Latest / The Counter Momentum of Spin, with Dr. Franco Musio / The Mind: A beautiful servant but a dangerous master
Transcript
- 0:03Welcome to the Midday Report on the America
- 0:06Out Loud News Talk Radio Network, the countermomentum
- 0:09of spin. I'm your host, Dr. Franco
- 0:12Musio. So to our friends listening in the
- 0:15United States and around the world, I always
- 0:18mention this there is no lack of hard
- 0:20news items to keep our adrenaline going. It
- 0:23will not stop. Our aim, though, is to
- 0:26dissect out the nuances and underlying causes and
- 0:29foundations of the events with which we come
- 0:32into contact continuously.
- 0:35So as kind of a um, I'm gonna
- 0:39do another pivot, if you will. Please allow
- 0:42me to do this. Today's show, I'm titling
- 0:45The Mind: A Beautiful Servant but a
- 0:48Dangerous Master.
- 0:51And I I got this idea after our
- 0:54um several shows with Dr. Young, and
- 0:57just going back and thinking of all
- 1:01wow, what's going on and has been going
- 1:04on, had been going on in our world
- 1:06with dictators, with uh this, that, and the
- 1:10other uh suffering, but also beautiful things as
- 1:13well. But I want to talk about this
- 1:15a little bit. So, this phrase, uh, the
- 1:18mind of beautiful servant, but a dangerous master,
- 1:21it's um an old phrase. It's an
- 1:24anonymous, it's an anonymous proverb rather than the
- 1:27creation uh or through the creation of a
- 1:29single named author. It's widely used
- 1:33in um philosophical circles and
- 1:36mindfulness circles, if you will, and it's been
- 1:40popularized by various spiritual
- 1:42writers and teachers over time. So the core
- 1:45meaning as a servant, the mind is a
- 1:48servant, the mind actively solves,
- 1:52obviously, problems, creates beautiful things,
- 1:55creates art, processes
- 1:58logic
- 2:00when under our conscious control. So it's a
- 2:03beautiful gift from God. But
- 2:06the opposite as a master, and
- 2:09if left unmanaged,
- 2:12it generates a whole loop of stress, of
- 2:16anxiety, nonstop negative chatter that
- 2:19controls our well-beings. But not only
- 2:22that, it can go way beyond that. And
- 2:25ultimately, it's been responsible for much of
- 2:29the evil in this world, from death and
- 2:31destruction to a great deal of suffering. And
- 2:34we're gonna talk about that. We're gonna talk
- 2:37about the medical parts of that, the neurobiology,
- 2:40neurobiological inputs of this.
- 2:43So I'm I'm reminded of this, the iconic
- 2:46phrase, a mind's a terrible thing to waste.
- 2:49It's a famous tagline created in
- 2:511972 by an ad agency for the
- 2:54United Negro College Fund. I remember watching this
- 2:58on television all the time. It's a public,
- 3:00was a public service announcement. It was designed
- 3:02to raise money for minority education and
- 3:05scholarship. And then they updated it six days
- 3:08uh, or I'm sorry, not six days, uh,
- 3:11many years later, in 2013, to
- 3:14um the classic campaign adding, but a
- 3:18wonderful thing to invest. So the
- 3:21mind is a terrible thing to waste, but
- 3:23a wonderful thing to invest in.
- 3:26Um so yeah, but as an
- 3:29introduction, and and again, this is going to
- 3:32be a little bit going into the weeds
- 3:34somewhat, but not really. Um, the
- 3:37phrase it captures a deep psychological
- 3:41truth. The mind really excels
- 3:44in an as an instrument under conscious
- 3:47leadership, but it can become harmful
- 3:50when it governs without scrutiny. Look at all
- 3:54of our terrorists, look at our dictators. I'm
- 3:57going to talk about that in a moment.
- 3:59So, framing this as practical distinctions and
- 4:02mechanisms, it kind of clarifies why the metaphor
- 4:05resonates and how to shift from being controlled
- 4:08by the mind to using it skillfully,
- 4:11not only skillfully, but ethically and
- 4:14morally. So how can a mind
- 4:18function as a servant, meaning
- 4:22something beautiful? Well, it has
- 4:25instrumental strengths, it it from the
- 4:28neurobiology pattern recognition,
- 4:31abstraction, the ability to abstract, think
- 4:34abstractly, obviously, problem solving,
- 4:37language, memory, these are all powerful tools
- 4:40when um the intentions are for goals
- 4:44and very positive endpoints. Now,
- 4:47there are mental models that let humans
- 4:50anticipate outcomes and coordinate complex
- 4:53actions that enable, but also,
- 4:56or I should say, in addition to that
- 4:58beautiful thing, science, art, relationships,
- 5:01survival, executive control, when guided
- 5:05by values and attention and morals, the mind
- 5:08optimizes behavior, such as
- 5:11social navigation, learning
- 5:14schedules. Now, the
- 5:17antithesis. Yes, the antithesis.
- 5:21So, for example, mental illness, rumination, and
- 5:24feedback loops, there's repetitive negative thinking, worry,
- 5:28regret, shame. Uh, all of
- 5:31this takes attention and amplifies uh
- 5:35stress or puts attention on stress and
- 5:38reducing adaptive behavior.
- 5:41Certainly cognitive biases, cognitive biases,
- 5:45their mental shortcuts. We've talked before about
- 5:48confirmation bias, negativity bias,
- 5:51availability heuristics, these distort
- 5:54perception and decision making when
- 5:58not tamed. Um, how
- 6:02about identification with thoughts? So conflating
- 6:05thought content with self or
- 6:08truth, what we think is truth, it
- 6:11creates anxiety, rigidity,
- 6:14and negative reactivity. So
- 6:18these can drive behavior in maladaptive ways. And
- 6:21we'll talk about that with the dictators and
- 6:23such. So emotion-driven cognition,
- 6:26emotions can actually commandeer reasoning.
- 6:30Um, this happens to some degree with all
- 6:33of us. Um and narrative traps.
- 6:37If we have a compelling internal story
- 6:40about a threat or our identity or failure,
- 6:43this can lock people into
- 6:46self-fulfilling cycles. And, you know,
- 6:49we hear self-fulfilling prophecies.
