Latest / Surrounded / 1 Liberal Man vs 20 MAGA Conservatives (ft. Harry Sisson) | Surrounded
Transcript
- 0:00How long did it take you to put on your clown makeup this morning?
- 0:03How many times do you practice that in the mirror?
- 0:04I know people personally who walked inside the Capitol.
- 0:07Why are you hanging out with January 6th insurrectionists?
- 0:09Harry,
- 0:09you should use your platform and tell all the illegal immigrants,
- 0:12pay 100% of your taxes to support this country.
- 0:15I'm saying it right now.
- 0:16Has Trump normalized political violence
- 0:19or has the fight against Trump become its own excuse for it?
- 0:22I'm Paris Rose from Jubilee Media,
- 0:23and this is Surrounded
- 0:25where one brave soul faces a room full of disagreers.
- 0:29Today we're exploring immigration in America,
- 0:31the Epstein files,
- 0:32and if Trump and his administration have made Americans less healthy.
- 0:36I'm here with our future guest,
- 0:38Democrat commentator Harry Sisson.
- 0:40Hi,
- 0:40I'm Harry Sisson.
- 0:41I'm the host of the Harry Sisson Show,
- 0:43and today I'm surrounded by MAGA.
- 0:50My first surrounding claim is that immigration makes America stronger,
- 0:53not weaker.
- 0:54If you would like to be the first debater,
- 0:56please get to the chair in 321.
- 1:02Nice to meet you.
- 1:03Nice to meet you,
- 1:04man.
- 1:06All right,
- 1:06yeah,
- 1:07so,
- 1:07uh,
- 1:07let's start.
- 1:08Do you mean stronger in terms of economic power in terms of societal influence?
- 1:13What do you mean in your province?
- 1:14I think broadly,
- 1:15broadly as a whole,
- 1:16OK,
- 1:16so have you driven through South LA and saw the type of world that you were in?
- 1:21Um,
- 1:22maybe,
- 1:22I don't know.
- 1:22I'm,
- 1:22I'm from,
- 1:23were you on your phone?
- 1:24Were you on your phone making a TikTok or something?
- 1:26I wasn't on my phone.
- 1:26I was reading,
- 1:27but so I drove through South LA and I saw that,
- 1:30I saw that,
- 1:31I saw the homeless camp.
- 1:32I saw everything and I don't think it's a laughing matter.
- 1:34And,
- 1:34and,
- 1:35in
- 1:35fact,
- 1:35Harry,
- 1:36he was laughing,
- 1:37so I was asking why he was
- 1:38anyway,
- 1:38go ahead.
- 1:39But yeah,
- 1:39I wouldn't say it's a laughing matter when you
- 1:41have all these homeless people falling into the street
- 1:44using,
- 1:44uh,
- 1:44their own
- 1:45fecal matter as ways to bathe.
- 1:47That's disgusting,
- 1:48Harry.
- 1:49And in fact it's been perpetuated by illegal immigration,
- 1:52especially
- 1:52under the last regime that you supported.
- 1:54Well,
- 1:55in fact,
- 1:55when they go in and eat up our healthcare costs.
- 1:58Everything else in the economy
- 2:00as well,
- 2:01they've devalued our currency to the rate
- 2:03that you haven't seen in any other country.
- 2:05How do you know it's because of,
- 2:05of immigrants?
- 2:06Well,
- 2:07I would have to say there are a lot of low paying jobs,
- 2:09labor jobs,
- 2:10and such like that,
- 2:11and you would argue that's helpful for the economy,
- 2:13correct?
- 2:14Uh,
- 2:14I think people working is helpful for the economy at any level.
- 2:16Yeah,
- 2:17OK,
- 2:17so
- 2:18I would say illegal immigration and this amount of legal immigration that
- 2:22we see to the tune of a million people per year.
- 2:24is nothing that we see in any other country.
- 2:27We should end birthright citizenship in the United
- 2:29States because you should hate the Constitution.
- 2:31That's what it is.
- 2:31No,
- 2:32yeah,
- 2:32the Constitution.
- 2:33I state that I hate the Constitution you're like,
- 2:34yeah,
- 2:35I think you're asserting a claim
- 2:36on
- 2:36me.
- 2:36I think if you're saying we should end birthright citizenship,
- 2:38that is squarely against the Constitution.
- 2:40The Supreme Court agrees with me,
- 2:41not you.
- 2:41By the way,
- 2:42the economic data on immigration is abundantly clear.
- 2:45It's not,
- 2:45it's just like asking is 2 + 2 equals 4?
- 2:47Yeah,
- 2:48uh,
- 2:48the CBO,
- 2:49Congressional Budget Office,
- 2:50nonpartisan.
- 2:51Found that because of the unexpected surge in immigration between 2021 and 2026,
- 2:55they're expected to produce
- 2:56over $8.9 trillion in GDP.
- 2:59They're also expected to reduce immigrants have made $900 billion.
- 3:02You think immigrants have made us a third world country instead of a first world?
- 3:05I think they've improved the United States,
- 3:06and I know that as well because almost,
- 3:09almost half of the Fortune 500 companies.
- 3:11Many of them,
- 3:11did we have what we had in
- 3:13LA 40 years to answer your question or not?
- 3:14We'll get to the point,
- 3:15please.
- 3:15Well,
- 3:16I spoke for two seconds,
- 3:17then you jumped in.
- 3:17So,
- 3:18uh,
- 3:18for the
- 3:19half of Fortune 500 companies,
- 3:20many of them stationed here in LA,
- 3:21headquartered here in LA,
- 3:22nearly half were started by either immigrants or
- 3:25children of they all want to leave LA.
- 3:27I mean,
- 3:27they want to stay in the United States,
- 3:28don't they?
- 3:29Yeah,
- 3:29to places where there isn't as much of
- 3:31an immigration problem like LA and California,
- 3:33Texas,
- 3:34where Elon Musk wants to go.
- 3:35There's not an immigration problem in Texas.
- 3:36You don't see the rising costs like you do here in California.
- 3:39And why is that?
- 3:39Wait,
- 3:39wait,
- 3:40Texas has inflation because of the Reagan era policy that let in
- 3:43millions and millions of illegal immigrants.
- 3:45So
- 3:45that helps your argument,
- 3:46Harry.
- 3:47Wait,
- 3:47wait,
- 3:47Republicans let them in just to be clear,
- 3:49you didn't actually respond to anything I said regarding the CBO and any data.
- 3:53So you did have a response to what I said about the
- 3:54economic data have been listed once how immigrants have made our nation.
- 3:57I just cited $9 trillion in GDP.
- 4:01Is that good or bad?
- 4:02How about the deficit that they've created?
- 4:03You want to acknowledge that.
- 4:04Wait,
- 4:04the CBO in that same estimate found that immigrants over a 10-year period
- 4:08reduced the deficit by $900 billion.
- 4:11What percentage of illegal immigrants pay taxes into our system?
- 4:13Is it 100%,
- 4:14Harry?
- 4:15Is it almost the amount of citizens in our nation?
- 4:17We don't,
- 4:17we don't have the exact percentage.
- 4:19And so when I estimate,
- 4:20we don't have the exact percentage.
- 4:21But by the way,
- 4:22immigrants pay more don't have the exact percentage.
- 4:24Immigrants pay more in taxes than they take in.
- 4:25You're advocating for fraud.
- 4:26They paid $900 billion.
- 4:28They paid $900 billion in federal taxes in 2023,
- 4:32and that's more than they took in.
- 4:33They're funding Medicare,
- 4:34Medicaid,
- 4:34Social Security for all of the American people,
- 4:36and they're generating a bunch of economic output.
- 4:38What's the negative?
- 4:39So I let Harry talk,
- 4:40and so what you said is we don't know
- 4:42the amount of money illegal immigrants are paying into our
- 4:45system.
- 4:45The percentage.
- 4:46Don't you think that's a problem?
- 4:47Yeah,
- 4:47I think that's great.
- 4:48I think everybody should.
- 4:49Oh,
- 4:49you think that's great.
- 4:50I think everybody should pay taxes.
- 4:51I think everybody should pay taxes whether you're
- 4:52an immigrant or undocumented immigrant or legal.
- 4:54So how about when illegal immigrants.
- 4:56The emergency healthcare does that burden our system?
- 4:58Undocumented immigrants pay taxes through the ITIN.
- 5:01Are you aware of that?
- 5:02Yeah,
- 5:02I am.
- 5:02OK,
- 5:02great.
- 5:03And are you aware of the fact that in 2023 they paid $90 billion in federal taxes?
- 5:06Are you aware of that?
- 5:07That's a total number.
- 5:08I'm talking about per capita.
- 5:09When you talk about the amount that they put in,
- 5:11is that good or bad?
- 5:12Is that good or bad?
- 5:13It's an overall net good to the economy and our government,
- 5:15but I would say,
- 5:16OK,
- 5:16great.
- 5:16And are them,
- 5:17them generating $9 trillion
- 5:19them generating $9 trillion of GDP,
- 5:20is that good or bad?
- 5:21So should it be 100%
- 5:22is generating $9 trillion worth?
- 5:24Economic output,
- 5:25good or bad,
- 5:25you said it should be 100% and it's 53%
- 5:28question.
- 5:28Don't you agree with that trillion dollars?
- 5:30That's what it is.
- 5:30Don't you agree with $9 trillion of economic output?
- 5:32You know it's a loaded question.
- 5:33Here's what I'll say a loaded question.
- 5:35It's just,
- 5:35do you agree with $9 trillion of economic overall you
- 5:38say that they need to pay 100% into our system,
- 5:40yet you're advocating,
- 5:41OK,
- 5:4153% with $90 billion is enough.
- 5:44How does that make sense?
- 5:45Your claim has no standing.
- 5:46Wait,
- 5:46are you,
- 5:46are you serious?
- 5:47I said that I think everybody should pay taxes into the system,
- 5:50but what I'm also advocating or
- 5:52Pointing out the fact that they paid $90 billion in federal taxes,
- 5:54that does not mean that others shouldn't.
- 5:56That means that so far a lot are paying.
- 5:58And by the way,
- 5:59that the ones that pay you,
- 6:00not enough.
- 6:01Let's,
- 6:01let's do it.
- 6:02So more taxes for people.
- 6:03Harry,
- 6:03you should use your platform and tell all the illegal immigrants,
- 6:06pay 100% of your taxes to support this country.
- 6:09And you know what,
- 6:10I would support you on that,
- 6:11and I would actually believe you mean your claim.
- 6:13But you're not gonna do that.
- 6:14Wait,
- 6:14I,
- 6:14I think I'm saying it right now.
- 6:16We're in,
- 6:16we're in a film debate right now that people should pay taxes.
- 6:19So I'm not quite sure.
- 6:20I'm not quite sure where you're saying.
- 6:21I don't think I would believe that.
- 6:22But I'm looking at the actual data.
- 6:24Wait,
- 6:24hold on.
- 6:24I'm looking at the actual data,
- 6:25and you have not yet cite a single piece
- 6:27of data that says that immigration makes us weaker,
- 6:29not stronger.
- 6:30Uh,
- 6:30yeah,
- 6:30I cited the 53% that only pay
- 6:32tax
- 6:32voted out by the majority.
- 6:34Thank you very much,
- 6:35brother.
- 6:35Come back.
- 6:36OK,
- 6:36got you.
- 6:39If you would like to be the next debater,
- 6:41please get to the chair in 321.
- 6:48How are you?
- 6:48Nice to meet you.
- 6:49Um,
- 6:50all right,
- 6:50so I wanna start with,
- 6:51I think that you and I have a lot of common ground here,
- 6:53um.
- 6:54In terms of immigration,
- 6:55I think that generally speaking,
- 6:56immigration can be
- 6:58super beneficial for the country,
- 6:59but it has to be regulated and it comes down to responsibility.
- 7:02You would agree with that?
- 7:03OK,
- 7:03um,
- 7:04so we've,
- 7:05or you guys were talking a lot about GDP and economic growth.
- 7:08I was actually looking at the CBO too,
- 7:10and
- 7:10I agree with the numbers.
- 7:12Would you say that
- 7:14aggregate GDP though is the sole or primary indicator of
- 7:18whether or not like the country's border policies are succeeding?
- 7:22Oh,
- 7:22is GEP indicative of border policy succeeding?
- 7:25No,
- 7:25not,
- 7:26not automatically.
- 7:26No.
- 7:27OK,
- 7:27so I think it contributes to a broader conversation though.
- 7:29I think,
- 7:30um,
- 7:30when we're talking about immigration,
- 7:31it should be a variety of things that we factor into the conversation.
- 7:33It should be border security.
- 7:34It should be how we regulate it.
- 7:36It should be the benefit of this.
- 7:37I think that's
- 7:37applicable to any policy.
- 7:39OK,
- 7:39so is there,
- 7:40say,
- 7:41any,
- 7:41um,
- 7:42any amount of immigration that you would say is too much?
- 7:45Yeah,
- 7:45I mean,
- 7:46absolutely.
- 7:47Like if we had like 100 million people coming into the country,
- 7:49um,
- 7:50obviously there has to be some regulation.
- 7:51It's kind of arbitrary though,
- 7:52right?
- 7:52Like it's for you and me drawing a line being like this many is good,
- 7:55this many is bad.
- 7:55It's kind of arbitrary.
- 7:57But I think like
- 7:58keeping our immigration levels at what they are,
- 8:00or at least maybe I should speak to,
- 8:01um,
- 8:01perhaps like under a Democratic president,
- 8:03keeping that at the level that they are,
- 8:04um,
- 8:05and of course encouraging legal immigration and hopefully
- 8:07introducing some immigration reform.
- 8:09I think we as a country should be encouraging immigration,
- 8:11not
- 8:11discouraging.
- 8:12OK,
- 8:13um,
- 8:13so like for me personally,
- 8:14I think.
- 8:15And again,
- 8:16I agree,
- 8:17immigration,
- 8:17good thing overall,
- 8:19but it comes down to,
- 8:20first of all,
- 8:20scale,
- 8:21how many people are coming in at once.
- 8:23Um,
- 8:24it comes down to,
- 8:25I'd say national interest.
- 8:27Is it actually,
- 8:28yes,
- 8:28in terms of
- 8:30money,
- 8:30in terms of the GDP it's helping with the economy,
- 8:33but
- 8:33is it helping the national interest?
- 8:35Is it broadening,
- 8:36I guess,
- 8:36the American point of view making things?
- 8:39OK,
- 8:39how so?
- 8:40I mean,
- 8:40if we have people coming to the United States,
- 8:42starting businesses,
- 8:43working these jobs,
- 8:44contributing to our economy,
- 8:45contributing to our society,
- 8:46I mean,
- 8:47a lot of people,
- 8:47you know,
- 8:47immigrants come into the country and they give back,
- 8:49not just through their jobs,
- 8:50but
- 8:50they coach the soccer team at the school,
- 8:52they help out with their neighbors,
- 8:53kids,
- 8:53or whatever it is.
- 8:54Like they're humans too.
- 8:55They have
- 8:56Desires and wants and goals like the rest of us,
- 8:58and they want to help out as well.
- 8:59And so I think that's beneficial.
- 9:00I think they're beneficial to the culture.
- 9:01I've lived
- 9:02all over the world.
- 9:02I was born in Singapore,
- 9:03grew up in Dublin,
- 9:04Ireland.
- 9:05Yeah,
- 9:05and it was,
- 9:06I appreciate it.
- 9:07And it was,
- 9:07uh,
- 9:08you know,
- 9:08that's an invaluable experience that I had meeting different people,
- 9:10different ideas,
- 9:11different cultures,
- 9:12listening to different music,
- 9:13watching different types of media.
- 9:14I think that's really beneficial.
- 9:15OK,
- 9:16so pause.
- 9:17You've been voted out.
- 9:18I actually wanted that to be.
- 9:19All right,
- 9:19man.
- 9:20We'll talk again.
- 9:21Thanks,
- 9:21man.
- 9:23If you would like to be the next debater,
- 9:25please get to the chair in 321.
- 9:30What's up man?
- 9:31Nice to meet you.
- 9:31Nice to meet you.
- 9:33OK,
- 9:33so let's get into a little bit of the economics of immigration.
- 9:36You brought up 1st 900 billion.
- 9:38And then you brought up reduction of deficit.
- 9:40Sorry,
- 9:40well,
- 9:40if I said,
- 9:41oh,
- 9:41the $90 billion was taxes paid in,
- 9:43the $900 billion reduction 2023 number,
- 9:45right?
- 9:45It's actually,
- 9:45it's $98.7 billion.
- 9:46And that's
- 9:47taxes paid in.
- 9:48How much is the cost of immigration?
- 9:50Do you know that?
- 9:50Uh,
- 9:51I mean,
- 9:51well,
- 9:51how are you quantifying in terms of,
- 9:52so illegal,
- 9:53like illegal immigration,
- 9:54we're talking about illegal immigrants,
- 9:55right?
- 9:56I mean,
- 9:56that $98.7 billion is about illegal immigrants that contribute to the system.
- 10:00Sure,
- 10:00if you want to focus on the undocumented,
- 10:02we can do that.
- 10:02Yeah,
- 10:02well,
- 10:03that's the number that you're citing.
- 10:04Yeah,
- 10:04yeah,
- 10:05it's OK,
- 10:05sure,
- 10:05purely undocumented.
- 10:06It's you're
- 10:07like,
- 10:07because I see this a lot with the left that
- 10:09they try to conflate legal immigration with illegal immigrants.
- 10:12We have no,
- 10:12a lot of us don't have a problem
- 10:13trying to conflate.
- 10:14I was just trying to understand what you're saying,
- 10:15right,
- 10:16right,
- 10:16right.
- 10:16But like,
- 10:16so the numbers are kind of conflated.
- 10:18So I just want to,
- 10:18I just want to be clear,
- 10:19we're talking about undocumented immigrants.
- 10:22They
- 10:23contribute 98.7 billion
- 10:242023 numbers.
- 10:25How much do they cost?
- 10:27How are you quantifying it?
- 10:27Like just across the board?
- 10:29Well,
- 10:29if you have the number you should.
- 10:30If an illegal family comes here,
- 10:31you know,
- 10:31their kids go to school K through 12 is publicly paid for.
- 10:34So if you're averaging that,
- 10:36it costs about $19,000 per student per year,
- 10:38you know,
- 10:39that adds to the cost.
- 10:40If an illegal immigrant uses our healthcare system,
- 10:42places like California where you're sitting right now,
- 10:44we have federal matching assistance program where 60% of the Medicaid costs
- 10:48that goes to illegal immigrants is paid for by the federal government.
- 10:51OK,
- 10:51so we're all paying into that.
- 10:52So it's like
- 10:53then you have the courts,
- 10:54then you have,
- 10:54you know.
- 10:56Any
- 10:57essentially you have a,
- 10:57you have a bunch of different domains where illegal immigrants cost money.
- 11:00So my question to you is if you're willing to claim that
- 11:02$98 billion is the contribution,
- 11:04what is the cost?
- 11:05Well,
- 11:05what is the cost?
- 11:06The cost is upwards of $150 to $200 billion.
- 11:08Yeah,
- 11:08but I think like,
- 11:09but this is what the left,
- 11:10hold on,
- 11:10hold on,
- 11:10but let me,
- 11:10let me make my point.
- 11:11It's like
- 11:12the left focuses on the,
- 11:13on one side of the equation and completely ignores.
- 11:15If you're gonna make an economic argument,
- 11:17understand what you're arguing.
- 11:18Like,
- 11:18do you know what GDP is?
- 11:19Yeah,
- 11:19gross domestic product.
- 11:20What is a very There's 4 variables to it.
- 11:22Do you know what
- 11:22are the 4 variables?
- 11:23So it's consumption,
- 11:25investment,
- 11:25government spending,
- 11:26and net
- 11:27exports.
- 11:28Government spending is a key metric in that.
- 11:30If government spending increases,
- 11:32which
- 11:33bringing people,
- 11:34like you could bring 100 million people,
- 11:35like,
- 11:36which is what you said the other,
- 11:37that that would be too much.
- 11:38If you brought 100 million people,
- 11:39government spending would go up,
- 11:40GDP would go up.
- 11:42Is that is that positive for us
- 11:43if housing goes up?
- 11:44Well,
- 11:45that's why I think there needs to be a line 100%,
- 11:47right?
- 11:47But what we're seeing right now also,
- 11:49can I just quickly on the,
- 11:49on the,
- 11:50on the topic of,
- 11:51well,
- 11:51first of all,
- 11:51where'd you get the 150 billion number?
- 11:54There's different,
- 11:54there's different studies.
- 11:55So there's,
- 11:56there's a Cato Institute study.
- 11:58There's different studies.
- 11:59Cato Institute has actually found that,
- 12:00um,
- 12:01immigrants pay more into the system than they take.
- 12:02What
- 12:03immigrants or illegal immigrants.
- 12:05Either,
- 12:06yes,
- 12:06they have.
- 12:07The Cato Institute.
- 12:08There's a Manhattan Institute is not.
- 12:09There's Manhattan Institute is,
- 12:10is conservative.
- 12:11It is conservative,
- 12:12and Cato Institute
- 12:13conservative is right leaning,
- 12:14right?
- 12:15They're libertarian,
- 12:15but they're saying,
- 12:16but they're contradicting me a left wing source that give me a left.
- 12:19Wait,
- 12:19I just want to make the point I was about to make.
- 12:21I'm happy to accept any number from a left-wing source that you give me,
- 12:23but the left doesn't.
- 12:24Have a number because they know the truth.
- 12:26And to be clear,
- 12:26let's just say hypothetically side of the equation is ugly.
- 12:28Let's just say that hypothetically it is 150 billion.
- 12:31That's the number you said on the low end,
- 12:32it's more,
- 12:33but OK,
- 12:33let's just say it is.
- 12:34That is still a worthy investment
- 12:35for the United States.
- 12:36You're not,
- 12:37it depends how you attribute because again,
- 12:39if we go to GDP,
- 12:40it's like,
- 12:40well,
- 12:40what is GDP?
- 12:41Are we happy just spending more money?
- 12:43But when we know that immigrants and undocumented
- 12:45immigrants make up a significant portion of different industries
- 12:49and undocumented undocumented.
- 12:50Undocumented immigrants make up a significant portion of.
- 12:53Yes,
- 12:53they do.
- 12:54They undercut
- 12:55that undocumented immigrants don't make up a significant part do.
- 12:58But here's the thing,
- 12:59here's the thing,
- 12:59they do undercut wages.
- 13:01They undercut wages here in LA.
- 13:03The unemployment rate in Los Angeles and California
- 13:05as a whole in these sanctuary cities is
- 13:07some of the highest in the country's some
- 13:08evidence to suggest that an independent or,
- 13:10or,
- 13:11uh,
- 13:11except not broader,
- 13:12not in the broader numbers for the scale,
- 13:13but in independent instances,
- 13:15there might be some wage oppression for Americans.
