Latest / Unforbidden Truth / A conversation with Seattle mass shooter Naveed Haq: Live feed
Transcript
- 0:16Hey, good afternoon. How you doing. Hey good, I'm doing Yeah,
- 0:22I'm doing pretty good. Yeah, we can hear you. We can
- 0:23hear you. We're live right now. Uh. This, so I want
- 0:27to introduce you to my friends Amy and Jennifer. Hi there, Hi,
- 0:36I'm Amy, I'm jen And we also have two other people on here named
- 0:41Tiff and Marissa as well. Tip's my line rater for right now, so
- 0:46that everybody will behave Yeah. No, no, if you need any additional
- 0:50mind so, I'm more than willing to assess if needed. Okay, thank
- 0:54you. Yeah, So, Navid, this is a five minute call right
- 0:57then after that it'll be fifteen minutes. No, no, this is okay
- 1:03because they said you have a free call, so I thought that it was
- 1:04one of those three five minute calls. No, no, it's a prepete
- 1:10I'm using okay, okay, all right, thank you. You don't have
- 1:14to. I have money on my account, but you don't have to.
- 1:15When you call back, I might as want to use it behind because I'm
- 1:21comfortable with that. Okay, all right, cool? Cool, So Navid,
- 1:27to start us off, before you read your statement, can you give
- 1:30a little background on your case, like maybe like a two minute background on
- 1:34what happened when you were convicted, what you were sentenced to, so on
- 1:38and so forth. Yeah, I have an introduction, you can I yeah.
- 1:46Does that sum up the crimes too? Yeah? Yeah, that's fine,
- 1:53all right. The mental health system being broken in our country. My
- 1:57diagnosis is the scape the penalty spectrum. A contributor to my shooting was being
- 2:06prescribed A hand to the depresidant affects her, which can induce psychosis uter our
- 2:12pieces hand mcdall, it moved stabilizer which can talk suicide ideation along with effects
- 2:20her. Hello, my name is de beat Hawk. First of all,
- 2:23I would like to apologize to the people I armed, after the Jewish community.
- 2:30I especially want to apologize to Miss Pamela Lector's family. She's the woman
- 2:35who died in my shooting. Affects her is a powerful and a depressant that
- 2:39what needs to meet psychosis. Over the course of the year preceding the shooting,
- 2:46I deteriorated at that time and the medication has contributed to my actions.
- 2:52I became de lesional and the whole thing was a big suits that attempt talked
- 2:57by both of them mcdall and effects her I did not expect to live through
- 3:00the crime. I'm not an extremist, I'm a person suffering from midduliless reason
- 3:07why I chose the Jewish Federation of Greater Seattle as an ultimook tugget was because
- 3:14there was a war going on in the Middle East in two thousand and six.
- 3:20In I respect, the Jewish Federation was doing a walk for Israel as
- 3:24a peaceful protest, and I should have done a peaceful counter protest. I
- 3:30should not have broad guns to the Jewish Federation's office. However, the offecture
- 3:38caused delusions that I could offer wars in the Middle East. If I had
- 3:43been in my right mind, I would have turned myself in to my mental
- 3:47health therapist father or to the police. I had to live with this regret.
- 3:54I needed a mental health health to help in jail. In prison for
- 3:59mental health have been so much better than what I received in the community.
- 4:03The mental health system fail me. I did not have continuity care after I
- 4:10lost my private out assurance had not put on medication. I fell for the
- 4:15cracks of the medial system. My medication nurse and psychiatrists did not switch me
- 4:21off a fixer, A limit tall. However, with all these mitigating circumstances,
- 4:28I still I'm gonna make it clearer. I mean, I take full
- 4:31responsibility for my crime. A couple of the notes I have to my introduction
- 4:39is h number one stalls the Central Psychopharmacology, the Prescripber's Guide sim peedition Stephen
- 4:47Astall and number two of the Indian Journal of Psychiatry, Little of vaccine induced
- 4:55psychotic symptoms by eighty piece of Peak and digzel in to these forces, the
- 5:03medications contributed to my shooting. So with that, I open up four questions
- 5:11and construct Concurtiss, Okay, thank you for that. In Avid, before
- 5:16I start, does anybody have any questions or comments? Not everybody at one
- 5:25time? Now, when were you diagnosed? We were diagnosed before it happened.
- 5:34Yeah, I was done before it happened. I was diagnosed when I
- 5:39was twenty in Philadelphia in nineteen ninety six, and the crime happened in two
- 5:46thousand and six, so I had a ten year documented history. I'm mental
- 5:50help when I committed my crime? What takes the crime? I hate crime?
