Latest / Politics with Paul / Politics with Paul #41: Knowledge Gaps in Politics Part 1: How They are Exploited
Transcript
- 0:00Hey there, and welcome back to the politics with Paul podcast.
- 0:03I'm your host, Paul Rader.
- 0:06Today, we're gonna talk about knowledge gaps in politics and how they get exploited.
- 0:12Today is, in some sense, a little bit of a changing gears in what I typically talk about.
- 0:18It's a little less focused on data and explaining political topics like how a certain
- 0:24government function works or how it's structured.
- 0:27One of the driving reasons for why I do what I do, this whole nonpartisan civics education
- 0:33focus, is the desire to close political knowledge gaps among the public.
- 0:39But that's not just for the general populace.
- 0:43I have my own knowledge gaps to close as do other people involved in politics in some way
- 0:48for a living.
- 0:49We all have gaps in our knowledge even about things that we know a lot about.
- 0:53We're all ignorant about something when it comes to politics, even when it comes to topics
- 0:58we are well versed in.
- 1:00All of us think we know more about politics than we actually do.
- 1:05There's just too much info that's out there.
- 1:10And, unfortunately, these gaps in knowledge and understanding get exploited by people who have
- 1:17vested political interests, be they partisan or ideology or issue based or simply they want
- 1:24money in some way.
- 1:26And every single one of us, if we aren't careful, can be susceptible to manipulation
- 1:32tactics, especially if you think you can't be manipulated.
- 1:37Well, yeah, you certainly can.
- 1:38We all can because we're all human beings.
- 1:41Even if we are careful, we can be easily swayed.
- 1:45And it may not even be deliberate manipulation by somebody who's doing the exploiting.
- 1:52They could just be that utterly convinced that they have everything figured out and that you
- 1:57just need to see the light.
- 1:59But it's still exploiting ignorance, a lack of understanding, and biases for political gain.
- 2:05So what are the ways that we can be manipulated and exploited for somebody else's political
- 2:12victory?
- 2:14This is like many other topics we talk about, one that we can go on and on and on about for
- 2:20hours, days, weeks.
- 2:23But, of course, to make it digestible, I'm gonna boil down to just several basic subtopics
- 2:28going into how our knowledge gaps about politics get exploited, and they're all
- 2:33interrelated.
- 2:34There's they're not mutually exclusive and why these cause such problems for us.
- 2:40So fun stuff today.
- 2:42Here we go.
- 2:44So exploiters, who are they?
- 2:48This is the term I'm gonna use for, throughout the the episode.
- 2:52I'm gonna use the general term exploiter to describe people who use knowledge gaps in the
- 2:58public to their advantage.
- 3:00They exploit these knowledge gaps for their political gain.
- 3:04Maybe they're trying to win an election that they're running in.
- 3:07Maybe they're a campaigner for a candidate, and they're trying to win that election for their
- 3:13candidate.
- 3:14Maybe they're trying to get a ballot measure passed that they have a vested interest in.
- 3:19Maybe there's just general a general political victory where they're trying to own the other
- 3:24side and and and tell them what's what.
- 3:28And these people tend to be very polarized in some way.
- 3:32Not always, but usually, they're one-sided.
- 3:36They really just see things through one specific lens.
- 3:41They're convinced that they have everything figured out and that their worldview explains
- 3:45everything.
- 3:46Nobody's worldview explains everything, but there are some people who are utterly convinced
- 3:51that, no.
- 3:52Yeah.
- 3:52I I I know exactly how the world works, and it's a very frustrating attitude that people
- 3:59have.
- 4:00But, unfortunately, it is a thing you see quite commonly in politics.
- 4:07And and make no mistake, though.
- 4:08These exploiters can be all across the political spectrum.
- 4:12Now who exactly are these people?
- 4:15I have my own opinions on who some of these people are, but true to my typical way of
- 4:23trying to address things, I try to keep my opinions out as much as possible.
- 4:27So I don't I'm not gonna single out any individual or groups.
- 4:31So I I'm very reluctant to name specific people or groups in general.
- 4:37You you and I might think the same people are exploiters.
- 4:42Maybe we have complete opposite feelings on who the exploiters are.
- 4:46Maybe there's some agreement and some disagreement.
- 4:49I think there's plenty of exploiters out there, but I I don't wanna focus on specific people,
- 4:55a, because, a, trying to keep my bias out as as much as possible because I have them just like
- 5:01everybody else does, and we'll get into biases specifically in a minute, but or in a moment.
- 5:07But there would also be disagreement from listeners as to who I think is an exploiter
- 5:12anyway, and that's just gonna derail the point.
- 5:15They're they're just gonna get focused on the fact that you disagree or I disagree with who
- 5:20exploiters are.
- 5:21So this is just a very general generic exploiter person.
- 5:27They're not gonna single out anybody.
- 5:30So now that we've got that out of the way, let's go on to the very first subtopic I wanna
- 5:36talk about of how people exploit knowledge gaps in the public.
- 5:41And, you know, start off with the concerning power of our biases because that I mean, that's
- 5:47that's the most sensible starting point.
- 5:50It's it's much of what our knowledge gaps are based in.
- 5:54Everybody has biases.
- 5:56The differences lie in whether we recognize our biases, knowing how to check and counteract our
- 6:03biases, and recognizing why other people have the biases they do.
- 6:08So when we recognize our biases, do we know, okay, I tend to favor this party or maybe I
- 6:15don't favor a party, but maybe I tend to favor this individual.
