Latest / Comeback Files: Human strength, healing & change / How to Hold Space for Pain Without Trying to Fix It | Comeback Files
Transcript
- There is a terrifying silence that happens when someone you love finally breaks open, and your first instinct is to rush in with answers before they’ve even finished falling. But what if the bravest thing you could offer isn’t a solution, but simply the courage to stay still while they shatter? I want you to think about the last time you sat across from someone who was hurting. Maybe it was a friend whose heart had just been broken, or a colleague who was drowning in grief, or maybe it was someone in your own family who was navigating a loss so heavy it seemed to warp the air in the room. What did you do? I bet, if you’re honest, you felt a physical tightening in your chest. You wanted to reach out and smooth things over. You wanted to say something clever, something comforting, something that would act like a bandage on a wound that needed stitches. We are conditioned, aren’t we, to believe that love looks like action. That if we see someone in pain, our job is to make the pain go away. It’s a reflex as old as humanity. We see suffering, and we panic. We think, 'If I can fix this, then I am safe. If I can solve their problem, then the world makes sense again.' But here is the quiet truth that takes us years to learn: most pain cannot be fixed. It can only be held. And holding space is infinitely more difficult than fixing it, because it requires us to surrender our need to control the outcome. Let me tell you about my friend Sarah. A few years ago, she lost her job after twenty years of loyal service. She came to my kitchen table, and she didn’t cry. She just stared at the steam rising from her mug, her hands wrapped around it like it was the only thing keeping her upright. My first instinct, the one that comes from years of trying to be helpful, was to start brainstorming. I was going to suggest resume edits. I was going to name-drop contacts. I was going to offer a five-year plan. But then I looked at her face, really looked at it, and I saw how small she had become. So, I stopped talking. I just poured her another cup of tea. I sat down opposite her. And I waited. For ten minutes, there was nothing but the hum of the refrigerator and the sound of her breathing. It felt awkward. It felt like I was failing her. But in that silence, something shifted. She exhaled, a long, shaky breath that seemed to come from the bottom of her lungs. And then she said, 'I don’t know who I am without this job.' In that moment, I realized that my plans would have invalidated her identity crisis. By staying silent, by refusing to rush her through her grief, I gave her permission to feel the full weight of her loss. I didn’t fix it. I witnessed it. And sometimes, being witnessed is the only medicine that works. We often mistake empathy for sympathy, but they are very different creatures. Sympathy looks down from a high place; it says, 'I’m sorry you’re in that hole.' Empathy climbs down into the hole with you and sits in the dirt. When we try to fix someone’s pain, we are essentially saying that their pain is a problem to be solved rather than an experience to be lived. We minimize their reality by offering quick fixes. We say, 'At least you have your health,' or 'Everything happens for a reason.' These phrases might be true, but they are not helpful in the immediate aftermath of trauma. They shut down the conversation. They tell the person that their feelings are inconvenient. When we hold space, we validate their experience without judgment. We let them know that their anger, their sadness, their confusion—it all belongs here. It is allowed. This is where the magic happens. Not in the resolution, but in the recognition. When someone feels truly seen in their messiness, they begin to heal. They stop performing strength for us and start processing their own emotions. And that process is messy, loud, and non-linear. It doesn’t look like a straight line back to happiness. It looks like a spiral, going deeper into understanding before coming back up. Holding space requires a kind of quiet fierceness that society rarely praises. We live in a culture that celebrates hustle, productivity, and positive vibes. We are told to bounce back quickly, to optimize our grief, to find the silver lining immediately. But holding space asks you to resist that urge. It asks you to be uncomfortable. It asks you to sit with the discomfort of not knowing what to say. It asks you to trust that the other person has the capacity to survive this, even if they can’t see it right now. This is where my previous thoughts on struggle come in. Remember how hard it is to admit we are struggling? Well, holding space for others means creating a container where that admission doesn’t feel like screaming into the void. It means listening with your whole body. It means putting down your phone. It means making eye contact even when you want to look away. It means resisting the urge to fill the silence with your own noise. Because in that silence, the other person finds their own voice. They find their own truth. And you get to be the steady ground beneath their feet, rather than the wind trying to push them forward. So, how do we actually do this? How do we move from the urge to fix to the practice of presence? First, check your ego. Ask yourself: Am I trying to help them, or am I trying to ease my own anxiety about their pain? Second, use simple, grounding language. You don’t need profound wisdom. You just need to show up. Say things like, 'I’m here.' Or, 'This sounds incredibly hard.' Or, 'I don’t know what to say, but I’m not going anywhere.' Third, listen to understand, not to respond. Let them finish their thought without interrupting with your own story or advice. Fourth, ask permission. Before you offer any perspective, ask, 'Do you want to vent, or do you want ideas?' Most of the time, they will choose venting. And that is okay. Finally, respect their timeline. Healing is not a race. Do not expect them to be better next week. Do not measure their progress against your expectations. Just be present. Be the constant. Be the friend who remembers that some wounds don’t close; they just become part of the landscape of who you are. Now, I want to turn this gently toward you. Because to hold space for others, you must also hold space for yourself. You cannot pour from an empty cup, and you certainly cannot offer steady presence if you are running on fumes. Pay attention to your own boundaries. Holding space is exhausting. It leaves you feeling drained, hollowed out, emotionally stretched. That is normal. It is the cost of deep connection. But you must recharge. You must have moments where you are not the listener, the supporter, the strong one. You get to be soft. You get to be messy. You get to be human. Take your time in your own healing. You don’t have to be the hero for everyone else. Sometimes, the most loving thing you can do is step back and let someone else hold space for you. It’s a cycle, a beautiful, imperfect spiral of giving and receiving. And in that cycle, we find our strength. Not in fixing, but in being. In showing up, again and again, with open hands and an open heart, ready to witness the beauty in the broken pieces. Thank you for sitting with me today. Thank you for the courage it takes to be soft in a hard world. I’ll be here next time, waiting for you. Until then, take care of your heart. It’s doing its best. Goodnight, friends.