- 6:01Like explain that part. Unfortunately, at that time, there was a
- 6:06rivalry between the Judish community in the Muslim community in the Middle East because of
- 6:13the conflict in Israel. I won't say that I hated Jews particularly a lot,
- 6:21but I did have some animosity towards Jews at that time because of the
- 6:27conflict in the Middle East, and that conflict continues to pull up even to
- 6:31this day. What's going on in the Middle East. So I don't I
- 6:39no longer anti Semitic. I want to make it clear I have a constructive
- 6:46dialogue with the Jewish community since I've been down trying to make amends for my
- 6:50prime. I have also talked to Jewish prisoners and Jewish professors. We are
- 7:00teaching me here and uh so I've aged the effort to be commuted for my
- 7:06pride to the Jewish community. So Navide, somebody asked, what medications are
- 7:14you currently prescribed at the present time. Currently, I'm being prescribed black sabine
- 7:19and risper at all. They're bold and psychotics and prozac which is a depression
- 7:28and it's a good cock deal of medications. I'm able to function well,
- 7:32get out of bed, have be productive during the day. I'm not have
- 7:40hallucinations, delusions or psychosis. I'm riding my punishing pretty well. Does your
- 7:49family have a history of mental illness or diagnosed or either way? I guess
- 7:58on my mongside of the family, my aunt takes Abilify and then I have
- 8:05an uncle in Pakistan who help medicates with alcohol. So my family history on
- 8:13my mom's side, we do have a family history of bipolar and schizophrenia.
- 8:24Somebody also asked where were the symptoms leading up to your diagnosis in nineteen ninety
- 8:28six. Well, I was basically out of my mind. My mind was
- 8:37racing and I was having highs and lows because I have both. I used
- 8:43to have what they call UH but I said this schizophrenia I was. My
- 8:50diagnosis is schizopectic bipolar TITE. That means I have a psychotic component and the
- 8:56mood component to my DIMS. So my former started when I was fifteen and
- 9:05my schizophernia get started. But I was about twenty twenty one and the system
- 9:11was losing up to that time, where I was having like hyper sensitivity.
- 9:18I could feel people's feelings, I could read people's minds. I was having
- 9:24delusions, hallucinations at thoughts were being placed in my head, voices of highs
- 9:35and lows, mood, fluctuations, all those sorts of things. I was
- 9:41really non functional before I got on a mass. Any other questions, Yeah,
- 9:52so were you hearing voices and seeing things at the time of the shooting
- 9:56took place like that, that moment in time where were you hearing anything?
- 10:01Where you seeing anything? Was anybody telling you to kill or hurt people?
- 10:09Jams told me to kill er hurt people. But the medications mcdall and effects
- 10:16her They have side effects of suicidal ideation and also homicidal ideation. And I
- 10:26have an article here by the Indian General say Guy three. It was effects
- 10:33induces psychotic symptoms. This was an article published in two thousand and nine.
- 10:39So basically in the article, but what happened to be Thatcha, I had
- 10:46delusions. And my delusion was that I could alter war was in the Middle
- 10:52East by going to the Jewish Federation and attacking it. And and uh,
- 11:01I did have some voices while I was there. I heard a voice say
- 11:07murder. I heard I heard a voice say awesome. When I was shooting,
- 11:13I saw the victims going. That was the visual station. So I
- 11:20didn't have some hallucinations. But the main component that that was a psychosis,
- 11:28the illusions that I could alter wars in the Middle East with my actions at
- 11:35the Jewish Federation, and that was medication induced by the effecture and the big
- 11:43doll. And it was the biggest suicide attempt to because I wanted to commit
- 11:48suicide at the time, and then the effects and a little bit doll could
- 11:52me in that mindset where I wanted to kill myself. Jenner Amy, can
- 12:01you scroll up and read those other questions because I can't. My screen is
- 12:05cracked and I can't see them. Yeah, hang on one second. What
- 12:11was his early life behavior or behavior early whatever? Like, how is the
- 12:18behavior in early life? My behavior in early life was, actually I was
- 12:24a pretty kid. I'm holding me, But at that time I wasn't put
- 12:35on Riddlin Ratal or anything like that. I played soccer in elementary school.
- 12:46I basually got a great so I was a good kid. I did get
- 12:54in trouble. Was kind of a loader. I went to an allwine school
- 13:03and I was the only minority. What I had to do with race it
- 13:07them and and I was kind of an outcast because a lot of people thought
- 13:11I was a foreigner, and I'm not a foreigner. I'm born in the
- 13:16United States, born in Cleveland, and raised in Eastern Washington. But there
- 13:22was that perception that since I had my parents, I was a foreigner of
- 13:28myself. So there was some racism, xenophobia, and I sawmophobia that I
- 13:33had to deal with growing up, especially in the Eastern Washington, which is
- 13:39a very conservative hearing of the state. So it was it was a rough
- 13:45childhood, but I had loving parents, and my parents voted on the end,
- 13:52gave me everything I wanted and took care of me, and I had
- 13:58a happy childhood, even though I was a loner at school, and I
- 14:03had these a lot of friends the MUZZLE community. Did you have any misdiagnosis
- 14:13at the beginning when you were first starting to undergo treatment. In the beginning,
- 14:20they diagnosed me with bipolar two, which is a less severe form of
- 14:26bipolar, And then they diagnosed me with bipolar one, and then they diagnosed
- 14:33him with gets so effective bipolar die and and uh, the Social Security Administration
- 14:41when they when I applied for benefits, they diagnosed me with supophrenia and it's
- 14:48so effective, and that's probably a little closer to the correct diagnosis. Now
- 14:58my bipolar is under cont role, and I'm just suffering from schizophrenia and depression.
