Latest / CXOTalk / CIO Agenda 2026: The Enterprise AI Promise | CXOTalk #909
Transcript
- 0:00If you are thinking I should have a seat at the table, you
- 0:03have failed. You have failed.
- 0:07You should be asking yourself how do I earn a seat at the
- 0:10table and the title does not get you there. 88% of companies use
- 0:15AI, but fewer than 6% get measurable value.
- 0:22The pilot era of AI is over. Tim Crawford and Isaac Sacolege
- 0:29are both former CIOs and world class CIO advisors.
- 0:35Tim, what's failing? AI strategy or IT execution?
- 0:41Flatly, both. We're focused on the wrong
- 0:43thing, we're not thinking about the outcomes and companies are
- 0:48suffering because of it. If you flashback a year ago, you
- 0:52know, every board, every executive committee want didn't
- 0:56want to fall behind in AI and every tool became accessible
- 1:01just like the mobile era. And So what you ended up with is
- 1:04lots of people in companies trying out AI, whether it was a
- 1:08large language model or an agent that appeared in a SAS tool.
- 1:13And so all of a sudden you got tenfold, twentyfold, sometimes a
- 1:16hundredfold more experiments, undocumented happening inside
- 1:21the organization. And so now the CIO is
- 1:23backtracking and saying we need to make sure there's a strategy
- 1:26here, that we're focused on the right things and making sure
- 1:29that we have governance in place so we know which tools, which
- 1:32teams, which data, and that all falls into where are we focusing
- 1:38our effort when it comes to AI. And the reality is that the CEO
- 1:42is increasing the pressure on the CIO to produce the results.
- 1:47And the problem is they're not. And they're struggling through
- 1:50how to put their arms around it, how to connect the dots, what
- 1:54metrics to use. I know we're going to talk about
- 1:57many of these things, so I don't want to steal that Thunder.
- 1:59But at the same time, the reality is we're we're in a
- 2:03tough spot as IT leaders and we've got to navigate our way
- 2:07through this. Talk, talk about metrics.
- 2:10I mean, the number one thing people have talked about coming
- 2:12out of AI is either productivity or efficiency.
- 2:16We've been terrible at having productivity measures.
- 2:19We don't agree on what they are and efficiencies take time to
- 2:22materialize. So we're still looking at using
- 2:26AI to take what we're doing today and make it a little bit
- 2:29more efficient, little bit maybe less error prone at times.
- 2:32We're not at a point where we're taking AI and saying how is it
- 2:35transforming our businesses. Tim, you mentioned CEOs, so I'll
- 2:41direct this to Tim. Why don't I start with you and
- 2:43then Isaac jump in. What do CE OS and boards want
- 2:49from Chief information officers in 2026?
- 2:54Seems like should it should be. I, I was going to say that it
- 2:56seems should be kind of an obvious question, but is there
- 3:00uncertainty around this? Yes and no.
- 3:02So the question still exists. The question is not new, right?
- 3:06They want to take advantage of the new innovation.
- 3:09They want to take advantage of AI.
- 3:10They know there's a there there, they just don't know what the
- 3:14there there is for them. And so that's where the that's
- 3:18where the real question comes up is how do you start to
- 3:21understand kind of to Isaac's earlier point, how do you
- 3:23understand which of those efforts, which of those
- 3:26experiments are actually going to prove out something that is
- 3:30valuable to the business that is going to move the business
- 3:32forward, accelerate the business, achieve some of those
- 3:35business objectives that the board is, is outlining and the
- 3:39ELT is, is focused around? Or are you going to continue
- 3:45through this experimentation and kind of to our, our earlier
- 3:48conversation in the last episode, I'm talking about
- 3:51staying in this AI purgatory, right?
- 3:54That's, that's where a lot of folks still are.
- 3:56So I think the number one thing that people have to understand
- 4:00is they have to understand their business first and foremost,
- 4:04full stop. Forget about the technology for
- 4:06a minute. Understand your business because
- 4:09if you don't, you're going to have a really hard time
- 4:12understanding where IAI can apply and how it's going to
- 4:17apply and the output that it's going to achieve for your
- 4:21company and for your customers and what's just another tech
- 4:26bright shiny object that you're putting in place.
- 4:28Isaac, I have to ask you something.
- 4:31How is it even conceivable that a chief information officer
- 4:37would not understand the business and we're here to talk
- 4:41about AI and why are we even talking about this?
- 4:45Most CIOs will understand the business strategy.
- 4:48Most. There's still a lot of CIOs who
- 4:51are being hired as operators and still a lot of CIOs who see
- 4:56themselves as operators. But I think the bigger issue is
- 4:59even when you have ACEO who understands, you know what is in
- 5:03their quarterly yearly filings to the street about where their
- 5:07growth is and where they're going to find efficiencies, that
- 5:10doesn't translate down very well.
- 5:12And most of the work that we're doing around AI is a lot of
- 5:15bottom up work. It's a lot of, you know, what
- 5:17can I do as a marketer to become more efficient or to drive a
- 5:21campaign? How am I using AI inside my
- 5:25development tools to deliver features a little bit more
- 5:28reliably and a little bit more feature, a little bit faster?
- 5:32Those are the things that we're doing.
- 5:33And there's like a lot of layers of disconnect from business
- 5:37strategy around delivering value to customers or expanding what
- 5:42we're doing from a customer service perspective and what the
- 5:45individual teams and people are doing with AI today.
- 5:48I actually want to take exception to one thing that
- 5:50Isaac said. I agree with most of it, that
- 5:52for one thing, and that is that I don't believe that most CI OS
- 5:56truly do understand their business at the level that they
- 5:59need to. I think that they think they do,
- 6:03but in many cases they have a layperson's understanding of how
- 6:08their business operates and they need a much more intimate
- 6:11understanding of how their business operates.
- 6:13But otherwise, I completely agree with what Isaac said.
- 6:16No, I, I agree with that, Tim. I mean, when I talk to CI OS and
- 6:19we say, how are you spending your time week to week, month to
- 6:23month, you know, quarter to quarter?
- 6:25And we, you know, break that down into percentages.
