Latest / The Yacht Captain Investor / From Corporate Collapse to $150M Multifamily: John Casmon
Transcript
- speaker-0: I was in corporate America, was working a W-2 job. I was grinding it out, trying to climb up the corporate ladder. ⁓ but I was at GM when we went through bankruptcy. So I saw that firsthand, navigated those landmines, and realized, you know what, I better figure out a plan B. And real estate was that plan B for me. ⁓ so I ended up, you know, moving to Chicago, working at an advertising agency, and slowly kept investing and building up this portfolio. ⁓ but the company I was with actually went into bankruptcy as well. And it's crazy day. I go into the office. I get a call from a buddy of mine who works in our New York office. And he's asking what's going on in Chicago. And I'm like, what are you talking about? And he's like, well, no, you're taking stuff here. You know, they're taking fax machines, printers, computers. And I'm like, Wow, who who was the they? And he's like, I don't know. It was like, looks like it's the bank or something. And I called the CEO and I told him. And he had no clue because he was in Houston. And he had no clue what was going on. speaker-1: the Yacht Captain Investor Podcast. I'm your host, Scott Kid, where every week we dive deep into conversations with real estate pros, business owners, and maritime professionals about their mindset and journey to success. Please help support us on our journey and our channel by liking, subscribing, and commenting below so we can help you on your journey to success. How you doing today? This is Scott Kidd with the Yacht Captain Investor Podcast. I have a friend of mine, John Kasman, here today. How you doing today? speaker-0: Scott, I'm great, man. Excited to be here and be on the show talking to all your, you know, your wonderful listeners and yourself. speaker-1: Well, th thank you so much because ⁓ I really like your your story. You know, you I know you started ⁓ started in the business world and you moved on into multifamily. ⁓ just ⁓ for people that don't know you, just tell us a little bit about yourself and then we'll get into your your origin story there. speaker-0: Yeah, man. Well, first of all, I know you spent a lot of your time on the water and I'm in what they consider more of a flyover state. So hopefully ⁓ my story still resonates with your listeners, man. ⁓ but I'm a Midwest kid, you born and raised in Cleveland. ⁓ went to school in Dayton, lived in Chicago, Detroit. I'm here in Cincinnati now. And like many of your listeners, I was in corporate America. I was working a W Two job. I was grinding it out, trying to climb up the corporate ladder. but I was at GM when we went through bankruptcy. So I saw that firsthand. navigated those landmines and realized, you know what, I better figure out a plan B. And real estate was that plan B for me. So I ended up, you know, moving to Chicago, working at an advertising agency, and slowly kept investing and building up this portfolio. But the company I was with actually went into bankruptcy as well. And it's crazy day, I go into the office, I get a call from a buddy of mine who works in our New York office And he's asking what's going on in Chicago. And I'm like, what are you talking about? And he's like, Well, you're taking stuff here. You know, they're taking fax machines, printers, computers. And I'm like, Wow, who who was the they? And he's like, I don't know. It was like looks like it's the bank or something. And I called the CEO and I told him. And he had no clue, because he was in Houston. And he had no clue what was going on. And ⁓ it was that moment I just realized, man, I did all this to you know, insulate myself from this kind of situation from a corporate standpoint. And here I was again just trying to navigate it. And ⁓ I just realized I was investing in real estate. I just wasn't doing it the right way. And in that moment I just decided, man. I just decided I had to really double down my efforts, all those things that were limiting me from from investing, from growing, you know, lack of money, all this stuff that we draw up in our head. Some of it true, but some of it is, you know, you just gotta figure out a way around it. I just I just decided that moment to to figure it out, man. And and I slowly started to to do that, to invest some time, talking to other people, networking, and through, you know, a lot of action, I ended up making some great connections. And to date, we built a hundred and fifty million dollar real estate portfolio. So ⁓ we focus on multifamily apartments primarily in the Midwest and continue to work with other investors, whether they work in corporate America or do something else. Folks wanna get passive income, we partner with them to invest in our deals. speaker-1: Excellent. I mean that's you know, I know w we had several conversations about ⁓ you know, the Ohio market. I I mean a lot of people consider it a flyover market, but I think it's got some really great ⁓ attractions there, especially with all the tech stuff going on. I mean, it's you know, it's it's a stable stable climate other than it gets it used to get really cold. I I'm not sure how it hasn't gotten cold as as it has in the past, but I know there's a lot of data centers and Intel's building chip ac factories and Amazon's doing a a lot of stuff like that and there's only gonna be more to come. ⁓ what are you ⁓ currently working on now as as far as ⁓ and what you s what you're seeing? speaker-0: Yeah, we closed on 133 units in Columbus ⁓ earlier, what a few months ago. We're actually repositioning our portfolio today. ⁓ I think there's a lot of opportunity in the market. So for us, some of the projects where we've kind of executed the business plan, we're liquidating, we're looking to free up some capital to invest in new opportunities. So we're super excited about it. You know, I I think it's one of the best buying opportunities in multifamily that we've seen in like 10 years. And the reason is we Finally have gotten some resistance. And I know this may seem a little weird, but the reality is when everything is going up, you know, at times you're kind of just waiting for things to correct. And the numbers simply didn't make sense for us for a number of years on most deals, I should say. And the way the market has shifted, even with interest rates being high, the fundamentals of some of these deals are starting to pencil. And quite frankly, there's less players out there. So we don't have as much capital pursuing some of the same deals, which create some value and opportunities. Now, with all that said, there's still larger capital players looking for some of the bigger deals, but we're actually trying to get, you know, a little lean and nimble to navigate the landscape and really lock in on kind of our Midwest market, specifically Cincinnati, where we think we can take advantage of, you know, speed to leads and really taking advantage of our team and boots on the ground. to be more effective and more efficient in a way that, you know, out of market operators really can't can't execute. So I'm excited about it, man. We're