Latest / Credit Union Exam Solutions Presents With Flying Colors / IRR, the Interest Rate Evironment Credit Union Risk
Transcript
- 0:00Hey everyone.
- 0:01This is Mark Rele with another short take on the interest rate risk and
- 0:05the interest rate environment as it relates to credit union risk.
- 0:08We chat with three of my team members.
- 0:11This was part of a longer video from early in the month, and
- 0:16I'm breaking it down into more snackable slash digestible content.
- 0:21Without further ado, here's Todd, Steve, and Dennis on the
- 0:25interest rate environment and what it means for credit unions.
- 0:30Treichel: So interest rate, environment created is creating mixed opportunities.
- 0:34One thing that popped into my head is, Todd, I think you mentioned the
- 0:38Trump tariffs and it's kind of like, should we stay or should we go now?
- 0:43The Clash song?
- 0:44But the Fed came out.
- 0:45The fed chair came out saying, yeah, one of the reasons I haven't reduced.
- 0:49Rates is because of, of the tariff situation.
- 0:52So that kind of feeds into the interest rate environment, uh, that we're having.
- 0:56Any, any general thoughts on, on the interest rate environment for banks and
- 1:01how it might apply to credit unions?
- 1:04Bauer: One Oh, go ahead.
- 1:07Okay.
- 1:07Yeah.
- 1:07One thing I, I've noticed, and I followed this quite a bit, and as a
- 1:11CFO, right, as the yield curve, right?
- 1:13The yield curve was, was inverted for so many years, and then right in, I think at
- 1:18the end of last year, it finally, if you look at the 10 year and the two year rate
- 1:23was inverted, you had negative spread.
- 1:26But now, right, and I think that's why we're starting to see margins improve is
- 1:30that yield curve is not between the 10 and two year now it is plus 50 basis points.
- 1:35So that makes it a little bit easier to work in an environment where
- 1:38the longer term rates higher than, than shorter, shorter term rates.
- 1:42Back in September of 24, it was a negative 35 basis points.
- 1:47Today it was about 50, so Right.
- 1:49That's a 85 basis point swing in a fairly short period of time.
- 1:53So yeah.
- 1:53Right.
- 1:54I think Mark was, mark was talking depending upon Fed
- 1:56that could influence that.
- 1:58Maybe not so much the tenure, but the short end of that curve might come
- 2:01down even farther, thereby Right.
- 2:03Hopefully allowing credit unions to continue to maybe drop their
- 2:06cost of funds a little bit faster rate than on their asset side.
- 2:09So, and we actually did see, right, a drop in, in cost of funds in the
- 2:13credit union world in Q1 2025, similar to, I think in that article in the
- 2:18LCCI think banks saw that as well.
- 2:20Um, so that rate, that's all helping improve margins.
- 2:23For credit unions, we're up about 20 basis points.
- 2:26If you go back to pre COVID or around right when COVID started, we're up about
- 2:2920 basis points, um, from the Q1 of 2020.
- 2:33So that, that looks positive from that perspective, just we're, the environment
- 2:36that we're in, the yield curve is getting back to maybe a more normal.
- 2:39Um, that, that, that could have an impact.
- 2:42And then also the mix, right?
- 2:43A mix of deposits has changed dramatically, which also could have an
- 2:47impact on cost of funds and margins.
- 2:49Right.
- 2:50Back in 2022, right before rates started to jump, we were sitting
- 2:54only with 13% of, in credit unions.
- 2:5713% of our deposits were in CDs.
- 3:00Today, that's 28%.
- 3:02So we got a lot of high cost CD money sitting out there with the Fed,
- 3:06most likely dropping rates for sure.
- 3:08Or hopefully by September.
- 3:09You know, all of that will start to reprice.
- 3:11And again if that yield curve stays positively sloped, that should be good
- 3:15news for, I think the credit union world.
- 3:19Treichel: Todd, go ahead.
- 3:20I know, I know.
- 3:20Todd, in the past you've talked about CDs being at all time lows and going back to
- 3:25new normal are we at normal or is it gonna swing back a little bit or any other?
- 3:30I think we're,
- 3:32Miller: I think we're back close to normal.
- 3:34It's been pretty stable for the last two or three quarters, and it's kind
- 3:38of about back to where we were in prior to the last recession in 2008, 2009.
- 3:45Back then CDs, money markets together were running around 40,
- 3:4845% of credit union deposits.
- 3:51And then we had those long periods through COVID were interest rates were flat,
- 3:55where there was really no difference in pricing in the industry between a
- 3:58regular share account and a money market.
- 4:00And you maybe got five more basis points for a cd, you know, hot money.
- 4:05Was kind of mixed with regular money.
- 4:08Um, once rates started coming up out of COVID, you started seeing a reversion
- 4:12to mean where people are putting money to where it fits their lifestyle.
- 4:16I'm willing to tie money up.
- 4:17I want a little bit more for my money market.
- 4:20Both credit union and banks improve their net interest margin in 2024.
- 4:26So I would say what's really going on is they're adapting to the new normal.
- 4:30And even now it's hard to make money 'cause rates are really flat.
- 4:34Um, Monday fed funds were 4 33 and a 10 year treasury was 4 32.
- 4:39So really, really a flat curve still exists.
- 4:45The OCC report throws out that volatility of those longer term rates
- 4:51is higher than it was in the past.
