Latest / The Psychology Undergrad Podcast / Critical Thinking in the Classroom: How Teachers Build Complex Thinking Skills
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to the psychology undergrad. So glad
- 0:02you're here. Picture a kid, right? Let's call
- 0:05him Joey. He is sitting with his teacher, Ms.
- 0:09Eaton, and he is reading that classic kids book,
- 0:11Good Night Moon. Oh, yeah. In the great green
- 0:14room. Exactly. He's looking at the pages and
- 0:17just confidently saying, in the great green room,
- 0:20there was a telephone and a red balloon. Like
- 0:22he is seemingly crushing it. But Ms. Eaton notices
- 0:26this tiny detail. He's not actually reading,
- 0:29is he? No, go. Joey's constantly flicking his
- 0:32eyes back and forth between the pictures and
- 0:33the words. He's just memorized the cadence of
- 0:36the story and is using the illustrations as visual
- 0:39cues. Which is honestly a brilliant, entirely
- 0:42natural cognitive shortcut. I mean, the human
- 0:44brain is a massive energy hog, right? And actual
- 0:47reading -like decoding symbols into sounds and
- 0:50then stringing those sounds into meaning is cognitively
- 0:53expensive. Yeah, it takes work. Memorizing a
- 0:55rhyme and just looking at a picture of a balloon
- 0:57is incredibly cheap, calorically speaking. Joey's
- 1:01brain is literally just taking the path of least
- 1:03resistance. Right. So Ms. Eaton catches on to
- 1:06this shortcut. She covers the pictures and asks
- 1:08him, hey, could you read it without the illustrations,
- 1:11just looking at the words? And Joey pauses, realizes
- 1:14his crush is gone, and admits, maybe, but not
- 1:18quite so well. Oh, busted. Yeah. But in that
- 1:22split second, Ms. Eaton makes a choice. She grabs
- 1:25a giant sheet of paper and writes just the words
- 1:27out for him to practice. She completely isolates
- 1:30the text See that three -second interaction that
- 1:33is the absolute nucleus of educational psychology
- 1:36every single day a teacher has to make like 100
- 1:39of those microscopic calculations. When you let
- 1:42a student rely on their scaffolding, and when
- 1:45do you pull that scaffolding away to force their
- 1:47brain to build new neural pathways? It is a constant
- 1:50balancing act between supporting their confidence
- 1:52and, well, intentionally frustrating them to
- 1:55trigger cognitive growth. and that intentional
- 1:57frustration in the mission of our deep dive today.
- 2:00We're going to explore how humans actually develop
- 2:02complex thinking skills. We'll look at the hidden
- 2:04cognitive traps our brains fall into and actual
- 2:07playbooks teachers use to get us there. Yeah,
- 2:10the strategies that engineer those aha moments.
- 2:12Exactly. And since we are all psychology undergrads
- 2:16trying to absorb this material for an upcoming
- 2:18exam, consider yourself our third study buddy
- 2:21today. we are actively going to use memory hacks
- 2:25and common ways of thinking to really lock these
- 2:28definitions in. Definitely. And to understand
- 2:30how we learn, we first have to clearly define
- 2:33the goal, which is complex thinking. This goes
- 2:36way beyond rote memorization. Psychologists generally
- 2:39categorize complex thinking into the big three.
- 2:42Critical thinking, creative thinking, and problem
- 2:44solving. Okay, let's unpack this, starting with
- 2:47the first pillar. Critical thinking. I feel like
- 2:49in popular culture, being a critical thinker
- 2:52has devolved into just being, I don't know, a
- 2:54cynic. Oh, for sure. Someone who just points
- 2:56out flaws or adopts a contrarian stance just
- 2:59for the sake of arguing. Right. It's a super
- 3:01common misconception. But true critical thinking
- 3:03is really synonymous with metacognition. Thinking
- 3:06about your own thinking. Exactly. It's an active,
- 3:10highly conscious evaluation of evidence, logical
- 3:12reasoning, and crucially, your own internal assumptions.