- 6:19Maybe I tend to favor this group.
- 6:20Maybe I tend to favor this ideology or issue stance.
- 6:24And and that mean that that's that's a bias.
- 6:28It's not necessarily wrong that you support any of those things or people, but it is a bias.
- 6:36So do we know that we do that, or are we convinced that, oh, well, our bias is fact
- 6:42we've we've we've figured it out.
- 6:43We figured out who the good people are and who the what the good stances on issues are,
- 6:49knowing how to check and counteract our biases.
- 6:52Maybe we recognize that we're biased, but we don't really know how when we interact with
- 6:57people, we don't know how to keep our biases, you know, under wraps or or checked whenever
- 7:05we're having any sort of political discussion.
- 7:09And and then, of course, there's people that know their bias, but they don't really bother
- 7:13to they don't really want to keep them in check.
- 7:15They just want to put forth their opinion and beat you over the head with it.
- 7:20And then recognizing why other people have the biases they they do.
- 7:25We all have life experiences that greatly influence why we think the way we think.
- 7:32We can we can it's good to be try to be as independent in your thinking as possible, but
- 7:40some people think they are completely independent in their thinking, and that's just
- 7:43not how us human beings are.
- 7:46There's something that's influencing our opinion.
- 7:49We we cannot be a % independent in our thinking because there's something that's influencing us
- 7:56to think a certain way.
- 7:57Now we should certainly strive to be as independent as possible in our thinking, but
- 8:03you can never quite get to a %.
- 8:07And so confirmation bias in particular is one of the biggest issues when it comes to
- 8:15political discourse.
- 8:16It's arguably one of the most oft cited psychological phenomena there is.
- 8:21We seek out info that confirms what we already believe, and we dismiss info that doesn't
- 8:26comport with it.
- 8:27Or at the very least, we're much more skeptical and critical of info that we don't agree with,
- 8:34or if it comes from somewhere else that we typically don't support.
- 8:38We think either it's a bunch of a bunch of crap or we assume that it's faulty in some way.
- 8:47Whereas if it's from a trusted source, yeah, there's another wrong with it.
- 8:50They figured it out, so I'm just gonna inherently trust them.
- 8:57But there's a whole bunch of different kinds of biases.
- 9:01And the ones I'm talking about mostly are those that clearly favor an individual, group, party,
- 9:06side of an issue, so on and so forth.
- 9:08They and these are the ones I explicitly try to avoid.
- 9:12But there are still other important biases to, be careful of.
- 9:19Biases come in all sorts of different types, and some are more obvious than others.
- 9:24A a few examples is the wording and polling questions.
- 9:28It's so critical that when polling is done, that they are worded a very specific way.
- 9:38Because even even if you change just one term, it can completely change the answer to a
- 9:46polling question.
- 9:48For example, if I were to talk about ask somebody what their thoughts are on welfare
- 9:53versus government aid, basically the same thing, but welfare has a negative connotation
- 9:59to it, whereas government aid is a more positive connotation.
- 10:04So you really gotta be careful as to how you say those things.
- 10:09And then in a sin similar manner, there are certain words that clearly indicate a writer's
- 10:15political persuasion.
- 10:17If we talk about immigration, which is obviously a very hot topic right now.
- 10:22If I were a reporter or journalist or some or some sort of pundit and you heard me say the
- 10:31words illegal immigrants or you heard me say undocumented migrants, you probably know where
- 10:40I'm coming from.
- 10:41If I said illegal immigrants, I'm probably coming from a conservative point of view.
- 10:45If I say undocumented migrants, I'm probably coming from a liberal point of view because of
- 10:51just the way these groups, these sides have framed an issue.
- 10:57So you gotta be careful with how they're framing an issue.
- 10:59And they're not again, they're not necessarily wrong terms to use, but they're just co opted
- 11:05to the point where certain people who use them, you, you know, which side of the aisle they're
- 11:11coming from.
- 11:12So they sort of activate a certain kind of bias.
- 11:16Another one, which is a little less obvious, is and the the the thing about bias is it doesn't
- 11:23have to be partisan or ideological or issue based in nature.
- 11:28It could be devoid of any of those kinds of things, but it can still something can still be
- 11:35biased in a way to maybe favor another side.
- 11:39So if I assign a value judgment to a number, if I say 50% of something, is that a significant
- 11:47proportion?
- 11:48Is 30% a significant proportion?
- 11:51Is 20%?
- 11:54Does our view of that number being significant change depending on the context?
- 11:59Like, if I said 30% of people supported this candidate for, I don't know, governor.
- 12:09Is that a significant proportion?
- 12:12Now what if I said, 30% of, people voted, voted for this candidate for president?
- 12:21Now is that more significant?
- 12:23I had another example that I was gonna use, but now I forgot what it was.
- 12:26But in any case, technically, calling that a significant proportion is a bias.
- 12:32It's trying to it it sort of intimates what I think about a given topic.
- 12:39Like, if I said 30% of people voted for this governor if I if I said a significant
- 12:45proportion, 30% of people voted for this candidate for governor, that's gonna prime you
- 12:51to think, oh, wow.
- 12:52That is a lot.
- 12:52Now if I just straight up said 30% of people voted for this candidate for governor, maybe
- 12:56you'll maybe you'll still think that is that's a significant, proportion, but, you also might
- 13:03not.