- 13:17Because of immigrants,
- 13:17but that is not a trend.
- 13:18Is there housing in the United States?
- 13:19Is there housing?
- 13:20There might be,
- 13:20there might be,
- 13:21there might be,
- 13:21there might be some small,
- 13:22I think it's like 1 to 2%.
- 13:24Yeah,
- 13:241 to 2% of housing inflation is caused by immigrants.
- 13:27But again,
- 13:28the main problem why housing has gone up and
- 13:29it's been so expensive recently is because we're not building
- 13:32and yeah,
- 13:32because liberal policies,
- 13:33but that's a whole another,
- 13:34that's it is.
- 13:35It's because zoning laws,
- 13:36that's not true.
- 13:36I mean,
- 13:36I agree that there should be,
- 13:38I think there should be,
- 13:38I think there should be reforms to zoning.
- 13:40OK,
- 13:40well,
- 13:41housing prices in red states have gone up because of the demand.
- 13:43Because everybody's leaving the blue states because it's so
- 13:46poorly managed.
- 13:46More people have come to California from Texas than California to Texas.
- 13:49That's not true.
- 13:49It is true.
- 13:50LA has
- 13:51anyway,
- 13:51listen,
- 13:52of 230,000 people since COVID,
- 13:54hold on,
- 13:54let me make my point.
- 13:55Texas has literally the most people moving to,
- 13:58to make
- 13:58any other crucial industries in the United States
- 14:00that everybody in this room relies on,
- 14:02a lot of them have,
- 14:03uh,
- 14:04make up a lot of immigrants.
- 14:05So like 30% of the construction industry is made up by,
- 14:07OK,
- 14:07I'm pro-immigrant.
- 14:08OK,
- 14:08so would you agree with.
- 14:09Would you agree with the prompt that immigration makes America stronger,
- 14:11and would you disagree with,
- 14:13again,
- 14:13you're trying to,
- 14:13would you disagree illegal immigration,
- 14:15would you disagree with Donald Trump's policies so far on it?
- 14:17What like on what
- 14:18his,
- 14:18his policies broadly,
- 14:19his increase in funding for ICE,
- 14:21the people getting abducted off the streets with masks.
- 14:23Who's getting abducted?
- 14:24We should increase funding for ICE.
- 14:25Kilmore Abrego Garcia was illegally deported,
- 14:27dude,
- 14:28we should absolutely have law enforcement.
- 14:29Do you believe that we should have borders and law enforcement,
- 14:31wait,
- 14:31wait,
- 14:31I think,
- 14:32I think,
- 14:33I think having law enforcement is fine,
- 14:34but what Donald Trump has done with.
- 14:35ICE
- 14:36what Donald Trump has done with ICE and
- 14:38so picking random people off the streets,
- 14:40random
- 14:40people.
- 14:41Kilmar Abrego Garcia
- 14:43Kilmar Abrego.
- 14:43Are you familiar with Kilmar Abrego Garcia?
- 14:45OK.
- 14:45And what did the Supreme Court say about his deportation?
- 14:47I don't recall.
- 14:48OK,
- 14:48they 9-0 ruled against Donald Trump and then Donald Trump was not a technicality.
- 14:52It was not a technicality because he was ordered to stay technicality.
- 14:54It's due process.
- 14:56Was he an illegal immigrant?
- 14:57No,
- 14:57he was,
- 14:58he was,
- 14:59he's an El Salvadorian citizen.
- 15:00He was here illegally.
- 15:02He was
- 15:02here because of a
- 15:03case.
- 15:03A judge was a domestic.
- 15:05A judge was a domestic he was allowed to stay in the United States.
- 15:07No,
- 15:07that he had to stay in the United States
- 15:09because he of a domestic abuse judge rules that,
- 15:11what does that make,
- 15:11right?
- 15:12But it's because of a domestic abuse issue.
- 15:13It wasn't because he wasn't illegal.
- 15:15If you actually know the case,
- 15:16no,
- 15:16no,
- 15:16no.
- 15:17Well,
- 15:17you don't,
- 15:17you don't even know what the Supreme Court ruled on it.
- 15:19The judge,
- 15:20the judge ruled that Gilmar Abrego Garcia was allowed to stay in the United States.
- 15:24If a judge is saying that,
- 15:25does that,
- 15:25does that make him illegal or legal?
- 15:27He was here illegally.
- 15:29He had to stay in the United States because there were,
- 15:30he was.
- 15:31He was involved in a domestic abuse case and a judge ruled that he could
- 15:35say drug trafficking by the Supreme Court.
- 15:36Wait,
- 15:37that's an allegation that hasn't been proven in court.
- 15:38Number one,
- 15:39that's true.
- 15:39OK,
- 15:40but I'm just saying that you know what has been ruled in court?
- 15:42Why the,
- 15:43you know what has been ruled in court that he was here legally.
- 15:44A judge allowed him to stay and the Supreme
- 15:47Court ordered that Donald Trump brought him back.
- 15:49But listen,
- 15:49listen,
- 15:49you're saying that people are being picked off randomly on the streets.
- 15:52Kilmar Abrego Garcia was picked up randomly.
- 15:53No,
- 15:53he was,
- 15:54he was.
- 15:54What about
- 15:55Mahmoud Khalil?
- 15:55Let's,
- 15:55let's,
- 15:56let's disprove this.
- 15:56This will take less than a minute.
- 15:58It'll be painless,
- 15:58I swear.
- 15:59How many ICE agents are there?
- 16:01Uh,
- 16:01I don't know what the number 22,000 in the US.
- 16:03Do you know how many of them are?
- 16:04Do you know the difference between HSI and ERO officers?
- 16:07Homeland Security investigations
- 16:08and enforcement removal.
- 16:10So we don't have much time left.
- 16:11So just make the point.
- 16:11Uh,
- 16:12it's only about 10,000 actual enforcement removal officers
- 16:15that are day to day going out,
- 16:16going around.
- 16:17They literally HSI stakes out locations to go to send their officers,
- 16:21and then
- 16:22like the claim that they're picking off people randomly by this,
- 16:24like on the street.
- 16:25It's a country of 340 million people.
- 16:27LAPD
- 16:28is.
- 16:2912 million.
- 16:29It's 9000 LAPD officers.
- 16:31Do you think that 10,000 officers,
- 16:34ICE officers that are on the streets are randomly picking people up?
- 16:36Is that your,
- 16:37like,
- 16:37do you really believe that they,
- 16:38they quite are.
- 16:39They're not literally arbitrarily picking people.
- 16:41What about Mahmud Khalil?
- 16:43What about him?
- 16:43So,
- 16:44OK,
- 16:44he was,
- 16:45he was here in the,
- 16:46he was here in the United States of America.
- 16:47He was here in the United States of America legally.
- 16:49Yes,
- 16:49uh,
- 16:50he was here legally.
- 16:51OK,
- 16:51no,
- 16:51no,
- 16:51wait,
- 16:52wait,
- 16:52which one?
- 16:52Mahmud Khalil?
- 16:53Yeah,
- 16:53Columbia,
- 16:53the one,
- 16:54the Columbia student,
- 16:54um,
- 16:55yes,
- 16:55he was.
- 16:55OK,
- 16:56great.
- 16:56And what did he have?
- 16:57What made him legal here in the United States?
- 16:58He had a green card.
- 16:59He had a green card student like for he was a student,
- 17:01right?
- 17:01Right.
- 17:01And so,
- 17:02exactly.
- 17:03And so,
- 17:03but again he has a pro-Palestinian,
- 17:05but no,
- 17:05no,
- 17:05wait,
- 17:05hold on,
- 17:06hold on.
- 17:06This is,
- 17:07this is the claim is that ISIS randomly he was a legal person here in the United
- 17:10States and he and he was inciting terrorists
- 17:12and he was inciting terrorist language in Colombia.
- 17:14He was.
- 17:15Wait,
- 17:15wait,
- 17:15wait,
- 17:15what happened to the First Amendment.
- 17:16He was praising Hamas.
- 17:17Well,
- 17:18you can praise Hamas under the first.
- 17:19The thing about you can,
- 17:21but there might be consequences if you're not a permanent resident here.
- 17:23Sure,
- 17:25the Secretary of Secretary of State Marco Rubio,
- 17:27the Secretary to repeal his.
- 17:30Wait,
- 17:30wait,
- 17:30no,
- 17:30it didn't.
- 17:31The judge ruled that it was only he was only being,
- 17:33um,
- 17:34you're trying to.
- 17:36Wait,
- 17:36wait,
- 17:36wait,
- 17:36can I make my point?
- 17:37Can I make my point?
- 17:38A judge ruled that the only reason Mahmoud Khalil was,
- 17:41uh,
- 17:41was picked.
- 17:42Picked up by ICE was because of his speech.
- 17:44That is a First Amendment issue.
- 17:46If a judge is saying that it's not
- 17:47necessarily if they're not a permanent resident here.
- 17:50Incitement to should we be able to deport people that hate
- 17:53this country and they're calling for the destruction of this country?
- 17:56Well,
- 17:56it depends on who they are.
- 17:57If they're not,
- 17:57if they're not legal citizens here,
- 17:59if they're if they're here
- 18:00on a green card or a visa,
- 18:02like,
- 18:02for example,
- 18:02Marco Rubio,
- 18:03I think this was last week.
- 18:04He revoked 175,000 visas of people that,
- 18:07oh,
- 18:07different people that like were like saying like,
- 18:09oh,
- 18:09death to America and these,
- 18:11these crazy like
- 18:13essentially jihadists.
- 18:14Do you,
- 18:14do you,
- 18:14would you be against that?
- 18:15Do you think we should,
- 18:16I think it's host,
- 18:17do you think America should host people that hate this country?
- 18:20I think it's circumstantial.
- 18:21So,
- 18:21uh,
- 18:22yeah,
- 18:22I'm a big First Amendment guy.
- 18:23Sorry.
- 18:24I'm a big First Amendment guy too.
- 18:26If Mahmoud Khalil is advocating for Palestine and Colombia,
- 18:28and he's not what he was doing.
- 18:29That's exactly.
- 18:30What he was doing.
- 18:30And even if you disagree with,
- 18:32even if you disagree with his speech,
- 18:34that's great.
- 18:34You can disagree with a terrorist organization
- 18:36that's called that openly called whatever,
- 18:38however,
- 18:39however you interpret his speech,
- 18:40whether you interpret,
- 18:41however you,
- 18:42it is your interpretation,
- 18:43a speech is not objective.
- 18:44I mean,
- 18:44come on,
- 18:45we're this is basics.
- 18:46So however you interpret his speech,
- 18:47be constructed into abstractions so you can't argue.
- 18:50You're saying that his speech was one thing.
- 18:52It was just as a matter of,
- 18:53just as a matter of conversation,
- 18:54however you interpret.
- 18:55His speech,
- 18:56he should not be picked up,
- 18:57held in an ICE detention center for over 100 days
- 19:00because he said something
- 19:01that
- 19:02Donald Trump doesn't like with you.
- 19:03We can agree with that.
- 19:03I never said send his ass out of here.
- 19:05Now you're straw man.
- 19:05It's not a straw man.
- 19:06I don't know.
- 19:06When did I say that he should be we have to tolerate,
- 19:08obviously why do we have to said that he should be.
- 19:10Why do we have to tolerate people that hate this country?
- 19:12Because don't we have a First Amendment?
- 19:13We do have a First Amendment.
- 19:15Don't we have a principles that people
- 19:16don't we have principles we also have to be tolerant.
- 19:18We also have to be disagree with,
- 19:19you know,
- 19:19we also have the rule of law.
- 19:21So we,
- 19:21we need,
- 19:22we need an enforcement agency.
- 19:24We can say I like,
- 19:25I like terrorists.
- 19:26You can say I like Hamas.
- 19:27You can say I like all these things,
- 19:28and that is protected by the First Amendment.
- 19:30So we do have a rule of laws.
- 19:31There's
- 19:32there might be consequences depending on your legal.
- 19:34Let me just,
- 19:35let me just fatus here,
- 19:36but let me.
- 19:36Say
- 19:37on the topic of rule of law,
- 19:38you're a Trump supporter,
- 19:39you like a felon,
- 19:39so you apply the law.
- 19:41You apply the law differently in some
- 19:42instances straw man.
- 19:43Do
- 19:44you support Trump?
- 19:45I support Trump,
- 19:46but OK,
- 19:46and he's a felon.
- 19:47He's a felon.
- 19:48We have to pause here.
- 19:49You've been voted out.
- 19:50Nice to meet you,
- 19:51man.
- 19:51Come back.
- 19:55If you would like to be the next debater,
- 19:57please get to the chair in 321.
- 20:02Hey,
- 20:02nice to see you again.
- 20:03All right,
- 20:04so
- 20:04your claim regarding immigrants and their contribution to the economy,
- 20:07I just want to check if that's good faith
- 20:09because I suspect you might not agree with that.
- 20:11So
- 20:12you say that overall immigrants contribute more than they take from the system,
- 20:15right?
- 20:15And that's one of their huge pluses.
- 20:16But you're bundling all immigrants together.
- 20:18We could actually separate them out by country,
- 20:20and you can see that some countries like Japan,
- 20:23England,
- 20:23China,
- 20:24when they have immigrants.
- 20:25They are huge net contributions,
- 20:26right?
- 20:27But then we can also see some countries aren't like Mexico
- 20:29and El Salvador are on the bottom of net contribution.
- 20:32Would you be OK if we restricted immigration from countries
- 20:34that were net detractors to America rather than net benefactors?
- 20:37No,
- 20:37I mean,
- 20:38I was hoping to get,
- 20:39I was hoping that we,
- 20:39no,
- 20:40I wouldn't want to restrict that immigration from this place,
- 20:41but I was hoping that we have GDP for you.
- 20:43Our immigration policy in the United States should not just.
- 20:45To be whether they are productive or not.
- 20:47It should be part of the conversation.
- 20:49GDP economy,
- 20:50100%.
- 20:50But also I think there has to be
- 20:51a humanitarian perspective on the topic of immigration,
- 20:54pragmatism.
- 20:55Why?
- 20:55Because they're human beings too.
- 20:56And if somebody,
- 20:57for example,
- 20:58is being persecuted based on a protected trait,
- 21:00we have an asylum system for that.
- 21:01I,
- 21:02I support the asylum system.
- 21:03I think that people should be able to claim asylum.
- 21:04Why should we be the battered women's shelter of the world?
- 21:07Because,
- 21:07well,
- 21:07we've been that first of all,
- 21:08we've been that our entire,
- 21:09our entire existence.
- 21:09We've had
- 21:10we've had the Statue of Liberty that says bring me your huddle,
- 21:12bring me your poor.
- 21:13That's been a foundation
- 21:14that's been a foundation of the United States.
- 21:16But also if we as a country,
- 21:17if we as
- 21:18a country,
- 21:19if we as a country can take people in who are being persecuted on protected traits,
- 21:23I think we have a moral obligation to do that.
- 21:25Not only is that moral,
- 21:26but don't legislate your morality.
- 21:28Please don't legislate your morality on my country.
- 21:30That's what does that mean?
- 21:31What I,
- 21:32I don't know.
- 21:32You guys say it all the time when Christians try to.
- 21:34I've never,
- 21:34I don't know what you're talking about.
- 21:35I've never said that,
- 21:36but I think we have a moral obligation.
- 21:38You're lying about the Statue of Liberty thinking it's really gonna bother me.
- 21:40You said it's always for our whole history said give me your tired report.
- 21:43When was that added to the Statue of Liberty
- 21:44because it didn't come with the original one.
- 21:45Wait,
- 21:46can you just respond to the broader point
- 21:47as opposed to picking the Statue of Liberty.
- 21:49Do you agree with the
- 21:50or not?
- 21:50No,
- 21:50I don't.
- 21:51OK,
- 21:51so it's quite obvious.
- 21:52So we should get rid of the asylum system as well.
- 21:53Yes,
- 21:53we should let people into this country when they would benefit the country.
- 21:56We shouldn't let them in when they would be a net drain to the country.
- 21:58So that's crazy.
- 21:58In World War II,
- 21:59when there was a boat of Jews who came from Europe who were being attacked by Germany,
- 22:03we turned them away.
- 22:04Yeah,
- 22:05would you be in favor of turning them away?
- 22:06No,
- 22:06Jews benefit this country.
- 22:08Do you disagree with that?
- 22:09Wait,
- 22:09so,
- 22:09so my,
- 22:09what I just said,
- 22:10wait,
- 22:10wait,
- 22:11wait,
- 22:11wait,
- 22:11people live in your morality,
- 22:12your morality says that if,
- 22:14if they would benefit America,
- 22:15if they're being attacked by a foreign power or their government or something,
- 22:19we should only let them in
- 22:20if they are productive,
- 22:21not because they're being attacked by foreign.
- 22:23Obviously if they benefit America,
- 22:24are you,
- 22:25are you religious by any chance?
- 22:26No,
- 22:26you're not religious.
- 22:27No,
- 22:27I'm not religious.
- 22:27I'm an atheist,
- 22:28so I'll just make it we're two atheists and
- 22:29you've come to basically like a weird Catholic Christian.
- 22:32Morality of we've got to help the world and it's not,
- 22:34it's not a Catholic or Christian when
- 22:35we
- 22:36have that as Catholic.
- 22:37I don't know where you're deriving from that
- 22:38we have to be the battered woman's shelter.
- 22:39What's your moral principle
- 22:40that you're going?
- 22:41I,
- 22:41I think that if the United States has the capacity and there are,
- 22:44for example,
- 22:44Jews in World War II who are being persecuted,
- 22:46we should let them in.
- 22:47That's just like,
- 22:47what's the moral principle just like just like be a hecking good person.
- 22:50Like what is your basic moral principle you're going on?
- 22:52Just like with Mexico,
- 22:53if somebody is being targeted by cartels
- 22:56and we Have an opportunity to let them in the United States
- 22:57or at least have that legal process play out with asylum.
- 22:59We should do that.
- 23:00But if it doesn't benefit America and I don't
- 23:02want to do something that doesn't benefit America,
- 23:04what's your argument to me as to why I should do that?
- 23:06Wait,
- 23:06why should I do something unbeneficial to our country?
- 23:09They do benefit the United States.
- 23:10Well,
- 23:10we just went over this just because,
- 23:12so let's go over Mexico,
- 23:13for example.
- 23:13You said that they are less productive for the United States
- 23:15in a country like China in terms of immigrant productive.
- 23:16I'm saying they are in terms of immigrants.
- 23:18They cost more on government services in terms.
- 23:20Of immigrants,
- 23:20are they,
- 23:21are they more productive for the United States?
- 23:22No,
- 23:23I just gave you the stat.
- 23:23No,
- 23:24I just gave you the stat on that.
- 23:25So they cost more tax services than they contribute taxes,
- 23:28right?
- 23:28They are a net drain on the budget.
- 23:30Great.
- 23:30So,
- 23:30but you're saying that for that applies to immigrants,
- 23:33for example,
- 23:33from like China versus immigrants.
- 23:35China is a positive.
- 23:35Well,
- 23:35China's positive.
- 23:36Yeah,
- 23:36yeah.
- 23:36So for positive,
- 23:37yeah,
- 23:37that applies to China,
- 23:38not for like El Salvador,
- 23:39right?
- 23:39El Salvador,
- 23:40I think is the bottom line of like contribution versus cost 100%.
- 23:43So in my
- 23:44In my perspective,
- 23:45just to lay it out,
- 23:46if somebody from El Salvador is being targeted because of their identity,
- 23:49or if they make a valid asylum claim,
- 23:51I see no reason not to let them in the United States,
- 23:52even if it might be a drain on our federal budget.
- 23:55The valid asylum claim is an appeal to existing law.
- 23:57I'm suggesting changing the existing law.
- 23:58So to what?
- 23:59To we shouldn't let people in on the basis of asylum.
- 24:02We should analyze whether or not they will contribute to the country.
- 24:04So then what should we do to make illegal immigration easier?
- 24:06To make illegal immigration easier,
- 24:07legal.
- 24:08We should do so.
- 24:09Well,
- 24:09I'm not saying it should be easier,
- 24:10but I'm saying,
- 24:11so we should make it harder.
- 24:12We should have it be based on analysis of whether you'll contribute to the country,
- 24:15not just this arbitrary quantify that.
- 24:16What should,
- 24:17what should the law be?
- 24:17Just like if they have money,
- 24:19education,
- 24:19specialized skills,
- 24:21training,
- 24:21things like that,
- 24:22that,
- 24:22that's already what the law is.
- 24:23It's not.
- 24:24Yes,
- 24:24it is.
- 24:24No,
- 24:25you can literally come to America without really any sort of meaningful display.
- 24:28Of contribution.
- 24:29Yeah,
- 24:29that's absolutely not true.
- 24:30There's a lottery system for workers to come into the United States.
- 24:33There's only shouldn't be right.
- 24:34There's only around a 35% acceptance rate.
- 24:36It's especially bad for lower income workers.
- 24:38So what should the law be?
- 24:39Because you're you're advocating,
- 24:40you're advocating for what the law is right now.
- 24:41What should the law be,
- 24:42right?
- 24:42I'm explaining it shouldn't be a law.
- 24:44OK,
- 24:44we got to pause.
- 24:44We're out of time for this claim.
- 24:46All right,
- 24:46maybe I'll see you again.
- 24:47Absolutely.
- 24:51My next surrounding claim is that Donald
- 24:53Trump has normalized political violence in America.
- 24:55If you'd like to be the first debater,
- 24:57please get to the chair in 321.
- 25:02Oh,
- 25:03how's it going?
- 25:03Nice to meet you,
- 25:04man.
- 25:04Charlie,
- 25:05nice to meet you.
- 25:06So I actually say that the media has done
- 25:08a great job in normalizing political violence in America
- 25:12because of what they have said about Trump supporters for the past
- 25:158 years since President Trump started running for office,
- 25:18they've called us racist,
- 25:19they've called us homophobic,
- 25:21they've called us transphobic,
- 25:22they've called us bigots,
- 25:23and because of that,
- 25:24a lot of the people on the left are
- 25:25hearing these things and they're being radicalized by the media
- 25:29and therefore they're taking steps forward to commit acts of violence.
- 25:33We've
- 25:33Seeing people on the radical left time and time again
- 25:36commit these acts,
- 25:37whether it be riots in
- 25:38big cities like LA or New York City or Baltimore
- 25:42or
- 25:43the assassination of Charlie Kirk.
- 25:45Unfortunately,
- 25:46these people have been
- 25:47being radicalized greatly,
- 25:48not by Donald Trump,
- 25:50but by the media's rhetoric of
- 25:52Republicans and magazines.
- 25:53So
- 25:54let's just say,
- 25:55because I want to understand your point a little bit more.
- 25:57Let's just say hypothetically I were to call you,
- 25:59um,
- 26:00a.
