Latest / Podcasts By Donna Jodhan / Remarkable World Commentary Episode #112: Interview with Brian Moore, Senior Accessibility Specialist, TD
Transcript
- 0:12Podcast Commentator: Greetings. Donna J. Jarden LBAP and MBA invites you to listen to her bi weekly
- 0:21podcast, Remarkable World Commentary hear Donna shares some of her innermost thoughts,
- 0:27insights, perspectives, and more with her listeners.
- 0:31Donna focuses on topics that directly affect the future of kids,
- 0:35especially kids with disabilities.
- 0:38Donna is a blind advocate, author, sight loss coach,
- 0:42dinner mystery producer, writer, entrepreneur,
- 0:45law graduate, and podcast commentator.
- 0:49She has decades of lived experiences, knowledge,
- 0:53skills, and expertise in access, technology and information.
- 0:58As someone who has been internationally recognized for her work and roles,
- 1:02she just wants to make things better than possible.
- 1:07Donna J. Jodhan, LLB, ACSP, MBA: Hello everybody, and welcome to another episode of The Remarkable World Commentary.
- 1:14I'm Donna Johnson, a lifelong disability advocate and one who sees the world mainly
- 1:21through sound, touch and stubborn optimism.
- 1:26I am a law graduate, an accessibility consultant,
- 1:29author, lifelong barrier buster who also happens to be blind.
- 1:36You may know me from a few headline moments, as in November of 2010,
- 1:42I won the landmark charter case that forced the Canadian government to make its website
- 1:48accessible to every Canadian, not just to sighted ones.
- 1:53And in July of 2019, I co-led the Accessible Canada out with more than two dozen
- 2:01disability groups to turn equal access into federal law.
- 2:07And most recently, on June 3rd, 2022, I was greatly humbled by Her Majesty's
- 2:15Platinum Jubilee Award for tireless commitment to removing barriers.
- 2:21When I'm not in a courtroom or in a committee room or in a pottery studio,
- 2:28you'll find me coaching kids with vision loss,
- 2:33producing audio mysteries, or helping tech companies to make their
- 2:39gadgets talk back in plain language.
- 2:43Everything I do circles one goal to turn accessibility from an afterthought into
- 2:49everyday practice. I invite you to think of this show as our shared workbench where
- 2:57policy meets lived experience and lived experience sparks fresh ideas.
- 3:04Now, before we jump into today's conversation,
- 3:09let me shine a spotlight on today's guest, a changemaker whose work is every bit as
- 3:18remarkable as the world that we are trying to build.
- 3:23Brian Moore, I'd like to welcome you to our Remarkable World Commentary podcast.
- 3:30You and I go back many years.
- 3:32I won't tell our listeners how many years, but it is a pleasure and a privilege to have
- 3:36you. I've watched you grow.
- 3:38I'm really, really proud of what you've done and the way you stick up for something
- 3:44whenever it matters to you.
- 3:47Welcome to my show.
- 3:49Brian Moore: Thanks, Donna. I appreciate you inviting me.
- 3:53Donna J. Jodhan, LLB, ACSP, MBA: Anytime. So, Brian, most people meet accessibility as a rule.
- 4:02They have to follow. You have spent more than 30 years meeting it as a way of life.
- 4:12Tell our listeners who you are and what you actually do on an ordinary Tuesday
- 4:22at the bank.
- 4:24Brian Moore: Okay. So I am a. A blind person first.
- 4:34So that's, that's the, the lens that I bring to everything because
- 4:40it's unavoidable, right?
- 4:41I can't turn that piece off.
- 4:43Right. I mean, so what I do impacts my real life every day.
- 4:52And the lives of many people I know.
- 4:56So my job is actually sort of leading a digital accessibility program.
- 5:05So things like, you know.
- 5:10We should ensure that our apps and our websites and basically all as many of our
- 5:17processes as we can get to and dig into are accessible to everyone.
- 5:24And that involves all kinds of things.
- 5:32So I mean, I, like you said in the introduction,
- 5:35I've been in the accessibility space for basically my,
- 5:41almost my entire adult life.
- 5:48In everything ranging from tech support to helping with website design,
- 5:55like where you're actually in the code to sort of now in a more of a manager role where
- 6:03I don't get to be a geek quite as often.
- 6:06I still get to do some of it because it's fun,
- 6:09but now it's a bit more of an oversight role and audit and providing training and
- 6:18sort of trying to influence policy decisions and that type of thing.
- 6:24So, you know, my typical day will involve maybe coaching on code,
- 6:31maybe meeting with the vendor to push them to make sure that the things that we're buying
- 6:35that we're going to use to expose to customers are accessible to meeting with
- 6:41senior leadership to say, hey, this is why you should do what we do,
- 6:45and this is why you should not push back against this executive order from the
- 6:50government that says that DEI and accessibility which was included,
- 6:55are bad and against the will of whatever flavor God you believe in and.
- 7:04So it's a whole range of things.
- 7:07Donna J. Jodhan, LLB, ACSP, MBA: So basically, Brian, you're all over
- 7:09the place, right?
- 7:10Brian Moore: Yeah.
- 7:13Donna J. Jodhan, LLB, ACSP, MBA: Enjoy it.
- 7:14Brian Moore: I do, I love it, I still love it even after 30 years.
- 7:20Means change, but I still love it.
- 7:24Donna J. Jodhan, LLB, ACSP, MBA: Now you have said that you started out at a school for the blind and then moved into
- 7:31mainstream school while you were still living in the schools.
- 7:37Residents. That is a very particular kind of childhood in that it is one foot in each
- 7:46world. What did living in both of them at once.
- 7:52Teach you that you still care with you today.
- 7:58Brian Moore: So I've heard a lot of people who sort of were in mainstream education and
- 8:09had a terrible time, like didn't have any friends and didn't have good interactions
- 8:15with their peers and stuff.
- 8:16And that simply was not my experience.