- 6:28If they're not spending time in the field with customers in
- 6:32operations, on a factory floor with their HR teams in terms of
- 6:37what types of struggles they're having or marketing with how
- 6:40they're growing the business. If they're not actually spending
- 6:42real time with business teams and business leaders, then
- 6:47they're only going to see things at a paper's strategy level and
- 6:50and very separated from how things are executing on the
- 6:53ground floor. Let's hit directly on IT and AI.
- 6:58Why are so many organizations stuck in pilot mode with with
- 7:06AI? They're still learning the tools
- 7:08is a big part of it. I mean, the tools are evolving
- 7:12so quickly that if you asked a development team just six months
- 7:17ago, you know, how much productivity are you getting out
- 7:20of using a code generator? They're going to, you know, the
- 7:23study showed about 20 to 30% depending on what was the after
- 7:27effect of using that code generator.
- 7:29And then a few months ago, you know, vibe coding became the new
- 7:33set of platforms that development teams are using.
- 7:36And now they're producing applications with English and
- 7:39getting 60, seventy, 80% of the way applications built out.
- 7:44And then if you believe, you know what Entropic is saying and
- 7:46what open AI is saying a couple weeks ago, they're saying 100%
- 7:50of what they're doing at the coding level is now happening
- 7:53with AI. And so a lot of CI OS in their
- 7:56teams are a little paralyzed by that velocity, right?
- 7:59If I even figure out something today that we think is worth
- 8:04taking out of pilot mode and getting a few more teams using
- 8:08it and seeing how we operationalize it, it might be
- 8:11evaporated in three to six months that, you know, there
- 8:13might be another model that leapfrogs it.
- 8:15Or maybe I'll be building less because a lot of my SAS
- 8:18providers already providing the functionality directly in their
- 8:21platforms. So there's a lot of uncertainty
- 8:23where CI, OS have to really focus implementation and their
- 8:27AI strategies. I completely agree.
- 8:29I mean, the velocity is way too fast for the enterprise to be
- 8:33able to consume. And so they're just skipping
- 8:35along the surface and hoping they can they can grab a hold of
- 8:39some of that value along the way.
- 8:41But it is creating a bit of consternation.
- 8:45And I say that lightly, although the reality is that it's
- 8:48creating a lot of consternation internally because the belief is
- 8:52at least from those that are uninitiated or are not familiar
- 8:56with the technology or understanding how technology is
- 8:59used within the company, they think they can just drop this in
- 9:02and be able to use it quickly. I wrote a post just recently
- 9:06and, and kind of outlined that I'm finding 2 swim lanes of
- 9:09success. One is you either have to bring
- 9:12this technology in a way, and I mean AI technology specifically,
- 9:17you have to bring it in in a way that doesn't impede the way that
- 9:21people work, meaning they're actually using it, but they
- 9:25don't realize they're using it. Or the alternative is you have
- 9:29to wrap it with training. You have to put the training
- 9:33effort in to help people understand how does this change
- 9:36how they work? Why should they be using it?
- 9:38Not just, hey, here it is, go to town, try and use it.
- 9:43What we're finding is that individuals within the company
- 9:46don't know what to do with it. And so that creates this gap
- 9:50between those that are having success and those that aren't.
- 9:54Tim's hitting on one of the failure modes, one of the areas
- 9:57that IT traditionally struggles with, and that's in change
- 10:01management. So even when you have a pilot
- 10:04and you think it's working, and now you're saying, I'm going to
- 10:06take it from, you know, one team in New York doing marketing and
- 10:12scaling campaigns with an AI behind it, and now I'm going to
- 10:17apply it in six other businesses or in four other departments
- 10:20across the world, I don't know how to do that very well.
- 10:23That's an entire ability to do change.
- 10:26And the other side of it is we're not really good at testing
- 10:29things. So you might have a team that
- 10:32says, hey, we have a pilot that's working and CIA needs to
- 10:36know is it reliable? Is it putting out valid results?
- 10:40When where is its boundaries where we know the AI is
- 10:43providing incorrect results, be able to test in a robust way and
- 10:48say this AI is release ready even to a pilot group.
- 10:52Is this a second area that we really struggle with?
- 10:55This is really helpful, especially because you're you're
- 10:58focusing on the AI specific set of issues as opposed to just the
- 11:06broader set of CIO role challenges that have been
- 11:11basically unchanged for the last 25 years.
- 11:14You should subscribe to the CXO Talk newsletter so we can notify
- 11:18you of upcoming shows. So go to cxotalk.com and just
- 11:22subscribe. All right, let's take some
- 11:25questions. And the first question is from
- 11:28Chris Peterson on Twitter. And, he says, is AI adoption
- 11:33still living in the inside out world of starting with
- 11:37technology instead of starting with business needs.
- 11:42It is absolutely still stuck in inside out thinking as opposed
- 11:46to outside in thinking. And this is really where some of
- 11:50the best opportunities are coming from is when you start to
- 11:52think about things like in the CX space, you start to think
- 11:56about things from the customer centric viewpoint as opposed to
- 12:00what your agents are doing internally or what your staff
- 12:03are doing internally. Think about it from the
- 12:06customer, whether that's an external customer, your
- 12:09company's customer or an employee, if if you're talking
- 12:12about support with NIT or HR or finance.
- 12:16But absolutely, we have to change that vernacular.
- 12:19We have to change that viewpoint.
- 12:21And that gets back to understanding your business,
- 12:24understanding your customers, your stakeholders, how are they
- 12:26engaging with your company, what's going to be meaningful
- 12:29for them. And that's really what's going
- 12:32to drive the difference between success and failure.
- 12:35And we're already seeing examples of that play out.
- 12:38Isaac, here's a question from Arsalan Khan.
- 12:40And I think it's very directly related to what Tim was just
- 12:44talking about. And Arsalan Khan says we always
- 12:49ask CIOs to quote, understand the business, but why don't we
- 12:54have the same type of emphasis for non-technical executives to
- 12:57know about technology, be beyond just the hype and now especially
- 13:01with AI? That's a critical part of the CI
- 13:04OS job, particularly with boards of the executive committee, you
- 13:08know, setting realistic expectations without getting
- 13:11into how the sausage is being made.
