Latest / Five Games for Doomsday / Advent Calendar-Dec 1st-Wingspan
Transcript
- 0:13From the kitchen of the cabin, we look the best games of all time
- 0:17according to board game Geek in Ben and Steve's advent calendar or December the first
- 0:31Eve. Isn't it lovely to be outside? Genuinely on December the first Eve?
- 0:35Yeah? I don't really look forward to winter in Berlin, but there
- 0:38is something about this particular season. It's crisp, the Christmas markets, the
- 0:43sort of like uncharacteristically jovial, jovial, jovial. Yeah, that's the word.
- 0:49Jovial atmosphere in Germany, like the entire rest of the year, like
- 0:53no, no, nobody's fucking got Yeah, I get it, I get
- 0:58it. I love it too, because you know, you go outside and
- 0:59you get pissed. Yeah, on glue vine. So that's the one thing
- 1:02about Germans, right, They love a drink. Didn't like, they love
- 1:06a drink. Who doesn't love a drink? Who doesn't love a drink?
- 1:07Well, I mean like one third of the world, I suppose, yeah,
- 1:11dang drink. I assume they love a drink, but they just can't
- 1:14have a drink, that's the thing. And not out in the open of
- 1:15course exactly. Anyway, So here we are December the first. It's is
- 1:19it is genuinely December. It is December the first, that's true, right,
- 1:25And we're here to talk about this year's advent calendar. We discuss a
- 1:30game every day up until Christmas Day. Steve, it's a great idea.
- 1:36It was yours, wasn't it? Last year? Well? I kind of
- 1:38like pitched the premise and you like fill it out because you were you were
- 1:41so bored because you were stuck in America last year. Yeah, you just
- 1:44needed something to do, so you did this. Who else am I going
- 1:47to reach out to? So? Last year I have a benship hole in
- 1:52yah exactly somewhere exactly. So last year we just talked about games we wanted
- 1:56to talk about. But this year we're going to be more systematic. Yep,
- 2:00I'm going to talk about the board game gig top twenty five games State.
- 2:04Now, this is your idea, So let me ask you why that
- 2:07wasn't wasn't it? No? Someone suggested it on the ever fucking useful five
- 2:13Games for Doday discord. Right, we've basically have outsourced all of our ideas
- 2:16to the community, to the Discord. Yet it's great. The actual board
- 2:19game community so do you think we'll talk about the game in a second,
- 2:23But do you think the discord has hit critical mass yet? I don't know
- 2:27what counts as critical mass. Is it like completely self sustaining without us?
- 2:30Is that what you mean? Yeah? And I think it kind of is
- 2:34that. No, that's good, isn't it. I think there are a
- 2:36lot of interesting conversations happening, and like whether or not we weigh in,
- 2:38Yeah, exactly, So this is going to be an interesting conversation because number
- 2:42twenty five, according to board game Giek, the twenty fifth best game in
- 2:46the world, Steve Ye is one that I think you like more than me.
- 2:51Okay, And you know, whenever I don't give universal praise to this
- 2:58game, well, actually, when you don't give universal praise to things,
- 3:00people go, oh, you don't like it, and it's something I don't
- 3:02like it. I just I think I think the game is fine, and
- 3:07I think but I think it is certainly the twenty fifth best game in the
- 3:12world. I think it's it's an overrated title, and this one is Wingspan.
- 3:15I think we have to say, do you agree with me? Yes,
- 3:19I'm gonna agree with you, But I also want to say that when
- 3:21we talk about games we like or don't like, or we have critiques,
- 3:25I think we're really talking about like the top sliver of all games that have
- 3:30ever been made, and like very distinctions among them, right, because we're
- 3:35not talking about par cheesy. I mean this is true or like Risk or
- 3:39Mousetrap or Monopoly or what. So. I am sure you have played twenty
- 3:44five games that you would rank higher than Wingspan, right, sure, right,
- 3:47and yet Wingspan. So I think every kind of decade you get at
- 3:54least one sort of evergreen classic. Yeah. So in the nineties, it
- 4:00was, the nineties was pretty well. So the nineties you had Katan yep,
- 4:05two thousands was quite good. Actually, you had Ticket to Ride.
