Latest / Live Like a Girl with Dr. Mindy Pelz / You've Tried EVERYTHING to Lose Weight… Here's Why Nothing Is Working with Dr. Dan Siegel
Transcript
- [00:00:00:00 - 00:00:01:15] (Gentle Music) [00:00:02:16 - 00:01:42:17] Hey, Dr. Mindy here, and welcome to the Live Like a Girl podcast, where I bring you icons, disruptors, educators, scientists, and doctors that show you what can be possible when you love and celebrate the female body you are blessed to live in. Let's dive in. (Gentle Music) There was a stretch of my life when I wasn't sleeping. I was anxious all the time with this low hum of fear that something horrible was about to happen. I was depressed more often than I'd really like to admit out loud. And on top of that, I was deeply in my experience of perimenopause. So I just told myself, maybe this is just what happens. I was doing hormone replacement therapy. I was doing all the things right that I teach so many of you, and it still wasn't touching something that I could not put words to. Eventually, I decided to slow my life way down. And I did something I had never done before. I stopped trying to fix the symptoms and started asking the symptoms what they were trying to tell me. And to be completely honest, the answer was quite shocking. They were telling me I was on the wrong path. The life I was living wasn't one that I was congruent with. I was chasing the wrong dream. [00:01:44:06 - 00:02:05:17] I see the same pattern in women everywhere. Sometime after 40, a woman hits a wall. She can't lose weight, she can't sleep, she becomes short-tempered with the people she loves. Some women start collecting diagnoses. And when I look at all of that together, I keep landing on one root cause. [00:02:06:23 - 00:02:09:19] What's going on with her nervous system? [00:02:10:22 - 00:02:42:02] And what I'm finding is that most women come screaming into their perimenopausal years with a dysregulated nervous system. And they don't even realize it. And when I ask women why they wanna lose weight, I almost never get an answer about the weight. I get an answer about their marriage or about their worth, about a pain that's been living in their bodies for decades. The body is holding something the mind hasn't been able to say. [00:02:43:04 - 00:02:46:23] This is why I have brought you Dr. Dan Siegel. [00:02:48:00 - 00:03:57:22] Dan is a Harvard-trained psychiatrist, the founder of the Mindsight Institute, and the author of five New York Times bestselling books. His books have been translated into more than 40 languages. And he's the founding editor of the Norton series on interpersonal neurobiology, which has published over 100 books on how our minds and relationships shape each other. His work has changed how I understand nervous system regulation, because he'll tell you the answer to dysregulation isn't some fancy hack. It's actually a term he uses called integration. In this conversation, he explains the river of wellbeing, where chaos lives on one bank and rigidity lives on the other. And how to find the flow in between both of those. We talk about why women in their 40s feel their window of tolerance is shrinking. Why that sudden irritation in midlife may actually be a message rather than a malfunction. [00:03:59:00 - 00:04:10:03] And the simple practices we can all do to start to train our attention, our awareness, and most importantly, our intention for our lives. [00:04:11:09 - 00:04:30:15] And at the end, as always, Dan answered my live like a girl question with something so simple, I almost missed how big it was. I'll leave that right here for you to listen to. It is with great honor that I bring you Dr. Dan Siegel. [00:04:31:20 - 00:04:50:00] Okay, Dan Siegel, I wanna just start by telling you what an incredible honor it is right now to have this conversation with you. I don't think you think of yourself this way, but you are iconic in the mindset world to many of us. So thank you for joining me. [00:04:51:01 - 00:06:18:00] Well, thank you. And you're right, I don't think of myself that way, but it's an honor to be here with you, Dr. Mindy. Thank you so much for having me. Yeah, thank you. So here's the dilemma that I'm finding myself in recently through the lens of educating women on how to be healthy. It seems like something happens after 40 where all of a sudden a woman gets stuck with her health, that she can't lose weight, she can't sleep, she's irritable all the time, she's short tempered. Some women start to get diagnoses after 40, heart problems, cancer, autoimmune conditions, thyroid problems. And the more I dive into working with these women, I see there is one core dysfunction happening, and it's their nervous system that they are incredibly dysregulated and that dysregulation seems to show up somewhere in our 40s. They have been driving meaning from the things that society said was meaningful, how you look, you know, what your socioeconomic status looks like, your spouse behaving a certain way, your kids being successful to a certain degree. And so a lot of women are chasing that external carrot, and then they get to their 40s and they're like, "Wait a second, this thing that I have been chasing [00:06:19:02 - 00:07:18:15] "is vapid, I don't want it, "and it's not providing me that deep level "of happiness and satisfaction." So when a woman hits that moment, then the question becomes, what's the purpose of my life? Exactly, exactly. And people sometimes say, "Whoa, why are you asking what the purpose of your life? "What's wrong with you?" It's actually what's right with you. And so what you're beautifully pointing out is that when people are driven by external rewards, then they can try to meet those criteria that are set up by the larger society or their parents or whoever it is. But if it's not coming from inside of them, then they're busy, busy, constantly trying to figure out, "Oh, that's what they want me to do, I'll do that. "Okay, I've done that, and by their measure, "I'm accomplishing that." And at some point, people will wake up to that and go, [00:07:19:16 - 00:07:28:05] "Whoa, I have put all this energy "in this particular direction, "whether it's home life or professional life, "and you know something? [00:07:29:10 - 00:07:34:12] "I feel like I've been living a lie. "This isn't actually giving me meaning." [00:07:35:19 - 00:09:13:23] And they're gonna pivot. You know, Caroline would talk about pivoting and presence and all these pieces. But with the pivoting, you say, "You don't have to give up everything that was you. "Now you're gonna say, hey, I'm 40, "I'm gonna pivot, and I'm going to now "try out a different direction." Right. Right. And people sometimes say, "Well, but you started in that direction," or whatever. It's like I started in pediatrics, you know, and I thought I was gonna be a pediatrician, and it wasn't working for me. But I had to go inside to feel that, and I knew externally, I loved the idea of being a pediatrician, I loved kids, I loved working with families. Oh my God, it was just such a natural fit with who I felt I was, my identity, all this stuff. But when I was actually doing it, I was miserable. Isn't that interesting? And it didn't have meaning for me. Yeah. You know? And so I had to ask the question, "Well, what am I gonna do with this feeling of misery?" I became very dysregulated. I actually, as a young guy, I had to have this monitor on my heart. My heart was having all these palpitations. "What's going on with you?" they said, you know. And I knew I was stressed because I was living a life of distress because it wasn't my life of meaning, right? And then when I switched, all the palpitations went away. Yeah. You know, I had a very similar experience where I really thought I wanted to be a New York Times bestselling author, which I have accomplished twice now. And I thought, thank you, I thought that's what I wanted. And then I got out into the world, traveling, podcast interviews, TV