- 26:00Fascist,
- 26:01a communist,
- 26:02and a gnat that I had to get rid of,
- 26:04like a gnat,
- 26:05like a bug.
- 26:06Would you think that's inciting violence against you as a Trump supporter?
- 26:08No,
- 26:09you wouldn't.
- 26:09I,
- 26:09I don't think so at all.
- 26:10I think that you would be making those claims,
- 26:12and it's up to me whether or not I want to be
- 26:14radicalized by those claims.
- 26:16I know that I'm not those things,
- 26:18so I would just brush that.
- 26:19So then how can you claim that the media is inciting violence?
- 26:21I mean,
- 26:21aren't those claims at least somewhat similar to what they were saying,
- 26:24we've seen political violence go up these last few years.
- 26:27Would you agree?
- 26:28Uh,
- 26:29well,
- 26:29what's the time frame?
- 26:30Well,
- 26:30between 2016 and 2026,
- 26:33and we've seen the media
- 26:35really
- 26:37name names as far as Trump supporters.
- 26:40They call us names.
- 26:41They call us
- 26:42horrible things,
- 26:43and people are hearing these things like people on the radical left.
- 26:46And they're taking matters into their own hands and therefore
- 26:48committing these,
- 26:49these acts of violence.
- 26:51I mean,
- 26:51I mean,
- 26:53I mean,
- 26:53we could use Charlie Currick as an example.
- 26:54I mean,
- 26:55he was sitting right where you were
- 26:56almost a year ago and they,
- 26:58they killed him.
- 26:58He's dead.
- 26:59And,
- 26:59and it was somebody on the radical left side who,
- 27:02who pulled the trigger
- 27:04and they were.
- 27:06Radicalized not by
- 27:07Donald Trump,
- 27:08but they're radicalized by what the media,
- 27:10in my opinion,
- 27:12was saying about
- 27:14us as Republicans,
- 27:15us as Trump.
- 27:16I mean,
- 27:16do you hold Donald Trump accountable for his rhetoric because,
- 27:18for example,
- 27:19on social media,
- 27:20he posted a video that included a truck
- 27:22that had an image of Joe Biden hog tied in the back.
- 27:25Sure,
- 27:25but is that not inciting violence against,
- 27:27did that lead to any act of physical violence?
- 27:30Actually there have been people prosecuted for alleged
- 27:32threats against Joe Biden and Kamala Harris's life.
- 27:34Yeah,
- 27:34but they,
- 27:34I mean,
- 27:35people threatened every president,
- 27:36you know,
- 27:36you could say there's hundreds and hundreds of threats,
- 27:38but who actually went forth and did something?
- 27:40Well,
- 27:40when Donald Trump is posting,
- 27:42when Donald Trump is posting images like this,
- 27:43I think that's bad.
- 27:44I think that's inciting political violence.
- 27:46And also,
- 27:46when I think Donald Trump was running the first time,
- 27:48he had rallies
- 27:49where there was a protester that was thrown out and he offered to pay
- 27:52the legal bills of anybody that punched
- 27:54that protester who obviously disagreed with him.
- 27:56Is that not normalizing political violence in America?
- 27:58I don't.
- 27:58I think when you say,
- 27:59is he normalizing political violence in America?
- 28:01Meaning we see it a lot more often because of Donald Trump.
- 28:05So the reason we're seeing political violence,
- 28:07the reason we're seeing acts of violence take place
- 28:09is because of Donald Trump.
- 28:11That's what you're saying.
- 28:11You don't think it's,
- 28:12it's,
- 28:12it's interesting that Donald Trump's rise in politics has also coincided
- 28:16with a rise in threats against political officials,
- 28:18poll workers,
- 28:19and things like that.
- 28:19You don't think it's a coincidental that after 2021 we saw an
- 28:22increase of threats toward judges or people in the legal field,
- 28:25so much so that Chief Justice John Roberts in his end of year report in 2024,
- 28:29uh.
- 28:29Specifically condemn these threats against judges that came after Donald
- 28:32Trump was doing everything that he did with the 2014.
- 28:34Maybe,
- 28:35like I said,
- 28:35maybe we've seen threats.
- 28:36Maybe we've seen
- 28:38rhetoric on social media from
- 28:40people on the conservative side,
- 28:41but we've also seen it with people on the left side as well.
- 28:44What I'm talking about is like
- 28:46from the people on the left side,
- 28:47we've seen action.
- 28:48We've seen not just have we not seen action from the Republicans?
- 28:51Name me an example.
- 28:51Melissa Hortman,
- 28:52a state legislator in Minnesota,
- 28:54shot and killed in her house along with her dog and her,
- 28:56her husband.
- 28:57By a Trump supporter.
- 28:58His name was Vance Bolter,
- 28:59self-proclaimed Trump supporter.
- 29:00He had a list of people he wanted to target,
- 29:02all Democratic representatives,
- 29:04and I want to be clear,
- 29:05I'm not claiming that there have never been anybody on
- 29:07the left who hasn't acted violently or killed anybody.
- 29:10There's more people on the right than people.
- 29:11I think that Donald Trump has encouraged it.
- 29:12And also the data does show that it's more often in
- 29:15common on the right than it is on the left.
- 29:16I think that we have to pause here.
- 29:18You've been voted out by the majority.
- 29:19Thank you.
- 29:20Thanks,
- 29:20man.
- 29:20We'll talk soon.
- 29:22Nice to meet you too.
- 29:25If you'd like to be the next debater,
- 29:26please get to the chair in 321.
- 29:32Hey man,
- 29:33Harry,
- 29:33OK,
- 29:33so the claim you made is that President Trump has
- 29:36led to an increased political violence has normalized it,
- 29:38normalized and also an increase for sure.
- 29:40So I think when we look at at least around your age,
- 29:43and I don't know your exact age,
- 29:45so I apologize,
- 29:4623,
- 29:46so
- 29:47I'm 27.
- 29:48So in our lifetime we look at the
- 29:49most significant acts of political violence being conducted
- 29:52in America.
- 29:53The three most significant acts in
- 29:56general order would be
- 29:57first,
- 29:58the assassination attempt of the members
- 30:00of Congress during the congressional baseball game
- 30:02where Republican member of Congress Steve Scalise was the one
- 30:05who was victimized by a radical Bernie Sanders supporter.
- 30:08We'll look at the next
- 30:10very notable act of political violence
- 30:12of President Trump's assassination attempt where
- 30:14we were inches away from absolute civil unrest in this society
- 30:18from a radicalized left-wing lunatic
- 30:21trying to shoot
- 30:22President Republican,
- 30:23by the way,
- 30:23but sure.
- 30:24And then we move on to the third act.
- 30:27An individual who sat in this room a year ago,
- 30:29Charlie Kirk,
- 30:30was killed
- 30:31by a radical left-wing
- 30:34Democrat.
- 30:34So I,
- 30:34I ask you,
- 30:35uh,
- 30:36how long did it take you to put on your clown makeup this morning
- 30:39to ask those questions and try to claim that President Trump is responsible for
- 30:43the rise of political violence in this country?
- 30:45How many times you practiced that in the mirror?
- 30:47Didn't.
- 30:48Nobody laughed.
- 30:49So I was,
- 30:50you know,
- 30:50kind of,
- 30:50kind of fell flat at least.
- 30:52Um,
- 30:52but you are missing a couple of examples of political violence in there,
- 30:55I noticed.
- 30:56And of course,
- 30:57I'll get to the topics that you mentioned,
- 30:59but you
- 30:59forgot Melissa Hortman,
- 31:00who I just mentioned to the gentleman I was just speaking to.
- 31:03And you also forgot January 6th.
- 31:05example of political violence in American history.
- 31:07So I'm glad you actually mentioned January 6th.
- 31:09OK,
- 31:10go ahead.
- 31:10If you want to mention January 6th,
- 31:11we talked about actual impact,
- 31:12and I'm not going to sit here and defend January 6th.
- 31:14In fact,
- 31:15I'm going to say that any action of breaking into a government building is horrible.
- 31:18I do not
- 31:19condone it.
- 31:20I do not want anybody to support that action.
- 31:22I look at the actual impact of the actions of political violence.
- 31:26There's political violence on both sides.
- 31:28Pew Research shows that both sides view
- 31:30pretty much equally that the opposing side is more violent than their side,
- 31:34and that they are
- 31:35dealing with expressed beliefs where the other side is
- 31:38essentially more violent than them.
- 31:40Statistically speaking,
- 31:41both sides have the same viewpoint of that.
- 31:44We look at the most notable examples.
- 31:45You talk about January 6th,
- 31:47the summer before that we had the George Floyd riots.
- 31:49We want to talk about the actual impact.
- 31:5193% of those were peaceful.
- 31:5293%.
- 31:53OK,
- 31:53we want to talk about the action.
- 31:54By the way,
- 31:55anybody that did anything wrong should be convicted and in jail.
- 31:57I have no problem with that.
- 31:58But Donald Trump with January 6th,
- 32:00he had a bunch of people beating police officers almost to death,
- 32:02uh,
- 32:03threatening to kill members of Congress,
- 32:04wanting to hang Mike Pence.
- 32:05And what did,
- 32:05what did Trump do to them?
- 32:06What did Trump do for them?
- 32:09Trump told people on January 6th to stand down.
- 32:11Back,
- 32:11back to the George Floyd riots,
- 32:13uh,
- 32:13going to the actual impact of these policies.
- 32:15I feel like how much,
- 32:17how much damage.
- 32:18Uh,
- 32:18was caused during January 6th.
- 32:19About how much damage?
- 32:20Um,
- 32:20I think it was in terms of property damage.
- 32:22Property damage,
- 32:23I think it was under a billion dollars.
- 32:24I mean it was estimated at $2.7 million.
- 32:27Yeah,
- 32:27right.
- 32:27So
- 32:28the George Floyd riots the summer before,
- 32:29you know what the estimate was from insurance claims from private companies,
- 32:32businesses,
- 32:33many of whom were black owned businesses.
- 32:35It was over $1 billion of property damage.
- 32:38We talk about the impact of violence on the left versus violence on the right.
- 32:41$2.7 million.
- 32:43Versus 1
- 32:44million.
- 32:44Are you talking about mainstream Democrats?
- 32:46Yeah,
- 32:46like when is Joe Biden,
- 32:47for example,
- 32:48when is Joe Biden or Kamala Harris ever pardoned
- 32:50those people or said that that was OK?
- 32:52Advocating for it,
- 32:53putting links to donate to the Minnesota Freedom Fund to try to
- 32:57have people's legal defense.
- 32:58Yeah,
- 32:58bail fund for rioters people's legal defense.
- 33:01Did Kamala Harris or Joe Biden ever say,
- 33:02wait,
- 33:03hold on.
- 33:03Did Kamala Harris or Joe Biden ever say that if you commit political violence
- 33:06or anything along those lines,
- 33:08Pardon you.
- 33:09Or did they give anybody a pardon that
- 33:11committed political violence like beating police officers,
- 33:12for example?
- 33:13The implication when you
- 33:15share a donation link to a rioter bail fund
- 33:18is the answer is not the actions of that rioter.
- 33:21OK,
- 33:21so does that mean that Donald Trump supports the actions of
- 33:23January 6th insurrectionists who beat police officers because he part,
- 33:26OK,
- 33:26so wait,
- 33:27hold on.
- 33:27If you share a donation link for
- 33:30somebody to hire a lawyer,
- 33:31that means you support their actions.
- 33:32But if you pardon them beating police officers and call them wonderful people,
- 33:35that means you don't support them.
- 33:37When did he say that people were wonderful people?
- 33:39January 6th,
- 33:40he said they're great people who love
- 33:42our country advocate for beating police officers.
- 33:44When did he advocate for the actual
- 33:46wait,
- 33:46by your own definition,
- 33:47Donald Trump supports it because you said Kamala
- 33:49Harris posting a link means she supports it.
- 33:51So by your own definition,
- 33:52if Donald Trump is pardoning those people
- 33:54and saying that they're great people who love this country,
- 33:56by your own definition,
- 33:57Donald Trump must support what they were doing.
- 33:59And by the way,
- 34:00we have extensive reporting that during January 6th,
- 34:02Donald Trump was watching it take place on Fox.
- 34:04News and his family,
- 34:06his advisors were begging him to do something.
- 34:08Tell people to be peaceful,
- 34:09tell people to go home.
- 34:10He wouldn't do it.
- 34:11When he was confronted with the fact that people were chanting Hang Mike Pence,
- 34:13he said,
- 34:14Well,
- 34:14maybe he deserves it.
- 34:16Is that not normalizing political violence?
- 34:17Is not the act of pardoning them normalizing political violence?
- 34:20On January 6th,
- 34:21President Trump very clearly tweeted out
- 34:23publicly for those how long after
- 34:26President Trump tweeted,
- 34:27come on,
- 34:28during the riots on January 6th.
- 34:29Walk in for me.
- 34:30How long after?
- 34:31How long after?
- 34:31I believe it was within an hour.
- 34:33Within an hour and what
- 34:34and what tweet did he also post in that time?
- 34:36He told people to stand by and stand down.
- 34:38No,
- 34:38no,
- 34:39he did.
- 34:39Well,
- 34:39first of all,
- 34:40he didn't tweet that.
- 34:40That was in the 2020 debate when he told the Proud Boys to stand back and stand by.
- 34:44But during that time,
- 34:45he also tweeted that Mike Pence just has to do the right thing.
- 34:47He knew that violence was taking place and
- 34:49he was still attacking his vice president,
- 34:51who was in the Capitol building.
- 34:53Wait,
- 34:53so
- 34:54we're going all the way back to the actual point of this prompt talk about political
- 34:57violence
- 34:58voted out by the majority.
- 34:59OK,
- 34:59thank you.
- 35:00Thanks,
- 35:00man.
- 35:03If you would like to be the next debater,
- 35:05please get to the chair in 321.
- 35:12Hey man,
- 35:12nice to meet you.
- 35:14So can you please explain to me,
- 35:15um,
- 35:16how the man who was shot at is
- 35:17responsible for normalizing political violence in America?
- 35:20I mean,
- 35:20I,
- 35:20I feel like we've discussed this at large
- 35:21right now with everything that he said publicly,
- 35:23everything he's posted,
- 35:24but also just to be clear,
- 35:25when Donald Trump was targeted in that assassination attempt,
- 35:28I condemned it,
- 35:29and every single elected,
- 35:31I'm not saying that,
- 35:31yes,
- 35:32but I'm not saying that you're responsible for the rise in political violence.
- 35:34I'm not saying that you're responsible.
- 35:35You're faulting
- 35:37Trump
- 35:38with the rise in political violence,
- 35:39right?
- 35:40Yeah,
- 35:40OK,
- 35:40so now you have.
- 35:41To provide claims as to why he actually
- 35:42is responsible because nobody's saying that you are,
- 35:44right?
- 35:44So I don't care whether or not you condemned it and I'm glad you did.
- 35:47But nobody's trying to say,
- 35:48oh,
- 35:48Harry Sisson's the reason why Trump was shot.
- 35:50Well,
- 35:50OK,
- 35:51and so I'll leave everything aside we've discussed already,
- 35:53the pardoning of people who be police officers,
- 35:55which is inherently normalizing it and being OK.
- 35:57How many people were there on January 6th?
- 35:59There were a couple 1000
- 36:00only a couple 1000.
- 36:01Yeah,
- 36:01I think there was more than that.
- 36:03How many people actually committed violence against officers?
- 36:05I don't know the exact number.
- 36:06Yeah,
- 36:06it was not even close to a couple of 1000.
- 36:08I'm not sure of the number,
- 36:09but I watch.
- 36:09So how do you know that it's not,
- 36:11but it doesn't matter.
- 36:12It doesn't matter even if one person I
- 36:13know people personally who walked inside the Capitol,
- 36:16um,
- 36:16and they didn't
- 36:17the company you're keeping.
- 36:18Why are you hanging out with January 6th insurrectionists?
- 36:19I don't hang out with them.
- 36:20I just know people who are conservatives.
- 36:21Well,
- 36:22anyway,
- 36:22even if it's one person and conservatives,
- 36:24even if it's one person who's beating a police officer,
- 36:26they shouldn't do that.
- 36:27But on the topic of normalizing Trump ever say that that was OK,
- 36:29he pardoned them.
- 36:32So wait.
- 36:33But he pardoned them because they had been in jail for several years without trial.
- 36:37That's unconstitutional.
- 36:38No,
- 36:38that's not a lot of people.
- 36:39That's not.
- 36:40So wait,
- 36:40wait,
- 36:40wait,
- 36:41hold on.
- 36:41Trial doesn't exist.
- 36:42A lot of those people had been convicted.
- 36:43They'd been convicted.
- 36:44And,
- 36:44and also,
- 36:45why would he not wait for them to have their trials?
- 36:48Because they were
- 36:49being held in solitary confinement.
- 36:50be police officers,
- 36:51you should be held in prison.
- 36:52No,
- 36:52no,
- 36:52because our Constitution says that you're guaranteed a right to a speedy trial,
- 36:56right?
- 36:56If you.
- 36:57Yeah,
- 36:57not if,
- 36:58yeah,
- 36:58who wasn't want a speedy trial if you're being held in solitary confinement,
- 37:01if you,
- 37:01you can invoke that right or you can pass up on it and so you think,
- 37:04so you're making the claim that those people
- 37:05passed on the right to a speedy trial because the speedy
- 37:07trial is a specific set of time under the Constitution.
- 37:10I believe it's 60 days,
- 37:11but if there's somebody that multiple years is obviously longer than 60,
- 37:13they can choose that.
- 37:14So I think Trump pardoned those people because
- 37:16they were already treated wrong and unfairly.
- 37:18They were people that were convicted of crimes that not everybody's officers.
- 37:21They were people who were convicted of beating police
- 37:23officers and they were pardoned by Donald Trump.
- 37:24That's normalizing it.
- 37:25But to
- 37:26again,
- 37:26put aside what we've discussed so far,
- 37:28you want to talk about normalizing political violence,
- 37:29making it OK,
- 37:30kind of laughing it off.
- 37:31Let's talk about what Trump has said about Paul Pelosi.
- 37:33After Paul Pelosi had his house invaded,
- 37:36he was beat over the head with a hammer,
- 37:37and the police thankfully caught the perpetrator.
- 37:39Donald Trump made jokes about it after the fact.
- 37:41Donald Trump Junior
- 37:42posted a meme about it on Instagram.
- 37:43No,
- 37:44I'm not
- 37:44saying
- 37:44Democrats.
- 37:45Anything that's happened to Donald Trump or anybody like that saying what Trump
- 37:48everything Trump says is OK,
- 37:49but you're trying to,
- 37:49is that normalizing political you're trying to say that
- 37:52he is the reason why political violence is escalating.
- 37:54I'm saying,
- 37:54I'm saying he's normalized it and he's escalated it.
- 37:56But,
- 37:57OK,
- 37:57so you say that that is normalizing political violence for it.
- 38:00Can you answer my question?
- 38:00Can't you say that that's normalizing political violence?
- 38:02Yes,
- 38:03but I also think he was joking.
- 38:04OK,
- 38:04so you agree with the claim.
- 38:05No,
- 38:05I don't agree with the claim because you're just,
- 38:07you just agreed that it normalizes political violence.
- 38:09OK,
- 38:09because that doesn't mean that everything that
- 38:11Trump does actually normalizes political violence.
- 38:13I'm not saying everything that Trump has done,
- 38:14but when you're pardoning people,
- 38:15your
- 38:15officers,
- 38:16your claim is that he's responsible for the rise in political violence,
- 38:18is it not?
- 38:19My claim actually here is that Donald Trump has normalized it,
- 38:21but I will also,
- 38:22yes,
- 38:22say that he's the rise of,
- 38:23so he's responsible.
- 38:24OK,
- 38:24so then why wasn't Biden shot at?
- 38:26Biden did have assassination attempts against him.
- 38:28He did,
- 38:28yeah,
- 38:28somebody shot him in the ear.
- 38:29No,
- 38:29no,
- 38:29he wasn't shot at,
- 38:30but thank God that the FBI foiled it before somebody could do anything.
- 38:34There was a,
- 38:34it was,
- 38:34I think it was a guy in it was either 2023 or 2024 that was arrested for it.
- 38:38And it was just,
- 38:38just so you know,
- 38:39people get arrested all the time for stuff like that.
- 38:42Tons of people make death threats against the president.
- 38:43All of them are treated as serious,
- 38:44obviously,
- 38:45right?
- 38:45So only one time in your lifetime
- 38:47somebody actually took a shot at a president
- 38:49and it was Trump,
- 38:50right?
- 38:50And that's,
- 38:51and that's bad,
- 38:51and no Democrat is normalized.
- 38:53OK,
- 38:53but can you,
- 38:54OK,
- 38:54so if your claim is that no Democrats.
- 38:56Who is normalized?
- 38:57Who has normalized Donald Trump's assassination?
- 38:59Media.
- 38:59People said,
- 39:00Wait,
- 39:01what media outlets were you on?
- 39:03Were you on social media at all during the time?
- 39:04Yes,
- 39:04I was,
- 39:05and I was getting death threats from people on your side after it when people,
- 39:08I'm not here to defend your death threats.
- 39:09I'm not,
- 39:10I'm not saying you are,
- 39:10but we're talking about a normalization of political violence
- 39:12that's coming from Donald Trump in one side.
- 39:14But then how you're saying that you're saying that you disagree.
- 39:16So do you think that Democrats are normalizing political violence?
- 39:18I do think that.
- 39:19How well,
- 39:202020,
- 39:21um,
- 39:21Maxine,
- 39:21what about 2020,
- 39:222020,
- 39:23the riots that took place were 93% of them were peaceful,
- 39:26and Joe Biden,
- 39:26the Democratic,
- 39:2793% of them were peaceful,
- 39:28and Joe Biden,
- 39:29the Democratic nominee,
- 39:30and Kamala Harris,
- 39:31the vice presidential nominee at the time,
- 39:32all condemned violent protests.
- 39:34OK,
- 39:34yeah.
- 39:35And so what Trump,
- 39:35Trump condemns violent protests too on January 6th.
- 39:38What did Trump,
- 39:38how is that condemning
- 39:39Trump say to the protesters before they showed up?
- 39:41What did he say?
- 39:41He said,
- 39:41you have to fight on when you see fraud like this,
- 39:43you go by a different set of rules tell them to protest.
- 39:45What did he say?
- 39:46He said,
- 39:46I want you to protest peacefully and patriotically in his speech.
- 39:48That you should peacefully and and patriotically protest.
- 39:51I said once in his speech.
- 39:52So peace and patriotic if Donald Trump is saying
- 39:5510 inflammatory comments to 1 comment to be peaceful,
- 39:58which do you think has more weight?
- 39:59No,
- 39:59because there's a reason you can protest.
- 40:01You can't just say one comment in his speech.
- 40:03It exonerates everything else that Donald Trump has done,
- 40:05and he didn't call the fact he didn't call for any violence in that speech.