- 13:03And then if you compare it to, but 70% voted for this other person, Well, maybe the 30%
- 13:10doesn't seem so significant.
- 13:12So and that's not necessarily, you know, a bad thing that you said that that was significant
- 13:18or something.
- 13:19It's not like it's not the worst bias that you could come up with, but it is a sort of bias.
- 13:24There's also coat rack bias.
- 13:26So if I'm that's basically talking about something tangentially related to a topic, but
- 13:33really really isn't relevant to a situation being talked about.
- 13:39Like, if I talk about two candidates running for, I don't know, state legislature, state
- 13:46state house representatives, and candidate a and candidate b, here's what they think about
- 13:51these five specific issues.
- 13:55And then I bring up at the end that one of them had a DUI.
- 14:00That's a code rack bias.
- 14:01It's not it's not necessarily that it's not important, but it's not really relevant to the
- 14:08particular topic.
- 14:09We were just talking about their views on on political issues, and then I brought up a
- 14:19personal transgression that one of them had.
- 14:22It's again, it still is an important consideration, but it's not important to the
- 14:28particular topic at hand.
- 14:32So, again, doesn't have to be inherently partisan or ideological or issue based.
- 14:39You can just another way is you can just think you know more about how something in politics
- 14:45works, like a type of election, election history, so on and so forth than you actually
- 14:51do.
- 14:52That's a type of bias, and it happens to all of us.
- 14:55I whenever I research things, whether for this podcast or for something else, I'll sometimes
- 15:02go back into it to see, no.
- 15:06Let me just make sure that I've got something, correct.
- 15:09And then I'll find out something completely new.
- 15:12Like, oh, interesting.
- 15:13I didn't know there was that little wrinkle to things.
- 15:15So, again, that's a that's technically a type of bias, but not necessarily favoring one side.
- 15:24You just think you've got something more figured out than you actually did.
- 15:29And these biases, the more sinister biases, they can lead to knee jerk reactions to what we
- 15:36hear and read.
- 15:38So how does this issue get exploited by the exploiters?
- 15:42Well, exploiters, they feed off of voters' anger, fear, disgust, hatred, distrust, and
- 15:52that these biases activate.
- 15:55If I'm a republican, I'm probably gonna find democrats, or I'm gonna be probably be biased
- 16:01towards against democrats.
- 16:03If I'm a democrat, I'm probably gonna be biased against republicans.
- 16:07Biased info is much more prevalent and in your face than the nonbiased info is.
- 16:14And, again, I'm not gonna name specific outlets, but there's a lot of media outlets out
- 16:19there that favor left, right, middle, whatever, and they are clearly biased towards their
- 16:27group, their party, their candidate, who, whatever the case may be, something that they
- 16:32support or something that they favor or someone that they favor is going to be prop probably
- 16:39propped up more on that outlet.
- 16:42And then people not associated with that point of view, probably gonna be knocked down a few
- 16:49pegs.
- 16:51If you're predisposed toward or against a party, individual, ideology, group, etcetera,
- 16:59exploiters can pander to these views, especially if you, a, don't realize that you're
- 17:03biased, or, b, you realize that you're biased, but you don't really care, and you're just
- 17:10going to keep on being that way because it's your point of view.
- 17:15People who don't think that they are biased or put less effort into checking these biases,
- 17:23they are particularly susceptible to exploiters that get these knee jerk reactions or, like,
- 17:29the coat rack bias I talked about.
- 17:32If I'm trying to be even if it's somebody that has a vested interest in who wins an election,
- 17:40but they talk about the candidate's issues.
- 17:43And then the one that they don't like, they bring up that DUI or some other personal
- 17:47transgression, their, infidelity, for example.
- 17:52You know, they're probably trying to get a certain, reaction out of you.
- 17:55And then if you are biased towards that candidate, you might make excuses for that
- 17:59personal transgression instead or or say, oh, that's not important, though.
- 18:04What's important is what they think about the issues.
- 18:08But if the sides were flipped and it was the other candidate that had the DUI or cheating
- 18:15scandal, then the other side would be talking about how this is not important to the
- 18:22political discussion or they just just completely disregard it.
- 18:25And then the other side is talking about how this is not somebody that is fit for office.
- 18:31But more than maybe not more than anything, but one of the biggest issues when it comes to
- 18:38biases is that there's a disturbing inability for many people to differentiate between fact
- 18:46and opinion, not just fact from fiction.
- 18:49Yes.
- 18:49We do have a serious problem with misinformation and disinformation, but just the
- 18:55fact that people can't differentiate between fact and opinion.
- 19:00In a 2024 study from the University of Illinois at Urbana Champaign, forty five purse forty
- 19:07five point seven percent of respondents performed no better than a coin flip at the
- 19:11task of differentiating fact from opinion.
- 19:15That's a problem.
- 19:17People oftentimes like to peddle their opinion as fact, or they say the other side doesn't
- 19:23have the facts.
- 19:24They just have opinions.
- 19:25If it and even then, that might be a little bit generous if they don't outright say they're
- 19:29just being.
- 19:30They're just saying falsehoods.
- 19:32So these biases are one of the biggest reasons that exploiters can, well, exploit knowledge
- 19:41gaps.
- 19:42Another way that these exploiters try to take advantage of people is the rise of artificial
- 19:51intelligence.
- 19:52AI is unfortunately going to become increasingly tied to our lives.
- 19:58And now it still has a ways to go.