- 6:52There are
- 6:54neuroscientific and psychological bases
- 6:58for all of this, but the bottom line,
- 7:00bottom line is this is treat the mind
- 7:03as a tool. And in order to
- 7:06cultivate awareness, strengthen regulation,
- 7:09design contexts that favor
- 7:13intentional use. And so when it's guided by
- 7:16clear values, disciplined attention, and corrective
- 7:19practices, the mind is beautiful, it's a
- 7:22beautiful servant. On the other hand, if
- 7:25left unchecked, then the opposite
- 7:28happens. It's biases, it's narratives, it can
- 7:32become a dangerous, very dangerous
- 7:34master. I wrote an article
- 7:38about a year and a half ago, maybe
- 7:40two years, so entitled The Psychoneuropathology of
- 7:43Terrorists and Dictators and Dictators.
- 7:46And in today's world, especially Xi Jinping is
- 7:49in the news quite a bit. Clearly, what's
- 7:52going on in Iran and the Ayatollahs and
- 7:55the theocracy in Iran, it goes through,
- 7:59you know, when we bomb Iran continuously, it
- 8:02goes through major news cycles, and then when
- 8:05we don't, and we're going through uh you
- 8:07know other psychological warfare and now
- 8:10major, major economic more. How can you
- 8:14get to even more? But economic uh type
- 8:17of restrictions, um then
- 8:21these all go through cycles in terms of
- 8:23the news. But in my field, it's
- 8:26nephrology and internal medicine, but I but I've
- 8:28been a student of human behavior, I have,
- 8:31for a long, long time. And these perverse
- 8:34acts committed by Iran against their own people,
- 8:38or committed by China against their own people,
- 8:41or committed by the Soviet ex-Soviet Union
- 8:44and Russia against their own people throughout
- 8:47history, history of humankind, with no uh
- 8:51there's no reticence in our modern day world.
- 8:54I mean it had and it continues. Why?
- 8:56Is there a nature versus nurture equation?
- 9:00Uh nature meaning what's in our genes,
- 9:03what's structurally, organically in our brains
- 9:07dictating this, or or is it nurture? Is
- 9:10it more learned behaviors, learned
- 9:13behaviors growing up, and not so much genetic
- 9:16or structural issues, or combinations, but um
- 9:20combinations of these underlying these hideous
- 9:23behaviors and activities. So
- 9:26considering the porn activities what we've seen
- 9:29with Hamas, with Hezbollah, Houthis,
- 9:32terrorist groups, ISIS in the past,
- 9:35al-Qaeda, uh, Iran against its own people, I'm
- 9:39gonna keep talking about that. Um, how can
- 9:42this happen? Well, we need to have some
- 9:45degree of understanding uh by by kind of
- 9:48delving a bit into the neuroscience. It's in
- 9:51its infancy, it's really is, but the
- 9:54neuroscience of radicalization and
- 9:57terrorism, um
- 10:00you look at these illegal aliens in the
- 10:02United States and legals, legals
- 10:05killing American, um, non-illegal,
- 10:08non-illegal, but legal American city killing
- 10:11American citizens, murdering. Uh, do these
- 10:15share biological foundations? And
- 10:18um
- 10:19yes, is this supported by studies?
- 10:23Um, and and somewhat yes. Uh,
- 10:27you know, the dictators joining these ranks of
- 10:29the dregs of global society in the context
- 10:32of sociopathic behavior,
- 10:36um, and effectuation of the sociopathic behavior.
- 10:39So we have research, we have up-to-date research,
- 10:42which elaborates, shows neural pathways,
- 10:46as well as um possible learned
- 10:48characteristics, which is where the the
- 10:52nature, uh I'm sorry, the nurture part comes
- 10:54in of learned characteristics unique to
- 10:58this group of individuals. And and yes,
- 11:01it it can continue the age-old contention of
- 11:05nature versus nurture is foundations for human
- 11:08behavior, particularly uh,
- 11:10particularly these are negative human behaviors. They can
- 11:14be very easily turned around. And as we
- 11:17said in the beginning, the mind uh can
- 11:19be absolutely beautiful, but it can be our
- 11:22masters in beautiful things or very
- 11:25hideous things. So um
- 11:29let me start with two terms. We we've
- 11:31heard these bounced bounced around quite a bit:
- 11:34radicalization uh and political
- 11:37extremism. Radicalization, and this is kind
- 11:40of integral to our talk here. Uh,
- 11:43Ryan Hunter, he's an author and previous FBI
- 11:46intelligence analyst, uh, he wrote in a perspective
- 11:50piece in 2011, referring to the
- 11:53influence driving Islamic terrorists as quote,
- 11:56the process by which individuals
- 12:00come to believe um their
- 12:03engagement in or facilitation of
- 12:07non-state violence to achieve social and political
- 12:10change is necessary and
- 12:13justified. And he also termed political
- 12:16uh, or others have termed political extremism,
- 12:19which is another important term. Um Professor Peter
- 12:22Newman from King's College in London describes this
- 12:25term in his book, quite famous book, 2009,
- 12:29entitled Old and New Terrorism as
- 12:32political, uh this is what he quotes,
- 12:36as political ideologies and methods
- 12:40that oppresses a society's core values and
- 12:43principles, and show disregard to the life,
- 12:46liberty, and human rights of others, and
- 12:49support the murder of ordinary people
- 12:52to advance their extremist ideology,
- 12:55ideological objectives. So
- 12:58the genetic, the structural,
- 13:02the nature variable. Is there a nature variable?
- 13:05Oh my goodness. Uh yes, indeed, there
- 13:08there is a nature variable. So
- 13:12um, and then the learned, the nurture, yeah,
- 13:15there is too. So let me start a
- 13:17little bit with the the genetic. It's fascinating,
- 13:21it's absolutely fascinating. Our
- 13:24brains are much more complex than any technology,
- 13:27including AI, including AI-powered
- 13:30tools. So there's a growing body of
- 13:33literature now focusing on the circuitry
- 13:37between the prefrontal cortex, it's located at the
- 13:40very front of the brain, and the limbic
- 13:42system, which is located nearly at the bottom
- 13:45of the brain. So anatomically,
- 13:49the prefrontal cortex is divided into three parts.
- 13:52We have the lateral sides, the right and
- 13:54the left, we have the medial, midline,
- 13:58and we have the orbital frontal, right behind
- 14:00the eyes. And the limbic system is
- 14:04further subdivided into a number of different parts.
