Latest / Onramp Bitcoin Media / The New Frontier E003: Navigating Economic Shifts in the Middle East with Saifedean Ammous
Transcript
- 0:16Welcome to The New Frontier, a Bitcoin centric podcast that
- 0:19bridges the gap between the transformative world of Bitcoin
- 0:22and the unique financial landscape of the Middle East.
- 0:25This podcast is brought to you by Onramp Mino and is Co hosted
- 0:28by Ralph Debran, Managing Partner, Onramp Mino and Harris
- 0:31Irfan, CEO of Cordoba Capital Markets and advisor to Onramp
- 0:35Mino. Ralph and Harris have built
- 0:37their careers in traditional finance, accumulating extensive
- 0:40experience across capital markets, investment banking and
- 0:43asset management. Each episode delves deep into
- 0:46how Bitcoin is reshaping finance, technology and
- 0:49investment within the region and beyond.
- 0:51From macroeconomic trends to real world applications, and
- 0:54from Islamic finance to sustainable energy practices,
- 0:57this show covers it all. In this episode, we have a truly
- 1:01special guest who has profoundly shaped the global understanding
- 1:04of Bitcoin and sound money. He's an internationally best
- 1:07selling author. Whose?
- 1:08Works include the Bitcoin standard, the Fiat standard, and
- 1:11principles of economics. His insights have influenced
- 1:14thinkers, investors, and policy makers around the world.
- 1:18He's also the founder of the Safety dean.com platform
- 1:21dedicated to educating people on Bitcoin and sound monetary
- 1:24principles. We are honored to welcome to the
- 1:26show Saifuddin Ammuth. Get ready for an enlightening
- 1:29discussion that delves into the principles of economics.
- 1:32The future of Bitcoin. And what it means for both
- 1:34conventional and Islamic finance.
- 1:37Let's jump right in. Hey everyone, thank you for
- 1:40joining the New Frontier. We have a special guest today,
- 1:43Saifuddina Moose, a best selling author and one of my favorite
- 1:48authors actually here to talk about, you know, the general
- 1:52macroeconomics of the Middle East.
- 1:54So say first of all, thank you for being here.
- 1:57I'm joined by my Co host, Harris Irfan.
- 2:02Say thanks. Really appreciate you taking the
- 2:04time today. Thank you so much for having me,
- 2:06it's a pleasure. Great, great.
- 2:08So we're just going to dive straight into it.
- 2:11So safe given your work on macroeconomics, given you know,
- 2:16you thought in the Middle East, you spent time in the Middle
- 2:19East, had a few questions for you.
- 2:21So let's start it off with how have the economic, economic
- 2:25policies and strategies in the Middle East evolved in recent
- 2:29years? I mean, you've been here for
- 2:30quite some time. You've seen it evolve and you
- 2:33know, I want to understand more so in the context of
- 2:36diversifying away from oil dependence because the past few
- 2:40years, Middle East and oil have been intertwined.
- 2:45You can't think about one without the other, so.
- 2:48Please tell us your. Views on that.
- 2:50Yeah. I think the the transformation
- 2:53that has happened in the Gulf over the last couple of decades
- 2:56is truly remarkable. I think the World Cup in putter
- 3:00was a was a real milestone of a kind of very strong statement of
- 3:07the kind of economic capacity that exists in the region.
- 3:10Because I don't think there is anywhere else in the world that
- 3:13can host A1 city World Cup. I don't think any other city can
- 3:17host this. It's an enormous, enormous
- 3:19undertaking in terms of the infrastructure.
- 3:21So the world's major cities will have one or two World Cup level
- 3:27stadia. Maybe there are some big cities
- 3:30that can have three within driving distance from one
- 3:32another. Some of the very big
- 3:33metropolises, No cities that I know of have eight World Cup
- 3:38ready stadia. Qatar managed to pull together 9
- 3:42and they managed to get a lot of people to attend it and that was
- 3:45just from the people in Qatar. It was because of extensive
- 3:49amount of travel for people coming from all over the world
- 3:51through Qatar Airlines and other airlines into Qatar.
- 3:54So I think that in terms of organization was a truly
- 4:00monumental achievement. And the fact that it went so
- 4:03smoothly and it went so well, and of course it's reflected in
- 4:06the quality of the football because for the players, it was
- 4:10the best World Cup ever because they didn't have to travel.
- 4:12They were all in one hotel for five weeks.
- 4:15So they managed to get into, you know, acclimatize, get into the
- 4:20proper rhythm, not have to move hotel rooms every day or two,
- 4:24which usually ends up ruining most World Cup campaigns.
- 4:27Just a lot of travel and players having to adjust and acclimatize
- 4:31it. Usually by the time of the semi
- 4:32final, one of the teams has a major advantage because it's
- 4:35playing close to where it played its previous game, whereas the
- 4:38other team had to travel 4 hours by airplane.
- 4:40And it ends up being a decisive factor in the game.
- 4:42And so the Qatar World Cup managed to get rid of that and
- 4:45it wasn't something cheap. It's not something easy to
- 4:47replicate. You don't have other countries
- 4:49that are capable of doing something like this.
- 4:51So I think that was truly remarkable, and I think it's
- 4:54really raising a lot of eyebrows.
- 4:55Obviously during the World Cup, there was a lot of negative
- 4:58publicity and propaganda about Qatar and about the region in
- 5:01general, but I still think the achievement itself was truly
- 5:05remarkable. At the end of the day, nobody's
- 5:07going to remember any of that stuff.
- 5:08Everybody's going to remember the One City World Cup.
- 5:11But many people I know say that it was the best World Cup in
- 5:14their living memory and I agree with that.
- 5:16I think it was amazing. Yeah, I mean, just in terms of
- 5:19the quality of the football, it was incredible.
- 5:20It was every game was what? Maybe not every game, but it was
- 5:23it was the best World Cup. I think I used to think the 2014
- 5:26World Cup was the best I'd seen in my life.
- 5:28I think this one takes the award now.
- 5:32Yeah, I wish I was closer to home because I'm a big football
- 5:35fan and I would love to attend, but sadly I was in Canada where
- 5:41soccer is not a thing. It is, it's it's a bit of a
- 5:45thing. Canadians like their football,
- 5:47they just don't have a league. That's the problem in the US and
- 5:49Canada. They don't have a proper league.
- 5:51They have a franchise system which destroys the development
- 5:54of the sport. Yeah, I agree.
- 5:56And there's just so little investment in that space that,
- 6:00you know, the players don't get their value.
- 6:03You know, it's they'd rather do something else like play hockey
- 6:06or, you know, American football or something like that.
- 6:09And you know, it's not just Qatar though, save.
- 6:13I mean, you have Dubai Expo, you have Saudi Expo.
- 6:18It seems though that there's a lot of spending happening and
- 6:23over the long term seems to be paying off because it's like you
- 6:26said, raising eyebrows from an economic policies point of view.
- 6:31So do they do things differently in the Middle East compared to
- 6:36what we're accustomed to in the West in terms of monetary
- 6:40policy, fiscal policy? Yeah.
- 6:42I think one thing that's noticeable about the Gulf in
- 6:44particular is they've probably got the best monetary policy of,
- 6:49you could argue, any central bank in the world, because
- 6:52they've had their currencies back to the dollar.
- 6:54And none of them, I think, have depreciated significantly over
- 6:59the past 30-40 fifty years or so.
- 7:02And they've managed to maintain that effectively saying that
- 7:06they're not making any money from seniors.
- 7:08So inflation is not a source of income for the Gulf economies.
- 7:12They charge some taxes, very little taxes, but generally they
- 7:16leave people alone and they have an enormous amount of economic
- 7:19freedom. I think if you were to
- 7:21objectively assess the economic freedom in the Arab Gulf versus
- 7:24Europe in the US today, I think it's a lot freer in the aspects
- 7:30that matter the most, particularly taxation and
- 7:33inflation. So still of course they import
- 7:35the inflation from the West because the dollar is an
- 7:38inflationary currency and they're pegged to the dollar.
- 7:40They have to be pegged to the dollar almost, but well, they
- 7:43don't have to. But now we have Bitcoin, we're
- 7:46going to get to that. But given that it's the
- 7:50strengths of knowing that you have to use a dollar based
- 7:54system, they don't as good as you can expect.
- 7:57The currencies haven't devalued, taxes are very low.
- 7:59And I think what's truly remarkable now as you see that
- 8:03across the West, security is breaking down pretty much
- 8:06everywhere and the West is becoming less and less secure.
- 8:10The Gulf presents a truly good place for people to go and raise
- 8:13their families, for people to live.
- 8:15And so people who are interested in families, I think it's
- 8:18becoming more and more attractive to go there because
- 8:21the pay is good, the taxes are low, and the kids can play in
- 8:24the street. Very few places left in the
- 8:26world where kids can just go, wander out in the streets and
- 8:28play on their own. So I think this is truly
- 8:32remarkable. And the way that I see it, the
- 8:34way that I try and the way that I understand this remarkable
- 8:37transformation these places have witnessed, I think it's down to
- 8:40the fact that this is essentially a government that is
- 8:46in the market for a population. So they have had to learn how to
- 8:51run their governments properly because they need to get
- 8:53foreigners. All of these economies depend
- 8:55heavily on foreigners. And that means they're
- 8:58constantly trying to get the best deal out of the foreigners
- 9:02that they get and constantly trying to offer a better deal to
- 9:05the foreigners that they get. So I think this is similar to
- 9:09what you see in terms of markets.