really, you know, excited for the opportunities ⁓ for the rest of this year and going into next year and really just trying to set the stage for a really nice ⁓ twenty twenty six. speaker-1: Are you are you ⁓ doubling down on your efficiencies and your operations and stuff like that as well with the properties you're keeping? Are you seeing some more increased costs and stuff like that with ⁓ well I know since COVID w things have been kinda all over the place. So what have you seen since then and with the properties that you're keeping? Are you ⁓ optimizing everything for future? speaker-0: We we are, I I think it looks different for every operator and based on the project. ⁓ what what's important to us is understanding the right business plan for that property and also the right just overall solution and exit strategy based on market demand, investor demand, and other factors that are out of our control. Because every project's different, you know. You could have ⁓ two properties on the same street. But maybe there are different phases of renovation or stabilization. ⁓ you could have two properties that are similar business plans, but one's in a little bit of a nicer sub market and maybe one's ⁓ you know, in in a less desirable submarket. So all those little factors come into play because we're always trying to gauge what we can do today to drive and optimize value, to drive and optimize cash flow, but also long term. You know, how do we increase the NOI? How do we increase the value of this asset? And when is the right time to consider an exit? Which is something that, you know, everyone doesn't think about. I know some investors love to buy and hold and they never think about the exit. When I started, that's how I thought about it. Right. I never I didn't know how to factor an exit. You know, I just I just looked at ⁓ you know, income, expenses, NOI and cap rate, right? If I knew the NOI and cap rate, if I could make money, great. And then it was like, ⁓ and I can Push rents and make even more money. Awesome. But we never factored in the exit, right? And and when you start to mature and get more sophisticated as an investor, you realize the importance of some of these metrics, but also you don't want to rely on them all. I mean, there's some really great metrics out there, like IRR and you know, cash on cash return and so many others. And they have a role for sure. But at the end of the day, I like to keep it relatively simple. It really comes down to cash flow and creating value. And we're always managing and kind of monitoring those things to decide what's right for the business plan for that particular property. speaker-1: Yeah, I would I would agree 'cause when I when I started out I would I always had the mentality, well I would ever sell any of this, but as you get into in the commercial real estate, it's really it's really very critical what you do with the exit strategy and and ⁓ and also as you're seeing nowadays, ⁓ with a lot of a lot of properties not being able to refinance or, you know, they're n not getting the correct debt debt component. The right amount of leverage and the right type of leverage in that strategy is probably one of the more optimum things. The cash on cash is going to be cash on cash and stuff, but if you don't find the right debt instrument, you really could could really kill yourself at the at the end, you know, or kill the deal. Especially what we're seeing now with these these and and I'm sure you're seeing a lot more of these things coming online. And ⁓ So what are you seeing in your Cincinnati market? Are you seeing a little more private credit coming in? Are you are you seeing the banks still kind of moving slow or ⁓ are they just kind of opening up slowly? speaker-0: Yeah, I mean everything is a bit cyclical, right? I mean, everyone gets a little nervous, especially big lenders and big banks. So that that's part of the process is, you know, they're naturally cautious, so they're not gonna move as quickly, especially when things get a little tumultuous. So some of that's slow, but there's still opportunities. There's definitely lenders out there who are putting money out there. There's certainly investors who are looking at deals, private equity as well. ⁓ what I would say though, going back to your other point, you know, cash flow is is certainly important. But it's not the only thing. Same with rates, right? I think too often we just get into these broad stroke comments and philosophies of hey, you know, ⁓ perm debt is great, you know, variable rate debt is bad. And that's just not the case. It just depends on the business plan. ⁓ let me give you an example, right? Even let's talk about great cash flow. You could have a property that delivers phenomenal cash flow, let's say double digit cash flow out of the gate and for five years, right? However If the demand for that area, the demand for that property doesn't grow, you may not have create created any additional value in that asset. So if you buy a property for, say, two million dollars, you can have great cash flow for five years, but it may still be worth two million dollars five years from now. And that's part of the strategy you've got to factor in is like, you know, there's there's a balance of cash flow and kind of what you live off of from a distribution standpoint or from the monthly income. And then there's the value creation over time, you know, the appreciation component. And you want to have the right mixture to really create value and mitigate your risk. There's nothing wrong with having a strong cash flow deal that doesn't appreciate as long as you know that's what it is and you can manage that. On the flip side, probably nothing wrong with having a property that doesn't cash flow, but it's going to appreciate crazy over time. But there's more risk because if you don't have cash flow, You maybe turn those keys in still anything you want, right? So there's always the balance in a business plan. So I would say it's too hard to get into like the specifics of like, hey, this market is doing this, or hey, this is doing that. It really comes down to the business plan. What I will tell you is in the Midwest in particular, it's smart and savvy to focus more on that mixture of cash flow and appreciation because These markets do not appreciate at the same level and the same rate as some of those coastal markets. You know, Arizona, Texas, Florida, even Georgia and the Carolinas, those markets tend to go up pretty high when everything was on fire. But when that new supply came online and interest rates shot up, you saw the value start to come down. The rents started to come down in those markets, and that hurt a lot of investors. In the Midwest, you don't have those. those swings quite as wild as far as the written growth or the demand. So it's a little bit more predictable. It's more stable. And that's one of the reasons we love investing in the Midwest. speaker-1: Yeah, I would imagine it's much much more steady. I've done the we've done a lot of ⁓ research and stuff in the Columbus market, especially. I worked on a few deals that didn't work out ⁓ there in Columbus, but it got pretty competitive and ⁓ we I still love ⁓ the market. I d I don't consider it a flyover. I think it's a fly in place that I I think is going just got has a lot of legs to it just because I mean it's a high quality place to live, you know, and that's one thing that a lot of people forget is that you know, the resident experience, happy residents, happy investors, you know, if you focus on that, that's what ⁓ is the best thing you can do to keep improving the property. 