- 13:15I mean, if you read all the hype that's out there about what we
- 13:18can do with AI, man sent Wall Street crashing SAS stocks just
- 13:23a couple weeks ago believing SAS is going to disappear and
- 13:26enterprise CI OS are going to rebuild CRM and ERP platforms
- 13:31using vibe coding. It's just not going to happen
- 13:34that way. So CI OS need the right
- 13:38vernacular, the right storytelling, the right
- 13:41analogies to go back to their boards and their executive
- 13:44groups and tell them a little bit of what's important to be
- 13:47ready for AI. As the technology chains, we
- 13:50need to have our our data ready. What does that mean?
- 13:53Well, we need clear customer data.
- 13:55We need real policies about where they can be applied.
- 13:58We need a real testing methodology as we're rolling out
- 14:01pilots. We need a a seasoned group of
- 14:04individuals who can lead change management efforts.
- 14:07Those are the kinds of things CIOs need to be communicated.
- 14:10This is from Simone Joe Moore who says that CIOs have fought
- 14:16hard to get a seat at the table as chief but still seen by other
- 14:20C level leaders as quote, let's pass an order to this area.
- 14:26Again, this seems very much relating to this this attitude
- 14:31of IT as being separate. I wrote a post quite a while ago
- 14:36now several years ago talking about the three legged race and
- 14:41it hits on this very question, which is how people look at IT,
- 14:45but also how the IT leader kind of conducts themselves.
- 14:49And it kind of to Isaac's point of how they conduct themselves
- 14:53amongst the ELT as well as in the boardroom, assuming they
- 14:56have exposure to those environments.
- 15:00That's not always the case. One thing that's that's
- 15:03important is to understand that just because you have the title
- 15:07doesn't mean that you have earned that title.
- 15:10And what I mean by that is that there are a lot of folks that in
- 15:14this gets back to an earlier comment I made.
- 15:16Unfortunately, there are a lot of folks that have the CIO title
- 15:19but do not operate or are seen as a Chief officer similar to
- 15:25your CMOCOOCFOCHROCEO. And so that's one thing that if
- 15:31you do have the CIO title today, you need to ask yourself how can
- 15:35you operate at that level, at that strategic level with that
- 15:40business inside. I often say that you have to be
- 15:43a business leader first that happens to have responsibility
- 15:45for technology, not the other way around, and that that's a
- 15:50hard transition for a lot of these leaders to make.
- 15:54But getting back to the three legged race, there are three
- 15:56aspects that you have to think about. 1 is how you conduct
- 15:59yourself as CIO. Number 2 is how your
- 16:03organization, how the IT organization conducts themselves
- 16:06and are they business oriented all the way down to the most
- 16:09junior person on your team. And #3 is how do people perceive
- 16:13you outside in? So how do folks on the ELT
- 16:17perceive you? Are you the one that they call
- 16:19when the projector stops working or you the one that they're
- 16:22going to bring into the open-ended conversation around
- 16:25where we take the company next? And so you have to be able to
- 16:29navigate that. But one thing that's really
- 16:32important is if you are thinking I should have a seat at the
- 16:37table, you have failed. You have failed.
- 16:41You should be asking yourself, how do I earn a seat at the
- 16:45table? And the title does not get you
- 16:47there. You have to think about
- 16:49relationships. You have to think about how you
- 16:52earn that seat. And keep in mind, just because
- 16:54you get a seat at the table doesn't mean you get to keep a
- 16:57seat at the table because there's someone right behind you
- 16:59willing to take that seat should you stumble.
- 17:02Isaac, we have let's jump to another question.
- 17:05You can see I I try to prioritize the audience
- 17:07questions over my own. So Isaac Joseph Puglisi says the
- 17:12following. He says, how do we move from
- 17:17introducing AI to improve efficiency or accelerate the
- 17:22current business to true business process re engineering
- 17:27or better total business transformation?
- 17:31How do we get the real value out of of the promise of AI?
- 17:36Yeah, I've been telling CIOs that a lot of what AI is doing
- 17:40in their organization is reshaping its business.
- 17:43It's not really transforming yet.
- 17:44We're not really focused on customer experience.
- 17:48We're not really focused on growth yet.
- 17:50We're we're not at the things that are really going to evolve
- 17:53and make most businesses competitive for the next 3, five
- 17:56to 10 years. Now if you look at how winning
- 18:00CIOs have accomplished this, right, the ones that are truly
- 18:04innovative there, they replicated this 10 years ago, 15
- 18:08years ago off of what SAS companies were doing and why
- 18:11they were successful. If you look at traditional IT,
- 18:14we were ticket based in our history.
- 18:17Business came in with a ticket. We responded to the ticket.
- 18:21We measured how well we responded.
- 18:23Eventually we started measuring employee satisfaction.
- 18:27If you look at how a SAS company operates, they have a function
- 18:30in there called product management.
- 18:32And product management says we're going to look at what are
- 18:36the P&L objectives, what are the growth objectives, what markets
- 18:40do we want to be in? And they come up in partnership
- 18:44with the technologists what the road map should look like, what
- 18:48is the release strategy, where do we need to experiment and do
- 18:52our D with. I did an article last year for
- 18:54CIO magazine around product based IT for that exact reason,
- 18:59because when you, you look at all this technology, you know to
- 19:02you know the question about inside out.
- 19:03We need people in the business experimenting with how
- 19:09enterprise SAS platforms are investing, are putting agents
- 19:12into their system. What are these things actually
- 19:15do? And then we need to marry down
- 19:16top down strategy that says, you know what, in HR we should focus
- 19:21on recruiting and marketing. We should focus on campaign
- 19:24management and IT, we should focus on AI operations and
- 19:28improving our ability to maintain our systems that are
- 19:33that improve stability. That's the strategy part.
- 19:36And what we need is a group in individuals inside our IT
- 19:40organizations called a product management function that's going
- 19:43to own the outcome. So it's going to prescribe here
- 19:46are the road maps that are going to get us to the strategy that
- 19:49we've outlined at the beginning of the year.
- 19:52I mean in a lot of ways it's it's kind of shifting your
- 19:55organization to move from a project oriented focus to a
- 19:59product oriented focus. We have a great question from
- 20:05Derek A Butts, who says he thinks CIOs need to be in
- 20:11alignment with their Cisos to understand the challenges of the
- 20:15AI promise along with the risk that will be introduced.