- 8:21I think part of that, which was an unheard of concept when I went,
- 8:27was people get educational aids now, like a full time adult to trail them about.
- 8:34No wonder they don't have friends.
- 8:36Donna J. Jodhan, LLB, ACSP, MBA: Right?
- 8:38Brian Moore: I had none of that when I was 11 years old.
- 8:41I took public transit to school and that was just normal.
- 8:48Like I, I took the STM or whatever they're calling it now in Montreal.
- 8:55And that was just expected, right?
- 8:57That was part of integration.
- 8:59So. It was. I think we
- 9:09spend a lot of time now, particularly in education,
- 9:11but I've seen it in other areas where we shelter people too much,
- 9:16like try and insulate them from the real world and consequently they don't adjust to
- 9:23it. Well, and the, the downside of that, I mean,
- 9:27there's a few downsides, but one of them is that you don't develop
- 9:30the, the friendships and the social interactions that are typical of a kid in
- 9:36school. And that I did develop because I didn't have an adult shadow because I went
- 9:42places by myself. I don't know, I could go on.
- 9:52Donna J. Jodhan, LLB, ACSP, MBA: But but it's true. I mean, I grew up a bit ahead of,
- 9:56you know, of, of your era here.
- 9:59And it was the same thing for us.
- 10:01You know, we did this.
- 10:04We didn't have an adult chaperones as such.
- 10:08And today it's so much more sheltered for these poor
- 10:12guys. Right.
- 10:14Brian Moore: Yeah. Like the concept of an 11 year old kid taking public transit to school.
- 10:18They just wouldn't do it now.
- 10:20Donna J. Jodhan, LLB, ACSP, MBA: No, no.
- 10:22Brian Moore: But, I mean, look at the bright side.
- 10:24I haven't had an O and M lesson since I was 12,
- 10:27and I'm almost 60 because they did a really good job of teaching me the basics.
- 10:36They covered it well. They did what they call structured discovery before it was called
- 10:40structured discovery.
- 10:44Donna J. Jodhan, LLB, ACSP, MBA: Boy, things have changed a lot.
- 10:46Brian Moore: Yeah.
- 10:47Donna J. Jodhan, LLB, ACSP, MBA: Gosh, no. Take me back to 1993.
- 10:53And that small organization in Calgary where all of this began for you.
- 11:00What did assistive technology even look like back then?
- 11:06And what was the what was it that made you decide this is the work I
- 11:14want? So.
- 11:19Brian Moore: It was actually an organization.
- 11:24So in 19 well, 1994, actually, that was Calgary,
- 11:27the TRC. So I would have been 27.
- 11:39And it was an organization that did.
- 11:44Assistive Technology for various disabilities.
- 11:47Actually, blind wasn't one of them.
- 11:49Donna J. Jodhan, LLB, ACSP, MBA: Oh, okay.
- 11:51Brian Moore: It was mostly people with physical issues.
- 11:54So it was things like Dragon and what very limited alternative keyboards there were at
- 12:01the time. So it was all dos.
- 12:05Donna J. Jodhan, LLB, ACSP, MBA: Oh, gosh. Okay.
- 12:07Brian Moore: Yeah. There was no windows yet.
- 12:09Really? Well, there was, there was 3.1, but it wasn't super widely
- 12:15adopted. And I mean, it was a lot harder to get working than it is today.
- 12:25It was a lot more geeky and technical and fiddly and.
- 12:29Gee, I have to install this, this board to make my speech work.
- 12:33I gotta find an IRC and a free com port.
- 12:36And like, nobody even remembers what I'm talking about nowadays.
- 12:41Donna J. Jodhan, LLB, ACSP, MBA: Yeah.
- 12:42Brian Moore: Yeah. But. It was work.
- 12:49It was life changing for people.
- 12:51Right. For some people, you know, you could use a computer and they
- 12:56couldn't otherwise. And I sort of broadened the scope because I,
- 13:03just because I was there to.
- 13:06Let's talk about screen reader stuff.
- 13:07And I used a thing. What did I use?
- 13:09Oh, tiny talk. I think it was.
- 13:11Donna J. Jodhan, LLB, ACSP, MBA: Oh my Lord. And yeah.
- 13:15Brian Moore: You had to have a hardware synthesizer.
- 13:17Yeah. But and, and it was interesting because it was only a contract,
- 13:25but at the time they, I actually went there to volunteer because I
- 13:31thought, oh, it'd be neat to learn this stuff. But the executive director said,
- 13:37hey I have some money from the Alberta government to employ some people.
- 13:42Are you interested? And it wasn't much money at all.
- 13:47But it was a whole lot more than I was getting on on welfare because Alberta
- 13:52wouldn't give me disability because I wasn't disabled
- 13:56enough. Yeah.
- 14:00Donna J. Jodhan, LLB, ACSP, MBA: Well, I don't get it.
- 14:02Brian Moore: No. They said being blind is not sufficient to get the what they call the assured income
- 14:10for the severely handicapped.
- 14:12Donna J. Jodhan, LLB, ACSP, MBA: Oh, God. Oh, my God, I'm blown out of my chair.
- 14:18Okay. Hold on.
- 14:20Brian Moore: So, you know, working any kind of low wage job was better than that,
- 14:24right? And I wanted to work.
- 14:27Yeah. So I did that for close to a year.
- 14:39And then the funding ran out and he said, I'd really like to keep you, but I can't
- 14:42afford it. And then to make a very long story short,
- 14:51I ended up coming to Toronto and working at a place that no longer exists
- 15:01called frontier computing.
- 15:03Donna J. Jodhan, LLB, ACSP, MBA: Right, right.
- 15:04Brian Moore: That was a adaptive tech dealer.
- 15:07And even that was I went because they were offering an internet course which I didn't
- 15:12really need, but I thought it would be a cool way to meet people in this new city.
- 15:17Well, the next time they ran the internet
- 15:19course. I was the teacher.