'Cause if they they love living in there, they're probably going to stay for quite some time. You know, are there are there any emerging regions, are you solely focused on the Ohio region or are you looking at other other areas? speaker-0: Yeah, I mean there's there's a number of emerging regions. I mean, what makes sense for us is closer to home. So certainly Ohio, Indiana, ⁓ northern Kentucky, we absolutely love ⁓ Kentucky. Even ⁓ Tennessee is is pretty hot at this point anyway, but ⁓ we like that area and that region of the country. ⁓ but the Northeast has has been on fire as of late as well. Doesn't fit us, it's a little further away and we don't have any competitive advantage there. I think the Southeast and some of those Sunbelt markets are starting to come back around. ⁓ supply has kind of started to even out a little bit there with not as many starts of new construction. So you're starting to see some of that come back online. ⁓ I think the biggest thing though that I would push your investors is the last couple of years have been a bit of a challenge, but that's not necessarily indicative of what's going to happen over the next couple of years. I think there's going to be opportunities and it's so important to stay focused on your investing thesis and your investing goals because. There's going to be more opportunities now. And and sometimes you need a bit of turmoil or some friction so you can find deals, right? I mean, if if every deal is great, then you're not gonna make money. So we need some deals to not work out. So there's opportunities. We need some investors on the sideline. So when people go to make their offer, they actually can get it at a pretty good basis. And that's it it's unfortunate, but it's the reality is I think we've been on such a high. for so long that the market realities haven't set in. You know, to to paint this picture, right? I bought my first real estate property ⁓ in 2012, right? ⁓ my first ⁓ two unit or first multifamily, 2012. And then we we started slow buying more smaller multifamily after that. Bought a three unit building, bought an eight unit building. And in twenty eighteen, I remember going to an event and ⁓ there was a speaker And they were talking about just the market and the economy. And what they basically said was, Hey, it's frothy, it's at the top, you want to sell everything and get out. This is 2018. So I mean, for about almost 10 years, we were hearing that the market was at its peak. You gotta get out, right? And it just goes to show just similar to stocks, man. It's like no one ever knows. You can't really time the market. The best thing you can do is create a plan, create a strategy where you're constantly investing and you can ride and navigate the market based on what makes sense for you at any given time. So for us, we would have loved to have bought more properties over the last five years. We just didn't see as many deals that penciled. I'm very bullish that we will see deals that pencil over the next twenty-four months. Which is why we're looking to get more aggressive with our actions and positioning ourselves to take advantage of these deals and we invite other investors to join us. speaker-1: Yeah, that I w I would have I have the you know, the same thing. I would I would ⁓ definitely repeat that same statement myself because ⁓ you know we're doing a l working on a lot of development deals and with with the rates going up so fast a lot of people have kinda went pencils down. So we're going to have a gap of of a lack of building and we're also going to have, you know, with all these others coming online and deals not being able to restructure. ⁓ those are gonna need to be re redone and re and turned over as well. So we're we'll see a good ⁓ portion of that. So there's going to kind of be a gap in the market over the next twenty-four months. ⁓ I think so. And going forward, we're going to we're still going to be a shortfall of of amount of units that we actually need. So how does that ⁓ play into what you've seen over the last couple of years with ⁓ investor sentiment and what do you see going forward with with them? To kind of piggyback on to what you were just talking about. speaker-0: Well, I mean, investor sentiment in general has certainly soured to a degree, right? I mean, you don't have as many people excited about multifamily. ⁓ I've got a good friend who, you know, you check her her LinkedIn page, she, you know, has very few positive things to say about multifamily. Yeah. She's a good friend of mine. It's funny because she ⁓ she's gung ho multifamily, but she's now doing other asset classes. But here's the truth of the matter. Multifamily didn't change. It didn't. speaker-1: I think I know what you're talking about. No. speaker-0: You know, it just got super hot and the environment was right for it to to excel and people stopped investing using their fundamental strategy. I mean, if think about it like this. If I told you that we were gonna buy a brand new class A luxury apartment community, but we're gonna put variable debt on it. We don't really have a clear way of creating value because it's brand new, but it's just gonna go up in value over time. And we're gonna get a two year bridge loan with three one year options. I'm telling you that today, you probably recognize the flaws in my strategy, right? You don't have to be the most sophisticated investor to recognize that, well, if you don't have a clear way of creating value since it's brand new. How are you going to ultimately create value? And you don't have a long-term loan in place, so you're really subject to interest rates. That's what happened to so many people over the last few years. Versus, again, if you separate it, one strategy might be: hey, we got this brand new asset. We love it. It's in a great area. We're just going to put long-term debt on it and allow the market to speaker-1: Yeah. speaker-0: you know, do what it does over 10, 12, 15 year period. And we're just gonna get some modest cash flow, but we think in about 10 years is gonna be worth more and it's gonna be worth more. That's one strategy. The flip of that is hey, we got this older property, but hey, we're gonna go in, we're gonna renovate it. We're gonna increase the value. Here's all the numbers that suggest we should be able to do this. And then once we're done, we're gonna refinance it, we're gonna sell it or whatever you're gonna do. Like those strategies make sense from a fundamental standpoint when it's set that way. And I can't tell you how many people ignored all that and just bought stuff because they could buy it. They just tried to figure out a way to make