- 40:08He didn't call for the fact he pardoned people who beat police officers.
- 40:11There's still no justification for that.
- 40:12He didn't call for violence in his speech.
- 40:13Well,
- 40:13he told people he knew that their people wanted to be violent on January 6th.
- 40:16How did he know that the FBI.
- 40:17Secret Service.
- 40:18This was part of the January 6th.
- 40:19OK.
- 40:19So then why didn't Nancy Pelosi increase security?
- 40:21Nancy Pelosi is not in charge of that.
- 40:22Donald Trump,
- 40:23Donald Trump of the House.
- 40:24No,
- 40:24the Speaker of the House is responsible for security.
- 40:26No,
- 40:26the Board of Police on the Capitol are for board for Capitol Police,
- 40:29and you know who's in charge of the National Guard in DC?
- 40:32Donald Trump.
- 40:33Yes,
- 40:33but he can't and Mark Milley,
- 40:34who was the Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff at the time in the line of command,
- 40:38said he never received any request
- 40:40for more National Guardsmen at the Capitol because despite after it started,
- 40:43because that's Nancy Nancy Pelosi does not control the National Guard.
- 40:46No,
- 40:47no,
- 40:47she does that,
- 40:47it's her job to request National Guard and then Trump's job.
- 40:50It is not her job to do that.
- 40:51Donald Trump is the president.
- 40:52He controls a lot of DC because it's not a state,
- 40:55it's federal ground.
- 40:56He is the guy who can invoke the National Guard.
- 40:58He didn't.
- 40:59People in Donald Trump's administration didn't.
- 41:01So
- 41:01because Nancy Pelosi is the one in charge of security.
- 41:02Wait,
- 41:03wait.
- 41:03Why does Donald Trump have to be asked?
- 41:05Why doesn't he just take initiative and do it?
- 41:06Because he's not the one in charge of security.
- 41:08He's in charge of the National Guard.
- 41:10Yes,
- 41:10OK.
- 41:10And he's in charge of the military,
- 41:12but that doesn't mean that he should just send them wherever he wants.
- 41:14I'm not,
- 41:14wait,
- 41:14I'm not.
- 41:15Hold on.
- 41:15Time out.
- 41:15The military and the National Guard are two different things.
- 41:17I'm just saying he should send the military
- 41:18because he's in charge of the National Guard.
- 41:19Well,
- 41:19do you think that Donald Trump should have
- 41:21sent the National Guard there on January 6th?
- 41:22Somebody gets,
- 41:23if they get asked to do that,
- 41:24yeah.
- 41:24Why would he have to be asked?
- 41:25He's president.
- 41:25He controls it.
- 41:26He's the decision maker,
- 41:27not in charge of the security.
- 41:28He is,
- 41:28he is not in charge.
- 41:29I can't believe we're still going around in circles.
- 41:30Donald Trump controls the National Guard.
- 41:32We're gonna pause here.
- 41:32We're out of time on this claim.
- 41:35Next time.
- 41:37Anyway,
- 41:38thanks man.
- 41:38Nice to meet you.
- 41:39My next surrounding claim is that Donald Trump and
- 41:41his administration have made us sicker and less healthy.
- 41:44If you would like to be the first debater,
- 41:46please get to the chair in 321.
- 41:51All right,
- 41:52yes,
- 41:52dude.
- 41:54All righty.
- 41:54Nice to meet you.
- 41:58All righty.
- 42:00Um,
- 42:00so I'd first like to start with the fact that
- 42:03I don't think that our government necessarily has that much to do with our health.
- 42:07I think that's more of a culture thing.
- 42:09I think that American culture as a whole,
- 42:10we are,
- 42:11we're really practicing fat acceptance.
- 42:13We have a giant social media problem,
- 42:16you know,
- 42:16we're,
- 42:17we're practicing body positivity,
- 42:19and these are things that American culture needs to regulate.
- 42:22If we look at other countries like East Asia where,
- 42:24you know,
- 42:25they,
- 42:25they don't
- 42:26Allow this stuff as much.
- 42:27It's more of like a socially
- 42:29um prevented thing.
- 42:31We don't have that here.
- 42:32Um,
- 42:33and that's kind of fundamentally where all of this comes from.
- 42:35I think that,
- 42:36oh,
- 42:37go ahead.
- 42:37You,
- 42:37you had something to say.
- 42:38I mean,
- 42:39like,
- 42:39so the government is not there to like,
- 42:42You know,
- 42:42lift your arm
- 42:44when you have a hamburger in one or a piece of broccoli in the other,
- 42:46right?
- 42:46It's personal
- 42:46choice 100%.
- 42:47But they can also influence the health of the country and they certainly have.
- 42:51So for example,
- 42:52hep B vaccination rates among kindergartners has gone down.
- 42:55Um,
- 42:56measles vaccination rates among Americans have gone down as well.
- 42:59Well,
- 42:59I think,
- 42:59you know,
- 42:59vaccination is a different topic.
- 43:01I think that,
- 43:01you know,
- 43:02people,
- 43:02people's obesity is,
- 43:03I think,
- 43:03a lot more.
- 43:04Problematic in terms of
- 43:06how people are feeling.
- 43:07Sure,
- 43:07I think,
- 43:08I think obesity is a major medical issue.
- 43:10Yeah,
- 43:10and I just to be clear,
- 43:11it's not sickness is not just about obesity.
- 43:13Obesity can cause a lot of chronic issues,
- 43:16but you know,
- 43:16it's American culture that's causing this problem.
- 43:18We're allowing it and we shouldn't be allowing this,
- 43:20you know.
- 43:20OK,
- 43:21great,
- 43:21we wonderful,
- 43:22um,
- 43:23what the issue is,
- 43:24is that,
- 43:25you know,
- 43:26um.
- 43:27Vaccination is just,
- 43:29I mean,
- 43:30I'm not necessarily anti-vax,
- 43:31but I think that
- 43:33People's daily lives aren't going to be affected as
- 43:36much as to whether they're vaccinated or not.
- 43:38Well,
- 43:38I think
- 43:38we have a couple of children who have died
- 43:40from measles I think that having chronic heart disease
- 43:41is going to be a lot worse and it's a lot bigger problem in the United States.
- 43:45I
- 43:45chronic heart disease is,
- 43:46is very bad,
- 43:47and we should advocate against it.
- 43:48So,
- 43:48but it's,
- 43:49I'm not,
- 43:49I'm not disagreeing with anything,
- 43:50but that's culture's problem,
- 43:52and it's also culture choosing whether they want to get vaccinated or not.
- 43:55No,
- 43:55it's not,
- 43:55it's not,
- 43:56no,
- 43:56it's not just culture because you would recognize that government.
- 43:58Policy has an effect.
- 43:59So Donald Trump has been anti-measles vaccine.
- 44:02RFK Jr.
- 44:02by way of,
- 44:03by way of RFK Jr.
- 44:04has been anti-measles vax,
- 44:06has been anti-hep B,
- 44:07has been anti- a bunch of these vaccines,
- 44:08and said that they've caused autism or they're bad for your kids.
- 44:11That's bad for the United States.
- 44:12Now in 3 quarters of states,
- 44:13the problem is,
- 44:14wait,
- 44:14hold on,
- 44:14in 3 quarters social media 3/4 of states so much worse,
- 44:16and this is also physical health.
- 44:18Can I just finish the point really quickly?
- 44:19In 3/4 of states,
- 44:20the measles vaccination rate for herd immunity has now dropped.
- 44:23Below where we want it to be.
- 44:24That's bad.
- 44:25OK,
- 44:26that's bad,
- 44:26but want to know what else is bad?
- 44:27Social media.
- 44:28OK,
- 44:28so we're agreeing,
- 44:29completely destroying.
- 44:30OK,
- 44:30yeah,
- 44:30it's completely destroying Donald Trump,
- 44:32and I don't think that whether someone's vaccinated or
- 44:34not has much to do with someone's mental health,
- 44:36and that's so much.
- 44:37I'm not claiming that Donald,
- 44:39I'm not claiming that vaccination has a connection.
- 44:41I know,
- 44:41but you're talking,
- 44:41your claim is that Donald Trump is making us sicker and less healthy,
- 44:44and I'm saying that there's,
- 44:45there's a giant problem of health and that.
- 44:49This,
- 44:49this is very small compared to the entire problem.
- 44:52It's not very small.
- 44:52Obesity.
- 44:53We eradicated measles in 2000 and now in 2025
- 44:56we've had the most measles cases in decades.
- 44:58How many people are dying due to measles versus chronic heart disease?
- 45:01One
- 45:01person dying from measles is too much,
- 45:03especially because it was eradicated.
- 45:05It doesn't have to be this way.
- 45:06We've had two
- 45:07kids,
- 45:07but we're talking about the entire.
- 45:09We're talking about the entire health of the
- 45:11United States have died because of measles.
- 45:13That should be terrible.
- 45:14How many people have died because
- 45:16their heart failed?
- 45:16I'm not disagreeing with you.
- 45:18That's bad.
- 45:19How many people are
- 45:20killing
- 45:21themselves
- 45:21because of social media?
- 45:23That's that we're aligned.
- 45:24You don't have to preach to me about heart health and suicide.
- 45:26I think it's been voted out by the majority.
- 45:28All right,
- 45:29all right,
- 45:29thank you.
- 45:29Thanks,
- 45:29man.
- 45:30I appreciate it.
- 45:33If you would like to be the next debater,
- 45:34please get to the chair in 321.
- 45:41Nice to meet you again.
- 45:43So your claim is that Donald Trump is making
- 45:46tiring,
- 45:47isn't it?
- 45:47Yeah,
- 45:48yeah,
- 45:49your claim is that Donald Trump is making
- 45:51America
- 45:52sicker,
- 45:53less healthy.
- 45:55Donald Trump has done numerous of things.
- 45:57He's cut the vaccine mandates from 77 vaccines down to
- 46:0111.
- 46:02There is no reason that a child,
- 46:03it's not,
- 46:04uh,
- 46:05who,
- 46:05when does,
- 46:06when does that 70,
- 46:07it's by the way,
- 46:08it's not 77,
- 46:08but when does that I can't remember.
- 46:10I apologize,
- 46:10I can't remember what it is.
- 46:11What's the time frame?
- 46:12It's,
- 46:12it's spread out during a period of time.
- 46:14Do you have kids?
- 46:15No,
- 46:15thank God.
- 46:16Yeah,
- 46:16I do.
- 46:17Um,
- 46:18when I witnessed my son going through
- 46:21having to get 5 or 6 shots at one time at 3 days old,
- 46:24do you think those shots should be able to give to a child at 2 days old?
- 46:29I'm a,
- 46:29I was a stepfather
- 46:31to an autistic child
- 46:32when I was dating his mother.
- 46:34The mother said that his,
- 46:35her son,
- 46:36my stepson at the time,
- 46:37was perfectly normal,
- 46:38doing normal little boy things.
- 46:40As soon as he got the 2nd to 3rd dose of shots,
- 46:44his mind changed,
- 46:45changed,
- 46:46and he went into complete autistic.
- 46:50And there's all complete.
- 46:51OK,
- 46:52it's just an interesting went went from nonverbal,
- 46:54non-communicative,
- 46:56didn't look at you.
- 46:57So how do you know it was because of a vaccine?
- 47:00Because there's no reason that you should be a
- 47:02child should go from being a normal little child
- 47:05to getting the 3rd dose,
- 47:06and all of a sudden
- 47:08there's plenty of claims out there.
- 47:10There's,
- 47:10there's,
- 47:11there have been study after study,
- 47:12um,
- 47:13huge studies on whether vaccines cause autism,
- 47:15and every single time it's produced the same result that they don't.
- 47:18Well,
- 47:19it's starting to get to the point that it's not,
- 47:20it is,
- 47:21it is not,
- 47:21it is.
- 47:22So you're OK with a child getting that many vaccines at such a young age.
- 47:25Well,
- 47:26whatever you describe getting like 6,
- 47:27what were the vaccines that he got?
- 47:28I can't remember what he got.
- 47:29It was so long ago
- 47:30for me if doctors are advising that that is what they should.
- 47:33I think that's perfectly fine.
- 47:35They were gonna call
- 47:36child protective surgeons on me and my my son's mother because who's
- 47:40the doctors,
- 47:41because we didn't want to get the full diagnosis.
- 47:44All the shots done to him at that one time.
- 47:46We wanted to split it up with him,
- 47:48and they called.
- 47:49They were gonna call
- 47:50HHS on us.
- 47:52I feel like there might be more to that
- 47:53story than like doctors just like looking at your child
- 47:56and seeing like,
- 47:56oh,
- 47:57you don't want to get him vaccinated.
- 47:58My next claim is that Donald Trump has made this.
- 48:00He has stopped the gender mutilation of children.
- 48:03At 12 years old there was never any
- 48:05any gender mutilation of children.
- 48:07No,
- 48:07that's never been a policy.
- 48:08Can you point to a state where that was the policy?
- 48:10It's a policy here in the state of California.
- 48:12You cannot,
- 48:13you cannot hold on.
- 48:14Scott Wiener passed,
- 48:15passed SB 107 that made California transgender sanctuary state,
- 48:18right?
- 48:19He passed AB 665
- 48:21that would,
- 48:22would criminalize parents if they were not gender affirming in this state.
- 48:26I,
- 48:26I don't,
- 48:26I,
- 48:26I can't speak to these laws,
- 48:27so I don't know because it's happening to me,
- 48:29brother.
- 48:30My son's 8 years old.
- 48:31And I'm,
- 48:32I'm,
- 48:33yes,
- 48:33his mother started.
- 48:35You can't love and support a,
- 48:37a,
- 48:38a,
- 48:38a lie.
- 48:40Oh
- 48:41yeah,
- 48:41I feel like that's pretty up for your kid.
- 48:42I mean,
- 48:42if your kid is it
- 48:43up for my kid,
- 48:44your kid is,
- 48:44so you're OK with a child getting,
- 48:46getting mutilated.
- 48:47You're OK with a child at 12 years old
- 48:49getting puberty blockers.
- 48:51You're OK with cross-sex hormones.
- 48:53You're OK with a child,
- 48:54a girl.
- 48:54I can,
- 48:55I can answer your question,
- 48:56but I know,
- 48:56I know,
- 48:56but puberty blockers have been in use for children for a long time.
- 48:59Like,
- 48:59you know what the original
- 49:00if puberty blockers were used for,
- 49:02for early onset puberty.
- 49:03No,
- 49:04yeah,
- 49:05no,
- 49:05that's what,
- 49:05that's what.
- 49:05They were given to pedophiles in
- 49:07the state penitentiary to chemically castrate them
- 49:10in terms of what they've been used for recently.
- 49:12I don't know what you're referencing with pedophiles using
- 49:14puberty blockers,
- 49:15but for,
- 49:16for at least in,
- 49:17you know,
- 49:17normal society,
- 49:18puberty blockers have been used for kids for kids for a very long time,
- 49:21irreversible damage.
- 49:22No,
- 49:22it's not irreversible seizures.
- 49:24It's not irreversible.
- 49:25But anyway,
- 49:25I don't want to,
- 49:26I don't want to get into a conversation about trans.
- 49:27But first of all,
- 49:28no,
- 49:28but this should,
- 49:29this is you talking about
- 49:30how Trump has made.
- 49:32Yeah,
- 49:32but I,
- 49:32this is,
- 49:33this is our system sicker.
- 49:34So Donald Trump,
- 49:35Donald Trump has not passed any policy that's like,
- 49:37yeah,
- 49:37you can't do this to kids because it was already illegal.
- 49:39Like there's just that you can't do that.
- 49:40Yes it is here in California.
- 49:42You can do it.
- 49:42Let me just circle real quick.
- 49:43AB
- 49:44AB 1876.
- 49:46They are now forcing health insurance companies.
- 49:48Wait,
- 49:48you said Donald Trump stopped it,
- 49:49huh?
- 49:49You said Donald Trump stopped it.
- 49:50So no,
- 49:51I never said Donald Trump stopped it you did.
- 49:52No,
- 49:53I never did.
- 49:53All right,
- 49:53well,
- 49:54look,
- 49:54can we wrote an executive order,
- 49:56so Donald Trump is making.
- 49:58Yeah,
- 49:59yeah,
- 49:59I think,
- 49:59can we get back to the main point?
- 50:01We can,
- 50:01we,
- 50:01we can have a trans debate,
- 50:02but this is kind of outside the realm of,
- 50:03but this is making children healthier by cutting them off
- 50:06from being really so irreversible kids not having the hep B vaccine,
- 50:09kids not having the measles vaccine is making them healthier.
- 50:12No,
- 50:12that,
- 50:12that,
- 50:13that was those weren't in the,
- 50:14in,
- 50:14in the,
- 50:15I'm not saying that's in the executive order,
- 50:16but that's what this administration has done.
- 50:17No,
- 50:18he's cut out.
- 50:18All right,
- 50:19we're gonna pause here.
- 50:20You've been voted out by the majority.
- 50:22You need to research yourself.
- 50:23I don't know what you're talking about in California.
- 50:25I don't live in California.
- 50:26Well,
- 50:26we can talk about that later.
- 50:27All right,
- 50:27we'll talk about it after.
- 50:28If you'd like to be the next debater,
- 50:30please get to the chair in 321.
- 50:34Hm
- 50:35Hey,
- 50:36that was tough.
- 50:37How's it going,
- 50:37man?
- 50:38Good to see you again.
- 50:38Good to see you.
- 50:39Oh.
- 50:41So yeah,
- 50:41you said uh Trump is making people sicker.
- 50:44I would totally agree with your prompt actually,
- 50:46Harry.
- 50:46I believe he's made you a lot sicker.
- 50:48In fact,
- 50:48when you go on social media and constantly talk about a man,
- 50:52even though I,
- 50:52I think you're straight,
- 50:53for hours and hours out of the day,
- 50:55a lot of therapists would actually diagnose you with something.
- 50:58And so,
- 50:59what I would have to say to that is,
- 51:00could you just address the claim?
- 51:02Do you think Donald Trump has made you sicker as a person?
- 51:04If he wasn't in your life,
- 51:05would you be a better person now?
- 51:07I feel like if you're gonna make it like come
- 51:09up here and start with like an attempt at comedy,
- 51:11you have to get at least one laugh.
- 51:12There's not a single person in this circle that's not a joke,
- 51:15but I think genuinely asking,
- 51:16I'm sure you are.
- 51:17I'm sure you're genuinely asking,
- 51:18but I think the broader claim,
- 51:20the more important claim here is not
- 51:21about me.
- 51:22It's about what Donald Trump has done to our health systems.
- 51:25So for example,
- 51:26there are probably people in this room right now who have had
- 51:29been impacted by cancer in some way,
- 51:31whether it be maybe themselves,
- 51:32maybe a loved one,
- 51:33friend,
- 51:33family,
- 51:33whatever.
- 51:34Why has Donald Trump cut
- 51:36cancer funding by billions of dollars?
- 51:38That's a loaded question,
- 51:39Harry.
- 51:39You didn't answer mine at first,
- 51:41so let's start back there so you can't answer it,
- 51:44because,
- 51:44well,
- 51:44if it doesn't apply for you,
- 51:45does it apply for everybody?
- 51:46Let's engage in good faith here and let's have an actual actual conversation,
- 51:49because if you're not gonna engage with what I'm saying,
- 51:50just get out of the circle and let somebody
- 51:51else who would have a good faith conversation.
- 51:53Could you react the question?
- 51:54Why it's not loaded?
- 51:55Great.
- 51:55Why has Donald?
- 51:56Trump cut cancer funding by billions of dollars.
- 51:58So why do you believe Joe Biden
- 51:59slighted all of the diabetes people under Trump?
- 52:03So you're not gonna answer the question?
- 52:04No,
- 52:04because it's a loaded questionnaire.
- 52:05How is it loaded?
- 52:06Just what?
- 52:07Why is Donald Trump cutting cancer funding?
- 52:08Why is he doing it?
- 52:09Is it Donald Trump by himself or is it his administration?
- 52:11He's in an executive order.
- 52:13The buck stops with him.
- 52:13It's budget.
- 52:14The budget they passed.
- 52:15OK,
- 52:15so what is budget determined by the Congress and the legislative branch,
- 52:19and he signed it into law.
- 52:20Buck stops with him.
- 52:20No.
- 52:21So why has Donald Trump?
- 52:22Why don't you ask the rest of Congress that supported that by the way,
- 52:25by the way,
- 52:25and it went through committee and it's not just rehearsed.
- 52:27It's not just rehearsed.
- 52:28It's not just Congress.
- 52:29The executive can cancel contracts,
- 52:30and Donald Trump has done that.
- 52:31So why have they cut cancer funding by billions of dollars?
- 52:33So why haven't the courts challenged it?
- 52:34you answer the question?
- 52:35If it's so illegal and so corrupt in your eyes,
- 52:37why isn't the court challenged it?
- 52:38The court,
- 52:39they've challenged everything that Trump has done.
- 52:41There have been some cases.
- 52:41So explain why our system isn't working the way that you.
- 52:44You won't answer the question because you know it's bad.
- 52:46Oh,
- 52:46what you should just admit,
- 52:47I said it was a bad question.
- 52:48What you should just admit here is that
- 52:50Donald Trump should not be cutting cancer funding.
- 52:51You know what else Donald Trump has done with cancer?
- 52:53There's a pediatric brain tumor consortium.
- 52:55It's been funded by Democrats,
- 52:57Republicans for the past 26 years.
- 52:59It focuses on pediatric brain cancer,
- 53:00the number one killer of kids with cancer in the United States of America.
- 53:03There were active studies
- 53:05as a result of this consortium.
- 53:06You know what happened to it?
- 53:07All funding gone.
- 53:09Why?
- 53:09So why did you tell that father that was here before,
- 53:12Thank God I don't have kids.
- 53:13You can't answer the question
- 53:15because you can't just ask me loaded questions,
- 53:17Harry.
- 53:17The only loaded question justify
- 53:19Donald Trump's actions.
- 53:20You see,
- 53:20you've come up here this entire time we've engaged.
- 53:22There are people waiting,
- 53:22and I think people should be putting,
- 53:23that's right,
- 53:24you should be putting up your red flags because there are people waiting.
- 53:26Y'all are gonna listen to Harry,
- 53:27by the way.
- 53:28No,
- 53:28no,
- 53:28they're doing it because you,
- 53:29because you're not,
- 53:30you're not good at debating.
- 53:31You kind of suck at this,
- 53:31and you haven't answered,
- 53:32you haven't answered my question.
- 53:33You've danced around.
- 53:33You've tried to make jokes.
- 53:34Nobody laughed.
- 53:35It's a little bit embarrassing.
- 53:36You haven't made a single point on what I've said about cancer cuts.
- 53:38All right,
- 53:39we're gonna pause here.
- 53:40You have been voted out by the majority.
- 53:41Good choice,
- 53:41gentlemen.
- 53:42Good choice.