- 15:24Donna J. Jodhan, LLB, ACSP, MBA: Okay. Are you going?
- 15:28Brian Moore: Well, and then I stayed there for years, like it was on and off.
- 15:33But I was there sort of doing adaptive technology,
- 15:37tech support to until 2015.
- 15:41Donna J. Jodhan, LLB, ACSP, MBA: Wow. Okay. So for close to 20 years.
- 15:49Right? Yeah. You were, in your own words, the entire technical
- 15:55support and an entire technical support department of a Toronto access
- 16:03technology company.
- 16:05Brian Moore: Well, one of them there were there were a few at the time.
- 16:09Yeah. I don't think any of them are left, but.
- 16:12Donna J. Jodhan, LLB, ACSP, MBA: No. Tell me about that company and those years and tell me what being the voice on the
- 16:21other end of that phone taught you about our community.
- 16:28Brian Moore: So it taught me so many things.
- 16:30I mean, it, it was a it was a company started by two blind guys.
- 16:37Which was a novelty at that point.
- 16:42And they made it successful, like regardless of what ended up happening.
- 16:46These were these two blind guys that wanted to start and they made it successful.
- 16:50Donna J. Jodhan, LLB, ACSP, MBA: Yes.
- 16:51Brian Moore: Like whatever else happens, I'll give them that. They made it successful.
- 16:54Yeah, I agree. And I mean, it was a good place to work.
- 17:00Like I liked the people.
- 17:05Tech support, you know, and I was basically self-taught.
- 17:11Right, right. Like I never went through any training really.
- 17:22Later, I did like, you know, a few years later,
- 17:25for example, in 2008, maybe I took like the jaws scripting course,
- 17:30for example. Right, right.
- 17:33But I essentially, I started out as completely self-taught.
- 17:39Because I was a nerd and I liked to play with this stuff.
- 17:43Donna J. Jodhan, LLB, ACSP, MBA: And you still are.
- 17:44Brian Moore: And I still am. Absolutely, yes.
- 17:45Absolutely. I wear that badge proudly.
- 17:48Yes. Even when I don't have to do it at work.
- 17:52I still do it on my own.
- 17:57So it was a great place to work and it taught me a ton about our community.
- 18:04It taught me a lot about myself too.
- 18:06First of all, you can only do it for so long because quite honestly,
- 18:11intellectually, it's not that challenging.
- 18:16Doing tech support. So if you I got like, I stayed longer than I should have.
- 18:23Donna J. Jodhan, LLB, ACSP, MBA: Oh, okay.
- 18:24Brian Moore: Because I got burnt out.
- 18:25But, you know, I gotta eat, right?
- 18:28Donna J. Jodhan, LLB, ACSP, MBA: That's right.
- 18:31Brian Moore: And my kid thinks I should support him.
- 18:37So. But I learned a ton about our community.
- 18:42First of all, one of the biggest lessons I think I learned was that there are so many
- 18:48people that aren't as privileged or something as me.
- 18:57And I don't know what that something is because.
- 19:03In my experience, sort of, I, I knew lots of blind people and people
- 19:07with disabilities, but a lot of them were like me,
- 19:09right. They managed, they lived on their own.
- 19:12They had most a lot of them had employment.
- 19:15Sometimes we didn't. But a lot of times we did and some didn't.
- 19:20But. We were functioning adults.
- 19:24And what I encountered during this job was a lot of people who.
- 19:30Because they never had the opportunity, I think mostly just didn't have the skills to
- 19:38sort of live independently and stuff with things I took for granted.
- 19:42Right. I didn't know that was not a thing.
- 19:46But I remember. Having to train somebody once and I,
- 19:54they lived somewhere and I called them up and I said, hey,
- 19:56I, you know, I have the address and stuff.
- 19:58I have no idea where that is.
- 20:00How do I get there? And they said, I don't have a clue. I don't ever go out on
- 20:04my own. And I did a double take,
- 20:07right? Yeah. What?
- 20:10Donna J. Jodhan, LLB, ACSP, MBA: Yeah.
- 20:13Brian Moore: But what? That's far more common than I thought,
- 20:17actually. Or people who, who live with family because they,
- 20:26they don't believe they have the skills to live independently.
- 20:32And I think that is because no one's ever expected it,
- 20:36right? If you've always been given the message,
- 20:39you can't, you can't, or you need protecting or you need somebody
- 20:42to take care of you. Eventually you will internalize that and believe it.
- 20:48Donna J. Jodhan, LLB, ACSP, MBA: You know, that's very true.
- 20:49I mean, yeah, I agree.
- 20:52I think I'm very sad though, you know, like.
- 20:56Brian Moore: It really.
- 20:56Donna J. Jodhan, LLB, ACSP, MBA: Is. Yeah. Because, you know, I consider myself to be very privileged in
- 21:01many, many ways like yourself, but there's too many of our community that
- 21:08they're not in the same
- 21:09position. Right?
- 21:11Brian Moore: No, no. I mean, I have lots of stories of things that happened related.
- 21:16And I would never. Share anybody's personal info.
- 21:21But I think just an anecdote, one of the ones that really stuck out was I
- 21:28remember going to train somebody at their home one time and they said,
- 21:34oh, don't let your guide dog go in the kitchen because I dropped the jar of pickles.
- 21:38And I said, well, okay, are you going to clean it?
- 21:41Oh no, I don't know how.
- 21:43But my home, my home care worker is coming in three days and they'll be able to sort of
- 21:51pick up the glass and stuff.
- 21:54And I'm thinking, wait, what?
- 21:56So you're going to be stuck out of your own kitchen for three?
- 22:01I said like, do you have a broom and dustpan?
- 22:05Yeah. Can you get it for me?
- 22:08But it really made me think, right?
- 22:10Like, I guess I'm privileged or something.
- 22:14I don't I don't know what it is.
- 22:20Donna J. Jodhan, LLB, ACSP, MBA: I've heard similar stories.
- 22:22And, you know, like you.