- 20:00I mean, there's countless examples where AI was wrong about information.
- 20:04If I search for something on chat GPT or Grok or Gem Gemini or any any pick any AI, and they
- 20:15have information that's just flat out wrong.
- 20:18It makes weird images that are clearly AI.
- 20:21I remember seeing one, AI graphic that was trying to make two football teams across from
- 20:28each other.
- 20:28And one side of the the the field, there were two guys on the line of scrimmage that had
- 20:36footballs.
- 20:37It's like, it's only one football, and it's and it it was just a interesting image that AI came
- 20:47up with.
- 20:48It's like, that's that's not that's not what happens in a football game, but you get other
- 20:55ones too, like maybe a human's hand has six fingers instead of five.
- 21:02AI, if you use AI to voice over something, a lot of times it clearly sounds robotic.
- 21:08It's obvious that you did AI.
- 21:11So it still has a lot long ways to go, but it still has some startling capabilities already.
- 21:16It's it's cutting out a lot of people's jobs.
- 21:20They create deep fakes.
- 21:22Well, deep fakes aren't a a new thing, but they are becoming worse and worse.
- 21:28And there's been, federal and state level legislation that has tried to tackle deepfakes,
- 21:37especially when it comes to things like revenge porn.
- 21:42Has made algorithms more powerful.
- 21:46One of my biggest pet peeves right now is the the general trend of really hate when companies
- 21:55are trying hard to personify their AI and make it seem like, oh, this is just it's basically,
- 22:02it's your buddy or or and create an avatar for it so it looks like a a person.
- 22:07Obviously, that's that's the point.
- 22:09So that you become so you that you're more likely to use that AI and you're not as
- 22:14apprehensive about it, but it still drives me it drives me crazy.
- 22:18There's a lot of things that drive me crazy, though.
- 22:20So, I mean, I don't know how much that's saying, but and to some extent, these Internet
- 22:26and social media algorithms were precursors to the capabilities of AI today.
- 22:32These algorithms that pander to what you want to see, taking your personal data to try to
- 22:40figure out what kind of things you like and showing you these kinds of things that you
- 22:44wanna see, creating information silos, especially when it comes to politics.
- 22:50So how does this issue get exploited by the exploiters?
- 22:54Well, just a few of those things.
- 22:55But citizens are sometimes it it may sound weird, but a lot of citizens are still way too
- 23:01trusting of what AI tells them.
- 23:05When we when we research info, there's younger people often over rely on AI in schoolwork and
- 23:11assume what they are getting is good info.
- 23:13They'll sometimes just copy and paste what chat GBT or or whatever tells them and then just put
- 23:19it on their paper thinking that they're not gonna get caught.
- 23:21I mean, you are.
- 23:23Believe me.
- 23:23I, you know, I was around when, you know, plagiarism detection was getting better and
- 23:29better.
- 23:29And believe me, those things will catch you.
- 23:31I did not make that clear.
- 23:33I I did not plagiarize anything, but heard plenty of stories about other people
- 23:39plagiarizing things, and and you you'll get caught.
- 23:43Older people, like with with phone scams and Internet scams, they could be too trusting
- 23:48because they're not as tech savvy.
- 23:50But people of all ages, regardless of possible apprehension about AI, they might take the AI
- 23:55at face value even if it supposedly cites sources.
- 24:00Like, if I you go on Google where it has those AI summaries of of something you're searching,
- 24:07they still have sources, so you can you should go in those and make sure that what information
- 24:12you're getting is good.
- 24:14But exploiters are taking AI to a whole new level by getting better at creating those
- 24:20deepfakes that cater to people's biases.
- 24:24I've if I don't like a candidate, it's getting way and way easier to create a fake image or a
- 24:32fake video of that candidate saying something completely abhorrent, but it's not something
- 24:40that they actually set.
- 24:41And, that thing that kind of technology has been around for a while, but it's getting
- 24:45better and better, and it's starting to become indistinguishable from reality.
- 24:52So AI is increasing its capabilities, and you might have more and more political groups and
- 25:00individuals have their own AI that tries to tell you false information or at least
- 25:07disinformation about their candidacy or the candidacy for for, opponents.
- 25:15So with AI becoming a greater and greater part of society in general, it's gonna become a
- 25:22greater, greater part of politics in general.
- 25:26So we really need to be careful about what exactly it's telling us.
- 25:31Don't let it completely supplant and replace the need for critical thinking skills, which
- 25:40we'll talk about a little bit later on.
- 25:44But before we get to that part, let's talk about the fragmentation of mass media and
- 25:52competing for consumers' attention.
- 25:54So in the early days of TV specifically actually, you know what?
- 25:57Let's go back to really early days of of media in The US where you had newspapers.
- 26:07A lot of people like to talk about how news used to be so unbiased, and it only told you
- 26:13the facts.
- 26:13Like, now even in the earliest days of US media, you had newspapers that clearly favored
- 26:20one side or another.
- 26:21So the you still had those biases that now journalistic standards had obviously evolved
- 26:27since those early days.
- 26:28But if we fast forward to the early days of TV, Obviously, TVs were not as ubiquitous as they
- 26:39are now, but you only had a few channels.
- 26:42You had NBC, CBS, ABC, all three of those are still around.
- 26:47And then you had the now defunct Dumont.
- 26:51So if you wanted to watch TV, those were the only games in town.
- 26:54You had to go straight to those.
- 26:56And so there are far fewer programs.