- 53:44Thank you.
- 53:46If you would like to be the next debater,
- 53:47please get to the chair in 321.
- 53:55Nice to see you again.
- 53:57So I don't want to assume that I know what you mean
- 54:01when you say that Donald Trump and his administration has made America sicker.
- 54:04So for clarification,
- 54:05if you can give me a little bit or expound on what you mean by that.
- 54:09Well,
- 54:09I think if you're looking at,
- 54:10as I mentioned in previous conversations,
- 54:12like the vaccination rates,
- 54:13the fact that measles has gone up,
- 54:14I think that by cutting cancer research funding,
- 54:17you are actively hurting people who have cancer or
- 54:19will get diagnosed with cancer in the future,
- 54:21where we could have discovered some kind of cure or
- 54:24at least preventative for some different types of cancers.
- 54:26Um,
- 54:26I think that by canceling $500 million worth of
- 54:29mRNA vaccine trials and contracts for different companies,
- 54:31that's making us sicker.
- 54:32So maybe that answers your question.
- 54:34A little bit,
- 54:35a little bit.
- 54:35But I,
- 54:35but I,
- 54:36but I like to,
- 54:36I like to come up with this.
- 54:38For the amount of research that the United States has spent
- 54:40in the last 20 years over cancer research,
- 54:42over
- 54:43different vaccinations,
- 54:44how many cures
- 54:46have that money funded?
- 54:48For cancer?
- 54:49For anything?
- 54:50I'm sure a lot.
- 54:51I mean,
- 54:51you'd have to give me a specific disease,
- 54:53but cancer is not something that we consider curable at this moment in time.
- 54:56I,
- 54:56I believe,
- 54:56I believe that
- 54:58there are some instances where people have created something that has cured,
- 55:01that could cure cancer.
- 55:02But my,
- 55:03my,
- 55:03my,
- 55:03my overall,
- 55:04my overall point is this.
- 55:06A lot of people get upset about cuts to to to certain programs,
- 55:10uh,
- 55:10for the NIH and other and other medical facilities when
- 55:13it has been proven that the amount of money that we've spent on these programs
- 55:18has not covered the amount of,
- 55:20uh,
- 55:20cures that should have been made
- 55:22by the amount of money that we spent.
- 55:23In my opinion,
- 55:25it's like boxing.
- 55:25How many times are you gonna fight
- 55:27before you not win a match?
- 55:28And
- 55:29with the amount of money that we've spent on,
- 55:31on research,
- 55:33We haven't developed anything that was
- 55:35actually,
- 55:36I,
- 55:36I completely disagree.
- 55:37I mean,
- 55:38so a lot of the breakthroughs in cancer research,
- 55:41um,
- 55:41and cancer medication has come from the United States.
- 55:44It's come from a result of our funding,
- 55:45and we're seeing breakthroughs every single day.
- 55:47I mean,
- 55:48AI is a hotly contested topic,
- 55:50but AI is showing that it can diagnose breast cancer or different tumors.
- 55:53Before the human eye could.
- 55:54We're seeing some breakthroughs with pancreatic cancer,
- 55:56a protein
- 55:57that appears in 90% of pancreatic cancer
- 56:00cases.
- 56:01We thought we couldn't be able to penetrate with the medication,
- 56:03and there was like no entry point.
- 56:04Now we're finding that actually with a new drug,
- 56:06we can,
- 56:06and it has less side effects than chemotherapy for a pancreatic pancreatic cancer.
- 56:10Pancreatic cancer is incredibly serious,
- 56:11incredibly deadly.
- 56:12So these are all
- 56:13A result of hardworking doctors,
- 56:15nurses,
- 56:16scientists who have dedicated their lives to making people better,
- 56:19and I think we should continue to fund that effort because again,
- 56:221 in 2 Americans on average are going to be diagnosed with some form of cancer.
- 56:25That's something that's gonna affect a lot of
- 56:27people and we should keep funding that.
- 56:28I understand that.
- 56:29I think one of the main points
- 56:30that you've mentioned throughout through your argument,
- 56:32this past argument was that
- 56:34um.
- 56:35These breakthroughs have been found using AI.
- 56:37So you think it'd be plausible to take
- 56:38that money that they spent on research and development
- 56:40through the different
- 56:41health organizations and and repurpose that money
- 56:44to increase our AI capabilities?
- 56:46No,
- 56:46I mean,
- 56:47like I,
- 56:47I think that AI and medicine is certainly something that we should be investing in,
- 56:50but it should be a two-pronged approach.
- 56:52So if we have like,
- 56:53you know,
- 56:53developments in medicine that can help better diagnose,
- 56:55then that should absolutely be funded.
- 56:57But we should also continue to fund cancer research because again,
- 56:59we're still having breakthroughs and our understanding is still evolving.
- 57:02During COV19,
- 57:03uh,
- 57:04Donald Trump fast tracked a,
- 57:06uh,
- 57:06experimental vaccination that the majority.
- 57:09The majority of the United States was forced to take.
- 57:11Um,
- 57:13yes,
- 57:14yes.
- 57:16I believe that
- 57:18I believe that even even in California,
- 57:19I,
- 57:20I was running for Congress during this time,
- 57:21Californians,
- 57:22they had to shut down their businesses,
- 57:23they had to shut down schools,
- 57:24they shut down churches,
- 57:26and in order to reopen at some point,
- 57:28you have to have that vaccine.
- 57:29You have to have a vaccine card,
- 57:30you have to mask up,
- 57:31even a flight to the airport,
- 57:32you have to have a vaccine card,
- 57:33so on and so forth.
- 57:34Um,
- 57:35so,
- 57:35so yes,
- 57:36a lot of people were forced to take that.
- 57:37Do you believe that vaccination,
- 57:39even though even till this day it's still considered experimental,
- 57:41even the boosters are considered
- 57:43experimental,
- 57:44it's not considered experimental.
- 57:45And are you gonna ask me,
- 57:46do I think the vaccine's good?
- 57:47Yes,
- 57:47yes,
- 57:48you do.
- 57:48Yes,
- 57:49saved millions of lives.
- 57:50How do you know?
- 57:51We've had study after study.
- 57:52There have been massive studies in Europe actually,
- 57:54where they evaluated millions of people and found that
- 57:57anybody that was vaccinated had a significantly
- 57:59lower death rate than people who weren't.
- 58:01Um,
- 58:01in some parts of the pandemic,
- 58:02you were more likely to get infected.
- 58:04With COVID,
- 58:04if you didn't have the vaccine.
- 58:05Now,
- 58:05the goal of the vaccine is not to prevent infection,
- 58:07it's to prevent death.
- 58:08But the data is pretty clear on that here in the United States and around the world.
- 58:11What about the data that shows that anybody under
- 58:13the age of 35 did not need the vaccination?
- 58:15The vaccination was actually more effective
- 58:17for senior citizens,
- 58:18anyone who's over the age of 65.
- 58:20So yeah,
- 58:21the data is,
- 58:22is uh pretty clear that older people certainly experience COVID more.
- 58:25They died from COVID at a higher rate than younger people.
- 58:27Younger people have stronger immune systems,
- 58:28but it's still advised that young people do get the COVID vaccine
- 58:31because young people still have died.
- 58:32They were around,
- 58:33I think,
- 58:34and I,
- 58:34maybe there's a fact check here,
- 58:36but I think the number was around.
- 58:365000 of young people who died from COVID,
- 58:39um,
- 58:40and you know,
- 58:40there are young people with,
- 58:41uh,
- 58:42comorbidities,
- 58:42which are like existing,
- 58:44uh,
- 58:44conditions that might,
- 58:45uh,
- 58:45be emphasized or worsened by COVID.
- 58:47So you should still get the vaccine.
- 58:49So,
- 58:49so you think that because of,
- 58:50because they have a vaccine,
- 58:51this experimental vaccine,
- 58:53that the death rate for younger people is lower,
- 58:55that they still should get it.
- 58:57Yeah,
- 58:57it's not experimental though.
- 58:58And and that and that's where you think the funding should go for
- 59:00people to be forced to take a vaccine that they don't need.
- 59:03Nobody's been strapped down to a gurney and injected with the vaccine.
- 59:05You can,
- 59:06you can choose.
- 59:07You have a choice,
- 59:07right,
- 59:08right.
- 59:08Choose where
- 59:09in Florida,
- 59:10Texas,
- 59:10anywhere where they didn't shut the
- 59:12anywhere.
- 59:12Because,
- 59:13because I,
- 59:13if I'm not mistaken,
- 59:14New York shut their whole entire economy down.
- 59:16California shut their entire economy.
- 59:17I was,
- 59:17I lived in New York at the time of COVID,
- 59:19and,
- 59:19uh,
- 59:19we didn't get shut down.
- 59:20I mean,
- 59:20you know,
- 59:20schools were temporarily closed,
- 59:22and of course there were some businesses,
- 59:23but that was
- 59:24sometimes a result of the businesses making that decision.
- 59:27Sometimes it was the state directing this.
- 59:28But how long,
- 59:29how long were the schools closed?
- 59:30Sorry to cut you off.
- 59:30How long
- 59:31were those?
- 59:31Uh,
- 59:31I mean,
- 59:32I think it depends on the state for a very long time.
- 59:34Yeah,
- 59:34for and for a decent amount of time,
- 59:35and the data is now showing that that probably was the wrong move.
- 59:38But hindsight's 20/20 and what we were doing in COVID
- 59:41with policy positions is a better safe than sorry approach.
- 59:44It's better.
- 59:44I'd rather be safe and not have my classmates
- 59:46die than be sorry and have everybody get infected.
- 59:48So then it goes back to at what cost?
- 59:50At what cost?
- 59:51I think there was,
- 59:51look,
- 59:52regardless of how COVID took place,
- 59:54whether we were like,
- 59:55you know what,
- 59:55no,
- 59:56no shutdowns,
- 59:56everybody do your thing,
- 59:57or extreme shutdowns,
- 59:59whatever,
- 59:59it was always going to have a cost.
- 1:00:01I mean,
- 1:00:01a million people still died from COVID.
- 1:00:02That number is actually higher than a million,
- 1:00:04but that was kind of like when people stopped counting.
- 1:00:06a million people died from COVID.
- 1:00:08Young people in this room probably had their
- 1:00:10experiences as young people stunted because of COVID.
- 1:00:12It was just a bad situation all around.
- 1:00:14There was no real winning.
- 1:00:15The reason why I asked the question,
- 1:00:17you have been voted out by the majority.
- 1:00:19Thank you.
- 1:00:19Thanks,
- 1:00:19man.
- 1:00:20Yes sir,
- 1:00:20appreciate it.
- 1:00:23If you would like to be the next debater,
- 1:00:25please get to the chair in 321.
- 1:00:30Hi,
- 1:00:31nice to meet you.
- 1:00:31How are you?
- 1:00:31Nice to meet you.
- 1:00:33Um,
- 1:00:33so you're,
- 1:00:34you're bringing up some claims about
- 1:00:36everyone during the COVID
- 1:00:38pandemic being able to.
- 1:00:41Being able to do what they wanted in a sense,
- 1:00:44um.
- 1:00:45And I think the previous guy here mentioned
- 1:00:48that um
- 1:00:49New York City and places like California were affected
- 1:00:52and so I,
- 1:00:53I would agree with what he was saying in the sense that
- 1:00:56Gavin Newsom
- 1:00:58was
- 1:00:59promoting
- 1:01:00uh state legislation that was basically forcing
- 1:01:03tech companies even in Silicon Valley to
- 1:01:05lay off a bunch of employees who were refusing
- 1:01:08to uh receive the COVID vaccine,
- 1:01:10so state employees.
- 1:01:13You said state employees.
- 1:01:14No,
- 1:01:14no,
- 1:01:14no,
- 1:01:14no,
- 1:01:14I'm saying in the state of California
- 1:01:17for Silicon Valley tech
- 1:01:18industry workers,
- 1:01:20um.
- 1:01:21My concern really has to do with,
- 1:01:23you know,
- 1:01:24your,
- 1:01:24your claim saying
- 1:01:25that Donald Trump.
- 1:01:28Doesn't,
- 1:01:28um,
- 1:01:29can you state the claim again?
- 1:01:30Yeah,
- 1:01:30he's making us sicker and less healthy.
- 1:01:32Yes,
- 1:01:32so.
- 1:01:35My,
- 1:01:36my regard to this is
- 1:01:37people like stars um Leanne Baker
- 1:01:40who were
- 1:01:42essentially doxed and considered domestic
- 1:01:44terrorists by the Joe Biden administration
- 1:01:46because she refused to give her
- 1:01:49children the COVID vaccination and then moved to Nashville.
- 1:01:52So for me,
- 1:01:53I'm thinking what kind of person
- 1:01:56would call,
- 1:01:57especially the president,
- 1:01:58the former president Joe Biden,
- 1:01:59what kind of person
- 1:02:01would call a mother a domestic terrorist for attempting to
- 1:02:04what seemed to her like protecting her child,
- 1:02:06domestic terrorist.
- 1:02:07That's what she was called by that's what she by her,
- 1:02:10by Joe Biden,
- 1:02:11by Joe Biden said in a speech that this person is a domestic terrorist.
- 1:02:14He called her a domestic terrorist.
- 1:02:15What was the exact quote.
- 1:02:17Because I can guarantee you Joe Biden didn't
- 1:02:18call her she was considered a domestic terrorist.
- 1:02:20I don't think Joe Biden,
- 1:02:21I mean,
- 1:02:21look,
- 1:02:21there's gonna be a fact check here,
- 1:02:22but of course,
- 1:02:23and she was reportedly saying this out in the media as well,
- 1:02:26and that's why she
- 1:02:28moved to
- 1:02:28national,
- 1:02:28she,
- 1:02:29she can endanger her right.
- 1:02:31So to the premise of your
- 1:02:33argument,
- 1:02:34how is Donald Trump,
- 1:02:35um,
- 1:02:36making America
- 1:02:38unhealthy,
- 1:02:39I would say he's actually protecting people like Leanne.
- 1:02:41Baker,
- 1:02:42who have full faith
- 1:02:43in that they should be allowed to protect their children at all costs.
- 1:02:46Is he protecting cancer patients?
- 1:02:48Well,
- 1:02:48that funding actually was granted.
- 1:02:50The funding that you're talking about,
- 1:02:51the,
- 1:02:52the NCI,
- 1:02:53yes,
- 1:02:53it was 7.2.
- 1:02:54I know what you're talking about.
- 1:02:55Donald Trump suggested in his budget a 40% cut
- 1:02:58to wait,
- 1:02:59what?
- 1:02:59No,
- 1:03:00just hold on.
- 1:03:00In Donald Trump's budget,
- 1:03:01he initially suggested a 40% cut to cancer research funding across the board.
- 1:03:05That was an
- 1:03:06actual.
- 1:03:06Taken out by Congress.
- 1:03:07So Congress said we're not going to do that.
- 1:03:08And that was
- 1:03:09done by Senator
- 1:03:11Kirsten Gillibrand,
- 1:03:12Democrat from New York,
- 1:03:12Mike Lawler,
- 1:03:13Republican from New York as well.
- 1:03:14It was bipartisan.
- 1:03:15So Donald Trump's
- 1:03:16more extreme cuts were actually taken out.
- 1:03:18But in the 1st 3 months of Donald Trump's administration,
- 1:03:20cuts,
- 1:03:20right,
- 1:03:20but the congressional in Donald Trump,
- 1:03:22in Donald Trump's 1st 3 months of his administration,
- 1:03:24cancer funding research was reduced by 30% year over year.
- 1:03:27So did they receive funding from the congressional NCI?
- 1:03:31The answer is yes.
- 1:03:33Congress gave NCI Institute
- 1:03:35funding.
- 1:03:36If you cut funding,
- 1:03:36it doesn't mean that all funding is gone,
- 1:03:38right?
- 1:03:38But what you're misleading people on here in the,
- 1:03:40in the audience,
- 1:03:41and I think I'll.
- 1:03:42In public where people are going to watch this is
- 1:03:44they did receive funding.
- 1:03:45So whether they never claimed they got all their funding slashed,
- 1:03:48no,
- 1:03:48but you're claiming that
- 1:03:50they were not receiving funds.
- 1:03:52I claim that they're.
- 1:03:54I claim that their funding got cut,
- 1:03:56not that they didn't receive any funds.
- 1:03:57My claim is that Donald Trump has cut cancer funding research.
- 1:04:00Yes or no?
- 1:04:00Is that true?
- 1:04:01So
- 1:04:02just true or false,
- 1:04:03is that true or false,
- 1:04:03to some extent,
- 1:04:04but not OK.
- 1:04:05So to some extent.
- 1:04:06So if you're cutting cancer research funding,
- 1:04:08I think that makes it worse.
- 1:04:09Do you know why he was cutting and people who would die?
- 1:04:11Because a lot of research institutes were actually withholding some of those funds
- 1:04:16and hoping that they could roll them over to the next year.
- 1:04:19And so that's.
- 1:04:20I would say
- 1:04:21something that they were supposed to be using.
- 1:04:23So the,
- 1:04:24the if you're a research institute and you're
- 1:04:27trying to do research on cancer patients,
- 1:04:29I would think you would use all your funds,
- 1:04:31not withhold.
- 1:04:32So that's,
- 1:04:33that is,
- 1:04:33that is certainly not the case for why Donald Trump cut these funds.
- 1:04:36Um,
- 1:04:37the justification from the administration,
- 1:04:39well,
- 1:04:39first of all,
- 1:04:40he did in the 1st 3 months of his administration,
- 1:04:42cancer funding research was down 30% year over year.
- 1:04:44So that happened.
- 1:04:44That's.
- 1:04:45Not even disputable.
- 1:04:46So $7.2 billion is the same as 2025.
- 1:04:50So no,
- 1:04:51he actually cut $2.1 billion in cancer funding research.
- 1:04:54So that is,
- 1:04:54that is not even up for debate.
- 1:04:56So but you just also agreed that Donald Trump did cut cancer funding research,
- 1:04:59but you're making it seem like he cut everything.
- 1:05:01I did not say he cut everything,
- 1:05:03but you did.
- 1:05:04I did not.
- 1:05:05I did not.
- 1:05:05Are you kidding me?
- 1:05:06I just said that Donald Trump cut
- 1:05:07cancer
- 1:05:08funding.
- 1:05:09Part of this is the other part of this is
- 1:05:12under COVID,
- 1:05:14Gavin Newsom was whoa,
- 1:05:15whoa,
- 1:05:15whoa,
- 1:05:16whoa,
- 1:05:16whoa,
- 1:05:16you still haven't given me a coherent.
- 1:05:17How about the pediatric I was speaking to this guy,
- 1:05:19the pediatric Brain
- 1:05:21Tumor
- 1:05:22Consortium,
- 1:05:22which focused on pediatric brain cancer.
- 1:05:24OK.
- 1:05:24Why?
- 1:05:25Why did they get their funding cut?
- 1:05:26By the way,
- 1:05:27$0.
- 1:05:28They didn't have it reduced.
- 1:05:29Maybe they were doing effective work really,
- 1:05:31because they had a bunch of studies,
- 1:05:32a lot of research institutes.
- 1:05:33To get cut.
- 1:05:34They had a bunch of studies.
- 1:05:35This is a,
- 1:05:36a,
- 1:05:36a,
- 1:05:36a group of people,
- 1:05:37a group of people and experts who have been funded for 26 years,
- 1:05:41and they were,
- 1:05:41they had active clinical trials.
- 1:05:43What do you say to the families who their children
- 1:05:45who have not only gone through a cancer diagnosis,
- 1:05:46but we're going through the studies and then were taken out of that study?
- 1:05:49What do you say to those families?
- 1:05:50Well,
- 1:05:51why don't you answer?
- 1:05:53What would you say to the
- 1:05:54families?
- 1:05:55Well,
- 1:05:55why would you say to the families
- 1:05:56who were forced to.
- 1:05:58Give their children
- 1:06:00on this point you can't say anything to the families.
- 1:06:01It's indefensible.
- 1:06:03We're cutting
- 1:06:04pediatric brain cancer,
- 1:06:05again,
- 1:06:05I said it to him,
- 1:06:06the number 1 killer of kids with cancer in the United States.
- 1:06:08There is no defense
- 1:06:10for cutting the funding
- 1:06:12for research for this issue.
- 1:06:1350% effectiveness of COVID vaccine.
- 1:06:15Well,
- 1:06:15that's just misinformation.
- 1:06:16You're,
- 1:06:17you're making stuff up and you're making stuff
- 1:06:18up in response to what I'm talking about.
- 1:06:20You won't even answer why Donald Trump did it.
- 1:06:21Why?
- 1:06:23Maybe it was too much funding.
- 1:06:24Maybe it was too much funding.
- 1:06:25How much do you think it was funded?
- 1:06:26It was in the tens of millions.
- 1:06:27I'll answer the question for you because we might be out of time
- 1:06:30for the pediatric brain.
- 1:06:31No,
- 1:06:31no,
- 1:06:31no,
- 1:06:32exactly.
- 1:06:32So I'm talking about this in particular.
- 1:06:33What's the justification?
- 1:06:36I mean,
- 1:06:36you're back to your claim,
- 1:06:38which is that people
- 1:06:40were are suffering health wise
- 1:06:43under the Trump administration,
- 1:06:45I would say that Trump is actually doing a great thing for our country.
- 1:06:48So cutting,
- 1:06:48cutting childhood cancer research is a good thing.
- 1:06:51You cut some funds.
- 1:06:52You don't cut everything.
- 1:06:53Oh,
- 1:06:53it's OK,
- 1:06:54great.
- 1:06:54But the fact that you're position of the
- 1:06:56administration that cutting childhood cancer research is good.
- 1:06:58Some of those,
- 1:06:59those,
- 1:06:59those funds were not all used though.
- 1:07:01They were all used by the PD,
- 1:07:03but this,
- 1:07:03we are going to pause here.
- 1:07:04We are out of time.
- 1:07:06Thank you.
- 1:07:07Thank you.
- 1:07:07Yeah,
- 1:07:07of course.
- 1:07:11My final surrounding claim is that the Epstein File cover-up
- 1:07:14is one of the worst scandals in American history.
- 1:07:16If you'd like to be the first debater,
- 1:07:18please get to the chair in 321.
- 1:07:24Firstly,
- 1:07:24I just want to say
- 1:07:25I totally agree with you that her failure to release the Epstein files,
- 1:07:29despite being president for 4 years,
- 1:07:31despite having control of Congress,
- 1:07:33was one of Joe Biden's biggest failures,
- 1:07:35and I'm glad you're ready to criticize Joe Biden for that failure,
- 1:07:37that he chose not to release them.
- 1:07:39It's even weirder given that your side's so confident
- 1:07:41that Donald Trump's gonna be named in the files.
- 1:07:43It's extra weird that Joe wouldn't want to drop those files,
- 1:07:45right?
