Latest / Building Brand Gravity: Attracting People Into Your Orbit / Ethics and GenAI in Communications
Transcript
- 0:06You are listening to Building Brand Gravity Attracting People into your Orbit, a GNS
- 0:12Business Communications podcast. This is a show for communications pros across industries looking to
- 0:19gain an inside of you into industry influence. You're about to hear a conversation
- 0:24with leading industry professionals talking about the importance of building business impact through sound brand
- 0:31strategy. Let's get into the show. Welcome to Building Brand Gravity. I'm
- 0:37a Green, I'm a principal and managing director here at G and S Business
- 0:41Communications, and I love my two guests. I'm very sucked about them today.
- 0:45So first we've got Kim Sample. She's president of the PR Council,
- 0:48which, if you don't know, is the US industry association that represents more
- 0:53than a hundred, well more than a hundred agencies of PR integrated marketing communications.
- 0:59And you made me laugh when I asked for your bio and you described
- 1:03yourself as a one hundred percent agency animal, which I am as well.
- 1:07So she's worked in big firms, small firms. She built a firm from
- 1:10zero dollars to thirty five million dollars, which I am very very impressed by.
- 1:15And she's just been an incredible leader of our profession as President of the
- 1:19pr Council. And then we have Mark McLennan, who I've known I think
- 1:23Mark almost twenty years now, probably he's worked in tech and fintech comms for
- 1:29twenty plus years against small firms, midsize, big holding company agencies, and
- 1:34he's now general manager in the Boston office of C plus C, which is
- 1:38a purpose driven agency. But for the conversation today, I think what's really
- 1:42notable is Mark has been a big voice on ethics in our industry. So
- 1:46he's hosted Ethical Voices dot com the podcast since twenty nineteen, one hundred plus
- 1:52episodes check it out, and also author to book Ethical Voices, Practicing Public
- 1:57Relations with Integrity, which hit number one on Amazon and its categories in twenty
- 2:01twenty two. Good job, Mark, I love that. And he was
- 2:04twenty sixteen National Chair of PRSA. So thank you both for joining me today.
- 2:08Awesome, great to be here, My pleasure. So we're here today
- 2:13to talk about what is a hot topic, generative AI. I'm sure everybody
- 2:17is thrilled for more content on this, but frankly, we got to talk
- 2:21about it and the reason that specifically we're talking today is because the PRC worked
- 2:28together with Mark and I in a task force to create new guidelines on the
- 2:31ethical use of generative AI in the communications industry. And this is truly,
- 2:38I mean, you both know, a hot topic everywhere, not just in
- 2:40the news, but every industry association meeting we go to. I know,
- 2:44Mark, you said you just came back from Counselor's Academy for PRSA. I'm
- 2:47sure it was talked about there, but I guess let me set the stage
- 2:51by asking Kim, why these guidelines and why now? What was the genesis
- 2:57of this project? Yeah, we made the decision. It's our twenty fifth
- 3:00anniversary, and we felt like an important piece of work to launch as part
- 3:05of the twenty fifth anniversary was a focus on ethics and standards for our industry.
- 3:12Because so much is evolving, our work is so fully integrated, we
- 3:17just wanted to put a dedicated focus on making sure that we were being as
- 3:23ethical as possible and really meeting the demands of a changing society. And it
- 3:30just so happened. As soon as we launched that work and I was able
- 3:35to attract these two amazing leaders to lead that work, generative AI became the
- 3:43hot topic and our agencies. Everybody was talking about it, everybody was handwringing
- 3:47about it or fast forward on it, and it just felt like a huge
- 3:53public service if we could bring together the minds in public relations focused on ethics,
- 4:04d EI, technology, corporate reputation, all of these different areas.
- 4:10If we could bring everybody together and come up with guidelines, it would be
- 4:13a huge assist not only for our member firms, but across the industry.
- 4:17And we just felt like there was so much at stake for the industry in
- 4:21not approaching this in a really smart way. Mark, what was your feeling
- 4:27about the urgency of it or why you said yes when Kim approached us about
- 4:30taking this on. What was your first thought about this as the right time
- 4:34to try to put guidelines. I was so happy. I mean, this
- 4:38is one of the most significant issues and transformative opportunities for PR agencies, and
- 4:46I thought there was a lack of clear, actionable guidance. Ollers have looked
- 4:49at it, There's been some folks that have definitely given some great advice,
- 4:53but I thought there was a void that needed to be filled, and I
- 4:56was so happy the CPR Council stepping up to Philip. Yeah, you know.
- 5:00And what's interesting about these guidelines, right, because there's again, I
- 5:04mean, we all know the news cycle, right, we know how the
- 5:08hype cycle, like something is off your radar and then maybe you're a first
- 5:13mover and you start to see it cooking and then suddenly boom, it's everywhere,
- 5:15and then then the flow changes, it goes up and down. Right.
- 5:19But there's so much discussion going on. We'll get into some of the
- 5:23big trends as we get into this conversation, but I want to center this
- 5:28the start of this conversation on the fact that these guidelines are focused around ethical
- 5:31use of generative AI, which is an interesting and critical to me. I
- 5:36agree, Mark, like right in the wheelhouse of stuff I think about.
