Latest / eMotors: Electric Revolution / The Delayed Horizon of Solid-State Battery Production
Transcript
- 0:10Welcome back to the Deep Dive. Today we are tackling what might
- 0:13be the single most hyped technology in the entire
- 0:16Automotive World. Oh, this is a big one.
- 0:19It is if you follow EV news, even, you know, casually, or if
- 0:23you just own a smartphone that dies by 4:00 PM, you have seen
- 0:26the headlines. I'm talking about the Holy Grail
- 0:30of energy storage. We're talking about batteries
- 0:34that promise a 1000 kilometer range, charging from zero to 80%
- 0:38in literal minutes. And this is the crucial part 0
- 0:42risk of Catching Fire. We're talking, of course, about
- 0:45solid-state batteries. Is a technology that is always
- 0:48just around the corner, isn't it?
- 0:49It feels a little bit like the nuclear fusion of the car world,
- 0:52always five years away. Exactly.
- 0:54I feel like I've been reading about this for a decade.
- 0:56Toyota promised them by 2025, Samsung said they were right
- 1:00there. And yet, I walked out to my car
- 1:02this morning and guess what? Still lithium ion.
- 1:04Still running on a lithium ion battery, the exact same tech in
- 1:07my laptop and my phone. So the question we really need
- 1:09to answer today is what is actually going on?
- 1:12Is this vaporware or is it actually have?
- 1:14It is happening, but perhaps not in the way the marketing
- 1:18brochures would have you believe.
- 1:20It's a lot messier and frankly a lot more interesting from an
- 1:23engineering perspective than just better batteries.
- 1:26So our mission today is simple. We are going to cut through all
- 1:30that noise. No marketing fluff, just the
- 1:33engineering reality. We're going to look at the
- 1:35chemistry, the costs, and the absolute production hell that
- 1:39stands between US and that 1000 kilometer drive.
- 1:42Sounds good, but before we get into the nitty gritty, I need to
- 1:45take a second here and do something important.
- 1:46What's that? I just want to say a massive
- 1:49thank you to our listeners, to the learners, seriously, we see
- 1:53your emails, we see you sharing the show.
- 1:55And whether you're an engineer prepping for a meeting or just
- 1:58someone who's, you know, insanely curious about how the
- 2:01world works, we really appreciate you tuning in.
- 2:04We do. We know this topic is confusing.
- 2:06There's so much conflicting info out there.
- 2:08So this deep dive is dedicated to clearing that up for you.
- 2:11So seriously, thank you for being here and trusting us with
- 2:14your time. Absolutely critical thinking is
- 2:17in short supply these days, and we appreciate you diving deep
- 2:20with us. And to help us do that, today we
- 2:22have a serious stack of sources. That's here.
- 2:25We're pulling from technology Rd. maps by the Fraunhofer
- 2:27Institute, market analysis from Trendforce and Bloomberg NEF,
- 2:32and some very, very candid industry reports coming out of
- 2:35China and the US. OK, let's unpack this.
- 2:37First things first, clarity. We need a baseline what exactly
- 2:42is a solid-state battery because I think a lot of people just
- 2:45assume it's a better battery. But like physically what is
- 2:48different inside the casing? It really all comes down to 1
- 2:50component, the electrolyte. Let's visualize the battery.
- 2:54You have now a standard lithium ion battery.
- 2:57You've got a cathode and an anode.
- 2:58Right, the positive and negative ends.
- 3:00Exactly. And between them occupying that
- 3:03space, you have a liquid electrolyte.
- 3:06Think of that liquid as a highway for ions to travel back
- 3:08and forth. When you charge, the ions move
- 3:11one way. When you drive your car or use
- 3:13your phone, they move the other way.
- 3:15That liquid is what makes the movement possible.
- 3:17Right, and the issue with the current tech is that the liquid
- 3:20itself is problematic. It's volatile.
- 3:24It's a chemical solvent. It's flammable and it has speed
- 3:27limits. You know the ions can only move
- 3:29through that liquid soup so fast without generating too much
- 3:32heat. So a solid-state battery simply
- 3:35it just deletes the liquid. Effectively, yes, it replaces
- 3:39that liquid highway with a solid material.
