Latest / Psychology In Seattle Podcast / Psychopathic Therapists (2017 Rerun)
Transcript
- 0:07Hey, deserving listeners. Is just me today. I wanted to talk about
- 0:12psychopathic or narcissistic therapists and counselors. You know, people in the mental health
- 0:20field, professionals who have major personality issues that may or may not lead them
- 0:28to harm other people. So that's what I'm going to talk about today.
- 0:33This is the Psychology and Seattle podcast. I'm your host, doctor Kirk Honda.
- 0:37I'm a therapist and a professor. The reason why I want to talk
- 0:41about this is because famous patron Linden Lindon runs are the Facebook fan page fan
- 0:49group if you want to join that. He moderates that famous patron. Lyndon
- 0:53wrote in and said, hello Kirk, to what extent can people make it
- 0:57all the way to a profession as a therapist by having psychopathic or sadistic or
- 1:02narcissistic traits? Can a person make it into the profession despite having a cruel
- 1:07nature, a sadistic style, or a dominating personality? What checks and blocks
- 1:12are in place to hold back people like this from entering the profession. What
- 1:18are your experiences with people and the profession who have dark personalities? Is it
- 1:23something you encounter while teaching or supervising. Do the theories actually make successful therapists
- 1:30who are antisocial more effective at exploiting, instrumentalizing, objectifying, and abusing their
- 1:36clients. I understand that you might feel averse to discussing this topic, as
- 1:40it seems to cast a dark shadow over the profession. End of email excellent
- 1:46questions, famous patron Lennon. Before going into this, I want to say,
- 1:53I don't feel averse to talking about it. I guess I might have
- 1:57felt a verse talking about it before, but I don't know. I don't
- 2:00think so. So many of you have written me stories and accounts of therapists
- 2:07who are at the very least ineffective and at the worst are abusive to you,
- 2:15and I feel responsible for that. I'm embarrassed about it. These people
- 2:21make me look bad and they and I feel angry and sad about the whole
- 2:27thing. And I feel like it's part of my job to try to raise
- 2:31awareness about this problem and try to eliminate or reduce the incidents of this sort
- 2:38of thing. And I'll talk more about my recommendations in a second here.
- 2:44Okay, So another caveat before moving forward is that there is some research in
- 2:50this area, but not enough to really comment on. It's really hard to
- 2:55research this sort of thing. It's hard to gather a bunch of therapist together
- 3:00and have them be truthful about their personality or have them be truthful about their
- 3:06harmful tactics and this sort of thing. So it's hard to nail down in
- 3:13that way. But it's also just hard to study in that personality and psychology
- 3:16is extremely squishy. It's people will debate whether or not it's even a hard
- 3:22science, and I would too. It's just really hard to say anything concrete
- 3:29when it comes to this sort of thing. So what I'm about to talk
- 3:31about is my sense of things having been in the field for twenty years,
- 3:36my sense of things having worked with thousands of other therapists, and my sense
- 3:42of things having worked under many professionals who were faculty or supervisors of mine,
- 3:49and all just the wide variety of people I've worked with, And I feel
- 3:53like I can speak to this topic with some authority. Okay, so famous
- 3:59Patronlyn And to what extent can people make it all the way to a profession
- 4:03as a therapist despite having psychopathic, statistic or narcissistic traits. Well, what
- 4:09we call this in the profession is. We call it gate keeping. We
- 4:14are supervisors and faculty such as myself are. We are responsible for keeping the
- 4:20gate. We need to not let someone through the gate into the profession who
- 4:28has issues that will lead to them likely harming other people. And there's various
- 4:33research and literature on this. Sometimes they call the therapist and impaired, and
- 4:40they'll say, you need to keep the gate and prevent an impaired therapist from
- 4:44entering the field. I don't like that word. I'm actually writing about this
- 4:47in my upcoming book on supervision in somewhat of a detailed way regarding the terminology
- 4:55about all this, and I also go into a number of anecdotes regarding situations
- 4:59in which I have had to actually keep the gate and prevent some reformenting entering
- 5:02the field. But we all think about that supervisors, or will at least
- 5:08supervisors and faculty are supposed to think about it. And I can tell you
- 5:11from personal experience that all the other supervisors and faculty that I work with it's
- 5:16on their mind now, whether or not they live in it or exist in
- 5:21an organization or a system that allows them to actually have the power to keep
- 5:26the gate. Is another issue. There are faculty that I know who when
- 5:31they come across a student or supervis who seems to have a personality problem,
- 5:35that is a problem and will likely present a problem for them in there with
- 5:43clients and in their career, the faculty member almost always feels that anxiety.
- 5:48They almost always say something's wrong here now, whether or not the organization that
- 5:54they exist in supports them and their efforts to keep the gate, it's a
- 5:58whole other thing. And when I was chair, I really tried to support
- 6:01people with that, and in my program at Antioch University, I really try
- 6:06to support that. Having said that, it happens pretty rarely. Some people
- 6:11might think that it's something that happens frequently, but it's actually pretty rare that
- 6:15I identify someone in need of being prevented from entering the field. And I'll
- 6:20get more into that in a second as to why it actually doesn't have very
- 6:25often. Okay, so Lyndon, you're asking specifically about very specific, three
- 6:32specific personality types. So we have you're asking about psychopathic trainees or psychopathic therapists,
- 6:41meaning that they don't have empathy or compassion for other people. And then
- 6:45you're asking about sadistic people, meaning that they take pleasure in harming other people.