- 4:08You had a Carcassan pandemic dominion, right is a rather big hits? Yeah,
- 4:13yeah, a bunch of ryder, knittier games, like at least five
- 4:15hundred twenty tens. You've got what I'm trying to think of, like as
- 4:20like a classic. Yeah, of like the big sort of Azul maybe.
- 4:26Yeah, Castle's a Burgandy if you Wingspan count wings Span hums. Wingspan released
- 4:32I think twenty I don't know, twenty seventeen. Yeah, and then and
- 4:38then we haven't seen in this decade yet, and I think of the twenty
- 4:43tens, Wingspan is the one. It's the one you would talk about as
- 4:46being the sort of eternal classic. Yeah. And I don't think Wingspan is
- 4:50as big as Ticket to Rider Caracroissan much any game ever will be as big
- 4:55as as those again, because I think the market is just so different and
- 4:58so like much larger, and so much are fragmented. But Wingspan is still
- 5:00a game that sells gangbusters, right, So why the tenth of Catan though?
- 5:04Right? Yeah, but Catan's had Catans had twenty five years on it,
- 5:10right, I think, I think Wingspan, Yeah, and they continue
- 5:12to come out with expansions, as with the other game board game empires.
- 5:15I think Wingspan is a it's like the euro game for families. Yeah,
- 5:23and it broke up in a new sort of thematic category for board games like
- 5:28animals and that. So I don't think that's true. I think there have
- 5:31been nature games forever, but you know what I think, Wait, wait,
- 5:33wait, you know you this is the distinction. Though they have been
- 5:36animal games, have there been nature games? I think so? I think
- 5:40so, like what they're probably ten thousand. We can't think of Johnny's Walk
- 5:45through the Woods, right, Yeah, what Bob Johnston's Bob Johnson loves the
- 5:50High Kings, Click Up the Mountain, Morel's for instance, Mermis for instance.
- 5:56Morel's come out before Wingspan. Yeah, I mean that. I don't
- 6:00know. Then I'm talking out of my ass, but I think somehow Wingspan
- 6:03popularized the like medium weight euro category for this. But so so, do
- 6:11you know what? I think Wingspan was fucking great at the yes ending in
- 6:14I don't know. I think Wingspan was the first one of what the first
- 6:18coffee table game? What a game that you you talk about having and like
- 6:24the New York Times writes articles about and yeah, exactly if Hargrave goes on
- 6:28NPR, right exactly, it is a game that you would have on your
- 6:30coffee table that would imbue you with a level of sophistication. I mean,
- 6:36there must be something about it. Maybe I can't quite say what it is,
- 6:41like it's like the National Geographic of board games. It's more than that,
- 6:45because the National Geographic on your coffee table, so that it's on your
- 6:49coffee table, but it is you don't read it. This is true,
- 6:53but Wingspan is a is a refined piece of design work, and I mean
- 6:58I mean sort of the will design. It's beautiful as much as it is
- 7:01a board game. Yeah, I think that's a huge contribution to its success.
- 7:05But tell me why you think the game is good? Do I think
- 7:11it's good? Do you think it's good? Well? I have a good
- 7:13time playing it. I mean, like coming from a lot of other euro
- 7:16games, it's it purports to be a card driven engine builder type of game,
- 7:21and I don't know, it's like quite pleasant to play. You have
- 7:25some goals, you draw some birds. The birds are fun, and I
- 7:29think you can play the game with just about anybody. I mean maybe,
- 7:30I don't know if people call it an entry entry game. I mean I
- 7:33think it certainly has brought a lot of attention to the hobby. I mean,
- 7:38for me, what's more important about Wingspan is not whether it's good or
- 7:42not. It's just like some memories I have about it, which is well.
- 7:46We met Elizabeth Hargrave at Berlin Bretspiel Khan. We had a very nice
- 7:49time playing games with her, and then that was before the pandemic. We
- 7:53played an animal game with her, actually we did which one was it Dungeon
- 7:57Pets. Yeah, And I think while we were playing that or other game,
- 8:00there were people right behind us playing Wingspan really with it, yeah,
- 8:03and then I think they had some question about a rule and I invited Elizabeth
- 8:07to go over and set them straight, and she demurred. She did not
- 8:11want to be known in the crowd. I think she's very well known now
- 8:13anyway, during the pandemic, I actually invited Elizabeth to play Wingspan with with
- 8:20Sam, Sam and myself. Yeah, Sam, being your good lady wife,
- 8:22yeah, over the internet, and she did. She kicked her asses,
- 8:24by the way. Sure. And then later I played Great Zimbabwe with
- 8:28her and yeah, I know we just developed. I wouldn't say friendship per
- 8:33se. We don't. We're not in touch all the time, Ben,
- 8:35But I thought that was quite you know, lovely to have that really nice.