- 14:07Now, the circuitry and one-way
- 14:10connections between the amygdala of the
- 14:13limbic system, this is associated with emotional
- 14:16processing, including anxiety, fear, conditioning,
- 14:20aggression, and the orbital frontal cortex
- 14:24of the prefrontal cortex, these appear to be
- 14:27key in the studies of the behavior of
- 14:30terrorists, these the circuitry. So we
- 14:33have potentially, it's conjectured, uh
- 14:36both a bottom-up and a top-down neuronal processes,
- 14:40which coexist. The bottom-up is a paradigm
- 14:43involving the overreactive aggression triggered, uh
- 14:47triggering mechanism, the amygdala to orbital frontal
- 14:50cortex, whereas an opposing one-way top-down paradigm,
- 14:53the orbital frontal cortex to the amygdala, involves
- 14:57a countering, a tempering, and regulation
- 15:00of the aggression. So you could
- 15:04see that there could be a dysfunctional or
- 15:06imbalanced circuitry that may explain the
- 15:09underlying impulsive aggression of terrorists
- 15:12and other criminals. So a series of sentinel
- 15:15experiments were conducted
- 15:18in Barcelona in 2019
- 15:22on highly radicalized Pakistani
- 15:25men, particularly those supporting Al-Qaeda,
- 15:29um and the violence against the West and
- 15:32armed jihad, all of that. So they
- 15:35utilized ultra-high technology, functional
- 15:38magnetic resonance imaging. So it's an MRI,
- 15:42but a functional MRI, uh,
- 15:45recording in real time which area of the
- 15:47brains, which areas of the brain are active
- 15:50during specific tasks. It's just incredible
- 15:53technology. And they had 38 subjects that they
- 15:57were studied with questioning of their willingness to
- 15:59fight and die for their sacred and non-sacred
- 16:02values. And in regard to the willingness to
- 16:05fight and die for their sacred values, there
- 16:08was a deactivation of the network in,
- 16:11we call it the dorsolateral, uh, behind
- 16:14and below, uh, or I should say below
- 16:17and to the side of the prefrontal cortex.
- 16:20So this is associated with deliberative reasoning
- 16:23and cost-benef benefit analysis. So
- 16:26in fact, uh there was increased
- 16:29activation of other parts of the prefrontal cortex.
- 16:32So the bottom line is there was activation
- 16:35of areas that that uh kind of
- 16:38went along with aggressive
- 16:41behavior and then deactivation of
- 16:45areas which conversely
- 16:48deactivated this aggressive behavior.
- 16:51So anyway, hold tight. We're gonna go to
- 16:53commercial break and we're gonna get into the
- 16:56the reality, uh, what's going on in modern
- 16:59day, modern day society with what we're talking
- 17:02about. Are you tired of struggling with low
- 17:04energy? We get it. That's why we created
- 17:07organic energy juice. In just one minute, you'll
- 17:10have clean, natural energy all day and never
- 17:13struggle with low energy again. And it tastes
- 17:15amazing. And there's no toxic chemicals or stimulants
- 17:19that make you crash. You shouldn't have to
- 17:21struggle with low energy, and with organic energy
- 17:23juice, you won't. If you're struggling with low
- 17:26energy, then buying organic energy juice is the
- 17:28right decision. With our double your money back
- 17:30guarantee, there is zero risk to try it.
- 17:33Go to chemicalfreebody.com forward slash out
- 17:36loud for an exclusive discount. That's chemicalfreebody.com
- 17:39forward slash outloud. Feeling off lately? Bloated,
- 17:43brain fog, low energy? It could be parasites.
- 17:46These sound invaders that weaken your gut, immune
- 17:48system, and mental clarity. That's why Dr. Peter
- 17:50McCullough and the doctors at the wellness company
- 17:52formulated ivermectin and mabendazol cleanse, a medical
- 17:55grade solution designed to help eliminate parasites and
- 17:58restore balance. No gimmicks, just real medicine trusted
- 18:01by top doctors. Go to TWC.health
- 18:04forward slash outload and use code outload for
- 18:0720% off your first order. Take control of
- 18:09your health today.
- 19:10So there is a what's known as the
- 19:13low at quote low activity variant of
- 19:16the monoamine oxidase agene. Okay,
- 19:19monoamine oxidase agene, particularly individuals with
- 19:23a childhood history of abuse. And it
- 19:26appears to be associated with a higher risk
- 19:28for impulsivity, aggression, and
- 19:31violence. This is more of a
- 19:34combination, if you will, of
- 19:37learned components and genetic components. So this genetic
- 19:41variant results in a decreased production of
- 19:44the MOA
- 19:46enzyme, okay? The MOA a gene,
- 19:50okay, the enzyme, leading to increased levels of
- 19:53neurotransmitters in the brain, such as serotonin, dopamine,
- 19:56norepinephrine, which may negatively
- 19:59affect control of impulses and regulation of
- 20:02emotions. Now, the lay
- 20:06press coined the term the warrior gene to
- 20:08apply to this variant due to its association
- 20:10with aggressive and risk-taking behavior. Now, let's look
- 20:14at the other, the nurture variable, the learned
- 20:16components, the psychosocial components.
- 20:20So prior to enduring radicalization, this is clearly
- 20:23a process, or there appears to be a
- 20:26process of socialization among terrorists in
- 20:29the forming of a collective identity. So these
- 20:32are there's a leader who is typically
- 20:35charismatic, manipulates common characteristics
- 20:39and behavioral features such as um, or
- 20:43among his followers, such as resentments, grief,
- 20:46dissatisfactions. Ultimately,
- 20:50the trainees are guided to an external society
- 20:53in which they're indoctrinated to believe the cause
- 20:55of life's frustrations, such as the West,
- 20:59must be targets of attacks. And so this
- 21:02is cult-like behavior, right? Belonging to a
- 21:05cult and being brainwashed. So the
- 21:07socialization is parallel to that
- 21:11experienced by street gangs in the US and
- 21:14Central South America and those
- 21:17involved in urban street crime.
- 21:27Now, are there other ingredients to this? Oh,
- 21:30100%.
- 21:31So mass media, at least now, uh
- 21:35possible genetic predispositions we talked about,
- 21:38the stage of maturation of the brain, all
- 21:41these are important. The mean age, you know,
- 21:44I never thought about this, but it's true.