- 6:49And you're asking about narcissistic people, meaning that they're extremely self centered and
- 6:54self grandizing, that sort of thing so so hot. You're asking, have
- 7:00I encountered these these particular personalities in my profession? And the answer is absolutely,
- 7:06As with any other profession, there are psychopathic and narcissistic and sadistic people
- 7:13who who live in who work in that profession. If you took all the
- 7:17garbage men or men and women who work in collecting garbage, you would find
- 7:25the same distribution of personalities. If you look at politicians, you're going to
- 7:29see a similar distribution of personalities. Now, some personalities will tend to move
- 7:34into particular jobs, but but it's hard to generalize. I find that in
- 7:41any profession you're going to get a wide variety of personalities. And it's it.
- 7:46And there's there's slight increases in percentages, but but not any um.
- 7:51It's you know, some people will say, well, all CEOs are psychopathic,
- 7:55and it's like, that's ridiculous. The research doesn't support that. And
- 8:00now, might there be a somewhat increase incidents of psychopathy in upper ranks of
- 8:05executive positions. It's hard, again, hard to research, it's hard.
- 8:11It's hard to know that some research seemed to suggest that that CEOs and other
- 8:16types of positions like that tend to have somewhat more psychopathy in it. But
- 8:22it's such a hard thing because whenever you're talking about personality, you're asking for
- 8:26either the individual to report on their personality, which of course anyone can be
- 8:31distorted about that, or you're asking an outside observer to report on that person
- 8:39and observe and assess that person, And of course that's a hard thing to
- 8:41do. And before I entered the field of assessment, I I always thought
- 8:48that that psychologists had this magical ability to test people, that there are all
- 8:52these really complicated tests that would trick you into revealing who you are. And
- 8:58the fact is that that's just not true. There are some tests that help
- 9:01in that way that are a little tricky, but it's really just one of
- 9:07those things that will just at this point in our science, we just have
- 9:11no way of really locking this down. I mean, we barely understand the
- 9:13concepts that we're trying to measure, let alone actually measuring those concepts within people.
- 9:18So but anyway, So your question is, have I encountered statistic,
- 9:22narcissistic, psychopathic people in my profession? The answer is yes, absolutely.
- 9:28But here's the weird thing. The first thought that people will have because because
- 9:33sometimes I'll complain about someone at work or something, I'll just be like,
- 9:37oh my god, there's this person that I'm complaining about. And whenever I
- 9:41complain about that person to someone who doesn't work in my profession, they will
- 9:46say to me, how can that be? How can that person be a
- 9:48therapist? They'll say, you know, that is that person a therapist.
- 9:50They'll be like, yeah, that person is a therapist. And they'll say
- 9:54that person is crazy, They're insane. How are they possibly a therapist?
- 9:58They sound so immature, or so reactive, or just so confused about life.
- 10:05And when I first started in the profession, I remember thinking that too.
- 10:09I would look at my classmates or I'd look around at other people in
- 10:13the field, and I'd be like, man, something's wrong with that person.
- 10:16I'm sure they are terrible as a therapist. Well, here's the thing.
- 10:20After supervising and teaching and working alongside thousands of other professionals, what I'm
- 10:26here to tell you is that it's actually strangely the case that these problematic people
- 10:33can actually be excellent therapists. Sometimes their problems can actually help them as a
- 10:39therapist. But at the very least, what I've seen is a lot of
- 10:43times it doesn't hinder them. The thing that I can say is that being
- 10:48a therapist it's a job. It's it's something that you do for a living
- 10:54right. You don't do it for free. You do it because you get
- 10:56paid, and so all of us therapists are we're incentivized to try to provide
- 11:03the best service possible. And so let's say you're narcissistic and you are very
- 11:09self centered, and you have a hard time with empathy, but you can
- 11:15kind of access a version of empathy, or you can at least kind of
- 11:18fake empathy by listening a lot, and you learn over time, particularly as
- 11:24you're being trained, that that is required of you. And if you don't
- 11:28do that, no one wants to come see you, and you'll get complaints
- 11:31or something like that. So you know, it's sort of like, can
- 11:37a psychopathic person be a carrying nurse in a hospital? Can a psychopathic person
- 11:46be a nun in a convent and actually help human beings. Can a psychopathic
- 11:52person be a very friendly cashier? Adam McDonald's The answer is yes, because
- 11:58it's a job. They everyone understands that they're not in their normal They're not
- 12:01in their living room hanging out. They are at a job and they need
- 12:05to put on a certain persona in order to provide a service to people who
- 12:13are paying for a service. So, in some ways, what I'm saying
- 12:18is that these people, narcissistic, psychopathic, sadistic people can suppress their urges,
- 12:22or they can fake empathy and compassion. Another way of saying it is
- 12:28that they can access their empathy and compassion temporarily while they're at work. Having
- 12:37said that, though, there are plenty of therapists who are out there actively
- 12:41harming their clients, so it's not as if people who have personality problems are
- 12:48immune to harm. Having said that, it's not as if the people who
- 12:54harm their clients are necessarily narcissistic, psychopathic, or sadistic. There are plenty
- 12:58of therapists who are harmful to their clients that actually don't have a personality disorder.
- 13:05They're just either mistaken or they don't understand, or they're immature or something
- 13:09like that. But anyway, there are plenty of therapist who are narcissistic,
- 13:15who are stadistic, who are psychopathic, who actually are harming their client.
- 13:18All I got to do is listen to episodes that I've made before about this
- 13:22topic. The most recent one was a therapist what was it called a therapist
- 13:28loses his license? I think? Is that what I called it. There
- 13:31was a whole series that I did, I think three different episodes. A
- 13:35therapist kisses his client. This therapist, I don't know him, but he
- 13:41lost his license a patron. A patron wrote in about the full account of
- 13:48what he did. He was very sexually exploitative is the word for it.