- 9:11If there is a, if there's a firm that has a monopoly on its
- 9:13customers, you know, if you have the only gas station in a town
- 9:17or the only hospital in a town and by law nobody else can open
- 9:22another hospital, you have a, a captive population.
- 9:27And then you start neglecting the quality and focusing on how
- 9:30you can maximize the revenue that you can get from this
- 9:34captive market. Whereas in a situation where you
- 9:37have to compete for customers, you need to constantly be
- 9:40offering a better deal than other people.
- 9:42So the Gulf, I think since most of these countries or I think
- 9:45all of the countries have a majority of their population
- 9:47that is actually foreign, not local, they've developed
- 9:51extremely good institutions to try and attract people because
- 9:55why would people want to go live in a country that is not theirs
- 9:59unless it offered a very compelling package.
- 10:02And so I think this has helped them maintain this kind of
- 10:07competitive edge by constantly maintaining an attractive
- 10:13package for foreigners to come. And now we see people from all
- 10:15over the world coming. It's not just cheap labor, it's
- 10:19very expensive labor as well. And it's some of the most high
- 10:21skilled people want to move to these parts of the world because
- 10:24they've got a much better deal going on.
- 10:25I also think my other hobby horses to talk about monarchy.
- 10:29I'm a big fan of monarchy. It's not a very popular position
- 10:32to take. Very few people are brave enough
- 10:34to say this in public. But I have no problems with it.
- 10:36I think monarchy is a much better model for governance than
- 10:41democracy. Ideally, you know, I'm an
- 10:43anarchist. I don't want government, but
- 10:46pressed to choose. I'd rather have a king and a
- 10:49monarchy in particular, because I think the difference is that
- 10:52the monarch has a lot more security and power.
- 10:54And so he expects to be in power for a long time and he expects
- 10:59his children and grandchildren and great, great, great
- 11:01grandchildren to remain in power.
- 11:04So he has a time frame for his decision making that takes into
- 11:07account the well-being of you and your descendants generations
- 11:12from now, because he wants to make sure that his own kids are
- 11:15going to have a prosperous, peaceful Kingdom to be able to
- 11:20run and benefit from. And so I think this provides for
- 11:24an alignment of incentives that you don't see in democracies
- 11:27where every leader gets in and has four, five, 710 years,
- 11:31whatever in and in and in that time they can't, they are king,
- 11:36but it's only a short period of time.
- 11:38They can do whatever they want. They can do all kinds of things
- 11:40to benefit themselves and their children, but they can only do
- 11:44it for seven years. So they've got a very high time
- 11:46preference in that period. They care a lot about what
- 11:49happens in those seven years and they discount what happens
- 11:51later. And so that encourages them to
- 11:54borrow at the expense of the future and in order to finance
- 11:58the present. And they do that financially,
- 12:00but also in metaphorically in all kinds of different ways in
- 12:04terms of sacrificing the future for short term gain.
- 12:06So I think this and I think the Arab Gulf is a great
- 12:09advertisement for monarchies and you compare them to Arab
- 12:12countries that are not monarchies and you see very
- 12:16stark differences that I think should give a lot of the
- 12:19intellectuals in the Arab world a lot more to think about than
- 12:23they usually do. Very few people like to say the
- 12:26pro monarchy line, but even even monarchs, even pro people who
- 12:30are pro monarchy try and justify it by appealing to
- 12:33constitutionalism and appealing to parliamentary reforms.
- 12:37And that, you know, well, we're striving toward a democratic
- 12:40idea. But I, I think I'm
- 12:45unapologetically pro monarchy in a, in, in a strict sense, in the
- 12:49sense of the more decision making concentrated in an
- 12:52individual, the better he's able to carry out decisions.
- 12:55But I'd say the, the key thing for the success of this model,
- 12:59the way they are, I understand it, is that you need to have the
- 13:03respect for the right of people to exit or secede.
- 13:07And so here this I, I base this on the work of the Prince of the
- 13:10ruling Prince of Liechtenstein, Prince Hans Adam.
- 13:14He's written a book called The State in the Third Millennium.
- 13:17And in it he explains what he views as the vision of human
- 13:20freedom and what the state should offer in the third
- 13:22Millennium. And I think it's a very
- 13:23compelling and very mind opening vision wherein he says,
- 13:29essentially, look at how your iPhone is made.
- 13:34It's not made because all the iPhone users get to vote on who
- 13:38gets to be CEO. They don't get to vote on who
- 13:40gets to handle the design committees.
- 13:43They don't get to vote on any of that stuff.
- 13:45There's ACEO when he takes decisions and his decisions are
- 13:48practically final and that there is no right to appeal for the
- 13:52customers or for the workers. But everything is voluntary.
- 13:55And you as a customer, you only have one right, which is you
- 13:57could choose to buy it or not buy it.
- 14:00And the fact that you could just exit, the fact that you could
- 14:02choose to buy or not buy the good is what encourages and
- 14:08incentivizes everybody in that corporate structure, from the
- 14:11CEO down to the lowest employee to do their best.
- 14:14Because there are no bailouts in this world where if you don't
- 14:19deliver a good product, people are just not going to buy it and
- 14:22then your business is ruined. So that's ultimately what it
- 14:25comes down to is the right to exit.
- 14:29And what Prince Hans Adam presents is the idea that if
- 14:33this was the model for government, if people, if, if
- 14:35everybody respected the right for self determination, the
- 14:38right for secession so that individuals or individual
- 14:42regions could secede and exit countries, then governments
- 14:47would be a lot more accountable and they'd be a lot more
- 14:51efficient. And so for him, you know, all
- 14:54the last couple of 100 years of political thought are all about
- 14:56participatory democracy and getting more and more people to
- 14:59vote on decisions that affect them.
- 15:04But he's saying, no, we shouldn't go in that direction.
- 15:06We should go in the direction of CEOs, have CEOs who have more
- 15:10executive authority in their hands, but give people the right
- 15:14to secede and exit. So I think in a sense the Gulf
- 15:17is an embodiment of that because that that's what's happening in
- 15:20the Gulf because the majority of the population truly has the
- 15:22right to exit. At the end of the day.
- 15:24If you're British or Australian or Nepali or Egyptian or Syrian
- 15:29and you're in Saudi Arabia or Dubai or Qatar, at any point in
- 15:35time, you can choose to leave and that's it.
- 15:38Well, I mean, you have contractual obligations.
- 15:40You might need to pay money or something, but you can finish
- 15:42then your contract and leave. You don't have to stay at any
- 15:45point in time they can kick you out because they're very clear
- 15:47stipulations in the contract that specify what are the things
- 15:50that you're allowed and not allowed to do.
- 15:52And so because of that, there's a very clear relationship and
- 15:56it's continuously improving to the benefit of both parties.
- 16:01Yeah, that's. That's yeah.
- 16:03Sorry Ralph, you make some very powerful arguments there.
- 16:06I mean, I was somewhat anti monarchy until I heard your
- 16:11argument for why monarchy is low time preference.
- 16:14And then you appeal to my, my sort of sense that, you know, we
- 16:19should be planning for the future and our grandchildren
- 16:21and, you know, further down the line.
- 16:23And that's for me a very powerful argument.
- 16:26And it, it flipped my thinking on that.
- 16:28And having spent eleven years living in the Middle East, I
- 16:31also came to the conclusion that despite a lot of the stuff that
- 16:34you hear in the West about, you know, places like Dubai and
- 16:37Qatar and Bahrain and so on, actually it was a fantastic
- 16:41place to bring up a young family, a secure place, a place
- 16:45where, you know, I felt in many ways safe and free, perhaps more
- 16:50so than than other places in the West.
- 16:52So, you know, I, I think there is a very powerful argument
- 16:55there. Lots to unpack as well.
- 16:56And you, you, you even briefly having talked about, you know,
- 16:59low time preference, you touched on Bitcoin.
- 17:02And so I'm going to bring the discussion to well, the basis, I
- 17:05think let's, let's take a step back.
- 17:07Let's talk about Austrian economics because that's really
- 17:09your specialist subject. I, up until 2017, I was an
- 17:14insider, you know, I, I was a sort of Fiat insider, worked for
- 17:18a bank and I vaguely had come across this, this theory of
- 17:23Austrian economics. I'd read Derek O Dewani's book
- 17:25The Problem with Interest, which had a powerful impact on me.
- 17:28And, you know, many people that I knew and I, I guess I never
- 17:32really appreciated it until I did a deep dive on Bitcoin.
- 17:35And at that point in 2017, I left the industry and focused on
- 17:39this. I guess we could spend weeks
- 17:43discussing this subject you we could fill textbooks with it,
- 17:46but I guess in a in a relatively short space of time.
- 17:48Can you give us some background on the economic theories, the
- 17:51principles behind Austrian economics and and how they
- 17:55differ from mainstream theories? OK, well, first of all, I'm not
- 17:59going to let this pass without an advertisement.
- 18:01I've written an entire book to answer your question.
- 18:04So I wrote a whole book called Principles of Economics.
- 18:08It's out in English and a bunch of languages, and it's being
- 18:10translated to Arabic. It should be out very soon from
- 18:13Jarir, from Dar Jarir in Saudi Arabia.