- 21:46The mean age of September 11, 2001, those
- 21:49terrors um
- 21:52that uh will be very soon, um
- 21:5425-year horrible, horrible anniversary,
- 21:58um, they were similar to that of a
- 22:01mean of 27, 27 years
- 22:05among uh uh many other groups. So many
- 22:08other groups that the mean age of these
- 22:10terrorist activities, not only 9-11, but
- 22:13so many other, is about
- 22:1627. And um
- 22:20unbelievable. So multiple studies
- 22:24corroborate that the mean age of terrorism uh
- 22:27also, other terrorist activities are in the mid-20s.
- 22:30Um, although the the leaders are marginally older.
- 22:34They're marginally older at about 27,
- 22:37just like the average or the mean of
- 22:39those who committed the horrific 9-11 attack.
- 22:43So the prevailing thought among many
- 22:46researchers is that as the brain matures, there's
- 22:49a fine-tuning of sorts among
- 22:52neuronal pathways and between regions of the brain
- 22:55that we talked about, uh, such as a
- 22:57decrease in one-way firing of neurons from the
- 23:01amygdala to the orbital frontal portion of the
- 23:04prefrontal cortex, and an increase in firing of
- 23:07other opposite pathways from the prefrontal cortex to
- 23:11the amygdala. Hence, there's a decrease in risk
- 23:14taking, a decrease as the brain matures.
- 23:17Uh, there's a decrease in criminal activity and
- 23:20decreased radicalization behavior, and it
- 23:24may be a byproduct of this maturation
- 23:27of the brain. So, bottom line is many,
- 23:30many terrorists are in their early 20s, whereas
- 23:34those who are a bit more mature in
- 23:36their late 20s are not, uh,
- 23:40are not as uh do not have as
- 23:43horrible behavior. Now,
- 23:46let's go into dictators because this is different.
- 23:49This is different, this is somewhat different. And
- 23:53the neurological, neurobiological
- 23:56studies, sometimes they go along with real
- 23:59life, sometimes they don't. Um,
- 24:02there is a psychopathology, very,
- 24:06very, very clear, uh, without doubt. I'm gonna
- 24:09say duh, but yes, of dictators. Uh, there's
- 24:12been too many tyrants throughout history. Uh, just
- 24:16to name a few, uh uh Adolf Hitler,
- 24:18Hitler, we all know these names, Joseph Stalin,
- 24:20Mao Zedong, Benito Mussolini, Pol Pot, Fidel
- 24:24Castro, Ho Chi Minh, Nikita Khrushchev,
- 24:27uh Kim Jong il,
- 24:30and currently his son, Kim Jong-un
- 24:33in North Korea, E. D. Ameep, Omar
- 24:36Gaddafi, Sudem, Saddam Hussein, all
- 24:40these horrible individuals. Now, now
- 24:43we're all familiar with their names. Now we
- 24:45have Vladimir Putin, we have uh Xi
- 24:48Jinping of China, we have, we just talked
- 24:51about Kim Jong-un in North Korea. So the
- 24:54neurobiology underlying their
- 24:59atrocious activities is likely,
- 25:02as we talked about, um
- 25:05similar, similar to um
- 25:08kind of what we talked about just organically,
- 25:11but but our knowledge of these despots is
- 25:13solely based on informant reports, and and none
- 25:16have submitted to a direct psychological profiling. And
- 25:19of course, there's no brain scans or genetic
- 25:22data available. So what has been
- 25:25found is that um yeah, there
- 25:27there's probably most likely a
- 25:30socialization component to this, a a
- 25:34nurture part, a nurture part. Um,
- 25:37but but we don't know 100%. So I
- 25:40personally came across two dictators. Well,
- 25:44it wasn't really fun, but uh during my
- 25:46volunteer work in Africa in 1985. So one
- 25:49is Joseph Mabutu, he was a president of
- 25:52Zaire, which later was named the Democratic
- 25:55Republic of Congo, Dutch Congo. Um,
- 25:58he self-proclaimed himself Lord
- 26:02Mabutu. His name was Lord Mabutu, according to
- 26:05him, and many other grandiose titles. Um
- 26:08he was responsible for the deaths of many,
- 26:11many opposition uh party politicians
- 26:15and multitudes, multitudes of
- 26:17individual citizens. Samuel Doe,
- 26:21remember him, president of Liberia. Um
- 26:24I saw him too. Uh this guy was
- 26:27uh oh my god, uh he was responsible
- 26:30for utter disregard of human rights and
- 26:34numerous deaths, including the murder of his whole
- 26:36cabinet, which he actually filmed for the
- 26:39nightly Liberian News. He himself was then
- 26:43murdered by his heir, and also that was
- 26:45broadcast throughout Liberian media. So, I mean,
- 26:49just think about that. It's just horrible. Now,
- 26:52the sociopathic and psychopathic personality traits
- 26:55and profiles these tyrants have, in common, they're
- 26:59they're legion. And again, going back
- 27:02to the title of this broadcast, uh, the
- 27:05the brain can be absolutely
- 27:09horrible in terms of being a master
- 27:12in in very negative ways.
- 27:16So
- 27:17uh these tyrants, their personality traits, they're
- 27:20manipulative, lack of remorse, obviously, or
- 27:23guilt, impulsive, irresponsible,
- 27:26yeah, pathological lying,
- 27:30um, hyper or asexual. Very
- 27:33interesting. Hypersexual or asexual.
- 27:36Um
- 27:38malignant narcissism, sadism,
- 27:41paranoia,
- 27:43grandiosity, and aberrant thinking. So
- 27:46a common thread is in early childhood, early
- 27:49childhood trauma and abuse, typically by their
- 27:52fathers, or loss of their
- 27:55biological parents. That is the common
- 27:58thread here. And in their formative years, many
- 28:01had experienced additional
- 28:04psychological abuse, poverty,
- 28:07and other activities. So there
- 28:11yeah, it's it's it's interesting, it's horrible, but
- 28:15but these are um nurture, um
- 28:19uh nurture or uh
- 28:22sociological traits that are in common.
- 28:25So the three major dictators
- 28:29with whom we're currently dealing with, and the
- 28:32uh that the US, the world is currently
- 28:34dealing with, I would say, in my opinion,
- 28:37Vladimir Putin, Xi Jinping, the
- 28:39Ayatollahs, the Khomeini, who of course
- 28:43was killed in our bombings, now his son,
- 28:45who knows if he's still alive, Mochutaba,
- 28:49uh the other Ayatollah, uh, or the current
- 28:52Ayatollah, who knows if he's alive or not.