interviews, [00:09:15:16 - 00:09:56:15] publishers wanting another book, and the pace was so fast. And it was less rewarding than working with patients. And there became a moment where I was like, this thing I swore I wanted, I am no longer interested in participating in it. Exactly. And it's a really hard moment. It is a tough moment when you're like, but I've been working my whole life for this. And now I don't want it. How did you know you didn't want it? Oh, well, this is a great question. I wasn't sleeping. I was depressed often. [00:09:58:00 - 00:11:29:05] Anxiety was a big one, just like this fear that something was gonna fall apart or something horrible was gonna happen to me. And ironically, I was also going through menopause. And so there was sort of this, oh, is this menopause? Is this what happens? And I was doing the HRT and everything. I was like, what is this? And that's when I actually slowed my life down and went into a deep inquiry like you're mentioning. And it was, because I don't want this, I don't want this. Mm-hmm. And that's what all these symptoms are, is they're telling me that I'm on the wrong path. Exactly, exactly. And you had the wisdom to listen to your body. Yeah, yeah. Yeah, and some people are scared to do that. Yeah, yeah. And I see this with women, and I know many of them are listening right now that want so bad to drop 30, 40 pounds. And I would sit with these women in my practice, and I'd be like, oh, that's easy, we can make that happen. And I would map out some beautiful weight loss plan. And then all of a sudden, we'd get three, four months into it, and they weren't responding to the protocols that I knew worked. And when I went and asked them a different question, not about how much weight you want to lose, but I asked, why do you wanna lose weight? [00:11:30:06 - 00:12:26:13] Then I started getting a deeper and deeper answer. So it would look often like, I'm worried because my husband hasn't gained weight, but I've gained weight, and I'm worried that he's going to leave me, okay? Then we would scratch under that a little bit of like, what in your relationship is not working right? Or we would scratch underneath that, and a lot of women would say, I don't want my husband to touch me because I don't feel good about my body. And you'd start to see that there was a deeper, more emotional reason for wanting to lose weight. And when I got women to that point, coming full circle to how we started this conversation, then the results happened. Then everything started to change for them. Once they understood. You helped them make sense, which is an integrative process of where they were at in their life. [00:12:27:18 - 00:12:59:12] That's beautiful. That's so beautiful. And then you see it on the reverse, where women I would sit with would say, I just can't lose weight. And then as you dove deeper into that, it was a core belief that they don't feel worthy. And then if you scratched underneath that, you started to see that one of the core beliefs is, if I stay overweight, I am proving to myself that I can't find a mate and I'm proving to myself that I'm not worthy. [00:13:00:15 - 00:13:02:12] But if I start to lose weight, [00:13:03:15 - 00:13:26:06] I'm gonna have to let go of that belief. That belief is now staring me straight in the face. Yeah, exactly. Well, you have uncovered something that is so powerful, which is that the mind's beliefs set up how we handle our bodies. Yep. I remember when I was in medical school, thinking about pediatrics or psychiatry, [00:13:27:10 - 00:13:35:05] I was doing child psychiatry, and one of the patients had a totally numb leg. [00:13:36:14 - 00:13:47:00] And they were gonna do this surgery, which will be permanent removal of one of the nerves that led to the numbness and there was pain on the other side. It was a complicated story. [00:13:48:05 - 00:14:08:07] But I asked her a simple question. "What would happen if you didn't have this numbness "and you didn't have this pain?" And she goes, "You know something? "I'd probably have to walk with my grandfather on the beach." And I go, "And what would that mean?" And she goes, "He would abuse me again." [00:14:10:18 - 00:14:13:11] That's crazy. Yeah, and I said, "Okay." [00:14:14:22 - 00:15:45:03] And do you think there might be a way you could express to your parents you don't wanna be with your grandfather so that you wouldn't have to be in that position other than you have a pain in your leg? She goes, "Well, I never thought about that." Right. It was amazing. That's very similar to what I sat with these women. It was like, "Oh, wait, I can't lose weight "because this is padding that is protecting me "from something deep inside of me "that I can't quite address." Yeah, yeah, exactly. It's fascinating. Yeah. It's really fascinating to see. Yeah, and those beliefs, like in this young patient and probably the person you're talking about, the beliefs are quartered off. They're placed in a separate aspect of the mind. So the person speaking to you wouldn't even necessarily know what's been warded off. You can call them a state of mind that has a belief system and accessing these different states because we have this many layers of states. In this person's case, it was about a relationship with her grandpa that she wouldn't talk to anyone about. And then by the way, she didn't need the surgery and the pain went away and the numbness- Isn't that crazy? It's good, yeah. I mean, I hear those stories all the time. It's just fascinating. The body does things to try to deal with what our beliefs are and our experiences. So it's a really important lesson, not just about pain, but you're talking about weight loss, how the mind is fully embodied. [00:15:46:04 - 00:15:52:23] We even have words like understanding, which means to stand under something or to comprehend as to hold with your hands. [00:15:54:16 - 00:16:02:05] The mind is fully embodied and it's fully relational and you see this weaving together. And so when you're talking about regulation, [00:16:03:11 - 00:17:07:08] when in this young woman's case, she had a relational experience that was inappropriate, it was abuse, and she couldn't talk to her parents because she was terrified to do that. She was then locked in separation and her body figured out a way to keep her safe. Isn't that fascinating? I am not gonna be able to walk with my grandpa like that. It was a simple question and there was a really direct answer like that. But a lot of us carry these states that we need to access. And I think that when people may be listening to us can realize that, then they can be kind to themselves. Because it's not that there's something wrong with you. It's actually there's something right with you. That's right. And there's a great part of a song from Leonard Cohen, the wonderful songwriter and poet that goes something like this, ring the bells that still can ring, forget your perfect offering. There's a crack in everything. That is where the light gets in. [00:17:09:04 - 00:17:54:02] And so people can realize, life is full of stuff that gives us cracks. But then we try to avoid the crack because we think it means we're bad, we're defective, we're cracked. But in fact, that is where the light of love and light of hope comes in. When you realize, okay, we all have these cracks. And instead of not having the bell ring of our life, we need to ring this bell and live it up and not be enslaved by, in this person's case, almost having surgery that would have permanently changed her ability to use her legs because she had an extirbulation. That's crazy. Yeah. That's crazy when you think about what she would have gone through. I know, I know. I had another patient who was just interviewed for a book on pain. [00:17:55:17 - 00:18:24:00] Sally Maslansky wrote this book called A Brilliant Adaptation, and you can read about the therapy with her, but she was gonna go for back surgery. And I just said to her, I