- 5:40But let's go to you. Mark. You've been a voice, a very
- 5:44powerful, thoughtful and insistent voice around centering ethics in our industry for years and
- 5:50years, since the early days when I've known you. Why talk about generative
- 5:56AI in that context? And why was that important that that's how guidelines are
- 6:00shaped around ethics is central to the human condition. It has been the key
- 6:05pivot point as long as there's been humanity without ethical guidance. We have murder,
- 6:11Mayhem and Machiavelli maneuvering, and I think this is a case where when
- 6:15people understand it, there's laws that are evolving. You know, there's going
- 6:18to be a lot of evolving legal issues when it comes to the use of
- 6:23generative AI. But the good part about ethics is the fundamental ethical guidelines and
- 6:28rules are universal and stand the test of time. So by using that to
- 6:32center the discussion is a great framework to build a discussion for agencies on what
- 6:38you should and shouldn't do with genertive AI. Yeah, Kim, I love
- 6:43that answer, and I love the alliteration. Nice job there. That's I
- 6:46agree we would it's kind of chaos if that sense of and ethical framework ethical
- 6:51decision making. What is the ethical mind? How does that come into us
- 6:55as individual as us as into our organizations. But I'll ask you the same
- 7:00question, Kim. We are talking about these guidelines within the pr Council with
- 7:04technologists, with the leaders, and our agencies that are digitally driven, with
- 7:09overall leadership, organizational leaders Why for you was it important or did you see
- 7:14the deep connection to let's look at this through that ethical lens and the pr
- 7:17Council Code of Ethics. Yeah, it just made perfect sense. And I
- 7:24think I was spurred on by the realization that I don't think our agencies are
- 7:31talking enough about ethics. I think we get so busy, we're so in
- 7:38service of client needs and wants. But it was like an important reminder that
- 7:44this is central to what we do. This is the backbone, and we
- 7:48need to be having constant conversations. And I feel so lucky that the two
- 7:53of you were willing to take leadership of this effort because you so firmly believe
- 7:59that and model that. I mean, I'll build off on and riff on
- 8:03that. And then I have a follow up question for Mark that I know
- 8:07is in your wheelhouse. I do very very much believe that ethics is not
- 8:13necessarily thought of, not just in our firms, but by individuals and also
- 8:18our society in a way that I think makes sense to how it actually operates.
- 8:24It's sort of what you said, Mark Er, it's a central engine,
- 8:26a central lens that we can deploy. And this question of I mean,
- 8:33Kim, you've heard me say this, and I think Mark, you
- 8:35may have two When I do ethics training in my own firm, and I've
- 8:39very been very happy over the years that the PR Council has taken programs from
- 8:45some of the larger agencies and white labeled them and made it available. And
- 8:48I would y I was a big consumer of those take it. I'm a
- 8:52very big proponent of in person or it's small group training, role playing,
- 8:56etc. Because what I often say is that ethics is not the villain.
- 9:03The you know, with the black hat standing in the corner toiling is mustache
- 9:07saying haha, I'm going to do evil. Now. What it often is
- 9:11and it's actually really tragic to see it. It's death by a thousand paper
- 9:13cuts. It's a lot of small, bad decisions and often a huge failure
- 9:20in leadership. We've seen a lot of examples out there of where there was
- 9:26pressure from the top of an organization and the pressure wasn't saying I want you
- 9:31to break the rules or I want you to act on ethically, but the
- 9:33message was basically results at any cost, and therefore it drove a culture of
- 9:39permissiveness and blind eye turning to this. So I think that for me,
- 9:45I agree. I was really excited about this because it was a chance to
- 9:48again recenter ethics in the fact that it's woven into everything. I mean,
- 9:54Mark, tell me you and I've talked about this that for a lot of
- 9:56organizations, ethics can be kind of like a once the year check the box.
- 10:01What is the challenge with that for you and what would you rather see
- 10:05in organizations today? Well, to my mind, ethics that once a year
- 10:09training this is effective to going to the gym once a year or taking your
- 10:13vitamins once a year. It is not going to make you fit and healthy
- 10:18people do it, They check it and they go back and it shows,
- 10:20frankly, that you're looking at ethics as a check the box compliant initiative and
- 10:24you're telling your folks that you don't have significant weight on it. And my
- 10:30dream when it comes to ethical training, and I talk about this a lot,
- 10:33is people need to train their ethical minds because there's studies that show biologically,
- 10:39our initial instinct is to be selfish and it is only when we give
- 10:45a deliberative flot that we tend to elevate. And I don't know about you,
- 10:48but there's fewer things that are less controlled chaos than a pr person's day.
- 10:54And so by having these discussions, it's like a golfer homes they're swearing
- 10:58a batterer hones that swing. You get ready to make these decisions. And
- 11:01what I love to have people do is both talk about it, have senior
- 11:05management bring it up, and make it a part of your regular meetings at
- 11:09least twice a month. Share relevant ethical issues. Did you see this?