- 20:20How can CIOs prepare for the challenges and alignment of AI
- 20:25within their business, culture and ecosystem when there is no
- 20:30CISO? This kind of gets to one of the
- 20:33reasons why AI solutions are struggling, the more sensitive
- 20:39the data and Isaac kind of talked about getting your data
- 20:42prepped and, and you have to have it prepped better today
- 20:46with AI than ever before. Like it, it takes it to a whole
- 20:49new level of preparation. But one of the other things you
- 20:52have to think about are the governance models that sit
- 20:55around that data and how agents, and especially as you move into
- 20:58an agentic world and you start thinking about MCP, you start
- 21:01thinking about a 2A, you start thinking about ephemeral agents.
- 21:05You have to start thinking about how those governance models
- 21:08start to to play a role. And so the risk, which is really
- 21:13where Csos need to be focused, the risk associated with AI as
- 21:19opposed to the opportunity is really causing some folks to
- 21:22say, you know what, I'm only going to use very specific
- 21:25aspects of AI because I don't know how to put those governance
- 21:30models in place. And to be fair, it's a really
- 21:33complicated problem because you have governance models for the
- 21:36user. You know, what does Tim get
- 21:38access to versus Isaac when, when they engage with the agent
- 21:41versus what the agent has access to versus the knowledge base
- 21:45that the agent agents have access to.
- 21:47Oh, and by the way, that data may not exist within a central
- 21:51repository like your snowflake repository or data bricks or
- 21:54whatnot. So it might sit in a system of
- 21:57record, which has its own governance models.
- 22:01And so how do you start to rationalize that?
- 22:04And the reality is it's a really hard problem in this.
- 22:06This is why companies are starting off really small to get
- 22:10their arms around the data, put a governance model in place that
- 22:13they can control and manage and reduce the risk.
- 22:16And why they're not just running what I call running with
- 22:19scissors down the road and trying to do all these crazy,
- 22:24crazy things that people talk about in the press.
- 22:27Tyler James Johnson on LinkedIn says at what point does
- 22:34governance need to shift from reporting to real time
- 22:37enforcement in order to safely scale AI?
- 22:42I think the question is, how do you, how do you start to put the
- 22:45right governance models in place?
- 22:46And this is where #1 if you don't have an AI council
- 22:51established within your organization that is cross
- 22:53functional, that has got to be the starting point.
- 22:56This is not an IT problem. This is a company problem.
- 23:01And so you're going to need that cross functional conversation to
- 23:05be able to understand then what are those different layers and
- 23:08how do you start to put those layers in place?
- 23:11Tim took the words right out of my valve.
- 23:13We have a long history of saying this group is responsible for
- 23:17strategy and innovation, and this group is responsible for
- 23:20risk management and security. It doesn't.
- 23:23It didn't work before. It totally falls apart when we
- 23:26think about AI, right? We need to be having that same
- 23:29group together. Your idea of a council is one
- 23:32way of solving for that, but don't embark on an AI experiment
- 23:37or a pilot or think about even putting into production without
- 23:41that group together. We've been doing agile for a
- 23:43very long time, right? We know how to solve for this.
- 23:46You put a multidisciplinary group together and say, look,
- 23:50we're not just trying to improve efficiency and productivity and
- 23:54get that value out of it. We're also require these
- 23:57attributes, these attributes interpreters of reliability in
- 24:02terms of privacy, in terms of data bias and put that all into
- 24:06the objectives of that group to accomplish all of it at the same
- 24:09time. I know it sounds simple, but
- 24:11that org separation is killing us.
- 24:13Some of those AI councils, in fact, a number of them are not
- 24:17actually led by the CIO or head of IT.
- 24:21They're led by the CEO or someone else within the
- 24:24executive leadership team. So don't think of it in the
- 24:27context of IT should be leading this effort or driving this
- 24:31effort. That's that's not necessarily
- 24:33the case here, again, because you need to start with that
- 24:36business context to be able to make the right decisions for how
- 24:40AI gets used from governance to outcomes to risk.
- 24:44This is from Sagar Bouchball, and Sagar says it's a it's a
- 24:51long question, so I'm going to comment.
- 24:53So I'm going to paraphrase this, but essentially he's saying that
- 24:57the winners, AI winners will be the ones who operational AI.
- 25:03And by understanding the way AI tools can accelerate workflows
- 25:10and decision making speed while keeping judgement with humans
- 25:15and laggards are letting AI replace thinking and outsource
- 25:20judgement. So.
- 25:21So my question therefore is how should technology leaders
- 25:28evaluate AI technologies in order to ensure that the tools
- 25:35are capable and map onto say innovation related processes as
- 25:42opposed to pure efficiency driven outcomes?
- 25:48Michael, a lot of what you're seeing in AI right now is
- 25:52helping a person, a specific role, accomplish a specific
- 25:57task. That's what an agent is doing
- 26:00inside all the major SAS platforms and they're starting
- 26:03to build up the skill set so that AI can accomplish a bunch
- 26:08of different skills or a particular area of
- 26:12responsibility. And that is a work in progress.
- 26:15Another one of the big announcements over the last
- 26:18couple weeks, it's just the explosion of how AI is being
- 26:22implied and legal and financed. So a top down ability to replace
- 26:26a lot of different functions. And that's how organizational
- 26:30leaders. I like your point, Tim.
- 26:32That's not just the CIO. You have to really look at the
- 26:35organization and really look at the process because we're not
- 26:38going to take out just a step in the process or really impact
- 26:42just a role in the process. We're going to say, what does
- 26:45this department need to do now that we have AI in place?
- 26:49I saw a CIO speak about it six months ago and he's he's now
- 26:54ACEO and he questioned his HR department.
- 26:57Why do we need an HR department if I have AI?
- 27:01And so when you ask a question like that to the head of HR, you
- 27:05start unpacking what is the value an HR department is
- 27:09delivering that an AI isn't going to be delivered.
- 27:12And I think all organizations have to start thinking that way.
- 27:15By the way, I don't advocate not having an HR department.
- 27:18I think they're very important. I mean, that's where I was going
- 27:21to go. I mean, there, you know, there's
- 27:23been a lot of crap out there talking about how AI is going to
- 27:27replace people and replace the world and will it?