the numbers work on an exp an Excel sheet. And I'm not knocking anybody and I hope no one takes this personal. It's just it's a thing that we've seen with investing and in business in general, right? You go back to the last economic downturn. I mean they're giving away loans to people who speaker-1: Should not have been on the speaker-0: Just cause they could breathe. I mean, hell, they gave me a loan when I was in college. I I ⁓ I I was ⁓ a junior in college and my ⁓ my stepmother and I were gonna do ⁓ a group home and I worked like a part-time job, you know what I mean? Like my income was like less than twenty thousand dollars. And somehow, these are the no doc loans kind of thing, right? Man, somehow they they approved me for this loan. Even though I didn't live anywhere close to the property, all this other stuff, right? And in hindsight, I'm like, ⁓ no wonder if y'all were doing this all over the country. Yeah, yeah. No wonder there was a house, you know, there was this mortgage crisis, right? ⁓ and and that's it. So it's not, you know, things today aren't that bad, but on the same note, what happens when things get hot is people start to move away from those fundamentals and those principles that they've learned just to get that volume up or just to make money, just to do deals. And unfortunately, that situation can't last forever. So I think it's really important to just stick to your fundamentals. I'm not saying you can't be creative and figure out ways to make deals work, but I do think it's important to focus it, focus on a deal-by-deal basis and focus on operators that have a proven track record. And just on that point, everybody looked great from 2015 to 2022. I think if I'm an investor today, I'm asking about the last two to three years. I'm asking about decisions, I want to know about the properties. I want to know how you were as an operator. And from our standpoint, you know, we've got deals that we're gonna be exiting and delivering, you know, quite frankly, close to almost a three X return in this environment that we did buy in twenty twenty one. So I hear people talk about like, ⁓ anything bought in twenty twenty one is not that's not true. No. It's not true. And we can't generalize that. So we have deals that are performed really well. We have had deals that were challenged that had to drag and drag to ⁓ to the finish line. They were dragged to some operational performance. But it really comes down to the actual deal, the business plan, and building in some conservative traps so that if this happens, we know what we're gonna do. And it's not to say that we're perfect, we're not. But on the same note, I think it's really important to understand who you're investing with, understand how they look at the business and how they're going to protect your capital in case you are faced with a challenging situation. speaker-1: Yeah, that's so very true. It's all all really about the operator. That's you know, that's one of the things that I always ⁓ tell people and I I keep saying it over and over, is especially, you know, fund of funds or ⁓ sponsors, the look at the manager, their track record and and I I have like a list of ⁓ a hundred and twenty questions that I go through and I I kinda I give it out to to people because if they're thinking of investing that, you know, they should really They should have their own set of questions, but that's at least a good guideline. And then the main you know, the first fifty of them are all about the sponsor or the fund manager and you know, their track record. One of the really important questions I think is, you know, what was your worst deal and how did you make it succeed or how did you get out of it? How did you, you know, protect the investors and you know, 'cause things, you know There were certain things that that looked great maybe twenty twenty and that, you know, three years later things resetting right in the middle of the ⁓ you know, of that ⁓ that whole rate spike and everything else, you know, which was unanticipated. But like you were saying to your example of the you know, the bridge debt with, you know, two years one, one and one, you know, that's obviously not a long term strategy like you're your ⁓ ten year like we're gonna keep it for ten years. Cause if somebody tells me that they're gonna keep something for ten years, that's kind of a more long term strategy of, you know, and and granted, if anything happens in between that where hey, this is a good time to sell, you're in a good position. But if you're at that two one one one, you're beholden to every one of those ⁓ you know, resets of loans you got to pay. You know, it's not a it's not like those times when money was cheap and You know, people are turning over deals in two to three years. Everyone got used to that and doing that. So then five years I think is long term, but really five years should be at least your minimum of what you're looking at, you know. I don't think anything is realistic before that. ⁓ you always need to kind of have that guideline there. speaker-0: And Scott, I think it's important to understand the the the how, right? How do we end up in that situation? Because it's not to say these people were were foolish or made poor choices, whatever. It's not to for criticism, right? That doesn't help anybody. It's important to learn, right? Just to learn and so you don't fall into the same trap or the same kind of mental mistakes. And part of it was interest rates were so low for so long that folks didn't anticipate what was a historic. Historic run up on interest rates, right? You may have decided, you know what, let's let's assume they go up a hundred basis points or maybe 150, maybe 200 basis points, right? Nobody assumed that rates are gonna go up 40%. You know what I mean? That wasn't something any logical person, no economist, no investor, like no one had that in their carts. And it's not to remove responsibility, and it's something I told my kids, right? It may not be your fault, but if you're the one impacted, you got to be responsible, right? It doesn't help to point, you know, point blame and all that, but you also got to recognize you're responsible for your investments. And we got to learn from it. And that's why I go back to as an investor, if you invested in deals like that, if you're the operator who put together deals like that, it is what it is. That's in the past. You can't do anything about it. Learn from it, adjust and go for it. And that's why your question is so great. About asking about your worst deal or deal that didn't work out because a good operator is going to learn from that mistake and they're going to adjust their investing thesis so that it doesn't happen again. A bad operator is simply going to blame interest rates in the fit or a bad contractor or a bad property manager or a bad partner. And they're not gonna take accountability. They're not gonna own what they could do better, and they're gonna be subject to the similar mistakes on the next deal. So those are huge red flags that I'm looking for when I'm looking to partner with somebody, invest as an LP myself, or when I'm looking at