- 11:13Have other staff bring in ethical issues, discuss it, debate the pros and
- 11:18cons, what can applied scenarios that you may be dealing with, and really
- 11:22that gets your entire staff to understand that you're putting ethics first. I'd say
- 11:26it shouldn't just be with your staff. You should share it with your clients
- 11:30because frankly, one, let your clients and know the importance you put on
- 11:33ethics and also what may alert your client issues they may have because if your
- 11:37client has ethical failings, that may come and blowback on you as well.
- 11:41And so you really just want to have this discussion. And the final point
- 11:46I'll say about that is as a senior leader, you shouldn't be the one
- 11:50giving your opinion first. You need to wait, otherwise you're going to stifle
- 11:54debate. And don't ever worry about running out of topics I teach pr ethics
- 11:58a BOSS University and the first half an hour of every class is what were
- 12:03the pr ethics issues this week? And I have never had a lack of
- 12:07anybody having an issue to bring up. Somehow that does not surprise me in
- 12:13our society today. But to pick on something you said, it's that training
- 12:18your mind and it's very important, I think for people to understand that that
- 12:22moment of intentional thought, whether it's looking at through an ethical framework, it
- 12:28can also be trying to interrupt your own bias, which is something we talk
- 12:31about a lot with d E and I. It can be stopping and asking
- 12:35yourself, what is the implications of the decision I'm making? Is there's someone
- 12:39else that should bring into this? And this does bring us back to generative
- 12:41AI, because there's so much power being unfurled and it is so transformative and
- 12:46it's kind of you know, the first time you encounter these large language models,
- 12:52especially with the release of the various platforms of chat, GPT over the
- 12:56past few months, it feels like a magic trick. It feels amazing.
- 13:00It sort of blows you away, but you start to unpeel what are the
- 13:05implications of this what is the positive power the negative power? And one thing
- 13:09I'd love you guys to reflect on because it's really a personal thing as well
- 13:13as a business question. We're hearing now a lot of discussions either this is
- 13:20amazing, It's going to be totally amazing, the utopian kind of view which
- 13:22always comes with tech, which is I think a very important energy. But
- 13:26there's also the destroyer narrative, which is are we about to be in the
- 13:31matrix? Right? And it's interesting to see people like Jeffrey Hinton, one
- 13:33of the pioneers of AI, just left Google so that he can be a
- 13:39very open voice of Hey, this is moving faster than rerealize and there may
- 13:41be bad implications here as we get caught up as leaders and as people in
- 13:46this hype zone where it's like Utopia destroyer, Utopia destroyer. How are each
- 13:52of you modulating that as especially in our field. I mean, Kim,
- 13:56how are you weighing these two poles of discussion? Yeah, I mean,
- 14:01I think it's very interesting, and I would say that the extremes are moderating
- 14:07a little bit, and I feel that people in our industry are getting a
- 14:13bit more in the middle. And I use as evidence. We had a
- 14:16digital community meeting yesterday and we were all talking about how we're using generative AI
- 14:22and our agencies and to a person, you know, they are not using
- 14:28it for client work. They are encouraging experimentation, and they're encouraging its use.
- 14:35You know, if there's a roadblock, you know, you could use
- 14:39generative AI, play around with it, see if it helps you open up
- 14:43your roadblock. So I think we're getting to a good place, which we
- 14:50can take credit, you know, for really pushing people to have these ethical
- 14:56conversations. But I think it's so important for our industry, like that doom
- 15:01and gloom message was so strong for a while that our industry is going to
- 15:07be most affected and I don't see that. And I think it's important for
- 15:11people to understand, like this is this is an opportunity. You know,
- 15:16you have a responsibility as a communications professional to learn maybe to safely experiment,
- 15:24but to understand that really the value that we're offering clients is still there,
- 15:31It's going to be even more so there. But maybe there's a way that
- 15:35AI can be used to eliminate some of the more you know, wrote aspects
- 15:43of our job that frankly nobody enjoys. So if there's an opportunity to create
- 15:46more exciting jobs, we're all in right. Shout out to all the people
- 15:52of a certain age who used to cut clips out of newspapers and measure them
- 15:56to see what the advertising equivalency would be. And if you didn't understand any
- 16:00of those words, then you're younger. And back then the debate was do
- 16:03you tape the clips or do you pace the clips? And you had people
- 16:07on either side. I really enjoyed a glue stick mark that was a tape
- 16:11guy. But the one point I want to build on kim'stone this is it's
- 16:14an interesting concern I have. I think we're talking a lot about agency and
- 16:18agency operations, and I go back and forth. I am more utopian over
- 16:22where I'm seeing some of the technology going, but I am also in some
- 16:26very specific cases being extremely dystopian. Deep fakes scare the heck out of me,
- 16:32and the technology is getting better, and the more I learned about that,
- 16:36the more concerned I am. And I was just talking as a number
- 16:37of colleagues recently, if you do not have deep fakes as part of your
- 16:41crisis plan, and you're not looking and thinking about how to respond to them.