- 27:00And if you wanted to, you know, it's like the Tonight Show with excuse me.
- 27:07The Tonight Show with Johnny Carson.
- 27:09He was really the only at the time, he was really the only late night television host that
- 27:17there's a lot more late night TV and and daytime talk shows and stuff like that.
- 27:23But, you know, American culture media culture was a lot more unified in the sense that the
- 27:30vast majority of TV viewers were watching the same things, like, the mostly the same news
- 27:37channels with guys like Walter Cronkite, tonight show with Johnny Carson, sporting
- 27:45events that were on TV.
- 27:47There there's there's really nowhere to go.
- 27:51But you inherently were exposed to more varied content.
- 27:58Even though there was only a few television channels, because more because there are so few
- 28:07TV channels, people all had to kinda watch the same channels, and so you had a lot more
- 28:13different kinds of people watching something.
- 28:15So you got a lot more varied content.
- 28:17It wasn't so fragmented information silos.
- 28:21But especially over the past thirty to forty years, the number of media outlets has
- 28:26exploded.
- 28:26It's gone up exponentially, and that's not just in politics.
- 28:30Hundreds and hundreds of of TV channels about everything under the sun.
- 28:36And then you've got YouTube.
- 28:39You've got radio.
- 28:40You've got newspapers and magazines.
- 28:44People who don't want politics at all can easily find nonpolitics content and mostly
- 28:50stick to it.
- 28:51When they go on social media, it's a little bit hard, you know, a little bit more difficult to
- 28:55completely avoid.
- 28:57But now these channels can be a lot more catered to a specific audience.
- 29:04Doesn't have to have such varied content.
- 29:06It can just focus on that content that those viewers of that TV channel or listeners to that
- 29:15radio station or viewers of a YouTube channel or or or social media account in general, they
- 29:23don't have to be so varied in their content anymore.
- 29:26And peep so people who want a specific worldview to Pinterest to them, they can easily
- 29:33find something on any of those media any of those types of media and specific channels on
- 29:42those media.
- 29:44And this can be especially challenging to deal with if you have a wide variety of interests.
- 29:50Example, I obviously, I'm involved in politics for a living, but I also am a big sports fan
- 29:56and fan of video games.
- 29:58And there's other stuff like history that I enjoy as well.
- 30:02But a lot of these channels are are fragmented, and I have to go to different places to get
- 30:08them.
- 30:09And there's just the sheer amount of information that's out there.
- 30:13It's just overloading people's brains, and it can be hard to there's just too there's just
- 30:19too much stuff to consume, and you're not gonna be able to consume all of it.
- 30:23So it's very easy to just completely separate yourself from politics, for example.
- 30:29So the fragmentation of mass media and competing for consumers' attention, how does
- 30:34this issue get exploited?
- 30:36The thing that we really need to recognize is it's easy to just blame media, and there's a
- 30:44lot of issues with media.
- 30:46But media and media consumers, us, and the nature of the mass market have also contributed
- 30:53to the problem.
- 30:54I wanna focus on contribution, not blame, because contribution focuses more on how can we
- 31:02all get better.
- 31:04But many biased media outlets, they deliberately cover stories in a way that will
- 31:09generate clicks and views, especially in our clout obsessed society, you know, with
- 31:14especially when you have all these influencers starting to sound like a an old fart at this
- 31:21point, saying that kind of thing.
- 31:23But, I mean, it's it's I personally find it really ridiculous how many influencers, quote
- 31:29unquote, that that there are, especially when it comes to politics.
- 31:34But media consumers, they flock to their information silos.
- 31:37They don't venture outside of it, and the media caters accordingly in the market.
- 31:42So the market incentivizes outlets so that in order for them to survive, they need to overly
- 31:47cater and pander to their segment of the consumer population.
- 31:51If you try to branch out too much, you're it's it's gonna be hard for you to appeal to enough
- 31:57people in the population to keep yourself afloat economically.
- 32:02There's also the fact that the polarizing insightful, not insightful, but inciting
- 32:11content gets much more circulation be both by the people who the content panders to and the
- 32:19people who hate it.
- 32:20The people who hate it still engage with it and share it to say, look how stupid this is.
- 32:25This is terrible.
- 32:26This is awful.
- 32:26What what what a bunch of jerks?
- 32:31But you're still circulating it.
- 32:32You're still engaging with it.
- 32:33So it's it's getting more reach.
- 32:35These algorithms think, oh, more people wanna see this.
- 32:41The the that and therefore, the polarizing content breaks through to more consumers much
- 32:45more often than non polarizing content.
- 32:47Even though we have these information silos, these really polarizing things can break out of
- 32:51those and reach more people just because more and more people who both love it and hate it
- 32:57are engaging with it.
- 32:59Despite what we say about wanting less negativity in our media, wanting less negative
- 33:07political campaigning, it is the thing that we respond to most.
- 33:12We respond to stories about conflict in general more than the stories about cooperation or
- 33:18something heartwarming.
- 33:19I'm not saying that we don't like that stuff because we do, but we respond a lot more
- 33:24emphatically to the stuff that gets a rise out of people in some way.
- 33:31So exploiters can craft information silos like never before, and a large chunk of the
- 33:37population will flock to them.
- 33:39And there's again, I don't wanna name specific ones, but there are you for your particular
- 33:47political group, for your particular political segment, there's gonna be a channel made just
- 33:52for you.