- 18:17And this is a book that's written from the Austrian
- 18:19perspective and it's just a full treatment of the main ideas in
- 18:24economics is 18 chapters. Each chapter has a specific
- 18:28concept in economics like capital, labor and so on.
- 18:31Now, it's obviously very hard to summarize a whole book in a
- 18:35couple of minutes, but it's not going to stop me from trying
- 18:39anyway, so let's just go ahead. I would say the key starting
- 18:44point and the key difference between the Austrian School of
- 18:49Economics and the other schools of economics is that the
- 18:51Austrian School of Economics analyzes economics through the
- 18:54lens of human action, that they're looking at human beings
- 18:58acting. I guess a good way of thinking
- 19:00of it is that the material world around us, every single thing
- 19:05that we see that is non human, you could think of it as like as
- 19:09if it is putty that we as human beings shape with our hands into
- 19:13whatever form and shape that we want.
- 19:16We are able to manipulate that stuff in order to produce the
- 19:19things that we want from it. And it's all a product of our
- 19:23reason. We develop reason.
- 19:26We start thinking about what we want to do to the world, we act,
- 19:30we bring about changes in the world.
- 19:31And so if you want to understand the material world, you need to
- 19:34understand it through the eyes of the humans that shape it
- 19:38through and, and through the hands of the humans that act
- 19:42upon it. So how how this translates
- 19:46practically is that within the Keynesian or mainstream or
- 19:50neoclassical schools of economics, there is an
- 19:54analytical framework that is not based on human action primarily
- 19:57it is based on mathematical aggregates.
- 20:00And so in macroeconomics in particular, there are all these
- 20:03mathematical aggregates like unemployment, inflation, GDP,
- 20:07industrial output, aggregate demand.
- 20:10And we try to establish scientific relationship between
- 20:12those aggregates in the same way that physics tries to establish
- 20:15scientific relationships between its variables and its analytical
- 20:21units. And so in in physics that you'll
- 20:25try and develop regular relationships to understand,
- 20:29you'll try to study the regularities of relationships to
- 20:31understand the relationship between a pressure volume and
- 20:35temperature in a gas. And similarly in macroeconomics,
- 20:38they ape the traditions of science by trying to apply that
- 20:41into the on to the question of economics in in a macro sense.
- 20:47And so they imagine that if we just study GDP and unemployment
- 20:52and industrial output and these and inflation and all those
- 20:56things hard enough, then we're going to be able to uncover the
- 20:59physical laws of the universe that govern these metrics.
- 21:04And that for the Austrian is pseudoscience, that for the
- 21:08Austrian is invalid and methodologically.
- 21:10And so you may as well be using tarot cards because these
- 21:16aggregates are made-up in our mind and we are measuring
- 21:20certain phenomena. And there's no reason that the
- 21:22phenomena that we are able to measure through whatever
- 21:24incomplete and imperfect statistical office technique
- 21:28applied by government agencies, there's no reason to assume that
- 21:32the universe has to bend it to these fake aggregates that we
- 21:35make. And the reason for that, there
- 21:38are many reasons. And Hayek gets into a lot of
- 21:40philosophical stuff about the discussion of this.
- 21:42But ultimately the really precise answer is what Mises
- 21:46specifies, which is that the reason that you can't do that in
- 21:50the economic sciences is because in the natural sciences you have
- 21:54constant constants. You have physical constants that
- 21:58you're able to establish. You can, you're able to measure
- 22:00what is a meter and what is an inch and what is a second and
- 22:03what is a Kelvin temperature or centigrade or speed or all of
- 22:13these things that all these metrics for them that you're
- 22:15able to measure and reproduce between different locations
- 22:20between different people. But in economics, the, there is
- 22:25no such constant with which to measure things because all
- 22:30things are valued in the human mind.
- 22:33And so this brings us to the perhaps the main starting axiom
- 22:38of Austrian economics, which is the idea that value is
- 22:41subjective. And that's where the Austrians
- 22:44differ from others. So the others think that
- 22:46valuation is something that you can calculate, whereas for the
- 22:49Austrians valuation is something that is subjective.
- 22:52It is constantly changing and it is marginal, and it's the key
- 22:56term meaning that it is always determined at the margin, at the
- 23:00place and time where the process of valuation is taking place.
- 23:04Value is not something that is inherent in goods.
- 23:08So if you assume that value is something that is inherent in
- 23:10good, then that you can calculate it, then you can come
- 23:12up with all kinds of amazing equations and models and
- 23:16mathematical ways of representing economic phenomena,
- 23:19which can get you incredibly boring jobs in academia or more
- 23:26look at the jobs in banking. But let's face it, they don't
- 23:29really do an accurate job of describing how the world
- 23:31actually works quantitatively because it's just, again, for
- 23:37the issue that I mentioned, which is that there are no
- 23:39constants. So you're constantly making,
- 23:42trying to create relationships or trying to examine
- 23:46relationships that don't necessarily exist because
- 23:48ultimately what is shaping what is happening to all of your
- 23:51statistics and to all of your theories and to all of the
- 23:55metrics that you're counting? What is shaping it as human
- 23:58beings acting? And human beings are not a, an
- 24:02inert gas. Human beings have their own will
- 24:05and they have the ability to give value to things.
- 24:07And so it is their action that shapes everything.
- 24:10It is not, it is not an inanimate object.
- 24:14It is something that has a soul, has a will of its own.
- 24:18And so it acts on the world. It understands the world and it
- 24:21brings about changes in the world.
- 24:23And so these are the causative factors in reality and the
- 24:29regularities that you might see in social phenomena.
- 24:33You can, you can see those things, you can establish them,
- 24:36you can see how they can be made, and you can see the degree
- 24:39of reliability of them. But you'll never be able to
- 24:42establish the same kind of reliability that you do with
- 24:44scientific experimentation, like with gases or physical objects
- 24:48where you can determined with extreme precision, say, deliver
- 24:53a projectile to a particular distance because you're able to
- 24:55calculate those things precisely.
- 24:58But you don't have that in Austrian economics.
- 25:01So this is a little bit too much on the methodology.
- 25:03And that's basically chapter one.
- 25:05So we still have 17 more chapters.
- 25:06Let's see how far we can get along.
- 25:09But I'll, I'll, I'll putting the methodology aside and focusing
- 25:14on the practical implications of this form of economics.
- 25:19I'd say perhaps the most practical, the important way in
- 25:22which they differ from the mainstream economics is on the
- 25:25question of money. Because for everybody else,
- 25:29money is whatever the state says is.
- 25:31And the only question that an economist needs to bother his
- 25:36little brains with is the question of how do we get the
- 25:39government to manage money best according to some desirable
- 25:47moral subjective outcome that whichever School of Economics
- 25:50has. So whether it's for the good of
- 25:52the workers or the good of the GDP or the good of the nation or
- 25:55whatever it is, the only question is how do we get the
- 25:58government to manage that money properly.
- 26:00And the Austrians are completely heretic on this question because
- 26:03they their whole point is that they just want to get that guy
- 26:07asking the question about how do we manage the money.
- 26:09They want to get him away from your money, from our money.
- 26:13That's essentially the perspective from the Austrian
- 26:15school is how do we stop people trying to manage money?
- 26:17Because money is a creation of the market.
- 26:19And so the same critique that you would get from a free market
- 26:22economist on why you wouldn't want a central planning board to
- 26:26handle, say, the potato market or the car market or any kind of
- 26:32market, and why you'd rather have a free market that with
- 26:35free entry and exit affirms. The same critique would apply to
- 26:38the question of money. You wouldn't want the government
- 26:40to decide what money is, because when they do that, then they end
- 26:43up bastardizing the money. They end up inflating the
- 26:46supply. They mix the metals with cheap
- 26:49metals or they print more money and then they suspended the
- 26:52mobility of money for gold and they create all kinds of
- 26:56problems. So from the Austrian perspective
- 26:57is this, it's just this completely alternative
- 27:01understanding of reality to the mainstream economist where the
- 27:05mainstream economist think of themselves as the firefighters
- 27:08that are helping bring down the fire.
- 27:11What is the Austrians are just out there saying these guys are
- 27:13the arsonists. And for most arsonists, they
- 27:17don't realize that the arsonists.
- 27:18So they find it completely insane that they think they're
- 27:23putting out a fire. They're just, you know, pouring
- 27:24gasoline onto this. They're thinking they're
- 27:27helping. And then all these crazy people
- 27:29are telling them, don't pour gasoline on the fire.
- 27:32You're making it worse. So this is kind of, I would say,
- 27:35the the root of the misunderstanding between the two
- 27:39schools. So, I mean, there's a danger
- 27:42that I might now describe the central bankers of the Middle
- 27:44East as as arsonists and I, I don't want to do that.
- 27:48But do you, do you think there is a future in which economic
- 27:53policies in the Middle East could be, might be determined by
- 27:58and led by Austrian economics? I think so, because I think
- 28:04there's a, there's a, there's a huge amount of congruence
- 28:09between the two. So initially when I first
- 28:12started studying Austrian economics, that was what really
- 28:16made me begin to understand Islamic finance or to start to
- 28:23think about Islamic finance initially.
