Latest / Automotive State of The Union / There Is No Technician Shortage... IF You're Invested In Your Community
Transcript
- 0:00[upbeat music] Good morning. It is March 22nd. We're just two episodes away from episode 1,000 of the Automotive Troublemaker.
- 0:07And I don't know if it's in celebration of that, Kyle, but we have Todd Caputo and two very special guests for you today. [upbeat music] Oh, almost ran out of breath there. Woo. You went for, you went for the full jump.
- 0:18I didn't take a big enough breath. Right off the bat. That was good. Man, I, you know what? This is, I think this is actually a first for a Saturday episode, but I like the vibe.
- 0:28You know, we're always talking about community, we're, we're talking about what people are doing, and we had, Todd, you were, you were like, this is your first on location. Saw you doing selfie videos walking around.
- 0:39Yeah. Yeah. How'd that feel? I, I need, I need, it, I need some work, to be quite honest with you. I think I need some training.
- 0:42Well, I wasn't gonna say it, but [laughs] But I, I, I did buy some $200 gimbal that I tried to learn how to use when I was there. That, that explains- That I walked around with...
- 0:51why some of it looked [laughs] really good. Yeah. Yeah. So that was the... But, um, yeah, I, I need some more equipment and some more practice, but what an awesome event. Yeah. I mean, I don't wanna get...
- 0:59But it was, it was amazing. Um, thanks for asking me to do it. Um, it was great. I mean, I can't say enough about it.
- 1:05Well, tell us about how, tell us about how you first found out about the event and then- Well, I found out about it f- really from, from you and Nathan, right? Like,
- 1:11you know, you guys reached out to me and said, "There's an event in Charlotte." Um- AKA Nathan, because I can't, I don't remember details. But [laughs] Well, Nathan, so Nathan said, "Hey, y- we know you live there.
- 1:22Um, Paul and Kyle cannot get there. There's just too much going on, and it's in your own backyard. Are you interested in going down and, um, and covering this for us?" And I'm like, "Yeah, I'd love to."
- 1:31So I went and, and met Ahmad, right, who, uh, I'll introduce in a second, who's responsible and, and, and the, uh... Uh, what's your title, Ahmad?
- 1:41Are you the vice president of the or the president of the, uh, Greater Charter, Charlotte Auto Dealers Association? What's your formal title? Yeah. Formal title is, uh, executive director, but- Yeah.
- 1:50So I, I went and met him first at his office and got to know him a little bit. Uh, he just had a beautiful baby girl. I hope you don't mind me bringing that up- Congrats... but I'll bring it up anyways. Congrats.
- 1:59Thank you. Right, like, right, right, his, his wife was due, I think, like, three days before I met him. But, um- Yeah...
- 2:04I got to know him a little bit, found out what the association does, and he told me what this event was gonna be in. I was just so excited when I got there. Um, I was able to meet George, right, from ASE, who...
- 2:15George, if you wanna introduce yourself, if you don't mind. George Aarons, Vice President, ASE Education Foundation. So I get there, I pull into Charlotte Motor Speedway, which is just- Awesome...
- 2:25an amazing, awesome place, right? Like- Aw. Just a place to have a thing, right? Yeah. Wow. And I live, I live in NASCAR heaven, like, literally car heaven.
- 2:32It's the best place to live in the world if you love cars like me. And, um, there's kids everywhere. There's buses out in the parking lot. I walk in and there's literally kids everywhere.
- 2:43You know, mostly guys, but girls as well, that all just love cars and, and wanna be, uh, auto mechanics at the end of the day. And it was just [laughs] it was, it was amazing, right?
- 2:55And these guys can kind of get into the details of exactly what, you know, the d- the day looked like.
- 2:59But from my perspective, o- of someone that used to be a dealer and now a consultant in the industry, I c- I, I can't even tell you what an amazing event this was, um, for just,
- 3:10just enthusiasm for the car business and, and, and just seeing these kids that are so excited about getting into the workforce and just love car dealerships and, and love cars and love fixing them.
- 3:20And it g- it was awesome. So I, I can't say enough how, how awesome it was. Yeah. Oh, my gosh. Warm, warm fuzzies all around.
- 3:25Ahmad, why don't you tell us, um, kind of, like, the origin of the event and why you all support it the way you do? Yeah. And George can get into the de- uh, details regarding that too.
- 3:35But, uh, three years ago, the, our association, uh, my predecessor, Jen Jackson, was able to go out and visit, uh, the North Texas, um, competition that takes place there.
