much for sharing your perspective with
- 44:21us today. Thank you for having me wonderful and if you like what you're
- 44:24hearing, we invite you to follow and subscribe to Building Brand Gravity. Thank
- 44:30you very much and have a great day. You are listening to Building Brand
- 44:39Gravity attracting people into your orbit. A GNS Business Communications podcast. This is
- 44:46a show for communications pros across industries looking to gain an inside of you into
- 44:52industry influence. You're about to hear a conversation with leading industry professionals talking about
- 44:59the importance of building business impact through sound brand strategy. Let's get into the show.