Latest / Newcomer Pod / SBF in Shambles (w/Teddy Schleifer)
Transcript
- 0:05Welcome silicon Sally. We've been had welcome to Jad
- 0:14Cat episode about how Sam Venkman freed fooled us all
- 0:18Trick the world. The ultimate con.
- 0:21It's been the craziest story in Tech.
- 0:22Like, I don't know, I think since, I mean, I covered Uber so
- 0:26closely, but I think this is crazy.
- 0:27I mean, in terms of 0 to 100 this, Is the biggest scam CEO
- 0:33story. Since we've started covering
- 0:36Tech design, we disagree with that.
- 0:37Well, first of all, I would say 100 to 0, not 0, to 100.
- 0:41And, and to go full Bill Simmons on this here.
- 0:44I would say we're looking at, maybe what is one of the
- 0:46craziest weeks in VC like Tech History?
- 0:50Like, I think this got a rank up there in terms of one of the
- 0:52most just like astonishing story lines, hilarious characters,
- 0:57being, you know, brought up to the This is got a rank up.
- 1:01There's got to be top five. Did I introduce Our Guest?
- 1:03We have teddy slavery early. I think we just will just want
- 1:06to jump in people. Figure it out, figure it out,
- 1:08halfway through. Its got the fedayeen here,
- 1:10Teddy's life or you can't see the video here but he is he's
- 1:13looking like Yasser. Arafat his prime.
- 1:15I'm pretty sick, daddy. We've called you the ask me off
- 1:18whisper before, you know now, Alex?
- 1:20Yeah, I've gotten a few texts from people who are like, sorry
- 1:23for your loss. Such a good story.
- 1:26Or, like, I think is reporters always.
- 1:29I love, you know, maybe consciously or unconsciously
- 1:33like I'm betting on storylines, right?
- 1:35Right people you think are interesting and obviously Sam is
- 1:38still interesting for other reasons.
- 1:40Very interesting, I would have more interesting but however
- 1:43I've gotten a few messages from people that are like suggest
- 1:46that you know, Odin better for you know my career if he was
- 1:50exploring the read between the lines for the listener a little
- 1:53bit, I mean you in particular cover sort of philanthropy and
- 1:57wealth and this is a guy who is doing In the most interesting
- 2:00stuff. I mean, funneling tons of money
- 2:02into effective altruism using as well, swearing.
- 2:05He was going to give it all away.
- 2:07And so if you cover the philanthropy wealth beat, and
- 2:09you have this guy who's pretty open about it, creative about
- 2:12it. I mean, it's just the story that
- 2:14keeps on giving, I mean, that's what you're saying.
- 2:16Yeah. Yeah, I mean, you know, look, I
- 2:17mean, he shot out of a cannon. I think I do think it was 0 to
- 2:20100, 100 100 0. I mean, he is someone who I
- 2:25first talked to Sam and like September 20 20 was off the
- 2:32Record but it was based sandwich, starting to do more
- 2:35and more political donations. And at that point, like no one
- 2:38knew who he was. This is not a brag.
- 2:40It's like a point about like, the speed here and I stand back.
- 2:43Yeah, well on me. Nobody even realize until
- 2:48reading some of the stories that FTX is.
- 2:50Only a three year old company. Like this motherfuckers only
- 2:53been on the scene since like the last year's of the Trump
- 2:56presidency. It's like this guy's been like
- 2:58hanging around the hoop for a long time and finally had his
- 3:00moment. Sure, he fucking came out of
- 3:02nowhere. I mean, I'm like, yeah, I agree
- 3:03with you 100 0 to 100 and then 100 is 0.
- 3:06But like that progression is basically a super car that got
- 3:09200 miles per hour and then crashed into a cliff, right?
- 3:12I mean, glass we guide coffee with someone who is sort of in
- 3:14his orbit and it was like a totally normal conversation.
- 3:17I think I said something along the lines of like yeah I'm not
- 3:20one of them just about interested in the story.
- 3:21Any more like you know, I'm covering?
- 3:23You know, I'm interested in Peter teal stuff and other
- 3:26characters like Didn't you guys stop reading like the sandbank
- 3:29been freed profiles like God six months ago.
- 3:31I am so I never wrote one, you know.
- 3:34Yeah. How long before he was flooding
- 3:39the zone for a while, right? He would appear at everything
- 3:41like hilariously enough, he was just at the Wall Street,
- 3:43journal's Tech conference, you know, he was being interviewed
- 3:46by an editor over there. But that guy would not turn down
- 3:49a lot of interview requests and so he was playing this perfect
- 3:53game with the media which was, you know, appearing as this
- 3:57Accessible understandable familiar eventually figure
- 4:01within a community that is often the opposite of that.
- 4:04And it was such brilliant presentation.
- 4:06But look, there's so much to talk about with this but I feel
- 4:09like we have to do like, a little.
- 4:10Let me give the foot a little bit quick.
- 4:12I'll do the quick footnotes in classic fashion, you know, at
- 4:15four and a half minutes into the episode whatever.
- 4:16That's why I say don't even introduce the guests until like
- 4:1920 minutes ago. Right?
- 4:19Exactly leave. One out for we have a high
- 4:22information audience. They know Teddy by voice and
- 4:24they know Sam Baker fade because I read every story.
- 4:26Yeah. No, my initial right Sam,
- 4:28bingaman free who are all going as p.f., you know, grows this
- 4:33firm Alameda research which becomes like a major crypto
- 4:36investor and then because of the success of that firm, I mean he
- 4:41and all this story will be scrutinized for probably like
- 4:44decades at this point. So this is all based on sort of
- 4:47the public narrative, but the story was that this is the guy
- 4:50who figured out how to sort of connect, the there was always a
- 4:54gap in the price of Bitcoin in Asia in the United States.
- 4:57It's and he helped close that Gap and pricing.
- 4:59He was an Army is an Arbitrage Trader and made a bunch of money
- 5:02on that his experiences ARB helped him to found ft x.
- 5:07Which then became one of the largest exchanges for
- 5:11cryptocurrencies outside. The United States, he ended up
- 5:14raising two hundred ten million dollars from Sequoia the best
- 5:17Venture Capital firm in the world.
- 5:18He raised billions of dollars at very high valuations.
- 5:22I think he got up to thirty two billion dollars.
- 5:24There's a hysterical story that Sequoia self.
- 5:27Published by the ultimate piece of like propaganda.
- 5:29That has them just like fawning over him and he's playing like,
- 5:32legal Legends on the side, which they don't even know at the time
- 5:35and like, somehow that spun into a positive and the guy is like
- 5:39we could sell bananas on FDX, we could sell everything and you
- 5:41know it's the total like we can build world so he builds up FDX,
- 5:44can I stop you for a second there?
- 5:46Because I didn't read the article.
- 5:47What does that mean self-publish to they just put it on
- 5:49Sequoia.com. Yeah.
- 5:51Yeah it's like hired like so I think it was a magazine writer
- 5:53but I mean it's a colorfully written magazine article.
- 5:56It's Fawning. But so they basically just had
- 5:59like the kind of played in a 16 Yankees.
- 6:01It was a go directing, it's the most it's now the most like,
- 6:04high-profile instance of going directors, what people want they
- 6:07want, they don't want, they want to cut us out of the loop.
- 6:09They want to go straight to the consumer actually and is that, I
- 6:12mean, it shows exactly how every action has equal and opposite
- 6:16reaction in the, you know, you make a story so glowing that
- 6:20then when something bad happens, you look like an absolute fool
- 6:22to the point that Sequoia took the magazine style profile down
- 6:27Replaced it with like, it's letter to limited partners.
- 6:30Basically apologize to get that. Yeah, the same time, the article
- 6:33which the media doesn't do, you know, even a correction on you.
- 6:35Try not to just delete things but they're screenshot everybody
- 6:39fucking. I'm sorry.
- 6:39Sukhoi. This kind of intense your
- 6:41integrity as a media outfit. I mean, I just think people are
- 6:44not going to trust you anymore. I've just canceled my
- 6:45subscription of Sequoia monthly. All right.