- 1:07:46Do you,
- 1:07:46do you have any theories as to why Joe Biden refuses to release the Epstein files?
- 1:07:49Yeah,
- 1:07:49I mean,
- 1:07:49I'm happy to talk about it.
- 1:07:50I mean,
- 1:07:50first.
- 1:07:51First of all,
- 1:07:51Donald Trump was named in the Epstein files.
- 1:07:53His name appears more times in the files than Jesus' name does in the Bible,
- 1:07:57which is a pretty interesting
- 1:07:58statistic.
- 1:07:59But there's a lot of
- 1:08:00I'm happy,
- 1:08:00I'm happy to answer the question.
- 1:08:02So the reason why Joe Biden
- 1:08:03specifically didn't release the Epstein files is for a couple of reasons,
- 1:08:06mainly because there was an independence between the DOJ
- 1:08:09and Joe Biden during his administration.
- 1:08:11Joe Biden wasn't calling up Merrick Garland and say,
- 1:08:12Hey,
- 1:08:12do this for me,
- 1:08:13right?
- 1:08:14There just wasn't that,
- 1:08:14and there's no evidence of that there a reason he couldn't have done that?
- 1:08:16I mean,
- 1:08:17he could have,
- 1:08:17but he To maintain that independence between the DOJ and the presidency,
- 1:08:20which has existed for many decades,
- 1:08:22many centuries.
- 1:08:23So that's number 1.
- 1:08:24But also number 2,
- 1:08:25I think the bigger reason is that Ghislaine Maxwell's
- 1:08:27case was still working its way through the courts,
- 1:08:29and there's DOJ policy across any administration
- 1:08:31that any active court case,
- 1:08:32a lot of the files can't be released to
- 1:08:34the public because it's part of that court case.
- 1:08:35Could any of the files,
- 1:08:37some of them maybe.
- 1:08:38How come he didn't release any?
- 1:08:40I mean,
- 1:08:40I think that Joe Biden should have.
- 1:08:42I have no problem with any Democrat,
- 1:08:43any Republican,
- 1:08:44number one,
- 1:08:44if they're named in the file.
- 1:08:45If they did something bad,
- 1:08:46they should be held accountable.
- 1:08:47But any administration should do that.
- 1:08:49And I think
- 1:08:49more so the onus is on like someone like Merrick Garland,
- 1:08:52who was the head of the DOJ as opposed to Joe Biden,
- 1:08:54because again,
- 1:08:54there was that independence.
- 1:08:55But the point,
- 1:08:56but the point here is that there are still millions of Epstein files out there.
- 1:08:59Donald Trump has been legally mandated to release the files,
- 1:09:02and he still hasn't.
- 1:09:03Why are there still millions of files missing
- 1:09:05and why hasn't he complied with the law?
- 1:09:06Yeah,
- 1:09:06because truthfully,
- 1:09:07this isn't a partisan issue.
- 1:09:08Your,
- 1:09:09your framing on this claim wants to make it a partisan issue.
- 1:09:11I just said any Democrat,
- 1:09:12Republican.
- 1:09:12hold him accountable.
- 1:09:13I understand,
- 1:09:14but the way you and your side talk about this is this is all Donald Trump.
- 1:09:16It's all
- 1:09:17I'm talking about it,
- 1:09:17right?
- 1:09:18So if I'm saying hold both sides accountable,
- 1:09:19this is obviously not a political issue for me.
- 1:09:21I think this is,
- 1:09:22I say it's one of the biggest scandals regardless of politics.
- 1:09:24Can I inquire how many times you called for this under Joe Biden's presidency?
- 1:09:28Uh,
- 1:09:28I,
- 1:09:28I don't know.
- 1:09:29I mean,
- 1:09:29I don't have a number.
- 1:09:30I probably at some point,
- 1:09:31but I've been doing this for like 6 years now.
- 1:09:33So,
- 1:09:33so
- 1:09:34I don't remember every word I've ever said online.
- 1:09:356 years ago,
- 1:09:36that was pretty solidly at the beginning of Joe's presidency.
- 1:09:38No,
- 1:09:39it was Donald Trump's.
- 1:09:40Six years ago,
- 1:09:40OK,
- 1:09:41when I started at least.
- 1:09:42OK,
- 1:09:42so then 2020,
- 1:09:43so you were
- 1:09:43doing this for the entirety of Joe's presidency.
- 1:09:45You never once called for Joe Biden to release.
- 1:09:47I probably did at some point,
- 1:09:48but again,
- 1:09:49I don't know every word I've ever spoken online.
- 1:09:50Did you call for Merrick Garland to ever release the
- 1:09:52I imagine I did at some point,
- 1:09:53but even if I didn't,
- 1:09:54the fact still remains that Donald Trump has not released these files.
- 1:09:56He's been legally mandated to.
- 1:09:58Why?
- 1:09:58What's the answer?
- 1:09:59But what's the answer?
- 1:10:00Because like I'm saying,
- 1:10:01this is a nonpartisan uniparty issue.
- 1:10:03Neither side wants to release these files,
- 1:10:05and my question to you is why?
- 1:10:07Why do you think neither
- 1:10:08Democrats,
- 1:10:09Democrats wanted to release the files?
- 1:10:10They voted overwhelmingly to.
- 1:10:12Donald Trump,
- 1:10:12when they didn't have the the Epstein Files
- 1:10:14Transparency Act was working its way through Congress.
- 1:10:16Donald Trump called up Republican members who had put their name on
- 1:10:18the discharge petition and told them to take their name off.
- 1:10:20Marjorie Taylor Greene,
- 1:10:21Lauren Bobert,
- 1:10:22they've been open about this.
- 1:10:23Why doesn't Donald Trump want the files to come
- 1:10:24out and why hasn't he released all of them?
- 1:10:25And that's my.
- 1:10:26Exact point.
- 1:10:26Neither the Democrats nor the Republicans want it.
- 1:10:29Can I get an answer to the question?
- 1:10:30Why?
- 1:10:30Right?
- 1:10:30Because both parties on some issues actually
- 1:10:32happen to have very good cross-partisan unity,
- 1:10:34right?
- 1:10:35You would agree with that.
- 1:10:36This is one of those issues,
- 1:10:37and it's one of those issues for the same
- 1:10:38reason pertain typically anytime both parties have cross-party loyalty,
- 1:10:42it
- 1:10:42goes to essentially
- 1:10:44favoring the elites,
- 1:10:45right?
- 1:10:45We could let,
- 1:10:45let's just talk about that.
- 1:10:47The elites that actually benefit no matter which party is in office,
- 1:10:50right?
- 1:10:50They tend to get their way regardless of who the president is.
- 1:10:53Agree with that.
- 1:10:53Wait,
- 1:10:53can we just go back to your claim that it's cross-party unity?
- 1:10:55Only 4 Republicans put their name on the discharge petition.
- 1:10:58Yes,
- 1:10:58conveniently,
- 1:10:59when they knew that it was going to
- 1:11:00be a Democrat-led discharge petition under Trump's presidency,
- 1:11:03how many times did the Democrats under Biden's presidency?
- 1:11:05We're talking about Donald Trump's presidency right now.
- 1:11:07Why did only 4 Republicans put their name on the discharge petition?
- 1:11:10That's what I'm trying to put them on it.
- 1:11:11Doesn't it mean that it's not quite no,
- 1:11:13it means a unit.
- 1:11:14See,
- 1:11:14they know in advance.
- 1:11:15Yeah,
- 1:11:15I'm trying to explain this to you.
- 1:11:17So when there's no chance the files will get released under Trump.
- 1:11:19The Democrats will clamor for it.
- 1:11:21But under Biden,
- 1:11:22when he could release it,
- 1:11:23then the Republicans might clamor for it.
- 1:11:24But the Democrats conveniently silent.
- 1:11:25Wait,
- 1:11:26despite the politics that you're talking about,
- 1:11:27the games of politics,
- 1:11:28which happen with every single issue,
- 1:11:30would you agree that all the files should be released at this point in time?
- 1:11:33Of course.
- 1:11:33Would you agree that Donald Trump is legally mandated to release the files?
- 1:11:36I don't have a legal analysis opinion on whether he is,
- 1:11:38but he should,
- 1:11:39regardless of whether he is or not.
- 1:11:40Epstein files Transparency Act,
- 1:11:41it's a law,
- 1:11:42and they're actually working on a second version to make it more enforceable.
- 1:11:44I mean,
- 1:11:44I don't want to get into a boring constitutional argument.
- 1:11:46I don't know if that law is valid because of executive.
- 1:11:48No,
- 1:11:48because there's like there's an issue that maybe he can't,
- 1:11:50they can't compel the president to do stuff.
- 1:11:52Either way,
- 1:11:52he should release them,
- 1:11:53as should Joe Biden.
- 1:11:54And so why should Merrick Garland?
- 1:11:55Why hasn't he?
- 1:11:56There's no,
- 1:11:56there's no good answer to this question on why hasn't he,
- 1:11:58and that's where the cover-up comes up.
- 1:11:59What do you mean by good answer?
- 1:12:01I can give you
- 1:12:01there's maybe what I think is a correct answer.
- 1:12:03There's no explanation.
- 1:12:03There's no justification.
- 1:12:04That's what I mean by good answer.
- 1:12:05And there's an explanation.
- 1:12:07Well,
- 1:12:07what's the explanation?
- 1:12:08The explanation is the same group of people that benefit
- 1:12:10from these files not being released who benefited under.
- 1:12:13Joe Biden,
- 1:12:13who benefit under Merrick Garland,
- 1:12:15who benefit under Donald Trump,
- 1:12:16actually have a lot of money.
- 1:12:17They have a lot of influence in the United States government,
- 1:12:19and they don't want it revealed that they had
- 1:12:21a pedophile island where they were kidnapping children.
- 1:12:23So you're in,
- 1:12:24you're saying that Donald Trump has fallen victim to these wealthy people who are
- 1:12:28essentially buying him not to release the files.
- 1:12:30Is that your claim?
- 1:12:30I'm saying every American president in at least the last
- 1:12:3340 years has fallen victim to a group of wealthy
- 1:12:35people who donate a lot of money and you're still
- 1:12:37supportive with that and you're still supportive of Donald Trump.
- 1:12:40I'm,
- 1:12:40well,
- 1:12:40first of all,
- 1:12:41do you think Joe Biden wasn't,
- 1:12:42wait,
- 1:12:42can you ask my question?
- 1:12:43Do you think,
- 1:12:43are you supportive of Donald Trump still?
- 1:12:44Yeah,
- 1:12:45because,
- 1:12:45OK,
- 1:12:45so wait,
- 1:12:46both parties,
- 1:12:46you still support both beholden to these you still support Donald Trump,
- 1:12:49but by your own admission he's been bought evils.
- 1:12:52Wait,
- 1:12:52wait,
- 1:12:52wait,
- 1:12:53you're still supportive of Donald Trump despite by your own admission
- 1:12:55he's been bought by wealthy people to not release the files?
- 1:12:57Yes,
- 1:12:58because so has Kamala Harris.
- 1:12:59Yes,
- 1:13:00right.
- 1:13:00I,
- 1:13:00I know you wanna like act incredulous.
- 1:13:02You wanna act like incredulous,
- 1:13:03but you're kind of not listening to what I'm saying.
- 1:13:04It's
- 1:13:05both,
- 1:13:05both parties
- 1:13:06have been bought by wealthy people.
- 1:13:08Do you think that Joe?
- 1:13:09Biden wasn't like under the control of wealthy people.
- 1:13:11I don't think he wasn't advancing oligarchical
- 1:13:13interests.
- 1:13:13What wealthy people were giving money to Joe Biden so he wouldn't release the files?
- 1:13:16Well,
- 1:13:16he,
- 1:13:16I don't think he needed money specifically to not release the files.
- 1:13:19OK,
- 1:13:19so Joe Biden falls on,
- 1:13:20falls apart,
- 1:13:20at least on the Epstein file issue.
- 1:13:22And I want to bring up another thing he did about the love of the game.
- 1:13:24He hid the Epstein files for the love of the game.
- 1:13:25Well,
- 1:13:26again,
- 1:13:26Ghilaine Maxwell's case was still working its way through the courts.
- 1:13:29I'm not exactly sure why you're ignoring that.
- 1:13:30What's the legal theory where by which they
- 1:13:32can't release any files because it's DOJ policy?
- 1:13:34It's been DOJ policy throughout who controls the DOJ policy?
- 1:13:37That was Merrick Garland at the time.
- 1:13:38And who appoints.
- 1:13:39Garland with Joe Biden.
- 1:13:40Oh,
- 1:13:40OK,
- 1:13:40so he could change it.
- 1:13:41Uh,
- 1:13:41no,
- 1:13:42Joe Biden can't change DOJ policy because again,
- 1:13:44as I said,
- 1:13:44there was an independence between the DOJ and Joe Biden.
- 1:13:46He wasn't calling up,
- 1:13:47he wasn't calling up the DOJ and saying,
- 1:13:49hey,
- 1:13:49do this for me,
- 1:13:50which is the right thing to do.
- 1:13:51No,
- 1:13:52he shouldn't do that.
- 1:13:52The president of the,
- 1:13:53the president of the United States,
- 1:13:54at least
- 1:13:55via the standards that we've had in the United States for decades,
- 1:13:57should not be directing the DOJ to do things that they want them to do.
- 1:14:00Donald Trump,
- 1:14:01on the other hand,
- 1:14:01has been doing that,
- 1:14:02which I think is a failure of this administration.
- 1:14:04Who's the current we're gonna have to pause here.
- 1:14:06You've been voted out by the majority.
- 1:14:07Thank you.
- 1:14:12If you'd like to be the next debater,
- 1:14:14please get to the chair in 321.
- 1:14:19So I think one of the biggest things that we're
- 1:14:21missing is the children in this whole entire aspect.
- 1:14:23Um,
- 1:14:25both sides have failed and dropped the ball
- 1:14:27on this.
- 1:14:28The number one issue that not
- 1:14:30one person has
- 1:14:32brought to the attention is the children that Epstein trafficked.
- 1:14:36The,
- 1:14:36the mutilation,
- 1:14:37the brutalization that these children have gone through.
- 1:14:41And Trump's first administration,
- 1:14:43it could have been brought up,
- 1:14:44but under Biden,
- 1:14:45he had
- 1:14:46the authority to,
- 1:14:48to focus on
- 1:14:49exactly where these children are going
- 1:14:51and how these children,
- 1:14:53um,
- 1:14:53where they went and how they're,
- 1:14:55what happened to them,
- 1:14:56and that's what we're not focusing on.
- 1:14:57I don't care
- 1:14:58on my personal opinion is I don't care on the Republican or the Democratic side.
- 1:15:03Something happened and and this
- 1:15:05federal government is not focusing on the main issue,
- 1:15:08and Biden could have
- 1:15:10really stepped up his game because trafficking is is is a nightmare in this country
- 1:15:15and he really could have done something
- 1:15:17to,
- 1:15:18To find out what happened to these kids,
- 1:15:20who was involved with these kids?
- 1:15:22Well,
- 1:15:22Joe Biden prosecuted Ghilaine Maxwell.
- 1:15:24That prosecution took place under his administration,
- 1:15:26and of course there are other trafficking cases,
- 1:15:28but nothing.
- 1:15:29He had the power of the DOJ.
- 1:15:31He could have pushed the DOJ to
- 1:15:33prosecute people,
- 1:15:34brought people to justice,
- 1:15:36and nothing has been ever accomplished.
- 1:15:37Well,
- 1:15:37look,
- 1:15:38if you want to make the claim that
- 1:15:39Previous administrations have failed on this issue.
- 1:15:41I'm like happy to entertain that,
- 1:15:43but I think right now we have
- 1:15:44to entertain.
- 1:15:46I'm happy to have the conversation.
- 1:15:47OK.
- 1:15:47Or you wish other,
- 1:15:49other people,
- 1:15:49I wish there are so many
- 1:15:50different failures throughout this entire story stretching
- 1:15:52back to the early 2000s that I wish would have been different.
- 1:15:54I wish that
- 1:15:55Donald Trump's former Labor Secretary Alex Acosta wouldn't have given
- 1:15:58Epstein a sweetheart deal that allowed him to reoffend,
- 1:16:01right?
- 1:16:02Going and in Florida,
- 1:16:03kind of dropping the ball there.
- 1:16:04I wish
- 1:16:05that the United States government would have prosecuted this sooner.
- 1:16:07More people would have listened to the victims who
- 1:16:09spoke up years ago before Epstein was arrested.
- 1:16:11There's a lot of failures,
- 1:16:12but I think at this moment in time
- 1:16:13we have to focus on right now.
- 1:16:15There's a law mandating this
- 1:16:17100%.
- 1:16:17There's a law mandating that this administration release the files,
- 1:16:20and since then they've done pretty much anything but that,
- 1:16:23or at least they've
- 1:16:24worked in a way to avoid files about
- 1:16:26Donald Trump from being released or millions that
- 1:16:28still outstanding from being released,
- 1:16:30but there was nothing,
- 1:16:30nothing,
- 1:16:31no evidence that he was ever involved with.
- 1:16:35Epstein.
- 1:16:36Well,
- 1:16:36I mean there are,
- 1:16:36there are accusations against him in the files.
- 1:16:38Accusations are one thing.
- 1:16:39There's a,
- 1:16:40there's plenty of fathers out there that have gone through
- 1:16:42horrible accusations that have been stripped from their kids.
- 1:16:45Yeah,
- 1:16:45but it's accusations.
- 1:16:46I think it's weird that some of the accusations against Donald Trump
- 1:16:49were not included in the original drop of files,
- 1:16:51and only after reporting and pressure on the DOJ did they eventually come out.
- 1:16:54There was a 13-year-old girl
- 1:16:56who spoke to FBI investigators 4 times,
- 1:16:58and I mean.
- 1:16:58to an Epstein survivor.
- 1:16:59That's and that's great.
- 1:17:00I mean,
- 1:17:00I think everybody should hear from them.
- 1:17:02But of those 4 written interviews that the FBI did
- 1:17:04with that little girl or woman at the time,
- 1:17:06but she was a little girl when she alleged that took place,
- 1:17:08they only released one of them initially.
- 1:17:09The 3 came later and there are still documents missing from her file.
- 1:17:12And this is a girl who is specifically alleging
- 1:17:14that Donald Trump did something illegal to her.
- 1:17:16I think those documents should come out,
- 1:17:17and it's disturbing to me
- 1:17:19that those documents were withheld for quite some time.
- 1:17:23You know,
- 1:17:24this is a touchy subject when it comes to the FC files,
- 1:17:26um.
- 1:17:29I think,
- 1:17:29and I'm gonna get,
- 1:17:30I,
- 1:17:30I think that Biden
- 1:17:32could have done a lot more
- 1:17:34under his under his administration.
- 1:17:36Again,
- 1:17:36that's what I opened up with
- 1:17:37that both sides of this party,
- 1:17:39but both sides are,
- 1:17:40are guilty
- 1:17:41for not,
- 1:17:41don't you think that Donald Trump's is more offensive to the American people?
- 1:17:44I don't think Donald Trump's more offensive to at least his
- 1:17:47cover,
- 1:17:48I think Donald Trump makes America stronger.
- 1:17:50Well,
- 1:17:50we'll talk about that in some other ones for sure.
- 1:17:52Don't you think his cover up is perhaps a little bit more sinister than Joe Biden's?
- 1:17:56Absolutely.
- 1:17:57How is it a cover up because he still hasn't released the files.
- 1:17:59He's giving Ghislaine Maxwell preferential treatment,
- 1:18:01but Donald Trump has an incentive not to release the files.
- 1:18:04Joe Biden and other Democrats up all the files.
- 1:18:07No,
- 1:18:07he,
- 1:18:07no,
- 1:18:08he did not.
- 1:18:09If,
- 1:18:09if,
- 1:18:09if he did,
- 1:18:10what,
- 1:18:10when did he do that?
- 1:18:11When did he order Pam Bonnie to release all
- 1:18:12the files at the beginning of his second administration
- 1:18:15didn't happen.
- 1:18:16Right,
- 1:18:16it didn't happen,
- 1:18:17but he,
- 1:18:18but Pam Bondi could have,
- 1:18:19if,
- 1:18:20if anybody's fight is against anybody,
- 1:18:21it's against Pam Bondi
- 1:18:22for not releasing.
- 1:18:23No,
- 1:18:23it's against Donald Trump who was calling up Republicans telling them
- 1:18:26not to vote for the bill to release the files.
- 1:18:27And by the way,
- 1:18:28Donald Trump,
- 1:18:29Todd Blanche,
- 1:18:29more specifically,
- 1:18:30I don't think there's an independence between the DOJ and Trump now,
- 1:18:32but
- 1:18:33for the sake of argument,
- 1:18:34Todd Blanche could release all of the files right now as we're speaking,
- 1:18:37as we're filming this episode,
- 1:18:38he could release all of them,
- 1:18:39and they're not doing it.
- 1:18:40And also I think another thing I want to bring up,
- 1:18:42why is Ghislaine Maxwell getting preferential treatment?
- 1:18:44Why was she moved from a maximum security prison to a low level
- 1:18:47security prison in Texas after Todd Blanche met with her for 7 hours?
- 1:18:51Again,
- 1:18:51we're gonna pause here.
- 1:18:52You've been voted out by the majority.
- 1:18:53Thank you.
- 1:18:55Thanks,
- 1:18:55man.
- 1:18:55We'll talk soon.
- 1:19:01Alright,
- 1:19:01if you'd like to be the next debater,
- 1:19:02please get to the chair in 321.
- 1:19:08Nice to meet you,
- 1:19:09man.
- 1:19:09Good to meet you in person.
- 1:19:10Likewise.
- 1:19:12All right,
- 1:19:13so
- 1:19:13one,
- 1:19:14when you claim that something's a cover up,
- 1:19:16you're also claiming that
- 1:19:17there's a crime that you're actually covering up.
- 1:19:19So what evidence do you have that there's actual crimes that are being covered up?
- 1:19:23Yeah,
- 1:19:24so the Epstein Files Transparency Act requires
- 1:19:26the release of all files applicable,
- 1:19:28uh,
- 1:19:28and they haven't been released.
- 1:19:29Well,
- 1:19:30that,
- 1:19:30that is,
- 1:19:30that's an example.
- 1:19:31No,
- 1:19:31no,
- 1:19:31no,
- 1:19:31so that would have been a different claim had you said was your,
- 1:19:34if your claim was Trump should release all of the Epstein files,
- 1:19:38then we would be debating that.
- 1:19:40But your claim was that this is the worst cover up in American history,
- 1:19:43one of the worst in American history.
- 1:19:46So what evidence do you have that Donald Trump
- 1:19:49committed these crimes and is now covering it up?
- 1:19:51What committing crimes in what being committed,
- 1:19:53committed those crimes,
- 1:19:54committing crimes in connection with Epstein,
- 1:19:56or,
- 1:19:5600 no,
- 1:19:57they're all just allegations.