- 16:45You were not doing your clients a good service, and you need to
- 16:48learn how to do it, how you can count them, and really how
- 16:52you can incorporate that. So in some cases, the dystopian I think is
- 16:56still on the rise, and I think it's going to rise for quite a
- 16:59while. Yeah, I think that's really fair. I was going to ask
- 17:03you, guys, where the things that give you the most pause? I
- 17:07do think that, you know, I remember, and I've talked to both
- 17:11of you about this back when social media really first came to the flour and
- 17:14I'm really thinking about blogging. We forget how revolutionary Typepad and WordPress were when
- 17:21you could suddenly write to the web without any coding experience whatsoever. I mean,
- 17:25that was amazing, and those early days of social media kind of talking
- 17:30to clients about it, talking to colleagues about it. You know, we've
- 17:33been on this journey about what are the net positives, what are the net
- 17:37negatives? And I think that for me, you know, we're living in
- 17:41a world where we've really had to reflect a very long and hard about the
- 17:44impact on individuals and society of algorithmic manipulation, and none of us are innocent
- 17:52from this. You know, we're we are in the business of shaping perception,
- 17:56and so we're always under suspicion from the outside. I would ledge,
- 18:00though, and I would say, and I feel very strongly about this,
- 18:02that to Mark's earlier point, our industry actually thinks more about ethics and more
- 18:07about what are the implications of what we're communicating because we represent others, we
- 18:11have contractual obligations, etc. But it does give me a great pause.
- 18:15We've seen now the level of manipulation of the human brain, the behaviors that
- 18:21can come of it, radicalization, you know, polarization, and then when
- 18:26you get down to the pure deep fakes, it's scary. And I think
- 18:32you're right, Kim. I think one of the pieces I've been reflecting on
- 18:34is how this opens up more and more space for what we do best,
- 18:38which is to be counselors. What is the nature of how the media landscape
- 18:42is changing? How do you deal with things where there's no perfect or right
- 18:48answer? What do you you know? What is that mix of art and
- 18:52science in a crisis that helps you understand how to deal with this? But
- 18:55I think you're right, Mark. I if companies aren't thinking about the implications
- 18:57here. It's it's pretty heavy, for sure. There is an interesting thing
- 19:02you just brought to mind for me that I've been sort of pondering, is
- 19:08how will we train counselors when AI is doing a lot of the rotework.
- 19:17So, for example, when we stood at the copy machine and taped or
- 19:21pasted, we read those clips. It was our job to read every one
- 19:27of those clips, and new ideas came from that. So a machine can
- 19:34do that to some degree. I don't know. It's like, if we're
- 19:38eliminating some of those wrote tasks that trained your brain and let you search for
- 19:44patterns, how will we develop those analytical and counseling abilities in our young talent.
- 19:52I think that's a big TBD. It's a really good question. I
- 19:56mean, it makes me wonder. You know. Sometimes I've been the kind
- 20:00of person who says very literary focus growing up, of like, oh,
- 20:03we're not reading in this way anymore, we're not writing anymore in this way,
- 20:07or etc. And just new technology and how it changes the brain and
- 20:11how you communicate. And there's a school of thought that you know, folks
- 20:15adapt and they bring it in and they find new ways of expressing that like
- 20:18our folks today are pulling articles, they're using already tools, but they're still
- 20:22ingesting it. Maybe the AI helps them do an analysis if they find that
- 20:27to be accurate. But yeah, I don't know, Mark, do you
- 20:30have any thought. I think it comes down frankly to individual agencies making their
- 20:34own discussion. And the specific point I want to highlight, because we had
- 20:37a very robust debate at C plus C over lists, is on meeting notes
- 20:42and action items that you know there are tools out there right now that can
- 20:47absolutely do meeting notes and action items, automate the process and turn them out
- 20:52very quickly. And so the time is one. Does that let you save
- 20:56some billable hours and I'll bring a junior person to the meeting, let people
- 21:00be more present in the meeting. But the corollary a lot is, you
- 21:03know they're if you don't have somebody. The way you've learned how to pick
- 21:07up these key ideas and do the action on this is by doing the meeting
- 21:11notes. And so we need to decide do you want to use AI to
- 21:14say of time or do you want to make sure you still have somebody there
- 21:17and give them that training opportunity and I think you can make the argument either
- 21:19way, and that's why it's up to the agency decide what to do.
- 21:22In our case, we've decided we want to make sure we have somebody because
- 21:26we want to train their critical thinking and train their ability to find those key
- 21:30messages as Kim talked about. So we're not using it right now for that
- 21:33purpose. I think it might be also a magnificent way to engage all generations
- 21:40within an organizational environment to say, hey, what is the value to you.
- 21:45There's obviously the judgment we can bring as more senior leaders because we have
- 21:48seen professional development and sort of see the nuances of how that might shift from
- 21:53person to person learning style, but also to ask younger people what are the
- 21:59places where you feel you really need to be at the table and how does
- 22:03this bring the value for you, etc. Etc. I Mean, there's
- 22:07so much great stuff here. I think about this very much as an organizational
- 22:10leader, even thinking beyond the agency context, but also as a practitioner and
- 22:15as a person. I mean, I think we on this kind of issue.