- 28:24Because before, before I studied Austrian economics, my, I was,
- 28:28you know, I was up until I was 27 or so, I had not been
- 28:32introduced to the Austrian school in any series since I may
- 28:35have read one article by Hayek long time ago.
- 28:39But up until 27 or so, I was still looking at the world
- 28:41through mainstream economic lens but once.
- 28:44And so according to that world, you know, I have the kind of
- 28:48general idea of what Islamic finance is.
- 28:51That interest is bad. And but I didn't give much
- 28:54thought to it. But then when I started coming
- 28:57across Austrian economics, which made a lot of sense to help me
- 29:01in helping me understand how the world actually works and how
- 29:03economics actually functions. It immediately started to give a
- 29:07vivid meaning to the ideas in Islamic finance or in Islamic
- 29:12Sharia banking in general, the ideas of why interest is bad and
- 29:17usually and so on. And I would say the Austrians
- 29:23would disagree with this. So like the Rothbard and Mises
- 29:28have written extensively on the problems of on, on why interest
- 29:33is necessary in an economy and why trying to ban interest is
- 29:37counterproductive. But in this book, in Principles
- 29:40of Economics, you know, the whole book is Rothbard and
- 29:43Mises. And I agree with them pretty
- 29:46much on everything. I introduced a few things that
- 29:50they didn't really discuss in detail, which I discussed in
- 29:52more detail. But there's one place where I
- 29:54disagree with them and it is on the issue of interest.
- 29:57In this book, I make the Austrian case for why I believe
- 30:03on a free market interest lending would be eliminated.
- 30:08And I think this is we're probably far away from a time
- 30:13when this happens, but I think there is a strong case to be
- 30:17made for this being the natural state of things because the
- 30:23Austrians, I think offer the best explanation of the
- 30:26phenomenon of interest. Why is it that we have interest
- 30:28on the market? And the answer is because of
- 30:30time preference. Time preference is the degree of
- 30:32discounting of the future, so how much you discount the
- 30:35future. So from the Austrian
- 30:37perspective, the higher a society or an individual's time
- 30:42preference, the higher the interest rate that he would ask
- 30:45for in order to sacrifice some good today.
- 30:49So if I have $100 today, the higher my time preference, the
- 30:53higher the interest that I need to charge you in order for me to
- 30:56give up on this $100 now and for you to pay it to me next year.
- 31:02So the more I discount next year, the more money you need to
- 31:05pay, right? Because I if, if I have a high
- 31:08time preference, if I don't think about the future, if I'm
- 31:10very immediate gratification focused as a person, then what
- 31:15happens one year from now doesn't really matter much to
- 31:18me. So I discounted heavily.
- 31:20And so in order to give up money today for tomorrow, I'm going to
- 31:24ask for a high interest rate. And so as my time preference
- 31:28declines, the interest rate would be expected to decline.
- 31:32And so from the Austrian perspective, Hans Herman Hopper
- 31:36shows that if you look at the history of interest rates, and
- 31:40we've got a book called 5000, or I think it's called The History
- 31:45of Interest Rates. It's by Homer and Silla SY,
- 31:50Double LA and Homer 2 authors. Or maybe that's one author, I
- 31:54forget, but if you Google those words, you'll find the book.
- 31:57But anyways, it's a very interesting study that looks at
- 31:595000 years of data on interest rates going back to Babylon and
- 32:02all kinds of historical sources. And it finds that there's an
- 32:06unmistakable 5000 year trend of interest rates declining over
- 32:10time. And this had reached its lowest
- 32:14point at the turn of the 19th century, at the end of the 19th
- 32:19century, at the beginning of the 20th century, when interest
- 32:21rate, the lowest interest rate was what the Bank of England was
- 32:25charging the government, the British government, which was
- 32:28around 2 1/2 percent at that point.
- 32:30So that was the lowest interest rate recorded in history, more
- 32:35or less. I mean, not perhaps not
- 32:38obviously there have been lower loans, but it's the lowest
- 32:41prevalent market interest rate or generalized market interest
- 32:44rate that we've had. And this is a, a, a, a trend
- 32:48that has lasted for 5000 years. It's not completely smooth
- 32:52because there's a lot of jumps up and down in it.
- 32:55You get a plague, you get a disaster, you get war, you get
- 32:58all of those things. They raise people's time
- 33:00preference and they make capital more expensive and they raise
- 33:02the interest rates. But unmistakenly you see this
- 33:06process of civilization, as Hans Herman calls it, the process of
- 33:10civilization is the lowering of our time preference.
- 33:13As we become lower in our time preference, we start thinking
- 33:16about the future more. We start behaving in a way that
- 33:18is more civilized and more conducive for long term
- 33:22prospering. And that is reflected in say,
- 33:25being more moral, more civil, better neighbor, better husband,
- 33:30better father, better student at school, just all kinds of ways
- 33:34in which you take part, take part in society in a way that is
- 33:39conducive for long term benefit. Ethics.
- 33:41Not necessarily the present, the expense of the long term.
- 33:47So that's the process of civilization.
- 33:49It's reflected in all these non economic ways, but it's also
- 33:51reflected in the economic way wherein we start saving more and
- 33:54we start accumulating more capital and that makes capital
- 33:56more abundant and so that brings down the price of capital.
- 34:00So this came to a halt in 1914 when World War One broke out and
- 34:05the world went off the gold standard.
- 34:07And our time preference has been destroyed and we have been going
- 34:12through a hell of a ride over the last century.
- 34:15But I think my hypothesis is this.
- 34:19If the world had remained on the gold standard for the last 110
- 34:22years, so from 1914 we've been on the gold standard for another
- 34:25110 years, what would have happened?
- 34:29Imagine the whole world has access to gold as money.
- 34:32Now I argue in the Bitcoin standard and in the Fiat
- 34:35standard and the principles of economics in more detail.
- 34:37I argue that that the hardness of money is like a control knob
- 34:42for your time preference and that when money is hard, then
- 34:46you're able to save for the future.
- 34:48And so if you're able to save for the future, you the future
- 34:50becomes less than certain. So your time preference declines
- 34:53and you start thinking about the future more and more.
- 34:56Whereas when you're money is easy, when your money switched
- 35:00to easy mode and then your money supply keeps growing, your
- 35:04ability to provide for your future self is seriously
- 35:07compromised. And now you shift towards short
- 35:09term focus. How do I survive?
- 35:11You see an extreme version of this in hyperinflation
- 35:14scenarios. In hyperinflation, people are
- 35:15living day-to-day and they start figuratively and literally
- 35:19eating the seed corn of the future, the food that they
- 35:22should be growing for next season.
- 35:25They have no choice but to eat it today because there will be
- 35:27no next year if you don't eat it today.
- 35:30They cut down tree bearing fruits for warmth in the winter.
- 35:34And so that's high time preference.
- 35:36That's prioritizing the present at the expense of the future.
- 35:39And when we destroy the money, we raise our time preference
- 35:42enormously. And I think history shows this
- 35:44all throughout. You see it when mores break out,
- 35:46the currency collapses, people's time preference goes up.
- 35:49Anything happens to the currency, time preference shoots
- 35:52through the roof. So imagine if the last 110 years
- 35:55we'd remained on the gold standard.
- 35:57So everybody in the world has the ability to save in the money
- 36:00that does not get easily debased.
- 36:04The money supply under the gold standard increases that are only
- 36:06around 10, not only around 1 1/2% per year.
- 36:09So imagine 110 years. Everybody on earth in the last
- 36:13110 years has been robbed by inflation.
- 36:17Everywhere in the world. Your currency has been destroyed
- 36:19in terms of its value. It's not at 1% of the value that
- 36:21it had. So if your grandfather, a great
- 36:24grandfather 110 years ago, if he bought some money and he put it
- 36:27aside for you in any form of money, it would have lost value
- 36:31significantly over the last 110 years.
- 36:34Now imagine if it was gaining value every year, and imagine
- 36:38there was peace, there was no war, and the world continued to
- 36:41grow the amount of capital that we have, increase the
- 36:44availability of capital, and make more capital abundant.
- 36:49What's going to happen to the price of capital?
- 36:50What's going to happen to the interest rate?
- 36:52What's going to happen to the time preference?
- 36:53Time preference is going to decline.
- 36:55The interest rate is going to decline.
- 36:57The price of capital is going to decline.
- 36:59Eventually the price of capital is going to decline below the
- 37:03cost of storing capital, at which point, as a capital owner,
- 37:09it's profitable for you to lend at a nominal interest rate of 0.
- 37:13Because let's say the cost of storing capital is say, 1% per
- 37:18year. Then if the market interest rate
- 37:21is 1%, then you're going to happily lend to any person who
- 37:26charges you who, who asked for a 0% loan because he's saving you
- 37:31the 1% that you would have paid. So eventually the interest rate,
- 37:36the time preference continues to decline.
- 37:38We become more and more civilized, more virtuous, more
- 37:41moral as we accumulate more and more capital to the point where
- 37:45the natural market interest rate drops to zero.
- 37:47That people have so much capital and everybody is so trustworthy
- 37:51and everybody's so honest and everybody is so future oriented
- 37:54that it's there's never an issue of securing capital for anybody.
- 38:02Imagine you live in a very high trust society where everybody
- 38:05likes everybody, everybody's there for everybody.