said, well, is there anything about that location of the pain in your back that comes to mind? Something like this. And sure enough, there was a terrible experience of intrusive sexual experience that someone had where that part of her back was injured. And once we started to work on it, the pain went away and she had no surgery. [00:18:25:09 - 00:18:37:13] So, I mean, sometimes you do need surgery, so this is again surgery, but sometimes it is these experiences embedded in memory which develop beliefs around them, like I've got to be protected by this padding, [00:18:38:20 - 00:21:11:06] that people might say, oh, it's just the mind, it's not important. No, it's the mind and it's really important. And the body is not separate from the mind. Right. So then is there an inquiry that we can do if somebody's listening to this and they're stuck somewhere, whether in a relationship with their health, you talked about the wheel of awareness. Is there something we can take ourselves through to start to realize why we're stuck? Yeah, absolutely. I mean, we've talked about actually the integration of consciousness, which is the wheel. We've talked about a little bit about left and right hemisphere integration, but being in touch with the body is the vertical part and the left is more logical language. We've talked about, you know, now we're gonna talk about memory and narrative integration. So this is just what I say about both those. We can be in touch with sensations of the body, in this case, it was pain in my patient's back or when I was a medical student in her leg and numbness. And we can go, and this is the acronym you can use, SIFT. So right now, and you know, if you're driving, this isn't the best time to do it when you're driving, but you could sit down with a journal and say, let me SIFT my mind about a particular issue, losing weight, let's say. And you could say, let me do the S of SIFT. And these are bodily sensations. And it means I'm gonna open awareness to whatever comes up from my body. It could be my muscles, my bones, it could be my different organs, my genitals, it could be anything interior to the body. It's called interoception. So sensation is direct access to what's embedded in something called implicit memory, which we'll talk about in a moment. But when you do this, then just be aware something might arise that you won't understand. So for one of my patients, for example, she was applying for a job after graduate school and she felt really scared and just didn't think she wanted to apply for this job. She was very excited about it, but just said, you know something, I'm gonna fall flat on my face if I apply, I'm not gonna even apply. And I said, okay, well, let's do a SIFT process with you don't wanna apply because you're excited about the job, let's see what happens. And in her case, I'll just give you this example as we go through the whole SIFT. She had a feeling, a sensation in her body of pain in her mouth and then pain in her arm. [00:21:12:07 - 00:21:47:05] And she goes, ooh, ooh, ooh, like that. Now what happens in implicit memory that hasn't been integrated into our narratives is it can present itself in a way that feels like it's happening now. So then you go to images. So images are both visual things and they are auditory things, not just visual. So when we do the eye of SIFT, so S is sensation, eye is images. Now she started saying, and you can do this now in your journal, just write any images that come to mind about the topic we're bringing up. In this case, if it's losing weight. [00:21:48:05 - 00:22:37:07] And so you write just images. In this person's case, she had an image of being on a tricycle, hitting a rock and flipping over. And then the F of SIFT is emotions. When you've done your bodily sensations S, brought up images and where it is now, it's time for emotions. In this case, she had fear. She also experienced pain. And it was this feeling of kind of anxiety about stuff. And once you go to the emotions now, it's an invitation to finally get to the T of SIFT, which are thoughts. So now you may have thoughts that you wouldn't even know were there. Oh, in the case of that young woman when I was in medical school, well, I'd have to walk with my grandfather. And I go, okay, what about that? And then she says these things that, [00:22:39:08 - 00:23:18:10] even as she said them, I think she surprised herself. But in that sequence, is this really important? Because we're often dominated by left hemisphere thoughts with language. And we want to invite the right hemisphere in. And also implicit memory can start coming up in a way that feels like it's happening now. So she felt like she felt when she did crash on this tricycle. Now what happened with her is she made a memory association. I was excited to be on my tricycle. I got on it with all this exuberance. And literally I fell flat on my face and broke my teeth. [00:23:20:05 - 00:25:22:00] So she carried that belief. If I do something I'm enthusiastic about, it's gonna fall apart and I'll get hurt. So here she was now applying for this job and we could work it through that she had this issue as she sifted that could allow her to make sense. Oh, this is my old wound from literally when I was young. And now I can apply for this job, which she did. Now she still has that job and she loves it. So it's a way of liberating someone from a belief. If I do something in this case, then I'm excited about it will fail. So better not to do anything that I actually want to do. Yes, but that happens, that kind of language happens all the time with women and weight loss specifically. Oh, we have to. They've tried a thousand different things. They've tried and they're like, so I see this. It's one of the biggest challenges I have is women come in and they're like, I've tried this diet and that diet. I hired this trainer, I went to this retreat. I said, I've tried this, nothing worked over and over and over again. And again, I look at that and I go, I have a big mountain to climb with this woman because that's in the body. That's the memory of the body. And if I'm really take a wider lens, one of the things that I brought forward to the world was intermittent fasting for women. And it was this mind shift of what if we don't change what you eat, but we change when you eat. And all of a sudden we bypassed all of those implicit memories that were in the body so that the woman could now have a different experience, which gave her a new thought. And I didn't, in those scenarios, I didn't really have to go into all the failures, like, you know, and why they were, but that exists in women over and over again. I failed, I failed, I'm not enough. [00:25:23:07 - 00:26:39:08] That is a real core wound of so many women living in a very patriarchal society. Totally, and those messages of a patriarchal society get embedded in these, you can call them implicit beliefs, meaning it's not like you overtly explicitly say, oh, this is what I believe, it's just built into you. You see this in those incredible studies where you have people take a test, you probably know these studies, you take a test, let's say a math test, and you take the test, you get a score, they have half the group answers at the end of the test, you know, what's your name, what's your gender, your age, all that stuff, and half the people are asked it in the beginning, that's the only difference. Females will do much worse on a math test if they're asked their gender before the test. What? Yeah. Because we are not-- Because there's an implicit belief that says females can't do math. Can't do math, my mom was a math teacher, I remember this. Our daughter was told that when she was in the calculus and her volleyball mates would never take it, they'd go, girls don't do that, she goes, well, this one does, you know. That is insane. That's a belief. Yeah. [00:26:40:17 - 00:28:01:04] So I've been having this currently in my everyday