- 6:47That's a very disturbing back on track.
- 6:49So FDX seems like top crypto exchange as Teddy's going to
- 6:53talk about Sam. Bregman freed.
- 6:54I think it was the number two Democratic donor recently.
- 6:57What's the number you? Yeah, it depends on your
- 6:59definition is a top Democratic donors, though.
- 7:02He also promised some money that I think didn't come together.
- 7:04Which I think we can get into, but then coin desk who did great
- 7:08reporting. And I think also some of these
- 7:10like, you know, random Twitter accounts that I'm not even in
- 7:13insert deep enough in crypto world to know about.
- 7:15But, you know, people start to say something seems off with
- 7:18Alameda has the investment arms. Balance sheet.
- 7:21It seems like they hold a lot of FTX is made up currency which
- 7:26super worried. And then basically, you know,
- 7:29people start asking questions and all of a sudden it becomes
- 7:32it seems the oh allegations. What people sort of think
- 7:35happened is that xdx. Use customer money like billions
- 7:39of it to basically Shore, up Alameda has sort of failing
- 7:44positions. And once you start, you know,
- 7:46using customer money to, like, just gamble it away and try and
- 7:49make up your losses. You know, that's how every big
- 7:51scam comes undone and that's what happened to Sam bank
- 7:54manfried. So.
- 7:55Yeah, and that's happened. The last, like, few days.
- 7:58I mean, and we basically find out for sure, because Sam
- 8:01bregman freed says, we're going to get bought by, by Nance and
- 8:04it's like clear that it's like a fire sale by Nance's arrival,
- 8:07Real Enemy of ft x and then, that doesn't even come together.
- 8:11And today, we're recording this on Friday, I think they filed
- 8:14for bankruptcy. And yeah it seems like it'll
- 8:16keep getting worse and he stepped down as CEO which was a
- 8:19shocking turn of events here. The end and the guy they put in
- 8:22charge is the guy who dealt with enron's collapse.
- 8:26Yeah. You see that?
- 8:27Nice to have on your resume their, it's like, oh no, we've
- 8:29gotten that. You brought in the Enron guy to
- 8:30help check out the balance sheets, right?
- 8:32The last Asia. I mean this is gone 2-0, right?
- 8:34I know you initially said that I was skeptical, but if you're
- 8:37filing for chapter 11, you've basically assume that I think
- 8:40this is how Sukhoi explaining to their Partners.
- 8:42We expect our position in FTX to be worthless.
- 8:47Oh yeah, I said I was going to 0 right away.
- 8:49I don't know why you were skeptical of that.
- 8:50Well because they had spun it. You're also the guy who thought
- 8:53Blake Masters was going to win in Arizona so oh wow.
- 8:55Yeah fine. Later in the episode on that
- 8:58one. I'm glad we have teddy here for
- 8:59that but but no here because I initially had read the spin that
- 9:02Sam brankwyn free did put out that this was just about ft
- 9:05x.com. F DX, dot U, s-- is couldn't be
- 9:08stronger. We're actually going to be, you
- 9:10know, buying the naming rights to another Arena.
- 9:12So we feel as good as we've ever felt about that.
- 9:15So I was like, oh, maybe you know, I just didn't know.
- 9:17I assume that there is some Salvage will part of this
- 9:19company but no, it's all gone. It's all flushed, down.
- 9:22The toilet SPX basically walked into Sequoias office with his
- 9:25fucking shorts and his slide. And as like, will you give me
- 9:28any money to save this thing and they're like we just rescinded
- 9:32are glowing. So it seems like so quiet didn't
- 9:34know until really late. I mean, yeah, I wasn't, I wasn't
- 9:37asked you Eric to what extent, you know, since you reported the
- 9:40most on the investor reaction here like to what extent do you
- 9:44buy? The spin that?
- 9:45Like we had no idea versus you know?
- 9:49Right now I buy it. I mean why.
- 9:51So I was not unlike a formal board.
- 9:54There's some reporting there was like a board of Weird insiders,
- 9:58but they're sort of like an advisory Council of investors.
- 10:01But I mean, this Alfred Lynn, you know, the guy who invest in
- 10:05doordash, and a board member of Airbnb, very successful VC often
- 10:09at the top of the Forbes, he was the Midas list.
- 10:12Number one, at one point, five ways, he's not a crypto expert
- 10:14and he's like their main guy on F DX along with a growth
- 10:18investor. And so I just don't know how
- 10:20Savvy they were. And I do think you're sort of
- 10:22relying on the statement, you know, if you don't get an
- 10:24outside auditor they're relying on.
- 10:27Of the honesty of of the company.
- 10:29I mean, I think they look extremely bad for not knowing
- 10:31and every investor basically every other investors like well
- 10:34Sequoia invested its this is a sure thing.
- 10:36You know, I mean I literally have people admitting to me.
- 10:39Yeah, we sort of outsourced, our diligence to Sequoia on this
- 10:41one. Like they're, I mean, they're
- 10:42not even Heidi. I mean, it's, you know,
- 10:43anonymously but they're not really hiding the like, well, we
- 10:47thought Sequoia and Sequoia in their letter to limited partners
- 10:50was like, yeah, we do diligence, we do a lot of diligence.
- 10:52I mean, they, they do see themselves as the firm.
- 10:55This isn't quite and recent, It's like we take bets, you
- 10:58know, but Andrews. No additional work required.
- 11:00Andreessen Horowitz. Yeah, right Sequoia.
- 11:04You know, did say, you know, we're in the business of like
- 11:06Risk and and so, some have outside returns and some don't
- 11:11have you ever seen a VC firm Daddy?
- 11:12You Gonna actually out here and asking questions, but I have you
- 11:16ever seen a VC for? I'm genuinely curious because
- 11:18Eric, you cover this world more closely than Tom.
- 11:21Or I do like, have you ever seen a VC firm Tweeter?
- 11:24Frankly publicly release a letter to help ease.
- 11:27Before, I've never seen that know.
- 11:28I've never seen what I think just speaks to like and it came
- 11:31out to these, right? I want some credit, I don't
- 11:33know. Okay.
- 11:33Certainly, I got a lot of those facts out before they did.
- 11:36And wrote a very negative story about Sequoia and then they were
- 11:38doing my favorite part of the Sequoia letter was at the end.
- 11:41They said, we look forward to backing csps.
- 11:43Next venture, we're very excited about what the future holds with
- 11:47Sequoia has be. He's joking.
- 11:50No, we're not. People were just believe that
- 11:53that Andreessen with, you know, saddle up and like give them.
- 11:56Of course, you know Andresen. I mean, the funny thing this is
- 11:59sort of a side and then Teddy I want to ask you some questions,
- 12:02but you know, Andreessen could invest because they were big in
- 12:06coinbase anyway, but this is extremely validating to like
- 12:10Marc Andreessen worldview, right?
- 12:12Like SPF is like the perfect Democrat.
- 12:15All the media loves him because he liked shits, aren't crypto.
- 12:19He's not really a True. Believer is like a money guy.
- 12:21He's deep in Democratic politics, he has like this great
- 12:24philosophy of effective altruism.
- 12:27He loves him so Teddy were you had or like I mean you're not
- 12:30like a crypto reporter but like the, the media love this guy.
- 12:34Hmm. What's your reaction to that?
- 12:36No, I mean, look, there's an element of I guess I kind of
- 12:40feel like maybe Sequoia does. The only difference is that I'm
- 12:43not investing hundreds of millions of dollars into this,
- 12:45which is like I'm not expert on crypto, right?
- 12:47I mean Samuel legitimately was one of the, you know, five
- 12:51biggest Democratic donors in the country, you know, the lobbying
- 12:54work queue is doing and the philanthropic work you He's
- 12:57doing we're genuinely newsworthy.
- 13:00Like I mean I don't feel had. No I mean I feel like obviously
- 13:04I feel had in the extent that like you know, the business
- 13:06venture of that that was propping up all the other work
- 13:09he was doing, was clearly on ethical illegal, choose your
- 13:13best word but what he was doing was 100% newsworthy.