- 1:19:58So there's never been a criminal accusation.
- 1:20:01Well,
- 1:20:01no,
- 1:20:01I don't,
- 1:20:01I don't think that,
- 1:20:02um,
- 1:20:02just because Donald Trump hasn't been formally accused of a crime by
- 1:20:05law enforcement doesn't mean that he's not covering up the files because
- 1:20:07Donald Trump obviously,
- 1:20:08as I was just saying to the gentleman before,
- 1:20:10has an incentive to not release these files.
- 1:20:12He's named a lot in them.
- 1:20:13There are some embarrassing accusations against them.
- 1:20:15FBI even interviewed a victim,
- 1:20:16and you don't get an interview if your
- 1:20:18claims aren't at least of interest to the
- 1:20:19FBI and there might be some credibility here.
- 1:20:21But the law that he's breaking,
- 1:20:23the law that he's breaking the Epstein Files Transparency Act is still active,
- 1:20:26and he's breaking it so much and has been breaking it so often
- 1:20:29that members of Congress,
- 1:20:30Thomas Massey,
- 1:20:30Roe Connor,
- 1:20:31are working on an Epstein Files Transparency Act too
- 1:20:34to allow more enforcement of the law.
- 1:20:35OK,
- 1:20:35so basically what I got is that you actually don't have
- 1:20:38any evidence that Donald Trump committed any of these crimes.
- 1:20:40You have allegations.
- 1:20:41I never alleged that Donald Trump anonymous.
- 1:20:43that were never followed up on.
- 1:20:46Well,
- 1:20:46they did follow up on,
- 1:20:47but Harry,
- 1:20:48but Harry,
- 1:20:48when you say there's a cover up,
- 1:20:50when you're saying you're covering this up,
- 1:20:52you are implicitly affirming that there is a crime that has been committed.
- 1:20:55Wait,
- 1:20:56wait,
- 1:20:56let's just,
- 1:20:56that is like the definition.
- 1:20:57Let's just put this on a hypothetical.
- 1:20:58If person A commits a crime
- 1:21:00and then person B is covering up that crime,
- 1:21:03the person B is not necessarily guilty of the crime that person A committed
- 1:21:06Trump is covering
- 1:21:07up for other people.
- 1:21:08Yeah,
- 1:21:08he's covering up the Epstein files.
- 1:21:10Uh,
- 1:21:10I think Jeffrey Epstein.
- 1:21:12He's covering up for himself as well,
- 1:21:13Donald Trump,
- 1:21:14yeah,
- 1:21:14really,
- 1:21:15because Donald Trump,
- 1:21:16when Jeffrey Epstein was arrested,
- 1:21:18told the FBI that he's glad he's getting going after them.
- 1:21:21Uh,
- 1:21:21the Trump administration is the one that indicted
- 1:21:24Epstein.
- 1:21:25Um,
- 1:21:26Trump is the one that signed
- 1:21:27the Epstein Transparency Act to begin with because he was forced to,
- 1:21:32to begin,
- 1:21:32every member of Congress voted in favor of it.
- 1:21:34And by the way,
- 1:21:34I find it curious,
- 1:21:35OK,
- 1:21:35you said he's forced to,
- 1:21:36but he has the power to veto.
- 1:21:38You said if he's truly trying to cover this up,
- 1:21:40none of.
- 1:21:40This stuff aligns with him actually trying to cover it.
- 1:21:43You said in 2007 Donald Trump was happy about Epstein getting arrested.
- 1:21:46Is that right?
- 1:21:46That's yes.
- 1:21:47OK,
- 1:21:47so in 2003,
- 1:21:48Donald Trump kicked Epstein out of Mar a
- 1:21:50Lago because Epstein allegedly assaulted an 18-year-old beautician.
- 1:21:54Now it was already known around Mar a Lago that Epstein was creepy.
- 1:21:56Marla Maples had even warned Donald Trump himself,
- 1:21:59but that means that Donald Trump,
- 1:22:00knowing of an assault in 2003,
- 1:22:02waited 4 years before speaking up for that victim.
- 1:22:05Isn't that appalling?
- 1:22:07OK,
- 1:22:07but that
- 1:22:09Trump.
- 1:22:09Trump with that case,
- 1:22:10there's a ton of stuff.
- 1:22:12I mean,
- 1:22:12if you're just throwing out random accusations,
- 1:22:14how do you know Trump had
- 1:22:15plenty of evidence to even bring something forth like that?
- 1:22:18Somebody at Mar a Lago
- 1:22:20came to him,
- 1:22:20said that this 18-year-old accused Epstein of assault.
- 1:22:23What do you want to do about it?
- 1:22:24Donald Trump,
- 1:22:25after having Epstein assault a bunch of people at Mar a Lago,
- 1:22:27said,
- 1:22:28Let's kick him out now in 2003.
- 1:22:29And even after this,
- 1:22:30they were still kind of in correspondence.
- 1:22:32But why did Donald Trump not report it to police?
- 1:22:34Why?
- 1:22:34I,
- 1:22:35I'm not sure.
- 1:22:36And there could be
- 1:22:37numerous reasons why.
- 1:22:38Be numerous reasons what could possibly be a justification.
- 1:22:42The lack of evidence,
- 1:22:43an accusation from somebody who works for him.
- 1:22:44He wouldn't think maybe I should go to police about this.
- 1:22:46I,
- 1:22:46I'm not sure.
- 1:22:47Listen,
- 1:22:47I'm not sure that the accusation,
- 1:22:49I don't think it's I'm not saying,
- 1:22:50I'm not saying Donald Trump is perfect,
- 1:22:52but what you are alleging,
- 1:22:54your claim
- 1:22:55is that this is one of the worst cover-ups in US history.
- 1:22:59So one,
- 1:23:00you have not proven that there's any cover up of
- 1:23:02a of why are we going back in circles here?
- 1:23:04I already explained because you're not
- 1:23:06explaining.
- 1:23:06I can give you the hypothetical if person.
- 1:23:08Commits a crime.
- 1:23:09Donald Trump is covering up for Epstein himself.
- 1:23:12What are you talking about?
- 1:23:13Well,
- 1:23:14he,
- 1:23:14he was indicted.
- 1:23:15Epstein was indicted under Trump's.
- 1:23:17Why wouldn't he release these files?
- 1:23:18And hold on,
- 1:23:18by the way,
- 1:23:19he was covering up for just because
- 1:23:21Donald
- 1:23:21Trump indicted,
- 1:23:21just because Donald Trump's DOJ,
- 1:23:23just because Donald Trump's DOJ indicted Epstein back in 2019 doesn't
- 1:23:26mean that Donald Trump hasn't done bad things with Epstein.
- 1:23:28Again,
- 1:23:29he waited four years to speak about assault allegations.
- 1:23:32You are alleging that Donald Trump did bad things with.
- 1:23:34When did I say that Donald Trump did something illegal with Epstein?
- 1:23:37I think he did.
- 1:23:38I think he did bad things.
- 1:23:39That doesn't necessarily mean illegal.
- 1:23:40OK,
- 1:23:40so he hasn't handled Epstein properly,
- 1:23:43perfectly,
- 1:23:44and I agree he hasn't handled it perfectly.
- 1:23:46That's totally different from covering it up.
- 1:23:49With covering it up,
- 1:23:50your intention would have to be that you're trying to hide a crime
- 1:23:54for the benefit of the other person.
- 1:23:56Do you think that Donald Trump is unintentionally not releasing the files?
- 1:23:59No,
- 1:24:00OK,
- 1:24:00when it comes to not releasing the files,
- 1:24:02that doesn't necessarily prove that he's covering up.
- 1:24:04There's a lot of different things,
- 1:24:06as you explained
- 1:24:07why Biden didn't release the files.
- 1:24:09There's a lot of different reasons why you can't release the files,
- 1:24:12like protection of victims.
- 1:24:14They can have their names redacted and even when the files were released,
- 1:24:16a lot of the names that a lot of these files,
- 1:24:19a lot of these files.
- 1:24:19Files are paper.
- 1:24:20Do you
- 1:24:21like our government is so behind technologically.
- 1:24:23There's a lot of paper files that they were required to release these files
- 1:24:27in the winter.
- 1:24:28But then additionally,
- 1:24:29he's released 3.5 million files,
- 1:24:32and there's 3 million outstanding,
- 1:24:34as you said,
- 1:24:35had negative things in Trump
- 1:24:37in the files themselves,
- 1:24:39and
- 1:24:39this.
- 1:24:39If this is a cover-up,
- 1:24:41this is the worst cover up
- 1:24:43in American history.
- 1:24:44So not releasing 50% of the files is the worst cover up ever.
- 1:24:47Did Donald Trump,
- 1:24:48if Donald Trump is covering it up for Epstein,
- 1:24:50he's completely botched the cover-up.
- 1:24:52Like it wouldn't surprise me because Trump botches everything,
- 1:24:54but he still hasn't released 3 million files.
- 1:24:56Why not?
- 1:24:57The law requires him to do so.
- 1:24:58Why not?
- 1:24:59What's the answer?
- 1:25:00Because there are victims,
- 1:25:01you have to protect victims.
- 1:25:03Victims are saying they want the files out.
- 1:25:05It doesn't matter.
- 1:25:06There are laws.
- 1:25:07It doesn't matter what victims want.
- 1:25:08Trump has to follow the law,
- 1:25:10right?
- 1:25:10The law requires him to release the files,
- 1:25:12but there are laws that,
- 1:25:14that like what list requirements on what you have to do with these,
- 1:25:18and the Epstein Files Transparency Act includes all those
- 1:25:20requirements.
- 1:25:21You said earlier,
- 1:25:22Congress is trying to pass something else,
- 1:25:23right?
- 1:25:24So why,
- 1:25:24why are they trying to do that?
- 1:25:26Uh,
- 1:25:26because in the first Epstein Files Transparency Act,
- 1:25:28the enforcement mechanism,
- 1:25:30as in getting Donald Trump to release the files,
- 1:25:31is kind of like a gray area.
- 1:25:33So right now there's actually a court case
- 1:25:34working its way through courts where Katie Fang,
- 1:25:36a
- 1:25:37Uh,
- 1:25:37attorney,
- 1:25:37political commentator,
- 1:25:38newscaster
- 1:25:39is behind that case saying,
- 1:25:41hey,
- 1:25:41we want all the files out,
- 1:25:42and this is the way to enforce it.
- 1:25:43A judge is saying people need to know what's going on.
- 1:25:45Congress wants to pass another version where it says that anybody can sue,
- 1:25:48um,
- 1:25:49for the files to be released.
- 1:25:50And again,
- 1:25:50victims want this.
- 1:25:51So,
- 1:25:52OK,
- 1:25:52so wait,
- 1:25:52so I think we should listen to the court system.
- 1:25:54People are reporting on it.
- 1:25:56It's out in broad daylight.
- 1:25:58Doesn't really sound like a cover up to Donald Trump can't sounds.
- 1:26:01Like it's going through the process.
- 1:26:02Donald Trump can't control what journalists file in court or
- 1:26:05what media outlets report what for the most part.
- 1:26:07No,
- 1:26:07what are you talking?
- 1:26:08OK,
- 1:26:08have you actually studied any American cover
- 1:26:10up?
- 1:26:11You're saying,
- 1:26:12have you actually studied Watergate?
- 1:26:13You're saying that Donald Trump,
- 1:26:14uh,
- 1:26:14by the,
- 1:26:15by the nature of media outlets reporting on the Epstein Files' existence,
- 1:26:18that means that there's not a cover-up.
- 1:26:19If Donald Trump it's going through the courts.
- 1:26:21I mean
- 1:26:22people are aware of it,
- 1:26:23the fact that we're debating it right now.
- 1:26:25Almost goes to show that it's not in fact a cover up.
- 1:26:28Why haven't 3 million files been released?
- 1:26:30Why haven't 3 million files been released
- 1:26:32as required by law?
- 1:26:33No,
- 1:26:33you haven't.
- 1:26:34You haven't.
- 1:26:34You said that there might be some laws that
- 1:26:36apply to these documents that would restrict them,
- 1:26:37but that's not a coherent answer because the administration is not saying that.
- 1:26:41What's the administration's?
- 1:26:41What is the administration's?
- 1:26:42They don't have you know more about it.
- 1:26:43They don't have one.
- 1:26:44We're gonna pause here.
- 1:26:45You've been voted out.
- 1:26:46Thank you.
- 1:26:46You didn't
- 1:26:46answer my question.
- 1:26:47You didn't give any.
- 1:26:47We'll talk more.
- 1:26:48We'll talk.
- 1:26:50If you would like to be the next debater,
- 1:26:52please get to the chair in 321.
- 1:26:57Yeah
- 1:26:59And nice suit.
- 1:27:01Yeah,
- 1:27:01absolutely.
- 1:27:04All right.
- 1:27:05So,
- 1:27:05the Epstein files being a scandal and a cover-up,
- 1:27:08I would like to stick to the premise of the argument.
- 1:27:11Um,
- 1:27:11Watergate
- 1:27:12was
- 1:27:13ruled a scandal,
- 1:27:14Iran-Contra,
- 1:27:15a scandal,
- 1:27:16COINTELPRO
- 1:27:17is a scandal.
- 1:27:19Um,
- 1:27:20the Epstein files at this point is not a scandal,
- 1:27:22and there is no cover-up.
- 1:27:23I think at best it would be incompetence.
- 1:27:26Uh,
- 1:27:26and it'll be a failure on Donald Trump's part
- 1:27:28on his,
- 1:27:29um,
- 1:27:30campaign promise.
- 1:27:31We're going to release the Epstein files.
- 1:27:33And everybody's going to see what's going on.
- 1:27:34Pam Bondi even testified before Congress
- 1:27:36that there is a list of elites,
- 1:27:38and if the elites are exposed,
- 1:27:40it would destroy the whole system.
- 1:27:41I think.
- 1:27:42And,
- 1:27:42and hold,
- 1:27:43that's what everybody wants.
- 1:27:44So wait,
- 1:27:44you're,
- 1:27:44you're actively and publicly claiming that you believe there's a list of elites
- 1:27:48who did bad things with Epstein,
- 1:27:49assaulted kids with Epstein,
- 1:27:51and Donald Trump is covering up that list.
- 1:27:52He's not releasing it?
- 1:27:53No,
- 1:27:54what I said was Pam Bondi testified.
- 1:27:56So Pam is Pam Bondi a liar or is she telling the truth?
- 1:27:59I believe it's incompetence at best because she walked that claim back.
- 1:28:02It wouldn't necessarily be a scandal.
- 1:28:04It would be incompetence on the Trump administration on the,
- 1:28:06and we only have 14,
- 1:28:07but on the incompetence point,
- 1:28:08I mean,
- 1:28:09is Donald Trump
- 1:28:10accidentally not releasing the files?
- 1:28:12I couldn't tell you that,
- 1:28:13but what I can tell you is at this point in history it's not a scandal.
- 1:28:15There's no good answer for any of this stuff.
- 1:28:17People around us just have to accept that it's a bad part,
- 1:28:19a bad move on Donald Trump,
- 1:28:20and he's,
- 1:28:20it's,
- 1:28:21it's a failure in his campaign promise.
- 1:28:22But,
- 1:28:22but to,
- 1:28:23to,
- 1:28:23to not negate from the premise of the.
- 1:28:25Argument that is a scandal and it's being covered up
- 1:28:26at this point in time.
- 1:28:28I think the argument,
- 1:28:28I think if 3 million files,
- 1:28:30around 50% of the files that the DOJ has,
- 1:28:32have not been released by Donald Trump,
- 1:28:34what else do you call it?
- 1:28:35How do you,
- 1:28:36how can you just say,
- 1:28:36oh,
- 1:28:36it's incompetence?
- 1:28:37The victims want it.
- 1:28:38Everybody
- 1:28:39involved in the Epstein case wants it,
- 1:28:40but Donald Trump is the guy that's kind of holding it up.
- 1:28:42Todd Blanche is kind of holding it up.
- 1:28:43How can you just say that's incompetence as opposed
- 1:28:45to a deliberate effort not to release these files?
- 1:28:48I understand the question,
- 1:28:49and I,
- 1:28:49and I appreciate that question.
- 1:28:50The reason why it's incompetence is because
- 1:28:53They made a claim,
- 1:28:54they walked back that claim.
- 1:28:56But at that point in time,
- 1:28:57it is not a scandal.
- 1:28:58It can never be a scandal
- 1:28:59until the claim is proven false.
- 1:29:00So,
- 1:29:01so until we get another administration and they
- 1:29:02absolutely release the rest of the files,
- 1:29:05and then it comes out that the Trump administration
- 1:29:07absolutely lied and it's proven,
- 1:29:08Pam Bondi absolutely lied and it's proven without having to walk back claims,
- 1:29:12then we,
- 1:29:12we can't,
- 1:29:13we can't call it a scandal.
- 1:29:14We can't say don't you think that a president actively breaking the law is a scandal?
- 1:29:18I'm not here to debate that.
- 1:29:19What what we're talking about is the claim that the Epstein files
- 1:29:23is a scandal and the Epstein files is being covered up.
- 1:29:25You won't be able to find out during this administration.
- 1:29:28Alright,
- 1:29:28we're gonna pause here.
- 1:29:29We're out of time on this claim.
- 1:29:30Thank you so much.
- 1:29:32Thanks man.
- 1:29:36All right,
- 1:29:37now it is time for the final debate.
- 1:29:41Here you get 10 minutes uninterrupted.
- 1:29:44Now take your time,
- 1:29:45look around the room
- 1:29:46and choose someone you like to further the conversation with.
- 1:29:49Do my best.
- 1:29:55Reagan
- 1:29:57Reagan Bush
- 1:30:00Keep it respectful.
- 1:30:01Of course,
- 1:30:01always.
- 1:30:02So Harry,
- 1:30:03why did you choose Michael?
- 1:30:04I thought Michael and I had a good conversation.
- 1:30:06It got cut a little short,
- 1:30:07um,
- 1:30:07and so
- 1:30:08I wanted to hear more from him.
- 1:30:10All right,
- 1:30:10we get 10 minutes uninterrupted.
- 1:30:13My surrounded claim is that the modern Democratic Party is more interested in
- 1:30:17fighting President Trump than coming up with solutions for the American people.
- 1:30:23OK,
- 1:30:23um,
- 1:30:24so I guess I just wanna know why,
- 1:30:26why do you think that?
- 1:30:27So when we look at polling consistently and we look
- 1:30:29consistently what comes up as a top issue amongst Democrats and
- 1:30:32uh just internal polling amongst candidates,
- 1:30:34uh,
- 1:30:35across the spectrum we're seeing uh specifically Democrat voters are motivated
- 1:30:39heavily by a candidate who's going to be making it,
- 1:30:41making it a priority for them
- 1:30:43to combat the.
- 1:30:44Administration.
- 1:30:45We see this with rhetoric from the top Democratic campaigns.
- 1:30:47We see this,
- 1:30:48uh,
- 1:30:48especially here in California.
- 1:30:50We had
- 1:30:50a very notable campaign for governor where
- 1:30:53there are multiple high profile candidates in California,
- 1:30:56but every single one of them made it the center point that
- 1:30:59the policy of a state governor candidate in California
- 1:31:02is to fight and combat the presidential administration.
- 1:31:06So tell me how this is more beneficial to the American people to
- 1:31:09focus on combating the president rather than
- 1:31:11working on common sense solutions to find
- 1:31:14actual
- 1:31:16solutions for the problems facing Americans.
- 1:31:17Yeah,
- 1:31:17I mean,
- 1:31:18I think you're just kind of like you're being very picky with
- 1:31:20like campaign talking points.
- 1:31:23I mean,
- 1:31:23every Republican ever that ran during Joe Biden's administration was like,
- 1:31:26yeah,
- 1:31:27we're going to fight Joe Biden,
- 1:31:28we're going to fight the communism.
- 1:31:29It's just like a campaign talking point,
- 1:31:30and I think the justification for both sides is like,
- 1:31:33They're not just saying,
- 1:31:34oh,
- 1:31:34the only thing I'm gonna do is like stand up to Biden or stand up to Trump.
- 1:31:37They're saying I'm gonna stand up to the policies of this administration.
- 1:31:39So
- 1:31:40any Democrat running for Congress is gonna say,
- 1:31:42yeah,
- 1:31:42I'm against
- 1:31:43Trump's cancer cuts.
- 1:31:44I'm against Trump's policies on health care broadly.
- 1:31:46I'm against his immigration policy,
- 1:31:47I'm against whatever,
- 1:31:49but it's more so like being against him as a matter of principle.
- 1:31:51A matter of policy as opposed to just being like,
- 1:31:53I hate Donald Trump.
- 1:31:54We all,
- 1:31:54I mean,
- 1:31:54all of us,
- 1:31:55we hate Trump,
- 1:31:56but we hate his policies as well.
- 1:31:58OK,
- 1:31:58so now you mentioned Joe Biden and going back,
- 1:32:01back in time to the 2020 election,
- 1:32:02we see,
- 1:32:03I'd say my claim still holds faith for 2020 as well.
- 1:32:06The top issue amongst Democrats was combating President Trump,
- 1:32:09and we see that with,
- 1:32:10uh,
- 1:32:10you look around the room and I'll I'll
- 1:32:12speak anecdotally and not pure statistics on this.
- 1:32:15Uh,
- 1:32:15I don't know a single
- 1:32:16Democrat who is actually excited to cast their
- 1:32:18ballot for Joe Biden in the 2020 election.
- 1:32:21Me.
- 1:32:21So
- 1:32:21you are among the minority.
- 1:32:23I hate to break it to you in this end,
- 1:32:24but,
- 1:32:25uh,
- 1:32:25the reality is when we see the Democratic Party in 2020,
- 1:32:28they were wanting to unite against President Trump.
- 1:32:30And then
- 1:32:31when we see in 2024
- 1:32:33the results of the policies of the Biden
- 1:32:35administration during 2020 and throughout those years,
- 1:32:38the failures among the administration to handle any of the policies,
- 1:32:41any of the real issues facing the country,
- 1:32:44and we see the results of that.
- 1:32:45And the actual faith of the American people changing their perspective on their
- 1:32:49faith in the Democratic Party with the results of the 2024 election,
- 1:32:53where again the Democratic Party tried to do the bait and switch.
- 1:32:56We just need
- 1:32:57a beating heart to beat President Trump,
- 1:32:59where they switched out Kamala Harris with
- 1:33:02they switched out Joe Biden with Kamala Harris,
- 1:33:04and
- 1:33:05unfortunately we
- 1:33:06saw that the Democratic Party could not motivate the country
- 1:33:08to vote against President Trump in the 2024 election.
- 1:33:11Yeah,
- 1:33:11they only lost the election by like 200,000 votes in three swing states.
- 1:33:14So if those votes had just changed.
- 1:33:15Kamala Harris to be president today and we'd be far better off.