- 3:45And, and George and his team have really come up with these competitions across the country, and we saw value in doing that and bringing it to our dealers and our community, uh, and schools here in Charlotte.
- 3:56So it started as, I believe there was 10 teams that competed from a number of different schools that, uh, are in our greater Charlotte region. Uh, we are blessed this year to get to 22 teams- Whoa...
- 4:08uh, within the organization this year. Good. So it continues to grow each year. The automotive students at the high schools are excited about it. The instructors are excited about it.
- 4:17Uh, we get a- How many people on a team? How many people on a team? Yep. So there's three students that actually compete on the team, two on vehicle, and then there's one alternate.
- 4:25So all three of those students will go into the automotive dealership and work and have that time to, uh, actually be inside the back service area and men- get mentored by the dealership for, uh, 15 to 20 hours leading up to the event.
- 4:41So that's another piece that's really cool for the, the dealership side and the community side, 'cause oftentimes you'll see, you know, a school might have a partnership with one high school that's right by them.
- 4:53But what we try to also do is rotate those high schools so the community and the connections do change and there's new, you know, different learning tools and different con, uh, ways that they can meet dealers and those dealers can meet the schools, uh, that may not be directly right next door to them as well.
- 5:10Yeah. George... Oh, Kyle, were you gonna say something? Sorry, yeah.
- 5:12Well, yeah, I was gonna say, so George, obviously it seems like you're doing this, you know, not just in Charlotte, you guys have been kind of implementing a similar strategy across different cities and states across the US.
- 5:24Um, w- what, what's been like... Because so much right now is focused in our, in our industry around, you know, finding technicians, technician shortages, and- There's no technician shortage.
- 5:37There's no technician shortage? Okay, gr- I love that. Tell me about what, what you mean. I was gonna, I was gonna cue that. I was gonna cue that up- That's amazing... and you just did it.
- 5:46'Cause it's the first thing he said to me when I met him. Yep. When you say there's no technician shortage, what, what do you mean by that and where is that coming from?
- 5:52So everybody says there's a technician shortage, but I ask most employers, "Do you have a shortage of applicants or do you have a shortage of qualified applicants?"
- 6:01Nearly 90% say qualified applicants.That means we don't have a lack of interest in our industry, it's just that maybe the skill sets of those individuals doesn't match what the employer needs. Mm.
- 6:14Well, part of that problem is that employer or dealer who's both a personal and professional taxpayer in their community is not involved in their local high school or college automotive program, telling that school how to spend th- their money as taxpayers.
- 6:30But more importantly, what are they looking for in an entry level employee? [ding] Yeah. That's where the disconnect comes. And I tell people, "We have a national concern with a local solution. Get involved.
- 6:41If you're not involved in your local program, you're part of the problem." The way- You got all of the sa- a national concern with a local solution.
- 6:47[laughs] Like, I, I'm, I'm like, what, which one are we gonna use for the headline of this podcast? Okay. [laughs] You're just dropping these things. Okay. National... [laughs] It's so good.
- 6:55So, um- I'm sorry to interrupt you. It was just so good. A- and when, uh, t- when we met Todd, you know, when you talk to employers and you hear about technicians leaving all the time, and they always say, "It's money."
- 7:07It's not money. My question is, why were they looking in the first place? [ding] Any of us who's happy in our job, we're not looking. Those of us who are unhappy or unappreciated, [ding] we're out looking.
- 7:18And when we're out looking, guess what? We m- a lot of times get more money. So- Mm... it's about culture. And a lot of times employers have to look in the mirror, 'cause the problem's there. You know?
- 7:29A technician- Yeah... doesn't wake up one morning- George... and say, "I'm gonna pack up my toolbox." George, I'm gonna give you a microphone. [laughs] What are you doing on May 14th?
- 7:38[laughs] Like, this is, this is so good because, you know, our industry has just been overwhelmed with technician shortage. Can't find good people, can't find right people.
- 7:49And we've been talking about- No, they can't keep good people. [ding] Yeah, they, you gotta keep the good people. You gotta g- you gotta be engaged early.
- 7:55Well, you know, we've talked about, like, what CMA and some other c- corporations are doing, you know, at a high school, college, and even down into middle school level to, like, get people interested- We're working on a middle school project...
- 8:06educated, all of those things, right? Yep. So here- Yeah... here's the, here's the thing is. This technician shortage is only as big as it is for your organization. It's that simple. If you need one person- [laughs]...
- 8:18that's as big as it is. You have a one person- Total technician shortage, right. [laughs] It's, it's, if you need two or three.
- 8:24But, but if you have a revolving door, before you hire anybody else, you need to go fix the problem. 'Cause the problem is culture. George, what did you do before you do this?