- 33:54And and politicians and interest groups, especially ones that are I would consider or we
- 34:01would consider exploiters, mostly just go to a like minded channel to reach their audience
- 34:07that is predisposed to agree with them.
- 34:09And if somebody only and for the people who typically don't pay attention to politics, they
- 34:16only pay attention around election time because they they just don't wanna deal with politics,
- 34:21but they at least feel like they need to be involved in some way, or they don't feel like
- 34:26it's important for them to pay attention to until election time.
- 34:31They're just consuming other media.
- 34:32And all other times, exploiters tend to get their content in those consumers' faces first.
- 34:37So a lot of these people who don't pay attention to politics will get can get a skewed
- 34:42view of what's going on.
- 34:45Not necessarily that it's wrong, but it is going to be biased.
- 34:50Might be wrong, but in any case, it's gonna be biased.
- 34:54So their little bit of interaction with politics might get the exploiting content
- 35:02instead.
- 35:03The next way that exploiters can exploit knowledge gaps is because of the complexities
- 35:10of the political process.
- 35:12Politics is extremely complicated even if we wanna think that we know more about it than we
- 35:18actually do.
- 35:18There are so many political issues of the day with so many nuances.
- 35:26You just look at the the as as some people call it big beautiful bill in congress right now.
- 35:34It's over a thousand pages.
- 35:36I think it's 1,116.
- 35:38And, I mean, that's there have been other bills that have been that long, if not and even
- 35:44longer than that.
- 35:45But all those, there's so many issues just packed in that bill.
- 35:50And each one of them has a lot of nuance to it even though a lot of people wanna act like
- 35:55these issues are clear cut.
- 35:57This is the way that you should think about this issue.
- 36:01You either support this thing or you don't support this thing.
- 36:04Not not regarding like, okay.
- 36:06I like little bits of this, but not so much other parts of it.
- 36:11So many elected and appointed officials that have both a lot of the more public facing ones,
- 36:18the more obvious elected and appointed officials and then ones that are a little more
- 36:27esoteric that people don't know about.
- 36:29And then regardless of whether they're well known or not, a lot of these officials have a
- 36:36lot of public facing tasks and a lot of more esoteric tasks.
- 36:41There's so much interweaving of governmental duties, impacts of policies from multiple
- 36:46government officials at the federal, state, and local levels.
- 36:50So if I wanna talk about the policies of various elected officials, maybe I think, oh,
- 36:56this the president this this policy that the president has supported has led to a ton of
- 37:05terrible things, a lot of issues or something that they that the president didn't support,
- 37:11which would have fixed a lot of issues.
- 37:13This thing now or, like, if we're talking about unemployment, we wanna blame the president
- 37:19obviously, right now, it's Donald Trump, but you can say the same thing for Joe Biden and
- 37:24Barack Obama and George Bush and whoever.
- 37:28You can talk about, oh, well, their this policy has been terrible for the unemployment rate.
- 37:32It's making it go up.
- 37:33Well, what if you're in a particular state that is having an issue with the unemployment rate?
- 37:40Was it is it necessarily the president's fault, or maybe it's the governor of your state who
- 37:45had a policy that affected you?
- 37:47Or maybe it's it's a county commissioner or county commission that had a bad policy, for
- 37:55example.
- 37:55So sometimes it can be very difficult to figure out, you know, you know, putting aside any
- 38:02particular biases we have about elected officials to just put those aside for a second.
- 38:09You might not know which of these officials was was actually which of their policies was what
- 38:16directly led to that issue with the unemployment rate or lower wages.
- 38:22There's too many of them interweaving.
- 38:25I'm not saying that you can't blame any one of them or think any of their policies are bad,
- 38:29but there's just so many different officials that have juris that you're in the jurisdiction
- 38:37of, and they're doing all sorts of things that it can be hard to parse through and see which
- 38:45one of these are actually the ones that are responsible, but we can make make it seem
- 38:51simpler than it actually is.
- 38:52And so there's different reactions that people have to, and voters have to things when they
- 38:59get super complex.
- 39:01Some people will try to simplify things by going to trusted sources to tell them info.
- 39:06We all we all because everything is so complicated, we all try to find ways to
- 39:11simplify things in our head.
- 39:14And the way that some people do it is just go, okay.
- 39:16You know what?
- 39:17People that I tend to agree with, I'm just gonna let them tell me how something is.
- 39:21Some people, when they encounter a large amount of complexity, they try to understand what's
- 39:28going on, but then they just get bogged down.
- 39:30And some people just tune out politics altogether.
- 39:36It's like, you know what, I'm not gonna deal with it.
- 39:38I'm just not gonna listen.
- 39:39And so how does this issue get exploited?
- 39:43Again, as a sort of defense mechanism against complex issues, we try to simplify things in
- 39:49our head.
- 39:49A lot of times oversimplify things.
- 39:51It takes less time and effort, which we have limited quantities of, and exploiters take
- 39:58advantage of that natural tendency by making issues seem simpler than they actually are.
- 40:03Oh, you know, this policy by so and so is a terrible policy because x, y, and z.
- 40:12This this this person's policy is great because of x, y, and z.
- 40:17There might be there's probably a little bit more to it than that, especially if it's a
- 40:20really broad type of policy, like, when it comes to we wanna use guns as an example.
- 40:28Okay?
- 40:29It's not just a simple, do you want more gun control or do you want less gun control?
- 40:34It's okay.