- 28:55There's thought that there are look-alikes
- 28:59that he was killed, but or there are
- 29:02look-alikes, or that he's being transferred
- 29:06to just like Saddam Hussein was to many
- 29:09different locations every night. Who knows?
- 29:13But there's other tyrants. Uh there's others on
- 29:15this globe, such as the president of Myanmar,
- 29:19um, so Minong Lang,
- 29:22Myanmar, which is Burma, uh, the
- 29:25previous who we talked about, the North Korean,
- 29:27of course, um President uh Kim Jong-un, the
- 29:31Sudanese regime. Although, for purposes of
- 29:34this piece, um we'll we'll review
- 29:38the just just those currently in the limelight,
- 29:40but the Sudanese regime is awful too. Um
- 29:44peripherally, now you know the
- 29:47irony of all this is that they uh
- 29:51they they dress in three-piece Italian suits. They
- 29:54traveled every year to Davo, Switzerland for the
- 29:57World Economic Forums, right? Every year.
- 30:00And they wish to display, you know, a
- 30:02hip personality, uh, although in
- 30:06reality they're they're the opposite. So we can
- 30:09talk about Putin, Vladimir Putin. We've learned a
- 30:12lot about him. Um
- 30:15clearly lack of regret or remorse for the
- 30:17results of his decisions. He has none, he's
- 30:20an autocrat, he has very
- 30:23antisocial behavior, uh, such as
- 30:26you remember this, uh, his he has a
- 30:28Labrador retriever
- 30:31who uh who or which entered the
- 30:34meeting between himself and the previous Chancellor, Chancellor
- 30:37of Germany, Angela Merkel. He knew that she
- 30:40had a fear of dogs. Okay. Uh
- 30:44he poisoned, imprisoned, ultimately
- 30:46murdered those in opposition to him, such
- 30:50as uh what last year, uh Alexei
- 30:53Livalny. Um I remember during
- 30:56COVID, his own Russia uh
- 31:00pharmaceutical companies there came up with their own,
- 31:03the design of their own vaccine. I don't
- 31:05know how they they did that, but they
- 31:07did. And uh they probably got it from
- 31:10China or uh information from China. But he
- 31:13wouldn't take the vaccine. He he had his
- 31:15daughter do it. He basically forced his daughter
- 31:18to have the vaccine. Uh Xi Jinping did
- 31:21the same thing. Uh speaking of whom?
- 31:24Xi Jinping, antisocial, conning, detail-oriented, he's
- 31:28an autocrat, responsible for many, many
- 31:31abuses of human rights, no tolerance for
- 31:34dissent. The previous Ayatollah, previous
- 31:37Ayatollah, Khomeini, uh, he himself was
- 31:40jailed by the Shah numerous times and toured
- 31:43physical and psychological torture. So with this background,
- 31:46likely not compromised, he didn't
- 31:50at the time with anyone or any government.
- 31:52Now his son, if in fact it is
- 31:55his son, who is the ultimate Ayatollah, uh,
- 31:58same thing. He had no tolerance for dissent.
- 32:01That's pretty obvious, huh? Killing what now 40,000
- 32:04people of their own people, and and freely
- 32:07advocated for the oppression of dissent, uh, including
- 32:11murder. So I think with this
- 32:14background, we we all kind of we know
- 32:16this, but their interconnections between themselves, their
- 32:19nations, the interplay and our interplay as
- 32:22Americans. So a Russian member of parliament
- 32:25labeled the relationship recently between Beijing and Moscow
- 32:29and Tehran, this is hilarious, as the
- 32:32axis of good.
- 32:35This was the axis of good versus the
- 32:36axis of evil, coined by President George uh
- 32:40W. Bush in 2002 when he was referring
- 32:43to North Korea, Iran, and Iraq. That axis.
- 32:46So this hypocritical axis of good
- 32:50uh is unbelievable. It's commonly opposed to the
- 32:53US and the West, right? And these
- 32:56countries are also very much interested in their
- 32:58own individual gains, looking out for themselves.
- 33:02The phrase, the enemy of my enemy is
- 33:04my friend. It's not particularly true in their
- 33:07eyes. Um, so the metaphorical
- 33:11quadrangle, the interrelationships of US, China,
- 33:14Russia, Iran, the enemy of the US,
- 33:17uh
- 33:20China, Russia, Iran, is not necessarily the friend
- 33:23of each other, by the way. They say
- 33:25that they are, but they're really not. So,
- 33:29you know, go back a few years, uh,
- 33:31the meeting in Beijing, 2023, President Xi
- 33:35and Putin, they've had a couple meetings, a
- 33:37few meetings since that time. They refer to
- 33:40each other still as old and dear friends,
- 33:43building on their no limits to our friendship.
- 33:46So that was the initial statement in 2022,
- 33:49and then they reiterated that every year. So
- 33:53China is much more interested in trade and
- 33:55economic issues with us, uh
- 33:58the US, that than really in
- 34:02backing Russia. So there's a lot of play
- 34:04going on, and and the mind, okay, in
- 34:07this sense, is is also kind of playing
- 34:10games. And that's part of the the uh
- 34:13the bad part, if you will, the bad
- 34:15part about our minds being our masters.
- 34:18So now China doesn't
- 34:21provide significantly if we go into geopolitics here,
- 34:25support to Russia, as does Iran. So in
- 34:27fact, China has a GDP in population 10
- 34:30times the size of Russia. But but
- 34:34they're both commonly opposed to the West. So
- 34:36their relationship is is
- 34:39really rife with contradictions and
- 34:42inaccuracy. So
- 34:45any negotiations, negotiations between us and
- 34:48Iran. Oh my goodness, we've talked about this
- 34:51so many times, and we see this on
- 34:52a daily basis, they're fraught with complexities
- 34:56and is very well known.