- 3:41Could be a ceramic, a type of glass, or even a polymer.
- 3:44But the key functional difference is that there is no
- 3:47sloshing liquid inside that cell.
- 3:50The highway becomes a solid bridge.
- 3:52Simple enough concept, but why is everyone so obsessed with
- 3:55this? Why are companies spending
- 3:56billions of dollars to reinvent the wheel here?
- 3:59If liquid works, why change it? Comes down to three main
- 4:01reasons. Let's call them the three
- 4:03promises. First, and this is paramount for
- 4:05manufacturers, is safety. As I just said, liquid
- 4:08electrolytes are flammable and toxic.
- 4:10If you puncture a standard battery in a bad crash, you can
- 4:14get a thermal runaway event a fire.
- 4:16Which is the headline nightmare for any EV company.
- 4:19You see one car fire on the news and it just.
- 4:21It dominates the cycle for weeks.
- 4:22Exactly. Solids generally don't catch
- 4:24fire. They are chemically and
- 4:26thermally stable, you can puncture them and typically they
- 4:29just sit there. That safety profile changes
- 4:31everything. It means you need less cooling
- 4:34equipment, less heavy armor around the battery pack.
- 4:37Which leads right to the second promise, doesn't it?
- 4:39If you don't need all that armor and cooling, plumbing.
- 4:42You get better energy density. This is the big number everyone
- 4:45chases. Our sources indicate that while
- 4:47current batteries hold about, say, 150 to 300 Watt hours per
- 4:52kilogram, solid-state batteries could theoretically hit 300 to
- 4:56900. Let's contextualize that for
- 4:58everyone. That means you could have a car
- 5:00that goes twice as far on a battery of the same weight, or
- 5:03or conversely, a car with the same range that weighs half as
- 5:06much. Precisely.
- 5:08It breaks a weight spiral that a lot of EVs are currently stuck
- 5:10in. We keep making cars heavier to
- 5:12get more range, which of course makes them less efficient.
- 5:14solid-state could break that loop.
- 5:16And the third promise is the one consumers care about most
- 5:19charging speed. The gas station experience.
- 5:22I want to plug in, buy a snack and leave.
- 5:24And because of how the ions move through these solid structures
- 5:29and because the materials can handle much higher heat without
- 5:31degrading, we are looking at potential charging times of 10
- 5:34to 80% in just three to 15 minutes.
- 5:37That's the dream. Fill up in the time it takes to
- 5:39grab a coffee. But, and here's the big pivot,
- 5:42if the tech is so good and the concept is so simple, you know,
- 5:46swap liquid for solid, why aren't we driving them?
- 5:50This brings us to what one of our sources called the crisis of
- 5:53credibility. Yes, this is where it gets
- 5:56really fascinating. The term solid-state has become
- 6:00a massive marketing buzzword, and frankly, it's starting to
- 6:04lose its meaning. There was a great analogy in one
- 6:06of the sources we looked at. The Gelato 1.
- 6:08The Gelato versus frozen dessert analogy.
- 6:11I loved this. It's the perfect way to
- 6:13visualize the marketing tricks. So you go to the store, you buy
- 6:15what you think is ice cream, but the label says frozen dairy
- 6:18dessert. Right, because it doesn't meet
- 6:20the legal definition of ice cream.
- 6:21It's not too much air or oil in it or something.
- 6:24Exactly. And in the battery world, we
- 6:25have all solid-state batteries, which have 0 liquid.
- 6:28That's the pure Gelato. But then we have companies
- 6:31announcing these solid-state breakthroughs that are actually.
- 6:34Semi solid or quasi solid? So they're just blurring the
- 6:37lines. Significantly, a semi solid
- 6:39battery might still contain about say 10% liquid
- 6:44electrolyte. It's just enough to help the
- 6:46ions jump across the interface between the solid parts.
- 6:50A quasi solid might have less than 5%.
- 6:53They're basically wetting the solid material just a little bit
- 6:56to make it work OK, but. Let me play devil's advocate
- 6:58here. Does that, does that really
- 7:00matter if I'm a driver? Do I care if my battery is 5%
- 7:04liquid if it charges in 10 minutes and doesn't explode?