- 22:18I think we have to be considering and reflecting on those on multiple levels
- 22:22at all times because of the three sixty nature, so let's talk about the
- 22:26guidelines for a bit, and I've got them up here on my other screen.
- 22:29There's a lot of great things in here in terms of it, and
- 22:33it's aligned and Mark, you really were a proponent of this, aligning the
- 22:37view of generative AI and the use of it in an ethical context with the
- 22:41PR Council's Code of Ethics that is signed by all agencies. These guidelines are
- 22:45not mandatory, but the Code of Ethics is. So there's a lot of
- 22:48good stuff in here, protecting the integrity of client information, our role in
- 22:52society, accuracy, transparency. But for each of you, I don't know.
- 22:56I'll start with you, Kim. What are some of the key themes
- 23:00or areas of focus or topic in there, or maybe one of the guidelines
- 23:04that most resonates with you or that you would love to highlight. First,
- 23:08I just have to praise Mark for the brilliance in just using the Code of
- 23:15Ethics as the format. It just worked so beautifully. I think one of
- 23:22the sections that I really valued and I also enjoyed the discussion on an input
- 23:27from a number of people, was the preventing bias, particularly around diversity.
- 23:34I thought we were able to do a really good job of creating questions for
- 23:41folks to ask, and for me, it was so important because our industry
- 23:47lacks diversity, so we have to, you know, overcompensate for the fact
- 23:55that we don't have diverse teams typically and really all sort of teach ourselves to
- 24:03watch for that bias. And I think we did a good pass at that.
- 24:10Yeah, and shout out to the individuals and the diversity community, the
- 24:15CDOs, the chief diversity officers who corresponded with you, Kim and took a
- 24:19look at that, because they added a lot to it. And for those
- 24:23who haven't looked at the guidelines yet, not only are there the guidelines themselves,
- 24:26but relative to that issue, there's a whole series of questions that are
- 24:32part of this document that one can ask to interrupt bias or recognize bias in
- 24:37the process of engaging with generative AI. And I would argue that the questions
- 24:41are just good in general for putting yourself on the spot, stepping back from
- 24:47your normal mode and saying what is actually happening here? But Mark, the
- 24:51question goes to you, what was a theme or a piece of the guidelines
- 24:55that really resonated to you? For a lot of them, but I mean,
- 24:57we'll talk about training. I think I mentioned all ready, so I
- 25:00want to highlight something else that I think is important. And that was something
- 25:03I hadn't quite realized the full implications of was dealing with protecting the integrity of
- 25:08client information and really looking at all the different ways we could potentially be compromising
- 25:14ethically and legally our responsibilities when it comes to what we may use generative AI
- 25:21to enhance. And it's really important to understand the difference between closed and open
- 25:26generative AI, which is something and frankly we were laughing. We were always
- 25:30worried as we're developing these guidelines where they become outdated how quickly. And the
- 25:33good news about tying it to ethics, it doesn't really get outdated, and
- 25:37it may need to be modified and updated, but the current principles stay the
- 25:41same. But the day of the webinar we had announcing this, there were
- 25:44some new developments when it came to closed AI, and so that's why people
- 25:48need to constantly learn as well. But it's understanding that in any open AI
- 25:52system, any information you put in there can eventually be incorporated into a large
- 25:57language model, and so it's it's like, are you lenliable? Are you
- 26:00done putting your clients data at risk? There's a whole bunch of elements,
- 26:04and I think that's something where you've got to really look at what can and
- 26:07what should you not put into general of AI platforms. I think that's such
- 26:15a great one and that and that's one where it was really interesting some of
- 26:19the discussions we had around it because the space is so fast moving, and
- 26:25I think there's also maybe a sense and no one said this explicitly, like
- 26:29in our task force or in some of the reactions that we got from industry
- 26:32and conversations I've had. But I do wonder too, with the large public
- 26:37models like chat GPT, like the public version, if people don't have an
- 26:41assumption it's sort of like the school of fish there, Oh, there's so
- 26:45many fish, Like I'm just like, it'll never pop up, Like it's
- 26:48just so much stuff in there. But I think it's really important to be
- 26:52rigorous about that and say you don't know that it won't. You don't know
- 26:55that it won't. It's that's the power of these models. My favorite part,
- 26:59I mean, I really loved every part of this conversation because the frustrated
- 27:03academic in me really enjoys this kind of thing, like very deeply and profoundly.
- 27:07But the thing I enjoyed a lot was having a chance to reflect as
- 27:11a group with different points of view on what does transparency and disclosure mean in
- 27:18this context. So there were a lot of different threads of that conversation.
- 27:22One was and I have great respect for the folks that brought this up,
- 27:26and I understand the context of why, although I will dispute it right now.
