Latest / 323 Bourbon Library Podcast / 11/03/26 EPISODE 039: 2026 OLD FORESTER PRESIDENT'S CHOICE - BOTTLE BREAKDOWN
Transcript
- 323 Bourbon Library Podcast: Yeah. This is a fancy bottle. I'm excited. How fancy is this bottle? You know, I've never seen one of these. Well let's dive into it here in a moment. Welcome back, folks, to another episode on the 323 Bourbon Library Podcast. My name is Ronnie. John Cardle here. Also known as Life Well Made Co. on Instagram. so we're gonna be doing a review of a bottle that I have I mean, I've been in this game for fifteen ish years. I've never Tried this. I've never bought one. This is the only one I've ever physically seen with my eyes, so I bought it. Nice. Is the Old Forester 2026 release of President's Choice Bourbon. I've only heard of them. I've never seen one. But my game is limited to like two years. Yeah, no, it's fine. Like this is And I thought, why not? Let's look up some information about Old Forester. We'll talk about w what is President's Choice because it's kind of you don't see these sitting on the shelves. I've had some good old Forester stuff. I think James brought some stuff that was pretty good. Yeah. Do you know when you went to Old Forester. I'm gonna be I'm gonna just veer off course of the plan course here in a minute. I was just in Houston, Texas for work. And we went to dinner with a bunch of coworkers and one of the guys I work with was like, Hey, I'm gonna grab a drink at the bar at the hotel when we come back. You wanna meet me for like a nightcap? Like, sure. So I went down there. not a huge selection. They had Blantons and some stuff, but they had Old Forester King Ranch, which is essentially old forester that's been filtered through charcoal from mesquite from King Ranch. And I was like, This is gonna be ass. it's fucking really good. Really, really, really, really good. Big cherry note on it. I was like I went on immediately went online. I'm like, how fifty bucks for a bottle online. And I just paused because I knew I had a bunch of other bourbon expenditures coming, but I am gonna source two bottles of King Ranch just to have because it's really good. It's only sold in Texas. Awesome. So King Ranch is everywhere. Got trucks. The trucks, yeah. They got trucks. They got it's big Texas. Licensing that big. Yeah, and now they got a whiskey too. but let's dive in. We're tasting president's choice tonight. So the history of Old Foresters, this is one of those legacy brands that we're gonna dive into, which is fun. There's a long, long history here. I like the color. So Old Forester holds a legendary status in American whiskey history. It's defined largely by a series of industry firsts. so before 1870, bourbon was almost exclusive exclusively sold out of barrels. Saloon owners and merchants would dip jugs from casks, a practice that left the whiskey deeply suspicious susceptible to tampering, watering down, and poor quality. George Garvin Brown, who was a young pharmacist salesman in Louisville, Kentucky, wanted to guarantee a consistent pure product. He began sealing his bourbon in glass bottles and signing his name on every single one of the Personally guarantee the quality. This made Old Forester America's first bottled bourbon. Pretty cool. You think about all the bottle shapes and everything, and and these guys were the first to to decide, hey. Way to go, George Brown. Let's clean this shit up a little bit. Let's be a little more sanitary. Yep. So Brown named the brand after Dr. William Forester, a local physician and friend. the spelling neighbor the spelling of the name later dropped the R over the over time. so two R's in Forrester in the guy's name, so they dropped it down to one R. To ensure consistency, Brown originally blended whiskey from three local distilleries, Mattingley, Melwood, and Atherton. Melwood, interesting. That's the current location of where Pursuit Spirits resides. Nice in the old Melwood distillery. Fast forward a little bit to 1897, the Bottled and Bond Act to comply with new Federal Bottle and Bond Act. Old Forester increased its proof from 90 proof up to 100 proof to meet single distillery rules. George Garvin Brown purchased the Madden Lee Distillery in 1901. They were the first double barreled bourbon. So when the bottling line fire when when a bottling line fire halted production, whiskey whiskey that was ready to be bottled was temporarily temporarily transferred into a second charred barrel while repairs were made. This accidental innovation created a very old fine whiskey, the precursor to today's old Forester 1910 bourbon. so when bourbon struck when excuse me, when Prohibition struck in the 1920s, hundreds of distilleries closed forever. However, Brown