- 7:06And that is the pragmatic argument.
- 7:08If the user experience delivers the range and the safety, the
- 7:11specific definition matters less to the consumer.
- 7:14In fact, we are already seeing these semi solid batteries on
- 7:17the road. Really.
- 7:18Yeah, NIO and MG are deploying cars with these hybrid batteries
- 7:23right now. They're the bridge technology.
- 7:26They give you some of the benefits of solid-state without
- 7:29the manufacturing nightmare of going 100% solid.
- 7:32So the pure solid-state, the stuff with 0 liquid, that's the
- 7:35hard part. Let's get into the chemistry
- 7:37here because I was surprised to learn there isn't just one type
- 7:40of solid-state battery. I thought it was just
- 7:42solid-state, but it's actually more like a cage match between
- 7:46three different materials. Correct, it is not a monolith.
- 7:49According to the Fraunhofer Institute road map, there are
- 7:52three main contenders fighting for dominance polymers, oxides,
- 7:56and sulfides. And here's the kicker.
- 7:59Each one has a sort of fatal flaw they're trying to fix.
- 8:03OK, let's break them down. Contender #1 Polymers.
- 8:06Polymers are the most mature technology.
- 8:08They're basically plastics. We actually already have these
- 8:11in some electric buses, like the Blue Bus fleet in Europe.
- 8:14They're relatively easy to manufacture because they're
- 8:16flexible. You can roll them up like a
- 8:17carpet. There's always a butt.
- 8:19But they have terrible conductivity at room
- 8:20temperature. The ions really struggle to move
- 8:23through the plastic unless it's hot.
- 8:25They need to be heated to about 50 to 80°C to work efficiently.
- 8:30So not great for a passenger car sitting in a driveway in
- 8:32Minnesota in January. You'd spend all your battery
- 8:34energy just trying to warm up the battery so it could start
- 8:37the car. Exactly.
- 8:38Great for a bus that runs all day on a schedule, but terrible
- 8:41for a family car that needs to start instantly for a quick trip
- 8:44to the grocery store. OK, contender #2 oxides or
- 8:49ceramics? These are very chemically stable
- 8:51and tough. They're safe.
- 8:54The problem is purely physical. They are brittle.
- 8:58Think of a ceramic dinner plate. It's hard, but if you twist it
- 9:02or stress it, it cracks. And a car is basically a
- 9:04vibrating box moving at 70 mph over potholes.
- 9:07Right. If the electrolyte cracks, the
- 9:09battery fails. Plus making them is incredibly
- 9:12hard. You have to center them.
- 9:13Centering is basically baking the ceramic at extremely high
- 9:16temperatures. We're talking over 1000°C to
- 9:20fuse all the particles together. That sounds incredibly energy
- 9:23intensive. It is.
- 9:24It takes a massive amount of energy which drives up the
- 9:27manufacturing cost and the carbon footprint ironically.
- 9:31So you have a battery that is hard to make and easy to break.
- 9:34Not a winning combination yet. OK, so polymers are too cold,
- 9:38oxides are too brittle. What about contender #3
- 9:41sulfides? The sources seem most excited
- 9:44about these. Sulfides are the speedsters.
- 9:46They have the best conductivity by far.
- 9:49The ions move through them incredibly fast, sometimes even
- 9:52faster than in liquid. This makes them the best
- 9:55candidate for that super fast charging we talked about.
- 9:58Toyota is betting big on these. Let me guess.
- 10:00There's a catch. A big smelly catch.
- 10:03Sulfides are incredibly sensitive to moisture.
- 10:06If a sulfide electrolyte touches even a tiny bit of humidity in
- 10:09the air, it reacts and releases hydrogen sulfide gas.
- 10:13Which is. Highly toxic and smells like
- 10:15rotten eggs. Not exactly a selling point for
- 10:17a luxury vehicle. New car scent now with a hint of
- 10:20lethal rotten egg. And practically, it means you
- 10:23can't just build these in a normal factory.
- 10:25You have to manufacture them in extremely controlled dry rooms
- 10:29or inert gas chambers. This drives up the cost and the
- 10:32complexity enormously. You can't have a single leak in
- 10:36the production line or you have a major safety hazard.