- 34:59I mean, we know it repeatedly Iranian government
- 35:01lies and hoodwinks as their modus
- 35:04operandi. So their mind is a very
- 35:07pathological mind, not only to themselves,
- 35:10but to I think to everyone. So
- 35:14all of these nations and all of these
- 35:16nations' leaders, they're the the
- 35:20common thread is that they're they're tyrant dictators
- 35:23for life. There's no semblance of democracy in
- 35:26their governments. Dissent and speech are met with
- 35:28arrest, torture, sham trials, long jail
- 35:32sentences, and uh uh, you know,
- 35:35it it's kind of incredible that some of
- 35:38these some of these uh prisoners are are
- 35:41let out uh and often death. So
- 35:44the the weaknesses of all these
- 35:47dictatorships lies in their
- 35:50self-proclaimed strengths and common uh
- 35:53commonalities, their minds
- 35:57are uh uh are horrible masters of
- 36:00themselves, and really most dictators
- 36:03are assassinated by their own people and are
- 36:05forced to flee their own countries. Numerous,
- 36:08numerous examples of this. Um
- 36:12so communism, getting back down to
- 36:14communism and theocracies,
- 36:18so
- 36:19they don't have the strength of democracies and
- 36:21ultimately implode due to the weight of their
- 36:23own frailty, and the hypocritical access
- 36:27of good will change complexion and inevitably
- 36:30falter in the context uh and through the
- 36:32prism of our American peace through
- 36:36strength ideology. So um,
- 36:40you know, if could I say their minds
- 36:42are screwed up? Yeah, I I I could
- 36:44say that. Uh, and in terms of being
- 36:47their masters uh of of themselves, the
- 36:50tyrants, uh, in a very, very
- 36:54negative way. Yes, I would say that. And
- 36:57I could counter that by individuals like Mother
- 37:00Teresa or other incredibly
- 37:03wonderful, powerful,
- 37:06wonderful Nelson Mandela, uh
- 37:09Bishop Tutu, South Africa,
- 37:12wonderful individuals who have gone through
- 37:15hell. Their minds are very, very, very stalwart
- 37:18and and agents for good.
- 37:22So we're gonna take a break. We're gonna
- 37:24get into a discussion of groupthink, which is
- 37:27kind of a further uh extrapolation
- 37:30of our minds being uh really
- 37:34bad, bad masters in some ways. Anyway,
- 37:37hold tight. Thanks. Oral hygiene hasn't changed in
- 37:4050 years, but our diet and the way
- 37:42we eat has, creating an environment in your
- 37:45mouth for bacteria to wreck havoc on your
- 37:47teeth and gums. For better oral health, get
- 37:50spray dental defense, an oral care line designed
- 37:54to combat acid-creating bacteria. The toothpaste,
- 37:57mouthwash, mints, and gum all contain xylitol,
- 38:01a natural ingredient shown to dramatically improve oral
- 38:04health. Spry can be found online and at
- 38:06all fine natural retailers. The smartest food on
- 38:09the planet doesn't come from a lab or
- 38:12in a package. It grows in a glass
- 38:15jar. I'm Doug Evans, author of the national
- 38:18bestseller, The Sprout Book. Sprouts deliver up
- 38:22to a hundred times the antioxidants of mature
- 38:25vegetables. They grow in just three to five
- 38:28days from under a dollar serving. Get your
- 38:31sprouting kit at thesproutingcompany.com
- 38:34slash out loud. Use the code out loud
- 38:37for an exclusive offer. Grow smart.
- 38:42Welcome back. Welcome back. So our uh
- 38:45we've been discussing what we brought
- 38:49up initially. Quote, the mind, a beautiful
- 38:52servant, but a dangerous master. And I want
- 38:55to talk a little bit here on this
- 38:56segment, this last segment, about groupthink. And I
- 39:00wrote another article. Uh
- 39:03odd for a physician to do this, right?
- 39:06But I wrote groupthink, the elusive underpinnings of
- 39:08geopolitical decision making. So what
- 39:12is the definition of groupthink?
- 39:15Uh yeah, it's it's a psychological
- 39:18phenomenon observed within
- 39:22groups of people, ranging from several to an
- 39:24extreme large number, in which the overwhelming
- 39:28desire and need for conformity
- 39:31results in a typically dysfunctional and
- 39:34irrational decision-making process
- 39:38and usually outcomes. So this
- 39:41is another example of the master of our
- 39:44brains not really being for good.
- 39:48So this phenomenon can be applied to a
- 39:51multitude of social scenarios in daily life, so
- 39:54which require decisions and their requisite outcomes, such
- 39:57as nuclear and extended families, neighborhood
- 40:01councils, governments, militaries, businesses, the
- 40:04workplace, we go on and on. So, in
- 40:06any in essence, any relationship and
- 40:09interaction between human beings, as little as two
- 40:13to hundreds of millions. So, moreover,
- 40:17moreover, espousing a certain set of beliefs may
- 40:20be full of rife with hypocrisy, as the
- 40:23true nature of these tenets are exposed and
- 40:26carried out. So, much to the chagrin, really,
- 40:29of their original proponents. So, case in
- 40:32point, uh, what we're going through now,
- 40:35socialistic creeds, uh that, and
- 40:39radical, radical socialistic creeds, that uh
- 40:42if they were smart enough to look back
- 40:45in history, and usually these are very young
- 40:47people, but in history they realize this is
- 40:50not going to be uh the
- 40:53way that things will work out for the
- 40:56better. So the term was coined by the
- 40:59American sociologist and journalist William
- 41:02Haidt in an article in Fortune magazine in
- 41:051952, in which he referred to George
- 41:08Orwell's book, 1984, um, that
- 41:12was published in 1949,
- 41:15in which the term double think, double think
- 41:18was first introduced. Okay, double think. It wasn't
- 41:22um it wasn't groupthink, it was double think.
- 41:24So this novel, which remains required reading in
- 41:28many collegiate courses, describes a dystopian
- 41:31futuristic world in which the norm would be
- 41:34severe societal oppression. Now,
- 41:38the dangers of a totalitarian government are
- 41:42contrasted with the privileges of freedom and
- 41:45individuality. So, as White
- 41:48mentioned, uh as per White, uh quote,
- 41:51group think is becoming a national
- 41:54philosophy. Uh we are not
- 41:57talking about mere instinctive conformity.
- 42:00It is, after all, a
- 42:03perennial failing of mankind.
- 42:07What we're talking about uh is a rationalized
- 42:10conformity, an open, articulate philosophy which holds
- 42:13that group values are not only expedient,
- 42:17but right and good as well. End of
- 42:20quote.