life, I've been having this feeling of anxiety or something hits me and I go, okay, this isn't this moment, this isn't this moment. I just had this last night, I was dry, I needed to go run an errand, it was raining, it was dark, I found myself a little anxious, and I was like, I don't really wanna go out into the rain, and I looked out, I'm like, it's really not raining that hard, Mindy, what are you doing? And then I stopped and I was like, oh, wait, wait, this isn't about today, this is actually about when I was 16 years old and I was driving in the rain and somebody spun out and hit me. Yeah. Oh, okay, this is why I don't wanna get in the car into the rain. That level of awareness of that one body sensation that I could link back to a childhood wound which could propel me forward to actually go run the errand I wanted to go run was so helpful. Exactly, beautiful, yeah. But we have so many things like that running us. Right, well, here's the thing, when an experience happens, the first layer gets encoded in is implicit memory. So you had an experience when you're 16, [00:28:02:14 - 00:29:15:15] going out in the rain, you're driving a car, someone spins out and hits you. Embedded in your nervous system is, I went in the rain, it's dangerous, I got hurt, the car was hit by another car. And that gets embedded into bodily sensations, emotions, perceptions and behaviors. All those are called implicit memory. Now, if you had done a lot of therapy work around, maybe it would have been integrated fully into explicit memory, maybe not. But explicit memory, the key thing is, it's autobiographical. I remember when I was 16, I was in that accident or it's just factual. There was an accident I was in and you don't really know it was you, but you know the fact of it. Now, here's the key thing, when pure implicit memory is retrieved, like there's a cue, in this case, it's raining now, that's the cue, it triggers the implicit memory and emotion of that experience, the anxiety. When a pure implicit memory is brought to awareness as it's retrieved, it is not tagged as, hey Mindy, this is happening from the past, that only happens with explicit memory. [00:29:16:16 - 00:30:40:10] So pure implicit memory comes back as an emotion, anxiety or an image. I just have an image, something bad is gonna happen, a car is gonna hit me. Or any of those basics of images, the perceptions, bodily sensations, emotions, or even here's your behavior of going in a car. So pure implicit memory, when it's retrieved, you don't know it's a memory, it's an explanation for a flashback. So in a way you had a mini flashback in the terms of emotion, of anxiety, about driving in the rain. Now we could ask the question, what was going on now that something happened at 16 was being triggered, I mean we could ask that, but you would then do a sift process to really open it up. Got it. And as you got to the T of sifts, so sensations, images, feelings, now thoughts, now it's a time to do a wonderful, kind inquiry. Like, oh yes, that was a really scary thing that happened when you were 16. I'm gonna walk through that day, this is what I did, that day I got in the car, that day back when I was 16, I did this and this. So now you're activating an area brain called the hippocampus, which is very regulatory. And it's gonna now engage your implicit memory of the 16 year old experience and drive it through the hippocampus into factual memory and autobiographical memory. And now you'll have a narrative that can say, yeah, when it rains, [00:30:41:12 - 00:31:30:00] there could be a feeling of anxiety about it. Now I wanna make a very careful choice. Do I really need to drive? Is it really safe? Right, of course. I did that and believe me, I went all the way down that path for sure. So are you saying then when you go through this SIFT process, by just bringing it out into a deeper awareness, that is how it starts to soften on you? Yeah, well, because what you're doing is you're doing two things. You're seeking memory essentially with the SIFT process. Like, what's the meaning of this, I'm anxious when it's raining. Now the thoughts come in and they're gonna literally integrate all that stuff that's brought into awareness with this SIF. And now you're gonna think about what's the meaning of those things? Oh my God, I was 16. [00:31:31:01 - 00:31:46:22] Yeah, that was scary. I almost died or my dad told me, don't go out in the rain, but I did. And my rebellious spirit was squashed because whatever you might learn from that. And that process is called narrative. And the narrative is how we make sense of memory. [00:31:48:00 - 00:31:57:14] Got it, which is your story, your story. Your story, what's your story? Some people are scared to ask the story, like the patient with the grandpa, [00:31:58:15 - 00:32:32:04] it just got channeled into her leg pain and leg numbness. And now she had a leg that works because she had the courage to go deeply into exploring, how can I actually realize what my grandpa did, tell my parents so that I'm protected and not put in harm's way? And now I can work with that. That's beautiful. And this is where narrative is our real friend. It's how we make sense of sometimes a life that doesn't make sense. It really doesn't make sense a grandpa would do that. [00:32:33:15 - 00:32:52:06] So that's where the making sense process isn't like you try to rationalize how everything that happened to you was a good thing. It's just things that happened to you did happen to you. And by the making sense process, you're integrating it and becoming regulated. Are there signs that we would know we're dysregulated? Because a lot of these women, [00:32:53:11 - 00:33:30:22] they're not even seeing that they're dysregulated. So it's hard to fix something that you can't see is out of balance. Yeah, I mean, what happens in all of our lives is you can just be going along with how things are flowing and you figure it is just what it is. And so you wouldn't name it as, oh, this is a problem or I'm dysregulated instead of being regulated. So the broad way to think about this, it may sound simple, but this is kind of what it comes down to, is being regulated is like being in the central flow of a river where the feeling is one of flexibility and harmony. [00:33:32:05 - 00:34:38:04] But if you're dysregulated, it's when you're leaving the flow of harmony and flexibility of the river, and you're going to one of two banks. One bank is a bank of chaos, the other is a bank of rigidity. And what we mean by chaos is you can have a feeling, I had another day like this recently, where just things are out of control, they're unpredictable, they're explosive, you're having intrusive memories, feelings in your body that just come into your awareness and block you from doing what you want to do. All that, and I'm sort of saying it with that speed, can feel very chaotic. Right. Rigidity on the other hand is a loss of energy, a depletion, you feel despondent, sometimes even despair. You just feel like, oh my God, everything is just the same, the same, the same, nothing's ever changing, completely predictable. That's the rigidity side of the being out of the river of, I call it the river of integration, because ultimately here's this secret sauce, is that when you say, what is the difference between being regulated [00:34:39:05 - 00:35:25:11] and being dysregulated either in chaos or rigidity? The answer turns out to be quite simple. When there's integration, which we'll define in a moment, you are in the central flow of harmony. When integration is blocked, you can experience chaos or rigidity. I can give you a little example. Please, yeah. And describe it. When I'm doing workshops, I'll say to people, well, this is kind of what well-being is, this central flow of harmony. Do you want to experience what that's like? So I'll say who sings and people will jump up to the stage and we'll have, let's say 10 singers. And I'll say, okay, let's