- 27:30You know this sense of disclosure, well, hey, we're already using
- 27:33grammarly, I'm already using this AI is embedded like all through wherever my phone
- 27:37is all through that I feel that is a little bit. I think it's
- 27:45a misguided conflation of what is sort of the evolution of not even AI tools
- 27:52as they exist today, and what is coming. So this question of disclosure,
- 27:56I don't feel that that can be used as an excuse, and again
- 28:00I don't think people were proffering it as an excuse, but it's more like
- 28:03but this, So I think that was one big thing I had to really
- 28:07reflect on. And then this question of transparency, it's like if it walks
- 28:11and quacks like a duck? Is it a duck? So if if we
- 28:15created something an x percentage of it was contributed to by general of AI,
- 28:21whereas the authorship, does it have to be fifty one percent? Was the
- 28:25human Does it have to be sixty percent? Seventy percent? And there's a
- 28:30there's a thought leader in this space and I can't remember his name right now,
- 28:33we can put it in the in the show notes. Who one of
- 28:36my colleagues, Kyle Turner in our digital group, who's amazing, shared with
- 28:40me and this guy was talking about the release of fixed Facebook's Lama, which
- 28:44is open source, a whole nother level of this thing. He calls it
- 28:48the next pebble in the avalanche, and he at the beginning of his video
- 28:53said this, here's my disclosure. This was ninety five percent human driven.
- 28:59There's five percent where generative AI has created images for me. And I thought
- 29:03that was really really interesting. Um. My colleague Steve Halsey, who some
- 29:08of you note, said to me he was having discussion at Page about what
- 29:12if you had a Generative AI spokesperson that was generated video and they if there
- 29:18was a crisis with a company, they that that program could be set to
- 29:23communicate in you know, fifty sixty seventy languages simultaneously around the world. How
- 29:29would we feel about that? So, what do you guys think about that?
- 29:32That use case? That is really interesting to me. It's frightening to
- 29:37me. I mean, let's let's let's imagine in the thought experiment that it
- 29:44is the company doing it and there and they want to be able to communicate
- 29:48quickly, and they are using AI and it's an avatar and they're saying it's
- 29:52them. But it still feels weird a bit, does it? To him?
- 29:59It just feels like such a thin line between good and evil on that
- 30:04use case, right, Like, I don't know, it's super scary.
- 30:10And then if the information is wrong or dangerous or illegal, then is it
- 30:22the company? You know? I don't know. It just feels fraught with
- 30:26peril. What's your tick on that? Mark? This one? Really?
- 30:29I was like, Wow, that's so it's interesting. I mean, I
- 30:32think in the end, people would be more reassured right now, at least
- 30:34today, hearing from a live person making the statements and that real human because
- 30:41they want to hear from the CEO or the VP of marketing. I almost
- 30:44bifurcated in two ways. It's one around the image and the text and are
- 30:48we creating it as the AI creating it? And then two, as you
- 30:51said, fifty or seventy different languages. And yes, it's kind of really
- 30:53interesting to use with the translation automatic because there's tools that do that. But
- 30:59one of the things we under Dana's translation is in transcreation. And no matter
- 31:02how good the translation tools are right now, they do not get the cultural
- 31:07nuances, which is why I tend to involve, you know, human people
- 31:10from the cultures that can understand and use the right terminology. Otherwise you're going
- 31:15to have something which some people assume means one thing and everybody's talking about pop
- 31:19and you know that it's your father. Well, other people think it's a
- 31:22soda, and you know it's another thing that you got to make sure you
- 31:26deal those cultural nuances appropriately. Yeah. I'm originally from Ohio, so I
- 31:32was in the podcast Soda Our Bubble Lover. If you want, right,
- 31:33I mean, hey, Bubble the water fountain. Yeah, nope, I
- 31:37think I wanted to hit you guys with this sort of without warning, with
- 31:41this use case because it just came to me. Steve came into my office
- 31:45yesterday and said, listen to this, and I said, what an interesting
- 31:47thought experiment, because it does trigger so many questions that I think are the
- 31:51right questions. Again, going back to that ethical mind, the ethical decision
- 31:55making framework of what does it mean to have a non person avatar saying this
- 32:01versus how will it be received different cultures, different societies at different times,
- 32:07and sort of what you're implying in your answer, Mark is right now for
- 32:10many cultures and societies, probably a real person would be the more relevant thing.
- 32:16Will we adapt later on to where that'll feel differently? And then the
- 32:20question of is that translation good enough? You know, it's amazing to have
- 32:25lifetime translation tools, but where does that become a net negative if we don't
- 32:30really understand that. There's just I think it's going to be very cool.
- 32:35And we talked about this, Kim to start to create a repository of use
- 32:38cases or interesting questions or Harry, this is what's emerging. So as an
- 32:43industry we can start to look at Okay, here's some obvious uses already,
- 32:46but here's some ones that we maybe haven't thought about yet. And that's something
- 32:52I want to keep on my radar. It's hard to do that at scale,
- 32:54but maybe that's as this project the guidelines evolve, that could be something
- 33:00we look at. I agree. I think that's the power of having this
- 33:04task force. You know, you couldn't do this within your own firm.