- 10:39This brings us perfectly to the next section of our dive
- 10:42roduction. Hell we know the science works
- 10:44in a lab we can make a coin size battery work perfectly, but
- 10:48scaling it U to millions of cars seems to be the real nightmare.
- 10:52It is. Let's talk about cost, because
- 10:54that is the ultimate decider right now.
- 10:57A standard lithium ion battery cost the manufacturer about $115
- 11:01per kWh. OK, so 100 kWh pack, which is a
- 11:04big battery for a long range car is roughly what, $11,500?
- 11:08Roughly now, estimates for solid-state batteries currently
- 11:11sit somewhere between 400 and $800 per kWh.
- 11:14Whoa. So we're talking 5 to 10 times
- 11:16the cost. Yes.
- 11:17So that same battery pack, instead of costing 11 grand,
- 11:20could cost $80,000 just for the battery.
- 11:23That makes the car completely unaffordable for mass adoption.
- 11:26You can't put an $80,000 battery in a $30,000 car.
- 11:29You can't, and it's so expensive because of the manufacturing
- 11:33process. You can't just take a factory
- 11:35making liquid batteries and switch a lever.
- 11:37You need entirely new equipment. For oxides, you need those
- 11:40massive high temperature furnaces for sulfides, you need
- 11:43those hermetically sealed dry rooms.
- 11:45And then there's the pressure issue.
- 11:47Pressure. This is a detail often left out
- 11:49of the headlines. To keep the solid layers
- 11:52touching each other so the ions can move esecially with the
- 11:55lithium metal anodes they want to use, you often need to alley
- 11:58immense pressure to the cell, sometimes over 10 megapascals.
- 12:0310 megapascals put that in perspective for us.
- 12:06It's like stacking a gym weight on every single square inch of
- 12:08the battery surface. You can't just take the battery
- 12:10together. You need heavy, expensive steel
- 12:13casing and clamping mechanisms to maintain that pressure for
- 12:16the life of the car. Which adds weight back into the
- 12:19car, defeating some of the purpose.
- 12:21Exactly. And there's one more ghost in
- 12:23the machine. Dendrites.
- 12:25I read about these. I thought solid batteries were
- 12:28supposed to fix the dendrite problem.
- 12:30That was the hope. Dendrites are these little
- 12:33needle like spikes of lithium that grow inside the battery
- 12:36when you charge it fast in a liquid battery they Pierce the
- 12:40separator and cause a short circuit boom boom in a solid.
- 12:45It turns out lithium is tricky. Even in solids, these dendrites
- 12:49can find tiny cracks or grain boundaries in the ceramic and
- 12:53just push right through. They can crack the electrolyte.
- 12:55Think of it like tree roots breaking up a concrete sidewalk.
- 12:58So. Even the indestructible battery
- 13:00has an Achilles heel. It does.
- 13:01Scientists are working on coatings and things to stop
- 13:04this, but it's another major hurdle.
- 13:06That is disheartening, but there's another thing the
- 13:08experts mentioned the moving target challenge.
- 13:11It's not like standard batteries are just sitting around waiting
- 13:13to be replaced. This is a crucial point that I
- 13:15think investors often miss while solid-state is struggling to
- 13:19figure out how to manufacture at scale standard lithium ion and
- 13:22LFP. That's lithium iron phosphate
- 13:25batteries are getting better every single year.
- 13:28Right. LFP batteries are already in
- 13:30tons of cars. They're cheap, they're durable.
- 13:33And they're evolving. We're seeing LFP mixed with
- 13:36manganese to hold more energy. We're seeing silicon anodes
- 13:39being added to liquid batteries to speed up charging.
- 13:42So solid-state isn't competing with the battery of today, it's
- 13:45competing with the liquid battery of 2030, which will be
- 13:49much cheaper and much better than what we have now.
- 13:51Exactly. solid-state has to chase a benchmark that keeps
- 13:55moving further and further away. By the time solid-state is
- 13:58ready, liquid batteries might already offer 800 kilometers of
- 14:02range and fast charging for a fraction of the price.