do one example where you're gonna have no differentiation at all. [00:35:26:13 - 00:36:22:22] You're just gonna all do things exactly the same way. And so they pick a note and they said, ah, I just repeated it for, let's say a minute or two, unchanging, everyone is bored out of their minds, including the singers. It's completely predictable. That would be an example of rigidity. Now you have the singers, to give another example, plug their ears and just belt out whatever song that comes to their mind. And they come up with independent songs and they sing them really loudly. And it's cacophony, right? It's just blah, blah, blah, blah, blah. And everyone gets kind of anxious and nervous, not the singers, because they can't hear it. I have the audience then do it so the singers can experience it. That's an example of chaos. So what that example shows you is what's about to be illustrated in the third aspect of this exercise. I'll then say to the singers, and these are usually choir singers, I'll say get together and just sing a song. [00:36:24:05 - 00:39:33:17] And I don't say anything else. So they get in their circle, they talk to each other, and they come out with a song. It's often an amazing grace when it's in the United States or some song. Fascinating. Happy birthday, row, row, row your boat. But they'll do it in harmony. Now what, and people get the chills about how literally harmonious it is. What harmony is, is people are both linking together, they're singing the same song, but they're singing what's called harmonic intervals. So they're differentiating. That reveals spontaneously that this regulated choir that's now in this harmony and flexibility is combining two processes. One is differentiation. People are allowed to be different, things are allowed to be different in the song, and they're linking. And in the linkage, they're not losing the differentiation. So what this illustrates is something we can name as integration. And it turns out that when you say regulation, I think integration, because every kind of regulation depends on integration. And when you say dysregulation, I think disintegration by either blocking differentiation or linkage or both. And then the answer to your question, how do I become regulated or I'm dysregulated, is to find out which area of integration is blocked and then work to eliminate the blockages differentiation or the blockages to linkage and allow integration to flourish. To flow forward. So would it be fair then to say an early sign that you are stuck in dysregulation is the need to control, where if I look at rigidity as I'm needing to try to manipulate or control. And then when I hear the word chaos, I think of overwhelming, like can't function, you can't give me one more thing to think about, to do, I'm in complete overwhelm. Exactly. Yeah, well, those would be the signs. Right. Not so much what you do about it, but yeah, that would be the telltale sign that says, wow, I think I'm dysregulated. I'm having this overwhelm, or I'm feeling, when you say the need to control, that could be, that's complex because some people might just feel controlled, not a need to control. I just feel like shut down. My whole system's controlled, it's rigid. Sometimes when people are chaotic, they feel a need to control because it's not working so well. I'll just point out one thing about the central flow of that river. One aspect of it is having structure in your life. And that's on the river side of the bank, which is rigidity. And on the other side, near that bank of chaos, when you're still in the flow, it's spontaneity. So you wanna bring both structure and spontaneity in your life. Now, when you're saying people, women at 40, begin to experience dysregulation, [00:39:34:20 - 00:42:20:16] I would just ask the question, is that a kind of physiological aspect of an aging body? Or is there something about the life of someone who has become 40 in all sorts of ways we could talk about, especially in a woman's life, that would lead to a blockage of integration so that instead of having structure and spontaneity as a part of their natural flowing harmony of life, they've gone all the way over to rigidity instead of just structure, or to chaos instead of spontaneity. Yes, yes. So I just put out a book last year called "Age Like a Girl," and it was about the brain changes that happened to women after 40 as estrogen and progesterone start to decline, natural decline. And in the research for that book, what I discovered is that estrogen not only created a beautiful connection in our brain between our right and left hemisphere, but estrogen brought dopamine and serotonin, acetylcholine, oxytocin, BDNF, a lot of incredible neurotransmitters with her every time she showed up. With estrogen. Yeah, with estrogen. So when estrogen goes away, I call it the neurochemical armor. We don't have an armor on that cushions us from stress. And so we start to go to your analogy, we start to find ourselves on one side of that river, and we're stuck there. And what is so fascinating to me is that's the beginning step, and this is what I really want my audience to hear, is that's step number one. And if you don't integrate, which I'm really excited for you to teach us how to do that, then we start to see you become weight loss resistant. Then we start to see the autoimmune conditions show up. Then we start to see that your menopause symptoms are through the roof. But what I see, and I think you would agree, but again, correct me if I'm wrong, is that it was if you could identify that dysregulation as your neurochemical system is changing, if you could identify it and apply some of the techniques that you are gonna share with us, you would stop the cascade of physiological imbalances that are happening to women during this time. Yeah, well, it's a great question. I mean, I'll defer to you about when bio equivalent hormones might be introduced to maintain the estrogen. [00:42:21:17 - 00:42:27:05] So that may be necessary no matter what kind of-- For sure. It makes time often. Yeah, agreed. [00:42:28:19 - 00:45:28:18] But it's so interesting. When you talk about, let's say, the right and left hemisphere, that would be a good example of differentiating the size of the brain and then linking them. And so one kind of fun way to think about integration is it's more like a fruit salad where you maintain the differentiated elements of the fruits and you put them in one bowl versus a smoothie, where you're blending everything together and you lose the differentiation. So integration then, I mean, we can talk about the nine domains, but when a person is starting to experience chaos or rigidity, that can be both present in a given individual. It's not like, oh, I'm the kind of person who does rigidity. Yeah, you don't slant one or the other. No, you can flip flop over that, jumping over the river and not feeling the harmony of integration. So you can do certain things. For example, there's nine domains of integration. Let's start with the first one. It's called the integration of consciousness. So this is basically, I have a practice called the wheel of awareness, which you're welcome to do. From my website, we stream it for free. And what it does is it integrates consciousness by differentiating the knowing experience of being aware from the things you're aware of in a simple visual metaphor of a wheel. And people find it very accessible, even people who couldn't do other kinds of meditation, because it's so clear, I'm going to move a singular spoke of attention around this rim. And so I'm gonna experience the different elements that I have, like what I'm hearing or smelling or tasting or touching, the first segment of this rim, what I'm feeling inside of my body, right? What I'm gonna actually then move from the second to the third segment of this rim. I'm gonna be aware of my emotions, my memories, my thoughts, and then I have to go to my relationships. So