Latest / Flagged for Content / Minnesota Flagged-for-Content Commission
Transcript
- 0:00Yeah, so we're recording, so you know, worst case this is comes
- 0:04out pretty much like right after we do it. Okay, So welcome to
- 0:09the Minnesota Flag Commission Take two. Although I'm sure we all have kind of
- 0:16our own thoughts about that as well, the purpose of this is kind of
- 0:21a roundtable panel discussion to kind of all aspects of the new Minnesota flag.
- 0:28We're going to talk about, like the process. I know Tara for one,
- 0:31has some thoughts on that, we probably all do. We're gonna talk
- 0:35about the final design, all the other you know, designs that were out
- 0:40there it didn't make the cut. Obviously it's worth mentioning the north Star among
- 0:44those. But yeah, I think probably the right place to start with this
- 0:49is the process and then we'll get into the design. So, Tara,
- 0:54I'll throw to you first. What I know, this is the most broad
- 0:59question ever, but but I know you have some thoughts on the process.
- 1:02Some things they could have done better, not many things they could have done
- 1:06worse, But were your thoughts on that? Yeah, So this is the
- 1:10third big flag change we've seen in recent memory, but it's only the second
- 1:17one that most people have been able to pay attention to because pardon me,
- 1:22Mississippi. Happened so so fast. Right in the early stages of the pandemic.
- 1:29In twenty twenty, there was a race to get the what's commonly known
- 1:34as the Confederate battle flag off of their state flag. That incited a race,
- 1:40and there were a lot of other things going on. People were,
- 1:42you know, a little bit distracted, and of course, when it's you
- 1:47know, the first of its kind, sometimes that drags in attention. Sometimes
- 1:49it absolutely does not. Utah came in earlier this year, or I should
- 1:56say almost two years ago, with a very long, detailed process for getting
- 2:05a new flag together. There were multiple surveys done trying to gather what symbols
- 2:10represent Utah best and what elements would you like to see in a flag.
- 2:15There were thousands and thousands of submissions from professionals and amateurs in and out of
- 2:20Utah for their state Flag committee to work with. They found a lot of
- 2:25common elements, and what wound up happening is the flag they wound up selecting
- 2:31in the end looked like a lot of participants in the mix. They received
- 2:37a lot of criticism for I'm not remembering the figure off the top of my
- 2:40head, I want to say it was something like I can't remember if it
- 2:46was fifty thousand or five hundred thousand that went into the process, but there
- 2:50were complaints, you know, oh, this took up way too much of
- 2:53legislator's time. There weren't that many legislators on the day, no way.
- 2:57Well, yeah, And of course it's also it's not just the time you
- 2:59spend in committee, but people look at the time you spend not actually deliberating
- 3:04as wasted time, to which no, that's time you let a design settle.
- 3:08The best flags are time tested, and so you want to sit with
- 3:12things for a little while. Minnesota legislators or at least one had actually tweeted
- 3:16out and bragging, Utah spent too much money and too much time on their
- 3:21flag. We're going to do it on thirty five thousand dollars and in fifteen
- 3:24weeks. Spending less money does not necessarily get you a better flag, and
- 3:29it's going to get you just as many complaints from people who are saying,
- 3:30why are you replacing my flag in the first place? A single dollar is
- 3:34too much, right, And then not only you're not devoting enough resources to
- 3:39actually looking out to the people who care about this and want to see some
- 3:43change. But in addition, you're not giving those thoughts time. You're not
- 3:50giving this time to deliberate. I'm not asking for more time in committee.
- 3:53I'm not asking more nonsensical debate about what stick with what the design? Yeah,
- 4:00precisely let something sit, give it some time. Yeah, No,
- 4:05definitely agree with all of that. I am curious for our We've got three
- 4:10folks in various parts of Europe right now. I'm wondering what this process looked
- 4:15like to y'all's eyes, as you know, someone in who has experienced in
- 4:19French and Swiss vaccinology with Nasha Tariff, you know, with British, especially
- 4:25Scotland in particulars is kind of cranking out flags lately. And then Chrishtoph obviously
- 4:30in check ya whoever wants to take it first. But I'm just wondering what
- 4:32this looked like to you know, French chech or British eyes. This process
- 4:41I'll call on someone, uh, Nasha, So yeah, just your thoughts
- 4:46on the process maybe are e like as it compares to maybe the French process
- 4:50or or Swiss process, of course, I guess yeah, pretty different.
- 4:56Yeah for a Swiss process, it's it's you take quite a while because usually
- 5:00it's it's happening about new cities, you know, merging of cities. But
- 5:08most of the time it's actually going through the coat of arms, and then
- 5:12the coat of arms is actually displayed on a flag, not on a as
- 5:15just the coat of arms on a white field, but the kind of extend
- 5:18the coat of arms out of on a square and it becomes the flag.
- 5:24In France, I think we we didn't have that much of a process because
- 5:30for the moment, actually most of the time it's it's just logos put on
- 5:33on on a white flag, so we don't really have it. But in
- 5:40the cities where they chose one, it took with the help of the FRANCSGY,
- 5:46it took like probably six months, so it was like it involved the
- 5:54historians, sports societies, clubs, school and so on, and everybody was
- 6:01actually able to submit some process and so on. But then the process was
- 6:08like choosing a flag of course through a committee, but a committy of historians
- 6:14most of the time, and then it would have been put up to vote.
- 6:17It would not be an official vote like such as what we would probably
- 6:24or maybe having a in an American state way would be put before the people.
- 6:30But then it still you know, gives some kind of a popular way
- 6:35of understanding and what we call the social acceptability, so meaning we need the
- 6:44people to actually access and accept the new design to make it working. It
- 6:53was actually I was very surprised for Minnesota. It was that fast. I
- 6:58would have expected it would take at least I don't know, maybe half an
- 7:01hour. May probably know, And I had I don't know, I wasn't
- 7:05that much focused on it. I had the feeling it took for weeks.
- 7:10It probably was a bit longer, but it was very sudden for me.
- 7:15And then I was very surprised actually the yesterday the way now before yesterday,
- 7:20yesterday, I don't know, with the time changed were actually saying that they
- 7:26had a final flag. It was like, oh, I thought they were
- 7:29the at the beginning of the process and actually that we were already at the
- 7:33end. Yeah. So like quick question kind of wrapped in with all that,
- 7:36Like Tara mentioned here in the US, it's very like when stuff like
- 7:42this happens like at all, it's like, all right, how much is
- 7:45it going to cost us taxpayers? And how long is you know? It
- 7:47gonna take with bureaucracy, red tape, all this stuff. Is it as
- 7:51big of a deal in France? Like are people up in arms for the
- 7:55like maybe they don't like the design or whatever, but for like taxpayer reasons.