- 40:35What age does the gun carrier need to have?
- 40:40And even if they're if if do we make it 18 or 21?
- 40:44Even if they're not 21, do we give them a chance to fill out a waiver to as a sort of
- 40:50special case where they get to have a gun?
- 40:52Do they need to have background checks?
- 40:54Do they need to have, concealed carry lessons?
- 40:59Do they have to have a concealed carry permit at all?
- 41:01Bump stocks, limitations on how much ammo they buy, specific guns they can buy.
- 41:08It's not just simply, oh, we need more gun control gun control or we need less gun
- 41:12control.
- 41:13There's a lot more to it than that.
- 41:17And and the amount of complexity leads of these political issues and these, and the way that
- 41:24government works, it leads some registered voters to just set out of elections because
- 41:28they do not feel educated enough.
- 41:30And so the polarized voters and the exploiters have an inordinate amount of influence because
- 41:37they're the ones that are already participating at higher rates.
- 41:40And voters that are the more exploited ones, the more polarized ones participate at higher
- 41:47rates.
- 41:47So they're gonna be participating even higher rates than the less polarized, possibly less
- 41:54exploited people.
- 41:55So you still have exploiters having an inordinate amount of power because more of
- 42:00their like minded individuals are participating in the electoral process.
- 42:05And then the last topic I wanna focus on for how knowledge gaps get exploited is the
- 42:11inability and or lack of time to research issues.
- 42:15So just about everybody knows the importance of research.
- 42:18Maybe some people don't think it's that important, but most people know you should
- 42:23research things.
- 42:25But it's a whole other thing to know how to research and to know whether you are
- 42:31researched.
- 42:33Because research takes time.
- 42:35It takes effort, and it might take money if you need to access a certain resource that but they
- 42:42make you subscribe to something, you might need some money.
- 42:45But in any case, research takes time and effort.
- 42:49Taking time that you could be doing something else and applying it to researching an issue or
- 42:59or or candidates.
- 43:00Those of us who are involved in politics don't always appreciate the fact that regular people
- 43:05aren't necessarily taught how to find info or they don't have the time.
- 43:10And even those of us who are involved in politics for a living have these issues, and we
- 43:15all can improve on our research skills.
- 43:17I find new resources every day.
- 43:19They're like, oh, wow.
- 43:20I wish I knew about this thing.
- 43:21I'm gonna I'm gonna I'm gonna use it.
- 43:25There's also the fact that critical thinking skills have had less emphasis placed on them in
- 43:31schooling.
- 43:33Even, you know, people who don't even know, like, okay.
- 43:36I need to evaluate who this information is coming from.
- 43:41I need to evaluate how it stacks up to previous information.
- 43:45Need to figure out if it's like a if it's a study, okay, is this funded by somebody who has
- 43:52a particular point of view?
- 43:54Because some scientific studies, even if they are generally sound in how they're structured,
- 44:02they could still be commissioned at the behest of somebody who has a vested interest in a
- 44:09political outcome, and and they might be exploiters themselves, or the researcher
- 44:15doesn't account for their own biases when it comes to an issue.
- 44:20Even people who profess their belief in the need for critical thinking often falter in this
- 44:27regard and or or they don't actually believe in the need for critical thinking.
- 44:32They only believe in the need for critical thinking if it's somebody on the other side of
- 44:37the aisle because they haven't critically thought about things because if they did,
- 44:41they'd agree with me.
- 44:43Or and or they want to, shove some sort of opinion down people's throats, or they want to
- 44:49prevent another opinion from being, talked about.
- 44:55And then similarly, media literacy and the state of American civics has also taken a major
- 45:01dip.
- 45:01Media literacy, people take something at face value and don't really think about any context
- 45:08beyond that.
- 45:11American civics in general, I mean, you see studies all the time about how many people can
- 45:17name even one US Supreme Court justice or or name the three branches of government, and it's
- 45:25a startlingly low percentage of people who can do those things.
- 45:30Even the things that are that peep that people would typically consider basic knowledge about
- 45:38the political system of the system of government that we have in this country.
- 45:46There are great resources such as Ballotpedia, who I full disclosure, I used to work for, that
- 45:53are gaining more and more traction.
- 45:54Ballotpedia is the encyclopedia of American politics, and it has just thousands and
- 45:59thousands and thousands of pages about candidates, about election results, about how
- 46:07about specific political concepts, and and they serve as the source for some of my material
- 46:13that I have on on this podcast.
- 46:15But and and even though they become a lot more popular, there's still a lot of people that
- 46:20don't know about them or things like Pew Research Center, for example, although they're
- 46:26mostly public opinion data.
- 46:31That's who is another good example I'm trying to think of.
- 46:36National Conference of State Legislatures, NCSL.
- 46:39They have a ton of info about state legislatures and how they all work and how,
- 46:44they're similar and they differ.
- 46:47All these kinds of resources, but people don't necessarily know about them.
- 46:53So how does this issue about the lack of the time or the inability to research issues?
- 47:01How does that get exploited by the exploiters?
- 47:04Well, exploiters make their heavily biased info easy for people to find.
- 47:10And you you know, we just talked about how the polarizing exploiting content tends to have
- 47:15more reach than the content that is not exploiting.
- 47:22They're so because that thing that kind of info, the exploiting info spreads like
- 47:28wildfire, exploiters have a lot easier time making their heavily biased info easy for
- 47:36people to find.