you can do it. And it has what are called three pillars of mind practice, which are it trains your attention to be focused and strong. It trains your awareness to be open and receiving rather than reactive. And it trains your intention to be kind to your inner life and to the life of other people and to the nature. So it builds those three pillars, attention being focused, awareness being open, intention being kind. And other research on different practices that look at those three pillars, show one of the main impacts on the brain is it develops integration in the brain. And if you wanna talk about the areas of brain, I can tell you specifically how their function and structure becomes more differentiated and linked. And I'm happy to share those with you, but just the overall statement is three pillar mind practice of which the wheel is one. In the research on other practices that do those three, you develop a more integrated brain and you become more regulated. [00:45:29:18 - 00:45:35:18] Even if there were things that blocked that, like early trauma, for example, can block that. Yeah. [00:45:37:02 - 00:47:52:18] So, okay, so let's run a scenario. All of a sudden, this is a very classic scenario to women over 40. They have been doing everything in the house for their family, picking up after everybody cleaning, happily doing all that. And like one day overnight, all of a sudden, they are like, "I can't do it anymore. I can't make the meals. I can't clean up after everybody." And instead of having a conversation, a polite and easy conversation with their family, they tend to be reactive. Yeah. And so then there's yelling and screaming and fighting and everybody in the family doesn't understand what just happened because mom used to do that all the time, but like overnight, she can't do it anymore. Yeah. From my physiological lens, that's this brain changing, that's this neurochemical armor coming down. But how does she integrate into that moment then? Does she take the wheel of awareness and then pull herself out and start doing each one of those? Because that moment, as simple as it sounds, that's the moment that resentment builds. That's the moment that divorces start to happen. That's the moment that weight loss resistance from the angle that I'm looking at. It's that I'm reacting differently now and then everybody around her is confused. Yeah. Well, and I'd want to add into that really powerful picture you're painting, how sleep going because-- Right, oh yeah, sleep's horrible. When there's a disturbance of sleep, you do get insulin resistance. When there's a disturbance of sleep, you do see people change their capacity to hold things that before were difficult. Their attention is changed, their ability to remember things. I have this term called the window of tolerance. People bust through the window and become chaotic or rigid. It's kind of like the river metaphor, but just in a given moment of time. And so it narrows their window and so they may not have tolerance for doing work around the house or feeling that they're not getting gratitude. If you're talking about someone who's also a parent, a mom, [00:47:53:18 - 00:48:05:00] if they have adolescents at that age, I wrote a whole book called Brainstorm about this, it is such a big shift in what our role is as a parent to be parenting someone. So there's a lot that might be going on. [00:48:06:02 - 00:48:20:03] And I'll just say that I've been working for the last two decades with four other scientists about looking at how temperament might move forward into personality. And so I really wanna ask, [00:48:21:05 - 00:49:47:21] what was their deep motivation that might be shifting now? So in broad stroke terms, there are three deep brain-based motivations that at 40 would have a different kind of way they're being experienced by a person. One is agency, which is my need for embodied empowerment, getting my fundamental needs met. One is B, I made these names so you can do ABC. The B is bonding. So what are relationships in my life? And the C is certainty. And so all three of those, when you turn 40, there's gonna be certain issues, not only just about the family, but just about your body. I'm like at the halfway point in my life, how have I gotten my own needs met for agency? And what that happens is people might start experiencing irritation, frustration, and anger when they feel like their drive for agency is not being fulfilled. But for another third of the population, their deep, deep temperament drive is not for agency, but it's for bonding. And there, when that's blocked, like the kids are going off and being adolescents or a spouse is busy or people are not getting along with your partner, whatever might be there, when bonding is threatened, you get a feeling of separation to stress, kind of anxious feeling, and even depression and despair and sadness, [00:49:49:08 - 00:50:12:21] versus the anger of the other group. And then a third group is where the motivation is for certainty. And there you feel like, I don't know if this marriage is gonna keep on going. I don't know what's gonna happen to my kids. Oh my God, the future is so unclear, which it is for my kids or for any of us, that it's anxiety and worry and fear. And if it's extreme terror. [00:50:14:06 - 00:51:06:00] So I don't know if you've noticed this, but some people may come to you and say, "Dr. Mindy, look, I am so full of frustration and anger." Or someone else might say, "I'm so full of sadness and I feel so much depletion." Or someone else might come and say, "I'm so worried, I'm so scared." Have you noticed that it kind of falls into those three groupings? Yeah, the words definitely to give you a picture of what the fear state is. I've noticed that. And so how would you, in that moment, well, I guess my first question is, why does that temperament state, does it show up more in midlife? Well, it shows up throughout the lifespan in different ways of being expressed. So we can see it certainly in adolescence, you can see it in adults, young adults, you can see it when you get to, I guess you call that middle age 40. [00:51:08:02 - 00:51:36:18] And yeah, it would have different expressions. It wouldn't so much show up more, but it's complicated because there's a, we have different ways of dealing with our emotions. So some of us just shift away from them, some try to contain and control them and some are really out there expressing it. So it really depends on which way you're regulating emotions, what being 40 might do for you. So people can be very different and there's nine different ways of being human. [00:51:38:12 - 00:51:43:11] But feeling into that, the bottom line about it would be something like this. [00:51:44:23 - 00:52:48:17] I think what happens with temperament is that we have a sensitivity of one of those three, ABC. And when we're born, there's a longing for wholeness that we used to experience actually in the womb. This feeling of being at one with the womb, effortless being, you didn't have to do a thing, but once you're born, you have to work for a living. And if you don't breathe, if you don't have someone protecting you, you're gonna die. It's literally a do or die situation. So at 40, what can happen is that wave we've adapted to the new do or die situation, I think is what creates the pathway from temperament, these sensitivities of agency, bonding, or certainty into personality. And that personality, the research suggests, persists across stages of life. So you're asking, well, how does being 40 affect someone who's more in the agency group or the bonding group or the certainty group? And so you'd wanna really ask that specific question, but the general path for each of those patterns [00:52:49:18 - 00:53:11:04] is to try to get to wholeness. So you could ask someone coming to you at 40, who's saying, "I'm really, really angry about what's going on. I don't wanna take care of my family anymore. I've