- 15:07So right now my bipolar is in remission, okay, with the meditations
- 15:16that schizophrenia is under control right now too, So I'm I'm publishing at a
- 15:22high level right now. That's good. Okay. So somebody asked, can
- 15:28you expand a little more on how your delusions contributed to the Jewish population,
- 15:33specifically my delusions at the time when I was introduced by a picture and there
- 15:46was a horrible in these at the time, it was between Eds blown and
- 15:52Israel, and then Israel and Gaza, and I thought, and I could
- 16:02help my people in the Middle East through my actions at Jewish Federation by somehow
- 16:12getting attention of the government and having them withdraw their troops from Lebanon and from
- 16:22Gaza. I know it was crazy, but these were the delusions. I
- 16:27was happy that I could offer wars in the Middle East through my actions in
- 16:33the Middle East, and I mean at the Jewish Federation, so that that
- 16:40that was the delusion I was having, then, the grandiose delusions like very
- 16:48like I was bigger than I actually was, and that I could make these
- 16:55changes in the least some foreign policy for Israel and America. Well, my
- 17:00action is at the Jewish Federation, so obviously I'm just a man and and
- 17:08my actions at the Jewish Federation could never do that. But I was delusional
- 17:14at the time, so that's what I believed. Next question we have is
- 17:22as a younger child, did you display any kind of behaviors? I guess
- 17:29what's the earliest you started displaying issues, exhibiting issues early on in your childhood?
- 17:41Like when did you first start? When? When was the warning signs?
- 17:44I guess you could say when did they start? Okay, I started
- 17:48having been through health issues in junior high school when I was in thirteen fourteen
- 17:53years old. I started with drawing and isolating and my Bible or when I
- 18:00was fifteen, and the schizophrenias started when I was about twenty twenty one.
- 18:07So I mean, I don't to make clear that the violence at the Jewish
- 18:14Federation is an aberration by history. Have you ever been violent before the Jewish
- 18:21Federation shooting? And my record in prison has been spillar. I have exhibited
- 18:30no violence in my history in prison in incarceration, so this shooting that the
- 18:38Jewish Federation is an aberration by history the violence there. It was a tragic
- 18:45mistake and I have to live with that regret, but it's not the real
- 18:52meaning. The reason why it happened was because of the medication side effects.
- 18:59It put me in the mindset where I had the psychosis, delusions and suicidal
- 19:06aviation from the Olympic ball and the epexeter he contributed to the shooting. I
- 19:14would say that it was the major concreting factor. It was a major conturcting
- 19:22factor to the shooting. The medications and cap is almost you. You want
- 19:29me to call back, Yes, please if you can, Okay, Okay,
- 19:33all right, all right, I'll come back in a second. Okay.
- 19:38So so what was the What were the other questions? Amy? So
- 19:42two questions. One is how do you feel about the current events with Gaza
- 19:47now that you are stabilized. That's the first one. Yeah, I wish
- 19:55that there would be a two stage solution in the Middle East between the Israelis
- 19:59and out saying, I think the only way there will be a peace between
- 20:03the Israelis and the Palastimy people is if there's a negotiated settlement and they come
- 20:10to some terms where there's Israel and uh Palastamian state, uh living side by
- 20:18side in peace. Maybe the Palasian state has to be de militarized so that
- 20:26the Israeli is gonna have security, but they should have a security guarantees,
- 20:33they really should. But that's what I think. I think the only way
- 20:38that will be peace is if there's a devotiated settlement, and unfortunately both sides
- 20:48have experiments. On both sides, the Israeli government does not want to have
- 20:55a two state solution, AMAS does not want to have a through state solution.
- 21:00So we have to look for moderates on both sides to come together and
- 21:04somehow crowd out the extremis so that there can be a negotiated settlement. That's
- 21:11the only way that there will be peace, unless technology somehow gets to a
- 21:19point where they can just somehow overwhelm the Palestinians. But that time might be
- 21:26coming. But I hope that they will be negotiated settlement and that there will
- 21:34be peace between the Israelis and the Palestinians, and that both both of them
- 21:41have a right to that land. Israelis their their ancestors to that land,
- 21:47the Palestinians their ancestors to the land. They trace their lineage to the Philistines,
- 21:53so both of them are have ancestral ties to that land. They're both
- 22:02a part of that land. So I hope it can somehow upcome to terms
- 22:07with one another to have a peaceful solution. Okay, The other question was
- 22:15going back to like your I guess, like your childhood and stuff like that,
- 22:19Like what was your I mean, what did your parents like did your
- 22:23parents pick up on any of this, Like what was their attitude towards mental
- 22:27health intervention? And basically was there something you know, that could have been
- 22:34done differently that would have led to a different outcome from where you are now.
- 22:44See, thirty years ago, there wasn't too much awareness of bipolar as
- 22:48schizophrenia, so my parents had no idea. They never even heard of bipolar
- 22:55as schizophrenia, especially coming from Pakistani culture and even in American culture, it
- 23:03was not well known. It was not well publicized mental help it was.
- 23:08There wasn't a bunch awareness about it, and there was more of a stigma
- 23:12to it back about thirty forty years ago, so there wasn't any anything different
- 23:22that could have been done. Unfortunately, I had to diagnose myself. I
- 23:29went to college at reach Our Politechnic Institute in Poor New York in Upstate New
- 23:34York, and I took a psychology class and that's where I first learned about
- 23:40these terms schizophrenia and bipolar. And I'm a psychology minor, so I studied
- 23:48psychopharmacology. I studied introduction to psychology, psychomotivations, I studied some other psychology
- 23:56clauses, and I learned about how bipolar works, health cazophrenia works, and
- 24:04I was able to see that what's going on in my own life seems to
- 24:10be what was in the textbook. So when I was in Philadelphia and struggling
- 24:17in dental school, I went to a psychiatrist. I said, hey,
- 24:22I think I have bipolar disorder and he said, here, keep a journal
- 24:26for a month on your mood. And it was up and down for a
- 24:30whole month. He said, yes, you have bipolar. So so that
- 24:36was then I found another psychiatrist and he put me on a lithium and then
- 24:41helped. At first I was able to pass my person year of dental school.