- 27:30Well, maybe in some spaces, some specifics roles or functions of
- 27:35roles, but this is not about at least in this first horizon
- 27:41because there are, there are three basic horizons or three
- 27:44fundamental horizons for AI and we're still in this first
- 27:48horizon and still figuring it out.
- 27:49So there's a lot more opportunity to come, but in this
- 27:52first horizon of efficiency, which is largely what we're all
- 27:56talking about, it's not about replacing people, but it's more
- 28:01about how do you increase the value that each person in your
- 28:05organization delivers. And So what that's going to do
- 28:09is cause us to rethink how each of our functions operate from an
- 28:14organizational standpoint. But again, kind of back to
- 28:18Chris's earlier question, you have to think from the outside
- 28:22in, like what do your customers need?
- 28:24What do your customers want? What should they want?
- 28:27You know, it's the Henry Ford adage, right?
- 28:29If I ask customers what they want, they say faster horses and
- 28:33look where he took things. We have to do the same thing
- 28:36here. We have to rethink how we
- 28:38operate businesses. And so yes, we're starting off
- 28:42very slowly, maybe too slowly in some people's minds, but that's
- 28:48it's a really important point to make, which is how do you start
- 28:52to affect and then accelerate process in which you're adopting
- 28:58this technology. And that's a really key point
- 29:00here is we can no longer take this stance of bring a new
- 29:04technology in, then bring something else in and take this
- 29:08waterfall approach. Sorry, Isaac, I had to do a
- 29:11little agile there, but we had. But the reality is I got to
- 29:16laugh, Michael, to laugh. Yes, my goal is my goal is
- 29:20accomplished. But I think it's important.
- 29:22I think it's really important for IT leaders to understand
- 29:26that there is a velocity change, a market velocity change that
- 29:30your organization needs to take. That needs to start with IT, but
- 29:34it's going to happen across the entire organization.
- 29:38And so how you do that, how you accelerate your organization is
- 29:41really, really important. We have an interesting comment
- 29:45from our brilliant friend Sarbet Johal, who says titles and team
- 29:52sizes are all under reconsideration in this AI age.
- 29:58And I think this is speaking directly to the points you've
- 30:00both been making. AI is changing things up.
- 30:04I think that's been happening for a while now.
- 30:06You know, as we provide more technology capabilities, things
- 30:11that people had to do manually are being replaced by
- 30:14technology. And AI is doing a big piece of
- 30:17this. It's accelerating this.
- 30:19But it's really important for, you know, CE OS and boards to
- 30:24know that just because we're getting AI doesn't mean that we
- 30:28can release 10/20/30 thousand people from our job force and
- 30:33making that correlation right. And you could see it at the
- 30:36lowest level. Even if I can do 100% of my
- 30:40coding in my department with AI, even if I can do that, I still
- 30:46need expertise to weigh in trade-offs.
- 30:49If I give a requirement to build a login system and it does
- 30:54everything in memory, maybe that's not going to scale to
- 30:58hundreds of thousands and millions of users the way the AI
- 31:02system constructed it. So I need people who need to be
- 31:05able to ask the question the right way to realize it's worth
- 31:09developing something in the 1st place.
- 31:11There isn't something out there that I can already reuse to
- 31:14evaluate the conditions by which are responded.
- 31:17And that's going to happen inside every single function.
- 31:21So I mean that's, you know, that's a transformation at an
- 31:24operating level that's starting with some concrete roles right
- 31:28now that's going to expand and it really comes back down to
- 31:32again being able to listen from our staff, what is subject
- 31:36matter experts, how is this helping you today?
- 31:39And then I mean some top down questions about how we
- 31:42reorganizing around this capability?
- 31:44Tim, we have a question from Jay Cohen on LinkedIn that gets
- 31:50right to the heart of something essential that I'd like to dig
- 31:55into. And Jay Cohen says, will CIOs
- 31:59need to shift from AI capability discussions to explicit value
- 32:05definitions? And so somewhat my question to
- 32:09you, Tim, is why does, why do we even need to ask?
- 32:14Like shouldn't the CIO understand the value definition
- 32:20and have the ability to move beyond a discussion of tools and
- 32:26features or just, or just CI OS as a group?
- 32:31Well, I'm not going to say it. I won't.
- 32:32I won't. I won't go there.
- 32:34I will say it, I mean a CI OS, not a CI OS, not a CIO, OK.
- 32:39And I'm happy to happy to talk offline and talk more in depth
- 32:43publicly about this. But the reality is, yes, they
- 32:47absolutely should understand the value and the outcome and not be
- 32:51focusing on the bright shiny object.
- 32:53I mean, this is the this is the problem, right?
- 32:55That, that we've had for decades is there has been this over
- 32:59rotation of focusing on the, the net new thing and sometimes to
- 33:05the the chagrin of others that are going well.
- 33:08Why are we doing this? Like what, how is this really
- 33:11kind of moving the needle for our business?
- 33:13And the reality is you have to look at this, we see, we
- 33:16actually see this happen in the in different conversations.
- 33:21So for example, I was just involved in another conversation
- 33:24with a group of leaders yesterday talking about cost,
- 33:29talking about cost specifically. And I said, why are we talking
- 33:34about cost? Again, the conversation should
- 33:37not be cost. It should be about value, right?
- 33:40Because what is value? Value is opportunity or outcome
- 33:44minus cost. And the value is what moves the
- 33:48needle, not the cost. And so it's important to
- 33:51understand that relationship. And so yes, we should be talking
- 33:56about the outcomes. Another way to think about this,
- 33:59Michael, in terms of AI is when you, if you truly are thinking
- 34:04about those outcomes, you kind of don't care what happens in
- 34:07the black box, right? It could be AI, it could be
- 34:11advanced analytics, it could be black magic.
- 34:13It doesn't matter. What matters is what's the input
- 34:17that I need to be able to get that output and then the
- 34:21opportunity and risk equation that goes with it.
- 34:24But the actual technology itself, sure, we need to know a
- 34:28little bit about that and understand that.
- 34:30And that gets to this point of trust, which is another key
- 34:34thing that's a problem for AI, AI today.