been doing this for years. And I just feel like there's something missing and I really need to get my needs met some. I just feel really, really frustrated." So the deep process underneath that could be this. [00:53:12:05 - 00:54:17:09] They need to find a way to move toward wholeness, which their personality has been trying to do from the time they were born. And what you can do in speaking to them about that is ask about what has meaning for them. What draws their attention? What is really compelling for them? And they may say, "Well, it was to have a family, but now I actually resent doing all these things for my family." You go, "That's fine. You can change, but now let's not just say you resent that. Let's go forward in a positive way. What does it feel like would be empowering for you if this is a person who's talking about being angry?" If it's a person who's talking about being sad, the conversation would be more about how can you expand your relational connections beyond the family if you're feeling sad that your kids are growing up and there's nothing there for you. So they might start doing work in their profession or volunteer work at a museum or somewhere where they really do feel relationships or how I feel whole. And in the certainty group, it would be, [00:54:18:10 - 00:55:24:08] it's understandable. You had so much certainty raising a family before. Now you have adolescents. So this world now is so full of uncertainty. Kids are about to launch where they've launched. So how can you find certainty in your life? What would it be? Would it be gathering knowledge? Would it be really trying to go forward and something that gives you a sense of you can predict things and have a feeling of safety? Let's talk about you and what matters to you. Each of those three is still on the same path. How do I feel whole? How do I feel integrated basically? And so, 40 could be a time when this starts arising. Now, if that isn't addressed, then what can happen is the dysregulation you're speaking about can come from not working on your own particular way of having a personality pattern that's driving you toward wholeness, only now the change in your conditions, not just your physiological conditions, but your relational conditions are shaking everything up. And you want to wake up to that. So you have different stages of life and you can't stay regulated [00:55:25:16 - 00:55:33:02] and putting the bioidentical hormones aside, that might help. You still need to do work on saying, who am I? [00:55:34:05 - 00:56:10:00] How can I really understand myself? The Oracle of Delphi says, know thyself. And so it's really important to say, what is my temperament? What's my personality? And the regulation comes, sure, you can do the integration of consciousness, but there are eight other domains of integration that have to do with saying, who am I in my left hemisphere, in my right hemisphere? How do I understand that? Who am I in my body? These are vertical and bilateral integration, but there's also saying, who are you since you were a kid and how you were raised by your family and now you're 40, [00:56:11:05 - 00:56:25:15] what's the meaning of life for you? And people have lots of different ways of addressing that. So you not only integrate memory, but it's also called narrative. You have a story, not that you're just making up, but it's really how you've made sense of your life. [00:56:26:15 - 01:01:54:04] And that's an integrated process, integrated process. So people who are burnt out, people who are exhausted, wired and tired, what I'm hearing is that sitting on the couch and doing nothing isn't your ticket. I mean, it could be wonderful, but it's not as direct of a ticket or regulated nervous system as learning how to integrate the messages that are being sent. Well, I'll just say this, because I work a lot with people who do get burnt out and getting burnt out is a physiological state of depletion. And so chilling out on the couch actually is a good step at first, but not for the next 20 years, but at first. Because your nervous system is, was it wrought or overwrought? Anyway, it's depleted. So you do wanna give yourself chill out time, so up for the burnout thing. But you also wanna ask the question, just like you're saying is, how now, once I've allowed myself to replenish my nervous system, do I engage physical activity, make sure my sleep is good, having downtime, all these things are good, and have time in where I'm reflecting, what is the meaning of this? So in that work with people who burn out, what I found is super helpful is figuring out where in this personality pattern profile they are, because people can have very different reasons to burn out in the agency group. You may burn out because you just felt, I wasn't getting things done, I wasn't empowered. And that's a certain kind of burnout. If you're in the bonding group, you may burn out-- Know your temperament. Yeah, exactly, my relationships weren't there. The certainty group, they burn out with a lot of fear because they couldn't guarantee safety in whatever work they were doing. So it's really helpful to then know this temperament system so you can know how was I vulnerable to burning out, and now how can I reignite my passion and flame? So then these different temperaments have different motives to move towards wholeness is what I hear. Exactly. So I'm also extrapolating that out into, well, that would also probably show up when you're looking at how you wanna heal yourself or how you wanna lose weight, or because if you know what your little, like if control is moving you towards wholeness, then learning, like I get a lot of people who wanna count their macronutrients and they wanna look at their blood sugar levels. So if your temperament was one towards control and your life situation is not providing that, and you're trying to get more metabolically healthy, then all of those biometric wearables and all the ways you can manipulate the data to see how you're doing, that would actually work well for that person. Yeah, and what's fun about this system and looking at it is let's take what you just said. You have someone who says, I really wanna have a wearable where I can gain control. Some people wanna gain control for empowerment. Some people wanna gain the agency group. Some people wanna gain control because they feel like they can have a relationship with their body that's just more attuned. Some people wanna have control in quotes because they wanna have some kind of certainty. Is this thing working or not? Right. And so the deep motivation for the same surface thing, I want control, is something you can ask about and then to know about it, like for example, my life I lead from a temperament that's in the certainty group. So when I do stuff, I can tell, I'm trying to see what's the certainty, what's the predictability of it? Is it safe? Yep. Interesting. Am I gonna be in danger? And I'm not really, I'm in not in the agency group, so I'm not trying to assert my empowerment in all these different kinds of ways you can. And I love relationships, but it's not my main temperament to be driven for relationships even though I love them. Interesting. So you can kind of get a feeling for that. If I'm 40, I'm having trouble sleeping, already my insulin is gonna be off, I'm gaining weight, I can't lose weight because I'm under stress, now my cortisol is high, that makes it harder for me to sleep. There are these cycles, right, that we can intervene with and make sure we take it step by step, not missing the basics like sleep, for example. But if you do a three pillar practice, it's also been shown to lower cortisol, right? And to allow you to develop better cardiovascular health, it improves the immune system. It has all these physiological impacts, even it changes the epigenetic regulators that sit on top of genes to reduce inflammation. And in terms of autoimmune diseases, it also optimizes the