- 22:25What is it? What is it?
- 22:29And how have things changed?
- 22:34Brian Moore: Well, and I really think it's.
- 22:36If no one's ever expected it of you, they won't get it right.
- 22:39If no one's ever told you you could.
- 22:43And in fact, often the opposite.
- 22:46That's what you'll get as an end result.
- 22:54Donna J. Jodhan, LLB, ACSP, MBA: Somewhere around 2015, you started teaching yourself web and
- 23:02document accessibility because people kept coming to you asking how to comply with Aoda.
- 23:11No potty trained you. So how do you teach yourself an entirely new discipline when so
- 23:21much of what is written about it is not accessible to you in the first place?
- 23:31Brian Moore: So a lot of it, it actually is.
- 23:34I mean, yes, there is some that's not.
- 23:37Donna J. Jodhan, LLB, ACSP, MBA: Yes.
- 23:38Brian Moore: But a lot of it is. And basically the internet.
- 23:46So by then we had Twitter, which and there was a real before it turned
- 23:53into the mess it is now.
- 23:59It was actually a pretty thriving community with a quite active accessibility community
- 24:06where we all shared tips and tricks and hey, how do you do this?
- 24:09And how do you do that?
- 24:13And I had a mentor kind of, he didn't know he was my mentor,
- 24:18but he was so there was a guy who was part of the W3C working group who did,
- 24:27who started up a business.
- 24:29It was not a blind guy.
- 24:31He had other disabilities.
- 24:33But he, he ran a business conducting workshops on this stuff,
- 24:38and he asked me to come to one of them and do a screen reader demo.
- 24:42Donna J. Jodhan, LLB, ACSP, MBA: Okay.
- 24:43Brian Moore: And obviously paid me to do it.
- 24:48But I went to the, this three day workshop.
- 24:56And I thought, this stuff is really cool. I want to learn more. So I started reading and
- 24:59reading and reading and reading and absorbing everything I could and going to any free
- 25:05webinar thing that was happening and trying things like writing code and okay,
- 25:12this works for me. This doesn't work for me.
- 25:16And back to the, this impacts my real life.
- 25:19I would encounter barriers all the time, right when I tried to do things online and I
- 25:25thought, how much better would it be if I could Explain the barrier and if we're real
- 25:32lucky, how to fix the barrier.
- 25:39And sometimes that's useful. Sometimes it's not like if you.
- 25:44For example, encounter it with a big company and you call sort of the call center.
- 25:50There's not much point having that discussion with a call center agent.
- 25:53They're a likely not going to have a clue what you're on about.
- 25:56Right. And they're not in a position to do anything about it anyway.
- 26:03Donna J. Jodhan, LLB, ACSP, MBA: Frustrating me.
- 26:04Brian Moore: Yeah. And that still happens today.
- 26:10I mean, so the building I live in has a portal where you can submit maintenance
- 26:16tickets pay fees, etc.
- 26:21and I actually use it as in my sort of teaching web accessibility stuff in my job as
- 26:28an example of how to make a site completely terrible.
- 26:34I have a few of those sites I use as examples of how not to do this.
- 26:42One of the others is actually our rail.
- 26:45Rail company who put some effort into it.
- 26:50But like they got somebody who.
- 26:53Thought hey, accessibility means more area.
- 26:56Let's put lots and lots of area on everything.
- 26:59Oh yeah. And it's a mess.
- 27:08Donna J. Jodhan, LLB, ACSP, MBA: Okay. You were somebody's first hire at TD Bank.
- 27:16What did it feel like to walk into one of the largest banks in this country as a blind man
- 27:25I've been told. In effect, we need you to tell us the truth about our
- 27:33own hearts.
- 27:37Brian Moore: Well, it was pretty encouraging. I mean, he.
- 27:40So the guy who hired me actually left not that long after.
- 27:45Donna J. Jodhan, LLB, ACSP, MBA: Okay.
- 27:47Brian Moore: But he. I mean, it was great.
- 27:49He was a great manager.
- 27:51I learned a lot from him because that was the first time in my life I worked at a big,
- 27:56huge organization, right, where they had things like very formal
- 28:03performance reviews and evaluations and stuff.
- 28:06I never did that because I was either working in a small business of seven or 8 or 10
- 28:11people, or I was a contractor.
- 28:16Like when I worked for the provincial government, I was always a contractor.
- 28:19Donna J. Jodhan, LLB, ACSP, MBA: Right, right, right. Okay.
- 28:22Brian Moore: And kind of their token token disabled person that didn't have any real work to do.
- 28:30Donna J. Jodhan, LLB, ACSP, MBA: Don't say that. It's kind of true,
- 28:34though. But, you know.
- 28:35Brian Moore: Oh, it was true.
- 28:36Donna J. Jodhan, LLB, ACSP, MBA: Yeah, yeah.
- 28:40Brian Moore: I'm too old to have filters now.
- 28:43I don't have much filters.
- 28:45Donna J. Jodhan, LLB, ACSP, MBA: No, but it's the truth, you know?
- 28:47I mean, I experience the same thing when I work at Bank of Montreal.
- 28:51Same tokenism. Oh.
- 28:53Brian Moore: Yeah. And it's demoralizing.
- 28:56Among other things.
- 28:58Donna J. Jodhan, LLB, ACSP, MBA: Yes it is. Yeah. It's demoralizing.
- 29:01It's discouraging. And you're saying, what the hell am I doing here?
- 29:05Brian Moore: Yeah.
- 29:06Donna J. Jodhan, LLB, ACSP, MBA: Am I here? What am I going to gain out of that?
- 29:10Right. But anyway,
- 29:11continue on. Tell us.
- 29:15Brian Moore: But so when this guy hired me and I, I'm deliberately not naming because he may
- 29:21not want me to. Yeah.
- 29:23Donna J. Jodhan, LLB, ACSP, MBA: Of course.
- 29:24Brian Moore: He might. But I don't.