- 38:07If you your house burns down and you don't have any more money,
- 38:10you're not going to have a problem finding people who will
- 38:13lend you money because they know that you're going to be good for
- 38:16it. Because money is so abundant
- 38:18that the interest rate on the money is say .8%.
- 38:22But they would be getting, they would have to be paying 1% to
- 38:27store the money. So therefore they'd lend it to
- 38:29you at 0%. So I think this is essentially
- 38:32what Islamic finance is about. It's about a world in which
- 38:36people don't charge each other interest rate because their time
- 38:39preference is very low. And Islam teaches people to
- 38:42develop this, but with through a clear set of instructions that
- 38:46allow you to arrive at this. So you purify your heart in all
- 38:50kinds of different ways and you perform the right rituals.
- 38:54And among these ways in which you reform yourself is that you
- 38:58do not engage in verbal lending. In other words, you bring your
- 39:02time preference down very, very low.
- 39:05You lower your time preference when it comes to the issue of
- 39:07capital and lending. And I think Austrian economics
- 39:10helps us understand how this would be something that would
- 39:15emerge on the market on its own. And I think it helps.
- 39:18It helped me understand why historically that has always
- 39:21been such a strong opposition to interest lending, not just in
- 39:28Islam, also throughout civilizations across the world.
- 39:32You see ancient wisdom that speaks about this and you can
- 39:36see it why it is. Interest rate lending is
- 39:39monetizing people's high time preference in a sense.
- 39:44And so it puts it, it creates problems for society at large
- 39:49and it leads to all kinds of negative outcomes.
- 39:54And I think Austria economics help me understand that a lot.
- 40:02Yeah, that's, that's amazing. I'll just comment quickly.
- 40:05Just, I know Harris, you have a lot to say about this topic.
- 40:08So I want to put something out there and then I'll flip it back
- 40:11to you because this is your area of expertise.
- 40:13I'm sure you want to pick syphon's brain around the
- 40:16Islamic finance framework, but just quickly save.
- 40:19So I was professionally and academically trained in Canadian
- 40:26economics and IT. Took.
- 40:30Five years for me to unlearn that, starting with, you know,
- 40:33the Bitcoin standard and going down that rabbit hole.
- 40:35And as I was doing my readings on the Austrian side, one thing
- 40:40that's so clear and that people fail to see unless they actually
- 40:43take the time to get into it, is that it is.
- 40:47So much more. Straightforward and just
- 40:50rational thinking versus, you know, in university, they Wood
- 40:56Forest US to memorize these equations and these
- 40:59relationships. And all it takes is to question
- 41:02one metric, which I like to bring up with some of my Fiat,
- 41:06my Fiat friends, is how come CPI is constantly changing in the
- 41:11way it's being measured? Like how is that?
- 41:15How is that rational? How is that?
- 41:16You know, it just doesn't make sense.
- 41:18So I just wanted to put that out there in case someone's
- 41:20listening. I mean, just give it a shot,
- 41:22have a little read. Saif's book Principle of
- 41:24Economics is one of the easier ones, if not the easiest to to
- 41:29absorb this type of content because going backwards trying
- 41:33to read Mrs. and Hayek and Rossbard is, you know, a bit
- 41:38more difficult than, you know, streamline economic text.
- 41:40But I'll stop there, Harris, I'll let you go at it.
- 41:43I know you have a lot of questions.
- 41:45Let's take a moment to talk about On Ramp Nino As a driving
- 41:48force behind the new frontier. Onrakmena offers best in class
- 41:51education and advisory services for Bitcoin accumulation
- 41:54strategy in custody. Our expert team specializes in
- 41:58crafting tailored Bitcoin strategies and providing
- 42:00recommendations that ensure your assets are both secure and
- 42:04accessible. Book a consultation with
- 42:06Onrakmena today to take the first step towards securing your
- 42:09financial future with Bitcoin. Visit ourwebsite@onrakmena.com
- 42:14to learn more. And schedule your consultation.
- 42:17Now let's get back to the show. Yeah, sure.
- 42:19I mean, thank you say for some really a very interesting take
- 42:27on the intersection between Austrian economics and the
- 42:30Islamic Economic model. And I'm, I'm fascinated to know
- 42:33more about the case that you make for Austrian economics with
- 42:38no interest. But let's put that to one side
- 42:41for now, because I think we are gradually leading towards a
- 42:44discussion specifically on Bitcoin because that's the sort
- 42:48of natural progression of, of, of what we're discussing right
- 42:51now. And I can certainly see Bitcoin
- 42:55fitting into a framework for Islamic finance because, you
- 42:59know, like you, I see that intersection between Austrian
- 43:03principles and the Islamic Economic model And, and I think
- 43:07that Islamic finance would reach its sort of ultimate goal if it
- 43:11had a sound monetary base. What do you think?
- 43:14What sort of potential do you think Bitcoin holds for Islamic
- 43:18finance in this regard? So I think the the the most
- 43:24obvious answer to this question is on an individual level.
- 43:27I think only really when I wrote the Fiat standard, when I really
- 43:32got into studying how the Fiat monetary system works, did it
- 43:36really occur to me just how how Haram Fiat money really is.
- 43:43I mean, you vaguely always know that it is Haram money because
- 43:47it's government and it's not gold and money in Islam is
- 43:52supposed to be gold. So you get the sense that it is
- 43:55Haram. But it's not something that, you
- 43:57know, we live in a world in which the sheikhs are constantly
- 44:01calling everything Haram. So it doesn't seem to be that
- 44:04profound when you say, oh, that's just another thing that
- 44:07sheikhs are going to call Haram now.
- 44:10But then you actually think about how the Fiat monetary
- 44:12system works and you realize, my God, this is Haram at every
- 44:16level. I mean, it's, it's got Haram
- 44:18baked in at the protocol level as as they say in engineering
- 44:22terms, that it's because even if you're just using paper money,
- 44:28even if you don't even use the bank, if you just take get paid
- 44:31in cash and you only spend cash, well, that cash is not the money
- 44:35itself. That cash is a receipt for
- 44:37digital money. Fiat money is digital money.
- 44:40And the paper you have is like a physical receipt for the digital
- 44:42money that allows you to get on the government's digital network
- 44:48essentially. And the way that that money is
- 44:52created, whether you like it or not, is that that money is
- 44:55created through riba, through usurious lending.
- 44:58So the government creates loans or the government issues bonds,
- 45:02settle back buys the bonds, or banks issue deposits to
- 45:09borrowers. When when, when a new loan is
- 45:11made, new money is created. So the printer then prints that
- 45:16money into existence, but the money is created when the debt
- 45:20is created. So at every level of the
- 45:23creation of the Fiat money, you, you have a riba.
- 45:26So you are a partner in the riba at every point.
- 45:29So from a personal perspective, just simply realizing this
- 45:33should encourage, I believe, any honest Muslim to really try and
- 45:38take the Fiat out of their life as much as possible.
- 45:41And I think this is now, I mean, I'm not a Sheikh, but I think
- 45:47you could make a very strong argument that at this point,
- 45:50it's not just that Bitcoin is halal and Fiat is Haram.
- 45:52I think you could even say that Bitcoin is fodd, that Bitcoin is
- 45:56the duty of a Muslim to get into it because the you.
- 46:02The argument for using Fiat money is, I would say, similar
- 46:06to the argument for eating pork. If you were on a deserted
- 46:09island. If you find yourself on a, if
- 46:12you get shipwrecked, you're on an island.
- 46:13There's nothing to eat on this island except wild boars then,
- 46:19and you find yourself that you're going to really starve
- 46:21and there's nothing else to eat then.
- 46:23I, I presume most chicks would say it would be halal for you to
- 46:26eat the pork to survive. So you could make that argument
- 46:29perhaps for the Fiat monetary system, because it is so
- 46:31pervasive in our life, it is so important.
- 46:35You need money to be part of the world economy.
- 46:37And if you're not part of the world economy, if you try and
- 46:39live without it, you're going to suffer massively.
- 46:43So you could make the argument that in order for us to survive
- 46:46in the modern world, you need to use government Fiat money.
- 46:50And so in the same way that you need to survive on that island
- 46:52by eating pig, you need to survive in this modern Fiat
- 46:55world by using Fiat money. But then what happens one day if
- 46:59a cow shows up on that island? And then you find that actually
- 47:04you get to a place where there are 10,000 cows just roaming
- 47:07freely. Now, is it still how bad for you
- 47:10to be eating the pig? I don't think so.
- 47:14And I think the same thing happens here with Bitcoin,
- 47:16because Bitcoin now offers you an alternative to the dollar, an
- 47:19alternative to Fiat money, which allows you to get your wealth
- 47:24out of RIBA and not be part of usurious lending, because
- 47:28there's no usurious lending taking place when Bitcoin is
- 47:30created. Bitcoin is a commodity that's
- 47:32created through a process of mining, similar to the mining of
- 47:35gold. So Bitcoin is a present good,
- 47:37whereas Fiat money is a debt liability.
- 47:41And so now that a halal form of money is available, I don't
- 47:48think that is a good reason for using Fiat.
- 47:52I can see why you would want to have, you know, a checking
- 47:56account with a few expenses in it, but there's no reason to
- 48:01deal with. I could, I could see maybe that
- 48:04is would still qualify as necessary pork.
- 48:10Perhaps you could make the argument for it.