- 13:16Like, you know, he was headlining Congressional
- 13:18Retreats for Democrats and Republicans, you know, they
- 13:21bought a townhouse in Capitol Hill and was like hosting.
- 13:24Tons of, how do you legislators all the time?
- 13:25Like but here's, here's my. Question, here's my push, back
- 13:28to you on this Teddy because in one sense you are in the
- 13:30business of explaining his philanthropic work, but you're
- 13:33also in the business of profile in the guy in understanding
- 13:36where he sits now. I understand you're not a crypto
- 13:38reporter so you wouldn't have had the sourcing or the
- 13:40attention to find out whether this was all built on a giant
- 13:44over-leveraged house of cards. But in writing so much about the
- 13:47guy, you do sort of help build up his reputation.
- 13:50You helped give him the kind of access to the world that he
- 13:53wants to have access to. And do you not feel at least?
- 13:56Partly responsible for helping to build up that reputation in a
- 14:00way that benefited him, even though it was also
- 14:03foundationally week. Sure.
- 14:05But that's like, that's the way the world Works, which is like,
- 14:07you know, when Pete Buddha judge right?
- 14:09Does a bajillion interviews and is genuinely interesting, does
- 14:13that help people to judge in the Democratic primary?
- 14:15Of course it does. But like, I don't think the role
- 14:17of a journalist is to say no to good interviews.
- 14:20Like what am I? I don't I don't I don't think
- 14:23about this. I guess I guess.
- 14:24I don't know what you guys I know journals going to scream.
- 14:27About this. I don't think that much about
- 14:31the consequences of my reporting and I say that not to be
- 14:35callous, but I like like, sometimes you guys ever
- 14:37encounter this with the with the source or the story or a company
- 14:40is like, oh but if you write about our fundraise, it's going
- 14:43to empower all my fun. Oh yeah, I don't give a shit.
- 14:45So no, of course, I know it's my fundraise.
- 14:47So whatever. But like, but I, but this is
- 14:49this like a more generalized point that like, I feel like if
- 14:52sandbag manfried is a interesting juicy story then,
- 14:56Like that's kind of where my right like field of vision kind
- 15:00of Lile bit okay. That's does that like legitimize
- 15:03him? Like Daddy is not whatever Teddy
- 15:05is not. I mean you're writing for
- 15:07insiders and there's no question that like for insiders and
- 15:11donors like this guy was like a huge player and that he's he's
- 15:14propping up all these organizations.
- 15:16I mean, I, I would blame a little bit more not to let our
- 15:19friend off the hook but like, some of the magazine, articles
- 15:22were people really spent time with the guy right there.
- 15:24I mean, that right there, that's the Because if you're going to
- 15:27be profile, the guy, I don't know anybody, I don't know.
- 15:30And it looks like, I don't know if you ever did like a full-on
- 15:32profile of SPF, and by the way, I don't want to pick on you.
- 15:34I'm really glad you came on. You're obviously an expert on
- 15:37SPF in a very specific part of his life that turned out to be,
- 15:41you know, not what it really, you know, he presented it as.
- 15:44But if you are profiling, the guy, you have a responsibility
- 15:48at least somewhat to raise questions about his validity as
- 15:52a character and whether or not his business that he's built it
- 15:54on is at least questionable, you know?
- 15:56No, I guess that was the shocking thing about this whole
- 15:59episode to me was that you know in addition to him position
- 16:02himself. So cleverly to the media, as,
- 16:05you know, a very familiar face, he had kind of a Zuckerberg sort
- 16:08of air about him, he was playing through all the mainstream
- 16:11channels in terms of donated Democrats.
- 16:14He also was coming up as a legitimate business person, and
- 16:17there wasn't too many questions about the fact that he was going
- 16:20out and bailing out these shitty crypto startups, which also, I
- 16:23think helped feed into a presumption of stability on his
- 16:26part. He must be part of a stable
- 16:28business because he's buying out the shitty businesses.
- 16:30So he must be the good business so I guess.
- 16:32Yeah. Search you get some actual
- 16:33question here is like, just should there have been more
- 16:36questioning of just how stable he and FTX were, because I just
- 16:40didn't see any of it. And that's why, you know, if
- 16:42it's such a shock because if in the weeks leading up to this
- 16:45announcement, you know, that this collapse there had been
- 16:48whisperings in the mainstream, you know, present even just like
- 16:50coin desk, which is just a week ago.
- 16:52That there was a real question about how solid and And liquid
- 16:57Miss business was, it would have seemed a bit more reasonable
- 17:00when it happened. And instead of just felt like it
- 17:02came out of nowhere and I think to some degree that is a failing
- 17:04of the broader business, press that wrote so much about him and
- 17:07never even raised the questions that as cryptos collapsing.
- 17:10So to could this one solitary figure who is trying to position
- 17:13himself somewhat apart and yet clearly is tied up in all of
- 17:16the, you know, fragility on the space look.
- 17:19I mean my knowledge of crypto or of the Sam Empire, but from a
- 17:22business point of view was like, you know, I can write a sentence
- 17:25or two, you know, in the nook. After Orion Traders, but not to
- 17:28pass the buck. But like, you're totally right
- 17:30Tom, that I feel like there was like, zero reporting ever to
- 17:34suggest that, like, you know, I feel like, even with like other
- 17:38fintech companies, like, Robin Hood, you'd occasionally.
- 17:40See like this, this is not a little bias of media.
- 17:43This is the first time I'm really willing to agree with
- 17:46people and I feel like people are hammering.
- 17:48This one, hard enough like I do think it's like he was a good
- 17:51Democrat and not just that he was aligned with Democrats, but
- 17:54he does the things that sort of the intelligence Gia wants like
- 17:57he has sort of provocative you. And you think you think you
- 18:00think that explicitly encouraged reporters not to question the
- 18:04business? Yeah.
- 18:04And yes, yes, I definitely. I mean the China guy the by
- 18:09Nance company and fucking Brian Armstrong.
- 18:12The libertarian. Lex Luthor looking guy
- 18:14definitely like this is Sam bregman.
- 18:17Freed was what the media class like reporters are rooting for
- 18:21him to succeed just like oh just their their gut like their sense
- 18:24of who's like a believable person.
- 18:26Like SPF is like our type of guy.
- 18:29I mean it's just the reality I am including myself in this
- 18:33critique. Yeah look I didn't write shit
- 18:35about him not that it was my beat but like I yes I think he
- 18:37played on so many of the inherent unconscious biases,
- 18:41whatever term you want to use of what we consider a legitimate
- 18:44and stable business person is that people went to Stanford
- 18:49they're like Professor types lawyers you know it's certainly
- 18:53the effective altruism shit. All right he was a brilliant.
- 18:56Formance, what would the contrast is Elizabeth Holmes?
- 19:00Like there is some utility to the metaphor and total stops.
- 19:04I'm not. So I want to, I want to break it
- 19:05down to what extent do you think this is like, the Elizabeth home
- 19:09situation? Well, a little hard to see right
- 19:12now, Penny VCS, you know, that's that's why I ever investors,
- 19:17were worse. I mean, let me, let's see where
- 19:19the dust settles yards or trip the legal questions, right?
- 19:23We're not at liking and legal accusations.
- 19:25Yes, yes, you do. Two dead cat.
- 19:28But yeah, I mean the homes narrative, right?
- 19:32I think everyone would agree was like fraud and was a level
- 19:35Beyond you know your standard deception here like could be SPF
- 19:41storyline rival, that may be glowing magazine covers.
- 19:46I think the reporters believed in SPF more than they believed
- 19:50in Elizabeth Holmes, whereas Elizabeth Holmes did have the
- 19:52sort of we're rooting for the upstart woman Dynamic.
- 19:56That's Awkward talk about but is obviously true.
- 19:59No it's true. I mean, Sam being a young white
- 20:01dude is definitely part of this mostly being written about by
- 20:03other young white dudes. I would say it's hard because
- 20:07theranos was such an incredible story.