- 1:33:17Everybody in this room would be far better off.
- 1:33:19But
- 1:33:19to address your claims,
- 1:33:20I mean,
- 1:33:21uh,
- 1:33:21on,
- 1:33:21on the failures of the Biden administration,
- 1:33:23I'm curious,
- 1:33:23like,
- 1:33:23did you disagree with the PAC Act?
- 1:33:25Or do you know what the PAC Act is?
- 1:33:27So what aspects are you asking?
- 1:33:28So the PAC Act was expanding healthcare for veterans
- 1:33:31who had been exposed to toxic burn pits abroad.
- 1:33:33It's kind of like a,
- 1:33:34a field of veterans care that has been ignored.
- 1:33:36The VA used to like deny a lot of these claims.
- 1:33:38They said that there wasn't enough evidence to back up their claim.
- 1:33:41Joe Biden passed that policy.
- 1:33:42Within a year,
- 1:33:43a million people signed up.
- 1:33:44Is that a good thing or a bad thing?
- 1:33:45I'm not going to argue that passing any kind of funding
- 1:33:48towards helping our wounded veterans is what about the infrastructure bill?
- 1:33:51The infrastructure,
- 1:33:52if we want to talk about infrastructure,
- 1:33:53talk about the successes of the
- 1:33:55President Trump's administration,
- 1:33:56that he's,
- 1:33:56yeah,
- 1:33:57you know what,
- 1:33:57you know why he's,
- 1:33:58he's built some things?
- 1:33:59Because he's using money that was appropriated from Biden's infrastructure bill,
- 1:34:01the largest infrastructure bill since Eisenhower's highway system,
- 1:34:04over $1 trillion.
- 1:34:05And by the way,
- 1:34:06Democrats and Republicans voted for it.
- 1:34:08Are you against funding our infrastructure,
- 1:34:09creating more jobs as a result?
- 1:34:10So you want to Say that this is funding created by the Biden administration.
- 1:34:13What about the infrastructure packages passed during the first
- 1:34:16administration before the Biden administration even taken office?
- 1:34:19You mean Donald Trump did not pass an infrastructure bill.
- 1:34:21He passed funding towards infrastructure investment,
- 1:34:23infrastructure funding
- 1:34:24from an infrastructure priority for his
- 1:34:26campaign platform since he's been running.
- 1:34:28Yes,
- 1:34:28it hasn't.
- 1:34:29He hasn't passed any infrastructure has never been a focus for Donald Trump.
- 1:34:31He's not focusing on it right now.
- 1:34:33Investing in America's future.
- 1:34:34Yes,
- 1:34:34of course that's he's not focusing on,
- 1:34:35he's not trying to pass new funding.
- 1:34:36He's using.
- 1:34:37Funding from Biden's bill
- 1:34:38and claiming it as his own.
- 1:34:40But if we want,
- 1:34:41if you want to credit Donald Trump for building things,
- 1:34:43you should be able to sit here in good faith and say,
- 1:34:44actually,
- 1:34:45Joe Biden had a lot to do with that.
- 1:34:46Can you say that?
- 1:34:47What do you mean you're talking about saying that
- 1:34:50a sitting
- 1:34:51elected official in the United States has
- 1:34:53a part to play in passing a budget for the United States?
- 1:34:55Sure,
- 1:34:56I'm happy to concede that point.
- 1:34:57It wasn't a budget.
- 1:34:58OK,
- 1:34:58sure,
- 1:34:59talking about a funding package for the United States,
- 1:35:01talking about an entirely separate bill that funded our.
- 1:35:03Infrastructure.
- 1:35:04Yes,
- 1:35:04so I'm,
- 1:35:05so can you at least
- 1:35:05about
- 1:35:06general funding for infrastructure?
- 1:35:07Yeah,
- 1:35:07sure.
- 1:35:08Great.
- 1:35:08OK,
- 1:35:08great.
- 1:35:08So anytime that we focus on healthcare,
- 1:35:10we agree on infrastructure.
- 1:35:12I mean,
- 1:35:12it seems like you're kind of,
- 1:35:13uh,
- 1:35:13you're aligning with some of the major policies of the Biden administration.
- 1:35:16No.
- 1:35:16So are these really core tenets of
- 1:35:18the Biden administration and the Democratic Party?
- 1:35:20Are these what you see
- 1:35:22voiced on your evening news stations?
- 1:35:25I'm voicing it right now.
- 1:35:26Is this what we see
- 1:35:27coming from the modern day Democratic Party is the top topic.
- 1:35:29Points coming of how they are going to impact the,
- 1:35:32I think the Democrats should be talking about these bills and running on them.
- 1:35:35There's other.
- 1:35:35What about the Chips in Science Act?
- 1:35:36Why aren't they running on them?
- 1:35:38You have to go Democrat by Democrat,
- 1:35:39but there are some Democrats who are talking about,
- 1:35:41yes,
- 1:35:41we participate in this bill.
- 1:35:42We got it done.
- 1:35:42What about the Chips in Science Act?
- 1:35:43Yes,
- 1:35:43so my claim is that the modern
- 1:35:45or the modern Democratic Party,
- 1:35:47not California,
- 1:35:48I'll
- 1:35:49broaden it outside of California,
- 1:35:50the modern Democratic Party is more interested in
- 1:35:53combating the Trump administration than actually solving.
- 1:35:55Problems,
- 1:35:56but then you started to claim that Biden's
- 1:35:57administration wasn't productive and didn't do anything.
- 1:35:59So I just wanted to correct the record that there's actually a lot
- 1:36:01of things that you probably agree with that the Biden administration did.
- 1:36:03So we're talking about the actual political capital expended,
- 1:36:06the actual political time spent and used in these campaigns to be directing
- 1:36:10what the American people are talking about,
- 1:36:11what they're focusing on.
- 1:36:12Are you telling me that the modern Democratic Party is not directing
- 1:36:16all of their attention to combat President Trump and the Trump agenda?
- 1:36:19They're directing their attention toward
- 1:36:21Combating Trump,
- 1:36:22combating his policies,
- 1:36:23combating members of his administration,
- 1:36:24combating their effect in the United States.
- 1:36:25It's not just saying,
- 1:36:26hey,
- 1:36:27Donald Trump,
- 1:36:27that's our only message.
- 1:36:29Democrats are running on a variety of things like,
- 1:36:31hey,
- 1:36:31we think that Donald Trump's cuts to Medicare
- 1:36:33and Medicaid over a 10-year period being $-1 trillion is a bad thing.
- 1:36:37We think we should restore that funding and
- 1:36:39make sure that these programs are properly funded.
- 1:36:40We talked about cancer funding.
- 1:36:41Let's bring that funding back.
- 1:36:42Let's have comprehensive immigration reform that's pragmatic as
- 1:36:45opposed to what Trump is doing with ICE.
- 1:36:46That's what Democrats.
- 1:36:47are running on.
- 1:36:47They're not just saying orange man bad.
- 1:36:50I don't know what Democrats are listening to.
- 1:36:51If they're going on Fox News and saying that it's probably to get some,
- 1:36:54some donors,
- 1:36:55right?
- 1:36:55And Republicans and Democrats do that.
- 1:36:57But broadly,
- 1:36:57if you dig into the policy and what they're actually saying,
- 1:36:59what they're actually arguing for,
- 1:37:01there's substance there.
- 1:37:01There's policy there.
- 1:37:02See,
- 1:37:03I'm still thinking we're watching different candidates and
- 1:37:05different Democrats because the ones that I'm like,
- 1:37:07what candidates are you seeing that are only
- 1:37:08Trump?
- 1:37:09I'll refer all the way back to the candidates
- 1:37:11running for governor of the Democratic Party in California.
- 1:37:13We see that every single one of those candidates made it the single
- 1:37:16top
- 1:37:17talking point for their campaign to be combating the president,
- 1:37:20combating what,
- 1:37:21right?
- 1:37:21They're not just saying I'm gonna exactly they're,
- 1:37:23what are they combating?
- 1:37:24They're not just saying I'm going to combat Trump,
- 1:37:25and that's everything they're saying.
- 1:37:26There's no
- 1:37:27I'm gonna combine what they're saying.
- 1:37:28It's not true,
- 1:37:29really.
- 1:37:29Yeah,
- 1:37:30Javier Becerra,
- 1:37:31you're,
- 1:37:31you're soon to be governor.
- 1:37:32Congratulations everybody,
- 1:37:33a member of the Biden administration.
- 1:37:35You'll be
- 1:37:35just fine here in California,
- 1:37:36very unpopular member of the Biden
- 1:37:38administration if you talk.
- 1:37:39Other members of the cabinet by who?
- 1:37:41It's very clear
- 1:37:42reports from the cabinet.
- 1:37:43Xavier Becerro is not seen as a popular member,
- 1:37:45but
- 1:37:46referring all the way back,
- 1:37:47you still haven't provided concrete examples like the main democratic
- 1:37:51platform where they are doing anything proposing to the American.
- 1:37:53What's the solution on immigration?
- 1:37:55What's the solution to foreign policy?
- 1:37:56What's the solution to the economy?
- 1:37:58What are the solutions that the Democratic
- 1:37:59Party is presenting to the American people?
- 1:38:01I can give you as opposed to orange man bad,
- 1:38:03we need to fight.
- 1:38:04I can give you my solutions if you're asking.
- 1:38:05OK,
- 1:38:05what's the actual solutions being presented
- 1:38:07by the mainstream Democratic candidates?
- 1:38:09Well,
- 1:38:10I'll say
- 1:38:10one of the mainstream candidates ranked for president.
- 1:38:13Pick any of the litter of who you think would be a national figure.
- 1:38:16Yeah,
- 1:38:16a lot of the Democrats that are running that may or may not run for president,
- 1:38:20may or may not,
- 1:38:21they're all kind of aligned on different policies.
- 1:38:24So like if we're just taking immigration,
- 1:38:25for example,
- 1:38:26they're kind of aligned with what Joe Biden tried
- 1:38:27to do near the end of his administration,
- 1:38:29which was a bipartisan bill written by Senator James Lank.
- 1:38:31which hired more ICE,
- 1:38:33not more ICE agents,
- 1:38:33more border patrol agents and invested more in immigration judges because the
- 1:38:36wait for asylum seekers can be anywhere from 4 to 7 years.
- 1:38:39We want to bring that down to under 6 months.
- 1:38:41Um,
- 1:38:41it was actually more border security in terms of the ports of entry where
- 1:38:44most narcotics or illicit substances are brought in,
- 1:38:47wanted more advanced technology to scan these cars.
- 1:38:49And so,
- 1:38:50you know,
- 1:38:50that's good,
- 1:38:51right?
- 1:38:51That's kind of what Democrats are running on.
- 1:38:52OK,
- 1:38:53now you mentioned actually,
- 1:38:54I think we can walk away with this some actual common ground here.
- 1:38:57You're talking about.
- 1:38:58Increasing funding towards border security
- 1:38:59to specifically combat illicit substances.
- 1:39:01And earlier when you were talking about
- 1:39:03health in America,
- 1:39:04I was waiting for somebody to talk about fentanyl being
- 1:39:06one of the leading causes of death in this country.
- 1:39:07Fentanyl overdoses went down under Joe Biden.
- 1:39:09Yes,
- 1:39:10and when we look at the reality of which
- 1:39:12administration started actually looking at the fentanyl epidemic and
- 1:39:15actually focusing on
- 1:39:17enforcing policies to
- 1:39:19prevent fentanyl from coming into the streets of
- 1:39:21America would be the Trump administration in 20.
- 1:39:2316 and we look at the Democrats who consistently,
- 1:39:26consistently oppose any crackdown on border policy meant to
- 1:39:29crack down on fentanyl coming into the United States.
- 1:39:32That's not true.
- 1:39:32We don't,
- 1:39:32we weren't all,
- 1:39:33every single Democrat's aligned that we want
- 1:39:35to prevent illicit substances from coming in.
- 1:39:36I mean,
- 1:39:36it was part of Joe Biden's bill to be able to better scan for these things.
- 1:39:39So like to claim the Democrats are against it is just unfounded.
- 1:39:42But
- 1:39:42like there might be broader policy that this might be included in
- 1:39:45a bill that we're against because of other things in the bill,
- 1:39:47but as a matter of principle,
- 1:39:48nobody's against.
- 1:39:49Preventing fentanyl from coming into the country.
- 1:39:51And also I'd say that Donald Trump did a pretty bad job with it.
- 1:39:53To mention off that matter of principle,
- 1:39:55generally speaking,
- 1:39:56people aren't against that policy.
- 1:39:57You kept bringing up cancer funding,
- 1:39:59cancer research.
- 1:40:00I don't think there's a single person
- 1:40:01sitting here who thinks we shouldn't be funding
- 1:40:03cancer research when it comes to the actual.
- 1:40:05The impact of that funding where it goes.
- 1:40:07This guy couldn't condemn it.
- 1:40:08He wouldn't even engage on that.
- 1:40:10This guy as well wouldn't
- 1:40:11because you have them in a political talking
- 1:40:13point and a straw man argument where you're
- 1:40:14trying to pick and choose one piece of said it was a loaded question as well
- 1:40:17they're going to oppose all funding for cancer
- 1:40:19research,
- 1:40:20but in reality.
- 1:40:21I,
- 1:40:21when you want to pick apart that specific research,
- 1:40:23there may have been a specific reason it was cut,
- 1:40:25but maybe it was no,
- 1:40:26they actually didn't give a reason.
- 1:40:27The Trump administration hasn't given a reason.
- 1:40:29And when I asked for straight up like,
- 1:40:30what's the reason?
- 1:40:30What's the reason?
- 1:40:31Why are we doing this?
- 1:40:32Nobody would engage with me.
- 1:40:33So can you at least engage with me and say that's bad?
- 1:40:35I will tell you right now that generally speaking,
- 1:40:37we should look to be combative.
- 1:40:39diseases like cancer and we should be doing what we can.
- 1:40:41Yes,
- 1:40:41and we need to be looking at what cutting it.
- 1:40:43No,
- 1:40:43I will not because I don't know enough about the specific.
- 1:40:45So wait,
- 1:40:46you just said that everybody here is
- 1:40:47probably in favor of cancer research funding and
- 1:40:49then I asked you to condemn Donald Trump doing it and you said no,
- 1:40:51I won't.
- 1:40:51So are you going to tell me the exact policy,
- 1:40:54write down the exact funding that he
- 1:40:57you're going to tell me the exact program,
- 1:40:59what results were coming of that program,
- 1:41:01pediatric brain tumor consortium.
- 1:41:03OK.
- 1:41:04Why?
- 1:41:05I don't know why.
- 1:41:06Was there,
- 1:41:07were there no results coming from the?
- 1:41:08No,
- 1:41:08they had active studies.
- 1:41:09They were in clinical trials.
- 1:41:10OK,
- 1:41:10but was there actually something coming of it?
- 1:41:12Yes,
- 1:41:12a lot of plenty of people who can say they're an active study according to data,
- 1:41:15according to data from that program,
- 1:41:172000 kids
- 1:41:18have been helped by it.
- 1:41:192000,
- 1:41:19which is a lot of kids.
- 1:41:20OK,
- 1:41:21so why?
- 1:41:22Do we condemn it?
- 1:41:22Do you condemn that?
- 1:41:24Condemn Donald Trump defunding it.
- 1:41:25So you're trying to have me condemn President Trump for not funding a
- 1:41:29program that you are telling me now for the first time that I'll,
- 1:41:32I'll admit I had no research or no understanding of that program.
- 1:41:35Yeah,
- 1:41:35I am asking you to condemn it.
- 1:41:36Yeah.
- 1:41:36So I,
- 1:41:36I will not condemn the president based on
- 1:41:38that program and information you're presenting me.
- 1:41:40As soon,
- 1:41:41how about we do this?
- 1:41:41As soon as you go back in that chair,
- 1:41:43you have a phone on you,
- 1:41:43yeah,
- 1:41:44yes,
- 1:41:44OK.
- 1:41:45Google the,
- 1:41:45the Pediatric Brain Tumor Consortium.
- 1:41:48And look up has it been defunded in its entirety and then
- 1:41:51you can come back to me and we'll talk about it after.
- 1:41:52So I'm not saying that it hasn't.
- 1:41:53I'm just saying that there may have been a reason why you're trying
- 1:41:55to pick this one specific thing because it's a very compelling sounding point.
- 1:41:59It's not you're trying to pick a talking
- 1:42:01point that sounds good.
- 1:42:01You're trying to make people sound unempathized.
- 1:42:03Sure,
- 1:42:03of course,
- 1:42:04but you can look at a Democratic president.
- 1:42:05I'm sure there's some funding for some cancer
- 1:42:07research that Joe Biden restarted the cancer.
- 1:42:09Moonshot program,
- 1:42:10which invested even more in
- 1:42:11how much funding goes in front of each member
- 1:42:13of Congress to propose to put into spending bills
- 1:42:16that doesn't go through and then every single year
- 1:42:18you see the Republicans and the Democrats fighting about,
- 1:42:20oh,
- 1:42:20they cut this,
- 1:42:21oh,
- 1:42:21they're not willing to spend on this.
- 1:42:22And the reality is we have a budget that's trillions of dollars.
- 1:42:26So when it comes to when program counts for 27% of the debt,
- 1:42:28by the way,
- 1:42:29but continue.
- 1:42:3027.
- 1:42:31No,
- 1:42:31it's,
- 1:42:31it's not a joke.
- 1:42:3227%,
- 1:42:321 man.
- 1:42:33OK.
- 1:42:33Well,
- 1:42:33when it comes to an actual budget decision,
- 1:42:35we need to actually look at the fact that there are trillions of dollars deciding
- 1:42:38you want to pick and choose a straw man argument on one specific issue.
- 1:42:42The reality is you don't have something.
- 1:42:43It's not a straw man.
- 1:42:44I'm just,
- 1:42:44I'm asking a very like
- 1:42:46this is you want to go back to the actual
- 1:42:48claim that you have a policy solution that isn't.
- 1:42:51I'm happy to get back to that.
- 1:42:52This should not be understood as like a gotcha moment.
- 1:42:53I'm really not trying to just like the Epstein thing was not a gotcha moment.
- 1:42:56I'm asking genuinely,
- 1:42:57can we find middle ground?
- 1:42:59That Donald Trump
- 1:43:00should not be cutting
- 1:43:01cancer research funding,
- 1:43:03especially
- 1:43:03pediatric cancer research funding,
- 1:43:04and you're like dancing around,
- 1:43:05you're like,
- 1:43:06I don't know,
- 1:43:06I don't know.
- 1:43:07But this has been public for many years.
- 1:43:09I mean,
- 1:43:09we know for a fact that Donald Trump cut this funding,
- 1:43:11and if you've like paid attention to the news,
- 1:43:12you would have seen that he cut this funding.
- 1:43:13So you don't even have to take my word for it.
- 1:43:15You can just like all these different media outlets who reference this budget.
- 1:43:17It's not a political talking point.
- 1:43:19This is,
- 1:43:19I think,
- 1:43:20personal for a lot of people
- 1:43:21talking point.
- 1:43:21You came
- 1:43:22fully prepared with this talking
- 1:43:23point out of time.
- 1:43:24We are out of time.
- 1:43:26Thank you both.
- 1:43:27Thank you.
- 1:43:32All right,
- 1:43:33that is all the time we have.
- 1:43:35I want you guys to give yourselves a round of applause.
- 1:43:37You guys did great today.
- 1:43:41Of course,
- 1:43:42thank you Harry for joining the circle.
- 1:43:44How are you feeling?
- 1:43:45I'm tired now.
- 1:43:46I wanna go home and nap.
- 1:43:48I believe it.
- 1:43:49All right,
- 1:43:49and thank you guys for watching at home.
- 1:43:51Let us know what you think in the comments.
- 1:43:52I'm serious
- 1:43:53and we'll catch you next time.
- 1:43:55Bye.
- 1:43:59The unfortunate reality with people who are really diehard Trump
- 1:44:02supporters is that even on something like cancer research funding,
- 1:44:05which if you go out on any major city and just ask somebody on the street,
- 1:44:08they probably agree with you,
- 1:44:08but even on something like that,
- 1:44:10they can't get there.
- 1:44:11They're like,
- 1:44:11there's still some hesitancy to condemn Trump.
- 1:44:13But I think the positive thing is that there were 20
- 1:44:16people who showed up today and they engaged in conversation.
- 1:44:18Most of it was good faith,
- 1:44:19most of it I thought.
- 1:44:21Was cordial,
- 1:44:22um,
- 1:44:22and so you know there's
- 1:44:23different takeaways.
- 1:44:24I thought Harry was pretty good um I think he comes to debate in good faith.
- 1:44:28He's definitely a media trained guy,
- 1:44:30you know,
- 1:44:30he,
- 1:44:30he does this for a living.
- 1:44:32He knows what he's doing,
- 1:44:33but I do think he genuinely believes in what he's saying
- 1:44:35and that he wants what he thinks is best for America.
- 1:44:38So I think a lot of my disagreement really comes down to
- 1:44:40the fact that we were both navigating each other's talking points.
- 1:44:44And trying to get past each other's points,
- 1:44:46so he had a huge focus on January 6th and talking about
- 1:44:49how all these things about President Trump doing are so terrible
- 1:44:52that he doesn't actually have solutions of his own to present.
- 1:44:55That's what I wanted to make sure to mention in the follow-up
- 1:44:57question that we were able to talk about towards the end is
- 1:45:00there's just no solutions being presented from his end of the aisle
- 1:45:03when he shares things like ICE is just indiscriminately targeting people,
- 1:45:07they don't have the means to do that.
- 1:45:09That's not what the agency does.
- 1:45:10Um,
- 1:45:11the examples he cited I thought were weak for his argument.
- 1:45:14He's citing Mahmoud Khalil and like these
- 1:45:16other kinda
- 1:45:17it's more of like culture war issues and um like obviously
- 1:45:20it's very popular to say that from a rhetoric perspective but
- 1:45:23ICE is an agency that is
- 1:45:25solely determined on.
- 1:45:27Protecting the interior of the country,
- 1:45:28so to demonize them and call them Gestapos,
- 1:45:30not that he did that,
- 1:45:31but that's a lot of the rhetoric that you hear,
- 1:45:33I think it's totally,
- 1:45:34um,
- 1:45:35uncalled for.
- 1:45:36In the lead up to this episode,
- 1:45:37I was like,
- 1:45:37are they even gonna be able to find
- 1:45:39like 1020 people that are
- 1:45:41willing to defend the prompts we had today
- 1:45:42and defend Donald Trump?
- 1:45:43You guys did it.
- 1:45:44It was great,
- 1:45:45um,
- 1:45:45but yes,
- 1:45:45it's definitely hard to defend Trump.
- 1:45:47I can't think of anything that Donald Trump has done well.
- 1:45:49There's not a single point that I think is effective that they can
- 1:45:51run on in the midterms or even in the future or defend.