- 48:12But keeping your money in banks even if you're not getting
- 48:15interest on it, or putting it in government bonds or putting it
- 48:19in financial markets that are based on the river money, I
- 48:24think is now a completely untenable position.
- 48:28I'm loving your analogy with the wild boars on the desert island
- 48:32and a cow showing up. I'm going to reuse that if you
- 48:34don't mind. Yes please.
- 48:36Do you know in Arabic they say the Habra Alma bottle at Daemon?
- 48:40If water becomes available, you cannot do the dry absolution.
- 48:45Dry absolution. Yeah.
- 48:47Yeah. So this is, this is essentially
- 48:50what's going on now. You, you, you could make do with
- 48:53Fiat before because you didn't have an alternative, but now we
- 48:55do. Fantastic.
- 48:57Great explanation. And I know that when we in the
- 49:01Bitcoin community like to say Bitcoin, not crypto and we
- 49:04separate the two. And you know, we're very careful
- 49:08to to make sure that when we explain Bitcoin to people, we're
- 49:10not talking about some rug pull somewhere with some, you know,
- 49:13ridiculous tech project by a bunch of developers who are
- 49:16there to enrich themselves. That said, I mean, in the Middle
- 49:21East, we are seeing a lot of, you know, Fintech hives
- 49:25appearing and incubators and accelerators associated with D5.
- 49:29Do you, do you think there are unique opportunities for Bitcoin
- 49:33in this regard to set up, you know, new decentralized
- 49:38financial services with Bitcoin as a monetary base, specifically
- 49:42in the Middle East? I certainly hope so.
- 49:46I think this is really likely going to be a a long term
- 49:52opportunity that I see at at a certain point flipping into a
- 49:59much more, much more aggressive growth phase.
- 50:02I just think that something needs to click at a certain
- 50:05point. But at this point, I think the
- 50:08difficulty between the difficulty of distinguishing
- 50:11between Bitcoin and crypto and trying to discern the difference
- 50:13between Bitcoin and crypto is still pretty large.
- 50:19So we haven't really seen this kind of very viral growth in the
- 50:26Middle East. To some extent you do see it
- 50:29here and there, but I still think, well, I mean, it's still
- 50:32at the point where a small number of people do it and
- 50:36they're not very vocal about it when they do it.
- 50:38It hasn't gotten to a point where it's the thing that people
- 50:41are doing. It's not this very popular thing
- 50:44yet. But I think the typical point
- 50:47will be when people really understand the, the, the Islamic
- 50:52analysis that I just made. I think once more and more
- 50:54people get that point and then a few influential people start
- 50:59promoting that idea, I think then we'll likely see a major
- 51:04shift in this regard. But until then, I mean, the nice
- 51:07thing about Bitcoin, of course, is that it still works whether a
- 51:09lot of people join or not. So it's already one of the 10
- 51:14biggest currencies in the world. I think by capitalization at
- 51:17this point, definitely it doesn't work.
- 51:18I mean it actually. Works.
- 51:20I mean, I'll give you one example.
- 51:24I tried to make donations into Gaza for relief work on the
- 51:28ground and I couldn't do it through the normal banking
- 51:30rails. You know, it doesn't matter what
- 51:32currency it was, payments just get blocked.
- 51:35And the only way that one can get money into Gaza is through
- 51:39Bitcoin. And there are individuals on the
- 51:42ground who can use that money to buy essential goods and
- 51:45services. So, you know, it really does
- 51:48work, which which kind of leads me on to another question,
- 51:50actually just regarding geopolitical events in the
- 51:53Middle East. I mean, you know, obviously it's
- 51:56a big subject and more so in, in current days of the events
- 51:59around the world right now. And you've been very vocal about
- 52:02about events. But I, you know, I just wondered
- 52:05whether, you know, Bitcoin has proven to be a useful tool in
- 52:08this regard and facilitating work in places like Gaza.
- 52:11You know, how is it being utilized?
- 52:13What's the impact being on the ground?
- 52:15You know, how do these geopolitical events in the
- 52:18Middle East influence economic stability and growth in the
- 52:21region? Yeah, I think that's a great
- 52:23example. And I think that's also another
- 52:26reason why people eventually, I think in our region are going to
- 52:28wake up to this, because on top of the halal list that we
- 52:30mentioned is the fact that a lot of people in this region are on
- 52:34the wrong side of the financial authorities of the world.
- 52:38And so they get their accounts frozen and they get their
- 52:40central banks shut down and have their reserves confiscated and
- 52:45you get sanctions and you get war zones and you get all kinds
- 52:48of horrific things. And a lot of these people are
- 52:50turning to Bitcoin. You see it in Syria, you see it
- 52:52in Gaza, you see it in all over the region.
- 52:55You see more and more of this happening because it works.
- 52:58Because even in Gaza, I mean, it's this is, this is truly
- 53:01remarkable because Israel is doing everything it can to kill
- 53:06as many people as it can and to make life as impossible as
- 53:10possible, to make life impossible, I should say four
- 53:13people in Gaza for the future. And yet Bitcoin continues to
- 53:17work and continues to survive because it's a form of money
- 53:21that you can use into and out of the country.
- 53:24And even in the middle of the war zone, people are still able
- 53:27to use it. It's a very, very powerful tool
- 53:30because it's money at the end of the day.
- 53:31And everybody needs money. Everybody needs to access the
- 53:35division of Labor that money allows us to access.
- 53:37And Bitcoin just gives you that anywhere, anytime.
- 53:42And the technical requirement, I think people still have this
- 53:45idea that, you know, well, it's a digital thing.
- 53:46So it works with the computer. So, you know, once the power
- 53:48goes off, then my bitcoins are gone.
- 53:51Doesn't work that way. A Bitcoin doesn't just it's,
- 53:54it's not a game. It's, it's not Super Mario on
- 53:56your computer where if you don't save and the electricity goes,
- 53:59then your mushrooms are gone. That's not how it works.
- 54:02It's Super Mario on thousands and thousands of computers all
- 54:05over the world. So your mushrooms are safe.
- 54:08You're not going to be rugged. There is no single of piece of
- 54:11authority. There's no single authority
- 54:13behind it. There's no central authority
- 54:16that can decide to take your coins from it.
- 54:18So it's a, it's a very, very robust system to the point where
- 54:24your ability to access the network is immaterial to the
- 54:27safety of your coins. So even if you're unable to
- 54:29access it for a few hours or days through emergencies, you
- 54:33still have your savings there. And as soon as you can access
- 54:35them, they're they're yours. And it's unstoppable.
- 54:39There's no way that anybody can stop you from using it.
- 54:42You just need any kind of machine that can access the
- 54:44Internet. And I think Gaza is just a great
- 54:46advertisement for the resilience of technology today that even in
- 54:49all of this stuff, people still find ways of making electricity.
- 54:53People still find ways of charging their phone, people
- 54:55still find ways of accessing social media, and people still
- 54:58find ways of communicating with one another.
- 55:00And they still find ways of accessing their Bitcoin.
- 55:03They do it in Gaza every day. So check out Bitcoin for
- 55:07Palestine. They've been organizing
- 55:10incredible amount of relief work just from donations of people on
- 55:14Twitter. So this is this is truly
- 55:16remarkable. And I think it's going to open a
- 55:18lot more people's eyes to the true power of this technology
- 55:21because a lot of people are sympathetic.
- 55:24But as you said, they can't find a way of sending money.
- 55:26That's working because Zionist authorities all over the world
- 55:32don't want this stuff to happen, don't want relief to go to Gaza.
- 55:37Yeah, true testament of Bitcoins ability to, you know, protect
- 55:41your ability to transact safe. Wanted to switch it over a
- 55:48little bit. I mean, we mentioned how the
- 55:52region adoption is a bit lacking compared to, for example, the
- 55:56West and there is a bright future.
- 55:59So we honor Amina are here to help with that from an
- 56:03educational point of view. Now one thing I noticed in
- 56:08Dubai, for example, in the UAE is that the youth is very
- 56:12comfortable with the underlying tech itself.
- 56:15You don't have to explain concepts like, you know, hashes,
- 56:19blockchains, etc. I think where it's lacking is
- 56:23the understanding of sound money and its principles, and I think
- 56:27once we can unlock that, I think we're more likely to see a rise
- 56:32in Bitcoin adoption within the region on top of the Islamic
- 56:38Sharia compliance it provides. I want to turn the attention to
- 56:42so I know you've spent time in Lebanon.
- 56:45Lebanon is one of those countries, for those who are
- 56:48listening, that's going through hyperinflation, capital
- 56:52controls. I mean, myself, my family, my
- 56:55friends, I'm sure you have a lot of people as well that have been
- 56:58affected by the situation, Safe. And I'm wondering in Lebanon, it
- 57:03seems that Bitcoin adoption is also lacking, even though the
- 57:07system has turned against the people itself.
- 57:11Do you think Bitcoin could solve for that if more people, you
- 57:16know, what's stopping them from adopting it?
- 57:19Like what? What are your views on that?
- 57:24I think it's, I think 1 aspect of it is that Bitcoin is just a
- 57:33not easy to understand. There's a technical effort that
- 57:37needs to be put into understanding.
- 57:38And I think it's, it's really tempting.
- 57:41The vast majority of people, if not maybe even all people, are
- 57:46tempted to initially just dismiss it based on what you
- 57:48would learn from the first precursory observation of it.