- 8:39Yeah. So so what's what's interesting? Is it ease? I think
- 8:41Wingspan might be It's hard for me to separate the gameplay from that memory,
- 8:45which I think is true for a lot of plays of a lot of games.
- 8:46Sure, I think, And that's what games do, right, Yeah,
- 8:50they attached themselves to memories. That's why it's like that game of Googong.
- 8:54We had forget it, love it. So it's like, but the
- 8:58thing is, I think Wingspan is the most middle class game. I mean,
- 9:01it really is, right, it's exquisite, it's it's it's beautifully fabricated.
- 9:09It's fine. Not particularly expensive, though, is it. No?
- 9:13And this is very approachable to Jamie's credit, It's got those loves of little
- 9:16eggs. So I think Jamie understood what kind of game it was. But
- 9:20also I think Jamie understood that it can't be ludicrously expensive, and I think
- 9:24that's very wise. So I'm going to say something now. And when I
- 9:30said this to our friend lemon Cello, yep, he scoffed at me.
- 9:33Okay, Wingspan is not an engine builder, so he thinks it is.
- 9:39Everyone thinks it it is. Well, engine builders, I think you would
- 9:43typically have a bit more control over the engine that you can build exactly,
- 9:48and Wingspan is a bit more random than that. You sort of have to
- 9:50there's too many cards. You have to deal with the cards that you get,
- 9:56and you may be able to come up with some kind of engine.
- 10:00Does that just qualify it for you as an engine builder? Though? Yes,
- 10:03because the point is with an Engine Builder, is you build an engine
- 10:05in Wingspan? It is coincidence whether you build an engine because there are just
- 10:09so many cars. So it's a pleasant game. It functions potato. No,
- 10:16it absolutely not. Like why hold the line on what defines an engine
- 10:20builder in this case? Well, because if you're building an engine and you
- 10:22have, you know, various parts that would fit into your engine to make
- 10:28your engine function, or you're building an engine and you just have a load
- 10:31of disparate, disparate shit that if you manage to rummage through enough you might
- 10:37be able to build an engine, I would say one is an engine builder.
- 10:39One isn't it right? I think you can't win the game unless you
- 10:43have some kind of like you have to have combos. Right, Well,
- 10:46well, this is the point. I'm not sure you do tap tactical card
- 10:50combo game, but Tableau Builder, I mean, how would you categorize it?
- 10:56Then? So it is a it is a pleasant can't collection Gabe?
- 11:01So I think that it's a It's a fine game. I would never turn
- 11:07it down. I don't think no, nor me. On the other hand,
- 11:09given its popularity and the number of expansions, I guess I don't quite
- 11:13understand why I'd want to play it like over and over and over again.
- 11:16So I'm gonna ask you to rank now in front of all these people.
- 11:20Have a rank in front of all of these people, all the people in
- 11:24the Christmas market. Okay, they're not really paying attention to us though,
- 11:28Yeah, so you you'll be able to have a rank people would notice.
- 11:31So the big three Yep, wings Fan, so the big three for the
- 11:37listeners, Tickets, Rides, Catan, Coxon Yep, wings Fan, YEP,
- 11:43Pandemic YEP, Dominion have a big rank in front of all the I've
- 11:50got to rank all of these right in order of your preference. Okay,
- 11:54Okay, I gotta think, gotta think, I gotta think where would I
- 11:58rank these? I'm thinking for number one, am I gonna do a Pandemic
- 12:01or Carcasson? I think I want to say. I really want to say
- 12:07Pandemic at number one. Yep. The reason is it convinced me that co
- 12:11op games can work and can be brilliant yep. And it was just such
- 12:16a such a discovery. And I know that it was a discovery for you
- 12:20for a different reason, but like it opened up legacy games for me,
- 12:22and I think I know that you don't like part two, but I found
- 12:26all of them to be like equally competed. I didn't like it. I
- 12:28just don't think it's a patch on the other. I mean, I really
- 12:31liked all of them, and I really liked the experience of playing them,
- 12:33and also the other pandemic variation. So it's a very different type of game.