- 20:09Because this was a hardware device when, which he was making
- 20:13outlandish promises was was claiming Partnerships that
- 20:16didn't exist. I mean, the fraud went so deep
- 20:18and was so tangible. Whereas with crypto really you
- 20:24know what happened here it sounds like and you tell me,
- 20:26Eric bit. Like, you know, he was
- 20:28incredibly over-leveraged and was taking unadvisable risks
- 20:32with client money, right? Interview.
- 20:34Sure. Haunted by this session.
- 20:35You should never use client money.
- 20:37Like, I mean, obviously, you can invest climb money in some
- 20:40cases, but shifting climb money to a totally different, you
- 20:43know, vehicle to make speculative risk.
- 20:45I mean, that's, it's sort of far outside.
- 20:48Good. What is the Eric?
- 20:50What are the least incriminating version of events for Sam that
- 20:54you could come up with? Like what is the argument that
- 20:56Sam is? Nothing like Elizabeth Holmes.
- 20:57And that this was all, you know, a misunderstanding.
- 21:00I mean, I guess the least incriminating.
- 21:02This is total bull shitting. Though is just that like FTX was
- 21:07fucked as soon as like those earlier contagions went down and
- 21:10that he basically had to do everything to get out of that or
- 21:14otherwise, the customers were fucked anyway.
- 21:15And so he sort of violated customer trust once it was like,
- 21:20well, if you knew what was going on your, you were going to get
- 21:22destroyed so who cares? And then maybe he would have
- 21:25written it out if only By Nance hadn't like drawn attention to
- 21:28this and leaks hadn't tried to really raise questions.
- 21:31And then there was sort of a run on the bank and the run on the
- 21:34bank, really did A Min. But I mean, I feel like that's
- 21:36like, you could say similar things to Bernie Madoff.
- 21:38It's like, I Almost Got Away With It.
- 21:40Like, if you, if no one had flagged this, I would have
- 21:42raised more money know what's going on.
- 21:43This game works is that the problem is, when the Music Stops
- 21:47and then it all kind of falls apart.
- 21:49I mean, again, I think because crypto is still such an unstable
- 21:53space and, you know, the air went out of that balloon with
- 21:56such rapidity. Petit.
- 21:57It's just hard to compare it to like the organized and
- 22:00step-by-step deception, that Elizabeth Holmes had which, you
- 22:04know, like there was no there there with well.
- 22:06I mean there's that famous famous famous to the tech
- 22:08reporter said and super insiders but interview where Matt Levine
- 22:12of Bloomberg is like talking to Sam Venkman freed and like
- 22:17basically Sam admits that maybe like a lot of these like,
- 22:20made-up currencies or should be worth nothing and they're sort
- 22:23of playing games like he almost admits that the The thing is a
- 22:27farce and it's just like yeah. Matt Levine is like you sort of
- 22:31admitted that this is like fake, right?
- 22:34Well, why also did reporters not ask questions about FTX in the
- 22:39wake of all the collapse of the crypto companies and as he was
- 22:42buying up all of these shitty startups, bailing them out or
- 22:45whatever doing it as like as miss a few extras.
- 22:47In exchange, I think that's like Alamitos sort of like a private
- 22:51like speculative investment firm.
- 22:53It's like whatever who cares what Sam's doing with that, he
- 22:55talks about it, It, I would hear Whispers from people, like, I
- 22:58reached out to Sam one point. He didn't respond reply, but I
- 23:01was like, I heard you shorted, like the stock market.
- 23:03You made a ton of money, you know, there are all sorts of
- 23:05rumors on just like the genius of Sam.
- 23:08Bingman free day seem to have unlimited amounts of money and
- 23:11so it's like, okay Alameda. That's his like private, like
- 23:14investment firm. That doesn't really affect while
- 23:17their investors probably. I don't even know the Dynamics
- 23:19of it. It's not like public money.
- 23:20The crazy thing is using like, basically bank account style
- 23:23money with FTX right to Shore that up.
- 23:26So it's Not the same as he's like made up currencies you know
- 23:30which really felt like like tether.
- 23:32It is not like tether it is different than that but had the
- 23:35crypto Market not Fallen you know off a cliff in term.
- 23:39Sure yeah I'll give all these currencies everything keeps
- 23:41going on even fine. Yeah yeah I mean that you know
- 23:43it's in the same way that you know 2008 crisis exposed.
- 23:46Bernie Madoff. Was that early?
- 23:47That's not like oh we only build our investment vehicle going to
- 23:51work if everything continues to rise is like yeah that's that's
- 23:55nice. That's every scammer and The
- 23:56world. Unlike a crypto specific
- 23:58question and maybe we're not qualified enough to answer it.
- 24:01But, you know, problem, this is a podcast, you can say whatever
- 24:04you want, we alluded to it a little bit in Eric's intro, but
- 24:08you know, another key figure in this whole thing was CZ over at
- 24:12biting ants, who basically said, I'm dumping all my Holdings and
- 24:16ftt. And that basically kicked out,
- 24:18like the rotten leg underneath FTX that caused this whole thing
- 24:21to happen. And, you know, as you mentioned,
- 24:24Matt Levine, I mean, he had a pretty funny and Analogy.
- 24:27And one of his newsletters earlier this week or last week
- 24:30or something, where he was saying, you know, during the
- 24:322008 financial crisis, if you went around, you know, if you
- 24:36were like a banker, and you were saying to people, hey, I hear
- 24:39Lehman, Brothers isn't doing too well.
- 24:40These days, why don't you move your money over to my easier to
- 24:43our bank right? That actually would be a
- 24:44disastrous thing to do. Your boss should fire you
- 24:47because you aren't just bringing over a new account you're
- 24:49undermining you know trust making a system the entire
- 24:52system and so I do wonder if you know because you know It's easy
- 24:57when he when he, you know, there was a brief period where they
- 24:59were going to acquire them and then they ended up not doing it.
- 25:02I mean, this hurt the whole system here benefit himself.
- 25:04I think there's I doing this. It's easy.
- 25:06Did one sort of acquire, I had some situation but I think my by
- 25:10it was too bad. Well, I'm just wondering if he
- 25:12didn't realize how weak they were like.
- 25:14He thought he was going to dump them.
- 25:15I don't think he realized that he was going to be toppling, you
- 25:18know, a headline fucking Banner company in the space?
- 25:21That is like, undoubtedly going to hurt him, but I want to move.
- 25:25I want to change back. Sort of teddys area of expertise
- 25:28day. I mean what does this mean for
- 25:31Democrats and also don't Democrats like look bad.
- 25:33Like I mean I think people move on pretty fast from the donor
- 25:38for a given party is evil and less.
- 25:40They, it happens to be Laden with anti-Semitism but the I
- 25:44don't know. Do you think it's it's damning
- 25:46to the Democrats. They so readily took spfs money
- 25:49when he turns out to be this sort of - figure look.
- 25:53I mean like is this Harvey Weinstein?
- 25:56Well, we're, you know, Democrats had to like, donate his money to
- 25:59like times up. No much money to do that.
- 26:04Well, I mean, the read, the reality is, I mean, the, the
- 26:07money that Sam has donated has primarily been to his own Super
- 26:10PAC, Sam started a group called protect our future, which spent
- 26:14like 20, 30 million and related party transactions with this
- 26:19guy, everything. All right.
- 26:21That's not, that's not that unusual for a donor group.
- 26:24But basically, like the broader context here, Sam over the last
- 26:2718 months has hired a ton of fucking people.
- 26:31Like, there's so many consultants who I mean, will
- 26:34Macadam, the effect of altruistic altruist guy, that
- 26:37guy? Yes, terrible.
- 26:38I mean he is been out, the will mccaskill, it will mccaskill
- 26:41last night is a signatory to this like pretty extraordinary
- 26:44statement. So for folks who don't know what
- 26:46Castle was on the board of the FTX future fund, which is like
- 26:51Sam's primary philanthropy for Sam.