a deal ⁓ that I wanna that I wanna take on. And and if I can, I know you've got 150, which is that's a crazy amount of questions, man. I I hope people aren't ⁓ sitting down. speaker-1: No, you don't need that many. It's a hundred and twenty five, but it most of them kinda piggyback off each other. And a lot of them are kinda similar to what you're just talking about, like red flags are. Yeah. Because it it's ⁓ I try to be thorough because most of them just like ⁓ I I would you know, maybe answer ⁓ while I was talking to you, you know, 'cause I just make notes and I'd be able to answer all those questions and buy your track record and everything. And you know You know, that that brings me to a great point where you are saying that it's not your fault, but it is your problem. You know, and fault doesn't bring solutions. You know, pointing the finger at someone that doesn't that doesn't solve anything, it doesn't fix anything, don't learn from it, like you were saying. And I think that's great a great thing to definitely tell your kids and stuff. And I've done the same thing with my kids. You know, those those kind of things are learning moments and that type of operator operator, you're correct. that that person it's always going to be someone else's fault. You know, and if you they deflect if they didn't s if they don't come to the table and say, Yeah, we put the wrong kind of debt on it. We didn't see this happening. But now we have to we've negotiated with the bank and we've got a two year extension and we can ⁓ potentially get another rate lock after the rates reset in two years. It's costing us some money. You know, and they're they're open with their investors and say that. then if myself as an investor, as a LP limit investor as well, because I invest in other people's deals as well, I would say, okay, you're doing the best you can. I thought it was a a good plan in the beginning as well, and I took the risk. So, okay, if they say that to me, then okay, that's we all just gotta live with it. You know, and it's It's it's just something that you know that a lot of people don't learn that lesson of taking responsibility, a personal responsibility. It's it's easier to deflect than to take it. speaker-0: It it is, especially when you're a limited partner, right? Because I mean by definition, right, you're the passive investor. You're you're investing in this person and you you expect them to know what they're doing and to navigate. So I get it, right? In theory, I completely understand. ⁓ but I would challenge you as a limited partner too to learn from it. To ask better questions, right? And ⁓ you know, if if I can plug this, man, we we put together a guide. ⁓ because we had a lot of questions we asked, and then it was like, all right, how do you help people understand like the most important questions? So it's ⁓ seven it's seven questions you must ask before investing in apartments. And this is for both active and passive investors because active investors tend to get blind spots. You know, you come across a deal, you get super excited about it, right? And you just see what it could be. And sometimes they don't focus on like, hey man, but what if this happens? So it's a good way to just kind of level set, take the emotion and the excitement off for a second, and let's just really ask better questions to understand if this deal has really been thought through, if we've analyzed and identified where there is potential risk, and do we have the right people in place? So if anyone wants to check that out, it's seven questions you must ask before investing in apartments. You can get it at kasmancapital.com slash seven questions. And if I can go back to ⁓ just an example, man, with the kids, because I I think the kid examples are always really good. ⁓ there was a day maybe a month ago, ⁓ my youngest son, he doesn't like the school lunch of like, I don't know, Wednesday or Thursday or something like that. So ⁓ he asked me to pack him at lunch. So I'm like, okay, hey. So I've you know, normally I'll pack a lunch. Well one day, ⁓ I I didn't, you know, and he went to school and he came home, Dad! I didn't have lunch, man. They had their school lunch and it and it was not good. So I didn't eat lunch today, man. You know, you didn't pack me a lunch. I said, Hey man, I'm sorry I didn't pack your lunch, but ⁓ this is your responsibility. Cause I'm not the one impacted, right? I I'm I feel for you. I'm not the one that had a crappy lunch choice to do, right? So if you're the one that's going to be impacted, it's way more important for you to follow up and make sure you get what you need. speaker-1: Yeah. speaker-0: Than even the person that you're you're you're asking to help you or to do it, because they may not be accountable. So this goes back to skin in the game, right? So, in how do you make sure that the GP has a vested interest in seeing his deal succeed? Because yeah, if I know I'm gonna take the hit, yeah, there's money, we know there's money, but there's also reputational risk, there's other factors at play, you know, there's there's a lot of other things that general partners are putting on the line. You want to make sure someone's in game in game with you, right? Using that same situation, my kid. Well, what if he and I both went somewhere we didn't have lunch with I'm gonna be j I'm gonna be really upset now because I'm hungry. And he's hungry. So it it's a little bit of a different ⁓ expectation if he and I both are gonna not have lunch because now we both owe it to each other like hey man don't forget to bring the lunch right yeah it's it's it's different and that's kind of the situation here with investing is you want to make sure that your partner is not just equally vested, but also almost more vested because you want them to be thinking about this day and night and thinking through all the things that can happen. So you can truly be passive. Otherwise, you may need to be more proactive than you intended. And that also probably is a great sign that you don't have the right partner. You need to find somebody else who actually knows what they're doing. speaker-1: Well yeah, that's that's a great point because skin in the game is a is a big deal and and your seven questions, what we'll do is we'll you send me the link and we'll put it in the show notes that everyone has access to cause because that's a really great thing for people to have. because I know for me one time I was looking at being a limited partner in one deal and ⁓ I asked them if they had skin in the game and they said yes, and then I looked through and I did in doing my limited due diligence at the time because I I'd hadn't looked at enough of these, but then I looked at it and I noticed that the fees that they were charging was the exact amount that was going in the deal. And I asked them about that. I said, Well, your the the fee money is the same amount. Is there additional money that's going in? They said, No, that's what we're we're putting in. I said, Well, okay, so you're not you don't really have any skin in the game of your own personal money. So you're actually gaining by putting