Foreman, the parent company, was granted one of the very few federal licenses to manufacture and sell whiskey for medi for medicinal purposes only. Old Forester Old Forester proudly stands as the only bourbon continually sold by the same company before, during, and after prohibition. That's awesome. So 1941, World War II hits. So just two weeks after the attack on Pearl Harbor, Old Forester became the first distillery to convert its entire production into high-proof industrial alcohol to support the war effort. In response to a growing national preference of lighter bodied cocktails, the brand introduced an 86-proof expression in 1959. And Old Forester officially returned to its h historic home on Louisville's Whiskey Row at one hundred and nineteen West Main Street, opening a state of the art distillery and featuring the ol the only active cooperage in downtown Louisville where barrels are charred on site. And that happened in twenty eighteen, just recently. So the bourbon we're drinking tonight, let's dive into the president's choice. What is this thing? So Old Forester, the President's Choice, is an ultra premium, highly allocated single barrel bourbon expression. Historically and currently, these barrels are hand selected for their exceptional depth, maturity, and unique flavor for profiles by the company president, such as Campbell Brown, representing the fifth generation of the Brown family. The lineage of President's Choice traces back to early single barrel offerings by the company where barrels were occasionally handpicked or offered directly if consumers or customers bought an entire barrel. So unlike standard small batches or or the core expressions, President's Choice is bottled from an individual hand picked barrels. because they are single barrels, the exact proof and age, often around eight plus years, and flavor notes vary slightly from cask to cask. So this one says it was you got your calculator there. It was selected and aged for at least ninety two months. Ninety two months old. this particular whiskey. We'll pull up that calculator 'cause I'm not doing math. Seven seven and two two thirds years. So seven years, eight months. Seven years, eight months. This one comes in, it's barrel one eighty nine, hundred and twenty point two proof. so because we don't know what this particular barrel tastes like, I will read the tasting profile. So typically these barrels showcase bold, rich characteristics of the unique old Forester heavy char profile, including dense caramelized sugars, dark dried fruits, rich oak, sweet vanilla, and some warm baking spices and leather. So President's Choice bottles are famously rare. They are released in limited quantities. Often dropping as distillery only exclusives via special lotteries or through select high end retail channels, making them highly sought after collector items, commanding steep secondary prices. Let's get this thing popped and see what we taste. I've never seen one of these. My first we actually haven't done a ton of old Forester reviews on the podcast yet. We have not. And I think James brought through there's a fucking thing on this. Yeah, James brought through some old foresters that I I think he brought through one of their like pretty good one seventeen series. They were little guys. Mm-hmm. Yeah, the one seventeen. what one seventeen's? Yeah, it's just called the one seventeen series. Okay. I think is what they call it. But they were good. It was good. Can I find the fucking thing on the Pocket knife time. So rare they didn't put the perforations. Unicorn in the mist. All right. Got that port. Let's hear that pop. Got our top offer. There you go. Let's hear the pop. Nice spot. Color on this thing is dark. No, the color's nice. Very dark color. For those that are looking at it, getting these things poured up. but it has this like deep brownish I wouldn't call this mahogany because it's not red. It's yeah, it doesn't have a red. Deep brown. Yeah, I paused because I was about to say mahogany. I'm like legs. Jesus. Yeah, this thing is I think it's just sitting up there. Doesn't want to come down the button. No. my god, dang. The nose on this thing is I haven't even gone in yet. That's really nice. Mm. Ton to cherry for me. Big cherry note. Ton of cherry. Big cherry. Like Luxardo cherries. Yeah, syrup. Syrupy cherry juice. Some some warm vanilla. Mm-hmm. A little bit of spice in there too. Cinnamon or Maybe a light black pepper on the nose, but more cinnamon. More cinnamon. And a light little little toasted oak or oak note. Wow. Nose is nice. Not too sweet on the nose. No, kinda not getting that confectioner sugar. I'm not getting any of that, but I'm getting sweetness. I think it's more from like Yeah, for