- 24:45So unfortunately, the awareness of mental health did not exist back then,
- 24:52so I don't I don't follow my parents. They did the best they could
- 24:59with what they knew, but unfortunately the mental health was there was an awareness
- 25:06of it at that time. Does that answer your question? It does?
- 25:10What what's your sentence? What's your sentence that you're serving right now? Lester?
- 25:22There is life without the possibility of parole plus one hundred and twenty years,
- 25:30and the life without parole is for the for the murder, and then
- 25:33the one hundred and twenty years is for the attempted murder counts. Correct,
- 25:38the murderer gave the aggravated murder gave me life without the possiblity parole. I
- 25:45got any seven point five years for the five attempted murders, the other charges
- 25:55hate prime and conste taking unlawful imprisonment that was run concurrent to my other charges.
- 26:03And I got thirty three years in weapons enhancements. So all together it's
- 26:10l LAP plus. That's that's sort for life developed possibility goal plus one hundred
- 26:18and twenty point five years. Okay, is there anything that you are currently
- 26:27doing at the prison or through the prison to you know, help others who
- 26:34might be going through the same thing. Absolutely, I'm trying to join this
- 26:41one group right now. It's called peer mentorship where I'm a I'm a peer
- 26:47support, and I always try to upload people around me. I I'm here
- 26:53to tell people around here that you know, we're incarcerated and it sucks,
- 26:59but it's been than being homeless. So a lot of people I'm locked up
- 27:03with were I've locked up in the residential treatment unit in the mental health section
- 27:10of the present and a lot of people I'm locked up with almost all of
- 27:15them are disabled. They have mental health problems just like me. So,
- 27:22but a lot of them were homeless in the community or a lot of them
- 27:26struggled in the community. So I try to remind them that we have all
- 27:32the identity in corporation right now, I mean, in president we have very
- 27:37condition, we have all the food we want, basically, we have mental
- 27:45health care, we have medical care, we have video games, we have
- 27:49tablets, we have TVs, radios, we have limited internet like education,
- 28:00we have law library, we have we have a lot of amenities here,
- 28:03and we have access to jobs, present jobs, so we can make extra
- 28:10money for store. So I try to remind people of the positives that the
- 28:17situation that we're in, and I try to make it so it's not so
- 28:22bad. You know. I try to tell people it's not so bad.
- 28:23It could be worse. It could be homeless in the sweltering heat. We
- 28:29could be in the in where we could be in the freezing cold. We
- 28:33could be outside facing elements, not knowing where our next meal is. We
- 28:40could be getting high those people who are addicts and not taking care of ourselves.
- 28:51We can take care of ourselves better here incarceration. So I try to
- 28:56remind the people around me that look at positives. You know that at least
- 29:03we're not homeless. Let's see. I think we're caught up on questions.
- 29:22Okay, all right, So David Uh, if it were up to you
- 29:26today or a board of your peers, do you believe that you should be
- 29:30released into society? Why or why not? I still I take far responsibility
- 29:38for my crime, even though there are mitigating circumstances, especially the medications.
- 29:45So I want to do enough time so as not to disrespect the people that
- 29:52I armed. I do deserve some punishment, but at some point I'm going
- 29:57to try to get cletency because I have extraordinary circumstances. That's what clemency requires,
- 30:06extraordinary circumstances and my mitigating circumstances conformed to that opinion. So eventually I
- 30:15would like to be released. I'm going to try for it, and I
- 30:19know it's a long shot, but I think I deserve it. And it's
- 30:26because my history is not a violence, just an operation in my history,
- 30:32and it's unfortunate that this tragic mistake happened and that people were harmed, this
- 30:41pamble Lector's family, the other women that were harmed. Uh, it's it's
- 30:48it's just an unfortunate tragedy. It's uh, it's it's a terrible accident.