- 3:16We can see the mechanical difference this makes
- 3:19in how people process information, like take
- 3:22studying. Oh, the highlighting thing. Yes. Research
- 3:25shows a massive difference in comprehension between
- 3:27students who just highlight text and students
- 3:30who use active annotation, you know, actually
- 3:32writing notes and questions in the margins. Because
- 3:35highlighting feels productive, but it's totally
- 3:37passive. You're basically just painting a page
- 3:39yellow. Right. Active annotation forces a completely
- 3:43different mechanism. When you write a question
- 3:44in the margin, your brain has to synthesize the
- 3:47abstract concept, translate it into language,
- 3:50and physically move your hand to encode it. You're
- 3:52forcing the brain to process the why and the
- 3:55how. Not just the what. And there's this fascinating
- 3:57study by Hawkins in 2006 that illustrates just
- 4:00how deeply this metacognition can go, particularly
- 4:04when it intersects with our personal moral. Well,
- 4:06this is the one with the retail clerk, right?
- 4:07Yeah. So the study involved a classroom where
- 4:10students had to describe a recent disturbing
- 4:12personal incident to their peers. And one student
- 4:15shared a story about being snubbed and treated
- 4:17really poorly by a retail clerk while shopping.
- 4:20Right. And her initial reaction there is purely
- 4:23emotional. It's anger. feeling disrespected.
- 4:26Her brain probably just categorized the clerk
- 4:28as a jerk just to protect her own ego. Exactly.
- 4:30But the peer discussion acted as a catalyst.
- 4:33Her classmates started questioning the underlying
- 4:35assumptions of the interaction. They provided
- 4:38that external friction. And through that group
- 4:41critical thinking process, she realized her underlying
- 4:43assumption was actually that she had been a victim
- 4:45of racial profiling based on her skin color.
- 4:48Wow. Yeah. And she then used that realization
- 4:51to frame a deeply researched heavily reasoned
- 4:55essay on racial profiling in retail environments.
- 4:58She moved from a passive emotional reaction to
- 5:01a structural metacognitive analysis. That is
- 5:05critical thinking at its absolute peak. You can't
- 5:07evaluate evidence effectively if you haven't
- 5:09first evaluated the lens through which you're
- 5:11looking at the evidence. Man, that is so true.
- 5:14OK, to lock this in for our exam, I like to use
- 5:16a specific memory hack. Think of critical thinking
- 5:18as being a detective. But you aren't investigating
- 5:22an external crime scene. You are a detective
- 5:25investigating the corrupt police precinct of
- 5:27your own brain. Oh, I like that. Yeah. You are
- 5:31actively searching for your own biases, your
- 5:33lazy shortcuts, and like... planted evidence.
- 5:36That's a perfect transition to the second pillar,
- 5:38actually. Once you've used critical thinking
- 5:40to tear down bad assumptions, how do you build
- 5:42something new to replace them? That requires
- 5:45creativity. Right. And in psychology, creativity
- 5:48isn't just painting a pretty picture. It has
- 5:50a strict definition. An idea must be both novel
- 5:53and useful. Meaning, if you put a monkey in a
- 5:56room with a typewriter and it randomly mashes
- 5:58the keys until it accidentally produces a Shakespearean
- 6:01sonnet, That is not creativity. No. It's completely
- 6:04new, sure, but it lacks intention, utility, and
- 6:08a valued purpose. Exactly. And to generate truly
- 6:11creative ideas, the brain utilizes two distinct
- 6:14processes. The first is divergent thinking. This
- 6:18is the expansive, open -ended brainstorm. Like,
- 6:21if I ask you, how many different uses can you
- 6:24think of for a shoe, your brain branches out
- 6:27in a dozen directions. A planter, a hammer, a
- 6:29bug smash. Right. The second process is convergent
- 6:32thinking. This is the focused logical reasoning
- 6:35designed to narrow down options to find one specific
- 6:38correct answer. Okay, quick memory hack for you
- 6:41guys listening. Divergent starts with a D, so
- 6:43think different directions. Convergent starts
- 6:45with a C, so think... coming together. That's
- 6:48great. And creativity requires both. Divergent
- 6:51thinking supplies the raw, wild ideas, but convergent
- 6:54thinking is the filter that determines if any
- 6:56of those ideas are actually useful or even possible.