- 12:35I think Carcassone number two because of its just infinite variability and it's sort
- 12:41of like I love the tile laying. It's like you're painting a picture of
- 12:43this air z that to medieval scene as you play the game. It's quite
- 12:48lovely. Number three, I'm gonna go for Dominion. Dominion came along at
- 12:54a at a moment in my board gaming career when I wasn't actively acquiring games,
- 12:58but this when I played just over and over and over again. I
- 13:01had just recently come off of being like completely fed up with Magic the Gathering,
- 13:05and this was a kind of deck building sort of game that I immediately
- 13:09found familiar. But it was just sort of like not complicated enough. It
- 13:16had just enough stuff to be enjoyable, but I didn't have to like collect
- 13:20I know that has endlyst experience. It's a true revolution. I think.
- 13:22Yeah, Like I didn't have to have any of the expansions, you know,
- 13:24I can enjoy just just as a quick sidebar. Someone's come to the
- 13:28Christmas market and they're drinking a beer that's not with the spirit of things.
- 13:31Have they I mean they sell them. They do. We don't have a
- 13:33beer, you have a booze. At least make it hot. Anyway,
- 13:37So we got we got pandemic, pandemic carcassone, Coxon dominion, dominion,
- 13:41And I'm gonna have to say settlers ticket to ride. Yeah, I don't
- 13:46think I'm gonna be able to give ticket to ride a very fair hearing because
- 13:48I've only played it once. Yeah, it's great. I've played loads of
- 13:52Catan. I've played it. I've played to Ride a few times recently,
- 13:56and it really is spectacularly good. I think it's a good game. I
- 13:58just I don't. I don't feel like I know it well enough to say
- 14:01more about it. I think if I played it more, it could rise
- 14:03in the rankings here relatively to the relative to the others. Actually a good
- 14:09question. Do I put a wingspan above Catan? I think I might.
- 14:11I might because as much as I love Catan, I have nostalgia for it.
- 14:15I don't think I ever need to play it again. And I don't
- 14:16think it's as good a game as Wingspan. And it's also too long.
- 14:20Yeah, So for what it is, I'm gonna quick rank in front of
- 14:22all of these people, all right, Coxon number one. Out of all
- 14:26of these games that I've listed, Coxon is the best design. It is
- 14:31almost a perfect game. Then Pandemic number two. Okay, just because we
- 14:37would be speaking to each other if it wasn't for Pandemic. It's a very
- 14:39special game to me and I are very close on these two, and I
- 14:43think Pandemic Season zero is one of the best games I ever made. Yes,
- 14:46agree, Uh, dominion, just simply because it's an absolute thunderbolt of
- 14:52originality and deserves to be. It is the last can you think of a
- 14:58mechanic that's been invented since a mechanic? I mean when was like the card
- 15:03driven game in the eighties, like long ago? Yeah that was Mark Coleman
- 15:05in the eighties, right, Yeah, I mean just it has a lot
- 15:07of staying power in there. Yeah, Dominion. Then Ticket to Ride,
- 15:11because I've been playing it a bit recently and it's brilliant. And Alan Moon
- 15:16I said this in a review my review of Sunrise Lane. Alan Moon understands
- 15:20something about family games is that the phrase I used is this, they should
- 15:24have dirt easy rules that enable you to geld your friend and family. Why
- 15:30don't we play Ticket to Ride Legacy this winter? Yeah, let's do that.
- 15:33Let's do that. Yeah. Yeah, So Tickets Ride is brilliant and
- 15:35it's nasty and that's the important thing. Then Wingspan and it's a train game
- 15:41that's an absolute like ballag to get through. No, No, then Wingspan,
- 15:46then Qatar. Okay, so we're pretty close here. Yeah, all
- 15:48right, so well it's fifteen minutes. So that's December, the first eve.
- 15:56I love you. Yeah, thank you for listening. You can support
- 16:03the show at Patreon dot com, forward slash five gfi D and join the
- 16:07discord by going to five g f D dot com. Have a very merry Christmas