- 8:01Not really. I I had like some some some guy who was like
- 8:09who is in the French Society of Vexillology, And he's been doing a tremendous
- 8:15amazing work for the three regions, like a region between Germany, France and
- 8:22Luxembourg in azas. Yeah, like big, big grand test. Yeah that's
- 8:31and he told me today that unfortunately the Germans, who have the rotating presidency,
- 8:37decided not to go with the new proposition he he put forward for a
- 8:43new flag because they decided six months ago they already would take a logo that
- 8:48costed a bit of money. So the problem is most of the time they
- 8:52pay for logo and then it becomes a trademark and then it's only you is
- 9:00built by the people who actually have petted for it, Whereas when you actually
- 9:05in chate that didn't make anything pale like that. It wasn't the the budget
- 9:11was invested by the city to have a budget for making the city more beautiful,
- 9:18you know, like with like beautiful yeah, yeah, yeah, So
- 9:22those flowers for like real flurry or exactly or whatever exactly, So it was
- 9:26it was kind of those kind of budgets. Uh. Then I don't know
- 9:33exactly how it would cost, but it's not that big of an issue because
- 9:39region and region when they merged together, they had new flags and it wasn't
- 9:48that much of an issue. Of course, you will always have people who
- 9:50say that public money is used for that, and that's typically people who I
- 9:56guess at the ends of the flag. But that's kind of normal. You
- 10:00need something, you need to pay to have it somewhere, right, of
- 10:03course I was, I guess I'm curious about all these kind of cultural differences
- 10:07and things like that. Let's go to Crushed Off next. So you actually
- 10:11are one of the ones that is I mean, not that Nasha isn't,
- 10:13but you are like very hands on in the zech vex process, as you
- 10:20know mentioned on your episode and in your Patreon episode, Like you go to
- 10:24towns, you have this coat of arms that you've designed into a flag.
- 10:28You have different options for them. They're pretty stubborn sometimes, but like,
- 10:33uh, you know, like did this process strike you as as I don't
- 10:37know what the word like, lengthy, short, odd, I don't know,
- 10:45I mean definitely odd. For sure. I'm used to a very different
- 10:48process which is very much more centralized than than what we saw. This was,
- 10:54I guess you would say more democratic in some ways because and this is
- 10:58something I tweeted about on Twitter. Uh, they invited a lot of participants
- 11:05to the committee to an extent that it almost seemed unnecessary for some of them
- 11:11to meet. On one hand, of course, it's great to get a
- 11:13white, white white you know, range of opinions and range of people who
- 11:16are involved. That's great. But I find it's unnecessary at the cost of
- 11:22not having a vexillologist on board. Right that I found the biggest issue.
- 11:28I do understand that, Uh, the committee did a few times consult with
- 11:35k I'm not aware to what extent. Uh that Yes, yes, it's
- 11:43but I still think that that's a that's a The amount is way too low
- 11:50of consultation that happened compared to, uh, what should have been happening,
- 11:54honestly, and I think the result would have been very very different there was
- 11:58a vexillologist sitting there. Yeah, I think we are probably pretty much all
- 12:01agreed on that, whether we like the flag or not. And speaking of
- 12:05that, I guess, like, let's go ahead and get into the design
- 12:09aspects. You know, we could go on all day about the process or
- 12:13the well, yeah, I guess the process. But Tarif, I'm curious
- 12:18what you think about this design because we've talked a couple of times and at
- 12:22one point I thought you were kind of like more negative with it, and
- 12:26then maybe it's growing on you or or how do you how do you like
- 12:30it? How do you feel? I think initially I think I was.
- 12:33I was very much, but it grew on me quite quickly, I think.
- 12:39But I think in the back of my head the reason that it's it
- 12:43grew very quickly is because of what they currently have and I can't stand busy
- 12:50detailed flags. So this is obviously the other end of the spectrum, and
- 12:54therefore it takes all the boxes for me. So it didn't take me long
- 12:58to sway with, Oh yeah, let's that's this is going to be a
- 13:01winner compared to what they've already got, So I'll stand behind it for that
- 13:05reason. You know alone that it's you know, it's not a seal on
- 13:09a bedsheet, and nor should it ever be. So that That's why I'm
- 13:13in that camp of yeah, it's a winner for me, I'm not like
- 13:16it and I'll get behind it, all right, cool? Cool, Yeah,
- 13:22I can respect it. Alex. We haven't heard from you. Yeah,
- 13:28we haven't heard from Alex yet. So Alex, well, you can
- 13:31introduce yourself. The guests or the the audience doesn't know you yet. You
- 13:33are in an upcoming episode that hasn't dropped yet. But what are your thoughts
- 13:39on on the new flag? And yeah, I guess pretty much that.
- 13:43I was gonna say, what are they informed by? But you're in You're
- 13:46in Florida, you're far from Minnesota. I don't know. I guess esthetically,
- 13:48what do you think of it? Was specifically like the previous that the
- 14:00tricolor design actually really liked. Y. I did really like the tri colored
- 14:05design. I was hoping. I was really hoping. Well now well,
- 14:07I mean, I was rooting for the North Star flag, but knowing that
- 14:11was out, I was like, Okay, hopefully this one. Well.
- 14:13I also like the star Play flag, but if it was going to be
- 14:16one of these, I wanted to be the tri color. And I'm still
- 14:20kind of confused why they took it out, Like I did think it looked
- 14:24better, But with all of everything the way it is, I do like
- 14:28it, even if I wish it was different, but I still accept it
- 14:33as a flag. I definitely would take it over the current flag because they
- 14:37Yeah, I mean, i'd basically take anything over that. Yeah, But
- 14:41I do like the flag, and when I first saw I was more just
- 14:46kind of confused about why they why they made the changes to the winning design.
- 14:52I was confused. But I do think it has grown on me,
- 14:54and I think it will continue to grow on me because like all of us
- 14:58are just seeing it for like, it's been what has been like a day,
- 15:01two days, however long it's been day and a half. Yeah,
- 15:05yeah, so it's been that much time. All of us are still having
- 15:09our first impressions on it. I think in five years, our feelings on
- 15:13the flag will probably be completely different. We'll probably look at it in the
- 15:16same way we look at any other state flagu because we'll have been used to
- 15:20it. So I think a lot of it is the perception look at it
- 15:24like any other state flag. I mean, that's I don't know if that's
- 15:28a good thing or bad maybe the way, Well, what I mean is
- 15:31not like, I don't mean like, we'll look at it in the same
- 15:35way you look at Kansas's flag. I mean, we'll look at it more
- 15:37in the same way. We'll just we'll just be used to it. But
- 15:41I think that being used to it will help a lot of people grow on
- 15:43it. Like hearing what other people have been saying about this flag the most.
- 15:48One of the most common responses I hear are like or like, oh,
- 15:52well it wasn't what I was rooting for, but I still like it.