- 26:53And I just say I'm actually frankly, all these other kind of
- 26:55senior FTX Ex who are all aligned and there they put out
- 26:59the statement last night that said like we are shocked and
- 27:02appalled, effectively, you know, alleging possible deception by
- 27:05FTX leadership and it was, you know, interesting because well
- 27:08mccaskill is like Sam banquet, fried's Mentor.
- 27:10Well, mccaskill's literally, the guy in elon's messages, trying
- 27:14to pitch like Elon to take SBI a sales meeting as.
- 27:17Yeah, he could give you at least five billion as much as eight
- 27:19billion dollars a year long. The money's good here?
- 27:22Can you guys imagine if that happened?
- 27:24I don't have like Twitter later but out a bit of fun, fun.
- 27:26Also represent so Sam hired, all these people and like, you know,
- 27:30I talked with a lot of these people have like, you know, I
- 27:33have a talk with over the last 48 hours and like everyone is in
- 27:36a state of, you know, trepidation and shocked and, you
- 27:41know, to the point you're making about should Democrats Return of
- 27:43the money. Like, there's a feeling of
- 27:45almost complicity here. Did they legitimize this person
- 27:49in some untoward way? Now, what I'm about to say is
- 27:52not a reference to will be, as I don't know, all these individual
- 27:55actors but Sam was basically in like a cuddle puddle with some
- 27:59of these people, right? Or luck coin does just had a
- 28:01story that he was like on and off dating the CEO of Alameda
- 28:05research that. I mean somebody use the word
- 28:07which is a very San Francisco term Paulie.
- 28:10Cool look just like the idea that they were all just dating
- 28:14each other. And that was sort of a
- 28:15complicating factor in that. They were all living in a loft
- 28:18in the Bahamas, right? And just like that, they all
- 28:21they do. All looked.
- 28:22I have no independent reporting on me romantic relationships
- 28:24here, but it is. Truly did all live together.
- 28:26Talking about sex, not right? Yeah.
- 28:30There was no emotion here. This is purely transactional.
- 28:32They're all sucking and fucking in the Bahamas.
- 28:34Well, as well. They were protecting their
- 28:36Futures. Sure.
- 28:39I mean, the red flags just a quickly.
- 28:40We've covered a lot of them based in the Bahamas.
- 28:43Relentless, multi-party, transactions, no investor board,
- 28:47little investor oversight. People, use dating running
- 28:50things. Friends running other things, I
- 28:53mean, I did write. The one thing I will defend
- 28:55myself on is I did. Really push the point that like
- 28:58there was a lot of commentary that like spfs donations were
- 29:02like well-intentioned Goodwill. And I mean, clearly there was a
- 29:07strong incentive for him to like, stay close to.
- 29:09The Democrats is like pure pure strategy but but yeah, well I
- 29:13think, I think, I think you can are like, SPS people always got
- 29:21pissed at the idea that what they were doing on pandemics and
- 29:26a Democrat. Politics was like shoehorned
- 29:29into a narrative about crypto, right?
- 29:31So they were always you know like this this was a huge deal
- 29:33and few guys followed like Congressional race and origin in
- 29:37the spring where Sam's been like 15 million dollars and basically
- 29:40help prop up this kind of like you know random candidate and
- 29:44like everyone in Oregon was, you know, positioning this as why is
- 29:48this, you know, Bahamas, living tax.
- 29:51Avoiding crypto Billy are pushing his crypto agenda and it
- 29:54wasn't really about crypto that being Said like, of course,
- 29:58there are people in d.c. like Sam was doing these two things
- 30:01simultaneously. Right?
- 30:02As you know, pushing is pandemic preparedness.
- 30:05But if you really want to script Ojeda and like, can you really
- 30:08separate those two things? If you're a congress person who
- 30:11is like, taking the meeting, do you really like double down on
- 30:14the effective altruism True Believer thing?
- 30:17I've heard people joking in the seems like very implausible but
- 30:21they're like, you know, Sam basically absconded with all
- 30:24this money. It's like, oh I probably was
- 30:25going to make any more Our. I can donate this better than I
- 30:28could do anything with it. Just like run away with like
- 30:31billions to go like donate to. You know, that would be the
- 30:34ultimate effective altruism cause somebody literally tweeted
- 30:37like you know, if anybody has the most high torque sort of
- 30:40moral intuitions around utilitarianism, like would you
- 30:44push like 99 people in front of a train to save 100?
- 30:48It would be SPF. So like does this guy commits,
- 30:51like sort of the ultimate sort of heist to that would be the
- 30:55great that would be the Best version of this story that it's
- 30:58like Robin Hood, but unfortunately, I'm human like
- 31:01the story of Robin Hood, not the Robin Hood trading, but he was
- 31:04tasting, taking money from rich people, so we could direct it
- 31:07towards, you know, I mean, look, that is very effective.
- 31:09Altruism. The problem is that he brought
- 31:11down the entire movement through his collapse.
- 31:13So that's not what's the percentage chance on this
- 31:16Theory. There is a lot of discussion.
- 31:18As you guys might expect about this on the EA Forum which is
- 31:21like this like very active Community Message Board sort of
- 31:24for the effective altruism movement and there is A almost
- 31:27defensive posture about the question of fraud right now,
- 31:30like, is fraud. Okay?
- 31:32Like is being debated like vigorously, like, not really.
- 31:35That's, I'm Simon. No one is defending fraud.
- 31:38But like, her people are voluntarily making clear that
- 31:42their anti-fraud sort of see, I'm sort of EA grounds like is.
- 31:46Right. I think, I think, you know,
- 31:47there are, there is a theoretical argument to make
- 31:49that like, definitely, you know, hey shouldn't, isn't it like,
- 31:53you know, because, and, you know, utilitarianism and Andy a
- 31:56Takes this to the extreme anyways.
- 31:58I mean some of these you know, sort of more conservative type
- 32:00principles person would be very just are like what are the hard
- 32:04rules and otherwise like I'm free to do what I want.
- 32:07Where is like, very much utilitarianism is all about like
- 32:11let's run the calculus, anything murder could be, okay?
- 32:14If like you know you're saving 10,000 people in the future or
- 32:18whatever. You know this is all this really
- 32:19weird games they play. And so it's funny that they
- 32:22can't they don't want to defend fraud right now but it seems
- 32:25inherent to the View that you you can write, how committed are
- 32:28you to your beliefs here? Like, here's the ultimate test,
- 32:31we have you. No position to you that your
- 32:33great benefactor was in fact, allegedly engaging in deception
- 32:38and fraud. And yet he was doing the most
- 32:40amount of good with that fraud as possible.
- 32:42So, do you defend this all Tino effective altruism or not?
- 32:46You believe her and they're not, I mean, I think they should one
- 32:48by one have to answer for that because if not, then they just
- 32:50were never True Believers in the cause I mean, who of the great,
- 32:54you know, recipients of his of his do.
- 32:56Nations is suffering the most right now.
- 32:59Biden had a pretty good midterm, so maybe he's doing.
- 33:01Okay for the time being. But, I mean, a lot of this was,
- 33:04I mean, got to talk with some people who have gotten money
- 33:08from Sam over the last couple of years.
- 33:11You know, the basically, there's the main group is called
- 33:14guarding against pandemics, which is sort of Sam's lobbying
- 33:17operation in DC and they have a ton of people who work for them
- 33:22either full time or part time. And, you know, I reported the
- 33:26story today, That like right now, Sam's Brothers, got Gabe
- 33:30who's very intimately involved in sort of overseeing all of
- 33:32Sam's. Non FTX work Gabe right now is
- 33:35like kind of frantically looking for more cash for the
- 33:39organization because given to him, well I mean, you know,
- 33:43Gabe's argument that he's making to other people, is that this
- 33:46was really his operation, Gabe's operation that Sam funded.
- 33:49Obviously the Optics, you know, his last name is backman free.
- 33:53And, yeah, the guy would start there.
- 33:54Yeah, we're gonna be difficult to be difficult.
- 33:56So, The nepotism train runs out when your brother like absconds
- 34:01with the money that made it possible like, yeah, yeah, I'm
- 34:04g.b.f., I'm very different. Please, please give me your
- 34:09money. So there's that.