- 29:29It was pretty much out of the gate. Like he gave me real work to do.
- 29:34And I thought, oh, this is kind of refreshing.
- 29:37Like I'm actually contributing.
- 29:40Yeah. And. And I did raise things that people hadn't
- 29:49thought of or, or knew, like didn't even know about that they should
- 29:54have known about as far as I'm concerned.
- 29:57I think the best example was one of the things you can do with an app,
- 30:04a banking app is deposit checks.
- 30:08Well, not if you're blind.
- 30:10Donna J. Jodhan, LLB, ACSP, MBA: You can't know unless I'm missing something
- 30:14myself. I don't.
- 30:15Brian Moore: Know. No, it's all of them.
- 30:17I I've done a lot of investigating since And you have to essentially line up a check to
- 30:26get it right. Well, there's actually one new U.S.
- 30:30bank and one UK bank that kind of have nailed this.
- 30:35But I wish I had an account.
- 30:36I don't have an account either because I'd love to see actually see the experience.
- 30:42Donna J. Jodhan, LLB, ACSP, MBA: Yeah.
- 30:44Brian Moore: But when I came, I said, for example, that I can't do this.
- 30:51I can go deposit in the machine, but that means I have to go to the branch.
- 30:56Right. But I can't do it in the app.
- 31:00Donna J. Jodhan, LLB, ACSP, MBA: No.
- 31:01Brian Moore: Well, once or once or twice I was successful,
- 31:04but it was a fluke. And they said, oh, we never thought of that.
- 31:10And there were many other things.
- 31:12Right. Like so I would for example, go on our Mortgage stuff and say,
- 31:21you know, here's a barrier, here's a barrier. Here's because the people
- 31:25that were testing aren't actually users, right?
- 31:30They're people who, who have been told, okay,
- 31:34well, you have to test for this, but they don't use it. So they don't know
- 31:37what it's supposed to do.
- 31:38And my argument is if you don't know what it's supposed to do, you
- 31:40can't know if it's wrong.
- 31:42Donna J. Jodhan, LLB, ACSP, MBA: Well that's true. I mean, if I don't know what I'm supposed to do,
- 31:47how the hell can I test it?
- 31:49Brian Moore: Right.
- 31:50Donna J. Jodhan, LLB, ACSP, MBA: Yeah.
- 31:51Brian Moore: Okay. And, I mean, then there were other issues,
- 31:57like with real estate and stuff.
- 31:58Like with our building, for example, we have.
- 32:03What they call destination dispatch elevators,
- 32:07which are the ones where there's a touch screen and you tell it which floor you want
- 32:11and it tells you which elevator to
- 32:13take. Okay.
- 32:15Donna J. Jodhan, LLB, ACSP, MBA: Okay.
- 32:17Brian Moore: And it had a quote unquote quote.
- 32:19Accessibility mode. Very much in quotes that I don't think anyone's ever tried until I
- 32:27showed up and I said, hey, this is crap.
- 32:32It doesn't work properly.
- 32:36And here's what's wrong.
- 32:37Here's what it's doing.
- 32:38Here's what it's not doing.
- 32:41And I have to use this thing many, many times a day because I have meetings on
- 32:47all different floors of our building.
- 32:49I mean, we've moved since then, but our new building has that system too.
- 32:56But people, I mean, now that I've been there eight years,
- 33:02what I hear is that, you know, people respect me.
- 33:06They say, you know what you're doing.
- 33:09You give good counsel.
- 33:13You can convey information to different audiences.
- 33:16Well, so apparently I'm respected.
- 33:20At least that's what they said.
- 33:22That's what they said in my performance review.
- 33:24I don't know if it's true.
- 33:26Donna J. Jodhan, LLB, ACSP, MBA: Of course it's true. But you know, that's I think that's a great compliment for
- 33:33people, especially to us folks who are vision impaired.
- 33:37Right. You are respected because you know what you're saying.
- 33:41I mean, yeah, I kind of wonder sometimes if people really think of us as being.
- 33:48Do you know what I'm saying?
- 33:51Brian Moore: Yeah. Oh, that's absolutely a thing still.
- 33:55And I think. The truth is we're going to have to work a lot harder to prove ourselves than
- 34:02other people will. That's just the reality.
- 34:05Yeah. But it's not impossible.
- 34:08Donna J. Jodhan, LLB, ACSP, MBA: No, there's a lot of hard.
- 34:10Brian Moore: It's hard and it's hard.
- 34:11And it continues to be hard.
- 34:13Like every I again, I, I'm too old to have filters every day.
- 34:19There are barriers I encounter, and sometimes they're still demoralizing and
- 34:24I get exhausted and think, how long can I keep doing this?
- 34:28For example, as a a people manager, I encountered things where,
- 34:33okay, I have to do forms for people that report to me and those forms aren't
- 34:39accessible. Well, now I have a problem, right?
- 34:42They have a right to expect that that stuff will be confidential.
- 34:47So I can't ask a teammate to help me.
- 34:50Donna J. Jodhan, LLB, ACSP, MBA: No, no you
- 34:51can't. Wow. So what?
- 34:55Brian Moore: So there's workarounds.
- 35:01Engage people in different higher up not specifically for that,
- 35:07but so one of the funny story, one of the things I had to do when I started,
- 35:12they did use this third party company to do a pretty in-depth background check.
- 35:18Donna J. Jodhan, LLB, ACSP, MBA: Yes.
- 35:19Brian Moore: Including fact checking, like the standard stuff.
- 35:22Criminal record check.
- 35:23Most vulnerable sector.
- 35:25Although I don't know why they did vulnerable sector, but they did it. But they also fact
- 35:31checked your resume, which they didn't do very well.
- 35:38Because they didn't know what half the stuff was like,
- 35:40some of the certifications I had and stuff.
- 35:43And they just said, oh, we don't know how to find that. And you could
- 35:45have found it in a two minute search.