- 30:53So I do wish to some maybe release, But you know, I've become
- 31:00comfortable in prison, so if I don't get released, it's not the end
- 31:04of the world. But I would like to someday walk out of pre man
- 31:12because one of the professors I had in Africa berical literature program at inner highest
- 31:18Pressure Center, you must pull me. Prison is the minor leagues and society
- 31:26is the major leagues. So I would like to graduate somebody from the minor
- 31:32leagues to the major leagues. I think it is something that I would wish
- 31:37to happen, But if it doesn't happen, it's not the end of the
- 31:40world. So have you come to terms with living your first of your days
- 31:47out in prison should you not be released. Well, it is something that
- 31:56could happen that I'll be in prison for the rest of my life. And
- 32:01I can take solace that there was no other way for me to get out
- 32:07of prison because after the first for how they offered me a forty five year
- 32:14deal with only two and a half years good time. So I would have
- 32:17been out when I was seventy three. But my health is not very good
- 32:22right now. I have diabetes, I have hy prevention, I have cardiac
- 32:28proms, I have schizoprettia. I'm a little overweight. So I have all
- 32:36these help proms, and chances are I probably I'll be lucky to make it
- 32:42to seventy three. I hope I do, but I'll be lucky if I
- 32:46do. Especially in prison, there's accelerated aging for long term prisoners because it's
- 32:53a stressful environment. So I kind of got past, you know, to
- 33:01get a present. I want to take it that deal I would. I
- 33:06want to send degree and I don't think I'll make it that long. So
- 33:09I had to take a different approach, and that was the clemency approach,
- 33:15and I'm hoping laws change the light hospital of the dying. If that one
- 33:21is pasted or reintroduced and passed, that would bring back expanding clemency. So
- 33:29there are there are some options that I could possibly get out, but I
- 33:35have to understand that it may not happen, and if it doesn't happen,
- 33:40I have to be ready for that possibility. So it's sad, but it's
- 33:47something that I know I can make. If that bridge happens, I'll cross
- 33:52it and I'll make it no matter what. So I'm comfortable in prison,
- 34:00and I'm doing well, and I'm helping people, and I hope I'm giving
- 34:07a second chance as something. I graduated in the meter leagues. So somebody
- 34:14asked, how long after you were convicted did it take you to realize you
- 34:17were wrong or to develop remorse for your crimes. I developed provos almost immediately.
- 34:28Yeah, accident, as I trying to kill his panel elector the woman,
- 34:36and I saw her dead body. I felt a deep sadness that I
- 34:40saw the body, so I felt remorse right away, and then my plans
- 34:46for that day were actually worse. I actually wanted to kill a Spanic people
- 34:52as I could, but when I got up there and some people were nice
- 34:58to me, I couldn't go up through with my plans. So I stopped
- 35:04shooting after one clip, and I surrendered police, and I wanted to survive.
- 35:12After the nine one one operator reminded me that I have a family that
- 35:16cares about me, and I got emotional that oh yeah, now I remember,
- 35:24I knew that for a reason to live. So I was suicidal at
- 35:29the time, and but I was reminded of my family that gave me the
- 35:36reason for me to surrender to police and to survive. So I felt I
- 35:42felt remorse right away. And I'm just lucky to survive. I'm lucky that
- 35:46I have the extra time, that I survived this law and that I'm still
- 35:52living. Is a life is a blessing. It's a blessing to be alive.
- 35:58Even an incarceration, there's still reason to live. So I I just,
- 36:05uh, I'm so happy that I was given the extra time off conserve.
- 36:12Yeah, I could have also be killed that day, and I'm very
- 36:16lucky. The police response was one of the largest in Seattle history. So
- 36:23I'm very lucky to be alive, and so I hope someday that I'm giving
- 36:30a second chance, but just just happening extra time is a blessing. You
- 36:37know. There was a question about was this planned or was it something that
- 36:45happened impulsively. Uh no, this is planned. Over a week or two,
- 36:54I I was doing I was going to do a shooting, and the
- 37:00juwsh Federation was not my first target. I was thinking about doing the shooting
- 37:05in tri cities, Richmond, Castle, Kenwick, Washington, Eastern Washington,
- 37:12and I was thinking about shooting up a bar or a costco, but but
- 37:17maybe target the Jewish Federation because I was watching news on CNN and I saw
- 37:24that there was a war going on in the Middle East, and suddenly my
- 37:29attention got dragged to the war, and I was looking at possible targets on
- 37:34the internet, and I saw that the Jewish Federation was doing a walk for
- 37:38Israel, a peaceful protest, and so that we'd be angry and let these
- 37:47women and children are being killed and Palestinian women and children being killed and bombed,
- 37:54yet they're doing a walk for Israel. So that that that direct to
- 38:00by rage at the time that I was getting from the medications towards the Jewish
- 38:06Federation and so that's how the planning happened. It was it was originally a
- 38:12plan to do shooting in tri Cities, and then my attention got directed to
- 38:17the jewsh Federation. I got my guns and then on that Friday that I
- 38:25got my racing my guns on Thursday. Then that Friday I drove from pri
- 38:32Cities to Seattle and I didn't shooting back. So it was planned. Yeah,
- 38:44I'll cahol, I'll come back, okay, all right? What was
- 38:46the original motivation for a mass shooting? The motivation was, see, I
- 38:52was downed by right mind because I was under the influence of cerent medication that
- 39:01my psychiatrists prescribed me and made as psychosis delisions suicidal ideation, putting me that
- 39:14my stain. That was the motivation. The bands are what gave me the
- 39:22motivation to do mass shooting because I wanted to die in the process of doing
- 39:28the mass shooting. It was a suicide attempt. So I had come to
- 39:34the end of my rope and I thought it was the end of my life,
- 39:38and I was having all sorts of problems in my life at the time.