- 15:56Yeah, I've seen a lot of that pretty much. I yeah,
- 15:58I see a lot of that and so and a lot of people are kind
- 16:02of on the fence about it. But I think the on the fence crowd
- 16:06will grow closer over time. People who hate it maybe will never grow to
- 16:10like it, but a lot of people are on the fence, and being
- 16:12used to it is enough to get people to actually like it. So I
- 16:17think, yeah, I think just time thing and a lot we're also all
- 16:19tied up in this process, this complicated process of deciding what the flag is
- 16:26going to be. So a lot of us have a bad taste in our
- 16:29mouth with how that with how everything has gone, I think that once it's
- 16:33farther separated from this design process and we're left with just the flag, maybe
- 16:38a lot of us will feel differently. But yeah, there's no way to
- 16:42know for sure, but yeah, I think there's a good chance that it
- 16:45will one day become like a symbol that a lot of Minnesotans really do cherish.
- 16:52I feel like it could someday become that. I mean, I hope
- 16:56so, like, regardless of my personal feelings on it one way or the
- 16:59other. I mean, that's the best case is that they take pride in
- 17:03it, they wave it, you know, much like they've been waving the
- 17:06North Star for a long time. But whatever, speak of that nod,
- 17:10I'm going to go to Christoph next. We'll come to Terra Terra after.
- 17:15But yeah, krishtof now for something completely different. Opinion wise, regarding the
- 17:23design, I in general, I don't mind many of the elements used,
- 17:32the inverted wedge. I am absolutely fine that the star go ahead. That
- 17:36is perfectly fine. The thing that really grounds my gears, and I know
- 17:40this has been a topic of discussion in the discord server, is the two
- 17:44shades of blue that is honestly a no go for me, and that is
- 17:47something we've discussed many times. Some most agree and whist don't agree. I
- 17:49think that that is going to be detrimental to the flag, both in when
- 17:56you realize it's it's not just a picture on a screen, right, it
- 18:00is a flag that will be flying, that will be exposed to the elements,
- 18:03that will be exposed to the sun, et cetera. So that's that's
- 18:07something that I find, unfortunately in in the context of US flags, great,
- 18:14it's it's it is a step forward. Absolutely, in the context of
- 18:18the fact that it is a state flag, I honestly think they should have
- 18:22done better than that. If it was Upper Lower Tinyville in in in in
- 18:29backwoods Minnesota, sure go for it, right, But I think Upper Lower
- 18:33Tinyville is gorgeous this time of year. By the way, we say that
- 18:36in check when you when you want to say someplace it's tiny, you say
- 18:38Upper Lower So you know, if it was a town or whatever, I
- 18:45would be a lot less against it than I am. As a state flag.
- 18:48Simply the fact that it is a first level administrative unit for me,
- 18:52demands a better design. Yeah, that's a different take. I mean like
- 18:57just outside of design. It's that is a good way to think of it.
- 19:00Like the uh, the more prominent it is, the more eyes it's
- 19:04going to be in front of, and everything like that design matters more in
- 19:08that I mean that matters more is maybe the wrong way to put it,
- 19:11but uh, yeah, I don't know. You put it best as usual,
- 19:15just stumbling over words like I like to do something interesting that you said
- 19:19there too, or maybe just something that kind of like uh that I thought
- 19:22that maybe spun off from that is like you said, they are flags.
- 19:27They are not just meant to be static images on a screen, et cetera.
- 19:32If I remember, right Syracuse with the first light flag that they settled
- 19:36on, didn't they have all four finalists like have an actual flag version of
- 19:41it, and they each went to city Hall and like flew it for you
- 19:44know, ten minutes, got a photo op and then saw how it flew.
- 19:48You know. I think the commission was there, I assume, and
- 19:49then you know, took it down and the next guy did it. So
- 19:52yeah, I mean Minnesota do I mean didn't even try to do that.
- 19:56I don't think they made any they did anything out full of fact replicas they
- 20:00did the way they but the way they hung them was flat up on a
- 20:04wall. And the reason you build these fabric prototypes is to see how they
- 20:10hang limp on a pole, how they wave in the wind. They were
- 20:11hung horizontally from a wire at an indoor. If I can just say,
- 20:18I think this is this is really important. When the Czech flag was czechoslov
- 20:22time was being designed, they actually put it on a steamship on the river
- 20:26and had to go up and down the river through Prague to see how it
- 20:30would act. So I think this is extremely important and definitely a positive step
- 20:33in step in any design process for a city if it can, of course
- 20:37afford six different flags being made, produced, and displayed. This hopefully the
- 20:42US state can. Otherwise we got much bigger problems. Yeah, for sure,
- 20:47for sure, I've I mean, I'm sure we all have come around
- 20:49on a couple of flags once we actually saw them flying, like I won't
- 20:53lie, like, and I've told Michael this, Michael Green flags were good,
- 20:56but I was like, I didn't really like his Washington's Day design.
- 21:00It's still on my favorite favorite, but seeing it flying goes a long way.
- 21:03And uh, and that's the case with literally any flag. So yeah,
- 21:07good, good insight from you, Tara, and then we'll go to
- 21:11Nasha. But Tara thoughts on design. So this was highlighted for checking off
- 21:22all of the boxes of good flag, bad flag, and Ted Cake cannot
- 21:26stop singing the praises of this flag for that reason. I don't give a
- 21:32ship if it checks those boxes. Okay, No, here's the thing,
- 21:36right, No, I mean they're good guidelines. They're there for a reason,
- 21:41and unfortunately, right we're looking for symmetry. Right, it's like symmetry.
- 21:48It's got symmetry. That's so good. The point was to put Minnesota's
- 21:52map on the flag, and what it did was it made itself a little
- 21:56less distinctive by going symmetrical. I can and absolutely see the argument for the
- 22:00two blues not having enough contrast, but they may have enough contrast where it
- 22:04counts. And if they don't have enough contrast, Joseph in the chat has
- 22:07pointed out, Andy, you have a flag behind you with two blues that
- 22:11needs to come down in that case. Right, So it's it's not an
- 22:17accident the ones that I put behind me today. Yeah, the irony is
- 22:21not lost with either one of my favorite fucking flags of all time has two
- 22:25blues on it. Yes, crucially don't touch anyway. Go on, So
- 22:29I think I think the biggest issues that I have with with the flag are
- 22:33points where oh they're distinctive, they're better, but they're not that much more
- 22:37distinctive. You have two shades of blue, which is unique, but they're
- 22:41both shades of blue, which still puts them in a really large pool of
- 22:45US state flags that are predominantly blue. You have that inverted chevron, what's
- 22:51gonna inevitably become known as the Minnesota chevron as much as the Canadian I'd keep
- 22:56calling it pale. I don't think that's how it's pronounced, but it's become
- 22:59a new term vexillology. Right. You've got the eight pointed star, which
- 23:03has been proportioned just so to have meaning to the Dakota people or other native
- 23:10tribes. And Utah actually went against that particular shape for a number of reasons,
- 23:17but primarily because at a distance it looks less like a star and more
- 23:19like an asterisk or a circle when printed at small sizes. Yes, this
- 23:25is a step up, and as Twitter has said, it wasn't my first
- 23:27choice, but and I'm sure that it will grow on us with time,
- 23:30but we didn't have any time for it to grow on us in committee.
