Latest / Inside Commerce: Ecommerce Strategy, CX and Technology Podcast / EP263: Common Issues with ERPs: How They Hamper Ecommerce Teams & What To Do About Them, With Luke Hodgson
Transcript
- 0:02You're listening to the Insidecommerce podcast, hosted
- 0:05by experienced consultants James Gerd and Paul Rogers.
- 0:08Insidecommerce is your fast tracked additional knowledge
- 0:10featuring interviews with leading e-commerce retailers,
- 0:13industry thought leads and the C-Suite of key tech companies to
- 0:16explore the latest in digital strategy, customer experience
- 0:18and tech. Discover what the latest trends
- 0:21really mean and get practical advice based on experience to
- 0:24help fine tune your ECOM strategy and tech stack.
- 0:27Follow us on LinkedIn and reach out to James with Paul if you'd
- 0:30like to discuss an e-commerce project.
- 0:32We hope you enjoy the latest episode.
- 0:35You're listening to the Inside Commerce podcast sponsored by
- 0:38Centre and Greben. More about them later.
- 0:40Let me just tee up today's conversation.
- 0:42I'll introduce you to our guest. Some of you will know him well
- 0:45already, but the topic is common issues with ERPS and
- 0:49integrations with e-commerce, how they can hamper an E Comm
- 0:52set up and what to do about it. And the reason for this
- 0:55conversation it it's quite simple is that Erps are often a
- 0:59source of project complexity for E Comm migrations and re
- 1:03platforming and how the ERP setup can constrain what you can
- 1:06do in e-commerce. It can impact things like your
- 1:09ability to to process orders at peak and how you want to and
- 1:12understanding what can go wrong and knowing what to do about it.
- 1:14And also what questions you should be asking to better find
- 1:18out whether the setup in the back office stuff is actually
- 1:20going to enable you to deliver on your e-commerce plans is
- 1:23really, really important. So we've got a guest a who knows
- 1:26a thing or two about this. So welcome, Luke Codgson.
- 1:28How are you doing, Sir? Very well.
- 1:31Thank you. Thanks for inviting me on.
- 1:32It's lovely to see you both. Yeah, excellent.
- 1:36So I'll let you. Do you know what, instead of
- 1:37sitting there trying to talk through all the different things
- 1:39you do, I think it's probably best coming from you.
- 1:42Do you want to give people a bit of a flavour?
- 1:44You haven't come across you before?
- 1:45What do you do and what is your expertise relevant to this
- 1:48topic? Yeah, yeah, happy to.
- 1:51So yeah, my name's Luke. My background is in E com and
- 1:55retail. Spent the last 1213 years
- 1:58working with really closely with retail brands.
- 2:02Right now I run a consulting practice called Commerce
- 2:04Thinking. The easiest way to think of us
- 2:07is we fill the gap brand side where a conventional tech team
- 2:11would sit. So CTO or a tech director, and
- 2:15then the types of team members that person would have reporting
- 2:18into them is basically what my team is.
- 2:20So we've got a team of 6 that combines engineering, change
- 2:24management, product development and product management from a
- 2:30kind of physical product side all the way through to BI and
- 2:33engineering. So we we typically sit there and
- 2:36fill that gap brand side where a tech team would sit.
- 2:39And we do that through our consulting practice.
- 2:42And we've really nailed that through an audit program that we
- 2:45do. And so that's meant that we've
- 2:47worked very, very much embedded inside of some of the fastest
- 2:51growing brands out there. So recently we've worked with
- 2:54like Polly Stuzi representing clothing little sleepies over in
- 2:59LA, the list goes on and we'll be involved and it just means
- 3:04that we are overseeing some really, really big critical
- 3:07change projects and our focus is entirely on the back office.
- 3:12So that's what commerce thinking is.
- 3:14My background prior to that or alongside of that is I've been
- 3:18the Co founder in two successful integration platforms.
- 3:22And so most recently over the last 5-6 years been growing high
- 3:26cohesion and that business is run by Aaron Capilla.
- 3:30And I'm I suppose a bit of a silent partner to him and
- 3:33supporting him as he scales that business.
- 3:35And then prior to that, I was a Co founder in Patchworks.
- 3:38And so all of those, those experiences combined together.
- 3:42Yeah. I mean, I'm pretty well placed
- 3:44to talk about the topic that you wanted to cover off today, which
- 3:47was ERP and I suppose had to do it properly.
- 3:50Yeah. And this, this conversation came
- 3:51up, we were slacking about this because of a project I've been
- 3:54working on recently where I was just trying to get to the bottom
- 3:56about like order processing rate limits and how many orders
- 4:01should you be expecting to be at a process per minute per hour at
- 4:04peak into an ERP and where bottlenecks could be and what
- 4:09could be causing it. And I think this is really
- 4:11interesting because typically EE commerce leaders I'm talking to
- 4:14those might be a director of e-commerce, a head of e-commerce
- 4:16and E com manager don't have much exposure to the mechanics
- 4:20of an ERP and an ERP integration.
- 4:22They may understand the data flow requirements and the
- 4:25dependencies for the ECOM and ERP, but won't have the, the
- 4:29knowledge to, to maybe scrutinize, set up sort of
- 4:33decisions or be able to ask better questions.
- 4:34So I thought this would be a really interesting one.
- 4:36And it's definitely an area where I don't have, I mean, I
- 4:38don't have the entities you do, hence getting you on.
- 4:41And you, you've said a really important point before we start
- 4:44recording, which is accountability.
- 4:45Often this can be blurred between in a project, who owns
- 4:49the decision making round here and when there are potential
- 4:51issues or actions. Does it sit be, does it sit in
- 4:54an ITT? Is there an external third party
- 4:56specialist consultant and how would you manage that?