- 13:54And my very distant assessment is that there is something wrong with his personality given
- 14:01his behavior. That it's not just a misunderstanding or anything. There's something.
- 14:07There's something deeply wrong with the guy, and and it led him to be
- 14:13sexually exploitative in this really stupid way. That again, this is all just
- 14:18distance assessment. I have no idea who this guys. I've never met him,
- 14:22but from the client's account of what had happened, and from his account
- 14:28because I actually read his his his session notes, because she gave them to
- 14:31me. He just, um, he was exhibiting narcissism in that he was
- 14:39doing all these exploitative things sexually to his client and he didn't even recognize that
- 14:45they might be a problem. And in his notes he was he wasn't justifying
- 14:48it, he was just talking about it. Someone who isn't narcissistic or psychopathic
- 14:56would at least recognize that what they're doing is wrong, and they would try
- 15:00to sort of cover their cover their ass in their progress notes, right,
- 15:03they would say like, well, she asked me to do it, and
- 15:07there people would figure out a way to sort of cover their tracks. But
- 15:11this guy had nothing in there and about that he just he just he was
- 15:16completely thought that his sexually exploitive escalation with this client was completely okay. And
- 15:24there's something you've There's got to be something wrong with you. There's got to
- 15:28be something different about your personality that would lead you to think that way,
- 15:33because all of us therapists are at the very least paranoid about most of us
- 15:41are paranoid about doing anything wrong. So the fact that he didn't have any
- 15:48red flags seeming now maybe had tons of red flags. I don't know.
- 15:52But anyway, there in my experience, there are definitely people who have personality
- 15:56disorders who are actually out there harming their clients. Can watch the Netflix show
- 16:00Gypsy for an example of this. It's not a very satisfying show. I
- 16:04did a whole episode on it, but but it provides an example of someone
- 16:10who has a personality issue that's a therapist. When these people are doing bad
- 16:15things to their clients psycho psycho psychopaths and narcssistic people, it's not usually horrible.
- 16:22It's it's not usually like what you might have in the movies where like
- 16:27in Gypsy or something, or in another movie where the therapist is actively i
- 16:33don't know, poisoning the client or trying to kill the client or try to
- 16:38manipulate the client into becoming a slave or something. It's not usually like that.
- 16:44It's usually more subtle and mild than that. Like with the example that
- 16:49I had with the therapist that lost this license, it was bad, but
- 16:56he at any given time, the client was given some power to push back,
- 17:03and at a certain point it got too much for her and she did
- 17:06push back, and he tried to convince her to come back to therapy,
- 17:10but he wasn't super pushy or manipulative about it, and so it was bad
- 17:17and terrible and he lost his license and he should have lost his license.
- 17:21But but the degree of the maliciousness or something is, in my experience,
- 17:26it's not usually very intense. You know, it's predatory, but it's not.
- 17:34There are ways in which a therapist, if they really wanted to use
- 17:37their power to harm someone, they could actually really amp it up. Now
- 17:42can a therapist, and do therapists in rare circumstances use their power to absolutely
- 17:49harm their clients? Yeah, it happens that I've heard those stories from listeners,
- 17:53but it's it's not very frequent. Again, this is speculation based on
- 18:00anecdotal experience. But if you're a harmful person's particularly a sadistic person, or
- 18:06if you're really out to get people, being a therapist isn't really the best
- 18:10job to have because there's so many things that you there's so many reasons why
- 18:17you have to be compassionate and caring and selfless that it would be either difficult
- 18:22to exploit others or you would be detected pretty quickly. There are plenty of
- 18:29jobs outside of the field of mental health in which will not only allow you
- 18:34to be exploitative, but will actually actually reward you. You know, one
- 18:40job that pops into my mind is sales. Right, if you're a car
- 18:44salesman. Now again, plenty of car salesman are compassionate, nice people who
- 18:48are just doing their jobs. But but imagine that you know, you're a
- 18:51narcissistic, psychopathic person and you're really out for your own personal gain. If
- 18:56you're a car salesman, you're gonna be rewarded for your predatory practices. Right
- 19:03tricking some vulnerable person into buying a car, you get a commission, and
- 19:10it's sort of expected in society that, well, you're a car salesman and
- 19:12that's your job. You're supposed to try to get the sale. So now
- 19:18again, sometimes I talk crap about other professions and people will email me,
- 19:22and rightfully. So recently I said something about how therapists are the only ones.
- 19:30I think I was talking with Bob in an episode and I said something
- 19:34to the effect of therapists are the only people who worry about charging their clients
- 19:41too much or something, And I think I said something like, you know,
- 19:44I don't think heart surgeons worry about their salaries. And that's a pretty
- 19:48gross generalization. There's plenty of physicians and I'm guessing heart surgeons as well,
- 19:55who absolutely try to establish some quality regarding their service and their their salaries.