- 23:34We're throwing it out into the wild and finalizing it before having any of that,
- 23:38And I think there really is a fair bit of discussion to be had
- 23:44to say, is this Minnesota? A few people in Minnesota have said,
- 23:48yes, this is very Minnesota. This is more Minnesota than everything. Where
- 23:52was your spaceline? Right, There are a lot of people out there that
- 23:53says this isn't Minnesota enough. I'm Pennsylvanian, I'm not Minnesota. Pennsylvania.
- 24:00Minnesota probably have a lot more in common than Pennsylvania and Utah, so I
- 24:03feel like I have a little more insight. But again, ultimately I'm gonna
- 24:08have to leave it to the people. You've got my personal opinion. I
- 24:11trust y'all to know what you want and to inevitably do what's gonna be best
- 24:18for y'all. And I'm super proud of all we're going through that process.
- 24:22Just fingers crossed that other states are able to learn from your process, both
- 24:26what to do and what not to do. Yeah, Yeah, that's the
- 24:30hope with Maine, Michigan, South Dakota. Yeah, anyone in everyone in
- 24:34Massachusetts maybe you know, trying all that stuff. But so all right,
- 24:38so we'll round it out this part anyway with Nasha. Nasha, I don't
- 24:44think i've seen your thoughts as no, I have seen your thoughts online,
- 24:49and honestly, like, let's go take it away. Yeah. You know,
- 24:55it's funny because I saw one of your posts where you put all the
- 24:59fifties states flags and you say, can you guess can you find them in
- 25:02a certain flag like like and actually I found it like so quickly, and
- 25:07I was like, you put it right in the middle on that. I
- 25:12think it was in a alphabetical order, but it was like first on the
- 25:18two shades of blue. Well, anyway, it's a personal taste, but
- 25:23the light of blue is one of my favorite colors, so so I I
- 25:30loved it straight away, straight ahead I saw that. I was like,
- 25:33wow, that's just amazing. Then I was a bit confused about the star
- 25:37because I really favored the North Star flag. I really liked it. I
- 25:41think it's it's it's well understood, and you know, Astara said, you
- 25:48know you've got guidelines, but guidlines are sometimes made to be broken to make
- 25:53it more efficient and sometimes you've got always the exception, what was in French,
- 26:00the exception that confirms the rule, So forget that. That's typically you
- 26:06know what we would you know. I the eighth pointed Star was a bit
- 26:14wait for me, but then I it grew on me, like, I
- 26:18don't know, like in thirty seconds very fast. I really loved it because
- 26:23I was like really reading for the no stuff, Like I even posted on
- 26:26Twitter some tweets sporting the North stuff flag. I've wrote an email to the
- 26:33committee like where you could put like and put some information saying that they should
- 26:38have taken this flag and so on. But then I just saw the final,
- 26:45like the decision and for the two colors, the two shades of blue
- 26:48is not a problem for me. I it kind of remember, you know,
- 26:52I have a special bond with Minnesota. I in nineteen ninety six,
- 26:56I went for two months to live there in a hospital their house family to
- 27:00learn English. Was the second weakness protection kind of thing, or it was
- 27:07it was I wasn't the med g It was awesome. It was really cool.
- 27:10It was my first time I first French friends who have gone to live
- 27:14in Minnesota. Sorry, I don't mean to catch it. But yeah,
- 27:18I remember at the time they had a lot of people, like a lot
- 27:19of I was telling people I was Swiss, and everybody in Minnesota was telling
- 27:25me I was Swedish. You know, Switzerland, Swede. You know a
- 27:27lot of people like no, no, no, sweetish sweetsh You're like we
- 27:33But what it was really interesting because the the I remember, I don't I
- 27:40already loved the flags at that time, and I didn't remember having taken pictures
- 27:45of the flag of Minnesota. In Minnesota, right it was still you know,
- 27:51it was not digital pictures, so you had twenty four thirty six pictures
- 27:56for months, and you would be very careful of what you photot you would
- 28:00take four But then I I pretty much I remember, I have pictures of
- 28:06the United States, the flag of the United States, but I don't have
- 28:08a picture of the flag of Minnesota. And I stayed four days in New
- 28:14York, and I remember taking pictures of the flag of New York, so
- 28:18of the city of New York, which on big hotels, like the blue,
- 28:23white, yellow, orange with the with the ceil in the middle,
- 28:27and then I just think it was like the design to me is really like
- 28:37really interesting and it's kind of a it's I understand. I agree, it's
- 28:41kind of it's a bit stocky. It's it's like a bit heavy. But
- 28:45I think what could be good is that probably the flag not flying or just
- 28:52like hanging in a way will be very distinctively a scene because you see straight
- 28:59ahead the two colors and even maybe not the stars but the two blue we
- 29:03will see it. And yeah, I think it's it's it's. It was
- 29:08really interesting to see how fast grew up and grew on on me because I
- 29:15just like, I wasn't that sure. I was like, kind of I
- 29:18thought it was a missed opportunity for the nose stuff flag. And at the
- 29:22same time it was it was what I told you when I had my episode
- 29:26on flag for content. It's I was a bit sad for the for the
- 29:32person who actually really rouse out for this flag and and and worked on it
- 29:37and made it out and and and for so many, so many years,
- 29:41I think over thirty years something like that. Yeah, okay, so it's
- 29:48yeah, it's quite a long time. And at the same time it's like,
- 29:52okay, it's a great input. It was I was reading for that,
- 29:55but then there's a new flag, and it seems to what I've seen
- 29:59on Internet that a few politicians actually taking it, like, you know,
- 30:06taking it for themselves, printing it on and putting in frames and on the
- 30:10on the desk and so on. So I think it's it might be quite
- 30:12interesting to see how the people are going to react to this flag. I
- 30:19prefer I am. It's an unpopular opinion. I already said that on Twitter.
- 30:25I really pick with this flag then the Utah's one, because the UTAs
- 30:29one to me is has some kind of resemblance with a logo, not complete,
- 30:36but some kind of elements of a logo, whereas here I really have
- 30:41the feeling I'm in front of a flag and not of of something else.
- 30:45Yeah. Yeah, but again that's what I told you in private. If
- 30:49we would all agree in the flag, it would be a problem because it's
- 30:55personal taste, and you know the fact that everybody is kind of having different
- 31:00opinions on flags technically completely normal, I think, right, yeah, absolutely,
- 31:06yeah. I've got thoughts that I'll I'll go through real quick. But
- 31:10I had a live TikTok thing with Michael Green last night shorter than thirty like
- 31:15maybe twenty minutes or something like that. But we chatted mostly designed. I
- 31:21think we kind of left out the process stuff. But for me, I
- 31:25guess like I had a few points, but to kind of boil them down.