- 34:11I mean, there's also kind of like a broader, like, Democrats
- 34:15and progressives fundraisers were like obsessed with him.
- 34:18As this, you know, like, it's some of our don't know.
- 34:21This is a big, big, big scoop for run Puck internal
- 34:25imaginations. But like, People want to read
- 34:27about Sam, backman, Freight, like it was right, people
- 34:29converted, like I got subscriber.
- 34:31These people can pronounce it right by money train is running
- 34:33out. Yeah, shirts.
- 34:35So like, people were very, there's an obsession and, you
- 34:37know, anecdotally, we talk to people about like, you know,
- 34:39where the money is going to go in Democratic politics, like a
- 34:43lot of people wanted to get to know this person and get
- 34:46introductions to his Network partially these.
- 34:48So young, right? Like, you as someone who people
- 34:50thought might be, you know, a democratic power broker for
- 34:54decades, obviously, So that sort of it's almost like not only
- 34:58what was lost in the present, but sort of the future earnings
- 35:02that are now out of the picture. If this repeater, it's heal the
- 35:05media. I mean obviously we're all going
- 35:07ballistic over the actual FTX story but Republicans would get
- 35:11tagged with it much more than Democrats are getting.
- 35:13Yeah, yeah probably media bias are we talk about Peter teal and
- 35:17the election? I will say it.
- 35:19We have teddy on here so I will admit to it.
- 35:21I have said is that I thought Blake Masters would win.
- 35:24Now I want to say as we're recording this on a We should
- 35:27let the full Democratic process play out.
- 35:29Not all the votes have been counted.
- 35:30I want to make sure that everyone who vote in Arizona,
- 35:32has a chance to have their vote counted, but it doesn't look
- 35:35good for Blake Masters. He ate shit on Election night.
- 35:39Can I also just say on are related to pets?
- 35:41I had a bachelor party. I was pretty drunk, but I
- 35:44thought I had five-to-one odds. I'm John fetterman that if
- 35:48fetterman when I get $100 in to be lost, I had to pay 20, I was
- 35:51like, that's an insane deal, I'll definitely take it.
- 35:54And that friend, I texted him. Fetterman one and he hasn't paid
- 35:58me and I think you listen to this podcast so you know who you
- 36:01are. I thought that was a real bad.
- 36:03I don't know that we shook our hands.
- 36:04So so that friend that friend, Sam, Becky free, you're not
- 36:09seeing that money. Eric that money's all gone your
- 36:13money's not here. Your money's not here, it's over
- 36:16there. It's the okay.
- 36:18So, Peter teal, I mean, what, let's take stock a little bit of
- 36:22his kind of role in the future of Republican politics, because
- 36:26JD Vance did win although not maybe as impressively as people
- 36:30would have thought but you know, Ohio is basically just a
- 36:33straight-up Republican state now and so that really is all it
- 36:36took to carry JD Vance across the line.
- 36:39Blake Masters lost. I think you'll probably hear an
- 36:42argument from people that had there been a better candidate
- 36:45may be a candidate who had a job prior to running for office or
- 36:49was it not a little book factotum guy?
- 36:52Yeah, wasn't yeah. Terrifying people with his kind
- 36:55of blank stares and Really creepy demeanor that probably
- 36:58poster. Yeah, I do love the clip of Mark
- 37:02Kelly being like you want like this guy, the kind of guy you
- 37:04just like tells you he knows better than you like sort of
- 37:07debate school kid, you wanted this Skyrim?
- 37:09You know, I I did love just like, look at him, look at this
- 37:13great guy. My closing argument is like look
- 37:15at this fucking guy anyway. Yeah, so there's, you know, a
- 37:18solid argument you're hearing made among Republicans that they
- 37:20were just really bad candidates here and he was pushed across
- 37:23the line almost entirely by Peter teal.
- 37:25So what Make it visible the future.
- 37:28Okay, go, go, tell me. I mean I mean I mean I think the
- 37:31Peter teal narrative has been overstated.
- 37:34I think a lots of ways like being Peter spent 2.5 million
- 37:38dollars to boost Blake Masters in the general election that is
- 37:41right in the front like Masters would not even be on the
- 37:44political map if you have, who is this guy?
- 37:46There is nobody like Thomas saying that.
- 37:50If you pushed over a line by Peter teal, I don't like over
- 37:52the line in terms of getting the nomination he didn't know they
- 37:55sure do you know? In the primary, in the primary,
- 37:58I would, I would, I would, I wouldn't even put them in.
- 38:01This is debatable, but I would even argue that the Peter teal
- 38:05money for Blake Masters, and for JD Vance was not determined
- 38:10active in those races. Both of those races had had sell
- 38:13funders who ended up spending a lot of money.
- 38:16Like 15 million dollars is a lot but also not Blake Masters and
- 38:19JD Vance don't have a lot of here.
- 38:20You'll never live sure. They fucking nobody's.
- 38:24I agree that they do do not win the races without Teal.
- 38:26But okay. I don't know right now.
- 38:28Like, what no, but seriously though because I think there was
- 38:33so much written about and I the reason that I made the Blake
- 38:35Masters prediction was because I first of all believe the polls
- 38:38and, you know, Vibes and shit like that.
- 38:40But also I just foresaw this future in which both those guys
- 38:43got, you know, elected and we were going to be a wash and all
- 38:46these stories of Peter teal is the, you know, financial and
- 38:50ideological force behind the modern Republican party and
- 38:53because things played out in kind of complicated and bad ways
- 38:56for those Candidates. I think that really communicates
- 38:58that narrative. So so, where are we with you?
- 39:00Okay, let's me. Go JD, that's one, like let JT
- 39:03Vance is a u.s. senator, Peter teal was a huge part of shit
- 39:06events campaign. Like, you know, the fact that so
- 39:09when Peter wins like, well, I have a big deal and when, you
- 39:13know, I'm just pushing back on the idea that like, I feel like,
- 39:17I feel like you guys are framing this, like, both these
- 39:18candidates loss, like, here's the advance, want ya know?
- 39:22David flood is u.s. and Iran six-year term, like it sucks
- 39:25once. Which guy do not get?
- 39:27Do we get the guy out of you know the book or what?
- 39:30I can never remember that fucking books name.
- 39:32Well, I bet it's fucking complicated for him now, right?
- 39:34Because there were two. Right.
- 39:35You're saying there were, there were two JD Vance's.
- 39:37There was the one who was anti-trump, then there's the one
- 39:39who is like groveling at his feet so he could get the
- 39:41endorsement which he did. And that got him the nomination.
- 39:43So, but now Trump is sort of a damaged figure.
- 39:45So who does he who does he, you know, who does he loyal to?
- 39:48And then with Blake? Yes, he probably gonna lose
- 39:51though. Like, I mean like, you know, the
- 39:53I guess the, what is I guess it comes to what was the goal here?
- 39:56Was the goal to win the Senate seats, or was the goal to like,
- 40:00establish himself as like a republic and player?
- 40:03Because both of these people had no chance of being the nominee
- 40:06at the very beginning of their campaigns, right?
- 40:08I mean, it's still, obviously, for to I'm like, I feel like, I
- 40:11feel like it's still a win for Peter.
- 40:12Overall, he's the other day. Do you like, you like, it
- 40:14doesn't decide whether it's a red wave or not, like, that's
- 40:17way out of, like, Peter elected two, nominees one, u.s.
- 40:20Senator, I think if neither of them have been the nominee, it
- 40:23would this would have been a failure, but I think overall the
- 40:25Peter 20. To political experiment was a
- 40:28success. Yeah.
- 40:29Okay, great. And Shopkin is book basically
- 40:32says this is just the beginning and that seems to be what you're
- 40:34saying. Well I also asked so I think
- 40:36it's more, I've been more. I've been working here and I've
- 40:41been working. Sure it on that on that idea.
- 40:43I feel like some of Peters electoral interest in my opinion
- 40:47is overstated. I think some stories make it
- 40:50seem like he wants to be like a king maker and a power broker, I
- 40:53do not think of this true, the things that he's success.
