Latest / The Vegan Report / Is Standing Up for Farm Animals Political Suicide?
Transcript
- 0:00This is Zach Walderk for The Vegan Report. Today
- 0:03we're exploring the question, what happens when
- 0:05a political candidate in Brazil takes a stand
- 0:07on farmed animals? Do people reward them, punish
- 0:11them, or not care at all? Brazil is one of the
- 0:14biggest meat producers in the world, so you might
- 0:16expect that standing up for farmed animals there
- 0:18would be a political risk. Our new research at
- 0:20Fondalytics suggests the picture is more interesting
- 0:22than that. Some candidates making pro -animal
- 0:25proposals won big. Candidates making pro -animal
- 0:28agriculture proposals lost, and one popular policy
- 0:31didn't move votes at all. Before we dig in, I'd
- 0:34love to hear from you. Connect with me. My email
- 0:36and social links are in the episode notes. You
- 0:38can find new episodes on Wednesday on this podcast.
- 0:41Please share this episode with your community.
- 0:44So, why Brazil? Let's start with scale. Every
- 0:47year, Brazil slaughters roughly 6 .5 billion
- 0:50chickens, 58 million pigs, and 40 million cows.
- 0:53It's home to JBS, the world's largest meat company,
- 0:56and it's one of the largest exporters of animal
- 0:58products anywhere. That scale shows up in politics,
- 1:01too. Brazil's Congress has a powerful agribusiness
- 1:04-aligned caucus known as the Bancada Horalista.
- 1:08Meat can also play an important cultural role.
- 1:11Brazilians eat more meat than the Ministry of
- 1:13Health recommends, and the beef industry in particular
- 1:15contributes heavily to greenhouse gas emissions
- 1:18and to deforestation in places like the Amazon.
- 1:21Politics is one of the most powerful levers for
- 1:23change, but politicians might hesitate to speak
- 1:26up for farmed animals if they don't know how
- 1:28the public will react. In 2025, our political
- 1:31animals study found that US voters may reward
- 1:33candidates who support farmed animals, but Brazil
- 1:36has a different culture, political system, and
- 1:39animal agriculture landscape, so we wanted to
- 1:41know whether that pattern holds there. Here's
- 1:44how the study worked. We used a method called
- 1:46a choice -based conjoint experiment. That sounds
- 1:49technical, but the idea is simple. Participants
- 1:51saw pairs of hypothetical candidates and picked
- 1:53which one they'd vote for. Each candidate had
- 1:56a certain set of characteristics whose values
- 1:57were randomly chosen from a set of possible values.
- 2:00One of those characteristics was a policy proposal.
- 2:03Because everything varies at random, we can isolate
- 2:06how much each policy on its own helped or hurt
- 2:08a candidate. We tested nine proposals. Some would
- 2:12benefit farmed animals directly or indirectly,
- 2:14like banning the destruction of the Amazon rainforest
- 2:16and Cerrado Savannah for industrial animal agriculture.
- 2:19creating stronger punishments for poor treatment
- 2:22of farmed animals or banning cages on farms.
- 2:25Four would support the animal agriculture industry,
- 2:27like reducing health and safety regulations on
- 2:29large farms or increasing government financial
- 2:32support to meat companies. One quick tip for
- 2:34listening to the numbers. These numbers are the
- 2:37percentage of the two candidate vote a candidate
- 2:39got if they proposed a policy. So 50 % means
- 2:42a policy made no difference. Above 50%, it gained
- 2:45a candidate votes and below 50%, it cost them.
- 2:48In terms of protection wins, two proposals clearly
- 2:51stood out. Candidates who proposed banning the
- 2:54destruction of the Amazon and Cerrado for industrial
- 2:56animal agriculture got 69 .5 % of the vote. Candidates
- 3:00who proposed stronger punishments for poor treatment
- 3:02of farmed animals got 66 .8%. Those are big effects.
- 3:06In a head -to -head matchup, a single policy
- 3:08position pushed support well past an even split.
- 3:12Pro industry policies didn't perform so well.
- 3:14On the other side, every one of the four pro
- 3:17-industry proposals cost candidates votes. Reducing
- 3:20animal health and safety regulations on large
- 3:22farms did worst at 34 .2%. Letting the industry
- 3:26run its own health and safety inspections got
- 3:2843 .2%. Removing environmental rules that limit
- 3:31the expansion of industrial animal agriculture
- 3:34got 44 .6%. And more government financial support
- 3:37for meat companies got 45 .3%. So, even in a
- 3:41country with a large and politically influential
- 3:43meat industry, participants penalized candidates
- 3:46who proposed giving that industry even more advantages.
- 3:49Now for one of the more surprising results. A
- 3:52proposal to ban cages on farms didn't make participants
- 3:55any more or less likely to vote for a candidate.
- 3:57Its effect on votes was neutral. But that's not
- 4:00the whole story. Participants rated candidates
- 4:02who proposed it as likeable, competent, and compassionate.
- 4:05And when we asked about the policy directly,
- 4:07rather than about the candidate? cage -free performed
- 4:10well. So people seemed to like the policy and
- 4:13the people proposing it, but that goodwill didn't
- 4:16turn into votes in our simulated elections. One
- 4:18possibility is that some Brazilians see this
- 4:20as a change industry should lead rather than
- 4:22government. Our data can't confirm that, but
- 4:25it's an open question worth sitting with. We
- 4:28also looked at how results varied across groups
- 4:30of people. The two most popular proposals, protecting
- 4:33the Amazon and Cerrado and strengthening punishments
- 4:35for poor treatment of farmed animals, both gained
- 4:38votes across nearly every segment of the population
- 4:40we analyzed. Some groups were especially supportive,
- 4:43including residents of the South and women and
- 4:45non -binary participants, but support wasn't
- 4:48limited to those groups. It was broad. Finally,
- 4:51we looked at how policy positions shaped how
- 4:53people saw the candidates themselves. Candidates
- 4:56who proposed policies that would help farmed
- 4:58animals were usually rated average or better
- 5:00on competence, likability, and compassion. Candidates
- 5:03who proposed policies that would harm farmed
- 5:05animals were often rated average or worse on
- 5:07those same measures. In this study, we generally
- 5:10found that pro -animal positions didn't cost
- 5:13candidates their image, and pro -industry positions
- 5:16did. So, to sum up, protecting critical ecosystems
- 5:20and cracking down on poor treatment of farmed
- 5:23animals won votes. pro -industry proposals lost
- 5:25them, and cage -free was well -liked but didn't
- 5:28change votes. You can read the full report, Votus
- 5:31per los animais, how farmed animal policy wins
- 5:34votes in Brazil, at faunalytics .org. The link
- 5:37is in the episode notes. Thank you for listening.
- 5:40I appreciate your interest and support.