Latest / Comeback Project: Real stories of courage & reinvention / The Beautiful Mess of Being a Beginner Again | Comeback Project
Transcript
- I bought a pottery wheel last Tuesday and immediately threw away three pounds of wet clay before the hour was up. It was the most honest thing I’ve done in years. Let’s sit with that image for a second. Me, Lyndsay Garcia, the woman who used to manage crises for Fortune 500 companies, standing in my garage covered in gray sludge, looking like I just lost a fight with a mud pit. And you know what? I felt ten years old again. That specific, prickly heat of embarrassment that rises up your neck when you realize you have no idea what you’re doing. We spend so much of our adult lives curating competence. We want to be the person who knows how to fix the leaky faucet, who has the right outfit for the interview, who speaks confidently in meetings. But somewhere along the way, we decided that being good at something is the only valid reason to do it. So if we aren’t excellent, we don’t participate. We stay on the sidelines, watching others shine, telling ourselves we’re too busy, or too tired, or just not talented enough. But today, I want to talk about the radical act of showing up and being terrible at something new. Not because it will look good on your resume, but because it might save your soul. When I left corporate crisis management, I didn’t just lose a job title. I lost a very specific kind of identity. For a decade, I was the calm in the storm. People came to me when everything was falling apart because I knew exactly what to say. I had scripts. I had strategies. I had control. When I stepped off that ladder, as we talked about in an earlier episode, I felt like I was floating without an anchor. Who was I if I wasn’t solving problems for strangers? The silence in my small coastal town was deafening. I tried to fill it with productivity. I cleaned closets I didn’t need. I organized spice racks alphabetically. But none of it touched the part of me that was starving for play. You see, adulthood is full of responsibilities, but it rarely makes room for the messy, unproductive joy of learning. We treat hobbies like extensions of our careers now. If you paint, it better be portfolio-worthy. If you run, it better improve your split time. If you write, it better go viral. This pressure turns leisure into labor. It drains the color right out of life until everything feels like another metric to hit, another box to check. And when you can’t meet that impossible standard, you quit. You tell yourself you’re not cut out for art, or music, or gardening. But maybe you’re just cut out for rest, disguised as failure. So, I signed up for a beginner’s ceramics class. My hands shook when I paid the fee. Not because I was afraid of the cost, but because I was afraid of the vulnerability. There I was, surrounded by people who looked like they belonged there. They wore aprons that looked artistic, not stained. They talked about glazes and kilns like they were old friends. I felt like an imposter in my own skin. On my first day, the instructor, a gentle man named Elias, told us to center the clay. He said, 'Your hands are the eyes. Feel the spin.' I pushed down hard. The clay wobbled. It spun wildly, defying gravity, and then collapsed into a sad, flat pancake on the wheel. Elias nodded kindly. 'Again,' he said. I tried again. And again. By the fifth attempt, my arms were sore, and I was sweating. I looked around. A woman next to me had thrown her clay across the room in frustration. Another guy was laughing at his lopsided bowl. In that moment, the tension in my shoulders dropped. I realized nobody here was judging me. We were all just figuring it out together. We were all beginners. And there is a profound freedom in that shared ignorance. When you admit you don’t know, you stop performing and start experiencing. There’s science behind this, though I won’t bore you with jargon. What happens when you engage in a hobby where you are genuinely novice is something called neuroplasticity. Your brain is literally rewiring itself. It’s forming new connections, building new pathways, just because you’re trying to learn a new skill. It’s not about the end product—the ugly mug or the off-key song. It’s about the process of stretching your mind beyond its comfort zone. As we get older, we tend to stick to what we know. We rely on established neural highways. But when you force yourself to drive on a dirt road for the first time, your brain lights up. It wakes up. It remembers that it’s capable of change. I remember feeling this physically after those first few pottery sessions. I felt lighter. Sharper. Like a fog had lifted from my frontal lobe. The anxiety that usually hums in the background of my day quieted down. Why? Because for two hours, I wasn’t Lyndsay the former executive. I was just Lyndsay, the girl who couldn’t center clay. And that simplicity was intoxicating. It reminded me that I am more than my achievements. I am also my capacity to learn, to stumble, and to try again. We often mistake confidence for knowledge. We think we need to know everything before we can speak, or create, or lead. But true confidence comes from trusting yourself to figure things out. It’s the belief that even if you start poorly, you can endure the awkward phase until you get better. This is the pivot point for many of us in our forties and fifties. We’ve spent decades proving ourselves to bosses, to partners, to society. Now, we get to prove ourselves to ourselves. And the standard isn’t excellence. The standard is curiosity. Are you interested? Does it make you feel alive? Does it make you forget to check your phone? If yes, keep going. I started knitting recently, too. I’m bad at it. My stitches are uneven, my tension is inconsistent, and my scarf looks like a tangled nest of yarn. But every time I pick up those needles, I feel a sense of wonder. I’m exploring texture, rhythm, patience. I’m not trying to become a master knitter. I’m trying to become a person who allows herself to be a student again. This shift in perspective changes everything. It takes the weight off your shoulders. It lets you breathe. It reminds you that life is not a competition; it’s an exploration. So, here is my challenge to you this week. Find one thing you’ve always wanted to try but never did because you weren’t sure you’d be any good at it. Maybe it’s watercolor painting. Maybe it’s coding. Maybe it’s salsa dancing. Maybe it’s baking sourdough bread. Go do it. And give yourself permission to be terrible. Really terrible. Make a mess. Drop the ingredients. Step on your partner’s toes. Let yourself feel that initial discomfort without judging yourself for it. Embrace the awkwardness. That awkwardness is the price of admission to a new version of yourself. It’s the tax you pay for growth. When you show up as a beginner, you’re telling your inner critic to take a seat. You’re saying, 'I don’t need to be perfect to be worthy of this experience.' Brave, not perfect. That’s the mantra. It’s okay to be clumsy. It’s okay to be confused. It’s okay to ask questions. In fact, asking questions is the bravest thing you can do in a world that demands instant expertise. So let your hands get dirty. Let your voice crack. Let yourself fail beautifully. Because on the other side of that failure is a joy that success never gives you. The joy of discovery. The joy of becoming. I’ll leave you with this thought: You are allowed to start over. You are allowed to be a beginner. You are allowed to be messy. And you are absolutely allowed to enjoy the process. Until next time, keep creating, keep stumbling, and keep showing up. I’m so proud of you for listening. Take care of yourself, friend.