- 20:04There are plenty of professions that involve people who are very caring and actually do
- 20:10worry about their salaries. I think what I was saying that episode was that
- 20:15it's it's funny to me whenever I talk with therapists, it's it's universal one
- 20:19hundred percent of the time, especially therapists who are just starting out. They
- 20:25all have this guilt about charging their clients for service. And I just I
- 20:33think what I should have said, or maybe I did say this in that
- 20:36past episode, was that it's just ridiculous that as a profession, as professionals,
- 20:42we would feel guilty for making a living. It's just just a silly
- 20:48thing. And I think what I was saying is I wonder what other professions
- 20:52worry about this in the same way. And I'm guessing there are people and
- 20:56other professions that never worry about this. They don't say, oh, I
- 21:00don't like to charge from my service. I think a part of that comes
- 21:04from the innate, compassionate quality of therapists. You know, if you're compassionate
- 21:11and caring and social justice oriented, then you're attracted to the field of mental
- 21:15health. So it's a certain sort of person who enters the field that's going
- 21:19to say stuff like that. But another factor is ninety nine point nine percent
- 21:23of us all started out as unpaid interns. We were volunteers who were volunteering
- 21:30our time during our graduate training. And also at that time, most of
- 21:37us felt as though we didn't even deserve to be an intern. There's this
- 21:42self esteem problem in a lot of a lot of mental health professionals, and
- 21:47so we feel when we're starting out in the profession, we're like, well,
- 21:52please let me volunteer at your place so I can work for free.
- 21:56And then when you graduate, you feel like, well, sure, I'm
- 22:00not good enough to be paid for this job yet, because I'm you know,
- 22:03I'm a piece of shit. And so because you're treated like a piece
- 22:06of shit when you're an intern, and so I'm always trying to turn that
- 22:11around with my new therapist. I'm trying to pump them up by saying,
- 22:15you're a professional, you are a highly specialized clinician, you deserve to get
- 22:21paid and don't ever have guilt about getting paid and even potentially paid kind of
- 22:26well, because again, you're a highly specialized clinician who actually has value in
- 22:32the society anyway. So yeah, So on one hand, it's weird that
- 22:40I have come across people who seem very odd and very undifferentiated and very personality
- 22:48problematic sort of people, and yet when I actually look into it, their
- 22:52work with their clients is going pretty well. I've even had supervisees like that
- 22:57who I look at them and I'm like, and there's something off about your
- 23:02personality. I mean, I've supervised hundreds of people. So again, law
- 23:07of averages, I'm going to come across some people that have problematic personalities,
- 23:11and then with those people, I really start to look into their clients and
- 23:15actually listen, make sure I observe more of their sessions, maybe even talk
- 23:19with some of their clients, and really try to make sure that this therapist
- 23:25is providing a good service. And what I find is that a lot of
- 23:29times these people provide excellent service to their clients. And my guess is that
- 23:36when they sit down in that chair as a therapist, they put on a
- 23:40very professional, clinical persona that actually allows them to be helpful. Now,
- 23:45as soon as they go home, their life is falling apart, but when
- 23:48they actually go to work they can hold it together. Having said that,
- 23:52like I said, there are plenty of people with personality problems or not that
- 23:56are actually out there harming their clients in a very real way. Okay,
- 24:00so let's go on to your next question here, lyndon, what checks and
- 24:03blocks are in place to hold back people like this from entering the field?
- 24:08Checks and blocks? Is that a Is that a Irish? You're from Ireland,
- 24:14right, I know, I've pretty sure from Ireland, and um checks
- 24:19and blocks In the United States, we might say, what do you call
- 24:22it? Checks and balance? Anyway? What checks and blocks are in place
- 24:26to hold back people like the st entering the profession? Well, we do
- 24:32have some checks and blocks we have we have the complaint system, right,
- 24:37you can complain to the licensing board given that the person is a licensed professional,
- 24:42because coaches are not licensed. But if you're a marriage, family therapist,
- 24:47counselor psychologist, social worker, psychiatrist, nursed practitioner, then your your
- 24:52license. The state holds you to a certain requirement for licensure and so you
- 24:59can complain to that state licensing board as a way of taking away a license
- 25:06or sanctioning a license or something. And you know, it's it's it's a
- 25:11good system, but many clients don't know about it, or they don't even
- 25:15know how to use it, or they get bogged down and all the paperwork
- 25:19and everything, and so the complaint the licensing board system could be a little
- 25:26better, in my opinion, a little bit more ease of access, so
- 25:30to speak, and maybe a little quicker in its response time. It also
- 25:36lacks teeth in my opinion. Whenever I have come across therapists who have had
- 25:42a successful complaint waged against them, I'm always surprised at how soft the punishment
- 25:49is. So but you know, I guess rehabilitation is better than just punishing
- 25:56someone. But anyway, so we have the complaint Department of l system.
- 26:02We also have the civil court system. You can sue someone, right,
- 26:04but it's really difficult to sue a therapist. It's a very ambiguous area of
- 26:10trying to demonstrate to a jury or to a judge that you were harmed by
- 26:15a therapist. Plus a therapist can pretty easily if they wanted to, they
- 26:21could pretty easily drum up a narrative that makes the client look like a crazy
- 26:26person, and people tend to believe therapists over clients, and so the civil
- 26:32court civil courts there, and it's definitely something that has been used effectively to
- 26:38put an end to harmful therapists. But it's something of a bad situation,
- 26:45and that we're sort of waiting for something bad to happen and then waiting for
- 26:52that one brave client who has time to step forward and privileged to do so,
- 26:56to actually step forward. It's not actually trying to prevent it from happening.
- 27:02Right. That's where faculty and supervisors come in in terms of in terms
- 27:07of gate keeping preventing people from entering the field. But I'm here to tell
- 27:11you, as someone who has been tasked with gate keeping hundreds of maybe thousands
- 27:17of people over the past twenty years, I'm here to tell you that it's
- 27:19pretty difficult to detect a therapist who is going to be harmful. As I
- 27:25said, I have looked into therapists who seem like they're going to be harmful,
- 27:27and then I look into them and I realized that they're not harmful.
- 27:32So just just because someone comes across as weird or odd or even defensive.
- 27:37It doesn't necessarily mean that they're harmful. In fact, they could be excellent
- 27:40therapist. That's what's strange about it. So there's that confusion, and if
- 27:45someone is harmful, it's hard to detect because we're just not there that.