- 35:48Donna J. Jodhan, LLB, ACSP, MBA: Yeah.
- 35:49Brian Moore: To verify it, but it was completely inaccessible.
- 35:54And I called the company and they, you know,
- 35:56they said, we don't care.
- 35:58Reach out to your employer, talk to them about it.
- 36:01Yeah. So I got my, at the time, 11 year old kid to sign,
- 36:08fill out and sign my background check on.
- 36:17Donna J. Jodhan, LLB, ACSP, MBA: Oh my lord.
- 36:19Brian Moore: And I've told my employer this many times since,
- 36:21right? That technically I never signed the background check my 11 year old kid did.
- 36:26He did it at my direction.
- 36:28Donna J. Jodhan, LLB, ACSP, MBA: Of course, but still, he was 11 years old.
- 36:30I mean, I wonder what was going through Graham's mind.
- 36:34Brian Moore: It's not like he can enter into a contract at 11 years old.
- 36:39Donna J. Jodhan, LLB, ACSP, MBA: I wonder what he was thinking.
- 36:41Did he ever share his thoughts?
- 36:43Brian Moore: No, I don't think he cared.
- 36:44It's just like, okay, dad needs me to help him with this thing.
- 36:47Donna J. Jodhan, LLB, ACSP, MBA: Yes, I'll help him out.
- 36:49Brian Moore: Yeah.
- 36:53Donna J. Jodhan, LLB, ACSP, MBA: Fine. There is a real difference between reading and audit
- 37:02that somebody else wrote, and putting your own hands on a product that
- 37:10your own screen reader.
- 37:14What do you catch that an automated scan would never catch and that a sighted tester
- 37:24would never catch either.
- 37:27Brian Moore: So there are several things.
- 37:28First of all, automated scanning.
- 37:31It certainly has value.
- 37:33Yeah. But it can't catch everything.
- 37:36And it doesn't even pretend to catch everything.
- 37:39Like short of the companies claiming AI magic.
- 37:47Automated. Sorry.
- 37:55Donna J. Jodhan, LLB, ACSP, MBA: You okay?
- 37:58Brian Moore: Yeah. I made it. Scans typically can catch about 30% to 40% of accessibility
- 38:07issues. Things like code mistakes.
- 38:15Color contrast because that's easy, right?
- 38:18It's a binary for the most part with a machine can do it.
- 38:21But. There are many things that a machine will never be able to tell.
- 38:31Like, okay, a machine can tell you, for example,
- 38:35if an image has an alternative text, right?
- 38:39But it can't tell you if it's any good.
- 38:41Donna J. Jodhan, LLB, ACSP, MBA: Right? Right. Yeah.
- 38:43Brian Moore: I mean, it could, they could just could just be a space character and that will pass an
- 38:47automated check with a machine because there's something there.
- 38:56It can't tell you. Does your heading structure make sense?
- 39:03You know, are your headings logical on a page?
- 39:05Donna J. Jodhan, LLB, ACSP, MBA: Right. Right.
- 39:09Brian Moore: I can tell you if your form fields have labels,
- 39:11but it can't tell you if they're the right labels.
- 39:15Donna J. Jodhan, LLB, ACSP, MBA: Right, right. Right. Yeah.
- 39:18Yeah. Understood.
- 39:22Brian Moore: It can't tell you. Is it easy for someone to go through this process?
- 39:33Those are things that you need a human.
- 39:38And it helps, like I said before, if that human has some idea what's the
- 39:44expected behavior. So has actually had some experience using the tools that they're
- 39:52supposed to test with.
- 39:58So for example, a machine can never tell you that if someone is zooming their screen,
- 40:07this piece of text is going to get cut off.
- 40:12Only human can do that.
- 40:15Now, I can't do that. I can make guesses.
- 40:22Or for example, things like colors.
- 40:24I can't tell you if someone's if the colors are accessible,
- 40:29like passing or not, because even the tools to check it aren't actually accessible.
- 40:35Okay. But that's, you can use automation to a point for that.
- 40:45So automation has a place and a good place, like particularly because on something large,
- 40:52like a bank site, a lot of your issues will be in what they call in templates.
- 40:59Right. So yeah, you know, it'll be on a thousand pages that are based
- 41:03off that template. So if you fix it once, you'll fix a thousand pages.
- 41:07Donna J. Jodhan, LLB, ACSP, MBA: Right? Okay. Brian, you and I share
- 41:17something very painful.
- 41:21I said a certification exam with every one of my accommodations approved.
- 41:28And I still could not finish it because nobody in that room could describe the
- 41:36diagrams to me. You have told me that your experience was almost identical roughly
- 41:45two decades earlier. Would you walk our listeners through what happened to you that
- 41:55day and tell us whether anyone ever acknowledged it afterwards?
- 42:04Brian Moore: So yes, I will. So in 2010, I started taking
- 42:14Cisco courses because I wanted to get the certified Cisco Certified Network Architect
- 42:21designation, which is really nerdy.
- 42:25Donna J. Jodhan, LLB, ACSP, MBA: Yes.
- 42:26Brian Moore: But it's in my my love hobby area that I love,
- 42:31which is networks and network security and that sort of thing.
- 42:38At the time, there was a project out of the University of Perth in Western Australia.
- 42:49Called the Cisco Academy for the Visually impaired.
- 42:52Donna J. Jodhan, LLB, ACSP, MBA: Oh okay.
- 42:55Brian Moore: And they. Did a really good job of sort of teaching some of the sort of beginning level
- 43:04courses And giving you accessible material, which was all great.
- 43:13And a lot of work and they did a really good job.
- 43:16Thanks, doctor. Ian Murray.
- 43:18I don't know what ever happened to him, but he was sort of the guy that led that
- 43:23project. But then you get to the exam and
- 43:35you could get a reader for the exam.
- 43:40But the problem is that much of those exams are based on diagrams and context.
- 43:50In those diagrams is everything.