- 40:56Us from doing our the things you want to do the things he's not
- 40:59successful in doing are the things you never want to do in
- 41:01the first place. So do you mean I was just being
- 41:05ripped snide? I was just saying that.
- 41:06Yeah, he gets to decide whether he?
- 41:08Yeah, well I mean look, this is, you know, we're speculating, you
- 41:12know, however, we want to at this point, but from what you're
- 41:15hearing within the power Brokers in the Republican Party, are
- 41:18they happy with the way things played out for as candidates
- 41:21like, will they accept more advice and you know, ideological
- 41:24motivation from him? I mean, there are some in the
- 41:28Republican establishment in more moderate communities, right?
- 41:31Who think that Peters been a force has been a force for not
- 41:34for evil, but it is, it has been, it has not been a
- 41:37productive player, right? You know, there was a huge story
- 41:40line over the over the summer, with regards to Mitch McConnell
- 41:43and Peter teal, right? Where they were upset that Peter
- 41:46and their view supported these relatively right-wing candidates
- 41:50in the primary who they saw as less electable in the general
- 41:53election and then declined to spend money on.
- 41:56On them and the general. So they sort of thought that,
- 41:58you know, Peter handed them out, you know, turd sandwich and made
- 42:01them, you know, spend money to get the turd sandwich.
- 42:04Like they have at least something of a case with that
- 42:06like Masters, I don't know. I mean, it's hard to do the
- 42:08counterfactual here on like, how like Mark brnovich who is the
- 42:11Arizona Ag and they Blake's main rival on the primary like how it
- 42:15burn damage done against Kelly. Like who knows is teal as
- 42:19connected in DeSantis world as he is and Trump World.
- 42:24Peter and the Santa's have met before.
- 42:27I think twice Peter's Also, let's be clear like not that
- 42:30connected in Trump World. Like I think us in Silicon
- 42:32Valley media, make petered out to be this like, Trump
- 42:35Whisperer. He sort of had like the second
- 42:37orbit of, like, Business Leaders.
- 42:39This is from an and right and then supposed to be close to
- 42:41bash into hot. She like tried to get them to
- 42:44point all these crazy people right there.
- 42:46But like, I would, I would venture to this is like in for
- 42:48speculation based on some reporting Trump and Peter,
- 42:51probably talk every couple months.
- 42:54It's not like you can see you can see Trump in the Blake
- 42:57Masters clip. Like I don't know.
- 42:59Who is that documentary? Yeah yeah, we're just like, what
- 43:01is Peter doing, right? Talk about beauty.
- 43:03Looks up here in this way that he doesn't like relator giving
- 43:05you more money. Yeah, he should be giving you
- 43:07more money. That's good, that's good.
- 43:22He seemed like very respectful for Trump of teal, you know, it
- 43:26seemed like he understood. This was like a powerful guy.
- 43:30My point is like I went, I wouldn't overstate, I wouldn't,
- 43:32I would not say that Trump and teal, or close.
- 43:35I guess, I guess not, true. I don't know how much you pay
- 43:38attention to David Sachs. You know.
- 43:39He's nice nuts. Compared to Tijuana, comes to,
- 43:42you know, investing in or start donating.
- 43:44Is that a reference to these weird texts to Ilan about why he
- 43:48could owe you big bad girls with herself that yeah but like No.
- 43:52Yes, axe is part of this whole contingent of people that are
- 43:54fixated on cancel culture and woke people know.
- 43:57They've been super quiet since Republicans lost.
- 44:00I mean, yeah. It's been funny.
- 44:02Yeah. I mean, but there's, you know, I
- 44:03do think that is a contingent of right-wing, Silicon Valley
- 44:06belief that, you know, the biggest threat to free speech,
- 44:09and our democracy is woke people on Twitter, like announcing
- 44:13their gender pronouns and you can make an argument that, that
- 44:17world view is pretty handily rejected.
- 44:19Yeah, well and reception literally just I wrote a column
- 44:22basically saying he way over torqued around, whoa, culture.
- 44:26And you sort of embarrassed and normal, people actually weren't
- 44:29that upset about, right? And they were worried about
- 44:31democracy. It like turns out, you know, I
- 44:34don't know. It's very vindicate.
- 44:35I'm I hope I do think we're going to burn.
- 44:37I've been saying that I feel like cancel culture is like
- 44:39burning out. So what are these woke?
- 44:40People going to even have to yell about soon and like the
- 44:43anti whoop people or both? I guess I'm saying that.
- 44:46Yeah, the people who want to the anti woke people but they're the
- 44:50people who want to talk about Right?
- 44:52Woke - incessantly. So in a certain way they are the
- 44:54woke people because they're obsessed with it are not going
- 44:57to have much to talk about because while they can invent
- 45:00things like crime and like weird Libs of tick-tock stuff.
- 45:04It's just like they need the actual material at some point.
- 45:06And I do think it's it's like what openness is not.
- 45:09I live in Brooklyn. Like a lot of times these be I
- 45:11live in Brooklyn. I don't even see it that much.
- 45:13You know, I say all sorts of things.
- 45:14Like I don't really understand like where the cancel culture is
- 45:18anymore. I don't know if you have any
- 45:20thoughts on where things are, With, you know, that's trained
- 45:23up in this forward, about the, the woke backlash or you like,
- 45:26what the meet you, what do you mean term?
- 45:29Election means, broadly, for like political alignment and
- 45:34then translate that if at all possible into what it means for
- 45:38Silicon Valley and it's alive. Yeah, I mean, look the energy
- 45:40and Silicon Valley is with the right, you know.
- 45:43You Lawns takeover of Twitter or sort of the crystallization of
- 45:47that, like vague sense of where the energy lies, right?
- 45:51And quite like that I think people like David Sachs.
- 45:54I don't think they're not important.
- 45:55Like David Sachs is like you know, helping to her like run
- 45:58Twitter day-to-day right now, right?
- 46:00He doing a bang-up job. Somebody talks to Peter and
- 46:03healing musk, you know, frequently about political
- 46:06stuff. You know the podcast they host
- 46:08is obviously popular. And look, I mean I think that
- 46:12clearly he's going to have more influence going forward and you
- 46:16know like I think in terms of how the mid term effects this
- 46:18like you know this is not the like red wave that You know, all
- 46:22the you know, conservative influencers were were desperate
- 46:25for it to be lost? Well, I mean like look you know,
- 46:27Republicans don't roll house and you know, it's clearly going to
- 46:29be divided government which like I think Trump 2024 or will
- 46:34reveal whether or not Silicon Valley, serious about this or
- 46:37not is serious about this like political engagement because,
- 46:39you know, the always people love to Santos was the nominee,
- 46:41right? Because they can just sort of
- 46:43pretend that like Trump's not a factor in the party.
- 46:45But will Peter teal and David Sachs?
- 46:47Be hosting like this and is 2024 events.
- 46:50Like I can see it. Yeah.
- 46:51Twitter boy, guys, haven't been on it for the last week or so.
- 46:54Sounds like a lots going on over over at Twitter HQ.
- 46:58I've been told everyone's got to go into the office but what
- 47:00exactly they're going to be working on is a real question.
- 47:02Look here, I guess would be my quick thing on Twitter, which is
- 47:06the stories coming out. It about, you know, out of the
- 47:08company right now are just incredible.
- 47:10You know, the amount of just unrest and frustration, and fear
- 47:14and anger, that employees are expressing to Great reporters
- 47:17like Casey Newton and Zoe over a platformer and, you know,
- 47:20reports it in Cider. And the information and whatever
- 47:23clearly are showing that, there is a ton of people that are
- 47:26super fucking pissed off at how Elon is running things.
- 47:29I do have a tendency to think that whenever the media
- 47:32coalesces around a narrative. So strongly that we may be
- 47:35missing something and is very possible that there is a whole
- 47:39other side of things going on inside sweater.