- 33:08Most firms don't have the kind of expertise we were able to bring, you
- 33:14know, just even the person power to get this work done. One thing
- 33:19I wanted to mention on that use case is how long will it be before
- 33:22we can't tell avatar or human? I mean, I don't think that's that
- 33:27far off. Yeah, And that that gets back to the deep fit question
- 33:31and another piece that interested me, which is sort of the strands disclosure,
- 33:37transparency, authenticity. You know, there's been folks in our society that have
- 33:43been yearning for this singularity for decades, which is the what everyone judges to
- 33:49be the merger of man and machine, you know, And and that's a
- 33:52very kind of visionary tech utopian to me. That feels just topic. I
- 33:59just read just a lot of just topic fiction growing up, So I'm like,
- 34:01oh, but the idea of what is an authentic human expression? This
- 34:07is going to really challenge that, especially when it's taught to talk like us.
- 34:13You know, it comes out in a way that sounds human. I
- 34:15find it it's going to cause a lot of emotions, which it already is
- 34:20clearly. Yeah. I think another interesting conversation that I've been having is AI
- 34:25and art. Yeah, and I have felt worried for artists, musicians,
- 34:34visual artists, writers. But you know, in speaking with some friends,
- 34:38they're pointing out that, you know, technologies have been playing a role in
- 34:44the creation of art for so long, and artists are adaptable, so maybe
- 34:52it isn't a threat, it's a you know, aid to creating art.
- 34:58I don't know, Mark, I think i'd love to hear because I think
- 35:00this goes back to questions too about being really intentional about ownership and copyright.
- 35:05No, I think so. And I think the one point I want to
- 35:07really emphasize, and it's something we have discussed earlier, is you need to
- 35:10make sure you get multiple opinions because otherwise you're going to have your bias.
- 35:15And I'll tell you right now, I've been a PR guy and a digital
- 35:17PR guy for twenty five years. That's where I think at C plus C
- 35:22when we formed oria task force, we made sure we had somebody from research,
- 35:27somebody from creative, digital, multicultural, and the folks from creative that
- 35:30we're doing all the artwork and all the other issues, we're bringing up ideas
- 35:35that I never would have considered. I mean, and so I think we
- 35:37evolve some of our guidelines to deal with a lot of that creative area,
- 35:42which is not something we've necessarily talked about specifically on these because that's a point
- 35:45there is you need to look at, as you're doing business in multiple areas,
- 35:50what are some of the guidelines you're going to have. It may be
- 35:52different, and you need to keep that in mind. I love the idea
- 35:55of bringing multiple points of view and perspectives to the table, and that kind
- 36:00of gets to the earlier thing we talked about is sort of wrestling with a
- 36:02dynamic tension of everything humans create can be amazing or a garbage fire. Like
- 36:09we have demonstrated ability to have both at once with everything that we create,
- 36:15and some things are more potentially destructive than others. But I love the idea
- 36:17that because you know Mark, and tying back to something you said, that's
- 36:22a complete parallel with the question of ethics, which is more voices were better
- 36:29if you have a feeling something's wrong, get to others, talk about it,
- 36:32get perspectives. Same thing with biased if you feel like, am I
- 36:37gaslighting this person? Am I seeing this in a way that this performance evaluation
- 36:43of doing as someone warped because of the systems of race that's surround me in
- 36:46the society, Like what is happening here? And getting out of your whole
- 36:50and talking to multiple people. I love that advice, Mark, I think
- 36:52it's so important. So, guys, what comes next in this process?
- 36:57We have these guidelines, they're going to be a living document. You know,
- 37:00what do you think will be the journey for this kind of project?
- 37:05And what are you watching most closely? I mean, obviously we're not going
- 37:08to be updating them every week. We might look quarterly and say what's happened?
- 37:13But you know, Kim, what's on your mind about? Where does
- 37:15this go from here? I love the idea of regularly convening and you know,
- 37:22now I'm obsessing about we need creatives. We need to get creatives pulled
- 37:29together and have this conversation. But I think the more time we can make
- 37:34to talk about this, even if we're not issuing changes to our guidelines.
- 37:37But quarterly. Just having these conversations, I think is going to sharpen our
- 37:43thinking and it says a lot about the thoughtfulness of our industry. One thing
- 37:47I wanted to share, which is just the tiniest bit of a tangent,
- 37:50but we did a bunch of research on early career professionals in other industries.
- 37:55But you know, with the idea, how do we attract people with really
- 38:00valuable skills into our agencies? So law, yes, advertising, educators,
- 38:06we do so much education. We need educators. So we went through all
- 38:09of these different professions and we asked them do they think public relations is ethical?