- 4:59Probably so. So let I, I think let's start
- 5:01with the the framing question, which is why should E Comm
- 5:04leaders care about the state of their ERP?
- 5:06Why should they care about more than just a day to flow?
- 5:11Grebin create digital flagship stores for iconic brands of
- 5:14today and tomorrow. We are the number one Centra
- 5:17agency in the world with more than 50 Centra implementations
- 5:20to date. We are also e-commerce design
- 5:23specialists, platform and tech partner agnostic.
- 5:26Try our new e-commerce design subscription.
- 5:29Visit greben.com. I think the critical thing every
- 5:34business leader inside of a brand using an ERP needs to
- 5:39recognize is that if it's working properly, it should be
- 5:43the single system that everyone relies upon for transactions
- 5:48related to stock. So if you're in an ecom business
- 5:51and you're selling apparel, it's really important that you know
- 5:57how much stuff is being ordered, how much stuff you have on hand
- 6:00available to sell, and ultimately how many transactions
- 6:04have flown through your sales channels that need fulfilling.
- 6:07So every single transaction related to physical inventory
- 6:12should be recorded inside of an ERP.
- 6:16So I'd, I'd almost split the question and actually say how
- 6:20can an econ leader worth their salt not be interested in that
- 6:24information? Because that information
- 6:26determines a how much you've got to sell and therefore what you
- 6:30should be pushing hardest. So whether it comes to how
- 6:33people are viewing and how like a website is sorted to
- 6:37ultimately optimise it so that you're flogging the things that
- 6:40you want to flog and pushing the items that really need to be
- 6:43cleared down. Things like addressing aged
- 6:46stock issues, you're going to go to your ERP if it's set up
- 6:48properly for that information. And then similarly downstream,
- 6:52if you have done an amazing launch or an amazing promotion
- 6:56and you've got a shit load of sales coming through your ecom
- 6:59channel, your ERP is likely to be between the website and the
- 7:05warehouse or the three PL. Not always, and I'm sure we'll
- 7:08come back to that in a moment, but in a lot of businesses the
- 7:12ERP is that system that then is processing and sorting the
- 7:17orders and sending them downstream into a three PL. or a
- 7:20warehouse management system. So if it's not working perfectly
- 7:24for you in those peak moments, you've got a real problem
- 7:28because you've sold stuff that customers might not be getting
- 7:30shipped. So yeah, I almost turn it on
- 7:32it's head and say how can you not be interested?
- 7:35How can you not be taking care over that?
- 7:38So I think to my next question, which I've changed a little bit
- 7:41and I'll come on to like wine what the next question is.
- 7:44But I think to your point there around how can an E com, a good
- 7:48E com leader not be I guess involved in the ERP thing?
- 7:52I completely agree. But I do think one of the things
- 7:55that over the last few, I think that 8-9 years ago, every single
- 7:59econ director would have like a level of accountability for an
- 8:02ERP. It might be run out of IT or
- 8:04finance, but every single econ director would be having a big
- 8:08input and yeah, more responsibility in that area.
- 8:11Whereas I think two years ago post COVID when you got brands
- 8:15go up from zero to 100 million in a year as a result of kind of
- 8:20in as a result of like digital penetration, as a result of like
- 8:24various other kind of industry trends.
- 8:26I feel like there's been a new type of ecom director or digital
- 8:30director whose KPI is purely like new customer growth or like
- 8:34kind of, yeah, front office KP is.
- 8:38So I guess that was one point I wanted to make.
- 8:40And I guess alongside that, my question I kind of reframed was,
- 8:46and I think you and I have both worked with a couple of brands
- 8:48that fit this bill. I feel like there's more and
- 8:51more brands now that scaled to a certain level without an ERP.
- 8:55And I know you've got some really strong opinions on this.
- 8:59And part of that is kind of because of that growth
- 9:01trajectory, because of how these businesses are operating and
- 9:04they're more immature and they want to be lean and a focus on
- 9:07product and brand and everything else.
- 9:10But I do feel like the industry is starting to like calm down a
- 9:14little bit as well. So like my question is like 2
- 9:18years kind of after COVID and the kind of hyper growth phase
- 9:21and everything else, And also with D2C maybe not being as
- 9:26aggressive as it was do now, do you still see the same level of
- 9:31demand for ERP projects, relatively new businesses?
- 9:36And if not, what are they kind of doing instead?
- 9:40Centre is the only commerce platform built exclusively for
- 9:42fashion brands. Over 300 fashion brands run on
- 9:44Centre including icons like Paul Smith, Jeff Ave. and Nudie
- 9:47Jeans. Centre solves business logic
- 9:49challenges for fashion brands. I know other platform and they
- 9:51are on a mission to help you scale up rapidly globally across
- 9:54all online and offline channels. Take your fashion brand global.
- 9:57Faster, further, stronger today. Good questions, good questions.
- 10:02So I think you touched on it and I've now got enough experience,
- 10:06I've got enough grey hairs to have seen some changes in the
- 10:09trends and the demands for ERP. And I think if you'd have asked
- 10:13me 10 years ago, I would have been like, by the time you're at
- 10:1710 million, it's pretty much back sealed on that.
- 10:20You're going to need an ERP pretty soon.
- 10:23That has changed significantly. I think over the last five years
- 10:26in particular, the time that brands can go without an ERP has
- 10:30expanded significantly because there are just more ways of
- 10:34taking a business to say 50 mil turnover, 100 mil turnover
- 10:38without an ERP and we are actively helping brands in that
- 10:43way as well. I think also the marketplace has
- 10:47just got more educated on what it takes to properly deliver an
- 10:53ERP system. So the the kind of immature
- 10:56brands of 10 years ago, a lot of the leaders who were doing it
- 11:00for the first time in those brands have now left those
- 11:03brands and joined other newer smaller start-ups who are going
- 11:07on their own kind of rapid growth journey and they're
- 11:10bringing those lessons with them.