- 6:59Okay, but wait. Here's where I have a major bone
- 7:01to pick with modern education. Standardized testing,
- 7:04multiple -choice exams, strict grading rubric
- 7:07schools heavily, almost exclusively, test convergent
- 7:10thinking. There's only ever one right answer.
- 7:12Doesn't that just completely crush the divergent
- 7:15creative process? It absolutely can, and educational
- 7:18psychologists are highly aware of this. When
- 7:20a student is put in a highly evaluative environment,
- 7:23their brain shifts from exploratory mode to survival
- 7:26mode. Makes sense. If divergent thinking means
- 7:29taking a risk, and taking a risk means getting
- 7:32an F on a test, the brain will shut down the
- 7:35divergent process entirely. This is why teachers
- 7:38have to intentionally engineer spaces where intrinsic
- 7:41reward matters more than the extrinsic evaluation.
- 7:45Like letting kids write absurd nonsensical poems
- 7:48just to play with new vocabulary words instead
- 7:51of constantly drilling them for a high -stakes
- 7:53Friday spelling test. Exactly. Let them play
- 7:56with the tools before you grade the house they
- 7:58build. Now, when we combine critical evaluation
- 8:00with creative generation, we arrive at the third
- 8:03pillar, problem -solving. But to understand how
- 8:06we solve problems, we actually have to look at
- 8:08why our brains so frequently fail at it. Oh,
- 8:11the cognitive traps. First off, we have well
- 8:13-structured problems versus ill -structured problems.
- 8:15A well -structured problem is a math worksheet.
- 8:17The variables, the rules, the formulas, they're
- 8:20sitting right there on the page. Very clean.
- 8:22Right. But an ill -structured problem is like,
- 8:24how do we achieve world peace? The information
- 8:28is totally incomplete and the end goal is incredibly
- 8:32vague. And when faced with ambiguity, the brain
- 8:35desperately tries to impose order, which leads
- 8:38to our biggest obstacle, functional fixedness.
- 8:42There's this classic visual puzzle in the text
- 8:45called the nine dot problem. I hate this one.
- 8:48It's so frustrating. You have a grid of nine
- 8:49dots, three rows of three. The instructions are
- 8:52to connect all nine dots using only four straight
- 8:54lines without lifting your pen. And almost everyone
- 8:57fails this on their first try, because we look
- 9:00at a grid of dots and our brains instantly draw
- 9:02an invisible imaginary box around them. We just
- 9:05assume our lines aren't allowed to cross outside
- 9:07the perimeter of the dots. That assumption is
- 9:09functional fixedness. Evolutionarily, this kind
- 9:12of fixed thinking is highly efficient. If a rock
- 9:15works as a hammer, your brain doesn't want to
- 9:16waste 20 minutes of caloric energy pondering
- 9:19if the rock could also be a musical instrument.
- 9:21It just wants to smash the nut and eat. Right,
- 9:23but in complex problem solving, that efficiency
- 9:26becomes a prison. Like the student in the textbook,
- 9:29Alicia. She was entirely stuck on the nine -dot
- 9:32puzzle until her teacher explicitly coaxed her,
- 9:36asking, have you assumed anything about how long
- 9:38the lines ought to be? The teacher didn't give
- 9:40her the answer. She just forced Alicia to investigate
- 9:43her own assumptions. And suddenly, Alicia realizes
- 9:46her lines can extend way past the dots, which
- 9:50is the only way to solve it. Another great example
- 9:52of functional fixedness from the text is a dictionary.
- 9:56We think it's only for looking up words. If a
- 9:58door keeps blowing open, you might freeze thinking
- 10:00you don't have a door stop, completely forgetting
- 10:03you're holding a 10 -pound book. Exactly. Another
- 10:06major obstacle is how we represent a problem
- 10:08mentally. Irrelevant information hijacks our
- 10:11cognitive processing. Consider the water lily
- 10:14problem. Oh, this one gets me every time. Imagine
- 10:16a lake where water lilies double an area every
- 10:19single day. If it takes exactly 100 days for
- 10:22the lilies to cover the entire lake, on what
- 10:24day is the lake exactly half covered? The moment
- 10:26you hear that, your brain goes straight into
- 10:28algorithmic math mode. You start trying to calculate
- 10:31the total square footage of a lake or dividing
- 10:33100 by 2 to get 50. But the math is a distraction.