that in without ⁓ putting additional money. So you're really using the investors, you're raising the money to pay your fees, which is which is fine. But had you just told me, Hey, no, this is how we're doing it, then that would have been a different thing. But I ended up passing on it 'cause I didn't feel that that was really truthful. speaker-0: And Scott, what you're what you're getting at too is like it's there's two levels to it. One is do you have money in there? And and quite frankly, some operators are not in a position to do that. Yeah. The bigger issue is misleading you into thinking that they had more money into it than they did. And now that trust is broken. Or now you're like, Well, what else are you? You know, or use wordsmithing me around. speaker-1: You're just peeling back the first layer that could be rotten underneath, you know. Because, you know, had they told me like, well, hey, right now we're we're pretty ⁓ we're strapped as far as cash, but we're doing this deal and and we're gonna put our fees into the deal. That's a different thing than yes, we have skin in the game. you know, or or You know, it's it's just it's a it might be semantics to some people, but for me it was more like you said, where I felt like I was being misled. Had they told me that at the beginning, I would have been like, Okay, well then that that's fine. They're not trying to hide anything. Their their fees are the same. speaker-0: You know. And Scott, I I would share for any any young operators or newer operators who are maybe don't have the funds to invest in the deals right now, please listen to what Scott just said. You know, it it's not that I mean, yes, we it helps to have your own money in the deal for sure, but we reckon most people recognize that you may not be in a position to do that. Be clear and up front. And what we really what we really want to know, we want to know that you have an incentive. You are strongly incentivized to see this deal perform because the the the alternative or what we're really scared of is that you're getting a big check day one when you close, and you really don't care what happens after that. That's every investor's fear, right? Is that this person isn't highly motivated to do what's best for me as the limited partner because they already made most of their money, and yeah, of course, we'd love to get our our promote on the back end. But if something happens, we don't and and if I could share a story, I won't give names, but I got a call about a year ago from a group on a deal, and that was exactly the situation they're in. They the deal had gone sour, and they were not going to be able to get their promote. That was clear based on where the deal was. Well, guess what? They didn't have a whole lot of motivation to figure out how to make the deal work at that point. Yes, they wanted to return LP ⁓ equity, but No matter what they did, they weren't gonna get paid. So how hard do you think they really worked? Right? I mean at that point it was like, Yeah, we want to help you, but they're not about to stay up night and day and throw more good money after Yeah, you want to keep you know what I mean? So and that's what we're getting at is you want someone who cares. And it's you know in theory we all, you know, want to believe everyone's gonna do what's right by investors, but the truth is you don't know people's character until it gets challenged. And yeah, go ahead. speaker-1: Yeah, and it's it's one of those things where I've I've always kind of lived by the mantra that at at the end of the day I've I've found that a lot of times when things go bad, people show their true character and a lot of people do what they think is the best thing for them a lot of times. And there's on the other side of that I invested as an LP in a the deal actually in Cleveland and ⁓ it there was always from the get go you know, it was not as good as in as ended up, but there's always communicated through the whole thing. It was like they you know, the city came down on them, they couldn't do any construction for quite some time. You know, they had ⁓ bad tenant issues and stuff like that and you know flash for a few years later, still haven't gotten any distributions, but they were looking at doing capital calls and they said no and the operators put their own money in and they have since that point. And they said, well, our best case is we get you guys out of the deal and get your money back by the end of this year, which that is because they have a lot of money locked up in there that they know and we know that hey, they're they're fighting the best they can. You know, and that's that's what you want. That's not how you want the situation to go, but at least you know that they're on the hook with you and they're battling to make it right. speaker-0: And that that's exactly it, right? I mean, it it doesn't it's not like it's gonna change your IRR or your return profile, but you can sleep a little better at night knowing they're gonna do everything they can to make the deal work, right? And that character is so true, man. I mean my you know, we asked the question about the worst deal, man. My my worst deal was the flip project and I recall so it's a little bit different, right? But it was a a private lender and it was tr an individual, right? It's husband and wife teams, their money, and They worked with this guy who was a developer. They front loaded the projects. So it worked great for him because he got all of his money. He really was never in the hole. So it worked great for him. And he just did a bad job managing it, you know. ⁓ and in in short, everything came to a head and it was clear that we all were gonna lose money. He had like five he had like seven or eight different projects going at the same time with seven different investors. All of us knew each other. We all kind of would sit down and It was clear that they all all the projects are gonna lose money. And I remember sitting with the private lender and I said, Well listen, we have two options here. ⁓ I they both suck for me, to be clear. ⁓ option one is I cut my losses where they're at today, give you the keys and let you figure this out. Option two, if you increase my construction budget, because he blew through most of it, and everyone else I brought through here said it's gonna be a hundred thousand more. Than what we had left in our draw schedule. ⁓ If you increase and cover that, I will continue to pay the mortgage based on our initial agreement, right? With the with the new funds, we will finish this project, we will get it sold. You will be made whole on my project, but I'm actually gonna be taking a bigger loss because now I still have to pay the monthly holding fees, ⁓ which is gonna actually extend my, you know, my whole period and my my closing costs and everything. So I'm actually going to lose more money than if I just gave you the keys today. But those are the two options. And they were like, look, hey, yep, go ahead. We'll do it. We finished it. We sold the project. I lost a lot more money. Listen, the business thing for me probably would have been smart to cut my losses again