- 11:11So there is inside of brands a higher level of education as to
- 11:17we need to be really careful about when we do to go with ERP
- 11:20or not. So I think that kind of answers
- 11:22one of the questions, right, Paul.
- 11:23And then I think most recently given the trends and also like
- 11:28brands seeing that the the space for growing into as AD to C
- 11:32brand and 100% D to C, it's harder, right.
- 11:36Customer acquisition is more expensive, making really, really
- 11:39good margins in a 100% D to C model and just having that turbo
- 11:43growth. It's just harder, like it is
- 11:45harder than it was. And I actually think that whilst
- 11:49and I, I, I, I tend to agree with you that COVID and that
- 11:53post COVID period may have created a bit of a frenzied kind
- 11:57of atmosphere where people were just trying to bolt whatever
- 12:00they could on to support as they grew.
- 12:02I do think that there is probably a little bit more of a
- 12:05deliberation period now that's happening and I think that's a
- 12:07positive thing. But I think as a consequence of
- 12:10like D to C getting more and more difficult, brands are
- 12:14naturally saying, right, we need to look at wholesale as a
- 12:17channel, we need to look at physical retail as a channel.
- 12:20And as soon as you open up more like business operational
- 12:24channels like that, it increases the need to have a system that
- 12:29is complex enough to be able to handle those distinct
- 12:32requirements. So I think what we're going to
- 12:33see is actually probably an uplift in the amount of people
- 12:37that ultimately go with ERP systems.
- 12:39I just think it's going to take slightly longer because people
- 12:41are more informed and they know that they can't do an ERP
- 12:45properly without a proper plan, without the proper resourcing.
- 12:49At least that's what I'm seeing. Yeah, I think I've definitely
- 12:52seen a few brands that have chosen not to go down the ERP
- 12:56route due to complexity primarily and that have now
- 13:02changed their mind and are looking to do an ERP basically.
- 13:06Yeah, and I think that's natural, right?
- 13:08Like as the sorry to talk over you, but I think that's totally
- 13:10natural. And I, I actually think it's a
- 13:12good thing. People are exploring the
- 13:14alternative paths and in many times they're kind of like doing
- 13:18a proof of concept. They're investing in this
- 13:21alternative path and seeing whether it's going to work or
- 13:24not. And naturally some of those
- 13:26proof of concepts will be successful, but also naturally
- 13:29some of them will be unsuccessful.
- 13:31And people will go back to that decision point and say, OK,
- 13:34first time around we said we weren't going to go forward with
- 13:36the now we've got more information and more evidence we
- 13:40need it. And then they'll go forward with
- 13:42a much clearer understanding of what's going to be required.
- 13:45And I think looping backs to the kind of like econ leader.
- 13:49I think one of the key things that I'd always stress is that
- 13:52in a mature business, you would have like a digital and ecom
- 13:57leader and you would also have a tech leader.
- 14:00They are distinct and they have separate roles and
- 14:02responsibilities. So how actively involved an ecom
- 14:06and a digital leader is in the delivery and the maintenance of
- 14:09an ERP is different. They shouldn't be the person
- 14:13that is accountable for the ERP system in the vast majority of
- 14:17brands, but they do have a really, really critical role to
- 14:20play in specifying their requirements, testing what's
- 14:23being delivered. And as they do new and creative
- 14:26things or come up with new and creative ideas, if they are
- 14:30vetting those with the tech teams, they are making sure that
- 14:34those sorts of things aren't happening in a silo that then
- 14:37create downstream issues with data flows in and out of the ERP
- 14:41system. So yeah, it's probably a really
- 14:43key bit of context. I don't see ECOM and digital
- 14:46leaders typically being the people that own ERP, but they
- 14:49have a really important power to veto decisions and they also
- 14:52have a really, really big role to play in specifying
- 14:54requirements. That makes sense.
- 14:56I think at the end I might add a question around the pros and
- 15:00cons as having a very soon or like what level that tech person
- 15:04should come in at as well. It's a bit of a deviation, but I
- 15:06think it's a good addition. Yeah, and one sub question.
- 15:09So I think one of the things that I've always for would
- 15:13happen at some point, and a lot of other people have said the
- 15:16same, is that there would be a player in the back of this space
- 15:20similar to Shopify that commoditizes and elements of the
- 15:24ERP and is maybe a bit more modular, You know, truly API
- 15:29first, like the stripe of ERP essentially know there's some
- 15:34like new kind of startups of raised some money and stuff like
- 15:37that now. But I I personally feel like
- 15:39every time any client of ours mentions about ERP, it's usually
- 15:43followed by dynamics and nesser it.
- 15:48So I guess to your like, what do you think about that?
- 15:51Do you think there will be like an an interim into that market
- 15:55that yeah, kind of reduces some of the friction of of
- 16:00implementing an ARP or like is maybe a little bit more kind of
- 16:03modern an approach like do you think there'll be anyone like
- 16:06that coming to the market? If I was a betting man, I think
- 16:11the most likely company to create a Shopify ERP type
- 16:16experience is Shopify. If they really wanted it, they
- 16:19could go for it. I think.
- 16:21I think they are one of the few people that could actually one
- 16:24of the few companies that could actually give it a whirl.
- 16:28That said, Oracle bought NetSuite on the premise that
- 16:32they could be that and they're not that because I think that
- 16:38that I don't want to fall into the trap of saying back office
- 16:41is more complicated and therefore a Shopify like
- 16:44experience is not possible. But I think it is more
- 16:47complicated. There is more variability.