- 8:36Um, I taught high school and college automotive. I was a technician. Um, recruited for WyoTech and did a lot of different things. [laughs] That's amazing. It's okay.
- 8:47I mean, Todd, obviously you, you've, like, there's just so much learning when you get involved in something like this, and I'm seeing- Yeah... I'm, you know, we're on video, people can only hear us, but I'm just- Yeah...
- 8:56seeing you nod and going like, "I was learning these things." Well, so- "This is new." Right? It's, it's, it's textbook as the way it should be done.
- 9:03You have a, a, a very well run, highly involved dealer association in a local level, right? Yep. Charlotte's a big area, don't get me wrong. And there were, it wasn't just to me.
- 9:13Like, so I met some people from South Carolina. I mean, Charlotte and County- Yeah... Charlotte's right in the corner of the state. So you get South Carolina, some counties in North Carolina.
- 9:20So you have an involved dealer association, right? And then you have a partner like ASC that puts these things on and does it right.
- 9:25And the other thing that I wanted to add, too, and I brought this up in some of the footage that I sent you. These kids weren't just there to diagnose cars, right? They were also there to, to actually interview for jobs.
- 9:35[ding] And they got graded how they interviewed. Like, that was part of their score to actually win. Yeah.
- 9:40So they're actually learning how to go through an interview process, which, and a lot of that stuff's not taught in schools, at least the way that it should be, in my opinion.
- 9:47So ha- that being part of it, I think was huge, too, which made it a very well-rounded event. And I gotta tell you, these guys were there, so they'll,
- 9:55they, they can share this with you, but the smiles on these kids' faces, to be there, to feel wanted by all these different large and small dealer groups that were there recruiting these kids, as they're at Charlotte Motor Speedway, when they were actually...
- 10:08There were cars running around the track. You could hear it. Like, these cars, it was awesome. [laughs] Sometimes it was hard to hear. [laughs] But, like, it was just amazing.
- 10:15So you, you, you put yourself in a, in a- The energy... yeah, in a 17 year or 18-year-old k- kid's shoes. And then there was another group that came in.
- 10:21They just, that other group that came in on the buses kinda later in the day, they weren't part of the competition. They were just there to kind of s- watch, right? What was that all about? Yes.
- 10:28We invite, uh, there's 22 different automotive tech programs in the 11 counties that we serve. Some of them may have new teachers.
- 10:36Some of them may just wanna see what the competition is entitled before they go and, uh, com- compete the next year.
- 10:42But then we invite schools that don't have automotive technician programs, so that way those kids have the opportunity to really get involved as well. And maybe in the future they get involved in the, in the industry.
- 10:52So we start out at some of our local middle schools, they'll come out as well.
- 10:56And then invite, we had 325 students that were not participating in the actual competition come out to the career fair portion of the event as, too.
- 11:07Tell us what, do you have any stories, Ahmad, from, you know, of students that came through this program and ended up in dealerships and are- Oh, yeah. Yeah... doing very successful now? Like, tell, tell us one or two.
- 11:18Mm-hmm. Yeah, I know just from this event specifically, uh, I try to get with every dealer that has a team and see w- you know, how they're doing inside the shop.
- 11:29And there's been, uh, out of the 22 dealers that were participating, I know for a fact that 12 kids are for sure getting jobs after this event.
- 11:38And that's just from the ones that I've had one-on-one conversations from- Come on... uh, at the event itself. So this is- And they're not exactly minimum wage jobs. No. No, exa- yeah. So that's- Exactly.
- 11:49That's the beauty of what we do. It, we disguise the competition from our real objective. And our real objective is a long-term interview for the students to spend time in the dealership.
- 12:02And then if the dealer likes the kid or kids-They're gonna hire them, man. Um, so when we started this with the North Texas Auto Dealers some six years ago, we started at the Fort Worth Auto Show with eight teams. Um,
- 12:19today we're at 45 teams in Texas Motor Speedway, and last year 78 students secured employment in new car dealer franchises. So- This is as, like, 17 and 18-year-olds, correct? 18-year-olds. That's amazing.
- 12:33[laughs] So they're seniors only- Holy college recruitment, man. This is amazing. [laughs] Right? Like, this is like pro s- or college sports almost. It, it is.
- 12:41So [clears throat] most people, teenagers and adults, are horrible in a 20-minute interview, let's be honest. They just, just they- [laughs] Absolutely... not good. Absolutely.
- 12:52But by, but what Ahmad and his team do, and the others that do this, we partner a dealer with a high school, and the instructor picks three good seniors that are interested in a career path.