- 39:44I was having relationship proms, financial proms, housing proms, family proms,
- 39:52all sorts of proms, and it was just like a perfect storm,
- 39:59and I wanted to entered my life. I couldn't think of no other way
- 40:04of ending my life. I couldn't actually pulled the trigger on myself. I
- 40:12tried that before and I couldn't do it. So I learned to die through
- 40:17a mass shooting. That was the motivation, and it was a medications that
- 40:22put me in that mindset to do it that way. Does that make sense
- 40:29in a sense. Yeah. Somebody asked, is there anything that could have
- 40:32prevented this mass shooting from happening. The only thing that could have prevented the
- 40:39mass shooting is a couple like a month before, I tried to get bed
- 40:45at the mental hospital and then I was turned away because I said that there
- 40:53was no bed space second them all my medications I was seeing me at the
- 41:01time. She referred me to a psychiatrist only twice the whole year, and
- 41:08a psychiatrist didn't switch me up by medications even though I was struggling, and
- 41:15I even told her. I got arrested for the first time six months before
- 41:22the shooting, and I tried to tell her, hey, I'm trying to
- 41:25have probble with the law, and she didn't pardon me. So the medication
- 41:30nurses partially at fault hair too. Her name is Deborah Lush. I could
- 41:37have suit her, but I didn't have any money for an attorney at the
- 41:42time, and I didn't push the issue, but I should have. I
- 41:45should have sued her. She's a big reason this crime happened. She didn't
- 41:52switch me off a texture of lemito. Another thing that could have stopped the
- 41:58crime is I could have turned myself in either to the mental health purpose.
- 42:07It was by Jones at the time. He asked me if I had any
- 42:12guns. He asked me that on Thursday, the day before the shooting,
- 42:15and I lied and I said no, So that's my fault. And then
- 42:22I could have turned myself into my father. I could have turned myself into
- 42:27the police officer that pulled me over that day. So that this it is
- 42:31I think poor responsibility. It is it is my fault. And I lied
- 42:38on the gun form too, but I had purchased the weapons. I said
- 42:45that I had never been hospitalized at a mental health facility, so I passed
- 42:50a background checked. So I lied on the gun form. So I'm not
- 42:59in is in here. I but there are there were ways that this crime
- 43:06could have been premitted and it's my fault, and it's partially the mental health
- 43:13system failed me. So I think full responsibility though, is uh, that's
- 43:20the right thing to do. Does anybody? Does anybody have any more questions
- 43:31from Navide? So? Navide? How do you feel about media coverage on
- 43:46mass shootings and mass murders? Do you think it contributes to them? Why
- 43:50or why not? I think the media has gotten better of not since sationalizing
- 43:59mass shootings. I think in the beginning, like in the early two thousands
- 44:04and in the twenty tens, the media almost like glorified mass shootings. They
- 44:14just kept playing the scenes over and over again, and they wouldn't tell these
- 44:19mass shooters, tell their names, publicize their names, their motives. It
- 44:28was bad for a while, but I think the media has finally caught on
- 44:31that they were contributing to this mass shooting pandemic. And now they don't glorify
- 44:40the mass shootings like they used to, and they don't publicize the shooters names
- 44:46like they used to either. So it is the coverage hair has gotten better.
- 44:51But I don would say that it was a problem for a while,
- 44:53it certainly was. Yeah, I agree with you. I'm glad that they
- 44:59publicized the victims names now more than the actual shooter or perpetrator these days,
- 45:04because it's it's more important to talk about the victims rather than the actual offender.
- 45:12We have a question was he living alone at the time or and did
- 45:15anyone know that he was planning us? You know this is this was my
- 45:22own actions. No one participated in helping me. I lot the gun to
- 45:28myself. I kept to the secret from everyone. My father checked in on
- 45:35me to see if he could help me if I needed help with anything,
- 45:40and I told him I was flying. I like I lied to the police
- 45:47officer. I lied to the mental health service. I lied to keep my
- 45:52guns my pigs possibility. I could have stopped this if I would have turned
- 45:59myself in it. It's just a tragic mistake. And I wish I would
- 46:07have got that bid space at the poor the mass shooting, but it wouldn't.
- 46:15It would have helped me off these meds picture on the bit tall and
- 46:20and then the crime could have been prevented. That would do so, or
- 46:24my medicationers could have at least listened to my proms. Unfortunately, I was
- 46:30ONDIKID at the time, which is a very poor health insurance, so she
- 46:36didn't take me seriously. So I was kind of thrown under the bus.
- 46:42But the mental health system failed me, the health insurance failed me, and
- 46:50I failed myself. So I take full responsibility. Have you had any conversations
- 46:58at all with any of the victims of the family. Unfortunately, I can
- 47:12talk to my victims. But in the future, if they ever would want
- 47:17to have a dialogue with me and they want closure and they they want to
- 47:24ask me questions, I open to that, but we would have to lift
- 47:30our no contact for her and do it legally. So unfortunately in this country,
- 47:38they don't They don't have a approachmen, they don't have the reform of
- 47:45justice in his country. He's done talked to par They don't have making a
- 47:53means with victims. That it's not as widespread as in other countries. It
- 48:01would be better that way, but in its compretty they no no contact orders
- 48:08on everyone and then so then you we're not allowed to have closure. So
- 48:17it's it's unfortunate, but hopefully at some point I can have a dialogue with
- 48:25some of the people that I armed and give them closer if they need it,
- 48:31or maybe this program will give them closer if they listen to it.
- 48:37So either way, I'm I'm fine with it. So, Navid, if
- 48:49the no contact order was lifted today and you had all of the surviving victims
- 48:52and the family member of the victim that passed away, what might you say
- 48:55to them to gain some type of closure. I would tell them that you
- 49:02know, I've had a monster. I'm I apologize very deeply from my accents
- 49:09that day. I wish it would not have happened. I wish I would
- 49:14have a peaceful counter protestist. I wish I would not have bought guns.