- 16:50There are fundamentally just more processors involved in the
- 16:55procurement of product, the management of inbounding of
- 16:59product, the forecasting of sales and pumping that into a
- 17:02system that then gives you some kind of demand planning.
- 17:05Like these aren't simple concepts and they are always
- 17:08different to every brand, so commoditizing it is inherently
- 17:13more challenging. However, I wouldn't rule it out
- 17:17you you like if I was a betting man, which I'm not, but I would
- 17:22probably put my money on Shopify to continue to incrementally
- 17:26grow out it's. I personally think that Shopify
- 17:30will introduce more flexibility and functionality and some of
- 17:35the back end site, particularly order management and inventory
- 17:40management. And their goal will be to take
- 17:43the invest some of that investment for the smaller
- 17:46businesses like over the long term they might have a different
- 17:49plan. But I think that's how I
- 17:50personally think they would want a 510,000,000 LB fashion brand,
- 17:54£20 million fashion brand to see Shopify as their retail
- 17:58operating system including point of sale.
- 18:02Yeah, and I don't know if that then goes up market, but I
- 18:04completely agree. Anyway, James, I'll let you ask
- 18:06some questions. No, we, it's good.
- 18:09We're now on the future strategy of of Shopify a a free app.
- 18:13I'll, I'll bring this away from being Shopify centric.
- 18:19I I think quite a question. Follow along for that.
- 18:21I guess this is linked to like changing strategy of business
- 18:24and the tech they're using in their stack is that middleware
- 18:27piece. And obviously you've got strong
- 18:29opinions on this because you know Co found in two different
- 18:33businesses. But I find this really
- 18:35interesting because I, I think there's been a, a, a definitely
- 18:39mindset shift in e-commerce businesses away from pre built
- 18:43connectors to middleware and isolating different systems and
- 18:47doing any data transformation piece within the middleware to
- 18:50reduce that, that complexity and avoid customization at either
- 18:53the the front end or the back end, as I call it.
- 18:57What you seen and what, what role now are you seeing
- 19:00middleware playing? How has that changed in terms of
- 19:02helping like I guess reduce complexity between ECOM and ERP?
- 19:09It's definitely a space which has got a lot of differing needs
- 19:15and there is a place I think for lots of different players in the
- 19:19middleware space. You know, when we first started
- 19:23our very first integration platform all those years ago,
- 19:2711-12 years ago, it was a bit of a Wild West, right?
- 19:30There was only a handful of players and then everything was
- 19:34up for grabs. If you look at it today, it's a
- 19:36much more mature market and I think that's reflective of the
- 19:41types of businesses that they're focusing on.
- 19:43So I think you've got to use that commoditized phrase.
- 19:47I think you've got a lot of room for a commoditized player or
- 19:51players who are saying right, businesses who have got low
- 19:56budgets want very, very quick to deploy solutions and are
- 20:01accepting of the fact that they're not going to get
- 20:03everything they want, but they're going to get enough.
- 20:06Here's some plug and play connectors.
- 20:08Mega cheap. Low cost to adopt, if not free
- 20:12and they'll take them as far as they can before they then say,
- 20:15right, we can't customize this. We can't implement as much logic
- 20:18as we would like. And also this, we don't have
- 20:21people inside of the business who are able to do that work
- 20:25inside of these platforms. And at that point, they'll then
- 20:27say, right, what's the alternatives?
- 20:29And this is where you start getting into more serious brand
- 20:32territory where they just have more complexity in their
- 20:34business. They might be doing really high
- 20:36volumes of sales at massive peaks, whether it's Black Friday
- 20:40or new product drops. They might have things like new
- 20:43channels that are opening up and they're saying, OK, we've
- 20:46already got this like loads of different plug and play apps and
- 20:49none of them are doing everything that we want.
- 20:52Can we try and consolidate some of these into a single platform
- 20:55that then gives us a lot more flexibility and that is where
- 20:59high cohesion is playing. It's in this space where brands
- 21:03are mature enough to know that they need to do a proper
- 21:06comprehensive job on integration.
- 21:08They want to try and consolidate things into a single platform as
- 21:11much as possible. And they also know that these
- 21:14things require expertise and resource and people who are
- 21:18going to properly, properly focus on nailing it.
- 21:20It's not just something that's almost like an afterthought or a
- 21:23quick plug and play. It's a project in and of itself.
- 21:26And so I think what we're seeing particularly at that more mature
- 21:29serious end of the market is brands and the leaders inside of
- 21:33those brands have probably had their fingers burnt enough times
- 21:36with some of the plug and play options that promised the earth
- 21:38and didn't deliver and therefore they're just ready to do it
- 21:41properly. So I think there is a a couple
- 21:44of tears opening up in the market and then even more
- 21:47enterprise grade than say a a Heiko is you likes of mule
- 21:51softs, you know like the mule softs of this world are enormous
- 21:55enterprise platforms with incredible training programs for
- 21:58in house developers and things like that.
- 22:00But the cost is reflective of their positioning in the market
- 22:03and they are often not really playing in that kind of mid tier
- 22:08of of brands over there. That answers the question.
- 22:12It's just a much more mature marketplace as well.
- 22:14I'm seeing it is, I think this is, this is the challenges for
- 22:17ecom teams is, is when, when moving platforms, you often get
- 22:21a change. It's not just take out the ecom
- 22:24platform, it is the wider tech stack change and that can be
- 22:27introducing these additional layers.
- 22:30And it can be difficult to understand whether the, I guess
- 22:33the middleware solution being recommended is the right one is
- 22:37fit for purpose. I think people understanding and
- 22:39realising it's nuance and that it's not just, you know, it's
- 22:43not just a middleware is a middleware, it's very different
- 22:45in terms of what they're able to do is very important also.