- 31:30I don't mind the Minnesota ish shape on it. I think last night
- 31:37I compared it to like states, like or countries I guess in this case,
- 31:41but like Kosovo and Cyprus and those places that have the outline. And
- 31:45I know it's maybe not it's not a one to one comparison, but those
- 31:48places that have like the outline on their flag, it's because there's some kind
- 31:52of like ethnic or political strife or whatever. They don't want to They're like,
- 31:56all right, we'll put up the outline, maybe some stars, may
- 32:00be some laurels like whatever, and we'll leave it at that. That's what
- 32:02the place looks like. So to me, putting the shape of it has
- 32:06always seemed like a compromise solution. And again it's not a direct one to
- 32:10one because this is like hinting at the shape. I think my other big
- 32:16thought, what was man, I don't remember exactly. We've gone through the
- 32:21blues thing, We've gone through the star thing. Yeah, I don't know.
- 32:24I may think of it as we go, but I think it may
- 32:28be good to kind of get to some questions now since we've got I gotta
- 32:32put on my glasses for this, but we've got a few, and you
- 32:37know, anyone feel free to jump in on these. Yeah, Allan said
- 32:39flags are not maps. That was a while ago, but I definitely agree.
- 32:44Let's see, what do we got thoughts on the nonsense? Oh yeah,
- 32:51yeah, so quantum? I imagine I know who this is? Uh?
- 32:52Thoughts on the non symmetrical reverse chevron slash hoist shape slash whatever, where
- 32:59the end it was down the lower instead of being in the center. You
- 33:01guys know what he means by that question because he admits he phrased it,
- 33:06you know, wordying, wordy, wordily. Let me use some more words
- 33:09to describe wordily. Uh yeah, what are you guys? Thoughts on that?
- 33:14I'll briefly give mine and say that I think the current is my opinion
- 33:25is asymmetrical. Is that what we call it? But I quite liked this
- 33:30asymmetrical or feet where the top of the cave of one of the better word
- 33:36is bigger than the bottom. I quite liked that idea. And the north
- 33:39start sitting in the top of that, I thought it was just a very
- 33:46or more unique design that they could come up with, and what they have
- 33:51come up with, I just thought it just gave it that extra little edge
- 33:53and just gave it a little bit more design flare. It's just more words
- 33:59through what I'm thinking of it. But yeah, overall I thought that would
- 34:04that look better in my opinion, Sorry, Alex, that's okay my opinion.
- 34:13I wasn't really a big fan of the asymmetrical one. I'm looking at
- 34:16it just feels kind of off. I know, flags don't have to be
- 34:20symmetrical, but like the shape I think works better being I think it works
- 34:25better and more symmetrical, like flying, I think it would look kind of
- 34:29weird being being the shape being lower. So yeah, I definitely preferred the
- 34:35symmetrical one, although I also preferred the tricolor version. But but yeah,
- 34:38symmetrical one I definitely liked better, so I'm happy they did go with that
- 34:43one. I would say the asymmetrical option creates a sort of canton effect of
- 34:55sorts, you might say, which I actually like. Yeah, as Tara
- 35:01said with the star, I do like that, and yes, it is
- 35:05more unique, I mean, why not. I'm I'm I'm not crazy about
- 35:07it. I'm not against it at all, go for it in my view,
- 35:14do you think, like, sorry to briefly cut in here, do
- 35:15you guys think that like that offset one which I am coming around on basically
- 35:21for the reason that Krishtov just laid out. I do like anything in Canton,
- 35:25But do you guys think that version would have been better with not just
- 35:30an all light blue on the side, like maybe better with the stripes?
- 35:32I kind of on some of the designs. I liked the thinner stripe meeting
- 35:37where where the reverse chevron meets, if that makes sense, but not on
- 35:43all of them. I I don't know if I have a strong opinion on
- 35:45this really. I I have mixed feelings on the multiple stripes with with the
- 35:51asymmetrical inverted chevron, but I think part of that is is colored by a
- 35:59similarly chaotic sudden process with the redesign of the Polyamory flag earlier this year,
- 36:06which shares another offset chevron, not inverted but still offset to meet one of
- 36:12those lines. Of course, it's I'll wrap it up real quick. I
- 36:20will say I think the asymmetrical inverted chevron pairs better with not having those stripes
- 36:30in my personal opinion, and I don't know that I can quite articulate why
- 36:35at this exact moment, but it's it's definitely something to chew on. Yeah,
- 36:43I'm I agree with DA. I have seen the asymmetrical proposition and I
- 36:50found it cool because it looked a bit like it looked a bit like Minnesota.
- 36:55But at the same time I couldn't just I can't understand. But then
- 37:01the shape still reminds me of Minnesota. So even though it's not asymmetrical,
- 37:07it still reminds me of Minnesota. So I think it's the the effect is
- 37:12actually reached. It's that you don't need to have the exact shape of a
- 37:19of a state and anyway that wouldn't be exact because it was like kind of
- 37:23a very you know, it was not that the tiny line like such as
- 37:28cossovo or or Cypress way, it's very detailed. But I yeah, I
- 37:34kind of I don't know. I think that the problem is like probably it's
- 37:38it's it would have been with a line in between. Yeah, I'm very
- 37:45having the same thoughts around on the on the on the on the on the
- 37:50matter and the problem. I I think it's kind of yeah, anyway,
- 37:54I like, yeah, I I didn't. I think part of my opposition
- 38:00to it was the f nineteen fifty three, right that went through. Part
- 38:05of my opposition to it was was the stripes. And I know this is
- 38:08where Alex and I actually have kind of opposite opinions, I think. But
- 38:14these stripes, to me, especially that the most boring shade of green I've
- 38:17ever seen in my entire life. And this is like this kind of wrapped
- 38:23in with what I talked about with Max from Stockholm, Sweden. He's part
- 38:29of a new vacxiology, New Underscore Vexology on Instagram, and he talks about
- 38:34like how you know, there's this wave of new flags in the US,
- 38:37mostly city or lower level but that are just green and blue and maybe like
- 38:43a white or something like that, and it's like, you know, the
- 38:45green is the grass and the blue is the water or the sky or in
- 38:50Minnesota, I guess it's the land where the water reflects the sky, which
- 38:52is the only thing that makes me understand the two blues. But yeah,
- 38:58it's just boring because it's like what to me, because it's like, what
- 39:00are the two things that every place has outside of like Antarctica, vegetation and
- 39:06a sky like I don't know, so I think that was my main opposition
- 39:10to the stripe was just one that it was a very boring green. I
- 39:15understand what they were going for. Minnesota's very cold. They were going for
- 39:17a little bit more muted. At least that's my understanding of it. But
- 39:22I'm not in love with the new one, as I've said, but I
- 39:25like it better than the stripe version. And Nasha, you had something.