- 4:54And, you know, credit unions and banks, and it sounds like from
- 4:59the OCC report, banks are in worse shape than credit unions on this,
- 5:02but they still have investment portfolios that are way underwater.
- 5:06The credit unions here in the first quarter, their a FS
- 5:09stuff was about 6% underwater.
- 5:13Their, um, I have it right here somewhere in front of me.
- 5:19On their HTM portfolios, it's about 6% under their water.
- 5:23Let me correct that.
- 5:24Their a FS portfolios were still 7% underwater, so they still got some
- 5:29liquidity in pricing challenges in that they're still sitting with investment
- 5:32portfolios that are not yielding market rates and there's unrealized losses there.
- 5:39Um, I.
- 5:42You know, they, they mentioned this in the risk report.
- 5:45They expect GDP growth to be really flat this year.
- 5:49Like you said, the fed doesn't know which way to go on rates and, you know,
- 5:54because of this uncertainty, what we're seeing from examiners with our clients
- 5:58is they want way more stress testing on interest rate risk and liquidity.
- 6:03And they want different yield curves and they want different shapes of
- 6:06things and they want credit stresses combined with liquidity stresses.
- 6:11So there's it's uncertainty on their part.
- 6:14And you know, when you do all these stress tests of this nature and scenario analysis
- 6:20is, it's to inform decision making.
- 6:22And I think we're seeing a lot of regulators.
- 6:25Imposing this stuff on credit unions, not necessarily to inform the credit
- 6:29union's decision making, but Yeah, maybe somewhat that, but I think a
- 6:33lot of it is the examiners want to see this to inform their own decision
- 6:37making so they can apply appropriate risk ratings to their credit union
- 6:41for liquidity and interest rate risk.
- 6:43And it does help the credit union, but this whole uncertain market, it
- 6:48shows up in that your examiners want enhanced scenario analysis of what
- 6:54might happen under different scenarios.
- 6:57And that's a burdensome request at sometimes.
- 7:00Um, 'cause all the scenario analysis, it isn't easy to put together.
- 7:05It's costly, it's time consuming.
- 7:08Then when you end up with results from 6, 8, 10 different scenarios, how
- 7:12do you communicate that risk level?
- 7:15To your board and what should you do about it?
- 7:18So it it, it's things that can inform decision making, but it's things that can
- 7:24just lead to more, how would you put it?
- 7:27Confusion amongst the board or uncertainty.
- 7:30Some of the scenario analysis increases uncertainty rather than lowering it.
- 7:35But for our credit union listeners, you can expect that from your examiners.
- 7:40They want more scenario analysis around interest rate risks and liquidity and
- 7:45cash flow forecast, in part due to the uncertainty of where things might go.
- 7:50Treichel: And theoretically that should happen.
- 7:52You know, it, if you're, if this is the simple credit unions and you
- 7:56get more complex going up my arm here, if you're listening, you can't
- 7:59see the visual I'm creating, but.
- 8:01A plain vanilla credit union should need less.
- 8:04A very complicated credit union with different sources and uses
- 8:07of funds or unique loan programs should expect to see more of that.
- 8:12And that continuum doesn't always necessarily work for examiners.
- 8:15'cause examiners will see something cool that they learned that one, one
- 8:19examiner made a complex credit union do, and then they'll apply it in situations
- 8:23that might not necessarily make sense.
- 8:25And Todd, as you touched on you didn't say it this way, but one of the things
- 8:29NCA is not very good at is figuring out what actions they ask to be done
- 8:35compared to how much it costs the credit union to do that compared to
- 8:39what the actual value of that is.
- 8:40And you can see some disconnects in that.
- 8:42We've seen it amazing disconnects, I would say, over, over the five
- 8:46years in general, but in particularly over the last short period of time.
- 8:49Steve, any, any thoughts on this topic?
- 8:52Farrar: Uh, very, uh, item you talked about in that, be able to,
- 8:58if when asked to do some of these additional stress testing, have some
- 9:03knowledge of how much that's gonna cost and share that with the examiner.
- 9:07'cause uh, they don't tend to think that way,
- 9:10Treichel: then they beat 'em up on profitability.
- 9:12Yeah.
- 9:13So we tiptoed into unrealized investment.
- 9:15I think we co we may have covered that next topic.
- 9:17Any more thoughts on the upside down nature of investment portfolios?
- 9:21Bauer: Just the, just the comment that's been so volatile, right?
- 9:24The 10 year treasury rate alone, in, I think this year it's been as high as 4.8%
- 9:31and as low as 4%.
- 9:33Right.
- 9:33So that'll, that raises havoc on that unrealized investment
- 9:36losses and on health to maturity.
- 9:39Types of investments we're currently it's at 4 35, so hopefully that that
- 9:43stabilizes and you know, that, that those portfolios can get a little relief, but
- 9:48that's a big swing right in, in a less than six, seven months 80 basis points.
- 9:53So that's all I wanted to say on that.
- 9:56Treichel: Got it.
- 9:57Farrar: Yeah, we had some of our, a number of credit unions that ended
- 10:00up with, uh, in the COVID times, taking all that, uh, in inflow of
- 10:06funds and investing at long term.
- 10:08And now we're, we're starting to see the effects of that.
- 10:11The negative effects of that are starting to dissipate out of the balance sheets.
- 10:17Treichel: No, good point.
- 10:18Good point.