- 49:20I wish I were never brought guns to the Jewish Generation's office. I wish
- 49:25things would have gone down differently. It's it's uh, this is a tragic
- 49:32mistake, a tragic error, and it's it's I was almost like an accident
- 49:39because I was browing these medications and then the news was blasting what was going
- 49:45out in the Middle East, and and it's it's it's unfortunate that I directed
- 49:51my rage at the easiness and people. So I would apologize from from the
- 49:59depth of my being. Two by the people I armed, and I would
- 50:06I would tromb the best to answer all the questions that they had if they
- 50:12have any Somebody asked, were you inspired by any other mass shootings? I
- 50:17would say no, I was. I was not inspired by any other mas
- 50:22shootings. This, this, this mass shooting my mind in particular, was
- 50:27a suicide attempt. I I I just found it, uh, in my
- 50:34life at that time, I could think of no other way in my life
- 50:39than to do it through mass shooting. I thought for sure it would work,
- 50:44and when it didn't work, it was a big relief, a big
- 50:49uh. It was. It was just luck that it didn't work. So
- 50:53it's a blessing that I'm still alive. And I just, uh, yeah,
- 51:00it's it's just unfortunate, and it's a it's unfortunate that I got to
- 51:07that point in my life where I was suicidal. But it was a medications
- 51:13that put me in mind steam, the texture a little big tall put me
- 51:17in that my steam because the side effects of both medications are suicide of aviation.
- 51:24So it was just a big suitside attempt. So Navid, this next
- 51:31question, I mean no offense by it by any means, But why wouldn't
- 51:36you have taken your own life rather than inflicting harm onto other families and other
- 51:39victims. Yeah, Unfortunately, I could think of no other way to kill
- 51:45myself. I know, I know it sounds stupid, but I honestly it
- 51:52was cowardly. You know. I couldn't put the gun into my own head
- 51:57and then pull the trigger. I tried that before, and I couldn't do
- 52:01it. I just I loved life too much. But I was suicidal at
- 52:08the time, and I wanted to desire by suicide by cop so. I
- 52:15thought most people in Mashtings died by suicide by cop so I thought this was
- 52:21a perfect way for me to go. And it's unfortin. I wish I
- 52:27don't want it would have been harmed that team. I wish I werenna got
- 52:34help before the se At that time, they didn't have the nine to eighty
- 52:38number suicide versus prevention number. They have more opportunities now two poor people who
- 52:47are suicidal to reach out for help. Those those uh, those agues didn't
- 52:54exist back there. So it was. It was. It was unfortunate,
- 53:01but that was the only way I could think of the best way to think
- 53:06of the in my life, So it's it's unfortunate that it were harmed in
- 53:12the process. So it's it's just a tragedy. It's a tragedy. Does
- 53:19anybody else have any questions for Nvid? I wonder if if the isolation as
- 53:23a child contributed to future, you know, behaviors. That's actually a very
- 53:34insightful question. I would saying it absolutely had a lot to do with it.
- 53:38The isolation that I suffer through racism and as famaphobia and genophobia in my
- 53:46parent of years as a child helped to contribute to my rage when I was
- 53:53older and I was that contributed to me wanting to in my life through a
- 54:02mass shooting. So I would say that's a very insightful question. It was
- 54:09a contributor, contributor the isolation that I had when I was a child.
- 54:16I would think it almost have to be, because absolutely you're inside your head
- 54:23and then you get older, hormones, puberty, then you start needing medication
- 54:30that you weren't getting, and it's disaster. Absolutely, absolutely, that's it.
- 54:37That's exactly what happened. You know, there's isolation and that I wasn't
- 54:42getting help. One of my teachers told me, I needed counseling. One
- 54:46of my high school teachers, I tried to get counseling. My guidance counselor
- 54:52told me that they didn't do it at the school. They didn't have that
- 54:55type of shit up back then in nineteen ninety four where they gave therapy to
- 55:02students, So I was I had a road block there. I didn't get
- 55:13adequate help, and and then even when I saw help, but I finally
- 55:17got it in ninety six. But I'm going to a psychiatrist and then probably
- 55:24starting to see a therapist in Philadelphia. It wasn't adequate care because I was
- 55:32still isolated at school and and I needed more of a support network. I
- 55:40didn't have the support network in the community and I do in prison. I
- 55:47have my psychologist, I'm my psychiatrists, I'm my therapist, my parentily now
- 55:55my parently is finally on board my friend, so I am support network.
- 56:02Count that support network didn't exist and I was growing up, so that isolation
- 56:09definitely contributed to the crime. Have you had any issues in prison with other
- 56:17groups of people when they've learned that it was, you know, a hate
- 56:22crime. People have been respectful because I've been for murder, and there's a
- 56:31hierarchy in prison. Six offenders are usually the lowest along with stitches. And
- 56:39I'm I'm either I don't, I don't tell long people you have one minute,
- 56:45and I'm not a six offender, So people are generally respectful towards me.
- 56:53Can you call back one more time? Sure? Okay, thank you?