- 39:30Yeah, I remember when I was like in Minnesota that my host family brought
- 39:34me to the to the bed of Mississippi because actually the Mississippi is taking its
- 39:39ruth in Minnesota and close to Bimigi and the Mississippi River, and it's even
- 39:46when I saw the flag, it's it actually reminded probably it was not at
- 39:52all thought about that, but it even reminded me the shape of like you
- 39:55know, like a staff of the river. So yeah, I had like
- 40:02a few elements where of course it's personal, but then I I yeah,
- 40:07for all those kind of reasons, I was like, yeah, that's kind
- 40:10of it appeals to me. It's quite interesting. The one fifty three I
- 40:16liked it too. Actually, I kind of loved all of them. The
- 40:22only one I didn't really like by by the end was like the you know,
- 40:28the reaver meeting the clouds. Yeah, exactly weird. That looks really
- 40:36weird, But all the other way we're actually quite interesting. Yeah, that's
- 40:40actually a good question. I know. It's uh, we can kind of
- 40:44get to this briefly, like and you know, a few words, but
- 40:49maybe just a quick yes or no. Do we let's go around the horn
- 40:52and say do we think that they picked the best of the final three options?
- 40:55And I'm going to go ahead and say, yes, Tara, I
- 41:06think they picked one of the three best options. Way more than one word
- 41:10out of the final three. No, the final three did not include the
- 41:16north Star Knockoff. I was trying to recall. Everything has gone so quickly,
- 41:21nothing has had a chance to set, didn't it. Maybe I'm thinking
- 41:24final four. I thought it was north Star knockoff, weird River thing the
- 41:30one that they picked, and now I can't think of a fourth in my
- 41:34head. Those three. I might be wrong, though. I think if
- 41:37north Star Knockoff was knocked out, then I think they picked probably the strongest
- 41:42contender yet there you go. Okay, so they had those are the okay,
- 41:46so you had you had water Loon, you had Minnesota. Oh yeah,
- 41:51okay. So if those were the top three at the end, I
- 41:55think if they were gonna do as many revisions to the three star Minnesota shape
- 42:00as they did, they could have done a number of revisions to north Star
- 42:02knock off and turned it halfway to north Star. I'd say if north Star
- 42:07was out of contention, they probably picked the best out of what they had
- 42:09left. But I argue with the point that north Star was knocked out of
- 42:15contention, I don't know that it was. Yeah, I'm sure we all
- 42:22have thoughts on that too, But tariff, out of the final three,
- 42:24did they pick the best one and by final three were going with the the
- 42:30final three like designs you know, before remixing, I guess before remixing.
- 42:37Yeah, I still think it was, yeah, the best that they they
- 42:44reduced themselves down to had in front of them at the time. Yeah.
- 42:47So I'm in the yes camp again on that one, all right, Alex
- 42:54Christoph, I definitely think they picked the best of the up the River thing
- 43:00I didn't like very much to knock off north north Star I thought was okay,
- 43:06if it was more north starry, I probably would have liked it more.
- 43:08But yeah, of the three, I definitely like that one the best,
- 43:13although I do prefer the original version of it, the original proposal,
- 43:16than the one they picked. Yeah, yeah, I like to try colors.
- 43:21I like the shades better than the the other green version that came up
- 43:23with as well. Uh. For me, I would definitely go with the
- 43:30north Star knockoff, not just because I like the north Star design but which
- 43:35I've made very abundantly clear, but because, honestly, for me, the
- 43:39two blueses and no go in check we say not even a train runs over
- 43:43that, so so that that's an absolute no go for me. So north
- 43:49Star knockoff it is. Yeah. I'm trying to think of what would we
- 43:53like. I wouldn't touch that with a ten foot pole or something like.
- 43:55I'm sure there's plenty of meaning like that. There is no way to do
- 44:01them right, right, fair enough? Okay, do we have any other
- 44:07questions? Leslie agrees symmetrical. Yeah, Leslie, sorry about the the audio
- 44:12from the audience. I'll figure that out for the next live but for now,
- 44:16you know we're we're winding down tariff is uh you know, well,
- 44:22we got three European folks, so it's pretty late over there. Did Dan
- 44:27find his question, Tarah, things are out of order because of people being
- 44:34in different time zones, which I thought would be handled by this but apparently
- 44:37not. Oh oh. Dan was saying, okay, so yeah, for
- 44:40those who can't or whatever see the comments. But Dan McKay, I assume
- 44:45said, oh. In asymmetric oh, In asymmetrical designs, the viewer has
- 44:51to figure out why the design is off. Most people can't find forty eight
- 44:53to fifty states on a map let alone tell you what they're shaped like.
- 44:57And yeah, I do agree that the viewer having to figure out why the
- 45:00design is off is like, so the Maryland flag breaks my brain every time
- 45:06I look at it. It just like I know where the design is off,
- 45:10but my brain doesn't or can't, or like it's like, you know,
- 45:14the Call of Tulu or something. It's like looking into the mind of
- 45:16madness and it just drives you insane. I think Alex even has this on
- 45:21the TV Troops. Anyway, Tariff, you looked like you had something to
- 45:27say on that. I think I was just I was just agreeing. Actually,
- 45:32what I'm trying to think what the question was, Oh the ace,
- 45:36why that's it? The shapes trying to make it. There's part of me
- 45:38thinking that asymmetrical and like, yeah, the view are not understanding why it's
- 45:45like that. There is part of me thinking, well, should that spark
- 45:47enough curiosity to want to know more about it? I mean, okay,
- 45:52okay, take take take the keystone exactly. Surely looking at the keystone fag
- 45:58people who don't know about pencil bany would go why does it look like that?
- 46:01And be able to go right, get it now? Makes perfect sense.
- 46:07People are more likely to learn when they're the one. People are more
- 46:12likely to retain information when they're the ones seeking it. Right. I can
- 46:20tell you all of these things about the keystone flag. But if I'm just
- 46:23rattling this off at you, sure I can tell you that, oh,
- 46:27the wheat cheeves are for wealth of human resource in mind, and the horse
- 46:31is for horses. It legitimately has no symbolism. You cannot find it anywhere.
- 46:37But if you're not asking those questions, I'm I'm just telling you facts.
- 46:43You're not going to retain any of that. But if you're the one,
- 46:45why is it blue gold and green. Now you are actively seeking that
- 46:50information and it sticks. You can ask any teacher would they rather tell students
- 46:57about their state flag or would they rather have their students ask about the state
- 47:00flag. Every teacher will tell you they want their students to ask because they're
- 47:04more likely to retain that information. Yeah, every good teacher. Anyways,
- 47:07the flag that sparks interests definitely has something going for it, that's for sure.
- 47:14Yeah. Yeah, a flag is not a conversation. It's an icebreaker.
- 47:19I guess that's maybe my Yeah, I guess maybe that is my gripe
- 47:22with it, because like I maybe see that a different way. But like,
- 47:27I don't think this one's spark I think this one is supremely boring and
- 47:30does not spark an interest in me to know what it's more like, I
- 47:34agree with your overall thesis on that, Like, you know, interesting flags
- 47:37prompt you to look them up, which is how we learn, right,
- 47:40But this one, to me doesn't I think clear that hurdle. And maybe
- 47:45that's part of what I've been looking for the words to say. So I
- 47:51don't know, it falls a little flat for me, both in colors and
- 47:53design. But you know, as you said, NASA like, we're not
- 47:57gonna if anyone ever agrees all of us together agree on a flag, we
- 48:01need to go back to the drawing board. Probably are there any other Okay,
- 48:08wait, so wait, Dan's not asking you why does it have a
- 48:13beehive? He knows why it has a beehive exactly, but it's it's good.