seven years and eight months old, this smells much older. It does. Yeah, I would if this was in a blind, I wouldn't have guessed seven years, eight months. Not at all. Not at all on the nose. All right, I'm gonna taste it, see if it's exceptional or not. Here come the legs. Whoa. That's potent. Potent on the palate. Bunch of char in there. Like almost like molasses, like dark molasses, dark brown sugar, barrel char. Nice sweetness. I'm still getting that cherry in there. That looks sardo cherry is coming. That cherry syrup is coming through strong. This just like lays in your chest though, too. It does. It's not, it's the nice warm Kentucky hug. It's not. This is this one's fighting you a little bit. You think so? First sip I had, I was like, ooh, okay. I didn't bob and weave this thing this this thing sucker punched me a little bit. I don't I didn't get that. No. No. Would I say one twenty point two proof? Yeah. Not not super proofy. No. But it it definitely has a hug to it. Yeah. Yeah. And it's long. The cherry on the nose is now just like as the longer it sits open. Now I'm starting to get more of the confectioner sugars out of there too. Did they say this? Yeah. It definitely gave me that like non chill filtered, uncut vibe on the palate. I don't think I'm there yet. I can't I can't pick I can't pick that out yet. I like the v like oily. It's got this like oily to oiliness to it on the palate. She's thick. She's thick. I like thick. She's she it the nose is super sweet, though, but the palate isn't super sweet. It's not. The palate's more baking spice, oak, a little bit of leather, maybe a light, like pipe tobacco type note in there as well. But it's still enjoyable, and I usually like sweet notes, but this is pretty good. I I'm enjoying it. It's good. This is a great this is a great pour. I don't recall what I paid for this bottle. Couple hundred bucks probably. they're not cheap. I've never seen one before, so I was like, Yeah, I'm gonna snag it. I think I might have paid three hundred. I don't know. It's probably a little more. I think MSRP's two hundred bucks. I didn't that's interesting. I didn't I didn't jot down the MSRP on this bottle. I'll I'll have to make sure to do that. If you know, let us know. I know. I can tell you what it is. Let's see here. Bing this bitch up a little bit, huh? And President's Choice. This is the first time I'm tasting this expression. I I enjoy it. I think it's It's got depth of flavor and it's got those like older The flavor pro flavor profiles you get from older whiskey and like a seven. Yes, that that that's I would not guess this is a seventy or eight month product on the flavor. Yeah. This tastes like I mean it could be just like full cast strength, unfiltered, like you're getting all the barrel notes out of it. But now they do old Forester, I I'm pretty positive they do heat cycle their okay, their facilities. So depending on where the barrel came from for this bottle, I mean it could be because it heat cycled, it could it could be drinking like a twelve to fourteen year old whiskey instead of a seven, eight, seven year, eight month. Yeah. MSRP on this bottle is two hundred twenty five dollars. I think I paid like two fifty, three hundred somewhere in that range. Yeah. I'd do it again. Yeah, for sure. I quickly jumped on breaking bourbon because they're kind of fun. They're they're a fun website. They say Raspberry, cherry, sweet seasoned oak, vanilla, cinnamon, and raisin on the nose. I get that raisin on the very back side now. I don't think I got it on this that that leathery fruit leather note initially, but now that it's opened up, I'm getting it on the back side. For me for me the nose is is my favorite part about this whiskey. Personally. Great nose. Great nose. Palette they say cinnamon spice, brown sugar, vanilla extract, and fermented raisin. That is the most I've never heard of fermented raisin in my life. Like very generic. Cinnamon spice, yeah, brown sugar, vanilla. Fermined raisin. I don't know if I would have called it that, but I I I see what they're trying to go with there. It's definitely got a it almost I would almost say like a what's that raisin, the boozy raisin dessert? like you mean like the Christmas stuff? what am I thinking of? You soak you soak rum soaked raisin rum soaked raisin? What is rum soaked? There's something rum soaked. Usually rum soak raisins go in like a what is that freaking Christmas bread that nobody likes and everybody throws away. like what did they say? Panettone, I lo loaf. Yeah. I don't know what it's called. They have little gummies in there too. Yeah, exactly. I don't know what she's And the marchino cherries and stuff like that. Yeah. It's a loaf of some sort. Yeah. Loaf. What