Latest / Radio Baloney - The Richie Baloney Show! / FACEBOOK Blocks Canadian News Over Trudeau Internet Law

Transcript

FACEBOOK Blocks Canadian News Over Trudeau Internet Law · Radio Baloney - The Richie Baloney Show!

• 0:00
  Well, I don't think it's any secret that Justin Trudeau wants to control the
• 0:03
  Internet and what people can say about him on it, and of course he's
• 0:08
  going to legislate this. We just had another bill pass, Bill C eleven,
• 0:13
  the Online Streaming Act, and the purpose of that is to have a
• 0:18
  government regulator, the CRTC, tell social media companies what they can promote and
• 0:24
  what they shouldn't promote. What's authentic Canadian content. Yes, it's done under
• 0:29
  the guise of promoting Canadian content, but only the content that the government regulator
• 0:35
  themes Canadian content. See, I wonder if there's any possibility that there might
• 0:40
  be some bias happening there. And now we've got another one, Bill C
• 0:44
  eighteen. Here's the headline. Facebook Instagram set to shut down news content in
• 0:49
  Canada after new Trudeau law comes into effect. Meta, the parent company of
• 0:55
  Facebook and Instagram, announced Thursday that it would follow through on plans to block
• 1:00
  Canadians from posting news on the platforms in Canada after Parliament passed the law earlier
• 1:07
  this year requiring the companies to pay media outlets to share their stories. So
• 1:12
  you post a link onto Facebook and then Facebook has to pay the company that
• 1:18
  the link goes to. This really doesn't make any sense because if you click
• 1:23
  on the link, it takes you to their website, that brings eyes to
• 1:26
  their website and advertising revenue. So what it really is is a cash grab
• 1:32
  to try and prop up a failing industry. And I think there's something even
• 1:37
  deeper going on here, but we'll get to that in a second now.
• 1:41
  According to the Hill, the new Canadian law follows the design of a twenty
• 1:45
  twenty one Australian regulation. At the time, Meta made similar threats to restrict
• 1:51
  the platforms in the country, but later yielded to the Australian government. California
• 1:57
  is considering passing a similar law. Out do you think that Facebook is going
• 2:00
  to do this with every single country? Pay them on hundreds of millions or
• 2:06
  billions of dollars. At some point they're going to draw a line in the
• 2:09
  sand, And that line in the sand looks like it might be Canada,
• 2:15
  probably is Canada. And if that's the case, well, news outlets in
• 2:19
  Canada are gonna be denied all of those clicks, the many, many clicks
• 2:23
  they get from Facebook. And according to polling, at twenty five percent of
• 2:29
  Canadians get news get their news from Facebook. So that's a lot less clicks,
• 2:34
  that's a lot less advertising revenue. And I guess it's just lucky for
• 2:38
  the big companies that are going to be losing money because of this, that
• 2:42
  they've got Justin Trudeau to look out for him and hand him a bunch of
• 2:45
  cash like he's been doing all along. And I can't imagine that Trudeau would
• 2:50
  want anything in return, would he. I'm sure he's just concerned about jobs,
• 2:53
  just like he is in the energy sector. Oh wait a second,
• 2:57
  now, just scrub that. Scrub that. As a result of the new
• 3:00
  law, the companies will have to negotiate distribution deals with media outlets in order
• 3:06
  for their content to be linked in the platform's news feeds. If negotiations fail,
• 3:12
  the tech companies can go to arbitration. Well, arbitration, that sounds
• 3:15
  fair, but is it really. Let's I want to show you this article.
• 3:19
  As Sue Gardner, Bill C eighteen is bad for journalism and bad for
• 3:23
  Canada. From the Max Bell School of Public Policy, What would happen if
• 3:28
  C eighteen became law. C eighteen will require Google and Facebook to make agreements
• 3:34
  with news publishers to compensate them for Google and Facebook quote making available publisher's material
• 3:40
  to increase fairness in the marketplace. Yes, and as always with the modern
• 3:46
  left, fairness is a euphemism for favoritism. If a publisher can't reach an
• 3:52
  agreement with Google or Facebook that satisfies them, they will be able to ask
• 3:57
  the CRTC to appoint a mediator to help them reach a deal, and if
• 4:01
  that fails, to appoint an arbitrator. This process will benefit big legacy media
• 4:06
  companies at the expense of startups and indie publishers. Big legacy media companies have
• 4:14
  deal making capacity and lobbying power and presence in Ottawa. The platforms will make
• 4:19
  deals with them first. Indeed, they have already been doing so in anticipation
• 4:25
  of this legislation because they know that if they don't, they risk getting dragged
• 4:30
  in front of a regulator. Yeah, surprise, surprise. So the big
• 4:33
  corporate media that's run by people who like Trudeau and who are already richly rewarded
• 4:41
  by the federal government with subsidies, Yeah, they're going to benefit the most.
• 4:45
  And the little guys, these small news outlets that are reporting on things
• 4:48
  that the big guys don't, Well, it's going to be trouble for them.
• 4:53
  We know the big guys will benefit because that's what's happening elsewhere. Last
• 4:57
  February, Australia broad in the News Media Bargaining Code upon which the Canadian legislation
• 5:03
  is modeled. Since then, it's estimated that about ninety percent of revenues negotiated
• 5:10
  as a result of the new law have gone to Australia's three largest media companies.
• 5:15
  Just like what will happen in Canada, we can expect things to play
• 5:18
  out similarly here. In fact, they already are in anticipation of this or
• 5:24
  similar legislation. Google has struck deals with The Globe and Mail, the Toronto
• 5:29
  Star, led Devoir, and Winnipeg Free Press, as well as some smaller
• 5:32
  organizations. Meanwhile, many small and indie publishers are actually excluded from C.
• 5:40
  Eighteen. The bill excludes operations that employ fewer than two journalists and excludes those
• 5:46
  quote primarily focused on a particular topic in favor of those that make general interest
• 5:51
  news. Yeah, this isn't about saving the industry. This is about getting
• 5:58
  rid of all those pest ski smaller outlets who don't care about winning Trudeau's favor
• 6:03
  or any politicians favor. This is about having a few big corporate news outlets
• 6:10
  where the people who run them all go to the same dinner parties and all
• 6:14
  think roughly the same thing and are incentivized not to get on the wrong side
• 6:18
  of the power at the top, who ultimately controls their destiny. And if
• 6:24
  Canadians end up not being able to access news on Facebook or even Google,
• 6:29
  if you know, the legislation becomes absurd enough, which I don't think that's
• 6:33
  unlikely in Trudeau's Canada. So even if that happens, I'm sure Trudeau will
• 6:39
  be just fine with that as well, because financially that would put the major
• 6:43
  media companies even more in his pocket, or for that matter, any leader's
• 6:47
  pocket going forward. That may be good for them. That may be good
• 6:51
  financially for the media companies because they're just going to get bailed out anyway.
• 6:57
  But Canadians, regular Canadians who are interested in things like truth, well you
• 7:00
  know how it goes anyway. Please subscribe, like and share sharing It really
• 7:04
  helps me out. I thank you for that. I will see you next time.