- 48:16Oh he's talking about like what right the question that would be prompted by
- 48:20seeing the flag y Kyrgyzstan. Do they have a large xbox industry? I
- 48:24think they do, according to mister flag. It's funny you say that because
- 48:30as of I'm not sure if today or yesterday the flag has changed. Today
- 48:35flag Minnesota, eat your Yrgustan, It's time to shine. They decided they
- 48:44like they like Macedonia's raised better, so they so they stole the Macedonian ones
- 48:50the old flag, isn't it basically yes, yeah, yeah, which I
- 48:58think I have on order. This should be coming here at some point.
- 49:01I got a lot of weird flags coming to me in the in the next
- 49:06few months. I mean, Tariff was like, hey, we should collab
- 49:08on something, so some of them are going to be real weird. But
- 49:10anyway, beside the point, do we have any other questions because we are
- 49:16well we started about ten fifteen minutes late. But I don't want to do
- 49:22I can ask a question. Yeah, I'm very proud of my nickname for
- 49:25the new flag, the Minnesota Blues, because that's what it makes me feel.
- 49:30Any other ideas for a nickname from you guys? Right, I'm so
- 49:36glad you mentioned that because I was driving home, like about to get set
- 49:38up for this, and I was trying to rack my brain to think of
- 49:42one, because like, yeah, north Star first Light, you know,
- 49:45like there's there's plenty of keystone. Yeah. I don't know. Yeah,
- 49:51let's go roundtable and see what we come up with. What was your or
- 49:54Minnesota Blues? Yeah, I'd have to think on mine. Uh the little
- 50:02chevron that couldn't No, now, I'll work shop it. I don't know
- 50:10nobody has anything off the top of the Oh, I absolutely do. But
- 50:13I'm looking for my visual aid to drop into the chat. Oh yeah,
- 50:17I don't know how to drop you just copy and paste Andy Control, Seat
- 50:22Control V Command Sea Command V on Mac. Thanks, younger person. Very
- 50:28hard for a little bit on mobile devices. Wait, but even with an
- 50:35image, because it's not let me drop an image in there. I'm trying
- 50:37to find somebody dropped this into the server earlier today too. Oh my goodness.
- 50:45Yeah, I don't know how to if anybody else remembers it. The
- 50:47laser this this is secretly the laser lon. After all, people talk about
- 50:52New Zealand's laser key and people were like, where's our laser luon? This
- 50:58is this is literally a loon with its mouth gaping wide open, firing its
- 51:01laserived. I have received this meme from three friends independently within the last twenty
- 51:07four hours. Oh my god, did you guys also get the TikTok about
- 51:09the uh leather Pride flag? Because I got that one from like twenty different
- 51:14people. Wait what, No, all my friends who know I'm like the
- 51:19flag guy. There's some TikTok of some grandma who like bought a leather Pride
- 51:22flag because she liked the colors and the there's like hearts on it or you
- 51:25know, hearts on it or whatever, and she it's her bringing it home
- 51:29to her like I don't know, son or grandson or whoever, and him,
- 51:32he obviously knows what it is and she obviously doesn't. And she's like,
- 51:36oh, I thought it was cool. That's amazing funny. I got
- 51:40sent that like thirty times. I was I was wondering if y'all did.
- 51:43But yeah, I don't know Minnesota blues, Tara, did you? Is
- 51:51it not something about because it the blues? Maybe you know, is it
- 51:55not the Yeah, Minnesota's the land of ten thousand late as is the nickname,
- 52:02and then Minnesota. I'm not gonna attempt pronouncing it, but like the
- 52:07native name for Minnesota comes from like the land where the water reflects the sky.
- 52:15So like again, like, yeah, that I could see in the
- 52:16two blues like water and sky, is maybe why there's two blues. That's
- 52:22but I haven't seen anybody like official like kind of put that forward as an
- 52:24explanation. It's just in my head maybe. But land of ten thousand lakes,
- 52:31land of one Lake. Yeah, I don't know. I can't.
- 52:36I can't. I don't know. I lost my cleverness for the night.
- 52:40I think quantum did leave the LA did drop a link to the laser lone
- 52:45image in the chat? I do perfect, Sorry, I do know.
- 52:50Tara is very keen on remixing flags with various LGBT flags. Right sports,
- 52:55Thank you, very much. City just literally reads interesting. Interesting to see
- 53:01the asymmetrical flag, uh, remix with the with the new polyamory flag.
- 53:10Oh wait wait is there is there a Minnesota flag already? I mean,
- 53:20Tara, that's just challenge since I don't know what they get into. Is
- 53:23it disingenuous for me to make flags for other states too? Yes? No,
- 53:30no, I mean we all clearly have strong opinions on a state that
- 53:32I don't I've never been to. Uh but yeah, shoot, what was
- 53:37I just about to say? I lost my train of thought? Laser?
- 53:45Nothing else needs to be said about the laser land that things stands on its
- 53:47own two legs. Yeah, legs. Hmm. Okay, Well, I
- 53:57don't know if there's any other questions in the chat, and I know,
- 54:00Harris just to go to bed at some point, I assume, unless Tarif,
- 54:05are you an Android yet or is that still in process? Yeah?
- 54:10Still working? Yeah? Okay, but I know want to replace that last
- 54:14part. Yeah that I'll be fooled. But yeah, don't let let me
- 54:20stop you guys from carrying on. That's for sure, and I appreciate it
- 54:25just for me and later for others. Yeah, I just want to make
- 54:30sure you. You got everything in, uh that you had to get in
- 54:35as far as on this discussion, maybe if we could all give a quick
- 54:40ending summer. Yeah, I think that's probably good to do now. Yeah,
- 54:46whoever wants to start. I'm tired of hosting this thing, so somebody
- 54:51do it. M let's start. Let's start with Okay first, you know
- 55:00what, I just would like to to say, I prefer the flag than
- 55:05the new seal. I prefer the opposite, but I don't know if we
- 55:10have time. Okay, Yeah, the seal seems like it doesn't seem to
- 55:16look like a seal. It looks more to me as a logo than the
- 55:22seal. But again, you know, kind of taste. Yeah. No,
- 55:25I really interesting to to see the I know it's it's I think that
- 55:32the to sum up the problem. I think it's it's been too sudden,
- 55:37uh for for people. I think it's been too fast. That's why there's
- 55:43a lot of people who haven't been able to even make up their minds about
- 55:47it. And but at the same time, I think it's really interesting what's
- 55:52happening right now in the States with all those changes of flags, where you
- 55:59you come from a sub to something new and I think it's very encouraging for
- 56:06the remaining states that still have some kind of goat of arms or serbs on
- 56:12a blue field. And yeah, it's it's it's quite amazing for people here
- 56:17in Europe to look at what you can do best and you actually do like
- 56:24really good things. Uh, I mean, you know what, I was
- 56:28really surprised that they actually didn't go for something written on it. And I
- 56:36think it's a funb but just for that because Mississippi just I think in Missisippi,
- 56:40Missouri, I don't remember Mississippi. I think the new flag of Missippi.