- 10:36Totally. If the lilies double every day and the
- 10:39lake is full on day 100, then it had to be exactly
- 10:42half full the day before. The answer is day 99.
- 10:46Working backwards is such a crucial mental hack.
- 10:49We fail because the human brain evolved to understand
- 10:52linear progression gathering one berry, then
- 10:54a second berry. We are terrible at intuitively
- 10:58grasping exponential growth. Yeah, the big numbers
- 11:00overwhelm us. Right. So to bypass these biological
- 11:03traps, we rely on strategies, mainly algorithms
- 11:07and heuristics. Okay, here's where it gets really
- 11:09interesting. Think of an algorithm as a paved
- 11:12highway. It is a highly structured step -by -step
- 11:15procedure that guarantees a correct solution
- 11:17if you follow the rules perfectly, like long
- 11:20division. A heuristic, on the other hand, is
- 11:22like taking a dirt trail through the woods. I
- 11:24like that. It's a rule of thumb. scanning the
- 11:27titles of library books to quickly find a source
- 11:30for a research paper rather than reading the
- 11:32index of every single book in the building. Right.
- 11:34The algorithm reading every index is guaranteed
- 11:37to find the absolute best book, but it will take
- 11:40a year. The heuristic, the dirt trail might not
- 11:42get you there safely every single time, but it's
- 11:45way faster. And we also use strategies like problem
- 11:48analysis. That means breaking a massive goal
- 11:50like improve city bicycle transport into sub
- 11:53problems like add lanes and fix potholes. Okay,
- 11:56so we understand the mechanics of complex thinking
- 11:59and we understand the cognitive traps. The ultimate
- 12:02question for educators is, how do we actually
- 12:05get these concepts into a student's head? The
- 12:07playbook. Yes, the instructional playbooks. Let's
- 12:10move from the theory to the action, starting
- 12:12with teacher -directed models. This is about
- 12:14transmitting knowledge of Techniques include
- 12:17advanced organizers giving a comprehensive overview
- 12:20before a lecture begins. It essentially opens
- 12:22up the correct file folders in the student's
- 12:25brain so that when the new information arrives,
- 12:27it has a place to attach. And structured outlining,
- 12:30like note taking. Studies actually show the quantity
- 12:33of notes matters more than the specific style.
- 12:36Using note -taking guides helps massively, like
- 12:39giving students a setting, characters, plot,
- 12:42theme guide before a novel, or a standard science
- 12:44experiment guide. And an even more profound tool
- 12:47is the concept map. Oh, this was fascinating.
- 12:50The text compares a classroom teacher's concept
- 12:52map and a university professor's map on the exact
- 12:55same term, child development. The contrast is
- 12:58wild. Right. The teacher focused on super practical
- 13:01issues. school policies, drug use, abuse. But
- 13:05the professor focused on deeper cognitive frameworks,
- 13:08specifically including massive nodes for moral
- 13:11development and sexuality. Which perfectly demonstrates
- 13:13how our daily environments architect our cognitive
- 13:16frameworks. Two people can use the exact same
- 13:18firm, but they have completely different mental
- 13:20maps of what it means. Okay, so let's look at
- 13:22a highly structured direct instruction model.
- 13:25Mastery learning. Specifically, Madeline Hunter's
- 13:28effective teaching model. Right. Highly scripted,
- 13:31It blends cognitive and behavioral elements.
- 13:35It involves anticipatory sets. Like, before a
- 13:38lesson on plant biology, a teacher won't just
- 13:40list definitions. They'll ask, if you're making
- 13:43a fruit salad, would you put an apple, a tomato,
- 13:46or a cucumber in it? Just to instantly focus
- 13:48their attention. Yes, and activate those existing
- 13:51neural pathways. Then the teacher moves to direct
- 13:54instruction, checking for understanding using
- 13:56choral responses, having the whole class speak
- 13:59the answer in unison and independent practice.