- 57:00Okay. So my question is because I don't know, I don't know
- 57:06like the complete background of your family. But what is the stance that Islam
- 57:12has in terms of the medical intervention and mental health, Like does it prohibit
- 57:22it? Is it okay with it? Yeah? The Quran talks about it,
- 57:30doesn't talk about it, said that like God talks about how control of
- 57:37the problems whatever, so that you're not a mad poet. I mean,
- 57:43you're not insane. So there are references to general how in the Koran and
- 57:52in some of the law is law, it does talk about how you can
- 57:55have capital undershment if you were in scene at the time that were there's some
- 58:04case offer that. So mental health is regarded in the Islamic civilization. Now
- 58:15that's in theory. In practice, like in Pakistan there there isn't too much.
- 58:24There wasn't too much awareness of mental health, especially thirty years ago five
- 58:30over in schizophrenia, and even now Alas like the world staters, they will
- 58:40think that someone is possessed by a spirit, by a gin, so they
- 58:47have very outdated knowledge on mental health. Some of the more affluent, the
- 58:59rich, they know more about mental health because they're educated, so then they
- 59:06would go to a menialth professional. So that that's in Pakistan next city.
- 59:14Culture is still catching up. But you know, I was raised in America,
- 59:22so even even thirty years ago in American culture, I had barely ever
- 59:30heard of BiPOL or schizophrenia growing up. And it wasn't until I got into
- 59:37school and studied psychology in nineteen ninety four that I learned about what exactly was
- 59:49by four in schizophrenia, and that that led me to diagnose myself, how
- 59:58does Islam like view modern medicine in general? And then the second part that
- 1:00:02I want to ask, just because I'm walking over to make a plate for
- 1:00:07my husband, my second question is how does it view men in general?
- 1:00:15Like? Does it see anything like that as a weakness? That would you
- 1:00:19know, is there anything that's negative about it? We were just having this
- 1:00:23conversation earlier, so it's on my mind. Answer the second question. First,
- 1:00:30absolutely sees it as a weakness. There's a big stigma to it.
- 1:00:35Mental health is a big stigma, and it's even bigger in Islam. In
- 1:00:40American culture, there's been a lot of publicity for mental health and the help
- 1:00:49was starting to start out for spring Up starting to come come up, and
- 1:00:55and there's a lot more awareness now people know his term is by horrors,
- 1:01:01cazophrenia, PTSD, depression, major depression, personality disorder. People people know
- 1:01:10about these terms now. So in in Islam they're still catching up. But
- 1:01:20in or Rich Patrice, they they they're more educated and they they have some
- 1:01:30pals, like like one of my psychiatrists in the community was Textany. He
- 1:01:38was born in Pakistan, but he became a psychiatrist. So there there is
- 1:01:45even help in that community. But that turned out to be my worst psychiatrist.
- 1:01:52But but uh, there is starting to be awareness even in that culture.
- 1:02:00What was the first question as Islam view modern medicine in general, Well,
- 1:02:09there's no there's nothing against modern medicine in Islam. Medicine is uh encouraged
- 1:02:19for Muslims. Just to clarify, because you said something about the self diagnosis.
- 1:02:25You have been clinically diagnosed, so since then, right, absolutely,
- 1:02:31yeah, I've I've been I knew there was a problem with myself, got
- 1:02:37myself character by a psychiatrist, and then I got an official diagnosis. And
- 1:02:43that diagnosis has changed over time. But now it's a concrete it's affected by
- 1:02:50polar time. There's a psychotic component and a mood component. Okay, so
- 1:03:01are you are you currently still practicing as Lom. I'm not a strict to
- 1:03:09Muslim, but I I do pray. I I don't pass because I had
- 1:03:15bad eatings, but I prayed once so well and I read the prawn and
- 1:03:22I say, I'm I'm still a practicing Muslim, so I should do more
- 1:03:30prayers. But I'm still Muslim. Kisspam, I'm still Muslim. Another question
- 1:03:38that was asked was on the day of the shooting, were you targeting women
- 1:03:44specifically? Absolutely not. I didn't know that the building was filled with women,
- 1:03:52so that that's another big regret I have been that I wish it would
- 1:03:57have turned out differently, that no one would have been harmed, but especially
- 1:04:01that women were harmed. It really bothered me for a long time. And
- 1:04:09I have to regret for my actions that day. Another question is, in
- 1:04:16your culture, is holistic medicine pushed as the first option, or is both
- 1:04:21pharmaceutical and holistic seeen as equal. You know, my culture is American.
- 1:04:32I know, I know my background is Pakistani, but I don't know the
- 1:04:41question. I don't know the answer to how Pakistani's view holdistic medicine but they
- 1:04:50also be pharmaceutical medicine. But my my culture is American. I'm born and
- 1:05:00raised in this culture, and I identify the American culture. Excuse me,
- 1:05:14but it's almost dinner time over here. Well we'll cut this short, okay,
- 1:05:19all right, that's fine, na Vid, thank you so much.
- 1:05:21We appreciate it. Thank you so much. Yes, thank you. I'll
- 1:05:26do the problem. I hope that was helpful and I hope that helps people.
- 1:05:32Yeah, definitely was Thank you, David. We appreciate it, and
- 1:05:34I'll be in touch with you through email. Okay, okay, I think
- 1:05:41all right, thank you, all right, for sure, talk to you
- 1:05:44see, okay, okay, all right, bye bye,