- 42:21So let's fast forward 20 years from
- 42:25then, 1972, when the American psychologist
- 42:28Irving Janice, he expounded upon the term
- 42:31in his book, Victims of Group Think, um,
- 42:35as well as a revised edition in 1982
- 42:37entitled Group Think Psychological Studies of Policy
- 42:41Decisions and Fiascos. So
- 42:44eight separate, very interesting
- 42:46symptoms and characteristics were described
- 42:50in this book. And it remains the global
- 42:53globe standard, uh gold standard. It really is
- 42:56in modern-day society definition of groupthink. Now,
- 43:00again, I'm I'm classifying groupthink in
- 43:03our original phrase, uh, the mind, a beautiful
- 43:06servant. No, groupthink is not a beautiful servant,
- 43:09but a dangerous master. And in this particular
- 43:12sense, uh groupthink, I believe, in
- 43:16my opinion, can be a dangerous master.
- 43:19So these are the characteristics.
- 43:24And try to think of when we see
- 43:27in the news, we see in the news
- 43:28about these uh people who espouse socialism,
- 43:32especially, especially, we see this
- 43:35now. We're barraged by these democratic
- 43:38primary, uh, democratic primary
- 43:41elections and the Democratic Society of
- 43:44America, I guess that's what it is. Oh,
- 43:46no, no, Democratic Soci, no, sorry, Democratic
- 43:49Socialists of America uh are are
- 43:52just you know uh being talked
- 43:56about
- 43:57continuously. And it is
- 44:00true, it is true that, and and hopefully
- 44:03nothing positive will happen in terms of, or
- 44:06I should say negative will happen in terms
- 44:08of their being elected. But anyway, these are
- 44:10the characteristics of groupthink. Type one.
- 44:14They're uh they value or or or there's
- 44:17overestimations in their
- 44:20thoughts of uh the power and
- 44:22morality of the group. Okay, so
- 44:26there's illusions, there are illusions of
- 44:28invulnerability, um, which are created which create
- 44:32excess optimism and encourage risk
- 44:35taking. The risk taking being uh
- 44:38going all out for socialism in this particular
- 44:41case. There's an unquestioned belief in
- 44:44the morality of the group, uh causing its
- 44:47members to overlook the quant consequences of
- 44:50their actions, of not only their actions, but
- 44:53of what they espouse. And I think this
- 44:56is true. So what this means is that
- 44:59many of them probably do know that what
- 45:02they're talking about is ridiculous. But uh but
- 45:06still adhering to the group of the
- 45:09uh Democratic Socialists of America is is
- 45:12more important than anything else. Uh
- 45:16now the type two's characteristics,
- 45:19closed-mindedness. So there's
- 45:21rationalized warnings that might challenge
- 45:24the group's uh authority. Okay.
- 45:28Uh and then
- 45:30they're stereotyping those who are opposed to the
- 45:33group as weak, evil, bias, spiteful,
- 45:36impotent, or stupid. And and
- 45:39that's very, very true. Um
- 45:42there's pressure towards uniformity. So
- 45:46uh the self-censorship of ideas
- 45:49um you know that deviate from the
- 45:52apparent group consensus doesn't happen.
- 45:56Uh the illusions of
- 46:00unanimity uh among group
- 46:03members. Um the silence is used
- 46:06as agreement. Okay.
- 46:08Uh a unanimous. I I'm sorry, being unanimous,
- 46:12being unanimous. So they're the delusions of
- 46:15being unanimous. There's direct pressure to conform,
- 46:18and it's placed upon a member who questions
- 46:22the group. It's couched in terms of disloyalty.
- 46:25When you look at their inner uh their
- 46:28inner discussions, they do say, they do
- 46:32call others in the Democratic Party or other
- 46:34parties of being disloyal, being disloyal
- 46:38if they're not uh going along with with
- 46:41what others are saying. So also
- 46:44mind guards, their self-appointed members who who shield
- 46:47the group from dissenting information. There are,
- 46:51there are, there are people uh within the
- 46:53DSA who who shelter others in the
- 46:56DSA. So the the encapsulations
- 47:00is superb of Wyatt's and
- 47:03Janice's writings from two sources, so
- 47:07respectively, respectively. Steve Poole, Steve
- 47:10Poole, who was a British uh author,
- 47:14journalist. He was noted in The Guardian in
- 47:17November 2017. And quote
- 47:20Steve Poole, this is what he said, talking
- 47:23about Wyatt. Um, and he said Wyatt saw
- 47:26a group think as a kind of creeping
- 47:29cultural scientific communism,
- 47:33which freed people from moral decision making
- 47:36because the system
- 47:39would manage things better than the individual. Sound
- 47:43familiar?
- 47:44And uh in fact, the
- 47:47Neuroleadership Institute, it was a white there was
- 47:50a white paper that came out in 2021,
- 47:54and it referred to pools
- 47:57above comments that I just mentioned,
- 48:00with with this quote That's
- 48:04a far cry from the way in
- 48:07which Janice reconceptualized groupthink
- 48:10twenty years later,
- 48:13not as a philosophy at all, but a
- 48:16bias that afflicts groups.
- 48:20The way Janus conceived it,
- 48:24groupthink operates much as a
- 48:27consciously held belief,
- 48:30but
- 48:32as an invisible pressure to
- 48:35conform that arises spontaneously in the
- 48:38moment, affecting people's judgments
- 48:41without their even knowing they're being affected.
- 48:45Groupthink, in other words, is an unconscious
- 48:48bias, and that's what makes people that's
- 48:52what makes uh it so dangerous
- 48:55to people, so uh or for people. So
- 48:58this is amazing, but it's true.
- 49:02And again, the master, the mind,
- 49:06uh mastering the individual, or in this
- 49:09sense, uh individuals
- 49:12plural is not doing a good thing, not
- 49:16doing a good thing. So um the
- 49:19the mind as a servant in
- 49:22in a positive way, uh, we can
- 49:25see the mind as a servant in a
- 49:27negative way, or a master
- 49:30uh to the individual, the mind in a
- 49:34negative way. So there are
- 49:37case studies, a multitude, multitude,
- 49:40many case studies regarding the poor and
- 49:44unfortunate outcomes of groupthink in America and world
- 49:47history, uh, just to name a few. So,
- 49:50yeah, the U.S. Bay of Pigs, the invasion
- 49:53in April 1961, in which the Kennedy
- 49:57administration failed to verify the assumptions
- 50:00uh of the CIA that Fidel Castro's military
- 50:03was inept.