- 43:53It's critical that whoever's trying to convey that information has some clue what they're
- 44:02on about And what you suggested in your articles is absolutely the solution that the
- 44:10descriptive text for those diagrams should be standardized and come from the provider.
- 44:14It should not be up to the reader because.
- 44:19It's impossible for a reader to neutrally convey that information,
- 44:25right? If they know too much about the subject matter, they're probably going to
- 44:31slant their description to give you a more correct answer,
- 44:36because they can't help it, right? Because they know what they're reading
- 44:39and they understand it.
- 44:42But if they don't know, they won't know enough to describe,
- 44:48describe it. And.
- 44:59That's a blocker when it comes to these exams You can't complete them without being able to
- 45:07read and interpret those diagrams.
- 45:11And while it's the exam paper taker's job to glean the correct information out of
- 45:21those diagrams. They're very complicated.
- 45:29You need to ask a ton of questions that someone who isn't familiar with the material
- 45:34will probably really struggle to answer.
- 45:40Donna J. Jodhan, LLB, ACSP, MBA: Yeah.
- 45:41Brian Moore: And what I discovered was that as you get further,
- 45:47even if you pass that hurdle, then you get into virtualized lab exams,
- 45:54which were on simulators.
- 45:58And that was also completely inaccessible.
- 46:00So I would have even had I got past that hurdle,
- 46:04if I wanted to proceed any further, I would have been stuck again with another
- 46:08system with no alternatives.
- 46:13The only I mean, the people in Australia acknowledged this was a thing.
- 46:20The only other actual acknowledgement I got was actually from a lawyer from the
- 46:26NFB in the States.
- 46:28Donna J. Jodhan, LLB, ACSP, MBA: Okay.
- 46:31Brian Moore: I forget her name, but they were trying to sort of push this issue forward.
- 46:40And I was sort of keen to participate, but then at that point in my life,
- 46:44lots of life was happening.
- 46:46So I kind of got sidetracked.
- 46:53But yeah, I mean, when I read your series of articles,
- 46:56it's like, well, we really haven't
- 46:58progressed, have we?
- 46:59Donna J. Jodhan, LLB, ACSP, MBA: No. What do we do about this?
- 47:03And this is my final question to you because my clock was winding down.
- 47:06What what can we do?
- 47:10Brian Moore: Well, I think. We need to I mean, it's always going to be a problem,
- 47:18right? Getting certifications is really tough.
- 47:24Like, I mean, more recently I tried to get project management certification because I
- 47:30thought that would actually be somewhat useful in my day to day work,
- 47:34which would. And I ran into very similar barriers.
- 47:42I got to a certain point in the course material and then I started hitting the,
- 47:50you need to create these color coded charts and various things.
- 47:54Donna J. Jodhan, LLB, ACSP, MBA: Yeah.
- 47:59Brian Moore: So I don't know what the answer is.
- 48:01I mean, I think the answer for a lot of it is,
- 48:06is if we're going to offer certifications, things like alternative descriptions for
- 48:12diagrams must be provided by the test provider.
- 48:16There's no way around that.
- 48:19Donna J. Jodhan, LLB, ACSP, MBA: No, no.
- 48:21Brian Moore: And ideally not use a reader, use a computer.
- 48:26Because a reader, it's too hard with a reader.
- 48:29Donna J. Jodhan, LLB, ACSP, MBA: Yeah. Because everybody interprets things differently.
- 48:32Brian Moore: Yeah.
- 48:33Donna J. Jodhan, LLB, ACSP, MBA: Picture's worth a thousand words.
- 48:34Brian Moore: Yeah. I want and and I can go faster with a computer and I can query.
- 48:39I can query back. Oh. What did it say three sentences ago?
- 48:42Yeah. That's not so easy with the reader.
- 48:44Donna J. Jodhan, LLB, ACSP, MBA: No, because they get tired.
- 48:47Brian Moore: Yeah.
- 48:47Donna J. Jodhan, LLB, ACSP, MBA: They get frustrated. Yeah.
- 48:49And and, you know, when they say the second time,
- 48:52it may not be the same as the first time.
- 48:54Brian Moore: Yeah. Yeah. It's not I mean.
- 49:00I don't know if many of the tests for any certifications are accessible.
- 49:06And I'm not sure about, for example, the certification actual exam
- 49:12because I never finished the course material because I ran into too many barriers.
- 49:17I mean, I learned a lot of good stuff that I actually use,
- 49:21but I don't have the paper.
- 49:24Donna J. Jodhan, LLB, ACSP, MBA: Well, that's the same for me. I mean, I learned a lot in my cybersecurity course,
- 49:28but I don't have the paper.
- 49:30Where am I going to go?
- 49:33I have nowhere to go.
- 49:35Brian Moore: Yeah.
- 49:39Donna J. Jodhan, LLB, ACSP, MBA: Kind of a down note to end this really, really interesting.
- 49:42Brian Moore: Yeah. I mean. I in a way it's good.
- 49:48So I can put a positive spin on it this way.
- 49:52It's a good problem to have because more of us are getting to the position where we care
- 49:56about that stuff?
- 49:58Donna J. Jodhan, LLB, ACSP, MBA: Yeah, right.
- 50:01Brian Moore: Where we're getting into we want professional certifications in,
- 50:06you know, whatever. Discipline. Yeah.
- 50:11Donna J. Jodhan, LLB, ACSP, MBA: So with the caring be enough for us to come together to push
- 50:19these providers.
- 50:25Brian Moore: I don't know if there's enough of us yet, but we're getting there.
- 50:28Donna J. Jodhan, LLB, ACSP, MBA: Okay.
- 50:30Brian Moore: Now, in some ways, I think we've regressed over the past few years.
- 50:37Because there's, there is quite a, you know,
- 50:39a real push. Against marginalized groups.
- 50:45Like, I mean, it started as a sort of anti Dei push,
- 50:48but accessibility got caught up in that.
- 50:50Right. And it's not just the US government.