- 38:16And I'll be honest, I thought that there was not going to be
- 38:20a really positive response to that, just because of the impact of pop culture,
- 38:24you know, because of the way our industry is portrayed. And it
- 38:28was amazing, like almost to a person, they're like, well they have
- 38:34to be, don't they. I mean, how can you be a public
- 38:37relations professional and not be focused on ethics? Well, we know, you
- 38:43coun But I thought that that was really terrific to hear from young potential talent,
- 38:52and it made me want to do an even better job and have these
- 38:55conversations and get them out into the public a bit more people know we are
- 39:01doing this work very thowfully. Yeah, Mark, what do you think what
- 39:07are you looking at as next steps or things that you're keeping your eye on
- 39:10this week go forward in this well? I think two things that I want
- 39:13to circle back to. One thing Kim just talked about about how PR is
- 39:16ethical, and I mean, I think one of the things that really hardens
- 39:19to me if you haven't looked at the Ethosphere studies, you know, when
- 39:22people are talking about it, we say being ethical is good for business.
- 39:24There is an ethics premium. They have found usually ten to thirteen percent or
- 39:29higher performance by ethical companies, by the world's most ethical companies. So you
- 39:32know, paying attention to these things is not just more than the right thing
- 39:36to do, it's the right thing to do when it comes to business as
- 39:38well. But in terms of what I am looking at, and I've kind
- 39:43of gone down another rabbit hole right now, but I think it's absolutely fascinating.
- 39:46And we're focusing on generative AI, but when you look at what autonomous
- 39:51agents are going to be able to do in the coming years, that is
- 39:54something that is it changes it even more. We got to see how effective
- 40:00it's going to be. But I think over time, looking at the ethics
- 40:04of autonomous agents and what we're going to allow to do, we're just kind
- 40:07of taking general aid to the next level. Is going to be a bigger
- 40:09deal. That's a really great point. There's a lot of and I think
- 40:16we've been around long enough to see these conversions of technology. I remember working
- 40:21in tech and including wireless and healthcare and financial services and watching them all converge.
- 40:27Mark you and I both did that in the industries, and I think
- 40:30we're going to see a lot of conversions of these things. I think for
- 40:32me, I am really interested in how and I think Facebook did it to
- 40:37kind of catch up with the others. But the release of an open source
- 40:42it's not a full interface, it's not a fully baked platform. It's really
- 40:45non commercial open source software that gives other people the keys to a full a
- 40:51large language model that they can then fine tune for their own uses. And
- 40:54as I've dug into this more and technologists listening to this would be like no,
- 40:59duh. But there's just a huge amounts of smaller platforms now cascading off
- 41:06of that release. And how is it then our clients start to use AI
- 41:09internally in private models, so it's kind of like the private public cloud.
- 41:14There's a hybrid cloud strategy, hybrid AI strategies. I mean, I really
- 41:17feel like I want to keep digging into the tech side of it. But
- 41:21that's only because I always feel I was joke that as someone who's not a
- 41:24technologist. First and foremost, the technology train continues barreling down the track,
- 41:30I need to stay on at least the last car. I'd like to be
- 41:34farther up on the train if I can, but I have to at least
- 41:36hold onto the back of it. So I do feel like a real responsibility
- 41:42to try to read as much as I can and stay updated on how these
- 41:46technologies are morphing and evolving in real time. So the open source thing to
- 41:51me is really interesting and it may be something that you know. Eventually,
- 41:54some of these things shell together and later in the year we bring the task
- 41:59force back together and shout out to all the agency leaders on our Ethics task
- 42:02Force, and we talk about what everyone's seeing. And I love him.
- 42:06By the idea, by the way, the idea of maybe the PR Council
- 42:09convening specialized roundtables. Let's have another one with technologists. Let's have another one
- 42:15with people who identify as creatives. You know, there might be another one
- 42:19with the paid media professionals and our agencies, the d E and I professionals
- 42:22and our agencies, And that way we can keep all those voices going.
- 42:28Yeah, I think that's a great path forward. You know, I just
- 42:30want to put a sharp point on what both of you have just said,
- 42:35and that is the need for public relations professionals to constantly be educating themselves in
- 42:43this area, particularly in the area of technology. I really think it's a
- 42:50mistake if people at all levels are not seeing themselves as students, and it's
- 43:00going to be a big miss for your career if you don't. And isn't
- 43:04that the fun of being in this industry? Constant learning? It literally is
- 43:07the number one thing about especially being in an agency side. So mark any
- 43:10final thoughts from you, I think just John Kim's point, and it's a
- 43:14phrase I've already used a lot, I'm going to change it a little bit.
- 43:16AI is not going to cost PR professionals their jobs, but PR people
- 43:22that know how to operationalize AI, they're the ones that are going to cost
- 43:25you your jobs or cost your agency your clients. Well said with that,
- 43:30I think that's the end. But Kim sample Mark mcconnen. Always a pleasure.
- 43:36It's been such a pleasure to do this work together. And we're going
- 43:38to continue. And thank you for being on Building Brand Gravity and I'll talk
- 43:44to y'all soon. Thank you, Anne, Thank you you are listening to
- 43:51Building Brand Gravity Attracting people into your Orbit a GNS Business Communications podcast. Keep
- 43:58connected with us by subscribing to the show in your favorite podcast player. If
- 44:01you like what you've heard, please rate the show that helps us to keep
- 44:06delivering the latest and industry influence. Thanks for listening. Until next time,