- 14:05So let's get real, I'm a listener.
- 14:07I'm looking to buy an EV in the next few years.
- 14:10When can I actually buy a car with a true all solid-state
- 14:14battery? OK.
- 14:14If we synthesize all the road maps from Toyota, Samsung,
- 14:18Nissan and the market analysts, here is the realistic timeline.
- 14:22Lay it on me. Phase 1 is basically now 2024 to
- 14:252027. This is the pilot phase.
- 14:27You will see headlines about Toyota or Nissan launching a
- 14:29vehicle, but be warned these will be small demonstration
- 14:33fleets. Like a few 100 cars.
- 14:35Maybe 1000 cars total. Not something you can walk into
- 14:38a dealership and buy. It's a proof of concept.
- 14:40OK, so mostly PR moves and real world testing Phase 2. 2027 to
- 14:452030, this is what we're calling the premium phase.
- 14:49You might see these batteries in a high end Lexus or a luxury
- 14:51Mercedes. We are talking about $100,000
- 14:55plus vehicles where the buyer can absorb that massive cost
- 14:58difference we talked about earlier.
- 15:00So for the average person, you. Are looking at phase three 20-30
- 15:04to 2035 and beyond. That is when mass market
- 15:07commercialization might begin, and I have to emphasize might.
- 15:102035 that feels like a lifetime away in tech years and here.
- 15:13Is the really sobering statistic from our sources at Trend Force,
- 15:17even by 20-30, solid steep batteries are expected to hold
- 15:20less than 1% of the total EV battery market, 1% less than 1%.
- 15:24Even by 2035 it might only be slightly above 1%.
- 15:28Wow, that really puts the hype in perspective.
- 15:30We talked about it like it's taking over tomorrow, but in
- 15:32reality, liquid batteries, lithium ion, are going to be
- 15:35king for a long, long time. Absolutely.
- 15:37Liquid is king. It has the supply chain, the
- 15:40economies of scale, and the proven reliability.
- 15:43Solid-state is the future, but it is a distant future.
- 15:46So what does this all mean for us right now?
- 15:49Should we be disappointed? No, I don't think so.
- 15:51I think it means we need to view this technology as an evolution,
- 15:55not a revolution. We aren't going to wake up one
- 15:57Tuesday and suddenly every car has a solid-state battery.
- 16:01We are going to see a transition.
- 16:02We'll see those hybrid semi solid batteries first.
- 16:05They offer, say, 80% of the benefits without that
- 16:09manufacturing nightmare. That actually makes a lot of
- 16:11sense. Why let perfect be the enemy of
- 16:13the good? If a semi solid battery gets me
- 16:16800 kilometers in charges in 12 minutes, I'm probably happy.
- 16:19I don't really care if there's a teaspoon of liquid inside.
- 16:22Precisely. And that raises the final big
- 16:24question for the industry that the source is all kind of hint
- 16:27at. Which is.
- 16:28If these bridge technologies, the semi solids, advance quickly
- 16:31enough, and if standard LFP batteries get good enough, will
- 16:35we even need full expensive solid-state batteries for the
- 16:39average family car? That is an interesting thought.
- 16:41Maybe the Holy Grail ends up being a niche product for super
- 16:45cars and performance vehicles while the rest of us drive on
- 16:47good enough tech that costs a fraction of the price.
- 16:50It is a very real possibility. The market usually chooses the
- 16:54most cost effective solution, not necessarily the
- 16:57scientifically perfect one. It's like VHS versus Betamax,
- 17:01right? Betamax was better, but VHS was
- 17:04cheaper and good enough. Great comparison.
- 17:06Well there you have it. Solid-state batteries,
- 17:09incredible science, massive potential, but stuck in a very
- 17:12expensive production hall for the foreseeable future.
- 17:15But definitely worth watching, the breakthroughs are happening,
- 17:17just slowly. Always worth watching.
- 17:19I want to thank you all again for listening to the deep dive.
- 17:22We hope this cleared up some of the confusion between the
- 17:24headlines and the reality. And don't forget to check back
- 17:27in with us in 20 to see if we were right.
- 17:30We'll set a calendar invite. Thanks everyone, stay curious.