- 50:53Right. It's That gave a lot of people permission to say the quiet bits out loud
- 51:01that they wouldn't say before.
- 51:09But I still think. We're progressing.
- 51:14It's just not as quickly as I'd like.
- 51:17I think we've regressed a bit in the last couple of years,
- 51:21but I think we'll get back.
- 51:25And I mean, I'm far closer to the end of my career than the beginning.
- 51:29Donna J. Jodhan, LLB, ACSP, MBA: So am I.
- 51:30Brian Moore: But. But You know, I, I'll never
- 51:39stop sort of pushing for this stuff even if I'm not working.
- 51:44It's just too ingrained in who I am as a person.
- 51:51And some fights are worth having.
- 51:54I mean, some sometimes.
- 51:56I mean, I've always I always say to people, you pick your battles, right? Some things are
- 51:59just not worth the struggle.
- 52:00Not worth the effort.
- 52:02Donna J. Jodhan, LLB, ACSP, MBA: I agree. You pick your battles and like you like.
- 52:07Brian Moore: I just don't take Uber because I get sick of being refused.
- 52:12Donna J. Jodhan, LLB, ACSP, MBA: Yeah.
- 52:13Brian Moore: So I'll just keep my money.
- 52:15And I mean, occasionally that's a battle worth having,
- 52:17but mostly not. I don't care.
- 52:19Just take transit. Which maybe is conceding, but ultimately,
- 52:25I just want to live my life.
- 52:29And that has to be the end goal.
- 52:32You know, I, I'm all about being an advocate.
- 52:34I love doing it. I, I don't mind doing it, but I also just get on with life.
- 52:42Donna J. Jodhan, LLB, ACSP, MBA: Yeah. There comes a point when you say, you know, I got to enjoy the rest of my life.
- 52:47Brian Moore: Yeah.
- 52:48Donna J. Jodhan, LLB, ACSP, MBA: And you pick your battles and you go on and.
- 52:53Brian Moore: And, some battles you don't win.
- 52:54Like, I had a years long battle with Toronto District School Board to try and get an
- 52:59accessible report card.
- 53:02Donna J. Jodhan, LLB, ACSP, MBA: Oh.
- 53:03Brian Moore: Which was ultimately not successful.
- 53:05And now it doesn't matter anymore.
- 53:07They won. But.
- 53:11Donna J. Jodhan, LLB, ACSP, MBA: I mean, you know.
- 53:13Brian Moore: Now I don't have a stake in that game.
- 53:16Donna J. Jodhan, LLB, ACSP, MBA: No. Because your son is is
- 53:19finished. He's done.
- 53:20Brian Moore: Yeah.
- 53:22Donna J. Jodhan, LLB, ACSP, MBA: It takes a lot for someone to admit you didn't get what you wanted.
- 53:26And I haven't gotten what I wanted in many instances.
- 53:29Brian Moore: Yeah.
- 53:30Donna J. Jodhan, LLB, ACSP, MBA: But you got to draw the line and move on, you know?
- 53:35Brian Moore: Yeah. I mean, advocacy is great, and it's good and worth doing.
- 53:40Absolutely. But ultimately, we have to be able to live life and hopefully
- 53:47enjoy some of it. I.
- 53:50Donna J. Jodhan, LLB, ACSP, MBA: I hope so. Yeah, you still have to be able to go enjoy a nice meal,
- 53:57enjoy some drinks, you know what I mean?
- 53:59Yeah. Some travel. You cannot it burns you out.
- 54:04Brian Moore: Yeah.
- 54:05Donna J. Jodhan, LLB, ACSP, MBA: And it comes to a point where you say, I've had enough here.
- 54:09I'm gone, you know. But I want to thank you, Brian.
- 54:14I think I said, you know, we go back many years and I've watched you
- 54:17grow. I've watched you do a lot of things.
- 54:19I've admired your technical skills.
- 54:22You put me to shame sometimes, but, you know,
- 54:27keep on going. Don't give up.
- 54:29Brian Moore: Oh, I won't.
- 54:30Donna J. Jodhan, LLB, ACSP, MBA: No, I know you won't. Pick your battles.
- 54:33And you know, every now and then we would get together and talk about what's going on.
- 54:38Especially when Richard comes to town.
- 54:39I don't know when he's coming to town again, but you know,
- 54:43we should we should have some sort of a get together sometime in the fall.
- 54:49Brian Moore: Yeah. Sounds good.
- 54:51Donna J. Jodhan, LLB, ACSP, MBA: You know, maybe Melanie or I shouldn't be naming names here,
- 54:55but we'll work on it. How about that?
- 54:59Brian Moore: Yeah. Sounds good.
- 55:00Donna J. Jodhan, LLB, ACSP, MBA: Okay.
- 55:01Brian Moore: Yeah.
- 55:03Donna J. Jodhan, LLB, ACSP, MBA: Thank you so much, Brian, for taking the time.
- 55:05I know you're an awfully busy guy.
- 55:06Say hello to Graham. I don't know if he remembers me.
- 55:10I used to call him Little Prince.
- 55:12Brian Moore: I don't think he probably does, but.
- 55:15Donna J. Jodhan, LLB, ACSP, MBA: Yeah. But let's work on getting together some time,
- 55:21and we'll go from there.
- 55:23Brian Moore: Okay.
- 55:24Donna J. Jodhan, LLB, ACSP, MBA: All right.
- 55:25Brian Moore: All right.
- 55:26Donna J. Jodhan, LLB, ACSP, MBA: Thank you so much. Hey.
- 55:27Brian Moore: Thanks. Take care.
- 55:28Donna J. Jodhan, LLB, ACSP, MBA: Take care. Brian.
- 55:29Brian Moore: Bye.
- 55:30Donna J. Jodhan, LLB, ACSP, MBA: Bye bye.
- 55:34Podcast Commentator: Donna wants to hear from you and invites you to write to her at donna@gmail.com.
- 55:40Until next time.