- 22:48But let's go on to the bit that I'm really interested in
- 22:51chatting about is, is this this you talked about peak order
- 22:54volumes and how that can have a massive impact in terms of your
- 22:57operational processes and capabilities.
- 23:01And I have seen this personally in projects where when people
- 23:05start, you know, tripling, quadrupling overnight numbers,
- 23:10they can end up with process blocks, which could be down to
- 23:13how a system's configured. It could be down to how one
- 23:16particular platform is set up to enable volumes to be passed
- 23:19through and the processing speed.
- 23:22And I thought it'd be really interesting to hear from your
- 23:23point of life what typically causes peak order volume
- 23:26capacity issues from an ERP. Let's take the middleware and
- 23:30ERP setup. You know, we talked about these
- 23:33like concurrency limits and ERP's setup inefficiencies.
- 23:36So what are the common gottes you come across?
- 23:39Yeah. OK.
- 23:40So I think the most common gotcha is brands not forecasting
- 23:46the peaks properly and then sharing the information as well
- 23:51as they can with all of the parties that might be affected
- 23:53by that. Like honestly, I've seen brands
- 23:57nail peak sales periods but not be giving their warehouse or
- 24:01three PL. at least some indication of what numbers
- 24:05they're expecting in the first day of sale.
- 24:07So part of it is just very, very non-technical housekeeping.
- 24:11Be clear with the partners that are going to have to deal with
- 24:14the downstream effects of you ramming loads and loads of
- 24:17orders in at the top end. If we then look at more of the
- 24:20the technology side, if you look at if you've got an architecture
- 24:25that places e-commerce above ERP and then your warehousing and
- 24:30your kind of fulfilment beneath the ERP in kind of like a
- 24:33vertical stack with each of those systems feeding into one
- 24:37another. There is a huge, huge emphasis
- 24:39in peak sales periods for your ERP system to have the hosting
- 24:43ability to keep up the pace. And what we've found and Maxine
- 24:48from my team and Dom from my team, they were both part of the
- 24:52Gymshark systems teams for five plus years.
- 24:54And there is no business that I've ever worked with who have
- 24:58had such a focus on optimizing their tax stack for sales peaks
- 25:03and doing it really, really well over years and years and years.
- 25:06And for them, one of the key requirements was to ensure that
- 25:09the the hosting and the service tier that they were on inside of
- 25:12their ERP system was capable of handling those peak volumes
- 25:16twice a year. So you've got to make sure that
- 25:19your hosting is right within your ERP.
- 25:21Otherwise you just don't have enough lanes to send data into
- 25:25it and it just cannot keep up. So no matter how fast your
- 25:28middle Ware is at taking data from say Shopify and sending it
- 25:31into the ERP and how fast it is at picking up data from the ERP
- 25:36and sending it down to the three PL. or warehouse, if the system
- 25:40in the middle does not have the hosting capacity because you
- 25:42perhaps not upgraded it enough, you're going to have problems.
- 25:46So that's one of the key areas you've got to make sure that
- 25:48you've got enough concurrency inside of that system and that's
- 25:51usually linked to the hosting and service tier.
- 25:54The second element is again, middleware.
- 25:57So like you've got middleware needs to be able to handle that
- 26:00kind of throughput and that the high cohesion platform and the
- 26:04way that was architected from day one was geared up around
- 26:08that. There are other middleware
- 26:10platforms that I know are focusing in the similar way, but
- 26:13I can only talk about our approach.
- 26:15And it's a lot of that is around how you've actually
- 26:18fundamentally architected the system and how you're able to
- 26:21scale up each individual stream, IE sales orders from this
- 26:26Shopify instance to this ERP for this brand.
- 26:29Can we scale up that one stream sufficiently so that it can
- 26:33handle that kind of throughput? So HICO is one of those
- 26:36platforms that's got that built into it.
- 26:38If you don't have that scalability and that elasticity
- 26:41in your middle Ware, you'll get to peak volumes and it will just
- 26:44not be flowing the orders through anywhere near quickly
- 26:48enough. Sometimes they crash, often they
- 26:51just lag massively. So that doesn't, it doesn't
- 26:54matter how much concurrency you've got in your ERP, your
- 26:57middle Ware can't keep up. You're wasting money on those
- 27:00licences in the ERP and you're also falling behind massively in
- 27:04fulfilling those, those peak sales orders.
- 27:08And then I suppose the the more nuanced bit on top of that,
- 27:11because they're kind of like supposedly the common sense
- 27:13answers is how are you optimising the set up of all of
- 27:16those things in the run up and during peak sales periods?
- 27:20So one of the things that Maxime on the team is really, really
- 27:24bullish about is how very rarely does a brand go into a peak
- 27:29sales period and say, right, we're going to go live with our
- 27:33sale at one minute past midnight.
- 27:36Just for example, at 10 minutes past midnight, we're expecting
- 27:39an inbounding shipment of a load of new stock that we want to
- 27:42make available on the site ready for go live and ready for the
- 27:45sale. So as soon as it comes in,
- 27:47update the stock levels and enable that to be sold.
- 27:50Very rarely is a brand doing that through peak.
- 27:52And what you need to have is the maturity of understanding, OK,
- 27:55what integrations and flows of data do we actually need running
- 28:00in real time through our peak sales period.
- 28:04Because if you don't, if it is not business critical that you
- 28:08have all of these other transactional flows, whether it
- 28:11be inventory levels, whether it be purchase orders, whether it
- 28:15be inbound receipt of goods from the warehouse up to your ERP
- 28:20system. If all of these things are
- 28:21critical through those peak moments, turn them off, pause
- 28:26them and allow all of your focus and concurrency to be focused on
- 28:31the things that have to happen in real time through those first
- 28:34hour, 2 hours, four hours, 12 hours of a sale.
- 28:38And then have the plan and have the the whole process set up so
- 28:42that you can activate them again.