- 50:06The Pearl Harbor attack, December 7, 1941,
- 50:09with U.S. naval leadership not heeding the warnings
- 50:12from Washington of a potential
- 50:15Japanese attack. Um
- 50:20getting more in more recent history, the air
- 50:22traffic controller strike. I think about this all
- 50:24the time. It was in 1981. Many of
- 50:26our listeners were not born at that time,
- 50:28but it was the Met with the firing
- 50:30of over 11,000 individuals by President
- 50:34Ronald Reagan. And
- 50:37my goodness, uh, the very dear friend of
- 50:40mine who I've interviewed a number of times,
- 50:43Dutch, Captain Dutch Rauch, uh, the space
- 50:46shuttle challenger, he was responsible for the
- 50:49nose portion of that aircraft, but the explosion
- 50:53on January 28th, 1986,
- 50:56with the avoidance of warnings by Morton Thiacol
- 50:59engineers, that the cooler temperatures on the day
- 51:02of the launch could have resulted in failure
- 51:05of the rocket boosters, in addition uh to
- 51:08the pressures of NASA to proceed with the
- 51:10launch. That that involved group thing.
- 51:14How about uh how about uh even more
- 51:17recent, the Major League Umpires Associations, remember this,
- 51:21that in 1999 they had a
- 51:24mass resignation, but but they
- 51:27overestimated their self-perceived power.
- 51:30Right? And then uh here's another one.
- 51:332008, the financial crisis was due to Wall
- 51:36Street's failure to assess the risks of
- 51:39complex financial products. So
- 51:42groupthink is full of
- 51:45potential drawbacks. Okay, the mind can be very
- 51:49dangerous here, including the compromise of critical
- 51:52thinking,
- 51:53the higher risks for outrageous
- 51:57errors, uh, the suppression of dissent,
- 52:00and ultimately poor decision making.
- 52:04This can be extrapolated, as we did before,
- 52:07to the geopolitical arena, uh, to include a
- 52:10lack of innovative thought, uh, miscalculations,
- 52:14failure to adapt and accommodate, uh, and
- 52:17ultimately the escalation of global tensions and
- 52:20conflict. So I don't know what's happening
- 52:24right now in the White House, and and
- 52:26this is all not for public
- 52:29consumption in terms of the uh in
- 52:32terms of the ebbs and flows and and
- 52:35highlights of the US Iranian
- 52:38ordeal. Uh I think that there's
- 52:41information, much information that we're not aware
- 52:45of. And I don't know that groupthink is
- 52:48actually involved here. Um
- 52:51likely not, but I've heard so many different
- 52:54things as to why we haven't just blown
- 52:56them to smithereens, even more so. Uh
- 52:59yes, people would die. Many people would die.
- 53:03Trump does not want that, no one wants
- 53:05that. Uming
- 53:08the people in Iran. Well, many people would
- 53:11still die. So anyway, I'm going on a
- 53:13tangent. Now, could there be some silver
- 53:16linings in which groupthink may have
- 53:19positive implications? Yeah. Yeah.
- 53:23I believe so. In certain contexts and
- 53:26nuanced situations, there could. So it
- 53:29may have beneficial results. So using a
- 53:31counter-momentum metaphor, the name of our
- 53:35show, uh, of the negatives, particularly
- 53:38when there is a premium on rapid response,
- 53:41group think may result in expedited decision making
- 53:44without um stifling
- 53:47overanalysis. So very few
- 53:50decisions are set in stone. Um there's almost
- 53:53always room for modification and even even uh
- 53:57rescinding of decisions when required.
- 54:00So considering descending opinions and tempering
- 54:03unrealistic optimism, there may be a place
- 54:06in certain situations for groupthink
- 54:10decision making. There may be. Now,
- 54:13neurobiology, we spoke about that a bit, uh,
- 54:17still in its infancy, the study of neurobiology,
- 54:19but what about the neurobiology of groupthink? We
- 54:22have neuroscientists and research psychiatrists,
- 54:25they've been tackling the scientific basis for group
- 54:28dynamics and uh groupthink, with
- 54:32some success, some. Our brains are
- 54:35far less uh far more, I'm sorry,
- 54:39complex than we we talked about with AI.
- 54:43So, is there a neural circuitry that
- 54:46enables or favors groupthink behavior?
- 54:50In fact, there is an evolving study. There's
- 54:53an evolving study of what's called the mirror
- 54:56nervous system, such as mirrors in our bathroom,
- 54:59for example. So uh this is in every
- 55:01human being, which a neuronal or neural
- 55:04resonance resonance may occur uh
- 55:07between and among human beings. So there could
- 55:10be neural um circuitry, which is fired
- 55:14in the same pattern by the observer as
- 55:17that of the active initiator in a
- 55:20mirrored fashion. So the bonding of individuals in
- 55:23the group think paradigm uh may involve the
- 55:26sharing of this neuronal network and
- 55:29um strengthening also of this neural network.
- 55:33So our brains, they're wired to optimize
- 55:36survival. So any threat of this would set
- 55:39off cerebral alarms from our
- 55:42sympathetic nervous system, and hence our
- 55:45parasympathetic and mirror nervous
- 55:49system networks uh would result in
- 55:52individuals remaining in the same group. So,
- 55:55yeah, there's a lot to this. And
- 55:59lastly, a confluence of the
- 56:02nature versus the nurture. Uh
- 56:06we talked about that among dictators. So, in
- 56:09summary, yeah, it has
- 56:12overriding negatives, group thing, sprinkled with some
- 56:15potential positives. It's part of our human
- 56:18psyche and thus must be recognized, really, really
- 56:22recognized as operative in personal public
- 56:25decision-making processes.
- 56:28Well, that was a lot. That was a
- 56:31lot, but that's what's going on next. Next
- 56:34week, we're gonna we're gonna start interviewing, restart
- 56:36interviewing many individuals. So thank you so much
- 56:39for listening. I enthusiastically look
- 56:42forward to being with you weekly on the
- 56:45Counter Momentum of a Spin, where we will
- 56:47endeavor to address and work towards solving
- 56:50the problems of the world. Please note that
- 56:53this show, in all the shows on American
- 56:55Outline Talk Radio, go to your favorite podcast
- 56:58numbers within 24 hours. Apple Podcasts,
- 57:01Spotify, and Dolo tune in. Amazon
- 57:04iPhone video and others. Have a great day
- 57:08and
- 57:08and God bless you.