- 27:49The nature of supervision and the nature of being a faculty member is that the
- 27:56intern or the chinee is out there in the field by themselves, behind closed
- 28:00doors, providing a service to someone for several hours a day to several different
- 28:07clients, and the supervisor is outside of that office, and the supervisor relies
- 28:14on the trainee to report what's happening, And if a trainee decides to omit
- 28:19certain details, then the trainee is going to omit certain details. So it's
- 28:26hard to monitor that situation, and you know, it's a problem. The
- 28:32solution that I would propose is that to all this is that we need to
- 28:37increase awareness about this problem. In general. We need society to understand and
- 28:42the professional understand that there are clients out there being harmed or treated unfairly.
- 28:48Because I think there's this general belief that therapists are all good or that it's
- 28:55a rare thing, and yeah, I mean we could say it's rare,
- 28:59but it's common enough that I don't think we're doing enough to put it into
- 29:03it, particularly kind of like the low grade stuff, like clients who are
- 29:07late all the time, or who talk about themselves too much, or are
- 29:11a little physically inappropriate with their clients or something. So we need to raise
- 29:17awareness that this is indeed a problem. We also need to increase the general
- 29:22public's awareness about what to do if they are bothered or harmed by their therapist.
- 29:29If you just pulled the average client and said, Okay, let's say
- 29:33you don't like what your therapists is doing, what do you do? I
- 29:37would guess through anecdotal experience that most clients would be like, I have no
- 29:41idea. They might have a general sense that they could report the person to
- 29:45the government, but they don't know where to go. Now, all that
- 29:49information is supposed to be in the disclosure statement, and it's in mind,
- 29:53but how many people actually know it's in the disclosure statement or even where the
- 29:57disclosure statement is. And so it's a it's a hard thing for people to
- 30:02know about, and I think that we need to increase awareness so that people
- 30:06can actually utilize those systems. We also need to increase the rigor of supervision.
- 30:12We need to again, my upcoming book on supervision talks a lot about
- 30:17this. Supervision is an extremely important responsibility that is often not taken as seriously
- 30:23as it needs to be, and supervisors need to be watching more carefully and
- 30:29they need to take the gate keeping responsibility very, very seriously. I know
- 30:34supervisors who will say things like, well, you know, they'll sort of
- 30:38kick the can down the road and just be like, well, you know
- 30:41that. I'm sure someone else will come across this supervise and deal with this,
- 30:45but I just don't really want to deal with it. We also need
- 30:49more direct observation and supervision, which basically just means more money. So right
- 30:55now I have I don't know, a dozen supervisees, twenty supers or something,
- 31:00and for the most part, whenever I supervise them, it's us meeting
- 31:07either one on one or in a group situation, and the supervise the trainee
- 31:11is telling me what they did in session and then and then if I do
- 31:18directly observe, it's usually through audio recording, so so the supervisor will record
- 31:23their sessions and then they'll play that audio for me. Well, they get
- 31:30to choose which session they record, they get to choose what clip of that
- 31:33session they play for me. And so if someone was a terrible therapist,
- 31:37they could probably hide that from me for a long period of time. Or
- 31:41if someone is a terrible therapist, I might not detect it for a while
- 31:45because I just don't have'm because I'm not watching that carefully. So now that's
- 31:52not because I'm lazy. That's because the system is such that I'm actually de
- 31:59incentivized to watch people more closely because it requires a lot more time and effort
- 32:05for me to watch them more closely that I'm not actually going to get paid
- 32:07for, or I would have to charge the supervisees for it, which would
- 32:13drastically increase the cost of supervision to them. So so what I do is
- 32:17I just follow the standard of supervision, which is basically what I'm describing now.
- 32:23Some supervisors out there will actually watch their supervisees behind a one way mirror,
- 32:29or they'll be in the same room with them all the time, and
- 32:30so some supervisors have that luxury, but most supervisors, in my experience,
- 32:35don't have that luxury. And so what I would propose is that if we're
- 32:39going to do a better job gatekeeping and a better job watching for problematic therapists,
- 32:46there needs to be more money in the whole system, which basically means
- 32:52more tax dollars spent on this, so that supervisors can actually spend more time
- 32:59observing the supervise these work. We also might benefit from having longer periods of
- 33:07supervision or more requirements for supervision. Now, all of you new therapists and
- 33:13interns out there are probably groaning when I say that, because you are already
- 33:16required to do so much supervision. And maybe what I should say is maybe
- 33:22not more supervision, but just better supervision the whole field of supervision. And
- 33:28again I write about this all in my book and provide many anecdotal stories,
- 33:32including stories in which I have made mistakes as supers. As a supervisor,
- 33:37the state of supervision is pretty bad in my opinion, and according to a
- 33:43lot of research that I lay out in my book. And so if there
- 33:46was better supervision, presumably there would be a therapist would be less likely to
- 33:52be harm focused, they'd better trained, and also therapists would be more likely
- 33:58to be detected if they were harmful and therefore gate kept. Anyway for moving
- 34:02forward, let's take a break. What do you say? All right,
- 34:10we're back. If you haven't become a patron yet, please become a patron
- 34:15of the podcast by going to patreon dot com. When you become a patron
- 34:19of the podcast, you get access to hundreds of our patron only episodes.
- 34:25And also there's no ads for patrons, so if you're a patron of the
- 34:30podcast, you don't have to sit through any ads, which I think is
- 34:32a big benefit. All right, So Lyndon asked some of our questions here.