- 34:37But at the end of the day, it kind of doesn't matter.
- 34:40And that's what we have to focus on is the outcome first and
- 34:42foremost. Outcome, first and foremost,
- 34:47let's talk about that in terms of agentic AI.
- 34:53What should CI OS do about agentic AI right now?
- 34:58This discussion around value needs to be something that the
- 35:02CIO can have a collaborative discussion with their leadership
- 35:07team about what it is and how we're measuring it, right?
- 35:10If you have a conversation with your CMO and they say, you know,
- 35:15our value is delivering more leads to sales, you know, that's
- 35:18just not looking at a holistic picture.
- 35:21So there, you know, one of the reasons we're having a hard time
- 35:24with this is that CIOs need to get at a real collaborative
- 35:28discussion with their groups about how to express value that
- 35:32the entire organization can wrap their hands around.
- 35:35Now, when it comes to agents, OK, there's some folks are going
- 35:39to say, you know what? We're going to be, you know, we
- 35:41should be aiming at fully autonomous agents.
- 35:44They're going to take over organizations in different
- 35:47functions. And what we're really going to
- 35:49be doing is cutting back so that we can be we can establish
- 35:54trust. So we're going to design it for
- 35:56fully autonomous and cut back. There are others who say we're
- 35:59never going to achieve that fully autonomous or we're, it's
- 36:03going to take a long time or a lot of expense to achieve that
- 36:07autonomy. And so we're going to just look
- 36:09at it as human in the middle, human at the helm.
- 36:12How do we make people smarter, more efficient, more capable of
- 36:16doing the things that they need to do in their functions now
- 36:20that they have access to an AI language model, now that they
- 36:24have AI being able to answer a lot of questions proactively,
- 36:27now that we've connected all of our automation so we can have an
- 36:31AI explain trade-offs and connect to different things.
- 36:35And the answer is we're going to be doing a little bit of both of
- 36:37those for a while. It really depends on the value,
- 36:42where we start from and the risk of that function.
- 36:44I don't think I want a fully autonomous surgeon anytime soon,
- 36:49even though somebody's going to argue that that's perfectly
- 36:52capable. But should I have a fully
- 36:55autonomous response to a a set of systems going down that I've
- 37:00seen before and having a fully autonomous way of diagnosing the
- 37:04issue and being able to respond to that so it minimizes
- 37:07downtime. I absolutely should have agents
- 37:09that allow us to do that. So we're going to be doing a
- 37:12little bit of both. And so the CIO needs to be
- 37:15looking at that agent from what is it capable of doing, where do
- 37:19I need people, and what's the risk equation around that
- 37:22particular function? There's another piece to this
- 37:24too, that that they have to think about.
- 37:26I completely agree with what Isaac said.
- 37:29You have to understand where it's important to have the human
- 37:32in the loop and you have to understand where it's important
- 37:36to take the human out of the loop because in a number of
- 37:40different spaces today, today we have to be taking more humans
- 37:45out of the loop because our business is going to require
- 37:49that. Our competition, our
- 37:50adversaries. I mean, if you think about
- 37:52cybersecurity today, it is almost too slow in some
- 37:56functions to wait for a human to review a particular case, assess
- 38:01it, and then take action on it. By then, the damage is done.
- 38:05You need something that can identify, assess, and take
- 38:09action almost immediately because each second counts.
- 38:13Now that's just cybersecurity, but there are other aspects of
- 38:16the business that this is true too as well.
- 38:19So I do think it's important to understand the balance between
- 38:24where it's appropriate to be to bring a gentic in.
- 38:26And mind you, I am a huge proponent of a gentic when
- 38:30applied appropriately. But the other piece to this is
- 38:35really understanding how it works and how to start bringing
- 38:39that automation in in an appropriate way that you have
- 38:42the right balance of opportunity and risk.
- 38:44What about Shadow IT? So what is the impact of agentic
- 38:49AI on Shadow IT? Is agentic AI creating a new
- 38:53wave or variant of Shadow IT And do we care?
- 38:58And what do we do about it, if we do care?
- 39:00It's another variant of something that has always
- 39:03existed inside IT and will continue to exist, you know, as
- 39:07long as the tools make capabilities available.
- 39:11We're going to be striding that way between what we want people
- 39:14to self-service and try out, what are some of the things that
- 39:19we don't want them to touch at all, and one, have no capability
- 39:22to purchase, acquire, use in any shape or form inside our
- 39:27enterprise. And then there's a lot of Gray
- 39:29area in between that is focused on context, right?
- 39:33I have the tool in place. I've signed up Copilot.
- 39:37I have a license for it. I said yes to it, but it's being
- 39:40used in a way that I probably don't want this to be be used in
- 39:43that way. One of the things that
- 39:46organizations are terrible at doing is marrying in that I want
- 39:52to experiment to how do we capture the knowledge of that
- 39:56experiment and capture the end of result of that experiment,
- 40:00right? Should somebody be doing that
- 40:02experiment at all in that tool with that data?
- 40:05And if the answer is yes, how do we learn from it?
- 40:08Whether it passed, failed, or needs to continue on, That's the
- 40:12missing gap that's always impacted Shadow IT, and it needs
- 40:15to be addressed with Shadow AI because it's our subject matter
- 40:19experts. In their departments using these
- 40:22tools that are telling us what's working and what's not working.
- 40:26And why are they telling us that?
- 40:28Because they're the ones that understand the business the
- 40:30best. They're the closest to the
- 40:32problem. And so you will end up with
- 40:35things like a gentic sprawl. Again, something else I've
- 40:38written about, but you're going to end up with with a number of
- 40:42these issues. I don't necessarily think that's
- 40:45a bad thing, but you have to make sure that you have the
- 40:48appropriate guardrails in place so that you're not creating
- 40:51undue risk for the organization. Well, there's a whole set of
- 40:54governance challenges that start to emerge.
- 40:58And in a way it's not much different from Shadow IT in the
- 41:03past where you had lots of people in departments buying SAS
- 41:07products using their credit card.
- 41:10And eventually you can have fragmented data.
- 41:12You can bypass corporate compliance standards.
- 41:17Those who can also be great sources of innovation too.