- 56:45They just they just wrote again and we trusted and okay, no offense
- 56:49to anyone, but you know, it's so small. We don't even that
- 56:52was something they had to do. But the commission said they had to have
- 56:53that. Yeah, yeah, it was something black mandatory. So at least
- 56:59we we we we again. It's only guidelines, but I think it's yeah,
- 57:04it's a it's gonna it's gonna be a great, great flag to fly
- 57:08and I'm certainly gonna buy it to hang it at my window here in Paris.
- 57:15Okay, there you go, that'll be well, maybe not the first
- 57:19one. In Paris. It's a from what I understand, a rather large
- 57:22city. But among the first I would say. I actually I did the
- 57:27opposite last night. I went on Flags for Good and I ordered the star
- 57:30flake in what has to be the most mild form of protest ever. But
- 57:37you know what, screw it. Like, at some point, I'm sure
- 57:38I'll own this flag. I own Kansas's flag because somebody like Evan Dunker from
- 57:43Instagram sent it to me. I don't fly it, but I own it.
- 57:46That might be the fate of this one on my end. But anyway,
- 57:50all right, so tiff any any closing remarks here for us? I
- 57:55I probably echo Nash has just said. I mean, I overall, it's
- 58:00a good flag. Now, oh, excellent, even better, I will
- 58:04I'll be quick then. But I just think, well, I like it,
- 58:09and I like the the vertical version of it. It makes more sense
- 58:14flying vertically. To be fair, it was well, I'm sure we could
- 58:20all say missed opportunities on it. It's yeah, vertical. I think that's
- 58:24the main thing. All right, m shall we go to alex Yeah.
- 58:39I do hope that someday this will be a symbol that will be cherished by
- 58:45Minnesotans in the same way that a lot of other states have have fueled their
- 58:51flags very strongly in their identity. I don't know whether it will happen this
- 58:54way or not, but I do hope that that's someday this will be too.
- 59:00Yeah, that people will feel and Minnesotans will see this, will send
- 59:06that maybe maybe one day we'll see the flag everywhere. We'll see it on
- 59:08logos, we'll see it on signs, we'll see it on clothes. It'll
- 59:12be truly something that people will care about. Yeah, And I hope that.
- 59:15I do hope that happens someday. Excellent. Sorry, I was muted
- 59:24because I was typing something because I you you actually jogged my memory about one
- 59:28of my former or points from before. But I'm just gonna put in the
- 59:30chat since we're winding down, So all right, let's uh, at least
- 59:35on my screen anyway, let's move over to you christav Oh, there,
- 59:40we got you to it. I appreciate the very positive and open minded approach
- 59:46that we've heard in these closing remarks. I'm not going to be that guy.
- 59:52I am going to end on a more not on Minis note. I
- 59:53think it's not over yet. I think that there will be around two.
- 59:58And I think that the North Star flag will make a comeback. I know
- 1:00:04this is something that we've discussed in the discord and there are differing views.
- 1:00:07Maybe it's bias. I do hope that it'll make it comeback, but I
- 1:00:13don't think that the current flag has a in the way that it was designed
- 1:00:16and in the way that it lose, that it has a strong enough mandate
- 1:00:21to be a long term solution from Minnesota. Okay, that's that's my view.
- 1:00:29Okay, Yeah, I think you may be. I think you're probably
- 1:00:32onto something there. For sure. We both hope, so I think,
- 1:00:36I mean we both hope so like honestly even yeah, well we'll leave it
- 1:00:39at that. But Tara, any any closing thoughts on this. I think
- 1:00:45Kristoph put into words what a lot of us may secretly be hoping for.
- 1:00:51But also keep in mind that the rest of the world does not think the
- 1:00:55same way that we do. I do not think it is likely, but
- 1:01:00I agree that the flag does not have quite a mandate. I hope that
- 1:01:04Minnesotans have a symbol that they can hold up and cherish and love. I
- 1:01:08hope that it inspires civic pride in the way that many good flags do,
- 1:01:13and if they remix it and make it even more distinct and embrace it even
- 1:01:17further as a result, amazing for them. I think I'm very grateful to
- 1:01:22Minnesota for leading the charge and helping us all learn what this process can look
- 1:01:29like, and so we can take what was good, we can learn from
- 1:01:32what was paid, and we continue to see more positive changes across the states,
- 1:01:37across the world. Yeah, well, put, I guess that leaves
- 1:01:45me. Yeah, And closing, I think I'm probably echoing at least a
- 1:01:50couple of us when I say I I think I'm more just mourning what could
- 1:01:55have been more than anything else, because I saw so much potential in so
- 1:02:02many of the other designs, whether they ended up remixed like the final one
- 1:02:07Asterisk did or not. But yeah, it just seems like someone used the
- 1:02:13word missed opportunity. I can't remember who, but like that to me is
- 1:02:15the kind of like the double bold underline on it for me, And yeah,
- 1:02:22I think it's probably best if I leave it at that. Yeah,
- 1:02:27I said the other thing I had to say in the chat, which is
- 1:02:29basically that I don't think it has like a TriStar or a beehive or a
- 1:02:32keystone kind of element that is, you know, gonna be stamped everywhere.
- 1:02:37But we'll see, like Krustov said, it may not be over or we
- 1:02:42may be wearing rose ten and glasses and yeah, we'll see anyway. All
- 1:02:46that said badly by me. Thank you guys so much. Thanks to everyone
- 1:02:52here, not just on the panel, Tara Tarif, Nasha, Alex Krishtav
- 1:02:57thank y'all so much for like making this happen in the first place. This
- 1:03:01is my first ever time doing this and it was exciting. It was different
- 1:03:07than I thought. It was harder to set up than I thought. But
- 1:03:09next time, as I said somewhere in the chat, we will be on
- 1:03:12YouTube because I'll have the like permissions and all that stuff like enabled or set
- 1:03:15up. But yeah, and thank you huge. Thank you to the audience
- 1:03:20everyone who tuned in. There's more of you than I expected. And as
- 1:03:23I said in my note in the chat, like it's honestly touching to me
- 1:03:27when like anybody gives a damn about any of this. So to have six
- 1:03:32people on the panel and more in the audience, like truly means a lot.
- 1:03:37I'm not gonna cry like when Eric sent me the Utah flag, but
- 1:03:39maybe off camera later. Yeah, and I think that's a good place to
- 1:03:45I was just about to say, do we have any final words? We
- 1:03:47already did that, so otherwise it may go on all night. So again,
- 1:03:52thanks to all who participated in any way that you could, and I
- 1:03:57will. Yeah, I don't. I never know how to close anything,
- 1:04:00including these wives. Apparently Tariff has a way to close it. Oh oh
- 1:04:05oh that is a good way. Oh but then I can't click leave.
- 1:04:08I got all right left handed mouse. Bye everyone, Thanks so much,