- 47:37So when people are trying to research and they their research skills are not up to par or they
- 47:44don't really have the time to research, they're probably gonna come across that information
- 47:49first.
- 47:52But on on the unfortunately, quality and unbiased or at least significantly less biased
- 47:59content takes more effort and time to find.
- 48:02Again, time and effort, finite resources that we have.
- 48:06And then if you include money in the equation, is well, that's definitely finite for most of
- 48:11us.
- 48:13But because research uses so much of our personal resources, it can be very easy to put
- 48:19it off, especially if you have a procrastination gene.
- 48:25So if if you have if you're trying to research, the candidates in election, you might be taking
- 48:33a long time to try to sift through information, and it can it'd be very easy to just throw your
- 48:41hands up and not deal with it.
- 48:43Or to simply say, you know what, I'm just going to rely on my biases, you might not as you're
- 48:49not necessarily going to say that specifically, but it's easier to rely on our biases and
- 48:55mental shortcuts, what we call heuristics, which exploiters use to their advantage.
- 49:01So if I'm trying to find information about this candidate, okay.
- 49:04What what what do I typically think of Republicans?
- 49:07What do I typically think about Democrats?
- 49:09What do I typically think about Liberals and Conservatives?
- 49:13You use those heuristics to come to a certain conclusion, and explorers use that to their
- 49:18advantage, whether they're trying to get you to support their candidates.
- 49:21Like, look at this conservative warrior.
- 49:23Look at this liberal champion over here.
- 49:25Or they say or they or they use those heuristics to, to denigrate that person.
- 49:33Look at this conservative nut job.
- 49:34Look at this liberal wacko.
- 49:37And it's a lot easier to just rely on that and say, okay.
- 49:42I'm just not gonna vote for that person.
- 49:43I'm not even gonna look for their information.
- 49:45Now now some of some of these candidates don't do a good job about making their information
- 49:51available either.
- 49:53They might have a really terrible website, and they might not have a website at all, about
- 49:59them.
- 50:00And then some some of that though is, you know, they only have they have very limited money to
- 50:06make themselves known, but that's a whole other issue.
- 50:10But these exploiters then become the gatekeepers of info, especially as that
- 50:15information becomes more and more prevalent.
- 50:18It's harder and harder to sift through it to try to get through it all.
- 50:24So we have a very serious issue with when it comes to exploiting knowledge gaps.
- 50:31It happens more and more, and every one of us at some point in time is susceptible to it
- 50:36because we're human beings.
- 50:37We have our own biases.
- 50:39We every one of us believes in something that is not correct.
- 50:46And, you know, ideally, you eventually come up with more information and say, okay.
- 50:51I'm gonna change what I think about this thing now.
- 50:56And, again, bias isn't necessarily a wrong point of view, but it's an opinion about
- 51:02something.
- 51:03So Nina, stop peddling that kind of thing as fact.
- 51:07So it's it's one of these very serious issues that is one of my biggest gripes, this this
- 51:15whole exploding of knowledge gaps.
- 51:17I have a very strong distaste for when people try to take advantage of a system in a way that
- 51:27is that is in a way that they should not be taking advantage of it.
- 51:32That is using people and thought processes to their own advantage.
- 51:39Now, of course, people might have a different opinion of that.
- 51:44That's not exploiting.
- 51:45I'm just trying to win this election and trying to to put the to enact the things that I
- 51:51believe.
- 51:51But as a general concept, when it comes to exploiting people, again, maybe we have
- 51:59differing views on who's doing the exploiting, but it is something that is becoming more and
- 52:06more prevalent, and they're doing it through these ways like activating our biases, which
- 52:11are becoming easier and easier to figure out with the amount of of information that we have
- 52:21on on people, the rise of artificial intelligence, how mass media is fragmented into
- 52:28these information silos, how complex the political process is, and this this lack of
- 52:39researching ability that just hasn't really been taught well lately.
- 52:45Just a lot of these issues are becoming worse and worse, and I'm well, hopefully, I can do
- 52:53whatever I can to try to reverse that trend, and a lot more people, do the same thing.
- 52:58There are things that we really need to, address, and I'm gonna since this is running
- 53:05long, I'm going to save that for the next episode and talk about some of the ways we can
- 53:10start counteracting some of these, knowledge gap exploits.
- 53:14And, obviously, that's a lot easier said than done.
- 53:17I'm gonna try to give something a little bit more tangible than, oh, well, we need to stop
- 53:21doing this because that's not really helping anybody.
- 53:25But that is going to do it for today's podcast.
- 53:28So thank you as always for listening.
- 53:31Please like, comment, subscribe, share with everybody you know.
- 53:35Even if they try to exploit knowledge gaps, maybe they can look at this and say, oh, you
- 53:40know what?
- 53:41Maybe that's not how I should do things.
- 53:43I don't know.
- 53:44May that might just be idealistic.
- 53:46But in any case, please just share with anybody that you know and links in the show notes, my
- 53:53Facebook page, my LinkedIn profile, medium.com, my educational email course about how to
- 54:01depolarize political climate or what ways that we mistakes that we make when trying to
- 54:08depolarize the political climate and how we can fix those mistakes.
- 54:11My book, why independents rarely win elections and how they could become more competitive,
- 54:16available on Amazon, an ebook, and paperback format, and a couple other things in there as
- 54:22well.
- 54:23But, again, always, thank you for listening.
- 54:26Thank you for tuning in, and until next time, Take care.