- 57:52And so I was like that. I heard about Bitcoin early on
- 57:55and ignored it for a couple of years.
- 57:56And I had my very good, strong reasons for why obviously it
- 57:59couldn't work. And when I was making these very
- 58:01confident pronouncements, I had no idea how hashing worked.
- 58:05I had no idea how distributed networks worked.
- 58:11I didn't understand any of that stuff and I didn't understand
- 58:13the kind of resilience that Bitcoin has and it's resistance
- 58:17to control or the resistance to the central authority taking
- 58:20charge of it. So eventually you just need to
- 58:24get familiar with these concepts and there's no easy way around
- 58:26them. They need to spend some time to
- 58:27trying to understand it. And I think with time, more and
- 58:31more things are going to turn your attention to what it tell
- 58:34you. No, you need to pay attention to
- 58:35this thing. It's very important.
- 58:37So that's one aspect of it. Another aspect of it is I think
- 58:42in the, in the, in the parts of the Arab world where people have
- 58:46not had a problem of inflation historically because you know,
- 58:50of good governance or because of safety, because of the just the
- 58:55fact that your money continues to work and that you don't have
- 58:58to pay taxes. People are just not as they
- 59:04don't have a bitter experience with money, so they don't have
- 59:06the ability to develop the kind of healthy paranoia that you
- 59:11need to drive you to Bitcoin. So I think this is probably an
- 59:17impediment to this. And that's why people, I think I
- 59:19would say in the Gulf, there's a, there's a significant
- 59:22interest in the, the, the day trading aspect of it, the making
- 59:28a quick box, buying a meme, buying an NFT, this kind of
- 59:33stuff, which is completely missing the point about what
- 59:34really matters here, which is as a long term form of saving.
- 59:38But you know, if your bank account works and your
- 59:39currencies that Kuwaiti dinar or the Qatari, these currencies are
- 59:44doing all right. So they haven't had to think
- 59:47about the problem of inflation very seriously.
- 59:50And I think also unfortunately, people in the situations of
- 59:54conflict there is as as I was saying earlier, there is a large
- 59:59increase in your time preference naturally when you're in a
- 1:00:01situation where you're at risk. And so you discount the future
- 1:00:04heavily, and that precludes you from having a large appetite for
- 1:00:09something like Bitcoin with its volatility.
- 1:00:12That seems like it's going to be a problem in the long term.
- 1:00:16But in order to be able to stomach it, you need to commit
- 1:00:19to it to the long term. So I think intellectually and
- 1:00:22financially, your time preference rises in these
- 1:00:25situations of conflict that you've become unable to really
- 1:00:29get into Bitcoin. In these situations, sometimes
- 1:00:31people will use Bitcoin, but it will be transactional.
- 1:00:35You know, you, you, you use it to get your money out of a
- 1:00:38country. You buy something, you take the
- 1:00:40thing with you or, or you sell something, you take the money in
- 1:00:43Bitcoin, you leave the country with the Bitcoin and then you
- 1:00:45cash out the Bitcoin into something else.
- 1:00:49But that's not going to be the best setting for developing a
- 1:00:54long term saving plan with Bitcoin, which I think is what
- 1:00:57really matters and what the people should really be after.
- 1:01:00So I think it seems like maybe being in conflict might not be
- 1:01:06very conducive for this. It it, it's conducive to hearing
- 1:01:09about Bitcoin, trying it out, using it for payments, maybe
- 1:01:12using a stablecoin. But in terms of long term saving
- 1:01:15plan in Bitcoin, not very, not not very conducive.
- 1:01:20So maybe there is a happy medium, you know, not Lebanon,
- 1:01:23not Qatar. You need to be somewhere in like
- 1:01:27say the US, France in order for you to have the right amount of
- 1:01:32experience so that your time preface is low enough that you
- 1:01:35can get Bitcoin, but at the same time your currency in your
- 1:01:38government is bad enough that you are feeling the pain in your
- 1:01:43pocket and need to look into Bitcoin.
- 1:01:46That's so interesting. I, I, I love that description.
- 1:01:51Another question since we're on topic of the Middle East real
- 1:01:53fast Bitcoin mining and the energy of the Middle East.
- 1:01:59I mean right now states like Texas are dominating when it
- 1:02:05comes to Bitcoin mining. I think they've taken the vast
- 1:02:08majority of hash rate globally, and it seems that the Arab world
- 1:02:14is lacking when it comes to the integrating Bitcoin mining into
- 1:02:19their energy grid. They have huge amounts of solar
- 1:02:23irradiance. They have lots of oil, gas that
- 1:02:26they can flare. What are your thoughts on that?
- 1:02:29What do you think the game theory is going to be like?
- 1:02:31Do you think we'll see a world where mining gets more and more
- 1:02:36centralized within the Middle East, actually.
- 1:02:40I, I don't really have solid predictions about this.
- 1:02:44I will say I don't, people like to say that mining has
- 1:02:48geopolitical importance, that it is a race and who can accumulate
- 1:02:53more hash rate. I don't think that that is the
- 1:02:56case and I'm, I'm hesitant to use that pitch.
- 1:03:00I think a lot of people try and use that in order to promote
- 1:03:02Bitcoin that, you know, Bitcoin is the next biggest thing.
- 1:03:04So you need to build your own mining farms and you don't you?
- 1:03:10You don't need to be a miner of Bitcoin in order to use Bitcoin.
- 1:03:14In fact, Bitcoin is optimized for the holder, not for the
- 1:03:18miner. Bitcoin is by dint of being
- 1:03:21money. Bitcoin is designed to offer the
- 1:03:25miner horrific experience. If mining Bitcoin was easy and
- 1:03:30fun and profit, then Bitcoin would be an industrial commodity
- 1:03:33that would have enormous quantities and it wouldn't work
- 1:03:36as money. So the most important technical
- 1:03:39feature of Bitcoin, which I discussed in depth in the
- 1:03:41Bitcoin standard, which I think is truly the technical
- 1:03:46innovation that made Bitcoin possible because everything else
- 1:03:48in Bitcoin was there before that is difficulty adjustment.
- 1:03:52It was when you added the magic sauce of difficulty adjustment
- 1:03:55to all of these pre-existing technology and put them
- 1:03:58together. That's when they all managed to
- 1:04:00click together and work. And So what the difficulty
- 1:04:01adjustment does is that it ensures that the supply of
- 1:04:05Bitcoin is being produced in a decentralized way.
- 1:04:10So there's no central authority that decides how many bitcoins
- 1:04:13get produced. Anybody can join it, and yet the
- 1:04:16output does not change. So the output from the mining
- 1:04:20process is now at 450 bitcoins per day.
- 1:04:25And that would have been the case if today Bitcoin was being
- 1:04:29used by 8 people or 8 billion people.
- 1:04:32It doesn't matter. Bitcoin's going to be producing
- 1:04:34that amounts because it's constantly adjusting the
- 1:04:37difficulty of mining in order to to make the reward for mining
- 1:04:42happen at around 10 minutes so that we ensure that we're not
- 1:04:46producing more blocks. And this is what keeps the
- 1:04:48monetary policy working. So the, the, the, the moral of
- 1:04:53the story is that mining Bitcoin is extremely competitive because
- 1:04:57if you're able to make a profit, then the difficulty of mining is
- 1:05:01going to go up and only the most profitable are going to survive.
- 1:05:07And Bitcoin is constantly culling the weaker miners.
- 1:05:12And so the way that you are able to mine profitably is you need
- 1:05:15to have a lot of very cheap energy and you need to have it
- 1:05:18in the form of electricity reliably for a commitment for
- 1:05:2424/7 electricity for about 3 years at least.
- 1:05:28If you're able to secure something like this where you
- 1:05:29have a very, very, very high degree of certainty in the fact
- 1:05:33that you are going to have 24/7 electricity running for three
- 1:05:38years at least, preferably five years at a cost of at most I'd
- 1:05:43say five or six cents per kWh, preferably lower than three
- 1:05:48cents per kWh. If you're able to secure that
- 1:05:51kind of cost. And you also have experience in
- 1:05:56just operations for this kind of facility where you're going to
- 1:06:00need the giant data facility and you're going to need to run it
- 1:06:05and you're going to need to give need to make sure that it keeps
- 1:06:07getting it's electricity. If you have a competence in this
- 1:06:10field of business and you have very cheap electricity, then you
- 1:06:14should think about getting into mining.
- 1:06:17Otherwise it's not a good idea. You you need to have very, very,
- 1:06:20very cheap electricity. You need to have a ability to
- 1:06:24build mining facilities. If you want to mine at scale.
- 1:06:25Of course, if you want to mine at small scale, if you have,
- 1:06:29say, free electricity at home, which may be a lot of people in
- 1:06:31the Gulf do, or at least very cheap electricity, then yeah, it
- 1:06:34makes sense to get one miner. But it is loud.
- 1:06:36So you want to put it somewhere away from the house and just
- 1:06:39keep it running. But ultimately, really, it's
- 1:06:45important to separate the real value of Bitcoin from the mining
- 1:06:48business. The mining business is just a
- 1:06:50business like any other, like growing bananas, like selling
- 1:06:53cars, like making computers. There's an industry.
- 1:06:58There are people out there who are doing it.