- 13:04Those students shadow in the dealership for, like Ahmad said, 10 to 15 hours a week for up to 10 weeks, and they learn the factory scan tool, factory service information, how to type into the repair order, tell the story, how to approach diagnostic procedures, how to do a multi-point inspection.
- 13:24And then when it's all over at the competition, the car they've been learning on is sitting there bugged. Basic set of hand tools, factory scan tool, factory service information.
- 13:35And our friends at ALLDATA provide us with a shop management system, and there's a repair order for each vehicle that's custom to that car. [laughs] Wow.
- 13:44And they only score points by how they type in the cause and correction. So they can fix the whole car, but if it's not on the repair order, just like a technician- Yeah... they don't get points. It doesn't count.
- 13:55They don't get paid. You know, I was just... I was driving in, I have an 18-year-old son, and he works as a, a content creator and editor here for us at ASOTU.
- 14:04Um, but we were talking about one of his friends said he's going to college next year, so he's taking, like, this gap year. And I was like, "Well, what's he going to college for?"
- 14:12And he said, "Ah, something to do with, like, robotic prosthetics or something like that." And I was like, "Well, well, that's what he wants to do." "Well," he said, "that's what he wants to do."
- 14:22I said, "What's he wanna do?" He said, "He wants to do that." I said, "What's he going to college for?" He said, "He can go to college for anything, it just needs to be a four-year degree, so he's taking business."
- 14:30And I was like, "Wait a minute. So he wants to do that, it requires a college degree, and it doesn't even have to necessarily be in that field." And my son was just like, "What a waste of time.
- 14:40Like, what a waste- [laughs]... of four years and money. Like, why can't you just go do the thing you wanna do?"
- 14:45And here we have 18, having 17, 18-year-old students being like, "This is what I wanna do," getting trained, recruited, courted by indus- you know, by companies that'll be able to put them right to work, and within, if they're good, within several years will really be approaching six figures.
- 15:00So- By the time that kid gets out of college to do the thing that he didn't no- need to go to college for. Right.
- 15:05[laughs] And what's, what's, what's really cool about this is all the different competitions you hear about the success stories.
- 15:14We do one in Houston outside where I live, and their top two teams go to North Texas to compete. But [clears throat] the Nissan dealer, Starling McCall Nissan, took a team and three students.
- 15:28Not only did they hire all three students, but they hired two of their friends. They got five technicians from a competition.
- 15:37And Rudy, who's the service manager, said, "George, if it wasn't for this competition, I would've never met any of those kids." Woo. That's amazing. What an amazing thing.
- 15:46Well, Todd, thanks for introducing us, and thanks for, thanks for being on the ground. Ahmad, George, thanks for joining us today. I, like, we've gotta do this again. George, A- Ahmad- You guys-...
- 15:56look at your schedule in mid-May because, uh, because I think, uh, finding your way to, uh, the greater Baltimore area may make a whole bunch of sense- Oh, yeah...
- 16:03'cause there's a lot of people that need to know more about this, that can do this across the industry. We're gonna be keep talking about this, uh- Yeah. Well, I could-... but for today, yeah, it's time...
- 16:12Paul and Kyle, you need to go to one of these. I'm telling you right now. Let's do it. Yeah. You guys need to go, and you gotta cover it. We're down.
- 16:17Gotta connect with George, and whether it's in Charlotte, I'd love for you to come stay and hang out with me- Heck yeah. Get done... next year if you do it. [laughs] But if you don't, like, the...
- 16:24George, where, you do these, um, where? 'Cause you told me- The, the-... like, all across the country. Yeah. The one at Texas Motor Speedway is the first Thursday and Friday of December.
- 16:32And, uh, we're looking to expand that competition to include trucks, uh, medium duty trucks. Um, in the Balt- Super smart... in the Baltimore area, I'll be at, uh, Dover Speedway the end of May.
- 16:46We partnered with the Goodguys car shows, and we have an event on Fridays called Careers in Hot Rodding, and we bring out high school automotive and collision seniors, and we do an event with them and builders and showcase the other part of our industry.
- 17:02Good night. Okay. Well, we're gonna ke- we're gonna keep connecting, get some dates on the calendar, get some things coordinated so, uh, we can bring this to more people.
- 17:10George, Ahmad, Todd, as usual, thank you for joining us on the show today and doing- Thanks... all the meaningful work you do.
- 17:16We're not just talking about today, but the next generation and solving all the problems, uh, that our industry needs to solve.
- 17:22[upbeat music]