- 41:21And I think this is this is part of the problem is what is your
- 41:24orientation for shadow IT or shadow AI and how are you
- 41:30encouraging or discouraging that?
- 41:32There are a number of IT leaders that flatly will say shadow IT
- 41:36is a very bad thing for the organization full stop.
- 41:41I personally don't agree with that.
- 41:43I have seen opportunity or seen examples where the opportunities
- 41:48that come from those, those little experiments and again,
- 41:51you got to put guardrails on you can't you just can't be the
- 41:54wild, Wild West and let everybody run and do whatever.
- 41:57So it's not living at the extremes of all yes or all no.
- 42:01There is a lot of middle ground there.
- 42:03That is fertile opportunity. And when we start talking about
- 42:06AI and now we're talking about something that requires it's not
- 42:12an option anymore, it requires intimate understanding of your
- 42:15business, that's even more fertile.
- 42:18And so we have to make sure that we as IT leaders put the right
- 42:21guardrails in place, but encourage that innovation
- 42:26because that's where those great beams of light are going to come
- 42:30from and the great opportunities.
- 42:32I think that shadow IT highlights gaps where IT and
- 42:39technology is not fulfilling the need and therefore is a great,
- 42:46very fertile ground for discovering what folks in the
- 42:50organization need. But Tim, the question then
- 42:53becomes, what kind of governance challenges do autonomous agents
- 42:59create? This is part and parcel of the
- 43:01shadow agent problem. If you are thinking of how to
- 43:06put governance in place as a bolt on, you will fail.
- 43:10But if you're thinking about how you how you put governance in
- 43:14place all the way from technology solutions to culture.
- 43:19So starting to change your culture and supporting employees
- 43:24to understand why these policies and why these governance models
- 43:27are, are actually there. You help them stay out of harm's
- 43:31way. I mean, in most cases, folks
- 43:34that, that you, you look at what they do from a shadow IT
- 43:37perspective and you go, why'd you do this?
- 43:41And you dig into the reasons why.
- 43:43It's not because they're trying to be malicious against your
- 43:45organization or against the company.
- 43:47They're just trying to do something better.
- 43:49They're trying to get their job done right.
- 43:52They might go outside of the bounds of a particular policy,
- 43:55but let's be honest, at this point, most enterprises have so
- 43:59many policies on top of policies that nobody, nobody in the
- 44:04organization truly understands all of those policies.
- 44:07And that's a whole nother bureaucracy problem that maybe
- 44:11we can start to use AI to kind of work through.
- 44:15But I do think if you start with governance from the get go and
- 44:18it's cross functional, you start to address some of these issues
- 44:22right out of the gate. Isaac, help us out here with
- 44:24some of these governance challenges and what do we do
- 44:27about it? The answer isn't just creating
- 44:29another buck of of policies. I mean, we need policies, but
- 44:34most people aren't going to read them.
- 44:35So we need to simplify some of the language around this.
- 44:39One way of doing that, you know, I recommend CI OS sees those
- 44:44come together and define some of the non negotiables, right?
- 44:49Things that you're absolutely not going to do, you're not
- 44:52going to copy PII information out of your CRM system and paste
- 44:57it into an open LLM. And here's why that is a non
- 45:02negotiable, OK. And then at some point between
- 45:05non negotiables and policies, there's a bunch of principles
- 45:10that we want to leave our organizational leaders and our
- 45:13employees with some good criteria for decision making.
- 45:18I've put Excel out into my organization.
- 45:20Everybody has a copy of it on their desktop.
- 45:23If a single person's using an Excel to do a job for a single
- 45:27day or a single week to solve a problem, probably not an issue.
- 45:31That Excel grows into something 100 people have access to,
- 45:36that's being updated every single day and has all kinds of
- 45:39corporate information to it, maybe I'd be able to be talking
- 45:42to it about getting some help about operationalizing it.
- 45:46Those are things that you can codify in simple principles
- 45:49because ultimately the boundary around Shadow IT or Shadow AI
- 45:54is, you know, where do you want to give people direction and
- 45:57where do you actually trust people to make good decisions.
- 46:00I think we're talking about skills here.
- 46:02What kind of skills gap in IT has AI created and what should
- 46:09CIOs do about that burgeoning skills gap that arises because
- 46:17of the growth of AI and agentic AI?
- 46:20You got to start with business acumen.
- 46:22I mean, you just cannot be an engineer or developer sitting
- 46:27behind a screen and just focusing on executing your
- 46:31day-to-day job. It's got to start there.
- 46:33It's got to go on to critical thinking, being able to use any
- 46:38of the AI tools and be able to ask the right questions and then
- 46:42evaluate the answers around that.
- 46:44And if I needed to pick one single skill that everybody
- 46:48needs to have today, it's data skills, right?
- 46:50Because ultimately that's what these systems are using, Being
- 46:54able to understand what data is being used to actually make a
- 46:58decision, or what data is being used to support a recommendation
- 47:04coming in out of an AI. We need people to make
- 47:07independent evaluations around that.
- 47:09Absolutely, business acumen, critical thinking, critical
- 47:13thinking, critical thinking, critical thinking like that.
- 47:15That is so, so important. But the other thing that's
- 47:18important is curiosity. And these are things that you
- 47:21can't necessarily teach, but you absolutely should be hiring too.
- 47:26I'm the the ways that that I've been advising companies and the
- 47:29ways I've done it in my organization is hire to the soft
- 47:32skills. You can teach the hard stuff all
- 47:34day, all night. You can teach about data, you
- 47:36can teach about technology, getting people to be more
- 47:39curious and understanding, like where their inspiration comes
- 47:43from. That's that's quite a bit harder
- 47:45to to go down and you have to ask yourself like, am I really
- 47:49going to put the energy in to really expound upon that?
- 47:52But the other thing is encouraging people and creating
- 47:55a culture within your organization that helps them
- 47:59understand how they can be inspirational and tap into that
- 48:03curiosity that they already have.
- 48:05For decades we've been, we've been hammering people down and
- 48:08just knocking them down right, left and center and not giving
- 48:11them the right tools and capabilities for them to really
- 48:15shine. We need that now more than ever
- 48:18because the the people is what's going to help us differentiate
- 48:21even in the era of AI. And on this topic, we have a
- 48:27question from Elizabeth Shaw on Twitter who says, how can you
- 48:33apply lessons learned in AI pilots to new AI initiatives and
- 48:38pilots, even if it's understanding what not to do?