- 28:44And it'll have no business impact, negative business
- 28:46impact, but it'll enable you to concentrate all of the
- 28:50bandwidth, all of the concurrency, basically all of
- 28:53the firepower into the thing that needs to be on point.
- 28:56And that's normally orders down and potentially inventory backup
- 29:00depending on how complex you want to make the setup.
- 29:04Great. So I think that was a really
- 29:06detailed answer that has answered the next question,
- 29:09which was what tactics or tips do you have for E com businesses
- 29:14looking to maximize performance on the back office side around
- 29:18P? So I will use this opportunity
- 29:20to ask the question that I was thinking of earlier and I think
- 29:24this is a really interesting question.
- 29:26The only thing is, is it's, I think you will probably coming
- 29:29at it from one side and maybe James and I come at it from
- 29:32another side. But it's something that we've
- 29:33talked about little bit on the podcast.
- 29:35But I've spoken quite a lot of people about post COVID.
- 29:39You mentioned hiring a very senior technical leader and you
- 29:43didn't mention of what level they come in at.
- 29:45And there's something that I've seen certain brands do.
- 29:49So some even some of those brands that I talked about
- 29:52earlier. So they've got to 100 million
- 29:53very, very quickly and they've bought in a CTO and that CTO is
- 29:58like board level super senior. And essentially that person has
- 30:03freedom or at least a lot of control around how the end to
- 30:08end tech stack is approached. 1 dangerous thing that I've seen
- 30:13when a person's coming at that level in the past is when it
- 30:15comes to the front office. I think from the back office
- 30:18side, I can definitely see a lot of value there.
- 30:22But when it comes to like a fashion brand or a beauty brand
- 30:25or whatever else, I've certainly seen some people come in and
- 30:29like over architects that all aspects of like the front end
- 30:32stack, be that like, you know, a composable build or you know,
- 30:36investing in different Mac technologies, whatever.
- 30:39Basically, they've just taken away like maybe 18 months of
- 30:45feature development or like kind of focus on things that are
- 30:49going to make a material impact the business by introducing this
- 30:52kind of technology. Change isn't always needed and
- 30:55that's definitely not always the case.
- 30:57And like we're working right now, it's got a CTO and they're
- 31:00the complete opposite. And you know, they're like
- 31:02focused on consolidation and modern tech and low code and
- 31:06whatever else. But I guess my question to you
- 31:07is like what, how like type of brands that we've worked in the
- 31:12past, 50,000,000 LB fashion brand, you know, they maybe they
- 31:16don't have any RP, they're relatively immature from a
- 31:20technology perspective across a business.
- 31:22What level do you think that technology person should come in
- 31:25AT and what do you think that rematch should be?
- 31:29It's a good question and I'll give you the lawyer's answer 1st
- 31:33and then I'll give you a bit more of a detailed answer.
- 31:35But the lawyer's answer is it depends.
- 31:38It really depends on who's already in the business, what is
- 31:41the growth trajectory of the business and ultimately what
- 31:44talent are you talking to and what is their background like?
- 31:47All of those factors are things that you'd need to discuss and
- 31:51explore. But if you think about what the
- 31:53what I think of the accountabilities of a tech
- 31:55leader are, start with those and then you can figure out what
- 31:58level based on some of those other factors that I mentioned
- 32:01before, like a tech leader in a fast growing sort of 50 million
- 32:06turnover brand. First responsibility is make
- 32:10sure things work like above everything else, they're there
- 32:14to support the operation, which means making things work
- 32:17securely with like minimal errors or downtime.
- 32:21So it's making sure that the operational, the operations that
- 32:25the business relies upon work. Next is strategic execution.
- 32:29So they've got to align the business on a really clear
- 32:33understood tax strategy. And crucially, this has to be in
- 32:36collaboration with other stakeholders.
- 32:39It is no good hiring a tech leader, giving them that
- 32:42responsibility and then that tech leader operating in this
- 32:46like ivory tower and saying I know best in an arrogant way.
- 32:50Actually they're there to facilitate the discussion and
- 32:53align different stakeholders. So if a brand already has a
- 32:56really strong tech oriented digital leader or ECOM leader,
- 33:00or maybe a really strong technically oriented operations
- 33:04leader, it may be that the person that you bring in to lead
- 33:08tech in the way I'm describing doesn't necessarily need to sit
- 33:11above or alongside those people. They may just be facilitating
- 33:15the the decisions beneath them in the organizational structure.
- 33:19And then the final one is like enabling, enable or remove
- 33:24barriers to to growth. So they've got to be the most
- 33:27proactive problem solver within a business and that means
- 33:31they've got to identify the problems in the 1st place, help
- 33:34define them and then drive the operational efficiency that goes
- 33:39to resolving them. And they've got to manage
- 33:41prioritisation inside of the business as well.
- 33:44So that means making sure people are aligned on the change and
- 33:47the sequence of change. Then managing a budget, Are we
- 33:51on track or off track? Are we delivering on time or off
- 33:53time and ensuring the business expectations are managed.
- 33:56Now those types of responsibilities in an
- 33:59organization are pretty high level, right?
- 34:02Make sure things work, execute things strategically and remove
- 34:07barriers to growth. So you tend to find that it sits
- 34:10at a relatively high level. And I'm not like mega bullish or
- 34:16evangelical about you have to have a CTO, you have to have a
- 34:19tech director. I think more often than not when
- 34:21we work with brands, so in commerce thinking, we go in to
- 34:25fill the gap where a tech leader should be SAT in a brand side
- 34:29and we fill it by auditing the business.