- 34:37He asked, do the theories actually make successful therapists who are antisocial more
- 34:40effective at exploiting, instrumentalizing, objectifying, and using their clients? Yeah?
- 34:45I mean we all do this, honestly, We're all all. All therapists
- 34:50are prone to using our theories and our power and our prolivate privilege to harm
- 34:55anyone, even if it's not clients. We are prone to do it to
- 35:00our spouses. You know, whenever a therapist gets into a fight with their
- 35:06spouse, they at least have a temptation to say, look, I'm the
- 35:09expert on communication and relationships. And you're not, and so let me tell
- 35:15you how you're wrong. So it's just it's just human nature. When whenever
- 35:20anyone has power they are they're likely at least to be tempted to use that
- 35:24power when it suits them, right, And so therapists are no different than
- 35:29this. And I've experienced this. I had a professor who a long time
- 35:34ago, who had tremendous power over my life, and I was terrified of
- 35:38her and she would just randomly abuse me in class and outside of class,
- 35:44so I never knew when she would strike, and I was always just walking
- 35:49around on eggshells around or just just terrified of when the next time she would
- 35:53come down hard on me. And I'll never forget this one time we had
- 35:58this one on one meeting and I it was some sort of supervision or some
- 36:02sort of consultation, just regular teacher student interaction. And I went into that
- 36:07movie and into that into that meeting saying, I want to have a I
- 36:12want to try to build a relationship with her because I feel like for some
- 36:15reason, she you know, has it out for me. And so maybe
- 36:17if I am really nice to her and we can build a relationship and she
- 36:22can stop attacking me all the time, and so I was. I was
- 36:28trying to build this relationship with her, and we having this conversation and all
- 36:31I was just trying to do was just to please her. I was just
- 36:35I'll just trying to make her happy. Everything she said. I was like,
- 36:37oh, okay, good. So I was because I was again I
- 36:39was trying to um, you know, build this relationship with her, and
- 36:44as we were talking about various different issues, she somehow manipulated the conversation into
- 36:51this zone that I suddenly realized we were we were talking about my privilege over
- 36:57her. And it wasn't until like later that I had to analyze the whole
- 37:04conversation. I was like, wait, how did we get to a place
- 37:07where the main guestat of the conversation was that I had power over her?
- 37:15Which was ridiculous because I had no power over her, and she had all
- 37:17this power over me and she was always using it against me. Well,
- 37:24again, I'm not this person's assessor or clinician, but this professor has a
- 37:30profound personality problem. I had so much contact with her that I can tell
- 37:36you that with high levels of confidence, particularly because it's not only me but
- 37:42there's hundreds of other people who have experienced it too. And I've talked with
- 37:45dozens of other people about this particular professor, and they will they'll all say
- 37:51the same thing. They'll just be like, Yep, that was my experience
- 37:53too. And I've talked with co workers of hers, and blah blah blah,
- 37:58and so there was some thing profoundly wrong with this person's personality and she
- 38:05would manipulate people into she would use her power essentially to intimidate and control other
- 38:12people, and to make everyone feel as though they needed her, and to
- 38:17make everyone feel as though they were blessed to have attention from her. It
- 38:22was this very, very excellent way of manipulating everyone around her, and many
- 38:30people fell for it. But the more contact you had with her, the
- 38:32more you realized that something was wrong, and the more you talk to other
- 38:37people, the more you realized, oh, this isn't just me, Because
- 38:42she had a way of making it feel like you were crazy and that there
- 38:45was something wrong with you. She also was kind of smart. She had
- 38:50at least enough knowledge to come across as like someone of authority, and she
- 38:55so anyway, I'm in this conversation, I'm just trying to please her,
- 38:58and at this point, I think it's just me. I didn't realize that
- 39:00all these other people were suffering from her. So I'm trying to be nice.
- 39:04I'm trying to be nice. And then she somehow turns the conversation around
- 39:07to saying that I had all this privilege and power over her, and that
- 39:13I would need to be responsible with that power, and that I needed to
- 39:17acknowledge my privilege over her, and so I started so at the moment,
- 39:22I'm like, okay, yeah, yeah, I acknowledge my power. And
- 39:25she's like, so, what are you going to do with that privilege?
- 39:28And I'm like, oh, well, I'm going to become more humble and
- 39:30I'm gonna try to help you out with that, and she's like good.
- 39:35And then I just felt completely insane, and again I would I left that
- 39:40conversation and then went on this whole, you know, epic journey regarding my
- 39:45feelings about it and reaching out to other people. And then I looked back
- 39:50and I was just like, my god, that was masterful. How she
- 39:52got me to say those things and to believe them. You know, there's
- 39:59a certain level of we might call it psychopathy or we might call it narcissism.
- 40:06We might call it just something generally wrong with someone's personality. We called
- 40:10we could maybe we could even say she's traumatized or terribly insecure. Something is
- 40:16deeply wrong with someone that would create such such feelings in so many different people.
- 40:24So many people around her were terrified of her, so many people around
- 40:28her didn't like her, So many people around her had to go to therapy
- 40:31just to cope with being around her. I mean, I knew people that
- 40:35worked with her that went to therapy for two years just because they just had
- 40:40to deal with her at work. And she was she has she's so toxic.
- 40:45Okay, So, and she was a clinician, she was a therapist,
- 40:52and it's hard to imagine her being a good therapist. But I had
- 40:59had no reason to believe that she That she was a bad therapist was the
- 41:02thing. Now, I didn't have access. She was by professor, I
- 41:05didn't have access to her clients. But given my experience of other people like
- 41:09her, when I do have that power, I'm here to tell you that
- 41:12sometimes those people actually can be good therapists. That's what's so weird about this.