the keys. But I respected this couple for believing in me. And it wasn't their fault. It wasn't my fault. It was clear. But going back to it, Just because it's not our fault doesn't mean it wasn't our responsibility. Yeah. And I think that character was important for me, even if I was in my legal right to just give them the keys back. If you've invested with me, I I thought it was really important to stand by your belief in me. And that can't be tied to a dollar amount, you know? I mean that I I just don't think it ⁓ and I just don't believe that way. And it it sucked when I was going through it. I mean speaker-1: It's it's not. speaker-0: It was like I was working my W Two job and trying to do these other projects and then just it felt like I was just setting it on fire, you know, turning over here because I'm like, ⁓ and I won't see that back. But from a character standpoint and when you talk about your personal values, ⁓ you know, your values aren't values until they cost you money. And that was my example of it costing me money where it's like, okay, you truly do believe in this. 'Cause it's fun it's again, it sounds good, but until it really costs you money, ⁓ you know Listen, everybody's great when things are good. Like you said, yeah. So I think it's really important to understand who people are when things are down, because that's gonna tell you who you're really rocking with. speaker-1: Well and that and and that's true. That's so true. Well let me ask you this like that that lender since you made them whole, did they do business with you again? speaker-0: They would have, but I decided I didn't want to flip anymore. I was like, ⁓ I'm done. So Yeah, I that's when I doubled down on multifamily. And and the reason and listen, ⁓ at that time it was so hard, man. I I I saw like a ⁓ Counselor, because mentally it was draining. I did just have my second child, and in my head, man, I was doing all this to create passive income and to build this generational wealth and all these things, man. And I've got two young kids, I'm working my W-2, I'm getting in multifamily. I hired my mentor. I'm starting to build it right. And around the same time, the company I was at was going through the bankruptcy that I alluded to earlier. And I'm like Man, I got so much money committed between the flips. I just bought an eight unit building. I had these two little kids. I don't know what's going on with my job situation. I was stressed out, man. And I never experienced that level of stress. You know, as men, I think we're we're taught to just be strong and, you know, just have shoulders and shake your heads And I I just I had no one to talk to 'cause no one, you know speaker-1: I can take ⁓ speaker-0: my friends didn't get real estate and saw it as risky. And if I exposed what I was going through, I think like, you shouldn't have been in real estate. Yeah, n no help there, right? ⁓ I had a mentor and I I felt almost ashamed to come to him with what I was going through, right? Like I was a failure and a disappointment. so I just remember like holding it all in. My wife, you know, anytime we talked, I could see the stress. So I would start hiding like how bad some of that actually was. speaker-1: Yeah, yeah, they they wouldn't have been helpful. speaker-0: Because I'm like, well, when I start talking to you, you stress out. And then I'm like, okay, well, that's not helping anybody. So I just felt like I had to be the person carrying the burden, man. So I ended up seeing this this guy. And ⁓ I I'm guessing he's a count. I don't know what to describe him. We were at a B and I meeting and another investor kind of introduced me. And I'm like, you know, I maybe I should talk to somebody. I don't know. So I'm like, sure. So I sat down. I think he called himself a life coach, but either way. speaker-1: I don't want to put it on her. speaker-0: I had never done any of that, right? So I'm talking to this guy and I'm sharing what's going on. And I don't know what the hell I thought ⁓ his job was or what I was gonna get out of it. But I'm just unloading, man. I'm just like, finally I can tell somebody all this stuff happens. And he says to me at one point, he's like and he leans forward, he says, John, it sounds like you're failing forward. I'm like, failing forward. Man, look, I I thought you were gonna give me the solution to this. Did you know? I'm waiting, yeah. I'm waiting on like, ⁓ just pay this guy off with this and talk to my lender guy. Like, I'm waiting on a real solution. This man talked about some failing forward. I'm like, I can't do no with this. So I'm pissed, man. That was the last time I saw him. I left. I'm like, all it's a quack. ⁓ but years later, it it it settled in and clicked, man. And here's the here's the reality. I had another buddy, I was talking to him, and he said, you know, investing is a game. And what happens is so many people get caught up in a bad turn or a bad event, a bad play that they want to quit the game. And that's not how it goes, not for those who want to win. You don't get to play a sport, have a turnover, and just say, Okay, well, I don't wanna And Yes quit, I guess game's over. There's still time on the clock. You're playing a board game. You you roll the dice and you lose three, you know, go back to three spaces. You don't just walk away and say, Well, I guess the game's over, right? And investing is the same way. You have to focus on your goal. Every investment, it's just a turn, it's just the play during the larger game. And you just have to learn from it and adjust and stay focused on the outcomes you want. It's not that syndication deal you invested in or that stock or this, you know, flip project. Those are just terms. They're just turns. Now, when you're in it, I get it. I mean, I was there. It it doesn't feel like a turn. It feels like your entire identity and your entire life. But it's not. And when you can start to separate that and just learn from it and say, okay, hey, you know what? Here's what I like about this. Don't really like this aspect about this, or here's what I'm realizing I'm I'm more comfortable with, or I got a really good team with. Now you can learn how to win the game, right? If you can do that, you're going to find success. And for me, I learned I'm not a flipper, man. I I just what the things I loved about multifamily were the simplicity of it. There's a somebody who's gonna pay rent. My job is to collect that rent and for that rent to cover all the expenses and put some money in my pocket. It's that simple. Flipping was a completely different game. That was a race against the clock to finish a project and get it sold before my holding costs, you know, w ate up all the profits, right? That's a way different thing. You gotta manage construction crews and be on site. That was a different animal than rentals at scale. Because I can manage there's ten apartments or even a hundred apartments. How many people are in these apartments? How many of them are paying me? What are all my expenses? And how do I just make sure there's more money left over at the end of this? Like that to me is that's just basic business