- 34:32That takes 50 days. But the other side of that will
- 34:34typically have, we'll have a strategic road map, 12 months to
- 34:3724 months of length. We'll have a budget and we'll
- 34:40have a clear articulation of the resources that that business
- 34:43would need. More often than not, the
- 34:44business says you guys be our tech team for a period of time
- 34:48until these things are delivered.
- 34:50And one of the things that is delivered is actually hiring.
- 34:53So our exit is when we've hired and trained and on board our
- 34:57natural replacement. More often than not, I'm not
- 35:00hiring ACTF. I'm hiring a head of systems and
- 35:05a systems manager or a systems admin and then a systems
- 35:08engineer. More often than not, it's a head
- 35:11of systems is the most is the most senior.
- 35:13In some instances it's a no brainer.
- 35:16It's got to be ACTO, but that's usually because there isn't
- 35:20anybody with the ability or the motivation to take on that in
- 35:25the existing team. That makes sense.
- 35:28So I kept interrupting that, but you kept pausing for short
- 35:30periods of time. I'd try and jump in.
- 35:34Because. You needed to mention COVID
- 35:36again because you've only. This is my full stop, but this
- 35:41is my filibuster. I'll just keep going.
- 35:45No, I think that makes complete sense.
- 35:47And essentially what you're saying is it's more about the OR
- 35:49like, yeah, same as what I'm saying, which is you don't
- 35:52always need a CTO or a CTO is not the silver bullet for a
- 35:55brand that's struggling with technology.
- 35:58And then also it's about the person.
- 36:00And I think one other thing that I've seen recently, well, I said
- 36:04basically I've seen two people that have been more BA
- 36:06background end up as a CTO, which I think is quite
- 36:10interesting. And I think that comes back to
- 36:11your point around the person where they're a bit more
- 36:13pragmatic, but go in and understand the business.
- 36:17And then, you know, essentially like be a bit more agnostic in
- 36:21terms of approaching tech as opposed to some of these CTOS
- 36:24that like immediately in house engineering and immediately like
- 36:27invest into that type of tech. But now I think that makes sense
- 36:31to them. James, I'll let you ask the next
- 36:32question now. No, it's too early.
- 36:34You do sorry James, just before you.
- 36:35I think that's a really good point.
- 36:37And, and one of the things that we are really, really committed
- 36:41to is when there is clearly somebody with the potential to
- 36:46actually grow and become a senior tech leader inside of an
- 36:51organization. Half of the battle from our
- 36:53perspective as consultants going into the business for a period
- 36:56of time is helping other strategic leaders recognize
- 37:00that. Because if you are not a tech
- 37:03strategic leader and you've never worked with a really good
- 37:06tech strategic leader, there's not much chance you're going to
- 37:09be able to identify the potential in people you've
- 37:11already got inside of the organization.
- 37:14And you might be missing a massive opportunity to build
- 37:16your own strategic tech leader over the next 2-3 years.
- 37:20There could be somebody in the team already who just needs that
- 37:23path laid out for them, just needs a bit of support.
- 37:26And if that happens, that for me is like the Holy Grail situation
- 37:30for a brand is you've got somebody who understands the
- 37:33brand deeply understands the context, has all of the
- 37:36relationships that are required, has the trust of those people.
- 37:39Because the, the, the typical sign that you've already got as
- 37:43a tech leader, they just need some support and development is
- 37:46that, but they're like the glue person.
- 37:48Everyone goes to them when there's a problem, everyone goes
- 37:50to them because they need some kind of sophisticated Excel
- 37:54spreadsheet developing and they know how to pull all of the
- 37:57numbers together. Like there are signs and signals
- 37:59that there are really talented tech leaders in your
- 38:01organization you and they just don't realise it yet.
- 38:05And I think that goes to your point, Paul.
- 38:07Often brands can fall into the trap of saying we just need to
- 38:10go out and get a heavy hit here and that'll solve all of our
- 38:12problems. More often than not, it
- 38:14compounds the problems. And and equally sometimes the
- 38:19yeah, sometimes the problems are doing and getting stuff done
- 38:22and, and and basically execute a road map that's stifled and a
- 38:27high level strategic person isn't going to do that without
- 38:29the additional resource. You're right.
- 38:31But the other bit is often the commercial bit that's lacking
- 38:34where there isn't an owner to do the commercial negotiations to
- 38:38make sure you've got the right set up licences, contract.
- 38:42And actually what the problem is is that you're not paying for
- 38:45the environments you need in order to execute the changes in
- 38:49sport. And so I think, you know, you're
- 38:51right. It's the most important thing in
- 38:52all these and all the pro cyber works and is who who owns
- 38:55decisions, Like all decisions have to be made.
- 38:57And is there a clear owner if there isn't a clear odor and
- 39:00somebody has to step up and take it or you've got to bring
- 39:03somebody in who's going to provide that decision making
- 39:05ability to execute. So yeah, that feels like a
- 39:08really pragmatic answer to that question.
- 39:11Actually it kind of aligns with the projects I've seen and a lot
- 39:14of them I've seen especially at the ERP level is that, that
- 39:18people that have put a gone for a, I'm not going to say cheap
- 39:21because it never is. But they've, they've gone for a
- 39:24limited budget implementation and they've made compromise as
- 39:27you alluded to earlier, whether that is in terms of the the host
- 39:31environment, whether it's in, in terms of the Technical Support
- 39:33they had from an expert consultant.
- 39:36So that they haven't made necessary the right decisions in
- 39:39the original setup and that's brought the compromise from the
- 39:41start. It's like almost a mirror image
- 39:46of how we've positioned commerce thinking and we've learnt this
- 39:50through doing right. So when we're auditing a brand,
- 39:54we're filling the gap or like there is a missing tech team, so
- 39:57we're filling it and we're doing that to help them make informed
- 40:02decisions, choose the right things, plan in the right way,
- 40:05have the right level of budget, and also the resource plan in
- 40:08place to make it successful. Beyond that point, you're in
- 40:11delivery mode and at that point you need different skill sets to
- 40:16what a typical CTO would have. Like I essentially perform the
- 40:19CTO role at that auditing stage. Get everything set up, get the
- 40:23procurement done and then out out the other side of that,
- 40:26you're in delivery mode and that's a different set of skill
- 40:29sets and a different set of people.