a ridiculous word. But it I I can see that. The boozy raisin, it almost has a little bit of like that rum chata. Bro, that's thick in my back. Not rum chata, but like rum soaked something. Yeah. I don't know. I guess I'd never stoked. Rum chata is like basically rum with pina colada essentially, right? No, rumchata is rum with horchata flavor. orchata. Yeah, that's true. No, it's not that. No, it's not. But the rummy part of it, I get that on this like I get what you're saying. Boozy raisins. Yeah. Fermented raisins, whatever. there I think their finis notes are pretty spot on. Dry oak, yeah, leather, cigar leaf. I think I said that. Spiced raisin. I don't know. Raisin all over the damn fucking thing. I know. I don't know. And I like raisins too. My kids are always on me like you like raisins. You're old, Daddy hates raisins. I'll fuck with a like a oatmeal raisin cookie. Raisin yeah, all the cookie. Those are my favorite cookies. All day not my favorite, but I will That and a chocolate chip are my favorite. There's not a cookie I won't fuck with, by the way. So like I'll tell Vanessa to make some cookies. All the cookies. Don't I don't care. Snickerdoodle, chocolate chip, macadamia is the ones that I really love. My chocolate macadamia. Anyway, we we have digressed here. here's a quick question. Do we think this should be in our competition for best of the year? It's definitely better than that last one we we had that we were Okay we were thinking about. So maybe we need to have like a like a play in bracket. You think? Yeah. Better than the makers. That's what you're saying. Yeah, it's better than the makers. We might need to have a play in bracket of like ones that are on the cusp. Honorable mentions. There we go. Yeah. That's good. It might go in that. I don't I don't have anything to compare it to because I've I've not tried any previous versions of this, but I think it's really good. Yeah. It's good. I enjoy it. I would I I personally enjoy a little more sweet and a little more fruit. I do as well, and less dry. This is this is a little more tannic drying to it. For so for that reason I like it, but it's probably not one I'm like running back to the shelf to grab all the time to taste. Yeah. It's a special occasion type port, yeah. hey guys, let us know in the comments. Old Forester President's Choice bourbon. Have you got one? I don't have the rye, they have a rye. nice. Yeah, I like rye. I have not I've not picked up a bottle of old forester rye, President's Choice. Yeah. Yeah. Let us know. Have you had this before? You've had to you have another expression an earlier year. Yeah. Let us know how you like it. Let us know what your thoughts are. We enjoyed this one. This is really good. Let us know in the comments. Is this a bottle you're chasing? Did I somehow just miss on a really good bottle for the last fifteen years? I'll be honest with you, old Forester products for me, I I have not chased them all that much. I'm not I don't chase birthday bourbon. I've never owned a bottle of birthday bourbon. really? I heard that one's the one to chase. They're like two hundred dollars and I'm like, they're watered down to ninety hundred proof usually. That's the problem. And so I'm like and they also there's a they're a shelf monster. They're like they're big base, they take up a lot of space. Yeah, you don't like that. I don't like that. And I don't understand why they're watering them down. I don't get that either. No, this is not watered down. No, so if they're not this is the not watered down version. Maybe they're doing the right thing by the by the birthday bourbon. I don't know. Could this be could birthday birth just be a watered down version of I'm gonna be honest with you. That f old Forester King Ranch I had, I might like a little bit better than this. really? As a as more of like a daily drinker where I'm like, Yeah, I could go back every single day after work and have a pour of that and be like, Okay, this is good. Or this I'm like that might be that this needs to be my last pour of the night, probably. I don't wanna open up with this. Feels like it's a little too Robust. Like a Marlboro ready. A little more robust. A little more gravelly. Yeah. It's a robust whiskey for sure. anyway, thank you all for following along, joining us for another episode on the 323 Bourbon Library. Thank to my buddy John Carlo here to be in here and always fun, sir. Tasting some good whiskey. let us know in the comments should we put this in the best of blind for twenty twenty six? That may be the determining factor of what we need to do with this bottle. It's good. It is good. We'll see you next time on another episode of the 323 Bourbon Library Podcast. Cheers. Mm-hmm.