- 41:15Now, she could also be extremely exploitative and harmful and horrible. There's
- 41:20also that possibility as well, and I actually saw some evidence of that.
- 41:23She had some weird boundaries that she had with students and stuff. Hard to
- 41:29tell, but anyway, so and so I could I could tell you a
- 41:34story after story of people like this that I've bumped into in the field.
- 41:37It's actually kind of weird. I was thinking about this as I was preparing
- 41:42for this episode, and the people that scare me the most, the people
- 41:46who I've been traumatized as an adult the most, are people who are in
- 41:54the field. Now, you could say it's because I've been in the field
- 41:59for so long that most of the sort of randos that I have to deal
- 42:02with are in the field. So maybe it's just the a factor of that.
- 42:06But if I was to catalog like the four people on this planet that
- 42:13I really despise, they are people in the field that I've had to work
- 42:16with, and it's just hard to imagine them being good therapists. But again,
- 42:22as I said, it's hard to know if they're bad therapists or not.
- 42:25Are they exploitative of their coworkers and of their students and their supervisees?
- 42:30Absolutely I've absolutely seen that. I've seen people who have issues with their personality.
- 42:39Well, let's just put it this way. If you're in a position
- 42:43of power, particularly, the more power you have and the more people you
- 42:46have power over, the more likely that apart whatever sort of personality flaw you
- 42:52have, it's the more likely it is that that flaw is going to become
- 42:57problematic for somebody. You know, if if you're if you have no one
- 43:00under you, and you you just go to work and you do what you're
- 43:05told, then your personality flaws don't don't don't usually come out in that situation,
- 43:10and if they do, it means that your personality flaw is very intense.
- 43:15But when I was program director, I had dozens of professors who were
- 43:22working under me. I had hundreds of students who were underneath me. I
- 43:25had all of these on site supervisors and staff people at the university. And
- 43:30I had to deal with so many people when I was program director, which
- 43:36is part of the reason why I didn't like that job. It was just
- 43:37too overwhelming. There's too many people I had to manage, and and when
- 43:44I was in a bad mood, people people knew it, you know,
- 43:47because I had power, and I didn't have to mask my bad new my
- 43:52bad mood to those people, or at least I didn't feel like it.
- 43:54And so so if I was parly, you know, grumpy that day,
- 44:02or if I was feeling the need to be narcissistic in a moment, or
- 44:07if I felt the need to gain some control or something, because I had
- 44:10power and because I was in contact with so many people, people would feel
- 44:15it. I'm guessing no one ever said anything, but if they were to
- 44:17be truthful, I'm guessing they would say that. And so so the people
- 44:22that I have been affected by our people and who have power over me essentially
- 44:28or at least on the same level, and their personality issues come out.
- 44:34So anyway, yeah, I could. I could tell you so many horrible
- 44:37stories. They're not on the level of like murders or sexual assaults or anything,
- 44:44but they are. They're on the level of bullying. Let's just put
- 44:46it that way, Like there's there's in my profession, there are isolated individuals
- 44:52who have the sort of personalities that lead them to bully other people, probably
- 45:00not their clients. Now, let me just comment a little bit on something
- 45:05else. The psychopathy as a personality is on a spectrum, right, And
- 45:13there are various different elements and components of psychopathy. Well, one of the
- 45:17elements of psychopathy is that you don't care about society's rules as much as someone
- 45:23else does. And to become a therapist, you kind of have to be
- 45:28at least a little psychopathic in that you have compassions. So it's not a
- 45:34matter of not having empathy. But you're not a rule follower. Therapists generally
- 45:38are are not super rule following sort of people. Now, you might be
- 45:45the sort of person who likes to follow rules, but you definitely have a
- 45:50thing about you definitely have a question about society. Right, if you're a
- 45:53therapist, you're thinking, well, you know, some of society's rules are
- 45:59okay, but some of them are not. Well, that just that questioning
- 46:02of society and that little bit of pushback on the establishment is is on the
- 46:09psychopathic spectrum. It's it's just like the beginning of the psychopathic spectrum or what
- 46:15we call the psycho what you call it psycho deviancy or it's one of the
- 46:22it's one of the measures on the MMPI. But anyway, so there's that.
- 46:25So therapists often score high or at least a little bit higher than normal
- 46:32in that in the psychopathic deviancy realm. Another thing that therapists tend to be
- 46:39is narcissistic because the belief that you can help people and the belief that you
- 46:47are special enough to help someone requires you to have a little bit of some
- 46:53self esteem. Now this isn't mean that therapists have high self esteems. It's
- 46:59it's it's a different thing because some therapists have really low self esteem. But
- 47:04on average, when you lump all therapists together, there's a general higher than
- 47:09average amount of narcissism. And then when you get to the level of supervisor
- 47:16and an instructor and podcaster by the way, you're going to see even higher
- 47:21levels of narcissism. I mean, listen to me right now. I've been
- 47:24talking for was it forty minutes? You have to have at least some notion
- 47:30of self esteem to talk into a microphone for forty minutes and feel like anyone
- 47:34would possibly be interested in that. You need to have some level of narcissism
- 47:38just to start a podcast. You know, you're just sitting there, You're
- 47:40like, you know what, I got things to say, and people should
- 47:44listen to it and I'm going to start a podcast. And so, now
- 47:46that doesn't mean it's malignant narcisism. It doesn't mean that you don't have compassion,
- 47:51because I certainly know I have compassion and empathy for other people. But
- 47:55this belief that you're special and so are therapists more likely to be on the
- 48:02psychopathic spectrum beyond the narcissistic spectrum. Yes, and there's data to support that,
- 48:07but there's a big difference between mild, benign narcissism and psychopathy and malignant
- 48:15narcisism malignant psychopathy. Now, the sadistic personality that Lyndon and you ask about,
- 48:22I don't have much experience. I haven't bumped into that in the field.