- 47:40And because Elon give zero shits about PR and it, you know, a
- 47:44normally, if you want has an incentive to make it seem bad
- 47:49right now, like, any good narrative, story teller, Was
- 47:52make it seem. He's saying we might go bankrupt
- 47:55you know like the media just takes that face value.
- 47:57There's very little like he's not a total idiot.
- 48:00Like why is he deciding to say that it might go bankrupt and I
- 48:04do think there's an argument that it's like tank expectations
- 48:07and then and then go from there. Yeah, the only thing, the only
- 48:11two reasons that make me a little bit, skeptical about that
- 48:13narrative and then I'll push to you guys is like one that
- 48:16actually really does damage your relationship with advertisers.
- 48:19The the worst things look will cause Cause them to want to pull
- 48:22their money. So it is kind of like a
- 48:24self-fulfilling prophecy. And I mean Eli, may just not
- 48:27know that because he doesn't know shit about advertising.
- 48:29So that's, you know, he could end up, you know, in trying to
- 48:32create the sense of urgency actually create real urgency.
- 48:36And the other thing is that if you fucking read the text
- 48:38messages on Ilan, it really seems that they just have no
- 48:41clue what they're doing. They went into this thing with
- 48:43no real ideas. It just was like snowballed and
- 48:46and got out of control and this does kind of seem like the old
- 48:49so they're not seemingly smarter than you think.
- 48:51Yeah. Yes.
- 48:52Oh shit. So you know, I want to leave
- 48:55open the possibility. This place won't burn down to
- 48:57the ground in a couple of weeks. But man if you read the stories
- 49:01it seems like it will. I don't know.
- 49:02What do you guys think? I'm trying.
- 49:03I'm trying to spend I don't know.
- 49:06We can I divulge we've moved our group TM off of off of Twitter
- 49:12to Signal. Yeah yeah that huge blow right?
- 49:16Proprietary scoop must credit dead cat podcast.
- 49:20Yeah. No I'm I mean, I'm definitely
- 49:22concerned about just as a user, you know, he spends too much
- 49:26time on it, like I'm finding it much, much, much less useful
- 49:29than it's ever been. The problem is greeting every
- 49:31other second, so, maybe that's it.
- 49:33I say, I say, as I've literally on Twitter right now running at
- 49:35we try to do, I want Erica table.
- 49:39Let me off their show, send it anyway.
- 49:46It's not useful anymore, but it's also so become so Central.
- 49:51And it wired in our brains it's a huge part of my brain.
- 49:54Yeah. Did you want that to be the
- 49:56case? Eric?
- 49:56Or is that just like just my my it's I've said this before, but
- 50:00it is literally where the universe exists to me like that.
- 50:04More than the real world is like, what is happening in the
- 50:08world. Like it's hard to understate
- 50:09that I have gone on what I mean. After college, I hiked the
- 50:13Appalachian Trail for a month and that was like half of the
- 50:16motivation for that was like a digital detox and your brain is
- 50:19like totally different. After that.
- 50:21And I really need to do a lot more work and I'm trying to get
- 50:24better of like, really not looking in my phone for hours on
- 50:28end. But I am, my brain is like
- 50:30trained to just like wake up and look at Twitter notifications,
- 50:33it's dark. Yeah, yeah.
- 50:35But we all need to rethink our relationships with and this
- 50:39isn't the disease and this is a good opportunity to do it,
- 50:41right? I mean this is like a forcing
- 50:43function. Well, Tom and I were always I
- 50:45can't speak for you but we're always deleting apps from our
- 50:47photo. I mean Tom, you deleted Twitter
- 50:49on your phone right? It's been off for a while but I
- 50:51would just Do it through the browser so that didn't really
- 50:53work at all. Like that's what a real junkie
- 50:54tidally Tick-Tock, you know, every other day.
- 50:56And then I'm like, I'm more like whatever.
- 50:59Yeah. Now look, I've been off Twitter
- 51:00for it's been a week now. I will say that during the
- 51:04midterms it was a little sad, not being on there because it is
- 51:06sometimes useful to see you know the updates.
- 51:09Like there were people that published really valuable shit.
- 51:12Only on Twitter, you know, people like what's-his-name from
- 51:14the cook political report and wasn't a Dave Wasserman.
- 51:17Like if you really want like that, you know, the inch by inch
- 51:20progression of stuff like Twitter is useful for that
- 51:22important people will make a call.
- 51:24But on the flip side, like I felt like with the elections, I
- 51:27went to bed, woke up in the New York Times was like the same
- 51:30like nothing happened, like well-known.
- 51:31Imagine, if you were just sitting on Twitter for like
- 51:34hours all night, it's like nothing happened all night.
- 51:37Like you would have just been sitting there like with these
- 51:39dribs and drabs. Like totally made-up
- 51:41developments. Yeah.
- 51:42So I guess we can end this by saying there is a life outside
- 51:45of Twitter. I've done it for the last week.
- 51:46I can't say it's like mountains. You're off your off.
- 51:49I'm off badly. Yeah.
- 51:51I'll probably be back in a month or so I can't I wouldn't deprive
- 51:55the problematic. When would this like a problem
- 51:57is that it's like basically become my entire writing news
- 52:01consumption. You know like engine like I
- 52:04don't like I would venture to say that 90% of the news stories
- 52:08I read are things from Twitter. Like I never go to like
- 52:12newyorktimes.com. So I feel like I feel like if I
- 52:15got off Twitter tomorrow I would miss things.
- 52:17Oh yeah. And I would meet I would need to
- 52:19find some other way to Get that information, maybe, maybe maybe
- 52:23I could build healthier ways to get that information like
- 52:25through the hilariously or something.
- 52:28Hilariously to bring this whole podcast.
- 52:30Full circle a couple of days ago, Katie sent a DM to Eric.
- 52:33And I and idea I'm like a, like a message to Eric and I and she
- 52:35was like, wait. So is FTX like dead or something
- 52:38and I was like, no I think there's just some weird fight
- 52:40between s BF + CZ. I don't think there's anything
- 52:43more to it than that and that was literally like the you know,
- 52:45the company was shutting down. So so yeah, you do miss things
- 52:48when you're not when you're not hooked into the feet and the
- 52:50you're saying the point of that. Is that you weren't on
- 52:52Twitter's? You had no idea.
- 52:53Yeah, it was like you at her and I'm like, what are you talking?
- 52:55Yeah. What the fuck is wrong with you?
- 52:57And I just like, hadn't like updated technium that recently.
- 53:00So yeah, you do miss things. The other, you know, the side
- 53:02pointed that is like, well, what do you really miss?
- 53:04If it takes you an extra hour to get some news and we're not
- 53:07regular like because I mean part one of the answers to how people
- 53:10could Escape Twitter is like with newsletters that sort of
- 53:13round up like what the conversation is at any given
- 53:16moment. And so while that's good advice
- 53:18for other people at least for myself, you know, I would I'd be
- 53:21writing the newsletter. So I need to sort of experience
- 53:24Witter for other people. Now, if you're like a, I think
- 53:26if you're doing more step back pieces, investigative pieces
- 53:29magazine pieces, maybe don't feel that way.
- 53:31And and so more reporters could Escape Twitter pay for Teddy.
- 53:35Hey for Eric pay for Insider. That's all you need.
- 53:38Get off Twitter. Web does nothing.
- 53:39There it is. That's my closing statement.
- 53:41Alright, thanks so much for coming back on.
- 53:43What have you? Got your third or second?
- 53:45It's fine. Yeah, it's just her fourth.
- 53:48Now it's your third eye. Thank you.
- 53:49Get your 3 star. What?
- 53:51Erina, what? Saranac 3, yeah, well Karen
- 53:54Griffith, keep at it, keep it in trying to make it spicy for your
- 54:00that's what we need. Like if you want this to be like
- 54:02you know Sports podcast need to have some more beefs.
- 54:04All right thanks hon. Thanks
- 54:20goodbye. Bye good, bye good.
- 54:22Bye good. Bye good.
- 54:24Bye. Bye good, bye good.
- 54:22Bye good. Bye good.
- 54:24Bye.