- 1:07:00You need to do it better than those people or as good as those
- 1:07:03people. Offer some kind of advantage to
- 1:07:07have some kind of advantage that allows you to compete and
- 1:07:09survive on the market. And if you're mining Bitcoin and
- 1:07:13you make a profit mining Bitcoin, but you then sell the
- 1:07:16Bitcoin in order to keep a Fiat profit, you clowned yourself
- 1:07:21likely because you're really missing out because even if you
- 1:07:25make money in this, you're missing out and just holding on
- 1:07:27to the Bitcoin. That's what's really what really
- 1:07:29matters So for me, what matters is the ability to hold Bitcoin.
- 1:07:33You need to hold Bitcoin for the long term.
- 1:07:34That's the real opportunity, the real opportunities that you have
- 1:07:37a form of money whose supply increases at only currently .8%,
- 1:07:42and that's going to only go down over time.
- 1:07:46So this is the real value proposition.
- 1:07:48And this supply of money has less than a .5% penetration rate
- 1:07:54on the market for monies. And I would expect that it's
- 1:07:57going to go up. And the only way for it to go up
- 1:07:59in terms of its market valuation is for the price to rise,
- 1:08:01because we can't just make more Bitcoin for everybody.
- 1:08:03They're going to have to come and share all the bitcoins that
- 1:08:05exist. So this is a great opportunity
- 1:08:07to get in right now. That's where the real value is.
- 1:08:11Don't think about mining as a way of securing cheaper Bitcoin.
- 1:08:16I would guess from my experience talking to just random
- 1:08:21Bitcoiners that I've met through the years, and I've met a lot of
- 1:08:23Bitcoiners, I would say more people lose Satoshi's mining
- 1:08:27than they gain. So you get into it thinking, OK,
- 1:08:30well, I'm just going to get this miner and I'm going to hook it
- 1:08:31into my house and I'm going to make more Bitcoin.
- 1:08:35And then you pay for the miner. And then if you run the numbers,
- 1:08:38you know, you run it for five years.
- 1:08:39And then if you run the numbers back and you think, well, if I
- 1:08:42just took the sum of money that I paid for the miner and bought
- 1:08:46Bitcoin with it, and then bought Bitcoin with all the bills of
- 1:08:49electricity that I paid and all the operational cost of the
- 1:08:52miners, I would have more Satoshi's.
- 1:08:54I think a majority of people would answer the question with
- 1:08:57yes, that it would have been more profitable for them to just
- 1:08:59buy Satoshi's. So only get into mining if you
- 1:09:02have things that I mentioned, very cheap electricity.
- 1:09:05And if you want to do it at scale, you need to have some
- 1:09:06kind of very clear idea about how to host those miners and
- 1:09:11build a facility that can handle them for a very long time.
- 1:09:14It's not something you want to do in the last minute, you know,
- 1:09:18just buy the miners and then look around for the place.
- 1:09:20You need to have very clear plan and you need to have very long
- 1:09:23term focus on it. But in the Gulf, I'd say
- 1:09:29obviously there's a huge opportunity because of the
- 1:09:31enormous amount of oil fields with the stranded gas that would
- 1:09:37make great deal for mining because it's flared gas.
- 1:09:42And so this is gas that, you know, most oil companies pay to
- 1:09:45have people safely dispose it and get rid of it.
- 1:09:48And now you can just turn it into bitcoins.
- 1:09:52So I would recommend looking into that if you're in the
- 1:09:55business. Of course, there's also there's
- 1:09:58an added cost in the region, which is that there's a lot of
- 1:10:04dust, as you know in most of the Gulf.
- 1:10:07And so that gets into the data centers and gets into the
- 1:10:10machines. And so it requires more cleaning
- 1:10:11and maintenance. So thought something to keep in
- 1:10:14mind. Very interesting.
- 1:10:18Feel like we could talk, I mean hours and hours and I'm mindful
- 1:10:22of yours. So from me, I'm going to ask a
- 1:10:24couple more questions to finish off the 1st is, is regarding
- 1:10:29education. Yeah, I mean, you're kind of an
- 1:10:31academic institution by yourself and people can find out more
- 1:10:34about what you do at saferdine.com.
- 1:10:37But I mean, I'm thinking from the point of view of academic
- 1:10:40institutions in general. Have you taken any steps to to
- 1:10:44influence how they teach economics and their economic
- 1:10:48curricula? Is that something that you you
- 1:10:51do or something that you focus on?
- 1:10:52And you know what? What impact do you have to
- 1:10:56achieve through your work, you know, educational efforts and
- 1:11:00through saferdine.com and and other initiatives?
- 1:11:04For me the the main thing was that it allowed me.
- 1:11:09Leaving academia and working independently online was the
- 1:11:12obvious choice for me because it was just a much more productive
- 1:11:15way of doing teaching. And in my case, they had the
- 1:11:19added incentive for the fact that my ideas were just not a
- 1:11:24good fit with academia as it is dominant today.
- 1:11:30So it makes a lot more sense for me to just try and teach online.
- 1:11:34And for me, you know, I think the the ability to reach people
- 1:11:40directly, I'd say is something that is a blessing that I had
- 1:11:44because of the success of my first book that it developed
- 1:11:47some kind of audience all over the world that is interested in
- 1:11:51the ideas of the Austrian economics.
- 1:11:53You know, they got in because they saw Bitcoin in the title
- 1:11:56and then they read it and they heard about an Austrian school.
- 1:11:58So suddenly in 2018, after I published the book, I started
- 1:12:02getting a lot of interest from people from all over the world
- 1:12:05who wanted to learn more about Austrian economics.
- 1:12:06And I just thought I should take the chance on this and start
- 1:12:12teaching online. And now I've been doing it for
- 1:12:13five years. Last month was my five year
- 1:12:16anniversary. So I've thought something like
- 1:12:187000 students, more than 7000 students so far.
- 1:12:20So that would have been like a lifetime in regular university
- 1:12:26to get through 7000 students. But thanks to the Internet, you
- 1:12:30could do it a lot more easily. And for me, this is just the how
- 1:12:36do you fight the darkness? You can curse the darkness or
- 1:12:39you can light a candle. This is my little candle in the
- 1:12:42darkness of cyberspace. You know, the, the Harvards and
- 1:12:46the Mits and the Oxfords and Cambridge, they have their
- 1:12:51enormous horns of propaganda where they're constantly
- 1:12:55churning out their stuff. You could try and go and fight
- 1:12:58the beast from within and just end up getting hoarse from
- 1:13:04shouting and achieving nothing and just being called an
- 1:13:06extremist. Or you can go directly to people
- 1:13:09and tell them, well, here's what I think and here's how it
- 1:13:11explains the world and you make your own mind up.
- 1:13:14And I think that's a lot more productive.
- 1:13:16It's a lot better for my mental health and sanity.
- 1:13:19It's a lot better for my social life.
- 1:13:21I'm not being surrounded by people who think you're
- 1:13:24extremely weird in your workplace at all times and
- 1:13:28places. I'd say it's probably good for
- 1:13:29my safety too. I.
- 1:13:31Think we can all identify with that?
- 1:13:32Yeah, yeah, yeah. So what's next for you?
- 1:13:36I mean, any upcoming projects or initiatives?
- 1:13:39What can we look forward to from your end?
- 1:13:41So I'm I am working on 1/4 book right now but I'm not going to
- 1:13:45share details about it. I'm keeping it under wraps until
- 1:13:49it's out. I think you might enjoy it.
- 1:13:53But you know, I'm biased, obviously I'm writing the book,
- 1:13:56so buyer beware. But that's, yeah, that's my,
- 1:14:01that's my focus for now. So I'm heads down in this new
- 1:14:04book and you'll be hearing about it hopefully soon you'll get
- 1:14:08some more details on what's going on with that.
- 1:14:11Really looking forward to that. Again, like was well safe.
- 1:14:16Thank you so much for your time. This has been a very interesting
- 1:14:20conversation. Thank you for all the work you
- 1:14:23do and thank you for, you know, taking part in this fight.
- 1:14:27You're in your own way. So everyone is grateful, at
- 1:14:31least on my end. I've sent your book to many
- 1:14:34people. And, you know, I think a lot of
- 1:14:37people have done so as well. I've seen in the US, I think
- 1:14:40Dennis Porter may have shared the Bitcoin standard with a
- 1:14:43bunch of people. It is truly a gateway to the
- 1:14:47Bitcoin rabbit hole. And I think, you know, every
- 1:14:50other book you've put out has been amazing.
- 1:14:51We'll make sure to include all the details, all the links in
- 1:14:55the description. We'll be pushing it out, you
- 1:14:58know, on all social media channels.
- 1:15:00And thank you again for your time SO.
- 1:15:04Thanks, Dave. Thank you so much.
- 1:15:06Thanks for having me. It's a pleasure, guys.
- 1:15:24Thanks for listening. If you found the content
- 1:15:27valuable, please make sure to share with a friend and
- 1:15:29subscribe on your favorite podcast platform.
- 1:15:32Before we finish, a quick reminder that the content
- 1:15:34provided is for informational and entertainment purposes only,
- 1:15:38and nothing should be construed as investment or legal advice.
- 1:15:42Regardless of where you are on your Bitcoin journey, we'd love
- 1:15:45to hear from you. Visit Onrap Mina com Schedule a
- 1:15:48consultation.