- 48:27I maybe I have and just didn't know it. But when I thought
- 48:30about it, I'm like, have I Do I know any sadistic therapist,
- 48:35supervisees, professors, And I'm just like, no, I don't know.
- 48:38Sadism is a rare personality trait to begin with, And I'm guessing that if
- 48:44you are, if you do have a sadistic personality, you're probably not going
- 48:49to go in the field because because there's other jobs that would absolutely be more
- 48:52in line with allowing you to enact your sadism. Things like I don't know
- 49:00what would what would a sadist want to do as a job. Maybe maybe
- 49:04a tattoo artist. Now again, I know tattoo artists, and I know
- 49:09them to be extremely nice people. But but I'm just trying to imagine.
- 49:14It's like I want to harm other people, and I get pleasure from harming
- 49:20other people surgeon, And again it's just I'm sure most surgeons and tattoo artists
- 49:29are have the normal range of personality traits as anyone else. But I'm just
- 49:32trying to think why to say to Maybe there's a research on this, like
- 49:35what what does a sadistic personality person choose for a job or or do they
- 49:44just choose any old job just like anyone else does. Do they just sort
- 49:46of fall into an occupation like anyone else does. I don't know any interesting
- 49:51question, but anyway, so um, another thing I'll say is that for
- 49:58some for some personnelity, the traits that are problematic in your personal life,
- 50:02it can actually help you as a as a clinician. So for instance,
- 50:07if you're if you're a little bit borderline, you it actually can help you
- 50:13as a therapist. It's not going to it's not going to be it's not
- 50:15going to help you in your relationships because it's a vulnerability and it's it tends
- 50:20to cause overreactivity and and intense feelings of rejection and sensitivity to minor rejections.
- 50:27But when you're a therapist, it can help you because people who have who
- 50:32are on the borderline spectrum are trained from an early age to be very perceptive
- 50:37of other people's emotions and to be very just very adapt at knowing the other
- 50:45other people's mental states. And so if you are slightly borderline as a therapist,
- 50:51you will actually have a greater ability to empathize other people in general,
- 50:55depending on the person. Now, if you have full blown, one hundred
- 50:59percent borderline personality disorder, then there there comes a point when it will actually
- 51:07hinder your ability to empathize and hinder your ability to not have countertransference that will
- 51:15get in the way. Not to say that full blown borderline personality disorder people
- 51:20can't be clinicians because they can. I Marshall Lenahan is a famous person who
- 51:25has done a lot of wonderful things for people, and she has come out
- 51:30as someone who has borderline personality. So so actually that's a really great example.
- 51:37So Marshall Lenihan at University of Washington has come out. I don't I
- 51:40haven't read all the articles, but from what I understand, she's come out
- 51:45and said I have borderline personality. And she has helped thousands of, if
- 51:50not hundreds of thousands of people because she is a consummate professional, and when
- 51:55she's working, she is she is working. She at work, she's not
- 52:00She's not triggered as easily by her clients because they're clients, they're not people
- 52:07in her personal life. Now, I have heard that Marshall Nahan can be
- 52:10quite abrasive to work with as a co worker, but again that's just anecdotal.
- 52:17I think actually Bob might have told me that maybe I shouldn't say that
- 52:22on the internet. I have no experience with her, so maybe she's a
- 52:27very lovely person. It's all rumor, and I suspect that some of it's
- 52:30overblown because she's a famous person and people like to make fun of or like
- 52:34the hack on famous people. So who knows. But anyway, all right,
- 52:38so Lyndon, I hope that answers your question. Again, this whole
- 52:43talk was anecdotal based. It was not based on research. Research is hard
- 52:49to gather on this, and the research they do have on it is not.
- 52:53It's just hard to measure all this kind of stuff because it involves so
- 52:57many different little factors. So what's the final word. The final word is
- 53:04that are there psychopathic narcisistic people who work in the field? Yes? Is
- 53:12there a higher rate of malignant, psychopathic and narcissistic people who work in the
- 53:17field, I would say no, Just anecdotally, I would surmise there's there's
- 53:22a lower incidence of malignant personality disordered people who work in the field because they
- 53:29probably wouldn't be attracted to the field. But there is a slight increase in
- 53:36the amount of slight psychopathy and slight narcissism because it actually can help them and
- 53:42might attract them to the field. And are some of these people out there
- 53:46harming people? Yes? Are some of these people with problematic personalities wonderful therapists?
- 53:53Yes? Are there people without any personality problems that are out there harming
- 53:59other people and other clients? Yes? So it's all the above, it's
- 54:04yes, and everything is true. Well, that does it for that all
- 54:08encompassing episode of Psychology in Seattle. Again, if you haven't yet become a
- 54:15Patreon of the podcast, do so now go to Patreon dot com. The
- 54:19premium feed doesn't have any advertisements, which is kind of fun. Also,
- 54:22if you have thoughts about this stories you want to tell me, email me
- 54:27at contact at psychology and Seattle dot com. I always love hearing from the
- 54:31listeners, and I'm particularly interested in this topic because I want to raise awareness
- 54:38around harmful professors, harmful supervisors, harmful therapists. I want people to know
- 54:45what's happening out there, and at the very least, if you've been harmed,
- 54:50you should have someone validate your feelings and hear you. And I'm here
- 54:53for you in that way. All right, Please take care of yourself because
- 54:58you deserve it, you really do. Or