and basic math. And you can solve those problems easier. Okay, well, hey, we only have ninety out of the hundred. Okay, how do we get the other ten rented? Okay, we gotta do this and this. Okay, we can that's easier to manage. But when you have zero income coming in and all expenses and you don't even have something that's done. So you're racing racing the clock. And by the way, you're not used to managing blue-collar painters who you know aren't necessarily the most truthful people in the world, right? So if I'm at work downtown and they're telling me, yeah, we're gonna paint that tomorrow, I actually thought they were gonna paint it tomorrow. You know how you know who I was, I thought they were gonna show up tomorrow and paint. speaker-1: That would be show up at once, but speaker-0: Yeah, so I was like, you know what? I'm not gonna show up tomorrow 'cause I'm gonna let them finish and I'm just gonna show up Friday. Well guess what? I show up Friday, ain't done nothing. Nothing nothing, nothing, right? And it's just I had to shift the mind and it just it took me a minute to realize like, Yeah, I can't manage this like I manage my advertising folks. You know, this is not corporate America where If you tell me you're gonna do something by Wednesday, it damn sure better be done by Wednesday, or you better be calling me or emailing me, telling me, hey man, I know I said Wednesday, here's what happened. Can we get this to you by Thursday? Like if that's not happening where you're proactively communicating with me, it's a problem. And I didn't realize the renovation world, the blue collar world didn't work that way. And I don't I mean, just I was so far removed from it that I didn't process that. And that's the learning curve. But again, in multifamily, I'm mostly dealing with More professional property management companies, more professional contractors in a sense that they're licensed, insured, and bonded. So they they recognize the importance of actually following through or at least managing kind of these client relationships. So it's so much easier for me. And that's the thing that's wild if you don't get it, but managing a hundred unit building is so much easier for me than managing a single family house. And it's for the reasons I said I'm dealing with professionals. So yes, there's there's bigger numbers involved. So you still have to verify, you still have to confirm what's going on. But that's so much easier for me to manage that than being on site and making sure that, you know, ⁓ the drywall guy showed up at two o'clock like he said he was going to. speaker-1: Yeah. It it's it can be a tough ⁓ battle. I I I know that's why I never got into flipping or what have you 'cause smart man it's it's because I sa I had friends that were doing it and it just seemed very transactional and they were always going after the next one and the next one. But they had good systems in place and they had, you know, crews and and and they can had a construction background and and I don't I don't have that. I mean I've done large projects on yachts and stuff and done major refits, cars. You know, trucks, we're trucking business when I was a kid, airplanes, stuff like and all kinds of stuff like that, but I wouldn't take that on just because I wouldn't think those skills transfer over 'cause you you'd really have to do that. But getting back to your point about failing forward, I I I like that sound because ⁓ you know Failure is big part of the success. You know, without the failure, you don't you you don't succeed, you don't grow and everything. And I had a a coach for a while that he taught he taught me that too. He's like, Well, those were w weren't really failures, those were really learning moments. Those were, you know, where you you paid the tuition for that education that you couldn't get anywhere else. And without doing those things, you're never able to grow into that person you need to be, to to where you are now and to where you are going. You know, 'cause those things I know I've been there in those situations where you just feel like the whole weight of ⁓ weight of the entire world is on top of you. And ⁓ you know, you feel like you're alone and ⁓ a lot of times if you just open up and talk to ⁓ like to your point as as men, we're supposed to take it and be on you know, we can take all of it. We're we're a man or whatever and and ⁓ But if if you really look at it like anybody that's built any big company or anything, they didn't do it by themselves or any large organization. They did that with a lot of other people, a lot of help. So I always thought it was kind of very misguided for us to think that we can do it on our own, even though we're taught to be independent and and say that well, we can do a lot of other things, but it's okay to put your hand up and say, Hey, I need some help. You know, and and and that's tha that was a tough thing for me to learn as well because I w I was brought up that way as well. And I think it's something that us as men need to talk about more that hey, we need other other men, other women other people to talk to, 'cause I've been there where like you're in these situations when you start telling your wife you get really frustrated and you put it all on her and then she gets stressed down and then the family gets stressed down. Then you're more concerned and then it just kinda spirals even more. But no, I like here's the fa here's the failing forward. You know, it obviously worked out for you, you know, and I'm really glad that it did because we wouldn't be talking here, you know, we wouldn't have met and everything. And ⁓ these things happen for a reason, you know, and I really appreciate you coming on and ⁓ sharing your story and your journey and everything. For people that want to know more about you and what you're working on, how what's the best way for people to get get in ⁓ contact with you? speaker-0: Yeah, so I the biggest thing is, you know, we're all about educating others on scaling a multifamily portfolio. ⁓ there's two ways to really do that. One is through direct education, coaching, and mentorship. So we do offer that. The other is through investing. ⁓ but the best thing is really check that guy. You know, seven questions you must ask before investing in apartments. Check that out. And then I also am the host of the Multifamily Insights podcast. So you can check that out anywhere you listen to podcasts. That's readily available. And ⁓ just check out those two things, man, and let's connect and I'd love to hear more about you and where you're at in your journey and see how we might be able to help. speaker-1: Well, thank you so much, John, for for coming on and sharing your s story and everything. It's it's been really great. speaker-0: Thanks for having me, Scott. speaker-1: ⁓ we'll do we'll definitely follow up and see see how much more forward we can take this thing. I'm Scott Kidd with the Yacht Captain Investor Podcast. This this this last story that ⁓ John just shared is just ⁓ is just living proof that the best investment you can make is the one you make in yourself. Thank you. We'll see you guys next time.