- 14:01The philosophy is that every single student must
- 14:04reach the same high standard regardless of how
- 14:06long it takes. Okay, but this brings up a massive
- 14:08moral question directly from the text. Is mastery
- 14:11learning actually fair? Because if everyone has
- 14:14to reach the same standard, the fast learners
- 14:16get fun enrichment activities, while the slower
- 14:19learners get stuck doing repetitive remediation.
- 14:21Doesn't that create an unethical, two -tiered
- 14:24classroom experience? It is a huge ethical pitfall.
- 14:28If executed poorly, yes. But the text gives a
- 14:31clear solution. The remediation materials must
- 14:34be designed to be just as interesting and engaging
- 14:37as the enrichment materials. That is the only
- 14:39way to maintain ethical fairness. That makes
- 14:41sense. But because of the limitations of teacher
- 14:44-directed methods, educators developed alternative,
- 14:48student -centered models where the learner takes
- 14:50the driver's seat. Right. One method is independent
- 14:53study and self -reflection. But, and what's fascinating
- 14:56here is, self -reflection really only works well
- 14:58with outside feedback. Oh, the diary study. Exactly.
- 15:02The text highlights the study where students
- 15:04reflected on their own cultural and racial prejudices.
- 15:07Writing in a private diary did very little. The
- 15:10reflection only became deep and meaningful when
- 15:12the teacher actively commented and thoughtfully
- 15:14challenged their beliefs. You can't just talk
- 15:16to yourself. You need that external friction.
- 15:18Which naturally leads to cooperative or collaborative
- 15:21learning, like inquiry learning, posing questions
- 15:24like, why do leaves fall? Or why do nations go
- 15:27to war? And that naturally leads to working together.
- 15:31Strategies include think -pair -share, STAD student
- 15:34teams achievement divisions, and the jigsaw classroom.
- 15:38But wait, we all know group work and undergrad
- 15:40can be an absolute nightmare. How do teachers
- 15:43stop it from just failing entirely? It's hard.
- 15:46The biggest pitfalls are freeloading. One person
- 15:49doing all the work in over -specialization where
- 15:51they just divide the work so nobody actually
- 15:53collaborates. And furthermore, social prejudices
- 15:56like gender sexism or racial bias can cause some
- 15:59group members to be unfairly ignored. So how
- 16:02do you fix that? Teachers must use rich group
- 16:04work tasks. Like the medieval castle example.
- 16:07Yes. If you're presenting a medieval castle,
- 16:09you need diverse talents. You need writing, art,
- 16:12dramatic acting. The students realize they desperately
- 16:14need everyone's unique skills to succeed. It
- 16:17forces genuine interdependence. So what does
- 16:20this all mean? If we step back, whether teaching
- 16:22is direct or student -centered, the goal is always
- 16:25to move the student toward complex thinking.
- 16:27Exactly. Which brings us to the tease for Chapter
- 16:3010 regarding instructional planning. There's
- 16:33that famous Casey Stengel quote, If you don't
- 16:35know where you're going, you could end up someplace
- 16:36else. Yeah. Without a clear objective, all these
- 16:39strategies are completely useless. Absolutely.
- 16:42Well, to wrap up, I want to leave you, our study
- 16:44buddy, with a final thought to mull over. Think
- 16:47about your own education up to this point. Which
- 16:50model built your brain? Were you shaped by the
- 16:53strict algorithms of direct instruction or the
- 16:55messy heuristics of student -centered learning?
- 16:58It's a great question. And more importantly,
- 17:00now that you have the metacognition to see the
- 17:03matrix. How will you choose to learn tomorrow?
- 17:07Especially when we leave the classroom and our
- 17:10daily learning becomes social media algorithms
- 17:12that are designed to never cause friction. How
- 17:15do you maintain critical thinking in an echo
- 17:17chamber? Something to think about. Thanks for
- 17:20joining this study session on the Psychology
- 17:22Undergrad. We'll catch you next time.