- 48:44So the learnings and this gets to the culture as well.
- 48:47Isaac, you want to jump into this one?
- 48:49Yeah, it comes back down to basic scientific methods that
- 48:53we've learned in schools that often forget about, right.
- 48:57Say what your objective is, say your approach, be disciplined
- 49:02about executing against that approach, logging the outcome of
- 49:08that one approach, and then pivoting and saying what are we
- 49:11doing next? And sometimes that's going
- 49:13deeper into the solution that you went into.
- 49:16Sometimes it's saying, you know what, we're going in a
- 49:18completely different direction. We now have some amazing tools
- 49:22at AI to dissect and to interpret all that information,
- 49:26but we have to get our organization to know that just
- 49:29tinkering with the tools isn't good enough.
- 49:32Knowledge sharing, knowledge capture, training, teaching,
- 49:37even marketing, our successes are all things that we want our
- 49:41leaders doing so that we continue to evolve how we're
- 49:44using these different AI capabilities.
- 49:46Tim, many CIOs are just surviving being able to execute
- 49:53their typical IT functions, let alone being able to drive new
- 49:58complex AI initiatives. Are these folks mortgaging their
- 50:04organization's future and sabotaging their own careers?
- 50:09Yes, Unfortunately, yes. I mean, this is really the the
- 50:14difference between the traditional and the
- 50:15transformational CIO. The transformational CIO is is
- 50:20going to have that more under control and have a plan to get
- 50:24them from where they are to where they need to be.
- 50:27The traditional CIO is drowning, absolutely drowning.
- 50:31They can't get beyond the everything from the technical
- 50:34debt all the way through to how do I start to introduce
- 50:37innovation into my organization to bring this full circle to
- 50:41where we talked about, right, the three legged race.
- 50:44How do I get others to view me and my organization, me as the
- 50:47IT leader in my organization as a strategic function as opposed
- 50:51to a cost center. And that takes work, right?
- 50:54The trains have to go on time, right?
- 50:56You have to do that, but at the same time, you have to quickly
- 51:00understand, do I have the right players on the team, right?
- 51:04We've talked about this for years and years, right?
- 51:06Do we have the right people on the right seats on the bus?
- 51:09Do we have the right people on the bus?
- 51:12Do we even have the right stinking bus?
- 51:14Like, I mean, there, there's a lot that has to come into play
- 51:18and the way the and it goes all the way to the IT leader, the
- 51:22way that that I LED IT many moons ago doesn't apply today.
- 51:29So we have to think differently about how we work as a leader.
- 51:34If I were to step into an operational role today, I would
- 51:37work very differently than how I would have worked even 10:15
- 51:42definitely 20 years ago. And that change, that switch
- 51:47hasn't happened yet. But that will actually help
- 51:50folks start to understand what is important, what is not
- 51:54important. And if it's not important and
- 51:56not moving the needle for the business, why are we still
- 51:58focused on it? I mean, there are so many sacred
- 52:02cows or, or perceived sacred cows within the IT organization.
- 52:08Organization, oh, we can't touch this because of X&Y&Z.
- 52:12Guess what? If it's not moving the needle,
- 52:14out it goes. We don't have time for that.
- 52:16We got to move on. And so there's some hard
- 52:19decisions that have to be made here.
- 52:21Isaac, given all of this, what does CIO greatness look like
- 52:27today? Very quickly please.
- 52:29I did a article on CIO and did keynotes on this last year.
- 52:32What does a world class IT organization look like in the
- 52:37Gen. AI era?
- 52:38Well, we've covered some of these things.
- 52:40You know, they're bringing high strategy and governance
- 52:43together. They're putting product
- 52:45management at the forefront of their organization so that they
- 52:48can drive real decisions around Rd. maps and outcomes.
- 52:52Another big thing I've been writing about, you know, Tim
- 52:56just said it, the operating model that worked inside IT 357
- 53:01years ago needs to get rewritten, right?
- 53:03We have new tools in IT that's going to change every single one
- 53:07of the functions that we have. So what we called agile, what we
- 53:12called DevOps and what we called data governance, data
- 53:14operations, that all needs to change.
- 53:17And then I want to end with just, you know, Tim, operating
- 53:21CI OS. We've had them for a very long
- 53:23time. You know, there are periods in
- 53:25certain industries where you can get away with that and there are
- 53:29periods where in certain industries CE OS can't get away
- 53:33with that. If you roll back to the early
- 53:362000s, if you were in retail, if you were in media B to C and you
- 53:40had an operating CIO working there, you were in trouble
- 53:43because the entire customer experience in business model was
- 53:46changing. I was part of that.
- 53:48If you are here 2026, every industry is going to be
- 53:52disrupted with AI. And if you have an operating CIO
- 53:55who is just focused on productivity and efficiencies
- 53:58and reliability, you're just not going to get there.
- 54:01Tim and tweet sized bite. What does CIO greatness look
- 54:06like today? It's focused on trying to become
- 54:10that transformational CIO that is very much business oriented
- 54:14first, that happens to have responsibility for technology.
- 54:18Focus on what is going to move the needle for your business and
- 54:22figure out how to jettison the rest of it.
- 54:25All right, and with that, Tim Crawford and Isaac Sukolic.
- 54:30Thank you both so much for being here.
- 54:33I'm so grateful that you were sharing your wisdom and your
- 54:37expertise with us today. Glad to be here.
- 54:39Thanks again, Michael. Always great Michael, I'm so
- 54:42glad to see you laughing. And everybody who watched and
- 54:50who asked such great questions, thank you.
- 54:52Now, before you go, subscribe to the CXO Talk newsletter, go to
- 54:57cxotalk.com. We, as I always say this, but
- 55:00it's really true. We have incredible shows that
- 55:03are coming up and you guys in the audience make it.
- 55:06You guys are amazing. So subscribe to the newsletter.
- 55:11We'll update you on when we have shows coming up and we want you
- 55:15to join us. Have a great day everybody, and
- 55:19we'll see you again next time. Thank you.