- 40:31Once you're beyond that, you're then in, right.
- 40:34What is the continuity? Who is going to be maintaining
- 40:37this? And more often than not, when a
- 40:39brand starts working with commerce thinking within the
- 40:42first three months, they think they need a me full time.
- 40:46Within six months, they're convinced they don't need a me
- 40:49full time. They need a Maxim or a Dom or an
- 40:51Andy or a Nathan or an Amy. Like they very quickly realize
- 40:56that long term a look in the building is, this may sound a
- 40:59bit self deprecating. It is very true.
- 41:01They don't need a look, they need one of the others.
- 41:04That's where they'll get the value from long term.
- 41:06That kind of goes full loop back to your question, Paul, of like
- 41:09I think people convince themselves they need ACTO when
- 41:12actually they probably only need one for a period of time to make
- 41:15decisions and then they need the executors and the delivery
- 41:18people. That's so that as we got through
- 41:23all the questions are there, I guess, are there any, any, any
- 41:27part in advice in terms of if you're, if you're an e-commerce
- 41:31person who's in a project where you have some issues and where
- 41:37someone on the integration side has flagged that, oh, do you
- 41:39know what? We, we can't, we can't process
- 41:41that, that volume of orders in the way that you want to.
- 41:43And, and actually, no, we can't, we can't do like real time order
- 41:47sinks. We can only do every 10 minutes.
- 41:50You, you hear things coming back.
- 41:52What, what, what do you advise them?
- 41:54How should they go about approaches?
- 41:55How should they go about scrutinizing that the
- 41:58information coming back is is valid and accurate?
- 42:01Good questions. So obviously, if you've already
- 42:05got these things set up and these are real problems that you
- 42:08are living with, it's not like you can go straight back to the
- 42:12start and start all over again. So I think what I would be doing
- 42:16is, is proposing that people breakdown the problem.
- 42:19So when you talk about throughput of orders from say
- 42:23Shopify to NetSuite, then NetSuite to a warehouse
- 42:28management system, there are multiple stages that throughput
- 42:32relies upon. So how quickly is data going out
- 42:35of the EE E com platform and how quickly can the middle Ware
- 42:39process it? Then how long is it taking that
- 42:42middle Ware to drop that at the door of say NetSuite?
- 42:45At that point, the way NetSuite is configured in most cases is
- 42:49it will have some scripts and some some essentially like
- 42:53workflows inside of it. That's then processing that
- 42:55information. That takes some time.
- 42:57Then it's preparing that data for pick up from a middle Ware
- 43:01to send it down to the next point.
- 43:03So you've got already 3-4 stages that you need to have modelled
- 43:08out and then at that point middle Ware needs to process it.
- 43:11How quickly is it processing the data out of NetSuite and then
- 43:14how quickly is it dropping it at the door of the API or the flat
- 43:17file that the warehouse is processing it?
- 43:19Then the final link in that chain is that system's ability
- 43:22to digest that information. What you tend to find is that
- 43:25most people massively, massively oversimplify.
- 43:28We have an issue with throughput, and they think of it
- 43:31as either just an integration problem or just an ERP problem.
- 43:35Reality is it's much more nuanced than that, and until you
- 43:38model it out visually in front of you, you've got nothing to
- 43:41start benchmarking people against.
- 43:43And if you break it down, you can start getting actual data
- 43:46from people and you can start to isolate the issues.
- 43:49So that would be the most practical thing people could do
- 43:52is breakdown every single link in the chain and then scrutinise
- 43:56it with all of the third parties on the same call and you'd lock
- 44:00or lock them in a room until everyone's got to the answer.
- 44:03Like with throughput and volume, it's so, so precious and so
- 44:08important to a brand. It should be one of those
- 44:11instances where if there is an issue and there is a critical
- 44:14and sort of like disaster recovery, it's legitimate.
- 44:18You get everyone in a room and you don't let them out until
- 44:20that's understood and properly, properly interrogated.
- 44:23And that's one of those. Yeah, a fully agreed time
- 44:28stamping stuff at each ends so that you don't go through this
- 44:31endless leap of no, no, we're processing them.
- 44:34OK, it's all right. It's it's somewhere else's
- 44:37problem. Excellent.
- 44:40So I've already enjoyed that. I thought this would be a useful
- 44:42episode and hopefully those our audience listener found it
- 44:45really useful and some good insights there.
- 44:48We'll drop a link in the on the landing page if you want to find
- 44:52about how to contact Luke or you want to have a look at, you
- 44:55know, the the businesses he's been talking about, please do
- 44:58and reach out to him. Thanks to listen as always.
- 45:01And if you've got any questions about the episode, do get in
- 45:03touch and let us know you're listening to the Inside Commerce
- 45:07podcast. Hosted by experienced
- 45:08consultants James Gerd and Paul Rogers, Inside Commerce is your
- 45:12fast track to digital knowledge, featuring interviews with
- 45:14leading e-commerce retailers, industry thought leads and the
- 45:17C-Suite, key tech companies to explore the latest digital
- 45:20strategy, customer experience and tech.
- 45:22Discover what the latest trends really mean and get practical
- 45:25advice based on experience to help fine tune your E Comm
- 45:28strategy and text. Follow us on LinkedIn and reach
- 45:32out to James and Paul if you'd like to discuss an ecommerce
- 45:34project. We hope you enjoy the latest
- 45:36episode.