enzyme telomerase to repair and maintain the important ends of your chromosomes, telomeres, so telomerase is actually that enzyme that's kind of taking care of the ends of your chromosomes. So your cells stay healthier longer, it increases the health span. And when you have cells that are living longer, you actually live longer, it actually slows the aging process. So these are ways when it'll be really fun for you to recommend to people who you work with to say, [01:01:55:05 - 01:01:57:06] if you do a three pillar practice, [01:01:58:12 - 01:04:40:03] focusing attention, opening awareness, building kind intention, and the wheel of awareness is one of them, you're gonna have five molecular mechanisms of medical health. Why not do it if there was a vitamin that gave you those five changes, and then you say, and guess what? It's also gonna get your brain to be more integrated. So a sixth benefit, which is the basis of regulation, in 2015 Smith and Colleagues published a paper that shows the best predictor of every measure of wellbeing they could find was how integrated your brain was. I saw that study, it was a study on, it was like wisdom, they wanted to measure wisdom in the brain and they came out. With the connectome being interconnected, yeah. Yeah. Yeah. That, it's so crazy, because I researched that one for my last book, and I was like, wait a second, we are always trying to make life easy, but actually when we come up against difficulties, we are forced to take that difficulty, bring it into the brain, and then integrate it with the other patterns that are going on in there. Yeah, exactly. So, yeah. So that's like, you get functional structural changes in the brain of integration, and as we said, integration is the basis of regulation. I write this graduate school textbook, The Developing Mind, and I always have interns work with me when I revise it, and I said, hey, I want you to show me something that shows this is wrong, integration is based on regulation. They go, you misspoke, you mean show you something that shows it's right? I said, no, anybody can cherry pick and find one study. I want you to find even just one study that says this is wrong. So the 20 of them go on this search to try to find something to disprove that. All they found was lots and lots of evidence that shows that every form of regulation depends on integration, not only in the brain, but when you look at relationships too. When we honor each other's differences and promote compassionate linkages as communication, that we call an integrated relationship, and an integrated relationship stimulates the growth of integration in each individual's brain. Wow. So when we have a challenge we're faced with, the goal then is to learn how to meet that challenge, learn from it in whatever way you're gonna learn from it, and then integrate that into what your brain already knows about maybe the direction of your life, or the meaning of your life. [01:04:41:12 - 01:05:38:21] I'm just using challenge as an example. I'm sure it's many things, but if you're going, a dysregulated nervous system is one that doesn't know how to integrate all these different moments into it. Right, exactly. Exactly, there's a fabulous book in full disclosure. It's my life partner, but it's by Caroline Welch. It's called "The Gift of Presence, "A Mindfulness Guide for Women." And what Caroline does in that book is she points out exactly what you're saying. Finding purpose and finding meaning in life is not just a thing, oh, maybe I'll do that. It's a central thing to basically having this presence in your life, which is that flow of the river, right? And so what you're describing is, let's say someone's turning 40, and they're getting really irritated and really upset, and the way their life is going, they're not happy with it. They need to ask the question, why am I here? [01:05:40:00 - 01:09:55:05] What's the purpose of me being alive? What's the meaning of life? What gets me up in the morning, as Caroline would say, and gets me to want to do anything, right? And so when I got up this morning, and I was going to talk to you, I said, "Wow, this is great, this has meaning to it. "This is purposeful." Right, yeah. And so we do it, but when you see people who haven't asked the question, because everyone can find meaning in their life, but it's really a matter of opening your mind to that search. So sometimes when people get into chaos or rigidity, this fundamental drive to have meaning is not being fulfilled by them, because they didn't even know to ask the question. Yeah, it flips it all on its head. That's the way I think of this. It's like, what we thought was the path, or road to health and happiness, is not the road. It's a very different path. When I look at what it takes to get to know yourself and what you're talking about, and the results that come from doing that deep inquiry, from what I've seen have been spectacular. I mean, on the weight loss thing, I've seen once women get a hold of why they are emotionally holding onto weight, I've seen them drop weight in like 20, 30 pounds in a matter of weeks. Yeah, absolutely. It's really incredible. If people are listening to this, where can they, and they wanna dive into their temperament, they wanna understand themselves a little deeper, do you have, I know you have a lot of books, you have a website, is there a go-to place you would point people to? Yeah, I mean, you can start with my website, drdansiegel.com, D-R-D-A-N-S-I-E-G-E-L.com. And there's a link, if you wanna do courses or whatever, it's at the Mindsight Institute, there's a link there for that. I have a professional book out, but I'll have a book for the general public out in next year called "Nine Ways of Being Human" that really takes you on a journey down the Colorado River and you're also journey down into your brain and your temperament and personality and stuff like that. Amazing, amazing, I can't wait, when's that coming out? It should be September, 2027. Okay, amazing. Well, okay, my last question to you, this podcast, I call it the Live Like a Girl podcast because I believe that women have a unique way of living. What do you think would be the most helpful thing for a woman to dive into to keep her health and happiness level at its best? Wow, well, I think the first step would be to go inward and realize that you are worthy and you are good and whatever messages you got from the culture you're in or the society, what message you got in school or even sometimes from family about you not being okay are really distorted messages and you may have been holding on to them because you wanted to understandably be a part of a larger group along to whoever was giving you the message but to go inward and really feel the clarity that you are worthy and that you can find your own path of meaning and purpose in life. Yeah, I think if every woman did that, I actually don't think we would have the supplement industry that we have, biohacking world would never have been created, the nutrition diet world, I feel like all of that has been a distraction for women and if women actually did what you just said and went in and understood how they could feel the feelings of worthiness, everything a woman's looking for in her health would come to her. Oh, beautiful. Well, may it be so in the world. Yeah, thank you. Well, thank you, I appreciate this conversation and again, I can't wait, I'm looking forward to your new book, maybe if you're open to it, I will have you back. That'd be great, Dr. Mindy, I'd be honored to come back. Yeah, thank you and keep up all the amazing work you're doing. Thanks, you too. Thanks. [01:09:56:09 - 01:10:13:08] Thank you so much for joining me in today's episode. I love bringing thoughtful discussions about all things health to you. If you enjoyed it, we'd love to know about it, so please leave us a review, share it with your friends and let me know what your biggest takeaway is.